HINDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS LTD. versus THE WORKMEN & ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 3 October 1966 | [1967] 1 S.C.R. 652 | 1966 INSC 195
Key facts
- Decided
- 3 October 1966
- Bench
- K. SUBBA RAO*, M. HIDAYATULLAH, RAGHUBAR DAYAL, R.S. BACHAWAT
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 406/1964
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1967] 1 S.C.R. 652
- Neutral citation
- 1966 INSC 195
Text of the judgment
HINDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS LID.
v.
THE WORKMEN & ORS.
October 3, 1966
[K. SUBBA RAO, C. J., M. HIDAYATIJLLAH, S. M. SiKRI,
R. S. BACHAWAT AND RAGHUBAR DAYAL, JJ.j
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (14 of 1947), s. 10--Award by Tribunal-Fixation of Wage Scales--Public Sector underf(Jkings whether """
claim special ·treatment-:Dearness allowance, considerations in fixing-Gratuity scheme-Age of retirement of warkers-Retrospective operation
of award; discretion of Tribunal in fixing dale.
The appellant was a Government undertaking incorporated under the
Indian Companies Act. Its registered office was in Maharashtra and hi
main business the manufacture of antibiotics. The entire equity capilal
of the company was held by the President of India and his nominees and
the entire Board of Directors was nominated by him. Service conditions
of the workmen and other matters were subject to the approval of lbe
President of India. Though the company was a limited one and ther&fore had a distinct corporate existence, it was in effect finaoct.d and COil·
trolled by the Central Government. On dispute arising between the
workmen of the company and the management thereof the Government
of Maharashtra made a reference under s. IO(l)(d) of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 for its adjudication. The Industrial Tribunal gave
its award in two parts and gave, inter alia, the following findings :
Rejecting the contention of the company that in flXing the wage scale.•
different considerations and standards should apply to public sector undertakings as distinct from private sector undertakings, the Tribunal fixed the
wage scale on region.cum-industry basis. It found that the .company
was a very large and prosperous concern and its wage scales were on the
low side particularly in regard to the lower categories of workers, taking
into consideration the duties and qualification prescribed for them. The
Tribunal fixed the wage scales having regard to the company's financial
position, its productive. capacity, a comparative study of its wage struc~
ture with that of its neighbouring industries and similar other relevant
faclors. It retained the existing dearness allowance scheme except for a
small alteration in the slab of dearness allowance for the pay group
Rs. 301-500; it merged a .proportion of what would normally be paid
in the shape of dearness allowance in the ba.'iic pay in the case of lower
categories of workmen by giving increases wherever necessary for the
basic pay only. It linked the dearness allowance with the cost of living
index for Poona. It evolved a gratuity scheme for the \\.'Orkmen. It gave
retrospective operation to the award. There were other findings on the
various demands of the workmen. The company appealed to this Court
under Art. 136.
HELD : (i) In dealing with appeals brought to this Court under Art.
136 of the Constitution against awards which construct wage structures,
this Court would not interfere with the actual provisions of the wage
structure unless some general principles were involved. There was no
Justification for the argument that this C'.-0urt had by convention and
practice adopted a more liberal attitude in the case of appeals against
awards than in other appeals. [658 C..DJ
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
ffiNDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WORKMEN
A
B
c
D
E
F
653
Observations in Bengal Chemical and Pharmaceutical Works Ltd.,
Calcutta v. Workmen. [1959) Supp. 2. S.C.R. 136, teaffirmed.
(ii) The object of Industrial law is two-fold namely, (i) to improve
the service conditions of industrial labour so as to provide for them the
ordinary amenities of life, and (ii) by that process to bring about inclmtrial peace which would in its turn accelerate productive activity o~ tho
country resulting in its prospe~ty. The prosperity of ~e country !11 i!"
turn helps to improve the conditions of labour. By this process it is
hoped that the standard of life of labour cal) be progressively raised from
the stage of minimum wage, passing through need found wage, fair wage,
to livins; wage. The principle of region-cum~industry, the doctrine that
the mimmum wage is to be assured to labour irrespective of the capacity
of the industry to bear the expenditure in that regard, the concept that
fair wage is linked with the capacity of the indmtry, the rule of relevancy of comparable concerns, and the recognition of the totality of the
basic wage and dearness allowance that should be borne in mind ;n the
fixation of wage structure, are all well settled. [659 F-H]
Mis. Crown Aluminium Works .v. Their Workmen, [1958] S.C.R.
651, Express Newspapers (Private) Ltd. v. Union of India [1959] S.c.R.
12, French Motor Car Co. Ltd. v. Workmen, [1963] Supp. 2 S.C.R. 16 lind
TM Hi"ndiJstan Times Ltd., New Delhi v. Their Workmen, [1964) 1 S.C.R.
234, referred to.
(iii) All the principles referred to above though accidentally evolved
in industrial adjudication relating to industries born in the private sector
apply equally well to industries in the public sector. There is no justillcation from the standpoint of the employee that different wage structure
shall be adopted having regard to the fact that in one case the shares or
the company are held wholly or partly by the Central Government er
the State Government and in other cases by members of the public. The
worker is interested in his pay packet and if he is given reasonable wages,
it is expected that a satisfied worker will contribute to the growth of the
industry and ultimately the prosperity of the country. From this standpoint, which is a paramount consideration, so long as the capacity of the
industry is assured, the character of the employer is irrelevant. Jn the
ultimate analysis, the character of the employer or the destination or
profits has no relevance in the fixation of wages. Whoever may be the
employer, he has to pay a reasonable wage to the employees. [660 F.
662 BJ
Constitutional, legislative, executive and opinion trends in that regard.
all go to show that wages should normally be fixed on region-cum-industry basis. [662 C-668 Fl
G
;
H
. The . ma~erial on recor? further s~owed that the-re was no complete
un1form1ty ID pay scales m all public sector undertakings. The service
":"n.ditions of the employees in public sector undertakings were also not
similar to those of Government employees; there was no security of ser...
vice; the fundamental rules did not apply to them; there was no constitutional prcrtection; there was no pension; they were covered by standing
orders; their service conditions were more similar to those of employees
in the private sector than those in Government departments. The Pay
Commission recommendations were not applicable to the employees of
th.e Government .unde·rtakings in the public sector; indeed the Pay ComausSion Report did not deal with them. [668 G-669 A-BJ
There were no grounds for the fear that there would be any ri:percussions on other public sector undertakings situated in different parts of
654
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1967) I S.C.R.
the country because of the said ditferences in the wage structure of the
Oovemment undertakings in the public sector. [669-DJ
A
(iv) The doctrine of dearness allowance was only evolved in India.
lmtcad of increasing W38" as it is done in other countries, dearness allow&DCe is paid to neutralise the rise in prices. This process was adopted
in cxpectation that one day or other we would go back to the original
price levels. But when it was found that it was only a vain hope a part
of the dearness allowance was added to the basic wages. While the
Tribunal increased the wagea in fixing the dearness allowance it looked
into the overall picture namely, whether the total wage packet would
approximate to the total packet wages in comparable -industries. There
was no question therefore of paying dearness allowance on dearness
allowance, but it was only paymept of dearness allowance in addition to
tho increased wages. Even on the basis of increased wages dearness
ailowance was necessary to neutralise the rise in prlcea. The Tribunal
lll&o introduced the slab system so that in the case of employees falling
in the higher slabs the rise in prices was adequately neutralised. The
Tribunal did not commit any error of principle. [671 F; 672 DJ
B
c
(v) There was no double provision for house rent. The fact that in
the index . for_ Poona one of the components ~as house. rent. only m~t
that the nse Ill the house rent was also taken mto consideration 10 amv-
ing at the index. Unless it was established thal the house rent was a
major item which went in in11ating the price Index, it could not be said
that the Tribunal by awarding house rent allowance had given a double
adnntage to the employees. [672 El
(vi) Gratuity is an additional form of relief for the worker to fall
baclr. upon. U the industry can bear the burden, there is no reason why
he should not be entitled to both the benefits-provident fund and
gratuity. The Tribunal considerP.d all the relevant circumstances : the
stability of the concern. the profits made by it in the past, its future prospccl5 and its capacity and came to the conclusion that in the concern in
question the labour should be provided with a gratuity scheme in addition to that of provident fund. There was no justification to disturb the
conclusion. [674 DJ
D
E
In the nature of things a particular ceiling for gratuity cannot be
fixed. If depends on the facts of each case. The scheme as prepared
by the Tribunal was fair and equitable. [674 F]
(vii) Only such of the item; which go directly to reduce the expenditure that wowd otherwise go into the family budget are relevant m fixing fair wages. The Tribunal had taken all the permis<ible fringe benefits in fixing the wage scales and dearness allowance. It could not !her""
fare be said that the Tribunal went wrong in omitting any amenities in
fixing the wages. [675 C]
(viii) Having taken into account the relevant factors the Tribunal in
its discretion came to the conclusion that the revised scales should come
into elfect from !st January 1962. There was no reBlion to interfere
with its discretion. [675 GI
(ix) It was common case
that work in the 'closed area' involved
greater physical strain on the workmen. Therefore when the Tribunal
gave them a reasonable allowance it was not possible for this Court to
take a different view. [675 HJ
(x) The Tribunal accepted the principles generally applied in fixing
wages. It had not been shown that any principlu had been violated. rt
G
H
IHNDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WORKMEN (Subba Rao, C./~)
655
was true that in some cases. the total emoluments of a particular ·category
of employees of the company were higher than those of the other concerns, but the difference was not such as to be described as a flagrant
violation of the fixation of the wage structure. If no principle is violated
this Court will not interfere on the ground that it would have fixed the
wages at a. lower level than the Tribunal did. (676 F-DJ
B
c
(xi) The finding of the Tribunal that a foreman. was not a workman
was on a consideration of bis duties which it found to be of a managerial
or administrative nature. The finding was one of fact and therefore must
be accePted. [676 FJ
(xii) There was no error of principle in the rates fixed by the Tribunal in the case of daily-rate workers. (677 A-BJ
(xiii) The Tribunal was not right in giving a discretion to the employers to continue or not to continue employees beyond the age of 58
years. Following the trend of judicial opinion .the retirement age of the
employees of the company should be raised to 60 years. (677 HJ
(xiv) The Tribunal bad given linkage with effect from April 1, 1965.
The employees bad not made out any case for giving a further retrospective effect to the linkage. (678 B.CJ
D
CML APPELLATE!JuRISDICTION : Civil Appeals No. 406 and
407 of 1964.
Appeals by special leave from the award dated October
8, 1963 of the Industrial Tribunal, Maharashtra, in Reference (IT)
No. 147 of 1962.
E
S. D. Vimadalal, ·B. Dutta, J. B. Dadachanji, 0. C. Mathur
and Ravinder Narain, for the appellant (in C.A. No. 406 of 1964)
and the respondent (in C.A. No. 407 of 1964).
M. C. Setalvad, K. T. Sule, Madan G. Phadnis, Jatindra Sharma
and Janardan Sharma, for the respondent (in C.A. No. 406 of 1964)
and the appellant (in C. A. No. 407 of 1964).
F
M. K. Ramamurthi, for intervener No. 1.
M. R. K. Pillai, and M. S. K. Iyengar, for intervener No. 2.
G
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Subba Rao, C. J. These two Cross Appeals raise the question, among others, whether the wage structure, including dearness
allowance, of a Government undertaking in the public sector
sltould be of a pattern different from that of an undertaking in the
private sector.
H
The Hindustan Antibiotics Limited, hereinafter called "the
Company", is a Government undertaking and is incorporated
under the Indian Companies Act. Its registered office is· at Pimpri, Poona District, State of Maharashtra, and its main business
is the manufacture and distribution in bulk of antibiotics like
penicillin, streptomycin, etc. The entire equity capital of the
65.6
SUPREME COURT RBPORTS
(1967] l S.C.R.
Company is held by the President of India and his nominees,
and the entire Board of Directors of the Company is nominated
by him. The conduct of the business of the Company is subject
to the directives issued from time to time by the President of India
and its accounts are audited by tbe auditors appointed by the
Central Government on the advice of the Comptroller and Auditor
General of India. Service conditions of the workmen and other
matters are subject to the approval of the President of India. The
annual report of the working of the Company and its affairs along
with the Audit Report has to be placed before the Parliament.
There are no shareholders other than the Central Government
or its nominees, with the result that the dividends declared by
the Company entirely go to the coffers of the State, but the profits are ploughed back into the industry or kept as reserve for
future requirements. Jn short, though the Company is a limited
one and, therefore, has a distinct corporate existence, it is in
effect financed entirely from the funds of the Central Government.
A
The Company employs about 2,000 workmen. A dispute
arose between the workmen of the Company and the management
thereof and the workmen presented a charter of fifteen demands
to the Company. The Government of Maharashtra referred the
said dispute to the Industrial Tribunal, Bombay, for adjudication under s. lO(l)(d) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
(14 of 1947).
D
The Industrial Tribunal, after elaborately considering the
conflicting contentions of the disputants, gave an award dated
October 8, 1963. Jn making tbe said Award the Industrial Tribunal postponed its decision on the question of linking dearness allowance with the cost of living iudex which had not then
been prepared for Poona. The Company and its workmen, after
obtaining special leave, filed Cross Appeals against the said award
and on the last occasion when the said appeals came up for hearing, this Court by its order dated September I 4, 1965, adjourned
the same awaiting the pronouncement by the Industrial Tribunal of Part JI of its award. After the said adjournment of
the appeals by this Court, the Industrial Tribunal. on December 23, 1965, made part II of its award. These appeals arc now
before us for disposal.
The Industrial Tribunal made the following findings among
others : Rejecting the contention of the Company that in fixing
the wage scales different considerations and standards should
apply to public sector undertakings as distinct from private
sector undertakings, the Tribunal fixed the wage scales on rcgioncum-industry basis. On a scrutiny of the comparative study
of the wage structures of companies in the region, it found that
B
c
E
F
G
H
lfl:NDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WOllKMI!N (Stlbba Rao, C./,) 657
D
the Company was a very large and prosperous concern and its
wage scales were on the low side, particularly in regard to .the
lower· categories of workers, taking into consideration the duties
and qualifications prescribed for them. The Tribunal fixed the
wage scale8, having regard to the Company's financial position,
its productive capacity, a comparative study of its wage strl.lcture with that in the neighbouring industries, and sinillar other
relevant factors. It retained the -existing dearness allowance
scheme except for a small alteration ·in the slab of. dearness
allowance for the pay group Rs. 301-500; it merged a J)roportion of what would normally be paid in the shape of ~arness
allowance in the basic pay in the case of lower categories
of workmen by giving .increases wherever necessary in the basic
pay only. It linked the dearness allowance ·with the cost of living index for Poona. It evolved a gratuity scheme for the workmen. It gave retrospective operation to the award. The findings of the Tribunal on other points need not be mentioned here
they will be dealt with in appropriate places. In the result, pursmint to the said directions, the Tribunal had worked out the
figures in detail and giveq its findings on the various demands
·
made by the workmen.
B
At the outset it may usefully be reiterated that this Court
is not a regular court of appeal against orders of tribunals. The
scope of its power under Art. 136 of the Constitution vis-a-vis
awards of tribunals is stated in Bengal Chemical and Pharmaceutical Works Ltd., Calcutta v. Their Workmen('). Therein this
Court observed:
·
B
c
r
G
H
"Article 136 of the Constitution does not confer
a right of appeal to any party from the decision of any
tribunal, but it confers a discretionary power on the Supreme Court to grant special leave to appeal from the
order of any tribunal in the territory of India. It is
implicit in the discretionary reserve power that it cannot be exhaustively defined. It cannot obviously be
so construed as to confer a right to a party where he
has none under the law. The Industrial Disputes Act
is intended to be a self-contained one and it seeks to
achieve social justice on the basis of collective bargaining, conciliation and arbitration. Awards are given
on circumstances peculiar to each dispute and the tribunals are, to a large extent, free from the restrictions
of technical considerations imposed on courts. A free
and liberal exercise of the power under Art. 136 may
materially affect the fundamental basis of such decisions,
namely, quick solution to such disputes to achieve
(I} (1959] Supp, 2 S.C.R. 136, 140.
658
SUPUMB COURT UPO&TS
(1967] I S.C.Ro
industrial peace. Though Art. 136 is couched in widest
terms, it is necessary for this Court to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction only in cases where awards are made
in violation of the principles of natural justice, causing
substantial and grave injustice to parties or raising an
important principle of industrial law requiring elucidation and final decision by this Court or disclosing such
other exceptional or special circumstances which merit
the consideration of this Court."
We have cited the passage in sxtenso, as during the course of arguments, stress was laid on the fact that this Court has, by convention and practice adopted a more liberal attitude in the case of
appeals agaipst awards than in other appeals. We do not find any
justification for this argument. Indeed, in this very case, this
Court, on the last occasion adjourning the same, made the following observations:
"Normally, in dealing with appeals brought to this
Court under Art:cle 136 of the Constitution against
Awards which construct wage structures, this Court
does not interfere with the actual provisions of the wage
structure unless some general principles are involved.
This position is not disputed by the learned AttorneyGeneral."
No case has been cited before us where a conscious departure
has been made from the said observations in Be~gal Chemical
and Pharmaceutical Works Ltd., Calcutta v. Their Workmen(').
It may be that if the facts of some of the appeals decided by this
Court were analysed, a liberal attitude may be discovered but the
judgments therein would be found to have turned upon the peculiar facts of those appeals. In the absence of any definite pronouncements accepting a deviation from the said principle, we cannot
adopt a principle different from that recorded in the aforesaid
decision.
We, therefore, re-affirm the observations made in
the said judgment as laying down the correct approach to appeals
under Art. 136 of the Constitution against awards of tribunals.
The main contention of Mr. S. D. Vimadalal, learned counsel for the Company, may be put thus : The pattern of wage fixation in the case of Government companies born in the public
sector should necessarily be different from that of companies
born in the private sector. Elaborating the argument, he relied
upon the following circumstances to sustain the said distinction :
(i) nexus with the Central Government; (ii) need to keep parity
or at least no disparity between different public sector industries
in different parts of the country; (iii) the concepts of capacity
(I) [19S9J Supp. 2 S.C.R. 136, 140.
A
B
c
D
E
J1
G
H
lilNDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WORKMEN (Subba Rao, C.J.) 659
A
B
c
D
JI'
-
G
H
profitS and surplus have a new connotation which is different
from that they bear in their application to industries in the private
sector; (iv) pay scales are the same in all the industries throughout India born in the public sector; (v) amenities and fringe
benefits in public sector industries are incomparably greater
than in the private sector industries; (vi) the employees of the
public sector industries have greater security than those of the
private sector industries; (vii) the fact that the Government, instead of running the business departmentally formed a company
for the same purpose cannot possibly make any difference in the
wage structures; and (viii) the undertaking in question is entirely
financed by the Government. He would also say that _the appropriate pattern to a Government company was that laid down
by· the Second Pay Commission as applicable to departmentally
run industrial units of the Central Government.
Mr. M. C. Setalvad, appearing for the workmen of the Company, countered this argument by stating that in fixing the wage
structure, including dearness allowance, the question who is the
employer is irrelevant and the needs of the employee are only
paramount and that from the perspective of an employee there
cannot possibly be any difference between companies born in
the public sector and those born in the private sector. The apprehension, the argument proceeded, that there may be discrimination if this distinction is adopted between different industries has no real bearing, as it is impossible to eliminate completely all traces of discrimination between employees of different
industries whatever principle is adopted.
At the outset, it will in convenient to consider the question
of principle. The object of the industrial law is two-fold, namely;
(i) to improve_ the service conditions of industrial labour so as
to provide for them the ordinary amenities of life, and (il) by
that process, to bring ~bout industrial peace which would in its
tum accelerate productive activity of the country resulting
in its prosperity. The prosperity of the country, in it11 tum, helps
to improve the conditions of labour. By this process, it is hoped
that the standard of life of the labour can _be progressively raised
from the stage of minimum wage, passing through need found wage,
fair wage, to living wage. Industrial adjudication reflected in
the judgments of tribunals and the courts have evolved some principles governing wage fixation though accidentally they related
only to industries born in the private sector. The principle of ·
region-cum-industcy, the doctrine that the minimum wage is
to be assured to the labour irrespective of the capacity of the
industcy to bear the expenditure in that regard, the eonceP.t that
fair wage is linked with the capacity of the industry, the rule of
relevancy of comparable concerns, and the recognition of the
660
SUPRBMB COURT REPORTS
(1967) I S.C.R.
totality of the basic wage and dearness allowance that should be
borne in mind in the fixation of wage structure, are all so well
settled and recognised by industrial adjudication that further
elaboration i~ unnecessary. In this context, a reference to the
decisions in Messrs. Crown.Aluminium Works, v. Their Workmen(•),
Express Newspapers (Private) Ltd., v. The Union of lndia(2), French
Motor Car Co. Ltd. v. Workmen() and The Hindustan Times
Ltd., New Delhi v. Their Workmen(4) will be useful. There is
no, and there cannot be any, dispute on the laudable aims of
industrial policy of our country in the matter of wage fixation. Das
Gupta, J., in The Hindustan Times ltd., New Delhi. v. Their Workmen(•) said at page 240 :
"In trying to keep true to the two points of social
philosophy and economic necessiti~s which vie for consideration, industrial adjudication has set for itself certain standards in the matter of wage fixation. At the
bottom of the ladder, there is the minimum basic wage
which the employer of any industrial labour must pay in
order to be allowed to continue an industry. Above tbis
is the fair wage, which may roughly be said to apprmtimate to the need based minimum, in the sense of a wage
which is "adequate to cover the normal needs of the average
employee regarded as a human being in a civilised society".
Above the fair wage is the "living wage"-a wage "which
will maintain the workman in the highest state of industrial
efficiency, which will enable him to provide his family with
all the material things which afe needed for their health
and physical well-being, enough to enable him to qualify
to discharge his duties as a citizen"."
This passage briefly and neatly defines the three concepts of minimum wage, fair wage and living wage. In the application of the
said principles doubtless evolved in the industrial disputes in the
private sector, what is the difference between industries in the two
sectors to justify a different treatment of the industries in the public
sector ? There is socio-economic justification for the said principles. The social and economic upliftment of the labour is important for securing industrial peace which is essential to increase
the national productivity. It is an accident that industrial adjudication in the private sector has thrown out the said principles.
All the said considerations equally apply to industries in ·the public
sector: We are excluding, for the present, industries run by the
Government departmentally, for, in one sense they are also industries in the public sector. We are referring only to industries
run by limited companies wherein the Government owns the entire
share capital or a part of it. Now, take a particular region, say
(I) (19S8] s.c.R. 6SI.
(2) 11959! S.C.R. 12.
(3) (1963] Supp. 2 S.C.R. 16.
(4) [1964] I S.C.R. 234.
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
-
HINDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WORKMEN (Subba Rao, C.l.)661
Bombay. In that region-we are only takin11 a hypothetical
case-there may be four companies owning factories manufacturing antibiotics, namely, a limited company in ·which the Government does not own any shares and all the shares are owned by the
members of the public, a company in which all the shares are held
by the Central Government, a company whose share capital is
B owned by the Government as well as by the public and a company
which is a proprietary undertaking owned by a single individual
or a number of individuals. All the factories are making appreciable
profits and have capacity to pay the employees. What is the justification from the standpoint of the employees that different wage
structure shall be adopted having regard to the fact that in one case
shares are held wholly or partly by the Central Government or
c the
the State Government and in other cases by the members of the
public ? The worker is int_erested in his pay- packet and if he is
given reasonable wages, it is expected that a satisfied worker will
contribute to the growth of the industry and ultimately the prosperity of the country. From his standpoint, which is a paramount
consideration, so long as the capacity of the industry is assured, the
D character of the employer is irrelevant. Now, let us look at the
problem from the standpoint of the employer. It is said that
a company born in the private sector works with a profit motive
and exploits the workmen for its private ends, whereas a company
born in the public sector, though it is expected to make profits, really
contributes to the wealth of the whole country. This argument
poses the question of the comparative merits of different ideologies
such as price economy, mixed economy, socialism etc. We- do not
propose to go into these complicated economic problems; but it
cannot be posited that necessarily and inevitably companies born in
the private sector only care for profits by exploiting workers and
those born in the public sector always work for public good.
Different countries following different ideologies have reached prosperity or are on the way of prosperity. It cannot be said that a
particular ideology only will lead to that result : it depends upon
many other factors. That apart, whatever may be said about proprietary firms, it cannot be asserted that every company born in the
private sector only functions on private motives; it may earn profits,
pay reasonable dividends and plough back the balance of the profits
G into the industry for its further growth. So too, it cannot be asserted
that always a State will utilise the profits earned for the good of the
country. There are many instances in the world where the national
resources were frittered away. In the ultimate analysis, the character of the e_mployer or the destination of profits has no relevance
in the fixation of wages. Whoever may be the employer, he has to
R pay a reasonable wage to the employees. The incongruity of the
alleged distinction in the matter of wages is further exemplified
if we compare similar industries in the same region owned ·by the
State and by the Union. Now, if the argument be acoepted, the
'
fl62
SUPllBMB OOUll.T Jll!l'Olt.TS
[1967) I S.C.R.
pattern of wage structure between these also must differ, for, the
pay scales Ji.ow obtaining in the State Governments and the Central
Government radically differ. On the other hand, if the doctrine of
region-cum-industry is accepted, all the employees of industries of
similar nature, irrespective of the character of the employers, will
get a fair deal without any discrimination which will certainly be
conducive to the industrial development of our country.
Let us now consider the constitutional, legislative, executive
and opinion trends in that regard. Art. 39 of the Directive Principles of State Policy says that the State shall direct its policy towards securing equal pay for equal work for the both men and
women and Art. 43 thereof enjoins on the State to endeavour
to secure, by suitable legislation or economic organisation or in
any other way, to all workers, agricultural, industrial or otherwise,
work, a living wage, conditions of work ensuring a decent standard
of life and full enjoyment of leisure and social and cultural opportunities. This constitutional directive will certainly be disobeyed
if the State· attempts to make a distinction between the same class
of labourers on the ground that some of them are employed by a
company financed by it and the others by companies floated by private enterprise. Th~ Articles do not countenance the invidious
distinction which is now sought to be made on the basis of the
character of the employer. The Legislatures in India even before
the coming into force of the Constitution passed Acts regulating
industries such as the Industrial Disputes Act, 1938, Industrial
Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946 and Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947. In these Acts no distinction is made between industries
in public and private sectors vis-a-vis the service conditions of the
labour. Under s. 2(g) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 'employer'
means in relation to an industry carried on by or under the authority
of any department of the Central Government or a State Government the authority prescribed in this behalf, the head of the department; and un'.ier cl. (j) 'industry' means any business, trade, undertaking, manufacture or calling of employers and includes any calling,
service, employment, handicrafts etc. S. 2cl. (s) defines workman to
mean any person employed in any industry to do ...... work for
hire or reward.
A combined reading of these provisions indicates-indeed it is
not disputed-that the Act regulates the relationship of employer
and employee irrespective of the fact that the employer is the State
Government or not. But what is stated is that though the said Act
governs the relationship between the employers and workmen irrespective of the fact whether the employer is Government or Government-aided corporation, the pattern cf wage structure need not
necessarily be the same; but the fact that the disputes between tile
employers and employees, irrespective of the character of the em-
A
B
c
D
E
G
H
mNDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS l'. WORKMEN (Subba RllD, CJ.)663 .
A
B
c
D
ployer are made the subject of industrial adjudication is indicative,
though not decisive of the legislative intention to treat workmen
similarly situated alike in the matter of wage structure and other
conditions of service. S. 20 of the Payment of Bonus Act of
1965 directs the application of the Act to establishments in public
sector in certain cases.
Industrial adjudication also adopted the same pattern for both
the categories of industries. Awards given by tnlmnals in industrial
disputes raised by the workmen of Air India, State Bank of India,
municipal undertakings, collieries, Bombay Electricity Supply and
Transport Undertaking, and Life Insurance Corporatio~ of India,
show that the tribunals applied the principles evolved by industrial
adjudication in regard to industries in the private sector to the said
public undertakings. The comment that some of them had a
private sector background and, therefore, the tribunals treated them
on par with the industries in the private sector has no force, and
indeed the fact that the same principles were applied notwithstanding
the conversion of the private sector industries into public sector
industries shows that a different treatment was not thought necessary.
So too, the wage. boards constituted by the Government of India
for different indu8tries, such as steel, engineering, cement, hotel etc.
made enquiries into their service conditions without making any
distinction between the industries in the two sectors.
•
The pronouncements made by the Government or its official
agencies do not also support any such distinction. In the 15th session of the Indian Labour Conference held in New Delhi on July 11
and July 12, 1957, the labour, the employees, the employers, the
State Governments and the Central Government were represented.
One of the recommendations made by that Conference in regard to
fair wages is found in para 5 of its report. It reads :
I'
"As regards faif wages, itwas agreed that the Wage
Boards should go into the details in respect of each indnstry
on the basis of the recommendations contained in the report
of the Committee on Fair Wages. These recommendations of the Fair Wages Committee should also be made
applicable to employees in the public sector."
Another recommendation was that the study groups inay assemble
materials for rationalisation of the management in industries, includinll those in the public sector. Pointing out the difference
between ·the two sectors, the Planning Commission observed :
G
B
'"l>nblic undertakings differ in an important respect
from tfrivate undertakings. The 'profit' motive and the
exploitation ofworkers for private 'gain have no significance
in the State owned enterprises. The undertakings have no
doubt to show the same, if not greater efficiency of working
M16llup.CJ/66-14
664
SUPRBJa COURT Rl!POll.TS
(1967] I S.C.R.
as private owned undertakings. They have also to show
profits. But the nature of these profits is different. The
profits which these undertakings make are not profits intended for any individual or group of individuals but are
extra wealth for the whole country."
In the First Five Year Plan the· Planning Commission laid down
the policy in respect of different undertakings thus :
"The aim should be to have a co-operative and contented labour force. The ways by which this can be achieved
while maintaining peace in the undertakings and increasing
production are :
(a) Wages in public undertakings should not be less
favourable than those prevailing in the neighbouring
private enterprises. In so far as working conditions
and welfare amenities are concerned, undertakings in
the public sector should set the pace and serve as
models.
(b)
(c) The benefits of all labour laws which arc applicable to
similar private undertakings should also be made
available to fhe workers of these undertakings ..... .
(d)
A
B
c
D
.....................................
The atmosphere should be such that the workers be
made to feel that in practice, as well as in theory,
they are partners in the undertaking.
E
(e)
(f) Collective bargaining between workers and management
should be encouraged. Such collective bargaining should
embrace both economic and non-economic demands ..
Government conciliation and arbitration machinery
should be made available to the workers of these undertakings. The existing right of Government to accept,
reject or modify an award should be restricted to
period of emergency."
It is true that the said extracts have no statutory force but only represent the opinion of the Planning Commission. But both the
parties only relied upon it to show the thinking of the policy-making
bodies and the trends in the matter of industrial adjudication.
While recognising the differences that existed between industries
in the two sectors, the Planning Commission expressed the view that
the object was to have a co-operative and contented labour and that
therefore, the employees of the public sector should also have the
benefit of industrial adjudication. Both the sides relied upon the
,
G
H
HINDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WORKMEN (Subba Rao, C.l.)665
passage which said that wages in public undertakings should not be
less favourable than those prevailing in the neighbouring private
enterprises. Wo do not see how this passage helps the Company.
Indeed, in a way, it supports the respondents for it seeks to put
the wages in both the sectors on the same level.
8
c
D
E
F
G
H
The Planning Commission in its report on the Second Five Year
Plan not only reiterated but also emphasised its earlier view.
Therein it observed.
"Any attempt, therefore, on the part of public employer
to avoid the responsibility of an employer on the ground
that he is not working for profit has to be discouraged.
............ In the last analysis employees in the public
sector should, on the whole, be at least on par with their
counterparts in private employment and should feel a legitimate pride in what they produce and in their position as
employees in the public sector."
So too, the report on the Third Five Year Plan, though it brought the
distinction between the two sectors, it again stated that similar
scales of pay should be given to employees in both the sectors.
The relevant passage thereof runs thus :
"Increased profits, which in the private sector would create inequalities, {and possible conspicuous and wasteful
consumption), in the public sector can be directly used for
capital accumulation. By efficient conduct of enterprises
and following a rational and economically sound price
policy for its products and services, the public sector undertakings ought to secure adequate return on capital employed
and contribute their full share to the increase in the portion
of national resources devoted to investment."
This passage only says that the public sector should function efficiently so that there may be capital accumulation. But, at the same
time, the Planning Commission proceeded to observe :
"However, to avoid the risk of. migration of personnel
from one public sector undertaking to another if different
scales of pay are adopted by them for posts of similar
nature, it may be necessary to indicate to the Board broadly
the basic scales of pay for different categories _of posts.
It should, however, be open to the Board to fix specific pays
for specific jobs."
The Planning Commission's report on the Third Five Year Plan
also did not make any departure from its earlier policy and did not
suggest that the two sectors vis-a-vis the labour should be put in
different compartments.
666
IUPIUIKB COURT llBPORTS
(1967] I S.C.R.
Estimate Committees which are constituted by Parliament had
also to make certain observations in regard to the subject. During
1960-61 the Estimates Conunittee in its !20th Report suggested that
the Government might review the scales of pay obtaining in all its
undertakings and revise them with the objectofintroducing uniformity
wherever possible. The Government turned down the suggestion on
the ground that it was not possible to suggest cancrete scales of pay
which can be applicable to all industries, because conditions differ
from region to region and from industry to industry. For 1963-64
the Estimates Conunittee expressed the view that all wholly Government-owned public undertakings should generally be in the form of
statutory corporations and the company-form should be an exception to be resorted to only for an organisation of a specific nature.
To that, the Government replied that the company-form had the
advantage of allowing the necessary flexibility and autonomy needed
for the successful operation of commercial enterprises. The Committee also suggested that there should be some uniformity in the
classification of staff in all public undertakings. The Estimates
Committee also in para l 42 of the Report made the following
observations :
"The Committee feel that varying practices in these matters
are likely to lead to repercussions in other public undertakings and it may be difficult to resist a similar demand
made by their employees. It is therefore desirable that
public undertakings follow a common pattern in this regard
as far as possible."
The Government rejected it on the ground that the nature and
responsibilities of staffs differ from undertaking to undertaking
depending upon the size, line of production etc. and the pay scales of
posts also varied from undertaking to undertaking. It also pointed
out that while uniformity might be desirable, a measure of
flexibility and autonomy was necessarily to be allowed for varying
nature and activities of the undertakings and, therefore, uniform
classification of staff whose nature and responsibility varied from
undertaking to undertaking was not possible. It will be seen that
though the Estimates Committee suggested a common pattern of
wage structure for all public undertakings, the Government, for
the reasons given, rejected the said proposals.
The opinions of the experts on the subject who had made a
special study thereof were relied upon. We are not .in a position to
evaluate the said opinions cited at the Bar, for the learned counsel
on both sides did not agree on the credentials of the experts. In
the book on "Cross Purposes in Wage Policy" by R. G. Hawtrey,
the following passage appears in Chapter VII :
"When an industry producing a freely marketable produce, like coal, is nationalised, it can proCeedlikea private
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
IDNDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WOllDO!N (Subba Rao, C./.)667
A
B
c
D
E
...
G
H
enterprise, paying wages at rates prevailing in the labour
market for similar grades, and fixing prices to cover costs."
It is Said. that this passage is based upon the exploded doctrine of
laissez-faire. But, in our view, the learned author was not referring
to any such theory, but was only expressing his opinion that in a
nationalised industry the rates of wages prevailing in the private
sector could profitably be adopted.
In his book on "Public Enterprise and Economic Development" though the author expressed the view that the duties and
attitudes of the personnel of a public corporation must dilfer from
those of civil servants, he pointed out that in many countries there was
a strong resistance against this policy either because they knew no
better or because powerful pressures virtually compel them to do so.
Dealing with India, he observed :
"The issue of 'Parity' with the civil services becomes
most acute when Government decides to convert a departmental enterprise into a public company or corporation."
Wdliam A. Robson in his book "Nationalised Industry and Public
Ownership" brought out. the differen~ between nationalised industry and a private enterprise. Incidentally he cited a passage
from a White Paper on broadcasting policy in respect of the level
of remuneration for the employees of the B.B.C. wherein it was
stated:
" ...... while it (the Corporation) is not rigidly bound
to relate the salaries and conditions of employment of its
permanent staff to those ruling in the Civil Service, it
should in fixing such salaries and conditions, pay proper
regard to those of the Civil Service and to the greater security
offered by employment in a public corporation, as
compared with employment in most business concerns."
This does not mean that the wage structure of the public corporation
should be of the same pattern obtaining in depa$ents of Government. It was only anadvice to the effect thatin fixing the pay s4:Ucture, due regard should be had to that in the ciYil service. We do
not know the comparative merits of the pay structure obtaining
in the two sectors in England.
"In Collective Bargaining'' by, International Labour Office,
Geneva, the following article appears:
"One main difference from private industry is that in a
nationalised industry tio profits go to private shareholders.
Any surplus, after setting aside funds needed for the development of the industry, is used for the benefit df the
whole community. Surpluses are not used to give special
advantages to the workers in nationalised indu~tries.
There is no reason why such workers should be better off
668
SUPllBMl! OOUllT llBPOllTS
[1967] I S.C.R.
in some industries than in others merely because their
industries have been nationalised. On the other hand, they
should not be worse off either. Their wages and conditions
should be determined as in otherindustries by the nature of
the work they .do, and should be related to the training
and skill required. Thus there should be similarity between
the wages and conditions of employment of workers in
nationalised and private industries. Labour can move freely
from one to the other, and workers in nationalised industries have no justifiction for claiming preferential treatment. The State as the employer of workers in nationalised
industries should be a good ·employer, but its labour conditions will be very much like those established by good
employers in private industry."
lbis passage gives the modem trend of opinion in respect of wage
structure in a succinct form. It shows that the labour of a nationalised industry should get a fair deal in the same manner as
their counter~part get in private industries.
In a paper submitted by Dr. H. K. Paranjape of the Institute
of Public Administration, New Dclhi to Seminar on Management
of Public Industrial Enterprises sponsored by the Government of
India and the United Nations, it is stated:
"As regards the condition about wages and allowances,
one cannot say that the situation of the employees in State
enterprises is in a way specially different from that in private industry. Rates of wages and allowances have naturally
to be related to the rates prevalent for the particular type
of workers in a given area. Of course in some regions
Government enterprises have created a demand for skilled
labour which did not exist before and this had had an
upward effect on the wage level in these regions."
We have referred to these books and papers not because they
have any binding effect, but only to gauge the correct trend in regard
to the wage structure. They show that the wages should normally
be fixed on region-cum-industry basis.
There is also some material to prove that there is a no uniformity of scale pattern in the public sector. In the 54th report of
the Estimates Committee it is suggested that there should be some
uniformity in the classification of staff in all public undertakings.
But the Government replied that the nature and responsibility of
staff differed from undertaking to undertaking .depending upon the
size and line of production etc., and that the pay scales also differed
from undertaking to undertaking and that complete uniformity in
pay scales was not practicable. The same variations in different
public sector undertakings are pointed out in the 52nd and 135th
reports of the Estimates Committee.
A
c
D
I.
F
G
ff
HINDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WORKMEN {Subba Rao, CJ.)669
B
c
D
E
'
G
H
Nor the service conditions of the employees in public sector
undertakings are analogous to those of the Government employees.
There is no security of service; the fundamental rules do not apply
to them; there is no constitutional protection; there is no pension;
they are covered by service standing orders; their service conditions
are more similar to those of employees in the private sector than
those in Government departments.
In Ex. U-13, a letter dated May 31, 1961 from the F"mancial
Advisor of the Company to Shri R. P. Sharma, the Financial Advisor, informed Shri Sharma, who was a U.D.C., Internal Audit
Section of the Company, that the Pay Commission recommendations were not applicable to the employees of the Company. Indeed, the Pay Commission Report does not deal at all with Government undertakings in the public sector.
Nor can we appreciate how there would be any repercussions
on other public sector undertakings situated in different parts of the
country because of the said differential in the wage structure of the
Government undertakings in the public sector. The labour who
have by now accepted the 'region-cum-industry' principle, will not
raise any dispute if their wages are similar to those obtaining in
comparable concerns in the region. On the other hand, in a vast
country like India, the labour cannot appreciate the uniform structure of wages on an All-India basis, if they find that in the region
where they are working, employees similarly situated are getting
higher wages than theirs. So too, in a particular region, the pay
structure of a Government industry may happen to be better than
that obtaining in comparable concerns in the same locality. This will
lead to industrial unrest, for the labour force in the comparable
concerns ~y demand that their.wages should be equalised with those
obtaining in Government concerns. By and large, therefore, the
acceptance of the principle of region-cum-industry will be more
conducive to industrial relations than that of the Governmental
wage structure framed on an All India basis. Nor can we appreciate the argument that the principle of region-cum-industry will
lead to discrimination. But, if the expression "labour force'' is
understood to mean the labour force employed in both the sectors,
the alleged discrimination between different parts of the public
sector will disappear, for, as far as possible, the labour to whichever
sector it .may belong in a particular region and in a particular
industry, will be treated on equal basis.
On a consideration of the relevant material placed before us,
we· have come to the conclusion that the same principles evolved
by the industrial adjudication in regard to private sector undertakings
will govern those in the public sector undertakings having a distinct
corporate existence.
670
SUPllJ!MB OOUJlT DPOl.TS
(1967] I S.C.R.
On the question of dearness allowance, the Tribunal iii para 36
of its award said that dearness allowance should be altered as under :
Basic Pay
Rs.
51-75
76-100
101-112
113-150
151-200
201 and over
A
Dearness allowance
(including the present
components of
additional dearness,
allowance and compensatory allowance)
B
Rs.
65
67
77
c
80
85
90
D
In addition, the Tribunal gave house rent allowance where the
workman is not given a houseto continue on the same basis as existed
earlier. In arriving at these figures, the Tribunal observed :
"Having considered the viewpoints of both sides I have
come to the conclusion that there should be some merger of
part of the dearness allowance with the basic pay in the case
of the lower categories. I have in revising the wage scales,
kept this in view and whenever an increase in the totality
of emoluments has been considered by me to be necessary I
have given the additions in the basic pay. In respect of the
higher categories, there is already some degree of merger,
I would maintain the present scheme of dearness allowance
with a slight modification."
But, as the Tribunal was of the opinion that dearness allowance
bad to be linked with the cost of living index for Poona.and as the
said index was not prepared by that time, it adjourned the consideration of that part of the award and it dealt with it in its subsequent award, Part II of the award. Having considered the arguments on both sides, it directed that with effect from April I, 1965,
the dearness allowance awarded under Part I of the A ward be varied
as follows:"For a variation (rise or fall) of every 5 points in the
Poona Index over the base 1961 there should be a variation
of Rs. 3.50 per month in the dearness allowance for
employees drawing basic wage/salary up to Rs. 75 ..... .
E
F
G
H
HINDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WORKMEN (Subba Rao, CJ.)671
For employees drawing basic wages/salary above Rs. 75
the variation will be, instead of Rs. 3.50, as follows:
B
c
Rs.
76-112
113-150
151-200
201 and over
Rs.
4
5
6.
7
The effect of this award was that dearness allowance was linked
both with wages as well as with the cost of liVing index for Poona.
To put it differently, the Tribunal gave dearness allowance varying
with different slabs of wages and linked the same with the said
Index.
Learned counsel for the Company raised before us two points:
(I} The Tribunal, having merged part of the dearness allowance
D
E
F
G
H
with the basic wages and having linked dearness allowance both with
wages and with the Index for Poona, in effect gave dearness allowance on dearness allowance. To put it in other words, it was
argued: by the said merger the wages were raised with the result, that
by the operation of the linking with the Index for Poona, the rate of
dearness allowance was also raised. (2) One of the components
of the Index for Poona was the house rent, and the Tribunal having
linked dearness allowance with the said Index, erred in again giving
house rent allowance.
The first argument is based upon a fallacy. The doctrine of
dearness allowance was only evolved in India. Instead of increasing wages as it is done in other countries, dearness allowance is
paid to neutralise the rise in prices. This process was adopted in
expectation that one day or other we would go back to the original
price levels. But, when it was found that it was only a vain hope
or at any rate, it could not be expected to fall below a particular
mark, a part of the dearness allowance was added to the basic wages,
that is to say, the wages, to that extent, were increased. While the
Tribunal increased the wages, in fixing the dearness allowance,
it looked into the overall picture, namely, whether the total wage
packet would approximate to the total packet wages in comparable
industries. There is no question, therefore, of paying dearness
allowance on dearness allowance, but it was only a payment of
dearness allowance in addition to the increased wages. Even on
the basis of the increased wages, dearness allowance was necessary
to neutralise the rise in prices. That is exactly what the Tribunal
has done. The Tribunal adverting to this argum~nt stated:
"I am, however, of opinion that in linking the ·dearness allowance, a portion of which has been merged
672
SUPJUIMB COUllT JUIPORTS
(1967] 1 s.c.R.
in the basi.;; wage, the totality of emoluments should not
be ignored, otherwise in the case of a market increase
in the cost of living, if the linkage is done without bearing
in mind the total emoluments, the total emoluments
would not be satisfactory and may even become out of line
with those in other large concerns in the region. Again
the linkage need not be done so as to provide increase
in dearness allowance at a uniform rate. Otherwise
increase in dearnesi allowance on account of rise in the
cost of living for employees drawing wages and salaries
above certain ranges of basic wage or pay as would vary
inadequately neutralise the· rise in cost of living"'
A
It is, therefore, clear that the Tribunal increased the wages of the
lower category of employees by adding part of the dearness allowance to their original basic wages, at the same time bearing in
mind that the total packet of wages and dearness allowance compared favourably with those in similar concerns. It has introduced
the slab system so that in the case of employees falling in the higher
slabs, the rise in prices is adequately neutralised. The Tribunal
did not commit any error of principle.
c
Nor can we accede to the argument that there was a double
provision for house rent. The fact that in the Index for Poona
one of the components is house rent only means that the rise in the
house rent was also taken into consideration in arriving at the
Index. Unless it is established that the house rent was a major
item which went in inflating the price index, it cannot be said that
the Tribunal by awarding house rent allowance has given a double
advantage to the employees in question. It has not been established before us that the Index for Poona was inflated because of
its rent component. Indeed, this argument does not appear to
have been raised before the Tribunal. We cannot, therefore, accept
this argument.
B
D
F
In the result, the contentions rai~ed in respect of dearness
allowance are rejected.
The next question relates to demand 6-A i.e., demand for
gratuity. The Tribunal directed the Company to give gratuity
aocording to the following scheme:
"(a) On the death of an employee while in the service
of the Company or his becoming physically or mentally
incapable for further service---0ne half of a month's
wages (including dearness allowance but excluding house
rent allowance and all other allowances), for each completed year of service, subject to a maximum of 10 months'
wages, payable to the workman or to his heirs or executors,
as the case may be.
G
H
HINDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WORKMEN (Subba Rao, C./.)87$.
A
B
(b) On voluntary retirement or resignation after
15 years' continuous service on the same basis as above.
(c) On termination of service by the Company after 10
years' continuous service but less than 15 years' service-one half of a month's wages, asdefined in clause (a) above,
for each completed year.
Gratuity will not be payable to a workman discharged
or dismissed for misconduct causing financial loss to the
Company, to the extent of the loss so caused.
c
Wages for the purpose of the scheme shall be computed at the average of the wages for the year preceding
the event of death, retirement, resignation, or termination
of service, as the case may be.
The Scheme shall come into force from the date on
which this Award becomes enforceable."
D
Learned counsel for the Company argued that it had been contri-buting to the employees' provident fund from !st April 1960 at
the rate of 8 i per cent on the basic wage and dearness allowance
though the rate laid down under the Employees' Provident Funds:
Act was only 61 per oent and that the Government oflndia came to
a decision that gratuity _scheme shoU!d not be introduced in an
industry where the rate of employer's contribution for the contributory provident fund was 8 I /3 per cent. He further contended
that no case had been made out on the facts of the present case for
giving the worker both the pension as well as gratuity.
The law on the subject is fairly well settled. In B.T. Mills
v. B. T. Mills Mazdoor Sangh(!) Hidayatullah, J. speaking for this
Court brought out clearly the distinction between a scheme of
gratuity and a scheme of pension. The learned Judge said:
G
"A scheme of gratuity and a scheme of pensions have
much in common. Gratuity is a lump sum payment
while pension is a periodic payment of a stated sum. They
are both "efficiency devices" and are considered necessary
for an "orderly and humane elimination" from industry
of superannuated or disabled employees who but for
such retiring benefits would continue in employment even
though they function inefficiently."
Gajendragadkar, J. in Indian Hwne Pipe Co. v. Its Workmen(2)
also gave a workable expression of gratuity. He stated:
H
"Gratuity is a kind. of retirement benefit like the
provident fund or pension. . . . . . Gratuity paid to .work(!) A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 839.
(2) (196S] 2 L.LJ. 830
I .
674
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1967] I S.C.K.
men is intended to hr1p them after retirement, whether
the retirement is the result of the rules of superannuation
or physical disability. The general principle underlying
such gratuity schemes is that hy their length of service
workmen are entitled to claim a certain amount as a retiral
benefit."
That apart, from the standpoint of the employee the said two
schemes give him something to fall back upon after his retirement. It is commonplace that industrial adjudication under the
present circumstances is not able to provide the labour a living
wage. At the best, they get only. a little more than the necessities
of life. If the industry is a flourishing one, we do not see any
reason why the labour shall not have the benefit of both the schemes. Doubtless, the provident fund gives him relief, but to earn it.
he contributes a part of his wages. But that in itself may not be
sufficient to meet the requirements of his old age or to provide for
his dependents during his life-time or after his death. Gratuity
is an additional form of relief for him to fall back upon. If the
industry can bear the burden, there is no reason why he shall not be
entitled to both the retirement benefits. The Tribunal considered
all the relevant circumstances: the stability of the concern, the
profits made by it in the past, its future prospects and its capacity
and came to the conclusion that in the concern in question, the
labour should be provided with a gratuity scheme in addition to
that of a provident fund scheme. We sec no justification to
disturb this conclusion.
Nor can we agree with the argument of Mr. Setalvad that the
Tribunal should have given twenty months' basic salary as gratuity.
In the nature of things, a particular ceiling for gratuity cannot be
fhcd. It depends upon the facts of each case. The Tribunal has
taken all the relevant circumstances including the fact that the
Company was contributing to the employees' provident fund at the
rate of 8! per cent instead of 6! % and also the fact that part of
the dearness allowance was included in the basic wage. We do
not sec any error of law or anything contrary to the practice obtaining in _industrial adjudication to compel us to interfere with the
details of the said scheme. They are quite fair and equitable in the
circumstances of the case. We therefore reject the contention of
the Company as well as the employees in this regard.
It was then contended for the Company that it has provided
amenities to the employees which no other comparable concern
has provided ar.d therefore they should have been taken into consideration in fixing the wage structure. The Company has shown in
Ex.C-12 the various amenities it has provided for the labour. The
relevant principle has been fairly stated by the Fair Wages Committee in para 28 of its report which reads:
B
c
D
•
F
G
H
HINDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WORKMEN
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
(Subba Rao, C.J.) 67S.
"Where a benefit goes directly to reduce the expenses
of a worker on items of expenditure which are taken into
account for the calculation of the fair wage, it must necessarily be taken into account in fixing the actual fair wage
payable. Where however the benefit has no connection
with the items of expenditure on which the fair wage is
calculated it cannot naturally be taken into account."
To state it differently, only such of the items which go directly
to reduce the expenditure that would otherwise go into the family
bu<iget are relevant in fixing fair wages. The Tribunal has taken
all the permissible fringe benefits in fixing the wage scales and dearness allowances. It cannot therefore be said that the Tribunal
went wrong in omitting any amenities in fixing the wages.
The learned counsel took objection to the part of the award
where the Tribunal gave retrospective operation to it from !st
January, 1962. The reference of the dispute to the Tribunal was
made on 11-.8-1962. The first award was made on 8th October
1963. A Tribunal ordinarily makes its award operative from the
date of reference; but, in exceptional cir.cumstan~es it gives retroactive operation to some of its proposals. It will be seen from the
record that the original demand emanated as early as 6-2-1957,
but because of some technical difficulties, namely, whether the
Centrnl Government Authorities or the State Government Authorities were the appropriate authorities for entertaining the dispute
in conciliation proceediugs, the said proceedings took a long time
for reaching the stage of reference: Having regard to that fact
and also to the fact that the totality of the emoluments, particularly,
in the case of lower categories of manual, technical and clerical
staff were on the lower side in the company, the Tribunal in its
discretion came to the conclusion that the revised scales should
come into effect from !st January, 1962. We do not see any reason
to interfere with its discretion.
The next contention of the learned counsel for the Company
relates to the workmen in the "closed area". The Tribunal gave
the workmen an allowance of Rs. 5 per month from the date the
award became enforceable. While the workers say that to work
in the sections of closed area is a health hazard and reduces the lifespan, the Company admits that the workers functioning therein are
easily fatigued but states they are given the necessary safety equipment, food and rest. It is therefore common case that the work in
the 'closed area' involves a great physical strain on the workmen.
In the circumstances, when the Tribunal gave them a reasonable
allowance, it is not possible for this court to take a different view.
The learned counsel for the Company then argued that there is
a flagrant violation or departure from the accepted norms in fixing
the wage structure and the dearness allowance and therefore, as an
676
SUPRBMB COUllT :UPOlln
" (1967) I S.C.R.
exceptional case, we should set aside the award of the Tribunal
and direct it to re-fix the wages. He has also taken us through
comparative tables to satisfy us that the wages and the dearness
allowances fixed for the labour in the instant Company are abnonnally high compared with the other companies like Ruston and
Hornsby and Mahindra. The award discleses that the Tribunal
accepted the principles generally applied in fixing wages. It has
not been brought to our notice that any principle has been violated.
We have also scrutinised, with some care, the tabular statements
placed before us. It is true in some cases the total emoluments of a
particular category of employees of the Company is higher than those
of the other concerns, but the difference is not such as to be described as a flagrant violation of the fixation of the wage structure.
Almost always no Tribunal fixes nor can fix the wage structure to
reach the perfection point. If no principle is violated, this Court
will not interfere on the ground that it would have · fixed the wages
.at a lower level than the Tribunal did. We do not find any such
abnonnal variation of wages from those obtaining in other companies. We do not, therefore, think that this is such an exceptional
case as to call for a departure from our usual practice of not interfering with the award of the Tribunal in the fixation of wage structure.
Now, coming to the Cross Appeal, the first question is, what
is the status of a foreman in the industry in question. The defi·
nition of 'workman' in s. 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act ex·
eludes therefrom any person who is employed mainly in a managerial or administrative capacity or who being employed in a supervisory capacity, draws wages exceeding Rs. 500 per mensem. It
was contended that a foreman was a supervisor within the meaning
of the said definition and as, in the instant case, he was drawing less
than Rs. 500 per mensem, he would be a workman within the
meaning of the definition. The Tribunal held that he was not a
workman on the ground that his work was predominantly managerial and administrative in nature. It has come to that conclusion
on a consideration of the various duties allotted to the foreman.
The finding is one of fact and therefore must be accepted ..
The next question raised on behalf of the workmen relates to
the daily-rate workers. The Union demanded the following
scales of pay for daily-rate workmen:
"Unskilled
Skilled
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
Rs. 3 ·00--0 · 75-4 · 50
Rs. 4·50----1 ·00-6·50."
The Company claimed that the existing rates were adequate but the
Tribunal having regard to the rates of wages for casual workmen
in the concerns in the neighbourhood, increased the rates of male
aisual labour to Rs. 2 · 75 and the female casual labour to Rs. 2 · 25.
H
HINDUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS v. WORKMEN
A
(Subba Rao, C.l.) 677
It also directed that if any semi-skilled or skilled person was em-
ployed as casual work~r he should be paid at the rate of the monthly
wage and dearness allowance fixed for the particular category
divided by 26. The Tribunal having regard to the relevant circumstances, fixed the rates and we do not see any error or principle
in arriving at that figure. We accept the findings.
8
c
D
JI
G
H
The next' question is the fixation of the age of retirement for
the employees. The existing age of retirement is 55 extendable
to 60 years at the discretion of the management if the workmen
are considered suitable and if they are medically fit and mentally
alert. The Tribunal raised the age of retirement from 55 years to
58 years but gave a discretion to the Company to continue an employee after that age. The learned counsel for the workmen contended that the superannuation age fixed by the Tribunal does not
reflect the social changes that have tiiken place in the country and
has also ignored the judicial trend in that regard. Reliance is
placed upon the decision of this Court in G. M. Ta/ang v. Shaw
Wallace and Co.(1). Therein this Court held that the opinion
furnished by the several documents on record clearly showed a
consistent trend in the Bombay .region to fix the retirement age of
clerical and subordinate staff at 60 years. In the course of the
judgment, this Court noticed the Report of the Norms Committee
in which the following opinion was expressed:
"After taking into consideration the views of the earlier Committees and Commissions including those of the
Second Pay Commission the report of which has been
released recently we feel that the retirement age for workmen in all industries should be fixed at 60. Accordingly
the norm for retirement age is fixed at 60."
But it is said that the scope of the judgment was confined only
to the Bombay region and it should not be extended to the Poona
region. A perusal of the Tribunal's Award shows that it followed
the decision given by it in the dispute of Shaw Wallace & Co. Ltd.(')
which was reversed by this Court. That apart, the Tribunal also
recognised that the.retirement age should be raised from 55 years to
58 years and that even thereafter discretion should be given to the
employers to continue the employees or not to do so. This indicates that in the view of the Tribunal, the retirement age in the case of
the employees of the industry in question could reasonably ~e r~ed
beyond 58 years. We do not think it is proper to give a discretion
to the Company to raise the age of retirement or not to do so, for,
the vesting of such uncontrolled discretion in the employer might
lead to manipulation and victimisation. We would, therefore,
following the trend of judicial opinion, hold that the retirement age
of the employees of the Company should be raised to 60 years.
(I) [1964) 7 S C \l.. 424.
678
SUPRBIO OOUllT UPOllTS
[1967] I S.C.R.
On behalf of the workmen it was contended that the linkage
should be done with effect from January I, 1962. The Tribunal
pointed out that it had no intention of giving retrospective effect
to the linkage for the following reasons: (I) it had substantially
increased the wages; (2) a long retrospective effect would unduly
increase the burden on the Company; and (3) the workmen had been
getting handsome bonuses. But, having regard to the fact that the
Poona index figures had been published from April 1964, it held
that the linkage should be from April I, 1965 and not from the earlier date; that is to say, it had given, having regard to the aforesaid
circumstances, a limited retrospective operation to the linkage.
The employees have not made out any case for giving a further
retrospective effect to the linkage.
In the result, Civil Appeal No. 406 of 1964 preferred by the
Company is dismissed with costs; and Civil Appeal No. 407 of
1964 preferred by the Workmen is dismissed with costs, except that
the Award is modified in regard to the age of retirement.
G.C.
Appeals dismissed and award modified.
A
B
c
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org