ALL INDIA RESERVE BANK EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION versus RESERVE BANK OF INDIA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 23 April 1965 | [1966] 1 S.C.R. 25 | 1965 INSC 120
Key facts
- Decided
- 23 April 1965
- Bench
- P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR*, K.N. WANCHOO, M. HIDAYATULLAH, V. RAMASWAMI
- Bench size
- 4
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4/1965
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1966] 1 S.C.R. 25
- Neutral citation
- 1965 INSC 120
Text of the judgment
A ALL INDIA RESERVE BAl'llX EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION
•
v.
RESERVE HANK OF INDIA
April 23, 1965
B
c
D
E
F
G
•
•
-
H
(P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR, C.J., K. N. WANCHOO,
M. HIDAYATULLAH AND V. RAMASWAMI, JJ.]
lndustriul Disputes Act, 1947, s. 2(s)-Definition of 'workn1an'-'Supervisory capacity' ·whether different fro1n 'supervisory work'-Disputes about
non-workn1en when can he raised by ..,vorknien-Central Govern1nent whe1!ier can refer such disputes to Trihunal-Need-hased n1inimu1n "tt-'ageFor1nula to be adopted for connunption units per fa1nily-Proper coefficient for lVhite-col!ar lvorkers, lvhat is-Enforcen1ent of a1vard : discretion of Tribunal in the 111atter of.
The Class ll and Class Ill staff of the Reserve Bank of India through
their Association, and Class lV staff through their Union raised an
industrial dispute 1,vith the Bank \vhich was referred by the Central Government on March 21, 1960, to the National Tribunal. The items referred bore upon scales of pay, allowances, and sundry matters connected
with the conditions of service of the three classes, the most important ones
being the den1and of Class 11 staff for a scale commencing with Rs. 500,
and the <le1nand of other workmen for a need-based minimum wage as
recommend·:::d by the Tripartite Conference. of 1957. In its award the
1'ribunal pointed out that Class II staff worked in a supervisory capacity
and its demand for a minimum salary of Rs. 500, if conceded, \Vould
take the said staff out of the category of 'workman' as defined in s. 2(s)
of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Such an award, and any award
carrying \vages OCyond Rs. 500 at any stage, the Tribunal said, 1,vas
beyond its· jurisdiction to make. It went on to ho1d that other workmen
could not raise a dispute which woukl involve consideration of matters.
in relation to non-\vorkmen and that it would be even beyond the jurisdiction of the Central Government to refer such a dispute under the Industrial
Disputes Act. The Tribunal ther-efore made no a\vard in regard to the
supervisory staff in Class II. As for the demand for a need-based minimum
wage, the Tribunal held tha,t the Tripartite rewlution had not been accepted
by the Government and was not binding; that a need-based minimum wage
was an ideal incapable of present achievement; that as against the demand
of a formula of 3 consumption units per family it was possible to allow
only 2.25 units; and that thei coefficient for white-collar \vorkers wouJd
not be changed from 80 to 120 as demanded, The Tribunal's award was
given on September 8, 1962 but made operative from January I, 1962.
Dissatisfied with the award, the workmen appealed by special leave, to this
Court. Subsequently by resolution dated April 24, 1963 the Resen-e
Bank raised the minimum total emoluments, as envisaged by the definition
of wages, of each and every m-ember of the Class II staff, above Rs. 500
with effect from the date of operation of the a\vard.
In their appeal before this Court it was urged on behalf of the appellants
that there was a difference between 'spervisory capacity' mentioned in
cl. (iv) of s. 2(s) and 'supervisoiy work' mentioned in the main part of
the section. and as Class II officers did not work in a 'sup·~rvisorv capacity' they were 'workmen' under the definition. 'Supervisory Capacity' it
was urged, arose only \vben the employee was an agent of the employer.
SUPREME
26
--....
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] l S.C.R.
It '\.Vas aiso urged that Class' n \VOrkmen only had clerical and checking
duties which were not supervisory in character. Alternatively it \Vas
contended that as Class lI was filled by promotion from Class III the
question as to the emoluments of the former could and should have been
gone into by the Tribunal in view of the 'Principle enunciaited in the
Dimakuchi Tea Estate case.
HELD : (i) (a) Tue amendment to s. 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes
Act in 1956 introduced among the categories of persons already mentioned
as 'workmen' persons employed to do supervisory and technical \York. So
far the language of the earlier enactment was used. \Vhen, however, exceptions were engraftotl, that language was departed from in cl. (iv) partly
because the draftsmen followed the language of cJ. (iii) and partly because
from persons employed on supervision work some are to be excluded
he.cause they dra\v \vage.s exceeding Rs. 500 per month and some because
they function mainly in a managerial capacity or have duties of the same
i:haracter. But the unity bet\veen the opening part of the definition and
cl. (iv) was expressly preserved by using the word 'such' twice in the
()pening part. The \.Vords, which bind the two parts, are not-"but does
not include any person". They are--"but does not include any such
person" showing clearly that what is being excluded is a person \.vho answers
the description "employed to do supervisory work" and he is to be excluded because being~ employed in a 'supervisory capacity' he drav.·s \Vages
exceeding Rs. 590 per month or exercises functions of a particular charac-
-
~~
Like the Taft-Hartley Act in the United States the Amending Act
of 1956 in our country was passed to equalise bargaining power and
also to give the power of bargaining and invoking the Industrial Disputes
Act to supervisory workmen, but it gave it only to some of the workmen
employed on supervisory work. 'Workman' here includes an employee
employed as supervisor. There are only two circumstances in which
such a person ceases to be a workman. Such a person is not a workman
if he draws wages in excess of Rs. 500 per month or if he performs 1nanagerial functions by reason of a po\ver vested in him or by the nature
of duties 2ttachcd to his office. The person \vho ceases to be· a ·\vorkman
is not a person who does not answer .the. description "employed to do
supervisory work" but one who does answer that description. He goes
out of the category of "workmen" on proof of the circumstances excluding
him from !ho category. [42 F-H]
A
\"
B
J
C
D
E
Packard· Motor Co. v~ T.Jze National Labour Relatloi1~ Board, 9l L.ed.
1040, referred to.
(b) The National Tribunal was not justified in holding that if at a
future time an incumbent would draw wage in the time scale in ex.cess
of Rs. 500, the matter must be taken to be withdfawn from the jurisdiction
of the Central Government to make a reference in resvcct of him and
the National Tribunal to be ousted of the jurisdiction to decide the dispute
if referred. Sup!'f"isory stajf drawing less than Rs. 500 per month cannot
be debarred from claiming that they should draw more than Rs. 500
preseD.tly or at some future stage in their service. They can only be
deprived of the benefits if they are non-workmen at the time they seek
the protection of Industrial Disputes Act. [43 C-D]
(c) The word 'supervise' and its derivatives are not words of precise
import and must often be construed in the light of the context, for unless
controlled they cover simple oversight and direction of manual work of
others. It is, therefore necessary to see the full context in which the
words occur and the words of our own Act are the surest guide. Viewed
in thi& manner one should nOt overlook1 the import of the word "such"
•
G
H
-
EMPLOYEES V. RESERVE BANK
27
A which expressly links the exception to the main part. Unless this was
B
c
D
E
F
done it would have been possible to argue that cl. (iV) indicated something, which, though not included in the main part, ought not by construction ·to be so included. By keeping the link it is clear that what is excluded
is something which is already a part of the main provision. [43 F-G]
(d) Ins. 2(k) the word 'person' bas not been limited to 'workmen' "'
such and must, therefore, receive a more general meaning. But it does
not mean any person unconnected with the disputants in relation to v.-hom
the dispute is not of the kind described, It could not have been intended
that although the dispute does not concern them in the least, workmen
are entitled to fight it out on behalf of non-workmen. [44 D-E]
Dimakuchi Tea Estate's case, [1958]2 L.LJ. 500 referred to.
If the dispute is regarding employment, non-<:mployment, terms of
employment or conditions of labour of non-workmen in which workmen are
themselves vitally interested, the workmen may be able to raise an industrial dispute. Workmen can, for example, raise a dispute that a class
of employees not within the definition of "workmen' should be recruited
by promotion from workmen. When they do so the workmen raise a
dispute about the terms of their own enzploymen.t though incidentally the
'&erms of employment of those who are not workmen is involved. But
workmen cannot take up a dispute in re-spect of a class of employees who
arc not workmen and in whose terms of employment those workmen have
no direct interest of thrir own. What direct interest suffices is a question
of fact but it must be a real and positive interest and not fanciful or
remote. [44H]
In the present case the National Tribunal was in error in not considering the claims of Class TI employees whether at the instance of merribcra
drawing less than Rs. 500 as wages or at the instance of those lower do\vn
in the scale of employment. The National Tribunal was also in error in
thinking that scales of wages in excess of Rs. 500 per month at any stage
were not within the jurisdiction of the Tribunal or that Government could
not make a reference in such a contingency. r45 C-D]
( e) Duties such as distribution of work, deteotion of faults reporting
for penalty, making arrangements for filling vacancies are supervisory.
Class II staff performing such duties could nC>t be said to perform only
clerical or checking duties. [46 D-E]
Ford Motor Company of India v. Ford Motors Staff Union, [1953]2
L.L.J. 444 and Llyods Bank Ltd. v. Panna!al Gupta, [1961]1 L.L.J. 18, referred to.
G
•
;
(ii) (a) Minimum wage is the lowes1 wage in the scale below which tho
efficiency of the worker is likely to be impaired. It allows for living at a
•tandard con&idered socially, medically, and ethically to be the acceptable
minimum. [47 C-D]
Fair wage by comparison is more generous and involves a rate sufficiently high to pr<YYide a standard family with food, shelter, clothing,
medical care and education of children appropriate to the worker's station
in life but not at a rate exceeding the wage earning capacity of the class
of establishment concerned. [47F]
The living wage concept is one or more steps higher then fair wage.
H
It has now been generally accepted that living wage means that every
male earner should be able to provide f(}r his family not only the essentials
but a fair measur-e of frugal comfort and an ability to provide for old age.
or evil days. [48AJ
LlSup.Cl/65-3
.
28
SUPREME
COURT REPORTS
[1966] l S.C·R.
It may be taken that our political aim is 'living wage' though in actual
practice living wage has been an ideal which has eluded our efforts like
an ever-receding horizon and will so remain for sometime to come. Our
general wage structure has at best reached the lower levels of fair
wage. [48DJ
Standard Vaccum Refining Co. v. Its Workmen, [1961]1 L.L.J. 227,
.referred to.
(b) There can be no doubt that in our march towards a truly fair
wage in the first instance and ultimately the living wage we must first
achieve the need~based minimum. In detennining family budgets so as
to discover the \Yorker's normal needs \vhich the minimum wage regulations
ought to satisfy the size of the standard family is very necessary to fix. One
method is to take Simple statistical average of the family size and another
is to take into account some other factors such as the frequency of variations in frunily sizes in certain region and employments, the number of
\Vage earners available at different &tages, and the increase or decrease
in consumption at diJTerent stages in employment, that is, the age structure and i~ bearing on consmnption. The plain averages Jaid down in
the Resolution may have to be weighted in different regions and in
different industries and reduc-od in others. [52 F-H]
A
B
.
c
Crotvn Alu1ninht11z Works v. Workn1e11, [1958]1 L.L.J. 1, referred
to.
(c) Although the 3 consumption units formula is if anything on the
low· side the National Tribunal could not be said to be wrong, in the
present circumstances, in accepting 2.25 consumption units. But by
graduated increase the consumption units. must be raised to 3 v.•ithin five
years of service. [52F; 53Cl
(d) The Tripartite Conference of 1957 was a very representative body.
There must be attached proper value to its Resolution on wage policy.
The Resolution was passed on to indicate a first step towards achieving
the living wage. Unfortunately, we are constantly finding that basic
\\'age, instead of moving to subsistence plus level, tends to sag to poverty
level when there is a rise in prices. To overcome this tendency our wage
structure has for a long time been composed of two items (a) the basic
wage, and (b) a dearness. allowance which is altered to neutralise, if not
entirely, at least the greater part of the increased C09t of living. This
docs not solve the problem cf real wage. At the same time, we haYe
to beware that too sharp an upward movement of basic wage is likely
to affect the cost of production and lead to fall in our exports and to the
raising of prices all-round. There is a vicious circle which can be broken
by increased production and not by increasing wages. What we need
is the introduction of production bonus, increased fringe benefits free
medical, educational and insurance facilities. As a counterpart t~ this
capital must also be prepared to forego a part of its re'lum. There i~
much to be ~aid for considering the need-base formula in all its implicallons for 1t IS bound to be our first step toward• living wage
As in
many other matters relating to industrial disputes the problem may,' perhaps,
be best tackled by. agreement between Capital and Labour in an establishment where a begmnmg can be safely made in this direction. [54 E-Hl
East Asiatic Co. v. Workmen, [1962]2 L.L.J. 610 referred to.
(e) Without further data it is difficult to determine what coefficient
should be applied to the working class wage for the purpose of determming the need-ba<.ed minimum wage of clerieal staff. When fresh anol
wmprehen.sive enquiries are conducted, tl~e results would show whether
the coefficient should go up or down. With the rise of wages to higher
D
•
E
F
G
H
-
EMPLOYEES
•
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
•
v. RESERVE BANK ( Hidayatullah, ]. )
29
le'Yels among the working class the differential is bound to be lower and
thi• is a matter for inquiry. Till then there is no alternative but to
adliere to the coefficient already established. [56 F-G]
(iii) Seniority and merit should ordinarily both have a part in prom<>tio;, to higher ranks and should temper each other. The National Tribtmal
was right in thinking that there was little scope for giving directions to
the Bank in this regard. [57 F-G]
(iv) Gratuity is not a gift but is earned and for feiture eornept to
recoup a loss occasioned to the establishment is not justified. [58F)
Express Newspaper (P) Ltd. & Anr. v. Union of India, [1961) 1 LL.I.
339, Garment Cleaning Works v. Its Workmen, [1962)1 S.C.R. 711, Greaves
Cotton Co. Ltd. & Anr. v. Their Workmen, [1964)1 L.L.J. 342 and
Burhanpur Tapti Mills Ltd. v. Burhanpur Taptl Mills Mazdoor Sangh,
A.LR. 1965 S.C.. 839, referred to.
(v) The Tribunal rightly declined to accept the demand that the Association and the Union should be allowed 'lo participate and represent workers in disputes between individual workmen and the Reserve Bank. This
would make internal administration impossible. [60B]
(vi) In making its award operate from January 1, 1962 and rejecting
the appellants' demand that it should come into force from November 1,.
1957 or at leai;t from March 21, 1960, the National Tribunal did not
act unreasonably. Ordinarily an award comes into operation from the time
stated in sub-3. (1 ) of s. 17A of the Industrial Disputes Act.. 1.e. on the
expiry of thirty days from the date of its pnblication. The Tribunal however is given power to make it applicable from another date, and it could'
not be said that in the present case the discretion had not been exercised'
on judicial principles. [63 A-Bl
Upton>'s case, [1959)1 L.L.J 431, Remington Rand's [1962)1 L.L.J. 287,
Rajkamal Kalamnndir (P) Ltd. v. Indian Motion Picture Employees' Union
& Or», [1963]1 L.L.J. 318, Western India Match Co. Ltd. v. Their Workmen, [196212 L.L.J. 459, Wenger & Co. and Ors. v. Their Workmen, [1963)2
L.L.J. 403 and Hindustan Times Ltd. v. Their Workmen, [1964]1 S.C.R.
234, referred to.
Appeal by special leave from the award dated September 8,
I 962 of the National Industrial Tribunal (Bank Disputes) at Bombay in Reference No. 2 of 1960.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 4 of
1965.
A. S. R. Chari, D.S. Nargolkar, K. Rajendra Cha11dh11ry and
K. R. Chaudhuri, for the appellants.
N. A. Palkhivala. N. V. Phadke and R. H. Dhebar, for respondent No. 1.
A tiqur Rehman and K. L. Hat hi, for respondent No. 2 .
•
H
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Hidayatullah, J. This is an appeal by special leave from the
Award of the National Industrial Tribunal (Bank Disputes)°
Bombay, in a dispute between the Reserve Bank of India and its
30
SUPREMB COURT
REPORTS
[1966] l S.C.R.
workmc:1. Jdi vcred on September 8, 1962 and published in the
Gazette of lt;tiia (Extraordinary) of September 29, 1962. Th·~
appellants are the AH India Reserve Bank Employees' A~socia
tion, Bombay (s:iortly the Association) representing CIJss JI and
Class Ill staff and the All India R~"Scrvc Bank "D'' Cla\s Employees' Union, Kanpur (i,hortly the Union) representing Cia's
IV »ta!I, of the Reserve Bank.
By notification No. S.0. 704 dated the 21st March 1960, the
untral Government, in exercise of its powers under s. 7B of
the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, constituted a J',;ational lndu'trial Tribunal with Mr. Justice K. T. Desai (later Chief Justice of
the Gujarat High Court) as the Presiding Officer. By an order
notified under No. S.O. 707 of the same date, Central Government.
in the exercise of the powers conferred by sub-s. (IA) of s. 10 of
the Industrial Disputes Act, referred an industrial dis~·Ute, which,
in its opinion, existed between the Re,erve Bm1k and its workmen
of the three classes above-mentioned. The Order of Rcfeoencc
specified the beads of dispute in two schedules, the first in respect
of Class II and Class Ill stall and the second in rcsricct of Cla~s
IV staff. 111e first Schedule consisted of 22 items and the second
of 23 items. These items (a considerable number of whkh are
common to the two schedules) hear upon the scales of
pay nnd dearness and other allow~nces am! sundry mat·
ters connected with the conditions of service of th,:
three cbsses. The reference was registered as Reference No. 2
of 1960. During the trial of the Reference the Association and
the Union severally made applications for intcr:m relief a'king
for 25 % of the total emoluments to Class IV employees with a
minimum of Rs. 25 and for 25% of the basic pay to the employees of the two higher classes, with effect from July 1959, but
this was refused by an interim Award dated December 29, 1960.
The final Award was delivered on September 8, 1962 bec:mse in
the meantime the Tribunal dealt with another reference re[!istered
as Reference No. I of 1960 in a dispute involving 84 banking cOJ11p~nies and Corporations and their workmen in respect of creation
of categorie9 of banks and areas for purposes of adjudication and of
scales of pay, diverse allowances and other conditions of service.
The Award in that Reference was delivered on June 7, 1962. The
Tribunal was next occupied with the resolution of yet ano:hcr
dispute over bonus between 73 banking companies and their workmen which was registered as Reference No. 3 of 1960 and which
was concluded by an award on July 21. 1962. We shall have oecasion to refer to these awards later. We may now give the facts of
Ike dispute in the Reference from which this appeal arises.
A
•
B
c
D
E
F
G
•
'
H
\
-
EMPLOYEES
'
A
•
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, /.)
31
The Reserve Banlc was established on April l, 1935 as a
shareholders' Banlc with a capital of Rs. 5 crores which was mainly
subscribed by the public. It was taken over in 1948 by the
Government of India, when, under the Reserve Banlc (Transfer
to Public Ownership) Act, 1948, the shares were compulsorily
acquired by Government at a premium of Rs. 18.62 over and above
the face value of the share of Rs. 100. Thereafter the Reserve
Bank is administered by a Central Board of Directors nominated
by the Central Government from the civil services and public
men. There are four local Boards to advise the Central Board
and to function as its delegates. The Head Office of the Reserve
Bank is situated at Bombay with branches at Calcutta, New Delhi,
Kanpur, Madras, Bangalore, Nagpur, Lucknow, Hyderabad,
Gauhati, Trivandrum, Patna, Ahmedabad, Ludhiana, Jaipur and
Indore. The Reserve Bank acts as Banlc to the Central and State
Governments and Commercial Banks and controls the issue and
circulation of currency. It has special duties to perform under
the Banking Companies Act 1949 and supervises and controls the
banking industry in India. It regulates and controls foreign
exchange and exchange of currency and remittances to and from
India. It is hardly necessary to refer to its multifarious duties and
functions as the Central Bank and as the bankers' bank.
The Reserve Bank employs four classes of employees of which
the three lower classes are before this Court, the first class being of
officers. At the material time the total number of employees of all
description was about 9,500 of which 3,300 were in the Head Office,
1,800, 1,100 and 1,100 respectively at Calcutta, New Delhi and
Madras and the rest were distributed in varying numbers among
the remaining twelve branches. The present dispute has a long
history into the details of which it is hardly necessary to go but
as both sides have made reference to it, some of the leading events
connected with bank disputes in general, and the present dispute
respecting the Reserve Banlc, in particular, may be mentioned.
As is well-known there has been a rise in the price of commodities since 1939 and workmen earning wages and persons in the
fixed income groups are specially affected. Between the years
1946 and 1949 there were set up numerous Commissions and Tril>unals to deal with disputes between the commercial banks and
their employees. In 1946 strike notices were served on many
banks in Bombay, Bengal and the United Provinces. Jn Bombay
Mr. H. V. Divatia dealt with a dispute between the Banlc of India
and its employees, happily settled by consent (August 15, 1946)
and again with a dispute between 30 named Banks in Bombay and
32
SUPRBMB COURT REPORTS
[1966] I S.C.R.
their employees. The Award was given on April 9, 1947. That A
award was extended to Ahmedabad Bank employees by another
award published on April 22, 1948. Conciliation procccdmgs
were conducted by Mr. R. Gupta between the Imperial Bank of
India and its employees in Bengal which concluded on August 4.
1947. Other awards and adjudications were made by Mr. S. C.
Chakravarti and Mr. S. K. Sen. In the United Provinces first ti
Mr. B. B. Singh, Labour Commissioner, began arbitration in dL,.
putes between as many as 40 banks and their employees, which later
wen& before Conciliation Boards headed first by Mr. Nimbkar. and
on his death, by Mr. Bind Basni Prasad and the rccommcudatiom
were made effective by a Government order. On the representation c
of the Banks an Ordinance was promulgated (followed by an Act)
and the Central Government took over the resolution oi disp•1te'
between banks and their employees in all cases where the hanks
had offices in more than one province. On June 13, 1949 the
Central Government appointed an All India Industrial Tribunal
<Bank Disputes) with Mr. K. C. Sen and 2 members to codify the D
terms and conditions of service of bank employees. The Sen
Award (as it is known) was published on August 12, 1950 hut on
appeal this Court on April 9, 1951 declared it to be void a~ therl'
was a flaw in the composition of the Tribunal. As a re.•ult of thi'
contingency a stand-still Act was pass~d and another Tribunal with
Mr. H. V. Divatia and 2 members was erected. This Tribunal did F
not conclude the work and resigned and in 1952 another Tribunal
presided over by Mr. S. Panchapagesa Sastry was appointed which
published its award in April 1953. That Award was subjected
to an appeal before the Labour Appellate Tribunal and it was
much modified. Some banks represented to Government their inability to implement the modified award and the Central Govern· F
ment intervened and modified the award of the Labour Appellate
Tribunal by an order dated August 24, 1954. We mav leave this
general narration at thLs stage to view the di,putes b~tween the
Reserve Bank of India and its employees during the same period
In 1946 the Association delivered a charter of demand<; for
revision of pay scales and allowances of the employees of the c;
Reserve Bank from April I, 1946 and after negotiations some revision in wages and dearness allowances was effected. During the
interval between this revision and the appointment of th·~ s7istry
Tribunal other revisions took place. When the Sastry Tribunal
gave its award in March 1953, the Association in May of tt.c same
year delivered a revised charter of demands to the Reserve Bank II
but owing to the pendency of the Appeal before the Labour Appel·
late Tribunal, the demand could not be considered. The Reservl'
I
•
•
EMPLOYEES \'. RESERVE BANK
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
.
•
H
(Hidayatullah, !.)
33
Bank, however, assured its employees that after the decision of
th.e Labour Appellate Tribunal was known, the entire question
would be reviewed. When the Labour Appellate Tribunal gave
its decision in April 1954, the Association served a fresh charter
of demands on May l 8, 1954 but the decision of the Appellate
Tribunal was modified by Government and on September 17, 1954
a commission presided over by Mr. Justice Rajadhykshya and late1
by Mr. Justice Gajendragadkar (as he then was) was constituted to
consider whether the Appellate Tribunal's decision should be restored or continued with modifications and to suggest further modifications having due regard to the overall condition of banks in general
and individual banks in particular. In October 1954 the Association, realising tl1at delay was inevitable, agreed to accept the scalel•
cf pay on the basis of the modified Labour Appellate Tribunal's
decision though the employees obtained by the agreement something more than their counterparts in the higher class commercial
banks under the order of Govermnent which modified the decision
of the Labour Appellate Tribunal. The advantage to the Reserve
Bapk employees was neutralized when the Bank Award Cornmission restored the decision of the Labour Appellate Tribunal in respect of the Commercial Banks. The agreement lasted till October
31, 1957 and the Reserve Bank employees honoured it.
On July 11, 1959, the Association submitted a fresh charter
of demands asking for a complete revision of the pay structure and
invoked the norms settled at the Fifteenth Indian Labour Conference and asked for iml'.)rovement generally in the conditions of
service. As the Reserve Bank was not agreeable to negotiate, the
Association called upon the Reserve Bank to ratify the Code of
Conduct evolved at the Sixteenth Indian Labour Conference anc!
to proceed to arbitration but the Reserve Bank declin~<l. The
Association called upon the Reserve Bank to ratify the Code of
work from March 25, 1960. Before this happened the All India
State Bank of India Staff Federation had given a notice and there
was a strike from March 4, 1960 and on March I 9 all bank
employees struck work in support and the several references to
which we have referred followed.
The Reserve Bank during the years between 1946 and 1960
undertook from time to time revision of salaries and allowances.
In 1947 and 1948 dearness allowances were revised and in 1948
there was a general revision of scales of pay as from Aprill, 1948 .
These revisions were made at the demand of the Association. In
1951 ad hoc increases in dearness allowances were made and compensatory allowances were introduced and from 1951 local allowances were paid to certain classes of employees serving at some of
34
SUPRB:ME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] I S.C.R.
the important offices of the Reserve Bank and subs~quently the
scheme of local allowances was extended 10 a kw other branches.
In 1954 local allowances were converted into local pay and 25%
of the dearness allowances was treated as pay for calculation of
retiring benefits etc. In 1957 family allowances to class IV employees were raised and in 1958 aJOd 1959 d~arness allowanc~
were again slightly raise<l. These increa.ses, though welcome to
them, hardly satisfied the demands of the employees. There were
many conciliation confcreilces but none w:1< succc"ful. The cost
of living index with b:t"c year I 949c-c I 00 had increased by 26
points in February 1960 and the principl:s of minimum and fair
wages were deliberated upon and advcrt,·d to in ti~c Report of the
15th Indian Labour Conference. Th:;e princirk>. hl which detailcd reference will be made presen!ly, were desired by the employees
of the Reserve Bank to be put into o~rn:ion. 1\s a result the gap
between the demands of the employees and the olTers of the Reserve
Bank, which was wide already. became wid~r still and conciliation
which had always succoeded in the pa>!, was not po>sible. The
Associa1ion suggested arbitration but lhc Rcserv~ Bank by its
letter daled February I I. 1960. did not agree. Ti1e Reserve Bank
>talcd that it did not wbll 10 gel ·'seriously out of step"' with Government or the Commercial Banks. The Reserve Bank referred to
the Pay Commission Report and pointed out that the demand~ of
the employees took no notice of the slate of Indian ewnomv. The
Association, through iis Secrntary. in !c~1ly ( F~b. 22. 1960)
observed :
"'Your criticism. that the Association's Charter of
Demand has been pitched so high as to exclude all scope
for satisfactory solution through negotiations we may
point out, is baseless and incorrect, as the Charter has
been based on the norms set up by the l Slh Tripartite
Labour Conference at Nainital where the need-based
wa~e formula for Indian worker was evolved, and the
coefficient for conversion to arrive at the minimum wage
for a middle class salaried employee has been accepted
from the Rajadhyaksha Report ...... ".
The Association also pointed out that it had been conceded hy the
Governors of the Reserve Bank in the past that the emoluments of
the Reserve Bank employcc.s ought to be higher than
those of other Bank employees and, therefore, the recommendations of the Pay Commission were irrelevant. In this appeal one
of the fundamental points argued is whether the National Tribunal
was right in rejecting the demand for the inauguration of the need-
A
•
B
C
D
E
G
•
II
EMPLOYEES
A
'
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, !.)
35
base formula. It was, however, in this background that the
National Industrial Tribunal was constituted and the whole of
the dispute was referred to it.
This Reference embraced as many as 22 items in respect of
II and Class III employees and 23 items in respect of Class
Class
B
IV employees. Some of these were decided in favour and some
against the employees. Not much purpose would be served if
we mentioned the many points of controversy or the decision on
them, for in this appeal, the employees have stated their case with
commendable restraint and Mr. Chari, though he argued it with his
c customary earnestness and ability, did so appreciating the realities
of our national economy. He paid (it may be noted) sincere
tributes to the Reserve Bank for its helpful attitude at all times, and
expressed regret that there was no conciliation as on previous occasions. Mr. Palkhivala too, on behalf of the Reserve Bank, showed
an awareness of the point of view of the employees and on some
D of the less important points, as we shall show later, agreed to consider the matter favourably.
E
The dispute now centres round two fundamental or major
points and a few others not so fundan1ental. We shall deal with
the main points first and then deal w!th the others. The first major
point concerns employees of Class IL This class of employees
was in the scales of pay which were settled by the agreement of
November 2, 1954. These were :
1. Research
F
G
'
H
Superintendents
Rs. 301l--25-401l--E.B.-25-6SO.
2. Superintendents and SubAccountants
Rs. 275-25-375-E.B.-25-50025- 650.
3. Deputy Treasurers (Bombay
and Calcutta)
Rs. 450-25-650.
4. Deputy Treasurer (Gauhati)
Rs. 375-25-550.
S. Assistant Treasurers
Rs. 330-25-450.
6. Personal Assistant to the
Governor
Rs. 321'~30-650.
7. Personal Assistant
Rs. 325-25-550.
8. Caretakers. Grade I (Bombay and Calcutta)
Rs. 275-10-325-E.B.-12l:-
9. Staff A.ssistant5
Rs. 250-25-450-E.B.-25650.
10. Supervisor, Premises Section
Rs. 250-15-310-E.B.-20650.
11. Deputy Treasurer (Hyderabad)
Rs. 350-25-500.
400.
36
SUPllEME
COURT
REPORIS
tl966J I S.C.R
There was in addition local pay for these employees equal to 10%
of pay, at Bombay, Calcutta, Ahmedabad, New Delhi, Madras and
Kanpur. There was also a family allowance of Rs. I 0 per child
subject to a maximum of Rs. 30 for employees drawing le<s than
Rs. 550 per month with ~ completed service of 5 years.
A
The National Tribunal in considering the dem:m<ls of Class 11
staff of the Re;erve Bank came to the conclusion that it could not
give any award regarding these employees who were employed in a
superviwry capacity. In this connection the Re,et vc Bank had
pleaded :hat the Reference concerned only those employees who
came within the definition of "workman" in the Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947, as amended by the amending Act of 1956, and the
Reserve Bank had contended that it was futile to fix a time scale
for Class II staff because every incumbent in it w:h cm~!,1ycd in a
supervisory capacity and under the existing scales of pay every
incumbent at a local pa,)' centre would draw wages in excess of
Rs. 500 after three years' service and every other incumbent at
the end of 5 years' service and that most of the employees in that
class had entered it by promotion and even at their entry were
drawing wages in exce~s of Rs. 500. The Rese1•·c Rank had
funher contended that a dispute could only be rahed before the
National Tribunal provided a workman continued to be a workman
as defined .. If the National Tribunal was asked to provide a scale of
payment which would make the workman cease to be workman by
reason of the award, the Reserve Bank e<'ntended, the National
Tribunal had no jurisdiction to make such an award anti the Reference itself would become incompetent. The relation.ship of employer and workman, so it was contended, must exist (a) at the
time of dispute, (b) at the time of the award, and (c) during the
currency of the award, otherwise the Reference and the consequent
award would he without jurisdiction.
JI
The Associ:uion had contended in reply (a; it docs in t11i.s
appeal) that the duties performed by these employees were not
of a supervisory nature and further that they were doing .111pervisory work and were not employed in a supervisory capaci1y. In
Reference No. 1 of 1960, Mr. Sule, on behalf of the employees, had
contended (a) that workmen could raise an industrial dispute for
themselves and for a section of them at any level, (b) that per.;ons
who were workmen could raise an industrial dhpute regarding
their conditions of service not only at sta~cs '·'·hen they would be
workmen but also at stages when they would cease to be workmen
under the same employe•, and ( c) that workmen could raise a
dispute on behalf of non-workmen in the .same estahlishmo:lt pro-
'
('
F
(;
ll
-
EMPLOYEES \', RESERVE BANK
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
•
H
(8idayatullah, /.)
37
vided they had a direct and substantial interest in the dispute and
bad a community of interest with such non'workmen.
The National Tribunal in the present award adopted its discussion of the question in paragraphs 5.206 to 5.219 of the award in
Reference No. 1 of 1960. It pointed out that the demand by
Class II Supervisory Staff envisaged a scale commencing at Rs. 500
and that if the demand were considered favourably everyone in tliat
class would cease to be a workman and such an award was beyond
its jurisdiction to make. The National Tribunal held that even
though by reason of community of interest other workmen might
be entitled, having regard to the definition of "industrial dispute",
to raise a dispute on behalf of others, they could not raise a dispute
either for themselves or on behalf of others, when the dispute
would involve consideration of matters in relation to non-workmen.
The National Tribunal also held that it would even be beyond the
jurisdiction of Central Government to refer such a dispute under
the Industrial Disputes Act. The National Tribunal, therefore.
held that the expression "scales of pay and methods of adjustment
in the scales of pay" in Schedule I of the present Reference conld
not cover non-workmen such as supervisory staff in Class II. Those
employed in supervisory capacity and drawing more than Rs. 500
p.m. were treated as not present before the National Tribunal and
ll.i they could not be heard the National Tribunal found it inexpedient to fix scales of salary affecting them. As regards those employed in the same capacity but drawing less than Rs. 500 per
month but on scales carrying them beyond that mark, the National
Tribunal thought that if all that it could do was to fix a scale up to
Rs. 500, it would be unfair to lower the scale already fixed. The
National Tribunal thus made no award in regard to supervisory staff
in Class II.
Before we consider the case of the appellant' an event which
happened later may be mentioned. The Reserve Bank by a Resolution (No. 8) passed at their 1456th weekly ineeting held on April
24, 1963, increased the scale of pay, dearness allowances, house
rent allowances etc. for Class II staff with effe.ct from January 1,
1962, that is to say, the date from which the impugned award
came into force. Under. the Resolution scales of pay, which were
acknowledged by Mr. Chari, to be as generous as the present circumstances of our country permit, have been awarded. But more
than this the minimum total emoluments as envisaged by the definition of wages, even at the commencement of service of each and
every member of Class II staff on January I, 1962 now exceed
Rs. 500 per month. This, of course, was done with a view to with-
:<8
SUPREME COURT
REPORTS
[ 1966) l S.C.R.
drawing the whole class from the ambit of the Reference, because,
it is supposed, no member of the class can now come within the
definition of "workman". We shall, of course, decide the question
whether the Resolution has that effect. If it does, it certainly
relieves us of the task of considering scales of pay for these employee& for no remit is now possible as no National Tribunal is
.,i1ting. The scales having been accepted as generous, the dispute
regarding scales of pay for Class II employees under the Reference,
really ceases to be a live issue.
However, in view of the impo11ance of the subject and the
rossibility of a recurrence of such question in other spheres, and
the remarks of the National Tribunal as to jurisdiction of the
Central Government and itself we have considered it necessary to
go into some of the points mooted bcforo us. Before we deal with
them we shall read some of the pertinent definitions from tho Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 :
"2. In thi, Ac!, unless there is ;1nything repugnant in
the subject or context,-
(k) ··industrial dispute"' means any dispute or difference between employers and employers, or between employers and workmen, or between workmen and workmen, which is connected witti the employment or nonemployment or the terms of employment or with the
condition of labour, of any person;
A
B
'
c
D
E
...
( rr) ··wage·," means all remuneration capable of
being c~prcsscd in tenns of money, which would, if tho
terms of employment, expressed or implied, wero fulfilled, be payable to a workman in respect of his employment or of work done in such employment, and
includes-
G
( i) such allowances (including dearness allowance) as the workman is for the time being
entitled to;
(ii) the value of any house accommodation, or of
supply of light, water, medical attendanco or
other amenity or of any service or of any concessional supply of foodgrains or other articles;
•
H
EMPLOYEES
•
A
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, J.)
39
(iii) any travelling concession;
but does not include( a) any bonus;
B
(b) any contribution paid or payable by the employer
to any pension fund or provident fund or for the
benefit of the workman under any Jaw for the
time being in force;
( c) any gratuity payable on the termination of his
service.
C
D
E
(s) "workman" means any person (including an
apprentice) employed in any industry to do any skilled
or unskilled manual, supervisory, technical or clerical
work for hire or reward, whether the terms of employment be expressed or implied, and for the purposes of
any proceeding under this Act in relation to an industrial dispute, includes any such person who has been dismissed, discharged or retrenched in connection with, or
as a consequence of, that dispute, or whose dismissal,
discharge or retrenchment has Jed to that dispute, but
does not include any such person(i) who is subject to the Army Act, 1950, or the Air
Force Act, 1950, or the Navy (Discipline) Act,
1934, or
(ii) who is employed in the police service or as an
officer or other employee of a prison; or
F
G
,.H
(iii) who is employed mainly in a managerial or
administrative capacity; or
(iv) who, being employed in a supervisory capacity,
draws wages exceeding five hundred rupees per
mensem or exercises, either by the nature of the
dttties attached to the office or by reason of the
powers vested in him, functions ma.inly of a
managerial nature."
Mr. Chari contends that the exclusion of Class II staff is based
on a wrong construction of the above definitions particularly the
definition of 'workman' and a misunderstanding of the duties of
Class II employees who have been wrongly classed as supervisors.
He contends alternatively that as Class II is filled by promotion
from Class III, the que~tion could end should have been gone into
SUPllBMI! COURT
REPORTS
(1966) I S.C.R
in view of the principle enunciated in the Dimakuclri Tea Estate(') A
case. Mr. Chari in support of his first argument points to the
opening part of s. 2(s) where it speaks of "any skilled or unskilled
manual, supervisory, technical or clerical work" and contrasts it
with the words of clau~e (iv) "being employed in a supervisory
capacity" and submits that the difference in language is deliberate
and is intended to distinguish spervisory work from plain super- 8
i-mon. According to him 'supervisory work' denotes that the
person works and supervises at the same time, whereas 'supervisory capacity' denotes supervision but not work. Mr. Chari
divides supervision into two kind, : (a) supervision which i~ a part
of labour and (b) supervision which is akin to managerial func- C
tions though it is not aatually so. He submits that this division is
dearly brought out in the definition of 'workman' by the use of
different expressions such as "work" and "capacity" for that a
supcrvi,or doing work enjoys the status nf labour and a supervisor
acting only in supervisory capacity enjoys the status of employer's
agent at the lowest level.
D
In support of his contention Mr. Chari has referred to the
amendment of the National Labour Relations Act of the United
States of America [commonly known as the Wagner Act(')] by
the Labour Management Relations Act 1947 [commonly known
as the Taft-Hartley Act(')] and the case of the Packard Motor Co.
v. The National Labo11r Relations Hoard(') which preceded the
amendment. The Packard Motor Cu. case arose under the Wagner
Act and the question was whether foremen were entitled as a class
to the rights of self-org;misation and collective bargaining under it.
The benefits of the Wagner Act were conferred on employee1;
which bys. 2(3) included 'any employee'. The Company, however, sought to limit this wide definition which made foremen employees both at common law and in common acceptance, with the
aid of the detinition of 'employer' ins. 2(2) which said that the
word included "any person acting in the interest of an employer
direccly or indirectly .... ". The Supreme Court of the United
States in holding that foremen were entitled to the protection of the
Wagner Act held by majority that even those who acted for the
employer in some mailers including standing between the management and manual labour could have interests of their own when
it came to iixation of wages, hours, seniority rights or working conditions. Mr. Chari sug!!e'1s that th~ <lcfinition in the Industrial
(I) (1958! t Ll..J. 500.
(3) \1947) 6t Stat 136.
<2' (1935) 49 Stal 449
(4) 91 1-. ,d_ 1040.
E
F
G
II
•
EMPLOYEES
A
•
•
n
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, J.)
41
Disputes Act serves the same purpose when it makes a distinction
between 'work' and 'capacity' .
This ruling, of course, cannot be used in this context though as
we shall presently see it probably furnishes the historical background for the amendment in the United States and leads to the
next limb of Mr. Chari's argument. The minority speakin~
through Mr. Justice Douglas, made the following observation which
puts the Packard Motor Co. case(') out of consideration"Indeed, the problems of those in the supervisory
categories of management did not seem to have been in
the consciousness of the Congress. . . . . . . . There is no
phrase in the entire Act which is description of those
doing supervisory work".
In this state of affairs it is futile to refer to this ruling any further
for to derive assistance from any of the two opinions savours of
a priori deduction.
D
E
F
G
The argument is extremely ingenious and the simile interesting
but it misses the realities of the amendment of the Industrial Disputes Act in 1956. The definition of 'workman' as it originally
~tood before the amendment in 1956 was as follows : -
•
.•
The Packard Motor Co. case was decided in March 1947 and
in the same year the Taft-Hartley Act was passed. Section 2 of
the latter Act defined employer to include "any person acting as
agent of an employer, directly or indirectly ...... " and the term
'employee' was defined to exclude any individual employed as a
supervisor. The term 'supervisor' was defined to mean an individual "having authority, in the interest of the employer to hire,
transfer, suspend, lay off, recall, promote, discharge, assign, reward,
or discipline other employees or responsible to direct them, or to
adjust their grievances, or effectively to recommend such action,
if in connection with the foregoing the exercise of such authority is
not of a merely routine or clerical nature, but requires the use of
independent judgment". Mr. Chari suggests that the Industrial
Disputes Act recognising the same difficulty, may be said to have
adopted the same tests by making a distinction between 'work' and
'capacity'. According to him, these tests provide for that twilight
area where the operatives (to use a neutral term) seem to enjoy
a dual capacity.
H
''2. (s) 'workman' means any person employed (including an apprentice) in any industry to do any skilled
(1) 91 L. ed. 1040.
42
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] 1 S.CR.
or unskilled manual or clerical work for hire or reward
and includes, for the purposes of any proceedings under
this Act in relation to an industrial dispute, a workman
discharged during that dispute, but docs not include any
person employed in naval, military or air service of the
Government."
A
•
8
The amending Act of J 956 introduced among the categories of
persons already mentioned persons employed to do supervisory
and technical work. So far the language of the earl;er enactment
was used. When, however, exceptions were engrafted, that language was departed from in cl. (iv) partly because the draftsman
followed the language of cl. (iii) and partly because from persons c
employed on supervision work some are to be excluded because
they draw wages exceeding Rs. 500 per month and some becau~
they function mainly in a managerial capacity or have duties of
the same character. But the unity between the opening part of
the definition and cl. (iv) was expressly preserved by using the
word 'such' twice in the opening part. The words, which bind the D
two parts, are not-"but does not include any person''. They are
-"but does not include any such person" showing clearly that
what is being excludo:l is a person who answers the description
"employed to do supervisory work" and he i~ to be excluded
because being employed in a 'supervisory capacity' he draws wages
exceeding Rs. 500 per month or exercis~s functions of a particular E
character.
The scheme of our Act is much simpler than that of the
American statutes. No doubt like the Taft-Hartley Act the
amending Act of 1956 in our country was passed to equalise bargaining power and also to give the power of bargaining and invoking the Industrial Disputes Act to supervisory workmen, but it
gave it only to some of the workmen employed on supervisory
work. 'Workman' here includes an employee employed as supervisor. There are only two circumstances in which such a person
eeases to be a workman. Such a person is not a workman if he
draws wages in excess of Rs. 500 per month or if he performs G
managerial functions by reason of a power vested in him or by
the nature of duties attached to his office. The person who ceases
to be a workman is not a rer<on who does not answer the description "employed to do supervisory work" but one who doe• answn
that description. He goes out of the category of "workmen" on
proof of the circumstances excluding him from the category.
H
By the revision of salaries in such a way that the minimum
emoluments equal to wages (as defined 'P the Act) of Class II
•
EMPLOYEES
..
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, !.)
43
A
staff now exceed Rs. 500 per month, the Reserve Bank intends
to exclude them from the category of workmen and to render the
Industrial Disputes Act inapplicable to them. Mr. Palkhivala
frankly admitted that this step was taken so that this group might
be taken away from the vortex of industrial disputes. But this
position
obviously did not exist when the scale was such that some
B
at least of Class II employees would have drawn wages below
the mark. The Reference in those circumstances was a valid reference and the National Tribunal was not right in ignoring that
class altogether. Further, the National Tribunal was not justified
in holding that if at a future time an incumbent would draw wage
c in the time scale in excess of Rs. 500, the matter must be taken
to be withdrawn from the jurisdiction of the Central Government
to make a reference in respect of rum and the National Tribunal
to be ousted of the jurisdiction to decide the dispute jf referred.
Supervisory staff drawing less than Rs. 500 per month cannot
be debarred from claiming that they should draw more than
D Rs. 500 presently or at some future stage in their service. They
can only be deprived of the benefits if they are non-workmen at
the time they seek the protection of the Industrial Disputes Act.
E
Mr. Chari next contends that considering the duties of Class;
II employees, it cannot be said that they are employed in a supervisory capacity at all and in elucidation of the meaning to be given
to the words 'supervisory' and 'capacity' he has cited numerous
dictionaries, Corpus Juris etc. as to the meaning of the words.
"supervise",
F
G
H
"supervisor", "supervising", "supervision"
etc. etc ..
The word "supervise" and its derivatives are not words of precise
import and must often be construed in the light of the context, for
unless controlled, they cover an easily simple oversight and direction as manual work coupled with a power of inspection and
superintendence of the manual work of others. It is, therefore,
necessarv to see the full context in which the words occur and the
words of our own Act are the surest guide. Viewed in this manner
we cannot overlook the import of the word "such" which expressly
links the exception to the main part. Unless this was done it would'
have been possible to argue that cl. (iv) indicated something,
whlch, though not included in the main part, ought not by construction to be so included. By keeping the link it is clear to see
that what it excluded is something which is already a part of the
main provision.
In view of what we have held above it is hardly 'necessary
to advert to the next argument that under the principle of the
L5Sop, CI/65-4
SUPR.l!MB
COUR. T
lll!POR. TS
[1966] I S.C.R
Dimakuchi Tea Estate Case(') workmen proper belonging to
Clas!! II and Ill in this Reference are entitled to raise a dispute
in respect of employees in Class II who by reason of cl. (iv) teit
have ceased to be workmen. The ruling of this Court in the
above case lays down that when the workmen raise an induitrial
dispute against an employer, the person regarding whom the dispute is raised need not strictly be a 'workman' but may be one
in whose temis of employment or conditions of labour the workmen raising the dispute have a direct and substantial interest. The
definition of 'industrial dispute' in s. 2(k), which we have set out
before, contemplates a dispute between
(a) employers and employers; or
A
B
c
(b) employers and workmen; or
(c) workmen and workmen;
but it must be a dispute which is connected with the employment
or non-employment or the terms of employment or with the conditions of labour of any person. The word 'person' has not been
limited to 'workman' as such and must, therefore, receive a more
general meaning. But it does not mean any person unconnected
with the disputants in relation to whom the dispute is not of the
kind described. It could not have been intended that though
the dispute does not concern them in the least, workmen are entitled to fight it out on behalf of non-workmen. The National
Tribunal extended this principle to the supervisors as a class relying on the following observations from the case of this Court :
"Can it be said that workmen as a class are directly or
substantially inte:rested in the employment, non-employment, terms of employment or conditions of Jabour of
persons who belong to the supervisory staff and are,
under provisions of the Act, non-workmen on whom
the Act has conferred no benefit, who cannot by themselves be parties to an industrial dispute and for whose
representation the Act makes no particular provision?
We venture to think that the answer must be in the negative."
It may however, be said that if the dispute is regarding employment, 'non-employment, terms of employment or conditions of
labour of non-workmen in which workmen arc themselves vitally
interested, the workmen may be able to raise an industrial dispute.
Workmen can, for example, raise a dispute that a class of em(I) {1958) I L.L.J. 500.
[)
E
F
G
H
.
EMPLOYEES
.
•
A
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, J.)
45
ployees not within the definition of workman should be recruited
by promotion from workmen. When they do so the workmen
raise a dispute about the terms of their own employment though
incidentally the terms of employment of those who are not workmen is involved. But workmen cannot take up a dispute in respect of a class of employees who are not workmen and in whose
B terms of employment those workmen have no direct interest of
their own. What direct interest suffices is a question of fact but
it must be a real and positive interest and not fanciful or remote.
It follows, therefore, that the National Tribunal was in error in
not considering the claims of Class II employees whether at the
instance of members drawing less than Rs. 500 as wages or at
the instance of those lower down in the scale of employment.
The National Tribunal was also in error in thinking that scales
of wages in excess of Rs. 500 per month at any stage were not
within the jurisdiction of the Tribunal or that Government could
not make a reference in such a contingency. We would have
D been required to consider the scales applicable to those in Class II
but for the fact that the Reserve Bank has fixed scales which are
admitted to be quite generous.
It may be mentioned here that Mr. Chari attempted to save
the employees in Class II from the operation of the exceptions in
cl. (iv) by referring to their duties which he said were in no
E sense 'supervisory' but only clerical or of checkers. He also cited
11 nUD1.ber of cases, illustrative of this point of view. Those are
cases dealing with foremen, technologists, engineers, chemists,
shift engineers, Asst!. Superintendents, Depot Superintendents,
godown-keepers etc. We have looked into all of them but do not
F find it necessary to refer to any except one. In Ford Motor Company of India v. Ford Motors Staff Union, ( 1 ) the Labour Appellate Tribunal correctly pointed out that the question whether a
particular workman is a supervisor within or without the definition
of 'workman' is "ultimately a question of fact, at best one of
mixed fact and Jaw .... " and "will really depend upon the nature
G of the industry, the type of work in which he is engaged, the
organisational set-ttp of the particular unit of industry and like
factor". The Labour Appellate Tribunal pertinently gave the
example that "the nature of the work in the banking industry is
in many respects obviously different from the nature and type of
work in a workshop department of an engineering or automobile
concern." We agree that we cannot use analogies to find out
whether Class II workers here were supervisors or doing mere
(l) [1953] 2 L.L.1. 444.
46
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1966] l S.C.R.
clerical work. No doubt, as Mr. Chari stated, the work in a Bank A
in?Olves layer upon layer of checkers and checking is hardly
supervision but where there is a power of assigning duties and
distribution of work there is supervision. In Llyods Bank Ltd. v.
Pannalal Gupta ( 1 ), the finding of the Labour Appellate Tribunal
was reversed because the legal inference from proved facts was
wrongly drawn. It is pointed out there that before a clerk can B
claim a special allowance under para 164(b) of the Sastry Award
open to Supervisors, he must prove that he supervises the work of
oome others who are in a sense below him. It is pointed out
that mere checking of the work of others is not enough because
trus checking is a part of accounting and not of supervision and
c
lhc work done in the audit department of a bank is not supervision.
The Reserve Bank has placed on record extracts from the
manuals, orders, etc. relative to all Class II employees and on
looking closely into these duties we cannot say that they are not
of a supervisory character and are merely clerical or checking.
These employees distribute work, detect faults, report for penalty,
make arrangements for filling vacancies, to mention only a few of
the duties which are supervisory and not merely clerical. Without
discussing the matter too elaborately we may say that we are
satisfied that employees in Class II except the Personal Assistants,
were rightly classed by the National Tribunal as employed on
supervisory and not on clerical or checking duties. In view of
the fact that all of them now receive even at the start "wakes" in
excess of Rs. 500 per month, there is really no issue left concerning them, once we have held that they are working in a supervisory
capacity.
•
•
D
E
F
The next fundamental point requires narration of a little
history before it can be stated. In December 1947 there was an
Industries Conference with representatives of the Government of
India and the Governments of the States, bminessmen, industrialists
and labour leaders. An Industrial Truce Resolution was passed
unanimously which stated inter alia that increase in production G
was not possible unless there was just remuneration to capital
(fair return), just remuneration to labour (fair wages) and fair
prices for the consumer. The Resolution was accepted by the
Central Government. In 1947 a Central Advisory Council was
appointed which in it$ turn set up a Committee to deliberate and
report on fair wages for workmen. The Report of that Committee H
ha~ been cited over and over again. In the Standard Vacurnn
(I) (1961] I L.L.J. 18.
•
EMPLGYEES
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, l.)
47
A
•
-
Refg. Co. v. Its Workmen('), this Court elaborately analysed the
concept of wages as stated by the Committee. The Committee
divided wages into three kinds: Living wage, fair wage and
minimum wage. Minimum wage, as the name itself implies represents the level below which wage cannot be allowed to drop .
Jtwas universally recognised that a minimum wage must be pres·
B
cribed to prevent the evil of sweating and for the benefit of workmen who were not in a position to bargain with their employers.
This received immediate attention in India, though there was an
International Convention as far back as 1928 and the demand
for fixation of minimum wages extended even to non-sweated
c industries. The result was the Minimum Wages Act of 1948.
The Fair Wages Committee understood the term minimum wage
as the lowest wage in the scale below which the efficiency of the
worker was likely to be impaired. It was described as the "wage
floor" allowing living at a standard considered socially, medically
and ethically to be the acceptable minimum. Fair wages by comD parison were more generous and represented a wage which 'lay
between the minimum wage and the living wage. The United
Provinces Labour Enquiry Committee classified the levels of
living as :
(i) Poverty level;
(ii) minimum subsistence level;
E
(iii) subsistence plus level, and
(iv) comfort level.
The concept of fair wages involves a rate sufficiently high to enable the worker to provide "a standard family with food, shelter,
f clothing, medical care and family education of children appropriate to his status in life but not at a rate exceeding the wage
earning capacity of the class of establishment concerned." A
fair wage thus is related to a fair workload and the earning capacity. The living wage concept is one or more steps higher than
fair wage. It is customary to quote Mr. Justice Higgins of
G Australia who defined it as one appropriate for "the normal needs
of average employee, regarded as a human being living in a civilized community." He explained himself by saying that the living
wage must provide not merely for absolute essentials such as
food, shelter and clothing but for "a condition of frugal comfort
estimated by current human standards" including "provision for
H evil days etc. with due regard for the special skill of the workman". It has now been generally accepted that Jiving wage means
(I) [1961] l L.L.J. 227.
48
SUPiEMI! COURT REPORTS
[1966] l S.C.R.
that every male earner should be able to provide for his family
not only the essentials but a fair measure of frugal comfort and
an ability 10 provide for old age or evil days. Fair wage lies
between the concept of minimum wage and the concept of Jiving
wage.
During the years wage determination has been done on industry-cum-region-basis and by comparing, where possible, the wage
scales prevailing in other comparable concerns. The Constitution
by Art. 43 laid down a directive principle :
"The State shall endeavour to secure, by suitable
legislation or economic organisation or in any other way,
to all workers, agricultural, industrial or otherwise,
work, a iiving wage, conditions of work ensuring a decent standard of life and full enjoyment of leisure and
social and cultural opportunity. _ . __ . "-
It may thus be taken that our political aim is 'living wage'
though in actual practice living wage has been an ideal which has
eluded our efforts like an ever-receding horizon and will so remain
for sometime to come. Our general wage structure has at best
reached the lower levels of fair wage though some employers are
paying much higher wages than the general average.
In July 1957 the Fifteenth Indian Labour Conference met as
a Tripartite Conference and one of the Resolutions adopted was :
"The recommendations of the Committee as adopted
with certain modifications, are given below : -
A.
•
B
C
D
'E
( 1)
( 2) With regard to the minimum wage fixation it was
agreed that the minimum wage was 'need-based' and
should ensure the minimum human needs of the industrial worker. irrespective of any other considerations.
To calculate the minimum wage, the Committee accepted the following norms and recommended that they
should guide all wage fixing authorities, including minimum wage committees, wage boards, adjudicators, etc;
( i) In calculating the minimum wage, the standard
working class family should be taken to consist
of 3 consumption units for one earner, the earnings of women. children and adolescents should
be disregarded.
(ii) Minimum food requirements should be calculat-
ed on the basis of a net intake of 2700 calories,
G
If
•
EMPLOYEES
A
•
B
c
D
E
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, /.)
49
as recommended by Dr. Aykryod for an average
Indian adult of moderate activity.
(iii) Clothing requirements should be estimated at a
per capita consumption of 18 yards per annum
which would give for the average worker's family
of four a total of 72 yards.
(iv) In respect of housing the norm should be the
minimum rent charged by Government in any
area for houses provided under the Subsidised
Industrial Housing Scheme for low income
groups.
( v) Fuel, lighting and other 'miscellaneous' items
of expenditure should constitute 20 per cent of
the total minimum wage.
( 3) While agreeing to these guide lines for fixation
of the minimum wage for industrial workers throughout
the country, the Committee recognised the existence of
instances where difficulties might be experienced" in implementing these recommendations. Wherever the minimum wage fixed went below the recommendations, it
would be incumbent on the authorities concerned to
justify the circumstances which prevented them from
the adherence to the norms laid down .
.
The Association and the Union desire that the wage-floor
should be the need-based minimum determined at the Tripartite
Conference in the above Resolution and that the emoluments of
the middle class staff should be determined with a proper coefficient. They suggest a co-efficient of 120% in place of the
80% applied by the National Tribunal, to determine the wages
of the middle class staff in relation to the wages of the working
G classes. In support of their case the employees first point to the
Directive Principle above-quoted and add that the First Five Year
Plan envisaged the restoration of "pre-war real wage as a first-step
towards the living wage" through rationalisation and modernisation and recommended that "the claims of labour should be dealt
with liberally in proportion to the distance which the wages of
!I dilferent categories of workers have to cover before attaining the
living wage standard." The employees next refer to the Second
Five Year Plan where it is stated :
F
•
•
SUPdMB COUAT llBPOllTS
50
[1966] l S.C.R.
"21. Wages
A wage policy which aims at a structure with rising
real wages requires to be evolved. Workers' right to a
fair Wage has been recognised but in practice it has
been found difficult to quantity it In spite of their best
efforts, industrial tribunals have been unable to evolve a
consistent formula ...... ".
(p. 578 para 21).
The establishment of Wage Bnards, the taking of a wage census
and the improvement of marginal industries which operate as a
'drag' on better industries was suggested in that Plan. Finally,
it is submitted that the Third Five Year Plan has swnmed up the
position thus; in paras 20 and 21 at p. 256:
"20. "The Government has assumed responsibility
for securing a minimum wage for certain sections of
workers, in industry and agriculture, who are commercially weak and stand in need of protection. Towards this
end the Minimum Wages Act provides for the fixation
and revision of wage rates in these occupations. These
measures have not proved effective in many cases. For
better implementation of the law, the machinery for
inspection has to be strengthened ........ ".
"21. Some broad principles of wage determination have
been laid down in the Report of the Fair Wages Committee. On the basis of agreement between the parties,
the Indian Labour Conference had indicated the content
of the need-based minimum wage for guidance in the
settlement of wage disputes. This has been reviewed
and it has been agreed that the nutritional requirements
of a working family may be re-examined in the light
of the most authoritative scientific data on the subject . ....... ".
The Association and the Union contend that the National
Tribunal ought to have accepted the Tripartite Resolution and
determined the basic wage in accordance therewith.
The National Tribunal in adjudicating on this part of the case
referred to the Crown Aluminium Works v. Workmen(')
where at page 6 this Court observes :
"Though social and economic justice is the ultimate
ideal of industrial adjudication, its immediate objcc(t) [l 958) I L.L.J. I.
A
•
•
B
c
I)
•
E
F
G
II
•
EMPLOYEES
A
•
B
c
D
E
F
G
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, /.)
51
tive in an industrial dispute as to the wage structure
is to settle the dispute by constituting such a wage
structure as would do justice to the interests of
both labour and capital, would establish harmony
between them and lead to their genuine and wholehearted co-operation in the task of production ..... .
In achieving this immediate objective, industrial
adjudication takes into account several principles
such as, for instance, the principle of comparable
wages, productivity of the trade or industry, cost of living and ability of the industry to pay. . . . . . . . . . . . In
deciding industrial disputes in regard to wage structure,
one of the primary objectives is and has to be the restoration of peace and goodwill in the industry itself on a
fair and just basis to be detenn ined in the light of all relevant considerations ...... ".
Tke National Tribunal pointed out that the Planning Commission
had set up an official group for study and as a result of the deliberations, the group decided to prepare notes on different aspects
of wage so that they could be sent to wage fixing bodies. Four
such notes were drawn up and were circulated to the 15th Indian
Labour Conference and the 15tl1 Indian Labour Conference deliberated on them and the Resolution on which reliance iS placed
by the employees was the result. The National Tribunal, while
appreciating the importance of the Resolution, was not prepared
to act on it pointing out that it was not binding but recommendaklry, that Government did not accept it and that the Reserve
Bank not being a party was not bound by it. There is no doubt
that Government in answer to a query from the Pay Commission
answered:
" ...... The Government desire me to make it clear
that the recommendations of the Labour Conference
should not be regarded as decisions of Government and
have not been fonnally ratified by the Central Government. They should be regarded as what they are, namely, the recommendations of the Indian Labour Conference which is tripartite in character. Government have,
at no time, committed themselves to taking executive
action to enforce the recommendations".
The National Tribunal, therefore, did not consider itself bound
in any way by what the Resolution said.
52
SUPRBMB
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] I S.C.R.
The National Tribunal then considered the Resolution on
merits as applicable to the. case in hand observing :
"For the first time in India, norms have been crysta·
lised for the purpose of fixation of a need based minimum
wage in a Conference where the participants were drawn
from the ranks of Government, industry and labour.
Thc'c recommendations represent a landmark in the
struggle of labour for fixation of a minimum wage in
accordance with the needs for the workmen. The resolution bys down what a minimum wage should be. It
recognises that the n1inimum wage was "need-based".
The National Tribunal, however, could not accept the Resolution
hccause the Re-5olution standardised norms applicable to all indtLs·
trial workers whatever their age or the number of years of ser·
vice or the nature of thcir employment. It felt that there was
t!iniculty in accepting the basis of three consumption units at all
stages of service or the net intake of 2700 calories at all ages
pointing out that this much food was what Dr. Aykroyd thought
as proper to be consumed. The National Tribunal did not see
the need for changing the co-efficient of 80%. The National
Tribunal held that in the economy of our country the need-based
minimum suggested by th.e Resolution was merely an ideal to be
achieved by slow stages but was impossible of achievement ins·
tantly.
We ha"c been nddresjC(j able and \'Cry moving arguments on
behalf of the employees by Mr. Chari. There can be no doubt
that in our march towards a truly fair wage in the first instance
and ultimately the living wage we must first achieve the need-based
minimum. There is no doubt also that 3 consumption units for·
mula is, if anything, on the low side. In determining family
budgets so as to discover the workers' normal needs which the
minimum wage regulations ought to satisfy, the size of the standard
family is very necessary to fix. One method is to take simplc
,tatistical average of the family size and nnother is to take int(l
account son1c other factors, such as,
A
•
B
c
•
D
•
F
c;
(i) the frequency of variations in family sizes in cer·
tain regions and employments;
(ii) the number of wage earners available at different
stages;
(iii) the increa'e or decrease in consumption at diffe·
rent stages in employment, that is the age struc·
ture and its bearing on consumption.
II
•
EMPLOYEES I'. RESERVE BANK
•
•
•
53
A
The plain averages laid down in the Resolution may have to be'
weighted in different regions and in different industries and reduced in others. It is from this point of view that the Reserve Bank
has pointed out that though the consumption units are taken to
be 2.25, the earning capacity after 8 years' service is sufficient to
provide for 3 consumption units as required by the needn base formula. The question thus is whether the National Tribunal
is in error in accepting 2.25 consumption units instead of 3 as
suggested in the Resolution.
c
•
(Hidayatullah, J.)
D
Jn our judgment, the Tribunal was not wrong in accepting·
2.25 consumption units. But it seems to us that if at the start
the family is assumed to be 2.25, it is somewhat difficult to appreciate that the family would take 8 years to grow to 3 consumption
units. We are aware that the Sastry Tribunal thought of 3 consumption units at the 10th year and the Sen Tribunal at the 8th
year but we think these miss the realities of our national life.
In our country it would not be wrong to assume that on an average3 consumption units must be provided for by the end of 5 years'
service. The consumption units in the first five years should be:
graduated. As things stand today, it is reasonable to think that
3 consumption units must be provided for by the end of five
years' service, if not earlier.
The difficulty in this case in accepting the need-base formula
is very real. The Reserve Bank is quite right in pointing out that.
tbc minimum wage so fixed would be above per capita income·
in our country and that it is not possible to arrive at a constant
figure in terms of money. According to the Association and\
F the Union, the working class family wage works out to Rs. 165.9
(though the demand is reduced to Rs. 145 by the Association and
RJ;. 140 by the Union) while according to the Reserve Bank to·
Rs. 107. 7 5. The middle class wage, according to the Association,
will be Rs. 332.75 while, according to the Bank, Rs. 202. This
is because emphasis is placed on different dietary components in
G the first case and the increased differential in the second case:
Further the food requirement of 2700 calories was considered by
the Pay Commission to be too high and by the Planning Commisc
'ion (Third Plan) to be a matter for re-examination. It will have
to be examined what type of food should make up the necessary
calories and how many calories are the minimum. Further the
H amount of minimum wage calculated on the need-base formula
was said by the Pay Commission to be extraordinarily high. This
was also the view of the Labour Appellate Tribunal in East·
54
SUPREME
COURT
REPORTS
[1966] I S.C.R.
Asiatic Co. v. Workmen(1 ). Both the'c documents contain
valuable calculations and they show the enormous increase pq
sa/tum which would certainly cause enormous unrest among workmen in general in the country. It is also to be noticed that the
Reserve Bank, which Mr. Chari claims is the best employer, lo
apply the formula, is not really the right place for the experiment.
If the experiment has to be performed it must have a beginning
in a commercial concern after thorough examination and a very
.careful appraisal of the effect on the resources of the employer
and on production. The Reserve Bank is not a profit-making
commercial undertaking. Its surplus income is handed over to
·Government and becomes national income. 1ts main sources of
income are discounting Treasury Bills and interests on sterling
securities and rupee sccurilies held against the note is.,ue. Income
from exchange on remittances, commission on the management
of Public Debt and interest on loans and advances to Banks and
Governments is small. It would, therefore, appear that the Reserv"
Bank is not a proper place to determine what the need-based minimum wage should be and for initiating it. It cannot also be oveilooked that even without the formula it pays better wages than
·elsewhere.
There is, howe.-cr, n1ucb justification for the argument of
The Tripartite Conference was a very representative
·body and the Resolution was passed in the presence of representatives of Government and employers. There must be attached
proper value to the Resolution. The Resolution itself is Jl(ll!.
difficult to appreciate. It was passed as indicating the first step
towards achieving the living wage. Unfortunately, we are coo.>
·tantly finding that ba>ic wage, instead of moving to subsistence
plus level, tends to sag to poverty level when there is a rise in
prices. To overcome this tendency our wage strncture has for a
long time been composed of two items, (a) the basic wage, and
( b J a dearness allowance which is altered to neutralise, if not
entirely, at least the greater part of the increased cost of Jiving.
This docs not solve the problem of real wage. At the same time
we have to beware that too sharp an upward movement of basic
wage is likely to affect the cost of production and lead to fall in
our exports and to the rai>ing of prices all-round. There is "
vicious circle which can be broken by increased production and
not by increasing wages. What we need is the introduction Of
production bonus, increasd fringe benefits, free medical, educational aad insurance facilities. As a counterpart to this capital
•
A
D
c
D
•
Mr. Chari.
-·
-
(I) [1962] l L.L.l. 610.
••
G
•
H
EMPLOYEES
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, J.)
55·
must also be prepared to forego a part of its return. There is.
much to be said for considering the need-base formula in a1I its·
implications for it is bound to be our first step towards living wage.
As in many other matters relating to industrial disputes the problem
may, perhaps, be best tackled by agreement between Capital and
Labour in an establishment where a beginning can be safely
B made in this direction.
A
•
The next objection to the Award is in respect of the co-eflicient chosen by the Tribunal. The difference in the cost of living
between the members of the clerical staff and the subordinate
staff has been held to be an increase of 80% over .the remuneraC tion of the latter. This was laid down by the late Mr. Justice
Rajadhyaksha in a dispute between the Posts & Telegraphs Department and its non-gazetted employees. Mr. Justice Rajadhyaksha's.
oalculation was made thus :
•
D
E
F
•
"In 1922-24 there was a middle class family budget enquiry in Bombay and it was found that a family
consisting of 4.58 persons spends Rs. 138-5-0 per
month. But the average expenditure of the middle·
class family in the lowest income group (having incomes between Rs. 75 and 125) per month was
Rs. 103-4-0. In 1923 the cost of living Index
figures was 155 whereas in 1938-39 it was 104.
According to these index numbers the cost of
10
x ,. . of thc same f am1·1y wouId be 103
]1vmg
- 15
= Rs. 69·
class budget enquiry consisted of 3.29 consumption
units. Therefore for an average family of 3 consumpin 1938-39. The lowest income group in the middle
tion units, the expenditure required in 1938-39 would
have been '~;'. = Rs. 63. According to the findings
of the Rau Court of Enquiry a working class family consisting of 3 consumption units required Rs. 35 for minimum subsistence. It follows therefore that the proportion of the relative cost of living of a working class
family to that of a middle class family of 3 consumption
units is 35 : 63, i.e. the cost of living of a middle class
family is about 80 per cent higher than that of a working class family."
••
H
The family budget enquiry and the Rau Court of Inquiry were in
1922 and 1940 respectively. The Sen Award was in favour of
reducing the coefficient because the income of the working classes
56
SUPREME
COURT
RBPORTS
[1966] I S.C.lt.
.had incrcase<l remarkably in most cities after 1939. The Shastry
Tribunal actually reduced it. The Central Pay Commission fixed
.the minimum pay of middle class employee as Rs. 90 as agaiil$t
~he minimum pay of the subordinate stafI of Rs. 55, lhus making
the coefficient 64 % . The Labour Appellate Tribunal restored
the coefficient to 80%. The Association asked for a coefficient
of 120% but the Tribunal in its award m Reference
No. I gaw reasons for not accepting it. The National Tribunal
was in the advantageous position of knowing the views of employees of commercial Banks and comparing them with tho coefficient demanded here. Other Unions and Federations did not
.ask for such a high co-efficient. The National Tribunal not having any data felt helpless in the matter and preserved !ht c<>-clli·cient at 80%. It observed as follows :
"In the year of grace 1962 this Tribunal is in no
better position than the earlier Tribunals who have
dealt with the matter. The inherent infirmities in this coefficient have been pointedly referred to before me. I am
not at all certain whether I would be very much wiser by
an enquiry which may be conducted at present. Expenditure is conditioned by the income received by the
class of persons whose expenditure is being considered.
By and large, over a period of time expenditure cannot
exceed the income. The only pattern which such enquiry may reveal may be a pattern based on the income
of the class of persons whose case is being considered."
This Court is in no helter position than the National Tribunal to
say what other coefficient should be adopted. When fresh and
comprehensive enquiries are conducted, the results would show
whether the coefficient should go up or down. With the rise of
wages to higher levels among the working class the differential
is bound to be lower and this is a matter for inquiry. Till then
there is no alternative but to adhere to the co-efficient already
es1ablished.
We shall now take up for consideration some minor points
which were argued by Mr. Nargolkar. The first is a demand by
the Association for a combined seniority list so that promotion
may be based on that list and not upon the reports about the wO£k
of the employee. The National Tribunal dealt with it in Chapter
XVII of its award. Regulations 28 and 29 of the Reserve Bank.
of India (Staff) Regulations, 1948 deal with seniority and promotion and provide :
A
•
R
c
D
..
F
G
•
H
•
\
EMPLOYEES
•
•.
•
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatul/ah, !.)
57
"28. An employee confirrned in the Bank's service
shall ordinarily rank for seniority in his grade according
to his date of confirmation in the grade and an employee
on probation according to the length of his probationary service."
"29. All appointments and promotions shall be
B
made at the discretion of the Bank and notwithstanding
his seniority in a grade no employee shall have a right to
be appointed or promoted to any particular post or
grade."
Promotion, it will therefore appear, is a matter of some discretion
c and seniority plays only a small part in it. This dispute is concerned with the internal management of the Bank and the National
Tribunal was right in thinking that the item of the reference under
\ffiich it arose gave little scope for giving directions to the Bank
to change its Regulations. The National Tribunal, however, considered the question and made an observation w)Uch we reproD duce here because we agree with it :
" ...... I can only generally observe that it is desirable that wherever it is possible, without detriment to the
interests of the Bank and without affecting efficiency, to
group employees in a particular category serving in
clifferent departments at one centre together for the purE
pose of being considered for promotion, a common
seniority list of such employees should be maintained.
The same would result in opening up equal avenues of
promotion for a large number of employees and there
would be lesser sense of frustration and greater peace of
mind among the employees."
F
A
Seniority and merit should ordinarily both have a part in promotion to higher ranks and seniority and merit should temper each
other. We do not think that seniority is likely to be completely
lost sight of under the Resolutions and Mr. Palkhivala assured us
that this is not the case.
G
Mr. Hathi next raised the question of seniority between clerks
and typists but we did not allow him to argue this point as no
question of principle of a general nature was involved. The
duties of clerks and typists have been considered by the National
Tribunal and its decision must be taken as final.
H
The next point urged was about gratuity. In the statement
of the case the Association and the Union had made numerous
demands in regard to gratuity but it appears from paragraph
SUPRBME
COURT REPORTS
[1966] l S.C.R.
7, 10 of the A ward that the dispute was confined to the power to
withhold payment of gratuity on dismissal. Rule 5 ( 1) of the
Reserve Bank of India (Payment of Gratuity to Employees)
Rules, 1947, provides as follows:-
"5 ( i) No gratuity will be granted to or in the case
of, an employeo---
A
•
B
(a) if he has not completed service in the Bank for
a minimum period of 10 years, or
(b) if he is or has been dismissed from service in the
Bank for any misconduct."
c
The Association and the Union demanded modification of subrule (b) quoted above. The Sastry Tribunal had recommended
that there should be no forfeiture of gratuity on dismissal except
to the extent to which the mis-conduct of the worker had caused
loss to the establishment. The Labour Appellate Tribunal modi·
lied the Sastry Award and decided in favour of full forfeiture of
gratuity on dismissal. The Reserve Bank relied on the Express
Newspapers (Private) Ltd, and another v. Union of India and
nthers( 1 ) in support of the sub-rule and also contended that there
was no jurisdiction in the National Tribunal to consider this subject under item 20 of Schedule I or item 21 of Schedule II. The
Reserve Bank relied upon item 7 of Schedule I and item 6 of
Schedule 11. The demand of the Association and the Union was
rejected by the National Tribunal. It had earlier rejected a
similar demand in connection with the commercial banks. The
Reserve Bank did not, however, pursue the argument before us
perhaps in view of the later decisions of this Court reported in
the Garment Cleaning Works v. Its Workmen(') Greaves Corton
Co. Ltd. and others v. Their Workmen(•) and Burhanpur Tapti
Mills Ltd. v. Burhanpur Tapti Mills Mazdoor Sangh('). In these
cases it was held by this Court that gratuity is not a gift but is
earned and forfeiture, except to recoup a loss occasioned to
the establishment, is not justified. Mr. Palkhivala undertook
to get the rules brought in line with the decisions of this Court.
G
The next demand was with regard to pensions. In the
Reserve Bank there are only two retiring benefits, namely, provident fund and gratuity. There is no scheme for pensions. It
appears, however, that a few employees from the former
Imperial Bank, who are employed with the State Bank, enjoy
all the three benefits. The demand, therefore, was that the
Ii
.. -··----- - - - -· .
(I) [1961) I L.L.J. 339.
(3) 11"4) I L.L.J. 342.
(2) (196:2] I S.C.R. 711.
(4) A.l.R. 1965 S.C. 839.
D
E
F
•
EMPLOYEES
•
•
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, I.)
59'
A Reserve Bank should provide for all the three benefits, namely,
provident fund, gratuity and pension. The Reserve Bank contended that the National Tribunals had no jurisdiction under
the Reference to create a scheme of pensions for the employees.
The National Tribunal did not consider the question of jurisdiction because it rejected the demand itself. In the statement of
B the case filed by the Association this decision is challenged on
numerous grounds. The ground urged before us is tliat the
National Tribunal failed to exercise jurisdiction in respect of
this demand and indirectly declined jurisdiction by rejecting the
demand itself, The National Tribunal came to the conclusion
that two retirement benefits were sufficient and it is difficult
C for us to consider this without re-opening the question on merits,
of the demand and re-examining the view-point of the Reserve
Bank. We stated, therefore, at the hearing that we were not
inclined to enter into such a large question not of principle but
of facts.
D
E
F
The next demand was with regard to the confirmation of
temporary employees. The Association had filed a number of
Exhibits (Nos. S, 71, S72, Sl09 to Sll2) and the Union (R. 45
to R. 4 7) to show that a very large proportion of employees
were borne as temporary employees and that it took a very
long time for confirmation of temporary servants. The Bank
in reply filed Schedules (T. 67 to T. 69 and T. 112 to T. 125).
The question of confirmation and the period of probation are
matters of internal (management and no h,ard and fast rules
can be laid down. It is easy to see from the rival schedules
that probationary periods are both short and long. As no
question of principle is involved we decline to interfere and we
think that the National Tribunal was also justified in not giving.
an Award of a general nature on this point.
The next point is about the extra payment which the graduates were receiving and the fitment of persons in receipt of such
G extra amounts in the new scale provided. In the year 1946
the Bank accepted the principle of giving an allowance to employees who acquired degrees while in employment. At the
time of the present dispute graduates were in receipt of Rs. 10
as special pay. The question was whether in making fitment
in the new time scales these amounts should have been treated
H as advance increments. It appears that the National Tribunal
reached different conclusions in the two awa:rds ariSing ifrom
Reference No. l and the present Reference. In the case of
LSSup CI /65-5
60
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1966] l S.C.R.
Commercial Banks the fitment was on a different princirle and
Mr. Palkhivala agreed to make fitment in the new scale takmg
into account this special ad /we pay as advance increment.
The next demand made by both the Association and the
Union was that they should be allowed to participate and represent workers in disputes between an individual workman and
the Reserve Bank. The Tribunal did not accept this contention
for the very good reason that if Unions intervene in every industrial dispute hctween an individual workman and the establishment the internal administration would become impossible. In
our judgment, this demand cannot be allowed.
Tile last ccntcntion is with regard to the time from which
the award should operate. The stand-still agreement reached
in 1954 expired in October 1957 and the demand was that the
Award should come into force from November I, 1957 or at
least from March 21, 1960. the date of the reference. The
National Tribunal has made its award to operate from January
I, 1962. The Reserve Bank strongly opposes this demand.
According to ·the Reserve Bank the Tribunal acted more than
generou<ly and gave mare to the employees than they deserved.
The Reserve Bank submits that the employees had made exorbitant demands and wasted time over interim award and. therefore,
they cannot claim to have the award operate from the date of
the reference much less from November I. 1957. The Reserve
Bank relies upon the Lipton's cave(') and also contends that the
Tribunal's decision is discretionary and this Court should not
interfere with such a decision. Reliance is placed in this connection on Remington Rand's case,(') Rajkamal Kalamand;r
(Private) Ltd. v. lndian Motion Piclllre< Emn/nyee1" Unin" and
others(') and Western India March Company /,Id. v. Their
Workmen(') . In reply the Association contends that the demand
was not at all extravag:mt or exorbitant because it wa·; based
upon the Resolution of the 15th Indian Labour Conference and
the Reserve Bank itself was guilty of delay after 1957 inasmuch
as it asked that the report of the Pay Commission should be
awaited.
The solution of this disrute depends upon the provisions of
s. 17A of the Industrial Disputes Act. 1947. That section reads
as follows :
(I) [ 9591 t LU. 43t
(3) [196311 L.L.J. 3t8.
(2) [1962] 1 L.1..J. 187.
(4) 11962] 2 L.L.J. 459.
A
•
B
c
D
•
E
G
•
H
EMPLOYEES v. RESERVE BANK
A
B
(Hidayatullah, J.)
"17A. Commencement of the award.
( 1) An ward (including an arbitration award)
shall become enforceable on the expiry of thirty days
from the date of its publication under section 17 :
Provided that(a)
(b) if the Central Government is of opinion, m
any case where the award has been given by
a National Tribunal,
c
•
D
E
F
G
•
that it will be expedient on public grounds affecting
national economy or social justice to give effect to the
whole or any part of the award, the appropriate Government, or as the case may be, the Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette,
declare that the award shall not become enforceable
on the expiry of the said period of thirty days .
( 2) Where any declaration has been made in relation to an award under the proviso to sub-section ( 1 ) ,
the appropriate Government or the Central Government may, within ninety days from the date of publication of the award under section 17, make an order
rejecting or modifying the award, and shall, on the
first available opportunity, lay the award together with
a copy of the order before the Legislature of the State,
if the order has been made by a State Government, or
before Parliament, if the order has been made by the
Central Government.
( 3) Where any award as rejected or modified by
an order made under sub-section (2) is laid before
the Legislature of a State or before Parliament, such
award shall become enforceable on the expiry of fifteen days from the date on which it is so laid; and
where no order under sub-section (2) is made in pursuance of a declaration under the proviso to sub-section
( 1), the award shall become enforceable on the expiry
of the period of ninety days referred to in subsection
(2).
,
H
( 4) Subject to the provisions of sub-section ( l)
and sub-section ( 3) regarding the enforceability of an
award, the award shall come into operation with effect
from such date as may be specified therein, but where
61
62
SUPREME COURT
REPORTS
[l 966] l S.CR.
no date is so specified, it shall come into operation on
the date when the award becomes enforceable under
sub-section ( 1) or sub-section ( 3), as the case may
be."'
Ordinarily, an award comes into operation from the time stated
in sub-s. ( 1). The Tribunal, however, is given the power to
order that its award shall be applicable from another date. The
Tribunal stated that the date from which the award should
come into operation was not a term of reference and the Reserve
Bank had also contended that there was no specific demand for
retrospective operation of the award. In Wenger & Co., and others
v. Their Workmen, ( 1 ) lt was explained that retrospective
operation implies the operation of the award from a date prior
to the reference and the word 'retrospective' cannot apply to the
period between the date of the reference and the award. There
was no claim as such that the award should operate from
November 1, 1957 and the demand cannot be considered in the
absence of a reference to the National Tribunal. The question,
however, is whether a date earlier than January l, 1962 but not
earlier than March 21, 1960 should be chosen. Sub-section
( 4) quoted above gives a discretion to the Tribunal and this
Coun in dealing with that discretion observed in The Hindustan
Times Ltd. v. Their Workmen(') that no general principle was
either possible or desirable to be stated in relation to the fixation
of the date from which the award should operate. The Tribunal
in fixing a date earlier than that envisaged by the first sub-section
justified itself by stating that much of its time in the beginning
was occupied by Reference No. 1 and a significant amount thereafter was occupied by Reference No. 3 and there was justification
in making the award operate from January 1, 1962. From the
way in which the Tribunal expressed itself in this award and in
the award in Reference No. 1 it appears that but for the delay
that took place the Tribunal would have made the award to
operate as laid down in sub-s. (I). It has been ruled in the three
cases-Remington Rand's case,(') Rajkama/'s caYe(') and
Western India Match Company's case(')~that a discretion
exercised on judicial principles by the Tribunal about the commencement of the award should not be interfered with. Nothing
was shown to us why the award should be made to commence
earlier. Both sides were to blame in regard to the time taken up
----------(I) [1963) 2 L.L.J. 403.
(3) (196211 L.L.J. 287.
B
C
D
•
E
F
G
II
(2) [1964] I S.C.R. 234.
(4) (1961] I L.L.J. 318.
(5} (1962] 2 L.L.J. 459.
A
'
EMPLOYEES
A
B
c
v. RESERVE BANK (Hidayatullah, J.)
63
and the Tribunal perhaps found it difficult to reach a conclusion
earlier in view of the number of the references before it. In the
circumstances, it cannot be said that the selection of January 1,
1962, when the inquiry in the present reference was completed,
except the preparation of the Award, was bad. In any event
this was a matter of discretion and it cannot be said that the discretion has not been exercised on judicial principles. We decline
to interfere.
In the result the appeal fails and it will be dismissed. It may,
however, be said that the appeal would have partly succeeded
but for the creation of new scales of pay for Class II employees
and acceptance of some of the minor points by the Reserve Bank.
In this view of the matter we make no order about costs.
Appeal dismissed.
•
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org