UNION OF INDIA & ORS. versus M/S. RAI BAHADUR SHREE RAM DURGA PRASAD (P) LTD. & ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 19 November 1968 | [1969] 2 S.C.R. 727 | 1968 INSC 303
Key facts
- Decided
- 19 November 1968
- Bench
- S.M. SIKRI*, R.S. BACHAWAT, K.S. HEGDE
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 45/1968
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1969] 2 S.C.R. 727
- Neutral citation
- 1968 INSC 303
Text of the judgment
727
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
A
V.
M/S. RAI BAHADUR SHREE RAM DURGA PRASAD (P)
LTD. & ORS.
November 19, 1968
B
[S. M. SIKRI, R. S. BACHAWAT AND K. S. HEGDE, JJ.]
Foreign Exchange R£gulation Act (7 of 1947), ss. 12, 22, 23 and
•••
23A-Forcign Exchange Regulation Rules, 1952 r. 5 and Sea Custon1s
Act (8 of 1878), s. 167(8)-Scope of-Form requiring declaration
c
of
correct invoice value before export-If restriction under s. 12( 1) of the
F'or.eign Excha11f?e Regulation Act-Sea Custonzs Act, provisions of, when
can he invoked.
By a notificatiun dated August 4. 1947 issued under s. 12(1) of the
Foreign Exchange Regulation. Act, 1947 and the. Foreign Exchange Regulation Rules, 1952, and amended thereunder, the Central Government
D
prohibited the export to countries mentioned in its Schedule, of goods,
except by post, unless a declaration supported by such evidence as · may
be prescribed is furnished by the exporter to the prescribed authority
that the am,,unt representing the full export value of the goods has been
paid or would be paid within the prescribed period. In 1957, the respondents shipped goods after furnishing to the prescribed authority,
namely, the Collector of Customs a declarati'On in the statutory form
prescribed under the Foreign Exchange Regulation Rules, and the Collector of Customs passed the goods for shipment. In 1965, the Dy. Collec1or of Customs issued a notice to the respondents calling upon them to sho\v
E
cause why a penalty under s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act. 1878,
should not be imposed, on the basis that the respondents under valued
the goods deliberately, that they gave in the prescribed form false parti-
F
culars supported by false evidence-, that there \Vas a failure to repatriate
large amOunts of foreign exchanv,,e contrary to the requirements of
s. 12(2) and r. 5, thats. 12(1) of the Foreign Exchan.ge Regulation Act
and Rules required a declaration of the actual amount representing the
full export value and a mere declaration of any value would not be
~ufficient compliance with the provisions, that under the circumstances by
virtue of s. 23 A of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, the exportation
constituted an offence under s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act. The
respondents thereupon, filed_ a writ petition contending that the declaration to the Collector of Customs was sufficient compliance with the
statutory pr'Ovisions and that the Collector havin.g passed the consignments for shipment, had no further jurisdiction to take proceedings
G
against them. A single Judge of the High Court dismissed the petitio~s,
hut on appeal, the Divisional Bench allowed the petitions. In 'appeal
to this Court.
HELD : Per Bachawat and Hcgdc, JJ .. On the facts set out in the show
cause notice thl.! respondents could not be held to have contravened
s. 12(ll.
H
( 1) Th.c r~gulations contained in the Act are enacted. in the econon1ic
anJ financial 1?terest of the coun.try. Therefore, the rigour and sanctity
of the regulations should he mruntained but at the same time it should
no_t be forgotten that s. 12(1) is a penal section, and in interpreting it
it is _not c?mpctent to the Court to stretch its language in order to carry out
the intention of the Legislature. [752 E]
728
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
To/aram Rc/11111al v. State of Bombay
followed;
[ 1969] 2 S.C.R.
[1955] 1 S.C.R.,
158,
164,
A
Re. H.P.C. Production Ltd. [1962] Ch. Dn. 466, 473, and London &
North Eastern Ry. Co. v. Beriman, [1946] A.C. 286, 295, applied.
(2) Neither s. 12(1) nor any other provision of the Act empowers
the rule-making authority to add to the restrictions imposed by the section,
and, for finding out the restrictions imposed by the section one can only
look at that section. The only restriction placed by s. 12(1) read with
the notification~ dated August 4, 1947 is that no one should export any
,
B
goods from this country \Vithout furnishing the declaration mentioned in
s. 12(1). The items of information called for in the prescribed form
cannot be considered as restrictions imposed by s. 12(1). They arc
meirely information called for the proper exercise· of the po\vers under
the Act. In fact many of them do nJt relate to t~e restrictions in1poscJ
bf the section. [751 C-FJ
(3) So far as goods sold to the foreign buyer arc concerned it is
possible for the exporter to know the, exact export value, but that \vould
not be the position when the goods are sent on consignment basis, and, in
such a case the: exporter can give onJy an estimated value. If every declaration which does not state accurately the full export value of the goods
exported is held to be. a contravention of s. 12(1) then all exports on
consignment basis must Qe held to contravene the restriction imposed
by s. .12(1), but, the Legislature could not have intended that min.or
m~stakes in giving the full export value should be. punished under s. 23A.
T·herefore, the· dei:larations given in the present case do satisfy the requirements of s. 12(1) though they did not correctly 'furnish all the information asked for in the fOrm, an.d hence, there \Vas no contravention
of the section. [751 H-752 DJ
(4) The main purpose of s. 12(1) is to get a declaration from the
exporter that he has either brought or _ will. bring back the
amount representing the full export value of the goods. The scheme of
the Act is that so far as customs authorities are concerned all that they
have to see is that no goods are exported without furnishing the declaration prescribed under s. 12(1). Once that stage is passed the rest of
the matter is left in the hands of the Reserve Bank and the Director oE
Enforcement under ss. 12(5) and (6). [752 B, 754 F]
(5) Beforn a case can be held to fall within the scope of ss. 23A.
and 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act, 1878, could be invoked, it must
be shown that there has been a contravention of the restrictions imposed bys. 12(1); but the language of s. 12(1) does not permit the
interpretation that the Legislature intended that the offen~s complain.i:;d
in these· proceedings should be punishable under s. 23A. The contraventions complain~d of in this case arc really contraventions of s. 12(2)
an.d r. 5 and they arc punishable, the formc.r, under s. 23 and the Jatter,
under ss. 22 and 23. [751 B-C, G]
c
D
E
F
G
Per Sikri, J. dissenting. On the facts alleged by the Customs authorities no case for the issue of a writ to the authorities had been made
out.
(1) The Act. \Vas enacted in the in.terests of national economy. Since
a de1iberate large, scale contravention of its provisions would have serious
effects, it should be construed so as to make it workable. No subject
can insist on an interpretation which wHI have the effect of sabotaging
the national economy. [739 H-740 A]
lI
"'"
UNION V. RA! BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD.
A
B
72[)
(2) As s. 12(1) itself does not imp·ose any restrictions and contemplates mies being made on : (a) evidence which is to support declaration; (b) authority to which the declaration is to be furnished; and
( c) the n1anner of payment; the re1Strictions imposed by rules which are
n::ferrable to the section must be treated as restrictions imposed by the
section. [740 HJ
Welli1111dale v. Norris (1909] 1 K.B. 57, 64, Wicks v. Director of
Public Prosecution, [19471 I All E.R. 205, 206, R. v. Wicks, [1946]
2 All E.R. 529, 531 and Rathbone v. Bundock, [1962] 2 All E.R. 257,
applied.
Dr. Indranwni Payare/al Gupta v. W, R. Nathu, [1963J 1 S.C.R.
721. 737, distinguished.
U.S. v. George R. Eaton, 36 L.Ed. 591 and Singer v. U.S. 89 L.Ed.
c
D
E
F
.•
G
258, 290. referred to.
( 3) Even in a case where the amount has not been rece.ived, then.:.
n1ust be declaration of some actual figure, which, according to the declaration represents the 'full export value' It may be an estimate if the
goods have not been sold before the· export, but a figure must be il"ldicated. The requirement of supporting evidence and r. 5 (2) (ii) requiring the statement of the invoice value in the declaration indicatt: that
an actual figure has to be mentioned. Section 12(1) ·and the notification impose a conditional prohibition an on exporter v.·hich he can lift
by a unilateral declaration. When such a power is conferred on an exporter by a statute good faith on his part must be implied an<l is a
condition pre-requisite. Section 22 provides that the declarant shall no:.
give any information which he knows or has reasonable cause, to beliel:e
to be false or not true Clerical mistakes and mistakes made bona fide
even in respect of material particulars would not come, within the mischief of the section, hut a deliberate falsehood and deliberate eva<;ion of
the provisions of the section would be· a contravention of s. 12( 1) fnr
othenvise the ambit of the section read with s. 23A would be narro\ved
to the point of extinction. An exporter and persons concerned in the
export, could \vith impunity give a deliberately false declaration but in
apparent compliance with s. 12(1) and deprive this country of foreign
exchange. There is . no distinction, between an exporter and the
persons. c?ncerned 111 ~he ~port when no declaration under s.
12(1) is give~ at all and rn a case where the exporter gi,·es a deliberately
false declaration, for the purpose of the applicability of s. 167(8) of th
Sea Customs Act. [744 D-745 DJ
e
( 4) Since the same contravention may attract penalties under the
Sea Customs Act as well as the Foreign Exchange Act it will be incongruous to hold that the restrictions imposed by s. 12(1) are cl'ff
t
!or the two acts. (740 F-G]
1 eren
The Mayor of Portsmouth v. Charles Smith , JO AC
. . 364 , 371 , app l'1e(I.
. ( 5) Section 23A of the Foreign Exch
,A t d
h
, •· ·
1n1posed under s 12(1) t h
b
. ange c eems t e re~.dct1::n1s
Cust s A
:
o . ave een imposed under s. 19 of the Sea
pen
~t. without pre1ud1ce to th~ provisions in s. 23 dealin!! with
a Y an f?roc~dure for contravention of the provisions of 8 ,_12
any ru1e or dJrection or order mad th
d
p . ·
or
and therefore offenders v,rho vio1at: th~reun ~r. o~ ore1gn Exchange Act
ed with both, under the Foreign E h se ~s nct10ns could be proceeedSea Customs Act It mai' b , thxct ang~ e1J:ulation Act as well as the
.
t
·
.
e
a act10n can b
take
·
expor er under other sections of th F
.
E
e
n against an
e ore1gn xchange Regulation Act
um
H
730
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1969] 2 S.C.R.
or the Sea Customs Act, but that does not prevent action under s. 23A
read with s. 12(1) with the aid of customs authorities, both against ex·
porters and persons concerned in the prohibited export. [745 E--H]
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal Nos. 45 to
49 of 1968.
Appeals from the judgment and order dated September 20,
1967 of the Madras High Court in Writ Appeals Nos. 247 to 251
of 1966.
C. K. Daphtary, Attorney-General, Niren De, SolicitorGeneral, N. S. Bindra, Mohan Kumaramangalam, R. H. Dhebar,
A. S. Nambiar and S. P. Nayar, for the appellants (in C.As.
Nos. 45 and 47 to 49 of 1968).
Nircn De, Solicitor-General, Mohan Kumaramangalam, N. S.
Bindra, R. H. Dhebar, A. S. Nambiar and S. P. Nayar, for the
appellants (in C.A. No. 46 of 1968).
A. K. Sen, Soli Sorabji, S. R. Vakil, B. D. Barucha, G. L.
Sanghi, and S. K. Dho/akia, for the respondents (in C.A. No. 45
of 1968).
A
B
,• •
•
'>
.',.
c
~-
D
N. A. Palkhivala, Soli Sorabji, D. N. Misra, S. R. Vakil and
B. D. Barucha, for the respondent (in C.As. Nos. 46 and 49 of
1968).
G. L. Sanghi, S. R. Vakil and B. D. Barucha, for respondents
(in C. A. No. 4 7 of 1968) and their respondent (in C.A. No. 48
of 1968).
E
N. A. Palkhiva/a, P. P. Ginewala, D. N. Mukherjee and Ajit
Chaudhury, for interveners Nos. 1 to 4.
A. K. Sen, S. D. Khetri, Avadh Behar; and R. N. Bajoria, for
intervener No. 5.
.
F
N. A. Palkhivala and D. N. Gupta, for intervener No. 6.
M. C. Chagla and D. N. Gupta, for intervener No. 8.
N. A. Palkhivala, A. K. Basu, S. C. Mitter and I. N. Shroff,
for intervener No. 7.
·
M. C. Setalvad and M. K. Banerjee, for intervener No. 9.
i.
G
SJKRI, J. delivered a dissenting Opinion. The Judgment of
BACHAWAT and HEGDE JJ. was delivered by HEGDE, J.
Sikri, J. These five appeals by certificate are directed against
the judgment of the High Court of Madras whereby the High
Court accepted the Writ Appeals against the judgment of Kailasam, J., in Writ Petitions Nos. 1592, 1593, 1594 and 1601 of
1966 and 3948 of 1965, and directed the issue of writs of prohi-
H
.
..
UNION v. RA! BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD. (Sikrf, J.)
•
B
c
. •
D
E
--,
•
F
.t
G
H
7 31
bition to the Union of India, the Collector of Customs, Madras,
and the Deputy Collector of Customs, Visakhapatnam, appellants before us, prohibiting them from taking any action in pursuance of certain show-cause notices issued by the Deputy Collector Customs, Visakhapatnam. Common questions of law are
involved in these appeals and it would suffice if I give facts in
Writ Petition No. 1592 of 1966 out of which Civil Appeal No. 45
of 1968 arises.
The relevant facts in that writ petition, for appreciating the
points raised before us, are as follows: On February 17, 1965,
the Deputy Collector of Customs, Visakhapatnam, issued memorandum No. S/21/14/65 to Mis. Rai Bahadur Seth Shreeram
Durgaprasad (Private) Ltd., Tumsar, and five others, hereinafter
referred w as the Shippers. In this memorandum, in brief, it was
stated that the Shippers had entered into a formal contract on
October 13, 1965, with Ml s. Intercontinental Ores Supply
Corporation, New York, for the shipment of 20,000 tons of
Indian Manganese Ore of the grade of 43% Mn., from the port
of Visakhapatnam at a price of $0.157 per unit of Manganese per
dry long ton, f.o.b. Visakhapatnam/Bombay. The Shippers exported froin the port of Visakhapatnam 3,300 tons of Indian
Manganese per s.s. 'ALPHEM' under the cover of Shipping Bill
No. 187 dated March 20, 1957, declaring therein that the export
was being made in pursuance of the aforesaid contract. A G.R.l.
form was attached. It was stated that a certain not.e-book which
had been seized earlier in August 1963 disclosed that a sum oi
$25298.24 was received on April 21, 1957, from INOSCO, i.e.,
Intercontinental Ores Supply Corporation, New York, the consignee of the subject goods, the amount having been credited
to an account in the name of Gangadhar Narsinghdas Agrawal
with the Trust Co. of North America, 115, Broadway, New
York. It was further alleged in the memorandum that the Shippers had derived financial benefits in respect of the subject export
over and above those revealed to the Customs Authorities and/or
other concerned authorities and the information about them was
deliberately suppressed. It was further alleged that this constituted a contravention of s. 12(1) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1947, read with Notification No. 12(17)-F.1/47 dated
August 4, 1947, as amended, issued thereunder and the Foreign
Exchange Regulation Rules, 1952.
I may mention that by this notification the Central Government had prohibited "the export otherwise than by post of any
goods either directly or indirectly to any place outside India other
than any of the countries or territories in the Schedule annexed
to this order unless a declaration supported by such evidence as
may be prescribed is furnished by the exporter to the prescribed
732
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969] 2 S.C.R.
authority that the amount representing th~ full export val~e ?f
the goods has been or will within the prescnbed penod be paid m
the prescribed manner."
Accordin" to the Deputy Coilector Customs, the goods have
been thus exported in contravention of the restrictions and prohibitions imposed under s. 19 of the Sea Customs Act, 1878, read
withs. 12(1) and the Notification No. 12(17)-F.1/47 dated August
4 1947 issued thereunder, ands. 23A of the Foreign Exchange
R~gulati~n Act, 194 7, which exportation constituted an offence
liable to be punished under s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act,
1878. Accordingly, the parties concerned were called upon to
explain the matter and show cause in writing to the Collector of
Custom~, Madras, why a penalty should not be imposed on them/
him under s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act, 1878.
It appears that a number of such memoranda were issued in
respect of diverse shipments. Thereupon five petitions were filed
in the High Court of Madras. In Writ Petition No. 1592 of 1966
it was alleged that 125 show-cause notices had been issued to the
petitioners on various dates and it was prayed that a writ of prohibition or other appropriate writ, order or direction under Art. 226
of the Constitution of India prohibiting the respondents from taking any action in pursuance of the said show-cause memos, may be
issued.
Various allegations were made but I need only mention the
following allegations. It was submitted that the petitioners had
complied with the statutory provisions inasmuch as a declaration
in statutory form had been furnished to the prescribed authority,
to wit, the Collector of Customs, and the Collector of Customs.
having passed the consignments for shipment, had no further
right or jurisdiction to take proceedings relating to the consign- ments in question. It was contended that if a declaration is found
to be false, it did not mean that there was a breach of the provisions of s. 12(1).
In reply it was contended that what was required nnder s.
12(1) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act and the Rules was
not any value bnt the actnal amount representing the full export
value, and a mere declaration of any value would not be sufficient compliance with the provisions of s. 12(1) of the Foreign
Exchange Act.
. The lea~ned Si~gle Judge, Kailasam, J., dismissed the petit10ns. Var1ous pomts were urged but on the point addressed to
us he held that the declaration to be given by the exporters meant
not only that the value of the goods will be paid in the prescribed
manner but also that the full export value of the goods given is
the correct value.
A
•
B
c
D
I
E
•
r·..
F
G
H
UNION V. RA! BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD.
"'
'
A
•
B
c
-,
•
l
(Sikri, J.)
733
I may mention that before the Division Bench the case of the
Revenue was clarified in an affidavit and we may set out para 5
thereof:
"Since the Court has now directed the respondents
to file a supplemental affidavit clarifying the stand taken
by the department I state respectfully that the stand
taken by the department both in the show-cause memo
and here is that the essence of the offence committed by
the appellants is that in the declaration required under
section 12(1) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act.
they have deliberately given false particulars supported
by false evidence. By giving this fraudulent declaration,
they have secured the export of their goods. This fraud
vitiates the declaration itself, thereby making the export
one in violation of the prohibition contained in Section
12(1) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Ac:.'°
It is not necessary to set out the modus operandi adopted by
the petitioners but I may mention that it was contended that a
D scheme was entered into prior to the actual export and the goods
were undervalued deliberately and the department was induced
to accept their declarations by means of false evidence and fraudulent suppression of facts. It is suggested that by this method a
sum of Rs. 3,20,00,000 had been suppressed and there has been a
failure to repatriate a corresponding amount of foreign exchange
E which had been earned surreptitiously. It was further stated that
this scheme was adopted for all the shipments covered by the
show-cause notices, and also for many other shipments in respect
of which show-cause notices yet remain to be issued .
The Division Bench on appeal came to the conclusion that
as the declarations were made under s. 12(1) and as they were
F scrutinised by the authorities it is not possible to contend that
these goods were either exported or attempted to be exported in
violation of the prohibitions or restrictions imposed by law and
are, therefore, liable to be confiscated under s. 167(8) of the
Sea Customs Act. The Division Bench further held that the
~leged fraud on t~e part of the petitioners did not make any
d1~erence.
Accor~1!1g to the Division Bench "if the petitioners had
G
m!Sled t~e autho:1hes by false representations or failed thereby
to repatriate foreign exchange, by virtue of his obligation under
s. 12(2), these are different offences for which separate and specific penalties can be imposed."
H
The relevant statutory provisions at the time of exportation
were as follows :
"The Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1947 s.
12(1) The Central Government may, by notification in
4 Sup. CI/69-14
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
734
[1969] 2 S.C.R.
the Official Gazette, prohibit the taking or sending out
by land sea or air (hereinafter in this section referred
to as e;port) of any goods or class of goods specified in
the notification from India directly or indirectly to any
place so specified unless a de~laration suppo!ted ~y
such evidence as may be prescnbed or so specified, 1s
furnished by the exporter to the prescribed authority
that the amount representing the full export value of the
goods has been, or will within the prescribed period be,
paid in the prescribed manner.
·
(2) Where any export of goods has been made to
which a notification under sub-section (1) applies, no
person entitled to sell, or procure the sale of the said
goods shall, except with the permission of the Reserve
Bank, do or refrain from doing any act with intent to
secure that
(a) the sale of the goods is delayed to an extent
which is unreasonable having regard to the ordinary
course of trade, or
(b) payment for the goods is made otherwise than in
the prescribed manner or does not represent the full
amount payable by the foreign buyer in respect of the
goods, subject to such deductions, if any, as may be allowed by the Reserve Bank, or is delayed to such extent
as aforesaid :
Provided that no proceedings in respect of any contravention of this sub-section shall be instituted unless the prescribed period has expired and payment for
the goods representing the full amount as aforesaid has
not been made in the prescribed manner.
(3) Where in relation to any such goods the said
period has expired and the goods have not been sold and
payment therefor has not been made as aforesaid, the
Reserve Bank may give to any person entitled to sell the
goods or to procure the sale thereof, such directions as
appear to it to be expedient for the purpose of securing
the sale of the goods and payment therefor as aforesaid,
and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing
provision, may direct that the goods shall be assigned to
the Central Government or to a person specified in the
directions.
(4) Where any goods are assigned in accordance with
sub-section ( 3) the Central Government shall pay to
the person assigning them such sum in consideration of
the net sum recovered by or on behalf of the Central
A
,; -
•
B
i.,,
-~
c
.
D
... •
E
rI
F
'
./
G
H
•
•
UNION V. RAI BAHADUR SHREERAM .LTD.
. ".
Government in respect of the goods as may be determined by the Central Government.
A
(5) Where in relation to any such goods the value
as stated in the invoice is less than the amount which in
the opinion of the Reserve Bank represents the full export value of those goods, the Reserve Bank may issue
an order requiring the person holding the shipping documents to retain possession thereof until such time as
the exporter of the goods has made arrangements
for the Reserve Bank or a person authorised by the
Reserve Bank to receive on behalf of the exporter payment in the prescribed manner of an amount which represents in the opinion of the Reserve Bank the full
export value of the goods.
•
~
B
..) .
c
(6) For the purpose of ensuring compliance with
the provisions of this section and any order or directions
made thereunder, the Reserve Bank may require any
person making any export of goods to which a notifi·
cation under sub-section (1) applies to exhibit contracts
with his foreign buyer or other evidence to show that the
full amount payable by the said buyer in respect of the
goods has been, or will within the prescribed period
be, paid in the prescribed manner.
.,
~
D
E
-;
'
F
.
.
~
S. 22. No person shall, when complying with any
order or direction under section 19 or with any requirement under section 19B or when making any application
or declaration to any authority or person for any purpose under this Act, give any information or make any
statement which he knows or has reasonable cause to
believe to be false, or not true, in any material particulars.
S. 2.3. ( 1) If ~y person c?ntravenes the provisions
of sec1;1on 4, section 5, section 9 or sub-section (2)
of section 12 or of any rule, direction or order made
thereunder, he shall-
~
•
(Sikri, J.)
G
H
. (a) be liable to such penalty not exceeding three
t1m.es the value of the foreign exchange in respect of
which the contravention has taken place, or five thousand rupi;es, whichever is more, as may be adjudged
by the Di:ector of Enforcement in the manner hereinafter proVIded, or
. C?) upon conviction by a Court, be punishable with
llllpr~sonment for a .term which may extend to two years,
or with fine, or with both.
735
736
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969) 2 S.C.R.
(lA) Wheever contravenes(a) any of the provisions of this Act or of any rule,
direction or order made thereunder, other than those
referred to in sub-seetion (1) of this section and section
19, shall, upon conviction by a Court, be punishable
with imprisonment for a term which may extend to two
years, or with fine, or with both;
(b) any direction or order made under section 19
shall, upon conviction by a Court, be punishable with
fine which may extend to two thousand rupees.
(lB) Any Court trying a contravention under subsection (1) or sub-section (lA) and the authority adjudging any contravention under clause (a) of sub-section
(1) may, if it thinks fit, and in addition to any sentence or penalty which it may impose for such contravention, direct that any currency, security, gold or
silver, or goods or any other money or property, in
respect of which the contravention has taken place, shall
be confiscated to the Central Government and further
direct that the foreign exchange holdings, if any, or
the person committing the contravention or any part
thereof shall be brought back into India or shall be
retained outside India in accordance with the directions
made in this behalf.
Explanation.-For the purposes of this sub-section,
property in respect of which contravention has taken
place shall include deposits in the bank, where the said
property is converted into such deposits
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in section
32 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, it shall
be lawful for any Magistrate of the first class, specially
empowered in this behalf by the State Government, and
for any Presidency Magistrate to pass a sentence of fine
exceeding two thousand rupees on any person convicted
of an offence punishable under this section.
(3) No Court shall take cognizance(a) of any offence punishable nnder sub-section (1)
except upon complaint in writing made by the Director
of Enforcement, or
(b) of any offence punishable under sub-section (lA)
of· this section or under section 54 of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, as applied by section 19 of this
Act, except upon complaint in writing made by the
Director of Enforcement or any officer authorised in
A
•
B
c
•
D
E
r-'
F
f •
G
H
UNION v. RAJ BAHADUR SHREE.RAM LTD.
A
B
C
D
(Sikri, J.)
737
this behalf by the Central Government or the Reserve
Bank by a general or special order :
Provided that where any such offence is the contravention of any of the provisions of this Act or any rule,
direction or order made thereunder which prohibits the
doing of an act without permission, no such complaint
shall be made unless the person accused of the offence
has been given an opportunity of showing that he had
such permission.
(4) Nothing in the first proviso to section 188 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, shall apply to any
offence punishable under this section.
S. 23A. Without prejudice to any provisions of section 23 or to any other provision contained in this Act,
the restrictions imposed by sub-sections (1) and (2) of
section 8, sub-section (1) of section 12 and clause (a)
of sub-section (1) of section 13 shall be deemed to
have been imposed under section 19 of the Sea Customs
Act, 1879, and all the provisions of that Act shall have
effect accordingly, except that section 183 thereof shall
have effect as if for the word "shall" therein the word
"may" were substituted."
E
0
The Sea Customs Act, 1878
167. The offe1_1ces mentioned in the first ~o1umn of the fc1kw:ng ~chedule
sh<;i11 b~ pumshable to the extent mentioned in the third cclumn of the
same with reference to such offences respectively:
F
Offences
8. If any goods, the importation
or exportation of which is for
•
the time being prohibited or
G
restricted by or under Chapter
!Y of this Act, be imported
mto or exported from India
contrary to such prohibition or
restriction; or
If any attempt be made so to
import or export any such
goods; or
H
If any such goods be found in
any package produced to any
officer of Customs as containing
no such goods; or
Sections
of this Act
to which
offence has
reference
18
&
19
Penalties
Such goods shall be liable
to confiscation·
and
'
Any person concerned in
any such offence shall bo
liable to a penalty not ex..
ceeding three times the value
of the goods, or not exceeding
one thousand rupee.s,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
738
-
[1969] 2 S.C.R.
A
Offences
Penalties
If any such goods, or any dutiable
goods, be found either before or
after landing or shipment to have
been concealed in any manner on
board of any vessel within the
1imits of any port in India; or
B
If any goods, the exportation of
which is prohibited or restricted
as aforesaid, be brought to any
wharf in order to be put on board
of any vessel for exportation
contrary to such prohibition or
restriction.
c
"Foreign Exchange Regnlation Rules, 1952.
3. Form of declaration.--(!) A declaration under
section 12 of the Act shall be in one of the forms set
out in the First Schedule as the Reserve Bank may by
notification in the Gazette of India specify as appropriate
to the requirements of a case.
(2) Declarations shall be executed in sets of such
number as indicated on the forms.
D
E
•
r
4. Authority to whom declaration to be furnished.
(I) The original of the declaration shall be furnish-
ed to the Collector of Customs : provided .that when
export is by post, the original of the declaration shall
be furnished to the postal authorities.
F
(2) Copies of the declaration shall be submitted to
the authorities and in the manner specified qn forms.
(3) The documents pertaining to every export passed by the Customs shall within 21 days from the date
of the export, be submitted to the authorised dealer
mentioned on the relevant declaration form, unless the
Reserve Bank, in its discretion, authorises otherwise.
•
5. Evidence in support of declaration. (I) The Reserve Bank, or subject to such directions, if any, as
may be given by the Reserve Bank, the Collector of
Customs or the postal authorities, may, to satisfy themselves of due compliance with section 12 of the Act,
..
•·
G
ff
f'
UNION v. RAI BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD. (Sikri, J.)
A
•
'·
B
A
".
c
require such evidence in support o~ the declaratio_n as
may satisfy them that the exporter 1s a person resident
in India, or has a place of business in India.
(2) The Reserve Bank, or subject to such directions,
if any, as may be given by the Reserve. ~ank, the C?llector of Customs, or the Postal authorities may requrre
any exporter to produce in support of. the declaration
such evidence as mai be in his possession or power to
satisfy them.
(i) ...
(ii) that the invoice value stated in the declaration
is the full value of the goods; and (iii) that the amount
representing the full export value of the goods has been
or will be paid to the exporter.
Explanation.-. ..
7'
~
D
E
-i
.
F
,
• ~
G
739
,,
The points which have emerged from the discussion at the
Bar and which require determination may be formulated thus :
(1) What is the meaning of the expression "restrictions imposed by sub-section (1) of section 12" occurring in s. 23-A of
the Exchange Act ? Can other sections of the Exchange Act be
looked at for determining the ambit of the restrictions imposed
by s. 12(1) ? Do restrictions imposed under the Rules made under
the Exchange Act and relating to s. 12(1) come within the meaning of this expression '!
(2) What is the true meaning of the words "a declaration
supported by such evidence as may be prescribed or so specified
is furnished by the exporter to the prescribed authority that the
amount representing the full export value of goods has been or
will within the prescribed period be paid in the prescribed manner" ? Is it necessary that the declaration shall be made honestly
?r in good faith ? Should it disclose the true export value? Is
1t a breach of the sub-section if a declaration is made honestly
but happens to show incorrect export value to a small but not
material extent? Does not a deliberately false declaration contravene the provisions of s. 12(1)?
(3) If an action is a contravention of s. 12(1) and other provisions of the _Excha~ge ~ct, e.g., ss. 22, 23, 12(2), 12(3) and
12(5), . was It the mtentlon that it should be treated as a contravention of s. 12(1)?
H
·"I
. Before deali1_1g with point (1) mentioned above, a few prelim1~ary observatmns may be made. I have to construe an Act
wh!ch was enacted in the interest of the national economy. A
deliberate large-scale contravention of its provisions would affect
740
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969] 2 S.C.R.
the interests of every man, woman and child in the country. Such
an Act, I apprehend, should be construed so as to make it workable; it should, however, receive ·a fair construction, doing no
violence to the language employed by the Legislature. It was
said that if two constructions are possible the one that is in
favour of the snbject should be accepted. It is not necessary
to pronounce on this proposition for I have come to the conclusion that there is one true construction of s. 12(1). But I should
not be taken to be assenting to this proposition in so far as it is
applicable to an enactment like the Exchange Act, for no subject
has a right to sabotage the national economy.
Coming to the first point, I find that the following words of
Lord Blackburn express my views as to how the construction of
s. 23A should be approached. He was dealing with a case
where a single section of an Act of Parliament has been introduced
into another Act. He said in The Mayor of Portsmouth v.
C.harles Smith(') :
"When a single section of an Act of Parliament is
introduced into another Act, I think it must be read in
the sense which it bore in the original Act from which it
is•taken, and that consequently it is perfectly legitimate
to refer to all the rest of that Act in order to ascertain
what the section meant, though those other sections are
not incorporated in the new Act. I do not mean that if
there was in the original Act a section not incorporated,
which came by the way of a proviso or exception on that
which is incorporated, that should be referred to. But
all others, including the interpretation clause, if there
be one, may be referred to."
It seems to me that this is the correct way of looking at s.
23A of the Exchange Act for another reason. The restrictions
imposed by s. 12(1) cannot be different for the purpose of the
Exchange Act from that for the purposes of s. 167(8) of the Sea
Customs Act, for the breach of s. 12(1) may also be punishable
under the Exchange Act. In other words, the same contravention
may attract penalties under the Sea Customs Act as well as the
Exchange Act, and it would be incongruous to hold that the restrictions imposed by a section are different for different Acts.
Then am I entitled to take into account the restrictions imposed by the Rules made under s. 27 of the Exchange Act? It
seems to me that rules not referrable to s. 12(1) cannot be taken
into account, but any restrictions imposed by rules referrable to
s. 12(1) must be treated as restrictions imposed by s. 12(1). Section 12(1) itself contemplates rules being made on three points,
(!) 10 A.C. 364, 371.
A
.I
B
c
D
E
r.
'
F
G
H
UNION v. RA! BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD.
. .•
A
•
B
c
•
D
E
-t
'
F
(Sikri, J,)
741
i.e. (1) the evidence which is to support the declaration, (2) the
authority to which the declaration is to be furnished; and (3)
manner of payment. It was said that the words "by sectio11
12(1)"' exclude the restrictions made under the Rules. But though
in some contexts and scheme of an Act this proposition may be
true, the general rule is as stated by Lord Alverstone, C.J., in
We/lingdali:. v. Norris(') as follows :
"If it be said that a regulation is not a provision of
an Act, I am of opinion that Rex v. Walker( 2 ) is 1n
authority against that proposition. I should certainly
have been prepared to hold apart from authority that,
where a statute enables an authority to make regulations
a regulation made under the Act becomes for the purpose
of obedience or disobedience a provision of the Act. The
regulation is only the machinery by which Parliament
has determined whether certain things shall be or shall
not be done."
These observations were approved by tbe House of Lords in
Wicks v. Director of Public Prosecution(') thus :
"There is, of course, no doubt that, when a statute
like the Emergency Powers (Defence) Act, 1939, enables
an authority to make regulations, a regulation which is
validly made under the Act, i.e., which is intra vires
of the regulation-making authority, should be regarded
as though it were itself an enactment. As the Court of
Criminal Appeal has pointed out in its judgment, that
was decided by the Divisional Court in Willingdale v.
Norris('), and it appears to me that that decision is
perfectly correct. Consequently, the charge against the
appellant here was, in effect, that he had committed
crimes defined or contained in the Act of Parliament."
The Court of Criminal Appeals had stated in R. v. Wicks ('),
as follows :
G
H
"The first observation which the court would make
is that they are in complete agreement with the decision
of the Divisional Court in Willingdale v. Norris(') that
where a statute enables an authority to make regulations,
a regulation made under the Act becomes for the purpose of obedience or disobedience a provisiqn of the
Act.. The regulation is only the machinery by which
Parliament has determined whether certain things shall
or shall not be done. Jt is, therefore, clear that the
(I) [1909] l K.B. 57, 64.
(3) [1947] I All E.R. 205, 206.
(2) [1875] L.R. IO Q.B. 355.
(4) [19461 2 All E.R. 529, 531'.
742
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969) 2 S.C.R.
regulations must be read as _thou~ they were contained
in the Act itself. They denve their efficacy solely from
the Act and accordingly expire with the Act, but it may
be that the legislature has provided that some restrictions or consequences shall remain effective notwithstanding the expiration of the Act."
In a recent case, Rathbone v. Bundock(' ), the Divisional
Court following these cases held that regulation 89 of the Motor
Vehicles (Construction and Use) Regulations, 1955, was for the
purpose of obedience or disobedience a provision of the Road Traffic Act, 1930.
A
•
B
\,..
· i,...
In Dr. lndramani Pyarela/ Gupta v. W. R. Nathu and
Others( 2 ) this Court was concerned, inter alia, with the interpretation of s. 3(1) of the Forward Contract (Regulation) Act, 1952,
which used the words "such duties as may be assigned by or
under this Act"; Ayyangar, J., speaking for the majority, ob-served:
C
"Learned Counsel is undoubtedly right in his submission that a power conferred by a bye-law is not one
conferred "by the Act" for in the context the expression
"conferred by the Act" would mean "conferred expressly
or by necessary implication by the Act itself .... The
words, "under the A ct" would, in that context, signify
what is not directly to be found in the statute itself but
is conferred or imposed by virtue of powers enabling this
to be done; in other words, by laws made by a subordinate law-making authority which is empowered to
do so by the parent Act. This distinction is thus between
what is directly done by the enactment and what is done
indirectly by rule-making authorities which are vested
with powers in that behalf by the Act. (vide Hub/i
Electricity Bombay Ltd v. Province of Bombay( 3 ),
and Narayanaswami Naidu v. Krishna Murthi( 4 )".
The observations of Subba Rao, J., as he then was, at p. 775,
Telied upon by the appellants are these :
"I would, therefore, construe the words "by or
under this Act, or as may be prescribed" as follows :
"by this Act" applies to powers assigned proprio vigore
by the provisions of the Act; "under this Act" applies to
an assignment made in exercise of an express power
conferred under the provisions of the Act; and "may be
prescribed" takes in an assignment made in exercise of
D
{1) [1962] 2 All E.R. 257.
(2) [1963] 1 S.C.R. 721, 737.
(3) 67 I.A. 57. 66.
(4) J.L.R. (1958) Mad. 513. 547.
E
t-
•
F
G
H
i_.
UNION V. RA! BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD.
. .•
A
B
c
D
>
E
-t
'
F
G
H
(Sikri, J.)
743
a power conferred under a rule. This construction gives
a natural meaning to the plain words used in the section
and avoids stretching the language of a statutory provision to save an illegal bye-law."
In my opinion that case does not assist me because the Court
was construing the words "by or under the Act", and Ayyangar,
J., specifically discussed the meaning of "by the Act" in the context.
Regarding the case of United States v. George R. Eaton,(')
relied on appellants' behalf, I find that the Supreme Court of
the United States explained and distinguished that case in Singer
v. United States(2) as follows :
"United States v. Eaton(') turned on its special
facts, as United States v. Grimaud(') emphasizes. It
has not been construed to state a fixed principle that a
regulation can never be a "law" for purposes of criminal prosecutions. It may or may not be, depending on
the structure of the particular statute. The Eaton case
involved a statute which levied a tax on cleomargarine
and regulated in detail cleomargarine manufacturers.
Section 5 of the statute provided for the keeping of such
books and records as the Secretary of the Treasury
might require. But it provided no penalty for non-compliance. Other sections, however, laid down other
requirements for manufacturers and prescribed penalties for violations. Section 20 gave the Secretary the
power to make "all needful regulations" for enforcing
the Act. A regulation was promulgated under s. 20 requiring wholesalers to keep a prescribed record. The
prosecution was for non-compliance with that regulation. Section 18 imposed criminal penalties for failure
to do any of the things "required by law." The Court
held that the violation of the regulation promulgated
under s. 20 was not an offence. It reasoned that since
Congress had prescribed penalties for certain acts but
not for the failure to keep books the omission could not
s~pplied by. regulation. And Congress had not added
cnnunal sanctions to the rules promulgated under s. 20
of that Act."
m:
. I would in this connection prefer to apply the English decision~ r~ferred to above, as s. 12(1) itself does not impose any
restnct10ns and contemplates certain things to be prescribed.
(I) 36 L. Ed 591.
(2) 89 L. Ed 285, 290.
(3) 220 US 506, 518, 519: 55 L. Ed 563, 568: 31 S. Ct. 480.
744
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969] 2 s.c.R.
Coming now to the construction of s. 12(1), it seems to ~e
that what it requires is a declaration of some actual figure which
according to the declarant represents 'the full export valu~·. Otherwise there is no point in requiring support of such evidence as
may be prescribed. Further it is clear that some actual figure
has · to be mentioned when the exporter declares that he has
received the amount representing the full export value. I apprehend that the same applies in the case where the amount has
not yet been received. The rules make this clear. Rule 5(2)(ii)
which requires the ·invoice value stated in the declaration to be
the full export value of goods, is referrable to s. 12(1) of the
Exchange Act and may be taken to indicate that an actual figure
has to be mentioned. It may be an estimate if the goods have
not been sold before the export, but a figure must be indicated.
Coming to the crux of the problem, does s. 12(1) by itself
require absolutely correct particulars? It is said that s. 12(1)
does not require it for s. 22 requires the exporter only to make a
declaration "which he knows or has reasonable cause to be false
or not true in any material particulars." How could it be that
if s. 12(1) itself requires absolutely correct particulars, s. 22
limits the requirement ? It seems to me that there is force in
this contention. but only to a limited extent. Section 12(1) and
the notification dated August 4, 1947, made under it, impose a
conditional prohibition. The section confers a power on an exporter to lift the bar by a unilateral declaration. When such a
power is conferred on an exporter by a statute, good faith on
his part must at least be implied and be a condition pre-requisite.
This construction is necessary in order to prevent abuse of the
power given by the Act. (See Maxwell on Interpretation of Statutes, 11th Edition, p. 116). If the exporter makes a deliberately
false declaration he contravenes s. 12(1) because he has not made
the statutory declaration in good faith. It is not necessary to
say that the declaration becomes anullity because the breach of
good faith, a condition prerequisite, is itself a contravention of
the conditional prohibition or restriction, within s. 167(~) of the
Sea Customs Act read with s. 23A and s. 12(1) of the Exchange
Act. Clerical mistakes and mistakes made bona fide even in respect of material particulars are not within the mischief of s.
12(1), but a deliberate falsehood and a deliberate evasion of the
provisions of s. 12(1) come within' s. 12(1). Otherwise the ambit
of s. 12(1), read with s. 23A, would be narrowed to the point of
extinction. An exporter and persons concerned in the export
could with impunity give a deliberately false declaration but in
apparent compliance with s. 12(1), and deprive this country of
foreign exchange. I cannot give an interpretation which will make
A
B
c
D
E
'
-r·•
F
G
;.
H
UNION v. RA! BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD.
A
B
c
D
E
-+
'
F
•
G
(
H
(Sikri, J.)
745
a mockery of the section. But it is said that other sections of
the Exchange Act will take care of such an exporter. He can be
prosecuted under s. 23(1A) read with s. 22. He can be sentenced
to imprisonment which may extend to two years. He can also
be fined to an unlimited extent. The Foreign Exchange lost can
be retrieved by a court acting 1 under s. 23 (B). This may be true
that the exporter is liable as stated above. But what about persons concerned in the illegal export ? It is the persons concerned
in the export which in most cases enables the exporter to successfully evade the provisions of the Exchange Act. These persons
are taken care of only under the Customs Act. If they are covered by s. 167(8), there is no reason to exclude the exporter himself. It is not unusual IO make persons liable both to penalties
under the Sea Customs Act and the Exchange Act. It is indeed
conceded that if no declaration is given under s. 12(1) and the
goods are exported, the exporter and the persons concerned in
the export would be liable to be proceeded both under s. 167(8)
of the Sea Customs Act and the Exchange Control Act. I can
draw no distinction between such an exporter and an exporter
who gives a deliberately false declaration for the purpose of the
applicability of s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act.
I am not impressed by the argument that the Foreign Exchange
Act deals with the basic policy regarding foreign exchange and
it was not the intention to punish offenders who violate foreign
exchange restrictions under the Sea Customs Act. It is s. 23A
of the Exchange Act which itself deems the restrictions imposed
under s. 12(1) to have been imposed under s. 19 of the Sea Customs Act. Not only that. The opening sentence of s. 23A makes
it clear that this is without prejudice to s. 23 and to any other
provisions in the Exchange Act. In other words, the provisions
of s. 23 and other relevant sections are not affected or limited.
They will have their full operation.
The fact that the exporter may be proceeded under s. 12(2)
(I may assume that this is so for the purpose of this case) for
non-payment of the full amount payable by the foreign buyer, or
that the Reserve Bank can in the eventualities mentioned in s.
12(5) require the holding up of shipping documents or that the
Reserve Bank by exercising powers under s. 12(6) secure contracts and other evidence to discover the full amount payable do
not throw any light on the construction of s. 23A and s. 12(1)
except that the Legislature is anxious that the "full export value"
shall be received in this country. Section 23A read withs. 12(1)
calls in the aid of Customs authorities to achieve the same object,
but ropes in alongwith the exporter the persons concerned in the
prohibited export.
746
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969] 2 S.C.R.
I am not able to appreciate how the existence of s. 167(37),
s. 167(72) and s. 167(81) is of any assistance for the purpose of
interpreting s. 23A and s. 12(1) of the Exchange Act. It may
be-I do not decide it-that an exporter, like the respondents,
will also be liable to be proceeded against under these items of
s. 167.
Taking the facts as alleged by the Customs authorities to be
true, as they must be taken to be true for the purpose of this
application under Art. 226, it seems to me that no case for the
issue of a writ of prohibition has been made out. In the result
the judgment of the Appeal Court is reversed and that of the
learned Single Judge restored. The appellants will have costs
incurred in this Court. One hearing fee.
Hegde, J. We had the advantage of studying the judgment
just now delivered by our brother Sikri, J. but we regret that
we are unable to agree with the conclusions reached by him.
After carefully analysing the arguments advanced before us we
have come to the conclusion that no grounds were made out to
interfere with the order of the Appellate Bench of the Madras
High Court. We shall now proceed to give our reasons in support of our conclusion.
The respondents in these appeals are exporters of manganese
ore. It is said that they had exported large quantities of manganese ore after ostensibly complying with the formalities of
Jaw but in reality they had under-invoiced the various consignments sent by them and further that they had failed to repatriate
foreign exchange of the value of about three crores of rupees obtained by them as the price of the manganese ore exported. It is
said that by so doing they had contravened s. 12(1) of the Foreign
Exchange Regulation Act, 1947 (to be hereinafter referred to
as the Act) read with s. 23(A) of that Act and ss. 19 and 167(8)
of the Sea Customs Act. The case for the appellants is that d!:•·
ing the search of the houses of some of the respondents on suspicion that they had hoarded gold, certain documents from the
house of some of the respondents were seized and those documents disclosed the facts set out above. On the basis of the said
information the Deputy Collector of Customs, Visakhapatnam
issued several notices to the respondents requiring them to show
cause why no action should not be taken against them under the
aforementioned provisions. On receipt of those notices the respondents moved the High Court of Madras under Art. 226 of the
Constitution praying that that court may be pleased to quash the
sho_w cause notices in question and prohibit the appe113!1lts from
takmg any further action on the basis of those notices. Those
petitions were dismissed by Kailasam, J. on September 1, 1966
A
B
c
D
E
•
+I
F
G
H
'
UNION v. RA! BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD. (Hegde, J.)
. .,
A
B
c
'
D
E
•""-•
F
,
G
f
H
747
but his orders were reversed by the Appellate Bench of that Court
by its Judgment dated September 12, 1967. The App~Ilate Be~ch
granted the reliefs prayed for by the respondents. It IS a~ ~gamst
that decision these appeals have been brought after obtammg the
necessary certificates from the High Court.
The only question that arises for decision in these appeals is
whether on the facts set out in the show cause notices, which
facts have to be assumed to be correct for the purpose of these
proceedings, the respondents can be held to have contravened s.
12(1) which reads:
"The Central Government may, by notification in the
Official Gazette, prohibit the taking or sending out by
land, sea or air (hereinafter in this section referred to
as export) of any goods or class of goods specified in
the notification from India directly or indirectly to any
place so specified unless a declaration supported by such
evidence as may be prescribed or specified, is furnished
by the exporter to the prescribed authority that the
amount representing the full export value of the goods
has been, or will within the prescribed period be, paid
in the prescribed manner."
On August 4, 1947, the Central Government issued a notification prohibiting the export of all goods to any place outside
India unless a declaration supported by such evidence as may
be prescribed is furnished by the exporter to the prescribed authority that the amount representing the full export value of the
goods has been or will within the prescribed period be, paid in
the prescribed manner. Rule 3 of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Rules 1952 framed under s. 27 of the Act provides that a
declaration under s. 12 of the Act shall be in one of the forms
set out in the First Schedule as the Reserve Bank may by notification in the Official Gazette specify as appropriate to the requirement~ of a case. The form that is relevant for our pre.~ent purpose is G.R. 1. Rule 5 empowers the Reserve Bank, the Collector of C:ustoms or !he pos~al authorities, to require the exporter. to furmsh such evidence m support of the declaration as may
satisfy them that the exporter is a person resident in India or
has ~ place of business in India. These authorities may also
requrre the exporter to produce in support of the declaration such
evidence as ~ay ~e in his possession or power to satisfy them (1)
that th~ d~stmatmn stated on the declaration is the final place
of destmatlon of the goods exported; (ii) that the invoice value
s~-~ted in the declaration is the full export value of the goods, and
{m) that the amount .representing the full export value of the goods
has been or will be paid to the exporter. Form G.R. 1 stipulates
that the exporter should furnish the information called for therein.
748
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969] 2 S.C.R.
Therein the exporter is also required to make the following declaration.
·
"I hereby declare that I am the seller/ consignor
of the goods in respect of which this declaration is made
and that the particulars given above are true and (a)
that the invoice value declared is the full export value
of the goods and is the same as that contracted with the
buyer; (b) that this is a fair valuation of the goods
which are unsold,
I/My principals undertake that I/they will deliver to
the bank mentioned below the foreign exchange/rupee
proceeds resulting from the export of these goods or
before ........ "
It is not denied that the respondents before exporting the
goods in question had furnished declaration in the prescribed
forms. Therein they had declared that the full export value of
the goods has been or will within the prescribed period be paid
in the prescribed manner. It is also not denied that they had furnished to the appropriate authorities the prescribed evidence.
The case against them as mentioned earlier, is that they had
under-invoiced the goods and failed to repatriate a portion of the
foreign exchange earned by them. It is also alleged that they gave
incorrect information in their declarations. If these allegations
are correct which we have to assume to be correct for the purpose
of this, case, then it is obvious that the declarations given by the
respondents do not comply with the requirements of rule 5.
Section 22 of the Act provides that no person when making
an application or declaration to any authority or person for any
purpose under the Act shall give any information or make any
statement which he knows or has reasonable cause to believe to
be false or not true, in any material particular. Section 23
prescribes that if any person contravenes the provisions of s. 12
or of any rule, direction or order made thereunder he shall (a)
be liable to such penalty not exceeding three times the value of
the foreign exchange in respect of which the contravention has
taken place, or five thousand rupees, whichever is inore, as
may be adjudged by the Director of Enforcement in the manner
provided in the Act or (b) upon conviction by a court, be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to two
years, or with fine, or with both. In view of these provisions
it was not disputed before us that if the information given by the
respondents in the aforementioned declarations was false to the
knowledge of those who made those declarations or if they had
reasonable cause to believe that it was false or not true in any
A
•'
B
c
·'
D
E
.,..'. .
F
G
H
~
..
UNION v. RAI BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD. (Hegde, /.)
A
B
•
'-/ .
•
c
D
E
..
,
•
F
G
'
. . . ,,J,
H
749
material particular then they are liable to be dealt with under
s. 23.
Sub-section (2) of s. 12 provides that :
"where any export of goods has. been made to wh~ch
a notification under sub-s. (1) applies, no person entitled to sell, or procure the sale of the said goods shall,
except with the permission of the Reserve ~ank, do or
refrain from doing anything or take or refram from taking any action whic_h has the effect of securing that :
(b) payment for the goods is made otherwise than
in the prescribed manner or does not represent the full
amount payable by the foreign buyer in respect of the
goods, subject to such deductions, if any, as may be
allowed by the Reserve Bank, or is delayed to such extent as aforesaid ...... "
The contravention of the above provisions is punishable
under s. 23. Hence the respondents' failure to repatriate any
part of the foreign exchange earned by them by the sale of
the mauganese ore exported can be penalised by imposing on them
a penalty not exceeding three times the value of the foreign exchange in respect of which the contravention had taken place
or Rs. 5,000/- whichever is more as may be adjudged by the
Director of Enforcement in the manner provided in the Act.
Hence it is open to the Director of Enforcement to levy on such
of the respondents as have contravened s. 12(2) panelty not exceeding three times the value of the. foreign exchange not
repatriated which in the present case can be about nine crores of
rupees. They may also be punished under s. 23(l)(b). This
position is conceded by the Counsel appearing for the appellants.
But it is urged on behalf of the appellants that for the offences
committed by the respondents they are not only liable to be
punished under s. 23 but also under s. 23(A). The Appellate
Bench of the Madras High Court negatived that contention. Section 23(A) as it stood at the relevant time provided that :
"withol!t.prejudice. to t~e pr?visions of s. 23 or any
other prov1s10n contamed m this Act, the restrictions
imposed by ........ sub-s. (1) of s. 12 ........ shall
be deemed to have been imposed under s. 19 of the Sea
Customs Act 1878 and all provisions of that Act shall
have effect accordingly, except that s. 183 thereof shall
have effect as if for the word 'shall' therein the word
'may' were substituted."
!f the allegations mentioned in the show cause notices come withm the scope of s. 23(A) then it necessarily follows that they will
4 Sup, Cl/69-15
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
750
[1969] 2 S.C.R.
be governed by the provisions of s. 19 and s. 167(8) of the Sea
Customs Act, 1878. Section 19 of the Sea Customs Act provides:
"that the Centriil Government may from time to time
by notification in the official gazette prohibit or restrict
the bringing or taking by sea or by land goods of any
specified description into or out of India across any customs frontiers as defined by the Central Government." ,
This section is similar to s. 12(1) of the Act. Section 167(8)
provides for punishments for offences under that Act. That section to the extent material. for our present purpose reads :
A
"The offences mentioned in the first column of the
following schedule shall be punishable to the extent mentioned in the third column of the same with reference
to such offences respectively -
c
Offences
Sections of
"11
this Act to
which offence has refe-
'
ta
G
or exportation ·of which is for 19
the time being prohibited or
restricted by or under Chapter
IV of this Act, be imported into
or exported from India contrary
to such prohibition or restriction;
or
if any attempt be made so to
or export
B
•
Penalties
D
rence
8. If any goods, the importation 18 and
import
•
Such goods shall be liable
to confiscation; and
any person concerned in any
such offence shall be liable
to a penalty not exceeding
three times the value of the
goods, or not exceeding one
thousand rupees.
E
•
any such
goods; or
if any such goods be found in
any package produced to any
officer of Custon1s as containing
no such goods; or
if any such goods, or any dutiable
goods, be found eithef before or
>
after land or shipment to have
been concealed in any manner on
board of -any vessel within the
limits of any port in India; or
if any goods, the exportation of
which is prohibited or restricted
as aforesaid be brought to any
wharf in order to be put on board
of any vessel for exportation
contrary to such prohibition or
restriction.
If an offence falls under s. 23A the fact that the said offence
is also punishable under s. ,23 is immaterial. The provisions of
{
G
H
UNION V, RA! BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD. (Jhgde, J.)
• ••
B
-.
'
•
•
c
D
E
F
G
H
751
s. 23(A) are without prejudice to the provisions of s. 23. The
mere fact that the offences alleged against the respondents are .
punishable under s. 23 would not exclude the application of s.
23(A). Therefore all that we have to see is whether those off~n
ces fall within the ambit of s. 23(A). If they do then the llllpugned show cause notices must be held to be valid. If they
do not, then no proceedings can be taken on the basis of those
notices.
Before a case can be held to fall within the scope of s. 23(A)
it must be shown that there has been a contravention of the restrictions intposed by s. 12(1). Therefore we have to find out what
those restrictions are? The only restriction placed by s. 12(1)
read with the Central Government Notification dated August 4,
1947, is that no one should export any goods from this country
without furnish the declaration mentioned in s. 12(1). Admittedly the stipulated declarations in the prescribed forms have
been furnished. The evidence specified have also been given.
Therefore prima facie there was no contravention of s. 12 ( 1).
What is said against the respondents is that the invoice price
mentioned by them in the declarations did not represent the full
export value; hence the declarations given by them are invalid
declarations which means that the concerned goods were exported
without furnishing the declarations required by s. 12(1). It is
not possible to accept this argument. The declarations given to
satisfy the requirements of s. 12(1) though they do not correctly
furnish all the informations asked for in the form. Such declarations cannot be considered as non-est. The informations called
for in the prescribed form cannot be considered as restrictions
intposed by s. 12(1). They are merely informations called for
the proper exercise of the powers under the Act. Many of them
do not relate to the restrictions intposed by s. 12(1 ). Neither s.
12(1) nor any other provision in the Act empower the rule making
autltority to add to the restrictions imposed by s. 12(1). For
finding out the r.estrictions imp?sed by s. 12(1) we have only to
!ook to .that sect10n. 'J'!ie reqwrement of that section is satisfied
1f the st.1pula~ed dec!aratlon supported by the evidence prescribed
or. specifi~d 1s furrushed. The contravention complained of in
this cas~ 1s re~y the contravention of s. 12 (2) and Rule 5. The
fo.rmer is purushable under s. 23 and the latter under s. 23 read
with s. 22.
The declaration r~quired by s. 12(1) is only to the effect that
the amoun.t re~r~enting the full export value of the goods has
b~en or will within .th~ presc~ibed period be, paid in the prescnbed manner. ThIS IS as 1t should be because this section
governs both the goods sold to the foreign buyers as well as to
those sent on consignment basis. So far as the goods sold to
752
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969} 2 S.C.R,
the foreign buy are concerned it is generally possible for the
exporter to know the exact export value but ~at would ~ot be
the position when the goods are sent on consignment bas!S. In
the case of goods sent on consignment basis, the exporter can give
only an estimated value. The main purpose ~f s. 12(1) is to get.a
declaration from the exporter that he has either brought or wI!l
bring back the amount representing the full export value of the
good~ exported. There are other provisions in the Act to deal with
other situations. We shall presently refer to them.
If we are to hold that every declaration which does not state
accurately the full export value of the goods exported is a contravention of the restrictions imposed by s. 12(1) then all exports
on consignment basis must be held to contravene the restrictions
imposed by s. 12(1). Admittedly s. 12(1) governs every type of
export. Again it is hard to believe that the legislature intended
that any minor mistake in giving the full export value should be
penalised in the maner provided in s. 23(A). The wording of
s. 12(1) does not support such a conclusion. Such a conclusion
does not accord with the purpose of s. 12(1).
It is trµe that the regulations contained in the Act are enacted in the economic and financial interest of this country. The
contravention of those regulations which we were told are widespread are affecting vital economic interest of this country; Therefore the rigour and sanctity of those regulations should be maintained but at the same time it should not be forgotten that s. 12(1)
is a penal section. The true rule of construction of a section like
s. 12(1) is, if we may say so with respect, as mentioned by Plowman J. in Re H. P. C. Productions Ltd.(') Therein the learned
Judge observed :
"I approach the question of the construction of the
Exchange Control Act in the light of the principles stated by Upjohn J. in London and Country Commercial
Properties Investment v. Attorney-Genera/( 2 ) to which
Mr. Bagnall referred. In that case the court was concerned with the construction of the Borrowing (Control
and Guarantees) Act, 1946 and the Control of Borrowing Order 1947. Upjohn J. said: "The first question I
have to consider is what are the principles of construction which I mnst adopt in construing this Act and this
order . . . . I have to bear in mind that this is a penal
statute. It indeed, I suppose, represents the high water
mark of the Parliamentary invasion of tlie traditional
rights of the subjects of this realm ..~ Then Ire went on
--(1) {1962] Ch. Dn. 466 at 473,
Q) [1953] 1, All E.R ..43&
A
.'
•
B' ·
..'
c
D
E
F
G
H
•
UNION V. RAI BAHADUR SHREERAM LTD. (Hegde, J.)
A
>
~.
>
B
..•
c
'
f
D
E
'
...•
F
4
"'
\
G
'
H
~
•
753
to explain why that was so and continued : "In. those
circumstances what are the canons of construct10n to
be adopted ? I do not propose to refer to the authorities at length. I think that the proper approach to the
construction of such a statute as this is that I must construe it as I would any other instrument, that is to say,
I must look at all the surrounding circumstances, I must
look at the mischief intended to be remedied, I must
above all give effect to the words that have been used
in the section. That is plain from the decision in Dyke
v. Elliot(') see, in particular, the judgment of James
L.J. but if on construing the relevant sections of the Act
and the order there appears any reasonable doubt or
ambiguity, then being a penal statute I must apply the
principles laid down succinctly by Lord Esher in Tuck
and sons v. Prester.( 2 )
In London and North Eastern Rly. Co. v. Berriman,( 3 ) Lord
Macmillan observed :
"Where penalties for infringement are imposed it is
not legitimate to stretch the language of a rule, however
beneficent its intention, beyond the fair and ordinary
meaning of its language."
This Court in Tolaram Relumal and anr. v. State of Bombay(')
speaking through Mahajan C.J. observed :
"It is not competent to the Court to stretch the
meaning of an expression used by the Legislature in
order to carry out the intention of the Legislature."
Hereinbefore we have examined the language of s. 12(1) and its
purpose. We have also referred to the provisions which provide
for the punishment of the contraventions complained of in these
cases. Those provisions are adequate to meet the situation. In
our opjpion the language of s. 12(1) does not permit the acceptance of the interpretation placed on it by the appellants nor are
we able to come to the conclusion that the legislature intended
that the offences complained of in these proceedings should be
made punishable und.er s. 23(A). If the interpretation sought to
be placed by the appellants on s. 12(1) is accepted it may result
in unnecessary hardship in numerous cases.
There are two facets in every export, one relating to the goods
exported and the other r~lating to the foreign exchange earned
as a result of the export. Broadly speaking the former aspect is
dealt with by the Customs authorities and the latter either by the
(I) [1872] LR. 4 P.C. 184, 191,
(2) [1887] 19 Q.B.D. 629.
(3) [1946] A.C. 286 at 295.
(4) [1955] 1 S.C.R. 158 at p, 164.
754
·SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1969] 2 S.C.R.
Reserve Bank or by the Director of Enforcement. The price ef .A
the goods exported has to be mentioned in the invoice. But the
Reserve Bank has power to examine whether the price mentioned
in the invoice is correct. Section 12(5) provides that where in
relation to any goods exported the value as stated in the invoice
is less than the amount which in the opinion of the Reserve Bank
represents the full export value of those goods, the Reserve Bank B
may issue an order requiring the person holding the shipping
documents to retain possession thereof until such time. as the
exporter of the goods has made arrangements for the Reserve
Bank or a person authorised by the Reserve Bank to receive on:
behalf of the exporter payment in the prescribed manner of an:
amount which represents in the opinion of the Reserve Bank the c
full export value of the goods. Sub-Section (6) of s. 12 says that
for the purpose of ensuring compliance with the provisions of
that section and any orders or directions made thereunder, the
Reserve Bank may require any person making any export of
goods to which a notification under sub-s. (1) applies to exhibit
contracts with his foreign buyer or other evidence to show that D
the full amount payable by the said buyer in respect of the goods
has been or will within the prescribed period be paid in the
prescribed manner. These povisions go to indicate that so far
as the value of the goods exported is concerned the matter is left
primarily in the hands of the Reserve Bank, and the Customs
authorities are not burdened with that work. This aspect becomes
relevant in ascertaining the true scope of s. 12(1). If we bear in
mind th.e scheme of the Act, it is clear that so far as the Customs
.authorities are concerned all that they have to see is that no
goods are exported without furnishing the declaration prescribed
under s. 12(1). Once that stage is passed the rest of the matter
is left in the hands of the Reserve Bank and the Director of EnF
forcement.
In view of our above conclusion it is unnecessary for us to
examine the other contention advanced on behalf of the parties.
In the result these appeals fail and they are dismissed \Vith costs.
One hearing fee.
ORDER
G
'
•
+·
'
/
...
In accordance with the opinion of the majority, these appeals
are dismissed with costs. One hearing fee.
Y.P.
•
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org