STATE OF WEST BENGAL versus JUGAL KISHORE MORE & ANR.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 10 January 1969 | [1969] 3 S.C.R. 320 | 1969 INSC 7
Key facts
- Decided
- 10 January 1969
- Bench
- J.C. SHAH*, V. RAMASWAMI, A.N. GROVER
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 14/1968
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1969] 3 S.C.R. 320
- Neutral citation
- 1969 INSC 7
Text of the judgment
STATE OF WEST BENGAL
v.
JUGAL KISHORE MORE & ANR.
A
Janµary 10, 1969
J. C. SHAH, V. RAMASWAMI AND A, N. GROVER, JJ.J
Extradition-N~ture. of-:-Fugitive Offenders Act (44 & 45 Viet c. 69
B
o{ .1881)-Inapp/1cab1lity m Republic of India, if bar to obtain ntra-
d~t~on of fugitive offenders from another Commonwealth country-Extra-
d1110n Act (34 of 1962), effect of.
After this Court held. in. Sto·te of Madras v. C. G. Menon, [1~51 1
S.C.R. 280 that the Fugitive Offenders Act 1881 was inconsistent with
Art. 14 of the Constitution and was on th;t acco~nt unenfOrceable after
26th January 1950, the Government of India, Ministry of External Affairs
issued a notification on May 21, 1955 indicating the procedure for securing the presence of a fugitive offender in India from the United Kingdom
and other Commonwealth countries. Under the Notification, the Magis-
c
trate concerned is to issue a warrant of arrest of the fugitive offender
under the Criminal Procedure Code, 1898, and the warrant is to be sent
to the Government of India, Ministry of External Affair& through the
concerned State Government. Thereafter, the Ministry is to address the
appropriate authority in the Commonwealth country through the High
Commissioner for India for the surrender of the fugitive offender.
In 1962, the Indian Extradition Act was passed, but as Hon& Kong
was not included in the First Schedule, that Act could not be resorted
for the surrender of the respondent who was a fugitive offender residing
in Hong Kong.
Action was therefore taken in the present case, pursuant
to the notification. The Chief Presidency Magistrate Calcutta issued a
warrant under the Criminal Procedure Code for the arrest of the respondent and the warrant was forwarded by the Government of West Bengal
. to the Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India. The Ministry
forwarded the warrant to the High Commissioner for India, Hong Kong,
who in his turn requested the Colonial Secretary, Hong Kong, for an
order extraditing the respondent under the Fugitive Offenders Act 1881
(44 & 45 Viet Ch. 69). The Central Magistrate, Hong Kong, endorsed
the warrant and directed the Hong Kong police to arrest the respondent
referring to the Republic of India as a British possession to which the
Fugitive Offenders Act was applicable.
E
F
On the questions : (I ) Whether the Chief Presidency Magistrate had
no power to issue the warrant as it would have extr:i-tenitorial operation;
(2) Whether the Fugitive Offenders Act, having ceased to be part of the
Jaw of India, could be resorted to for obtaining extradition of fugitive
offenders; (3) Whether the instructions of the Government of India for
G
obtaining extradition are..an invasion upon the authority of courts; a.n?
( 4) Whether the Extrad11!6n Act, 1962, operates as a bar to the requlSltion made by the Ministry of External Affairs for the extradition of the
respondent,
HELD : (I) The Courts of the country which make a requisitio~ for
surrender proceed upon prima facie proof of the offence .and leave it to
the State to make a requisition upon the other State, in which the offender•
has taken refuge. Under s. 82 of the Criminal Procedure Code. when a
·warrant is issued by a Magistrate in India, it can be executed anywhere
H
WEST BENGAL V, JUGAL KISHORE
A
B
c
D
E
F
321
in India and has no extra-territorial operation. By making a requisition
to another State, in pursuance of such a Wflrrant, for assistance in securing
the presence of the offender, the warrant is not invested with extraterritorial operation. If the other State requested agrees to lend its aid
to arrest the fugitive, the arrest is made by the issue of an independent
warrant or endorsement or authentidation of the warrant of the court
which issued it. By such endorsement or authentication the State expresses its willingness to lend its assistance in implementation of treaties
or international commitments to secure the arrest of the offender. The
offender arrested pursuant to the warrant or endorsement is brought before the Court of the country to which requisition is made and that cuort
holds enquiry to determine whether the offender may be extradited. [326 F327B]
Courts in India have no authority to sit in judgment over the order
passed by the Hong Kong Magistrate. He acted in accordance with the
municipal law of Hong Kong and agreed to surrender the offender : his
action cannot be challenged in this Court even if it is wrong. The invalidity of the· arrest in Hong Kong, if any, cannot affect the jurisdiction of
Indian Courts to try the respondent if and when he is brought here. [334
EJ
Emperor v. Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, l.L.R. 35 Born. 225,
approved ..
(2) But, in fact the Colonial Secretary of Hong Kong was, according
to the Jaw applicable in Hong Kong, competent to give effect to the
warrant issued by the Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta and the Central Magistrate, ~ong Kong had jurisdiction under the Fugitive Offenders
Act to direct that the respondent may be surrendered to India. Whatever
may be the position in India after it has become a Republic the United
Kingdom and several Colonies have treated the Fugitive Offenders Act
as applicable for the purpose of honouring the requisition made by the
Republic of India. Merely because, for the purpose of the extradition
procedure, in a statute passed before the attainment of independence by
the former colonie·s and dependencies, certain territories dpntinue to be
referred as 'British Possessions' the ·statute does not become inapplicable
to those territories. The expression 'British Possessions' in the old
statutes me'rely. s1,.1rvives as an artificial mode of reference. Though it is
not consistent with the political realities, it does not imply political depeo..
dence of the Governments of the territories referred to. The order of
surrender passed by the Magistrate in Hong Kong was vaJid according to.
the law in force in Hong Kong. [338 H; 3370)
Re. Government of India and Mubarak A.Ii Ahmed, [!952] 1 All E.R.
1060, Re. Kweshi A.rm<h [1966) 2 All E.R. 1006, Zacharia v. Republic
of Cyprus, [1962] 2 All. E.R. 438 and Halsbury's Laws of England 3rd
Edn. Vol. 5 Art. 987, p. 433, referred to.
G
(3) This Court, by holding in C. G. Menon's case that since India
became a Republic the Fugitive Offenoers Act could not be enforced in
this country, presented the Government of India with a problem which
had to be resolved by devising a machinery for securing the presence of
offenders \Vho were fugitives from justice.
H
The notification was issued
only in the nature of advice about the· procedure to be followed and was
not in any manner intended as an affront to the Courts or to impose any
executive will upon the courts in judicial matters. [339 E-FJ
Jn the present case, the Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta, had
power to. issue the warrant for the arrest of the respondent bCcause there
was prfma facie evidence against him.
If the. warrant was to be success·
322
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969] 3 S.C.R.
fully executed. against the. respondent, who was not in India, the assistallce
of the execbtive government had to be obtained._ Therefort, the is.!ue of
the warrant a~d the procedure followed in transmitting· it were not illegal
and not even irregular.
.( 4) Extradition is the surrender by one Slate to anothe!' of a person
desired to be dealt with for crimes of which he had been accused or convicted. Such a surrender is a political act done in pursuance of a treaty
or ."!' ad hoc arrangement, and founded upon the pi'inciple that it is in
the interest of all civilised communities that criminals should not go unpunished. While the law relating to extradition between independent
States is based on treaties, whether an offender · shoUid' be handed over
pursuant to a requisition is determined by the domestic law of the State
on which the requisition is made. Therefore, the fact that the Extradition Ac~, 1962, could not be availed of for securing the presence of the
respondent for ·trial in India, did not operate as a bar' to the requisition
made by the Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India, if t&ey
were able to pursuade the Colonial Secretary; Hong Kong,
deliver"the
respondent for trial in this country. If the Colonial Secretary was willing
to do so, it cannot be said that the warrant issued by the Chief Presidency
Magistrate; Calcutta, for the arrest of the respondent with the aid of the
requisition for securing his presence from Hong Kong in India, was illegal.
[325 H; 340 C-E]
to
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.
14 of 1968.
Appeal by special leave from the judgment and order dated
April 20, 1967 of the Calcutta High Court in Criminal Revision
No. 502 of 1966.
B. Sen and P. K. Chakravarti, for the appellants.
A
B
c
D
E
A. S. R. Chari, B. P. Maheshwari and Sobhag Mal Jain, for
respondent No. I.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Sbllk J. In the course of investigation of offences under
ss. 420, 467, 4 71 and 120 B.I.P. Code the Officer in charge of the
investigation submitted an application before the Chief Presidency
Magistrate, Calcutta, for an order that a warrant for the arrest of
Jugal Kishore More and certain other named persons be is.sued
and that the warrant be forwarded with the relevant records and
evidence. to the Ministry of External Affairs, Government of
India, for securing extradition of More who was then believed to
be in Hong Kong. It was stated in the application that More
and oth•!rs "were parties to a criminal conspiracy in Calcutta between May 1961 and December 1962 to defraud the Government
of India in respect of India's foreign exchange", and thei& presence
'IVas req.uired for trial.
The Chief Presidency Magistrate held an enquiry and recorded
· an order on July 19, 1965, that on the materials placed before
him, a prima facie case was made out of a criminal conspiracy,
F
G
H
WEST BENGAL V, JUGAL KISHORE
(Shah, J.)
32 3
A
was "hatched in Calcutta" within his jurisdiction, and More was
one of the conspirators. He accordingly directed that a nonbailable warrant in Form II Sch. V of the Code of Criminal Procedure be issued for the arrest of More, and that the warrant be
sent to the Secretary Home (Political) Department, Government
of West Bengal, with a request to take all necessary steps to ensure
B execution of the warrant. A copy of the warrant was sent to the
Commissioner of Police, Calcutta, for information. In the warrant
More was described as Manager, Premko Traders of 7, Wyndhan
Street and 28, King's Road, Hong Kong. The Chief Presidency
Magistrate forwarded to the Government of West Bengal, the
warrant with attested copies of the evidence recorded at the enquiry
and photostat copies of documents tendered by the prosecution
in evidence "in accordance with the procedure laid down in Government of India, Ministry of External Affairs, letter No. K/52/
6131/41 dated 21st May,_ 1955". The warrant was forwarded
by the Government of West Bengal to the Ministry of External
Affairs, Government of India. The Ministry of External Affairs
D forwarded the warrant to the High Commissioner for India, Hong
Kong, who in his tU!l)t, requested the Colonial Secretary, Hong
Kong, for ·an order extraditing More under the Fugitive Offenders
Act, 1881, (44 and 45 Viet., c. 69), to India for trial for offences
described in the warrant. The Central Magistrate, Hong·Kong,
endorsed the warrant and directed the Hong Kong Police, "pur·
suant to section 13 of Part II and section 26 of Part N of the
E Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881", to arrest More.
The order
recited :
F
G
H
"WHEREAS I have perused this warrant for the
apprehension of Jugal Kishore More, . . . accused
of an offence punishable by law in Calcutta, Republic
of India, which warrant purports to be signed by the
Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta, and is sealed
with the seal of the Court of the said Magistrate, and, is
attested by S. K. Chatterjee, Under Secretary in _the
Ministry of External Affairs of the Republic of India and
sealed with the seal of the said Ministry;
AND WHEREAS I am satisfied that this warrant
was issued by a person having lawful authority to issue
the same;
AND WHEREAS it has been represented to me
that the said Jugal Kishore More . . . is suspected of
being in the Colony;
AND WHEREAS Order in Council S.R. and 0. No.
28 of 1918 by virtue of which Part II of the Fugitive
Offenders Act, 1881, was made to apply to a group
324
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969] 3 S.C.R.
of Br,itish Possessions and Protective States including
Hong Kong and British India, appears to remain in full
force and effect so far as the law of Hong Kong is concerned.
Now therefore under section 13 of the Fugitive
Offenders Act, 1881, I hereby endorse this Warrant
and all;thorise and command you in Her Majesty's name,
forthwith to execute this Warant in the Colony to apprehend the said Jugal Kishore More, . . . wherever he may
be found in the Colony and to bring him before a
Magistrate of the said Colony to be further dealt with
according to law."
More was arrested on November 24, 1965. By order dated
April 4, 1966, the Central Magistrate, Hong Kong, over-ruled
the objection raised on behalf of More that the Court had no
jurisdiction to proceed in the matt.er under the Fugitive Offenders
Act, 1881, since the Republic of India was no loneer a "British
P0ssession ",
On May 16, 1966, Hanuman Prasad-father of Moremoved in the High Court of Calcutta a petition under s. 439
of the Code of Criminal Procedure and Art. 227 of the Constitution for an order quashing the warrant of arrest issued against
More and all proceedings taken pursuant thereto and restraining
the Chief Presidency Magistrate and the Union of India from
taking any further steps pursuant to the said warrant of arrest and
causing More to be extradited from Hong Kong to India. The
petition was heard before a Division Bench of the High Court.
A. Roy, J., held that the warrant issued by the Chief Presid~ncy
Magistrate was not illegal and the procedure followed for securing
extradition of More was not irregular. In his view the assumption made by the Central Magistrate, Hong Kong, that for the
purpose of the Fugitive Offenders Act, India was a "British possession" was irrelevant since that was only a view expressed by him
according to the municipal law of Hong Kong, and by acceding
to the requisition for extradition and surrender made upon that
country by the Government of India in exercise of sovereign
rights the status of the Republic of India was not affected.
In the view of Gupta, J., the warrant issued by the Chief Presidency Magistrate and the steps taken pursuant to the warrant were
Without jurisdiction, ·that the request made to the Hong Kong
Government by the Government of India was also without authority in the absence of a notified order under s. 3 of the Extradition
Act, 1962, and the High Court could not ignore the "laws of the
land, even to support a gesture of comity to another nation," that
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
B
WEST BENGAL V, JUGAL K!SHORE
A
I
I
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
(Shah, J.)
325
what was done by the Hong Kong authorities pursuant to the
request made for the surrender of More was "not an instance of
international comity but was regarded as the legal obligation
under the Fugitive Offenders Act under which the Central Magistrate, Hong Kong, regarded India as a Colony or Possession of
the British Commonwealth". The case was then posted for
hearing before R. Mukherji, J. The learned Judge held that the
Chief Presidency Magistrate had no power to issue the warrant
of arrest .in the manner he had done,-a manner which in his view
was "unknown to the Code of Criminal Procedure", since the
Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881, had ceased, on the coming into
force of the Constitution, to be part of the law of India and
could not on that account be resorted to for obtaining extradition
of offenders from another country; that the instructions issued
by the Government of India by letter No. 3516-J dated June 14,
1955, laying down the procedure to the followed by the courts
for securing extradition of offenders from the Commonwealth
countries shouid have been ignored by the Chief Presidency Magistrate, and that the Extradition Act 34 of 1962 did not authorise
the Chief Presidency Magistrate to issue a warrant and to send
it to the Secretary, Home (Political) Department, Government of
West Bengal; that there "was no legal basis for the requisition
made by the Central Government to Hong Kong" for extradition
or surrender of More or for the issue of the warrant by the Chief
Presidency Magistrate; and that the demand made by the Government of India to the Government of Hong Kong by making a
requisition to Hong Kong for. the arrest of More "was not a political act beyond the purview of law and judicial scrutiny" and
being inconsistent with the law was liable to be rectified. He
observed that the Central Government had the power under s. 3
of the Extradition Act, 1962, to issue a notification for including
Hong Kong in the· list of countries from which offenders may be
extradited, but since the Government had not issued any notification under that clause in exercise of the executive power, ·the
Government could not attempt in violation of the statutory procedure seek extradition which the law of India did not permit.
The learned Judge accordingly• ordered that the warrant of arrest
dated July 30, 1965, issued by the Chief Presidency Magistrate,
Calcutta, against More and all subsequent proceedings taken by
the Chief Presidency Magistrate and the other respondents be
quashed.
The State of West Bengal has appealed to this Court
with special leave .
.Extradition is the surrender by one State to another of a person
des1red to be dealt with for crimes of which he has been accused
or convicted and which are justiciable in the courts of the other
State. Surrender of a person within the State to another
.326
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1969] 3 S.C.R.
State-whr:ther a citizen or an alien-is a political act done in
,pursuance of a treaty or a~ arrangement ad hoc. It is founded on
the broad principle that it is in the interest of civilized communities that crimes should not go unpunished, and on that account
it is recognised as a part of the comity of nations that one State
~hould ordinarily afford to another State assistance towards bring'.ng offenders to justice. The law relating to extradition between
mdependeiiit States is based on treaties. But the law has operationnationaJ as well as i.lltemational It governs international relationship between the sovereign States which is secured by treaty
·obligations. But whether an offender should be handed over
pursuant to a requisition is determined by the domestic law of
the State on which the requisition is made. . Though extradition
is granted in implementation of the international commitments of
the State, the procedure to be followed by the Courts iai deciding
whether extradition .shoulq be granted and on what terms, is
determined by the l!lunicipal. law.
As observed in Wheaten's International Law, Vol. I, 6th
Edn., p. 213 :
"The constitutional doctrine in England .is that the
Crown may make treaties with foreign States for the extradition of criminals, but those treaties can only be
carried into effect by Act of Parliament, for the executive has no. power, without statutory authority, to seize
an alien here and deliver him to a foreign power."
Sanction behind an order of extradition is therefore the international commitment .of the State under which the Court functions,
but Courts jealously seek to protect the right of the individuai
by insisting upon strict compliance with the conditions precedent
to surrender. The Courts of the country which make a requisition for surrender deal with the prima facie proof of the offence
and leave it to the State to make a requisition upon the other
State in which the offender has taken refuge. Requisition for
surrender is not the function of the Courts but of the State. A
warrant issued by a Court for an offence committed in a country
frnm its very nature has no extra-territorial operation. It· is only
a command by the Court in the name of the sovereign to its
officer to arrest an offender and to bring him before the Court.
By making a requisition in pursuance of a warrant issued by a
·Court of a State to another State for assistance in securing the
presence of the offender, the warrant is not invested with extraterritorial operation. If the other State requested agrees to lend
·its aid to arrest the fugitive the arrest is made either by the issue
of an ·independent warrant or endorsement or authentication of
the warrant of the Court which issued it. By endorsement or
A
B
c
D
E
F
•
G
H.
-1
WEST BENGAL V, JUGAL KISHORE
A
'B
...
--{
·C
D
E
F
G
(Shah, J.)
327
authentication of a warrant the country in which an offender has
taken refuge signifies its w,illingness to lend its assistance, in implementation of the treaties or international commitments and to
secure the arrest of the offender. The offender arrested pursuant
to the warrant ·or endorsement is brought before the Court of the
country to which the requisition is made, and the Court holds an
inquiry to determine whether the offender may be extradited. International commitment or treaty will be effective only if the Court
of a country in which the offender is arrested after enquiry is of
the view that the offender should be surrendered.
The functions which the Courts in the two countries perform
are therefore different. The Court within whose jurisdiction the
offence is committed decides whether there is prima facie evidence
on which a requisition may be made to another country for surrender of the offender. When the State to which a requi~ition is made
agrees consistently with its international commitments to lend its
aid the requisition is transmitted to the Police author:ities, and
the Courts of that country consider, according to their own laws
whether the offender should be surrendered-the enquiry is in
the absence of express provisions to the contrary relating to the
prima facie evidence of the commission of the offence which is
extraditable, the offence not being a political offence nor that the
requisition being a subterfuge to secure custody for trial for a
political offence.
Prior to January 26, 1950, there was in force in India the
Indian Extradition Act 15 of 1903, which as the preamble expressly enacted was intended to provide for the more convenient
administration of the Extradition Acts of 1870 and 1873, and the
Foreign Jurisdiction Act of 1881-both enacted by the British
Parliament. The Act enacted machinery in Ch. II for the surrender of fugitive criminals in case of Foreign States i.e .. States
to which the Extradition Act of 1870 and 1873 applied and in Ch.
II for surrender of fugitive offenders iill case of "His Majesty's
~ominions". The Extradition Acts of 1870 and 1873 sought to
give effect to arrangements made with foreign States with respect
to !he surrender to such States of any fugitive criminals Her
Ma1esty may by Order in Council, direct and to prescribe the procedure for extraditing fugitive offenders to ~such foreign states.
As observed in Halsbury's Laws of England Vol. 16, 3rd Edn.,
para 1161 at p. 567 :
H
"Whe_,n a tr.e~ty has been made with a foreign State
and th~ Extrad1t10n Acts have been applied by Order in
Council, one of Her Majesty's principal Secretaries of
·State may, upon a requisition made to him by some person recognized by him as a diplomatic representative nf
328
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
•
(1969] 3 S.t.R.
that foreign State, by order under his hand and seal,
signify to a police magistrate that such a requisition has
been made and require him to issue his warrant for the
apprehension of the fugitive criminal if the criminal is in
or is suspected of being in, the United Kingdom."
The warrant may then be issued by a police magistrate on
receipt of the order of the Secretary of State and upon such evidence as would in his opinion justify the issue of the warrant if
the crime had been committed or the criminal convicted in England.
The procedure for extradition of fugitive offenders from
"British possessions" was less complicated. When the Extradition
Act was applied by Order in Council unless it was otherwise provided by such Order, the Act extended to every "British possession" in the same llllliOOer as if throughout the Act the "British
possession" were substituted for the United Kingdom, but with
certain modifications in procedure.
Under Part I of the Fugitive Offenders Act 1881 a warrant
issued in one part of the Crown's Dominion for apprehension of
a fugitive offender, could be endorsed for execution in another
Dominion. After the fugitive was apprehended he was brought
before the Magistrate who heard the case in the same manner and
had the same jurisdiction and powers as if the fugitive was charged
with an offence committed within the Magistrate's jurisdiction. If
the Magistrate was satisfied, after expiry of 15 days from the date
on which the fugitive was committed to prison, he could make an
order for surrender of the fugitive on the warrant issued by the
Secretary of State or an appropriate officer. There was also provision for "inter-colonial backing of warrants" within groups of
"British possessions" to which Part I of the Fugitive Offenders
Act, 1881 has been applied by Order in Council. In such groups
a more rapid procedure for the return of fugitive offenders between
possessions of the same group was in force. Where in a "British
possession", of a group to which Part II of the Act applied, a
warrant was issued for the apprehension of a person accused of
an offence punishable in that possession and such term is or was
suspected of being, in or on the way to another British possession
of the same group, a magistrate in the last-mentioned possession,
if satisfied that the warrant was issued by a person having lawful
· authority to issue the same, _was bound to endorse ~tich warrant,
and the warrant so endorsed was sufficient authority to apprehend,
within the jurisdiction of the endorsing magistrate the person
named in the warrant and to bring him before the endorsing magist~ate or some other magistrate in the same possession.
If .the
magistrate before whom a person apprehen.ded was broug~t was
satisfied that the warrant was duly authenticated and was 1ss~ed
A
B
c
J)
E
G
WEST BENGAL V, JUGAL KISHORE
(Shah, J.)
329
A
by a persoo having !awful authority to jssue it, and the identity of
the prisoner was establ,ished he could order the prisoner to be returned to the British possession in which the warrant was issued
and for that purpose to deliver into the custody of the persons to
whom the warrant was addressed or of any one or more of them,
and to be held in custody and conveye<j to that possession, there to
B be dealt with acco~ to Jaw as if he had been there apprehended.
This was in brief the procedure prior to January 2!l, 1950.
c
D
E
F
The President of India adapted the Extradition Act 1903, in
certain particulars. The Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881 and the
Extradition Act, 1870, in their application to India were however
not repealed by the Indian Parliament and to the extent they
were consistent with the constitutional scheme they remained
applicable. In order to maintain the continued application of
laws of the British Parliament, notwithstanding India becoming
a Republic, the British Parliament enacted the India (Consequential Provision) Act 1949 which by s. 1 provided :
" ( 1) On and after the date of India's beconiing a
republic, all exis~g law, that is to say, all law which,
whether being a rule of law or a proyision of an Act of
Parliament or of any other enactment or instrument
whatsoever, is in force on that date or has been passed
or made before that date and comes into force thereafter, shall, until provision to the contrary is made by
the authority having power to alter that law ancl subject
to the provisions of sub-s. (3) of this section, have the
same operation in relation to India, and to persons and
things in any way belonging to or connected with India,
as it would have had if India had not become a
republic.
( 3) His Majesty may by Order in Council make
any existing law to
which this Act extends as may appear to him to be
necessary or expedient in view of India's becoming a
republic while remaining a member of the Commonwealth, and sub-s. ( 1) of this section shall have effect
in relation to any such law as modified by such an
order in so far as the contrary intention appears in
the order. An Order in Council under this section- ·
pr~vision. for such satisfaction of
G
H
(a) may be made either before or after India· becomes a republic, and may be, revoked or varied by a
subsequent Order in Council; and
330
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1969] 3 S C.R.
(b) shall be subject to annulment in pursuance
of a resolution of either House of Parliament."
In 1954 this Court was called upon to C!ecide a case relating
to extradition to Singapore, a British Colony, of a person alleged
to be a fugitive offender The State of Madr¥S v. C. G. Menon
and Another('). In that case Menon and his wife were apprehended and produced before the Chief Presidency Magistrate,
Madras, pursuant to warrants of arrest issued under the provisions
of the Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881. Arrests were made in pursuance of requisition made by the Colonial ,Secretary of Singapore
requesting the assistance of the Government of India to arrest
and return to the Colony of Singapore Menons under warrants
issued by the. Police Magistrate of Singapore. Menons pleaded
that the Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881, under which the action
was sought to be taken against them was repugnant to the Cons·
titution of India and was void and unenforceable. The Chief
Presidency Magistrate referred two questions of law for decision
of the High Court of Madras :
(1) Whether the Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881, applies
A
B
c
D
to India after 26th J:i,nuary, 1950, when India
became a Sovereign Democratic Republic· and
(2) Whether, even if it applied, it or any of its provisions, particularly Part II thereof, is repugnant to
the Constitution of India and is therefore void and
or inoperative.
The High Court held that the Fugitive Offenders Act was inconsistent with the fundamental right of equal protection of the
laws guaranteed by Art. 14 of the Constitution and was void
to that extent and unenforceable against the petitioners. In
appeal brought to this Court it was observed :
•
I
"It is ·plain from the .
. provisions ·of
the Fugitive Offenders Act as well as from the Order
in Council that British Possessions which were contiguous to one another and between whom there was
frequent inter-communication were treated for purposes of the Fugitive Offenders Act as one integrated
territory and a summary procedure was adopted for
the purpose of extraditing persons who. had committed
offences in these integrated territories. As the laws
prevailing in those possessions were substantially the
same. the requirem!)nt that no fugitive will be surrendered unless a prima facie case was made against him
was dispensed with. Under the Indian Extradition
(\) [\955] 1 S.C.R. 280.
E
.F
G
H
WEST BENGAL v. JUGAL KISHORE
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
(Shah, J.)
33I
Act, 1903, also a similar requirement is insisted upon
before a person can be extradited.
The situation completely changed when India became a Sovereign Democratic Republic. After the
achievement of independence and the coming into
force of the new Constitution by no stretch of imagination could India be described as a British Possession
and it could not be grouped by an Order in Council
amongst those Possessions. Truly speaking, it became a foreign territory so far as other British Possessions are concerned and the extradition of persons taking asylum in India, having committed offences in
British Possessions, could only be dealt w~th by an
arrangement between the Sovereign Democratic Republic of India and the British Government and given
effect to by appropriate legislation. The Union Parliament has not so far enacted any law on the subject and it
was not suggested that any arrangement has been arrived
at between these two Governments. The Indian Extradition Act, 1903, has been adapted but the Fugitive
Offenders Act, 1881, which was an Act of the British
Parliament has been left severely alone. The provisions
of that Act could only be made applicable to India by
incorporating them with appropriate changes into an Act
of the Indian Parliament and by enacting an Indian Fugi'tive Offenders Act. In the absence of any legislation on
those lines, it seems difficult to hold that section 12 or
section 14 of the Fugitive Offenders Act has force in India
by reason of the provisions of article 372 of the Constitution. The whole basis for the applicability of Part II of
the Fugitive Offenders Act has gone : India is no longer
a British Possession and no Order in Council can be made
to group it with other British Possessions.
.
.
.
The political ba~~ground and shape of things when
Part ff of the Fug11Ive Offenders Act, 1881, was enacied
~n~ envisage~ by ~at Act h~ving completely changed,
11 1s not possible without radical legislative changes to
adapt that Act to the changed conditions. That being
so, in our opinion, the tentative view expressed by the
Presidency Magistrate was right.
"
After this judgment was delivered, the Government of India
Ministry of External Affairs, issued a notification on May 21'
1955, to all. State Go~ernments of Part A, B, C & D States.
was stated m the nollfication that :
It
" .... in a certain case of extradition of an offender, the Supreme Court of India recently ruled that in
.332
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[!969) 3 S.C.R .
the changed circumstances, the English Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881, is no longer applicable to India. There
can therefore, be no question of issuing a warrant of
arrest, addressed io a foreign police or a foreign court,
in respect of persons who are residing outside India ex·cept in accordance with the Code of Criminal Proce·dure, 1898.
2. In the circumstances, to obtain a fugitive offender from the United Kingdom and other Commonwealth
·countries, the following procedure may be· adopied as
long as the new Indian Extradition law is not enacted
and the Commonwealth countries ·continue to honour
our requests for the surrender of the fugitive offenders
notwithstanding decisions of the Supreme Court;
(a) The Magistrate concerned will issue a warrant
for the arrest of the fugitive offender to Police officials
of India in the usual form prescribed under the Code of
·Criminal Procedure, 1898.
(b) The w0 rrant for arrest, accompanied by all
such documents as would enable a prima facie case to
be established ,against the accused will be submitted by
the Magistrate to the Government of India in the Ministry of External Affairs, through the State Government
<:oncerned.
3. This Ministry, in consultation with the Ministries
.of Home Affairs, and Law, will make a requisition for
the surrender of a fugitive offender in the form of a
letter, requesting the Secretary of State (in the case of
dominions, the appropriate authority in the dominion)
to get the warrant endorsed in accordance with law.
This letter will be addressed to the Secretary of State
(or other appropriate authority in case of Dominions)
through the High Commissioner for India in the United
Kingdom/Dominion concerned and will be accompanied by the warrant issued by the Magistrate at (a)
of para 2 above and other documents received therewith."
The Chief Presidency Magistrate Calcutta made out the warrant
for the arrest of More pursuant to that notification and sent the
warrant to the Secretary, Home (Political) Department, Government of West Bengal. Validity of the steps taken in accordance
with the notification by the Chief Presidency Magistrate is questioned in this appeal.
To complete the narrative, it is· necessary to refer to the Extradition Act 34 of 1962. The Parliament has enacted Act 34
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
WEST BENGAL V. JUGAL KISHORE
A
B
c
D
(Shah, J.)
333
of 1962 to consolidate and amend the law relating to the extradi·
tion •f fugitive criminals. It makes provisions by Ch. II for extradition of fugitive criminals to foreign States and to commonwealth countries to which Ch. III does not apply. Chapter III
deals with the return of fugitive criminals to commonwealth
countries with extradition arrangements. By s. 12 it is provided :
"(I ) This Chapter shall apply only to any such.
commonwealth country to which, by reason of an extradition arrangement entered into with that country, it
may seem expedient to the Central Government to apply
the same.
(2) every such application shall be by notified
order, and the Central Government may, by the same or
any subsequent notified order, direct that this Chapter
and Chapters I, IV and V shall, in relation to any such
commonwealth country, apply subject to such modifications, exceptions, conditions and qualifications as it may
think fit to specify in the order for the '" ' 'e of imple·
menting the arrangement."
E
Section 13 provides that the fugitive crimi:.:'L; from commonwealth countries may be apprehended and returned. Chapter IV
deals with the surrender or return of accused or convicted persons
from foreign States or commonwealth countries. By s. 19 it was
provided that-
F
( 1) A requisition for the surrender of a person
accused or convicted of an extradition offence committed ,in India and who is or is suspected to be, in any
foreign State or a commonwealth country to which
Chapter Ill does not apply, may be made by the Central Government-
( a) to a diplomatic representative of that State or
country at Delhi; or
.
G
(b) to th~ Gov7rnment of t~at State or country
through the d1plomatlc representative of India in that
State or country;
~d if neither of th~se modes is convenient, the requisition shall be made m such other mode as is settled by
arrangement made by the Government of India with
·
that State or country.
H
(2) A w~rrant issued by a magistrate in India for
the ap~rehens10n of any person who is, or is suspected
to be, m any commonwealth country to which Chapter
III applies shall be in such form as may be prescribed."
R Sup Cl/69-3
334
~:Ul'REME
COURT REPORTS
[1969] 3 S.C. R
By cl. (a) of s. 2 the expression "commonwealth country" means
"a commonwealth country specified in the First Schedule and
such other commonwealth country as may be added to that
Schedule by the Central Government by notification in the
Official Gazette, and includes every constituent part, colony or
dependency of any commonwealth country so specified or
added : ". But in the Schedule to the Act "Hong Kong" is not
specified as one of the commonwealth country and no notification
has been issued by the Government of India under s. 2(a) adding to the First Schedule "Hong Kong" as a commonwealth
country. It is common ground between the parties that the
provisions of the Extradition Act, 1962, could not be resorted
to for making the requisition for surrender of the fugitive offender
from Hong Kong, and no attempt was made in that behalf.
Validity of the action taken by the Chief Presidency Magistrate must therefore, be adjudged in the light of the action taken
'Pursuant to the notification issued by the Government of India
on May 21, 1955. Counsel for the respondent More urged that
the warrant issued by the Chief Presidency Magistrate was intended fo be and could in its very nature be a legal warrant enforceable within India : it had no extra-territorial operation, and
· could not be enforced outside India, and when the Central Magistrate Hong Kong, purported to endorse that warrant for enforcement within Hong Kong he had no authority to do so. But this
Court has no -authority to sit in judgment over the order passed
by the Hong Kong Central Magistrate. The Magistrate acted in
accordance with the municipal law of Hong Kong and agreed to
the surrender of the offender : his action cannot be challenged in
this Court.
It may also be pointed out that Form II of the warrant prescribed in Sch. V of the Code of Criminal Procedure only issues a
direction under the authority of the Magistrate_ to a Police Officer
to arrest a named person and to produce him before the Court.
It does not state that the warrant shall be executed in any designated place or area. By s. 82 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
a warrant of arrest may be executed at any place in India. That
provision does noi impose any restriction upon the power of the
Police Officer. The section only declares in that every warrant
issued by any Magistrate in India may be executed at any place in
India, execution of the warrant is not restricted to the local limits
of the jurisdiction of the Magistrate issuing the warrant or of the
Court to which he is subordinate.
In Emperor v . .Vinayak Damodar Savarkar and Ors.(') the
Bombay High Court considered the question whether a person
who was brought to the country and was charged before a Magis(I) I.LR. 35 Born. 225.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
WEST BENGAL v. JUGAL KISHORE
A
(Shah, J.)
335
trate with an offence under the Indian Penal Code wa• entitled
to challenge the manner in which he was brought into the country
from a foreign country. Savarkar was charged with conspiracy
under ss. 121, 121A., 122 and 123 of. the Indian Penal Code. He
was arrested in the United Kingdom and brought to India after
arrest under the Fugitive Offenders Act, 18 81. When the ship
B in which he was being brought to India was near French territory
Savarkar escaped from police custody and set foot on French
territory at Marseilles. He was arrested by the police officers
without reference to the French police authorities and brought to
India. It was contended at the trial of Savarkar that he was not
liable to be tried in India, since arrest by the Indian police officers
in a foreign territory was without jurisdiction. Scott, C.J., who
c delivered
the principal judgment of the Court rejected the contention. He observed :
"Where a man is in the country and is charged before a Magistrate with an offence under the Penal Code
it will not avail him to say that he was brought there illegally from a foreign country."
D
It is true that Savarkar was produced before the Court and he
raised an objection about the validity of the trial on the plea that
he was illegally brought to India after unlawful arrest in foreign
territory. In the present case we are concerned with a stage anterior to that. The respondent More though arrested in a foreign
country lawfully by the order of the Central Magistrate, Hong
E Kong, had not been surrendered and the invalidity of the warrant
issued by the Chief Presidency Magistrate is set up as a ground
for refusing to obtain extradition of the offender. But on the
principle of Vinayak Damodar Savarkar's case(') the contention
about the invalidity of the arrest cannot affeci the jurisdiction of
the Courts in India to try More if and when he is brought here.
F
G
H
The Indian Extradition Act 15 of 1903 which was enacted
to provide for the more convenient administration of the English
Extradition Act, 1870 & 1873 and the Fugitive Offenders Act.
1881, remained in operation. But after January 26, 1950, India
is no longer a "British Possession." Jn C. G. Menon's case( 2 ) it
was decided by this Court that application of ss. 12 and 14 of
the Fugitive Offenders Act, 18 81, for surrendering an offender
to a Commonwealth country in pursuance of a requisition under
the Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881, is inconsistent with the political
status of India. It is somewhat unfortunate that the Court hearing that case was not invited to say anything about the operation
of the India (Consequential Provision) Act, 1949.
But C. G. Menon's case(') was a reverse case, in that, the
Colonial Secretary of Singapore had made a requisition for
(1) I.LR. 35 Born. 225.
(2) [1955j 1S.C.R.280.
336
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[!969] 3 S.C.R.
surrender of the offender for trial for offences of criminal breach
of trust in Singapore. Whether having regard to the political
status of India since January 26, 1950, the Fugitive Offenders
Act, 18 81, insofar as it purported to treat India as a "British
Possession" imposed an obligation to deliver offenders in pursuance of the India· (Consequential Provision) Act 1949 is a
question on which it is not necessary to express an opinion. By
the declaration of the status of India as a Republic, India has not
ceased to be a part of the Commonwealth and the United Kingdom and several Colonies have treated the Fugitive Offenders
Act, 1881, as applicable to them for the purpose of honouring
the requisition made by the Republic of India from time to time.
In Re. Government of India and Mubarak Ali Ahmrd(')
an
attempt to resist in the High Court in England the requisition by
the Republic of India to surrender an offender who had. committed offences in India and had fled justice failed. Mubarak
Ali a native of Pakistan was being tried in the Courts in India
on charges of forgery and fraud. He broke his bail and fled to
Pakistan and thereafter to England. He was arrested on a pro, visional warrant issued by the London Metropolitan Magistrate
on the application of the Government of India. After hearing
legal submissions the Metropolitan Magistrate made an order
under s. 5 of the Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881, for Mubarak Ali's
detention in custody pending his return to India to answer the
charges made against him. Mubarak Ali then filed a petition
for a writ of habeas corpus before the Queen's Bench of the High
Court. It was held that the Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881, was
in force between India and Great Britain on January 26, 1950,
when India become a republic and it was continued to apply by
virtue of s. 1 (I ) of the India (Consequential Provision) Act,
1949, and, therefore, the Magistrate had jurisdiction to make the
order for the applicant's return. Pursuant to the requisitions made
by the Government of India, Mubarak Ali was surrendered by
the British Government. Mubarak Ali was then brought to India
and was tried and convicted. One of the offences for which he
was tried resulted in his conviction and an appeal was brought
to this Court iiil Mobarik Ali Ahmed v. The State of Bombay(').
There are other cases as well, in which orders were made by
the British Courts complying with the requisitions made by the
Governments of Republics within the Commonwealth, for extradition of offenders under the Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881. An
offender from Ghana was ordered to be extradited pursuant to
the Ghana (Consequential Provision) Act, 1960, even after
Ghana became a republic Re. Kwesi Armah('). On July 1, 1960,
Ghana while remaining by virtue of the Ghana (Consequential
(2) (1958] S.C.R. 328.
(I) (1952] I All E.R: 1060.
.
(3) (1966] 2 All E.R.1006.
A.
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
WEST BENGAL V, JUGAL K.ISHORE
(Shah, J.)
3 37
Provision) Act, 1960, a member of the Comonwealth became a
Republic. Kwesi Armah who was a Minister in Ghana fled the
country in 1966 and took refuge in the United Kingdom. He
was arrested under a provisional warrant issued under the Fugitive
Offenders Act, 1881. The Metropolitan Magistrate being satisfied that the Act of 1881 still applied to Ghana and that a prima
facie case had been made out against the applicant in respect of
B
two alleged contraventions of the Ghana Criminal Code, 1960,
by corruption and extortion when he was a public officer, committed Kwesi Armah to prison pending his return to Ghana to undergo
trial. A petition for a writ of habeas corpus before the Queen's
Bench Division of the High Court was refused. Edmund Davies,'
J., was of the view that the Act of 1881 applied to the Republic
c of Ghana, in its new form, just as it did before the coup d'etat of
February 1966. The case was then carried to the House of Lords;
Armah v. Government of Ghana and Another('). The questions
decided by the House of Lords have no relevance in this case.
But it was not even argued that a fugitive offender from a republic
which was a member of the Commonwealth could not be extraD dited. under the Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881.
There is yet another recent judgment of the House of Lords
dealing with repatriation of a citizen of the Republic of Cyprus :
Zacharia v. Republic of Cyprus and Anr.(2). Warrants were
issued against Zacharia on charges before the Courts in Cyprus of
offences of abduction, demanding money with menaces and
E murder. Under the orders issued by a Bow Street Magistrate
under s. 5 of the Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881, Zacharia was
_committed to prison pending his return to Cyprus. An application for a writ of habeas corpus on the ground that the offences
alleged against him were political and that the application for the
return of the fugitive was made out of motive for revenge was
F rejected by the Queen's Bench Division and it was ordered that
Zacharia be repatriated. The order was confirmed in appeal to
the House of Lords.
Merely because for the purpose of the extradition procedure,
in a statute passed before the attainment of independence by the
former Colonies and dependencies, certain territories continue to
G be referred to as "British Possessions" the statute does not become inapplicable to those territories. The expression "Bijtish
Possession" in the old statutes merely survives an artificial mode
of reference, undoubtedly not consistent with political realities,
but does not imply for the purpose of the statute or otherwise
political dependence of the Government of the territories referred
to. It is not for the Courts of India to take umbrage at expresH sions used in statutes of other countries and to refuse to give effect
to Indian laws which govern the problems arising before them.
A
(1) [1966] 3 All E.R. 177.
(2) [1962] 2 Ail E.R. 438.
338
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969] 3 S.C.R.
It is interesting to note that by express enactment the Fugitive
Offenders Act, 1881, remains in force as a part of the Republic
of Ireland : , see Ireland Act, 1949 (12, 13 and 14 Geo. 6 c. 41).
In Halsbury s. Laws of England, 3rd Edn., Vol. 5 Art. 987, p.
433-m dealmg with the expression "Her Majesty's Dominions"
m old statutes, it is observed :
A
''The term 'Her Majesty's dominions' means all the
territories under the sovereignty of the Crown and the
territ~)fial water~ a~jacent thereto. In. speciai cases it
may mclude terntones under the protection of the Crowri
and mandated and trust territories. References to Her
Majesty's dominions c~ntained _in statutes passed before
India became a republic are still to be construed as including !ndi~; it is _u~ual t.o name Jndia separately from
Her Ma1esty s donumons m statute!. passed since India
became a republic."
8
c
In foot-note ( 1) on p. 433 it is stated, British India, which included the whole of India except the princely States; and che
Government of India Act, 1935 as amended by s. 8 of the India D
and Bunna (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act, 1940, fanned
part of Her Majesty's dominions and was a British possession,
although it was not included within the definition of "colony".
The territory comprised in British India was partitioned between
the Dominions of India and Pakistan (Indian Independence Act,
1947), but the law relating to the definition of Her Majesty's E
dominions was not thereby changed, and it was continued in being
by the India (Consequential Provision) Act, 1949 ( 12, 13 & 14
Geo. 6 c. 92), passed in contemplation of the adoption of a republican constitution by India. India is now a sovereign republic,
but that by itself does not render the Fugitive Offenders Act,
1881, inapplicable to India.
F
If the question were a live question, we would have thought
it necessary to refer the case to a larger Bench for considering
the true effect of the judgment in C. G. Menon's case('). But by
the Extradition Act 34 of 1962 the Extradition Act, 1870 and
the latter Acts and also the Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881, have
been repealed and the question about extradition by India of
G
fugitive offenders under those Acts will not hereafter aris.e.
We are not called upon to consider whether in exercise of the
power under the Fugitive Offenders Act a Magistrate in India may
direct extradition of a fugitive offender .from a "British Possession".
who has taken refuge in India. It is sufficient to observe that the
Colonial Secretary of Hong Kong was according to the law applicable in Hong Kong competent to give effect to the warrant issued· H
by the Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta, and the Central
(!) [1955] l S.C.R. 280.
WEST BENGAL V. JUGAL KISHORE
(Shah, ].)
339
Magistrate, Hong Kong, had jurisdiction under the Fugitive Offenders Act, and, after holding inquiry, to direct that ~ore be s~r
rendered to India. The order of surrender was valid according
to the law in force in Hong Kong, and we are unable to appreciate
the grounds on which invalidity can be attributed to the warrant
issued by the Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta, for the
an:est of More. That the Chief Presidency Magistrate was comB petent to issue a warrant for the arrest of More agains~ whom
there was prima facie evidence to show that he had committed an
offence in India is not denied. If the Chief Presidency Magistrate
had issued the warrant to the Commissioner of Police and the
Commissioner of Police had approached the Ministry of External
Affairs, Government of India, either through the local Govc ernment or directly with a view to secure the assistance of
the Government of Hong Kong for facilitating extradition
Qf More, no fault can be found. But Gupta, J ., and
Mukherjee, J., thought that the notification issued by the
Government of India setting out the procedure to be followed by
a Magistrate, where the offender is not in Indian territory and his
D extradition is to be secured, amounted to an invasion on the authority of the Courts. We do not think that any such affront is intended by issuing the notification. The Fugitive Offenders Act, 1881.
had not been expressly repealed even after January 26, 1950.
It had a limited operation: the other countries of the Commonwealth were apparently willing to honour the itntemational commitments which arose out of the provisions of that Act. But this
E Court on the view that since India had become a Republic, held
that the Fugitive Offenders Act could not be enforced in this
country, presented to the Government of India a problem which
had to be resolved by devising machinery for securing the presence
of offenders who were fugitives from justice.
The notification
issued was only in the nature of advice about the procedure to be
F followed and did not in any manner seek to impose any executive
will upon the Courts in matters judicial. Observations made by
Mukhcrji, J., that the notification issued by the Central Government authorising the Chief Presidency Magistrate to issue the
warrant in the manner he had done, came "nowhere near the law"
and "to a Court of law it is waste paper beneath its notice" appear
G to proceed upon an incorrect view of the object of the notification.
A
H
The Chief Presidency Magistrate had the power to issue the
warrant for the arrest of More, because there was prima facie
evidence before him that More had committed certain offences
which he was competent to try. The warrant was in Form TI of
Sch. V of the Code of Criminal Procedure. If the warrant was
to .be successfully executed against More who was not in India.
aSSJStance of the executive Government had to be obtained. It
is not an invasion upon the authority of the Courts when they are
informed that certain procedure may be followed for obtaining
340
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1969] 3 S.C.R.
the assistance of the executive Department of the State in securing
through diplomatic channels extradition of fugitive offenders. In
pursuance of that warrant, on the endorsement made by the Central Magistrate, Hong Kong, More was arrested. The warrant
was issued with the knowledge that it could not be enforced within
lndia and undoubtedly to secure the extradition of More. Pursuant to the warrant the Ministry of External Affairs, Government
of India, moved through diplomatic channels, and persuaded the
Colonial Secretary of Hong Kong to arrest and deliver More.
Issue of the. warrant and the procedure followed in transmitting
the warrant were not illegal, not even irregular.
A
B
One more argument remains to be noticed. It is true that
under the Extradition Act 34 of 1962 no notification has been
issued including Hong Kong in the list of the Commonwealth
countries from which extradition of fugitives from justice may be
secured. The provisions of the Extradition Act, 1962, cannot
be availed of for securing the presence of More for trial in India.
But that did not, in our judgment, operate as a bar to the requisition made by the Ministry of External Affairs, Government of
India, if they were able to persuade the Colonial Secretary, Hong
Kong, to deliver More for trial in this country. If the Colonial
S--.cretary of Hong Kong was willing to hand over More for trial
in this country, it cannot be said that the warrant issued by the
Chief Presidency Magistrate for the arrest of More with the aid
of which requisition for securing his presence from Hong Kong
was to be made, was illegal.
D
We are unable to agree with the High Court that because of
the enactment of the Extradition Act 34 of 1962 the Government
of India is prohibited from securing through diplomatic channels
the extradition of an offender for trial of an offence committed
within India. There was, in our judgment, no illegality committed
by the Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta, in sending the warrant to the Secretary, Home (Political) Department, Government
of West Bengal, for transmission to the Government of India,
Ministry of External Affairs, for taking further steps for securing
the presence of More in India to undergo trial.
F
The appeal must therefore be allowed and the order passed
by the High Court set aside. The writ petitioq filed by More
must be dismissed.
Y.P.
Appeal a/l~wed.
c
E
G
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org