PRABHAKAR YESHWANT JOSHI & ORS. versus THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 29 September 1969 | [1970] 2 S.C.R. 615 | 1969 INSC 263
Key facts
- Decided
- 29 September 1969
- Bench
- M. HIDAYATULLAH*, S.M. SIKRI, G.K. MITTER, A.N. RAY, P. JAGANMOHAN REDDY
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 112/1968
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1970] 2 S.C.R. 615
- Neutral citation
- 1969 INSC 263
Text of the judgment
615
A
PRABHAKAR YESHWANT JOSID & ORS.
v.
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS.
'.B
September 29, 1969
[M. HIDAYATULLAH, C.J., S. M. SnrnI, G. K. M!TTEF., A. N. RAY,
AND P. JAGANMOHAN REDDY,
c
JJ.J
Seniority-Fixation of~Maharashtra Service of Engineers-Seni"o: ity
inter se of promotees and direct recru/111-Jf violative of Articles 14 and 16
of the Constitution.
The petitioners were direct recruits to the post of Deputy Engineers in
Bombay Service of Engineers Class II. In petitions under Art. 32 of the
Constitution they challenged the promotion, by the first respondent. of
responJents 2 to 5 and others similarly situated to the posts of officiating
Executive Engineers contrary to the principles of natural justice arid in
violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. It was contended
that under the rules in force the respondents were. on1y officiating Deputy
D
Engineers and they had to put in after confirmation as Deputy Engineers
seven years of actual service before being eligible for promotio1;1 as officiating Executive Engineer:;; further, particularly in the case of employees
from the erstwhile State of Hyderabad the first respondent bad contrary
to the ruJes relating to promotion, by a resolution in 1967 directed those
employees to be. treated as having been appointed in the reorgan•sed Bom~
bay State as temporary Deputy Engineers only for the purpose of fixation
of their ·seniority in the grade of Deputy Engineers and for promotion to
E
higher posts and therefore those employees did not satisfy the 7 year
requirement. Dismissing the 11etitions,
HELD: (i) There is nothing in rules 6 7 'and 8 of the 1960 Resolution to militate against the interpretation that the service specified there
can be the total service of any description whether 11rovisional, temporary
or 11erm.anent. If promotion from Class II as officiating Executive Engineer
can only be made after 7 years of permanent service then there would be
F
no meaning in including the temporary service in Class II for the purpose
of absorption as Executive Engineers. If temporary service can be taken
into account for confirmation as an Executive Engineer so can officiating
service and if officiating service can be taken into consideration there is no
impediment to a Deputy Engineer with 7 years' service whether officiating,
temporary or permanent to be entitled for promotion as an E.i:ecutive
En!!ineer The Resolution of 1963 makes it abundantly clear th&t the
seniority of promotees should be considered as from the d_ate of promotion
G
H
to officiate continuously irrespective of whether the appointments were
made in temporary or permanent vac:u.cies. [626 G-627 E]
(ii) Those respondents who were from Hyderabad State were iu fact
selected by the Hyderabad Public SerVice Commission as Assistant Engh
neers ·and would have been appointed. as such but for the States Reorganisation Act which came into force from J 956. Had they be>n appointed earlier they would have had to be equated with the posts in Bombay. The
allocation of persons after• the reorganisation from one State to another
was subject to ihe Reorganisation Act which dealt with matters pertaining
to allocation, transfer. fixation of service conditions, seniority etc. The
claims of the respondents who were allotted from the Hyderabad State
arose earlier than the. aj)pointrnents of the petitioners and the Govern-
616
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1970] 2 S.C.R.
A
meat of Bombay and subsequently the .Maharashtra Government
wu entitled to consi.der these claims and to give redress. There is no
statutory bar or rule which prohibits the Government of Maharashtra from
deeming their appointment as from 31-3-1967 for the limited purpose
of seniority and promotion. [628 E--629 CJ
(iii) Further, wheii promotions are made on the basis of seniority-cum·
merit all that can be required is that persons entitled to promotion should
be considered and if having been considered they have been left out they
would have no claim to promotion as: a matter of right. The petitioners
did not possess the required length of service in Class II for them to be
entitled to promotion when the respondents were included in the List and
promoted; as such they cannot cha1lenge the appointments made as beini
in Yiolation of Arts. 14 or 16. 629 D-E]
State of Mysore v. Syed Mahmood, f1968] 3 S.C.R. 363.
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION :
B
c
Writ Petitions Nos. 112 to 114 of
1968.
Petition under Art. 32 of the Cc:mstitution of India for the
enlorceent of fundamental rights.
S. V. Gupte, M. J. Rana and B. R. Agarwala, for the petitioners.
M. C. Chag/a, G. L. Sangh/ and S. P. Nayar, for respondent
No. 1.
S. Mohan Kumaramangalam, Y. S. Chitle, S. N. Prasad and
R. B. Datar, for respond~nts Nos. 2, 4, 6 to 23, 27 to 30 and 32
to 34.
D
E
Respondent No. 3 appeared in person.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
lagarunohan Reddy, l. The three petitioners by these petitions under Art. 32 of the Constitution have challenged the
promotion by the first respondent, who, ignoring the claims of the
petitioners, have promoted respondents 2 to 5 and other persons
i:imilarly situated to the post of officiating Executive Engineers
contrary to the principles oi natural justice and in violation of
Arts. 14 and 16 of the Constitution. All the three petitioners
were directly recruited by the Public Service Commissicn as
Deputy Engineers in the Bombay Service of Engineers Class II,
now known as Maharashtra Service of Engineers Class II. The
first respondent is the State of Maharashtra. Respondent No. 2
belonged to the erstwhile State of Bombay; respondents 3 and 4
belonged to the fonner State of Hyderabad, while respondent No,
5 to the fonner State of Madhya Pradesh, and were allocated to
the State of Bombay under the States reotganisation. Likewise
the other respondents who were formerly in the service of different
States referred to above, now belong to the Maharashtra Service
of Engineers.
G
H
P. Y. JOSHI v. MAHARASHTRA (Reddy, J.)
'
617
A
The petitioners' case is that under the mies in force the
respondents who were in the substantive rank of overseers were
only officiating Deputy Engineers and that as they did not belong
to the cadre of Deputy Engineers they were not entitled to promotion inasmuch as they had to put in after confirmation as
Deputy Engineers 7 years of actual service before being eligible
B for promotion as officiating Executive Engineers. On the other
hand, the petitioners were direct recruits and were entitled to
promotion after 7 years oi service from the date of appointment,
as their subsequent confinnation related back to that date. It is
contended that the first respondent, contrary to these rules.
appointed respondents 2 to 34 as officiating Executive Engineers
they had completed 7 years of actual service after the date
before
c of confinnation
and particularly in the case of employees from
the erstwhile State of Hyderabad it had, contrary to the rules
relating to promotion, by a resolution dated the 23rd February
1967 directed respondents 3, 4, 6 to 14 to be treated as having
been appointed in the reorganised Bombay State as temporary
Deputy Engineers with effect from 31st March 1937 only for the
D purpose of fixation oi their seniority in the grade of Deputy
Engineers and for promotion to higher posts. By so directing,
respondent No. 1 conferred, in an arbitrary manner, an advantage on the said respondents to the detriment of the petitioners
while, as a matter of fact, those respondents had not completed
either 7 years of actual service after confirmation as required by
E the rules nor did they have even 7 years' service as officiating
Deputy Engineers on the date of promotion as officiating Executive Engineers.
F
G
H
In order to understand the contentions urged on behalf of the
petitioners it will be necessary to state briefly the history al the
service and the several resolutions which are applicable to them in
respect of recruitment as well as seniority. The Bombay and
subsequeiltly the Maharashtra service of engineers consists of
Class I and Class II (Deputy Engineers). They were initially
governed by rules framed under the resolutions of the Government in the Public Works Department dated the 22nd March
1937. The recruitment to these services both in class I and class
II was partly bv direct recruitment and partly by promotion from
amongst the members of the lower cadres. In 1939 fur.her rules
were made to· regulate the method of recruitment to the State
services. Under these rules recruitment to the Bombay Service
of Engineers Class I was to be from two sources, ( 1) by nomination under r. 3 by virtue of the guarantee given to the engineering college of Poona and (2) by promotion from the existing
Bombay Service of Engineers (since discontinued) or from the
Bombay Service of Engineers Class TI. The recruitment to
the Bombay Service of Engineers Class n under the rules Of 1939
~18
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1970] 2 $.C.R.
was also to be similarly from two sources, ( 1 ) by nomination
under r. 11 in accordance with the guarantee to the Royal College
of Poona (which was withdrawn in 1947) and (2) by promotion
from (a) Bombay Subordinate Engineer Service, (b) permanent
and temporary supervisors and ( c) temporary engineers appointed on annual sanction. These rules however did not specify the
principles upon which the seniority of the di~ect recruits and the
promotee officers was to be determined. The Government of
Bombay accordingly by a resolution dated 21st November 1941
laid down the following principles to be applicable to direct
recruits and promoted officers in the provincial service except the
·
Bombay Service of Engineers Class I : ( 1) "In the case of direct recruits appointed directly
on probation, the seniority should be determined with
reference to the date of their appointment on probation;
(2) In the case of officers promoted to substantive
vacancies the seniority should be determined with
reference to the date of their promotion to the substantive vacancies provided there has been no break in
service prior to their confirmation in those vacancies."
•
It may here be stated that the Bombay Government had appointed
a committee known as Gurjar Committee to examine whether class
I and class II cadres in the said services should be continued or
whether they should 1Je combined into one class and what should
be the ratio between the direct recruits and the departmental
promotees to the said service. The Committee made it~ recommendations in 1951. The Government after due considerations
of the recommendation$ and the earlier ;rules regulating the
condition of service in the Bombay Service of Engineers passed a
re5olution dated 29th April 1960 setting down the principles for
recruitment to the Bombay Service of Engineers Class I and Class
II. Before this resolution, as we have noticed earlier, the Deputy
Engineers Class II service cadre consisted of (a) direct recruits
to the Bombay Service of Engineers Class II, (b) Deputy Engineers confirmed from the subordinate services of Engineers, ( c)
temporary deputy engineers recruited by the Bombay Public
Service Commission and ( d) officiating Deputy Engineers and
siimlar other categories. These four categories were being com piled into 2 lists only, namely, ( l) Bombay Service of Engineers
Class II cadre of permanent Deputy Engineers and (2) the list of
officiating . Deputy Engineers. It also further continued the
existing constitution of class I and class II engineering service.
. The appointments to be made were to be both by direct recruitment through the competitive examinations held by the Public
. Seivice Commission and by promotion, provided however that
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
1'. Y. JOS.lil v. MAHAMSH!il (Reddy, J.)
A
619
lhe ratio of appointments by nomination and by promotion shall
as rar as pracucabie oy 7:i : 25. The canuiaates appointed to
e1lher ot me two services by nomination had to be on probation
tor 24 years before being confinned provided t.urther that an
Assistant Engineer would be confirmed as Executive Engineer after
nine years' service unless the period is exiended by the government. The Deputy Engineers Permanent in class II cadre had
put in at least 1:i years of service in class II in temporary and
permanent capacities and must be officiating executive Engineers
at tne time ot their absorption.
'°
c
D
E
F
G
H
The resolution ol 1960 provided that in future recrui!I!J.ent to
Bomoay Service of Engineers class II cadre shall be made ( 1) by
nommation of canaiaates recruited directly by a competitive
exanunation held oy the Commission and (2) by promotion from
the list of ofhciatmg Deputy Engineers. The direct recruitment
01 temporary Deputy Engmeers was to cease and the officiating
vacancies were to be. filled from the ranks of subordinate service
of Engineers tor which purpose a statewise select seniority list of
members of the subordinate service ol Engineers cadre considered
fit to hold sub-divisional charges was to be compiled and main·
tained as on 30th June each year. On July 29, 1963 the Government of Bombay further amended the rules prescribed in Government Resolution of November 21, 1941 for regulating the seniority
C'f direct recruits and promoted officers. In supersession of the
previous rules it proviaed that the seniority of the direct recruits
is to be determined according to the date of appointment on
probation and of the promotees according to the date of promotion
to officiate continuously irrespective ol whether the appointments
are made in temporary or in permanent vacancies subject to the
provisions contained therein.
In so far as promotion from lower to higher grade of post is
concerned, the principle of seniority-cum-merit was always followed by the Government which subsequently also formed tl1e
bases of the Government resolution dated 18th December 1950
which inter alia prescribed that no officer who had positive qualification should be passed owr by an officer junior to him unless
the latter had in addition really exceptional ability or qualification.
This resolution was passed after consultation of the Bombay
Public Service Commission and in supersession ol the orders of
the previous resolutions dated 22nd May 1944, 23rd March 1945
and the 18th March 1947. Thereafter by another resolution
dated 4th March 1957 the principle for the preparation and maintenance of a select list of Deputy Engineers who were considered
fit for promotion as Executive Engineers was formulated.
Acoording to this resolution,. a committee consi~ting of 3 Chl•f
Engineers under the chairmanship of the senior Chief Engineer
L3Sup:CJ'/7()-9
'··
620
SUPRiME COURT REPORTS
(1970] 2 S.C.R.
was to review in December each year the claim of officers in the
Bombay Service oi Engineers class II for promotion to the post of
Executive Engineer. This committee had to prepare a select list
with due regard to the provisions of the government resolution
dated the 18th December 1950. Likewise, the Government by a
resolution dated 20th August 1965, revising its previous resolution
dated 24th August 1954 and 14th December 1959, formulated
the principles for preparation, maintenance and revision of a list
of overseers fit for promotion as Deputy Engineers. Under this
resolution statewise list as on !st April of every year of each of the
categories of overseers had to be made comprising of ( 1) graduate
overseers, (2) diploma holder overseers (DCB-Poona) or equi·
valent, (3) subordinate overseers holding the Diploma oi the
Osmania University, and ( 4) non qualified overseers. The length
of service required for eligibility to promotion to the post of
officiating Deputy Engineer in respect of the first category W:li 3
years, second category 8 years, third category 10 years including
past service as sub-overseers of those allocated from the
ex-Hyderabad State, and fourth category 13 years.
We may now briefly state the different grades of service and
the channels of promotion in the Engineering service of the
Maharashtra State created as a consequence of the various rules.
At the apex of the service are the Chief Engineers, Superinter.iing
Engineers and the Executive Engineers who constitute class I
service. The channels of promotion to the cadre of Executive
Engineers is from two sources, (a) direct recruit to class ! Assistant Engineers, and ( 2) Deputy Engineers class II. The
cadre of Deputy Engineers class II is constituted by direc~ iecruits
75 per cent and promotees 25 rer cent. The channels of promotion to the promotecs class I were from temporary engineers
and from the subordinate service, namely, graduate engineers,
now known as junior engineers, diploma holder overseers and
junior or non-technical overseers promoted from still lower ranks.
The case of the first respondent and the other respondents is
that the 7 years' qualifying service required for promotion as Offi.
ciating Executive Engineers is continuous officiating service as
Deputy Enigneer and not as contended by the petitioners to be
reckoned from the date of confirmation as Deputy Engineer>. It
is contended first, that the interpretation of rr. 6, 7 and 8 of the
1960 Resolution does not ex facie lend itself to the interpretation
suggested by the petitioners; secondly, that it ignores the subsequent amendment effected by the 1963 Resolution; thirdly, that
for the purpose of promotion the seniority which is relevant is
not the seniority in the department but the seniority in the Select
List to be prepared in accordance with the Resolution of 1957 in
which the petitioners cuL1ld not ~nu did not find a place during the
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
I'. Y. JOSHI v. MAHARASilTli (Jteddy, J,)
G21
A
relevant period, fourthly, the basis of promotion being senioritycum-merit the petitioners who had at no ti~e complained 'that
their names were not considered cannot complain ol a violation of
Art. 14 or Art. 16, nor could a writ of mandamus lie in such
circumstances; and fifthly, that the Resolutions to which references
have been made and which are relied upon by the J?etitioners are
B . not made ei•her under Art. 309 or any other provis10n of law but
are merely executive instructions which the Government would be
entitled to issue in the absence of rules which have statutory bind·
ing force. In so far as respondents who are allotted from Hyderabad service are concerned, it ii: contended that they were all
selected by the Hyderabad Public Service Commission in June
1956 and would have been appointed as Assistant Engineers in
C that State in a few months had not States reorganisation taken
place. In view of the tact that they had been selected by the
predecessor State and also the successor state it was open to the
Government to make the appointment of the respondents having
regard to the various provisions of the States R~ganisation Act,
and accordingly the Government directed that their appointments
D be treated as temporary Deputy Engineers effective from 31-3-1957
for the purpose of seniority and promotion. What in fact the
Government has done is to recognise the just claims of those who
had ·already been selected for class I posts in the Hyderabad State
which posts have been equated with the post of Deputy Engineers
in the Bombay State while arriving at the equation envisaged under
E the States Reorganisation Act and under the allotted Government
Service Rules of 19 57. In fact the claim of the respondents was
that the Assistant Engineers of class I of the Hyderabad State
should be equated with the posts of Assistant Engineers Chss I
of the Bombay State.
F
G
H
Shri Gupte learned counsel for the petitioners however contends
that all the respondents from the erstwhile Hyderabad State were
allotted to the Bombay State as overseers which posts they were
holding substantively on and after 1st November 1956. They
were thereafter promoted as officiating Deputy Engineers between
1958 and 1963 and were not confirmed in their respective posts
on the date when they were appointed officiating Executive Engineers.. The learned Advocate further contends that these persons
were m fact not appointed as Assista11t Engineers in the erstwhile
Hyderabad State though they might have been selected by the
Hyderabad Public Service Commission ar.d that in any case as the
Bombay Public Service Commission did not select them they could
not be cla_ssified in the category of temporary Deputy Engineers
selected by the Bombay Public Service Commission. Apart from
this category, there are respondents who were appointed as offi·
ciating Deputy &gineers before the reorganisation on 1st November 1956 and were confirmed only after the petitioners were directly
SUPREME COURT REPORIS
[ 197UJ j S.C.R.
appointed. The first petitioner was appointc<l on 9th June 1959,
the second petitioner on 11th June 19:i9 and the third petitioner
on 12th June 1959. Though the petitioners were confirmed 2
years thereafter, namely, on 9th June 1961, 24th June 1961 and
the 18th June 1961 respectively, none the less for the purpose of
seniority the dates on which they were first appointed in June 1959
would be relevant dates because confirmation under the rules
relates back to that date and therefore they would be senior to
those respondents who were confirmed thereafter. There are yet
a few respondents who were promoted as officiating Deputy Engineers after the 1st November J 956, namely, those persons who
were non gazetted sub divisional officers of the former State of
Madhya Pradesh and the former State of Hyderabad who were
treated as Deputy Engineers from lst November 1956 and there
were others who were not so deemed but were not cr>nfinned as
Deputy Engineers on the date when they were promoted as officiating Executive Engineers. The contention of Shri Gupte in the
main is that officiating Deputy Engineers could only be considered
as promoted to the grade of Deputy Engineers on confirmation and
therefore the 7 years qualifying service necessary for their being
promoted as officiating executive engineers is to be reckoned from
the date of their confirmation as Deputy Engineers and since good
many of them were confirmed after the appointment of the petitioners and most of them were not so confirmed even on the date
of their promotion as Executive Engineers under the rules they
would not be entitled to those promotions. Shri Chagla and Shri
Kumaramangalam, on the other hand, contend that the rules nowhere prohibit the promotion to Executive Engineers from officiating Deputy Engineers, nor is tfiere anything to indicate either
expressly or otherwise that the 7 years' qualifying service should
be from the date of confirmation. All that is required is that a
person in order to become eligible for promotion as officiating
Deputy Engineer should be promoted as Deputy Engineer that in
either case he should have 7 years in that capacity whether as permanent Deputy Engineer or continuosly as an officiating Deputy
Engineer and that he should be selected and put on a Select List.
The respondents, it is contended, have fulfilled all these requirements. The second respondent who appeared in person h3s
adopted these arguments of the learned Advocate for the respondents.
We may here read the relevant rules as set out in tile rc-spcctivc
resolutions.
1957 Rules( 1) Government should review in December cacl\ vear the
claims of all officers in the Bombay Service of Engineers, -Class JI
for promotion to the posts of Executive Engineers by setting up a
Committee consistin_g of the three Chief Engineers under the
A
B
c
D
F
G
H
P. Y. JOSHI v. MAHARASHTRA (Reddy, /.)
A
B
.c
D
E
623
Chairmanship of the Senior Chief Engineer, which should draw up
a select list of those considered by them suitable for promotion.
( 2) The Committee should scrutinise the case of each officer
and prepare a select list with regard to the provisions of Government Resolution and Government Circular Memorandum,
Political and Services Department Nos. 4099 I 34, dated the 18th
December, 1950. Only such officers should be selected for inclusion in the select list as hav~ put in at least seven years' service
(excluding the period of training but including the period of probation) in the grade of Deputy Engineer. The officers should
also possess the necessary personality, initiate, strength of character, fitness to assume independent responsibility and capacity for
outdoor as well as office work. No officer should be included in
the Select list merely on the negative ground that he is not manifestly unfit.
( 3) The seniority of the officers on the Select list should be
determined by the date of entry of their names in the select list.
The seniority inter se of officers whose names are entered on the
same day should be determined in accordance with their seniority
in the Class II cadre, unless in consultation with the Commission,
it is decided to give an officer accelerated promotion on account
of really exceptional ability or qualification.
( 4) The Committee should submit to Government the Select
List for approval in consultation with the Bombay Public Service
Commission. While submitting the list, the Committee should
give full justification for supersession involved, if any, and full
information regarding qualifications and previous service of those
recommended to be brought on the Select List should be given.
•
F
•
•
•
•
•
1960 RulesG
H
6. (i) The number of posts to be filled in the Bombay Service
of Engineers, Class I by promotion of officers from the Bombay
Service d Engineers, Class II shall be about 25 i;er cent of the
total number of superior posts, in th~ Bombay Service of Engin~ers~ Cjass I cadre; this percentage should be aimed at for ~onfir·
~24
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1970] 2 s.c.R.
mations made after 1st November 1956, subject of course, to
Class II officers of the requisite fituess and length of service being
available.
(ii) For absorption into Class I, a Class II Officer must be in
the permanent Bombay Service of Engineers, Class II ~adre, should
have at least 15 years service to his credit in Cla~s II in temp_or~ry
and permanent capacities, and should be . holdrng an officiating
divisional rank at the time of such absorption. On such absorption, the Class' II Officer shall be confirmed as an Executive
Engineer.
(iii) The seniority of the Class n promotees shall be fixed
below the bunch of Assistant Engineers, any one of whom is due
for confirmation as Executive Engineer during that calendar year,
provided that no Class II promotee shall be placed senior to a
direct recruit to Class I Assistant Engineer who has been officiating
as Executive Engineer from a date earlier than the Clas! II promotee. In the latter case, the Class II promotee, though holding
a post and lien as a confirmed Executive Engineer shall be shown
both under permanent Engineers, and, also along with the direct
recruited Class I Assistant Engineers with a !uitable remark under
the Permanent "Executive Engineers list. Thi& is also subject to
further conditions as in paragraph 7 below.
7. (i) Since the percentages in the superior posts of direct
Class I recruits and promotees from Class Il is to be ·about 75 an~
25, the number of promotions from Class Il in any year would be
about one third the number of direct recruited Assi,tant Engineers
confirmed as Executive Engineers during that year. Recruitments
in the past have, however, been erratic and insufticient even to the
extent of there being no recruitments to Class I in certftin vears.
In order to deal with such situations, the following rules shall be
supplemental and exceptional to those in paragraph 6 above : (ii) As far as possible, promotions as officiating Executive
Engineers shall be so made that the promotee, under consideration
from Class II has to his credit at least 6 years longer service than
a promotee under consideration from Class I, subject. ~' frr as
practicable, to the condition that a Class I Officer shall not hold
a divisional rank at less than 4, and a Class II Officer at less than
7 years service.
Subject to availabilities, and, the above criteria. an attempt
should be made to maintain the percentages. stated in parn!!l"ar>h
6 ( i) above, between direct Class I and promoted Class II officers
in the total of permanent plus officiating superior posts.
(iii) In the interests of manning superior administrative ranks.
it is considered necessary to have at least two confirmations to the
Executive Engineers ranks every year. In years when this is not
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
P. Y. JOSHI v. MAHARASHTRA' (Reddy, J.)
ezs
A
possible of achievement according to the percentages as per (i)
above, the number of promotions from Class II may be increased
to get the two confirmations, mentioned hereinabove.
Per contra, there would be a reduction in the percentage promotions from Class II in the following years in order to work up
to the overall percentages of about 75 to 25.
B
(iv) Confirmatiom, if any, made from ·the bunch of Temporary Executive Engineers, who have, at present lien on no cadre,
shall be counted against the 25 per cent meant for the non-direct
recruits to Bombay Service of Engineers, Class I.
8. (i) The Sub-Divisional posts in the Department are, at
present, manned by direct recruits to Bombay Service of Engineers,
Class II cadre, Deputy Engineers confirmed from subordinate
Service of Engineers, the temporary Deputy Engineers recruited by
the Bombay Public Service Commission, officiating Deputy Engineers and similar other categories. These various categories are
being compiled into two lists only viz. Bombay Service of Enginers,
D Class II cadre of permanent Deputy Engineers and a list ~ Officiating Deputy Engineers. The future recruitments to Bombay
Service of Engineers, Class II cadre shall be made by nomination
of candidates recruited direct by competitive examination, held by
the Commission, and, by promotions from the list of officiating
Deputy Engineers. The number of such promotions shall be about
one-third the.number of direct recruits appointed in that year.
E
(ii) All direct recruitment of temporary Deputy Engineers
having been stopped, further officiating vacancies will be manned
from the ranks of the Subordinate Service of Engineers. For thi~
purpose, a statewise Select Seniority List will be maintained of
members of the Subordinate Service of Engineers cadre, considered fit to hold subdivisional charges. This list shall be compiled
F as on 30th June each year.
For inclusion in this list a graduate shall have to his credit
not less than 3; a diploma holder not less than 8, and, a non.
qualified person not less than 13 years' service as ovcrilecr.
c
G
H
For confirmation as a Deputy Eni;ineer, the Officer would be
expected to have put in not less than 3 years' service as Officiating
Deputy Engineer.
(iii) The probationers recruited directly to in the Bombay
Service of Engineers, Class n cadre in any year shall, in a bunch,
be placed senior to promotees confirmed during that year.
1963 Rules( A) The seniority of direct recruits and promoted officers in
the State services should be determined according to the tkte of
62,6
StJP!UiMI COtJR.T QPORTi
[1970) 2 S.C.R,
appointment on probation in the case of direct recruits . . . .
and according to the date of promotion to officiate continuously
in the case of these appointed by promotion, irrespective of whether the appointments are made in temporary or in permanent
vacancies, subject to the provisions of the following clauses : B
(B) A list of services in respect of which special orders for
fixation of seniority are in force and to which these orders will not
apply will be issued in due course.
It would be apparent from the 1941 rules that lhey merely
provide for fixation of seniority of the direct recruits and officers
promoted to the substantive vacancies but have nothing to do with
the qualifications required for promotion to the next higher rank.
Rule 6 of 1960 deals with class I posts. Clauses l, 2 and 3 of
this nde provide ( 1) that 25 per cent posts in clas8 I are to be
filled up by promO!ees, (2) that for absorption into class I. class
II Officer must have (a) permanent service in class II cadre, (b)
have 15 years ol servi<:l? In clas~ n in temporary and permanent
capacities, and ( c) that he must be holding an officiating divisional rank_ at the time of such absorption. Clause 3 deals with
inter se seniority between the Assistant En~ineers and Class Il
promotees to the post of Executive Engineers. The abs.orption
referred to in r. 6 is a permanent absorption because cl. 2 provides
that on such absorption the clas.s Il officers shall be confirmed as
Executive Engineers, Clause 6 ·gives no indication that class H
officers whether direct recruits or promotees cannot be prom.Jic:d
as officiating Executive Engineers. That is dealt with by cl. 2 of
as officiating Engineers. That is dealt with by cl. 2 of r. 7 which
r. 7 which provides that Class II officers should have as far as possible at least 6 years longer service than the promotee under consideration from class I, viz., Assistant Engineers, and further that
be· should at least have seven years service.. Even this rule does
not indicate that the qualifvin~ service of either of six years or of
7 years specified in the rule has to be permanent service. In cl,
(ii) of r. 6 it is provided that 15 years of service in class II for
ab&orPtion as Executive En~neer can be in temJ)Orary or perma·
nent cat1acities. There i.~ nothing in r, (ii) to militate against the
interpretation that the service specified there can he the total service of anv description whether orovisional. temoorary or penna·
nent. If oromotion frnm clas' n a• officiatinQ" Executive En~neer
can onlv be made after 7 veArs of oennanent service, then there
would be no meaninR" in inclt1din2 the temoorArv service in class II
for the t111rpose of absorotion as Executive Enllineer; Even r. 8
upon which -Shri Oupte has laid ~re at emphasis in supPort of his
contontion, does. not. in-our view, justify an interpretatjon that the
c
D
E
-·I
I
F
I
1
G
ff
p, Y. JOSHI V. MAHAlASHTRA. {Reddy., J,)
A
627
7 years' service required to entitle persons in class IT for promotion
as an officiating Executive Engineer should be permanent service in
class IT. Shri Gupte however relied on the requirement in cl. (ii) of
r. 8 that the recruitment to Bombay Service of Engineers, Class TI
cadre shall in so far as promotees are concerned be by promotion
from the list of officiating Deputy Engineers. Relying on this rule
B the learned Advocate contends that for promotion as Deputy
Engineer Class II he must be on the list of officiating Deputy
Engineers before he is entitled to promotion as Deputy Engineer
Clilss II and be confirmed in that po>t after satisfying the requirements of 3 years' service as officiating Deputy Engineer. Until
he is so confirmed. he will not be considered to have been promotc ed as Deputy Engineer or to belong to class TI service for p•omotion as officiating Executive Engineer as required under cl. (ii)
of r. 7. As we have seen earlier, cl. (ii) of r. 7 does not use the
'Yord 'belong' b~t requires only that the person u~der consider~·
tton for promotion should be from class II service. To be m
cla8s II service the Deputy Engineer promoted from subordinate
service has to put in at least 3 years of service as officiating Deputy
D Engineer· before being confirmed and thereafter he can when he
is p•omoted to the next higher ramk be confirmed as Executive
Engineer if .he has put in 15 years in class TI service in temporary
or permanent capaeities and is holding'. an officiating divisional
rank, namely of an Executive Engineer. If temporary service can
be taken into account for confirmation as an Executive Engineer,
E so can officiating service, and if officiating service can be taken into
consideration, there is no impediment to a Deputy Erigineer with
1 years' service whether officiating, temporary or permanent to
entitle hitri for promotion as an Executive Engineer.
The list that Is reterred to in cl. ( i) of r. 8 must be read with
the. further provision in that ru1e that for in.clusion in that list of
F persons a graduate shlill nave to his credit not less than 3, a
diploma holder not less .than 8 and a non qualified per8Qil not less
th.llli. 13 years of service as ove11eers. In our view it is the ).ist
qf such.persons that is referred to in cl. (ii) of r. 8 and not that
there .sh0J1ld be a list ol. persons actually officiating as Engineers
for further promotion to the same post which will have little mean.
G ing, for there cannot be a promotion of a person in the sallle cadre
of. service who ls already promoted whether as. an officiating or
teD1pcirary .or permanent incumbent, If cl. (i) of r. 8 provides
that class ti cadre shall. be recruited by competitive examination,
the vt'Qnio!ees. al~o are prdm,oted from the list of persons considered
flt to hold .sub diyisiQnal charge, i.e., posts of .Deputy Engineers.
It In. the c·~se ~ direct recruits the appointllient is Without reference
H
to cotlf!nn~tion, it. cal\IlOt be any different in the case of promotees.
We camiot,., $erofore;
the contention of Shri Gupte that
·ir promotee olll4iatin~ Peputy Engineer Class U is not entitled to
accem
628
SUPIU!ME· COURT RllPORTS
(1970] 2 sc.R.
be considered for promotion under r. 7 to tlw post of an officiating
Executive Engineer lllllless he has put in 7 years of service from
the date of confirmation. On the other hand, the subsequent
resolution of the Govermuent of 1963 makes it abundantly clear
that the seniority of promotees should be considered a8 from the
date of promotion to officiate continuously irrespect:ve of whether
the appoi:ntments are made in temporary or permanent vacancies.
It is no doubt submitted that this does not have the force of rules
and cannot therefore have the effect of amendinl( the rules of 1960.
As we have already held on an interpretation of the rules of 1960
that they do not support the contention of the petitioners, the
question whether the resolutiQll has the force of rules may not be
relevant in this context, but none the less in our view, there is
force in the contention of Shri Kumaramangalam, learned advocate for the respondents, that even the 1960 rules h·.1ve no statutory force aind are no better than the executive instructions issued
from time to time by means of resolutions. It may be observed
that the rules referred to are part of the resolution of 1960. The
resolution itself lays down the principles and in the end formulates
those principles in terms of rules, which however are not purported
to be made under any provision of law or even under Art. 309,
There also is nothing to indicate that the procedure and fonnalitie~
required for making rules have been gone through.
A
B
c
D
It is next contended that the persons from the Hvderabad
St:rvice did not have 7 years even as offi.ciatinq Deputy EnjJinecrs E
but were only deemed to have been appointed as temporary engineers as from 31-3-1957. This contention also, in our view, has
no force because the respondents who were from Jl'~·derabad State
were in fact selected by the Hyderabad Public Service Commission
as Assistant Engineers and would have. been appointed as such
but for the States Reorganisation Act which came into force as F
from 1-11-1956. Had thev been appointed earlier. they would
have had to be equated with the posts in Bombay. In fact as the
notification issued bv the Hyderabad Public Service Commission
furnished by Mr. Joshi shows. the candidates who were to be
selected were required to serve in any of the districts of Hyderabad
State. Hyderabad proper or accordinl( to the allocation in the
reor~anised set up of the State if and when it took place. It was,
therefore, in the contemplation of the Public Service Commis~lon
that the State would !:le reorgainised and the candidates selected
may be required to serve in the reorganised State. The allocation
of persons alter the reoro:anisation from one State to the other was
•ubject to the Reorganisation Act which dealt with matters pertaining to allocation, transfer, fixation of service conditions, seniority H
etc. The claims of the resporidents who were allotted from the
H~bad State arose earlier than the appointments of the petitioners and the Govemment of Bombay and subllequently the
•
P. Y. JOSHI V. MAHARASHTRA (Reddy, J.)
A
B
c
D
E
F
H
629
Maharashtra Government was entitled to consider these claims
and to ~ve redress.
It ii again argued that if they had a claim under the States
Reorganisation Act, they should have been treated as Deputy
Engineers from 1st Nov. 1956 and not from 31st March 1957
and therefore they could not be considered as having been dealt
with under the States Reorganisation Act. We are unable to
accept the force of this argument because it was open to th~
Govemmeint of the State to which they were allotted to take into
consideration the fact that they would have been appointed in the
erstwhile State from a particular date, to treat them as such and
to equate their posts which they would have held. In these circumstances, there is no statutory bar or rule which prohibits the
Government of Maharashtra from deeming their appointment as
from 31-3-1957 for the limited purpose of seniority and promotiQD..
Apart from these contentions it appears to us that there is
another formidable obstacle in the way of the petitioners' success
and it is that under the 1957 Resolution for promotion to the post
of officiating Executive Engineers, they should be put on the Select
List by a committee of the Chief EnginCers to be prepared each
year for that purpose. When promotions are made on· the basis
of seniority-cum-merit, all that can be required is that persons
entitled to promotion should be considered and if ha·:ing been
considered they have been left out, they would have no claim to
p~omotion as a matter of right. lJ1 State of Mysore v. Syed
Mahmood(') this Court had so held. Bachawat, J. speaking for
the Court observed at p. 366.
"Where tht promotion is based on seniority-cum·
merit the officer cannot claim promotion as a matter Of
right by virtue cl. his seniority alone. If he is found unfit
to discharge the duties of the higher post, he may be
passed over and an officer junior to him may be
promoted."
It is however stated that no list was made for 1966 which is the
crucial year in so far as the petitioners are concerned because their
7 years would have been completed in June 1965 and they would
have been entitled to be considered for promotion in 1966. In
aill6wer to this contention the affidavit on behalf of the respondents
shows that the select list of the Deputy Engineers fit for promotion
to the post of Executive Engineers in class .I '!as prepared for ~e
year 1964 and 1965 according to the pnnc1ples and rules 181~
down in the resolutions of 14th December 1957 ~ 29th .Apnl
1960. None cA the petitioners, it is averred, was included IQ the
Select Liat for 1964 or 1965 because not only did any of them not
[1] [19SB] 3 S. C. R.
)eJ,•
630
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1970] 2 s.c.R.
have the requisite seven years' service as Deputy Engineer at the
relevant time but they were also not entitled to be included because
of the classes of recommendation earned by them during the relevant period. The petitioners however denied in their rejoinder
that the lists were prepared keeping in view the criteria faid down
by the rules, but, in our view, it is signiiicant that they did not
possess the required length of service in class II for them to be
Mtitled to promotion when the respondents were included in the list
and promoted as such they cannot challenge the appointment•
made as being in violation of Art. 14 or Art. 16.
In the result these petitions merit dismissal and are ~ccordingly
dismissed.
Y.P.
Petitions dismissed.
A
B
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org