GHANSHYAM DAS versus REGIONAL ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF SALES TAX, NAGPUR
Supreme Court of India | Decided 16 August 1963 | [1964] 4 S.C.R. 436 | 1963 INSC 171
Key facts
- Decided
- 16 August 1963
- Bench
- S.K. DAS*, K. SUBBA RAO, RAGHUBAR DAYAL, N. RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR, J.R. MUDHOLKAR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 101/1961
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1964] 4 S.C.R. 436
- Neutral citation
- 1963 INSC 171
Text of the judgment
436
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1964] .
GHANSHYAM DAS
v.
1963
August 16
REGIONAL ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF SALES
TAX, NAGPUR
(S. K. DAs, AcTING C.J., K. SuBBA RAO, RAGHUBAR DAYAL,
N. RAJGOPALA AYYANGAR AND J. R. MUDHOLKAR, JJ.)
•
Sales Tax-Assessnient of turnover escaping assessment"Escaped Assesstnent"-Meaning of-Assessment proceedings in respect of a registered dcaler-Comn1encen1ent of-Central Provinces and Berar Sales Tax Act, 1947 (XX/ of 1947), ss. 10(1), 11-A.
The appellant was a registered dealer carrying on business
in bidis. For the year 1949-50, i.e., for the period from October 22, 1949 to November 9, 1950 he submitted only one return on October 5, 1950 for one quarter and defaulted in respect of the other quarters. He \Vas served a notice on August
13, 1954 under s. 11(1) and (2) of the C.P. and Berar Sales
Tax -Act, 1947, in respect of the turnover for the said period. There
after, he filed the returns, but in the assess1nent proceedings
he contended inter alia, that the proceedings before the sales tax
commissioner \Vere barred by time. This contention was rejected
and his tax liability was detern1ined. Then. the appellant
moved t'ne I-Iigh Court in writ petition. In the other appeal
No. 102/1961, .the appellant had not filed :1ny return for the
year 1950-51 i.e. for "the period from November 10, 1950 to Oc·
tober 31., 1951. He was served a notice on October 15, 1954,
under s. 11 ( 4) of the Act, The said notice was within 3 years
from October 16, 1951 which fell within the 4th quaner of the
concerned year. The appellant then, filed his returns under protest and contended that the assessment proceedings were barred ·by limitation under s. il(A) of' the Act. This plea was rejected and his tax liability was detennined. The appellant
then, filed another writ petition for a si.milar relief. Both the
writ petitions were heard together and the learned single Judge
relying on a decision in Firm Sheonarayan Matadin v. Sales Tax
Officer, Raipur, quashed the said assessrrients. The respondent
then, filed Letters Patent Appeals before the Division Bench
and by a common judgn1ent the orders of the learned single
Judge· were set aside. In this Court, the appellant contended : (I)
the expression "escaped assessment" in s. '11-A of the Act would
apply also to a case where there was no assessment at all ;
(2) even if the first assessment proceedings were pending before tbe appropriate authority, ·it could only nlake the assessment
within three years fi:-om the date of the commencement of the
said proceedings, which would start only after the appropriate
authority issued a notice under s. 10( 1) or s; 11(2) or s. 11 (5)
<_?f the Act; (3) in the present case no proceedings in respect
of the said assessment were pending and ( 4) as only a part of
the· fourth quarter in the second appeal falls within three years,
i
4 S.C.R.
,;'I
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
437
1963
the proceedings in respect of the said entire quarter would be
barred under s. 11-A of the Act and, in any view only the turnover escaped in respect of the period between November 10, 1950 Ghanshyam Das
v.
to October 31, 1951 could be assessed. The respondent
mainly contended that whatever inay be said in the case of an Regional Assis·
tant Commisunregistered dealer, in the case of a registered dealer the proceedings commence fro1n the date fixed in the registration certi- sioner of Sales
Tax, Nagpur
ficate within \vhich the said dealer has a statutory obligation to furnish his return.
Held; (Raghubar Dayal, J. dissenting) ; The expression
"escaped assessment" in s. 11-A of the Act includes that of a
turnover \vhich has not been assessed at all, because for one
-
reason or other no assessn1ent proceedings \Vere initiated
therefore, no assessment was n1ade in respect thereof.
and
Comn1issioner of Income-tax, Bon1bay v. Pirojbai "l'l. Contractor, (1937) 5 I.T.R. 318, Maharaj Kumar Kamal Singh v. Com1nissioner of Income-tax, Bihar and Orissa, [1959] Supp. - S.C.R. 10
Mahnrajadhira1 Sir Kameshwar Singh v. State of Bihar, [ 1960]
1 S.C.R. 332, Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay v. 1Varset!
Nagsee Ct Co. [19601 3 S.C.R. 988 and State of Madras v. Balu
Chettiar, (1956) 7 S.T.C. 519, relied on.
The assess1nent proceedings ' under the sales tax must he
held to be pending from the time the said proceedings were initiated
until they \Vere terminated by a final order of assessment. Before
the final order of assessment, it could not be said that the entire
turnover or a part thereof of a dealer had escaped assessinent,
for, the assessment was not completed and, if completed, it might
be that the entire turnover \Vould be caught in the net.
Jn re Lachhiram Basantlal, (1930) l.L.R. 58 Cal. 909 and
Rajendra Nath Mukherjee v. Income-tax Commissioner, (1938)
L.R. 61 I.A. 10, referred to.
Under sub-section (1) of s. 10, the Commissioner need not
issue a notice to a registered dealer for furnishing the relevant
returns, but a statutory obligation is imposed on the said deaier
to do so by such dates and to such authority as may be prescribed.
In the case of a registered dealer there are four vanations
in the matter of assessn1ent of his turnover : ( 1) He .submits
a return by the date prescribed and pays the tax due in terms
of the said return; the con1missioner accepts the correctness of
the return and appropriates the amount paid towards the tax due
for the period covered by the return. (2) The Comn1issioner is
not satisfied with the correctness of the return ; he issues a
notice to him under s. 11 (2), and makes an enquiry as provided
under the Act, but does not finalize the assessment. (3) The registered dealer does not submit a return ; the Commissioner issues a notice under s. 10(3) and s. 11(4) of the Act. (4) The
registered dealer does not submit any return for any period and
the Commissioner issues notice to him beyond three years.
438
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1964]
Chanshyam Das
In the case of a registered dealer the proceedings before the
Commissioner starts factually when a return is made or when a
notice is issued to him either under s. 10(3) or under s. 11(2)
v.
of the Act.' '"fhe acceptance of the contention that the statutory
1963
Regional Assistant Commissioner of Sales
Tax, Nagpur
obligation !o file a return initiates the proceedings is to invo~<e
a fiction not sanctioned by the Act.
Bisesm· House v. State of Bombay (1958) 9 S.T.C. 654 ac1d
Ramakrishna Ramnath v. Sales Tax Officer, Nagpur, (1960) 11
S.T.C. 811, distinguished.
A statutory obligation to make a return within a prescribed
time does not proprio vigore initiate the assessment proceedings
before the Commissioner; but the proceedings would commence
after the return was submitted and would
continue till a final
.order of assessn1ent was made in regard to the said return.
In the first case, therefore, the tribunal had no jurisdiction
to issue a notice under s. 11-A with respect to the quarters other
than that covered by return made by the appellant. In the second case, the Comn1issioner had jurisdiction to assess the
turnover in respect of the entire fourth quarter, but as it ·was
done without showing separately the assessment of tax payable
in respect of each quarter, this Court cannot confine the relief
to be given to the appellant in these appeals to the period barred under s. 11-A of the Act. The appeals, therefore n1ust
be allowed.
Per Raghubar Dayal, ).-The turnover for the years 1949-50
and 1950-51 could not be said to be turnover which csca·
ped assessment, within the meaning of that expression in s.
11-A of the Act and therefore, the notices issued by the Assistant
Commissioner of Sales Tax in 1954 under s. 11(2) cannot be said to
be notices issued under s. 11-A beyond the period within which
they could have been issued.
The proceedings for the assessment commence against. the
registered dealer from the prescribed date for his submitting the
return \vhich he is required to submit by sub-section (1) of s. 10.
No notice is necessary to be issued to him for the submitting of
the return for the purpose of assessment. The statute, by the provisions of sub-section, (1) of s. 10, gives him the required notice to the effect that he is to submit the necessary returns by
the dates prescribed by the rules. The registration certificate
issued. to him mentions the period of the dealer's year, the prescribed return period ·and the dates by \vhich the dealer had to
furnish the returns. The registered d~aler is, in this way, in no
worse position than an ordinary dealer who receives a notice for
submitting the returns by a certain date. In the case of the unregistered dealer, the proceedings commence by the issue of a
notice under sul>-seetion (!) of s. 10.
There is no time limit fixed for the sales tax officer to take
action against the registered dealer under sub-sections (2) and ( 4)
<if '· 11. He does not contravene Art. 14, if he takes action
-
·•
4 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
439
against a registered dealer under sub-section (2) or sub-section 4
of s. 11 even after the expiry of three years from the period whose
turnover is to be assessed.
>
..
'
1963
Ghanshyam Das
v.
Crv1L APPELLATE JuR1smcnoN : Civil Appeals Nos.
. Regional Assis101 and 102 of 1961.
tant Commis~
Appeals from the order dated December 13, 1957, of sioner of Sales
the Madhya Pradesh High Court in Letters Patent Ap- Tax, Nagpu_r
peals Nos. 208 and 207 of 1956 respectively.
/. M. Thakar, H. M. Thakar, 0. C. Mathur, /. B.
Dadachanii _and Ravinder Narain, for the appellants.
B. Sen and I. N. Shroff, for the respondents.
August 16, 1%3. The Judgment of S. K. Das, Acting
C.J., K. Subba Rao, N. Rajagopala Ayyangar and J. R.
Mudholkar, JJ. was delivered by Subba Rao, J. Raghubar
Dayal, J. delivered a dissenting Opinion.
SuBBA RAo J.-These two appeals by certificate raise
Subba Rao/.
the question of the true interpretation of the meaning of
the expression "escaped assessment" .in s. 11-A of the Central Provinces & Berar Sales Tax Act, 1947 (XXI of 1947),
hereinafter called the Act.
The facts in Civil Appeal No. 101 of 1961 are as
follows: the appellant is the manager of a joint hindu
family firm carrying on business in bidis. He is registered as a dealer under s. 8 of the Act. Every registered
dealer under the Act is required to furnish quarterly returns of his turnover within one month from the end
of the quarter. For the year 1949-50, i.e., for the period
from October 22, 1949 to November 9, 1950, he submitted a
return of his turnover on October 5, 1950 for one quarter
only and made a default in respect of the other quarters.
The Assistant Commissioner of Sales-Tax, Nagpur, issued a notice to the appellant on August 13, 1954 in Form
No. 11 under s. 11(1) and (2) of the Act in respect of the
turnover of the firm for the said period. The appellant
thereafter filed the returns for the three quarters in respect of which he had made default, but in the assessment proceedings he contended, inter alia, that the Assistant Commissioner could not assess his escaped turnover
as he could only do so within three years from the
expiry of the period in respect whereof his turnover
had escaped assessment. The Sales-tax Commissioner re-
440
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1963
[1964]
jected the said contention, proceeded with the assessment and determined the tax liability at Rs. 15,846.00.
Ghanshyam DRS Aggrieved by the said order, the appellant filed a petiv.
tion under Art. 226 of the Constitution in the High Court
Regional Assisof Judicature at Nagpur mainly on the ground that the
tant Commissioner of Sales proceedings before the Sales-tax Commissioner were barTax, Nagpur
red by time under s. 11-A of the Act.
Civil Appeal No. 102 of 1961 is in respect of assessSubba Rao /.
ment of sales-tax on the turnover of the appellant for the
year 1950-51. The appellant had not filed any return for
the whole year. The Assistant Commission'er of Sabtax, Nagpur, served a notice on the appellant on October 15, 1954 under s. 11 ( 4). of the Act. The appellant
filed his returns and produced the account-books under
protest and also raised objections that the assessment proceedings were barred by limitation under s. 11-A 0£ the
Act. The Assistant Commissioner rejected his plea of
limitation and determined his tax liability at Rs.
16,537-5-0. The appellant filed another petition under
Art. 226 of the Constitution in the said High Court for a
similar relief.
Both the petitions were heard together by Kotwal
J. The learned Judge, following the decision of a division Bench of that Court in Firm Sheonarayan Matadin
v. Sales-tax Officer, Raipur('), held that, as the notices
were issued beyond three years from the expiry of the relevant periods, the Sales-tax Commissioner had no juri'diction to make the assessments. On that ground he
quashed the said assessments.
The respondent filed Letters Patent Appeals to a
division Bench of the said High Court. On the formation of the State of Madhya Pradesh, the above appeals were
transferred to the Madhya Pradesh High Court and were
heard by a division Bench consisting of Hidayatullah
C.J. and Chaudhuri J. The Division Bench held that s.
11-A of the Act could apply only to a case where there
was a final assessment and that in the instant cases
the first assessment proceedings were pending and therefore, the said section had no application thereto. In
the result, by a common judgment, they set aside the
orders of Kotwal J. Hence the present appeals.
(1) 1956 S.T.C. 623.
4 S.C.R.
>
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
441
1963
Mr. J. M. Thakar, learned counsel for the appellant
raised before us the following four points : (I) The exDas
pression "escaped assessment" in s. 11-A of the Act would Ghanshyam
v.
apply also to a case where there was no assessment Regional Assisat all. (2) Even if the first assessment proceedings
tant Commiswere pending before the appropriate authority, the said sioner of Stdes
authority could only make the as:.cssment w'th:n three Tax, Nagpur
years from the date of the commencement of the said
Subba Rao/.
proceedings, which, according to him, would start from
the date of issue of notice by the said authority in the
manner prescribed by the Central Provinces & Berar
Sales Tax Rules, 1947, hereinafter called the Rules. (3)
In the present case no proceedings in respect of the said
assessments were pending before the said authority. And
(4) as only a part of the fourth quarter in Civil Appeal
No. 102 of 1961 falls within three years, the proceedings
in respect of the said entire quarter would be barred under s. 11-A of the Act and, in any view, only the turnover escaped in respect of the period between October 16,
1951 and October 31, 1951 could be a>sessed.
Mr. B. Sen learned counsel for the re<pondent, controverted the said argument and contended that in the
case of registered dealers there was a statutory obligation
to make a return and, therefore, the proceedings must be
deemed to be pending from the date an assessee was bound
to make his return and that as the proceedings in the present case were pending by statutory force, there was no
scope for invoking the provisions of s. 11-A of the Act.
In Civil Appeal No. 102 of 1961 he raised the point that
a calendar year in s. 11-A must be calculated from January
to December and if so calculated no part of the fourth
quarter would be beyond three years, but he did not pursue the Ii ne of argument.
The main question in the appeals is the true construction of the provisions of s. 11-A of the Act. The
material provisions thereof may be set out. They read :
Section 11-A (!) : If in consequence of any information which has come into his possession, ·,he Commissioner is satisfied that any turnover of a dealer
dui ing any period . . . . . . . . has escaped asse5'ment
. . . . . . . . the Commissioner may, at any time within
three calendar years from the expiry of such period
29-2 S. C. lndia:64
442
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1964]
1963
proceed in such manner as may be prescribed
to ...... assess ........ the tax payable on any such
Ghanshyam Das
'
turnover ..................... . ,,
v.
Regional Assis- Under this section if the turnover of a dealer during
tant Commisany period has escaped assessment, the Commissioner
sioner of Sales may at any time within three calendar years from the exTax, Nagpur
piry of such period proceed in the manner prescribed
assess the tax payable on the said turnover. The cruto
Subba Rao /.
cial expression for the present purpose is "escaped assessment". What does it mean? Does it include, as learned counsel for the appeliant contends, a case where no
assessment has been made at all or, as learned counsel
for the respondent contends, take in only the post-assessment detection of evasion of tax? This problem has received the attention of Courts in different contexts.
In Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay v. Pirojbai
N. Contractor(1) the words "escaped assessment" in the
Indian Income-tax Act were defined. It was held therein that the said words were wide enough to include cases
where no notice under s. 22(2) of the Income-tax Act
had been issued to the assessee and therefore his income
had not been assessed at all under s. 23 thereof. The
said view, has been assumed to be correct by this Court
in Maharaj Kumar Kamal Singh v. Commissioner of
Income-tax, Bihar & Orissa( 2 ) and Maharajadhiraj Sir
Kameshwar Singh v. State of Bihar(3) and extended to
cover a case where the first assessment was made in due
course but a part of the income escaped thereform.
This Court, in Commissioner of Incomectax, Bombay
v. Narsee Nagsee & Co.( 4 ), construing the provisions
of s. 14 of the Business Profits Tax Act, 1947, reviewed
the law on the subject and came to the following conclus10n :
"All these cases show that. ,the ~ords "escaping assessment" apply equally to cases where a notice was
received by the assessee bl)t resulted in no assessment
at all and to cases where ~ue to any reason no notice
was issued to the assessee; · and, therefore, there W<\S
-(1937)5 I.T.R. 338.
(') [1959] Supp. 1 S.C.R. 10.
(') f 1960] 1 S.C.R. 332.
(4) [1960] 3 S.C.R. 988.
r
--(1 )
)-~
4 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
443
no assessment of his income."
r
-
,.
It . is true that the said decisions were given with
reference to either s. 34(1) of tb.e Income-tax Act or
s. 14 of the Business Profits Tax Act, but so far as the
present enquiry is concerned the said sections are pari
materia with s. 11-A of the Act. In construing the meaning of the expression "escaped assessment" in s. 11-A of
the Act there is no reason why the said expression should
bear a more limited meaning than what it bears under the said two Acts. All the three Acts are taxing
statutes and the three relevant sections therein are intended to gather the revenue which has improperly escaped.
A division Bench of the Madras High Court in The State
of Madras v. Balu Chettiar('), following the decision of a Full Bench of that Court, held that where an
assessee did not file at any time a return of his turnover for a year and, therefore, there was no assessment
made, the turnover escaped assessment. It was observed
therein:
"Whether it was a case of omission or of deliberate
concealment on the part of the assessee, he did not
submit anv return. It was his default that led to
the escape. of the turnover for 1951-52 from assessment to the tax lawfully due. It was the whole of
the turnover for that year that escaped assessment."
It is not necessary to multiply citations. We, th,:refore, hold that the expression "escaped assessment" in
s. 11-A of the Act includes that of a turnover which has
not been assessed at all, because for one reason or other
no assessmq1t proceedings were initiated and therefore,
no assessment was made in respect thereof.
The next question is whether a turnover could be said
to escape assessment if proceedings in respect of the first
assessment were pending and no final order of assessment
was made therein.
In In re Lachhiram Basantlal(') Rankin C.J. tersely
observed:
"Income has not escaped assessment if there are pending at the time proceedings for the assessment of
the assessee's income which have not yet terminated
( 1)
(1956) 7 S.T.C. 519, 522.
!") (1930) l.L.R. 58 Cal. 909.
1963
Ghanshyam Das
v.
Regional Assistant Commissioner of Sales
Tax, Nagpur
Subba Rao f.
444
1963
SUPREME COUR1 REPORTS
[1964J
m a final assessment thereof".
This dictum laid down a clearly understandable principle.
How can an escape of a turnover from assessment be
Regional Assis- predicated before the assessment is completed?
The
tant CotnmisJudicial Committee in Rajendra Nath Mukherjee v. [n ..
sioner of Sales
come-tax
Commissioner(') relied upon this dictum in reTax, Nagpur
jecting the contention to the contrary raised by the asses-Subba Rao/.
see before them, and endorsed the said view. That
decision turned upon the interpretation of s. 34 of the
Indian Income-tax Act. . There, Burn & Co., an unregistered firm, made a return of their total income on January 13, 1928. On February 25, 1928, the Income-tax
Officer made an assessment on Martin & Co., the partners whereof purchased the business of Burn & Co., in
respect of the combined incomes returned by Martin &
Co. and Burn & Co. The High Court held that under the
income-tax Act the income of the said firms could
not be aggregated and that the income of each must be
separately assessed. Thereafter, on November 8, 1930, an
assessment was made on Burn & Co. on their income
as returned by them on January 13, 1928. It was contended that under the Income-tax Act it was not competent to make any assessment to tax after the expiry of
the year for which the tax was charged except in the cases
provided for under s. 34 oE the Income-Tax Act. It
was held by the Judicial Committee that the income of
Burn & Co. had not escaped assessment within the meaning
of s. 34 of the Income-tax Act. It was observed therein :
Ghanshyam Das
v.
"If . .an assessment is not made on income within the
tax year then that income, they submit, ha·s escaped
assessment within that year, and can be subsequently assessed only under s. 34 with its time limitation.
This involves reading the expression "has escaped
assessment" as equivalent to "has not been assessed". Their Lordships cannot assent to this reading. It gives too narrow a meaning to the word "assessment" and too wide a meaning to the word
"escaped". That the word "assessment" is not confined in the statute to the definite act of making an
order of assessment appears from s. 66, which refers to
( 1)
(1933) 61 I.A. 10, 15-16.
t
'f S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
445
1963
"the course of any assessment". To say that the income of Burn & Co., which in January, 1928, was
Ghanshyam Das
returned for assessment and which was accepted
v.
as correctly returned, though it was erroneously in- Regional Assiscluded in the assessment of Martin & Co., has escap- tant Commised assessment in 1927-28 seems to t11eir Lordships an sioner of Sales
inadmissible reading. The fact that s. 34 requires a Tar, Nagpur
notice to be served calling for a return of income Subba Rao/.
which has escaped assessment strongly suggests that
income which has already been duly returned for assessment cannot be said to have "escaped" assessment
within the statutory meaning."
As s. 34 of the Income-tax Act had no application
and as there was no other time limit prescribed or necessarily implied under that Act, it held tl1at the assessment
was not out of time. This decision is a clear authority
for the position that if a return was duly made, the
assessment could be made at any time unless the statute
prescribed a time limit. This can only be for the
reason that the proceedings duly initiated in time will
be pending and can, therefore, be completed without
time limit. A proceeding is said to be pending as soon
as it is commenced and until it is concluded. On the
said analogy, the assessment proceedings under the Salestax Act must be held to be pending from the time the
said proceedings were initiated until they were terminated by a final order of assessment. Before the final order
of assessment, it could not be said that the entire turnover or a part thereof of a dealer had escaped assessment,
for the assessment was not completed and if, completed, it might be that the entire turnover would be caught
in the net.
But the more difficult question is, when do the assessment proceedings under the Act in respect of registered dealer commence and when do they terminate?
While learned counsel for the appellant contends that the
said proceedings under the Act start only after the appropriate authority issued a notice under s. 10(1) or s.
11(2) or s. 11(5) of the Act, learned counsel for the respondent contends that whatever may be sait.1 in the
case of an unregistered dealer, in the case of a registered dealer the proceedings commence from the date iix-
446
1963
·SUPREME· COURT REPORTS
' [1964]
ed in the registration certificate within which ·the said
dealer has a statutory obligation to furnish his return.
Ghanshyam Das
To appreciate the rival contentions it is necessary
to
notice
the relevant provisions of the Act and the Rules.
Regional AssisUnder s. 4 of the Act, every dealer whose turnover
tant Commissioner of Sales exceeds the specified limits prescribed under sub-section
Tax, Nagpur
(5) thereof shall be liable to pay tax in accordance with
the
provisions of the Act on all sales effected by him.
Subba Rao/.
Under s. 8 no dealer shall, while being liable to pay tax
under the Act, carry on business as a dealer unless he
had been registered as such and possesses a registration
certificate. Part IV of the Rules prescribes the manner
in which a dealer shall get himself registered under the
Act. Under s. 8, if the dealer satisfies the requirements
prescribed in that regard, the Sales-tax Officer grants
him a registration certificate in Form II, which specifies
the particulars, such as, the location of the business,
the nature of the business etc. The said Officer enters
the name of every dealer registered in a ledger maintained under s. 9 and issues copies of registration certificates for exhibition in the places of their business.
Under one of the columns in that Form the period for
which and the date on which the return has to be furnished has to be mentioned. A list of such registered
dealer is also published under r. 17. Under the Act, no
dealer, who is liable to pay tax thereunder, shall carry
on business unless he has been registered as such and possesses a registration certificate. It is, therefore, clear that
registration is mainly conceived in the interest of revenue,
to facilitate collection of taxes and to prevent the evasion
thereof.
·
Next we come to the provisions dealing with the
manner in which a registered dealer will be assessed to
tax. Under s. 10 every registered dealer shall furnish
such returns by such dates to such authority as may be
prescribed. Rule 19 prescribes the manner in which such
a return has to be furnished. Thereunder every registered dealer shall furnish to the appropriate Sales-tax
Officer quarterly returns within one calendar month from
the expiry of the quarter to which the return relates and
in case he has more than one place of business in the
Provi nee, he shall submit a consolidated return for all the
y~
·' /
SUPREME'COURT REPORTS-.
447
'
. . \,
_,' .
. ~-.
,- ···--------------·--.
places of business aiid also a return separately for each
· 1963 ·
of the places of -business within two calendar months ·
from the. said date. _ It also says that each of.'sueh re- Ghansh~~m Dos
Y
turns submitted shall be accompanied -by. a treasury re- &gional Assis-.
ceipted chalan in Form V in respect of ·t1i_e tax due ac- tant Commis- .
cording to the return. In short he has to file a re- sioner of Sales
_ -- turn or ·returns in the prescribed form within the prescri- -. Tar, Nagpur
bed time and--also pay the tax payable by him along . Subba· Rao 1- ~:"
with the returns. Under s. Il(l) ·if the Commissioner
is satisfied that the return. furnished by the dealer in~ res- .
pect of a period is correct and complete, he assesses the dealer on it. If, he_ does not accept it, under cl. (2)
;
thereof•-he shall serve the dealer with a notice appointing
the place and date for enquiry ; _and after . enquiry he
shall assess him to tax under .r. 3. Rule 31 prescribes ,
that the notice under s. 11 (2) shall be served on the deal- · •
er in Form II. It may be stated that the mention of
sub-section (1) in that rule appears to be a mistake for _
no notice "is contemplated _under· that sub-section. If'the registered dealer fails to furnish his return under s.
10(1) of the Act in the manner prescribed within the
time prescribed under sub-section (3) -thereof,' the Com- mis~ioner, after giving a reasonable opportunity of_ being
heard, -may impose on him by way of peria lty a sum not
exceeding one-fourth of the ;mount of the tax which
may be assessed on him under s. 11. Rule 32, which
is an_ omnibus provision, says that in such -an event,
a notice in Form .XII has to be issued on- him. Under sub-S::ction (4) of s. 11, if a registered dealer makes the
· > defaults mentioned therein the Commissioner sh"ll, in the
preseribed manner, assess him to the best of his judgment. Rule 32 also governs the procedure for making
the said assessment. Rule 33 prescribes the maintenance of -a rej:(ister of cases instituted under s. 11. Rule
34 gives -the form of the order to be made and . r. 39 ·
/.
provides for the preparation of assessment record. ·
_ At this stage an argument advanced by learned coun_. - sel for the appellant, namely, that under s. )0(1) of the
Act_ the Commissioner has to give notice in the prescribed
manner. to a_ registered dealer, may be considered. Section 10(1) reads:· ·
"Every such dealer as may be required so to do by
4 S.C.R. \
"-.
448
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1964]
1963
the Commissioner by notice served in the prescribed
manner and every registered dealer shall furnish such
Ghanshyam Das
returns by such dates and to such authority as may be
v.
prescribed."
Regional AssisThe word "dealer", unless there is anything repugtant Commissioner of Sales nant in the subject or context, means any person who carTax, Nagpur
ries on the business of selling or supplying goods and in
its
wide meaning it certainly takes in both a registered
Subba Rao/.
dealer and a dealer who has not registered himself under
the Act. The question, therefore, is whether there is
anything repugnant in the subject or context of s. 10
to limit the word "dealer" in the first part of sub-section
(1) to a dealer other than a registered dealer. Sub-section
( 1) is in two parts : the first part speaks of a dealer
and the second part of a registered dealer and the subsection says that both of them shall furnish the returns.
If the dealer in the first part includes a registered dealer,
the mention of "every registered dealer" in the second
part will become redundant, for a registered dealer
is included in the expression "dealer". A construction
which would attribute redundancy to a Legislature shall
not be accepted excqJt for compelling reasons. This redundancy disappears if the expression "dealer" in the first
part exc:udes a regislertd dealer mentioned in the
second part. This legislative intention is further made
clear by the provisions of ss. 14 and 17 of the Act.
Section 14 imposes a duty on every registered dealer or
every dealer on whom notice has been served to furnish
returns under sub-section (1) of s. 10 to keep a true account of the value of goods bought and sold by him ; and
s. 17 imposes a duty on the said two categories of
dealers to inform the prescribed authority regarding
changes of business. The distinction between the two
categories of dealers is maintained not only in s. 10
but also in ss. 14 and 17. It is, therefore, clear that
' under sub-section (1) of s. 10, the Commissioner need
not issue a notice to a registered dealer for furnishing the
relevant returns, but a statutory obligation is impvsed on
the said dealer to do so by such dates and to such anthority as may be prescribed.
Now coming to the case of a dealer who did not register himself under the Act, the position is different.
-<
I
•
4 S.C.R.
-
>-
"-.J
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
449
1!163
There is no statutory obligation cast on him by any section to submit a return. His is really a case of evaGhanshyam Das
sion from his obligation to get himself registered under
v.
the Act. Section 10 (I) enables the Commissioner to issue Regional Assisa notice to him requiring him to furnish a return tant Commisin the prescribed manner. In his case also the same sioner of Sales
Tax, Nagpur
procedure as prescribed in ss. 10(3), 11(1) and 11(2)
has to be followed in the matter of assessment. But sub- Subba Rao/.
section (5) of s. 11 introduces a stringent provision to
prevent evasion of tax. Under that sub-section if upon
information the Commissioner is satisfied that any such
dealer, who is liable to pay tax under the Act in respect
of any period, has wilfully failed to apply for registration, he shall at any time within three calender years
from the expiry of such period, after giving the dealer
a reasonable opportunity of being heard, proceed in the
manner as may be prescribed to assess to the best of his
judgment the amount of tax due from the dealer in respect of such period and of subsequent periods. He may
also direct the dealer to pay, by way of penalty, in addition to the amount of tax so assessed a sum not exceeding 11: times that amount. So in the case of a dealer liable to pay tax, but who has failed to register
himself under the Act, the Commissioner may issue a
notice to him under r. 22 and assess him under s. 11 ; and
in the case of e\•asion, on subsequent information, the
Commissioner can assess him within three calendar years
from the expiry of the period in respect of which he was
liable to pay tax and for subsequent years and also impose a penalty on him. It is clear from this provision that in the case of such a dealer the assessment can
be made only within three calendar years from the expiry of the period in respect whereof he has been liable
to pay tax under the Act. If the contention of learned
counsel for the respondent should prevail, in the case of
a registered dealer there would be no limitation in the
matter of assessment, whereas in the case of a dealer who
evaded law, he would have the benefit of three years' limitation.
·
From the foregoing discussion it is seen that in the
case of a registered dealer there are four variations in the
matter of assessment of his turnover : ( l) He submits a
450
.1963
Ghanshyam Das
v.
Regional Assistant Commis-
sioner of Sales
Tar, Nagpur
Subba Rao[.
-SUPREME .COURT REPORTS
[1%4]
return by the date prescribed and pays the tax due in
terms of the said return ; the Commissioner accepts the
correctness of the return and appropriates the amount
paid towards the tax due for the period covered by the
return. (2) The Commissioner is not satisfied with the
correctness of the return ; he issues a notice to him under s. 11(2), and makes an enquiry as provided under the
Act, but does not finalize the assessment. (3) The registered dealer does not submit a return ; the Commissioner issues a notice under s. 10(3) and s. 11 (4) of the
Act. And ( 4) the registered dealer does not submit any
return for any period and the Commissioner issues notice to him beyond three years. If the return was accepted and the amount paid was appropriated towards
the tax due for the relevant period, it means that there
has been a final assessment in regard to the said period .
If any turnover escaped assessment, clearly it can be reopened only within the period prescribed in s. 11-A. In
the case where a return has been made, but the Commissioner has not accepted it, and has issued a notice for enquiry, the assessment proceedings will certainly be
pending till the final assessment is made. Even in a
case where no return has been made, but the Commissioner initiated proceedings by issuing a relevant notice
either under s. 1,0(3) or under s. 11(4), the proceedings
will be pending thereafter before the Commissioner till
the final assessment is made. But where no return has
been made _and the Commissioner has not issued any
notice under the Act, how can it be held that some proceedings are pending before the Commissioner when
none existed as a matter of fact? We are concerned in
this case with the last contingency.
It is manifest that in the case of a registered dealer
the proceedings before the Commissioner starts factually when a return is made or when a notice is issued
to him either under s. 10(3) or under s. 11(2) of the Act.
The acceptance of the contention that the statutory obligation to file a return initiates the proceedings is to invoke a fiction not sanctioned by the Act. The obligation
can be enforced by taking a suitable action under the
Act. Taking of such an action may have the effect of
initiating proceedings against the defaulter. The de-
.....
4 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
451
1963
fault may be the occasion for initiating the proceedings,
but the default itself proprio vigore cannot initiate proGhanshyam Das
ceedings. Proceedings in respect of the assessment of the
v.
turnover for the relevant period cannot, therefore, he said Regional Assistant Commisto be pending before the Commissioner. Learned counsel
sioner
of Sales
for the respondent contends that the certificate of registraTax,
Nagpur
tion is itself a notio' to the registered dealer to furnish
his returns within the prescribed time. Reliance is placed Subba Rao/.
upon Form II wherein under the appropriate column
the particulars in regard to a dealer's return and the
date which he should submit it are given. The main
purpose of the registration certificate is to localize
dealers with taxable turnovers and to facilitate the collection of taxes. The registration certificate enables the
dealer to carry on the business. Neither s. 8 which enjoins
such registration on every dealer with taxable turnover nor rule 8 which prescribes the particulars to be
incorporated in a certificate suggests that the certificate
itself is a statutory notice to a dealer. The objects of the
certificate and the statutory notices under the Act are different and the former cannot be equated with the latter.
Rule 33 provides that the assessing authority shall
maintain a register in Form XIII in which he shall enter the details of each case initiated under rr. 31 and 32.
Rule 31 says that on receipt of a return or returns required
under r. 19, 20 or 22 from any dealer, the assessing
authority shall serve on him a notice in Form XI. Rule
32 prescribes, inter alft2, the manner of assessment under
sub-section (3) of s. 10, cl. (a) of sub-section (4) of s. 11,
sub-section (5) of s. 11. Form XII gives the serial number,
name of the dealer, ·1ature of the business, gross turnover,
taxable turnover as determined for the relevant years and
the date of issue of notice in Form XI or Form XII. A
perusal of the said rules and the forms discloses that the
proceedings in the case of a registered dealer start
only on the receipt of a return or returns required to be
furnished under the rules. Under r. 33 a register is maintained giving the details of each case "instituted" . under
rr. 31 and 32. Rule 34 enacts that a case instituted would
be pending till an order of assessment was made. No
doubt it would be pending till a final order of assessment
was made by the highest tribunal or court under the Act.
452
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1964]
1963
At this stage some of the decisions cited at the Bar
may conveniently be noticed. A Full Bench of the BomGhanshyam Das
bay
High Court in Bisesar House v. State of Bombay(')
v.
Regi'onal Assis- held that a notice under sub-section (2) of s. 11 of the
tant ComrnisC.P. & Berar Sales Tax Act, 1947, could not be issued
siQner of Sales
more than three years after the expiry of the period for
Tax, Nagpur
which it was proposed to make the assessment ; but an
assessment
under sub-section ( 1) of s. 11 could be made
Subba Rao f.
more than three years after the expiry of such period.
There, a dealer made his return and paid the tax, which
according to him was due- for three chargeable accounting
years. The Commissioner of Sales-tax served notices on
him under s. 11 (2) in respect of the first two years more
than three years after the end of the chargeable accounting years. The Court drew a distinction between sub-sections (1) and (2) of s. 11 and came to the conclusion that
in the former case it was only a formal appropriation
of the amounts paid towards the tax due and therefore
it could be done even after three years,. but in the latter
case the issue of notice under s. 11 (2) was in a substantial sense an initiation of proceedings by the Commissioner
and his failure to tax these turnovers would constitute "escaped assessment" within the meaning of s.
11-A of the Act and therefore it could be reopened only
within 3 years prescribed thereunder. The learned
Judges, if we may say so with respect did not consider
the question, in what circumstances assessment proceedings could be held to be pending? As we have held that
the submission of a statutory return would initiate the proceedings and that the proceedings would be pending
till a final order of assessment was made on the said
return, no question of limitation would arise. A Division Bench of the same High Court, in Ramakrishna
Ramnath v. Sales Tax Officer, Nagpur('), made a distinction between proceedings under s. 11 ( 4) (a) and those under s. 11 (2) of the Act in that proceedings under s.
11 (2) are for the purpose of assessment whereas those
under s. 11(4)(a) are taken in terrorem and the dealer is
penalised by a best judgment assessment in default of compliance. On that reasoning they held that the period of
(') (1958) 9 S.T.C. 654.
2
( ) (1960) 11 S.T.C. 811.
'
4 S.C.R.
•
,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
453
1963
limitation prescribed under s. 11-A might apply to a pre>ceeding under s. 11 (2), but no such period of limitation
Ghanshyam Das
was laid down in the Act in respect of a proceeding under
v.
s. 10(3) or s. 11(4)(a) of the Act. We find it rather Regional Assisdifficult to appreciate the reasoning on which the learned tant CommisJudges distinguished the Full Bench decision. But the sioner of Sales
question of pendency of proceedings was not raised be- Tax, Nagpur
fore the Division Bench and was not considered by it. Subba Rao/.
For the foregoing reasons we hold that a statutory obligation to make a return within a prescribed time does
not proprio vigore initiate the assessment proceedings before the Commissioner; but the proceedings would commence after the return was submitted and would continue
till a final order of assessment was made in regard to the
said return.
Now let us apply the said legal position to the facts
of Civil Appeal No. 101 of 1961. The appellant has to
submit quarterly returns and assessments are made on the
basis of the said returns ; that is to say, he has to be assessed for his turnover separate! y in respect of each
quarter. Therefore, the question of escape of assessment
has to he considered on the ground that each quarter
is a separate period for the assessment. For the year
1949-50 i.e., for the period from October 22, 1949 to November 9, 1950, he had to submit 4 returns for the four
quarters. But he had submitted only one return on October 5, 1950 for one quarter. No assessment was made
in respect of any of the four quarters. So the assessment
proceedings must be held to be pending before the Commissioner only in respect of the quarter for which the
appeUant had made the return. In respect of the other
quarters no proceedings could be said to be pending before
the Commissioner. The Tribunal has no jurisdiction to
issue a notice under s. 11-A with respect to the quarters
other than that covered by the return made by the appellant.
So far as Civil Appeal No. 102 of 1961 is concerned,
the appellant had not submitted any returns for the year
1950-51 i.e., for the period from November 10, 1950 to
October 31, 1951. The Assistant Commissioner of Salestax issued a notice to him on October 15, 1954 in Form
XII purporting to be under s. 11 ( 4) of the Act. The said
454
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1964]
1963
notice was within 3 years from October 16, 1951 which
fell within the 4th quarter of the concerned year. Under
Ghanshyam Das
s. 11-A of the Act the period of 3 years has to be calcuv.
lated
from the expiry of the period in regard whereto any
Regional Assishas escaped assessment. As the unit of assessturnover
tant Commissioner of Sales
ment is a quarter, the period in s. 11-A can only mean a
Tax, Nagpur
quarter and it cannot be further split up into months,
weeks and days. The said period is the fourth quarter
Subba Rao Jand it expired on October 31, 1951. If so, it follows that
the Commissioner has jurisdiction to assess the turnover
in respect of the entire fourth quarter as the notice was
issued within three years from the expiry of the said quarter.
But in this case the Commissioner assessed the appellant in respect of the turnover of the entire year without showing separately the assessment of tax payable
in respect of each quarter. We, cannot, therefore, confine
the relief to be given to the appellant in these appeals to
the period barred under s. 11-A of the Act. We would,
therefore set aside the assessments in both the appeals
giving liberty to the respondent to make the assessment
separately for the periods not barred under s. 11-A of the
Act either because a return was filed, as in the first case,
or because the last quarter was within the period of three
years, as in the second case.
In the result, the appeals are allowed with costs
throughout.
Raghubar
RAGHUBAR DAYAL; J.-I am of opinion that the appeals
Dayal /.
should be dismissed as the turnover for the years 1949-50
and 1950-51 could not be said to be turnover which escaped
assessment, within the meaning of that expression in s.
11-A of the Central Provinces & Berar Sales Tax Act,
1947 (XXI of 1947), hereinafter called the Act and therefore the notices issued by the Assistant Commissioner of
Sales Tax in 1954 under s. 11(2) cannot be said to be
notices issued under s. 11-A beyond the period within
which they could have been issued.
It is not disputed that a turnover cannot be said to
have escaped assessment if the proceedings for the assessment of the sales tax on that turnover be pending. The
question then is whether proceedings for assessment of the
turnover for these two years were pending when the im-
•
-<.
...
4 S.CR.
•
,•
•
]"
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
455
1963
pugned notices were issued. To determine this question
we have to see when such proceedings for the assessment
Ghanshyam Das
of the sales tax on the turnover of a dealer in a certain
v.
period commences .
Regional AssisAll dealers whose turnover during a year exceeds the tant Commislimits laid down in sub-section (5) of s. 4 of the Act are sioner of Sales
Tax, Nagpur
liable to pay sale> tax in accordatlce with the provisions
of the Act. All such dealers have to get themselves
Raghubar
registered and obtain a registration certificate : vide s. 8.
Dayal/.
The registered dea!er is required by s. 10( 1) to furnish
the prescribed returns by prescribed dates to the prescribed authority. Rule 19 of the Rules provides for the
furnishing to th~ Sales Tax Officer quarterly returns in
Form IV withitr one calendar month from the expiry of
the quarter to which the return relates. In certain cases,
such a return is to be submitted within two calendar
months. The amount of tax calculated on the turnover
show:i in the return is to be deposited in the treasury and
the treasury receipt in Form V is to accompany the return.
If the registered dealer furnishes the necessary return,
the Sales Tax Officer can assess on the amount of turnover
shown in the returns :n case he considers them to be correct and complete: vic'.e s. 11(1). If he be not so satisfied
he has to serve a notice under sub-section (2) of s.
11 on the registered dealer to take the various steps he
requires for satisfying him about the correct amount of
the turnover and, on his computing this amount, he has
to asseS' the tax in accordance with sub-section (3) of s.
11 of the Act.
The Sales Tax Officer can also require an unregistered dealer to furnish returns by a certain date, in view of
the provisions of sub-section (1) of s. 10 and, if the
dealer submits such returns, he can make the assessment
on the basis of the returns if satisfied with their correctness, or he may serve another notice under s. 11 (2) on the
dealer to take steps to satisfy him about the correct amount
of the turnover and, if the dealer responds to the second notice, he assesses him, after necessary inquiry, to
tax under s. 11(3).
So far, the procedure for assessment of tax is the same,
both for the registered dealer and the ordinary dealer,
in case both of them furnish the returns of the turn-
456
1963
Ghanshyam Das
v.
Regional Assis~
tant Commis~
sioner of Sales
Tax, Nagpur
Raghubar
Dayal/.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1964}
over as required by the provisions of sub-section ( 1) of s. · ·
10 and also comply, if required, with the provisions of
sub-section (2) of s. 11.
Different procedures, however, have to be followed
if the two types of dealers do not file returns or, after
filing returns, do not respond to the notice issued under
sub-section (2) of s. 11. The Act does not provide for the
Sales Tax Officer's taking steps for the assessment of
the tax on the_ ground of the unregistered dealer's not
complying with either notice, i.e., when the unregistered
dealer does not submit a return, or, after submitting a return which is not accepted, does not respond to the notice
issued under sub-section (2) of s. 11.
•
The Sales Tax Officer can however, proceed against
such a dealer under sub-section (5) of s. 11 and will
probably do so as the conduct of the unregistered dealer
-4 .,
would tend to confirm the information which led him to
issue notice under s. 10( 1) ; but his action will be not
on the ground that the dealer had made default in furnishing the return or had failed to comply with the nC>tice issued under sub-section (2) of s. 11 but will be on the
ground that according to his information the dealer had
been liable to pay tax under the Act in respect of that
period and had, nevertheless, wilfully failed to apply
for registration. Under the provisions of sub-section (5)
of s. 11 he, after giving the dealer reasonable opportunity
of being heard, can proceed to assess the tax to the best
of his judgment within three calendar years from the
expiry of the period in respect of the turnover of which
he was liable to be assessed to tax. The dealer, in such a
case, has not only to pay the tax assessed, but has to pay
the penalty which is not to exceed one and a half times
the amount of the tax assessed. If such a dealer had been
one to whom a notice under sub-section ( 1) of s. 10 had
been issued and had failed, without any sufficient cause,
to comply with the requirements of that notice, he could
also be ordered to pay, by way of penalty, a sum not exceeding one-fourth the amount of the tax which be
assessed on him under s. 11, in view of the provisions of
sub-section (3) of s. 10.
It will be seen that though the Sales Tax Officer has
to proceed to make the assessment w!thin three calendar
4 S.C.R.
>
-
'
..
SUPREME COURT REl'ORTS
457
1963
years of the period whose turnover was liable to tax, there
is no time limit within which he must finish the Ghanshyam DtJS
assessment proceedings. They are simply to be started
•• Assiswithin the prescribed period of time, but can be finished Regional
tant Commis·
at any later period.
It may also be noticed here that the 'period of three ;ioner of S41es
years' in sub-section (5) of s. 11 was substituted by the Tax, Nagpur
Amending Act XX of 1953 in place of the expression 'from
Raghubar
the commencement of this Act and thereafter within
Dayal f.
twelve months' and that s. 11-A which deals with the assessment of the turnover escaping assessment was also introduced by the same Act and that these amendments were
given retrospective effect from the 1st of June 1947,
the date when the Act originally came into force. Section 11-A empowers the Sales Tax Officer to proceed to
assess or re-assess certain turnover, including turnover
which escaped assessment, within three years from the expiry of that period.
The procedure to b~ followed against the registered
dealer, in case he does not furnish the return in respect of
any period by the prescribed date-which he is required
to do by sub-section (1) of s. 10-or, having furnished such
returns, failed to comply with the notice issued under
sub-section (2) of s. 11, is different. Sub-section (4) of s.
11 empowers the Sales T ~ Officer, in such circumstances,
to assess the registered dealer to the best of his judgment,
in the prescribed manner. He has, however, to give a
further notice to the registered dealer in case the registered dealer has not furnished the return at all. The
registered dealer can also be made to pay penalty, if
his failure to furnish the return is without any sullicient cause, in accordance with the provisions of subsection (3) of s. 10. There is no time limit fixed for the
Sales Tax Officer to take action against the registered
dealer under sub-sections (2) and (4) of s. 11.
The question then is, when do the proceedings for
the ~ssessment of sales tax, commence against the registered dealer? I am of the view that they commence from
the prescribed date for his submitting the return which
he is required to submit by sub-section (1) of s. 10. No
Hotice is necessary to be issued to him for the submitting
&f the return for the purpoie of assessment. The statute,
30-2 SC India/64
458
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1964]
1963
by the provisions in sub-section (1) of s. 10, gives him
the required notice to the effect that be is to submit the
Ghanshyam Das
necessary returns by the dates prescribed by the rules. The
v.
Regional Assis- registration certificate issued to him mentions the period
tant Com 1nis~
of the dealer's year, the prescribed return period and the
· sioner of Sales dates by which the dealer had to furnish the returns. The
Tax, Nagpur
registered dealer is, in this way, in no worse position
than an ordinary dealer who receives a notice from the
Raghubar
Sales Tax Officer for submitting the returns by a cerDayal/.
tain date. The object of the notice to submit a return
is nothing but the obtaining of the material for the Sales
Tax Officer to determine the amount of the turnover and,
if assessable to tax, to assess the tax due on that turnover. The notice is a step towards the proceedings for
the assessment of the sales tax. In the case of the unregi•tered dealer, the Sales Tax Officer commences the proceedings for assessment by the issue of a notice under subsection (1) of s. 10, and, in the case of a registered
dealer, the statute has already fixed the date for the furnishing of the return and therefore has set in motion the
process for the assessment of the sales tax by the Sales
'Tax Officer. I do not see any good reason why the statutory notice to the registered dealer be not considered
to be at par with the notice issued to the ordinary dealer
by the Sales Tax Officer and why it should not be taken
to initiate the assessment proceedings just as the issue of
a notice bv the Sales Tax Officer would have initiated the
proceedings against the ordinary dealer. The failure of
the registered dealer to furnish the return enables the
Sales Tax Officer to assess the tax to the best of his judgment, of course, after giving an oportunity to the registered dealer of being heard. It would be incongruom if
. the Sales Tax Officer be held not to have initiated the
assessment proceedings against the registered dealer and
yet, on the failure of such a dealer to furnish the returns,
to proceed in the very first instance to assess tax on the
dealer to the best of his judgment. Such a power of taxing to the best of his judgment is an indication of the fact
that the dealer had defaulted in respect of some proceedings connected with the assessment of tax and thus has
made himself liable to tax on the best judgment basis
inste;i<l of a taK on the computed amount of turnover ac-
-
4 S.C.R.
-
1
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
459
1963
cording to the records. His default lies in his not submitting, the return o,f turnover and not depositing the tax <lue
Ghanshyam Das
on the turnover shown in the return. The payment of
v.
tax as a result of the statutory notice under s. 10(1) and Regional Assis~
r. 19 well points to the conclusion that the statutory notice tant Commis·
and rule initiate the assessment proceedings against the sioner of Sales
Tax, Nagpur
registered dealer at least from the date of the close of the
quarter for which the turnover is to be furnished and tax
Raghubar
is to be paid.
Dayal f.
The mere fact that the Sales Tax Officer cannot proceed against an unregistered dealer who, though liable to
pay a tax, did not get himself registered, after the expiry
of three years from the period the turnover in which was
liable to tax, cannot lead to the conclusion that the Saks
Tax Officer cannot take necessary steps to assess a registered dealer under sub-section (2) and ( 4) of s. 11 after the
expiry of three years from the period whose turnover he
proceeds to assess, for the simple reason that s. 11 or
any other provision of the Act does not lay down any
such restriction on the Sales Tax Officer's powers under
these sub-sections.
Such a power in the Sales Tax Officer does not con- ·
travene the provisions of Art. 14 of the Constitution. The
registered dealer and the unregistered dealer belong to
different classes. The former is one whose liabilitv to
tax is admitted. The other has admitted no such liab;lity.
The Sales Tax Officer can find out about the liability
of the unregistered dealer to tax only by issuing a notice to him under sub-section (1) of s. 10 when he thinks
that such a dealer might be liable to tax. It is only when
the information in his possession is sufficiently strong and
trustWorthy as to satisfy him that a certain unregistered dealer is liable to pay sales tax and has wilfully failed
to apply for registration that he can take action under
sub-section (5) of s. I I. The circumstances in which the
Sales Tax Officer can take action against the unregistered
dealer are different from the circumstances in which he
takes action against the registered dealer. I am therefore
of opinion that the Sales Tax Officer does not contravene
Art. 14 of the Constitution as contended for the appellant,
if he takes action against a registered dealer under
sub-section (2) or ( 4) of s. 11 even after the expiry of
,l
460
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1964]
1963
tllfet years from the period whose turnover 1s to be
assessed.
,
Ghanshyam Du
It
is
to
be
noticed
that
the
Act,
as
originally
enacted,
v.
s.
11-A.
That
was
intrdduced
in
1953
and
did
not
have
Regional Assismade retrospective from June 1, 1947.· Amendment was
tant Commis~
sioner of Sales
made in 1953 in s. 11 (5) and it made tl1e period· of limiTax, Nagpur
tation for proceeding to assess tax three years. No amendment
providing limitation was however made in s.
Raghubar
11(2)
and (4) in 1953. This must be deliberate and inDayal/.
dicates the intention of the Legislature not to limit the
period during which action can be taken under s. 11 (2)
and ( 4).
The Register of Cases in Form XIII of the Rules &
Forms is for cases instituted under ss. 10(3), 11, 11-A and
22-C of the Act. Its columns do not show when the assessment of tax proceedings commence. Still its column
14 is meant for 'Amount of penalty imposed, if any, with
relevant section under which it is imposed and reference
to defaulters' list'. This shows that the Sales Tax Officer
111aintains a list of registered dealers who had defaulted
in not complying with the notices under s. 10(1) or 11(2)
or under any other provision which makes the registered dealer liable to penalty. The maintenance of the
' defaulters' list indicates that the Sales Tax Officer initiates proceedings for tax assessment prior to his issuing notices under s. 10(3) and that this must be after the
expiry of the date for furnishing returns referred to in s.
10(1).
In view of the opinion I have expressed above, it is
not necessary to decide what the precise scope of the expression 'turnover escaping assessment' in s. 11-A is ..
It follows that the impugned notices were properly issued by the Assistant Commissioner of Sales Tax to the
appellant and that these appeals fail. I would accordingly
dismiss these appeals with costs.
ORDER BY COURT
In accordance with the opinion of the ma1onty, the
3.ppeals are allowed with costs throughout, one hearing fee.
-
-4. •
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org