EDWINGSON BAREH versus STATE OF ASSAM AND OTHERS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 29 November 1965 | [1966] 2 S.C.R. 770 | 1965 INSC 266
Key facts
- Decided
- 29 November 1965
- Bench
- P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR*, K.N. WANCHOO*, M. HIDAYATULLAH, V. RAMASWAMI, P. SATYANARAYANA RAJU
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 968/1965
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1966] 2 S.C.R. 770
- Neutral citation
- 1965 INSC 266
Text of the judgment
770
•
EDWINGSON BAREH
A
v.
'
STATE OF ASSAM AND OTHERS
November 29, 1965
(P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR, C.J., K. N. WANCHOO,
M. HIDAYATULLAH, V. RAMASWAMI AND P. SATYANARAYANA
RAJU, JJ.]
1950, VI Schedule, Para 1(3)-Scope of
Parliamentary legislation necessary . to. make
B
Constitution of India,
Governor's power-If
changes effective.
On 26th January 1950, the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills District was
formed as one of the Tribal Areas of Assam. The area along with other
Tribal Areas mentioned in Parts A and B of the Table appended to
paragraph 20 of the Sixth Schedule to the Constitution, are governed
by the provisions prescribed by that Schedule. Under Paragraph 2(4)
of the Schedule, the administration of the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills
District vested in the District Council inaugurated on 27th June 1952.
The appellant was elected as Chief Executive Member of the District
Council in March 1963, and by various notifications the term of the
District Council has been extended up to 2nd May 1965. On 26th
August 1963, the Governor of Assam appointed a Commission under
paragraph 14(1) to examine and report on the creation of a new autonomous district for the people of Jowai sub-division and for excluding it
from the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills District. The Commission made its
report for such creation and exclusion on 20th January 1964. The
Council of Ministers considered the ·report, decided to accept the recommendation, drew up an explanatory memorandum as required by
paragraph 14(2) of the Schedule and sent the entire file to the Governor
who noted on it "seen thanks". The Minister in charge, then laid the
report of the Commission and the explanatory memorandum, stating that
the Government had decided to accept the recommendation of the Governor on the report, before the Assembly. and the Assembly passed a
resolution approving the action proposed. On 23rd November 1964,
the Governor issued a Notification by which the new autonomous district was created and was excluded from the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills
District with effect from !st December 1964. The appellant challenged
the Notification by a petition for the issue of a writ in the High Court.,
which was dismissed.
In appeal to this Court, it was contended that : (i) Paragraph 1 (3)
of the Schedule does not confer upon the Governor power to constitute
a new autonomous district and that it could be done only by Parliamenta:ry legislation under Paragraph 21 of the Schedule under which powers
are granted to Parliament to amend the Schedule and ev~n if he had
the power, the. Governor's decision must be confirm•ed by Par1iamentary
legislatiofl; and (ii) the Notification was invalid because the mandatory
provisions of paragraph 14 had not been complied with.
HELD (Per Chief Justice, Wanchoo, Ramaswami and Satyanarayana
Raju, JJ.) : (i) When paragraph 1(3) (c) provides that the Governor
may, by public notification, create a new autonomous districts; it does not
contemplate, that the Constitution requires something more to be done
by Parliament, in order to make the notification effective. [782 A]
c
D
•
E
•
F
G
H
•
EDWJNGSON v. ASSAM
A
771
Paragraph 1 ( 3) confers on the Governor power to issue a notification for the purposes of bringing about any of the results enumerated
by els. (a) to (g) of the paragraph. Clause (c) refers to the power of
Governor to create a new autonomous district; cl. ( e) refers to the power
·'
r
•
to diminish the area of any autonomous district, and cl. (g) refers to the
power to define the boundaries of any autonomous district. The proviso
to the paragraph imposes a condition on the exercise of the powers conferred by els. ( c) to ( f) by requiring the Governor before exercising the
B powers to appoint a Commission under Paragraph 14(1) to report on
those matters and then to consider its report. Paragraph 1 ( 3) indicates
that the Constitution has delegated to the Governor a part of the power
conferred on Parliament itself by paragraph 21. If the Governor has
been clothed with the rele,vant power, the exercise of the power must by
itself, be effective to bring about the results intended by els. (c) to (f)
of paragraph 1 (3). The power must be exercised subject to the
prescribed by the proviso, but once it is properly exercised it
c condition
becomes effective and there is no need for parliamentary legislafon in that
behalf. [780 H; 781 A-B, C-D; 782 B, C-DJ
The two Acts, namely Act 18 of 1954 and Act 42 of 1957, one for
renaming a District and the other for excluding an item from Part A
and including it in Part B, do not show any legislative practice requiring
parliamentary legislation with respect to the matters covered by the
Notification. [782 G; 783 DJ
D
It is not necessary that for an effective exercise of his power by the
Governor there should be confirmation by Parliamentary legislation,
because, the power of Parliament under paragraph 21 is very wide and
includes the power to take away the Governor's power, and in the very
unlikely event of the Governor attempting to challenge the decision of
Parliament in respect of any of the matters mentioned in Paragraph 1(3),
Parl'amcnt can take away his power altogether by suitable legislation.
.
E [783 FJ
The modification made by the impugned Notification does not affect
the contents of paragraph 20( 1), because, even after the Notification the
paragraph truly and correctly provides that the areas specified in Parts
A and B of the table shall be tribal areas within the State. What the
Notification purports to do is to change one item into two. Since the
power to bring about the change is expressly conferred on the Governor
by paragraph 1(3)(c) to (g), the exercise of that power, which leads to
F a consequential change in paragraph 20(2) which just gives a discription
of the areas, does not require Parliamentary legislation to make the
change effective. Therefore, it would not be reasonable to hold that
without Parliamentary legislation the impugned Notification cannot validly effect any change in item 1 of Part A of the table appended to
paragraph 20. [784 C-E, H; 786 B, OJ
(ii) The power conferred on the Governor by paragraph 1(3) had
been
validly and properly exercised by him.
G
One of the conditions prescribed by paragraph 14 i• that the Qovernor should consider the report submitted by the Commission and make
his recommendations. Even if the Governor was expected to apply his
mind and make a recommendation., he is not precluded from receiving
the msistance of the Council of Ministers before he makes up his mind,
and. on the record it must be held that the Commission recommended
that a new autonomous district should be created and that the Governor
H agreed with the recommendation. [789 F; 790 BJ
Though the Commission appointed under paragraph.
14
used
the
\vords "District Council" on con.5idering its recommendations as a whole
772
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
A
there is no doubt that what it recommended was the creation of a new
autonomous district. [787 F-0]
Per Hidayatullah, J. (dissenting) : No action could be effective with·
out Parliamentary legislation under Paragraph 21 to amend the opera·
tive portion of paragraph 20 which Parliament alone can amend, Further,
the Governor, far from playing the key role which the policy underlying
the Schedule envisages, left the entire matter to the Government.
(i) When the final step is taken to divide a tribal area it amends the
Sixth Schedule. Paragraph 1(3) says nothing about the amendment of
paragraph 20, and the Governor has no power under els. (c), (d) and
(e) to amend the paragraph or the Table appended to it. A power to
amend paragraph 20 and an amendment of the paragraph and the table
cannot be implied, in view of paragraph 21, under which powers are
granted to Parliament to amend the Schedule. Even if it is not an
amendment for purposes of Art. 368, the amendment cannot be such a
simple affair that a Notification of the Governor amends the provisions
by implication. If the Notification alone did that there would be
antinomy between the Notification and the Schedule. Paragraph 20 and
the Table will remain unaltered and the Notification will render them
obsolete. Therefore, to complete the chain of steps the power under
paragraph 21 must be exercised to alter the autonomous districts" the
names and areas of which are laid down by Parliament. The Governor's
Notification is one of the means of achieving the change but effectiveness can only be given by Parliament as it was done on previous occasions when Act 18 of 1954 and Act 42 of 1957 were passed. There ii
no material as to what the practice or procedure was that was followed
when changes were made in the tribal areas, except that on previous
occasions Parliamentary legislation was undertaken, and while it is not
conclusive, it is a circumstance which also points in the direction
•
B
c
D
•
that
Parliamentary legislation must cap all other steps if the Schedule is to
read true to the new situation. [803 C,F-H; 804 F-H; 813 PIH]
(ii) The history of these hackward tracts and the scheme of the
Sixth Schedule show that the Governor is intended to discharge opecial
functions in the administration of the tribal areas in Assam in which a
start in democratic institution is being made. In the present case the
Governor was very much in the background and the initiation and
formation of opinion was by the State Government. He was only informed after everything was over. [810 F; 813 E]
The functions of the Governor are not made subject to the scrutiny
of the Government of Assam, and the Union also has not been given the
power to give directions as to the administration of these autonomous
districts. The Governor is expected to act independently and not with
the advice of Ministers. Should difference arise between them the legislature would decide. Under paragraph 14(2) there is provision for the
appointment of Commissions for various purposes mentioned in that
paragraph and paragraph 16.
As regards the changes in autonomous
districts contemplated by paragraph 1(3)(c) to (f), if the State Government agreed with the Governor there would be no need to explain
what action the Government was going to take; it has only to implement
the decision administratively and the Governor would notify the changeo.
The need for an explanatory memorandum arises if the Governor'• recommendations are not accepted by the State Government. Apart from
this control by the Legislature in specified matters, there is nothing to
show that in addition the District and Regional Councils, which are
autonomous in almost every way, are to be controlled by the Council of
E
,.
F
G
'
H
•
EDWINGSON V. ASSAM (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
773
I
A
Ministers through the Governor. The Governor's note hardly squared
with the special responsibilities contemplated by the Schedule. [805 D-E;
810 G; 811 B, D-0; 812 A, F]
Even in the Commission's recommendation there was some confusion, though it may be conceded that when reference was made to a
council, an autonomous district was meant. [813 DJ
B
C1v1L APPELLATE JuRtsmcnoN : Civil Appeal No. 968 of
1965.
Appeal from the judgment and order dated February 5, 1965
of the Assam and Nagaland High Court in Civil Rule No. 286 of
1964.
c
•
'
C. K. Daphtary, Attorney-General, and Naunit Lal, for the
respondents.
The Judgment of GAJENDRAGADKAR, C.J., WANCHOO,
RAMASWAMI AND RAJU, JJ. was delivered by GAJENDRAGADKAR,
C.J. HIDAYATULLAH, J. delivered a dissenting Opinion.
\)
Gajendragadkar, C.J. The appellant, Edwingson Bareh,
belongs to the village of Barato in Jowai area of the United
Khasi-Jaintia Hills District in Assam. He is an elector from the
said area to the District Council of the said United Khasi-Jaintia
Hills District. In fact, he was elected as a member to the said
E District Council from Nongjngi Constituency (No. 23). This
constituency fell within the Jowai area of the said District. Later,
the appellant was elected as Chief Executive Member of the
District Council in March, 1963. By virtue of his office, he
draws a monthly salary and other allowances under the provisions
of the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills District Council Chairman's,
F Deputy Chairman's and Executive Member's Salaries and Allowances Act, 1953. He is entitled to hold the said office till a new
District Council is elected and takes over.
G
•
'
M. C. Setalvad, and D. N. Mukherjee, for the appellant.
II
On the 26th January, 1950, when the Constitution came into
force, the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills District was formed as one
of the Tribal Areas of Assam, and in this area were merged the
Khasi States with the other areas of the Khasi-Jaintia Hills. The
boundaries of this area are defined by paragraph 20(2) of the
Sixth Schedule to the Constitution. All . the Tribal Areas
mentioned in Part A and Part B of the Table appended to paragraph 20 of the Sixth Schedule are governed by the provisions
prescribed by the Sixth Schedule.
Under paragraph 2(4) of the said Schedule, the administration
of the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills District vested in the District
774
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
Council which was inaugurated on the 27th June, 1952. This
Council consists of 24 different constituencies out of which 6 are
in the Jaintia Hills area. The District Council has been clothed
with administrative, legislative and judicial powers over the territory of the District by the relevant provisions of the Sixth
Schedule. By the notification issued on the l st of June, 1964,
No. TAD/R/8/62, the term of the present District Council was
extended up to the 2nd January, 1965, or until the newly elected
District Council takes over. By a subsequent notification issued
in December, 1964, No. TAD/R/8/62, the period of the said
Council was further extended from 3rd January, 1965 to the 2nd
May, 1965. Under the present administration set up, the Executive Committee of the District Council consists of three members
including the Chief Executive Member and two other members,
and all the executive functions of the said Council are vested in
the Executive Committee.
Purporting to act on certain representations received by him,
the Governor of Assam appointed a Commission under paragraph 14(1) of the Sixth Schedule on the 26th August, 1963.
This Commission was required "to examine and report in the
matter of, ( 1) creation of a new autonomous District for the
people of Jowai Sub-Division of the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills
Autonomous District, and (2) exclusion of the area from the
United Khasi-Jaintia Hills Autonomous District." The Commission made its report on the 20th January, 1964 and recommended
"'the creation of a new autonomous District Council for the Jowai
Sub-Division of the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills Autonomous District by excluding the areas comprising the area of the said SnbDivision from the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills Autonomous
District."
Thereafter, the Minister-in-charge of the Tribal Areas and
Welfare of Backward Classes Department of the Government of
Assam laid before the Assam Legislative Assembly during its
autumn session of 1964 the report of the Commission with an
-explanatory memorandum made on the 25th September, 1964.
This memorandum stated that the Government had decided to
pccept the recommendation of the Governor on the said report
.and give effect to it.
After the report was thus placed before the Legislative
Assembly, the Assembly passed a resolution approving of the
action proposed to be taken by the Government of Assam on
the report in question. On the 23rd November, 1964, a notification No. TAD/R/50/64 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Notifica-
•
A
'
B
c
D
E
fa
F
G
H
EDWINGSON V. ASSAM
(Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
77 5
tion') was issued by the Governor of Assam in accordance with
the memorandum which had been placed before the Legislative
Assembly of Assam. By this notification, the Governor of Assam
was pleased "to create a new Autonomous District to be called
the Jowai District by excluding the Jowai Sub-Division of the
United Khasi-Jaintia Hills District with effect from 1st December,
B 1964; and that the boundaries of the Jowai District shall be the
boundaries of the Jowai Sub-Division of the United Khasi-Jaintia
Hills District."
A
.,
•
The appellant challenged the constitutional validity of this
notification by filing a writ petition before the High Court of
c Assam and Nagaland on the 30th November, 1964. In his
writ petition, the appellant alleged that the notification was invalid
and ultra vires the powers of the Governor. Alternatively, it was
urged that in exercising his powers, the Governor has contravened
the mandatory requirements prescribed by paragraph 14 of the
Sixth Schedule to the Constitution. The appellant's case was
D that even if it was assumed that the Governor had the power to
issue the impugned notification, inasmuch as the mandatory provisions of paragraph 14 had not been complied with, the notification was invalid. To this petition, the appellant impleaded five
respondents; the first amongst them was the State of Assam; the
ethers were : the Minister-in-charge of Tribal Areas and Welfare
E of Backward Classes Department; the Secretary to the Government of Assam, T.A., O.B. & W.B.C. Department; the Chief
Secretary to the Government of Assam; and the Deputy Secretary
to the Government of Assam, Tribal Areas & Backward Classes
Department, respectively.
F
G
... "
ii.
""'.,..·
I
H
The respondents disputed the validity of the contentions raised
by the appellant in his writ petition. They urged that the notification had been issued by the Governor in exercise of the powers
conferred on him by paragraph 1(3) of the Sixth Schedule and
that all the relevant requirements of paragraph 14 had been complied with. The respondents did not accept the correctness of
the appellant's argument that in issuing the notification, the
Governor had acted outside his authority.
Since the point raised by the petition was of considerable
importance, and related to the construction of the relevant provisions contained in the Sixth Schedule, the writ petition ·was
placed for hearing before a special Bench of the Assam High
Coµrt consisting of three learned Judges. After the writ petition
was argued, the High Court, by a majority decision, has rejected
the contentions raised by the appellant and has dismissed the writ
LUup.CJ/66-3
776
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
petition filed by him. The minority judgment has upheld the
arguments of the appellant and has held that the impugned notification is invalid. After the decision of the High Court was
pronounced, the appellant applied for and obtained a certificate
under Art. 132 of •the Constitution, and it is with the said certificate that he has come to this Court in the present appeal.
On behalf of the appellant,. Mr. Setalvad argues that paragraph 1(3) of the Sixth Schedule does not confer on the Governor
the power to constitute a new autonomous district. For the valid
creation of a new autonomous district, parliamentary legislation
is necessary. In supoort of this plea, Mr. Setalvad has relied on
what he describes as "legislative practice" in that behalf. He
further contends that even if the Governor had the power to
· create new autonomous district under paragraph 1(3), the exercise
of that power c'in be effective only after Parliament passes a law
in accordance with the decision of the Governor. In other words,
the argument is that the Governor may, by virtue of his power,
decide to create a new autonomous district under paragraph 1(3),
but the decision of the Governor must be confirmed by parliamentary legislation before it becomes effective. In the alternative, Mr. Sctalvad co.ntends that even if the Governor can effectively create a new autonomous district by virtue of his powers
under paragraph 1(3), he can do so only after complying with
the mandatory provisions of paragraph 14; and since these provisions have not been complied with, the impugned notification
is invalid.
...
:"-
•
"~··-"
A
,.
·~·
B
C
D
..
E
Before dealing with these .points, it would be convenient to
refer broadly to the scheme of the Sixth Schedule which contains
the provisions in relation to the administration of tribal areas in F
A~sam. Article 24M 2) provides that the provisions of the Sixth
Schedule shall apply to the administration of the tribal areas in
the State of Assam; and that means that tribal areas in Assam
would be governed not by the other relevant provisions of the
Constitution which apply to the other constituent States of the
Union of India, but by the provisions contained in the Sixth G
Schedule. These provisions purport to provide for a selfcontained code for the governance of the tribal areas forming
part of Assam and they deal with all the relevant topics in that
behalf. The areas described in the table appended to paragraph 20 of the Sixth Schedule, consisting of Part A and Part B,
constitute the tribal areas within the State of Assam; sub-para- H
graph (1) of the said paragraph so provides. Sub-paragraphs (2),
(2A), (2B) and (3) of paragraph 20 describe the boundaries of the
...
't
ji·
;±.;
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM
--
(Gajendtagadkar, C./.)
777
A items mentioned in the Table. Part A of the table originally
consisted of six items; the first amongst them was the United
Khasi-Jaintia Hills District. The item of 'The Naga HillsDistrict' which was originally included in Part A has been subsequently taken out of Part A and has been added to Part B.
Part B which originally consisted of only one item, now consists
B of two items; the first item is North East Frontier Tract including other Tracts therein described; and the second is the 'Naga
Hills-Tuensang Area'. Thus, paragraph 20 read with the Table
gives a comprehensive description of the tribal areas falling within
the State of Assam for whose administration provision is made
by the other paragraphs of the Sixth Schedule.
c
Paragraph 1 of the Sixth Schedule deals with autonomous
districts and autonomous regions and confers certain specified
powers on the Governor. It is necessary to read this paragraph : D
E
F
"1. (1) Subject to the provisions of this paragraph,
the tribal areas in each item of Part A of the table
appended to paragraph ZO of this Schedule shall be an
autonomous district.
(2) If there are different Scheduled Tribes in an
autonomous district, the Governor may, by public notification, divide the area or areas inhabited by them into
autonomous regions.
(3) The Governor may, by public notification : (a) include any area in Part A of the said table,
(b) exclude any area from Part A of the said table,
(c) create a new autonomous district,
(d) increase the area of any autonomous district,
(e) diminish the area of any autonomous district,
(f) unite two or more autonomous districts or parts
G
thereof so as to form one autonomous district,
(g) define the boundaries of any autonomous
district :
H
.Provided that no order shall be made by the
Gove_rnor under clauses (c), (d), (e) & (f) of this subparagraph except after consideration of the report of
a Commission appointed under sub-paragraph (1) of
paragraph 14 of this Schedule."
778
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
Then follow several paragraphs dealing with the constitution of A
District Councils and Regional Councils; their powers to make
laws; the administration of justice in autonomous districts and
autonomous regions; conferment of powers under the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908, and the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898,
on the Regional and District Councils and on certain courts and
officers for the trial of certain suits, cases and offences; these are B
covered by paragraphs 2, 3, 4 and 5 respectively. Paragraph 6
deals with the powers of the District Council to establish Primary
Schools, etc. Paragraph 7 deals with the District and Regional
Funds; paragraph 8 refers to powers to assess and collect land
revenue and to impose taxes. Para. 9 has relation to licences or
leases for the purpose of prospecting for, or extraction of, minerals. C
Para. 10 confers on the District Council power to make regulations for the control of money-lending and trading by nontribals. Paragraphs 11 & 12 deal with the publication of laws,
rules and regulations made under the Schedule; and the application of Acts of Parliament and of the Legislature of the State to
autonomous districts and autonomous regions· respectively. Para- D
graph 13 is concerned with the question of estimated receipts and
· expenditure pertaining to autonomous districts which have to be
shown separately in the annual financial statement. Paragraph 14
is concerned with the appointment of a Commission and for the
purpose of the present appeal, it is necessary to read it :
E
"(1) The Governor may at any time appoint a
Commission to examine and report on any matter specified by him relating to the administration of the autonomous districts and autonomous regions in the State,
including matters specified in clauses (c), (d), (e) and (0
of sub-paragraph (3) of paragraph 1 of this Schedule
or may appoint a Commission to inquire into and report
from time to time on the administration of autonomous
districts and autonomous regions in the State generally
and in particular on-
(a) the provision of edocational and medical facilities and communications in such districts and regions;
(b) the need for any new or special legislation in
respect of such districts and regions; and
(c) the administration of the laws, rules and regulations made by the District and Regional Courtcils;
and define the procedure to be followed by such Commission.
•
F
G
H
•
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM
...,..,
A
y
(Gajendragadkar, CJ.)
779
(2) The report of every such Commission with the
recommendations of the Governor with respect thereto
shall be laid before the Legislature of the State by the
Minister concerned together with an explanatory memorandum regarding the action proposed to be taken
thereon by the Government of Assam.
B
(3) In allocating the business of the Government
of the State among his Ministers the Governor may
place one of his Ministers specially in charge of the
welfare of the autonomous districts and autonomous
regions in the State."
c
Paragraph 15 deals with the annulment or suspension of acts and
resolutions of District and Regional Councils. Paragraph 16
deals with the dissolution of a District or a Regional Council;
paragraph 17 is concerned with the exclusion of areas from autonomous districts in forming constituencies in such districts.
Paragraph 18 is concerned with the application of the provisions
of this Schedule to areas specified in Part B of the table appended
to paragraph 20; while paragraph 19 deals wiih the transitional
provisions. Paragraph 21 which is the last paragraph in the
Sixth Schedule, is relevant for our purpose; it reads thus : -
D
E
"(!) Parliament may from time to time by law
amend by way of addition, variation or repeal any of
the provisions of this Schedule and, when the Schedule
is so amended, any reference to this Schedule in this
Constitution shall be construed as a reference to such
·Schedule as so amended.
(2) No such law as is mentioned in sub-paragraph
F
(1) of this paragraph shall be deemed to be an amend-
ment of this Constitution for the purposes of Article
368."
That, broadly stated, is the scheme of the provisions contained
in the Sixth Schedule.
G
H
It is plain that under paragraph· 21, Parliament can make a
law amending by way of addition, variation or repeal any of
the provisions of the Sixth Schedule and when such an amendment is made, reference to the Sixth Schedule in the Constitution
shall naturally be construed as a reference to such Schedule as
so amended. In other words, Parliament is clothed with legislative competence of the widest amplitude in relation to any changes
it likes to make in any of the provisions contained in the Sixth
Schedule. Paragraph 21 (2) has provided that any changes
780
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
(1966] 2 S.C.R.
soug)lt to be introduced by parliamentary legislation under the A
power conferred on Parliament by sub-paragraph (1) thereof shall
not be deemed to amount to an amendment of the Constitution
for the purposes of Art. 368. There can thus be no doubt that
if Parliament wants to make any changes in any provisions of the
Sixth Schedule, it is entitled to do so; and that obviously means
that the change which has·been introduced by the impugned noti- B
fication might as well have been made by Parliament. The
question which calls for our decision is : can the same change be
validly introduced by the Governor in exercise of the powers conferred on him by paragraph 1(3) or not?
We have already noticed that the effect of paragraph 20 read C
with the table appended to it is that the areas specified in Part A
and Part B of the said table amount to tribal areas within the
State of Assam. Now, paragraph 1(1) of the Sixth Schedule provides that the tribal areas in each item of Part A of the table
appended to paragraph 20 shall be an autonomous district, subject
to the provisions of paragraph 1. '.(his provision is clear in two D
respects. It does not cover the areas specified in Part B of the
table; its application is confined to the areas in each item of
Part A of the table alone. It is also clear that the tribal areas
in each item of Part A aforesaid shall be an autonomous district, ·
but that would be so subject to the provisions of paragraph 1.
In other words, if any changes are made by the Governor in E
exercise of the powers conferred on him by paragraph 1(3 ), those
changes will have to be read into the relevant item in Part A
of the table, and paragraph 20 will have to be considered in the
light of the changes thus introduced in the said item. What is
the extent of the power conferred on the Governor by paragraph
1(3) and how it can be exercised, are matters to which we will F
turn presently; but confining ourselves to the provisions of
para 1 ( 1), it seems clear that the exercise of the powers prescribed by para 1 ( 3) has an impact on the description of the items
in Part A of the table appended to para 20; and that impact is
that the changes made in the description of the items will be G
introduced in Part 9 and thereby the scope and effect of para 20
will, in consequence, be suitably modified.
Paragraph 1(3) confers on the Governor power to issue notification for the purpose of bringing about any of the results
enumerated seriatim by clauses (a) to (g). In the present case,
we are not called upon to consider what clauses (a) and (b) really
<lenote. The notification with which we are concerned is referable to clauses (c), (e) and (g). Clause (c) refers to the power
H
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM (Gajendragadkar,
A
B
c
D
E
c. J.)
781
to create a new autonomous district, and this power has been
exercised by the Governor in creating a new autonomous district
to be called the Jowai District. Clause (e) refers to the power
to diminish the area of any autonomous district, and this power
has been exercised by the Governor by diminishing the area of
the pre-existing United Khasi-Jaintia Hills Disrict. Clause (g)
refers to the power to define the boundaries of any autonomous
district, and this power has, in substance, been exercised by the
Governor inasmuch as after the creation of the new Jowai
District, the boundaries of the pre-existing United Khasi-Jaintia
Hills District, as well as the boundaries of the newly created
District are automatically defined. Similar power can be exercised
under dauses (d) and (f).
The proviso to para 1 ( 3) imposes a condition on the exerci•e
of the power prescribed by clauses ( c), ( d), ( e) and ( f) of para
1(3). It requires that before the Governor exercises his power
under any of the said four clauses, he has to appoint a Commission under para. 14(1) and consider its report. The reason
why the condition prescribed by the proviso is not made applicable to cases falling under clause (g) can be easily understood;
the power conferred by the said clause appears, in the context,
to be· merely consequential on the powers prescribed by the previous four clauses. It is, however, not quite clear why the exercise
of the power conferred by clauses (a) and (b) has not been made
subject to the condition prescribed by the proviso; but, as we
have already indicated, we are really not called upon to consider
that aspect of the matter.
Now, reading para 1(3) by itself, it seems difficult to appreciate Mr. Setalvad's argument that though the Governor may
have the power to create a new autonomous district, the notification that he may issue in exercise of the said power, will not take
effect unless Parliament by law provides for the creation of the
said new district. It is true that the said power has to be exercised
subject to the condition prescribed by the proviso to para 1 ( 3).
G But if the said condition is satisfied, and the requirements prescribed by para 14 are complied with, is there anything in the
provisions of para 1 as well as para 14 which would justify the
argument that the exercise of the relevant powers is not intended
to be effective unless it receives the approval of parliamentary
legislation ? In our opinion, this question cannot be answered
H
in favour of the appellant. When clause (c) of paragraph 1(3)
provides that the Governor may, by public notification, create a
new autonomous district, it does not seem to contemplate that for
F
SUPREME
782
COURT
(1966] 2 S.C:R.
REPORTS
the creation of a new autonomous district, the Constitution A
requires something more to be done by Parliament itself in order
to make the public notification issued by the Governor effective.
In our view, paragraph 1(3) clearly indicates that the Constitution has delegated to the Governor a part of the power conferred
on Parliament itself by paragraph 21. Paragraph 21 shows that
Parliament has undoubtedly the power to make any change in B
any of the provisions contained in the Sixth Schedule. A part of
this wide power has, however, been conferred on the Governor,
because the Constitution-makers apparently thought tha~ Parliament need not be called upon to exercise its own power for bringing about comparatively smaller and minor changes in Part A
of the Table, and it accordingly decided to confer the appropriate C
power on the Governor to take action in that behalf. If the
Governor has been clothed with the relevant power, the exercise
. of the power must, by itself, be effective to bring about the results
intended by clauses (c), (d), (e) and (f) of para 1(3). This
power must, no doubt, be exercised subject to the condition D
prescribed by the proviso to para 1 ( 3). But once it is properly
exercised as required by the relevant provisions of the Sixth
·Schedule, it becomes effective and there is no need for parliamentary legislation in that behalf.
•
In support of his contention that Parliament has legislated in
respect of matters falling under para 1(3 ). Mr. Setalvad has E
referred us to two parliamentary statutes. The first one is Act
No. 18 of 1954. This Act was passed by Parliament on the
29th April, 1954 to change the name of the Lushai Hills District.
.Section 2 of this Act provides that the tribal area in Assam now
known as the Lushai Hills District shall, as from the commencement of this Act, be known as the Mizo District. Section 3 made F
a corresponding change in paragraph 20 of the Sixth Schedule
and in Part A of the table appended thereto. It is doubtful if the
power exercised by Parliament in re-naming a District by passing
Act 18 of 1954 is covered by any of the clauses of para 1 (3);
but even if it was, the exercise of the said power by Parliament G
cannot show that the same power, if delegated to the Governor,
cannot be exercised by him without the assistance of parliamentary
legislation in that behalf. This Act, therefore, is not at all decisive on. the point raised by Mr. Setalvad.
The other Act on which Mr. Setalvad relies is Act No. 42 of
1957. This Act was passed by Parliament on the 29th November, 1957. Section 3 of this Act omitted item 4-'Naga Hills
District' from Part A of the table appended to para 20 of the
.
-
H
-
~
EDWINGSON .v. ASSAM
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
(Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
783
Sixth Schedule; and substituted "The Naga-Hills-Tuensang
Area" as item 2 in Part B of the said table; and made the
necessary change in para 20. Wha~ we have said about Act
No. 18 of 1954 is equally true about this Act also. It is doubtful whether excluding an item from Part A and including it in
Part B would fall within any of the clauses prescribed by para.
1 ( 3) ; but even if it is so, the fact that Parliament exercises its
legislative power in regard to an item delegated to the Governor
will not show that the Governor does not possess that power.
Therefore, Mr. Setalvad's argument based upon what he calls
"legislative practice" does not really assist him.
Incidentally, Mr. Setalvad suggested that it would be anomalous to hold that the power conferred on the Governor by para
I (3) of the Sixth Schedule can be effectively exercised by him
without confirmation by parliamentary fegislation. He illustrates this point by taking a case where the Governor decides to
exercise his powers under para. 1(3) and issues a public notification accordingly. If Parliament does not approve of the said
decision, it may make a law reversing the decision in question;
and the Governor may adher~ to his earlier decision and issue
another public notification. Such a course of events, says
Mr. Setalvad, would lead to a very anomalous situation; and the
anomaly can be avoided by holding that the exercise of the
Governor's power under para. 1(3) has to be confirmed by parliamentary legislation under para. 21 before it becomes effective.
·We are not impressed by this argument. As we have already
observed, the power of Parliament under paragraph 21 is very
wide; it includes the power to modify or take away the power
conferred on the Governor by para. 1(3), and in the very unlikely
event of the Governor attempting to challenge the decision of
Parliament, Parliament can take away his power altogether by
suitable legislation. We have no doubt that the argument based
on a possible anomaly overlooks the fact that such an anomaly
can inherently be said to exist wherever the same power is vested
in two alternative authorities. That being so, the argument of
possible anomalies does not assist Mr. Setalvad's contention that
parliamentary legislation is necessary before the Governor's
decision becomes effective.
Before we part with this topic, it is necessary to refer to
another aspect of the problem which has relation to paragraph 20
of the Sixth Schedule. We have already observed that the
exercise of the powers prescribed by paragraph 1(3) has an impact
on the description of the items in Part A of the Table appended
to para 20, and we have also indicated that the said impact is
784
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
that the changes made in the description of the items will be
introduced in Part A and thereby the scope and effect of para 20
will, in consequence, be suitably modified. It is now necessary
to consider the nature of the modifications which may be made
in paragraph 20 and their impact on the question as to whether
parliamentary legislation is necessary to make the impugned
notification effective.
Paragraph 20(1) provides that the areas specified in Pans A
and B of the table shall be the tribal areas within the State of
Assam. The impugned notification has made a change in the
composition of the United Khasi-J aintia Hills District by carving
out of the said item in Part A of the table two separate items, viz.,
the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills District, and the Jowai District. It
is, however, clear that this change does not make any addition
to or subtractioii from, the total area covered by Part A of the
table, and in that sense, the modification made by the Governor
by the impugned notification does not affect in any manner the
contents of para 20 (1). Even after the said notification has
come into force, para 20( 1) truly and correctly provides that the
areas specified in Part A and B of the table shall be the tribal
areas within the State of Assam.
It cannot, however, be disputed that as a result of the
modification made by the impugned notification, paragraph 20(2)
has to be changed. Paragraph 20(2), as it originally stood,
describes in detail the territories comprised in the United KhasiJaintia Hills District, and as a result of the impugned notification,
the said description will have to be modified, becau~e the said
District has now been spli~ up into two Autonomous Districts.
That, however, is a change consequent upon the change made
by the Governor by issuing the impugned notification in exercise
of the powers conferred on him by para 1 (3 ). In our opinion,
where the Governor makes changes by virtue of the powers conferred on him by para. 1(3)(c), (d), (e), (f) and (g), what follows
is a change in the internal composition of the different iiems in
Part A of the table. The exercise of the said powers does not
change, and in the present case it has not changed, the total
area comprised in Part A. What it purports to do is to change
one item into two items of Autonomous Districts. Since the
power to bring about this change is expressly conferred on the
Governor by paragraph 1(3)(c), (d), (e), (f) and (g), it is not
unreasonable to hold that the exercise of the said power should,
as in the present case, lead to a consequential change in para
20(2). Such a change in para 20(2) is a logical corollary of
A
B
"""'
C
D
•
E
·"
F
G
H
EDWINGSON V. ASSAM (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
785
A the exercise of the power conferred on the Governor by para
1(3)(c}, (d}, (e), (f) and (g).
•
It is possible that by the exercise of the powers conferred on
the Governor by paragraph 1(3)(a) and (b), the area included in
Part A of the table may conceivably be either increased or dimiB nished, because the powers conferred on the Governor by para
1 ( 3 )(a) and (b), prima facie, refer to the inclusion of any area
in Part A, or exclusion of any area from Part A of the table.
We have not thought it necessary to consider or decide what is
the nature of the power prescribed by para. 1(3)(a) or (b). If
the power prescribed by para. 1(3)(a) or (b) is construed in a
C narrow way in the light of the context of para. 1(3) and is con, fined to making changes either by inclusion or exclusion in regard
to areas already included in Part A, the total area of Part A may
not be altered even by the exercise of such power.
D
•
1
E
F
G_
H
But assuming that the exercise of the said power would enable
the Governor to add to the area included in Part A of the table,
or to diminish the area included in the said Part by excluding
it from the said Part, a question may arise as to the effect of
such modification. In such a case, paragraph 20(1) itself may
be affected, and if that happens, it would become necessary to
enquire whether the exercise of the Governor's power prescribed
by para. 1(3)(a) or (b) can, without parliamentary legislation,
validly make a change in para. 20(1). In dealing with this
question, different considerations would arise. If an addition
is made to the area covered by Part A of the table by including
in it some outside area, or if a portion of the area included in
the said Part is taken out, it would alter the content and complexion of the table considered as a whole, and the question
about the necessity of parliamentary legislation to make such a
change effective may assume a different aspect. Including any
area in Part A, or excluding any area from Part A in the wide
sense of the terms used in the said two clauses may, prima facie,
import consideraiions of general policy which, it may be urged,
·can be effectively dealt with only by parliamentary legislation;
such considerations do not apply where the exercise of the powers
conferred on the Governor by para. 1(3)(c), (d), (e), (f) and (g)
means nothing more than permutation and combination of the
areas already included in Part A, and that is purely a matter of
internal administration. We are, however, not concerned with
the aspect of the problem relating to para. 1(3)(a) and (b) in the
present case, and need not, therefore, pronounce any opinion on
it.
786
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 s.c.R.
What has happened in this case is that one Autonomous A
District has been split up into two separate Autonomous Districts
without making any change in the totality of the area included
in Part A of the table; and that does not bring about any change
in para 20(1). Paragraph 20(2), however, stands on a different
footing; it just gives a description of the area included in the
United Khasi-Jaintia Hills District, and the change made in the B
said description by the impugned notification is of such a purely
consequential character in relation to the internal adjustment of
the areas mentioned in Part A of the table that we do not think
parliamentary legislation is required to make such a change effective. Therefore, we are satisfied that it would not be reasonable
to hold that without parliamentary legislation, the impugned noti-· C
fication cannot validly effect any change in item I of Part A of
the table appended to paragraph 20.
In this connection, we may incidentally refer to the provisions
of paragraph 18 which deals with the problem of the application
of the provisions of the Sixth Schedule to areas specified in Part B D
of the table appended to para. 20. Para. 18(1 )(b) provides that
the Governor may, with the previous approval of the President,
by public notification, exclude from the said table any tribal area
specified in Part B of that table or any part of such area. This
shows that where any area from Part B of the table has to be
excluded from it, it can be done by the Governor with the pre- E
vious approval of the President. Action taken by the Governor
in exercise of this power may conceivably fall under paragraph
1(3)(a), and in that sense, theJ inclusion of the area in Part A
of the table would, in substance, be the result of the decision
of the President. It is significant that paragraph 18(3) specifi- F
cally provides that in the discharge of his functions under subparagraph (2) of this paragraph as the agent of the President,
the Governor shall act in his discretion. Thus, 1t is clear that
paragraph 18 deals with the areas in Part B of the table independently, and ii\ respect of them, the Governor functions as
the agent of the President when he exercises his power under G
sub-paragraph (2) of the said paragraph.
That takes us to the question as to whether Mr. Setalvad is
right in contending that the notification is invalid, because before
issuing it, the mandatory requirements of paragraph 14 have not
been complied with. Wha~ then are the requirements of para 14 '!
The first requirement is that before taking any action in exercise
of the powers conferred on him by clauses (c), (d), (e) and (0
of para. I (3), the Governor inust appoint a Commission to
~
I
'
t "'
H
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM
•
-
787
A examine and report on any matter covered by the said clauses.
The second requirement is that the Governor should consider the
report made by the Commission and make his recommendations
with respect thereto. The third requirement is that the Commission's report along with the Governor's recommendations has
to be placed before the Legislature of the State by the Minister
B concerned, and this has to be accompanied by an explanatory
memorandum regarding the action proposed to be taken thereon
by the Government of Assam. There is no doubt that in the
present case, the Governor of Assam did appoint a Commission.
We have already indicated the terms of reference under which
the Commission was appointed. There is also no doubt that the
C Commission made its report, and it recommended the creation of
a new autonomous District Council for the Jowai Sub-Division
of the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills Autonomous District by excluding the areas comprising the areas of the said Sub-Division from
the United K.hasi-Jaintia Hills Autonomous Districts.
D
I
(Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
E
F
G
H
Mr. Setalvad contends that this report did not in fact
recommend the creation of a new Autonomous District at all; and
in support of this argument, he relies on the fact that the recommendation, in terms, refers to the creation of a new autonomous
District Council. He also points out that the Commission has
observed that "if the inhabitants of the Jaintia Hills work together
and maintain the existing system of administration, there is no
reason why a separate District Council for Jowai should not be
a success." The Commission also added that the establishment
of a separate District Council would resolve the prevailing tension
and bitterness, due to a lack of uniformity in administration,
between them and in Khasis; and the Commission hoped that the
creation of a separate District Council would lead to a better
understanding between them. It is true that the reference to
the creation of a new District Council is somewhat inappropriate
in the context; but on considering the Commission's recommendations as a whole, there is no doubt that what the Commission
recommended was the creation of a new Autonomous District.
It would be noticed that the Commission has expressly recommended that the areas comprising the areas of the Jowai SubDivision should be excluded from the existing Autonomous District known as the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills Autonomous
District, and that necessarily means that the Sub-Division area
has to .be taken out and formed into a new Autonomous District.
Therefore, there can be no doubt that the condition about the
appointment of a Commission has ~n satisfied, and that, in fact,
tli.e Commission which was appointed by the Governor, has
788
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
i-
[1966] 2 s.c.R.
~i<
I
recommended the creation of a new Autonomous District on the
lines ultimately adopted in the impugned notification.
It still remains to consider whether the other two conditions
prescribed by paragraph 14 have been satisfied or not. Has the
Governor considered the report submitted by the Commission and
made his rerommendations, and have those recommendations
along with the report been placed before the Legislature by the
Minister concerned along with an explanatory memorandum ?
As to the latter requirement, there is no dispute. The evidence
shows that the report along with an explanatory memorandum
was placed by the Minister concerned before the Legislature. This
memorandum set out the history about the appointment of the
Commissio~. and the receipt of its report; and it added that "after
a careful consideration of the report and the recommendations of
the Governor, the Government has decided to accept the recommendations of the Commission and give effect to them by taking
necessary administrative and other steps in this direction." The
main controversy centres round the question as to whether the
Governor considered the report and made his recommendations.
'""
A
•
B
...
C
D
In pressing his argument that it is not shown that the Governor
considered the report and made his recommendations thereon,
Mr. Setalvad assumes that the Governor, in the context, is not
functioning as the Constitutional Governor who receives the E
advice of his Council of Ministers, but is functioning in his own
individual character as Governor; and before the validity of the
notification can be upheld, it must be established that the
Governor did consider the report and did make his own recommendations.. It is not seriously disputed by Mr. Setalvad that
the power which is conferred on the Governor by para. 1(3) F
of the Sixth Schedule, has to be exercised by him as a Constitutional Governor; that is to say, he mus~ act on the advice of his
Council of Ministers. It is also not disputed by Mr. Setalvad
that ultimately it is the Government of Assam which has to decide
what action to take in such matter. -Paragraph 14(2) expressly
says that the explanatory memorandum which has to be laid G
before the Legislature of the State must indicate the action proposed to be taken ·by the Government of Assam. Mr. Setalvad,
however, argues that having regard to the context of para. 14(2),
it is clear that the Governor acts on his own in considering the
report and making his recommendations. His suggestion is that H
under para. 14(2), the report must first go to the Governor; he
must consider it and make his recommendations; and the Council
of Ministers must then decide what action to take. After that
I
EDWINQ50N v. ASSAM
•
(Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
78!>
A stage is over, the report made by the Commission, the recommendations of the Governor thereon, and the explanatory
memorandum drawn by the Government of Assam had to be
placed before the Legislature of the State.
B
c
D
'
E
F
G
•H
According to the respondents, what actually happened in
the present case was that after the report of the Commission was
received, the Council of Ministers considered the report at its
meeting on the 28th April, 1964, and decided to accept the
recommendations of the Commission. An explanatory memorandum was then drawn up, and the whole file was placed before
the, Governor. After the Governor read the file, on the 21st
September, 1964, he wrote on it "Seen, thanks". ·The affidavit
filed by the respondents shows that after the matter was considered by the Council of Ministers, the proceedings were placed
before the Governor, and he read the proceedings and expressed
his concurrence with the words "Seen, thanks" The question is
whether the 'procedure thus followed in the present case complied
with the relevant conditions prescribed by para 14(2) or not.
For the purpose of dealing with this aspect of the matter in
the present appeal, we are prepared to assume that when para
14(2) refers to the Governor, it refers to him as Governor who
must act on his own and not be assisted by the advice tendered
to him by the Council of Ministers. Even on that assumption,
we are unable to see how the procedure followed in the prese'lt
case can, in 'substance, be said to contravene the substantial
requirement~ of para 14(2). What para 14(2) requires is that
before the matter goes to the Legislature of the State, the Governor
must apply his mind to it and make his recommendations on it.
It would be unreasonable to suggest that in considering the report,
the Governor is precluded from receiving the assistance of the
Council of Ministers before he makes up his mind as to what
recommendations should be sent before the Legislature of the
State. If the Governor thinks that the questions raised by the
report should first be considered by the Council of Ministers
and then submitted to him, we do not see how it can be said that
para 14(2) has not been complied with. On the other hand, if the
Governor, in the context, is expected to act as a Constitutional
Governor, it would be appropriate that the matter should first be
examined by the Council of Ministers and then submitted to him
for his own recommendations. However one looks at it, the facts
disclosed in the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the State of
Assam unmistakably show that the matter has been considered
both by the Governor and the Council of Ministers and they are
790
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
(1966( 2 S.C.R.
all agreed that the recommendations of the Commission should
be accepted. The criticism that the Governor has not made any
recommendations as such, but has merely contented himself with
making a short note "Seen, thanks'', has, in our opinion, no
substance. We have looked at the counter-affidavit filed on behalf
of the State of Assam and have examined the other documentary
evidence to which our attention was drawn. In the present case,
the record clearly shows that the Commission recommended that
a new Autonomous District should be created, the Governor
agreed with the said recommendation, and so did the Council of
Ministers. Therefore, we see no reason to interfere with the
majority decision of the High Court that the power conferred on
the Governor-by paragraph 1(3) of the Sixth Schedule has been
validly and properly exercised by him.
The result is, the appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.
Hidayatullah, J. The appellant impugns !he judgment of the
High Court of Assam and Nagaland at Gauhati, dated February 5,
1965, by which his petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution,
filed to challenge notification No. TAD/R/50/64, dated November 23, 1964, which set up an· autonomous District of Jowai after
separating the Sub-Division of Jowai from the United KhasiJaintia Hills Autonomous District, was dismissed. According to
the appellant the notification forming the new autonomous district was ineffective without an amendment of the Sixth Schedule
of the Constitution by parliamentary legislation; and even by
i~self was insufficient because some necessary steps leading up to
the notification were not taken. In the High Court the petition,
from which this appeal arises by a certificate of the High Court
under Art. 132, was heard by a Full Bench and was rejected by
majority. The learned Chief Justice (Dutta J. concurring)
of the view that the contentions of the appellant were unsupportable while C. S. ;Nayudu J. was of the opposite opinion.
I have had the benefit and the privilege of reading the judgment just delivered by my lord the Chief Justice, but I have the
misfortune to disagree with the conclusion that th}s appeal should
be dismissed. The facts are fully set ou~ by my lord and I
need not repeat them. Before I give my reasons why I hold
that this appeal should succeed, I find it convenient to refer to
the constitutional provisions bearing upon this matter which
I apprehend differently.
Originally the territories of India consisted of the States
named in Parts A, B and C of the First Schedule and the terri·
tories specified in Part D of the same Schedule. There were
A
•
B
C
D
•
E
was F
G
H.
t
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM
A
B
c
"·
(Hidayatullah, /.)
791
9 States in Part A, 9 in Part B and 10 in Part C. Part D consisted of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. Assam was the first
State to be named in Part A. Its territories were described as
follows:-
"The territory of the State of Assam shall comprise the territories which immediately before the
commencement of this Constitution were comprised in
the Province of Assam, the Khasi States and· the Assam
Tribal Areas."
,,
'
Different parts in the Constitution laid down provisions as to th~
administration of the different States in the First Schedule.
Part VI dealt with States in Part A, Par~ VII with States in
Part B, Part VIII with States in Part C, Part IX with territories
in Part D and such other territories not specified in the First
Schedule and Part X with the Scheduled and Tribal Areas.
After the Constitution (7th Amendment) Act, 1956, the whole
D of the First Schedule was substituted by another Schedule and
some of the States had to be renamed and classified, as a result
of the reorganisation of the States. Indian territory thereafter
stood divided into: I the States (14 in number) and II the Union
Territories (6 in number). The reference to the territories of
hsam was also altered and it now reads :
E
F
;
!;..
r.'
.
"The territories which immediately before the commencemrtit of this Constitution were comprised in the
Province 1,,of Assam, the Khasi States and the Assam
Tribal .t-+leas, but excluding the territories specified in
the Schedule to the Assam (Alteration of Boundaries)
Act, 1951".
The Parts of the Constitution dealing with the administration of
the several territories, already mentioned, were also revised.
Part VI continued to govern the administration of the States and
Part VIII continued to govern the administration of the Union
G territories. Such changes as were necessary in view of the reorganisation effected in the First Schedule were, of course, made
in these two Parts, but I am not concerned with them. Part VII
and IX were repealed as they were not required. Part X continued as before with an amendment deleting reference to States
in Part A or Part B of the First Schedule. As Part X consists
H of a single article it may conveniently be set down here : "244. Administration of Scheduled
tribal areas.
L8Sup.CI/66-4
Areas
and
792
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 s.c.R.
( 1) The provisions of the Fifth Schedule shall apply
to the administration and control of the Scheduled Areas
and Scheduled Tribes in any State other than the State
of Assam.
(2) The provisions of the Sixth Schedule shall apply
to the administration of the tribal areas in the State of
Assam."
A
B
We are really not concerned with the first clause of Art. 244
but it may be noticed that there are two different schedules.
Schedule 5 is for Scheduled Areas and Scheduled Tribes in States
other than Assam and Schedule 6 is for the tribal areas in the C
State of Assam. It may also be noticed that the Fifth Schedule
contemplates not only administration but also control of the areas
referred to in Art. 244(1) while the Sixth Schedule refers to
administration only and not control. When I contrast the provisions of these two schedules the last distinction will have some
materiality. We are concerned with the tribal areas in the State D
of Assam and the entire question falls to be considered under the
Sixth Schedule. There is no connection between Part VI and
Part X and the provisions of the latter Part cann'Ot be amplified
by the provisions of the former in any respect. This is a fact
which is fundamental to the view I am going to put forward.
E
Although strictly speaking we are not concerned with the
Fifth Schedule, I shall refer to it briefly because it enables us to
see the special and very different provisions regarding the tribal
areas in the State of Assam. Scheduled Areas and Scheduled
Tribes situated in other parts of India are governed in common
by the Fifth Schedule. The tribal areas in Assam are, however, F
separately provided for. The difference between the two
Schedules throws some light upon the way the Sixth Schedule
is intended to work and it shall be my endeavour to unravel that
working but I shall begin with analysing the Fifth Schedule first.
The Fifth Schedule is divided into four Parts A, B, C and D G
and consists of seven paragraphs. Part A is general. Paragraph 2
in that Part says that subject to the provisions of the Fifth
Schedule the Executive power of the State extends to the
Scheduled Areas in a State. Paragraph 1 excludes the State of
Assam from the expression "State". As we shall see presently,
the Sixth Schedule does not contain such provision at all. The H
Executive power of the State of Assam has not been extended to
the tribal areas in Assam. Paragraph 3 of the Fifth Schedule then
,
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM (Hidayatul/ah, J.)
t
~
.
r
"
"
Ii
~
)(
I
793
A requires the Governor of each State to report to the President
annually or as often as required by the President, regardmg the
administration of the Scheduled Areas in the State and the executive power of the Union extends to the giving of directions to the
State as to the administration of the areas. Again, there is no
provision of this kind in the Sixth Schedule. The only control
B of the President there, is in respect of a portion of the Tribal Area
described in Part B of the Paragraph 20 to which I shall refer
later. Reverting to the Fifth Schedule Part B, which is headed
'Administration and Control of the Scheduled Areas and
Scheduled Tribes', contains the following scheme. Under Paragraph 4, Tribes Advisory Councils are to' be established. The
c duty of these Councils is to advise on matters pertaining to the
welfare and advancement of the Scheduled Tribes in the State,
referred to the Councils by the Governors. The affairs of the
Councils are governed by rules made by the Governor. By paragraph 5 the Governor is authorised to direct by public notification that any particular Act of Parliament or of the Legislature of
D the State shall not apply to a Scheduled Area or any part of the
Scheduled Area in the State and in applying the law the Governor
can make such exceptions and modifications as he may specify.
The Governor is given the power to make regulations for the
peace and good Government of any area in a State which is for
E the time being a Scheduled Area. The words 'peace and good
Government' were always understood as giving the utmost discretion in law making : Riel v. The Queen(') and Peare Dusam
v. Emperor('). In making the law the Governor has been given
the power to repeal or amend any Act of Parliament or of the
Legislature of the State or any existing law which is for the
F time being applicable to the area in question. The · words
"exceptions and modifications" have also been interpreted as
giving powers of amendment: Queen v. Burah('). These are
legislative powers of a very wide nature. They are subject to
two restrictions only. The first is that before making any regulation the Governor shall consult the Council and all regulations
G must be submitted to the President and until assented to by him,
do not have effect. Part C consists of one paragraph. This is
paragraph 6. By sub-paragraph (1) the expression "Scheduled
areas" is defined as such areas as the President may by order
declare to be Scheduled Area. The President has passed two snch
orders in 1950 relating to Part A and Part B States respectively.
u By sub-paragraph (2) the President may at any time by order(1) (1885) 10 A.C. 675.
(2) [1944] F.C.R. 61.
(3) (1878) 3 A.C. 889.
794
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS.
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
0
(a) direct that the whole or any specified part of a
Scheduled Area sha.ll cease to be a Scheduled Area or
a part of such an area;
(b) alter, but only by way of rectification of boundaries, any Scheduled Area;
(c) on any alteration of the boundaries of a State
or on the admission into the Union or the establishment
of a new State, declare any territory not previously
included in any State to be, or to form part of, a
a Scheduled Area; and any such order may contain
such incidental and consequential provisions as appear
to the President to be necessary and proper, but save as
aforesaid, the order made under sub-paragraph (1) of
this paragraph shall not be varied by any subsequent
order."
Part D then lays down that Parliament may, from time to time,
by Jaw amend the Schedule by way of addition, variation or
repeal, any of the provisions and such an ,amendment shall not
be deemed to be an amendment of the Constitution for the purpose of Art. 368.
B
c
D
To summarize : under the Fifth Schedule the Governor is the
sole legislature for the Scheduled areas and the Scheduled Tribes. E
He makes the Regulations after consulting the Tribes Advisory
Council and submits them to the President for the latter's assent.
The executive authority of the State extentis to the Scheduled Areas
but the executive authority of the Union extends to giving of
directions to the State as to the administration of such areas.
These areas are determined by the President by an order and may F
be altered from time to time by the President by another order
but the President cannot alter an order made under sub-paragraph
(1) except as laid down in els. (a), (b) and (c) of th!l second subparagraph. Any amendment of the Schedule must be done by
Parliament. I shall now turn to the Sixth Schedule which differs
in many significant respects.
G
The gist of the provisions as to the administration of Tribal
Areas in Assam is contained in the first and second subparagraphs of paragraph 1. It is that the tribal areas in each
item of Part A of the table appended to paragraph 20 of the
Schedule shall be autonomous districts and if there are different
Scheduled Tribes in an autonomous district the Governor may,
by public notification, divide the area or areas inhabited by them
into autonomous regions. The word 'autonomous', that is to .say,
..~
"
1
H
.Ji
');
--~
EDWINGSON V. ASSAM
A
B
(Hida.vatullah, J.)
795
the possession of the right of self-government is the key note of
the provisions. As will appear presently, the legislature, the
executive and the judiciary (except the High Court) in the State
of Assam do not freely function for these autonomous districts.
The Table attached to the Schedule gives the list of these districts
and the Tribal areas. It has been changed by Parliamentary
legislation from time to time.
"TABLE
PART A
c
!. The United Khasi-Jaintia Hills District.
2. The Garo Hills District.
3. The Mizo District.
4.
5. The North Cachar Hills.
D
E
6. The Mikir Hills.
[The name Mizo District was substituted for the Lushai Hills
District by the Lushai Hills District (Change of Name) Act 1954
(18 of 1964) and item No. 4 "Naga Hills District" was omitted
and was substituted as "Naga Hills-Tuensang Area" as item 2 in
Part B by the Naga Hills-Tuensang Area Act, 1957 by Act 42
of 1957].
PARTB
F
!. North East Frontier Tract including Balipara Frontier
Tract, Tirap Frontier Tract, Abor Hills District and
Misimi Hills District.
2. The Naga Hills-Tuensang Area".
[Item 2 has been deleted by the State of Nagaland Act, 1962 (27
of 1962)].
G
H
How deep is the autonomy in the Autonomous Districts and
in the Autonomous Regions can be gauged by a short survey
of some of the other paragraphs of the Schedule. Under paragraph 2 provision is made for constitution of District Councils
and Regional Councils which have power after they are constituted
under rules framed by the Governor to make rules for their own
composition, delimitation of constituencies, qualifications of
voters, conduct of elections and generally for the conduct of business before them and the appointment of officers. Their powers
and jurisdictions go much further than that of ordinary local
796
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
authorities. They have under paragraph 3 power to make laws A
for various matters and such laws are effective after the Governor
assents to them. Under paragraph 4 the administration of justice ;
is entirely under the control of the District and Regional Councils ·
and they can constitute courts and appoint persons to be presiding
officers of such courts and no other court, except the High Court ·
of the State and the Supreme Court, has jurisdiction over suits or B
cases assigned to the courts so set up. The Councils can also
frame regulations .(with the previous approval of the Governor)
laying down the procedure to be followed in trial of cases and
regarding such appeals as may be prescribed. Under paragraph 5
the Governor may, for the trial of suits or cases arising out of
any law in force in any autonomous district or region being a c
law specified in that behalf by the Governor, or for the trial of
offences punishable with death, transportation for life, or imprisonment for a term of not less than five years under the Indian Penal
Code or under any other law for the time being applicable, confer
on the District Council or the Regional Council, having authority D
over such district or region, or on courts constituted by such
Pistrict Council or on any officer apointed in that behalf by the
Governor, such powers under the Code of Civil Procedure 1908
or as the case may be, the Code of Criminal Pr'ocedure, 1898, as
he deems appropriate. The two Codes abovementioned apply
only thus far and no further. Paragraph 6 gives power to the E
District Council to establish primary schools, dispensaries,
markets, cattle pounds, ferries, fisheries, roads and waterways in
the district and to prescribe the language of instruction. Under
paragraph 7 District and Regional Funds have to be constituted
to finance administration. Under paragraph 8 power to assess
and collect land revenue on principles followed generally by the F
Government of Assam and to impose specified taxes is given.
Under paragraph 9 the District Councils are entitled to a fair share
of the royalties accruing from licences and leases for the purpose
of prospecting for, or the extraction of minerals granted by the
Government of Assam in respect of any area within an autonomous
district. In case of dispute the Governor is to decide the matter in G
his discretion. Under paragraph 10 the District Council can
make regulations for controlling and regulating money-lending
and trading within the District and for licensing of certain trades
and of money-lenders. All laws, regulations or rules made by
the District and Regional Councils are to be published in the
Official Gazette of the State and on publication have the force of H
law. Paragraph 12 provides that no Act of the Legislature of
the State in respect of which the District or Regional Councils
'
~·~
\-
Jl
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM (Hida,vatullah, J.)
797
have power to make law shall apply unless the District Council
by public notification directs and the District Council can in so
applying the law make any exceptions or modifications it thinks fit.
In respect of any other law made by Parliament for the Legislature
of the State the Governor shall determine whether it shall not
apply to the autonomous districts or regions and, if so, the
B Governor may make such exceptions or modifications as he may
notify with or without retrospective effect. Under paragraph 13
the estimated receipts and expenditure pertaining to autonomous
districts have to be separately shown in the annual financial statement of the State and laid before the Legislature of the State
under Art. 202. I shall omit paragraph 14 at this stage and come
c back to it later. Under paragraph 15 the Governor may annul
any act or resolution of a District or Regional Council which i:;
likely to endanger the safety of India and may even assume to
himself all or any of the powers vested in the Councils. Any
order made by the Governor is to be laid before the Legislature
of the State and unless revoked by it, continues for a period of 12
D months and if so resolved by Legislature for a further period of
twelve months unless cancelled earlier by the Governor himself.
The Governor may, on the recommendation of a Commission
appointed under paragraph 14, dissolve a Council, direct ·fresh
general election, and subject to the previous approval of the LegisE lature of the State, assume the administration, or place it under
the said Commission. No action to assume the administration
shall be taken by the Governor without giving the Council affected
an opportunity of placing its views before the Legislature of the
State. Paragraph 17 enables the Governor to exclude an autonomous district in forming constituencies in the District. I shall
F presently refer to paragraph 18 which applies the above-mentioned
provisions with some modifications to Part B of the Table
appended to the Schedule. Paragraph 19 includes transitional
provisions. The Governor was required by that paragraph to
constitute a District Council for each autonomous district in the
State and till then the administration of the District was to vest
G in !rim. He could make regulations for the peace and good
government and they were to become law on the President's assent.
He could also direct the application of an Act of Parliament or
of the Legislature of the State with such exceptions and modifications as he thought fit and unless he applied it the law was inapplicable in the Districts.
A.
H
These are the provisions for the administration of Autonomous Districts and Regions. To summarize : the laws made by
Parliament or the Legislature of the State do not run automati·
798
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
cally in these areas. The laws are either made by the District A
Councils or are applied by them. The administration of justice is
achieved by the District and Regional Councils through their own
agencies except that in serious offences the Governor has to
decide whether to invest the Councils and the courts set up by the
Councils with jurisdiction to try them. The Councils enjoy the
powers of taxation and establishing of institutions mentioned in B
paragraph 6. They have their own funds. Some actions of the
District or Regional Councils are capable of being annulled by
the Governor and the Governor may even dissolve the Councils.
There is complete autonomy as far as the powers and jurisdiction
of the Councils go. A check is supplied by the Governor and
the Legislature of the State comes into picture only when the C
Governor takes action against the Councils to revoke their acts
or resolutions or dissolves them and takes over the administration
himself.
I shall now refer to the paragraphs I did not mention so far.
I shall begin by referring to paragraph 18. That paragraph may D
be reproduced here :
"18. Application of the provisions of this Schedule
to areas specified in Part B of the table appended to
paragraph 20.(1) The Governor may(a) subject to the previous approval of the President, by public notification, apply all or any of the foregoing provisions of this Schedule to any tribal area
specified in Part B of the table appended to paragraph
20 of this Schedule or any part of such area and thereupon such area or part shall be administered in accordance with .such provisions, and
E
F
, (b) with like approval, by public notification,
exclude from the said table any tribal area specified in
Part B of that table 'or any part of such area.
(2) Until a notification is issued under subparagraph (1) of this paragraph in respect of any tribal
area specified in Part B of the said table or any part of
such area, the administration of such area or part
thereof, as the case may be, shall be carried on by the
President through the Governor of Assam as his agent
and the provisions of article 240 shall apply thereto as
if such area or part thereof were a Union territory specified in that article.
G
H
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM (Hidayatullah, !.)
.A
B
c
D
E
(3) In the discharge of his functions under subparagraph (2) of this paragraph as the agent of the President the Governor shall act in his discretion.
Three matters are provided here. The first is that the Government may by public notification, apply all or any of the provisions
of the Sixth Schedule contained in paragraphs 1-17 to any tribal
area specified in Part B of the table quoted by me earlier. The
second is that the Governor may exclude from that table any
tribal area specified in Part B. Both these powers are subject to
prior approval of the President. The third matter is that until
the tribal areas in Part B are brought)n line with' the autonomous
districts, the administration must be carried on by the Governor
in his discretion as the agent of the President, in the same manner
as if those areas werei Union territory. These provisions show
that in respect of the tribal areas in Part B the Governor acts for
himself when carrying on the administration and any change as
contemplated jJy clauses (a) and (b) of sub-paragraph (1) of Paragraph 18 must receive prior approval of the President. The State
Executive or the Legislature have no say in the matter..
I now come to the provisions of paragraph 1(3) read with
paragraph 14 and 20 under which the present action purports to be
taken. It is convenient to look at paragraph 20 first. The table
appended to that paragraph has already been quoted. The main
part which describes the extent of the autonomous districts named
in Part A of the table at the end may now be read :
"20. Tribal Areas.-
F
(1) The areas specified in Parts A and B of the
table below shall be the tribal areas within the State of
Assam.
G
(2) The United Khasi-J aintia Hills District shall
comprise the territories which before the commencement of this Constitution were known as the Khasi States
and the Khasi and Jaintia Hills District, excluding any
areas for the time being comprised within the cantonment and municipality of Shillong, but including so
much of the area comprised within the municipality of
Shillong as formed part of the Khasi State of Mylliem :
H
799
Provided that for the purposes of clauses (e) and (f)
of sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 3, paragraph 4, paragraph 5, paragraph 6, sub-paragraph (2), clauses (a),
(b) and (d) of sub-paragraph (3) and sub-paragraph (4)
SUPREME
800
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
of paragraph 8, and clause (d) of sub-paragraph (2) of
paragraph I 0 of this Schedule, no part of the area comprised within the municipality of Shillong shalr be
deemed to be within the District.
(2A) The Mizo District shall comprise the area
which at the commencement of this Constitution was
known as the Lushai Hills District.
(3) Any reference in the table below to any district
(other than the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills District) and
the Mizo District or administrative area shall be construed as a reference to that district or area at the commencement of this Constitution :
Provided that the tribal areas specified in Part B of
the table below shall not include any such areas in the
plains as may, with the previous approval of the President, be notified by the Governor of Assam in that
behalf."
These sub-paragraphs give the extent of the autonomous districts.
The table does not identify any area except by name but the
demarcation of the areas is done by the above sub-paragraphs.
The tribal areas are not immutable. They can be changed, so
also the autonomous districts. The question is how is this to
be done ? The third sub-paragraph of the first paragraph lays
down one of the steps. It provides :
"l. Autonomous
regions.-
districts
and
B
c
D
E
autonomous
(!)
(2)
F
(3) The Governor may, by public notification,(a) include any area in Part A of the said table,
(b) exclude any area from Part A of the said table,
(c) create a new autonomous district,
(d) increase the area of any autonomous district,
(e) diminish the area of any autonomous district,
(f) unite two or more autonomous districts or parts
thereof so as to form one autonomous district,
(g) define the boundaries of any autonomous district.
G
Provided that no order shall be made by the Governor under clauses (c), (d), (e) "and (f) of this subparagraph except after consideration of the report of a
H
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM
A
•
(Hida,vatu/lah, J.)
801
Commission appointed under sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 14 of this Schedule."
Some other steps are laid down in paragraph 14 mentioned here :
It provides :
"14. Appointment of Commission to inquire into
B
and report on the administration of autonomous districts
and autonomous regions.(1) The Governor· may at any time appoint a
Commission to examine and report on any matter specified by him relating to the administration of the autonomous districts and autonomous regions in the State,
c
including matters specified in clauses (c), (d), (e) and
(f) of
sub-paragraph (3) of paragraph 1 of this
Schedule, or may appoint a Commission to inquire into
and report from time to time on the administration of
autonomous districts and autonomous regions in the
State generally and in particular onD
( a) the provision of educational and medical facilities and communications in such districts and
regions;
(b) the need for any new special legislation in respect of such districts and regions; and
E
( c) the administration of the laws, rules and regulations made by the District and Regional Councils;
and define the procedure to be followed by such Commission.
F
(2) The report of every such Commission with the
recommendations of the Governor with respect thereto
shall be laid before the Legislature of the State by the
Minister concerned together with an explanatory memorandum regarding the action proposed to be taken
thereon by the Government of Assam.
G
(3) In allocating the business of the Government of
the State among his Ministers the Governor may place
one <;>f his Ministers specially in charge of the welfare
of the autonomous districts and autonomous regions in
the State."
H Lastly there are the provisions of paragraph 21 and the question•
is whether they involve the final step or are irrelevant in this
behalf. Paragraph 21 reads :
802
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R·
A
"21. Amendment of the Schedule.(1) Parli.ament may from time to time by law
amend by way of addition, variation or repeal any of
the provisions of this Schedule and, when the Schedule
is so amended, any reference to this Schedule in this
Constitution shall be construed as a reference to such
B
Schedule as so amended.
(2) No such law as is mentioned in sub-paragraph
(1) of this paragraph shall be deemed to be an amendment of this Constitution for the purposes of article
368."
Now the case of the appellant is that although a Commission C
was appointed and made its report to the Governor, the Governor
neither considered the report nor made his recommendations as
required by paragraph 14. The Government of Assam drew up
its proposals which were sent to the Governor who merely noted
on the file, "Seen Thanks" and returned the papers which were
then placed before the Legislature of the State and the Legislature D
approved the proposals by a resolution. The contention ·of the
appellant is that far from playing the key role which the policy
underlying the Schedule envisages, the Governor left the entire
matter to the Government and at the end of the deliberations
expressed himself by saying "Seen Thanks" which at best was a
very vague expression. In the alternative it is contended that no E
action could be effective without Parliamentary legislation under
paragraph 21, to amend the operative portion of paragraph 20
which Parliament alone can amend. Reference is made to legislation by which the tribal areas were changed on previous occasions by Parliament. In my judgment both these criticism are wellfounded.
·
F
It will be noticed that the Governor's powers under subparagraph 3 of paragraph 1 are to include or to exclude any area
from Part A of the Table. These are clauses {a) and (b) of this
sub-paragraph. Then the powers are to create a new autonomous district (cl. ( c)), to increase (cl. ( d) ) or diminish (cl. ( e)) G
the area of any autonomous district, unite two or more autonomous districts or parts thereof so as to form one autonomous district (cl. ( f) ) , define the boundaries of an autonomous district
cl. (g).
Powers in clauses (a), (b) and (g) are not subject to the
proviso and the Commission under paragraph 14 need not be H
·consulted before taking action under them. Action taken under
.clauses (a), (b) and (g) need not be reported to the Legislature
'
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM (Hidayatullah, J.)
,;;;_ '
A
'
I
80~
of the State. I shall have something to say about it later because
unless clauses (a) and (b) are also considered it is not possible to
interpret the other clauses.
We are concerned with powers exercisable under clauses (c).
{d) and (e) and the procedure contemplated by the proviso to
B paragraph 1(3) read with paragraph 14 must be followed. The
Governor has issued the public notification. There is no provision which bars inquiry : Is the action taken valid ? Since the
action is not under clauses (a) and (b) even Part A of Table
attached to paragraph 20 is not altered either directly or by implication. Paragraph 1(3) also says nothing about the amendment
C of paragraph 20 and as that power cannot be implied in view
of paragraph 21 that paragraph also continues unaltered. The
notification thus says one thing and paragraph 20 and the Table
another. This is clearly a situation which could not have been
intended. We are dealing with a Constitution which no agency
less than Parliament can amend. Take another example. Suppose
D the Governor next intends to exclude so much of the area comprised within the Municipality of Shillong as forms part of the
Khasi State of Mylliem. If he can do that by a notification he
may but what about paragraph 20(2) and the Table? His notification will be that the area comprised within the Municipality of
Shillong as forms part of the Khasi State of Mylliem shall form
E the autonomous district. The other patt will form another autonomous district or go out of the tribal area. Suppose the
Governor next divided the Khasi and Jaintia Hills sections and
formed two autonomous districts by another notification. The
Governor has no power under clauses (c), (d) and (e) to amend
paragraph 20 or the Table. Whether he has that power over
F parag'raph 20 even under clauses (a) and (b) is open to much
doubt. The paragraph and the Table will thus remain unaltered
and the notification will render them obsolete. It was argued by
the learned Attorney General that the paragraph and the Table
will be impliedly amended. I regret I cannot accept this arguG ment. We are dealing with the Constitution. It provides within
itself how Schedules 5 and 6 can be amended. Any other mode
of amendment is necessarily prohibited. There can be no amendment by any other agency much less an implied repeal and an
implied amendment. Is the amendment of the Constitution such
a simple affair that a notification of the Governor amends its proH visions by implication ?
(b).
I shall now consider the cases arising under clauses (a) and
There is some difference between clauses (a) and (b) on the
.804
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 s.c.R ..
one hand and clauses (c), (d), (e) and (f) on the other. It is signi- A
ficant that the procedure of paragraph H need not be
followed when the Governor acts under the former group.
Clauses (a) and (b) cannot therefore cover the same ground as
clauses (c), (d), (e) and (f). They are not a summary of the
action envisaged by the other clauses. They must represent inclusion and exclusion of areas from Part A of the Table. Otherwise B
there would be a reference to them in the proviso. The proviso
covers only those cases where the area of the autonomous districts
is involved and changes are made therein. The first two clauses
mention the Table but not the others. Now the legislative power
of the State does not extend to the tribal areas. The executive
power being coextensive with the legislative power does not extend C
either. In Schedule 5 the executive power has been expressly
extended. In Schedule 6 there is no such extension. Similarly the
word 'control' is omitted in Art. 244(2). The Union Government also has not been given the power to issue directions to the
State Government as is the case in Schedule 5. There is no
requirement of prior consent of the President or his approval as D
in the Fifth Schedule or paragraph 18 of the sixth Schedule. A
notification under clauses (a) and (b) would be subject to no control except that of Parliament. This demonstrates the utter need
·Of Parliamentary legislation to amend the schedule particulary
paragraph 20 and the Table.
E
The notification issued by the Governor is not under clauses
{a) and (b) but that hardly makes any difference. It does not
amend paragraph 20 or the Table. No doubt when all proper
motions have been gone through the United Khasi-Jaintia Hills
District will be cut down by excluding the Jowai Sub-Division and F
the Jowai Sub-Division will emerge as an autonomous district.
But one such step and the final step must be to amend the Sixth
Schedule. That can only be amended by Parliament under the
powers granted by paragraph 21. If "the notification alone did
that there would be antinomy between the notification and the
Schedule. Paragraph 21 says that Parliament may amend the G
Schedule by way of addition, variation and repeal. In my opinion
this power still remains to be exercised to complete the chain of
steps necessary to alter the autonomous districts, the names and
areas of which are laid down by Parliament. The Governor's
notification is no doubt one of the means of achieving the change
but the effectiveness can only be given by Parliament. No wonder H
that on three previous occasions Parliamentary power was in fact
exercised. Sub-paragraph 2(A) was added by Parliament. At
t ·_5·
.
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM (Hida,yatullah, J.)
805
A
that time consequential changes were also made in sub-paragraph
(3) and item No. 3 of Part A of the Table was also changed.
It is to be noticed that there is a difference between paragraph
6(2) of the fifth Schedule and paragraph 1(3) of the sixth Schedule.
The former authorises the President to include in his order such
incidental and consequential provisions as may appear to him to
B be necessary and proper. As this extra jurisdiction is missing
the Governor acting under the Sixth Schedule can only draw up
a notification. He cannot do anything more. Till Parliamentary
legislation follows, the final and effective step is wanting in the
purported action. It is as if the key stone is missing.
c
Ir
,
The action of the Governor is, with respect, not sustainable
on the other ground also. The analysis of the provisions of
Schedules 5 and 6 into which I went earlier clearly demonstrates
that the Governor is made specially responsible for various matters
connected with the administration of the autonomous districts. We
have seen above that the executive authority of the State of Assam
D does not extend to the autonomous districts as it does to the tribal
areas in States other than Assam. Further the Union has not
been given the power to give directions as to the administration
of the autonomous districts. This is because the autonomous
districts and autonomous regions are administered by Councils
which, sub1'ect to the control of the Governor, function indeE pendently. What the real position of the Governor is, vis-a-vis
the Councils on the one hand and the State Government on the
other will be clear if we look into the history of the administration
of these areas and the previous constitutional provisions relating to
the excluded and partially excluded areas as they were previously
called.
F
..
These areas, which were known as backward areas, were from
the earliest times excluded from the operation of laws, either completely or partially and they were directly administered under laws
made by the Executive under the authority of the GovernorGeneral. These orders bore resemblance to the Orders in Council
G of the Crown. As the legality of the laws was seriously in question
the Indian Councils Act of 1861, made provision validating these
so-called laws, by enacting that "no rule, law or regulation made
before the passing of the Act, by the Governor General or certain
other authorities shall be deemed invalid by reason of not having
been made in conformity with the provisions of the Charter Act."
H The power, which was taken away, was again conferred on the
Governor General by the Government of India Act 1870 (33 and
34 Viet. c. 3) and the Governor General was allowed to legislate
__
..____:__ __
,
806
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
separately for these backward tracts. Draft regulations were A
submitted by the Governors-in-Council, Lieutenant Governors or
Chief Commissioners and after their approval by the Governor
General became law for these areas. This state of affairs existed
right down to the Government of India Act 1915. As difficulty
arose in determining what laws were in force in which area, the
Scheduled Districts Act XIV of 1874 was passed which enabled lJ.
public notifications to be issued. The preamble of that Act clearly
sets out that the object inter alia was to ascertain the enactments
in force in any territory and the boundaries of such territories.
This Act then specified the "Scheduled tracts" and the Local Governments were given the power to extend by public notification
to any Scheduled District, with or without modification, any enact- C
ment in force in British India. When the Govermnent of India
Act 1915 was enacted, the Government of India Act 1870 (33
and 34 vict. c. 3) was repealed by the 4th Schedule and s. 71
was included which in effect provided the same procedure for
making and applying laws as has been described above. When
the Government of India Act 1919 (9 and 10 Geo., ch. 101) was I>
passed s. 52-A was inserted which read :
"The Governor-General in Council may declare any
territory in British India to be a 'backward trace and
may, by notification, with such sanction as aforesaid,
direct that this Act shall apply to that territory subject
to such exceptions and modifications as may be prescribed in the notification.
Where the Governor-General in Council has, by
notification, directed as aforesaid, he may, by the same
or subsequent notification, direct that any Act of the
Indian legislature shall not apply to the territory in
question or any part thereof, or shall apply to the territory or any part thereof, subject to such exceptions or
modifications as the Governor General thinks fit, or may
authorise the Governor in Council to give similar directions as respects any Act of the local legislature."
E
F
G
Thus at the inauguration of the Govermnent of India Act 1935
the position was that the Governor General in Council or the
Governor etc. under his directions legislated for these backward
tracts and the Governor General could direct that any Act of
the Indian Legislature should not apply at all or should apply H
with such exceptions and modifications as the Governor General
might think fit. Most of these areas were excluded from the
legislative power' of the Central and Provincial legislatures and
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM
(Hidayatullah, !.)
the Governors were responsible for their administration. In the
Bill of the Government of India Act 1935 the distinction between
the excluded and partially excluded areas was made. This
followed the White Paper and a Sixth Schedule was framed in
which the list of these areas was given. But this Schedule was
withdrawn and the designation of the areas was done by the
B Government of India (Excluded and Partially Excluded Areas)
Order 1936, dated March 3, 1936. The distinction between the.
excluded and partially excluded areas was this : Excluded areas
came directly under the Governor in his discretion and therefore
the administration of the areas was a direct responsibility of the
Governor himself. (Par!. Debates Vol. 301, col. 1395). In the
C Report of the Joint Committee it was stated (para. 67) that in
spite of Provincial Autonomy, "the Excluded Areas (i.e., tracts
where any advanced form of political organisation is unsuited to
the primitive character of the inhabitants) ...... will be administered by the Governor himself and Ministers will have no
constitutional righ~ to advise him in connection with them."
D Paragraph 89 again stated that "Ministers shall advise the
Governor in all matters other than the administration of
Excluded Areas." The position about the Excluded Areas was
summed up in paragraph 144 of the Report thus :
A
-f
\
~'
j
E
-F
G
H
'
807
"It is proposed that the powers of a ·Provincial
Legislature shall not extend to any part of the Province
which is declared to be an "Excluded Area" or a
'Partially Excluded Area'. In relation to the former,
the Governor will himself direct and control the administration; in the case of the latter he is declared to
have a special responsibility. In neither case will any
Act of the Provincial Legislature apply to the Area,
unless by direction of the Governor given at his discretion, with any exceptions or modifications which he
may think fit. The Governor will also be empowered
at his discretion to make regulations having the force
of law for the peace and good government of any
Excluded or Partially Excluded Area. We have
already expressed our approval of the principle of
Exel uded Areas, and we accept the above proposals
as both necessary and reasonable, so far as the
Excluded Areas proper are concerned, We think, however, that a distinction might well be drawn in this
respect bet ween Excluded Areas and Partially Excluded
Areas and that the application of Acts to, or the framing of Regulations for, Partially Excluded Areas is an
L8 Sup. Cl/66-5
808
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
executive act which might appropriately be performed
by the Governor on the advice of his Ministers, t:he
decisions taken in each case being, of course, subject to
the Governor's special responsibility for Partially Excluded Areas, that is to say, being subject to his right to
differ from the proposals of his Ministers if he thinks
fit·."
A
B
The administration of these areas thus followed the analogy of
the Governor-General's reserved departments, and the expenditure for these areas required by the Governor, whether from the
Provincial or Central revenues was not subject to the vote of the
Provincial Legislature. In the administration of the Tribal areas c
the Governor was to act as the agent of the Governor-General.
The administration of the partially excluded areas was a special
responsibility of the Governor General.
These provisions of the Government of India Act were,
therefore, so designed that the "Excluded Areas" were excluded
from the Provincial and Central Legislatures and the administra- D
tion of these areas was vested in the Governor in his discretion
while the administration of the "partially excluded areas" was in
the control of the Ministers subject to the special responsibilities
of the Governor acting in his individual judgment.
As regards the machinery for transfer of areas the Parlia- E
mentary Debates (Vol. 299, cols. 1553-54) contain the following
policy statement :
"There is bound to be infiltration from one district
to another, and in the course of times, we may be able
to bring certain of these districts under the ordinary
administration. In that case there ought to be power
F
to make the transfer and the powers ought to be
exercised in such a way that there is Parliamentary protection behind the transferred area. We ensure that
the transfer can only be undertaken by an order in
Council, which has to obtain the approval of both
Houses."
G
The Order in Council now has the counterpart in the notification
of the Governor and the approval of the Parliament has its
·counterpart in the amendment of Schedules 5 and 6 which our
Parliament alone can undertake.
The resulting position was the enactment of ss. 91 and 92 in H
the Government of India Act 1935 which may be set out here :
"91. Excluded areas and partially excluded areas.
~--
¥
Ji·'
,.
~
•
~
f
~~
;
)'
· - t;_,
.L
-
EDWINGSON v. A>SAM (Hidczyatullah, J.)
'
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
809
( 1) In this Act the expressions 'excluded area' and
"partially excluded area" mean respectively such areas
as His Majesty may by Order in Council declare to be
excluded areas or partially excluded areas.
The Secretary of State shall lay the draft of the
Order which it is proposed to recommend His Majesty
to make under this sub-section before Parliament within
six months from the passing of this Act.
(2) His Majesty may at any time by Order m
Council(a) direct that the whole or any specified part of an
excluded area shall become, or become part of, a partially excluded area;
(b) direct the whole or any specified part of a partially excluded area shall cease to be a partially
excluded area or a part of such an area;
(c) alter, but only by way of rectification of boundaries, any excluded or partially excluded area;
(d) on any alteration of the boundaries of a Province, or the creation of a new Province, declare any
territory not previously included in any Province to be,
or to form part of, an excluded area or a partially
excluded area,
and any such Order may contain such incidental and
consequential provisions as appear to His Majesty to
be necessary and proper, but save as aforesaid the Order
in Council made under subsection (1) of this section
shall not be varied by any subsequent Order."
"92. Administration of excluded areas and partially
excluded areas.
(!) The executive authority of a Province extends
to excluded and partially excluded areas therein, but,
notwithstanding anything in this Act, no Act of the
Federal Legislature or of the Provincial Legislature,
shall apply to an excluded area or a partially excluded
area, unless the Governor by public notification so
directs, and the Governor in giving such a direction
with respect to any Act may direct that the Act shall in
its application to the area, or to any specified part
thereof, have effect subject to such exceptions or modifications as he thinks fit.
810
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.G.R.
(2) The Governor may make regulations for the
A
peace and good government of any area in a Province
which j.s for the time being an excluded area, or a partially excluded area, and any regulations so made may
repeal or amend any Act of the Federal Legislature or
of the Provincial Legislature, or any existing Indian law,
B
which is for the time being applicable to the area in
question.
Regulations made under this sub-section shall be
submitted forthwith to the Governor-General and until
assented to by him in his discretion shall have no effect,
c
and the provisions of this Part of this Act with respect
to the power of His Majesty to disallow Acts shall apply
in relation to any such regulations assented to by the
Governor-General as they apply in relations to Acts of
a Provincial Legislature assented to by him.
(3) The Governor shall, as respects any area in a
Province which is for the time being an excluded area,
D
exercise his functions in his discretion."
After these two sections were enacted the Scheduled District Act
1874 became obsolete and was repealed by the Adaptation of
Laws Order 1936.
The question is : has the position changed in any way ? I E
think not. The fundamental fact, as I said before, is that article
244(2) very tersely says that the provisions of the Sixth Schedule
shall apply to the administration of the tribal areas in the State
of Assam. No inspiration can, therefore, be drawn from the
other parts of the Constitution. No doubt the Governor is the
constitutional head of the State of Assam having a Council of F
\Ministers. But the history of these backward tracts and the
scheme of the Sixth Schedule show that the Governor is intended
to discharge special functions in the administration of the Tribal
Areas in Assam in which a start in democratic institutions is being
made. There is no dyarchy in the Tribal areas in Assam so that
the Governor may be induced by the Council of Ministers to do G
contrary to what his judgment requires. Nor are the functions
of the Governor made subject to the scrutiny of the Government
of Assam. Indeed the Government of Assam is mentioned in
four places only and an examination Ieveals that no special power
has been granted to it at least in three places. In paragraph 3(a)
proviso it is provided that no law of the District or Regional
Councils shall prevent the compulsory acquisition of land for
public purposes by the Government of Assam, in paragraph 8
'
EDW!NGSON v. ASSAM
811
the assessment of land revenue and its collection by the Councils
is to be in accordance with the principles followed by the Government of Assam in the State of Assam generally, in paragraph
9 if any dispute arises between the Councils and the Government
of Assam: over the distribution of royalties the Governor is to
decide in his discretion what the Jlhare of each should be. The
B fourth and the last reference is at the end of paragraph 14(2).
Under that paragraph there is provision for the appointment of
Commissions for various purposes mentioned in the paragraph
and paragraph 16. One such commission considers the formation of and changes in the autonomous districts as contemplated
by paragraph 1(3)(c), (d), (e) and (f). The sub-paragraph conc templates all these reports because the report of every commission appointed for any purpose mentioned in paragraph 14(1)
or paragraph 16 together with the recommendations of the Governor and an explanatory memorandum regarding the action
proposed to be taken thereon by the Government of Assam has
to be laid before the Legislature of the State. Confining myself
D to the changes in autonomous districts contemplated by paragraph 1(3)(c), (d), (e) and (f), it is clear that if the State Government agreed with the Governor there would be no need explaining what action the Government was going to take. The State
Government would not then be required to take any action (apart
from implementing the decision administratively) and the GovE
ernor would notify the changes. The need for an explanatory
memorandum regarding the action proposed to be taken by the
Government would really arise in a situation in which the
Governor's recommendations are not accepted by the State Govermnent. We must not forget that there are many other matters
for which diverse commissions may be appointed and there would
F
be different kinds of reports. There may be room for detailed
differences over the reports of other commissions which the Legislature may have to consider. The Governor must be expected
to act independently and not with the advice of Ministers. Shoald
differences arise the Legislature would decide. It is intended
G to wield control over the Governor. It is the authority to decide
whether the Governor's action in annulling or suspending acts and
resolutions of District and Regional Councils should continue or
not. The Governor also has to obtain the previous approval of
the Legislature of the State before assuming the administration of
the area of a Council dissolved by him and the Council must be
H heard by the Legislature. There would be no need to bring in
the Legislature if the Governor was already being advised by
his Council of Ministers. Apart from this control of the Legisla-
A
-
(Hidayatul/ah, !.)
\
'
812
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
ture of the State in specified matters, there is nothing to show
that in addition the District and Regional Councils which are
autonomous in almost every way, are to be controlled by the
Council of Ministers through the Governor.
It is in this background that the action of the Governor must
be considered and the totality of the action taken this time compared with what was done in the past. I shall first take the
facts. The Commission made its report on the 24th January,
1964. In the opinion of Nayudu J. it is mentioned that the entire
proceedings were placed before the High Court and the learned
Judge observes that on 28th August, 1964, there was a note taken
on the file which read :
"In the present case we have not referred the matter
to H.E. (the Governor) at any stage".
A
B
C
The report together with the explanatory memorandum regarding
the action proposed to be taken by the Government of Assam
was placed before the Legislature of the State on September 25, D
1964. This memorandum in its last paragraph said :
"After a careful consideration of the report and the
recommendation of the Governor, the Government has
decided to accept the recommendations of the commission and give effect to them by taking necessary admiE
nistrative and other steps in this <;!irection."
There is no doubt a mention of the "recommendations" of the
Governor but in point of fact there was no recommendation. All
that the Governor did was to see the file before it went to the
Legislature and wrote "Seen, thanks". This in my opinion, and
I say it respectfully, hardly squared with the special responsibili- F
ties contemplated by the Sixth Schedule. When we turn to the
<:ommission's recommendations we find some confusion as to
whether a separate Regional Council was being recommended for
Jowai Sub-Division or a separate autonomous district. The
recommendation of the Commission reads :
G
"To sum up, we feel that if the inhabitants of the
Jaintia Hills work together and maintain the existing
system of administration, there is no reason why a separate District Council for Jowai sliould not be a success.
The establishment of a separate District Council would,
we think, resolve the prevailing tension and bitterness,
fl
due to lack of uniformity in administration, between
them and the Khasis, and we hope lead to a better
understanding between them.
EDWINGSON v. ASSAM (Hida,yatullah, !.)
A
B
-
c
813
We accordingly recommend the creation of a new
Autonomous District Council for the Jowai Sub-division
of the United Khasi and Jaintia Hills Autonomous
District by excluding the areas comprising the areas of
the said Sub-division from the United Khasi and J aintia
Hills Autonomous District. As we see it, the main
obstacle to smooth working of the new District Council
will be the Jaintias who are opposed to bifurcation.
In conclusion, we may point out that, according to
the 1961 Census, the area of Jowai Sub-division is
1,515 square miles with a population of 82,147 compared with 1,888 square miles and population of 54,319
in the North Cachar Hills, where there is already a
separate District Council".
The language is appropriate to the formation of a Regional
D .Council but it may be conceded that on the whole an autonomus
district was meant.
'
E
F
•
.G
H
In view of what I have said here bearing upon the special
responsibility of the Governor as envisaged by the sense and letter
of the Sixth Schedule considered in the light of the long and
'Uniform history of these backward tracts which have always been
•specially administered, it is perhaps right to think that the Governor was very much in the background and the initiative and
the formation of opinion was by the State Government. The
Governor was apparently only informed after everything was over
as to what was being done. No doubt the Governor's remarks
"Seen, thanks" did not express a dissent when he saw the file and
it may be presumed that he accepted the proposals of Government. But that was hardly what the Sixth Schedule expected
of the Governor. No material from any former occasion when
the changes were made in the tribal areas, was placed before us
10 show the practice or procedure then followed. The only
circumstance that has come to light shows that on three separate
occasions parliamentary legislation was undertaken, although it
is not in evidence whether it was supplemental to action under
;paragraph 1(3) by the Governor or without it. It is true that
legislative practice is not regarded as conclusive and it will be
less so here because Parliament was always competent to act by
itself to amend the Schedule. But it is a circumstance which also
points in the direction that Parliamentary legislation must cap
·all other steps if the Schedule is to read true to the new situation.
814
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
Without Parliamentary legislation amending the Schedule, readers
of the Constitution will have to hunt for Governor's notifications
to know what is the extent of tribal area in Assam, how it is
divided into autonomous districts and what is the tribal area
governed under paragraph 18. In course of time when many
iSUCh notifications have issued paragraph 20 will become obsolete
,and out of date. On the opposite view which I have been unable
to accept, it is, even today, inaccurate and does not mean what
it says.
In this view of the matter I am of the opinion that the appeal
l>hould be allowed and the respondent State ordered to bear costs
throughout.
;. r,:_"
A
>
B
-
c
ORDER
In accordance with the opinion of the majority the appeal is
dismissed with costs.
D
•
'
I
...
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org