C. S. ROWJEE AND OTHERS versus ANDHRA PRADESH STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION
Supreme Court of India | Decided 27 January 1964 | [1964] 6 S.C.R. 330 | 1964 INSC 15
Key facts
- Decided
- 27 January 1964
- Bench
- BHUVNESHWAR PRASAD SINHA*, K. SUBBA RAO, RAGHUBAR DAYAL, N. RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR, J.R. MUDHOLKAR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 771/1963
- Disposal
- Directions issued
- Citation
- [1964] 6 S.C.R. 330
- Neutral citation
- 1964 INSC 15
Text of the judgment
330
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1964
must be left unperformed forms a considerable
portion of the whole, or does not admit of
compensation in money, he is not entitled to
obtain a decree for specific performance. But
the court may, at the suit of the other party,
direct the party in default to perform specifi.
cally so much of his part of the contract as he
can perform, provided that the plaintiff relinquishes all claim to further performance, and
all right to compensation either for the defici·
ency, or for the loss or damage sustained by
him through the default of the defendant."
Balmukand
v.
Kamlawati
MudholklJI' J.
However, in the case before us there is no claim on behalf
ot the plaintiff that he is willing to pay the entire considera·
tion for obtaining a decree against the interest of Pindidas
alone in the property. In the result the appeal fails and
is dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
C. S. ROWJEE AND OTHERS
1964
January,
27
v.
PRADESH STATE ROAD
CORPORATION
ANDHRA
TRANSPORT
(B. P. SINHA, C.J., K. SUBBA RAo, RAGHUBAR DAYAL, N.
R.AJAGOPALA AYYANGAR AND J. R. MUDHOLKAR JI.)
Motor Vehicles-Nationalisation of road transport 1ervice-Pree.aration
and enforcement of scheme-Validity-Issue of permits fo State
Transport Undertakings-Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (4 of 1939), "'
amended
Act I of 1956, Ch. IV, ss. 68C, 68D(3), 68F(l)Andhra Pradesh Motor Vehicles Rules, 1957, rr 4, 141.
by
The respondent corporation appointed an expert committee to go into
the question as to the working of nationalised ~~nsport in the S_tate. i:ie
Committee laid down the criteria for determining the order 1n which
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
331
areas and routes had to be selected for nationalisation and had drawn up
1964
a list of the remaining districts in which nationalisation should be suctesC.
Rowi••
sively taken up. Accordingly, Nellore would have been the next district
v.
to be taken up and the turn of Kurnool district would have come up State of Andhr•
Pradesh
_after nationalisation of the routes in Nellore, Chittore and Cuddapah districts were completed. This report was submitted to the Corporation in
February, 1961 and the Corporation accepted it and embodied the approval
in its Administration Report dated March 24, 1962 which was published
in April, 1962. After the General Election in 1962 the Chief Minister
assumed office as Chief Minister on March 12, 1962. On April 19, 1962,
he summoned a conference of the Corporation at which, he suggested
that the nationalisation of bus routes in the Kurnool district should be
taken up first. By its resolution dated 4-5-1962, the Corporation made an
alteration in the order of the districts, successively to be taken up for
nationalisation and selected the western half of the Kurnool as the area
to be nationalised in the first instance. ·ne appellants, motor transport
operators whose routes were all in western half of the Kumool districts
filed objections to the Schemes before the Transport Minister. The Transport Minister approved the schemes. Thereafter, the Corporation applied
to the Regional Transport Authority for permits. The appellants then
challenged the validity of the schemes in the High Court and in support
of that allegations were made in the affidavit that the ..Chief Minister was
motivated by bias and personal ill-will against the appellants, that he tell
chagrined at the defeat of his partymen and supporters and desiring to
wreak his vengeance against the motor transport operators of the western
parts of Kwnool, his political opponents, instructed the Corporation to
change the order in which the districts should be taken up for nationalisation and that the corporation gave effect to these instructions and directions. These allegations were not denied by the Chief Minister, nor was
an affidavit filed by any person who could claim to know personally about
the truth about these allegations. 1~he High Court repelled these allegations and dismissed the petition. On appeal by certificate the appellants
mainly contended: (1) that the schemes did not in reality reflect the
opinion of the Corporation as required by s. 68-C of the Act, but that
the schemes owed their origin to the direction of the Chief Minister who
acted mala fide in directing the Transport Undertaking to frame the impugned schemes; (2) that the approval of the schemes by the Transport
Minister under s. 68-D(3) must be held to be vitiated by the malafides
of th.e Chief Minister; (3) that the impugned schemes did not conform to
the statutory requirements of s. 68-C and rule 4 of the Rules regarding
the particulars to be embodied in the schemes; ( 4) that some of the
routes included in the schemes were inter-state routes and that under the
proviso to s. 68-D(3) it could not be deemed to be an arproved scheme
unless the previous approval of the Central Government had been obtained and (5) that even when a transport undertaking applies for a
stage carriage permit under s. 68-F(l) it must comply with the provisions of r. 141 of the Rules.
s.
Reid: (!) On the evidence placed in the present case it must be held
that it was a result of the conference of the 19th April, 1962 and in
332
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
19M
order to give efiect to the wishes of the Chief Minister expressed there,
that the i~pugned scher:n~ were fonnulated by the Corporatiori and
v.
the~~fore, 1t would be vitiated by malafides notwithstanding the interState of Andhra position of the semi-autonomous corporation.
Pradesh
C. S. Rowjee
1~hough the counler-affidavits contained a denial of the allegation that
the Corporation was acting at the behest of the Chief Minister, there was
no explanation for the choice of the western portion of Kurnool district.
Therefore, the impugned schemes were vitiated by the fact that !hey
were ·not in conformity wjth the requirements of s. 68..C of the Act.
(ii) There was nothing on the record to indicate that the Chlef Minil·
ter influenced the Transport Minister. Besides, the Transport Minister
stated on oath that in considering the objections under s. 68-D(3) and
approving the schemes he was uninfluenced by the Chief Minister. Therefore, it cannot be held that his approval of the schemes did not satisfy
the requirements of the law.
(iii) In the present case some of the variations between the maxima
and minima in the number of the vehicles propoSed to be operated on
each route were such as to really contravene r. 4 of the Andhra Pradesh
Motor Vehicles Rules, 1957.
Dosa Satyanarayanamurthy v. The Andhra Pradesh State Transport
Corporation, [19611 I S.C.R. 642, referred to.
(iv) The route which was proposed to be nationalised under the
scheme admittedly lay wholly within the State. The right of the private
operators to ply their vehicles beyond the State border was not affected
by any of the schemes. Therefore, the proviso to s. 68·D(3) was not
attracted and consequently the schemes did not suffer from the defects
alleged.
(v) The High Court was right in holking that the Regional Transport
Authority which is specifically mentioned in s. 68-F( I) is empowered to
issue the permit to the transport undertaking ''notwithstanding anything
to the contrary contained in Chapter IV" and that the section rendered the
provisions of r. 141 of the Motor Vehicles Rules inappJicable to cases
covered by s. 68-F( 1). No doubt~ in a State where there is no Regional
Transport Authority at all. but there is some other authority which func~
tions as the Regional Transport Authority for the purposes of the Act,
such an authority might be that which would be comprehended by s.
68-F (I) but where as in Andhra Pradesh there is admittedly a Regional
Transport Authority, it cannot be held that such authority is deprived
of the power to issue a permit by reason of s. 68-F( I) merely becauso
the Regional Transport Authority of that area cannot grant permits under
Chapter IV.
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
333
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 770
of 1963.
WITH
Civil Appeals Nos. 771-778, 883 and 884 of 1963.
1964
..
C. S. Rowiu
State of Andhra
Prad<1h
Appeals from ihe judgment and order dated April 19,
1963, of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Writ Petitions
Nos. 267-275 and 289 anct 295 of 1963.
A. V. Viswanatha Sastri, P. Babula Reddy and K. R.
Chaudhuri, for the appellants (in C.A. No. 77 /1963).
P. Babula Reddy and K. R. Chaudhuri, for the appellants (in C. A. Nos. 771-777 /1963).
K. R. Chaudhuri, for the ap;iellants (in C.A. No. 778/
1963).
K. Srinivasa Murthy and K. R. Chaudhuri,, for ,the
appellants (in C. A. Nos. 883 and 884 of 196~).
D. Narasaraju, Advocate-General, Andhra Pradesh,
P. R. Ramachandra Rao and B; R. G. K. Achar, for the
respondents (in all the appeals).
January 27, 1964. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
AYYANGAR J .-This batch of 11 Appeals which have
been consolidated for hearing are directed against the common judgment of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh and
are before us on the grant of a certificate of fitness under
Art. 133(1) of the Constitution by the said High Court.
The proceedings concerned in the appeals arise out of
Writ Petitions filed before the High Court by the several
appellants before us under Art. 226 of the Constitution
challenging the validity of three Schemes framed under
Chapter IV-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, I 939. nationalising motor transport in certain areas in the Kumool Di~
trict of the State of Andhra Pradesh which for convenience
we shall refer to as the impugned Schemes. The appellants
who impugn the validity of the schemes are the previously
existin11: motor transport operators whose permits are
liable to be modified or cancelled under the provisions of
Ayyangar 1.
334
!964
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
the Schemes on their coming into force.
The impugned
c. s. Rowjee schemes were published by Government as G.0.Ms. 292,
State 0~· Andhra 293 and 294 of the Home, Transport Department on the
Pradesh
5th February, 1963 in virtue of the powers conferred on
Ayyangar J.
Government by sub-s. 2 of the 68-D of the Motor Vehicles
Act. The Andhra Pradesh State Road Trans;x>rt Corporation which for shortness we shall refer to as the Corporation, besides the State of Andhra Pradesh and the Regional
Transport Authority,· Kllffioo! were impieaded as respondents to the petitions. They are also the respondents before us. By reason of the first Scheme, 34 routes were
intended to be taken over, while under the 2nd and 3rd,
17 and 13 routes respectively were proposed to be nationalised. The routes covered by these three schemes are all
in the western half of the Kurnool District.
Before adverting to the points requiring consideration
in the appeals, it would be convenient to set out the relevant
statutory provisions relating to the nationalisation of Road
Transport for it is primarily on their construction that the
decision of the appeals would turn.
Chapter IV-A containing special provisions relating to
"State Transport Uundertakings" was introduced into the
Motor Vehicles Act (Act IV of 1939) by an amenclment
effected bv Central Act I of 1956 which came into effect
on 16-2-1957. The Chapter consists of sections numbered
68-A to 68-I. 68-A contains definitions and of these it
is sufficient to refer to the definition of "State Transport
Undertaking" which includes inter alia "any undertaking
providing road transport service, where such undertaking
is carried on by ...... any Road Transport Corporation
established under sec. 3 of the Road Transport Corporation
Act 1950." (to refer to the portion which is material.)
(It might be mentioned that the Corporation, the first
respondent before us is a body established under this enactment.)
68-B reads : "The provisions of this Chapter and the rules and,
orders made thereunder shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
335
contained in Chapter IV of this Act or in any
other law for the time being in force or in any
instrument having effect by virtue of any such
law."
The next section 68-C which is the one most involved in
the appeals runs:
"Where any State Transport undertaking is of opinion that for the purpose of providing an efficient, adequate, economical and properly coordinated road transport service, it is nec1111sary
in the public interest that road transport services in general or any particular class of such
service in relation to any area or route or portion thereof should be run and operated by the
State transport undertaking, whether to the
exclusion, complete or partial, of other persons
or otherwise, tb,e State transport undertaking
may prepare a scheme giving particulars of the
nature of the services proposed to be rendered
the area or route proposed to be covered and
such other particulars respecting thereto as
may be prescribed, and shall cause every such
scheme to be published in the Official Gazette
and also i.n such other manner as the State
Government may direct."
The first two sub-sections of section 68-D enable persons
affected by a Scheme published under s. 68-C to file objections thereto before the State Government within thirty days
after the publication of the Scheme. It further provides
for the State Government considering the objections raised
by persons affected by the Scheme after giving an opportunity to the objectors and the "undertaking" to be heard in
the matter before approving or ,nodifying the Scheme. The
Scheme so approved or modified ;, required to be published
in the State Gazette and on sucl:i publication it becomes
final and is to be called "the approved scheme". This is
followed by sub-sec. (3) which reads:"The scheme as approved or modified under sub-s.
(2) shall then be published in the Official
1964
C.
s. Row}tt
\'.
State of Andhra
Pradesh
Ayyangar J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
19M
C. S. Row;u
Y.
State of Andhra
Pradesh
Ayyangar /.
Gazette by the State Government and the same
shall thereupon become final and shall be called
the approved scheme and the area or route to
which it relates shall be called the notified area
or notified route :
Provided that no such scheme which relates to any
inter-State route shall be deemed to be an approved scheme under it has been published in
the Official Gazette with the previous approval
of the Central Government."
Section 68-E provides :
"any scheme published under sub-s. (3) of S. 68-D
may at any time be cancelled or modified by
the State transport undertaking and the procedure laid down in s. 68-C and s. 68-D shall
so far as it can be made applicable be followed
in every case where the scheme is proposerl
to be modified as if the modification proposed
were a separate scheme."
Section 68-F is really consequential on the approval of
the scheme and sub-s. (1) thereof enacts:-
.
"Where, in pursuance of an apprnved scheme, any
State Transport Undertaking applies in the
manner specified in Chapter IV for a stage
carriage permit or a public carrier's permit or
a contract carriage i;iermit in respect of a notified area or notified rolite, the Regional Transport Authority shall .issue such permit to the
State transport undertaking, notwithstanding
anything to the contrary contained in Chapter
IV."
Its second sub-section er·.ables the Regional Transport
Authority to refuse renewil of any other permits to private
operators and otherwise to deal with those permits so as to
give effect to the Scheme. Sections 68-G and 68-H deal
with the payment of compensation and the methods by
which the same should be computed but as these are hot
material, we shall not quote them.
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
337
Section 68-I empowers the State Government to make
196"
rules for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions c. s. Row;..
of Chapter IV-A and amo~g the specific purposes for which State of ~ndhra
such rules may be framed 1s one under s. 68-1(2) (a) which
Prad<1h
provides for the form in which any scheme or approved
·
Ayyangar J
scheme may be published under section 68-C or sub-section
(3) of Section 68-D and as usual a residuary clause··reading:
"any other matter which has to be or mav be considered."
These draft schemes prepared by the Corporation were
published under s. 68-D in the official Gazette on the 29th
of November, 1962. The appellants among others filed
objections to the schemes and thereafter there was a hearing of theSe objections by the Transport Minister of the
State under s. 68-0(2) on the 1 Hh of January, 1963. The
Minister passed an order according approval to the schemes
on the 12th of February, 1963, and the schemes as finalis~
ed weno published in the Gazette on the next day, February
13, 1963. In pursuance of the provisions of the schemes
the Corporation made applica:io'l to the Regional Transport
Authori.y for permits. Soon thereafter the appellants and
a few others filed writ petitions invoking the jurisdiction of
the High Court under Art. 226 of the Constitution praying
for the quashing of the schemes. These petitions were
dismissed by the High Court by a common judgment on the
19th of April, 1963, holding that the objections made to
the validity of the schemes would not be sustained. The
learned Judges, however, on the application of the Appellants granted a certificate of fitness under Art. 133 in pursuance of which these appeals have been preferred.
The points urged by the appellan<s before us in support
of their submission regarding the invalidity of the impugned
schemes, were substantially the same as were urged before
High Court and which the learned Judges repelled. Briefly
stated the principal ones were:-(!) that the schemes did
not in reality reflect the opinion of the Corporation that
"it was necessary in the public interest that the Road Transport services in the area or over the route, specified in the
134-159 S.C.-22
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
schemes should be run and operated by the State Transc. s. Rowjee port Undertaking" as is required by s. 68-C but that the
v. A dh schemes owed their origin to the direction of the Chief
Stale o1 n ra M' ,
. directPradesh
1ruster of A ndh ra Pradesh who acted ma/a fide m
ing the Transport Undertaking to frame the impugned
Ayyangar J.
schemes for the areas for which they were purported to be
framed; (2) that the decision by the Trnnsport Minister overruling the objections raised by the several road transport
operators to the schemes was also ma/a fide, in that he too
acted i.n pursuance of the mala fide intentions of the Chief
Minister. of Andhra Pradesh; (3) that the provisions of the
schemes (and this applied both to the draft schemes published by the Corporation as well as the approved schemes
published under s. 68-0(3) did not conform to the statutory
requirements of s. 68-C and rule 4 of the Rules regarding
the particulars to be embodied in the schemes and that in
consequence the core of the scheme was in violation of
Rule 68(E) of the Act; (4) that the schemes comprised not
merely intra-state routes but also included inter-state transport routes and in the latter case the procedure prescribed
by the proviso to s. 68-D was not followed and hence all
the impugned schemes which are integrated ones are bad
and require to be set aside. There were also a few minor
ones which we shall notice and examine later.
1964
We shall deal with these four pomts in the same order.
Before taking up the first one viz .. that the draft scheme in
s. 68-D really did not originate fromf the Corporation. the
State Transport Undertaking, but that it was done under
the direction of the Chief Minister who, it was alleged for
reasons which were set out in the affidavits and to which
we shall refer presently was stated to have compelled, directed or induced the Corporation to do so, it would be necessary to give a short resume of the history of nationalised
transport in Andhra Pradesh as well as certain events in
Andhra Pradesh politics which have been the subject of
allegations in these proceedings. The present State of
Andhra Pradesh is made uo of two distinct areas- ( 1) what
is known as the "Telengana area" consisting of nine districts of the old Hyderabad State and (2) the "Andhra area"
which separated from Madras i.e. from the composite
.
'
6 S.C.R,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
339
Madras State, in October 1953 and which comprised 11
districts. These two areas were integrated under the States
Re-organization Act, 1956, to form the present State of
Andhra Pradesh. In the Telengana area the road transport
services had been run by the Government of the Nizam since
the year 1932 and by 1956 private motor road transport
operators had been completely eliminated from this entire
area. In the Andhra Area comprising the 11 districts however, nationalisation of motor transport had not been undertaken. Soon after the formation of the State of Andhra
Pradesh, the Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation was established with effect from 11th of January,
1958 with a view to take steps for extending nationalised
transport to the Andhra areas of the State. Certain routes
in three of the 11 Districts Krishna, West Godavari and
Guntur were nationalised from 1959 onwards. The Vijayawada-Masulipatam and Vijayawada-Guntur routes -were
nationalised in the first instance and thereafter by about
September, 1959, almost the entire routes in Krishna District were nationalised. The next district to be taken up
was West Godavari which was done in March, 1960. The
process was nearly completed in this district by tl).e 1st
of February, 1960, except for a few routes. The Government had sanctioned certain schemes for nationalisation in
Guntur District which were expected to be completed by
Oc.ober, 1961. The question which was thereafter
the
subject of consideration was the manner in which and the
stages whereby nationalisation of the motor transport
throughout the State might be brought about. With this
object the Corporation adopted a resolution in 1960 by
which it decided to appoint an expert Committee to go into
question as to the working of nationalised transport with a
view to improve its efficiency as well as for drawing up
plans for the future expansion of the road transport services
in the State.
The terms of reference to that Committee
were comprehensive and it started functioning very soon
after the members were appointed. Shri S. Anantharamakrishnan, Chainnan of Messrs. Simpson & Co. Ltd.,
Madras, one of the principal motor transport operators of
the Madras State, was the Chairman of the Committee and
it comprised three other members who were officials of the
1964
C.
s. Row/ff
"·
State of ttndlrra
Pradtlh
Ayyangar /,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1964
Andhra Pradesh
State Government.
[1g64)
The Committee
c. s. Row}.. ·made various recommendations in the Report which it
v.
submitted to the Corporation on the 9th February, 196L
Stai.P~:a1.i!hra Among the several recommendations which this Committee
Ayyangar J.
made, what is of relevance to the present appeals and on
· h re,1ance
1•
wh1c
was placed in support of the plea that th-e
impugned schemes were vitiated by ma/a {ides are those
contained in Chapter IX of the Report and in particular the
priorities of areas for taking up nationalisation which the
Committee recommended in paragraph 125. They set out
in paragraph 124 the factors which should be taken into
account in fixing the orde1' in which new areas should be
taken up for nationalisation as being (1) "the most profitable areas should be taken up first;" (2) "from the traffic
point of view there should be contiguous expansion;" (3)
"from the administrative point of view it is convenient to
nationalise bus services district by district;" and (4) "the
proposal to form large sized divisions should be borne in
view." Adopting these ariteria ithe Committee stated in
paragraph 125 "that the nationalisation of bus transport
may be extended to the remaining districts in the Andhra
area as indicated below:1961-62-Guntur District
1962-63-Nellore and Chittor Districts
1963-64-Cuddapah and Kumool Districts
1964-65-Anantapur and East Godavari Districts
1965-66-Visakhapatnam
tricts".
and
Srikakulam
Dis
The Committee also added in paragraph 126 "we recommend that a policy decision may be taken by Government
on the proposal to extend nationalisation of bus services to
the remaining Andhra Districts during the Third Five Year
Plan. The order in which the new areas will be taken over
may also be decided by Government. The Corporation
will then be able to make its pla'1s well in advance, and
arrange to provide all the facilities that are needed for expanding its activities to other di~tricts." This report of the
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
341
Anantharamakrishnan Committee was the subject of consideration by the Corporation and they accepted in March,
1962 the above recommendation regarding the phased programme of nationalisa,ion of districts in the order indicated
and embodied this recommendation in their Administration
Report for the period January 11, 1958. (the day on which
the Corporation was formed) to March 31, 1961 which was
submitted to the Government as required bys. 35(2) of the
Road Transport Corporation Act, 1960, on the 7th of April,
1962. In this last document they said speaking of future
trends, "the programme for nationalisation of transport services in the remaining of tlre Andhra Pradesh is as indicated below:1961-62-Guntur District
1962-63-Nellore and Chittor Districts
1963-64-Cuddapah and Kurnool Districts
1964-65-Ananthapur and East Godavari Districts
1965-66-Vishakhapatnam and Srikakulam Districts."
In the impugned schemes, however, the Corporation
made an alteration in the order of the Districts successively
to be taken up for nationalisation. It would be seen that
after Guntur District which was nearly completed by the end
of 1961 the next districts to be taken up during the 1962-63
would have been Nellore and Chittor Districts in that order
and it was only thereafter that the District of Cuddapah
and after it Kurnool would be taken up. That was the
recommendation of the Anantharamakrishnan Committee
and which had been accepted by the Road Transport Corporation as late as April, 1962 and it may be mentioned in
this connection that the Vice-Chairman of the Road Transport Corporation was himself a member of the Anantharamakrishnan Committee. By its resolution dated, 4th
May, 1962,' the Road Transport Corporation decided that
instead of the above order Kurnool, Nellore and Cuddapah
Distric<s in that order would be chosen for nationalisation
and in the three schemes which were formulated in pursu·
;mce of this Resolution the western half of Kurnool was
selected as the area to be nationalised in the first instance.
1964
C.
s. Rowjee
v.
State of .A.ndhra
Pradesh
Ayyangar J.
342
1964
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
As we have indicated earlier the appellants before us
are
c. s. Row~• transport operators whose routes are all in the western half
Stat• 0/' A.ndhro of the. K~m°:°l Di~trict. It is this change in the orders of
Prod,.,,
the Districts m which the routes are to be nationalised and
A.yyangar 1.
the choice of the Western part of Kurnool for being taken
up in the first instance that are alleged to be due to the ma/a
fide intentions of the Chief Minister and this fonns the
main ground upon which the validity of the schemes is
impugned.
The allegations in this respect may now be stated. In
the affidavit in support of the Writ Petition No. 267 of
1963 from which Civil Appeal No. 770 of 1963 arises, this
is what is stated:
"The General Elections for the various Constituencies of Assembly and Parliament were held
in February, 1962. It is well-known that there
are two groups in the Congre~s and they wer~
actively ranged against each other. The previous Chief Minister (Shri Sanjivayya) and the
present Chief Minister (Shri Sanjiva Reddy)
were both returned from Kurnool District in
general elections. The then Chainnan of the
Zila Parishad Shri Vijaya Bhaskara Reddy
contested unsuccessfully from Yemniga11Qur
Constituency in Kurnool District. (Yemniganpur is in the western part of the Kurnool District) . He is the active supporter of the present Chief Minister.
Shri C. Ram Bhopal
son-in-law of the present Chief Minister also
unsuccessfully contested from the Nandikothur
(NandikoConstituency in Kurnool District.
thur is also iµ the western part of Kumool).
The person who successfully opposed him Sri
P. Venkafakrishna Reddy now M.L.A. is a
partner in 'Venkata Krishna Bus Service' Nandikothur. This firm owns 2 pem1its and they
stand in the name of Jayaram11yya who wa8
the Election Agent of Sri Venkata Krishna
Reddy. Two persons Sri Ganikhan and Sri
Antony Reddy who are staunch supporters c,f
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
343
the preseni Chief Minister Sri Sanjiva Reddy
were selected as Congress candidates by the
Parliamentary Board at Delhi when Sanjiva
Reddy was the President of the Indian National
Congress, were also defeated in their respective
Constituencies. It was considered by one and
all that leading transport operators among them,
(the petitioners) were responsible for the defeat
of these persons and this enraged the feelings
of Shri Sanjiva Reddy against the operators in
Kurnool District and particularly the operators
whose routes lay in the western areas of the
District and wi\h a view to cause them loss and
to ruin their business this nationalisation of
transport in the western part of Kurnool was
directed to be undertaken in spite of the Emergency and in spite of the incapacity of the Road
Transport Corporation to fulfil their eariier
commitments for want of buses. The undivided brothers of Sri T. Narayan. a transport operator, namely Sri Venkataswamy contested the
Assembly seat against Sri Sanjiva Reddy in
the Dhone Constituency from which he was
returned and he refused to withdraw even
though lots of pressure were brought on him.
Sri Rajasekhara Reddy and Sri Vijayakumara
Reddy sons l>f Sri P. Ranga Reddy, Minister in
the previous Cabinet are also transport operators in the Kurnool District. It is known to
every one that Sri P. Ranga Reddy is in the
group opposed to Sri Sanjiva Reddy.
Sri Y. Mahananda Reddy another transport operator is a staunch supporter of Sri P. Ranga
Reddy. When Sanjiva Reddy was President
of the Indian National Congress his selection
·for the Congress ticket was set aside by him
and one Vengal Reddy was selected by th<'
Pradesh Congress Committee. It is significant
that the three schemes framed for the part of
the Kurnool District relate to the areas in
1964
C.
s. Rowjee
v.
State of Andhro
Pradesh
Ayyangar /..
344
1964
C. s. Row/••
v.
Stal• of Andhra
Prail1sh
Ayyangar /.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1g64]
which the routes on which the _above stated
persons are running their buses. It is also significant that the areas in Kurnool District
where the supporters of the present Chief Minister are having permits are not sought to be
inr.luded in any of the three nationalisatior,
schemes. In the Nandyal area most of the
transport operators are the supporters of the
present Chief Minister and their routes are
excluded from the schemes. It is with a view
to achieve the object of hitting against those'
operators who have fallen into disfavour am'
to protect those who are in his good books
that the schemes have been evolved over routes
and parts of the .District."
11wo further matters were also urged as SW?porting this
plea of' mala {ides. The first was that with a view to carry
out the original programme which was approved and confirmed by the Corporation in their Administration Report
published on April 7, 1962, the routes in the Nellore District which according to the Anantharamakrishnan Committee Report had to be taken up next were surveyed and
though the elements of contiguity and profitable nature were
both present in regard to the extension of the services to
Nellore, contiguity by reason of the fact that some buses
belonging to the Corporation and running from Guntur
were already plying in Nellore District and the profitable
nature since these were evaluated by the Anantharamakrishnan Committee whose recommendations were examined
and approved by the Corporation, the nationalisation of the
routes in Nellore was, however, abandoned and that of the
western part of Kurnool was decided upon.
The other
fact was that the National Defence Council passed a resolution as late as the first week of November, 1962, urging
the -deferring of further nationalisation of transport services
for the present and it was in the teeth of this resolution
which was passed at the meeting at which the Chief Minister
himself was present that the schemes of nationalisation of
transport services in Kurnool district was published by the
Corpor<ition on the 29th November, I 962.
6 s:c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
345
1964
Before examining whether these allegations have been
ruaae out it would be necessary to explain the legal po>ition C. S. Rowjee
v.
in relation to which they have to be considered. To begin State of
Andhro
with the schemes now impugned have been formulated by
Pradesh
the Corporation which is an independent semi-autonomous
Ayyangar J.
body brought into existence by the State Governmen, by
acting under the Road Transport Corporation Act, 1950.
Under s. 68-C of the Motor Vehicles Act ii is the Corporation which is the State Transport Undertaking which has to
form the opinion whether "for the puv;:iose of providing an
efficient, adequate, economical and properly co-urdinated
road transport service it is necessary in the public interest
whether the service should be run c.nd operated by the State
Transport Undertaking."
Secondly, it is the Corporation
that has to be satisfied that such services should in public
interests be provided "for any area or route''.
In ,the
presen< case, it is undoubtedly the 'Corporation 'that 'has
published the schemes under s. 68-C in which' t\lese two
matters are stated to have been considered and decided
upon by the Corporation itself. It was not disputed by the
appellants that whatever be the inclinations, desires or
motives of the Chief Minister, if the Corporation had by an
independent consideration of the situation decided on the
formulation of the impugned schemes, their validity could
not be successfully impugned mearly because the schemes
satisfied the alleged grudge which the Chief Minister bore
to the affected operators.
The argument urged by the appellants on this part
of the case was however tow-fold: (1) That it was not in fact
the Corporation that formed the opinion indicated in
s. 68-C but really the Chief Minister; (2) That the Chief
Minister was motivated by extraneous considerations,
namely, to strike at his political opponents who worked
either against himself or his friends, supporters and relations- in the elections in Bebruary, 1962 and had devised the
schemes in order to cause them loss and compass their ruin.
A subsidiary point was also urged that the Transport
Minister who heard the objections under s. 68-0(2) was
also influenced by the Chief Minister.
It was thus said
that the Chief Minister dominated at every stage through
346
1964
.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
which the sche1~es .passed and that the schemes were really
C. s. Rowree the result of lllS improper motive to ruin his political
State 0/· Andhra ?pponents. It was again not disputed by the respondent that
Pradesh
if these steps were made out the schemes would be invalid
Ayyangar J.
and ought to be quashed.
The learned Judges of the High Court have on this
part of the case held: (I) That the allegations made against
the Chief Minister had not been proved; (2) Assuming,
however, that the Chief Minister was actuated by political
motives to hit at his opponents, still, the schemes which were
published by the Corporation, had been framed by the Corporation not at the dictation of the Chief Minister, but as a
result of their own independent judgment; and (3) Lastly,
the learned Judges held that there was no proof that the
Transport Minister who i1eard the objections raised by the
appellants to the schemes was influenced by the Chief
Minister or acted at his behest, and therefore that the
schemes framed and approved wefe fully in conformity
with the requirements of s. 68-C.
The correctness of these conclusions have been challenged before us and the first matter that requires to be considered is as to whether the allegations against, the Chief
Minister have been made out. The question raised has
manifestly to be considered from two aspects. The first is
whether the facts alleged which were stated to have been the
cause of the Chief Minister's animus against the transport
o;ierators in the western part of Kurnool have been established. In regard to this the first point to be noticed is that
the contents of the affidavit were, not vague, but details
were given and these were: (I) The existence of two groups
in the Congress Party, at the time of the General Elections
in 1962, the Chief Minister being the head of one of them
and of the other Mr. Sanjivayya; (2) That at the last General
Elections certain c;mdidates who were named and who are
stated to have belonged to the group of the Chief Minister
were defeated; (3) The Constituencies where tlley stood
were in the western portion of the Knrnool District; (4)
That tllis defeat was occasioned by persons belonging fo.
the other group in the Congress Party whose names are
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
347
also given; (5) That several of these members supporting the
dissident group were motor transport operators and who are
stated to have taken a prominent part in the elections and
in the defeat of the candidates belonging to the Chief
Minister's group; ( 6) The matters in relation to Ranga
Reddy and his sons etc. These are what might be termed
objective facts.
If thes.: allegations were held
not proved, then the
entire plea of the appellants on this part of the case fails,
because there would be no foundation for the submission
regarding the ma/a {ides of the Chief Minister. If, however, these facts were held to be made out, the second
aspect requires to be examined and that is whether the
Court has material to hold that these facts led the Chief
Minister to en;ertain feelings of personal hostility to these
transport operators because of the aid and support the latter
gave to the candidates belonging to the group opposed to
him which led to the defeat of .his partymen. On this
aspect the. allegations were that the Chief Minister felt
chagrined at the defeat of his partymen and supporters and
desiring to wreak his vengeance against the motor transport
operators of the western parts of Kurnool, his political
opponents. instructed the Corporation to change the order
in which the districts should be taken up for nationalisation
and had Kurnool taken up first, departing from what had
been decided upon, just a little while previously by the Corporation, and that the Corporation gave effect to these instructions and directions by not only taking Kurnool first,
but even in that district eliminating the private operators
from the western portions of the distrfot who were the political opponents of the Chief Minister. This, it is obvious,
would be a matter of probabilities and of the inference to
be drawn by the Court from all the circumstances on which
no direct evidence can be adduaed.
It is, no doubt, true that allegations of mala [ides and
of improper motives on the part of those in power are frequently made and their frequency has increasecl in recent
times. It is also somewhat unfortunate that allegations of
this nature which have no foundation, in fact, are made in
1964
C. S. Rowjee
v.
State of Andhra
Pradesh
Ayyangar J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1964
C.
several of the cases which have come u;i before this and other
s. Rowjee Courts and it is found that they have been made merely
oj·
State
Andhra with a view to cause prejudice or in the hope that whether
Pradesh
they have basis in fact or not some of it at least
Ayyangar 1.
might stick. Consequently it has become the duty of
the Court to scrutinise these allegations with care so as
to avoid being in any manner influenced by them, in cases
where they have no foundation in fact. i In this task which
is thus cast on the courts it would conduce to a more satisfactory disposal and consideration of them, if those against
whom allegations are made came forward to place before
the court either their denials or their version of the matter,
so that the court may be in a position to judge as to whether
the onus that lies upon those who make ailegations cf ma/a
{ides on the part of authorities of the status of those with
which this appeal is concerned, have discharged their burden
of proving i.t.
In the absence of such affidavits or of
.materials, placed before the Court by these authorities, the
Court is left to judge. of the veracity of the allegations
merely on tests of probability with nothing more substantial
by way of answer. This is precisely the situation in which we
find ourselves in the present case.
The learned Judges of the High Court have repelled
the allegations contained in the affidavits which we have
set out earlier on grounds and for reasons which do not
appeal to us. As the learned Advocate-General did not
seek to support those grounds and that reasoning
we do not consider it necessary to set them out or deal
If the reasons given by the learned Judges
with them.
of the High Court be put aside, th\: position resolves itself
into this that allegations with particularity and detail have
been made in the petition. We are here having in mind the
allegations we have enumerated and categorised earlier as
objective facts. As to these there is no denial at all of
them, not even by the Transport Minister who though he
filed an affidavit, confined himself to the allegations regarding his having been dictated to by the Chief Minister when
he approved the schemes, though it is obvious they are
capable of denial and if need be wiih the same particularity'
with which they have been made in the petition. The learn-
•
6 S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
349
ed judges of the High Court have not rejected the allegations regarding the objective facts on the ground of their
~atent improbability or absurdity, nor did the learned Advocate-General make any submission on these Jines.
The next question is as regards the inference to be
drawn from these facts which in the absence of their denial
have to be taken as true. It is here that we ·have felt the
greatest uneasiness, because if the facts which serve as the
foundation for the plea of mala fides are made out, the only
question would be whether the inference of mala fides on
the part of the Chief Minister would be a reasonable one to
draw. It is at this point that we are faced with the necessity of having to proceed without there being any effective
answer to the propriety of drawing the inference which the
appellants desire. There has been no denial by the Chief
Minister, nor an affidavit by any person who claims or can
claim to know personally about the truth about these allegadons. The Secretary to the Home Department-one Mr.
S. A. Iyengar has filed a counter-affidavit in which the allegations we have set out earlier have been formally denied.
He says, "I have been expressly instructed and authorised
by the Hon'ble the Chief Minister to state that the allegations suggesting personal animus and giving mandate are
false and mischievous and have been deliberately made to
create an atmosphere of sympathy". The learned AdvocateGeneral did not suggest that the Court could act upon this
second-hand denial by the Chief Minister, as the statement
by Sri S. A. Iyengar is merely hearsay. We are, therefore,
constrained to hold that th.e allegations that the Chief Minister was motivated by bi~ and personal ill-will against the
appellants, stands unrebutted.
The learned Advocate-General realising this position,
desired us to proceed on that basis and his submission was
that assuming that the allegations made against the Chief
Minister were made out and that he had bias and ill-will
against the iippellants, still there was no proof thM the Corporation which was an autonomous body was similarly motivated and that unless the appellants were able to establish
it,' bias or ill-will on the part of the Chief Minister would
be irrelevant
1964
C.
s. Rowjee
v.
State of Andltro
Pradesh
AY"""gar J.
350
19
64
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
We agree as already indicated that he is right in
this
C. s. Rowjee submission. This takes us to the consideration of the quesState of Andhra tion as to whether the Corporation carried out the mandate
Pradesh
of the Chief Minister as was alleged by the appellants or
Ayyangar J.
whether the impugned schemes were formulated bv them as
a result of the opinion which they themselves foriiJed that
they were necessary in public interest for the purposes set
out in s. 68-C of the Act. On this matter there is an affidavit by the Corporation denying the allegation made by
the appellants that the Corporation acted merely as the tool
of the Chief Minister in order to carry out his. behest, and
it is there asserted that the decision to frame the schemes
was taken as a result of the independent opinion formed by
them after an examination of the entire question. The
acceptability of these rival assertions were debated before
us most >trenuously during the hearing of these ~.ppeals.
Certain facts already set out have a bearing on this question, and these we shall recall. The Anantharamakrishnan
Committee had laid down the criteria for determining the
order in which areas and routes had to be selected for
nationalisation, and applying these principles had drawn up
a list of the remaining disllicts in which nationalisation
should be successively taken up. If that order was followed, Nellore would· have been the next district to be taken
up and the tnrn of the Kurnool District would have come
up after nationalisation of the routes in the Nellore, Chittor and Cuddapah districts were completed. This report
had been submitted to the Corporation in February, 1961
and after further detailed examination of these recommendations the Corr,:ioration had accepted the recommendation regarding the order of the Districts to be taken up for nationalisation and had embodied this approval in its Administration Report dated March 24, 1962 which was published in
April, 1962. It is only necessary to add that the Cor/oration had also had the routes in Nellore surveyed a little
while before. In February, 1962, however, the general
elections to the Assembly and the Parliamentary Constituencies had taken place and the allegations of the appellants
related to the feelings that arose during the course of elections. The present Chief Minister assumed office as Chief
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
351
Minister on March 12, 1962. On April 19, 1962, it is admitted that he summoned a conference of the Corporation
and its officials at which, and this also is admitted, he suggested that the nationalisation of bus routes in the Kurnool
District should be taken up first. Now the Chief Minister
himself made a statement as to what he did at this meeting.
It is the case of the appellants that it was the mandate given
to the, Corporation by the Chief Minister at this Conference that brought about this change in the order of the districts to. be taken up for nationalisation and not the independent opinion of the Corporation as to what was needed
in the public interest as required by s. 68-C. As regards
his part at the conference, the Chief Minister himself stated
in the Assembly on July 26, 1962:
"To say that the Corporation will do everything for
the simple reason that it is an autonomous body,
and also to say that we will not at all interfere, is not fair. It will not be fair. Now and
then we shall have conferences. For exampl~,
the Corporation wanted to nationalise Chittoor
district. We had discussions. Kurnool is surrounded by three nationalised distdcts; one
side Mahaboobnagar, one side Guntur and
the other side the district of Nellore which is
going to be nationalised. I questioned as to
why the district of Kurnool which is surrounded by three nationalised districts i~ left out, and
instead the district of Chittoor which is abutling the borders of Madras and Bangalore
is sought to be taken up. They could not
explain, I said Kurnool district is a very compact one and three districts around it are
nationalised. They thought that was more
practicable and reasonable,
Therefore they
changed their minds. As a result of such discussions, once in a way we (Government) do
interfere but will not interfere in day to day
administration."
The conference, as stated earlier, addressed by the Chief
Minister was on the 19th of April, 1962. This was follow-
1964
C.
s. Rowjee
v.
State of Andhra
Pradesh
Ayyangar J.
352
1964
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
ed by the resolution of the Corporation of May 4, 1962.
C. S. Rowjee This ran:
v.
Stale of Andhra
"The Corporation noted
Pradesh
4yyangar J.
[rg04}
the discussion which took
place in the office of the Chief Minister on
19th April, 1962, in regard to programme of
nationalisation of Road Transport Services
during the Third Five Year Plan period and
resolved that during the Third Five Year Plan
three more districts in the order mentioned
could be nationalised, viz., Kurnool, Nellore
and Cuddapah in view of difficult financial
position ........ Chief Executive Officer explained that as there is a depot at Kurnool and
as Kurnool is contiguous to the nationalised
districts, it would be easier to nationalise Kurnool rather Nellore district. The nationalisation could be extended to the Nellore district
after Kurnool disirict is nationalised. The Corporation therefore resolved that Kurnool district could be taken up for nationalisation in
preference to Nellore."
In the counter-affidavit which 1J1e Corporation filed to
the writ petition the Chief Executive Officer after denying
that the Corporation was actuated by ma/a fides in framing
the three impugned schemes, stated that the acceptance by
the Corporation of the recommendation of 1he Anantharamakrishnan Committee was tentative and that it could
not fetter them from discharging its powers and duties under
the statute. · It gave the following reasons for the decision
to nationalise Road Transport Services in a part of the
Kurnool district in preference to other areas: (1 ) because
there is a Government depot at Kurnool, (2) Kurnool is
contiguous to the entire Telangana area which is nationalised and also contiguous to the nationalised area of Guntur.
It also stated that the choice was made in the interest of the
maintenance of service contiguity and coordination and it
added that "the impending completion of the Ra.ngapur
Bridge over the river Krishna, which when completed
would facilitate the operation of direct services from Hyderabad through Kurnoof to the areas beyond." Besides it
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
353
asserted that the Corporation which was an autonomous
statutory authority was vested with powers under the Road
Transport Act and it was, therefore, malicious to allege that
the decision by the Corporation to prepare the impugned
schemes was either infiuen~ed by the Chief Minister or .was
under a mandate from him and it a_sserted that in formulating the schemes the necessary opinion under s. 68-C was
formed by itself.
The learned Judges of the High Court have accepted
this statement, made on behalf of the Corporation and have
repelled the attack made on it based on the schemes not
having been formulated as a result of the opinion formed
by the Corporation itself. The learned Advocate-General
commended this approach and this conclusion for our
acceptance. He also pointed out. that the Anantharamakrishnan Committee had themselves indicated in paragraph
126 of their report that the order in which the new areas
will be taken over for nationalisation might be decided by
the Government, so that the order in which motor transport in the several districts should, be nationalised, was not
prescribed by the Committee as a rigid or hard and fast
rule, but the order of the districts was treated even by them
as a flexible one which was capable of and was intended to
be, modified by the Government by making policy decisions on these matters taking into account not merely the
finances available for nationalisation but also other relevant
matters.
We have given the matter our best consideration, but
we are unable to agree with the learned Judges of the High
Court in their conclusion. The first matter which stands
out prominently in this connection is the element of time
and the sequence of dates. We have already pointed out
that the Corporation had as late as March, I 962 considered the entire subject and had accepted the recommendation of ihe Anantharamakrishnan Committee as to the order
in which the transport in the several districts should be
nationalised and had set these out in their Administration
Report for the three year perio<i 1958 to 1961. It must,
therefore, be taken that every factor which the Anantha134-159 S.C.-23
1964
C. S. Row/u
v.
State of Andhra
Pradesh
Ayyangar /,
354
1964
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
ramakrishnan Committee had
considered
relevant and
C. s. Rowie• material for determining the order of the districts had been
State 0/· Andhra independently investigated, examined and concurred in,
Pradesh
before those recommendations were approved. It means
Ayyangar 1.
that upto March-April, 1962 a consideration of all the re-
levant factors had led the Corporation to a conclusion
identical with that of the Anantharamakrishnan Committee.
The next thing that happened was a conference of the Corporation and its officials with the Chief Minister on April
19, 1962. The proceedings of the Conference are not on
the record nor is there any evidence as to whether any record was made of what happened at the conference. But
we have the statement of the Chief Minister made on the
floor of the State Assembly in which he gave an account of
what transpired between him and the Corporation and its
officials. We have already extracted the relevant portions
of that speech from which the following points emerge: ( 1)
that the Chief Minister claimed a right to lay down rules
of policy for the guidance of the Corporation and, in fact,
the learned Advocate-General submitted to us that under
the Road Transport Corporation Act, 1950. the Government had a ~ight to give directions as to policy to the Corporation; (2) that the policy direction that he gave related
to and included the order in which the districts should be
taken up for nationalisation; and (3) that applying the criteria that the districts to be nationalis~.d should be contiguous to those in which nationalised services ~!ready existed,
Kumool answered this test better than Chittoor and he,
applying the tests he laid down, therefore suggested that instead of Chittoor, Kurnool should be taken up next. One
matter that emerges from this is that it was as a result of
policy decision taken by the Chief Minister and the direction given to the Corporation that Kurnool was taken up
for nationalisation next after Guntur. It is also to be
noticed that if the direction by the Chief Minister, was a policy
decision, the Corporation was under the law bound to give
effect to it ( vide s. 34 of the Road Transport Corporation
Act, 1950). We are not here concerned with the question
whether a policy deci~ion contemplated by s. 34 of the Road
Transport Act could relate to a matter which under s. 68-C
of the Act is left to the unfettered discretion and judg-
6 S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
355
ment of the Corporation, where that is the State Undertak·
1964
ing, or again whether or not the policy decision has to be c. s. Row}••
by a .formal Government .order in writing, for what is rele·
P .,.d h
mu
vant 1s whether the materials placed before the Court estab- .Stat• 01 AlllihN
Iish that the Corporation gave effect to it as a direction A.yyangar /.
which they were expected to and did obey. If the Chief
Minister was impelled by motives of personal ill-will against
the Road Transport Operators in the western part of Kurnool and he gave the direction to the Corporation to change
the order of the districts as originally planned by them and
instead take up Kurnool first in order to prejudicially affect
his political opponents, and the Corporation carried out
his directions it does not need much argument to show
that the resultant scheme framed by the Corporation would
also be vitiated by ma/a {ides notwithstanding the interposition of the semi-autonomous Corporaiion.
It is also to be noticed that the Chief Minister in his
statement to the Assembly stated that when he made an
enquiry of the Corporation as to why they did not choose
Kurnool as the next district, the officials of the Corporation
had no answer to give. It is somewhat remarkable that
the Corporation and its officials should have remained silent
and tongue-tied notwithstanding that its Vice-Chairman
was a member of the Anantharamakrishnan Committee and
had as a inember thereof considered the entire question in
all its aspects and laid down ( 1) the criteria for determining
the order of priority; and (2) by ap;>lying these tests had
laid down the priorities among the districts and more than
this, the entire body of the Corporation had considered the
several recommendations of the Committee in their report
and while rejecting some had accepted this particular recommendation regarding the order in which the districts
should be taken up and this last one had happened within
a month or so before the conference addressed by the Chief
Minister. If in these circumstances the appellants allege
that whatever views the Co11poration entertained they were
compelled to or gave effect to the wishes of the Chief Minister, it could not be said that the same is an unreasonable
inference from facts. It is also somewhat remarkable that
within a little over two weeks from this Conference by its
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1964
resolution of May 4, 1962, the Corporation dropped Ne1lore altogether, a district which was contiguous to Gumm
v.
and
proceeded to 1ake up the nationalisation of the routes
Stai. of Andhra
of the western part of the Kurnool district and were able
· Pradesh
to find reasons for taking ~he ~tep. It is also worthy of
Ayyangar J.
note that in the resolution of the 4th May, 1962, of the Corporation only one reason was given for preferring Kurnool
to Nellore, namely, the existence of a depot at Kurnool because the other reason given, namely, that Kurnool was
contiguous to an area of nationalised transport equally
applied to Nellore and, in fact, this was one of the criteria
o.n the basis of which the Anantharamakrishnan Committee
itself decided the order of priority among 'he districts. As
regards the depot at Kurnool which was one of the two
reasons set out in the resolution for the choice of that district i.n the first instance, learned Counsel for the <!Qpellants
submitted that this rea1on was one invented to justify the
Corporation's action directed against them and to obviate
the comment that the reason for the change was political
and not for providing an adequate service for the area.
He submitted that the so-called depot wa1 merely a garage
with a few repairing tools and not any full-fledged repairing workshop. None of the affidavits filed on behalf of the
appellants, however, made any allegation regarding the
nature of the facility afforded at this 'depot'-and so we
are not in a position to act merely on the arguments adduced to us at the bar. It has however to be noticed that the
existence of this 'depot' at Kurnool escaped the notice of
the Anantharamakrishnan Committee, who in their report
have devoted some attention to the need for depots and
the equipment these should possess and referred to certain
deficiencies which they noticed in the depots which they
inspected. The officials of the Corporation did not evidently bring this depot at Kumool to the notice of the Committee. Again, when in their Administration Report, the
Corporation accepted the recommendations a1 regards the
order in which the districts should be nationalised, the
existence of this depot at Kurnool seems also to have escaped the a;tention of the Corporation itself, as a factor to be
taken into account in making the choice of the district. But
we are basing no conclusion on this feature.
C. s. Rowjee
(; S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
357
1964
When the Transport Corporation, however, filed the C. s. Row/et
counter-affidavit it was not content to rest merely with the
v.
of AndhN
reasons given in the resolut:on as those which were taken StatePradesh
into account in arriving at the decision but added one
Ayyangar J.
more, namely, the impending completion of the bridge at
Rangapur across the Krishna as a further reason which had
been taken into account for arriving at a decision. What
the Court is concerned with and what is relevant to the
enquiry in the appeal is not whether theoretically or on
a consideration of the arguments for and against, now
advanced the choice of Kurnool as the next district selected
for nationalisation of iransport was wise or improper, but
a totally different question whether this choice of Kurnool
was made by the Corporation as required by s. 68-C or,
whether this choice was in fact and in substance, made by
the Chief Minister, and implemented by him by utilism~
the machinery of the Corporation as alleged by the appellants. On the evidence placed in the case we are satisfied
that it was as a result of the conference of the 19th April,
1962, and in order to give effect to the wishes of the Chiet
Minister expressed there, that the schemes now impugned
were formulated by the. Corporation.
The next submission of the learned Advocate-General
was that even assuming the Chief Minister directed the
order in which districts were to be taken up for nationalisation, still the scheme framed by the Corporation could not
be assailed as not in conformity with the requirements of
s. 68-C of the Ac: so long as the choice of the "area" in
which and the routes in it to be run by the Corporation was
made by them alone. This argument proceeds from the
circumstance that even taking it that the Chief Minister
directed the Corporation to take up the nationalisation of
the routes in the Kurnool district in the first instance, there
was no allegation that he gave any direction regarding the
area in the district and the routes. We fail to see any for~e
in this argunient. If the choice of the district was that ot
the Chief Minister, the fact ·that within the area of the di~
trict pointed out to them, the Corporation selected some
area witl1 in the district and the routes within that area.
358
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[rg64)
1964
cannot on any reasonable construction of s. 68-C be a
sufficient
compliance with the statute. We are disposed to
C. s.. Row/••
read the word 'area' in the section as meaning such 'area•
11Gt6 "f Andhra
in the entire State as the Corporation should consider proper
Pradesh
and not as the learned Advocate-General would read as
Ayyangar J.
area within a circumscribed part of the State determined
by an outside authority.
...
Besides, there is really little or no explanation forthcoming from the Corporation for choosing the western part
of the Kurnool district for the exclusion of the private operators in the first instance. The principal allegation regarding mala {ides on the part of the Chief Minister made by
1the appellants was directed to demonstrate that the object
of the present schemes was to eliminate operators whose
routes lay .on the western side of the district. It is also
stated in the affidavits that the friends or supporters of the
Chief Minister were operating motor transport in the eastern part of Kurnool. Therefore it might. be expected that
th~ counter-affidavits filed offered a rational explanation as
to why this portion of the Kurnool district was chosen in
the first instance in preference to the other portion of the
district. Needless to say the resolution of the Corporation
of May 4, 1962, offers no assistance in this matter and as
we have said earlier though the counter-affidavits contained
a denial of the allegation that the Corporation was acting
at the behest of the Chief Minister, there is no explanation
for the choice of the western portion. Our conclusion
therefore is that the impugned schemes are vitiated by the
fact that they were not in conformity with the requirements
of s. 68-C.
The next question is as regards the approval of the
schemes by the Transport Minister under s. 68-D(3). It
was the case of the appellants that just like the Corporation, the Transport Minister also merely carried out the
wishes of the Chief Minister and that therefore the approval
by the Transport Minister must be held to be vitiated by
the mala {ides of the Chief Minister. In regard to this,
however, two matters hav11 to be remembered. The first is
that there is nothing on the record to show that the Chief
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
359
1964
Minister influenced his colleague and beyond the fact that
both the Chief Minister as well as the Transport Minister C. s. Rowi..
are members of the same Council of Ministers, there is State of Andhra
nothing to indicate that the Chief Minister influenced the
Pradesh
Transport Minjster. The other matter is that the Transport Ayyangar J.
Minister had stated on oath that in considering the objections under s. 68D ( 3) and approving the schemes he wrus
uninfluenced by the Chief Minister. We, therefore, consider that tliere is no basis for holding that the Transport
Minister's approval of the schemes does not satisfy the requirements of the law.
••
In view that we take the schemes have to be set aside
as not in conformity with s. 68-C of the Act, the other
objections raised do not require consideration but in view,
however, of the arguments addressed to us on them we shall
briefly deal with them.
The next ·point that was urged was that the schemes
were not in conformity with s. 68-C of the Act for another
reason. A scheme to be published by the Transport Undertaking is required by s. 68-C to give "particulars of the
nature of the services proposed to be rendered and such
other particulars respecting thereto as may be prescribed",
prescribed, of course, meaning "prescribed by rules". These
particulars, it is obvious, are required to be set out in the
scheme, so that (a) transport operators running vehicles on
tl!e routes might know that they are afrected by the scheme
and might, if they see sufficient reason therefor, prefer
objpctions under s. 68-D(l); '3lld (b) the operators and
others formulate. their objections properly, particularly in
the matter of pointing out the deficiency or inadequacy of
the schemes or the services proposed to be run under the
schemes for the approving authority to consider. It was
urged on behalf of the appellants that the impugned scheme
did not furnish particulars required by this provision. The
draft scheme, as published under s. 68-C, and that as
approved finally, contains six columns which are respectively headed (1) Serial Number: (2) Name of the Route,
indicating its course; (3) I&ngtlr of the route in miles; ( 4)
360
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[rg64]
1964
Number of vehicles proposed to be operated on each route:
C. s. Row/tt (5) Total number of trips each way to be performed on
v.
each route; and (6) The nature of the services. Now.
Stole of A.ndhra
1Prad'8h
columns 4 and 5 do not contain the precise number of vehicles proposed to be operated or the precise total of the trips
A.yyangar /.
each way to be performed daily. But on the other hand
each of these columns is sub-divided into twcr-4 and 4(a),
5 and 5(a). Under column 4 is given the minimum number
of vehicles proposed to be operated and under 4 (a) the
maximum number. Similarly column 5 sets out the minimum number,of total trips each way and 5(a) the maximum
number. Now in several of these the variation between the
maximum and the minimum in columns 4 and 5 is 1 to 2
i.e. if one is the minimum two is the maximum, and similarly if two is the minimum, four is the maximum, but there
are others in which the variation is even more pronounced.
for instance, in scheme number one, 1rt serial number 15
the. minimum is one and the maximum three in both
columns 4 and 5 and in serial number 16 the proportion
between, the maximum and minimum is even more pronounced for in column 4 it is 1 to 4. The position is similar in regard to serial No. 20. The objection that is raised
to this method of specifying the maximum and the minimum
of the number of vehicles which will be put on the route and
the number of trips which these vehicles will operate is, that
one of ,the objects of the schemes is the provision, among
others, of an adequate road transport serviCe. It is common
ground that the persons affected by the schemes may object
to the scheme on the ground that it does not offer an adequate service and that this would be a relevant matter for
consideration by the authority approving the scheme. It is,
therefore, urged on behalf of the appellants that the schemes
as promulgated which disclose not the actual number of
vehicles that would run or the number of trips which the
vehicles would make, do not enable the affected objectors
to raise their objections to the adequacy of the service proposed and similarly do not afford requisite information to
the approving authority under s. 680(3) to decide whether
to approve the scheme or not. Besides this general objection, it is pointed out that the cpecification of a minimum
I
t> S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
361
a
1964
and maximum in columns 4 and 5 is contrary to what has
been prescribed by the Andhra Pradesh Motor Vehicles C. s. Rowjee
Rules, 1957, made in relation to "the particulars to be con- State ofv. Andhra
tained in schemes under Ch. IV-A." Rule 4 of these Rules
Pradesh
which have statutory force under s. 68-C requires draft
Ayyangar J.
schemes and awroved schemes to contain inter alia "the
number of vehicles proposed to be operated on each route
and the total number of trips to be performed daily on
each rou•e." By a rule framed on the 26th of December,
1958, the State Government framed a rule numbered as
Rule 5 of these Rules which reads:
"5. The State Transport Undertaking may at its
discretion, vary the frequency of services on
any of the notified routes or within any nodfied
area having regard to the needs of traffic during any period, either by increasing or decreasing the number of trips of the existing buses
or by increasing or decreasing the number of
buses."
The validity of Rule 5 was one of the mattel's that was
raised for consideration by this Court in Dosa Satyanarayanamurty etc. v. The Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport
Corporation(') and this Court held that Rule 5 was repugnant to s. 68-E which reads:
"Any scheme published under sub-s. ( 3) of s. 68-D
may at any time be cancelled or modified by
the State Transport Undertaking and the procedure laid down in s. 68-C and s. 68-D shall,
so far as it can be made applicable be followed in every case where the scheme is proposed
to be modified as if the modifications proposed
were a separate scheme."
and struck it down. Thereafter rule 5 was deleted, but
rule 4 remains as we have set out. The question for consideration is whether the prescription of maxima and minim:·:
in c_olumns 4 & 5 is in conformity with the requirements
of Rule 4. It was submitted on behalf of the appellants ( 1)
that the reason why these maxi!Jla and minima were put
----------
362
1964
C.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[rg64)
do"":n in the sch~mes, contravening Rule 4, was in reality to
s. Rowjee avoid the operation of s. 68-E and to get over the decision
v.
State of Andhra
Pradesh
Ayyangar J.
of this Court striking down Rule 5 and that for the same
reason which underlay the decision of this Court in Dosa
Satyanarayanamurty' s case(') the prescription of maxima
and minima contravened s. 68-E as it operates iu no way
dissimilar to Rule 5 and that as this vice pervades the
entirety of the scheme as published, all the three schemes
should be set aside. In further support of their submission
the appellants relied -0n the affidavit filed by the Assistant
Secretary to the Transport Department who stated that the
prescription of maxima and minima was adopted because
"it enabled the Corporation to provide adequate services
with reference to the public needs, without having to go
through the elaborate gamut of modifying the approved
scheme for the purpose."
The learned Judges of the High Court have repelled
this contention on the grqund of the analogy furnished b· ·
ss. 46 and 48 of the Act under which applications for State
carriage permits by private operators and the permits granted to them are required tu state the minimum and maximum
number of daily services proposed to be provided in relation to each route or area, was an indication that a scheme
specifying the maxima and minima of the number of buses
and services was in conformity with and did not contravene
Rule 4. The learned Advocate-General adopted the same
line of argument and submitted that the language of Rule 4
did not in terms prohibit the specification of a minimum and
maximum and that Rule 5 which this Court struck down
as being repugnant to s. 68-E was attracted only when the
maxima or minima set out in the scheme was departed
from. He, however, conceded that the gap between the
minimum and the maximum specifiee in a scheme might be
so wide as to render the same a contradiction of Rule 4 but
he submitted that the variations in the 3 schemes before
us between columns 4 and 4(a) and columns 5 and S(a)
respectively were so slight as not to amount to a failure to
fix the number of vehicles to be operated or the trips they
would do on the routes.
c'l [19611 1 s.c.R. 642.
I
-
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1964
In the case before us in view of the conclusion we have
reached that some of the variations between the maxima C. S. Rowjee
v.
and the minima in the number of vehicles proposed to be
State of Andhro
operated on each route are such as, adopting the test sugPradesh
gested by the learned Advocate-General himself, to really
Ayyangar J.
contravene Rule 4 we have not thought it necessary to
finally decide the larger question, whether the mere prescription of the maxima and minima, particularly for the
reasons set out in the affidavit of the Assistant Secretary to
the Transport Department, constitutes a violation of s. 68-E
as also of Rule 4 of the Motor Vehicles Rules, 1957 as to
require the same to be struck down. We might, however,
mention in passing that' we are not much impressed by the
argument based on ss. 46 and 48. It must be remembered
that we are concerned with a requirement of Ch. IV-A and
under s. 68-B of the Act, not only the provisions of that
Chapter but the rules made thereunder are to have effect
notwithstanding anything in Ch. IV in which s. 46 and ~· 48
occur. This apart, the rule-making authority had the analogy of the provisions of ss. ·46 and. 48 before it, but yet
chose not to adopt the same phraseology as was employed
in these sections. Besides, as the provisions of Ch. IV-A
invade the rights of private operators to carry on business
and is justified as a reasonable restriction on their rights
in public interest, it might very well have been considered
that a more precise indication should be afforde<i by the
scheme to enable its adequacy to be tested by the quasijudiciat procedure which has to be followed before the
scheme becomes effective. However, as stated already,
there is no need to decide this matter finally in view of om
conclusion that the scheme contravenes Rule 4 even on the
test submitted by the Advocate-General. In saying this
we have in mind routes 15, 16, 18 and 20 of scheme No. 1
in which the variation in the number of vehicles fa 1 to 3,
1 to 4 and 3 to 8 and similarly in scheme No. 2 route No. 1
where the variation is 6 to 12 and in scheme No. 3 route
No. 1 the variation is 5 to 9. We might mention that we
have taken into account not merely the proportion but the
variation in the number. We have set these out as merely
illustrative and we have not thought it necessary to make
an exhaustive list of all the routes.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1964
C.
S.
Row;ee
v.
5tate of AnJhra
Pradesh
Ayyangar J.
The next objection was that some of the routes mcluded
in the scheme were inter-State routes and that under the
l(lroviso to s. 68D ( 3) it could not be deemed to be an approved scheme unless the previous approval of the Central
Government had been obtained. We consider this objection
as without force. The route which is proposed to be
nationalised under the scheme admittedly lies wholly within
the State. The right of the private operators to ply their
vehicles beyond the State border is not affected by any of
the scitemes. 1t would, therefore, follow that the proviso
to s. 68-D ( 3) is not attracted and consequently the scheme
does not suffer from the defect alleged.
The next point made was that the language employed
to indicate the na:ure of the service in column 6 of th.~
schemes was vague, with the result that operators who had,
in fact, been affected by the scheme understood the words
employed as not affecting them and consequently did not
make objections as they were entitled to under s. 68-0(2).
We have examined the language employed and we consider
that the submission does not deserve serious consideration
nor we are satisfied that any party was really misled by
ambiguous phrasing of column 6 of the scheme. In fact,
learned Counsel did not press this objection after the matter
was discussed during arguments.
The next series of objections to the schemes are those
which arise in Civil Appeals Nos. 771 to 778. The point
most strenuously contended related to an illegality which was
alleged to have occurred in the implementation of the
scheme. Under s. 68-(1) the State Transport Undertaking has to make the application in the manner specified
in Chapter IV-A for "a Stage Carriage permit" ....... .
"to the Regional T1 ansport Autliority" and that Authority
is directed to grant the permit to the Undertaking notwithstanding anything to the contrary in Ch. IV. In accordance
with the provisions of this section the State Road Transport
Corporation made an application for the grant of permits
to the Regional Transport Authority. The objection raised
is that the application had to be made not to the Regional
Transport Authority but only to the State Transport Authority which authority alone, it is urged, is competent to en·
/
6 S.C.K
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1964
tertain applications for the grant of permits where the
length of the route is 100 miles or over and such route is C. S. Rowiee
over a Trunk Road. Three of the rou:es in scheme 2 with State ofv.Andhra
Pradesh
which Civil Appeal Nos. 773, 776 and 777 are concerned
are of a length beyond 100 miles and the roadway on
Ayyungar J.
which the route lies are admittedly Trunk Roads. Under
Rule 141 of the Madras Motor Vehicles Act Rules permits
on routes covering a distance of over I 00 miles on Trunk
Roads could be granted only by the S:ate Transport Authority. It was this Authority that had granted the pertnits to
operate on these three routes to the respective appell;ints
in these appeals. The argument is that even when a Transport Undertaking applies for a stage carriage permit under
s. 68-F(l) it must comply with the provisions of Rule 14 I.
On the basis of this reasoning the appellants in these thr.ee
Civil Appeals have applied for a writ of prohibition against
the Regional Transport Authority before whom the applications have been filed. Section 68-F(I) reads:
"68-F(I). Where, in pursuance of an approved
scheme any State transport undertaking applies in the manner specified in Chapter IV for a
stage carriage permit or a public carrier's
pertnit or a contract carriage permit in respect
of a notified area or notified route. the Regional
Transport Authority shall issue such permit to
the State transport undertaking. notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in
Chapter IV."
'Ihe learned Judges of the High Court have held that
the Regional Transport Authority which is specifically mentioned in s. 68-F(I) is empowered to issue the pertnit to the
transport undertaking "notwithstanding anything to the
contrary contained in Chapter TV" and that the section
rendered the provisions of Rule 141 of the Motor Vehicles
Rul~s inapplicable to cases covered by s. 68-F( 1). We find
ourselves in agreement with this view. Bc>ide,. s. 68-B
of the Act enacts:
"68-B. The provisions of this Chapter and the rules
and orders made thereunder..ma}l have effect
366
19M
C.
S.
••
Rowfee
Stat• of Andhra
Pradesh
Ayyangar /.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1964]
notwithstanding anything inconsistent
therewith contained in Chapter IV of this Act or
in any law for the time being in force or in
any instrument having effect by virtue of any
such law."
Therefore any provisions in Chapter IV which are inconsistent with those contained in Ch~ter IV-A would to
that extent be superseded. No doubt, s. 68-F( 1) speaks
of an application in the manner specified in Ch. IV which
if the words stood alone are capable of being understood as
meaning the authority to whom the application has to be
made, but as the authority to issue the permit in pursuance
of the aipplication is specified as the Regional Transport
Authority and as that authority is directed 'lo issue the permit notwithstanding anything in Ch. IV so much of Ch. IV
or the Rules made thereunder, which specify the authority to
grant the permit as being someone other than the Regional
Transport Authority, is to that extent superseded. It was
pointed out that under Rule 141 the State Transport Authority was itself vested with the powers of the Regional Transport Authority where the route was of the description mentioned earlier, but this, in our opinion, makes no difference.
No doubt, in a State where there is no Regional Transport
Authority at all [vide e.g. proviso to s. 44(1 )], but there is
some other authority which functions as the Regional
Transport Authority for the purposes of the Act, such an
Authority might be that which would be comprehended by
s. 68-F(l) but where as in Andhra Pradesh there is admittedly a Regional Transport Authority, we cannot accede to
the submission that such authority is deprived of the power
to issue a pormit by reason of s. 68F(l) merely because the
Regional Transport Authority of that area cannot grant
permits under Ch. IV
There were certain other points urged in Civil Appeal
No. 771 which arose only if the Regional Transport Authority to whom applications under s. 68-F (1) were made,
was not competent to entertain application and issue a
In view of our conclusion as regards the point
permit.
urged in Civil Appeal No. 771 of 1963 do not arise.
6 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
IJIU
There remains for being dealt with one minor point
which was urged in Civil Appeals Nos. 883 and 884 which C. S. Rowlee
we consider entirely without substance. The point was that Statt ofv.Andlml
the description of the rout¢ in the scheme was too vague
Pradesh
and misleading, so much so that the appellants did not file Ayyangar J.
their objections before the Government. Taking the case of
Civil Appeal No. 883, it is by an operator who runs a
service from Uravakonda to Adoni. Serial No. 16 of scheme
No. 1 describes the route as Adoni to Uravakonda. It was
urged that as the scheme notified the route Adoni to Uravakonda but not Uravakonda to Adoni, the appellant
thought !!tat his route was not affected. The objection is
on its very face frivolous because throughout the scheme, it
is only the terminal points that are specified and that specification carries with it and obviously implies that the operation of transport between the two terminii is intended to
be nationalised. The complaint in Civil Appeal No. 884
is the same, only the route is different. This completes all
the points that are urged before us.
In view of our conclusion that the schemes are vitiated
by non-compliance with the requirements of s. 68-C and
the Rules made thereunder, we hold that they have to be
quashed as not warranted by Jaw.
The aippeals are accordingly allowed and the appellants
are granted a declaration that the schemes are invalid and
cannot be enforced. The appellants would be entitled to
their costs here and in the High Court-one hearing fee.
Appeals allowed.
AYYANGAR J.-When the judgment in the above
appeals was pronounced on January 27, 1964 the learned
Advocate for the appellants brought to our notice the following order passed by this Court on June 10, 1963 when
the interim stay of the operation of the schemes which are
impugned in the above appeals, was vacated on the opposition by the State Government:
"Stay vacated on the learned Advocate-General for
Andhra Pradesh giving an undertaking that
368
1964
C.
S.
Rowjee
v.
State of Andhra
Pradesh
Ayyangar
J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
in case the appeals succeed, the State will compensate the appellants for the loss incurred by
them during the period that the appeals were
pending in this Court by reason of the fact
that they were not allowed to ply their buses
on the routes under the respective permits
granted to them.
The learned AdvocateGeneral further undertakes that this amount
of compensation will be determined in the
present proceedings themselves. No order as to
costs."
The learned Coun'sel requested us that we should give
some directions in terms of this undertaking.
In view of
the above we would add the following at the end of the
judgment which was pronounced on January 27, 1964:
"In view of the order r,iassed by this Court on June
10, 1963, when the in1erim order of stay was
vacated at the instance of the respondent,
recording the undertaking on the part of the
State that it would compensate the appellants
for the loss incurred by them during the period
when the appeals were pending in this Court.
there· will be a declaration to that effect, and
the High Court will determine the amount so
payable and pass suitable directions for the
payment thereof."
R. CIDTRALEKHA & ANR.
1964
January,
29
v.
STATE OF MYSORE & ORS.
(B. P. SINHA, C. J., K. SUBBA RAO, RAGHUBAR DAYAL, N.
RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR AND J. R. MUDHOLKAR JJ.)
Constitution of //idia, 1950, Arr. 166-1/ mandatory-List I Entry 66-Scope of-Viva Voce test for admission in college-If violation of
Art. 14--Article 15(4)-Classification of backward classes-Yali·
tlity.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org