AHMEDABAD MILL OWNERS' ASSOCIATION ETC. versus THE TEXTILE LABOUR ASSOCIATION
Supreme Court of India | Decided 10 August 1965 | [1966] 1 S.C.R. 382 | 1965 INSC 148
Key facts
- Decided
- 10 August 1965
- Bench
- P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR*, K.N. WANCHOO, M. HIDAYATULLAH, V. RAMASWAMI
- Bench size
- 4
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 167/1965
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1966] 1 S.C.R. 382
- Neutral citation
- 1965 INSC 148
Text of the judgment
382
AHMEPABAD MILL OWNERS' ASSOCIATION ETC.
v.
THE TEXTILE LABOU1t ASSOCIATION
A
August 10, 1965- -- - - -
[P. B. GAJilNDRAGADKAR, C.J., K. N. '\VANCHOO,
M. HIDAYATULLAH AND V. RAMASWAMI, JJJ
The Bom6ay Industrial Relations Act (11 of 1947), ss. 42 and 73Payment of dearness allowance based on cost of living index-Principles.
After the 2nd World War broke out the industrial employees at
Ahmedabad, who had organised themselves as the Textile Labour Asso- c
ciation (Respondent herein) raised a demand for payment of dearness
allowance to meet the cost of living which had shot up as a -result of the
War, and the demand became the subject-matter of arbitration and .:in
award by the Industrial Court at Boµibay. As a result of petitions filed
by the Parties· and references made to it, the Industrial Court had been
giving directions, from time to time, regarding the payment of dearness .
allowance awarded, on the basis of cost of living index number, %-1th
1926-27 as the base year. In the Second Five Year Plan, the Planning D
Commission recommended that the series of cost of living indices should
be revised, and accordingly, the L'libour Bureau and the Central Statistical
Organisation of the Government of India undertook family liYing surveys
in 1958-59. One of the centres chosen was Ahmedabad and the Govornment of India began ·to publish consumer price index number for the city
of Ahmedabad from 1960 with 1960 as the b.Se year. The Government
of India also advised the State Government to remove various anoma1ies E
~n the State series of the 'price index number and publish a new series
linking the State series with that of Government of India, with 2.98 as the
linking factor. The Government of Gujarat set up an expert Committee
to advise it on the question and. that Committee made reconlmendations
for the removal of anomalies and also suggested 3.17 instead of 2.98 as
the linking factor. In November 1963, the Government accepted the re·
commendations for removing the anomalies and adjusted the consunler
price index nfunber, and the appellants paid the dearness allowahce accor- F
ding to the adjusted consumer price index· number under protest. In
February 1964, the Government of Gujarat announced its decisiqn-. -~to
adopt the linking factor at 3.17. The appellants were. ,not willing 'to pay
dearness allowance according to the converted price in'dex number in spite
of· a representation by the employees, and, S'6, 11ie dispute \Vas referred to
the lndUS1trial Court under s. 73 of the Bombay Industrial Relations Act,
1946. The Industrial Court decided th~t ihe appellants should pay dearness allowance to their employees for .fhe month of March 1964 am! for G
subsequent months on the consumer price index numbers for Abmeaabad
published by the State Government since February 1964 by using the
index numbers in the series for Ahmedabad compiled by the Labour
B'ureau at Simla, and the linking factor of 3.17 adopted for linking that
series to the State series with the old base, and gave directiOns as to the
manner of paying the dearness allo\vance.
In their appeal to this Court, the appellants contended that : H
( i) the reference was invalid because, before making the reference to re·
quirements of s. 42, which prescribes the procedure which has to be followed by the employer or the eillployee if either of them wants a ch:inge
1
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. V. LABOUR
A
B
c
•
D
E
F
G
H
383
to be effected in the tenns of the existing award, had not been complied
with; (ii) the Industrial Court erred in overruling their contention that the·
new survey suffered from two major infirmities, (a) inadequacy of the
sample size, and (b) impropriety of the method of inten·iew adopted _by
the investigators; (iii) the linking factor of 3.17 was improper; and (1v)
the Industrial Court wa• not right in coming to the conclusion that the
additional burden which its award would impose upon the appetiants.
would not be beyond their financial capacity.
HELD : (i) The dispute must be treated as an industrial dispute, notwithstanding the fact that s. 42 had not been complied with, and the
Industrial Court was right in coming to the conclusion that the objection
raised by the appellant against the competence of the reference was n1iS··
conceived. [398 F; 399 E]
The Act is a con1prehensive piece of legislation and n1akes elaborate
provision for the regulation of relations between employers and employees
and for tlie settlement of disputes between them. Section 73 deals with
. the powers of the State Government to make a reference and as such, it
could not have been intended that those powers are to be controlled by
s. 42. Section 42 provides that, if an employer or employee intenn< to
effect any change in respect of certain industrial matters, he will have·- to·
give notice of such intention to the representative of the employees or tlae·
employer respectively. The section can have no application to cases where
the State Government itself wants to make a reference. The meaning of
the non-obstante clause with which s. 73 opens also unambiguouslv indi-cates that the power of the State Government to make a reference· is not
controlled by any other provision in the Act. The definiiion of "indusM·
trial dispute" ins. 3(17) is so wide and comprehens-ive, that, even if an•
award is subsisting between the parties, if a difference aris-es betweeri them,_
the said difference would amount to an industrial dispute for the purpose
of s. 73 and a notice of change need not be given, either by the employer
or by the employee. It is true that the power conferred on the State
Government to make a reference is nOt absolute or unqualified, but could
be exercised only if one or the other of the conditions ~pccified in sub-ss....
(1), (2) or (3) of s. 73 is satisfied. But once the State Government
ls satisfied, its power to make a referernce is not limited to cases where
notice o.f change has been given by the partie9 under s. 42, On principle
also, the _conferment of powe~ on the State, Governn1ent is fu1ly justified ..
because, 1f as a result of a dispute between the e:mployer and his emplo~
yees, a serious outbreak of disorder, or a breach of public peace is likt'ly·
to occur, or a serious or prolonged hardship to a large section of the
community is likely to ~e caused, ?r the indu_stry concerned is _likely
to be affec~~d adversely, it would be idle to requ:ie that even in the face·
. of such serious danger, the procedure prescribed by s. 42 must be fOllowed
before reference can be made under s. 73. [396 D-F; 397 E-H; 398 C-E, G;
399 C-B]
(ii) (a) : The appellants were not justified in contending that the
inadequacy of the size of the sample in relation to the universe of the
'vorking class families vitiated the enqu:ry. [414 HJ
From the Report of Family Living Survey among Industrial v..'orkers
.at Abmedabad, 1958-59, it appears that the survey and field work was
the result of the cooperation of several expert institutions, official :-i:s well
as non-official. and w·as based on accepted principles and methods. The
size of the sample was determined in the light of the permissible margin
of error and was selected by the application of scientific sampling techniques and according to the principle that it is the quality of survey
that is more important, not so much the size of the sample. If the quality
of investigation has improved, and the method of working out the sample
J84
SUPl.BMll
COUl.T
llBPOl.TS
[1960] I S.CN.
sunocy has made very great progrw, then, it would not be correct 10
•ay that because !he size of the sample in the survey was smaller a.•
rumpared «> the sire of the sample taken in 1926-27, the inadequacy of
the size on the subsequent occasion introduces an infirmity in the investigation itself. [409 II; 410 G; 412 D, E, G; 413 D-EJ
(b) The Industrial Court was right in rejecting the appelbnts' contention that the impugned survey and the index constructed as a re5Ult
of it, suffered from the infirmity that ::le investigation v..·a.s conductl.XI in
the 8UrYey by the intefView method. (416 DJ
Having regard to the fact that a majority of working class population
in India is illiterate the method of interview is the only method which can
he adopted.
Besides, according to expen opinion, the interview method•.
if prorerly aJopled gives belier results than the alternative method ~f
supplymg account books and written questionnaire. (416 A-CJ
A
B
(iii) A' the ap!'Cllants had not p!a=l before the Industrial Court any
material to justify their contention that for determining the linking factor,
!he behaviour of prices for two or th= years should have been studied.
it could not be said that the Industrial Court committed an error in upholding the decision of the Government of Gujarat that the linking factOr
should be 3.17. (419 F-G; 420 BJ
Tbe lndr•trial Court had to cboooe between two courses. One was to
work out an entirely new scale of basic wages founded not on the pr~
war level of 1939 but on the cost of living of 1960 as the base year and
to award dearness allowance thereafter. The Industrial Court thought
that to adopt that course might conceivably create a large number of new
.problems, disturbing industrial peace and would be outside its terms of
reference. Therefore, it approved the other course of linking the State
seri~ with the new 9Cries to maintain continuity, which was the method
adopted by the Government of Maharashtra also. (418 E, G; 419 Bj
(iv) The appellants had failed to substantiate the contention that the
additional burden would be beyond their capacity to pay. [429 E]
Tbe claim of the employees for a fair and higher wage is undoubtedly
based on the concept of social justice, and if employees are paid helter
wa~eo which would enable them to live in comfort and discharge thclr
obligations to the membcn of their familie-5 in a reasonable way, their
work would show an appreciable increase in efficiency. On the other hand.
industrial adjudication must take into account the problem of the additional
burden which such wage structure would impose UPon the employer and
consider whether the employer can reasonably be called upon to bear such
burden. The task of consrructing a wage structure must be tackled oo
the basi• that such wage structure •hould not be changed from time to
time. It is a long.range plan and in dealing with the problem, which b
difllcult and delicate the financial position of the employer and the future
prospects of the industry and the additional burden which may be impooed
on the consumer must be carefully examined. A broad and overall view
of the financial position of the employer mU5t be taken into account and
attempt should always be made to reconcile the natural and just claims of
the employees for a fair and hi~her wage with the capacity of the employer to pay it, and in determining such capacity, allowance must be
made for a legitimate desire of the employer to make a reasonable prollt.
Unusual profit or loss should not be allowed to play a major role. It
ii true that normally, once a wage structure is fixed employees .are reluctant
to face a reduction in the contemt of the wage packet: but hke all otha
problems associated ~th industrial adjudication, the decision of the pro.
blet'n must also be based on the major consideration that the confticting
D
E
F
G
H
1
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. V. LABOUR
A
B
c
D
•
E
'
F
G
H
385
claims of labour and capital must be harmonised on a reasonable basis;
and so, if it appears that the employer cannot really bear the burden of
the increasing wage bill, indusuial adjudication cannot refuse to examine
hi• case and should not hesitate to give him relief if it is satisfied that
if ouch relief is not given, the employer may have to close down his
business. The last principle, however does not apply to cases where the
wages paid to the employees are no better than the basic minimum wage.
If what the employer pays to his employees is just the basic subsistance
wage and if he cannot a!Iord to pay it, he would not be justified in carrying on his industry. Since the wages paid to the textile employee• at
Ahmedabad cannot be regarded as sub>istence wages or bare minimum
wages, it would not be open to the re>pondent to contend that the appellants must pay the wages whether the employers can aJiord to pay them
or not. If it is shown that the appellants cannot bear the burden and
that the implementation of the award would inevitably have extremely prejudlcial effect upon the continued existence of the industry itself, there
would be justification for revising the scale of dearness allowance. Jn
considering the financial position of the appellants it would not be appropriate to rely unduly on the profitability ratio which has been adopted by
the Bulletin issued by the Reserve Bank of India dealing with the cotton.
textile industry, or other single-purpose statements produced by the parties ..
Indusuial adjudication should not lean too heavily on such statements.
whilst attempting the task of deciding the financial capacity of the employer
in the context of the wage problem. Taking a broad view which emerged
from a consideration of all the relevant facts, there is little doubt that
the productivity of the industry is increasing and that the demand
foc textile products will never decrease in future. It is true that the
te><tile industry at Ahmedabad has been leaning very heavily on borrowings, but that is a peculiar feature of the extile industry at Ahmedabad .
It helps the development of the industry and so the extent of borrowings.
cannot be pressed into service for the purpose of showing that the financial
position of the industry is unsatisfactory. On the contrary, the harmonious:
relations which have consistently subsisted between the employer and thi>
employees, would help the textile industry in Ahmedabad in its prospects
IO'Wllrds speedy economic growth. [420 C-E, F-G; 421 A-C, E-G, H;
422 C, G-H; 426 B, F; 427 G-H; 428 A, D; 429 DJ
CIVIL AP PELLA TE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeals Nos. 167 tC>
173, 537 and 538 of 1965.
Appeals by special leave from the award dated October 26,
1964 of the Industrial Court Gujarat in Reference (I.C.) No. 67
of 1964.
M. C. Setalvad, R. J. Ko/ah, I. M. Nanavati, J. B. Dadachanji, 0. C. Mathur and Ravinder Narain, for the appellant (in
C.A. No. 167 of 1965).
R. J. Kolah, I. M. Nanavati, J. B. Dadachanji, 0. C. Mathur
and Ravinder Narain, for the appellants (in C. As. Nos. 168 and
170 of 1965).
N. A. Palkhivala, I. M. Nanavati, J.B. Dadachanji, 0. C.
Mathur and Ravinder Narain, for the appellants (in C. As. Nos.
169 and 173 of 1965).
I. M. Nanavati, J.B. Dadachanji, 0. C. Mathur and Ravinder
Narain, for the appellants (in C. As. Nos. 171and172 of 1965).
386
SUPUMB COUJlT REPORTS
[ 1966) l S.C.R.
J. B. Dadaclranji, 0. C. Mathur and Ravinder Narain, for the
appellants (in C. As. Nos. 537 and 538 of 1965).
S. R. Vasavada, N. M. Barot, N. fl. Shaiklr, R. M. Shukla.
A .. N. Buch and D. T. Trivedi, for the respondents.
C. K. Daplztary, Attorney-GC'11eral, K. L. Tlathi and B. R. G. K.
A char, for intervener N'o. I.
G. B. l'ai, J. B. Dadachanji, 0. C. Mathur
Narain, for intervener No. 2.
and
A
B
Raviiufrr
G. Ramanujam. for intervener No. 4.
B. Narayanaswami, J. B. Dadachanji,
Ravi11der Narai1~. for intervener No. 5.
0. C. Mathur
and
c
-
I. M. Nanamti, J.B. Dadac/umji, 0. C. Mathur and Ravinder
Narain, for intervener No. 6.
II. K. Sowani and K. R. Chaudlwri, for intervener No. 7.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Gajendrogadkar, CJ.
Tbis is a group of seven appeals which
arise from an industrial dispute between the ~ppcllants, the
Ahmedabad Millowncrs' Association, Ahmedabad. and 67 employers on the one hand. and the respondent, the Textile Labour
Association. Ahmcdabad, on the other. This dispute was referred
by the Government of Gujarat to the Industrial Court, Gujarat,
under section 73 of the Bombay Industrial Relations Act, 1946
(No. XI of 1947) (hereinafter called 'the Act'). In making the
order of reference. the Government stated that 1t was satisfied
that the industrial dispute in question was not likely to be settled
by oth:!r means. The dispute itself consisted of three questions.
These questions have been thus stated in the reference : "(!) Whether under the award of the Industrial
Court, Bombay. dated the 2nd March, 1950, in Reference (IC) No. 189 of 1949 (as suhsequcntly modified)
read with award of the Industrial Court date<l the 27th
April, 1948, in Revision Petition No. Misc. 1 of 1947,
the Ahmcdabad Millowners' Association and the emploers mentioned in the Annexure arc bound to pay dearness allowance to their employees on the Consumer Price
Index )';umbers for working class for Ahmedabad published by the State Go"ernment since February, 1964,
by using the index numbers in the series for Ahmedabad compiled hy the Labour Bureau, Simla, and the
linking factor of 3.17 adopted for linking that series to
the State series with the old base;
D
•
E
,
F
G
H
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
•
H
387
(2) If not, whether the said Ahmedabad Millowners' Association and the employers mentioned in the
Annexure should pay dearness allowance to their
employees for March, 1964 and subsequent months in
terms of the aforesaid awards, by treating the index
numbers for working class for Ahmedabad published by
the State Govenunent since February, I 964, as the index
numbers in the State series compiled on the basis of the
family budget survey made in 1926-27;
(3) If not, how the dearness allowance to the aforesaid employees for March 1964 and onwards should be
paid on the index numbers for Ahmedabad published by
the State Government since February, 1964".
The Industrial Court has answered the first question in favour
of the appellants, whereas the two remaining questions have been
answered in favour of the respondent. In the result, the appellants
have been directed to pay dearness allowance to their employees
for the month of March, 1964 and for subsequent months 0n
the consumer price index numbers for working class for Ahmedabad published by the State Government since February, 1964,
(by using the index numbers in the series for Ahmedabad compiled by the Labour Bureau, Simla, and the linking factor of 3.17
adopted for linking that series to the State series with the old
base) at the rate of 2.84 pies per day for rise of each point in
the cost of living index number over the pre-war figure 73. The
Industrial Court has further directed that as per the award in
Miscellaneous Application (IC-G) No. l of 1960, 75% of the
average dearness allowance of the first six months of 1959, i.e.,
Rs. 63-15-9 per month of 26 working days, shall be consolidated
with the basic wage and the difference between the dearness allowance as worked out as indicated and the said sum of Rs. 63-15-9
shall be continued to be paid as dearness allowance. The other
terms and conditions in regard to payment of wages, including the
dearness allowance, shall continue as under the existing award.
The Industrial Court has made it clear that these directions should
be given effect to from 1st of January, 1965 and the difference
between what is paid and what has become payable under the
present award shall be paid on or before April 30, 1965. It
appears that before the Industrial Court an agreement had been
reached between the Fine Knitting Co. Ltd. of Ahmedabad and
the Textile Labour Association, and the award has, therefore,
provided that the directions issued by it shall apply only to the
spinning department of the Fine Knitting Co. and not to the
388
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
(1966] I S.C.R.
hosiery department. It is against this award that the appellants
have come to this Court by special leave. On January 5, 1965,
while granting special leave to the appellants. this Court directed
that the statements of the case should be dispensed with and the
appeals be listed for hearing in the week commencing March 8,
1965. That is how these appeals have now come for final disposal
before us.
A
B
Before dealing with the points raised by the appellants in these
appeals. it is necessary to set out somewhat elaborately the previous history of the present dispute. lbc story about the payment of dearness allowance to textile industrial employees at
Ahmcdabad takes us back to the time when the Second World c
War broke out in September, 1939. As is well-known, as a
result of the said War, the cost of living shot up; and in consequence, the industrial employees at Ahmedabad who had organised themselves as the Textile Labour Association, Ahmedabad,
raised a demand for payment of dearness allowance. This demand
became the subject-matter of arbitration by the Industrial Court D
at Bombay (Case No. 1 of 1940). The Industrial Court had to
consider, inter a/ia, two major questions; the first was as to what
was the extent of the rise in the cost of living consequent upon
the Second World War; and the second was as to the extent and
manner in which the said rise in the cost of living should be
neutralised by the payment of dearness allowance. The Industrial E
C'..ourt examined the matter at great length and came to the conclusion that for the purpose of determining the quantum of dearness allowance to be paid to the employees, it would be reasonable
to rely on the working class budget inquiry which had been conducted by the Government of Bombay between August, 1926 and
July, 1927. Another similar inquiry had been conducted by the F
same Government in 1933-35, but the Industrial Court preferred
to base its conclusions on the first inquiry. On the basis of the
cost of living index taken as I 00 for the base year 1926-27, the
index for August 1939 which stood at 73 was accepted as datum
index, so that the rise in cost of living over the datum index of G
73 had to be neutralised by payment of dearness allowance to the
employees.
Having reached this conclusion on the first question, the Industrial Court examined the problem as to the extent and method by
which the rise in the cost of living should be neutralised. On this
question, its conclusion was that for 11 points rise (which is
equivalent to a rise of 15%) in the cost of living for the month
of December, a cash relief to the extent of 10 per cent of the
•
•
•
II
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
A
B
C
D
E
'
389·
average wage, i.e. Rs. 3-8-0 per employees, should be awarded
for the month of December and a similar relief proportionately
determined should be awarded for other months. It was urged
bdore the Industrial Court that relief could be granted to the
employees in kind rather than in cash; but this contention was
negatived by the Court, though it expressed a hope that the
employers should start cost price grain shops at convenient centres
for the benefit of the employees. That, in substance, is the result
of the proceedings in Case No. 1 of 1940. It is with the decision
of this dispute that the story about the payment of dearness allowance under an award began in Ahmedabad in respect of textile
Jabour. It appears that as a result of this award, 66-2/3 per cent
neutralisation was allowed.
This award continued to be in operation till September, 1941.
On August 12, 1941, an agreement was entered into between the
appellants and the respondent by which it was resolved that the
dearness allowance to be paid to the employees in the member
Mills of the appellant Association be raised by 45 per cent from
the month of July, 1941, and in accordance with this agreement,
an award was made by the Industrial Court on September 15,
1941. As a result of this award, neutralisation came to be effected
to the extent· of 96% on the average wage over the pre-war cost
of living index of 73 in August, 1939, and to that extent the
respondent gained. We have already noticed that the neutralisation which was effected by the earlier award was 66-2/3 per cent.
Two years thereafter, the appellant Association filed a petition
(No. 1 of 1943) for a substantial reduction in the quantum of
dearness allowance. It urged that in the year 1943, the textile
F industry at Ahmedabad had suffered considerable loss in its
profits, and so, it was necessary that the dearness allowance fixed
by the consent award should be reduced. When the matter was
considered by the Industrial Court, it was discovered that the
claim made by the appellant Association was not substantiated
by sufficient or satisfactory data in the form of published balanceG sheets for the year 1943. The Industrial Court, therefore, refused
to interfere with the award, but permitted the appellant Association to raise the same dispute in April, 1944 if it thought necessary
to do so. No such application was, however, made by the
appellant Association in 1944, with the result that the consent
award passed on September 15, 1941, continued to be in operaH tion.
The said consent award had provided that the member mills
were to pay the dearness allowance prescribed by it till the termi-
390
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] I S.C.R.
nation of the Second World War; and so, as soon as the war came: A
to an end, the member mills stopped the payment of dearness allow.ance with effect from M<ay 8, 1945. The respondent then filed
Petition No. I of 1945 before the Industrial Court asking for a
direction against the appellant Association for pay1n~n1 <'f :he
deame!>.; allowance on t~c same scale as wa; then preB
vailing for three montl1s after May 8, 1945. This prayer
granted by the lndu;trial Court. That is how matters stood as a
result of the order passed on Petition No. I of 1945.
l\.kJnwhilc, the respondent gave a notice of change on May 20.
1945 and demanded continu<mce of the payment of dearness allowance until the working class cost of living index for Ahmedabad
stood above 73. It suggested that the quantum of dearness alllowance should be related to the cost of living index as awarded by
the lndtblrial Court Award dated tile 26th April, 1940, and
revised by the subsequent Award dated the 15th September. 1941.
While making this demand, the respondent made it clear that this
demand was made without prejudice to the claim of the employees D
for a revision in the entire wage structure. It appears that during
lhe course of these proceedings, it was urged bdor~ the Industrial Court that the rise in the cost of living should he wmputed
not with reference to the index figure of 73 in August, 1939, but
with reference 10 the figure of I 00 in 1926-27. This contention
was, however, rejected by lhG Industrial Court. By its award, the E
Industrial Court directed that neutralisation should be effected
to the extent of 76 per cent. As a result of this decision, the
Court awarded Rs. 4 for 11 points rise in the cost of living
index.
In 1946, the respondent moved for the revision of the said
award (Revision Petition No. I of 1946). By this revi>ion peti- F
tion, the re-spondent claimed that tl1e rise in the cost of living
should be neutralised fully instead of 76%, and this claim was
based on the allegation that the profits of the textile industry had
maintained a high level and the reduction in the extent of neutralisation from 96% to 76% in the award of the previous year had
adversely affected the employees and they had in fact begun to G
leave the industry. It may be pointed out that on all these occasions, the appellant Association urged before the Industrial Court
that the average monthly income and expenditure of the textile
employees in Ahmedabad left surplus with them and the need for
neutralising the rise in the cost of living was not as much as was
sought lo be made out by the respondent. This contention has, II
however, been consistently rejected by the Industrial Court. Even
so, the claim made by the respondent for increasing the extent of
"''L'
•
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
391
A neutralisation was rejected by the Industrial Court, liberty being
reserved to both the parties to approach the Court with a request
for continuance or revision of the allowance at the end of seven
months.
'
As soon as seven months expired, the respondent filed a ReviB sion Petition (No. 1 of 1947) before the Industrial Court on
March 8, 1947. By this petition, the respondent renewed its
claim for an increase in the dearness allowance. Meanwhile, the
minimum wage for textile employees in Bombay had been fixed
at Rs. 30 and dearness allowance was awarded to them with the
object of neutralising the rise in the cost of living to the extent of
c 90% on the minimum wage of Rs. 30. Taking advantage of the
fact that the minimum wage for textile employees in Bombay had
been fixed at Rs. 30, the appellant association urged that there was
no occasion to increase the rate of dearness allowance because the
wages of the employees had already been increased under the
standardization scheme which had been adopted in Ahmedabad.
D Alternatively, the appellant Association contended that if the Court
was inclined to revise the dearness allowance, it should follow the
same formula as in Bombay and provide for neutralisation at
the most at 90% on the minimum wage of Rs. 28 in Ahmedabad.
This contention was, however, rejected by the Industrial Court.
By its award, the Court directed that the rise in the cost of living
E over pre-war level of 73 in the case of the lowest paid employee
should be neutralised to th_e extent of' l 00% and all employees
earning Rs. 150 or less a month should be paid at a flat rate. On
arithmetical calculation, it was found that this rate came to 2.84
pies per day for rise of each point in the cost of living index
number over the pre-war figure.
F
•
The appellant Association issued a notice on October 31,
1949, purporting to terminate this award with effect from 1st
January, 1950. The ground for terminating the award set out
by the appellant Association in its notice was that the textile
industry in Ahmedabad was passing through a crisis and that cerG tain mills were completely closed down while others were partially
closing down. It appears that about that time, the Central Government acting in pursuance of the recommendations made by
the Tariff Board, directed a 4% cut in ex-mill cloth prices; and
that, according to the appellant Association, led to a crisis in the
financial affairs of the textile industry at Ahmedabad. It was also
H alleged in the notice that though the prices fixed were uniform,
Qte dearness allowance paid was not uniform and that the member
mills of the appellant Association were paying Rs. 15-4-0 more per
SUPREME
COURT REPORTS
(1966] I S.C.R.
month per employee in dearness allowance at Ahmedabad as
compared to that paid to the textile employees in Bombay.
Arithmetic:d calculations showed that as a result of this extra payment, the Ahmedabad mills had to bear an additional burden of
Rs. 238 lakhs in 1949 as compared to the burden borne by the
Bombay textile mills.
Before the notice thus issued by the appellant Association came
into force, the respondent gave a notice of change to the mills to
continue t<> ray the dearness allowance according to the existing
award; and since no settlement could be reached between the
parties, a reference was made to the Industrial Court. As a result
of these proceedings, however, neither party scored a victory, and
the award directed that payment of the dearness allowance should
he made in accordance with the order.s passed in Revision Petition
No. 1 of 194 7. Since the date when this order was made, the
terms of the award in Revision Petition No. 1 of 1947 have been
in operation between the parties.
A
,
8
c
Meanwhile, the Central Wage Board for the Cotton Textile D
Industry was constituted. One of the points which the Wage
Board had to consider was the demand made by the employees for
consolidating a part of the dearness aUowance in the basic wage.
The Wage Board recommended that 75% of the dearness allowance should be consolidated in the basic wage, and the remaining E
25% should bear a flexible character. The Board also made other
recommendations which arc not relevant for our purpose. In
consequence of the recommendation made by the Board as to
the consolidation of the dearness aUowance, an agreement was
reached between the appellant Association and the respondent,
as a result of which a joint application (No. I of 1960) was made F
hy both the parties under s. I l 6A of the Act; and on this joint
application an award by consent was passed directing that 75%
of the average dearness allowance of the first 6 months of 1959
which is Rs. 63-15-9 p.m. of 26 working days should be con~olidatcd with the basic wage, and the balance of the dearnes.~
allowance should be paid as worked out on the existing basis. G
That is how matters then stood between the parties.
It appears that about this time, there was a growing feeling
amongst both the employers and the employees that the different
series of consumer price index compiled and published in India
were not very satisfactory and some of them had become obsolete.
In the Second Five Year Plan, it was, therefore, recommended
that it was desirable that steps should be taken simultaneously with
the undertaking of wage census to institute enquiries for the
•
-
•
H
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
393
revision of the present series of cost of living indices at different
centres. According to the recommendation made by the Planning
Commission Report, the Labour Bureau, Simla, and the Central
Statistical Organisation of the Government of India took steps to
conduct fresh family living surveys among working class and
middle class population respectively with a view to construct the
B new series of consumer price index numbers. The working class
&llrveys were conducted at 50 selected centres and the middle
class surveys at 45 centres, 18 centres being common to both. The
work of these surveys was commenced in the second half of 1958
and was concluded by September, 1959. One of the centres
selected for this survey was Ahmedabad. The Government of
c India began to publish consumer price index number for the city
of Ahmedabad, having index number 100 for the base year 1960.
The publication of these series naturally raised the problem of
arriving at a linking factor between the present series published by
the State Government and the new series published by the GovemD ment of India. The Government of India considered this problem and indicated that 2.98 would be a proper linking factor.
This figure was arrived at as a result of taking the annual average
of the monthly index numbers of the State series for 1960 which
then stood at 298. For the base year of 1960, the figure of the
new series was 100 and the linking factor was, therefore, taken
E at 2.98.
A
,
F
G
H
It then appeared clear that there were several anomalies in
regard to the collection of prices in the State series. Some of the
items wlrich were specified in such series had ceased to exist,
whereas quotation for one major item, v(z., house rent allowance
bad been frozen for many years. After the Government of India
began to publish its new series, it advised the Government of
Gujarat to stop publislring its old series and publish the converted
index in its place. The Government of India thought that it would
be unjust to the employees if the conversion were allowed to take
place without removing anomalies of the State series.
Faced with this problem, the Government of Gujarat set up
an expert Committee under the Chairmanship of Dr. M. B. Desai.
The terms of reference of this Committee were thus formulated : "(1) to examine the validity of the submissions and
representations made to Government and to make
recommendations as to whether any readjustment is
necessary in the existing series for Ahmedabad published by the State Government, and if so, what readjustment should be made;
394
SUPREME
COURT REPORTS
[1966] I S.C.R.
(2) to consider how the new series of Consumer
Price Index Numbers for Ahmedabad should be linked
with the existing series, so readjusted if found necessary;
and in so considering, to take into consideration the
factor that the period of family budget enquiry on which
the new series for Ahmedabad is based is different from
the base period for the said new series".
The said Committee made a fairly exhaustive investigation, and
made two main recommendations. The first recommendation
involved an addition of 19 points in the overall price index in the
State series and the same was fixed at 317 instead of 298 as it
stood when the new series and its base period were decided upon.
The other recommendation which it made was that the conversion
or the linking factor should be 3. 17 as against 2. 98 per point in
the new series.
The Government of Gujarat accepted the first recommendation and revised the index number for the month of November,
1963, by adding 19 points to the figure originally released by it
and stated that its existing series would be adjusted month to
month by the addition of 19 points for adjusting the index for
clothing and house rent groups as recommended by the Fxpcrt
Committee. In regard to the second recommendation, the
Government took the view that it was necessary lo continue publication of the current series to permit industry and Jabour time to
have necessary modifications in the existing agreements, settlements and awards made to link up the dearness allowance with
the new series published by the Labour Bureau, Simla. This decision was announced by the GO\ crnment by a Press Note on
January 31, 1964.
When this deci,inn of the Government of Gujarat was
announced, the appellant Association found that it entailed considerable additional hurdcn on the textile indmtry: even so, it
advised its member milb to P"Y the dearness allowance according
to the adjusted consu111cr pric,· index number hy '1dding 19 points
for the month of JanU<lr). 1964. under prote't. This protest was
expressed by th,· President of the ,\ppcllant Association by issuing
A
B
•
c
D
.•
E
F
G
a prcs"i conltnuniquc critici~inµ the Governn1cnt for its unilateral
and hasty dcci,ion in the matl<'r.
On Fcbru;iry 29. I 964. the Government of Guj;irat issued
another Pre:;s Note hy which it accepted the second recommendation made by the Expert Committee to take the linking factor at
317 instead of 298. The Pre" Note shows that this decision was
reached by the Gmcrnment of Gujarat in acc,1rdance with the
11
-
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
39 5.
A
•
..
advice received from the Government of India. In consequence·
of this decision, the Government of Gujarat discontinued publication of the cost of living index number of its 1926-27 numbers
from January, 1964. This decision of the Government raised a
storm of protest from the appellant Association. A general meeting of the members of the appellant Association was held· on
B March 30, 1964, and it passed a resolution to the effect that the
discontinuance of the publication of the cost of living index by
the Government of Gujarat made it impossible for the appellant
Association to comply with the terms of the existing award in
respect of the payment of dearness allowance in the manner prescribed by the award and so, the appellant Association advised its
c members to pay to their employees dearness allowance for the
month of March, 1964, calculated on the basis of the last published index number for the month of December, 1963 in the
State's 1926-27 series and to continue to pay dearness allowance
for succeeding months on the basis of the same index number till
such time as the Government of Gujarat resumed publication of
D
index numbers in the said series. According to the appellant
Association, as a result of the decision of the Government of
Gujarat, an unbearable burden would be imposed on the members
of the appellant Association in the matter of dearness allowance;
and so, it was not prepared to accept that decision .
E
•
.
When the appellant Association adopted this attitude, the
Secretary of the respondent Association expressed his profound
sorrow at the decision of the appellant Association, and by his
letter addressed to the appellant Association on April 3, 1964,
he requested the members of the appellant Association to pay
dearness allowance to their employees according to the converted
F number published by the Government of Gujarat. This letter was
accompanied by a resolution passed by the respondent Association
in which it set forth its version of the financial position of the
members of the appellant Association and the justice of the claim
made by the employees for the payment of dearness allowance
G in accordance with the decision of the Government of Gujarat.
The appeal thus made by the Secretary of the respondent Association did not, however, receive any sympathetic response from the
appellant Association; and that made it necessary for the Government of Gujarat to refer the present dispute to the Industrial Court
at Gujarat under s. 73 of the Act. That, broadly stated, is the
H background and the previous history of the present dispute.
At the hearing of the present reference before the Industrial
Court. the appellants had urged a preliminary objection against
396
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966) I SC.R
the competence of the present reference. They contended that
the reference under s. 73 of the Act was invalid, because, before
making the reference, the requirements of s. 42 of the Act had not
been complied with. The argument was that, in substance, the
reference relates to a change in the terms of the award binding
between the parties, and for effecting such a change, the proce
<lure prescribed by s. 42 and the other sections in Chapter VJil
of the Act has to be complied with. It is common ground that the
>aid procedure has not been followed and the Government or
Gujarat has made the present reference in exercise of the power
<:onferred on it by s. 73. The Industrial Court has rejected the
appellants' contention and ha~ held that the reference is valid.
Mr. Setalvad for the appellants has urged before us that the view
taken by the Industrial Court is not justified by the terms of s. 73
read along with s. 42 of the Act.
A
•
B
,
-
C
The Act was passed by the Bombay Legislature in 1947. It
purports to regulate the relations of employers and employees, to
make provision for settlement of industrial disputes, and to pre>- D
vide for certain other purposes. It is a comprehensive piece or
legislation and it makes elaborate provisions for the regulation of
relations between employers and employees and for the settlement of disputes between them. Section 42 of the Act provides
for a notice of change. It is unnecessary to cite the provision! of
the said section, bccau.se for the purpose of dealing with the point E
raise<! by Mr. Setalvad, it would be enough if we state the sum
and substance of s. 42 (I) & (2). Section 42 (I) provides tbat if
an employer intends to effect any change in respect of an indll5trial matter specified in Schedule II, he will have to give noice
of such intention in the prescribed form to the representative of
employees. Similarly, s. 42 (2) provideqhat if an employee desires F
a change in respect of an industrial matter not specified in
Schedule I or III, he shall give notice in the prescribed form to
the employer through the representative of employees. Mr. Setal\"ad relics on the fact that Entry 9 in Sch. II relates to wages
including the period and mode of payment, and he points out
that the definition of "wages" prescribed by s. 3(39) includes G
dearness allowance. His case is that the present dispute falls
under Sch. II, Entry 9, and if the employees had intended to make
a change in the existing award in relation to the payment of dearness allowance, it would have been necessary for them to take
action as prescribed by s. 42(2). Since it is common ground that H
no notice of change has been given by the respondent, it is urged
that the reference made by the Government of Gujarat under s. 73
d the Act is invalid. It would be noticed that this argument
•
•
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gaiendragadkar, C.J.)
397
A assumes that the provisions of s. 42 would govern the provisions
of s. 73. The question is : is this assumption well-founded?
Let us then read s. 73; it reads thus : "Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, the
State Government may, at any time, refer an industrial
B
dispute to the arbitration of the Industrial Court, if on
a report made by the Labour Officer or otherwise it is
satisfied that( 1) by reason of the continuance of the dispute(a) a serious outbreak of disorder or a breach
of the public peace is likely to occur;
(b) serious or prolonged hardship to a large
section of the community is likely to be
caused; or
( c) the industry concerned is likely to be
seriously affected or the prospects and scope
for employment therein curtailed; or
(2) the dispute is not likely to be settled by other
means; or
(3) it is necessary in the public interest to do so".
'
c
D
E
'
On a fair reading of s. 73, it is plain that it deals with the powers
of the State Government to make a reference and as such, it is
difficult to assume that the said powers of the State Government
are intended to be controlled by the provisions of s. 42. Section 42
prescribes the procedure which has to be followed by the employer
and the employee respectively if either of them wants a change
F to be effected as contemplated by it. The scheme of s. 42 read
along with the other provisions in Ch. VIlI clearly shows that
the said Chapter can have no application to cases where the State
Government itself wants to make a reference. That is the first
consideraion which militates against the construction which
G Mr. Setalvad suggests.
The opening clause in s. 73 also unambiguously indicates that
the power of the State Government to make a reference will not
be controlled by any other provision contained in the Act. This
clause plainly repels the argument that the provisions of s. 42
should be read as controlling the provisions of s. 73. The meaning
H of the non-obstante clause is clear and it would be idle to urge
that the requirements of s. 42 must be satisfied before the power
under s. 73 can be invoked by the State Government.
L6Sup.CI/6S-1 I
398
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1966) I S.C.R.
It is, however, urged that the power conferred on the State
Government by s. 73 is the power to refer an industrial dispute
to the arbitration of the Industrial Court, and there can be no
industrial disput0 unless a notice of change has been given either
by the employer or the employee. In other words, the argument
is that unless a notice of change is given as required by s. 42, no
industrial dispute can be said to arise between the employer and
his employee, and that is how s. 42 governs s. 73. If it was the
true legal position that there can be no industrial dispute between
an employer and his employee unless a notice of change is given
by either of them, there would have been some force in this contention; but the definition of the words "industrial dispute" does
not ju\tify the assumption that it is only a notice of change that
bring' into existence an industrial dispute. Section 3 ( 17) of the
Act defines an "industrial dispute" as meaning any dispute or
difference between an employer and employee or between employers and employees or between employees and employees and
which is connected with any industrial matter. This definition is
so wide and comprehensive that it would be impossible to accept
the argument that it introduces the limitation suggested by
Mr. Sctalvad. Even if an award is subsisting between the parties
but a difference arises between them, as in the present case, it is
not easy to hold that the said difference does not amount to an
industrial dispute for the purpose of s. 73 merely because notice
of change has not been given either by the employer or the employee. Therefore, we are satisfied that the dispute which has
been referred by the Government of Gujarat in the present case
must he treated as an industrial dispute, notwithstanding the fact
that s. 42 has not been complied with either by the appellants or
by the respondent.
It is true that the power conferred on the State Government
to make a rcicrence is not absolute or unqualified. It can be
exercised only if one or the other of the conditions specified by
sub-sections (I), (2) or (3) of s. 73 is satisfied. But once the State
Government comes to the conclusion that one or the other of the
said conditions is satisfied, it~ power to make a reference is not
limited to cases where notice of change has been given by the
parties as required by s. 42. It is an over-riding power which
is intended to be exercised to avoid anomalies or other
serious consequences which would flow in case the Government docs not make an immediate reference. The requirements
prescribed by sub-sections (!), (2) and (3) of s. 73 indicate the
types of cases which are intended to be referred without requiring
the parties to take recourse to ~- 42. In the present case, the
A
B
c
D
E
,
••
G
H
-
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
399
A Government of Gujarat was satisfied that the dispute was not
likely to be settled by other means, and so, it made the present
reference. Therefore, we do not think there is any substance in
the argument that the reference is bad, because s. 42 has not been
complied with. The tenns of s. 73 are plain and unambiguous
and they leave no doubt that the power of the State Government
B to make the reference is not at all controlled by the requirements
of s. 42.
On principle, the conferment of this power seems to be fully
justified. If as a result of a dispute between the employer and
his employees, a serious outbreak of disorder or a breach of the
C public peace is likely to occur, or a serious or prolonged hardship
to a large section of the community is likely to be caused, or the
industry concerned is likely to be affected adversely, it would be
idle to require that even in the face of such a serious danger, the
procedure prescribed by s. 42 must be followed before reference
can be made under s. 73. The very nature of the conditions
D prescribed by sub-sections (1), (2) and (3) of s. 73 emphasises
the fact that the said conditions refer to categories of cases or
types of occasions on which reference has to be made promptly
and immediately, and that explains the conferment of the wide
powers on the State Government as prescribed by s. 73. We are,
therefore, satisfied that the Industrial Court was right in coming
E to the conclusion that the preliminary objection raised by the
appellants against the competence of the present reference was
misconceived. It appears that a similar view has been expressed
by the Bombay High Court in Suryaprakash Weaving Factory v.
The Industrial Court(').
F
That takes us to the merits of the controversy between the
parties in the present appeals. Let us begin by briefly indicating
the broad contentions raised by the appellants before the Industrial Court and its findings on them which are relevant for the
purpose of the present appeals. The first contention which was
G urged before the Industrial Court was that the family living survey
which was conducted by the Labour Bureau, Simla, in 1958-59
was unreliable, because the sample survey on which it was based
was inadequate, and the interview method which was adopted in
conducting it was unsatisfactory. It was also contended that the
linking factor at 3.17 which had been adopted by the Government
H of Gujarat was unscientific and irrational; and that the scientific
and rational way to deal with the problem pre.<>ented by the new
(I) '2 B.L.R. 902.
400
SUPIJ!lB COU1T REPORTS
(1966) l S.C.R.
consumer price index recently adopted by the Government of A
Gujarat would bl! to devise a scheme of dearness allowance afresh,
taking the present basic salary as a base, and relating it to the
changing price pattern from month to month with the base year
1960 = l 00. The appellants' case in respect of this aspect of the
matter was that for the purpose of fixing the dearness allowance,
the basic salary should be taken to be the total amount which is B
paid to the lowest-pair! employee after consolidating 75% of the
dearness allowance in th<! basic wage. That amount, it is said,
represents the true basic wage today. In the alternative, it was
suggested that if it is intended to correlate the present prevailing
wage structure, including the scheme of payment of dearness
allowance, by making suitable adjustments required by the change c
in the level of prices in the light of the new consumer price index
with the same base year, it would be more rational and scientific
to watch the behaviour of prices for two or three years and then
devise a linking factor on the average rise in prices during the said
period. The appellanis also emphasised the fact that before the
D
Industrial Court accepts the new arrangement on the ba,is of the
linking factor of 3.17, it is essential to examine their paying
capacity, and in this connection, they strongly urged that the
burden which would be imposed on them by the new scheme
would be plainly beyond their capacity.
E
The validity of these contentions was strenuously disputed by
the respondent. It urged that the sample survey was conducted
on rational and scientific lines and it did not suffer from any
infirmity at all. It further argued that the attempt to construct a
new wage structure by taking the basic salary with 75% of the
consolidated dearness allowance as the basis with 1960 "" 100 as F
the base year, would be beyond the terms of reference, and it
would, besides, create many problems and complications. According to the respondent, the hasic salary still continues to be what
it was before, though for practical purposes 75% of the dearness
allowance has bxn consolidated with it. The respondent seriously
challenged the appellants' case that the operation of the linking G
factor was either unscientific, unreasonable or unjust; and the
appellants' theory that the average rise in prices should be determined after watching the behaviour of prices for two or three
years, was characterised by the respondent as unreasonable,
inexpedient and unscientific. The respondent emphaticallY contended before the Industrial Court that the appellants' financial 11
position was perfectly sound and the argument that the burdro
would be beyond their capacity is wholly untenable.
•
•
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
A
B
'
C
D
E
F
G
H
401
During the course of hearing before the Industrial Court, the
appellants examined two Experts, Mr. Gokhale and Mr. Chokshi.
They also led voluminous documentary evidence. The respondent
filed detailed statements disputing the correctn~ss of the pleas
taken by the appellants, and in support of them, they filed several
charts which were prepared from the balance-sheets of the appelJants themselves. Both parties referred to the opinions expressed
by several writers on the subject of the preparation of consumer
price index and on other matters which became relevant for the
decision of the present dispute. Broadly stated, the Industrial
Court has rejected all the contentions raised by the appellants.
It has found that the recent survey was conducted under the
advice and guidance of a technical advisory committee of a high
order and that the work of carrying on the survey had scrupulously
followed the relevant recommendations made by the International
Labour Office and the United Nations. The Industrial Court did
not accept the contention of the appellants that the sample size
was inadequate or had vitiated the quality of the survey. It held
that the method of inquiry adopted by the Investigators who conducted the survey was by no means unsatisfactory or unscientific,
and in its opinion, having regard to the local conditions, it was
indeed the most feasible and satisfactory way to adopt. The
adoption of the interview method did not, in the opinion of the
Industrial Court, introduce any infirmity in the survey. The
Industrial Court was thus not satisfied that the compilation of the
consumer price index number by the Labour Bureau, Simla, for
the city of Ahmedabad was not proper or was unscientific oc
suffered from any major infirmity.
In regard to the question of the linking factor on which both
parties addressed the Industrial Court elaborately, the Court considered the matter in the light of expert opinion cited before it
and held that the Government of India was justified in recommending a simple arithmetical method of linking; it found that
the said method had been accepted by the Expert Committee
appointed by the Government of Gujarat and had been recommended by the Expert Committee appointed by the Government
of Maharashtra as well. It, therefore, reached the conclusion that
the said method based on the application of the linking factor at
3.17 was the most suitable to adopt. In this connection, it rejected
the appellants' suggestion that the dearness allowance should be
paid at a flat rate and held that flexible dearness allowance alone
would meet the ends of justice and would lead to industrial peace.
It noticed the fact that now there was only one cost of living
index existing in Ahmedabad and that is based on the new series.
402
SUPlllllB
CO~T
RBPORTS
[1966] 1 S.C.R.
The old series had rightly gone out of existence since it had
become antiquated. In thb situation, there were two possibilities;
one was to work out an entirely new scheme of basic wages based
not on the pre-war level of 1939, but based on the cost of living
of 1960 as the base year and to award dearness allowance thereafter. The Industrial Court thought that if such a course was to
be adopted, it would create a brgc number of problems in the
industry and would seriously disturb industrial peace. It observed
that this aspect of the m:ilter would also be beyond the terms of
its reference. Neverthckss, it was inclined to take the view that
"the results in terms of rupees, annas and pies may also not be
very different"', if this alternative method was adopted. It
suggested that such a method may be adopted by the Central
Cotton Textile Wage Board which had been recently appointed
with a view to bring out a fair amount of uniform wage level all
over India; but speaking for itself. it held that it would not be
necessary, advisable or practicable for it to attempt that task.
That left only one alternative and that is the adoption of the
arithmetical method of linking. The argument that even if the
arithmetical method of linking is intended to be adopted, it should
be worked on the basis of the average result derived from watching the behaviour of prices during two or three years, does not
appear to have been seriously prc,;scd before the Industrial Court
and has not been examined by it.
The Industrial Court then considered the question about the
paying capacity of the appellants. As a matter of law, it rejected
the respondent's argument that a wage structure once constructed
by industrial adjudication can never be revised to the detriment
of workmen, and it held that if it was shown that the financial
position of the employer had substantially deteriorated and such
deterioration was likely to persist for some time, it would be open
to industrial adjudication to make a suitable revision of the wage
structure, provided, of course, the wage structure docs not represent the wages at their basic minimum level. Considering the
problem presented by the appellants' plea of incapacity to bear
the burden in the light of this legal position, the Industrial Court
has found that, in its opinion, the textile industry of Ahmedabad
is in a sound financial position. It has also added that "in any
event, there has been no substantial deterioration in its condition
so as to justify any wage cut or abandonment of the basic principles in respect of its employees which have been laid down in
the past". It is on these findings that the Industrial Court has
held against the appellants on issues 2 & 3. As we have already
mentioned, the Industrial Court has found against the respondent
A
B
'
D
I·
G
•
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
403
A on issue No. 1; but since the respondent has not challenged the
correctness of the said finding, it is only the conclusions of the
Industrial Court on issues 2 and 3 that fall to be considered in the
present appeals.
,
-
•
The first point which we must now consider is whether the
B appellants are justified in contending that the Industrial Court
erred in over-ruling their contention tliat the new survey suffered
from two major infirmities-inadequacy of the sample size, and
impropriety of the method of interview adopted by the Investigators. In support of this plea, the appellants examined Mr. Gokhale
as an expert witness. Mr. Gokhale who served in the Labour
c Office at Bombay from 1926 to 1937, was directly associated with
the family budget inquiries, compilation of cost of living index
numbers, and with the first General Wage Census conducted by
the Labour Office in Bombay. He also worked as Assistant Secretary of the Bombay Textile Labour Enquiry Committee. Later,
he joined the Millowners' Association, Bombay, as their Labour
D Officer on 1-1-193 8 and served in that capacity until he retired
on 1-11-1962. He was deputed on a study tour to Lancashire in
1951 and attended the International Labour Conference at
Geneva. He has also been a member of the l.L.O. Committee on
Women's Employment. According to Mr. Gokhale, the 'new
survey was not as scientific as it might have been. He was
E inclined to take the view that the sample selected in the Ahmedabad inquiries was very inadequate. He commented on the fact
that the choice of the size of sample was determined, inter alia,
on the ground· of the workload manageable by the investigator,
and he said that it was difficult for him to understand as to why
in deciding the sample size "workload manageable by the investiF gator" had to be considered as a relevant factor. He then produced a chart showing the ratio of the size of the universe with
the size of sample, and said that nowhere had he found such a
low size of the sample as in the impugned inquiry. The size of
the sample, according to him, in the impugned inquiry was less
G than even half a per cent of the population group which was
intended to be covered.
Mr. Gokhale was cross-examined by the respondent. It was
put to him that his experience in the matter of sample survey was
somewhat limited and that the said experience had now become
antiquated in view of the great strides of progress which had been
H made in the science of sample survey after 1926. He agreed that
sampling technique involves knowledge of statistics and statistics
involves mathematics, and he did not make any claim to be an
404
SUPRBMB COUllT llEPORTS
(1966) 1 S.C.R.
expert either in statistics or in mathematics. In his examination- A
in-chief, Mr. Gokhale appeared to criticise the extent of imputation which was evident in the preparation of the new series; but
in his cross-examination, he fairly conceded that imputations have
always got to be done in compiling consumer price index. It had
been done in the past, he said, as also in the case of the present
series. When he was asked whether he knew what the percentage B
of imputation was in the compilation of the consumer price index
of 1926-27, he admitted that he did not know. He was, however, reluctant to agree with the Labour Bureau in so far as the
application of their reasons to individual items was concerned,
and in support of his theory he relied upon the illustrations given
by him in the affidavit which he had filed before he gave evidence. c
The statements made by Mr. Gokhale in his affidavit were
disputed by the respondent and the accuracy and the validity of
the views expressed by him were seriously challenged by Mr. Vasavada who filed a reply on behalf of the respondent (Item 19).
In his reply, Mr. Vasavada referred to Clause 14 of the Resolu- D
tion as reported at p. 403 of the International Labour Code-1951
Vol. II; and emphasised the fact that the main distinguishing
feature of the new survey was that it was carried out under the
technical guidance of professional statisticians not only with
adequate knowledge of sampling theory but also with actual experience in sampling practice, and with the help of a properly trained E
field and computing staff. This was the requirement laid down
by the publications issued by the I.LO. and the United Nations
as a very important test, and the impugned survey fully satisfies
the said test. Mr. Vasavada also referred to the opinion expressed
by Dr. Basu who is at present the l.L.0. Expert on the subject, F
that the size of the sample should be determined in the light of
the permissible margin of error in the resulting series of consumer
price index numbers. In our country, the permissible margin of
error in the index has been broadly set at 2 per cent; and so, the
case set out by Mr. Vasavada on behalf of the respondent was
that when the permissible margin of error in the index is 2%. the G
number of families, viz. 722 taken at Ahmedabad. is highly satisfactory.
Mr. Vasavada then questioned the accuracy of Mr. Gokhale's
statement that such a small percentage of the universe had never
been adopted before in any other inquiry. He urged that the
present techniques have advanced so far that a small sample size
can achieve the best results; and he cited the example of a survey
carried out in the United Kingdom where the proportion of 13,000
H
'
.
.
..
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
A
B
'
c
D
E
F
G
households surveyed to the total households which constituted the
universe came to 0.1 % . The Industrial Court has considered the
evidence given by Mr. Gokhale and ha5 taken into account the
arguments urged on behalf of the respondent, and it has held that
the size of the sample selected for the impugned survey cannot be
said to introduce any infinnity in the survey. The question which
we have to decide is whether the Industrial Court was right in
coming to this conclusion.
In dealing with this question, it is necessary to refer briefly
to the genesis and growth of the science of Social Survey. "In
its broadest sense", says the Encyclopaedia of the Social Sciences,
"a social survey is a first hand investigation, analysis and coordination of economic, sociological, and other related aspects
of a selected community or group. Such a survey may be undertaken primarily in order to provide material scientifically gathered,
upon which social theorists may base their conclusions; or its
chief purpose may be to fonnulate a programme of amelioration of the conditions of life and work of a particular group or
community"('). Wells defines a social survey as a "fact-finding
study dealing chiefly with working-class poverty and with the
nature and problems of the community"(2). As Moser has, however, pointed out, "this definition might have covered tbe clasaical community and poverty studies but would hardly be adequate,
the first part at any rate, to the modern fonns of survey"(').
The history of social survey in England can be said to have
begun with the publication of Mayhew's book "London Life and
the London Poor" published in 1851; and Booth made a very
significant contribution to the scientific development of social
survey by publishing his book "Labour and Life of the People of
London'' (1889-1902). Rowntree followed with his book
"Poverty : A Study of Town Life". Thereafter, a number of
studies have been made by social scientists, and the subject of
the theory and practice of social surveys has been the subjectmatter of valuable and extensive literature all over the civilized
world. During the First World War and thereafter, social scientists devoted their attention to the problem of family living studies
mainly from the point of view of tbe impact of price changes on
consumers' economic situation. The development of reliable consumer price indices naturally involved the use of weights that
-~-
H
405.
----· ·-·· -·
(1) Encyclopaedia of th.: Socia{ Sci::nccs, Vol. XIV edited by Edwin R. A. Scligman, p. 162
(2) Wells, A. F. (1935). The Local Social Survey in Great Britain, Allen and
Unwin. London.
(3) "Survey Method1 in Social lnl'e1tigation"' by C. A. Moser, p,' 1.
406
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[I 966] l S.C.R.
would properly reflect the consumption expenditure of the population. This led to further extension of family living studies in
different countries and for different periods, mainly to secure information on patterns of consumption expenditure(').
The Second World War and the conditions that flowed from
it made it necessary to carry on investigations on a wide range of
inquiry relatintg to all aspects of lh''.ng conditions, e.g., nutrition,
health, education and employment. The whole question of family
living survey came up for consideration in the Seventh International Conference of Labour Statisticians in 1949. This Conference adopted a resolution defining the objectives of family
living studies and setting new international standards as regards
the organisation of enquiries and the analysis and presentation of
the results that flowed from it(').
rn India, a standardised statistical type of family living study
was first initiated in Bombay in I 921. Such enquiries were also
conducted in Sholapur in 1925, in Ahmedabad in 1926 and in
some centres in Bihar in 1923. While reviewing the position of
social surveys in India, the Royal Commission on Labour pointed
out the great paucity of statistical material in this country for
judging the standard of living of the workers and recommended
conduct of socio-economic enquiries of the type of family living
surveys. This report naturally gave an impetus to the conduct of
family budget enquiries. In all the surveys that followed, sampling
and interviewing techniques were adopted, though, of course, not
of a much advanced nature. A statistical analysis of the data
collected was also attempted(')
The Second World War saw the appointment of the Rau Court
of Enquiry constituted under the Trade Disputes Act, 1929. One
of the recommendations made by the said Court was that the
Central Government should take up responsibility for maintaining
up-to-date cost of living index numbers for important areas and
centres. The Government of India accepted this recommendation
and set up a special organisation called 'the Directorate of Cost of
Living Index Numbers' and family budget enquiries among industrial workers were conducted at 28 centres during 1944-45 in the
course of which 2, 700 budgets were collected. A remarkable
feature of these enquiries was that for the first time in this country,
an attempt was made to condnct such enquiries simultaneously at
a large number of centres under more or less uniform techniqnes.
During the same period, the Labour Bureau of the Government of
(I) Labour Sur,.y Techniques issued by the Labour Bureau, Ministnr of
Labour & Employment, pp.171-72.
(2) LIZbour Survey Techniques, pp. 171-72.
A
B
c
D
•
E
F
G
H
.,
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
"
'
407
A India and some of the Organisations of State Governments continued to conduct family budget enquiries from time to time at
specific areas or centres, either for deriving weighting diagrams
for consumer price index numbers or for collection of data
required for fixation of minimum wages(').
B
It was in the background of these events that the Second Five
Year Plan made a significant recommendation. The Plan said
that:"The existing wage structure in the country comprises, in the main, a basic wage and a dearness allowance. The latter component in a majority of cases has
c
relation to cost of living indices at different industrial
centres. These indices have not been built up on a
uniform basis; some of them are worked out on primary
data collected about 20 to 25 years ago and are, therefore, not a true reflection on the present spending habits
of workers. Since one of the questions which the wage
D
commission will have to take into account is the demand
made by the workers' organisations for merging a part
of dearness allowance with the basic wage, evolving
recommendations for such a merger will not be sufficiently scientific if cost of living indices at different centres do not have a uniform basis. Steps will therefore
E
have to be taken simultaneously with the undertaking of
a wage census, to institute enquiries for the revision of
the present series of cost of living indices at different
centres".
F
It is in pursuance of this recommendation that the 1impugned
survey was made.
Let us now see on what principles and methods the impugned
survey was made. It is necessary to begin the discussion of this
question with the observation "that the consumer price index
number measures nothing but changes in prices, as they affect a
G particular population group; and so, it is really a price index
number as distinct from a cost of living index number. In fact,
these indices used to be termed as cost of living index numbers in
the past, but in order to make their meaning clear, it was decided
by Government to change the name to consumer price index
numbers in accordance with international recommendations and
H growing practice in other countries. Most of the State Governments compiling such index numbers have also adopted this
(1) Labour Survey Te~hnjques, pp. 171-72.
408
SUPREME comT REPORTS
(1966] I S.C.R.
usage"('). This index number is intended to show over a period
of time the average percentage change in the prices paid by the
consumers belonging to the population group proposed to be
covered by the ind~x for a fixed list of goods and services consumed b: them. The a»crage percentage change, measured by
the index, is calculated month after month with reference to a
fixed p~rioJ. This fL~cd period is known as the "base-period" of
the index; and since the object of the index is to measure the
effect of price-changes only, the price-changes have to be determined with reference to a fixed list of goods and services of consumption which i> known as a fixed "basket" of goods and services.
A
The index docs not purport to measure the absolute level of
prices but only the average percentage chang~ in the prices of a
fixed basket of goods and services at different periods of time.
There are ccrtnin preliminary considerations which are relevant in
the construction of consumer price index numbers. The tint
consideration is the purpose which the index is intended to serve;
and that necessarily involves the definition of the group of consumers to which the index is intended to relate. Then it is necessary to determine the consumption level and pattern of the population group at a period of time which generally becomes the bJsepcriod of the index numbers. For that purpose, a list of commodities and services has to be made. Usually, this list would contain items of food, fuel and light, clothing, and others; items of
services, such as barber charges, bus fare, doctor's fee, etc., have
also to be selected. It is the combined total of the items of commodities and services that constitutes the basket. Then follows
a description of the quality of each commodity and service through
which price changes have to be measured. Generally, one quality
which is popularly consumed by the population group is selected
for each commodity and service. The importance or weight which
has to be attached to each commodity or service is also a material
factor. For instance, if rice is considered to be twice as important
~s wheat in the consumption pattern, the weight of rice will be
2 in relation to I of wheat.
C
Havin<> determined the consumption level and the pattern of
the popul:tion group, the next task to attempt is to arrange for
the regular collection of price data for the various qualities of
commodities and services which enter the basket. With this
material, the consumer price index has to be compiled from month
to month subsequent to the base period. That, shortly stated, is
(I}
A- <i;dd: to c-:Onn.s,,;,.~; ?rice JNkx iVumbers isslJld by the Labot•r Bureau,
M.O. Labour & Employment, 5.
B
-
D
E
'
F
G
H
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
A
•
-
\
409
the nature of the preliminary considerations which have to be
borne in mind while constructing the consumer price index numbers.
We have just noticed the theory of weights on which weighting
diagrams are prepared. Weights are intended to indicate the
B importance attached to the percentage changes in the prices paid
by consumers for different items (commodities and services) of
consumption. Accordingly, each item in the index is given, what
is called in technic2l language, a "weight" to represent the relative
importance of the price changes recorded for that item. This
weight means nothing more than the percentage of expenditure
C on each item of goods and services in relation to the total expenditure. It will thus be seen that the main basis for determining
the weights of respective commodities and services is the investigation of the family budget; and that emphasises the importance
and significance of a proper investigation. During the course of
investigation, data are collected on all items on which money has
D been defrayed by families; but only such items as involve consumption expenditure are included in ·the average budget. Even
so, it is only selected items which find a place in the index calculations, because it is obviously neither practicable nor necessary to include all items featuring in the average budget. Since
only a sample of items from each group is included in the index,
E it becomes necessary to enquire as to what happens to other items
featuring in the average budget but not included in the index.
Their weights are added or distributed to the items included in
the index, so that the total expenditure of the average budget is
fully taken into account in the weights adopted for the index.
F This process is known as "imputation" of weights. Besides the
weights the other set of primary data which enter into the compilation of a series of consumer price index numbers are the prices;
and that emphasises the importance of collecting material data
in respect of prices. The Investigator, therefore, has to bear in
mind all the relevant factors that ulti.mately go to the construction
G of the index, and has to carry on his investigation in a proper and
scientific way.
Having thus briefly reviewed the theoretical aspects of the
factors that govern the construction of consumer price index
numbers, let us now proceed to see how the impugned inquiry
was in fact held. The material evidence which will assist us in
H this part of our inquiry is furnished by the Report on Family
Living Survey among Industrial Workers at Ahmedabad, 1958-59.
From this report it appears that the organisation of the survey
SUPllEMB COURT llEPOllTS
(1966) I S.C.R.
was based on the co-operation of several institutions. The survey A
was sponsored by the Labour Bureau, Ministry of Labour &:
Employment, Government of India; and its technical details were
worked out under the guidance of a Technical Advisory Committee on Cost of Living Index Numbers consisting of the representatives of the Ministries of Labour and Employment, Food and
Agriculture, Finance, Planning Commission, the National Sample
Survey Directorate, the Department of Statistics (C.S.0.), the
Indian Statistical Institute and the Reserve Bank of India. TI1oe
field work was entrusted to the Directorate of National Sample
Survey, and processing and tabulation of data collected in Schedule 'A' (Family Budget! to the Indian Statistical Institute,
Calcutta. The tabulation of data collected in Schedule 'B' which
dealt with Level of Living was done in the Labour Bureau. It
was a multipurpose survey; and so, the investigation conducted
under it covered both the Family Budget, and the Level of Living.
Ultimate analysis of the data, publication of reports on the results
of the surveys and construction and maintenance of new series
of consumer price index numbers "ere the responsibilities of the
Labour Bureau.
The first thing that the Organisation did was to define a
"working class family", because this definition determined the
size of the universe. A working class family which was the basic
unit of the survey, was defined in terms of sociological and economic considerations as consisting of persons :
( i) generally related by blood and marriage
adoption;
B
•
c
,
D
E
•
or
(ii) usually Jiving together and/or served from the
same kitchen; and
F
(iii) pooling a major pan of their income and/or
depending on a common pool of income for a
major part of their expenditure.
Then followed the delimitation of area. Tue geographical G
area to be covered during the survey was decided in consultation
with local organisation both official and non-official. At the
Ahmedabad centre, 46 localities were selected for the purpose
of th.~ survey; they consisted of 16 Chawls, 21 Labour Colonies
(Housing Societies) and 9 Villages. Before settling the ultimate
units of the family living survey, viz., the families, two types of H
sampling methods were adopted; they were the tenement sampling
and the pay-roll sampling. The sample size for a centre wu
'
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
•
A determined on the basis of the number of industrial workers, the
type of sampling followed, the work-load manageable by an
Investigator and the required precision of weights to be derived
from Schedule 'A' for consumer price index numbers. The sample
size for Ahmedabad was 720 families to be canvassed for Schedule
'A'. The number of schedules finally collected and tabulated was
B 722 for Schedule 'A'. The two samples drawn for Schedules
'A' & 'B' were however, mutually exclusive, because canvassing
for both the schedules from the same sampled families would
have caused fatigue both to the Investigators and the informants.
The whole sample was staggered over a period of 12 months
evenly so as to eliminate the seasonal effects on the consumption
pattern. The selection of sample was done in two stages. In the
first stage, the chawls within each of the wards were grouped to
form blocks of about 150 households each and these blocks along .
with the labour colonies (housing societies) were grouped to form
clusters of about 450 households each, so that each cluster had
blocks from different wards. From the list of these clusters and
villages, 4 independent simple systematic samples of 12 clusters
or villages each were selected for survey. Each of the 12 clusters
sampled for an Investigator was assigned to a particular month
for enquiry by a random process. That is how the first stage
was arranged.
E
•
411
The second stage unit for selection was a working class family.
Each month, the Investigator listed all the families in the cluster
allotted to that month by house-to-house visit and classified them
as working class families and others. While listing, information
was also collected on the family size, the expenditure class to
F which it belonged and the State of origin of the head of the family.
This information was utilised to arrange the working class families in the cluster, first by family size and within these classes by
expenditure class and within these by the State of origin. A simple
systematic sample of 20 working class families was drawn from
this arranged list. Every fourth family in this sample was conG !acted for filling Schedule 'B' (on Level of Living) and th.e
remaining three were for Schedule 'A' (on Family Budget). That
is the nature of the procedure adopted in selecting the families for
sample survey and determining the size of the sample. The same
survey was designed to cover a period of 12 months at each centre.
At Ahmedabad cenfre, the work was carried on between August,
H 1958 and July, 1959. The method of survey was the "interview
method". The questionnaire which each Investigator adopted
covered a wide range of subjects, accurate replies to some of
•
412
SUPllBMJI COURT REPORTS
[1966) I S.C.ll.
which could not he had without explaining the signific~nce of
the questions to the persons concerned.
The population of Ahmc<labad is about 11.5 lakhs. The
working class population in Ahmedabad wa> reported to be
concentrated in 13 localities. The markets predominantly patroni~d by the working class population in Ahmedabad were 6 and
it is th.ose markets that were selected for the collection of retail
prices for the new serie' of consumer price index number for
Ahmedabad centre.
This summary of the Report gives us a broad idea as to the
manner in which and the method by which the investigation was
made which ultimately led to the construction of the consumer
price inde;r; number.
,
A
B
•
C
Reverting then to the objections raised by the appellants that
the size of the sample was inadequate and the method of investigation was inappropriate. can it be said that the Industrial Court
was in error in holding that these objections were not valid? In D
dealing with this question, it is necessary to bear in mind that the
size of the sample has to be determined in the light of the permissible margin of error in the resulting series of consumer price
inde;r; numbers. As Dr. Basu has observed : "In our country, this
permissible margin of error in the index ha> hcen broadly set
at 2 per cent";(') and that is not contradicted by the opinion of E
any other Expert. The ~ample of consuming units has to be
selected by the application of scientific sampling techniques; and
there is no doubt whatever that during the last 40 years, this
branch of human knowledge has made remarkable prOgress. The
optimum sample design is now worked out by competent statisticians in the light of the available material and requirements in f'
each case, and as Dr. Basu has observed, "the desired data are
secured at minimum cost and at an evaluation of sampling errors
in the estimated data obtained from the survey". It is the quality
of the survey that is more important, not so much the ~ize of the
sample or the number of families with whom investigation wa.~
made.
G
On the question ahout the adequacy of the sample sire
selected for investigation on the present occasion it would be
material to refer to the opinion expressed by Moser on this subject. Says Moser : "Most people who are unfamiliar with sampling
probably over-rate the importance of sample size as
------ --·-·----·-·.
A .Buu, "Consumer Pri<c Index, pp.S4-55.
11
•
•
MILLOWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR
A
B
c
(Gajendragadkar, CJ.) 413
such, taking the view that "as long as the sample is big
enough, or a large enough proportion of the population
is included, all will be well". The fallacy in this is clear
as soon as one looks at any standard error formula, say
( 5 .1) on p. 61 above. If the population is large, the
finite population correction N-n/N-1 practically vanishes and the precision of the sample result is seen to
depend on n, the size of the sample, not on n/N, the
proportion of the population included in the sample. Only
if the sample represents a relatively high proportion of
the population (say, 10 per cent or more) need the
population size enter into the estimate of the standard
error". (' )
Mr. Kolah for the appellants has not cited before us the opinion
of any Expert to the contrary.
Considering the question from a commonsense point of view,
it seems to us reasonable to hold that if the quality of investigation has improved, and the method of working out the sample
survey has made very great progress, then it would not be correct
to say that because the size of the sample in the present case was
smaller as compared to the size of the sample taken in 1926-27,
the inadequacy of the size on the subsequent occasion introduces
E an infirmity in the investigation itself. That is the view which
the Industrial Court has taken, and we see no reason to differ
from it.
D
At this stage, it would be interesting to consider the comparative contents of the basket as it was devised in the two respective enquires, one held in 1926-27, and the other in 1958-59. The
F former enquiry reflects the consumption pattern of the working
class as it existed in 1926. The index number then devised was
composed of five groups, viz., (1) Food, (2) Fuel and Lighting,
( 3) Clothing, ( 4) House rent, and ( 5) Miscellaneous. The food
group in its turn consisted of 16 items; the fuel and lighting group
G of 4 items; the clothing group of 7 items; the house rent group
of the item of house rent; and the miscellaneous group of two
items, viz. bidis and soap. Thus, in all( 30 items were included.
These items represent 82.32 % of the average monthly expenditure, and they were respec~ively assigned 58, 7, 10, 12 and 4
weights which together aggregate 91. At the time of this enquiry,
H the items included in the investigation totalled 49; out of them,
30 w.~re priced and 19 were unpriced; and in respect of th.e
(I) C. A. Moser, Survey Methods in Social Investigation, p. 115, para 3.
LGSnp.CI/65-12
SUPRBMB COUllT llBPORTS
(1966] 1 S.C.R.
latter, the method of imputation was adopted. This series was
prepared after collecting the budgets of 985 families when the
estimated population of the city of Ahmedabad was 2,90,000.
The new series is based on the enquiry into 722 working
class families conducted in 1958-59 when the total population of
the city was about 11 Jakhs. The total working class families at
this time were estimated to be 51.5 thousand; and so, the percentage of the sample size in relation to the universe of the working class families would come to about 1.4 and not less than .5 as
appears to have been assumed by Mr. Gokhale. The weighting
diagram for the new series is based on 110 articles divided into
the main groups of food, fu.el and lighting, housing, clothing, and
miscellaneous. The important groups in this enquiry carried respectively the weights of 64.41, 6.22, 5.05, 9.08, and 15.24 which
aggregate to 100. The total number of items included in the
basket was 239. Of these, 89 were priced items and 150 unpriced, and in respect of the latter, the method of imputation was
adopted. It is true that in the new series, the unpriced items are
considerably more than in the earlier one; but it must be remembered that it is not so much the number of items that makes the
difference, but the percentage of eq-,enditure on unpriced items
to priced items. The total expenditure of all items in the l 926-27
enquiry was Rs. 36.01 of which Rs. 32.35 was the expenditure on
priced items and Rs. 3.66 was the expenditure on non-priced items.
In terms of percentage, the expenditure on priced items to total
expenditure was 89.8% and expenditure on non-priced items to
total expenditure was 10.2%. In the latter enquiry of 1958-59,
the total expenditure on all items was Rs. 139.06. Of this,
Rs. 124.91 was the expenditure on priced items and Rs. 14.15
was the expenditure on non-priced items. In terms of percentage,
the first expenditure was 89.8% and the second is 10.2%. Thus,
it is clear that the expenditure on unpriced items in the present
enquiry is not larger than in the fom1er enquiry at all. The fact
that the components of the basket have considerably increased,
cannot be a matter of surprise, because with the growth of Indian
economy and the change in the standard of living of all citizens,
the requirements of the working class have also increased and the
components of the basket which was devised in 1926-27 have now
become completely obsolete. It is in the light of th!s ~siti~
that we have tu oonsider whether the appellants are JUSttfied in
contending that the inadequacy of the si7.e of the sample vitiatei;
the enquiry. In our opinion, the answer to this question must ~
against the appellants.
'
·
A
8
'
C
()
E
r
F
G
H
•
MILLOWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR
A
B
c
0
E
•
F
G
(GajendragaJkar, C.l.)
41S
1be next question to consider is whether the Interview method
is unscientific and its adoption makes the enquiry itself defective
and unreliable. In dealing with this question again, it is necessary
to remember that the interview method itself has made very great
progress since 1926. The task of investigation is in no sense
merely mechanical; it is a constructive task, the efficient discharge
of which requires a well-trained Investigator. As Moser observes,
the investigators are expected to ask all the applicable questions;
to ask them in the order given and with no more elucidation and
probing than is explicitly allowed; and to make no unauthorised
variations in the working (p. 188). Interviewers, according to
Moser, are not machines. Their voices, manner, pronunciations
and inflections differ as much as their looks, and no amount of
instruction will bring about complete uniformity in technique;
and so, interviewers have to be properly educated in the task of
putting questions to the families interviewed. What is true about
asking questions, is also true about recording the answers. ''The
0
r~rding of answers", says Moser, would seem a simple enough
task and one which interviewers might be expected to perform
with accuracy". But he adds that "the task of interviewers is a
fairly tiring one. With random sampling, the interviewer may have
travelled and walked a good way before getting to the respondent. He has to go through what is often a lengthy, and always.
a somewhat repetitive, operation" (p. 190); and that makes the
task of recording answers also important. The Interviewers are,
therefore, appointed after selection, and it is now realized that
their work is not at all mechanical and cannot be compared to
the worlc:of Investigators who collect data at the time of population census. The Investigator must take interest in the task that
he has undertaken, must be accurate in asking questions and
recording answers, must show an equitable temper in meeting the
persons interviewed and must, above all, be a man of education
who understands the significance of sampling survey and the
purpose which it is intended to serve.
It is true that in England, the method of supplying accountbooks to the families is adopted. Under this method, the fa.mi-
.lies are expected to fill in every detail in the account-book, and
the cost of living is compiled from exact and correct information
given by the persons who keep regular accounts according to the
directions issued. But on the other hand, in countries like
H Canada and the United States, the method of interview is preferred to that of the account-books. It seems that according to Moser,
the method of mail questionnaire, which corresponds in a sense
416
SUPREMB COURT REPORTS
(1966) l S.C. R.
with the method of account-books, suffers from several infirmities; and so, he seems to prefer the method of interview, providod,
of course, this method i> scientifically and efficiently adopted.
In our country where a majority of working class population
still suffers from illiteracy, the method of interview is obviously
indicated. It would be impracticable to suggest that a written
questionnaire should be supplied to the members of the working
class or account-books should be given to them in the expectation
that they would furnish answers in return. Having regard to this
special feature of the life of the working class as it obtains in
our country today, the method of interview is the only method
which can be adopted. Besides, as we have just indicated, even
on the merits, expert opinion seem' to suggest that if the interview
method is properly adopted, it gives better results than the alternative method of account-books. Therefore, we are satisfied that
the Industrial Court was right in rejecting the appellants' contention that the impugned survey and the index constructed as
a result of it, suffer from the infirmity that investigation was ronducted in this survey by the interview method.
That takes us to the question about the propriety of the linking factor which has been upheld by the Industrial Court. We
have already noticed that the Government of Gujarat has adopted the linking factor at 3.17, and the Industrial Court has taken
the view that no case has been made out by the appellants to
interfere with the said decision of the Government of Gujarat.
Mr. Kolah contended that if a linking factor has to be adopted,
it would be more rational and scientific to watch the behaviour
of prices for two or three years and then devise a factor on tho
average rise in prices during the period in question.
Mr. Vasavada, on the other hand, seriously disputed the
correctness of Mr. Kolah's contention. As this case was being
argued on the 24th March, 1965, the parties suggested that the
question about the proper procedure to be followed in determining the linking factor in such cases was a very important question
and that it would be better if we hear the views of associationa
or bodies which would be interested in a proper solution of this
problem. That is why on the said date we adjourned the hearing
of the appeals to enable such interested parties to appear before
us. The parties furnished a list of sixteen institutions or bodie1
which, according to them, would be interested in assisting us with
arguments on this issue. On April 12, 1965, a letter of request
was accordingly sent to these bodies indicating to them the nature
of the question on which we wanted their assistance. In respome
A
B
c
D
E
•
F
G
1
H
MILLOWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.I.) 417
to the said letter, only four bodies have appeared; they are : The
All-India Organisation of Industrial Employers; the All-India
Manufacturers' Organisation; the Millowners' Association, Bombay; and the Indian National Trade Union Congress. The first
three bodies appear broadly to support the appellants' case,
whereas the fourth body has resisted the appellants' contention
B that the Government of Gujarat was in error in adopting the
linking factor at 3 .17.
A
C
D
E
F
G
H
•
The appeals were then set down for hearing before us on the
2nd August, 1965, and we indicated to the parties that having
regard to the unsatisfactory response which our letter of request
had received, we did not think it would be appropriate that we
should proceed to decide the larger issue raised by Mr. Kolah
as to what would be a rational and satisfactory method of evolving
a linking factor. The Indian National Trade Union Congress in
its affidavit has urged that the method of linking of the new series
with the old by the simple arithmetical ratio at the base period is
universally accepted. It appears that the employers and the empfoyees are not able to take a consistent stand on this issue and
their approach apparently differs from region to region and industry to industry, because considerations of expediency and selfinterest do not seem to dictate a uniform common approach to be
adopted in tile present case. Besides, tile issue is of a very technical
character and any decision of this Court on such an issue of
principle is likely to affect several industries in this country. We
have, tilerefore, decided not to embark upon a general enquiry
on this point. Our decision will be confined to the material
placed before the Industrial Court in the present proceedings, and
we will merely examine Mr. Kolah's contention that the view
taken by the Industrial Court is not correct. That is why we
wish to make it clear that our present decision should not be taken
to be of any general significance and should be confined to the
facts of tilis case. If it is thought necessary or desirable by the
employers and the employees that this question should be scientifically examined and determined in a general way, it would be
appropriate for them to move the Government to appoint a
special body of experts to deal with it.
Reverting then to tile narrow question as to whether the
appellants are justified in attacking the finding of tile Industrial
Court on tilis issue, let us mention a few relevant facts and considerations. We have already noticed that at the request of the
Government of India, the Government of Gujarat discontinued
the publication of the State series of the consumer price index;
418
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966) I S.CR.
and so, it became necessary for the said Government to secure A
the advice of an Expert Committee as to how the new !!Cries of
consumer price index for Ahmedabad should be linked with State
series after making such adjustments therein as may be found
necessary. The Expert Committee dealt with this problem of
arriving at the linking factor, so that when the new series is
adopted and the State series is discontinued, the dearness allow- B
ance on the pre'ent scale can be computed even on the basis of
the new series. The Government of India had, in this connection,
indicated that 2. 98 would be an appropriate linking factor. This
figure had been reached by taking the annual average of the
monthly index number of the State series for the year 1960 which
then stood at 298. The figure of the base year 1960 was obvious- c
ly 100. The linking factor of 2.98 was deduced by dividing 298
by 100. In doing so, however, the question about making necessary adjustments in the index numbers of the State and of the
new series had not been considered. This question was considered by the Desai Expert Committee, and it held that the linktng D
factor should be 3. J 7 as against 2. 98 per point in the new series
as was worked out without correcting the old series. In other
words, the Desai Committee suggested as a linking factor a mere
arithmetical ratio of 3.17.
•
y
<
A similar question was referred by the Government of Maharashtra to the Lakdawala Expert Committee, and the said Committee was inclined to take the same view. It no doubt observed
that "in spite of the fact a linking on the basis of a simple ratio
corrects a series only in respect of one of its dimensions, we
recommend this course because we are of opinion that such a correction is adequate for the requirements of our terms of reference
and in any case, the only correction that we can meaningfully
carry out." It would thus be seen that in accepting the linking
factor at 3.17, the Government of Gujarat has adopted the conclusion of the Desai Expert Committee.
The question which arises is whether in upholding this view,
the Industrial Court has committed any error. As the Industrial
Court has ob<erved, two possibilities presented themselves in
attacking this problem. One was to work out an entirely new
scale of basic wa£es founded not on the pre-war level of 1939,
but on the cost ~f living of 1960 as the base year of the new
series and to award dearness allowance thereafter. The Industrial
Court thought that to adoj>t this course may conceivably create
a large number of prob'cms which do not exist at present and in
fact, it may tend to destroy industrial peace. The Industrial Court
E
F
G
H
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
419
A
thought that such a course might even be outside its terms of
reference. Even so, in its opinion, the result which would be
achieved by adopting this course may not in the end be very
different. The other course is to link the State series with the
new series to maintain continuity. It is this latter alternative
which has been adopted by the Government of Gujarat, and the
B Industrial Court has approved of the said course. We are not
satisfied that the conclusion thus recorded by the Industrial Court
is shown to be erroneous.
As we have just indicated, the problem is a technical problem
and it can be decided only in the light of the opinion which
c experts may form on examining all the aspects pertaining to the
problem and after taking into account all the pros and cons which
may be put before them by the respective interested parties. The
stand which the parties may take in regard to this controversy
would differ according as the change in the cost of living index
in the respective States may help their interest one way or the
D other. That explains why there is no unanimity in the approach
adopted by the different parties. This is made clear by the contentions raised by the respective parties before the Lakdawala
Expert Committee.
There is no doubt that on the material as it stands, it would be
unreasonable, inexpedient and in fact impossible for this Court
E to attempt to resolve this controversy on the basis of the larger
issue of law raised by Mr. Kolah before us. The decision of that
question must, therefore, be left to a Committee of experts if and
when it is appointed. Meanwhile, the question will have to be
dealt with on an ad hoc basis in each industry, taking into account
the particular facts and circumstances of each case.
F
•
•
Looking at the question from this narrow point of view, we
do not think the appellants have placed before the Industrial
Court any material to justify their contention that for determining
a linking factor, the behaviour of prices for two or three years
during the relevant period should and can be studied. In fact,
G Mr. Vasavada's contention is that a study of the behaviour of
prices for such a period and deducing the average therefrom would
be inconsistent with the notion of evolving a linking factor. He
contends that we have to take one year by reference to which this
problem must be resolved. We express no opinion on.this part of
the controversy between the parties. In fact, the Award under
H appeal shows that the argument which Mr. Kolah has urged before
as was not placed in this form, and in any case does not appear
to have been pressed, before the Industrial Court. Even assum-
420
SUPREMll
COURT
REPORTS
(1966} 1 S.C.R.
ing that it wouid have been open to the Industrial Court to consider this larger issue under the tcnns of its reference, we do not
see how the Industrial Court could have attempted to solve the
problem safofactorily on the material placed before it. Therefore,
we cannot accept Mr. Kolha's argument that the Industrial Court
was not justified in upholding the decision of the Government of
Gujarat that the linking factor should be taken at 3.17.
A
•
8
The last question to consider is whether the Industrial Court
was right in coming to the conclusion that the additional burden
which its award would impose upon the appellants would not be
beyond their financial capacity. In dealing with this question,
there arc two general considerations which cannot be ignored. The C
first consideration is that the task of constructing a wage structure
of industrial employees is a very re,ponsible task and it presents
sever~! difficult and delicate probkms. The claim of the employees
for a fair and higher wage is undoubtedly based on the concept of
social justice, and it inevitably plays a major part in the construction of a wage structure. There can be litile doubt that if the D
employees arc paid a better wage which would enable them to live
in fair comfort and discharge their obligations to the members of
their families in a reasonable way, they would be encouraged to
work whole-heartedly and their wort; would show appreciable
increase in efficiency.
E
On the other hand, in trying to recognise and give effect to the
demand for a fair wage. including the payment of dearness
allowance to provide for adequate neutralisation against the ever·
increasing rise in the cost of living, indthtrial adjudication must
always take into account the problem of the additional burden
which such wage structure would impose upon th~ employer and
ask itself whether the employer can reasonably he called upon
to bear such burden. The problem of constructing a wag~ 'tructure must be tackled on the basis that .mch wage structure should
not be changed from time to time. !t is a long-rani!e plan; and
so, in dealing with this problem, the financial position of the
employer must be carefully examined. What has been the nrogress
of t!ic industry in question; what are the prospects of the industry
in future; has the industry been making profj.ts; and if yes, what
is the extent of profits; what is the nature of demand which the
industry expects to secure; what would be the extent of the burden
and its gradual increase which the employer may have to face?
These and similar other considerations have to be carefully
weighed before a proper wage structure can be reasonably constructed by industrial adjudication, vide Express New~papers
,,
G
•
H
•
MILLOWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
•
II
(Gajendragadkar, C.J.)
421'
(Private) Ltd., and Another v. Union of India & Others('). Unusual profit made by the industry for a single year as a result of
adventitious circumstances or unusual loss incurred by it for
similar reasons, should not be allowed to play a major role in the
calculations which industrial adjudication would mak~ in regard
to the construction of a wage structure. A broad and overall view
of the financial position of the employer must be taken into
account and attempt should always be made to reconcile the
natural and just claims of the employees for a foir and higher
wage with the capacity of the employer to pay it; and in determining rnch capacity, allowance mus\ be made for a legitimate
desire of the employer to make a reasonable profit. In this connection, it may also be permissible to take into account the extent
of the rise in price structure which may result from the fixation
o( a wage structure, and the reasonableness of the additionar
burden which may thereby be imposed upon the consumer. That
is one aspect of the matter which is relevant.
The other aspect of the matter which cannot be ignored is that
if a fair wage structure is constructed by industrial adjudication,
and in course of time, experience shows that the employer cannot
bear the burden of such wage structure, industrial adjudication
can, and in a proper case should, revise the wage structure. though
such revision may result in the reduction of the wages paid to the
employees. It is true that normally, once a wage structure is
fixed, employees are reluctant to face a reduction in the content
of their wage packet; but like all major problems associated with
industrial adjudication, the decision of this problem must also be
based on the major consideration that the conflicting claims of
labour and capital must be harmonised on a ~easonable basis;
and so, if it appears that the employer cannot really bear the
burden of the increasing wage bill, industrial adjudication, on
principle, cannot refuse to examine the emnloyer's case and should
not hesitate to give him relief if it is satisfied that if such relief
is not given, the employer may have to close down his business.
It is unlikely that such situation would frequently arise but, on
principle, if such situations arise, a claim by the employer for the
reduction of the wage structure cannot be rejected summarily.
This principle, however, does not apply to cases where the
wages paid to the employees are no better than the basic minimum
wage. If. what the employer pays to his employees is just the
basic subsistence wage, then it would not be open to the employer
to contend that even such a wage is beyond his paying capacity ..
(1) [19611 IL. L. J. 339.
422
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1966) I S.C.R.
Industrial adjudication has consisten:ly recognised and enforced
llle principle that social justice requires that an industrial employer
must be able to pay his employees a wage structure which can
be reasonably regarded as basic minimum wage. No employer
can be allowed to pay his employees wages which arc below the
basic minimum or the subsistence wage. It is well-known that 10
certain industries, minimum wages are fixed by the statute. Even
where minimum wages ar~ not fixed by statute, industrial ~djudi
cation can easily determine whether in a given case, the wage paid
is basic minimum or not. In either case. where the wage answers
the description of the basic minimum or subsistence wage, it has
to be paid by the employer; and if he cannot afford to pay it, he
would not be justified i~ carrying on his industry. vide Crown
A/11minium Works v. Their Workmen('). That is the second
consideration which has to be borne in mind in dealing with the
point raised by the appellants about their incapacity to bear the
burden.
We have thought it necessary to refer to these two theoretical
considerations at this stage, because if they are borne in mind,
we get a proper perspective of the problem raised by the appellants' contention as to their financial capacity. In the present proceedin~s. the Industrial Court is not constructing any wage
structure for the first time, nor is it dealing v.ith the question of
determining the quantum or the sliding scale of the dea~s
allowance to be paid to the textile employee6 at Ahmedabad.
These matters have been considered in the past on several occasions and they arc governed by consent awards passed between
the parties. It is because of the new survey made in 1958-59 and
the consequent change in the construction of the consumer price
index made by the series published by the Government of Gujarat
that the present dispute has arisen; and so, while dealing with the
appellants' contention, it would be pertinent to enquire whether the
appellants show that a case has been made out for reduction of
the wages paid to the employees. It is, of course, true that the
wages paid to the textile employees at Ahmedabad cannot be
regarded as subsistence wages or bare minimum wages; and so, it
would not be open to the respondent to contend that the appellants
must pay the said wai:es whether they can afford to pay them or
not. If it is shown that the appellants cannot bear the burden
and that the implementation of the award would inevitably have
extremely prejudicial effect upon the continued existence of the
textile indmtry itself, we would be ju<tified in revising the scale
of dearness allowance. But, as we have just indicated. such a plea
-·· · - - - - .
(I) (19~8} IL. L. J. J.
A
B
r
C
D
E
F
...
G
•
H
•
MILLOWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar,
C.J.) 423
A can succeed only if it is shown satisfactorily that the burden cannot
truJy and really be borne by the textile industry at Ahmedabad.
That is the proper approach to adopt in deali.ng with this problem;
and the award under appeal shows that the Industrial Court did
approach the problem in a proper way.
f
In support of their contention that the textile industry at
Abmedabad cannot bear the burden which would be imposed by
the award, the appellants examined Mr. Chokshi. Mr. Chokshi is
a Chartered Accountant and a senior partner in the firm of Messrs.
C. C. Chokshi & Co. He has been practising as a Chartered
Accountant for about 24 years. He wa~ a member of the Council
c of the Institute of Chartered Accountants for 8 years and its President for one year. It appears that the appellant Association sent
to him five statements and asked for his opinion on the financial
position of the textile industry at Ahmedabad. Mr. Chokshi first
filed an affidavit in which he set out his opinions and then gave
oral evidence. In his affidavit, Mr. Chokshi referred to the respecD tive statements on which his opinion was based and he stated that
the financial position of the textile industry at Ahmedabad was,
on the whole, not very satisfactory.
B
'
,
•
In appreciating the evidence given by Mr. Chokshi, it would,
therefore, be material to indicate the nature of the statements on
E which his opinion was based. The first statement shows the
depreciation, development rebate, and increase in gross block
per year of the Ahmedabad Cotton Textile Mill Industry for the
years 1945 to 1963. The statement indicates that all these items
have increased from year to year; depreciation was Rs. 0. 83 crore
in 1945 and it rose to Rs. 6.68 crores in 1963; development
F rebate was Rs. 0.05 crore in 1954 and it became Rs. 1.26 crores
in 1963; gross block rose from Rs. 20.25 crores in 1945 to
Rs. 101.98 crores in 1°963; and increase in gross block per year
for the same years was Rs. 1.31 and Rs. 9.77 crores.
The second statement shows the net worth and borrowings of
the said industry during the same period. The emphasis in this
·G statement was on the ever-increasing borrowings. In 1945, the
borrowings, consisting of secured and unsecured loans and other
deposits, were of the order of Rs. 9.58 crores, whereas in 1963,
they rose to Rs. 47. 76 crores. The third statement shows the
working capital and borrowings for the period in question. The
H fourth statement shows profits after tax as percentage of net worth
of the said industry for the same period. This statement refers
to profits before tax, loss, tax provision, profits after tax, net worth,
and the last column gives profits after tax and indicates percent-
4 24
SUPREME
COUil.T
REPORTS
[1966] I S.C.R.
ai;c of net worth. It is the last column on which Mr. Chokshi
relied when he gave his opinion that the financial position of the
Ahmedabad textile industry was not very satisfactory. Whereas
in 1945, the percentage of profits to net worth was 13.4%, in
1963 it was 3.3 % . The last statement shows dividends as perc~ntage of net worth in different industries. It covers the period
between 1951 and 1962. This statement shows that the dividends
paid by the industry in question are comparatively on the low
side. Dividends paid by 12 industries arc shown in this statement,
and it would be right to say that the textile industry has not been
paying dividends which can be said to be very high in comparison
to the dividends paid by other industries.
On the other hand, the respondent has filed several statements
showing that the financial position of the appellants has been con'istently good, and the fear that the appellants would not be able
10 bear the burden is entirely unjustified. Annexurc II filed by the
respondent along with its statement shows the percentage of wages
10 total income in Ahmedabad Cotton Textile Industry from 1939
10 1962. This percentage was 26 in 1939 and is 24 both in 1961
and 1962; for the intervening period, it has risen to 28 in 1949
and fallen to 20 in 1943. Annexure III gives the statement showing the growth of paid up capital by cash in the said industry for
the same period. In 1939, the paid up capital by cash was 407
lakhs. whereas in 1962 it was 770 lakhs. Annexure IV shows the
growth of total paid up capital including bonus shares for the same
period. l11is statement shows a remarbhle growth of total paid
up capital in this manner. In 1939, the total paid up capital was
442 lakhs, whereas in 1962 it has reached the magnitude of 2. l 29
(al~hs.
From 1950 onwards, this category of capital has been
con~i<.tent!y rising. Anncxurc V shows the value of gross h!ock
for the same period. In 1939, it was I. 915 lakhs whereas in 1962
it rose to 9,341 lakhs. Anncxurc VI shows the amount of Oenn:ciation Fund including Dcvelorment Rebate; in 1939 it was 74S
Iakhs. whereas in 1962 h was 5,643 lakh,. Annexure VII shows
the amount of Reserves excluding Depreciation Fund and LiabHity
Funds; in 1939 they w 're 360 lakhs, while in 1962 they were
2,51 R la1'hs. From Anrcxure VJll we gather that the amount of
Gross Profit including th~ Managing A!!cnts' Commission and
Depreciation was R'. 1 W lakhs in 1939. and it was Rs. 1.860
lakhs in 1961 and Rs. 1.296 lakhs in 1962. Incidentally, it is the
figure of gross profit which is more important, because it is not
disputed that wages payable to the employees are a first charge,
:md all other liabilities take their place after the wages. There are
A
)
B
c
D
•
E
,
F
G
H
•
MILLOWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR
A
(Gajendragadkar, C.l.) 425
three other Annexures filed by the respondent, but it is unnecessary
to refer to them.
The main comment which falls to be made on the opinion
expressed by Mr. Chokshi is that he has looked at the problem
merely from the investor's point of view. In fact, he fairly stated
B that he had made his analysis from the point of view of an investor.
That explains why Mr. Chokshi took the view that absolute figures
of more gross profit or net profit from year to year would be
misleading. He did not agree that most of the textile mills in
Ahmedabad are at present under-capitalised. He conceded that in
dealing with the problem of expanding business and increasing the
C wage bill, one of two methods can be adopted by the industry;
the industry can increase the capital or borrow money. Very often,
said Mr. Chokshi, borrowin,g is preferred to the increase of capital
in certain market conditions. He was not certain whether borrowings had been resorted to by the textile industry for the purpose
of expansion. In dealing with the problem of the financial capacity
D of the appellants to bear the burden, it would be inappropriate to
rely solely upon the approach which an investor would adopt in
such a case; and so, we are not prepared to hold that the Industrial
Court was in error in not accepting Mr. Chokshi's estimate about
the financial position of the Textile industry at Ahmedabad.
E
F
G
•
H
•
Mr. Kolha for the appellants has strongly relied upon certain
statements made in the Reserve Bank of India Bulletin issued in
July, 1964, in support of his argument that the financial position
of the appellants was not satisfactory. Dealing with the position
of the Cotton Textile Industry during the period under review, the
Bulletin says that cotton textiles recorded a steep fall of Rs. 17 .0
crores in net profits as against a rise of Rs. 2.1 crores in the previous year. Applying the profitability ratio, the Bulletin goes on
to say that cotton textiles, amongst others, showed declines in
profitability. This test is evolved by the ratio of gross profits to
sales, and the return on capital, as measured by the ratio of gross
profits to total capital employed. According to the Bulletin, the
decline in the return on shareholders' equity (ratio of profits after
tax to net worth) was substantial in the case of cotton 1extiles
along with other named industries. Table 4 in the Bulletin gives a
comparative statement of the profitability ratios. industry-wise, in
1960-61, 1961-62 and 1962-63. It is arranged in five columns
which deal respectively with gross profits as percentage of sales,
gross profits as percentage of total capital employed, profits after
tax as percentage of net worth, dividends as percentage of net
worth, and dividends as percentage of paid up capital. The figures
426
SUPlll!Ml! COU1T 11.BPORTS
[1966) l S.C.R.
shown against the cotton textiles in these five columns support the
main comment made in the Bulletin that the position of the textile
industry, considered as a whole in this country, was not quite
satisfactory.
We do not think in considering the financial position of the
appellants in the context of the dispute before us, it would be
appropriate to rely unduly on the profitability ratio which has
been adopted by the said Bulletin. Indeed, in appreciating the
effect of the several statements produced before the Industrial
Court by the parties in the present proceedings, it would be relevant to remember that some of these single-purpose statements
are likely to create confusion and should not ordinarily be
regarded as decisive. As Paton has observed : "Different groups
for whom financial statements are prepared are interested in varying degree in particular types of information; and so, it has been
held in some quarters that no one form of statement will sati~
factorily serve all these purposes, that separate single-purpose
statements should be prepared for each need or that the statements
usually prepared for general distribution should be expanded so
as to include all the detail desired". (1) Paton cites the comment
of Wilcox against these single-purpose statements. Said Wilcox :
"TI1e danger in undertaking to furnish single-purpose financial
statements lies in increasing confusion and misunderstanding, and
in the possible misuse of such statements for unintended purposes''.
Paton has then referred to certain methods for detennining the
financial position of a commercial and industrial concern. In this
connection, he refers to the proprietary ratio rate of earnings on
total capital employed, rate of dividends on common stockholders'
equity and others. Our purpose in referring to these comments
made by Paton is to emphasise the fact that industrial adjudication
cannot lean too heavily on such single-purpose statements or adopt
any one of the tests evolved from such statements, whilst it is
attempting the task of deciding the financial capacity of the
employer in the context of the wage problem. While we must no
doubt examine the position in detail, ultimately we must base our
decision on a broad view which emerges from a consideration of
all the relevant factors.
What then is the broad picture which emerges from the evi ·
dencc on the record in respect of the financial position of the
textile industry at Ahmedabad? The cotton textile industry at
Ahmedabad can legitimately claim to be the oldest organised
industry in the country. It recently celebrated its centenary in
(I) 'Accountants' Handbook Edited by Paton, p. 13
A
B
•
c
D
E
,
F
G
•
H
•
MILLOWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.J.) 427
A
•
B
'
c
D
E
F
•
1961. The story about the growth of this industry during this
century is very heartening. In its early stages, it no doubt made
a small and modest beginning; but at the time when the centenary
celebrations were held, it had an installed capacity of about two
million spindles and 42,000 looms and it employed 1,30,000·
workmen. Statistics show that textile mills at Ahmedabad account
roughly for one-third of the total mill production in the country,
and it would be no exaggeration to say that some of the best
varieties of cloth produced in the country are manufactured at
Ahmedabad.
The paid up capital by cash of the industry iu 1939 was 4.07
crores and it became 7.70 crores in 1962. The total paid up
capital including bonus shares was 4.42 crores in 1939 and in·
1962 it rose to 21.29 crores. It would thus be seen that out of the
total paid up capital of 21.29 crores in 1962, the capital collected
by cash is 7.70 crores, whereas the balance of 13.59 crores is by
way of bonus shares. In other words, the cash capital is increased·
by 175% because of capitalisation of the reserves. Similarly, the
gross block in 1939 was 19.15 crores and in 1962 it rose to·
93.41 crores. Almost the same rate of progress is evidenced by
the Reserves. The Reserves excluding Depreciation Fund and
other liabilitor funds at the end of 1939 was 3.60 crores and they
have gone to 25.18 crores m 1962. The gross profits have
registered a similar rise. In 1939, the gross profit including
Managing Agents' Commission and depreciation was 1.59 crores,
whereas in 1962 it has reached the magnitude of 12.96 crores. In·
this connection, it would be unreasonable to ignore the fact that
the industry has been able to save and capitalise from 1939
onwards 13.85 crores and has been able to pay a fair amount of
dividend on equicy shares throughout the period, in spite of a
very large capitalisation of reserves.
It is true that the textile industry at Ahmedabad has been
leaning very heavily on borrowings; but that may partly be due
G to the fact that the said industry has for several decades been
1111der-capitalised. Besides, the tendency to rely upon borrowings
for expanding the business is noticeable throughout this period of
the life of textile industry at Ahmedabad and has been the subjectmatter of comment by several persons. In fact, sometimes it is
treated as a peculiar feature of the development of the textile
H 'iiidustry at Ahmedabad; and so, the extent of borrowings cannot
be pressed into service for the purpose of showing that the financial'
position of the industry is unsatisfactory.
428
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1966] l S.C.R
One remarkable feature of the textile industry at Ahmedabad
is the harmonious relations which have consistently subsisted
between the employers and the employees. The employers, on
the whole, are enlightened and progressive in their outlook, and
the Trade Union leadership of the employees is also enlightened
and progressive. Both the employers and the employees reali:ze
that the progress of the industry depends primarily on the cooperation between capital and labour; and the large number of consent
awards and agreements to which they have been parties over a
period of several years, is a standing tribute to the spirit of cooperation which inspires the textile industrial life in Ahmcdabad.
As one looks back over the last hundred years of the life of the
textile industry at Ahmedabad, one is struck by the fact that
industrial life in that area has rarely been disturbed by bitterness,
feuds or general strikes. This spirit of co-operation, based on the
willingness to give and take, alone can ensure the economic and
industrial growth of our country, for, after all, it is the speedy
economic growth of industry of the country which must be the
ultimate object of both capital and labour. In considering the
prospects of the textile industry in Ahmedabad, this feature must
be given a place of pride.
It is significant that as a result of the spirit of co-operation
between capital and labour, the textile industry at Ahmedabad
has been able to enter into several agreements for rationalising the
industry itself. It is well-known that an attempt to rationalise
textile industry inevitably involves retrenchment of a large number
of employees; but the appellants and the respondents have entered
into agreements of rationalisation after hoth of them agreed to
three basic principles in that behalf. These principles are : -
A
B
•
('
.
0
E
•
,,
F
(a) Rationalisation to be effected without creating
unemployment of the existing workers;
(b) Gains of Rationalisation should be adequately
shared between the Management and the workers; and
<;
( c) The workload should not be increased in a
manner which may jeopardise the health of the workers.
The fact that a large number of agreements have been made
between the parties by consent concerning the vexed. su?ject of
rationalisation also shows that the future of the texule mdustry
at Ahmedabad is bound to be as bright as it has been in the past.
In this connection, we may refer to the tribute paid by the Central
•
II
•
MILL OWNERS' ASSN. v. LABOUR (Gajendragadkar, C.l.)
A
•
B
- ''
c
D
•
E
F
G
429
Wage Board to the Cotton Textile Industry at Ahmedabad. Says
the Board:"The industry, however, is conscious of the need for
rationalisation and modernisation as the sine quo non of
survival, the pace of which had been checked in the past
by the fear of unemployment; that fear has been allayed,
and labour now recognises that its own welfare depends
on rationalisation and modernisation, and it has agreed
upon the broad Jines for their introduction. Some mills
even today have very modem and up-to-date machinery,
and all mills which can manage to do so will have to
rationalise and modernise; for the nation is on the
march, and this industry must clothe the nation".
Let us then consider the question about the prospects of the
demand for textile products in future and the increasing productivity of the industry. On this point again, it is difficult to share
the pessimism disclosed by the attitude adopted by the appellants.
There is little doubt that the productivity of the industry is increasing and that the demand for textile products will never be on the
decrease in future. Therefore, we do not see how we can differ
from the conclusion of the Industrial Court that the appellants
have failed to substantiate their contention that the additional
burden would be beyond their capacity to pay. In this connection,
we ought to recall the fact that what the appellants are required
to prove is that the prospects of their financial position in future
justify a reduction in the wage which is being paid to the industrial employees during all these years; for that on the ultimate
analysis would be the result if their contention is accepted. The
Industrial Court has made a definite finding that it does not think
that the financial condition of the industry has deteriorated so as
to justify a departure _from the principles in regard to dearness
allowance hitherto laid down in respect of this industry at this
centre. In our opinion, this conclusion is well-founded.
It was conceded before us that our decision in Civil Appeals
Nos. 167-173 of 1965 would govern the decision of Civil
Appeals Nos. 537-538 of 1965. So, the result is that all the said
appeals fail and are dismissed with costs. One set of hearing fee.
Appeals dismissiu!.
U&p.Cl/65-!3
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org