N.VAJRAPANI NAIDU AND ANOTHER versus THE NEW THEATRE CARNATIC TALKIES LTD., COIMBATORE
Supreme Court of India | Decided 4 March 1964 | [1964] 6 S.C.R. 1015 | 1964 INSC 53
Key facts
- Decided
- 4 March 1964
- Bench
- P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR*, K.N. WANCHOO, J.C. SHAH, N. RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR, S.M. SIKRI
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 264/1962
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1964] 6 S.C.R. 1015
- Neutral citation
- 1964 INSC 53
Text of the judgment
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1015
1964
not like to go through the entire sale proceedings overagain.
In one contingency this proviso also works for the benefit Dhittndranath
Gorai
of the judgment-debtor, for he will be relieved of part of
v.
his indebtedness. But anyhow this does not show that the S11dhir ChaJulra
Gho•lt
main provision is not intended for the benefit of the judgment-debtor. We are, therefore, satisfied, on a true Subba Rao/.
construction of s. 35 of the Act, that it is intended only
foi: the be.nefit of the judgment-debtor and, therefore, he can
waive the right conferred on him under s. 35 of the Act.
',
If that be the legal position, 0. XX!, r. 90 of the Code
of Civil Procedure is immediately attracted. The concurrent
finding of the courts is that by reason of the non-observance
of the provisions of s. 35 of the Act no substantial injury
was caused to the judgme.nt-debtor. Further, though notice
was given to the judgment-debtor, in one case he did not
file objections at all and in the other case, though the
judgment-debtor filed objections, he did not attend at the
drawing up of. the prodamation. The sales are, therefore,
not liable to be set aside under the terms of the said provision.
In the result the orders of the High Court are set aside
and those of the Additional Subordinate Judge are restored.
The appellants will get their costs throughout from the 1st
respondent. There will be one set of hearing fee.
;.
Appeals allowed.
N. VAJRAPANI NAIDU AND ANOTHER
1964
Morch 4.
THE NEW THEATRE CARNATIC TALKIES LTD.,
COIMBATORE
(P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR, C.J., K. N. WANCHOO, J. c.
SHAH, N. RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR AND S. M. S!KRI JJ.)
Afadras City Tena111.~· PriJtection Act, 1922 (Act 3 o/ 1922),.ss. 9, 12-··
uasr of land for purpo•• of •nacting buildlngl-lf l•as• not ,....,.
ed after twenty years lessor entitled to vacant possts&ion . of land
after demolishing building-A.ct permitting tenant to either get
1016
JllH
N. J'aiNlfOnl
N•illN
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
CQRIPfRSalion jar building or purchase Ja.nd at price fixed by courtl'rovision whether violates landlord's jundamenral righ1s--('011s11rution of India, Arts. 19(l)(fj, 31.
Y.
Tilt appellant and his mother (the lessors) 11ranteJ a lease of an
N•w Th1alr1
Carnatic Talkie1 open silC m Ule town of co1mbatore to Abirama Chettiar under a re&istered 'deed dated Se9tember 19.1934. The ao1..ual rent stipulated under
the lease was Ks. 1u,~u anu the penuU ot tne 1ease was .lu years. ·1ne
term under the lease was that the land was to be utilised for constructi•e bwldmgs thereon for ..purposes of cinema, drama etc." It was
furthct agreed. between the par\lc:s that iu the encl oi the term the lessee
would demolish the buildings which be bad, constructed and deliver
vacant posseSSJon ot the site to the Lessor.
Abirama Cbettiar constructe'd a theatre on the site, and assigned his
rights to the respondent-company. ln an action against the company
for a decree in ejectment and for mesne profits, the Trial Court awarded
to the 1cS£Ors iii. d."'rce for poSSC1SJ.on and UlCSne profits. Against uie
decree lhe comp411Y-rospondent preferred an appeal to the Distncl
Court wtuch was transterrod for trial to the High Court. During the
pend.ency of this appeai., the ::,tale of Madras extended the Madras
City Tenants' Protection Act, 3 of 1922, as amendea by Madras Act
19 of 1955 to the Municipal Town of Coimbatore. The company then
applied under •. 9 of the Act and on thil appbcation the High Court
dlrected that the lessors do sell to the company the site in aisputo
under s. 9 of the Madras City Tenants Protection Act, 1922, agamsl
paymont ol the lull marlr.et value of the i&lld on the date of the order.
Tbc 111der was coolirmed in an appeal under tho Letters i'atenL
Held: Per Gajendragadkar, C.J., Shah and Sikri, JJ. section 12 bas been
enacted to protOct the tenants against any contractual engagements
which may ha.ve been made expressly or by implication to deprive them·
selves wholly or parually of the protection intended to be conferr"'1 by
the Statute. And the only class of cases in which the protection becomei
ineffective is where the tenant bas made a stipulation in writing registered
as to the erecUon of buildings, erected after the date of the contract
of lease. The stipulations not protected in s. 12 are only those in
writing rogistered and relate to erection of buildiU&s. such as restrictions about the size and nature of the building consrructed, the building
materials to be used therein and tlle purpose for which the building
is to be utilized.
(ii) Section 9( I) of the Act was manifestly in the interest of the
general public to electuate the mutual understanding between the landlords and the tenants as to the duration of the tenancies, and to conserve building materials by maintaining existing building'i for rurposes
for which the leases were granted. Restriction imposed upon the ri£)it
of the landlord to obtain poos...ion of the premises acmiscd accordin1
to the lcrms of the lease would, therefore not be regarded as imposing
llD unreasonable restriction in tho exeroioe of Ibo riibt coaferred upon
,r
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1017
the landlord by Art. 19(1) of the Constitution, because the restriction
WOUIU Ot: n:garot:ll as on..: Ul [fit! Ullt:ICSLS U1 lllC ,l4t:!H;:fi.1i puouc.
Whats.
•
1964
N. J'a1rai•an1
9 OOt:!J 1s nut so mu..:h to tit!!Jf!Vt: the 1anoton1 ot h1s property or 10
Naidu
acquire hl.s nghts to it as to give effect to the real agreemc:nt betwi;:en
v.
hun aud his tenant which induced the tenants to constru~;t !us buUU1ng New Theatre
on UJ.e p1ot u:t out lO hun. lt tne !aw lS not tnvaJ1J as ottenilillg Au. Carnatic Talkies
J.~l 1) llJ
01 Ule
Luns~Hul!Oil,
110 1uuepc:uuc:ut 1nrnngcn1ent 01 Art.
31 ( l J ot the Constituuon may be set up.
r
..
i'er Wanchoa and Ayyangar, JJ (dissenting) (I) The preamble of
the Act wowd indicate that tbe Act would not apply to allord protei.;l.lon
in a caso wnere oy an cxvress Lr.>fnl In a rt:g1su;reu least: ueeu a tenant
agret:J 10 surrender the slte on wllich he had erected a owJ.umg, where
he specJJi~aHy contracted that he would demoJ.Jsh the buao1ng anll oeuvta
\4;,;anl p0s::.t!S:,1on or uie s1te on lht• term1natlon of his tenancy. 11 tile
sco.ix ot the proviso to s. l!i! had to be construed 1n the;: light ot the
preamote, u is obvious that the tenant who had entered into a couttact
w11n a supulat1un of the sort as stated above could not be sa1U to have
cun::.tructell the bwldJugs on another's lan'd "in th~ hope tlld.t he woutu
nut ae evicted so long as he pays rent for the land". lhe Hlgh Court
erreu 1n mterpretung the proviso to s. 12 of the Act.
(ii) These words "as to the erection of buildings., mean a stipulation
uears on or is 10 re.1auon to the erection ui bu.1h.hn.:~. ,:,ucn a
<:Uns1rucuon would reconc1le the proviso with the prcan10Jc: w.tucn ::.e1s
out tne ObJCCt soul.ht to be acb..ieved by the Act. lt the lease deed
contains no sUpulauon whatsoever 1n regard to Lhe e1echon of uw1d1ng::.,
as wa-s the case with the large number of leases in the city ot Aiauras
wb.1ch were entered into prior to the enactment ot lhe Act 10 LY22., the
tenant wb.o erected the bu1ldlng exconc:ess1s wHhuut contravening any
1 • und.ertabng on his part, obtains protection under the Act. '1 he test
wouJ.d therefore be "did the panics advert to and have in m1nd tbe
conungency ot lbe tenant erecting buildings on the Jeased. land"'/ If
they had and had included in a solemn registered instrument a provision
wh1ch would bear upon the relative rights of the parties in the event of
the ~n:l:t1on ot buJid1ngs on the site, the stipulation would have etlci..:t
no1w1th.'!land1ng the Act; for in such an event the tenant would not
have con::.tru..:l~d buildings on the land in the hope that he would not
be UJ..Stu1 oed from possession so long as be p8.ld the rent agreed upon.
wh1~a
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 264
of 1962.
~
Appeal from the judgment and order dated April 24,
1959 of the Madras High Court in L.P.A. No. 75 of 1958.
A. V. Viswanatha Sastri and R. Ganapathy Iyer, for the
appellants.
M. C. Setalvad, M.A. Sattar Sayeed and R. Thiagarajan,
for the respondent.
ror8
1964
N. Vajrapanl
Naidu
v.
New Theatre
Carnatic Talkie.s
Shah J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
March 4, 1964. The Judgment of GAJENDRAGADKAR
C.J., SHAH and SIKRI JJ. was delivered by Shah J. Tiie ~
dissenting opinion of WANCHOO and AYYANGAR JJ. was
delivered by AYYANGAR J.
SHAH J.-The appellant Vajrapani Naidu and his mother
Bangarammal-hereinafter collectively called 'the lessors'granted a lease of an open site in the town of Coimbatore
to Abirama Chettiar under a registered deed dated September 19, 1934, for 20 years at an annual rental of Rs. 1,080/- '
for putting up a building suitable for use as a theatre.
Abirama Chettiar constructed a theatre on the site, and
assigned his rights to the New Theatre Carnatic Talkies Ltd.,
Coimbatore-hereinafter called 'the Company'. The Company attorned to the lessors and was recognised as tenant
under the lease dated September 19, 1934. On March 9, ;.
1954 the lessors served a notice calling upon the Company
to vacate and surrender vacant possession of the site, and
the Company having failed to comply with the requisition,
the lessors commenced an action against the Company for
a decree in ejectment and for mesne profits at the rate of
Rs. 1,000/- per mensem from September 19, 1954. The
Subordinate Judge at Coimbatore awarded to the lessors a
decree for possession and mesne profits at the rate of
Rs. 350/- per mensem and costs of the suit. Against the .~
decree the Company preferred an appeal to the District
Court at Coimbatore which was transferred for trial to the
High Court at Madras. During the pendency of this appeal
by G.O. No. 608 dated February 10, 1958, the State of
Madras extended the ~adras City Tenants' Protection Act 3
of 1922, as amended by Madras Act 19 of 1955, to the
Municipal town of Coimbatore. The Company then applied ....
under s. 9 of the Act for an order directing the lessors to
convey the site demised to the Company for a price to be
fixed by the Court. Panchapakesa Iyer, J., directed that
the lessors do sell to the Company the site in dispute under
s. 9 of the Madras City Tenants' Protection Act, 1922,
against payment of the full market value of the land on
the date of the order, and further directed that the trial -,.,
Court do appoint a Commissioner to fix the value of the
site based on the market value prevalent on July 28, 1958.
·-
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1019
An appeal under cl. 15 of the Letters Patent of the High
Court against the order of Panchapakesa Iyer, J., was dism_issed. With certificate granted by the High Court of
Madras, this appeal is preferred by the lessors.
1964
N Vajrapan1
Naidu
v.
New Theatre
Carnatic Talkies
Two questions fall to be determined in this appeal .:
( 1) Whether the Company is entitled under s. 9 of
the Madras City Tenants' Protection Act, 1922,
notwithstanding the terms of the lease, to an
order calling upon the lessors to sell the land
demised under the deed dated September 19,
1934; and
( 2) Whether the terms of s. 9 of the Act infringe
the fundamental right under Arts. 19(1 )(f) and
31 ( 1) of the Constitution, of the lessors, and
s. 9 is on that account invalid.
It is necessary in the first instance to notice the material
terms of the lease. The land demised under the lease was
a vacant site situate in the municipal town of Coimbatore.
The annual rent stipulated was Rs. 1,080/- and the period
of the lease was 20 · years from the date of delivery of
possession of the site. The land was to be utilised for
constructing buildings thereon for "purposes of Cinema,
drama, etc.". After the expiry of the term of 20 years
stipulated under the deed the Jessee had an option of renewal
for another period of 20 years on fresh terms and conditions.
The deed provided that "if after the termination of the
stipulated period" •
•
• the lessees "fail to pay the
arrears of rent that will fall due till that date and hand over
ipossession of the site" to the lessors "after making it clear
by dismantling the constructions therein and by demolishing
the walls etc." the lessors "shall, besides realizing the arrears
of rent due to them according to law, have the right to
take possession through Court of the site in which the
aforesaid buildings are put up after dismantling the constructions and demolishing the buildings therein''. The other
covenants of the lease are not material.
It aiJpears that before 1922, in many cases on lands in
the town of Madras belonging to others constructions had
Shah J.
1020
1964
N. Vafrapani
Naidu
v.
New Theatre
c:arnuti<: Taikies
Shah J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(rg64]
been put up by tenants obtained under periodic leases "in
the hope that they would not be evicted so long as they
paid falf rent". But on account of the inflationary pressure
m the wake of the First Wond War, there was a steep rise
in land values and rents, and many tenants who had
constructed buildings on lands obtained on leases were
sought to be evicted by the landlords. To prevent loss to
the tenants consequent upon the enforcement of the strict
provisions of the Transfer of Property Act, the Legislature
enacted the Madras City Tenants' Protection Act 3 of 1922.
Under the Act every tenant is on ejectment entitled to be
paid as compensatJon the value of any building which may
have been erected by him or by his predecessors-in-interest
and for which compensation has not already been paid to
him. Jn a suit for ejectment against a tenant in which the
landlord succeeds, the Court has to ascertain the amount of
compensation which is to be the value as on the date of
the order of the buildings constructed, trees planted and
other improvements made by the tenant and the decree in
the suit must declare the amount so found due and direct
that, on payment by the landlord into Court, within three
months from the date of the decree, of the amount so found
due, the tenant has to put the landlord into possession of
the land and the building. By s. 9 it is provided that any
tenant entiticd to compensation and against whom a suit
in ejectment has · been instituted may within the time
prescribed apply to the Court for an order that the landlord
shall sell the whole or part of the land for a price to be
fixed by the Court. The price under the Act as originally
~nacted was to be the market value of the land on the date
of the order, but by an amendment made in 1926 it has
to be the lowest market value prevalent within seven years
preceding the date of the order. On the price being fixed,
the tenant has the option wichin a period not being less
than three months and not more than three years from the
date of the order to pay into Court or otherwise the price
either the whole or in instalments with or without interest
as directed, and when the payment is made the Court has
to pass the final order directing conveyance of the land by
the landlord to the tenant, and thereupon the suit or proceeding is to stand dismissed, and any decree or order in
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1021
ejectment that may have been passed therein but which has
not been executed is to stand vacated. By s. 12 it is
provided:
"Nothing in any contract made by a tenant shall take
away or limit his rights under this Act. provided
that nothing herein contained ;hall affect any
stipulations made by the tenant in writing
registered as to the erection of buildings, in so
far as they relate to buildings erected after the
date of the contract."
The Act as originally enacted extended only to lands in the
City of Madras. let out before the commencement of the
Act for construction of buildings for non-residential as well
as residential use. By Madras Act 19 of 1955 power was
conferred upon the State Government to extend Act 3 of
1922 by notification to tenancies of land created before the
date on which the Act was extended. to any other municinal
towns and any specified village within five miles of the Citv
of Madras or such municipal town with effect from such
date as may be specified in the notification. Exercising this
µower. the Government of Madras issued a notification on
February I0. 1958. extending the provisions of the Act to
the municipal town of Coimbatore.
...
_
The scheme of the Act as extended by notification issued
under Act 19 of 1955 is that when under a tenancy of
open land within the municipal town created before the date
with effect from which the Act is extended, a building has
been constructed by the tenant. and he is sued in ejectment
by the landlord. he has the right on eiectment to be pa;d
as compensation the value as at the date of the llrder of
ejectment, of the building constructed and trees planted by
him, and he has in the alternative the right to claim an
order from the Court that the land belonging to the lessor
shall be sold to him at the price fixed by the Court according
to the terms of the statute. By s. 12 it is provided that
the rights conferred by the Act shall not be taken away or
restricted by any contract made between the landlord and
the tenant provided. however. the stipulations made bv the
tenant in writing registered as to the erection of buildings,
1964
/\' Va1tr1r..ani
Naidu
v.
New Theatre
Carnatic Talkies
Shah J.
1022
1964
N. Va1rapani
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
in so far as they relate to buildings erected after the date
of the contract of lease, are exempt from this restriction.
Naidu
v.
The lease granted by the lessors in this case was before
the
date on which the Act was extended to the Coimbatore
Carnatic Talkies
municipal town and it is common ground that the buildings
Shah J.
were constructed after the date of the contract of lease.
Ex facie, the Company as lessee had, when an order for
ejectment was made, an option to receive compensation for
the value of the structure, or to claim that the lessors shall
sell to it the land demised. But the lessors contend that
because of the stipulations in the deed of lease (which is
registered under the law in force for registration of assurances) relating to the obligation of the tenant on the expiry
of .the lease to deliver vacant possession of the land after
dismantling the constructions therein, the Company has .by
the terms of s. 12 disentitled itself to 1he benefit of s. 9 of
.the Act. It is submitted that the stipulation relating to
delivery of vacant possession of the site on the expiry of
the period of the lease after removing the buildings is a
stipulation "as to the erection of buildings" within the
meaning of s. 12, and therefore the restriction on the liberty
of contract between landlord and tenant ' imposed by the
opening clause of s. 12 is removed, and the Company is
bound by the terms of the lease and is not entitled to claim
the benefit of s. 9 of the Act. We are, for reasons presently
to be set out, unable to uphold that contention.
New
ThetJtre
Section 12 of the Act consists of two parts : by the first
part it enacts that the rights conferred upon the tenant under
the Act may not be taken away' or limited by any contract
made by a tenant. Such rights would, amongst others,
include the right to claim compensation under ss. 3 and 4 .
and the right to purchase the land from the lessor by order
of the Court under s. 9. By the second part of s. 12. the
protection granted by the first part does not avail the tenant
in certain conditions. If there be a stipulation "as to the
erection of buildings" made by the tenant in writing
registered, in so far as it relates to buildings erected after
the date of the contract, the protection conferred by the
first part of s. 12 shall not apply. A covenant in a lease
which is duly registered that the tenant shall on expiry of
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1023
19M
the lease remove the building constructed by him and deliver
vacant possession, is undoubtedly a stipulation relating to N. J'a}rapani
Naidu
).. the building, but it is not a stipulation as to "the erection
v.
of building". Section 12 has manifestly been enacted to New Theatre
effectuate the object of the Act which is set out in the Carnatic Talkies
preamble-viz. "to give protection to tenants who . . . .
Shah /.
have constructed buildings on others' lands in the hope that
they would not be evicted so long as they pay a fair rent
for the land". The Legislature has sought thereby to protect
" the tenants against any contractual engagements which may
have been made expressly or by implication to deprive themselves wholly or partially of the protection intended to be
conferred by the statute. And the only class of cases in
which the protection becomes ineffective is where the tenant
has made a st~ulation in writing registered ·as to the erection
of buildings, erected after the date of the contract of lease.
~ The restriction is therefore made only in respect of a limited
class ot cases which expressly attract fhe description of the
stipulations as to the erection of buildings. Having regard
to the object of the Act, and the language used by the
Legislature, the exception must be strictly construed, and
a stipulation as to the erection of buildings would not,
according to the. ordinary meaning of the words used,
encompass a stipulation to vacate and deliver possession of
the lanij en the expiry of the lease without claiming to
. f enforce the statutory rights conferred upon the tenant by
s. 9. The ·stipulations not protected in s. 12 are only those
in writing registered and relate to erection of buildings such
as restrictions about the size and nature of the building
constructed. the building materials to be used therein and
the purpose for which the building is to be utilized. It is
true that the operative part of s. 12 protects the tenant
• against the cteprivation or limitation of his rights under the
Act and the rights conferred by the Act do not directly relate
to covenants relating to erection of buildings. But on that
account it is not possible to give a wider meaning to the
expression "as to the erection of buildings" that the stipulation as to the erection of buildings would include stipulations
to remove buildings on the determination of the lease. It
,.- cannot be said that the literal meaning of the expression is
likely to render the exception ineffective, for stipulations
1024
1964
1V. l' a1.·apani
Naidu
v.
New Theatre
Cnrnatic Talkies
Shah J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1g64J
concerning erection of buildings in registered leases, or
contracts subsequent to the leases, providing for forfeiture
on fai.ure to comply with the terms of the lease relating to ~
the erection of buildings may undoubtedly involve limitations or deprivation of the rights of the tenant under the
Act and to that extent the protection conferred by s. 12
in favour of the landlord may be lost. The construction
for which the appellant contends assigns no meaning to the
words "as to the erection of buildings" and makes them
superfluous, besides it materially affects the scope of the ~.
relief which the Act obviously extends to the tenants falling
under its provisions.
Section 9 (I) which enables a tenant to purchase on
determination of the lease the land of 'the landlord is somewhat unusual. But it cannot be said that it imposes an
unreasonable restriction upon the right of the landlord to /.
hold and dispose of property within the meaning of An.
19 ( 1 )! f) of the Constitution. The Act applies to only a
limited class of lands : it applied to lands granted in lease
for construction of buildings before the date with effect from
which the Act is extended to the town or village. It was
enacted with a view to give protection to the tenants who
had, notwithstanding the usual covenants relating to deter~.
mination of tenancies, obtained lands on lease in the hope
~
that so long as they paid and continued to pay fair rent, '\.
they would not be evicted, but because of changed conditions
1
as a result of the War, appreciation in land values and
I
consequent increase in the level of rents, were faced with
actions in eiectment involving dismantling of properties
constructed by them. and evicti~n. The protection becomes
effective onlv when the landlord seeks to obtain, in breach
of the mutual understanding. benefit of the unearned incre- •
ment in the bnd values. by instituting a suit in ejectment.
It was manifestlv in the interest of the general public to
effectuate the m utua I understanding between the landlords
and the tenants as to the duration of the tenancies, and to
conserve building materials by maintaining existing buildings for purposes for which the leases were granted. Restric- .._
tion imposed upon the right of the landlord to obtain possession of the premises demised according to the terms
6 S.C.R.
,''(,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1025
1964
of the lease would, therefore, not be regarded as imposing
an unreasonable restriction in the exercise of the right N. Vajrapanl
Naidu
conferred upon the landlord by Art. 19 (1) (f) of the
v.
Constitution, because the restriction would be regarded as New Theatre
in the interests of the general public. We ought to empha- Carnatic Talkies
sise that what s. 9 does is not so much to deprive the landlord
Shah J.
of his property or to acquire his rights to it as to give effect
to the real agreement between him and his tenant which
induced the tenant to construct his building on the plot let
out to him. If the law is not invalid as offending Art.
19 (1 )(f) of the Constitution, no independent infringement
of Art. 31 ( 1) of the Constitution may be set up.
It was urged, however, that by the statute as amended
by the Madras City Tenants' Protection (Amendment) Act
VI of 1926 (before it was amended by Act 13 of 1960),
the price which the Court may fix and at which the tenant
is entitled to purchase the lane! is to be the lowest market
value prevalent within seven years preceding the date of the
order. This, it was submitted was unreasonable. But it
is not necessary for the rpurpose of this case to decide that
question, for the Company has offered to pay the market
value of the land as at the date on which the order was
passed by Panchapakesa Iyer, J. That absolves us from
the necessity to adjudicate upon the reasonableness of the
provisions relating to payment of compensation at the rate
prescribed by the Act as amended by Act VI of 1926. We
may observe that by the Amending Act 13 of 1960 several
alterations have been made as regards the extent of the right
of the tenants to require the landlords to sell the land and
the price which has to be paid by the tenants for purchasing
the land. For instance. under the Amending Act the Court
.nay direct sale only of the minimum area of land necessary
for convenient enjoyment by the tenant of the house built
by him and the rprice is to be the average marked value in
the three years immediately preceding the date of the order.
In view of this amendment, and having regard to the special
circumstances, viz. the offer made by the Company, notwithstanding the provisions of the Act, to pay the market value
of the land at the date of the order, we decline to enter
upon an academic consideration as to the validity of the
1a~159 s.c.-s~
"I.1
I0.26
N ~ Vajrapani
Naidu
v.
Ntw Theatre
Carnt.ttic Talkie1
Shah J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
provmon fixing compensation at the lowest market value
prevalent within seven years preceding the date of the order.
Assuming that a provision fixing such compensation is
•mreasonable and therefore invalid, it would be clearly
severable from the rest of the statute and would not affect
the validity of the provision relating to acquisition by the
tenant of the land demised by purchasing it from the landlord. At best, the landlord would be entitled to obtain
compensation which is equivalent to the market value, and
that the Company has agreed to pay. That, however, is a
matter on which we express no opinion.
The appeal therefore fails and is dismissed. There will
be no order as to costs.
Ayyan1ar I.
AYYANGAR, J.-We regret our inability to agree with
the order that the appeal should be ,dismissed. The facts
of the case have been set out in the Judgment of our brother
Shah, J. and do not, tlierefore, require to be repeated.
The two principal points arising for consideration and
on which the decision of the appeal would turn are, first,
the interpretation of s. 12 of the Madras City Tenants
Protection Act (Madras Act ill of 1922) and, second, the
constitutional validity of s. 9 of that enactment. Section 12
enacts :
"Nothing in any contract made by a tenant shall take
away or limit his rights under this Act, provided
that nothing herein contained shall affect any
stpulations made by the tenant in writing
registered as to the erection of buildings, in so
far as they relate to buildings erected after the
date of the contract."
The question that first calls for examination is the proper
construction· of s. 12 and in particular the meaning and
effect of the proviso contained in ·it. Before, however,
taking up the words of the section, it would be useful to
read the preamble and certain of the other provisions of
the Act because it is in the light of the guidance afforded
by them that the content of the proviso to s. 12 could be
determined. The preamble recites that the Act had been
I
'
6 S.C.R.
'·
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1027
1964
enacted as it was "found necessary to give protection to
tenants who in municipal towns and adjoining areas in the N. Vajrapanl
Naidu
State of Madras have constructed buildings on others' land
v.
in the hope that they would not be evicted so long as they New Theatre
pay a fair rent for the land". Section 1 ( 3) of the Act which Carnatic Talkitl
defines the tenancies within the local area to which the Act Ayyangar !.
extends enacts (to read the provision as it now stands) that
the Act shall apply only "to tenancies of land created before
the commencement of the Madras City Tenants Protection
(Amendment) Act, 1955 and in any municipal town or
village to which this Act is extended by notification under
5Ub-s. (2) only to tenancies created before the date with
effect from which this Act is extended to such town or
village." From these provisions two matters are clear:
(1) that the Act was enacted in order to ensure that the
hope entertained by tenants who had constructed buildings
on others' lands that they would not be evicted so long as
they paid fair rent was not frustrated, and (2) that the· Act
has application only to tenancies which having commenced
earlier were subsisting on the date on which the Act came
into force in the particular area.
With these preliminary observations we shall proceed to
deal with the construction of s. 12 of the Act.
The tenancy under which the respondent was inducted
into the land on which he has constructed buildings was
of 1934, a date long anterior to 1958 when by a notification
issued under s. 1 (2) of the Act its provisions were extended
to the municipal town of Coimbatore where the land
involved in the present proceedings is situated. It was therefore a tenancy governed by the provisions of the Act. Next,
the lease under which the respondent held the land was in
writing registered, and therefore the only question to be
considered is whether the stipulations it contains are comprehended by the proviso.
Section 12, it would be seen, is made up of two limbsfirst a general provision saving to tenants comprehended by
the Act, the rights conferred by its operative terms, notwithstanding any contract, and next a proviso which makes an
inroad into the generality of the saving, by saving con-
1028
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
tractual stipulations from the operation of the statutory
rights created by the Act. The entirety of the debate before
Naidu
us is as to the nature, scope and width of the saving effected
v.
by the proviso. It does not need any argument to establish
New Theatre
Carnatic Talkies that if s. 12 had stopped with its first limb, the respondent
would be entitled to the benefit of every right conferred
.A.yyangar J.
upon tenants by the Act, but the proviso it is conceded is
intended to cut down the scope of that saving. Expressed
in other terms, from the prohibition against the operation
of any stipluation in a contract limiting the rights conferred
on tenants by the Act an exception is carved out. So much
is common ground but the controversy is as regards the
scope and limits of that exception. As regards the exception contained in the proviso four matters are clear: ( 1)
The stipulation must find a place in a contract in writing
which is registered, (2) the s~ipulation which is within the
proviso and to that extent detracting from the non-obstante
provision contained in the opening words must be one in
relation to "the erection of buildings", (3) it must relate to
buildings erected after the date of the contract, and ( 4) if
there is a stipulation satisfying these three conditions such
stipulation would have effect notwithstanding anything in
the previous part of s. 12 which would be the same thing
as saying that the rights of the tenant under the Act may
be taken away or limited; by such a stipulation. It is
common ground and beyond controversy that conditions
1 & 3 above are satisfied and the only point in dispute is
whether the 2nd condition is satisfied so as to attract the
operation of condition 4.
1964
N. Vajrapani
The learned Judges of the High Court have understoo<!.
the words "as to the erection of buildings" occurring in
the proviso as equivalent to a stipulation regarding the
manner in which the building may be erected, the materials
to be used, the area the building should cover and other
details in relation to the construction of the building and
as not apt to cover the case of a stipulation whereby the
tenant undertakes to remove the buildings constructed by
him on the termination of the tenancy; and that was also
the submission made to us by Mr. Setalvad on behalf of the
respondent. With the greatest respect to the learned Judges
....
~
6 S.C.R.
r-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1029
of the High Court we are unable to agree with this construction of the proviso.
1964
N. Vajrapani
Naidu
v.
Before examining this we think it convenient and even
New Theatre
necessary to refer to the tenns of the lease deed under which Carnatic Talkies
the appellant became a tenant before considering whether
it is a stipulation which would fall within the words "stipula- Ayyangar J,
tions as to the erection of buildings". The lease deed which
has been marked as Ex. B-1 in the case is a registered
...' instrument dated September 19, 1934. The tenn of the
demise wa~ a period of 20 years from the date of delivery
of possession and the rent stipulated was Rs. 1,080/- per
year. The purpose for which the site was leased is stated
in ,the document to be "to construct buildings thereon as he
(the lessee) requires on the aforesaid site for the purpdse
of cinema, drama etc. at his own expense and also further
r- constructions necessary for the same". This is followed by
two clauses which have some relevance. Notwithstanding
that the lease was for a fixed definite period of 20 years,
the lessee was permuted to surrender the lease if he found
that the business venture for which the lease was taken was
not profitable. In that event the lessee was entitled to
surrender the lease, and put an end to the tenancy, when
he had to dismantle the buildings constructed by him at his
own expense and pay to the lessors one year's rent for
r
loss by the latter sustained by the premature tennination of
the ,lease. If this condition as to the removal of buildings
were not fulfilled by the lessee, the lessors. were authorised
to take ipossession of the vacant site dismantling the constructions and demolishing the walls. On the tennination of the
stipulated period of 20 years the lessees stipulated that they
would dismantle the constructions by demolishing the walls
1>
etc. and deliver possession of the vacant site to the lessors.
The qustion now for consideration is whether this
stipulation contained in the registered lease deed that at the
end of the tenn the lessee would demolish the buildings which
he had erected and deliver vacant possession of the site is a
stipulation which is saved by the proviso to s. 12. If the
scope of the proviso had to be construed in the light of the
preamble, it is obvious that the tenant who had entered into
a contract with a stipulation of the sort we have extracted,
could not be said to have constructed the buildings on
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
another's land "in the hope that he would not be evicted so
long as he pays rent for the land". The preamble would,
N. Vajrapani
Naidu
therefore, indicate that the Act would not apply to afford
v.
protection in a case where by an express term in a registered
New Theatre
·:arnatic Talkies lease deed a tenant agreed to surrender the site on which
he had erected a building where he specifically contracted
Ayyangar J.
that he would demolish the building and deliver vacant
possession of the site on the termination of his tenancy.
1964
The next matter to be noticed is that the tenancies dealt ·~
with by the Act are tenancies which came into existence
prior to the enactment or prior to the date .the Act became
operative in the local area and therefore one cannot expect
stipulations worded in exactly the same terms as in the Act,
because exconcessis the Act and its provisions were not in
the contemplation of the parties when they enterect into
the contract. The mere fact, therefore, that a stipulation "'
as regards the erection of the buildings is not worded in the
same manner as under the provisions of the Act or in terms
of the Act is no ground for refusing effect to it. Lastly,
since what is saved by the proviso from the operation of
the Act are the rights which are created in favour of tenants
by the Act, we are led to an inquiry as to the rights which
are conferred by the Act, for the saving must obviously have
reference to and be determined by these rights.
Broadly speaking two kinds of rights have been con- •' '
ferred on lessees under tenancies falling within the scope
of the Act-first a right to the payment of compensation for
buildings erected by them on leased land before they are
evicted, (under s. 3 of the Act) and secondly (this of
course could be only in the alternative) a right or option
to require the landlord to sell them the land under lease
for a price to be computed in accordance with s. 9. It is
obvious from the very nature of things having regard to the
time when the lease was entered into that there would not
and could not in terms be a stipulation in a deed against
the option accorded to a teuant to purchase the leased
any
land, and the matter is so self evident as not to
argument in support. We therefore reach the position that
the stipulation contemplated by the proviso to s. 12 could
only be one in relation to the right of the tenant to claim
compeni•ation for the buildings erected by him after the
need
6 S.C.R.
,
,;.;
/·
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1031
1964
commencement of the tenancy.
Expressed differently,
though the proviso is worded as to permit the saving of JV. l'ajrapani
Naidu
stipulations contained in registered deeds whether the
v.
stipulations relate to the right to the compensation receiv- New Theatre
able by tenants under s. 3, or their right to require the sale Carnatic Talkies
of the leased land to them under s. 9 when .on the termina- Ayyan1ar /,
tion of the tenancy they are sought to be evicted, the latter
right is not one which could be affected by an express stipulation in that regard, but its non-availability to the tenant
could be brought about only by a stipulation bearing on
the right of the tenant to compensation under s. 3 for
buildings erected by him during his tenancy.
We shall now proceed to ascertain the stipulation which
would affect the right to compensation in respect of buildings erected conferred on tenants by s. 3. That provision
reads:
"Every tenant shall on cjectment be entitled to be
paid as compensation the value of any building, which may have been erected by him, by
any of his predecessors in interest, or by any
person not in occupation at the time of the
ejectment who derived title from either of them,
and for which compensation has not already
been paid. A tenant who is entitled to compensation for the value of any building shall
also be paid the value of trees which may have
been planted by him on the land and of any
improvements which may have been made by
him."
A stipulation which if effective would limit the quantum
of compensation payable in respect of buiidings construct~
ed by a tenant provided for by s. 3, it is conceded, is within
the proviso to s. 12 as being one with respect to the
"erection of buildings". The effect of this concession on
the meaning of the proviso, we shall consider later. But
the question is whether these wotds can on any resonable
construction be limited or confined to such a contingency.
Let us take a case where in a lease like the one before us
~· for a fixed term say of 20 years there is a stipulation that
the tenant shall not b\lild on the land and that if he erected
1032
1964
N. Vajra11ani
Naidu
v.
New Theatre
Carnatic Talkies
Ayyangar J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
buildings he shall remove the structures, and deliver vacant
possession at the end of tbe tenancy. Obviously such a
stipulation would imply that he shall not claim any com- ~
ipensation for the structures which contrary to his un~er
talcing he erects. We did not understand Mr. Setalvari to
whom this was put during arguments to contend that the
tenant, who constructed buildings under a lease with a
stipulation such as this would be able to obtain compensation under s. 3, with the attendant rights conferred by s. 9.
This can only be on the basis that a stipulation forbidding
the erection of buildings by the lessee is a stipulation as ·,
regards "erection of buildings"-notwithstanding that it is
part and parcel of this stipulation that the tenant shall
demolish buildings which he constructed. If a stipulation
forbidding erection of buildings and requiring their removal
before surrendering possession of the site is conceded to
be one 'in respect of erection of buildings'-as has to be .<,
conceded, it is not possible to accept the construction that
a stipulation for the removal of buildings which the lessee
is permitted to erect and keep in the site only for the duration of the tenancy is any the less one "in respect of
erection of buildings". We understand these words to mean
a stipulation which bears on or is in relation to the erection
of buildings. Such a construction would reconcile the
proviso with the preamble which sets out the object sought
to be achieved by the Act. If the lease deed contains no ~.
stipulation whatsoever in regard to the erection of buildings,
as was the case with the large number of leases in the city
of Madras which were entered into prior to the enactment
of the Act in 1922, the tenant who erected a building ex·
concessis without contravening any undertaking on his part.
obtains protection under the Act. Again if the lease though
!t contains such a stipulation against construction of buildings on the leased land is not by a registered instrument-as
were again several leases in the city-the statutory rights to
compensation and purchase were protected. If however the
parties had recourse to a formal registered instrument for
putting through the transaction and such a deed contained
a stipulation against erection of buildings, or against the
continuance of the buildings on the land at the tennination -~
of the tenancy, or what comes to the same thing against the
tenant being entitled to compensation for the buildin!!s
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1033
1!164
erected by him during the currency of the lease, the stipulation would govern the rights of the tenant and not the N. Y11/rapa11i
Naitbl
statute. This in our opinion is the proper construction of
v.
the proviso to s. 12. The test would therefore 1»-"did the Nl!W Thntre
parties advert to and have in mind the contingency of the CanuJtic Talkla
tenant erecting buildings on the leased land"? If they had Ayyangar I.
and had included in a solemn registered deed a provision
which would bear upon the relative rights of the parties in
the event of the erection of buildings on the site, the stipulation would have effect notwithstanding the Act; for in such
an event the tenant would not have constructed buildings
on the land in the hope that he would not be disturbed from
possession so long as he paid the rent agreed upon.
Before concluding we shall examine how far the limited
meaning attributed to the phrase "as to the erection of
buildings" can be sustained. First let us take a case where
there is a stipulation in a registered deed under which the
lessee in consideration of a favourable rent undertakes to
construct buildings of a particular type and deliver possession
of the site as well as the building constructed at the end of
the term without any claim to compensation. On: the construction put forward by the respondent this would be a
stipulation which would be saved by the proviso since it
refers to the construction of buildings and not removal,
though it negatives all right to compensation to which he
would be entitled under s. 3. Such a stipulation being
valid and enforceable, on a suit for ejectment being
file4, the tenant would not be entitled to CQ111pensation and
would therefore be outside s. 9 because s. 9 applies only
' to cases where the tenant is·entitled to compensation. Now,
does it make any difference if the deed stipulated that the
buildings erected by the tenant should be removed, without
any claim to compensation in the event of non-removal. We
1-"llll see no sensible distinction between the two cases.. and
if the one is a stipulation in respect of "erection of bnildings", the other is equally sc..
1
Next we shall take the case which the respondent asserts
. is precisely the one intended to be covmd by the provtSO
viz: a stipulation that the lessee shall not construct a bnilding
in excess of a pa11li.cular plinth area, or beyond a ground. ft.oor, or in excess of a specified number of rooms.
1
134-159 S.C.-66.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1gtJ4j
1964
Obviously the question about the applicability of the proviso
would come in only if the tenant broke the covenant an ·
N. Yajrapani
Naidu
we
shall therefore assume that in breach of the stipulation,
v.
the tenant erects buildings contrary to his undertaking. In
New Theatre
Carnatic TgJkie1 such an event it is said that when the compensation to which
the tenant is entitled under s. 3 is computed, the amount
A.yyangar ],
would be confined to what he would have got, if he had
abided by the contract. But this is to ignore the basic
feature of the Act, under which the tenant who is entitled
to compensation under s. 3, and certainly the limited com- ,
pensation that the tenant obtains even when he breaks a ·
covenant would still be compensation under that section, is
tntitled to purchase the lease land under s. 9. The c;onstruction suggested therefore comes to this that though under
the proviso to s. 12 there might be stipulations which might
reduce the quantum of compensation to which a tenent
would be entitled under s. 3, there cannot be a stiphlation
apart possibly from a covenant against any erection of
buildings which we have already dealt with, which would
preclude a tenant from his right under s. 9. If as must be
conceded the first limb of s. 12, sa:ve the statutory rights of
tenants both under SS. 3 & 9 from the operation of any contract, it appears to us to stand to reason that the proviso
which saves rights lll!der contracts from the rights cqnferred
by the Act should be construed to be co-extensive with and
operate on the same field as the opening portion of s. 12.
We are, therefore, clearly of the opinion that the learned
Judges of the High Court were in error in their construction
of the proviso to s. 12. In this view the question as regards
the constitutional validity of s. 9 would not really arise for
consideration, and we express no opinion on it. We would
accordingly allow the appeal and decree the suit for eject
ment filed by the appellant.
ORDER
In accordance with the majority opinion, the appeal is
dismissed. No order as to costs.
Auueal dismissed.
GMGIPND-L-134-59 S. C. Of India(6021-46)-18- 10-65--2.?0C),
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org