STATE OF ORISSA versus SHYAM SUNDAR PATNAIK
Supreme Court of India | Decided 27 October 1965 | [1966] 2 S.C.R. 402 | 1965 INSC 232
Key facts
- Decided
- 27 October 1965
- Bench
- K. SUBBA RAO*, J.C. SHAH, S.M. SIKRI
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 382/1964
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1966] 2 S.C.R. 402
- Neutral citation
- 1965 INSC 232
Text of the judgment
A
STATE OF ORISSA
V.
•
SHYAM SUNDAR PATNAIK
October 27, 1965
B
[K. SUBBA RAo, J. C. SHAH AND S. M. SIKRI, JJ.]
Orissa Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1941-Family consisting of sons
of two deceased brothers whether Joint Hindu family for the purpose
of Cl. B of the Schedule to the Act-Income from milk derived from
cows and buffaloes maintained on agricu/lural lands whether agricultural
income.
The respondent represented a joint Hindu family consisting of himself, c
Ibis brother, and two sons of his father's brother. The joint family owned
agricultural land, cows and buffaloes. Under s. 10 of the Orissa Agricultural Income Tax Act, 1947, the income of joint Hindu family was
normally assessable as the income of one individual; but certain conces·•ions were given in cl. B. of the Schedule of the Act to a aoint family
consisting of brothers only. The Explanation to the Schedule stated that
for the purpose of the Schedule 'brother' included the son and the son D
of a son of a brother, and the widow of a brother. For the assessment
years 1950-51, 1951-52 and 1952-53 the assessing authorities under the
Act did not allow to the family the benefit given 'by cl. .B of the
Schedule and refused to treat the income from ttnilk derived from cows
and buffaloes maintained by the assessee family as agricultural income.
The order of asse<Sment was confiFmed by the Assistant Collector but the
Agricultural Income-tax Tribunal gav~ the benefit of the rates in. the E
Schedule to the family and Vreated the lincome from milk as agricultural ·
income. Jn a reference the High Court confirmed the view• of the Tribunal. The State of Orissa appealed to this Court against the High
Court's order by special leave.
It was urged on behalf of the State that (1) a family consisting of
the sons of two brothers both of whom were dead was not a family consisting of "brothers only" under cl. B to the 'Schedule, (2) the income
F
from the milk in question was not agricultural income.
HELD : If by the Explanation clause the expression "brother" has
been given an artificial meaning as inclusive. of the son and the son of a
'Son of a brother, it would be difficult to regard the family as not consisting of brothers only. For the purpose of interpreting cl. B Explanation (i) must be incorporated in the expression '1consisting of brothers
only" and by so doing the conclusion is inevitabl-~ that an undivided family
consisting of sons of deceased brothers, for the purpose of taxation under
the Orissa Agricultural Income-tax Act, would be regarded as one consisting of "brothers only". [405 E-F]
G
•
•
•
•
The question whether income from milk derived from milch cows
maintained by the respondent's family was agricultural income was held
to be concluded by lthe court's decision in Con1missioner of Income-tax,
West Bengal, Calcutta v. Raja Benoy Kumar Sahas Roy, [1958] S.C.R. 101.
[404 CJ
C1v1r. APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeals Nos. 382 to
384 of 1964.
•,;j
H
OR!SSA V. S. S. PATNA!K (Shah, J.)
A
403
Appeals by special leave from the judgment and order dated
August 20, 1962 of the Orissa High Court in S.J.Cs. Nos. 16, 17
and 18 of 1961.
S. V. Gupte, Solicitor-General and R. N. Sachthey, for the
appellant.
B
The respondent did not appear.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
..
(
C
Shah, J. These three appeals relate to proceedings for asses>ment of agricultural income-taJC under the Orissa Agricultural
Income-tax Act, 1947, for the years 1950-51, 1951-52 and
1952-53, and raise common questions.
The respondent represents a joint Hindu family consisting of
four members, relationship between whom is explained by the
following table :
Jadimani Patnaik
I
D
Bhagaban Jatnaik
Biswamber Jatnaik
I
•
I
Binod
Behari
PuranChandra
I
Shyam
Laxmi-
Sunder
dhar
E
Before the relevant years of account Jadimani, Biswambar
and Bhagaban had died and Binod Behari, Puran Chandra.
Shyam Sundar and Laxmidhar were the surviving members of the
family. The joint family owned agricultural lands, cows and
buffaloes. The assessing officer determined the income of the
respondent for 1950-51 at Rs. 11,949, for 1951-52 at Rs. 10,850
F and for 1953-54 at Rs. 9,549. In these sums were included in
each year Rs. 200 as income derived by sale of milk of cows and
buffaloes maintained by the family. The order of assessment
was confirmed by the Assistant Collector of Agricultural Incometax. In appeals to the Agricultural Income-tax Tribun1l, the
G amount of Rs. 200 in each year derived from sale of milk was
excluded and the Tribunal gave to the respondent benefit of the
rates prescribed in the Schedule to the Act.
At the instance of the State of Orissa the following questions
were referred to the High Court under s. 29(2) of the Act:
H
" (I) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the
case the Tribunal is right in holding that income from
milk derived from milch cows maintained by the opposite party is not agricultural income so as to be assessed
SUPREME
404
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 2 S.C.R.
to income-tax under the Agricultural Income-tax Act,
1947.
( 2) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the
case the Tribunal is right in holding that the Hindu
undivided family represented by Sri Shyam Sundar
Patnaik in the instant case, is a Hindu undivided family
consisting of brothers only."
A
B
The High Court answered both the quest.ions in the affirmative.
The State of Orissa has preferred these appeals with special
leave.
Before us the correctness of the answer recorded by the High
Cmfrt on the first question is not challenged, because the question C
raised is concluded by the judgment of this Court in Commi.~
sioner of Income-tax, West Bengal, Calcutta v. Raja Bencry
Kumar Sahas Roy(').
The second question alone remains to be determined.
Section 2(1) of the Orissa Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1947 D
defines "agricultural income". Section 3 defines _the incidence of
tax on ;tgricultural income. By s. 5 it was provided at the m:derial time that agricultural income-tax shall be payable by every
person whose total agricultural income of the previous year exceeds five thousand rupees. By s. 10 it is provided :
E
" ( 1) The total agricultural income of a Hindu undivided family shall be treated as the income of one
individual and assessed as such :
"Provided that if a Hindu undivided family consists of brothers only as explained in the Schedule, the
total agricultural income of the family shall be assessed
F
at the rate specified in the Schedule.
"
(2)
Clause B of the Schedule prescribed the rates of agricultural
income-tax in the case of every Hindu undivided family consistiilg of brothers only :
G
(a) If the share of a I
brother is five thousand } Three pies in the rupee.
rupees or less
)
(b) If the share of a I The average rate applicable
brother exceeds five thou- ~ to the share of such brother
I if he were assessed as an
H
sand rupees.
) individual.
(I) [1958] S.C.R J,JJ.
•
'
OR!SSA V. S. S. PATNA!K (Shah, /.)
405
A
The Explanation to the Schedule states that for the purpose of
the Schedule "brother" includes the son and the son of a son of
a brother and the widow of a brother, and the "share of a
brother" means the portion of the total agricultural income of a
Hindu undivided family which would have been allotted to a
brother if a partition of the property of such family had been
B made on the last day of the previous year.
-
Binod Behari and Puran Chandra sons of Biswamber were
brothers, and Shyam Sundar and Laxmidhar sons of Bhagaban
were brothers. By the Explanation, the expression "brother"
includes the son and the son of a son of a brother. The learned
c Solicitor-General for the State of Orissa submitted that the four
members of the respondent could not be regarded as brothers within
the meaning of the Schedule Cl. B. The Solicitor-General concedes
that if in the year of assessment, Biswambar and Bhagaban were
living and were sought to be taxed as an undivided Hindu family,
they could obtain the benefit of cl. B of the Schedule. Eren if
D one of them had died before the year of account and the family
consisted of the surviving brother and the sons of the deceased
brother, the benefit of cl. B would, it is conceded, have been available. But, says the Solicitor-General, after the two brothers
Biswambar and Bhagaban died, the family could not be regarded
as consisting of brothers only. If, however, by the Explanation
E clause the expression "brother" has been given an artificial meaning as inclusive of the son and the, son of a son of a brother, it
would be difficult to regard the family as not consisting of brothers
only. For the purpose of interpreting cl. B, we must incorporate
the Explanation (i) in the expression "consisting of brothers only"
F and by so doing the conclusion is inevitable that an undivided
family consisting of sons of the deceased brothers, for the purpose
of taxation under the Orissa Agricultural Income-tax Act would
be regarded as one consisting of "brothers only''.
The appeals therefore fail and are dismissed.
There will be
no order as to costs.
Appeals dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org