THE HINDUSTAN TIMES LTD., NEW DELHI versus THEIR WORKMEN VICE VERSA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 14 December 1962 | [1964] 1 S.C.R. 234 | 1962 INSC 385
Key facts
- Decided
- 14 December 1962
- Bench
- P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR*, K.N. WANCHOO, K.C. DAS GUPTA, J.C. SHAH
- Bench size
- 4
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 489/1961
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [1964] 1 S.C.R. 234
- Neutral citation
- 1962 INSC 385
Text of the judgment
231 SUPREME COURT REPORts [1964] Vot.
1962
"Vehru Motor TrOtrS•
port Co·of1tr•lir1
\Ve therefore dismiss the petition but in the
circumstances of this case pass no order asto costs.
Socitt) Lid.
v.
SllJU of Raja.""1it
Wanchoo, J.
1962
THE HINDUSTAN TIMES LT1).,
NEW DELHI
D"""b"', .H.
v.
THEIR WORKMEN
VICB VERSA
(P. B. GAJENDRAOADKA.R, K. N. WANCHOO,
K. C. DAS GuPTA and J.C. SHAH, JJ.)
Industrial Di~pute--Fi•·atiun of waye structure-Factor.•
lo be co11sidered-Fair IVage-Lidng IVagc-l!:xtent of power to
interfere under Art. 136 with w~gc •cale fixed by TribunalDearness allowance on basis of ,,/iJiny ocafcs-/nterim agreement
r<ganling interim relief not to be ignured-Lea.1:r, rule.s-Grutu.
ity-J!.ietireni.ent 1tqe-Retrusper:tit·c t1pr:rr1ti1J1l t1f azvard-J)c/hi
Shops & Jtstablisliment Act, 1954 (Ddlii 7 of 1Vii4)-1!:111ployw'
Stale In.rnrance Act, 1948 (34 of 1!148)-lwlu..•trial Di8putes
Act, 1947, (U of 1!147).
The Chief Commissioner, Delhi, referred an L1dwtrial
dispute for adjudication to the Industrial Tribunal, Delhi,
which gave its award on March 16, 1959. Both the appellant
and the respondents were dissatisfied with the award and they
came to this Court by Sp<.'Cii.l leave. The award was challenged
by the appellant with regard to scales of pay, dearness allowance,
adjustments, leave rules, gratuity and
rctro.<1pectivc
effect of the award. The respondents attacked the award as
reg~rds the working hours, l•ave rules and retirement age.
Ile/a, that while social justic demand• that workmen
should get a fair share of the national income which they help
to produce, it has also to be seen that that docs not result in
the drying up of the source of national income itself. lnroada
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
235
1962
on the profits of the capitalists should not Le such as have a
tendency to drive capital away from fruitful employment and Tht Hindustan T'un~s
thereby affect prejudicially capital formation itself. The Tribu·
Ltd., New D1lhl
nal had applied the correct principles and the award should
Thllr Workn.t
not be disturbed.
•.
Held, also, that the Tribunal had erred in awarding a
Jixt:d dearness allowance of Rs. 25!.. The object of dearness
allowance being to neutralise part of the rise or fall in the cost
of living, it should ordinarily be on a sliding scale.
'·
Held, that the contention of the appellant that in view of
1he provisions of the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948, no
provision need be made about sickness leave at all, was rejected.
It was pointed out that in providing for periodical payments
to an insured worker in case of sickness or for medical treatment
or attendance to him or the members of his family under the
Act of 1948, the Legislature did not intend to substitute any of
these benefits for the workmen's rig~t to get leave on full pay
on the ground of sickness.
Held, that as regards those workmen to whom the Delhi
Shops and Establishments Act, 1954. applied, the Tribunal had
acted illegally in fixing the period of sick leave at 15 days and
permitting accumulation. The appellant shall allow to the work·
men to whom the Delhi Shops and Establishments Act applied,
sickness or casual leave for a tnt ·il period of 12 days with full
pay and allowances, and such leave shall not accumulate. As
it was not desirable to .have two separate leave rules for two
classes of workmen, one to whom the Aot of 1954 applied and
the other to whom the Act did not apply, it was held that the
•ame rule should apply to other workers also.
Held, also, that the scheme of gratuity as framed by the
tribunal was not unduly favourable to workmen and it also did
not place any undue strain on the financial resources of the Com·
pany. As regards the provision in the gratuity scheme that an
employee who is dismissed for misconduct shall not be entitled
to any gratuity; it was held that the proper provision should be
that where an employee is dismissed for misconduct which has
resulted in financial loss to the employer, the amount of loss
should be deducted from the amount of gratuity due.
The award of the Tribunal on the question of retirement
age was set aside and the retirement age was fixed at 58, subject
to the proviso that it would be open to the company to conti·
nue in its employment a workman who had passed that age.
The rule was to apply to all the employees of the Company.
236
1962
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1964) VOL.
No general formula could be laid down as to the date
from which a Tribunal should make its award cffecti\·e. That
TIM Hintf11sta11 TU1111
que•tion has to be decided by the Tribunal on consideration
ltd., New Delhi
of the circumstances of each case. 'fherc was no justification
v.
Thtir Worknws
for interfering with the direction of the ·rribunal that in this
case the reliefs given liy it should become effoctive from the
date of the reference.
Standard Vacuum R•fining Co., of India v. /I.! workmen,
[1961] S. C.R. 536, Mf.•. Crorun Aluminium Works v. /I,. workmtn, {1958] S. C. R. 651, B~prM~ New•papers Lf4. v; Union
of India, [1959] S. C.R. 12, Mf"· Lipton Ltd. v. Their II orkrnen
(1959] Supp. 2 S. C.R. 150, Workmen llindi••lan Motor.< v.
llidu•lan Motors, (1962) 2 L. L. J. 352, French Motor Car Co. v.
Their IVorkmtn, (1962) 2 L. L..J. 744 and Gutst Keen, IVilliarns
(P) Ltd. v. P. J. Sterling [1961] 1 S. C.R. 348, referred to.
C1vIL APPELLATE JuRTSI>WTION: Civil Appeals
Nos. 489 & 490 of 1961.
Appeals by special leave from the award dated
March lti, 1959, of the Second Industrial Tribunal,
Delhi in Reference I. D. No. 20 of 1958.
G. S. Pathak, S. T. Desai, M. L. Sethi, B. Dutta
and Anand Prakash, for the appellant (in C. A.
No. 489/61) and the respondent (in C. A. No. 490/61).
lu. C. Setalvad, Attorney-General for fodia,
,lf. K. Rainamurt11i, D. P. SiWJh, R. !(, Garg and
S.C. Agarwal, for the respondents (in C.A. No. 48!l/6l)
and the appellants (in C. A. No. 490/61 ).
1962. December
Court was delivered by
D111 Gupl<l, J.
14.
The Judgment of the
DAS GUPTA, J.-These two appeals by special
leave, one by the employer and the other by the
workmen, arise out of an industrial dispute that was
referred for adjudication to the Industrial Tribunal
Delhi, by an order made on January 2:l, 1958 by the
Chief Commissioner, Delhi. The Tribunal made its
award on March 16, l!l59. Out of the numerous
1 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
237
1961
matters that were included in the terms of reference,
we are concerned in these appeals only with a few. Thi Hindustan Ttmes
The employer challenges the award as regards : (1) ltd., N•w Delhi
Thlir r¥or~m111.
Scales of pay, (2) Dearness allowance, (:1) Adjt19tments, (4) Leave Rules, (5) Gratuity and (6) RetrosDu Gupta, J.
pective effect of the award. The workmen also
attacked the award as regards the scales of pay and
dearness allowance. In addition, they have attacked
the award as regards the working hours, leave rules,
night shift allowance, retirement age and procedure
for taking disciplinary action. At the time of the
hearing before us however the learned Attorney
General, appearing for the workmen, did not press
their claim for modification of the award as regards,
night shift allowance, leave rules and procedure for
taking disciplinary action and working hour>.
•.
It appears that when the dispute was before the
Conciliation Officer, Delhi, for settlement an interim
agreement was ·arrived at between the parties on
December 20, 1957 by which the management agreed
to give certain interim reliefs, ranging between
Rs. 6/- to Rs. 10/- per month from the month of
November 1957. One of the terms of the agreement
was that this payment "will be adjusted against the
final outcome of the demands by constitutional
means". The Tribunal has in its award given a
direction that this interim relief shall remain unaffected. Taking this to be a direction th'lt the
adjustment as agreed upon of payments under the
interim arrangement shall not be made, the employer
has in its appeal challenged the correctness of this
direction also.
The most important of the matters in dispute
are the questions of the wage scale, the dearness
allowance and the adjustment of existing employees
into the new scales. It appears that from 1946 onwards the Company's workmen have had a consolidated wage scale, no distinction being made between
'
238 SUPRE:ME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
' '>'
1962
Tl~ Hindustan
Tunes
Ltd.• New Delhi
v.
Thier ~Vorkmeit
Da.s Gupta, J.
the basic wage and the de~rness allowance. This
wage scale has remained practically unaltered except
for some special increments· given in the year 1948.
By the award the Tribunal has introduced new wage
scale for certain existing categories. of workmen and
in some . cases .hits. introduced· ne\v. scales, after
amalgamating more than . one· ·category. Thus
certain· railway ; dcspatchers~ .. advertisers, Box No.
and bank,, clerks who
sorters,' filing' clerks
were formerly in the ·scale of Rs. 50-4-!JO-EB-4-115
and Junior Clerks etc.; who had a scale of Rs. 60-100EB-4-115 :have an· been ·put ori."a new scale of
Rs .. 70-5-loo:EB-5-150 .. There has been a similar
·. amalgamaticin of clerks; 'assistants, cashiers,' record
·.keepers and others some of whom were on Rs. 80-175
arid some on Rs. 80-203 scale, all of them· being now
put on a new scale of Rs. !J0-200.. · In both. cases the
starting s'alary has. been· raised;. the.~maximum has
been raised. for·· the first category; Supervisors and
others who were formerly ori three different scales,
some OD Rs. 125·350, some on Rs'. 125-300, and some
ori Rs. 100-250, have allbeen amalgamated and have
been put on a new scale'i:>f Rs. 100-350. Obviously,
this would mean £lower starting salary for some and
maximum for some. Job' Daftries some ofwhom
were on Rs. 70-ll5 scale and others on Rs. 100-155
. have .an been put on. a new scale of Rs. 80 to Rs.1f.5,
resulting thus in a lowering of starting salary for
soine . and a. rise: of a higher maximum for all.
A similar . lowering . in· the . starting salary
has also occurred in cases : of some of the jobmachinemen. They were . formerly on two scales,
one of Rs. 100-175 and the other of Rs. 75-175. The ·
Assistant Foremen. in the Job DepartmentJformerly
on. Rs. 125,175 are put on a scale of Rs.125-202.
\Vhere there has .been. no amalgamation the new
scale has resulted in a slight increase in some cases
· both ·in the starting salary and the maximum. ·In
· some catagories, no change has~ bc;en made at all.
I S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS 239
1962
It is unnecessary to give more details of the
difference between the old scale and the new scale as The Hindustan Tim11
Ddhi
what has been mentioned above is sufficient to indi- Ltd., N1w
v.
cate that there has been some change in favour of the
Thei' Workm1n
workmen, though this change is not much. The
Das Gupta. J.
employer's contention before us is that there was no
case for any revision whatsoever and the Tribunal
acted wrongly in making any change in the old wage
scale. The workmen's contention on the contrary
is that the changes do not go far enough.
The fixation of wage structure is among the
mQst difficult tasks that industrial adjudication has to
tackle. On the one hand not only the demands of
social justice but also the claims of national economy
require that attempts should be made to secure to
workmen a fair share of the national income which
they help to produce, on the other hand, care has to
be taken that the attempt at a fair distribution does
·not tend to dry up the source of the national income
itself. On the one hand, better living conditions for
workmen that can only be possible by giving them a
"living wage" will tend to increase the nation's
wealth and income on the other hand, unreasonable
inroads on the profits of the capitalists might have a
tendency to drive capital away from fruitful employment and even to affect prejudicially capital
formation itself. The rise in prices that often results
from the rise of the workmen's wages may in its turn
affect other members of the community and may
even affect prejwdicially the living conditions of the
workmen themselves. The effect of such a rise in
price on the country's international trade cannot also
be .tlways ignored. Thus numerous complex factors,
some of which are economic and some spring from social philosophy give rise to conflicting considerations
that have to be borne in mind. Nor does the process
of valuation of the numorous factors remain static.
While iuternational movements in the cause of labour
bii.ve for many years influenced · thinking-and
240
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
/J8Z
some· times even judicial thinking-in such matters, in
111 Hirttluslan ·rim1s this country, the emergence of an independent demo.
Ltd., }leco Delhi
cratic India has influenced the matter even more prov.
foundly. GajPndragadkar, J. speaking for the Court
1Mir Workm111
in Standard Vacuum Refining Co., of India v. ft.9
Da.s C11pla, J.
IVorl~men ('), has observed.:-
"In constructing a wage structure in a given case
industrial adjudication does take into account
to some extent considerations of right and
wrong, propriety and improprir.ty, fairness and
unfairness. As the social conscience of the
general community becomes more alive and
active, as the welfare policy of the State takes
a more'l:lynamic form, as the national economy
progresses from stage to stage, and as under the
growing strength of the trade union movement,
collective bargaining enters the field, wage
structure ceases to be a purely arithmetical
problem. Considerations of the financial position of the employer and the state of national
economy have their s•.y. and the requirement~
of a workman living in a civilised and progres·
sive society also come to be recognised.''
In trying to keep true to the two points of social
philosophy and economic necessities which vie for
consideration, industrial adjudica1ion has set for itself
certain standards in the matter of wage fixati•>n. At
the bottom of the ladder, there is the minimum basic
wage which the employer of any industrial labour
must pay in order to be allowed !o continue an
industry. Above this is the fair wage, which may
roughly be said to approximate to the need based
minimum. in the sense of a wage which is "adequate
to cover the normal needs of the average employee
regarded as a human being in a civilised society.''
Above the fair wage is the "livin~ wage" -a wage
"which will maintain the workman in the highest
stale of industrial efficiency, which will enable him to
(I) [1961] S.C.R. 536, 54l.
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
241
provide his family with all the material things which
are needed for their health and physical well-being,
enough to enable him to qualify to discharge his
duties as a citizen." (Cited with approval by
Mr. Justice Gajendragadkar in Standard Vacuum
Company's Case (') from "The living Wage" by
Philip Snowden).
While industrial adjudication will .be happy to
fix a wage structure which would give the workmen
generally a living wage economic considerations
make that only a dream for the future. That is why
the industrial tribunals in this country generally confine their horizon to the target of fixing a fair wage.
But there again, the economic factors have to be
carefully considered. For these reasons, this Court
has repeatedly cmpha,ised the need of considering the
problem on an industry-cum-region basis. and of
giving careful consideration to the ability of the
industry to pay. (Vide Crown Aluminium's Gase (');
the E.rpress Newsp11pers Ltd., Gase (') and the
Lipton's C1~se {').
On an examination of the Tribunal's award as
regards the wage scale, we are satisfied that all the
considerations mentioned above were present in the
mind of the adjudicator and we are of opinion that
there is nothing that would justify us in modifying
the award either in favour of the employer or in
favour of the workmen. lt is stated in the award
that before the Tribunal the Company's representative
desired that a fair wage level within its paying capacity should be evolved though at the time he argued
that existing wage structure is quite fair "looking to
the Company's financial position as well as the comparative rates prevailing in the other concern." The
Tribunal has not accepted 'the Company's contention
that the existing wage structure is fair, though at the
same time it has held that the wage system needs no
such radical change as -alleged by the Union.
(I) [1961] S.C.R. 535, .513.
(3) [191ql
S.C.R. 12.
(21 [1958] S.C.R. 651.
(4) [1959] Supp. 2 S.C.R. 150.
Jg62
Tlr1 Hindustan T m1t
Ltd., New Dalhi
••
Thlfr Workm,r.
DOI 01/114, J.
242
- r..,,,
n. H""""""
1161
IM., N111J Dt/Ai
••
71.v Wor'"""
Dwl Gwplo, 1.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
Mr. Pathak, who appeared before us for the Company, did not seriously suggest that the present wage
structure gives the employees "a fair wage." He
argued generally that no case was made out for any
revision of the wage structure. Such an extreme
proposition has only to be mentioned to deserve
rejection. At the time the Tribunal was dealing
with this question the wage scale of the workmen in
this concern had remained practically unaltered for
almost 12 years-12 years of momentous change
through which social ideas have moved forward in
favour of workmen getting a better share of the
national income; 12 years during which the new India
was born and a Constitution was framed for this new
democracy "to secure to all its citizens, justice, social
and economic and political" and enshrining in its
43rd Article the principle that "the State shall endeavour to secure by suitable legislation or economic
organisation or in any other way to all workers agricultural, industrial or otherwise" among other things
"a living wage and conditions of work ensuring a
decent standard of life and full enjoyment of leisure
and social and cultural opportunities ............ _..... ".
The mere passage of time and these revolutionary
changes would be sufficient to convince any right
thinking man of the need for revision of wage scales
which, on the face of it, were far below the "living
wage" and mostly also be low the "fair wage",
provided the industry could bear the additional
burden. The case for revision becomes irresistible
when one takes into consideratim1 the further fact
that the cost of living rose steeply during this period.
On the basis of 1939 cost as 100, the index for 1946
was 282. By I 958 it had risen to 389. It may be
mentioned that since then· there has be~n a further
rise. Nor can it be seriously suggested that this concern cannot bear the burden of an incrca~ed wage
scale. The Tribunal was, in our opinion, right in
its conclusion that the material on record shows that
the Company has been prospering and has financial
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
243
for
ourselves examined the
stability. We have
balance-sheets and the c>ther materials on the record
and have no hesitation in agreeing with that conclusion. Mr. Pathak's uphill task in the face of these
balance-sheets already on the record to show that
the Company would not be able to bear the burden
of an increased wage scale has been made more
difficult by the discovery that even after the implementation of the award the Company has made large
profits during the years 1959-60, 1960-61 and 1961-62.
It appears that when the Company was given
special leave to appeal to this Court the operation of
the Tribunal's award was stayed only in so far as it
directed the management to pay a_rrears of the wages
determined thereby but the operation of the award
in so far as it related to the payment of wages from
the date of the award was not stayed; and the management was directed to pay to the workmen from
that date wageq in accordance with the wage scale
fixed by the Tribunal by its award under appeal.
The result of this has been that the Tribunal's award
as regards the wage scales has been implemented with
effect from the date of the award and it is possible
for this Court to know how such additional payment
has affected the financial position of the Company.
It appears that after meeting the additional charges
and also after payment of bonus and appropriation
to reserves the net profits for the year 1959-60 rose
to Rs. 8,0i,508/-. For the year 1960-61 these profits
were Rs. 8,44,627/-. For the year 1961-62 the profits
are shown in the balance-sheet as Rs. 59,955/-. That
the Company has been prospering is clear. It has
its own aeroplanes and possesses immovable properties
of considerable value. It has built up good reserves
and inspite of that it has been making good profits.
It is reasonable to think that with the progress of
education in the country and the increasing news
mindedness of the people the future prospects of
the Company are no less bright. On a consideration
1962
The Hindustan Times
Lid., New D1/hi
••
Their Workmtn
D., Gupto, /.
244 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
1962
!ht HindtJs/IJn Tim~J
Ltd., .1\'tw Dtlhi
v.
TMir JVorkmtn
l'c; :.:}ta, J,
of all this, we are clearly of opinion that .~fr. Pathak's
contention that the wage scale fixe<l by the Tribu11al
is too hravy for the Company to bear, must be
rejcctrd.
Equally uuacccptablc is Mr. Pathak 's next
contention that the wage scale fixed by the Tribunal
operates unfavourably un this Comp.my vis-a-vis two
othrr cr,ncerns in Delhi region, viz., the Times of
India, Delhi and the Stat~sman, Delhi. \Ve have
compared th~ \\age scales in tlit»e two concerm \'iz.,
the Times of India, Delhi anrl the Scatcsman, Delhi,
with the wage scale under the award and have for
the purpose of comparison takrn into consideration
the dearness allowance as fixed by the Tribunal.
The comparison shows that while in some cases the
Company (the Hindustan Times) will have to pay
more to its workmen than what is bcin(( paid to workmen of the same c<llcgory by the Times of India,
Delhi and the Statesman, Delhi, in se,·eral cases it
will be less. It has also to be borne in mind that
the Times of India, Delhi and the Statesman, Delhi,
arc much smaller units of the newspaper industry
than the Hindustan Times. These Companies are
mere adjuncts to the Times of Incli.1, Bombay and
the ;:,tatesnian, Calcutta, respectively. Th~reforc,
even if for >ome categories the wage sea le under t be
award is hig-ht~r than that in the Times of India,
Delhi and the Statesman, Delhi, that \\'Ou!d be 110
groun::I for modifying the award in fa\'our of the
Company. We have therefore come to cltr. cunclusion
that there is no ground whatsoever. for murlifying the
wage scale fixe<l by the award m favour of the
Company.
On behalf of the workmen it was strenuouslv
contended that the increase given hy the awar<l O\'~r
the previous wage scale falls far short of justice. It
is pointed out that even the Times of India, Delhi
and the Statesman, Delhi, which ar~ much smaller
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
245
concerns and of lesser financial stability and strength,
pay to some categories of its workmen higher wages
than what has been fixed by the award. Thus our
attention has been drawn to the fact that for Assistants, the Times of India, Delhi, rate is Rs. 241-402,
and in the Statesman, Delhi, it is Rs. 190-297 for
some and Rs. 264-463 for others while under the
award the scale is Rs. 125-375. There are several
other cases also where the wage scale under the award
appear~ to be lower than what is being paid by the
Times of India, Delhi and the Statesman, Delhi.
It has been urged by the learned AttorneyGeneral that in view of the fact that the wage scale
of the Company has remained practically stationary
for the last 12 years and that it is indisputably well
below the fair wage and the further fact that even
smaller concerns in this region, like the Times of
India, Delhi and the ::>tatesman, Delhi, have been
paying more to some categories of its workmen, the
wage scale as fixed by the Tribunal should be raised
at least for some of the categories. There is undoubtedly some force in the contention a'.ld it may be
said that the Tribunal has been rather cautious in the
matter of revision of wage scales. Even so, it has
to be remembered that where, as in the present case,
the proper principles have been applied by the Tribunal, it is not the practice of this Court to interfere,
ordinarily, with details of this nature whcu exercising
its special jurisdiction under Art. 136 of the Constitution. It also appears to us that the very fact that
the Tribunal has been cautious in the matter of raising the wage scales has influenced it in the directions
it has given on the question of adjustment of the
present employees into the wage scale. In this way
some relief has been given to the present employees
which might otherwise have been given by raising the
wage scale. On a consideration of all these facts we
have reached the conclusion that it will not be
1962
The Hindustan Tim1s
Ltd., A'ew Delhi
v.
1'heir ~Vorkmtn
Du G1uita, J.
246 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
' , -~
proper for us to modify - the wage scales fixed by the
Tribunal in favour of the workmen also.
-'1962
'Thi Hilultatan Tim1s
-
Lld., N1w Del/U
••
Thir Workmm
DtU Gupta, J.
On the question of dearness allowance it is not
disputed before us that in the Circumstances of the
present case the Tribunal .icted rightly in awarding
dearness allowance at a flat rate for all categories of
workmen. On behalf of the Company it was however urged that the Tribunal has made an obvious
-mistake_ in_ fixing the amount of dearness allowance
at Rs. 25/-. · -For fixing the rate at Rs. 25/- the Tribunal has said : -
-c-.
\·
- \
"In view of the revised scales as now laid down,
I think the same should further be supplemented in the circumstances stated above by a flat
rate -()f dearness allowance. in all cases: viz.,
-Rs. 25/- with. retrospective_ effect from the date
- of reference so that the-lowest paidworker will
start -not less than Rs. 75/-. I direct accordingly."
- Mr. Pathak points_ out that the _lowest paid worker
_for whom wage scales have been fixed will be getting
under the award a minimum of Rs. 60/- so that with
--the dearness allowance of Rs. 25/- "the lowest paid
- worker" will start at RS .. 85/- and not Rs. 75/-.
- Mr. Pathak.' suggests that the Tribunal has made a
mistake in its calculation's and that having decided
· that the lowest paid worker will start at not less than
Rs .. 75/-, it should have fixed Rs. 15/- and not Rs. 25/- as the dearness allowance. . This argument however
overlooks the _fact that the reference as regards the
dearness allowance was in respect of all categories ·or- workmen, though the -reference as regards scales- of
pay did not cover some categories, i·iz., mazdoors
and canteen boys. They therefore continue to remaln
on their old scale of Rs. 50-3-!'5. When the Tribunal
- -in considering' the question of dearness allowance was
-_ -thinking of the starting pay of the lowest paid worker -
I S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
247
1962
it had obviously these categories in mind. Having
concluded that the lowest paid worker should start Tiu Hindustan 1 imtJ
at Rs. 75/· as the total amount of basic pay and Ltd., JW1 w Delhi
v.
dearness allowance the necessary conclusion reached
Their Workmen
by the Tribunal was that Rs. 25/- should be fixed as
the dearness allowance. It is, in our opinion, proper
Dc.s Gupta, J.
and desiiabre-that the dearness allowance sheu!EI noc
remain fixed at this figure but should be on a sliding
scale. As was pointed out in Workmen of Hindusthan
llfotors v. Hindusthan Motors (1 ), the whole purpose
of dearness allowance being to neutralise a portion
of the increase in the cost of living, it should ordinarily be on a sliding scale and provide for an
increase on rise in the cost of living and a decrease
on a fall in the cost of living. On a copsideration
of all the circumstances of this case, we direct that a
sliding scale be attached to the dearness allowance
of Rs. 25/- per month as awarded by the Tribunal
on the lines that it will be liable to be increased or
decreased on the basis of Re. 1/- for every ten points
in case of rise and fall in the cost ofli ving from the
base of 400, the 1939 index being taken to be 100
the sliding scale to take effect from April I, 1959.
This brings us to the question of adjustment of
1he existing employees into the new scalr. The
Tribunal has dealt with this matter thus :" .. _... the adjustment in the new scales shall be
made with retrospective effect from the date of
the reference, viz., 23rd January, 1958. In
making adjustment in the new scales no one
shall be adversely affected and it shall be on
the line laid down by the Industrial Tribunal
in the case of Caltex India Ltd., 1951 LLJ. 654
at p. 659 read with para. 23 of the decision
of the Labour Appellate Tribunal, reported
in 1952 LLJ. 183 at page 188."
It appears that in the case of Caltex India Ltd.,
(Supra) the Industrial Tribunal, West Bengal, gave
(IJ (1962) 2 L.L.J. 352.
248 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
1~62
1111 llinfu.ilan 11mts
Lttl., .Altw Dtllii
v.
7fitir U'orAmtn
the following directions for adjustment of employers
into the wage scale fixed by it.
"I. All employees for whom the scale has been
stated above should be stepped up in the
stage next above which the present pay is
drawn. A specia 1 increment at the rate of
one increment in the new scale for every
three completed years of service should be
given.
2. The employees whose salaries are less than
the minimum prescribed will be pulled up
to the minimum of the prescribed 5cale.
3. If the existing salary of an employee is
higher than the salary he will be entitled
to under the prcscr!!.Jed scale, there will be
no cut and he will be stepped up to the
nearest increase with the increments given
above.
4. After the salaries are adjusted, no employee
should be staggered and he will continue
to get future increments.
5. If an employee be already drawing a
salary which is higher than the maximum
prescribed by the award, he will be subject·
ed to no cut in his salary."
This was fo:lowed by a direction as regards the date
by which the adjustment was to be made. The
Labour Appellate Tribunal modified these directions
by introducing two provisions : (I) that the maximum
of the grade should not be exceeded and (2) that the
basic wage that was being paid to an ~mployee at
the date of the award of the Tribunal is not to be
affected to the employees' prejudice The employer's
objection is to the provision that a special increment
at the rate of one increment in the new scale for every
l S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
249
1962
three completed years of service should be given. It
is argued that such a provision may well be appro- Thi I!induj/tJn Times
Delhi
priate in a case where wage scale is being fixed for Ltd., New
v.
the first time or where even if there was already a
Their Jt'orhmen
wage scale in force the rate of increment in the new
Das Gupta, J,
scale is much higher than that in the old wage scale,
but not where, as in the present case, the increments
under the new scale and the old scale are practically
the same. We are not impressed by this argument.
As was pointed out by this Court in a recent
judgment in French lliotor Oar Co., Ltd. v. I ts
Workmen (1), what adjustment should be given is to
be decided when fixing wage scales whether for the
first time or in place of an old existing scale has to
be decided by industrial adjudication after consideration of all the circumstances of the case. It may well
be true that in the absence of any special circumstances and adjustment of the nature as allowed in
this case by allowing special increment in the new
scale on the basis of service already rendered may
not be appropriate. Clearly, however, in the present
case the Tribunal took into consideration in deciding
this question of adjustment the fact that it had been
extremely cautious as regards increasing the old wage
scales. Apparently, it thought that it would be fair
to give some relief to the existing employees by means
of such increase by way of adjustme11t while at the
same time not burdening the employer with higher
rates of wages for new incumbents. In these circumstances, we do not see any justification for interfering
with the directions given by the Tribunal in the
matter of adjustment.
It will be convenient to consider at this stage
the objection raised in the Company's appeal to the
Tribunal's direction in connection with the interim
agreement. As has been stated earlier, this agreement was arrived at between the parties when the
dispute was before the Conciliation Officer. The
(I) (1962) 2 L.L.J. 744.
-250 SUPREME COURT REP(lRTS (1964] VOL.
1962
Thi Hilld.u<an Timu
w., N"" D1lhi
v.
Thrir w,,.,m ..
DOJ Gup14, I.
relevant portion
these words :-
of
the
agreement
is
m
"It is hereby agreed between the parties that:1.
The Management agrees to make interim
relief on the following terms to every
employee, excluding working journalists,
drawing salary up to Rs. 400 p. m.
(i)
Advance payment ranging between
Rs. 6/· to Rs. 10/- per month beginn·
ing from the month of November,
1957 in the following manner:(a) Those with annual increment of
Rs. 3/·, Rs. 4/·, and Rs. 5/ ·
Rs. 6/(b) Those with
of Rs. 6/·
annual increment
Rs. 7/-
(c) Those with annual increment
Rs. 8/of Rs. 7/·
(d) Those with annual increment
Rs. 10/ofRs. 10/No#R-.
(i)
In
case any employee has
already reached the ceiling of his
grade, even then he would he
entitled for the above benefit.
(ii) This payment will be adjusted
against the final out-come of the
present demands by constitutional
means."
"The final out-come of the present demands by.
constitutional means" is the Tribunal's award. Under
the agreement therefore what has been received by
r:
1 s.c.R.-
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
251
the workmen as advance payment at Rs. 6/- or Rs. 7/or Rs. 8/- or Rs. IO/- per month as interim relief has
to be adjusted against what is due .to be paid to them
under the award. In other words, the Company is
entitled under the agreement to deduct the payments
made as iuterim relief from what is payable to these
very employees under the award. The Tribunal's
direction that the interim relief shall remain unaffec·
ted is in effect an order that term (ii) of the agreement need not be complied with. We can find no
justification for such an order. While it is true that
industrial adjudication can and often has to modifiy
existing contracts between an employer and its workmen, there can be no justification for modification of
an agreement of this nature pending final settlement
of a dispute. Such a direction that the solemn words
of the workmen's representatives . that interim relief
which may be given will be adjusted against the
relief finally given need not be complied with, is not
only unfair to the employer but is also not calculated
to serve the best interests of the workmen themselves.
For one thing, an order of this nature in one case by
a Tribunal that such an undertaking need not be
carried out is likely to hamper interim settlements
generally; it is also not desirable that workmen should
be encouraged to treat their undertakings as of no
value. Industrial adjudication must be careful not
to encourage bad faith on the part of the workmen or
the employer. A direction as given by the Tribunal
in this case that the term in the agreement that
payments made will be adjusted against the final outcome need not be complied with, is unfortunately to
have such effect on workmen. We therefore set aside
the Tribunal's direction that interim relief will
remain unaffected and direct that adjustments should
be made in terms of the said interim arrangement.
This brings us to the question of Leave Rules.
The Company objects to the award as regards this
matter in so far as it directs the Company to allow 15
1962
Tha Hindwtllll Timu
Liii., N1w D11hi
v.
Their Wor.bru•
Da1 Gupta, J.
252
1962
Thi HiMusl4n Tim1s
Lid., N1w Delhi
v.
Tluir Workmm
D., G•/I 14, J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
day's sick leave with full pay and allowances with
accumulation up to six months on production of
medical certificate given by a registered medical
practitioner. It also objects to the direction that the
present practice as to insistence on previous application for the purpose of casual leave should not be
relaxed in cases where it cannot possibly be so done
in emergent and unforeseen circumstances and the
direction that up to 3 days no medical certificate
should be asked for. It apJJears that at present the
Management grants JO days' casual leave to the
business staff and 7 days' casual leave to all the other
categories and there is no sick leave facility
available.
Mr. Pathak has tried to convince us that in
view of the provisions of the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948, no provision need be made about
sickness leave at al]; That this Act has been applied
to the Company and that the workmen of the Company get the benefit of this Act is not disputed. It is
difficult to see however how the benefit that the workmen will get under this Act can affect the question
of sickness leave being provided for the workmen.
This Act it has to be noticed d0es not provide for
any leave to the workmen on the ground of sickness.
It provides ins. 46 (1) (a) for periodical treatment
of any insured person in case of his sickness if certified
by a duly appointed medical practitioner. It is
unnecessary to mention here the several provisions in
the Act; viz., Sections, 47, 48 and 49 which deal
with the eligibility of workmen for sickness benefit
and the extent of the benefit that may be granted.
Section 56 of the Act provides for medical benefits to
the insured workman or in certain cases to the
members of his family. It appears to us clear however that in providing for periodical payments to an
insured worker in case of sickness (sickness benefit) or
for medical treatmrnt or attendance to him or the
members of his family, the legislature did not intend
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
253
to substitute any of these benefits for the workmen's
right to get leave on full pay on the ground of
sickness.
1962
TM Hindustan Timt1
Ltd., New JJe/hi
y,
Tluir Workmen
It is next contended that the Tribunal's direction as regards sickness leave offend the provisions of
Delhi Shops and Establishments Act, 1954. Admittedly, a large number of workmen covered by the
reference are governed by the provisions as regards
leave under the Delhi Shops and Establishments
Act, 1954. Section 22 of that Act fixes the maximum for sickness or casual leave with wages to a
period of 12 days and further provides that such
leave shall not be accumulated. It is thus clear
that as regards those workmen to whom the Delhi
Shops and Establishments Act, 1954 applies the
Tribunal has acted illegally in fixing the period
of sick leave at 15 days and permitting accumula.tion.
We therefore set aside this direction in the award
.and direct instead that the Company shall allow to
the workmen to whom the Delhi Shops and Establishments Act, 1954 applies, sickness or casual
leave of a total of I 2 days with full
pay
and allowances and that such leave shall not
be accumulated. We are also of opinion that it will
not be right to have two separate leave rules for the
two classes of workmen, one to whom the Delhi Shops
and Establishments Act, 1954 applies and the other
two whom it does not apply. For that is likely to be
a source of much discord and heartburning. Therefore, in respect also of those workmen to whom the
Delhi Shops and E~tablishments Act, 1954 does not
apply, we think that the same period of 12 days in a
year with full pay and allowances should be fixed
for sickness or causal leave, and there should be no
accumultation of such leave; and we direct
accordingly.
We cannot find any ju~tification for the direction
of the Trib:mal that the practice of insistence on
Du Gupta, J.
254 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964] VOL.
previous application for the purpose of casual leave
should be relaxed in cases where it cannot possibly be
TA. Hindiul m Tim1J
so done in emergent and unforeseen circumstances and
Ltd., Ntr.o Dtlhi
v.
that upto 3 days no medical certificate should be
Tlllir Workm,.
asked for. The leave rules of the Company as they
now
stand provide that ordinarily previous permission
DtU GuptA, J.
of the head of the departmtnt and the Establishment
Manager shall be obtained before casual leave
is taken but that when this is not possible due to
sudden illness, the head of the Department or
the Manager as soon as may be practicable should
be informed in writing of the absence from work and
of the probable duration of such absence. In our
opinion, this provision is reasonable and is calculated
to meet the needs of workmen for taking leave without previous permission, in case of emergency. In
these circumstances, the further directions as regards
this that have been given by the Tribunal appear
to us to be unnecessary and are hereby set aside.
1962
On the question of gratuity, the only argument
seriously pressed by Mr. Pathak was that the scheme
as framed by the Tribunal would put undue strain on
the Company'• sources. We have already expressed
our agreement with the Tribunal's conclusion that
the Company's financial resources are strong and
stable and that not only has the Company been prospering in recent years but that its future prospects are
also bright. Therefore, we do not thmk that the
scheme of gratuity as framed by the Tribunal is
unduly favourable to the workmen or that it places
any undue ~train on the Company's financial
resources.
One provision in the gratuity scheme which
ought to be mentioned is that under it an employee
who is dismissed for misconduct shall not be entitled
to any gratuity. It has been pointed out by this
Court in more than one case that having regard to
the natu.re of gratuity it will not b~ proper to deprive
I S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
255
1962
an employee of the gratuity earned by him because
of his dismissal for misconduct and the proper provi- Ti't1 Hindwtan Timu
D1lhi
sion to make in this connection is that where an Ltd., New
v.
T/uir Workemployee is dismissed for misconduct which has
resulted in financial loss to the employer the amount
Das Gupta, J,
lost should be deducted from the amount of gratuity
due. As however in the present case, the workmen
have not appealed against the award as regards the
gratuity scheme framed by the Tribunal, it will not
be proper for us to make the modification as indicated
above.
Coming now to the question of retirement age
on which the workmen have appealed, we find there
is some . controversy· as regards the existing position.
The workmen stated in their written statement
before the Tribunal that "at present there are no set
rules in the Company in this matter." Their claim
was that the retirement age should be fixed at 60 for
all the employees of the Company. According to the
Management's written statement "the existing superannuation system is that the age of retirement is fixed
at 55." The Magagement further stated that the
age ofretirement "as fixed, that is, 55 years" is appropriate and should not be raised. ln respect of this
controversy as rt'gards the existing position there
appears to be little material on the record. From
the appointment letters of some of the employees
that we find on the record it appears that for some
appointments made in 1955 the age of retirement
was mentioned as 55. In the several letters of
appointments made prior to that year no age of
retirement has been mentioned. It is not clear, therefore, how on the question of retirement age the
Tribunal proceeded on the basis that the "existing
retirement" age is 55. Proceeding on this basis the
Tribunal directed "that the existing retirement age
at 55 years should continue but the workers may be
allowed to remain in employment and work up to 60
years if found fit. The question of the further extension
256 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1964J VOL.
1962
should rest with the discretion of the ManageOn behalf of the workmen the learned
Tiu Hindustan Times mcu t."
ltd., Ntw Delhi
Attorney-General has contended that the assumption
that
the existing retirement a5e is 55 is wrong in res·
Tluir U'ork11Un
pect of most of the workmen and that except for a
IJos Gupta, J.
few persons appointed after 1955 no retirement age is
fixed either in the letlers uf appointment or in the
standing orders of the Company. For all these
employees for whom no retirement age has been fixed
already, the leamed Attorney-General argues on the
basis of the decision of this Court in Guest Kun,
Williams Private Ltd., v. P . .J. Sterling., (1) that it
would not be fair to fix any age of superannuation.
It was held in that case that it was unfair to fix the
age of superannuation of previous employees by a
subsequent standing order. The Labour Appellate
Tribunal had held that it would be unreasonable and
unfair to introduce a condition of retirement at the
age of 55 in regard to the prior employees having
regard to the fact that when they entered service
there was no such limitation. This Court felt that it
would not be justified in reversing this decision of the
Labour Appellate Tribunal. Dealing next with the
question whether it followed that there should be no
rule of superannuation in regard to these previous
employees the Court said :
..
"In our opinion it is necessary to fix the age
of superannuation even with regard to the prior
employees, ancl we feel no difficulty in holding
that it would not be unfair or unreasonable to
direct that these employees should retire on
attaining the age of 60. An option to continue
in service even thereafter which the respondent
claimed is wholly unreasonable and is entirely
inconsistent wi~h the notion of fixing the age of
superannuation itself. Once the age of superannuation is fixed it may be open to the
employer for special reasons to continue in its
employm!!nt a workman who has passed that
(!) [t960] I S.C.R. 348.
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
257
1962
age : but it is inconceivable that when the age
of superannuation is fixed it should be in the n. Hinawta• r...,
option of the employee to continue in service Ltd., N1w Dllhi
••
thereafter. We would accordingly hold that in
T1uir Wor.bnen
the circumstances of this case the rule of retireDOI Gu;ta, /,
ment for the previous employees in the concern
should be 60 instead of 55 and that the rule of
55 should apply to all employees who enter the
snvice of the appellant after the relevant
standing orders came into force."
Assuming therefore that for the majority of the
employees there is no existing retirement age it would
on the atithority of the above case, be open to the
Tribunal to fix the age of s11perannuation even with
respect to them. As however the Tribunal's decision
that this age should be 55 is vitiated by the incorrect
assumption that there is an existing retirement age
of 55 it has been necessarv for us to consider the
question .for ourselves. It· appears that before the
Tribunal the Union's representative himself desired
that the retirement age should be fixed at 58 years
which may be extended up to 60 years in fit cases.
Before us the Counsel for the\Company. did not
seriously contest that in consideration of the present
day circumstances in the country it would be fair to
fix the retirement age at 58. Accordingly, we set
aside the Tribunals award on this question of retirement age and fix the age at 58 years, subject to the
proviso that it will be open to the Company to
continue in its employment a workman who has
passed that age. This rule should apply to all the
employees of the Company.
There remains for consideration the question
of retrospective operation of the award. Under s. 17 A
of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, an award
shall · come into operation with effect from
such date as may be specified therein
but
where no date is so specified it shall come into
258 SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1964] VOL.
1961
operation
the date when the a ward becomes
Even without a specific reference
on this question it is open to an indus·
trial tribunal to fix in its discretion a date
from which it shall come into operation. The refc·
rence, in the present case, included as a matter in
dispute the question of retrospective effect in these
words:
011
'1711 HiMJut.. T ""'·' ~nforceable.
L'i., N1w Dtlhi
being made
••
7ltir Worhn1n
Dtu Gupto, J.
"Whether all the above demands shou Id be
made applicable retrospectively with effect
from April I, , 956 and what directions are
necessary in this respect ?"
The Tribunal rejrcted the workmen's claim
for giving . effect to its award from April I 956.
Wherever however the Tribunal has given relief the
Tribunal has directed that the award should come
into effect from
the date of reference, i. e.,
January 23, 1958. On behalf of the Company Mr.
Pathak contends that there is no reason why the
award should be given effect to from any date prior
to the date of its pronouncement. We are not
impressed by this argument . No general formula
can be laid down as to the date from which a
Tribunal should make its award effective. That
question has to be decided by the Tribunal on a
consideration of circumstances of each case. There
have been cases where this Court has made an
award effective from the date when the demand was
first made. There are other cases where the orders
of the Tribunal directing the award to be made
effective from the date of the award has not been
interfered with. It is true that in some cases this
Court has modified the Tribunal's award in such a
case. But it does not appear however that any
general principles have been laid down. Indeed, it
is difficult and not even desirable that this Court
should try to lay down general principles on such
matters that require careful consideration of the
l S.C.R. SUPREME GOUR T REPORTS
259
peculiar circumstances of each case for the exercise
f'f discretion. It is sufficient to say that we find
<10 reason to interfere with the Tribunal's direction
in this case that the reliefs given by it would become
effective from the date of the reference.
1962
The Hindustan Times
Ltd., N1w Delhi
v.
Their Wor~m111
Das Gupta. J
We therefore allow both the appeals in part
by modifying the Tribunal's award as regards
dearness allowance, leave rules and retirement age
and also as regards the adjustment of the interim
relief as mentioned above. In all other matters in
appeal before us the award is confirmed. The modifications made as regards dearness allowance will, as
already stated, take effect from April l, 1959. The
modifications as regards leave rules and as regards
retirement age will take effect from this date. In
both the appeals the parties will bear their own costs.
Appeals allowed in part.
•
OM PRAKASH GUPTA
1962
v.
December, 17
RATTAN SINGH AND ANOTHER
(B. P. SINHA, c. J., P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR,
K. N. WANCHOO, K. C. DAS GUPTA and
J.C. SHAH, JJ.)
Rent Control-Tenant availing benefit-Denyinq relationship-Jurisdiction of Rent Controller-Delhi Rent Control Act
(Act LIX of 1958), '· 15.
The appellant was sought to be evicted by the landlord
on the ground that be had habitually defaulted in the payment
of rent as well as on the ground of the bonafide requirement of
the land-lord for his own occupation. He resisted the suit
inter alia on the ground that the premises had been let to the
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org