S. AZEEZ BASHA AND ANR. versus UNION OF INDIA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 20 October 1967 | [1968] 1 S.C.R. 833 | 1967 INSC 238
Key facts
- Decided
- 20 October 1967
- Bench
- K.N. WANCHOO*, R.S. BACHAWAT, V. RAMASWAMI, G.K. MITTER, K.S. HEGDE
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 84/1966
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1968] 1 S.C.R. 833
- Neutral citation
- 1967 INSC 238
Text of the judgment
:s. AZEEZ BASHA AND ANR.
A
v.
UNION OF INDIA
October 20, 1967
B
(With Connected Writ Petitions)
[K. N.
C. J., R. S. BACHAWAT, V. R.AMASWAMI,
G. K. MITTER, AND K. S. HEGDB, JJ.J
WANCHOO,
Aligarh Muslim University Act (40 of 1920) as amended by Act
62 of 1951 and Act 19 of 1965-If violative of Arts, 14, lQ.i 25, 26, 29,
30 and 31 of the Constitution-'Establish' meaning of-Right of
religious minority to administer or maintain-When arises-Fundator perficiens, rights of.
c
In 1877, the Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College at Aligarh
(MA.O. College) was started as a teaching Institution under the D
Allahabad University for the educational regeneration of Muslims
in India Thereafter, the idea of establishing a Muslim University
gathered strength and the Muslim University Association was
formed. The Government of India informed the Association that
a sum of rupees thirty lakhs should be collected before the University could be established. Therefore, a Muslim University Foun- •
.dation Committee was started and it collected the necessary funds.
The contributions were made by Muslims as well as non-Mµsll.ms.
With the M.A.O. College as a nucleus, the Aligarh Muslim University was then established by the Alil!arh Muslim University
Act, 1920. The preamble and ss. 3 and 4 of the Act show that the
M.A.O. College, the Muslim University Association and the M11&llm University Foundation Committee legally came to lend, and
that the three bodies voluntarily surrendered whatever property 1
they had to the Aligarh University, so that, all their properties
movable and immovable were vested In the Aligarh University.
Section 23 of the Act provided for the constitution of the Court of
the University. By the proviso to s. 23(1) no penon other than a
Muslim could be a member. of the Court of the UniverSlty, and by
s. 23(2)., the Court of the University was to ba the sup!feme governing body of the University. By su\>4. (3) the Court of the Univer- 9
slty was given the power of making statutes. Section 13 provided for the Governor General of India to be ~ Lord Rector of the
University and s. 14 provided that the Governor of the United
Provinces, the members of his Executive Council, the Ministers,
one member nominated by the Governor and one member nominated
by the Minister In charge of Education to be the Vlsltln&. Board
of the University. These persons were not necessarily Muslims
but they had powers -over the administration of the Univenlty
o\'farriding those of the Court of the University. Further, ss 28(2) B
and 30(3) laid down that no Statute or Ordinance or amendment
or repeal of an existing Statute or C>tdinance ·would have any validity unless It had been approved by the Governor General In
Council. Section 40 gave further powers to the Governor General In
Council to remove any difficulty which might arise In the establishment of the University.
833
•'
834
A
SUPBJUIE COURT REPORTS
(1968] 1 S.C.R.
In 1951, the A!igarh Muslim University (Amendment) Act,
1951 was passed and it made certain chanl!es in the 1920 Act on
account of the coming into force of the Constitution. Sections 13
and 14 w>ere so anifended that in the place of the Lord Rector, the
University was to have a Visitor and the powers of the Visiting
Board were conferred on the Visitor. The proviso to s. 23(1) was
deleted, with the result that, non-Muslims could also be the mem11ers of the Court of the University.
B
There were further amendments ty Ordinance II of 1965 which
was replaced by the Aligarh Muslim University (Amendment)
Act, 1965. As a result of those amendments the Court of the University no longler remained the supreme governing body. Many of
its powers w>ere taken away and those of the Executive Council
were correspondingly increased. The Court practically became a
body nominated by the Visitor, every P.!rson holding office immeO diately before the date on which the Ordinance was promulgated
ceased to hold office from the said date, and, until the Court was
reconstituted, the Visitor might by flaneral or special order direct
any officer of the University to exercise the powers and perform
the duties conferred or imposed on the Court.
The petitioners challanged the constitutional validity of the
1961 and 1965 Acts, on the following grounds :-(1) the Muslim
D -minority had established the University and therefore had a right
to administer it under Art. 30(1) of the Constitution, and that the
amendment& deprived the Muslim minority of th!& right in violation of the Article; (2) even if the minority had not established
the University, they had a right to administer the University as an
educational institution· and that they were in fact administering It
after it was established; (3) the right of the Muslim minority
I: under Art. 26(a) to maintain the University as an institution for
charitable purposes, wu violated; (4) the right of the Muslim minority as a religious denomination, under Art. 26(c) and (d), to ad·
minister the movable and immovable property of the University,
was Violated; (5) the provisions of the Act as amended are different from those of othl!r Statutes creating other universities, and
therefore, there was a violation of Art. 14; (6) the Muslim minority
p had been deprived of their rilht under Art. 19 to manage the
University and to·hold the property which was vested in ilie University; (7) the Muslim minority had been deprived of their property, namely, the property vested in the University, inasmuch as
the Court of the Univertlty after the 1965 Act was a body .very
different from the Court under the 1920 Act· and there was thus a
Violation of Art. 31(1); and (8) the right of the Muslim minority
to· ·profeas, practitle and propagate their religion under Art. 25,
G and their right to conser11e their language, script or culture under
Art. 29, were violated.
HELD: (1) The Aligarh University was neither established
nor. administered by the M~l!m minority and therefore thene is
n 0 question of any amendment to the 1920 Act violating Art. 30(1)
for that Article does not at all apply to the Uni11ersity. [854 H].
The words establish and administer in Art. 30(1) must be read
B conjunctively. that is. Art. 30(1) postula~s that a religious community· w'11 have the right to establish qnd administer educational
institutions of their choice, meaning thereby, that where a religious
minority establishes an educational Institution It will have the
right to administer it, but not otherwille. The word establish for
the purpose of the Article means bring into eNtence and educational institution• include universities. But Muslims, assuming
AZllEZ BASHA ~. UNION
(Wanc/wo, 0,J.)
•
they are a minority based on religion, did not establish the Uni- A
versity. B2fore the enacting of the University Grants Comm!Rlon
Act of 1956, there was no law in India which prohibited any private
individual or body from establishing a University, that is, an educational institution which grants its own deirees; but the privaw
individual or body could not insist that the degrees must be recognised by the Goviirnment. Such recognition depended. upon th.i
w•ill of the Government generally expressed through statute.
Therefore, there was nothing in 1920 preventing the Musll111 m- a
rity from establishing a University; but if they did so Its degrees
were not bound to t e recognised by the Government,. and that wu
why the Aligarh University was established by legislation, name)J,
the 1920 Act, and provided by s. 6 that its degre.is shall be recognised by the Government. Thus, when the Aligarh University wu
established in 1920 and by s. 6 of the 1920 Act its degrees had to be
recognised by Government, an institution was brought Into exi&tence which could not be brought into existence by any private 0
individual or body. The Act may have been passed as a result of
the efforts of the Muslim minority, but that does not U1ean that the
University, when it came into being under the 1920 Act was established ty the Muslim minority. The conversion of the 14.A.O.
College into the University was not by the Muslim minority. TM
University was brought into being by the 1920 Act and must therefore be held to have been established by the Central Legislature. D
[847 F-H; 848 A; 849 C-H; 850 D-H; 851 A-B, C-D; 852 D-E] ..
St. David's College, Lampeter v. Ministry of Educcition, [1951)
All E.R. 559, applied.
In re: The KeraZa Education Bm, 1957. [1959] S.C.R. 996, explained.
Further, the Muslim minority could not claim any rights ~ B
the basis that the University was an eleemosynary COJpOration and
that the minority were in the position of fundato.- ~. blecause: (i) it is the donors (some of whom were non.:Miisllms) and
not the Muslim minority that could be said to be In the position of
fundator fle1'ficiens; (ii) even the donors could only hav,e visltorial
rights under the English Common Law; and (iii) even those rights
have been negatived by the 1920 Act for it specilkally conferred F
such rights on the Lord Rector and the Visiting Board. [851 E-H].
(2) The provisions of the 1920 Act do not bear out the contention that it was the Muslim minority that was administering the
University after it was brought into existence. On the other hand,
the administration of the University was vest.eel in the Lord Rector,
the Visiting Board, and the statutory bOdies created by the 1920
Act whose members were not necessarily Muslims. It was only a
in one of them namely the Court of the University that th..>re was
a bar to the appointment of any one else except a Muslim. But
even with respect to the Courtb paragraph 8 of the Schedule to the
Act shows, that e\l'm though t e members of the Court had to be
Muslims. the electoratP which elected the members of the Court
were not exclusively Muslims. (853 F-G; 854 F-H].
(3) Assuming that educational Institutions would come within
Art. 26(a) as institutions for charitabLa purposes the right under B
Art. 26(a) could not be claimed by the Muslim minority, because,
the right to maintain (which includes the right to administer) will
only arise where the Institution is established by the rellllious
denomination. In this Article also, the words establish and maintain must be read conjunctively. [855 B-C, E-F].
L/P(N)7SCI-1'
836
8UPQKli OOUllT llll'OBTS
[1968] I s.c.11.
(4) Article 26(c) and (d) give pow~r to a n~Jigious denomination to own and acquire movable and Immovable property, and if
It owns or acquires such property it can administer it in accordance with law. There is nothing in the amending Acts which in
any way bars the Muslim minority from owning, acquiring or
administering movable or immovable property. Assuming that befot!~ 1920 the property which was vested in the University was the
property of the Muslim minority, it was voluntarily surrendered
to the corporate body created by the 1920 Act, namely, the Aligarh
B University. Th~ore, when the Constitution came into force
the11~ was no property held ty the Muslim minority. As the Mus..
lim minority did not own the property which was vested in the
Aligl\l'h University on the date of the Constitution, they could not
lay any claim to administer that property by virtue of Art. 26(d).
[855 H; 856 A·B].
c
The Durgah Committee Aimer v. S11ed Huuain Ali, [1962] 1 S.C.R.
383, followed.
(5i Article 14 does not require that the provisions in every Uni·
versity Act must alv.-.ays be the same, because, each university must
be taken to be a class by itself having ita own problems and it is for
the Legislature to decide what kind of constitution should be conferred on a particular university established by it. Therefore, there
D can be no question of discrimination on the ground that some other
University Acts provide for a different set up. [856 G-H; 857 CJ.
A
(6) Article 19(1)(c) does not give any right to any citizen to
manage any particular educational institution. It only gives the
right to citizens to form associations or unions, and that right has
not bel.m touched by the 1965 Act. Similarly, Art. 19(1)(f) does not
E give any citizen any· right to hold property vested in a corporate
pody like the University. It only provides that all citizens have the
right to acquire, hold and dispose of property of their own. There
.is nothing in the 1965 Act which in any way takes away the right of
the MusIi ms of this country to acquire, hold and dispose of property
of their own. [857 D-G].
(7) There is no breach of Art. 31 (1) for the 1965 Act did not
I' deprive the Muslim minority of any property, because the property
was not vested in the Muslim minority at any time after the 1920
Act came Into force. Assuming 'Muslim minority' is a person for the
purposes of Art. 31(1) and the petitioners have a right to file the
writs on its behalf, the 1965 Act made no change in the ownership
of the property which had already vested in the Aligarh University
after the 1920 Act came into force. [857 H; 858 F-H].
G
(8) The amendments made by the 1965 Act in the 1920 Act do
not in any way affect the right, under Art. 25, of the Muslims to
profess, practise and propagate their religion; nor do they affect
their right under Art. 29, to conserve their language, script or culture which they might have. [856 C-E].
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Writ Petitions Nos. 84, 174, 188, 241
B and 242 of 1966.
Petitions under Art 32 of the Constitution of India for the
enforcement of fundamental rights.
M. R. M. Abdul Kari, K. Rajendra Chaudhuri, and K. R.
Chaudhuri, for the petitioners (in W. P. No. 84 of 1966).
AZEEZ BASHA V. t'NlON
(Wanc/ioo, LJ,J.)
837
B. K. Bhattacharya and M. I. Khowaja, for the petitioners (in A
W. P. No. 174 of 1966).
Daniel A. Latifi and M. I. Khowaja, for the petitioners (in
W. P. No. 188 of 1966).
K. L. Gauba and S. Saukat Hussain, for the petitioners (in
W.P. No. 241 of 1966).
S. Shaukar Hussain, for the petitioners (in W.P. No. 242 of B
1966).
C. K. Daphtary, Attorney-General, N. S. Bindra, R. H. Dhebar, S. P. Nayar for R. N. Sachthey, for the respondent (in W.P.
Nos. 84, 174 and 242 of 1966) and the respondents Nos. 1 and 3
(in W.P. No. 188 of 1966).
c
C. K. Daphtary, Attorney-General, Lily Thomas, P. C.
Kapur, R. H. Dhebar for R. N. Sachthey, for the respondent (in
W.P. No. 242 of 1966).
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Wanchoo, C. J. These five writ petitions raise common questions and will be dealt with together. They attack the constitution- D
ality of the Aligarh Muslim University (Amendment) Act, No. 62
of 1951 (hereinafter referred to as the 1951-Act) and the Aligarh
Muslim University (Amendment) Act, No. 19 of 1965, (hereinafter
referred to as the 1965-Act). The principal attack is based on the
provisions of Art. 30(1) which lays down that "all minorities, whe- E
ther based on religion or li,1nguage, shall have the right to establish
and administer educational institutions of their choice". The case
of all the petitioners is that the Aligarh Muslim University (hereinafter referred to as the Aligarh University) was established by the
Muslim minority and therefore the Muslims had the right to administer it and in so far as the Acts of 1951 and 1965 take away
or abridge any part of that right they are ultra vires Art. 30(1). r
Besides this principal attack, the two Acts are also subsidiarily
attacked for violating the fundamental rights guaranteed under
Articies 14, 19, 25, 26, 29 and 31 of the Constitution. It is unnecessary to set out the nature of the attack under these Articles
for that will appear when we deal with the matter in detail later; G
suffice it to say that all the petitions do not make the attack under
all these Articles, but the sum total of the subsidiary attack! in all
these petitions takes in its sweep all these six Articles .
. The petitions have been opposed on behalf of the Union of
India and its main contention is that the Aligarh University was
established in 1920 by the Aligarh Muslim University Act, No.
XL of 1920, (hereinafter referred to as the 1920-Act) and that this R
establishment was not by the Muslim minority but by the Government of India by virtue of a statute namely, the 1920-Act and·
therefore the Muslim minority could not claim any fundamental
right to administer the Aligarh University under Art. 30(1). It
L:P(N)7SCI-14(•)
838
SlJl>BBJfE COURT REPORTS
[1968) 1 S.C,I\
A was further contended that as the Aligarh University was established by the 1920.Act by the Government of India, Parliament
had the right to amend that statute as it thought fit in the interest
of education and the amendments made by the Acts of 1951 and
1965 were perfectly valid as there was no question of their taking
away the right of the Muslim minority to administer the Aligarh
University, for the minority not having established the University
B could not claim the right to administer it. It was further contended that the fact that under the provisions of the 1920-Act the
Court of the Aligarh University was to be composed entirely of
Muslims, did not give any right to the Muslim c_ommunity as
such to administer the University which ·had been adm;nistered
by the authorities established by the 1920-Act. It was further cone tended that the attack based on the six Articles of the Constitution to which we have referred already had no substance and
did not in any manner make the Acts of 1951 and 1965 unconstitutional. We do not think it necessary at this stage to give in
detail the reply of the Government of India on these points and
shall refer to it as and when the occasion arises.
D
It is necessary to refer to the history previous to the establishment of the Aligarh University in 1920 in order to understand the
contentions raised on either side. It appears that as far back as
1870 Sir Syed Ahmad Khan thought that the backwardness of
the Muslim community was due to their neglect of modern educaE tion. He therefore conceived the idea of imparting liberal educatbn to Muslims in literature and science while at the same time
instr~ction was to be given in Muslim religion and traditions also.
With this object in mind, he organised a Committee to devise
ways and means for educational regeneration of-Muslims and in
F May 1872 a society called the Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College Fund Committee was started for collecting subscriptions to
realise the goal that Sir Syed Ahmad Khan had conceived. In
consequence of the activities of the committee a school was opened
in May 1873. In 1876, the school became a High School and in
1877 Lord Lytton, then Viceroy of India, laid the foundation stone
G for the establishment of a college. The Muhammadan AngloOriental College, Aligarh (hereinafter referred to as the M.A.O.
College) was established thereafter and was. it is said. a flourishing institution by the time Sir Syed Ahmad Khan died in 1898.
It is said that .thereafter the idea of establishing a Muslim
University gathered strength from year to year at the turn of
H the century and by 1911 some funds were collected and a Muslim
University Association was established for the purpose of establishin11: a teaching University at Aligarh. Long negotiations took place
Detween the Association and the Government of India, which
eventually resulted in the establishment of the Aligarh University
in 1920 by the 1920.Act. It may be mentioned that before that a
AZEEZ BASHA
v.
UNION
(IVanchoo, C.J.)
large sum of money was collected by the Association for the University as the Government of India bad made it a condition that A
rupees thirty lakhs must be co~lected for the Unive~si.ty before it
could be established. Further tt seems that the extstmg M.A.O.
College was made the basis of the University and was made over
to the authorities established by the 1920-Act for the administration of the University along with the properties and funds attached
to the college, the major part of which had been contributed ~ B
Muslims though some contributions were made by other communities as well.
It is necessary now to refer in some detail to the provisions
of the 1920-Act to see how the Aligarh University came to be
established. The long title of the 1920-Act is in these words:
c
"An Act to establish and incorporate a teaching and
residential Muslim University at Aligarh".
The preamble says that "it is expedient to establish and incorporate a teaching and residential Muslim University at Aligarh, and D
to dissolve the Societies registered under the Societies Registration
Act, 1860, which are respectively known as the Muhammadan
Anglo-Oriental College, Aligarh and the Muslim University Association, and to transfer and vest in the said University all properties
and rights of the said Societies and of the Muslim University Foundation Committee". It will be seen from this that the two earlier E
societies, one of which was connected with the M.A.O. College and
the other had been formed for collecting funds for the establishment
of the University at Aligarh, were dissolved and all the;r properties
and rights and also of the Muslim University Foundation Committee, which presumably collected funds for the proposed University
were transferred and vested in the University established by the F
1920-Act.
Section 3 of the 1920-Act laid down that "the First Chancellor, Pro-Chancellor and Vice-Chancellor shall be the persons appointed in this behalf by a notification of the Governor General in
Council in the Gazette of India and the persons specified in the G
schedule [shall be] the first members of the Court" and they happened to be all Muslims. Further s. 3 constituted a body corporate
by the name of the Aligarh Muslim University and this body corporate was to have perpetual succession and a Common Seal and
could sue and be sued by that name. Section 4 dissolved the
M.A.0. College and the Muslim University Association and all
property, movable and immovable, and all rights, powers and H
privileges of the two said societies, and all property, movable and
immovable. and all rights, powers and privile~es of the Muslim
University Foundation Committee were transferred and vested in
the AJigarh Universitv and were to be aoolied to the obiects and
purposes for which the Aligarh University was incorporated.
8'0
SUPREME coui.·r RBPORTB
(1968) I s.c.R,
A All debts, liabilities and obligations of the said societies and Com·
mittee were transferred to the University, which was made responsible for discharging and satisfying them. All references in
any enactment to either of the societies or to the said Committee
were to be construed' as references to the University. It was further provided that any will. deed or other documents, whether
made or executed before or after the commencement o.f the 1920B Act, which contained any bequest, gift or trust in favour of any
of the said societies or of the said Committee would, on the commencement of the 1920-Act be construed as if the University had
been named therein instead of such society or Committee. The
effect of this provision was that the properties endowed for the
purpose of the M.A.O. College were to be used for the Aligarh
0 University after it came into existence. These provisions will show
that the three previous bodies legally came to an end and everything that they were possessed of was vested in the University as
established by the 1920-Act. Section 5 provides for the powers of
the University including the power to hold examinations and to
D grant and confer degrees and other academic distinctions.
•
•
•
Section 6 is important. It laid down that "the degrees, diplomas and other academic distinctions granted or conferred to or on
persons by the University shall be recognised by the Government
as are the corresponding degrees, diplomas and other academic
distinctions granted by any other University incorporated under
any enactment". Section 7 provided for reserve funds including
the sum of rupees thirty lakhs. Section 8 provided th;it "th~ University shall, subject to the provisions of this Act and the Ordinances, be open to all persons of either sex and of whatever race.
creed or class", which shows that the University was not established for Muslims alone. Under section 9 the Court was given the
power to make Statutes providing that instruction in the Muslim
religion would be compulsory in the case of Muslim students.
Sections 10, II and 12 made other provisions necessary for the
functioning of a University but they are not material for our pur·
pose.
Section 13 is another important section. It provided that
"the Governor General shall be the Lord Rector of the University". Further sub-s. (2) of s. 13 provided that "the Lord Rector
shall have the right to cause an inspection to be made by such
person or persons as he may direct, of the University, its buildings, laboratories, and equipment, and of any institution mainB taincd by the University, and also of the examinations, teaching
and other work conducted or done by the University, and to cause
an inquiry to be made in like manner in respect of any matter
connected with the University. The Lord Rector shall in every
case give notice to the University of his intention to cause an inspection or inquiry." .After the enquiry, the Lord Rector had the
'
AZEEZ B."BBA 11, UNION (Wmichoo, C,J,)
841
power to address the Vice-Chancellor with reference to the result A
· of such inspection and inquiry and the Vice-Chancellor was
bound to communicate to the Court the views of the Lord Rector
with such advice as the Lord Rector might offer upon the action
to be taken thereon. The Court was then required to communi·
cate tlirough the Vice-Chancellor to the Lord Rector such action
if any as was proposed to be taken or was taken upon the result
of such inspection or inquiry. Finally the Lord Rector was given B
the power where the Court did not, within reasonable time, take
action to the satisfaction of the Lord Rector to issue such directions as he thought fit after considering any explanation furnished
or representation made by the Court and the Court was bound to
comply with such directions. These provisions clearly bring out
that the final control in the matter was with the Lord Rector who 0
was the Governor-General of India.
-c,.
Then comes s. 14 which is again an · important provision,
which provided for the Visiting Board of the University, which
consisted of the Governor, the members of the Executive Council, D
the Ministers, one member nominated by the Governor and one
member nominated by the Minister in charge of Education. The
Visiting._ Board had the power to inspect the University and to satisfy itself that the proceedings of the University were in conformity
with the Act, Statutes and Ordinances, after giving notice to the
University of its intention to do so. The Visiting Board was also 8
given the power, by order in writing, to annul any proceedings
not in conformity with the Act, Statutes and Ordinances, provided
that before making such an order, the Board had to call upon
the University to show cause why such an order should not be
made, and to consider such cause if shown within reasonable time.
This provision. though not so all-pervasiv~ as the provision in s. r
13 of the 1920-Act, shows that the Visiting Board had also certain over-riding powers in case the University authorites acted
against the. Act, Statutes and Ordinancei. There is no condition
that the Lord Rector and the members of the Visiting Board
must belong to the Muslim community.
G
Sections 15 to 21 are not material for our purposes. They
made provisions for officers of the University and Rectors and
laid down that "the powers of officers of the University other than
the Chancellor, .the Pro-Chancellor, the Vice-Chancellor and· the
Pro-Vice-Chancellor shall be prescribed by the Statutes and the
Ordinances". Section 22 provided for the authorities of the University, name.ly, the Court, the Executive Council and the Academic B
Council and such other authorities as might be declared by the
Statutes to be authorities of the University. Section 23 provided
for the constitution of the Court, and the proviso to sub-section
(I) has been greatly stressed on behalf of the petitioners whirb
la;d down that "no person other than a Muslim shall be a member
SUPRllllE COURT REPORTS
[1968] I S.C.R.
A thereof". It may be added here that the Select Committee which
went into the Bill before the 1920-Act was passed was not very
happy about this proviso and observed that:
B
C
D
B
:r
I
B
"In reference to the constitution of the Court we
have retained the provision that no person other than
Muslim shall be a member thereof. We have done this
as we understand that such a provision is in accordance
with the preponderance of Muslim feeling though some of
us are by no means satisfied that such a provision is necessary."
By section 23(2), the Court was to be the supreme governing body
of the University and would exercise all the powers of the University, not otherwise provided for by the 1920-Act, the Statutes,
the Ordinances and the Regulations. It was given the power to
review the acts of the Executive and the Academic Councils. save
where such Councils had acted in accordance with powers conferred on them under the Act, the Statutes or the Ordinances
and to direct that necessary action be taken by the Executive or
the Academic Council, as the case might be, on any recommendation of the Lord Rector. The power of making Statutes was also
conferred on the Court along with other powers necessary for
the functioning of the University.
'
Section 24 dealt with the Executive .Council, s. 25 with the
Academic Council and s. 26 with other authorities of the University. Section 27 laid down what the Statutes might provide.
Section 28 dealt with the question of the first Statutes and how they
were to be amended, repealed and added to. There is an important
provision ins. 28 which laid down that "no new Statute or amendment or repeal of an existing Statute shall have any validity, until
it has been submitted, through the Visiting Board (which may
record its opinion thereon) to the Governor General in Council, and
bas been approved by the latter, who may sanction, disallow or
remit it for further consideration." This provision clearly shows
that the final power over the administration of the University
rested with the Governor General in Council. Section 29 dealt with
Ordinances and what they could provide and s. 30 provided which
authorities of the University could make Ordinances. Section 30(2)
provided that "the firiit Ordinances shall be framed as directed
by the Governor General in Council ...... " and sub-s. (3) thereof
laid down that "no new Ordinance, or amendment or repeal of
an existing Ordinance shall have any validity until it has been
submitted through the Court and the Visiting Board (which may
record its opinion thereon) to the Governor General in Council,
and has obtained the approval of the latter, who may sanction.
disallow or remit it for further consideration". This again shows
that even Ordinances could not be made by the University without the approval of the Governor General in Council. If any dispute arose between the Executive and the Academic Council as
AZEEZ BASHA
v.
l'NlON
(Wanchoo, U.J.)
843
to which had the power to make an Ordinance, either Council A
could represent the matter to the Visiting Board and the Visiting
Board had to refer the same to a tribunal consisting of three
members, one of whom was to be nominated by the Executive
Council, one by the Academic Council, and one was to be a
Judge of the High Court nominated by the Lord Rector. This
again shows that in the matter of such disputes, the Court which is
called the supreme governing body of the University, did not B
have the power to resolve it. Section 31 provides for the making
of Regulations, which had to be consistent with the Statutes and
Ordinances. It is only the Regulations which did not require the
approval of the Governor Genera 1 before they came into force.
Section 32 provided for admission of students to the University
and sub-s. (4) thereof provided that "the University shall not save C
with the previous sanction of the Governor General in Council
recognise (for the purpose of admission to a course of study for a
degree) as equivalent to its own degrees. any degree conferred by
any other University .or as equivalent to the Intermediate Examination of an Indian University, any examination conducted by any
other authority". This shows that in the matter of admission the D
University could not admit studentS of other institutions unless
the Governor General in Council approved the degree or any
other examination of the institutions other than Indian Universities established by Jaw. Section 33 provided for examinations, s.
34 for annual report and s. 35 for annual accounts. Sections 36 to
38 provided for supplementary matters like conditions of service E
of officers and teachers, provident and pension funds.- filling of
casual vacancies and are not material for our purposes. Section
39 laid down that "no act or proceeding of any authority of the
University shall be invalidated merely by reas.oh of the existence of
vacancy or vacancies among its members". Section 40 is important and laid down that "if any difficulty arises with respect to F
the establishment of the University or any authority of the University ~r in connection with the first meeting of any authority of
the Umversity, the Governor General in Council may by order
make any ap~ointment or do anything which appears to him necessary or ex~dtent for the proper establishment of the University or G
any authority thereof or for the first meeting of any authority of
the University." This again shows the power of the Governor
General in Council in the matter of establishment of the University.
This brings us to the end of the sections of the 1920-Act.
There is nothing anywhere in any section of the Act which vests
the administr~tion of the University in the Muslim community.
The fact that m the proviso to s. 23()) it is provided that the Court B
of the University shall consist only of Muslims does not necessarily m7an that the administr~tion of the University was vested or
was mtended: to be vested !n. the Musli.m minority. If anything,
some of the important .Prov1s1?ns to which we have already referred show that the final power m almost every matter of importance
844
SUl'RllKE COURT RllPORTS
[1968) l S.C.R.
A was in the Lord Rector, who was the Governor General or in the
Governor General in Council.
Then follows the schedule which provides for the first Statutes of the Aligarh University. These Statutes provided for the
Rectors of the University, the Vice-Chancellor, Pro-Vice-Chancellor, Treasurer, Registrar, Proctor and Librarian, the Court,
B constitution of the Court, the first Court, meetings of the Court
and the powers of the Court, the Executive Council, the powers
of the Executive Council, the Academic Council and its powers,
dep~rtments of studies, appointments, register of graduates, convocations, Committees and so on. The annexure to the 1920-Act
gave the names of the Foundation Memb.ers of the Court number0 ing 124 who were all Muslims and who were to hold office for
five years from the commencement of the Court.
Such were the provisions of the I 920-Act. They continued
in force • : 1951 without any substantial amendment. In 1951,
the 1951-Act was passed. It made certain changes in the 1920D Act mainly on account of the coming into force of the Constitution. We shall refer only to such changes as are material for our
purposes. The first material change was the deletion of s. 9 of
the 1920-Act which gave power to the Court to make Statutes providing for compulsory religious instruction in the case of Muslim
students. This amendment was presumably made in the interest
E of the University in view of Art. 28(3) of the Constitution which
lays down that "no person attending any educational institution
recognised by the State or receiving aid out of State funds shall be
required to take part in any religious instruction that may be imparted in such institution or to attend any religious worship that
may be conducted in such institution or in any premises attached
F thereto unless such person or, if such person is a minor, his guardian has given his consent thereto." It was necessary to delete
s. 9 as otherwise the University might have lost the grant which
was given to it by the Government of India. Further s. 8 of the
1920-Act was amended and the new section provided that "the
University shall be· open to persons of either sex and of whatever
G race, creed, caste, or class, and it shall not be lawful for the University to adopt or impose on any person, any test whatsoever. of
religious belief or profession in order to entitle him to be admitted
therein, as a teacher or student, or to hold any office therein, or
to graduate thereat, or to enjoy or exercise any privilege thereof,
except in respect of any particular benefaction accepted by the
University, where such test is made a condition thereof by any
H testamentary or other instrument creating such benefaction". The
new s. 8 had also a proviso laying down that "nothing in this section shall be deemed to prevent religious instruction being given
in the manner prescribed by the Ordinances to those who have
consented to receive it". Clearly. section 9 was deleted and s. 8
was amended in this manner to bring the law into conformity with
AZEEZ BASHA
v.
~NION
(Wanc/ioo, C.J.)
845
the provisions of the Constitution and for the benefit of the Univer: A
sity so that it could continue to receive aid from the Government.
Some amendment was also made in s. 13 in view of the changed
constitutional set-up and in place of the Lord Rector, the University was to have a Visitor. Section .14 was also amended and the
power of the Visiting Board was conferred on the Visitor by addition of a new sub-s. (6).
B
The next substantial change was that the proviso to s. 23(1)
which required that all members of the Court would only be Muslims was deleted. Other amendments are not material for our
purpose as they merely relate to administrative details concerning
the University.
c
It will thus be seen that by virtue of the 1951.-Act non-Muslims could also be members of the Court. But the Court still re·
mained the supreme governing body of the University as pi:ovided
by s. 23 ()) of the 1920-Act. It is remarkable that though the proviso to s. 23(1) was deleted, as far back as 1951. there was no
challenge to the 1951-Act till after Ordinance No. II of 1965 was D
passed. The reason for this might be that there was practically no
substantial change in the administrative set-up of the 1920-Act and
it was only when a drastic change was made by the Ordinance of
1965, followed by the 1965-Act, that challenge was made not only
to the 1965-Act but also to the 1951-Act in so far as it did away B
with the proviso to s. 23()). It is not our function in the present
petitions to consider the policy underlying the amendments made
by the 1965-Act; nor do we propose to go into the merits of the
amendments made by the 1965-Act We are in the present petitions concerned only with the canstitutionality of the provisions
of the 1965-Act. If the provisions are constitutional. they were F
within the legislative competence of Parliament.
This brings us to the changes made in the 1965-Act which
have occasioned the present challenge. The main amendment in
the 1965.Act was in s. 23 of the 1920-Act with respect to the composition and the powers of the Court of the University. Sub-sec- G
lions (2) and (3) of the 1920-Act were deleted, with the result that
the Court no longer remained the supreme governing body and
could no longer exercise the powers conferred on it by sub·ss. (2)
and (3) of s. 23. In place of these two sub-sections, a new subsection (2) was put in, which reduced the functions of the Court
to three oJ?ly. namely, "(a) to advise the Visitor in respect of any
matter which may be referred to the Court for advice; (b) to ad- H
vise any other authority of the University in respect of any matter
which may be referred to the Court for advice; and (c) to perform
such other duties and exercise such other powers as may be assigned to it by the Visitor or under this Act". It further appears
from the amendments of ss. 28, 29, 34 and 38 that the powers of
846
SUPBBKE COUBT REPOBTS
(1968] I s.c.n.
A the Executive Council were correspondingly increased. The Statutes were also amended and many of t.he powers of the Court
were transferred by the amendment to the Executive Council.
Further the constitution of the Court was drastically changed by
the amendment of the 8th Statute and it practically became a body
nominated by the Visitor except for the Chancellor, the ProChancellor, the members of the Executive Council who were ex
B officio members and three members of Parliament. two to be nominated by the Speaker of the House of the People and one by the
Chairman of the Council of States. Changes were also made in the
constitution of the Executive Council. Finally the 1965-Act provided that "every person holding office as a member of the Court or
the Executive Council, as the case may be, immediately before the
C 20th .day of May, 1965 (on which date Ordinance No. II of 1965
wa•s promulgated) shall on and from the said' date cease to hold
office as such". It was also provided that until the Court or the
Executive Council was reconstituted, the Visitor might by general
or special order direct any officer of the University to exercise
the powers and perform the duties conferred or imposed by or
D under the 1920-Act as amended by the 1965-Act on the Court or
the Executive Council as the case may be.
•
The contention of the petitioners is that by these drastic amend. ments in 1965 the Muslim minority was deprived of the right to
administer the Aligarh University and that this deprivation was
E in violation of Art. 30(1) of the Constitution; and it is to this question we turn now.
Under Article 30(1), "all minorities whether based on religion
or language shall have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice". We shall proceed on the
F assumption in the present petitions that Muslims are a minority
based on religion. What then is the scope of Art. 30(1) and what
exactly is the right conferred therein on the religious minorities.
It is to our mind quite clear that Art. 30(1) postulates that the
religious community will have the right to establish and administer
educational institutions of their choice meaning thereby that where
G a religious minority establishes an educational inst;tution, it will
have the right to administer that. An argument has been raised
to the effect that even though the religious minority may not have
established the educational institution, it will have the right to
administer it, if by some process it had been administering the
same before the Constitution came into force. We are not prepared to accept this argument. The Article in our opinion clearly
B shows that the minority will have the right to administer educational institutions of their choice provided they have established
them, but not otherwise. The Article cannot be read to mean
that even if the educational institution has been established
by somebody else, any religious minority would have the right to
administer it because, for some reason or other, it might have been
I
I-
AZliEZ BASHA
v.
UNION ( Wanc/wo,
C.J.)
847
administering it before the Constitution came into force. The A
words "establish and administer" in the Article must be read conjunctively and so read it gives the right to the minority to administer an educational institution provided it has been established by
it. In this connection our attention was drawn to In re; The
Kera/a Education Bill, 1957(') where, it is argued, this Court had
held that the minority can administer an educational institution
even though it might not have established it. In that case an B
argument was raised that under Art. 30()) protection was given
only to educational institutions established after the Constitution
came into force. That argument was turned· down by this Court for
the obvious reason that if that interpretation was given
to Art. 30(1) it would be robbed of much of its content. But that
case in our opinion did not lay down that the words "establish C
and administer" in Art. 30(1) should be read disjunctively, so that
though a minority might not have established an educational
institution it had the right to administer it. It is true that at p.
1062 the Court spoke of Art. 30(1) giving two rights to a minority i.e. (i) to establ.!sh and (ii) to administer. But thM was said
only in the context of meeting the argument that educational D
institutions established by minorities before the Constitution came
into force did not have the protection of Art. 30(1). We are of
opinion that nothing in that case justifies the contention raised on
behalf of the petitioners that the minorities would have the right to
administer an educational institution even though the institution
may not have been established by them. The two words in Art. E
30(1) must be read together and so read the Article gives the
right to the minority to administer institutions established by it.
If the educational institution has not been established by a minority it cannot claim the right to administer it under Art. 30(1).
We have therefore to consider whether the Aligarh University was
established by the Muslim minority; and if it was so .established, F
the minority would certainly have the right to administer it.
We should also like to refer to the observations in The Durgah Committee, Aimer v. Syed Hussain Ali('). In that case this
Court observed while dealing with Art. 26(a) and (d) of the Constitution that even if it be assumed that a certain religious institution G
was established by a minority community it may lose the right to
administer it in ·certain circumstances. We may in this connection refer to the following observations at p. 414 for they apply
equally to Art. 30(1):
·
"If the right to administer the properties never
vested in the denomination or had been validly surrendered by it or had otherwise been effectively and irretrievably lost to it, Art. 26 cannot be successfully invoked."
(') [1959) S.C.R. 995.
(') [1962) 1 S.C.P. 383.
H
848
SUPRBllB COURT REPORTS
(1968) I S.C,R,
A We shall have to examine closely what happened in 1920 when
the 192()..Act was passed to decide (firstly) whether in the face of
that Act it could be said that the Aligarh University was established by the Muslim minority, (secondly) whether the right to
administer it ever vested in the minority, and (thirdly) even if the
right to administer some properties that came to the University
vested in the minority before the establishment of the Aligarh
B University, whether it had been surrendered when the Aligarh
University came to be established.
Before we do so we should like to say that the words "edu
cational institutions" are of very wide import and would· include
a university also. This was not disputed on bi:half of the Union
C of India and therefore it may be accepted that a religious minority
had the right to establish a university under Art. 30(1). The position with respect to the establishment of Universities before the
Constitution came into force in 1950 was this. There was no
law in India which prohibited any private individual or body from
establishing a university and it was therefore open to a private
D individual or body to establish a university. There is a good deal
in common between educational institutions which are not universities and those which are universities. Both teach students and
both have teachers for the purpose. But what distinguishes a
university from any other educational institution is that a university grants degrees of its own while other educational institutions
E cannot. It is this granting of degrees by a university which distinguishes it from the ordinary run of educational institutions.
[See St. David's College, Lampeter v. Ministry of Education(')].
Thus in law in India there was no prohibition against establishment of universities by private individuals or bodies and if any
university was so established it must of necessity be granting degF rees before it could be called a university. But though such a university might be granting degrees it did not follow that the
Government of the country was bound to recognise those degrees.
As a matter of fact as the law stood up to the time the Constitution
came into force, the Government was not bound to recognise
degrees of universities established by private individuals or bodies
G and generally speaking the Government only recognised degrees
of universities established by it by law. No private individual or
body could before 1950 insist that the degrees of any university
established by him or it must be recognised by Government. Such
recognition depended upon the will of Government generally expressed through statute. The importance of the recognition of
Government in matters of this kind cannot be minimised. This
H position continued even after the Constitution came into force. It
was only in I 956 that by sub-s. (I) of s. 22 of the University Grants
Commission Act, (No. 3 of 1956) it was laid down that "the right
of conferring or granting degrees shall be exercised only by a
(') [1951] 1 All E.R. 559.
AZEKZ BASHA v. UNION (Wanchoo, C.J.)
849
University established or incorporated by or under a Central Act, A
a Provincial Act or a State Act or an institution deemed to be a
University under section 3 or an institution specially empowered
by an Act of Parliament to confer or grant degrees". Sub-section
(2) thereof further provided that "save as provided in sub-s. (I),
no person or authority shall confer, or grant, or hold himself or
itself as entitled to confer or grant any degree". Section 23 further
prohibited the use of the word "university" by an educational B
institution unless it is established by law. It was only thereafter that
no private individual or body could grant a degree in India. Therefore it was possible for the Muslim minority to establish a university before the Constitution came into force, though the degrees
conferred by such a university were not bound to be recognised
by Government.
0
There was nothing in 1920 to prevent the Muslim minority,
if it so chose, to establish a university; but if it did so the degrees
of such a university were not bound to be recognised by Government. It may be that in the absence of recognition of the degrees
grant~d by a university, it may not have attracted many students. D
and that is why we find that before the Constitution came into
force, most of the universities in India were established by legisla ·
tion. The Aligarh University was also in the same way established
by legislation and it provided under s. 6 of the 1920-Act that "the
degrees. diplomas and other academic distinctions granted or con- E
ferred to or on persons by the University shall be recognised by the
Government as are the corresponding degrees. diplomas and other
academic distinctions granted by any other university incorporated
under any enactment." It is clear therefore that even though the
Muslim minority could have established at Aligarh in 1920 a
university, it could not insist that degrees granted· by such a uni- F
versity should be recognised by Government. Therefore when the
Aligarh university was established in 1920 and by s. 6 its degrees
were recognised by Government, an institution was brought into
existence which could not be brought into existence by any private
individual or body for such individual or body could not insist
upon· the recognition of the degrees conferred by any university G
established by it. The enactment of s. 6 in the 1920-Act is a very
I important circumstance which shows that the Aligarh University
when it came to be established in 1920 was not established by the
~ uslim minority. for the minority could not insist on the recognition by Government of the degrees conferred by any university
established by it.
B
It is true, as is clear from the 1920-Act, that the nucleus of
the Aligarh University was the M.A.O. College, which was till
then a teaching institution under the Allahabad' University. The
conversion of that college (if we may use that expression) into a
university was however not by the Muslim minority; it took place
8110
SllPllEME COURT REPORTS
[1968] l s.O.R.
A by yirtue of the 1920-Act which was passed by the Central legislatdre. There was no Aligarh University existing till the 1920Act was passed. It was brought into being by the 1920-Act and
must therefore be held to have been established by the Central
Legislature which by passing the 1920-Act incorporated it. The
fact that it was based on the M.A.O. College, would make no
difference to the question as to who established the Aligarh ·UniB versity. The answer to our mind· as to who established the Aligarh Univers!ty is clear and that is that it was the Central Legislature by enacting the 1920-Act that established the said University.
As we have said already, the Muslim minority could not establish
a university whose degrees were bound to be recognised by Government as provided by s. 6 of 1920-Act; that one circumstance
0 along with the fact that without the 1920-Act the University in the
form that it had, could not come into existence shows clearly that
the Aligarh University when it came into existence in 1920 was
established b:v, the Central Legislature by the 1920-Act. It may be
that the 1920-Act was passed as a result of the efforts of the Muslim minority. But that does not mean that the Aligarh University
D when it came into being under the 1920-Act wa!s established by the
Muslim minority.
A good deal of argument was addressed to us on the nature
of eleemosynary corporations and the difference between fundatio incipiens and fundatio perficie11s and certain English cases
E were cited in support thereof. It was urged that the word "establish" in the 1920-Act amounted only to a case of fundatio incipiens and that so far as fundatio perficiens was concerned, that
was the Muslim minority. We do not think it necessary to go into
these distinctions of the English law; nor do we think it necessary.
to consider the nature of eleemosynary corporations. Suffice it to
P say that even if we assume that those who contributed money and
property which was vested in the Aligarh University (and some
of them were non-Muslims) were in the position of fundatio perficiens, they could only have visitorial rights under the English
common law. But Muslim minority as such could not claim to be
fundatio perficiens for that right would only be in the donors and
Q no others. Further even these visitorial rights must be held· to have
been negatived by the 1920-Act for it specifically conferred such
rights on the Lord Rector and the Visiting Board and no others.
Some argument was also based on some cases of the Supreme
Court of the United States of America which depended upon the
provisions of the Constitution of that country which prohibits impairment of contracts. It is profitless to refer to the cases cited in
H that behalf for our Constitution has no such fundamental right.
Further we cannot under any circumstance read the 1920-Act as
a kind of contrast.
What does the word "establish" used in Art. 30(1) mean?
In Bouvier's Law Dictionary, Third Edition, Vol. I, it has been
AZEEZ BASHA v. UNION (Wanchoo, 0. J.)
851
said that the word "establish" occurs frequently in the Constitu- A
tion of the United States and it is there used in different meanings;
and five such meanings have been given, namely (I) to settle firmly,
to fix unalterably, as to establish justice; (2) to make or form: as,
to establish a uniform rule of naturalization; (3) to found, to create,
to regulate; as, _Congress shall have power to establish post offices;
(4) to found, recognize, confirm or admit: as, Congress shall make
no law respecting an establishment of religion; (5) to create, to B
ratify, or confirm, as We, the people, etc., do ordain and establish
this constitution. Thus it cannot be said that the only meaning of
the word "establish" is to found in the serise in which an eleemosy·
nary institution is founded and we shall have to see in what sense
the word has been used in our Constitution in this Article. In
Shorter Oxford English Dictionary, Third Edition, the word C
"establish" has ai number of meanings, i.e. to ratify, confirm,
settle, to ·found;' to create. Here again founding is not the only
meaning of the word "establish" and it includes creation also. In
Webster's Third New International Dictionary, the word "establish" has been given a number of meanings, namely, to found or
base squarely, to make firm or stable, to bring into existence, create, D
make, start, originate. It will be seen that here also founding is
not lhe only meaning; and the word also means ·"to bring into
existence". We are of opinion that for the purpose ·of Art. 30(1)
the word means "to bring into existence", and so the right given
by Art. 30(1) to the minority is to bring into existence an educational institution, and if they do so, to administer it. We have there- E
fore to see wliat happened in 1920 and who brought the Aligarh
Fnlversity int<'> existenee.
From the history. we have set out above, it will be clear that
those who were in-<:harge of the M.A.0. College; the Muslim University Association and the Muslim University Foundation Com· 11'
mittee were keen to bring into existence university at Aligarh.
There was nothing in law then to' prevent theoi. from doing so, if
they so desired without asking Government to help them in the
matter. But if they had brought into existence a university on their
own, the- degrees of that university were noi bound to be recognised by Government. It seems to us that it must have been felt _by G
. the person~ concerned that it would be no use bringing into exittence a umversity, if !Jie degrees eonferred by the Said university
were not to be recogrused by GOvemment. That appears to be the
r~n. why ~ey ~pproached the Goveriiment for bringing into
existence a umvers1ty at Aligarh, whose degrees would be recognised. by GOvemment and thiit is why we find s. 6 of the 1920.Act
l~YJ~g ~own that "the degrees, diplomas, .and other academic :e:
~JStinctions granted. or conferred to or on ~ons by the university shall be recogmsed by the GOvernment..... .'" It may be accepted for ~resent pu!J>?ses that the M.AO. Coll,ege and the Muslim
Um~1ty Associ_ation and the Muslim University Foundation
Committee were institutions established by tbe Muallin minority
a
852
SUPI\EKE COUI\T REPORTS
(1968] l S.C.R.
A and two of them were administered by Societies registered undet
the Societies Registration Act, <No. 21 of 1860). But if the M.A.0.
College was to be converted into a university of the kind whose
degrees were bound to be recognised by Government, it would not
be possible for those who were in-charge of the M.A.O. College to
do so. Thal is why the three institutions to which we have already
referred approached the Government to bring into existence a uniB versity whose degrees would be recognised by Government. The
1920-Act was then passed by the Central Legislature and the university of the type that was established thereunder, namely, one whose
degrees would be recognised by Government, came to be established. It was clearly brought intt> existence by the 1920-Act for it
could not have been brougbt into existence otherwise. It wa5 thus
C the· Central Legislature which brought into existence the Aligarh
University and must be held to have established it. It would not
be possible for the Muslim minority to establish a university of the
kind whose degrees were bound to be recognised by Government
and therefore it must be held that the Aligarh University was
D brought into existence by the Central Legislature and the Government of India. lf·that is so. the Muslim minority cminot cJa;m to
administer it. for it was not brought into existence by it. Art. 30(1),
which protects educational institutions brought into existence and
administered by a minority, cannot help the petitioners and any
amendment of the 1920-Act would not be ultra vires Art. 30(1) of
the Constitution. The Aligarh University not having been estabE lished by the Muslim minority, a'ny amendment of the 1920-Act by
which it .was established, would be within the legislative power
of Parliament subject of ctiurse to the provisions of the Constitution. The Aligarh University not having been established by the
Muslim minority, no amendment of the Act can be struck down
as unconstitutional under Art. 30(1).
F
Nor do .we think that the provisions of the Act can bear out
the contention that it was the Muslim minority which was administering the Aligarh University, after it was brought into existence.
It is true that the proviso to s. 23(1) of the 1920-Act said that "no
person other than a Muslim shall be a member of the Court", which
G was declared to be the supreme governing body of the Aligarh
University and was to exercise all the powers of the University,
not otherwise provided for by that Act. We have already referred
to the fact that the Select Committee was not happy about this
provision and only permitted it in the Act out of deference to the
wishes of preponderating Muslim opinion.
B
It appears from paragraph. 8 of the Schedule that even
though the members ·of the Court had to be Muslims, the electorates. were not exclusively Muslims. For example, sixty members
of the Court had to be elected by persons who had made or would
make donations of five hundred rupees and upwards to or for the
purposes of the University. Some of these persons were and could
AZEEZ BASHA v. UNIOµ' (Wane/too,
o. J.)
85:)
be non-Muslims. Forty persons were to be elected by the Regis- A
tered Graduates of the University, and some of the Registered
Graduates were and could be non-Muslims, ·for the University
was open to all persons of either sex and of whatever race, creed
or class. Further fifteen members of the Court were to be elected
by the Academic Council, the membership of which was not confined only to Muslims.
B
Besides there were other bodies like the Executive Council
and the Academic Council which were concerned with the administration of the Aligarh University and there was no provision
in the constitution of these bodies which confined their members
only to Muslims. It will thus be seen that besides the fact that
the members of the Court had to be all Muslims, there was noth- c
ing in the Act to suggest that the administration of ,the Aligarh
University was in the Muslim minority as such. Besides the above,
we have already referred to s. 13 which showed how the Lord
Rector, namely, the Governor General had overriding powers over
all matters relating to the administration of the University. Then
there was s. 14 which gave certain over-riding powers to the Visit- D
ing Board. The Lord Rector was then the Viceroy and the Visiting Board consisted of the Governor of the United Provinces, the
members of his Executive Cot<ncil, the Ministers, one member
nominated by the Gbvcrnor and one member nominated by 'the
Minister in charge of Education. These people were not necessarily Muslims and they had over-riding powers over the adminis- E
!ration of the University. Then reference Ina!y be made to s. 28(2)
(c) which laid down that no new Statute or amendment or repeal
of an existing Statute, made by the University, would have any
validity until it had been approved by the Governor General in
Council who had power to sanction, disallow or remit it for further consideration. Same powers existed in the Governor General F
in Council with respect to Ordinances. Lastly reference may be
made lo s. 40, which gave power to the Governor General in
Council to remove any difficulty which might arise in the establishment of the University. These provisioos ;n our opinion clearly
show that the administration was also not vested in the Muslim
minority; on the other hand it was vested in the statutory bodies G
created by the 1920-Act, and only in one of them, namely, the
Court, there was a bar to the appointment of any one else except
a Muslim, though even there some of the electors for some of the
members included non-Muslims. We are therefore of opinion
that the Aligarh University wus neither established nor administered by the Muslim minority and therefore there is no question
of any amendment to the 1920-Act being unconstitutional under H
Art. 30(1) for that Article does not apply at 'all to the Aligarh
University.
The next argument is based on Art. 26 of the Constitution.
"hat Article provides that every religious denomination or any
SUPllJlllE COURT llEPORTS
[1968] 1 s.a.n.
A ·section thereof shall have the right (a) to establish and maintain
institutions for religious and charitable purposes ...... (c) to own
and acquire movable and immovable property; and (d) to adminis.ter such property in accordance with law. A question was raised
whether Art. 26 would take in its sweep educational institutions
on· the ground that such institutions are institutions for charitable
purposes. It was urged that Art 26 will not apply to educational
B institutions for there is specific provision in Art. 30(1) with respect
to educational institutions and therefore institutions for charitable
purposes in cl. (a) of Art. 26 refer to institutions other than educational ones. There is much to be said in favour of this contention. But. we do not propose to decide this question for present
purposes. We shall assume that educational institutions would
C also come within Art. 26(a) as institutions for charitable purposes.
Even so we fail to see how Art. 26 helps the petitioners. Clause
(a) of that Article gives the right to every religious denomination
and the Muslim minority may for present purposes be assumed to
be a religious denomination within the meaning of Art. 26-to
establish and maintain institutions for religious and charitable purD poses. What we b,ave said with ;espect to Art. 30(1) which gives
right to minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice applies equally to cl. (a) of Art. 26 and therefore we are of opinion .that the words "establish and maintain"
must be re3d conjunctively and it i~ only institutions which a religious denomination establishes which it can claim to maintain .
.l!i It is not necessary to go into all the implications of the word
"maintain": it is enough for present purposes to say that the right
to ·maintain institutions for religious and charitable purposes
would include the right to administer them. But the right under
cl. (a) of A,rt. 26 will only' arise where the institution is established
F by a religious denomination and it is in that event only that it
can claim to maintain it. As we have already held, the Aligarh
University was not established by .the Muslim minority and
therefore no question arises of its right to maintain it. within the
meaning of cl. (a) of Art. 26.
G
Reference is also made to Art. 26 clauses (c) and (d) which
give the right to a religious denomination "(c) to own and acquire
movable and immovable property, and (d) to administer such property in accord11nce with law". So far as that is concerned it is
enough to say that Muslim minority does not own the movable
and immovable property which was vested in the Aligarh University by virtue of the '920.Act and therefore cannot claim to ad,
B minister any such property. Clauses (c) and (d) give power to the
religious denomination to. own and acquire movable and immovable property and if it owns or acquires such movable or ·immovllble property it can administer such property in accordance with
law. But the Muslim minority did not own the property which was
vested in the Aligarh University on the date the Constitution came
AZlll!:Z llASJl.A v. UNION (Wancltoo, 0.J.)
into force, and it could not lay claim to administer that property A
by virtue of Art. 26(d). For the rest, there is nothing in the impugned amendment Acts which in any way bars the Muslim minority
from owning or acquiring and administering movable or immovable property if it so desires for purposes of Art. 26. But it cannot
lay claim under Art. 26 (d) to administer the property which was
vested in the Aligarh University by the 1920-Act, for it did not
own that property when the Constitution came into force.
B
The next attack on the constitutionality of the 1965-Act is
under Art. 25 of the Constitution. That Article provides that "subject to public order, morality and health and to the other provisions
of this Part all persons are equally entitled to freedom of conscience
and the right freely to profess, practise and propagate religion." C
We have not been 'able to understand how the amendment made
by the 1965-Act in the 1920-Act in any way affects the right freely
to profess, practise and propagate religion. It may be added that
learned counsel for the petitioners did not seriously press the contention that the 1965-Act was ultra vires as it violated Art. 25
of the Constitution.
D
The next Article of the Constitution on which reliance is
placed is Art. 29. That Article provides that "any section of the
citizens residing in the territory of India or any part thereof having
a distinct language, script or culture of its own shall have the right
to conserve the same". We have not been able to understand how E,
the amendments made by the 1965-Act in the 1920-Act in any
way interfere with the right of the Muslim minority to conserve
any distinct language, script or culture which they might have.
Here again we may add that no serious argument was raised before us on the basis of Art ?Q
F
The next Article of the Constitution on which reliance is
placed is Art. 14. Here again we are not able to appreciate what
the discrimination is which has been brought about by the amendments of the 1965-Act. It seems that the charge of discrimination
is based on the provisions of the Benaras Hindu University Act, G
which University is established' by an Act of its own. We do not
think that Art. 14 requires that the provisions in every University
'."ct must al~ays be the same. Ea~h University has problems of
its own and It seems to us that It 1s for the legislature to decide
wha! kind of. constituti_on should be conferred on a particular uni".ers1ty estabhshed by 1t. There can be no question of discriminat1?n on the ground that some other University Acts provide for some ·
?•fferent set up. Each university must be taken to be a class by 11
•~self _an~ the le,gisla.ture ~as a right to make such provision for its
<;?OS!l~ut1?n as 1t thinks ht suhjed always to the provisions of the
Cons!lll•llun. The mere fact that certain provisions in a statute
creating one university are different from provisions in another
806
SUl>REME COURT REPORTS
(1968] 1 B.C.R.
A statute creating another university cannot mean that there is discrimination. It has been urged in this connection that other universities, such as, Delhi, Agra, Allahabad, Patna and Benaras, have
certain elective element while the amendment of 1965 has done
away with the elective element so far as the Aligarh University
is concerned. We have already said that we are not concerned
with the policy of the legislature in enacting the 1965-Act; nor
B are we concerned with the merits of the provisions of the .1965-Act.
All that we need say is that simply because there is no elective
element in one university while there is such element in another
university it cannot be said that there is discrimination, for, as we
have said already, each university is a class by itself and may
require a different set up according to the requirements and needs
C of a particular situation. We therefore see no force in the attack
-0n the constitutionality of the 1965-Act on the ground that it is
hit by Art. 14 of the Constitution.
The next attack on the constitutionality of the 1965-Act is
based on Art. 19. and the argument seems to be that the statute
D deprives Muslims of their right to acquire, hold and dispose of
property and to form associations or unions. The argument has
merely to be stated to deserve rejection. We cannot understand
how the 1965-Act deprives the Muslim citizens of this country of
the right to form associations or unions. There is nothing in the
1965-Act which takes away that right, nor is there anything in the
E 1965-Act which takes away the right of the Muslim citizens to
acquire, hold and dispose of property. But it is said that the
Muslim minority bas been deprived of the right to manage the
Aligarh University and the right to bold the· property which was
vested in the Aligarh University by the 1920-Act. There is no
force in this contention either, for Art. J9(l)(c) does not give any
F right to any citizen to manage any particular educational institution. It only gives the right to a citizen to form associations or
unions. That right has not been touched by the 1965-Act. Similarly, Art. 19 (l)(f) does not give right to any citizen to hold property vested in a corporate body like the university. All that it
provides is that all citizens have the right to acquire, hold and
G dispose of property of their own. There is nothing in the 1965Act which in any way takes away the right of the Muslims of this
country to acquire, hold and dispose of property of their own.
Lastly reliance is placed on Art. 31(1) .which provides that
"no. person shall be deprived of his property save by authority of
law." We ma'Y assume that the "Muslim minority" is a person
B for purposes of. Art. 31 (]) and. the petitioners have a .right .to ~le
these writs on its behalf. It 1s urged. that the Mushm mmonty
has been deprived of their property, namely, the property vested in
the Aligarh University, by the 1965-Act inasmuch as the Court
now is a very different b-Ody from the Court as it was under the
1920-Act. It is difficult to understand this argument. It is clear
AZEEZ r.ASHA v. UNION (Wanclton,
C.J.)
837
from the history which we have set ou~ a~ove a_nd from the.provi- A
sions of the 192()..Act that the two soc1eues which were registered
under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, namely, the M.A.O.
College, and the Muslim University Association, voluntary surrendered whatever property they had including the college buildings etc. to the corporate body created by the 192()..Act, namely,
the Aligarh University. The third body~ namely, Muslim l!'niversity Foundation Committee also surrendered . the. money ~t h~d B
collected in pursuance of the Government direction that it will
only establish a university if rupees thirty lakhs were collected for
the purpose. The same was apparently collected, the major part
from Muslims but some contribution was made by non-Muslims
also. That fund was also made over to the corporate body,
namely, the Aligarh University which was brought into existence C
by the 192()..Acl This is clear from the preamble of the 192()..Act
and also from the provisions contained in s. 4 and s. 7 thereof.
Therefore, when the Constitution came into force on January 26,
1950, there was no property which was held by the Muslim minority as such, for the property had already vested in the corporate
body, namely, the Aligarh University brought into existence by the D
192()..Acl Even assuming that before 1920, the property which
-was surrendered to the Aligarh University was the property of the
Muslim minority, what happened in 1920 put an end to the rights
of the Muslim minority to hold the property and all that was done
with the consent of those who can be said to have held the property on behalf of the Muslim minority before 1920. There is n~ E
attack on the 192()..Act and it is not urged that any part of that
Act was in any way ultra vires the Constitution-Act which was
then in force. Therefore, when the present Constitution came into
force on January 26, 1950 the Muslim minority did not have any
right in the property which was vested in the Aligarh University
by the 192()..Acl The 1965-Act has made rto change in the F
ownership of the property which was vested in the Aligarh University. Even after the 1965-Act came into force, the property still
continues to be vested in the same corporate body, (namely the
Aligarh University). In the circumstances, it cannot be said that
the 1965-Act deprived the Aligarh Ur,iversity of the property
vested in it. As for the Muslim mit:011ty they had already given G
up the property when the Aligarh University was brought into
existence by the 192()..Act and that property was vested by the Act
in the Aligarh University. The Muslim minority cannot now
after the Constitution came into force on January 26, 1950 lay
claim to that property which was vested in the Aligarh University
by the 192()..Act and say that the 1965-Act merely because it made
some change in the constitution of the Court of the Aligarh Uni- B
v~rsity deprived the Muslim minority of the property, for the
simple reason that the property was not vested in the Muslim
minority at any time after the 192()..Act came into force. The
argument that there has been breach of Art. 31(1) has therefore no
force;
868
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1968) I s.c.R.
A
We are therefore of opinion !hat there is no force in any of
these petitions .. It is not disputed that the 1951 and 1965-Acts
are within the competence of Parliament unless they .are hit by any
of the constitutional provisions to which we have referred above.
As they are not hit by any of these provisions, these Acts are good
and are not liable to be struck down as ultra vires the Constitution. The petitions therefore fail and are hereby dismissed. In
B the circumstances we make no order as to costs.
V.P.S.
L/P(Nj7SC!-2,of:0-23 12-G -Gil'S
Petitions dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org