PANDIT UKHA KOLHE versus THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 11 February 1963 | [1964] 1 S.C.R. 926 | 1963 INSC 27
Key facts
- Decided
- 11 February 1963
- Bench
- BHUVNESHWAR PRASAD SINHA*, P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR, K.N. WANCHOO, K.C. DAS GUPTA, J.C. SHAH
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 131/1962
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1964] 1 S.C.R. 926
- Neutral citation
- 1963 INSC 27
Text of the judgment
926
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
PANDIT UKHA KOLHE
1963
p,hfuary1 111
,
v.
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
(B. P. SINHA, c. ]., P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR,
I
'
K. :N. WA:!)CHOO, K. c. DAS GUPTA
and J.C. SHAH, JJ.)
-
--
Griminbl--'f.'.rial-,-Offence under Prohibition Ad-Blood
taken before start of inve.tiyation-Report •f Gliemical
Examiner-Procedure prescribeil not- followed-Admissibility
of report-R•-lrial, when can be orrlered:_Bombay Prohibition
Act, 1940 (Bom. 25 of [9~11) '8. G6, 12:/A, 129B-God< of
Criminal Procedure, 1891! (Act .5 of 1808), ss,_ ~8,_.510.
On account of injuries received in a motor accident the
appellant was taken to the hospital at 6 A. M. on April 3,
196!. As he was found 'smelling of alcohol, a specimen of his
blood was taken and collected in a phial. Subsequently,
when investigation started this phial was taken by the rn.
vestigation Officer on April 13 and sent to the Chemical
Exa.111incr on April 18. -On examination, it was found to
ha\'e a concentration of alcohol in excess of that mentioned
in s. 66 (2) of Bombay Prohibition Act. The trial Court convicted the appellant relying upon the pr.,sumption arising on
the report of the Chemical Examiner. On appeal, the Sessions
Judge found that nc evidence hap been produced regarding
ihe,safe custody of the phial from ,April 3 to April 18, regard·
ing its storage at a place where it was not liable to deteriorate
antl regarding its delivery to the Chemical l~xan1iner, and
ortlcred a retrial. This order was upheld by th" High Court,
The appellant contended (i) that the report of the Chemical
Examiner \Vas not admissible in -evidence at the trial of the
appellant for an offeQce under the Bombay Prohibition Act as
the blond had not be~n collected in the manner prescribed by
.,' 129 A, and (ii) that the order for a fresh trial was illogal.
Held, (per Sinh~, C. J., Gajendragadkar, · Wanchoo and
Shah JJ., Das Gupta, J. contra) that the report of the
Chemical Examinei ·was admissible in evidence. Section
12QA was intended· primarily for compelling a person to
submit himself for medical examination and for collection of
blood; this power could be exercised only in the course of
investigation of an offence under t'be Act and only when 11
.
1 S ;C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
927
/j63
Prohibition Officer or a Police Officer had reasonable ground
for believing that a person had consumed liquor. If tho
examination of · blood is made otherwise than in accordance Pandil Uklia Kolhl
with s. 129 A the result may still be proved by virtue of subThe S:a11 qf
s. (8) to s. 129 A and there is nothing ins. 129A ors. 129B
Maharas~tra
which precludes proof of that fact if it tends to establish that
the person had consumed illicit Jiquor. By enacting ss. 129 A
and l29B the law provided one method of collection of
evidence in respect of an offence under s. 66 (2) but it d id not
thereby exclude other methods. Bombay Act No. 12 of 1959
which introduced ss. 129 A and 129 B and which had been
reserved for the consideration of the Pre.ident and had received
his assent prevailed, in the State of Bombay, overs. 510 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure to the extent of inconsistency
between the two. Accordingly, the report of a Chemical
Examiner in respect of blood collected in the course of investiration of an offence under the Act otherwise than in the
manner set out in s. l 29A cannot be used in evidence, but a
report in respect of blood collected at a time when no investigation was pending or at the instance of a Police Officer or a
Prohibition Officer, is admissible under s. 510 of the Code.
·
Nazir Ahmad v. Tf,e King Emperor, (1936) L. R. 63 I.A.
372,. Taylor v. Taylor, (1875) 1 Cb. D. 426, Deep Chand
v. 8!11,te of Uttar Prade.h, [1959] Supp. 2 S. C.R. 8 and
Oh, Tikaramji v. State of Uttar Prade.h, (1956] S. C.R. 393,
referred to.
••
..
•
Held, further, that the order for retrial was bad and that
the Sossions Judge should himself take additional evidence in
respect of the safe custody etc. of the phial of blood. An
order for retrial of a 'Criminal case is made only in exceptional
cases as it exposes the accused to another trial affording the
prosecution an opportunity to rectify infirmities disclosed at
the earlier trial. An order for retrial is not made unless the
·· .ppellate court is satisfied that the trial court had no jurisdiction to try the case. or that the trial was vitiated by serious
illegalities or irregularities or on accouyt of the misconception
of the nature of the proc~edings there has been no real trial
or that any of the parties had, for reasons over which it had
no control, been prevented from producing material evidence.
Since the Sessions Judge was of the view that "additional
evidence was necessary" he should have proceeded under
~a. 428 (1) of the Code.
Ramanlal Rathi v. State, A.I.R. (1951) Qal, 305, referred
"'·
92S
/HJ
•.
p,.r1;1 Ulha Ko/h1
'[Ju Stat1 of
~•·4.lhtra
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (ltlM] VOL.
Per Das Gupta,J.-Thercport of the Chemical faamincr
in respect of blood taken not in accordance with the provuiom
of s. 129A was not admissible. In virw ofsu~s. (8) ofs. 129A
the fact that a person h;is consumed an intoxicant may be proved
by evidc11cc other than that made available under s. 129A; but
for the determination of the percentage of alcohol in the
bloo<l no other procedure except that provided by s. 129 A
was permiS!ihlc. Section 66 (2), which provided for the
drawing of a presumption in favour of the prO!ccution if the
percentage of alcohol found in rhe
blood of an
accused exceeded that rncntioned in the Section, was introduced
in the Act Ly t)1e very Amending Act which introduced s. 1!?9 A.
It was reaso11able lo infer that the legislature intended the
presumption under s. 66 (2) to be drawn only in C<ISCS where
the procedure prescribed bys. 129A had been followed.
Na:ir Ahmad v. The Ki•vJ PJmperQI', (1936) L. ll. 63
I. A. 372 relied on.
CRIMINAL APPEI.UTE J Ul\ISU!l'TION : Criminal.
Appeal No. 131 of 1962.
Appeal by special leave from the judgment
and order dated June 13, l!J62, of the Bombay High
Court in Crimina1 Revision Application No. 402 of
1962.
R. K. Gary, S. C. Agarwa/a and M. K.
Ramamurthi, for the appellant.
C. K. Driphtary, Solicitor-General of India,
N. 8. Bindra and R. H. Dhebar, for the respondent.
1963. February 11. The followi.ng Judgments
were delivered by
SM.I, J
SHAB, J.-On• April 3; 1961 at about 2-30
A.M., a motor vehicle fell into a ditch by the side
of a highway near Edlabad, District Jalgaon, and
all the occupants of the vehicle were injured.· One
Mohmad Ywuf who was in that vehicle died of the
injuries. The appellant was tried before the
Bhusawal,
Judicial
Magistrate, First Class,
1 s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
929
for offences of rash and negligent driving when he
was under the influence of liquor and thereby
causing the death of Mohmad Yusuf and injuries
to four other occupants of the motor vehicle and
also for offences under the motor Vehicles Act.
The Trial Magistrate held that the evidence was
' not sufficient to prove that the appellant was driving
the motor vehicle at the time of the mishap, and
acquitted the appellant of the offences under the
Motor Vehicles Act and also under the Indian
Penal Code. But he held that the evidence
established that the appellant had at the materi,itl
time consumed illicit liquor and had thereby
committed an offence punishable \inder s. 66 (b) of
the Bombay Prohibition Act. He accordingly
convicted the appellant, and sentenced him to suffer
rigorous imprisonment for three months and to pay
a fine of Rs. 500/· and in default of payment of
fine, to suffer rigorous imprisonment for two months.
On appeal to the Court of Session, the order of conviction was set aside, and a retrial was directed,
because in the view of the Court there had not been
a "fair and full" trial. A revision application filed
against the order in the High Court of Bombay was
summarily dismissed. The appellant has appealed
to this Court with special leave agairist the
order of the High Court.
•
The· case for the prosecution, in so far as it
relates to the charge for the offence under the
Bombay Prohibition Act, is briefly this: Early in
the morning of April 3, 19Gl as a result of motor
vehicle Temp. No. 170 B. M. B. falling in a ditch
near Edlabad several persons including the appellant
were injured. At about 6 a. m., the appellant
reached
the Civil Hospital, Jalgaon. On Dr.
Kulkarni, Resident Medical Officer of the Hospital
informing him about the death of Mohmad Yusuf,
the appellant fainted and he was admitted as an indoor patient in the Hospital. On examination, the
1?63
P•niil Ukli• Kolh<
v.
Thi Stot1 nf
Moh•ruhtra
Sh.Ji, J.
030 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL
1963
!'..m1 Ukha KolA<
v.
Tiu Stall of
Mnht1ra;litra
~ho/i,
}.
appellant was found "smelling of alcohol". Dr.
Kulkarni thereupon directed one Dr. Rote to collect
a specimen _of blood from the body of the appellant,
anJ accord1m;ly some venus blood wa~ collected in
a phial. The phial was closed in the presence of
Dr. Rutc and scaled. But before treatment could
hr given to the appellant, he was di$charged from
the Hospital at the request of some persons who
:iccompanicd him. The blood specimen remained
in the Huspital. Information about the mishap to
the motor vehicle was received by the police at
Jalgaon at about 8 a. m., on that day and a case
was registered against the appellant and four other
persons for certain offences under the Indian Penal
Code and the Motor Vehicles Act. and on receiving
information that all the incumbents of the motor
vehicle were at the time of the mishap in a state of
intoxication, also under s. fill (b) of the Bombay
Prohibition Act XXV of 1949. The Oflicer in
charge of the investigation sent the appellant
to the Civil Hospital for medical examination.
The condition of the appellant was found by
Dr. Kulkarni to be normal. A specimen of the
appellant's blood was again collected at about 11
a. m., and was sent to the Chemical Analyser, for
examination and report. On April 12, 1961, the
Sub-Inspector in charge of the investigation came to
learn that a specimen of blood of the appellant
had been taken by the Hospital authorities early in
the morning of April 3, 1961. On demand by the
police officer the Medical Offi1:er delivered the phial
containing the blood specimen together ~ith a certifica tc from Dr. Rote that a blood specimen of the
appellant was collected by him at 6 a. m., on
April 3, J !Hi!. The investigating officer affixed
an additional seal on the package and forwarded
the same with a special messenger to the Chemical
Examiner on April 18, 1961. On examination vf
the contents of the phial it was found that there was
concentration of alcohol to the extent of 0·069 {>Cr
..
•
f
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS 931
cent w/v ethyl alcohol. This concentration being
in excess of the concentration mentioned in s. 66 (2)
• of the Bombay Prohibition Act, a complaint for the
offence under the Bombay Prohibition Act was also
lodged against the appellant.
190
Pontit Ukha r. •/h,
••
The Stol1 r/
.,\,f<JiaraJlitra
~h•h.
At the trial, on behalf of the prosecution among
others were examined Dr. Kulkami, Dr. Rote and
the investigating officer. The report of the Chemical
Examiner was also tendered in evidence. But the
special messenger who carried the sample was not
examined ; nor was any evidence given about the place
A where and the condition in which the phial containing
the blood specimen was kept in the Hospital. The
appellant in his statement to the Court denied that
concentration of alcohol· detected by the Chemical
Examiner from the spedmen taken by Dr., ·. Rqte
exceeded 0.069 per cent w/v. He admitted, that on
April 3, 1961 he was in the Civil Hospital in the early
morning, that when he was told by Dr. Kulkarni
about the death of Mohamad Yusuf he "suffered a
" shock", that thereafter he went home immediately, and
during that time his" mental condition was not good".
He further stated :
"I fell unconscious. I was semi-consciouo.
Diifiiig that time my relations and friends gave
me certain liquid as a sort of medicine. I felt
like that. Then I was carried to the hospital in
the same condition. As I regained my consciousness I told doctor that I want to leav~ the
hospital because my friend was dead in hospital
and as I did not feel it proper to live in hospital
under such circumstances, so I left the hospital.
I do not know who gave me medicine when I
fell down on the road, after I had left the hospital. This was, when I left the hospital for my
home."
~
The defence of the appellant therefore was that when
he was informed about the death of Mohamad Yusuf
J.
932
1963
r1•Jil UkM Kolh1
••
Thi St4t1 of
M.Jiar&Jlttra
Shafi, J.
SUPREME COURT RhPORTS [Hl64]VOL.
he fainted and some medicinal preparation was administered to him by his friends to revive him and thereafter he was carried to the Civil Hospital. He has not
admitted that any specimen of blood from his uody
was collected, uut it appears to be his defence that if
cxccssi ve concentration of alcohol was traced in the
blood it was the result of some mediciual preparatio1.
administered to him by his friends.
·
Section uli(l) of the llumbay Prohibition Act, in
so far as it is material, provides :
"(l) Whoever in contravention of the provisions
ol this Act, or any rule, regulation, or order
made, or of any licence, permit, pass or authorization issued, thereunder(a)
x
x
x
(b) consumes, uses, possesses or transports any
intoxicant. ............. .
shall, on conviction, be punished "(i) for a first offence, with imprisonment for a
term which may extend to six months and with
fine which may extend to one thousand rupees :"
·Intoxicant' is defined ins. 2(22) as meaning "any
liquor, intoxicating drug, opium or any other sub•t~nce, which the State Government may, by notifica•
tion in the Official Gazette, declare to be an intoxicant;
and bys. 2(24) liquor includes "(a} spirits, denatured
spirits, wine, beer, toddy and all liquids consisting of
or eontaiPing alcohol ; and (b) any other intoxicating
substance which the State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, declare to be liquor for
the purposes of this Act." The contravention referred
to ins. G6(b) is the contravention of acts prescribed by ~
s. 13. That section prohibits, amongst other acts,
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
933
consumption and use of liquor. The provisions of
s. 13 which occur in Chap. Ill are subject to a general
exception contained in s. 11, which provides, in so far
as it is material, that. :
''Notwithstanding anything contained in the
following provisions of this Chapter, it shall be
lawful to import, export, transport, manufacture, bottle, sell, buy, possess, use or consume any intoxicant. .... .in the manner and
to the extent provided by the provisions of this
Act or any rules, regulations or orders made or
in accordance with the terms and conditions of
a licence, permit, pass or authorization granted
thereunder."
The validity of the provisions of the Act as originally
enacted was considered by the Court in 7'hc State of
Bombay v. F. N. Balsara ('), and it was held i:nter
alia that cl. (b) of s. 13, in so far as it affected the
consumption or use of medicinal and toilet prepara ·
tions containing alcohol was invalid. The Legislature of the Bombay State thereafter amended the Act
by enacting s. 24A which provided a general excep·
tion in rcipect of toilet, me<licinal and antiseptic
preparat.ffim and flavouring extract, essence or syrup.
As .a consequence of the amendment made by
s. 24A the operation of the prohibition contained in
s. 13 and the other sections was limite<l in two respects: (1) by s. 11 where the contravention was in
pursuance of and in the manner and to the extent
provided by the provisions of the Act or any ru Jes or
regulations or orders made or in accordance 11ith the
terms and conditions of a licrnce, permit, pass or
authorisation granted; and (:Z) in respect of prepara.
tions and materials exempted under s. 24A. When,
therefore, a person was charged with consuming any
intoxicant in contravention of the provisions of thr.
,\ct or of the rules, regulations or orders mark nr of
(I) pi51) S.C.R. 682,
1963
Pan.Cit Ukh• Kolh1
y,
Tht Slate of
MdluJ11uhtt1J
: kali, J.
934 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [196~] VOL.
1963
••
Till ,,.,, If
AldataJIUro
S!i.h, J,
any licence, pass, permit or authorisation under
s. 66(l)(b), it had to be established that the contravention was not protected either by s. ll ors. 24A .
It is clear that direct evidence about the consumption of liquor in contravention of the provisions of
the Act, when such consumption is prohibited.
would not ordinarily be forthcoming. Mere
evidence that the person charged with consuming or using an intoxicant was in a state of intoxication would not be sufficient to bring home the charge
under s. 66(l)(b). That is illusrrated by the decision
of this Court in Brhr::mi Khurshfd Pesilcaka v. Thie
State of Bombay (1). It was held in that case that
the effect of the declaration in The State of Bombuy
v. P. N. Bal8ara ('), that cl. (b) of s. 13 of the
Bombay Prohibition Act is void under Art. 13(1)
of the Constitution in so far as it effects the consumption .or use of liquid medicinal or toilet preparations
containing alcohol is to render a part of s. l 3(b) of
the Bombay Prohibition Act inoperative and ineffectual and thus unenforceable, and that the bare
circumstance that a citizen accused of an offence
under s. 66(b) of the Bombay Prohibition Act is
smelling of alcohol is compatible with his innocence
as well as his guilt: the smell of alcohol may be due
to the fact that the accused had contravened the
enforci:able part of s. 13(b) of the Bombay Prohibition Act, or it may well be due to the fact that he
had taken alcohol which fell under the unenforceable
and inoperative part of the section. The onus therefore lies on the prosecution to prove that the alcohol
of which he was found smelling came under the
category of prohibited alcohol and therefore within
the enforceable part of s. 13(b).
The Legislature of the State of Bombay being
faced with this interpretation imposing a serious
burden which the prosecution had to undertake in
trials for offences of consumption or use of liquor
contrary to the provisions of the Act, for due
(I) [1955) I S,C,R, 613,
(2) 11951] 8,C.R• 68l.
....'
•
•
1 s.c.R.
.•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
935
enforcement of the law and to prevent evasion, enact·
ed certain additional provisions by Bombay Act 12 of
1959. By that Act, s. 66 was renumbered s. 66(1)
and suh·::. (2) was added thereto in the following
form:
"Subject to the provmons of sub-section (3),
where in any trial of an offence under clause (b)
of sub-section (1) for the consumption of an
intoxicant, it is alleged that the accused person
consumed liquor, and it is provided that the
concentration of alcohol in the blood of the
accused person is not less than 0.05 per cent,
weight in volume then the burden of proving
that the liquor consumed was a medicinal or
toilet preparation, · or an antiseptic preparation
or solution, or a flavouring extract, essence or
syrup, containing alcohol, the consumption of
which is not in contravention of the Act or anv
rules, regulations or orders made thereunde;,
shall be upon the accused person and the Court
shall in the absence of such proof presume the
contrary."
,.
By sub-s. (3) the provisions of sub-s. (2) are not to
apply to consumption of liquor by indoor patients
during the period they are being treated in any
hospital, convalescent home, nursing home, or dispensary, maintained or supported by Government or
a local authority, or by charity, or by such
other persons in
such otl)er institutions, or
in such circumstances as may be prescribed.
The result of this amendment was to make,
except in the cases expressly provided in cl. (3),
concentration of alcohol in excess of 0.05 per cent,
weight in volume in blood presumptive evidence of
consumption of liquor in contravention of the provisions of the Act and the burden of proving that the
liquor consumed was a medicinal or toilet prepa.ration
Qr all aQtiseptic preparation or solution, or a
1969
P11ndit Ukha Eolh1'
v.
The State nf
Maharashtra
Shah, J.
936 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964) VOL.
1963
l'e,ir UlrJut Kol.~1
v.
Tiu Sta111/
M.Jutrulttr•
Skd, J.
flavouring extract, essence or syrup, lay upon the
person charged with the offence.
The case of the prosecution in this case rested
primarily upon the report of the Chemical Exami·
ner certifying that alcohol concentration in the blood
of the appellant which was extracted at 6 a. m. on
April 3, HJ6f, was in excess of the percentage
prescribed by s. 66 (2). The prosecution had, there·
fore, to establish that the specimen examined by the
Chemical Examiner was the specimen of blood
collected from the body of the appellant and that
the specimen disclosed concentration of alcohol in
excess of the permissible limits. It is somewhat unfortunate that the trial Magistrate did not appreciate
that the only important piece of evidence on which
the prosecution case against the appellant rested was
contained in the report of the Chemical Examiner.
There is no dispute that the appellant went to the
Civil Hospital early in the morning of April 3, 1961.
He has admitted that fact in his statement before the
Court. Dr. Kulkarni has deposed that on being told
about the death of Mohamad Yusuf the appellant
fainted and was admitted to the Hospital, and that
he found that th.e appellant was smelling of alcohol.
Dr. Kulkarni has stated that no treatment was given
to the appellant and there is no suggestion by the
appellant that he was given any treatment in the
Hospital. Dr. Rote was asked by Dr. Kulkarni to
collect a specimen of blood from the body of the
appellant, and a l'>lood specimen was accordingly
taken and the phial was sealed in his presence by
a laboratory servant. Dr. Rote stated in erosscxamination that no methyl spirit was applied before
extracting blood. The certificate of Dr. Rote dated
April 13, Hlfil, that he had collected blood from the
body of the appellant on the morning of April 3,
I 961, and that the bottle containing the blood was
sealed in his presence corroborate~ the statement.
-1
.,
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
937
But there is no evidence on the record about the
person in whose custody this phial remained till it
~ was handed over to the Sub-Inspector of police on
April 13, 1961, when demanded. There is also no
evidence about the precautions taken to ensure
against tampering with the contents of the phial
when it was in the Civil Hospital and later in the
custody of the police between April 13, 1961, and
April 18, 1961. Even the special messenger with
whom the phial was sent to the Chemical Examiner
was not examined : and Ext. 43 which was the acknowledgment signed by some person purporting to
,, belong to the establishment of the Chemical Examiner does not bear the official designation of that
person. The report of the Chemical Examiner
mentions that a sealed phial was received from the
police officer by letter No. C/010 of 1961 dated
April 18, l\Hll, but there is no evidence that the
seal was the one which was affixed by Dr. Rote on
the phial. These undoubtedly were defects in the
prosecution evidence which appear to have occurred
.., on account of insufficient appreciation of the
character of the burden which the prosecution
undertakes in proving a case of an offence under
s. 66 ( 1) (b) relying upon the presumption under
s. 66 (2).
It was assumed by the Trial Magistrate that
the phial containing blood collected by Dr. Rote
was kept in a safe place and could not be tampered
with, that it was kept in such a place that it was not
liable to deteriorate, that thereafter this phial also
remained with the police at a place where it could
not be tampered with, and that the phial sealed by
Dr. Rote was delivered by the special messenger to
the establishment of the Chemical Examiner and that
the same phial was examined by the Chemical
Examiner, and that between April :I, 1961, and
April 19, 1961, when the contents of the phial were
Jubjected to chemical examination, they had not
1963
PanJii Ukha X'•lht
T,
The 'State ef
MJunashlra
Shah, .1.
938 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
1963
Parttiit l·°khtt Kollu
v.
Tkl.\1411 of
Afaluff4Sh"a
Shah. J.
deteriorated. Both the Prosecutor and counsel for
the appellant appear to have contributed to the somewhat slipshod trial of the case. Dr. Kulkarni and
J?r. Rote were examined as witnesses for the prosecuhon, but no examination or cross-examination of
either YI as directed in respect of these important
matters, and even to the investigating officer, no
questions seeking to elicit information on these
matters '~ere asked. The report of the chemical
examination of the blood specimen collected
at 11 a. m. on April 3, 1961, wa1 also not tendered
in evid~nce b1· the prosecution th')ugh the same was
demanded.
The Sessions Judge pointed out some of these
infirmities. He arrived at the conclusion that as
the examination of the blood specimen taken
at 6 a. m. on April 3, 1961, was not obtained in the
course of investigation at the direction of the invt>stigating officer, who had reasonable grounds for
believing that th~ appellant had consumed an intoxicant, the "presumption under s. 12fllr' could not
come to the aid of the prosecution. The learned Judge
observed--and it was conceded at the Bar before
him-that the prosecution could still establish that the
appellant had consumed liqucr otherwise th'an by a
certificate obtained in respect of examination of the
blood concentration procured in the manner provided
under els. (1) and (2) of s. l:!!lA, but as the trial
Magistrate had relied merely upon the presumption
under s. 66 (2) and had n H analy>ed the evidence
in that light, nor had he dir,·ctcd his attention to the
question whether the other evidence on the record,
apart from the prem1nption, <'.>tablished such case,
the order of the conv:nion could not be smtained.
Observing that there had not been a "fair and full
trial" in respect of the offence under the Bombay
Prohibition Act, the Sessions Judge set aside the order
of the trial Magistrate and directed that the case
be sent back to the M<tgi;trate and be retried in the
4
~
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
939
light of the observations made by him in the course
of the judgment.
An order for retrial of a criminal case is made
in exceptional cases, and not unless the appellate
Court is satisfied that the Court trying the procee·
ding had no jurisdiction to try it or that the trial
was vitiated by serious illegalities or irregularities -or
on account of misconception of the nature of the
proceedings and on that account in substance there
had been no real trial or that the Prosecutor or an
accused was, for reasons over which he had no con·
trol, prevented from leading or tendering evidence
material to the charge, and in the interests of justice
the appellate Court deems it appropriate, having
regard to the circumstances of the case, that the
accused should be put on his trial again. An order
of re-trial wipes out from the record the earlier
proceeding, and exposes the person accused_ to
another trial which affords the prosecutor an opportunity to rectify the infirmities disclosed in the earlier
trial, and will not ordinarily be countenanced when
it is made merely to enable the prosecutor to lead
evidence which he could but has not cared to lead
either on account of insufficient appreciation of the
nature of the case or for other reasons. Harries,
C. J., in Raman/,al Rathi v. The State (1), observed :
"If at the end of a criminal prosecution the
evidence leaves the Court in doubt as to the
guilt of the accused the latter is entitled to a
verdict of not guilty. A retrial may be ordered
when the original trial has not been satis·
factory for particular reasons, for example, if
evidence had been wrongly rejected which
should have been admitted, or admitted when
it should have been rejected, or the Court had
refused to hear certain witness who should
have been heard. But retrial cannot be ordered
on the ground that the prosecution did not
(I) A l.R. (1951) Col. go;.
1963
Pandit Ukl:a KO/he
v.
The St•le of
Mah6rashtra
~hah,
J.
'
'
'·, '\..--1"
:
·.-- ,~··11~.,---:· -":
- -
:;
1
PC!ltfit TJkh,Z Kol~
v.
Th• S1at1 of
~faha.raJhtra
Shah, J.
!
I
\
•
'
~. '.
'~- ~
•
/
"
I
!l40 ' SUPREME COURT REPORTS [l!l64] VOL. ·
• produce the proper evidence-and aid' not know
how to prove thefr case."
In the present case, undriubtedly. the trial before the
~Iagistrate suffered from irregularities which we have ·
already set out. The evidence, such as was led, was
deficient in 'important respects; but that could not
be a· sufficient ground for directing a retrial: ·If the
Sessions Judge thought that in the interests of justice ·
. and for a just and proper decision of the case· it was ·
necessary that additional evidence should'. be brought
on the record he' should have, instead of directing a ..
retrial and reopening the' entire proceeding; resorted to '
the procedure prescribed by s; ·42s (i) of the Code ·of
Criminal Procedure; There is no dotibt that ·if the •
,ends of justice require; th'e appellate Court should
exercise
its power
under the
said
section.'
"· ·
·
'
.
.
.
. . .
The observations made by the Sessions. Judge
do dearly suggest that in this case he ,\vas of the view ··
that·. "additional evidence· 'ivas necessary". The .
examination of bJth Dr. R'lte and Dr. Kulk:irni was
perfunctory. · \Vhat steps \Vere taken by Dr: Rote<
after he collected the blood spei:imen and sealed the ·
phial, to whom he entrusted the phial, where it was
. stored and what steps. were taken for preventing ·
interference, · deterioration or 'tampering ·with the :
same,· are matters which were never. investigated.
·Neither the prosecutor nor· counsel for the defence
asked any question in that behalf, and even· the trial
1-fagistrate did not take any. steps to obtain information·· in that ·behalf. · . The 'method of storage of
the phial when it was in' the custody of the ·police
officers and its dealing therewith when .it was in the
custody. of· the special messenger have been left in
obscurity. But the evidence dues disclose that the
phial was sealed in the pre5ence of Dr. Rote, and the
report of the Chemical Examiner, also· disclosed that
he had opened a phial which was sealed and that the
seal was intact, with the . device· ''Medico- Leg-al
1 S.C.k.
•
•
SU:PREME COURT REPORTS
941
Bombay'_'. Evidence regarding the dealing with the
phial since it was sealed and it was submitted for
examinatiun of the Chemical Examiner may appear
to be formal; but it has still to be led in a criminal
case to discharge the burden which lap upon the
prosecution. Such evidence would appear to be
"necessary" within the meaning of s. 428 (1) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, and may, having regard
to the circumstances, be permitted to be led in appeal.
The attention of the Magistrate docs not appear to
have been directed to the question whether the time
which elapsed betwi;en the collection of blood and
its examination had any material bearing on the
result of the examination. The Court would norri1ally require some evidence that the concentration
of alcohol is not due to deterioration or delay in the
examination of the contents of the phial or to exposure to weather conrlitiol'ls, before raising the
presumption under s. t)() (2). An opportunity to
lead this evidence may be given under s. 428, not
with a view to fill up lacunae in the evidence but to
regularise the trial of the accukd and to ensure that
the case is established against him beyond reasonable
doubt, more so when for the purpose of convicting
the accused reliance is, sought to he placed upon a
presumption arising from the report of a Chemical
Examiner, who is not examined before the Court, and
which substantially raises a presumption of guilt.
In this connection, the circumstance that the regularity of the process for extraction Qf blood and the
subsequent dealing of the blood phial was not
challenged by the appellant in the trial court is
material.
But counsel for the appellant contends that
the report of the Chemical Examiner on which alone
substantially the case of the prosecution rests is in·
admissible in evidence. He submits that in 01der
to raise a presumption under s. 66l 2) of the Act, i:n
a trial of a -person chargc;i:! ~with committing au
1963
Pandit Ukli• Eolh1
v.
Th6 StaJ1 of
M.luullSlllr•
51!.h, J.
942
196S
f'tll'ldit Uklio Ko/Ju
v.
1 !w Stalt of
/\faha10}'1fra
~Iv;~.
;.
SUPREME COURT REl'<!>RTS [1964] VOL.
offence under s. 66 (1) (b), it must be proved that
concentration of alcohol in the blood of the accused
person is not Jess than 0.0ii per Cfllt weight in
volume, and that can only be proved by the report
of the Chemical Examiner or the f\Icdical Officer
in the manner provided by s. 12913 in respect of
examination of blood collected in the circumstances
and under conditions prescribed by s. 129 A.
Counsel says that the Legislature having enacted
a special provision relating to the procedure by
which evidence about concentration of alcohol in
blood is to be collected, examined and placrd before
the Court, no other method of establishing con·
centration of alcoholic content in the blood of a
person charged with an offence under s. u6 (1) (b)
is permissible, and that even though a concession
was made before the Court of Session by counsel
appearing for the appellant, evidence rili11nde the
report under s. I :!9B was inadmissible. Starting on
this hypothesis, counsel submits that the report of
the Chemical Examiner in respect of blood collected
not in the manner and in the conditions set out in
s. 1W A, els. (I) and (2), cannot be used as evidence
for raising a presumption against the appellant, and
beyond the bare circumstance that Dr. Kulkarni
noticed that the appellant was "smelling of liquor"
at {j a. m. on April 3, 1961, there is no evidence on
which the appellant could be convicted.
It is necessary in considering the validity of
this argument to examine the scheme of ss. 66 (2),
l29A and 129 B, which were added by Act. 12 of
l!J59. In a trial of an accused person for an offence
of consuming liquor under s. 66 (1) (b) of the Act,
s. 66(2) makes proof of concentration of alcohol in
the blood of the accused in excess of the prescribed
quantity presumptive evidence that he has consumed,
i11 contravention of the provisions of the Act or the
rules, regulations or orders made thereunder, liquor
·•.
•
~
l S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPcm.TS
9'43
which is not excepted from the prohibitions in Ch.
III, and the burden lies upon the accused to prove
that liquor consumed by him was a medicinal, toilet
or antiseptic preparation or a solution or flavouring
extract, essence or syrup containinll' alcohol. Subsection (2) of s. 66 provides for raising a presump·
tion upon proof of concentration of alcohol in blood: it
docs not prescribe the manner or method of proving
concentration of alcohol in blood of the person
charged with the offence under s. 66 (1) (b) exceeding the percentage mentioned in sub-$. (2).
The material part of s. 129A is:
"(l) Where in the investigation of any
offence under this Act, any Prohibition
Officer duly empowered in this behalf by the
State Government or any Police Officer, has
reasonable ground for believing that a person
has consumed an intoxicant and that for the
purpose of establishing that he has consumed
an intoxicant or for the procuring of evidence
thereof it is necessary that his body be medi·
cally examined, or that his blood be collected
for being tested
for determining
the
of
alcohol
therein,
such
percentage
Prohibition Officer or Police Officer may
produce such person before a registered
medical practitioner (authorised by general
or special order by the State Government in
this behalf) for the purpose of such medical
examination or colllection of blood, and
request such registered medical practitioner or
furnish a certificate on his finding whether
rnch person has consumed any intoxicant and
to forward the blood collected by him for
test to the Chemical Examiner or Assistant
Chemical Examiner to Government, or to such
other Officer as the State Government may
appoint in this ·behalf.
1963
p.,1;1 Vkha Ir.th•
v.
Tit. Statr of
M•harnrhlt•
Shah, J.
944
1963
l'•ii1 U IW Ko/M
•• of
1-,,.
SI•••
MM.tultlr•
<halt, J.
summ COURT RnPORTS [1964] VOL.
( 2) The registered medical pr;,ictitioner
before whom such person has been produced
shall examine such person and collect a11cl
lUrwar<l in the manner ·prescribed the blood
of such person, and furnish to the officer by
whom such person has been produced, a
certificate in the prescribed form containi11g
the result of his examination. The Chemical
Examiner or Assistauc Chemical Examiner tu
Government, or other Ollicer appointed under
sub-section (l) shall certify the result of the
test of the blood forwarded to him, slating
therein, in the prcscribe<l form, the 1ierccntagc
of alcohol, and such uther particulars as may
be necessary or relevant.
•
(:l) If any person offers resistance tu his
production before a
registered medical
practitioner under sub-section (l) or 011 his
production before such practitioner to the
examination of his body or to the collection of
his blood, it shall be lawful co use all means
reasonably necessary to secure the production
of such person or the examination of his body
or the collection of blood necessary for the test.
(4)
x
x
x
•
x
"(5) Resistance to production before a
registered medical practitioner as aforesaid, or to
the examination of the body under this section,
or to the collection of blood as aforesaid, shall
be deemed to be an offence under section 186
of the Indian Penal Gode.
(6)
x
x
x
( 7)
x
x
x
f
(8) Nothing in this section shall preclude
the fact that the person accused of an offence
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
945
has consumed an intoxicant from being proved
otherwise than in accordance with the provi·
sions of this section."
•.
..
The section is intended primarily to provide tor.
compelling a person reasonably believed by an
Officer investigating an offence under the Act or by a
Prohibition Officer duly empowered, to have con·
sumed liquor, to submit himself to medical exami·
nation, and collection of blood. Before a person can
be compelled to submit himself to examination, two
conditions have to be fulfilled. It must be in the
course of investigation of an offence under the Act;
·and that a Prohibition Officer duly empowered in
that behalf by the State Government, or Police
Officer has reasonable ground for bdieving that a
person has consumed liquor, and that for the purpose
of establishing that such a person has consumed an
intoxicant, or for procuring evidence thereof, it is
necessary that his body be medically examined or his
blood be collected. It is only when these condi'.!ons
exist that a person can be sent or produced before a
registered medical practitioner for purposes of
medical examination or collection of blood. By
sub-s. (5), resistal'!ce to production before a registered
medical practitioner or to the examination of his
body or collection of blood is made unlawful. By
sub-s. (2), the registered medical practitioner is
obliged to examine the person produced before him
and to collect and forward in the manner prescribed
the blood of such person and to furnish to the
Officer a certificate in the prescribed form containing
the result of his examination. But sub·s. (8) expressly
provides that proof of the fact that a person has
consumed an intoxicant may be secured in a manner
otherwise than as provided in s. 129 A. Therefore,
production for examination of a person before a
registered medical practitioner during the course of
investigation by a competent officer who has reason·
able ground for believing that the person has
196$,
P..a1UiJM EaUil
••
Tiu SllJJI qf
Moiwnlluia
Slwh, I.
946 SUPR.EMECOURTREPORTS[I964] VOL.
llM
---.
l'"'°" VU. Kol"'
•• ef
n. Stit.
M"""'ashtro
Sb.I, I.
consumed an intoxicant and for establishing that
fact examination is necessary, is not the only method
by which consumption of an intoxicant may be
proved. An investigating <'fficer or a Prohibition
Officer empowered by the State Government must,
if he desires to have a person examined, or his blood
taken, in the course of investigation for an offence
under the Bombay Prohibition Act, take steps which
are prescribed ins. 129.A and the certificate of the
registered medical practitioner and the report of the
Chemical Examiner made' on the result of the test of
the blood forwarded to him are by s. 129 B made
admissible as evidence in any proceeding under the
Act, without examining either the registered medical
practitioner or the Chemical Examiner. But if exa·
mination of a person or collection of blood from the
body of a person is made otherwise than in the
conditions set out in s. 129· A, the result of the exa·
mination or of the blood may, if it is relevant to a
charge for an offence under the Act, be proved by
virtue of cl. (8), and there is nothing in s. 129 A or
s. 129·B which precludes proof of that fact if it tends
to establish that the person whose blood was taken or
was examined had consumed illicit liquor.
Nazir Ahmd v. The King Emperor ('), on
..which strong reliance was placed by counsel for the
appellant in support of his plea that s. 129 A (I) &
(2) and s. 129 B prescribe the only method of provinl(
. concentration of alcohol in blood; is of little assistance
in this case. In that case the Judicial Committee
held that ss. 164 and 364 of the Code of Criminal
. Procedure prescribed the mode in which confessions
. are to be recorded by Magistrates when made
during investigation and a confession before a
Magistrate not recorded in the manner provided was
inadmissible. In so holding the Judicial Committee
relied upon the rule that where power is given to do
. a certain thing in a certain way the thing must be
' done in that way to the exclusion of all other
(I) (1936) LR. 63, l.I\. 172.
•
.
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
947
methods of performance or not at all, and that the
rule was applicable to a Magistrate who waa a
judicial officer acting under s. 164 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure. It was therefore held that
ss. 164 and 364 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
conferred powers on Magistrates and delimited them,
and these powers could not be enlarged in disregard
of the provisions of s. 164. The Judicial Committee
observed:
"As a matter of good sense, _the poiition of
J
•
•
accused persons and the position of the magistracy are both to be considered. An examination of the Code shows how carefully and
precisely defined is the procedur~ regulating
what may be asked of, or done m the matter
of exai;nination ·of, accused persons; and as' to
how the results are to be recorded and' what use
is to be made of such records. Nor' is this
surprising in a jurisdiction where it is not permissible for an accused person to give evidence
on oath. So with regard to the magistracy;
it is for obvious reasons most desirable that
magistrates and judges should be in the position
of witnesses in so far as it can be avoided.
~ometimes it cannot be avoided, as under
s. 533; but where matter can be made of record
and therefore admissible as such there are the
strongest reasons of policy for supposing that
the Legislature designed that it should be made
available in that form and no other. In their
Lordships view, it would ~e particularly unfortunate if magistrates were asked at all generally to act rather as police·officers than as
judicial persons; to be by reason of their
position freed from the disability that attaches
to police-officers under s. 162 of the Code; and
to be at the same time freed, notwithstanding
their position as magistrates, from any obligation to make records under 1. 164. In the
1963
P•lit Ukha li'ollll
v.
Th. St.ii ef
Mllhllruhtr•
S/lah, J.
948 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [HIM] VOL.
1963
Pandiz UkM tro/A1
••
Thi Sl.U of
MaMttu/llro
SMh, J,
result they would indeed be regulated to the
position of ordinary citizens as witnesses, and
then would be required to depose to matten ...
transacted by them in their official capacity
unregulated by any statutory rules of procedure
or conduct whatever. Their Lordships arc,
however, clearly, of opinion that this unfortu·
nate position cannot in future arise because, in
their opinion, the effect of the statute is clearly
to prescribe the mode in which confessions are
to be dealt with by magistrates when made
during an investigation, and to render inadmi·
~
ssible any attempt to deal with them in the
method proposed m the present case."
The rule in Taylor v. Taylor ('), on which the
Judicial Committee relied has, in our judgment, no
application to this case. Section 66 ( 2), as we have
already observed, does not prescribe any particular
method of proof of concentration of alcohol in the
blood of a person charged with consumption or use of
an intoxicant. Section 129 A is enacted primarily
with the object of providing when the conditions
prescribed are fulfilled, that a person shall submit
himself to be produced before a registered medical
practitioner for examination and for collection of
blood. Undoubtedly, s. 129 A (I) confers power
upon a Police or a Prohibition Officer in the condi·
tions set out to compel a p1·rson suspected by hi~.,
of hadng consumed iilicit liquor, to be produced for
examination and for collcc1 inn 0f bhod before a
;·egistercd m~diral practiiionr.r. But proof of concentration of alcohol may be obtained in the manner
described in s. I 29A( I) & (2), or otherwise; that is
expressly provided bys. (8) of s. I 29A. The power
of a Police Officer to secure examination of a person
suspected of having consumed an intoxicant in the
course of investigation for an orrence under the Act
is undoubtedly restricted by s. l 29A. But in the
present case the Police Offict'r investigating the
(1) [1875) I Cb. D. 426.
1s.c.R.
J
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
949
offence had not produced the accused before a medical
officer : it was in the course of his examination that
Dr. Kulkarni, before any investigation was commenced, came to suspect that the appellant had consumed
liquor, and he directed that specimen of blood of the
appellant be collected. This step may have been
taken for deciding upon the line of treatment, but
certainly not for collecting evidence to be used
against the appellant in any possible trial for a
charge of an offence of consuming liquor contrary
to the provisions of the Act. If unlawful consumption of an intoxicant by a person accused, may be
proved otherwise than by a report obtained in the
conditions mentioned ins. 129A(l) & (~),there would
be no reason to suppose that other evidence about
excessive conrentntion of. alcohol probative of
consumption is inadmissible.
Admissibility of
evidence about concentration of alcohol .in blood
does not depend upon the exercise of any power of
the police or Prohibition Officer. Considerations
which were present in Nazir Ahmad's case (1 ), regarding the inappropriateness of Magistrates being placed
in the same position as ordinary citizens and being
1equired to transgress statutory provisions relating to
the method of recording. confessions also do not arise
in the present case.
Section 129B reads as follows :
"Any document purporting to be(a) a certificate under the hand of a registered
·.medical practitioner, or the Chemical Examiner
or Assistant Chemical Examiner to C~overn
ment, under section 129A or of an officer
appointed under sub-section (1) of that
section, or
(b) a report under the hand of any registered
medical 'practitioner in any hospital or dispensary maintained by the State Government or a
(1) (19S6) L.R. 631.A. 372.
1963
Pandii Ukha Kolh•
Y.
The Stall of
.Mobatashtra
Shah, J.
950 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
196!1
P•t41Uklla /Iollu
v.
n, SW1 of
M-u/Uro
s.w, J.
local authority, or any other registered medical
practitioner authorised by the ::itate Government
in this behalf, in respect of any person examin·
ed by him or upon any matter or thing duly
submitted to him for examination or analysis
and report,
may be used as evidence of the facts stated in
such certificate, or as the case may be, report,
in any proce~dings under this Act; but the
court may if it thinks fit, and shall, on the
application of the prosecution or the accustd
person, summon and examine any such person
as to the subject matter of his certificate or aJ
the case may be, report."
Section I29B, cl. (a) makei a certificate by a registered medical practitioner or the Chemical Examiner
admissible as , evidence of the facts stated therein.
Clause (b) of s. l 2!JB makes another class of documents admissible as evidence of facts therein. These
are reports of certain classes of registered medical
practitioners in respect of persons examined by them
or upon any matter or thing duly submitted for
examination or analysis and report. Therefore cl. (a)
of s. l29B makes the certificate under s. I :(9A admissible: cl. (b) makes reports of· registered medical practioners in respect of persons, matten or things
submitted to them admissible. Section I 29B is an
enactment dealing with a special mode of proof of
facts stated in the certificates and reports mentioned
therein : it has no other effect or operation. The
Sessions Judge in more places than one has in the
course of his judgment referred to "the presumption
under s. l 29B''. The section however deals with
proof of facts, and not presumptions : it enacts a rule
of evidence similar to s. 510 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure. Without proof of the facts stated, the
contents of the certificate or report may by s. l 29B
be proved by tendering the document. If the document is tendered, it is admissible as evidence of the
...
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
951
contents thereof. The certificate or the report proved
in the manner provided by s. 129£ raises uo presumption about consumption of liquor in contravention of
the provisions of the Act: it is proof by evidrnce of
concentration of alcohol in excess of the prescribed
percentage whether it is the manner provided by
cl. (a) or cl. (b) of s. 129B, or otherwise, that gives
rise to a presumption under s. 66(2).
Section 129A contemplates two classes of certi·
ficates-certificate of the result of the examination
by
registered medical practitioner whether the
person sent to him has consumed any intoxicantand the certificate of the Chemical Examiner of the
examination of blood collected by a register·
ed medical practitioner and sent to him for
examination. These are made admissible by virtue
of cl. (a; of s. 129B. Clause (b) of s. 129B deals
with the admissibility of reports in respect of examination of persons or of matters or things submitted to
the registered medical practitioners for examination
or analysis and report. These are undoubtedly
different from the certificates of examinations made
under s. 129A. The report of .a registered medical
practitioner under cl. (b) of s. 129B may be upon a
"matter or thing" and so may be in respect ofblooi
specimen submitted to him.
a
j
•
On an analysis of ss. 129A and 129B, it is
clear that the Legislature has provided in the first
instance for compelling persons suspected of consu·
ming intoxicants to be produced and to submit
themselves for examination and extraction of blood
which, under the law as it stood, could not be secured,
but thereby the law did not provide for only one
method of proving that a person had consumed
illicit liquor within the meaning of s. 66 (2). The
Legislature has made the certificate of the .examination under s. 129A, sub-ss. (1) and (2) admissible
without formal proof; but by sub-s. (8) of s. l 29A,
1963
Pandit Ukha Eolhe
v.
The Stat• of
Mahllrashtra
Sluih, J.
952
SVPRE~tt COL1RT REPOlO S [1964) VOL.
I
1963
P.rr4~ Uk.M
K.tAI
••
T!.. Stolt •f
M.JiM..,,,,.
SM/I, J.
the adoption of auy other method of collection of
evidence for proving that a person accusfd has consumed an intoxicanl is not precluded and a report of
any registered medical practitioner which tends to
establish that fact in respect of matters specified in
cl. (b) of s. 129B is also made admissible. On that
view of ss. l :WA and 129B, there is no warrant for
assuming that it was intended thereby to exclude in
trials for offencr.s undrr s. 66 ( l) (b) of the Act the
operation of s. 510 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The Cude makes a document pu.rporting to be
a report under the hand of a Chemical Examiner
and certain other documents upon any matter or
thing duly submittrd to him for examination or
analysis and report admissible in any enquiry, trial
or other proceeding under the Code. The terms of
1. 510 of the Code of Criminal Procedure arc general;
but on that account it cannot justifiably be assumed
that by enacting ss. l 29A and I 29B, the Legislature
intended that the certificate of a con1petent officer in
respect of matters not governed thereby shall become
inadmissible. It is open to the prosecution to rely
in corroboration of a charge of consumntion of illicit
liquor upon a certificate under cl. {a) of s. 129B if it
is obtained in the manner prescribed by s. l 2!!A, and
also to rely upon the report of a registered medical
pract;tioner in respect of any person examined by
him or upon any matter or thing duly submitted to
him for examination or analysis and report. It is
also open to the prosecution to rely upon the report
of the Chemical Examiner in cases not covered by
s. 129A as provided under s. 510 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure.
It was ur1ied that by the enactment of s. l 29A
and s. 129B of the Act, s. 510 of the Code stood
repealed in its application to offences under s; 66 ( l)
, of the Bombay Prohibition Act, and reliance in this
behalf was placed upon Art. 254 (2) of the. Constitution. It is true that power to legislate on matters
•
•
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
953
relating to Criminal Procedure and evidence falls
within the Third List of the Seventh Schedule to the
Constitution and the Union Parliament and the
"" State Legislature have concurrent authority in respect
of these matters. The expression "criminal procedure" in the legislative entry includes investigation
of offences, and ss. 129A and 129B must be regarded
as enacted in exercise of the power conferred by
Entries 2 . and 12 in the Third List. The Code of
Criminal Procedure was a law in force immediately
before the commencement of the Constitution, and
by virtue of Art. 254 (2) legislation by a State Legis~ lature \\>ith respect to any of the matters enumerated
in the Third List repugnant to an earlier law made
by Parliament or an existing law with respect to that
matter if it has been reserved for the consideration
of the President and has received his assent prevails
in the State. Bombay Act '\No. 12 of 1959 was
reserved for the consideration of the President
and had received his assent : ss. 129A and
129B will prevail in the State of Bombay to the
t
extent of inconsistency with the Code, but no more.
That they so prevail only to the extent of the
repugnancy alone and no more is clear from the
words of Art. 254 : Deep Ohand v. The State of
Uttar Pradesh (') and Oh. Tikaramji v. The Smte
of Uttar PradeBh ('). It is, difficult to regard s. 129B
of the Act as so repugnant to s. 510 of the Code as
to make the latter provision wholly inapplicable to
trials for offences under the Bombay Prohibition
' · Act. Section 510 is a general provision dealing with
proof of reports of the Chemical Examiner in respect
of matters or things duly submitted to him for exami·
nation or analysis and report. Section 129B deals
with a special class of reports and certificates. In
the investigation of an offence under the Bombay
Prohibition Act, examination of a person suspected
by a Police Officer or Prohibition Officer of having
' consumed an intoxicant, or of his blood may be
carried out only in the manner prescribed by s.129A:
(I) [1959) Supp. 2 S.C.R. a.
(2) [1956] l.C.R. 393.
1969
Psndit Uk/14 Kolht
v.
The Stau of
Maharashtra
SMh, I.
954
1963
Pandit liUa Ko/116
v.
1h1 ~ 1 0tt of
Mal arashlra
SW. J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
and the evidence to prove the facts disclosed thereby
will be the certificate or the examination viva voce
of the registered Medical Practitioner, or the ..,
Chemical Examiner, for examination in the course
of an investigation of an offence under the Act of
the person so suspected or of his blood has by the
clearest implication of the Jaw to be carried out in
the manner laid down or not at all. Report of the
Chemical Examiner in respect of blood collected in
the course of investigation of an offence under the
Bombay Prohibition Act, otherwise than in the
manner set out in s. 129A cannot therefore be used
as evidence in the case. To that extent s. 510 of
~
the Code is superseded by s. l 29B. But the report of
the Chemical Examiner relating to the examination
of blood of an accused person collected at a time
when no investigation was pending, or at the instance not of a Police Officer or a Prohibition
Officer remains admissible under s. 510 of the Code.
It was urged before the Court of Session that
the report of the Chemical Examiner was submitted
by that officer not to the Court or to the medical
officer but to the police officer and it was by virtue
of s. 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure inadmissible, except to the extent permitted within
the strict limits prescribed by that section. But
s. 510 makes provision with regard to proof of
documents by production thereof, and the application
of s. 162 ( l) is expressly made subject to what is
provided . in the Code of Criminal Procedure.
Exclusion from evidence of any part of a statement
made to a police officer or a record from being used
for any purpose at any enquiry or trial in respect
of an offence under investigation at the time when
such statement was made is "save as hereinafter
provided". The word "hereinafter" is, in our
judgment not restricted in its operation to s. 162
alone but applies to the body of the Code; to hold f
otherwise would be to introduce a patent inconsistency between s. 207 A and s. 162 of the Code.
•
_L -
1 S.C.R.
•
I
I
'
"'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
955
for by the former section in committal proceeding,
statements recorded under s. 162 are to be regarded
as evidence. The contention raised that the report
made to the police officer, by the Chemical Examiner
was inadmissible in evidence was rightly rejected:
Finally, it was urged that the blood specimen
was not submitted in the manner prescribed by rules
framed under the Bombay Prohibition Act, and
therefore it could not be regarded as, "duly submitted." The Government of Bombay has, by
notification dated April I, 1959, framed rules under
cl. (w) of s. 143 of the Bombay Prohibition Act,
called the Bombay Prohibition (I\1edical Examination
and Blood Test) Rules. Rule 3 deals with the
examination of a person by a registered medical
practitioner before whom he is produced _under
sub-s. (1) of s. 129A. Rule 4 provides for the manner
of collection and forwarding of blood specimen and
r. 5 deals with certificates of tests of "sample blood".
All these rules deal with medical examination of a
person who is produced before a registered medical
practitioner under _sub-s. (I) of s. 129A. To an
examination to which s. 129A does not apply, the
rules would have no application. The law not
having prescribed a particular method of submitting
specimen of blood collected from an accused person
when blood has been collected before any investigation has started, it is unnecessary to consider the argu·
ment whether the expression "duly submitted" used
in s. 510 of the Code of Criminal Procedure means
merely in the manner prescribed by rules in that
behalf or as pointed out by the learned Sessions
Judge. submitted after taking adequate precautions
for ensuring its safety and for securing against
tampering. In the present case, the blood specimen
was collected by Dr. Rote and thereafter it was
handed over to the police officer on demand by him
and ultimately submitted to the Chemical Examiner
for his examination, it -would, in our judgment, be
regarded as "duly submitted."
1963
Pandit Ukha Kolb1
••
Tire State of
MaharSJhtrtJ
Shah, J.
956 SUPREME COURT REPORTS(I964] VOL.
196!1
Paii< Uldta Kol~t
••
771. Stauof
MM.1trAh•
.IM>I, J.
We are unable to accept the contention of
counsel for the appellant that 1he appellant should,
on the view taken by the Sessions judge. be acquitted,
but for reasons already stated, we are also unable to
agree with the learned Judge that the appellant
should be retried before the trial Court.
We accordingly set aside the order passed by
the Trial Magistrate and direct that . the Sessions
Judge do hear the appeal and dispose of it according
to law, after giving an opportunity to the prosecution to lead evidence on the matters which are indicated in the course of this judgment, the additional
evidence may be taken by the Sessions Judge himself
or may be ordered to be recorded in the Trial Court.
The accused shall be examined under s. 342 of the
case of Criminal Procedure and be given an opportunity to lead evidence in rebuttal, if he so desires.
The Sessions Judge may require the presence of the
Chemical Examiner for examination before him or
before the Magistrate, if he thinks that examination
viva voce of the Chemical Examiner is necessary to
do complete justice in the case.
Subject to the above modification, the appeal
is dismissed.
Dos~ J.
DAS GUPTA, J.-1 think this appeal should be
allowed. The appellant was convicted under
s. 66 (I) (b) of the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949 on
the charge of having consumed an intoxicant agai11st
the provisions of the Prohibition Act and was sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 600/- or in default
to suffer rigorious imprisonment for two months.
On appeal, the Sessions Judge, Jalgaon, being
of opinion that the evidence already on the record
was not sufficient to establish the guilt of the accused, ,
set aside the conviction and sentence passed against
him. He, however, ordered the case to be sent back
to the learned Judicial Magistrate, Bhusawal, for
~
•
1 S.C.R..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
957
re-trial so that the prosecution might have an oppor•
tunity of adducing evidence l,' ,_._;nnect the report
of the chemical examination which was produced at
the trial with the blood of the accused perso.1 which
was taken at 6 a. m. on April 3, 1961, a few hours
after the alleged consumption of the intoxicant. It is
obvious that the only purpose that such additional
'evidence was expected to serve was that the prosecu·
tion would get the benefit of s. 66 (2) of the Bombay
Prohibition Act. The Revision petition filed by the
accused against this order was rejected by the High
Court of Bombay. Against that order of rejection,
this appeal has been preferred after obtaining special
leave from this Court.
The main contention urged in support of the
appeal is that as the blood that was taken at 6 a. m.
was not taken in accordance with the provisions of
s. 129 A of the Prohibition Act, no evidence as
regards the contents of that blood is admissible in
law for the purpose of s. 66 (2) of the Prohibition
Act. It is necessary to consider this contention care·
fully as it is not disputed that the prosecution must
fail unless it can get the benefit of s. 66 {2) of the
Prohibition Act.
'
~·
To understand, the nature of the right conferred
on the prosecution bys. 66 (:!) it will be helpful to
maintain briefly a few other sections of the Act.
Section 13 of the Act prohibits among other things
the consumption of an intoxicant. Section 2 (22)
defines intoxicant to mean "any liquor, intoxicating
drug, opium or any other !ubstance, which the State
Government may by notification in the official
gazette declare to be an intoxicant." "Liquor" is
defined ins. 2 (24) to include (a) spirits of wine
(denatured spirits), wine, beer, toddy and all liquids
consisting of or containing alcohol; and (b) any other
intoxicating substance which the State Government
may by notification in the official gazette, declare to
1963
Pandi1 U/k Ko/Ila
••
TA1 Slau ef
Malu.rtuhlra
Das Gupta, J •
958
IMS
1'.WiJ Cilia Co/Al
••
7lt ''11•11 of
M.,_IUAlra
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
I
be liquor for the purpose of this Act. It is important
to mention also s. 24 A of the Act, the relevant
portion of which for our present purpose runs thus : "Nothing in this Chapter shall be deemed to
apply to:
( 1) Any toilet preparation conta1mng
which is unfit for us as intoxicant
alcohol
liquor;
(2) Any medicinal preparation contammg
alcohol which is unfit for use as an intoxicating
liquor;
(3) Any antiseptic preparation or solution
containing alcohol which is unfit for use as
intoxicating liquor;
(4) Any flavouring extract, essence or
syrup containing alcohol which is unfit for use
as intoxicating liquor."
As section 13 is in Chapter III the position in
law is that the prohibition ins. 13 against consumption of liquor docs not apply to any of the subs·
taoces mentioned in s. 24- A. It is necessary to
mention also that it has been held by this Court in
State. of Bombay (now Gujarat) v. Narandas Mangi·
lal Aggarwal('), that the burden of proving that the
substances in respect of which the prohibition in s. 13
or any other section of the Chapter is alleged by the
prosecution to have been contravened, does not fall
within any of the four classes mentioned ins. 24-A, is
on the prosecution.
It is clear therefore that a prosecution for an
offence under s. 66(1 )(b) cannot succeed by the mere
proof of the fact that the accused consumed liquor.
It is also to be proved that the liquor does not fall
(I) (1962) ~upp. I S.C.11.. 15.
'
i.
1 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
\
•
~
959
within any of the substances mentioned in s. 24(A).
In other words, before a person can be .convicted
under s. 66(1)(b) of the Prohibition Act for consump·
tion of an intoxicant the prosecution has to prove
two things. It has first to prove that the accused
consumed an intoxicant, and secondly, it has to
prove that that intoxicant was not either a toilet
preparation or a medicinal preparation or an anti·
septic preparation or solution containing alcohol or a
flavouring extract, essence or syrup containing alcohol,
which while containing alcohol was not unfit for use
as intoxicating liquor. Section 66(2) of the Act
comes to the aid of the prosecution in proving both
these things by providing that if after alleging that
the accused consumed liquor the prosecution proves
that "the concentration of alcohol in the blood of the
accused person is not less than 0·05 per cent weight
in volume," then the burden of disproving the ingredients of the offence as mentioned above will ·be
shifted to the accused. The result of this is that
where the prmecution proves such concentration of
alcohol in the blood of the accused person the accused
will be liable to conviction until and unless the
accusei:l proves either that he did not consume any
intoxicant or that the substance he consumed was a
medicinal or toilet preparation or any antiseptic
preparation or solution containing alcohol or any
flavouring extract, essence or syrup containing
alcohol, "which is unfit for use as intoxicating
"
.
11quor.
If there had been no special provJS1on in the
Act as to how this concentration of alcohol in the
bloo~ of the accused person could be proved by the
prosecution, it would undoubtedly be open to the
prosecution, to obtain the blood of the accused person
in any manner not prohibited by law, have it
examined by an expert and produce the evidence of
the expert before the Court-either by examining the
expert himself or if the law permits by producing his
1969
..
Pandit UH• K.U..
Tiu SldJ10J
Ma/w1JShtr•
Das Gupld, I.
960 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
report even without such examination. A special
provision has however been made by the legislature
as regards the mode in which the prosecution can
bring before the Court the evidence as regards the
concentration of alcohol in the blood of the accused
person. This provision appears in s. 129A of the
Act. That section runs thus :-
Section 129A.
(1) Where in the investigation of any
offence under this Act, any Prohibition Officer
duly empowered in this behalf by the State
1
Government or any Police Officer, has reasonable ground for believing that a person has
consumed an intoxicant and that for the purpose
of establishing that he has consumed an intoxicant or for the procuring of evidence thereof
it is necessary that his body be medically
examined, or that his blood be collected for
being tested for determining the percentage of
alcohol therein, such Prohibition Officer or ,
Police Officer may produce such person before
a registered medical practitioner (authorised by
general or special order by the State Government in this behalf ) for the purpose of such
medical examination or collection of blood, and
request such registered medical practitioner to
furnish a certificate on his finding whether such
person has consumed any intoxicant and to
forward the blood collected by him for test to ~
the Chemical Examiner or A~istant Chemical
Examiner to Government, or to such other
officer, as the State Government may appoint
in this behalf.
(2) The registered medical practitioner before whom such person has been produced shall
r:xamine such person and collect and forward in ,.
the manner prescribed, the blood of such person,
and furnish to the officer by whom such person
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
961
and collect and forward in the manner prescribed, the blood of such person, and furnish to the
officer by whom such person has been produced,
a certificate in the prescribed form containing the
result of his examination. The Chemical Examiner or Assistant Chemical Examiner, to Govern·
ment, or other officer appointed under sub-section
( l) shall certify the result of the test of the blood
forwarded to him, stating therein, in the prescribed form, the percentage of alcohol, and such
other particulars as may be necessary or relevant.
· (3) If any person offers resistance to his
production before a registered medical practi•
tioner under sub-section (1) or on his production
before such medical practitioner to the exami·
nation of his body or to the collection of his
blood, it shall be lawful to use all means
reasonably necessary to secure the production
of such person or the examination of his body
or the collection of blood necessary for the test.
(4) If the person produced is a female,
such examination shall be carried out by, and
the blood shall be collected by or under the
supervision of a female registered medical
practitioner authorised by general or special
order, by the State Government in this behalf,
and any examination of the body, or collection
ofblood, of such female shall be carried out
or made with strict regard to decency.
(5) Resistance to production before a
registered medical practitioner as aforesaid or
to the examination of the body under this
section, or to the collection of blood as afore•
said, shall be deemed to be an offence under
section 186 of the Indian Penal Code.
(6) Any expenditure incurred for the
purpose of enforcing the provision of this
section including any fees . payable to a
196!
P.Uit Vk!ui KtlM
••
77u S1"'4 •f
M.Mrasldt•
Du GuPI•, /,
•
962 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
1963
I OAiil uu. K"""
v.
Tli1 St4le of
MaharOJhJro
Dai Gupta, J.
registered medical practitioner or the officer
appointed under sub-section (l), be defrayed
out of the money provided by the ~tate
Legislature.
...
( 7) If any Prohibition Officer or Police
Officer vexatiously and unreasonably proceeds
under sub-section ( l ), he shall, on conviction,
be punished with fine which may extend to
five hundred rupees.
(8) Nothing in this section shall preclude
the fact that the person accused of an
offence has consumed an intoxicant from
being proved otherwise than in accordance
with the provisions of this section".
On behalf of the appellant, it is contended
that no evidence as regards the concentration of
alcohol in the blood can br. given by the prosecution
unless the blood has been collected and forwarded
and thereafter examined in accordance with the
procedure laid down in s. 129 A. In my opinion,
this contention should succeed.
It has to be noticed, i1J the first place, that
the very detailed provisiom ma:ie in this section s. 129 A-were mad~ by the same amending Act
which created this special ri~ht in favour of the
prosecution by enacting e. !i6 (2). It does not, in
my opinion. stand to reason to say that even when
making such detailed procedure the legislature con·
templated that thmc in char.gc of the prosecution
might choose not to follow the procedure at all.
It has to be noticed that the production of an
accused person before a medical officer is provided
for in the first sub section for two different purposes. One is for the examination of his body for
procuring evidence of consumption of an i!'!toxican.t
I
•
I S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT.REPORTS
963
by him and the other is the collection of his blood
1993
for being tes~ed for . determining the percentage of , l'aiit-;;;:;; ,.,1111
-< alcohol therem. When the accused has been pro•.
duced the medical practitioner will examine the
r;~· 1 • 1h,ef
accused and himself give a certificate whether the
"" '"
person has consumed an intoxicant. He will also
D., Gu;ta, 1.
take the person's blood if so requested but he is
given no authority to examine the blood himself.
The definite provision as regards the examination of
the blood is that after the blood has been collected
by the registered medical practitioner he will forward
the same either to the Chemical Examiner or the
Assistant Chemical Examiner to Government or any
other officer as the State Government may appoint.
It is the duty of the officer be he the Chemical
Examiner or the Assistant Chemical Examiner or
any other officer appointed for the purpose to whom
the blood has been forwarded, to test the blood and
to give a certificate stating the percentage of alcohol
in the blood and such other particulars as may be
necessary or relevant. Provision is also made in the
• third sub•section for "use of all means" that may be
necessary to secure the production of such person or
the examination of his body or the collection of his
blood, if he offers resist ance. The fourth subsection makes special provision as regards how the
medical examination shall be carried out and the
blood shall be collected where the person is a female.
The fifth sub-section provides that resistance to production before a medical practitioner or to the exa~ mination of the body or to the collection of blood ·
shall be deemed to be an offence. The sixth sub-section provides as to how the expenditure shall be met.
The seventh sub·section makes the Prohibition
Officer or Police Officer liable to penalty if he has
proceeded vexatiously and unreasonably under
sub-section (1). The eighth sub-section which is
the last in the section and deserves special consideration will be separately dealt with.
•
964 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
1963
p...i;, (;IJia
One of the well.recognised
principles of
""°" .interpretation
of statutes is that when a law creates
v.
Th• S141t of
M oJu.,.,J, tra
DaJ Gupta, J.
a new right and at the same time prescribes a modei..
in which that right may be exercised, it will, ·in the
absence of anything indicating a contrary intention,
be ordinarily reasonable to hold that the right cannot
be exercised in any other mode. In the present case,
far from there bcin11; any indication to the contrary,
all the indications are, in my opinion, in favour of
the view that the prescribed mode in s. l 29A was
intended by the legislature to be the only mode in
which the right given to the prosecution by s. 66 (2) ~
can be exercised. What was the reason behind the legis.
lature's intention to prescribe such a detailed procedure ins. 129 A for the ascertainment of the alcoholic
content of the blood of a person accused of an offence
in connection with the consumption of an intoxicant ?
Why did it make such a careful demarcation of functions between the re11;istered medical practitioner
before whom a person is first produced by entro.~ting
to him onlv the duty of examining the body of the ~
person and if so requested of collecting his blood "for
being tested for determining the nercentage of alcohol",
and the Chemical Exa'lliner or the Assistant Chemical
Examiner or anv other officer appointed by the State
Government in this behalf by entrusting to them only
the dutv of testing the blood? It appears reasonable
to think that the real reason behind all this detailed
provision was the legislature's anxietv to ensure that
the very special righ.t created bv s. 66 (2) in favour of •
the prosecution for the proof of alcoholic content of
the blood shifting the onus on the accused should not
he availed of in a manner that might leave loopholes
for either errors or unfair practices. This motive is
also clear from the provision made in the seventh
sub-section that " if any Prohibition Officer or Police
Offiicer, vexatiously and unreasonably proceed,
under sub-section (1 ), he shall, on conviction, be•
punished with fine which may extend to five hundred
1 S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
965
rupees." All these steps taken by the legislature
for prescribing a special procedure would be set at
naught if it was .left open to the Prohibition Officer
or Police Officer to arrange for the taking of blood
and testing thereof in any other manmr. Thus, to
say that it is open to the Prohibition Officer or the
Police Officer to have the blood taken and also
tested by the registered medical practitioner himself
for using his finding as evidence to prove alcoholic
concentration in the blood for the purpose of s. 66 (2)
would be to fly in the face of the clear indication in
s. 129A that it is not for the registered medical
practitioner before whom a person is produced to test
the blood, that it is for him only to collect
the blood and then forward it to the Chemical
Examiner or the Assistant Chemical Examiner or
such other officer as the State Government may
appoint in this behalf to test the blood for the
alcoholic content. To say that the legislature did
not intend the procedure as prescribed ins. 129A
to be the only procedure for the ascertainment of
alcoholic content in a person's blood for the purpose
of getting the benefit of s. 66 (2) of the Act is really
to hold that even though the legislature did definitely
say that the registered medical practitioner should
only collect the blood and forward it to the other
functionary named in the section whose duty would
be to test it, the legislature was quite content that
this direction need not be complied with. With great
respect for the learned brethren who take the contrary
view, I am of opinion, that it is wholly arbitrary to
attribute to a legislature an intention that it did not
mean what it said.
Even if there had been any scope for doubt
on the question whether the legislature intended to
prescribe the procedure to be the only procedure
available to enable the prosecution to get the aid of
s. 66 (t), that doubt is, in my opinion, completely
set at rest by the 8th sub-section of s. 129A. This
1963
Pandit Ukha Kolh1
••
1he Stat• of
Maharashtra
Dc1 Gupta, J.
UG6
1963
Pandil Ukh• K•ll1~
...
Thi ~·1-.1111f
M.MrWatr•
Du Goµ•, I.
SUPREME COURT l{EPOl<.'1 S (1!164] VOL.
sub-section, as already set out, s:iys that "nothing in
this section shall preclude the fact that the person
accused of an offence has consumed an intoxicant
from being proved otherwise than in acc•irdance
with the provisions of this section . ., It is important
to note at once that the legislature did not in this
sub-section say "1hat nothing in this section shall
preclude the fact of the alcoholic content of the blood
of the person from being proved otherwise than in
accordance with the provisions of this section."
This omission cannot but be held to be deliberate.
The operative portion of the section deals,
as has already been pointed out earlier, with two
distinct matters-one as regards the medical
examination of a person's body for the purpose of
establishing that lie has consumrd an intoxicant and
the other as regards the testing of his hlood for
determining the percentage of alcohol therein. As
regards the first of these purposes the 8th sub·scction
makes a clear provision that the section shall not
have the effect of excluding any other mode of
proof. In other words, the fact that a person has
consumed an intoxicant may be proved by evidence
other than what is made available under the
provisions of this section. As regards the other
purpose, viz .. the determination of the percentage
of alcohol in the blood no such saving clause is
enacted. In my opinion, this is an eminent case for
the application of the principle expres.~io unius,
exclusio ttltuiu..' and that the expression of the
legislature's intention that the provisions of the
section shall not preclude the fact of consumption
of an intoxicant being proved by other modes
justifies a conclusion that the legislature's intention
was that the section shall preclude the fact that the
person had a particular percentage of alcohol in his
blood from being proved otherwise than in accordance
with the provisions of the section.
•
•
1 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
967
It appral\' clear to me, on a consideration of
s. 66 (2) together with s. J 29A that having conferred
on the prosecution the benefit in s. 66 (2) that if the
alcoholic percentage of an accused person's blood is
proved to be not less than 0.05 the accused would
be presumed to be guilty of an offence under s. 66 (1)
unless he proves to the contrary, the legislature at
the same time intended that this fact can be proved
only by evidence obtained in the manner provided
by the same amending Act in the new section 129 A.
It is for this reason that while leaving it open to the
prosecution to prove the consumption of an intoxicant by an accused person "otherwise than in accordance with the provisions of (s. 129A)" it did not
leave it open to the prosecution to prove the fact of
percentage of alcohol. in the blood also "otherwise
than in accordance. with the provisions of this
section."
·
•
In coming to this conclusion I have not overlooked the fact that s. 129B in providing for certain
reports and certificates being used as evidence even
without the examination of the person who prepared
the report or gave the certificate, has mentioned in
cl. (b) a report by a registered medical practitioner
"upon any matter or thing duly submitted to him for
examination or analysis and report", outside s. 129A.
It was pointed out that this very fact shows that the
legislature contemplated the examination by a
registered medical practitioner of "any matter or
thing", even apart from s. 129A. The argument is
that this can only refer to the examination of blood
for ascertaining its a!coholic content. I am unable to
agree that the only "matter" or "thing" that can be
submitted to a registered medical practitioner for
examination or analysis must be the blood of an
accused person and the examination can only be for
ascertaining the alcoholic percentage •
It is worth noticing that nothing is said in this
clause as to how the "submission" of the "thing"
1963
Pandii Ukha Kolh1
••
Thi State of
Malu.rashtrt1
Das Gupta, /.
968
1963
Paiit UU• I(.U..
••
f/,. su1../
M-os/W•
D"G•Pr.. /.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS[l964]VOL.
has to be proved. On~ can understand the
of things like, sav, some vomit
submission
by an accused per;on being seized by an
investigating officer and submit1ir1g it to a registered
medical practitioner for examination or a11alysis and
himself coming to prove the fact of such submission.
Where, however, as suggested, the blood of a person
is being submitted to a registered medical practitioner it will be unreasonable to think that anybody
except a qualified medical practitioner could have
collected the blood.
There is no. provision
in this clause that his report in the matter will be
available as evidence of the fart stated therein. On
the construction suggested by the respondent that
"thing" in cl. (b) of s. l z!JB can only mean blood of
the accused person, we shall have tht' curious position
that while the registered medical practitioner who
examined the blood need not come into the witnessbox to prove that fact and the result of his examination, the other medical practitioner who actually
collected the blood will have to come into the witness box to prove that fact and his certificate or
report will not be evidence of facts stated therein. I
can see ...... no compelling reason for accepting a
construction which will have such curious consequences.
0
A question somewhat similar to the one now
before us fell to be decided by the Privy Council in
Nazir Ahmad v. The King Emperor ('). That
question arose in connection with the procedure laid
down in the Code of Criminal Procedure for the
record of confessions by magistrates. Whik s. 164
of the Code lays down a detailed procedure for recording by magistrates of any confession made in the
course of an investigation of a case or at any time
afterwards before the commencement of the enquiry
or trial, s. 364 lays down the procedure that should
be followed by a magistrate or by any court other
than a High Court established by a Royal Charter
(I) (t9S6) L.R. 63 I.A. 372.
;.
•
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
969
when any accused is examined. The appellant,
(Nazir Ahmad) was convicted mainly, if not entirely,
~ on the strength of a confession said to have been
made by him to a magistrate of which evidence was
given by the magistrate but which was not recorded
by the magistrate in the manner required bys. 164
and s'. 364 of the Code. The High Court held that
this evidence was admissible. In support of ·that
·view it was urged before the Privy Council that the
evidence was admissible just because it has nothing
to do wi~h s. 164 or with any record and that by
virtue of ss. 17, 21 and 24 of the Evidence Act the
statement was admissible just as much as it would
be if deposed by a person other than a magistrate.
This argument was repelled by the Privy Council in
these words :"On the matter of construction ss. 164 and
364 must be looked at and construed, together,
and it would be an unnatural construction to
hold that any other procedure was permitted
than that which is laid down with such minute
particularity in the sections themselves."
Later on their Lordships proceeded thus :-
•
"It is also to be observed that, if the construction contt>nded for by the Crown be correct, all
the precautions and safeguards laid down by
ss. lti4 and 3o4 would be of such trifling value
as to be almost idle. Any magistrate of any
rank could depose to a confession made by an
accused so loug as it was not induced by a
threat or promise, without affirmatively satisfying himself that it was made voluntarily and
without showing or reading to the accused
any version of what he was supposed to have
said, or asking for the confession to be vouched
by any magistrate. The range of magisterial
confessions would be so enlarged by this process that the provisions of s. 164 would almost
1963
Pandit Uklia Kalh1
v.
Thi Stat• of
Ma/&arashtro
Dos Gupta, J.
970 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [HJ64] VOL.
1963
P.mdol Ukha Kol1"
••
TJ,. S..11 of
Maharashtra
Du G.p1., /,
inevitably be widely disregarded in the same
manner as they were di;rcgardcd in the present
case.''
It appears to me that these considerations which
weighed with the Privy Ctiuncil in rejecting the
argument that evidence of confession not recorded in
accordance with the procedure laid down in the Code
of Criminal Procedure could still be admissible,
apply with equal force to our present problem. If '
evidence as regards alcoholic content of the blood is
allowed to be given even where the procedure laid
down in s. l 29A has not been followed the salutary
provisions of that section would "almost inevitably
be widely disregarded". That the legislature did
not intend this is clear, as I have already pointed out
above, from what it laid down in the 8th sub section
of s. 129A.
For all these reasons, I have come to the conclusion that as admittedly the procedure laid down
in s. 129A was not followed for testing of the blood
that was taken at 6 a.m., the prosecution cannot get •
the benefit of s. 6fl(2) of the Prohibition Act. There
is no justification, therefore, for the order made by
the Sessions Judge, sending the case back to the
Magistrate for re-trial in order to give the prosecution an opportunity of adducing evidence as regards
the exammation of the blood taken at ti a.m. on
April 3, 19til.
I would therefore allow the appeal, set aside ,
the order of the High Court and also the order of the
Sessions .Judge directing re· trial and order that the
appellant be acquitted.
BY COURT. In accordance with the opinion
of the majority the Appeal is dismissed subject to the
modifications mentioned in the Judgment.
Appeal dismissed.'
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org