THE TRUSTEES OF THE PORT OF MADRAS BY ITS CHAIRMAN versus K. P. V. SHEIK MOHAMED ROWTHER & CO. AND OTHERS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 11 December 1962 | [1963] SUPP. 2 S.C.R. 915 | 1962 INSC 369
Key facts
- Decided
- 11 December 1962
- Bench
- S.K. DAS*, J.L. KAPUR, A.K. SARKAR, M. HIDAYATULLAH, RAGHUBAR DAYAL
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 187/1962
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1963] SUPP. 2 S.C.R. 915
- Neutral citation
- 1962 INSC 369
Text of the judgment
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
915
THE TRUSTEES OF THE PORT OF
MADRAS BY ITS CHAIRMAN
v.
K. P. V. SHEIK MOHAMED ROWTHER
& CO. AND OTHERS
(S. K. DAS, J. L. KAPUR, A. K. SARKAR,
M. HIDAYATULLAH and RAGHUBAR DAYAL, jj.)
Port Trust-Charges to be levied. on steamer agents-Labour
supplied by Port Trust not fully or properly utilised-Rate of
chargea-Liability of consignee-Madras Port Trust Scale of
Rates, 'E' scale-Madras Port Trust Act, 1905 (Mad. 2 of 1905)
88. 39, 40, 42.
In exercise of the powers under s. 42 of the Madras Port
Trust Act, 1905, the Tru•tees of the Port of Mardas, the
appellants, made amendments to the Madras Port Trust Scale
of Rates in 1958. By the amendment, Scale •E' was added
under Ch. V and it was to come into force from March 1,
1958. The scale laid down charges to be paid by Masters,
Owners or Agents of vessels in respect of Port Trust labour
requisitioned and supplied but not fully or properly utilised.
These charges were to be on account of the labour of the Port
Trust rendered idle on account of some lapse on the part of the
ship owners or on account of extra payment to labour for the
simultaneous working of more than one hook at the vessel's
hatch. The labour requisition Form to be submitted by the
steamer-agents was also modified and the new form contained
an undertaking on the part of the steamer-agents for the payment of the charges laid down in Port Trust's scale of rates
from time to time in respect of Jabour rendered idle or not
properly utilised and also for working more than one hook
simultaneously at the hatch. The respondents, the steameragcnts, filed petitions before the High Court ot Madras under
Art. 226 of the Constitution of India, praying for a direction
to the Port Trust not to enforce these rates and not to require
the filling in of the new form, on the grounds, inter alia, (I)
that the ship-owners and the steamer-agents could not be made
liable for charges for short Jabour employed in the receiving or
removal of cargo and such charges must be borne by the
consignee, (2) the Port Trust had power to impose and recover
rates only for services rendered and that they had no right to
jmp<>Se charges by way of compensation for default or to collect
1962
D1"mhlr, JI.
,,-·.
.-~
\
-·-·--- ,- ·-~--~
\<.
1002
916: SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
charges from l\.fasters, O\vners or Agents of vessels in respect of
operations not .properly falling under the head of discharge of
The Trust us of
t!u Porl of Ma.tiras "cargo from the vessel, (3) the compulsion imposed on steamer
v.
agents in the matter of the scale •E' rates and in respect of the
K.P.Y. SJui!; Mohd. signing of the requisition for shore labour \Va'I outsid~ the
Rowthn fl Co.
- authority conferred by law and was illegal, and (4) such imposi·
tion --,vhether ·as charges for services or as compensation for
default of steamer agents was an unreasonable restriction on the
fundamental right of the petitioners to carry on business as
steamer-agents a~d Was inoperative in law.
_ Held : (I) The object. behind the scale •E' rates was to
expedite the discharge of the cargo at the quay and thus to
enable a quantity of cargo to be discharged quickly. The
services rende1ed by the Port Trust were therefore services to
the ship and, consequently, charges_ for them could be validity
realised from the steamer-agents.
-(2) The Madras Port Trust Act, 1905, did not contain
any provision \vhich \Vould constitute -the Port
Tru~t
an agent
of the consignee for the purpo;e of the taking delivery of the
- goods and the expression "receiving" in cl. (b) of sub-s. (I) of
s. 39 of the Act did not mean receiving the goods on behalf of
the C'onsignee.
(3) Under ss. 39 and 40 the Port Trust took charge of
the goods on behalf of the ship-owner and not on behalf of the
consignee, and whatever ·services it performed at the time of
-- --the landing of the goods -or on their removal thereafter, were
services rendered to the ship.
- -- (4) The impugned charges were rightly levied by
scale •E' on the Master, Owner or Agent of the vessels and that
the Port Trust could validly insist on the steamer-agent requisitioning the shore-labour to express an undertaking in the form
for requisitioning labour that he \vould p.iy the charges laid
clown in the Port Trust's scale of rates from time to time in
respect of labour rendered idle or not properly utilised and also
·for \vorking more than one hook simultaneously at a vessel's
hatch.·
•
Case Ja\V re" ic\ved. --
C1v1L-APPELLATEjumsnrcTION; Civil Appeals
Nos. 187 to l\ll of l!J62.
Appeals from the judgment and order dated
l\1arch 3 l!J61 of the l\Iadras High Court in Writ
Appeal Nos. 53, M, 55, 56, and 57of1960,
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
917
M. 0. Sewl-vad., Attorney-General for India,
Visw.Jnatha Sc'stri, R. Gc-,,nc,pathy Iyer,
V. V. Raghavan and. G. Gopul(if;,i'islman, · for the
appellants.
A. V.
S. T. Desai and P. Ram Reddy,
for
the
1961
Tli1 Twsltts of
the p~, t of 1\fadr11s
v.
K.P.V. Sheik Mohd.
R~ii!lher & Co.
respondents.
1962. December 11.
Court was deli vcn~d by
RAGHUBAR DAY.AI~,
The Judgment of the
J.-The appellants, the
Trustees of the 11ort of Madras, hereinafter called
the Board, appeal ag.1inst the order of the High
Court of Madras allowing the writ petitions filed
under Art. 226 of the Constitution by each of the
respondents and issuing a writ of mandamus directing the appellants to forbear from enforcing the
scale 'E' rates of the Madras Port Trust Scale of
Rates and from requiring the signing of the Shore
Labour Requisition Form from the steamer agent.
The respondents, who arc
either partnership
firms or limited companies, carry on the business of
steamer agents at :Madras. The Board, with the
sanction of the Central Government, made amend·
ments to the Madras Port Trust Scale of Rates in
1958. By the amendment, scale 'E' was added
under Chapter V. It was to come into force from
March 1, 1958. The scale laid down charges to be
paid by masters, owners or agents of vessels in re·
spect of Port Trust labour requisitioned and supplied
but not fully or properly utilised. The charges, for
the sake of brevity, may be said to be on account of
the labour of the Port Trust, Madras, rendered idle
on account of some lapse on the part of the ship·
owners or on account of · extra payment to labour
for the simultaneous working of more than one ho0k
at the vessel's hatch. The labour requisition Form
to be submitted by the steamer-agents was also
modified and the new form contained an undertaking
Raghuhr D,,yal, J.
918 SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963] SUPP.
1962
on the part of the steamer-agents for the payment
of
the charges laid down in the Board's scale of rates
Thi Trustees of
th1 Porl of Madras
from time to time in respect of labour rendered idle
v.
K.l'.P. Sluik Mohd. or not properly utilised and also for working more
Rowlk1r & Co.
than one hook simultaneously at the hatch. These
amendments in the scale of rates were made by the
Ra:;hu/Jar Dayal, /,
Board in the exercise of its power under s. 42 of the
Madras Port Trust Act, 1905 (Mad. Act II of 1905),
hereinafter called the Act. This section empowers
the Board to frame a scale of rates at which and a
statement of the conditions under which any of the
services specified in the various clause~ of the section
shall be performed by the Board or by a person to
whom any service has been relinquished under
s. 41-A of the Act. Thereafter, the respondents, viz.,
the steamer-agents, filed petitions under Art. 226 of
the Constitution, in the High Court of Madras, and
prayed for the issue of a writ of mandamus directing
the Board not to enforce these rates and not to require the filling in of the new form. They contended that (I) the ship-owners and the steamer-agents
cannot be made liable for charges for shore labour
employed in the receiving or removal of,car~o and
such charges must be home by the consignee ;
(II) s. 39 of the Act provided for the performance of
services by the Board and the other sections provided
for the imposition and recovery of rates for the
services performed for the vessel and services performed for the goods. Services in the former category are to be paid for on behalf of the carrier i. e.,
by the master, ship-owner or the steamer-agent, and
the services in the latter category constitute a liability on the consignee ; (iii) the Board has power to
impose and recover rates only for services rendered
and that they have no right to impose charp; es by
way of compensation for default or to collect charges
from masters, owners or agents of vessels in respect
of operations not properly fallin~ under . the h ead
of discharge of cargo from the vessel ; (iv) prior
to 1914, the steamer-agents acted as landing-agents
2 $.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
919
for removing cargo from ship to pier and collected
for these services from the consignees a separate charge
known as 'landing charge' in addition to the freight.
When the quays were constructed and cargo came
to be landed there, the Board took over the landing
of goods and collected quay dues instead of 'landin~
charges' which wrre wholly paid by the consignees.
These quay dues later on merged in the 'harbour
dues' collected by the Board from the consignees ;
(v) usually, the steamer agent informs the Traffic
Manager the probable date of arrival of the vessel
under his agency, tonnage hatch-wise of cagro to
be landed at Madras and the number of hatches
proposed to be worked. Under the revised procedure
adopted by the Board on August I, 1957, before a
ship has reached its berth, the steamer agent is required to make an application and a deposit in his
current account to cover charges for the working of
the vessel in respect of overtime, supply of cranes,
water and appliances and from l\Iarch I, 1958, to
meet the scale 'E' contingencies also ; (vi) the opera·
tion which goes on at the quay is described thus :
After the Port Trust pilot brings the vessel to the
berth alloted to her :
"The stevedore labour su pplicd by the Madras
Dock Labour Board, a statutory body, board
the vessel, prepare the slings in the holds or
hatches, work the ship's winches and the cargo
is hoisted on the quayside. When the sling
rests on the shore or in the barge in the case
of discharge at moorings, the shore labour
unsling the cargo and the Trust's Tally Clerk
notes the items in a tally sheet. As each sheet
is closed a duplicate copy of the import tally
sheet is given to the steamer agent's rcpresen·
tativc on the spot. This duplicate copy is the re·
ceipt prescribed under section 39 (3) of the
Madras Port Trust Act ...... The shore labour
remove the cargo from the point of landing
Jfi2
The Trustees ef
Ike l'Mt ef Mafirc.s
~-
E.l'.V. Sheik Mohd.
lt.1wtlur & Co.
llqhuJ«t D1y«l, J.
920 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963) SUPP.
1962
Tiie Trustees of
the Port ef lvladraJ
v.
K.P.V. Sheik Mohd.
Rowther & Co.
Ro:liubar Do.ya!, J,
to the shed or open for stacking and subsequent delivery of the goods from the
Trust to the consignee. The consignee obtains
delivery order from tl1e Steamer agent and
then files Harbour Import Application with
the Trust for payment of Harbour dues and
Bill of Entry with the Customs for the duty
payable by him. On payment of the duty and
the harbour dues by the consignee the cargo
is delivered to him by the Trust."
(vii) The Board adopted the piece-rate scheme for the
Dock workers in pursuance of the report of the
Jeejeebhoy Committee and the new scale 'E' rates
arc a part of such a scheme. (viii) Prior to March l;
l!J58, the cost of shore· labour was met entirely by the
Port Trust. No distinction was made between the
charges for shore labour in ordinary cases and charges
for shore-labour in respect of idle time or additional
work. (ix) Under the scheme which was brought
into force on March 1, 1958, charges for shore labour
in the contingencies covered by the scale 'E' have been
excluded from Harbour dues. These charges are now
treated as charges for which the steamer-agent is
made responsible. (x) The compulsion imposed on
steamer agents in the· matter of payment of the scale
•E' rates and in respect of the signing of the requisition
for shore labour is outside the authority conferred by
law on the trustees of the Port of Madras and is illegal.
Such an imposition whether as charges for services or
as compensation for default of steamer agents is
illegal and an unreasonable restriction on the fundamental right of the petitioners to carry on business as
steamer agents and is inoperative in law. (xi) the
Port Trust authorities receiving goods on the quay or
in the barge at moorings, do so on behalf of the
consignee.
The Board, by the common counter-affidavit
filed on its behalf by the Deputy Traffic Manager of the
-
~
2 S.C.R.
--- ..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
921
Madras Port Trust, admitted the direct arrangements
between the ship-owner, master, or agent with the
stevedores but <lid not accept the allegations about
the nature of the various rates and duties levied and
the legal position as stated in the petitions. According tu the lloard, (i} the Harbour clues on the import
cargo under scale A, Chapter 11 of the Scale of
Rates, are payable on ·tonnage and include, beside
overhead, a nominal rent for storage for a specified
period etc., and the item of charges for porterage involved in moving the goods from the landing point to
the storage or stacking point. (ii) It is not correct
that the ship owner has nothing to do with the import
cargo after it h<1s been landed by the stevedores at
the lauding point on the quay, as the ship-owucr iu
each case by the bill of lading has to deliver the
goods lo the consignee named in the bill of ladiug or
his nominee and he remains liable under his contract
until he has delivered the goods to the person who
is entitled to take delivery of the goods. (iii) Under
s. 39 of the Act the Port Trust gives facilities and
undertakes certain services. One of such services is
the moving of the goods from the landing point to the
storage or stacking point and thereafter delivering the
goods to the persons entitled under the bill of lading.
The Board does not undertake the unloading of the
goods from the ship to the quay. The ship·owner
makes his own arrangements through the stevedores,
though the Board is authorised to undertake such
services on behalf of the ship·owncr. It is a service
to the ship-owner by the Board to give the ship-owner
a receipt for the goods to keep them in custody and
deliver to the consignee. The services undertaken in
respect of the import cargo till they have been moved
to the storage or stacking point arc services to the
ship-owner for which the ship-owner or master or
steamer agent is primarily liable and the charges
may properly and legally be levied from them.
(iv) The Board collects the harbour dues from the
consignee at the time of giving delivery, but in fact
1962
Tk1 Trustees of
th~ Port of Jladras
v.
K.P.V. Sheik Mohd.
Rowtlr.1r & Co.
Ra1llubar D1v•ol, J.
922 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963) SUPP.
1962
Tiu Trustees of
tlu Port of Majras
Y.
Ir.P.V. M<ik Mohd.
Rowther & Co.
Roghu.bar Dayal, J.
makes that collection as agent of the ship·owner,
master, steamer agent who are primarily the persons
liable for the dues. (v) The Board is entitled to
collect the harbour dues from the ship-owner, master
or steamer agent. (vi) The issuance of a receipt to
the master at the landing point is a mere matter of
convenience for betokening the fact that the goods
have been handed over to the Port Trust for removal,
storage and delivery and docs not in any way detract
from the fact that the subsequent services are facilities
and services rendered to the ship-owner in respect of
the goods which are the subject of contract of carriage by the ship-owner. (vii) The past practice had
been for the agents to inform the Board about the
shore labour which would be necessary for moving
the goods in respect of each steamer. Prior to 1956,
this was done orally and then the Form was introduced which contains the same particulars except
the undertaking to pay the scale 'E' charges as the
impugned Form now contains. Since the enforcement of the new piece-rate scheme, the payment to
labour was not based on tonnage but a daily wage
was fixed along With a provision for payment for
idle time and hook allowance for working two or
three hooks simultaneously at a vessel's hatch.
(viii) The proper utilisation of the time of the
labour depends upon the steamer agents first giving
a proper anticipation and shift at which they were to
be put on the job being the time when the cargo will
be ready for removal and, secondly, there giving a
continuous supply of cargo for removal so that there
is no gap in the work. (ix) The levy of multiple
hook allowance against the steamer agents is a facility
to the ship to discharge fast and sail quicker. When
two or more hooks work in a ship's hatch, the gangs
handling cargo will not be in a position to handle
more cargo and therefore the approval of Board was
obtained for payment of an allowance to compensate
such loss in their earnings. As working of additional
hooks in a vessel's hatch benefits the ship, the
..
-
.---
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
923
recovery of hook al\o_wanceJrom the steamer agents
under scale 'E' is legitimate. (x) The additional
charge made under scale 'E' is a charge in respect of
facilities afforded to and services undertaken on
behalf of the ship-owner, master, agent by the Board
in relation to the cargo which is under contract of
carriage by them, in the same way as harbour dues.
To understand the exact nature of the impu··
gned charges, it is necessary to quote the scale 'E'
charges to which objection is taken :
SCALE E-Charges Against Masters, Owners, or
Agents of Vessels in respect of Port Trust Labour
requisitioned and supplied but not fully or properly
utilised
Item Classification for purposes
of this Scale
no.
Charges Payable
1. Port
Trust Mazdoors
rendered idle on account
of the breakdown of ship's
winche3, wrigging of ship's
derricks, shifting of cranes
at the request of the
steamer agents or stevedores, cargo not being
ready for shipment, completion of loading and/or
unloading before the end
of the shift, late arrival
of vessel at the "berth or
for any other reason which
is attributable to the vessel
and is beyond the control
of the workmen.
64 nP. per mazdoor per hour in
the case of 8 hr.
shifts and at 80
nP. per hour in
the case of 6~ hr.
shifts.
Note : Idle time will be calculated as follows :
1962
T1u Tnutees oJ
IM Part ef Madras
••
K.P.V. Sheik Mohd.
Rowtlur & Co.
llaglw6.r Dq)'a/, J.
924 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1969) SUPP.
1962
Thi Trustees of,,,, Port of Madras
v.
lf.P. V. Sheik Mohd.
Rowther & Co.
Raghu/Jar D1Jyal, J.
Item Classification for purposes
of this Scale
no.
Any continuous stoppage
of work of 15 minutes or
under shall be ignored and
any continuous stoepage
in excess of 15 mmutes
and up to 30 minutes shall
be counted as 30 minutes.
If the said continuous
stoppage continues
in
excess of 30 minutes the
actual excess rounded off
to the next quarter will be
calculated as idle time.
For example, if there is
continuous stoppage for 35
minutes, the idle time will
be calculated as 45 minutes.
Charges Payable
Port Trust Mazdoors sent
away or not required after
shore work shall have
commenced at the start of
each shift.
Rs. 5 per mazdoor
per shift or part
thereof, or Rs.
2.50 per half shift
or part thereof.
2.
1
Allowances for working Rs. 1.25 for each
of two hooks simultane- mazdoor (Madras
ously at a vessel's hatch.
Port Trust Shore
Mazdoor) employed at the hooks.
4. Allowances for working of Rs. l.fl6 for each
more than two hooks Madras Port Trust ·
simultaneously at a vessel's Shore
Mazdoor
hatch.
employfd at the
hooks. •
3.
N. B.-One hour's clear notice in writing must be
given of cancellation of labour requisitioned
-
2 S.C.R.
SUPRE~E COURT REPORTS
925
for work at hooks. If cancellation orders are
not received in time, charges will be levied for
the full period requisitioned.
Note : The above amendment will take effe~t from
the date of Introduction of the Piece-Rate
Scheme, viz., March 1, 1958.
Sd/-etc.
A circular Ex:hibit-B was issued by the Board
all the steamer agents on February 25, 1958,
explaining ,the features of the Piece-Rate Scheme for
Dock and Stevedore works for the Port of Madras.
The Board emphasized that the Piece-Rate Scheme
was formulated to increase the out-turn of vessels and
sought the cooperation of the steamer agents and the
stevedores in the implementation of the scheme and
making it a success.
to
--~
The salient features of the scheme in respect
of payment of wages to the workers show that, under
the scheme, the worker is assured of a minimum daily
wage and that, the actual earnings· for a day really
depend on his output per shift, they being linked with
productivity. A gang of workers consists of one
maistri and 14 workers. They handle the goods at
a particular point, say a hook. Datum lines have
been fixed for different kinds of cargo per hook per
shift. •Datum lines' means the 'standard output' of
th~ work to be performed by a gang in a particular
hook during a shift. The output is calculated in
deadweight tons. Thus a daily wage rate as well
as a wage ri.te for standard output have been fixed
for all categories of workers who have been classified
in five categories, one of which is the Port Trust
Shore Labour. If the workers produce more than
the datum lines, they are entitled to the increased
wage rate. There is steady increase in the earnings .
1962
The Trusl•ts of
lhe Port of Afadras
"·
K.P.V. Sluik Mohd.
Rowther & Co.
Raglwbar Dayal, J.
926 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
1962
if the output exceeds the 100% of the datum tonnage
Tn. T rust1u ef
th< Port of Madta
and at 150% the worker gets twice his daily wage
rate and at 200% the piece rate wage is thrice the
daily wage rate.
...
K.P.V. Sheik Mohd.
Rowlher & Co.
Ra1hubiJ1 Dayal, ,I.
These features of the scheme sufficiently indicate the significance of 'idle time' for the workers.
If, during a shift, the workers are not actually
employed on the job for which they are engaged and
have to remain idle, their output of work during that
shift, on the basis of tonnage, is bound to be less and,
consequently, their earnings would be less than what
they could be if they had been continuously employed
during the shift. To compensate such loss in earnings
due to the time of the workers remaining unemployed
idle allowance is granted for such time during which
the workers are rendered idle for reasons beyond their
control for periods in excess of 15 minutes. The
circular shows that idle allowance is paid at the daily
wage rate for the following reasons :
{i) breakdown of cranes or winches.
(ii) shifting of quay cranes or rigging of ship's
derricks.
(iii)
cargo not ready for shipment
(iv) late arrival of vessels at the berth
(v)
completion of loading and/or unloading
before the end of the shift
(vi)
actual rain-time during shift working
hours, and
(vii)
any other reason beyond the control of the
workmen except slow work on the part of
the workmen covered by this scheme.
Item No. I of scale 'E' charges makes the idle
nos. (ii) to {v) and f9r
~llowances! for reasons
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
927
breakdown of ship's winches mentioned in reason (i),
chargeable agaimt masters, owners or agents of
vessels who control matters giving rise to those
reasons.
1962
Thi Tru.fte1J of
tlu Porl of MadrtJs
••
K.P.V. S.ilik Mohd.
Rowthtr & Co.
The workers are also paid multiple hook allowance. They are entitled to 'hook allowance' at the
rate of I/4th of the daily wage if two hooks work
simultaneously at a hatch and I/3rd of the daily
wage, if more than 2 hooks work at a hatch. One
gang of workers handle goods at one point, i.e., at
one hook. If several hooks are simultaneously worked at the vessel's hatch, an equal number of gangs of
workers will be employed to handle the goods. The
result is that the output per gang is proportionately
reduced and consequently its earnings are reduced.
There may be further reduction in earnings "if the
cargo is discharged during half-shift. It is to com·
pensate such losses that under the piece-rate scheme,
the workers are paid hook allowance.
The simultaneous working of more than one
hook at the hatch of a ship helps the ship to discharge
cargo fast and sail away quicker. The hook allowance is charged against the master, and steamer
agents of the ship as the working of additional hooks
benefits the ship.
The writ petitions were disposed of by a learned
Single Judge of the High Court. He dismissed them
holding that the liability to pay the charges, being
for services rendered, the charges could be imposed
only on the person to whom that service is rendered,
that the entrustment of the __ goods to the Board .is by
the shipping agent. though the entrustment is for ultimate delivery of the goods to the consignees and that
the serVice is rendered to the shipping agent even
though the consignee also benefits by that service and
it was not nece1JSary for imposing the liability thai
R•1luhar Dapl, J.
928 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963) SUPP.
1962
Tht Truslets oJ
!lit Fart of Madru.r
v.
K.P.V. Slilik Moh •
Rowthn & Co.
l/aghuhM Dayrl, J.
the shipping agent must exclusively benefit from the
service rendered.
On appeal, the appellate Bench reversed the
order, allowed the petitions and issued a writ of
mandamus as prayed. It held that the Board had no
authority to introduce the new scale 'E' rates payable
by the master, owner or agent of the vessel, that the
ship·owner's liability ends when the goods had been
put over the rail of the ship and from the moment
the goods are put within the reach of the Board
employees to take charge of them and tally clerk
passes the receipt on behalf of the Board. The
services in respect of which the new charges are
sought to be levied cannot be deemed to be services
rendered to the master, owner or agPnt of the vessel.
They must be deerned to be services rendered to the
consignee. The purpose of the requisition by the
steamer agent was really to avoid delay and conse·
quent congestion and, generally, for the convenience
of the Board. The requisition must be treated as one
on behalf of the consignees because it is not part of
the duty of the steamer agents to take delivery.
The contentions raised before us for the parties
are the same as were urged in the Courts below and
will be mentioned when dealt with later.
Before we deal with the contentions of the
parties, we may refer to the various provisions of law
having a bearing on the question before us. Clause (7)
of s. 5 of the Act states that 'owner', when used in
relation to goods, includes any consignor, consignee,
shipper .or agent for the sale, custody, loading or unloading of such goods. Section 39 provides for the
performance of services by the Board and reads:
" ( 1) The Board shall, according to its powers,
provide all rea~onable facilities for and shall
have power to undertake the following services:-(a) landing, shipping, or transhipping
1
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
929
passengers and goods between vessels in the port
and the wharves, piers, quays or docks in possession of the Board;
(b) receiving, removing, shifting, transporting,
storing or delivering goods brought within the
Board's premises;
(c) carrying passengers by rail, tramway or
otherwise within the limits of the port, subject
to such restrictions and conditions as the Central
Government may see fit to impose; and
(d) receiving and delivering, transporting and
booking and despatching goods originating in
the vessels in the port and intended for carriage
by the neighbouring railways, or vice verse, as a
railway company or administration under the
Indian Railways Act, 1~90.
(2) The Board shall, if so required by the
owner, perform in respect of goods all or any
of the services mentioned in clauses (a), (b),
and (d) of sub-section (1), provided that the
Board shall not be bound to perform any service
which it has relinquished under the provisions
of clause (a) of sub-section (1) of section 41-A.
(3) The Board shall, if required, take charge of
the goods for the purpose of performing the
service and shall give a receipt in the form and
to the effect prescribed from time to time by
the Central Government.
After any goods have been taken charge of
and a receipt given for them under this section
no liability for any loss or damage which may
occur to them shall attach to any person to
whom a receipt shall have been given or to the
1962
Th• Trustm qf
tlz• Port of Madru
v.
' K.P. V. Shlik Mo~.
Rowtlur l!f Co.
&g/.,bat DaJOI, I
930 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUP!'.
IHI
7ltTnul#1~
llu P.n ef Momo.r
v.
K.P.V. Sivik Moh".
&wthn ffJ c•.
master or the owner of the vessel from which
the goods have been landed or transhipped."
Section 40 laying down the responsibility of the
Board for loss etc., of goods reads:
R(lhui• Dlf1'l, J.
"(1) The responsibility of the Board for the loss,
destruction or deterioration of goods of which it
has taken charge shall, subject to the other
provisions of this Act and subject also in the
case of goods received for carriage by railway
to the provisions of the Indian Railways
Act, 1890, be that of a bailee under sections 151,
152 and 161 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872,
omitting the words 'in the absence of any
special contract' in section 152 of the last-mentioned Act. Provided that, till the receipt
mentioned in su b·section (3) of section 39 is
given by the Board, the goods shall be at the
risk of the owner.
'
(2) The Board shall not be in any way responsi·
hie for loss of or damage to goods of which it
has taken charge, unless notice of such loss or
damage shall have been given within one month
of the date of the receipt given for the goods
under sub-section (3) of section 39."
Section 41-A deals with relinquishment of services
subject to the control of the Central Government and
sub-s. (1) of s. 41 provides that any person to whom
any or all of the services under els. (a) and (b)
of sub·s. (1) of s. 39 has or have been relinquished
under s. 41 ·A, shall, if so required by the owner,
perform in respect of goods any of the services so
relinquished and for that purpose take charge of the
goods and give a receipt in the form and to the effect
prescribed from time to time by the Central
Government.
I
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
931
Section 42 which deals with the scale of rates,
reads:
"The Board shall frame a scale of rates at
which and a statement of the conditions under
which any of the services specified hereunder
shall be performed by itself or by a person to
whom any service has been relinquished under
section 41-A or partly by one and partly by the
other:(a) Transhipping of passengers
between vessels in "the harbour;
or
good11
(b) landing and shipping of passengers or goods
from or to such vessels to or from any wharf,
quay, pier, dock, land or building in the possession or occupation of the Board or at any place
within the limits of the port;
(c) cranage or porterage or goods on any such
place;
(rl) wharfage, storage or demurrage or goods on
any such place;
--
(e) any other service in respect of vessels,
passengers or goods excepting the services in
respect of vessels for which fees are chargeable
under the Indian Ports Act, 1908 (XV
of 1908)."
Section 44 provides that every scale and every state·
ment of conditions framed by the Board under ss. 42,
43 or 43-A shall be submitted to the Central Government for sanction, and when sanctioned and published, will have the force of law. Sections 45 and
46 provide for the enhancement or the rates by the
Board and the Central Go\-ernment, if the Board fails
to do so, respectively.
1962
Tiu Trust111 of
tlu Porl qf Madra1
••
E.P.V. Sluik Molrd.
Rowtlur l!I Co.
932 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
1962
Tli• Trustm of
tM
of Madras
p.,,
v.
lf.P.V. Sluik Mohd.
Rowth11 I'!! Co.
Section 50 provides that the rates in respect of
goods to be landed shall be payable immediately on
the landing of the goods and those in respect of goods
to be removed from the premises of the Board, or to
be shipped for export, or transhipped, shall be payable before the goods are removed or shipped or tran·
shipped. Section 51 gives the Board a lien on the
goods for the amount of the rates leviable under the
Act in respect of any goods and for the rent due to
the Board on any buildings etc., in which those goods
had been ·placed. Section 52 provides for the
priority of this lien of the Board over certain other
liens and claims. Section 53 provides for the preservation of lien for freight or other charges including
landing charges payable to the ship-owner after the
goods are landed and the lien for freight or charges
takes priority over the aforesaid lien of the Board.
Section 54 provides for the retention of such goods in
the custody of the Board at the risk and expense of
the owners of the said goods until such lien is discharged and also provides that the godown or storage
rent would be payable by the party entitled to such
goods for tfie time during which they may be so
retained.
Section 56 provides for the sale of goods after
two months if rates or rents are not paid or lien for
freight is not discharged. Section 57 provides for
the publication of the notice for sale in the case of
perishable goods in the custody of the Board, in the
Gazette and section 58 provides for giving notice to
the owner of the goods of his address is known.
Section 59 provides as to how the sale proceeds are
to be applied. It is to be applied in the payment of
the expenses of sale in payment of the liens and
claims excepted in s. 52 from the priority of the lien
of the Board and in payment of the rates and expenses of landing, removing, storing or warehousing
the same, and of all other charges due to the Board
in respect thereof.
'
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
933
The Board framed by-laws in exercise of the
powers conferred by s. 95 of the Act. By-law no. 2
provides for the regulation of admission to the
harbour premises by means of permits etc. ·They
are to be issued to such of the public as have business to transact within the premises in somewise
connected with the purposes, services or works of the
harbour. By-law no. 3 provides that the master,
owner or the agent of a vessel carrying cargo for discharge at the Port of Madras shall furnish the Traffic
Manager, Port Trust, within not less than six clear
working days a true copy of the complete Import
General Manifest before being permitted to break
bulk. The manifest is to show full details of each
consignment manifested, including litreage in the
case of liquids in bulk and gross weight in kilos in
other cases. Non,submission of such manifests within the stipulated time may result in the vessel concerned not being permitted to break bulk.
!
By-law no. 4 provides that no goods may be
landed or shipped except at places appointed by the
Port Trust for each class of cargo. By-law 4-A provides that if any vessel discharges upon any wharf
or property of the Port Trust any cargo in such a
rotten condition as to be a nuisance or injurious or
dangerous to health, the Traffic Manager, Port
"'' Trust, may require the consignee thereof or if the
consignee should disclaim, deny or dispute the consignment or decline all responsibility for the same or
if there should be no consignee, the owner, master or
agent of the vessel from which the same had been
discharged, to forthwith cause the said cargo or goods
or substance to be removed from the property of the
Port Trust and, on the failure of such persons to have
the goods removed, ·to have the removal effected by
the Traffic Manager in such manner as he may think
fit, or cause the same to be destroyed, and to demand
the expenses incurred from the said consignee or the
said master, owner or agent as the case may be.
1962
TM Trusl11s oj
•.
IM Port of Madras
K.P.V. Sheik Mohd,
Rowther & Co.
&ghu!Jar D<!J!ol, J.
934 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
/!J62
Th• Trrute1s of
IA1 Port of Madras
v.
K.Y.P. Slllik MoM.
Rowtlw& Co.
&ihubar Dqyal, J.
By-law no. 5 provides that when the Port Trust
undertakes the reception, removal, porterage or
storage of cargo under s. 39 of the Act, it shall deliver
it or permit its shipment after all dues shall have been
paid and that in the case of cargo of which the Port
Trust does not elect to undertake such services, no
steamer agent, shipper or consignee may remove any
part of such cargo from the harbour premises until
authorised by the Port Trust so to do after dues shall
have been paid. By-law no. 6 provides that harbour
dues on goods landed, together with any other charges
incurred under the Port Tmst Scale of Rates, shall
be paid before removal of the goods from the harbour
premises. By-law no. 7 provides that all applications
for permission to export or import goods shall be on
approved forms and that such forms shall be filled in
and signed by the shipper or consignee of the goods or
by his agent.
We may also refer to the Manual of Instructions
issued by the Board for the Traffic Department.
Mr. Desai has urged that the Manual should not
be looked into as it is not part of the record. Strictly,
this is correct, but whatever extra is contained in the
instructions is really amplification or explanation of
facts already on record, in the affidavit and the
common counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the parties.
We can look at the manual of instructions for this
purpose. The instructions provide that agents of vessels
will inform the Traffic Manager of the probable date
of arrival of their steamers and that the Traffic Manager will p.ote his requirements for a quay or a mooring
berth on such notice. Instruction no. 3 states that the
authority from the steamer agents as bailors to the
Trust as bailee to deliver goods may take the form of
an endorsement by the steamer agents on the bill of
lading and that a bill of lading presented without
the steamer agent's endorsement cannot be accepted.
Instruction no. 4 deals with the tally sheet and is in
these terms :
-
\
.A.
"='
2 S.C.R.
~
(
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
935
"The Form. prescribed by the Loca,l Government under section 39(3) of the Madras P&rt
Trust Act for cargo landed into the custody of
the Port Trust. The original copy serves the
Trust as its record. The duplicate copy, the
prescribed receipt, is handed to the tenderer
immediately the form has been entered up with
the marks, numbers, description (as far as
possible) and other particulars, such as outward
condition of each individual package and signed
by a Port Trust Tally Checker. Great care
must be exercised in entering up Tally Sheets
as they are the only records for the settlement
of claims between the tenderer and the Port
Trust and contribute largely towards smooth
working. Tally sheets are kept in the Traffic
Sections for 28 days after the departure of a
vessel and are then filed in the Application
Section in the Office of the Assistant Traffic
Manager (Shipping).
x"
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
Instruction No. 5 deals with receipting and provides :
"As each tally sheet which is prepared in duplicate with carbon paper is completely filled in,
it should .be signed by the Port Trust Tally
Checker and the Steamer Agent's representative
and the duplicate copy should be handed over
to the latter on the spot. This constituted the
receipt under s. 39(3) of the Act."
Instruction no. 26 states that the Trust grants delivery
of cargo on the authority of delivery orders granted
by the steamer agents as bailors. This authority may
take the form of an endorsement by the bailor on the
bill of Jading or a separate delivery order on the
Trust issued by the bailor.
It is to be noticed from the various provisions of
the Act that they do not make it obligatory on the
1962
Tiii Truste1s ~f
tlz1 PMI ef Madras
••
K.P.V. SAlik Mthi.
RowthM & Co.
Rafhubar Da]OI, J.
936 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]SUPP.
1962
111 Ttl!SltlS
of
l/u Port of Madras
v.
E.P.V. Shtik Moh4.
Rawl"" & C..
part of the Board to undertake the various services
mentioned in s. 3 9 of the Act.
Section 39, already quoted, empowers the Board
firstly, to provide all reasonable facilities, according
to its powers, for the services mentioned in the various
clauses of sub-s. (l), aud secondly, empowers the
Board to undertake those services. The Board is thus
enabled to undertake those services. Sub-section ( l)
does not make it a duty .of the Board to undertake
those services. It is only by virtue of sub-s. (2) that the
Board is to perform in respect of goods, if required, all
or any of the services mentioned in els. (a), (b) or (d)
of sub-s. (1), those services being in connection with
the landing of good• between vessels in the port and
the wharves, piers, quays or docks in possession of the
. Board and in connection with the receiving,
removing, shifting, transporting, storing or delivering
of goods brought within its premises and despatching
goods intended for carriage by neighbouring railways.
Sub-section (3) again says that the Board is to take
charge of the goods for the purpose of performing the
services, if required to do so, and, in that case, the
Board is to give receipt in the form and tn rhe effect
prescribed by the Central Government. It is therefore clear that the performance of any of the services
mentioned in sub-s. ( l) of s. :rn and the taking of
charge of the goods are consequent on the Board
being required to do so by the 'owner', which is a
general term including consignor, consignee, shipper
or agent. If the owner does not require the Board to
undertake such services and to take charge of the
goods for these purposes, the Board is not to undertake
those services.
It is the steamer-agent, who is in a position to
require the Board to undertake these services in respect of the cargo the ship is to unload. He alone is
expected to have full knowledge about the time when
the ship is to arrive, about the suitability of the berth
l.
I
•
I
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
937
for that ship, about the quantity and nature of the
consignment and about the time the ship would like
to be in the dock and consequently about the amount
of shore-Jabour required in connection with the goods
to be landed. It is for this reason that it is the
steamer-agent who informs the staff of the Board
about the arrival of the ship, who has to furnish the
manifest giving details of the goods to be land
ed and who has to submit a requisition about
the shore labour required and the period of
time during which it would be required. It is
admitted for the parties that the steamer-agent used
to convey the information about the necessary shoreJabour and about the period when it was required.
The new Form of requisition introduced from
March 1, 1958, contained an undertaking by the
steamer-agent for the payment of the labour dues on
account of labour remaining idle or on account of
Jabour working more than one hook simultaneously.
This was introduced in the Form because such payments were newly introduced and added to the
charges which used to be collected by them on the
basis of tonnage handled by the shore-labour and
possibly also on account of the· anticipated objection
on the part of the steamer-agents to their liability to
pay these charges. The liability to pay these charges,
however, does not arise on account of the IJndertaking
but on account of the sanctioned scale of rates at
which and the conditions under which the ,Board
would perform those services. Section 44 of the Act
provides that such sanctioned rates and conditions
shall have the force of law.
<I
-'·'
The question for determination, in. th<( 'case,
then is whether the law making the steamer-agent
liable to pay these charges is good law.
The learned Attorney-General has urged, for
the appellant, that the object behind the scale 'E'
rates is to expedite the discharge of the cargo at the
1962
Tiu Trusuu of
tlu Port of Mairas
••
IC.P.V. Muik Malul.
Rowlhw & Co.
l/JJghubar Dayal, J.
938 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963) SUPP.
1962
T/r4 T ru.stm of
1"4 Port of Madras
••
K.P.V. Sluik Mohd.
Rowt/r4r & Co.
Razhubar Dayal, J.
quay and thus to enable a quantity of cargo to be
discharged quickly. The services reridered by the
Board are therefore services to the ship and, cons·
equently, charges for them are to be realised from
the steamer-agents.
It is also urged that the harbour dues are collec·
ted from the consignees as the Board is a bailee of
the ship-owner who is a bailee of the shipper and
who is bound by the contract to deliver the goods to
the consignee or his nominee, on the presentation of
the bill oflading, The Board's taking charge of the
goods landed does not amount to its taking delivery
of the goods from the ship-owner in fulfilment of the
ship-owner's duty to deliver the goods to the consig·
nee, for the simple reason that the Board does not
get the goods on the presentation of the bill of lading.
There is no doubt that the object of the impug·
ned charges is what is urged for the appellant. The
charges are for labour rendered idle on account of
some default on the part of the ship-owner or his
agent and not on account of anything "which is within
the control of the workmen. We have already referred
to the features of the piece-rate scheme showing the
necessity for the payment of the idle allowance of the
workers for labour rendered idle. Similar considerations justify the payment· of that allowance when
labour is sent away or not required after the shore
work has commenced at the start of the shift.
When more than one hook is worked at the
same time, it necessarily means quicker unloading of
the goods. This, again, is in the interest of the ship·
owner. The ship completes its task of landing the
goods earlier. The provision for the workers working
more than one hook at the same time is therefore
again in the interest of the ship-owner.
Another reason for charging the steamer·agem
for these payments is that the goods unloaded by the
-
2 S.C.R. · SUPREME COURT REPORTS
939
ship need not be for one consignee alone. The goods
are not unloaded consignee.wise. It is not possible,
and if possible is bound to be very inconvenient, for
the Board to work out the proportionate charges for
each consignee, in col)nection with the payment for
idle allowance and the hook allowance when cargo is
discharged with more than one hook working simul·
taneouly at the vessel's hatch. It is reasonable therefore to make the ship-owner liable for their payment.
There is no doubt that the ship-owner is the
bailee of the shipper, the consignor, and that he is
responsible for the delivery of the goods to the
consignee or a transferee according to the terms of the
bill of lading. This duty the ship-owner discharges
only when he has delivered the goods to the consignee
or such person who be entitled to· take delivery in
accordance with the endorsements on the bill of
lading. Delivery to the Board is not drlivery to the
consignee or such person, both because the delivery is
to be on the presentation of the bill of lading and
because the Act contains no provision which would
constitute the Board an agent of the consignee for the
purpose of taking delivery of the goods.
We do not agree with the contention for the
respondents that the expression 'receiving' in cl. (b) of
sub·s. (1) of s. 39 of the Act means receiving the
goods on behalf of the consignee. The reception of
the goods can be on behalf of the ship-owner also.
The steamer-agent cannot ask the Board to receive
the goods on behalf of the consignee.
Sub-section (3) ofs. 39 of the Act empowers
the Board to take charge of tihe goods for the purpose
of performing certain services which do not include
the taking delivery of the goods from the ship-owner.
It is true that on the Bnrd's taking charge of the
goods and giving a receipt about it to the ship-owner,
the master or the owner of the vessel is absolved from
1962
Tiu Trustees of
t"4 Port ef Mair.,
••
K.P.V. Sheik MohJ.
Row/her I!/ Co.
Raghubar D41al, I.
940 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963) SUPP.
1962
liability for any loss or damage which may occur to
the goods which had been landed, but this provision
Tiu Trustees of
tlu Port of Madras by itself does not suffice to convert the receiving of
v.
the goods by the Board after they had been landed
K.P.V. Sheik Mohd.
by the ship-owner to the Board's taking delivery of
Rowlh~r & Co.
those
goods on behalf of the c6nsignee. The Board
Raghub01 Dayal, I•
simply takes charge of the goods on being required by
the steamer-agent to take charge of it.
I> Section 40 speaks of the responsibility of the
Board for the loss, destruction or deterioration of the
goods of which it has taken charge as a bailee under
ss. 151, 152 and 161 of the Indian Contract Act.
Section 148 of the Contract Act states that a bailment
is the deli very of goods by one person to another for
some purpose, upon a contract that they shall, when
the purpose is accomplished, be returned or otherwise
disposed of according to the directions of the person
delivering them. The person delivering the goods is
called the bailor and the person to whom they are
delivered is called the bailee. It is clear therefore that
when th~ Board takes charge of the goods from the
ship-owner, the ship-owner is the bailor and the Board
is the bailee, and the Board's responsibility for the
goods thereafter is that of a bailee. The Board does
not get the goods from the consignee. It cannot be the
bai!ee of the consignee. It can be the agent of the
consignee only if so appointed, which is not alleged
to be the case, and even if the Board be an agent,
then its liability would be as an agent and not as a
bailee. The provisions of ss. 39 and 40, therefore,
further support the contention that the Board takes
charge of the goods on behalf of the ship-owner and
not on behalf of the consignee, and whatever services
it performs at the time of the landing of the goods or
on their removal thereafter, are services rendered to
the ship. I>'
We may now deal with the points urged by
Mr. Desai, for the respondents. The first and the
-
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
941
main question urged is about the legal obligation of
the master in respect of the unloading of the cargo.
1'62
The Tr1Ule11 of
tlu Port of Madras
Mr. Desai has drawn attention to the provisions
of the Indian Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1925
(Act XX VI of 1925), and especially to the definition
of the expression 'carriage of goods' in Article I of
the Schedule to that Act. 'Carriage of goods' accor·
ding to cl. (e) of this Article, covers the period from
the time when the goods are loaded on to the time
when they are discharged from the ship. Of course,
once the goods are landed, they are no more 'carried'
by the ship and the expression 'carriage of goods',
could only cover the period up to the discharge of the
goods from the ship. But that does not in any way
affect the consideration of the quest ions before us.
Further, Rule 6 of Article III provided that unless
notice of loss or damage and the general nature of
such loss or damage be given in writing to the carrier
or his agent at the fort of discharge before or at the
time of the remova of the goods into the custody of
the person entitled to delivery thereof under the
contract of carriage, or, if the loss or damage be not
apparent, within three days, such removal shall,
prima facie, be evidence of the delivery by the carrier
of the goods· as described in the bill of lading. This
implies that till the time of the removal of the goods
into the custody of the person entitled to the delivery
thereof under the contract of carriage, the carrier
will not be deemed to have delivered the goods in
accordance with the terms in the bill of lading. The
responsibility of the carrier for the goods does not
cease merely by the technical discharge of the goods
from the ship but continues up to their delivery in
accordance with the terms of the bill of lading •
...--·•
It is urged by Mr. Desai that under the general
law, the responsibility of the master of the ship ceases
when he has discharged the goods from the ship and
has placed them in such position that the consignee
••
K.P.Y..•Mik Mohd.
/Wwthtr ~ Co.
Ra1h•bar Dayal, J.
942 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963) SUPP.
1962
Tli1 Tnu1111 of
IA1 Port qf Madras
v.
E.P.Y. Slrlik MoM.
&wlli" & Co.
&zlwhar Dayal, J.
can take charge of them and that whatever is done,
thereafter, in connection with the goods, is done on
behalf of the consignee and for his benefit.
The charges for labour rendered idle and for
labour working more hooks simultaneously, are not
charges for services rendered subsequent to the landing
of the goods. These are charges which are incurred at
the last stage of the process of landing of the goods
and therefore prior to the actual landing of the goods.
They are, even under the general law, for services
rendered to the master of the ship whose liability f'lr
loss or of damage to the goods continues up to the
placing of the goods on the quay and their receipt by
the Board.
The case Great Eastern Shipping Co. Ltd. v.
Govindasamy ('), is not of much help. It was not
disputed, in that case, that when the master of the
ship lands the goods and leaves them in charge of
the Port Trust the legal effect is as if the ·master
representing the shipping company has delivered the
goods to the consignee for whom the Port Trust must
be deemed to be agents and that, l;iaving regard to
the practice obtaining in the Madras Port, it was not
necessary that there should be a formal requisition by
the consignee to the Port Trust to take charge of the
goods. This case has not been taken rightly by the
Court below to be of any direct authority on the
question arising for decision in this case.
· It is stated at p. 684, in Carver's 'Carriage of
Goods by Sea', 10th Edition, that generally speaking,
the consignee of the goods or the charterer is bound
to remove the goods from the ship's side, and to provide for that purpose a proper number of men and
suitable appliances of the kind ordinarily used at
the port, having regard to the manner in which the
ship is to be discharged. It is stated at p. 687 :
"Where the customary manner of discharge at
the port requires that the cargo be put out by
(I) I.L.R. (1957] Mod. 840.
-
2 s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
943
those working on the ship, say into lighters or
on to a quay, it has been held that the word
'alongside' may mean, not actually at the ship's
side but in a lighter alongside her."
We may now consider some cases on which reliance
is placed for the respondents.
-
In Peteraoo v. Freebody &: Oo. (1), the facts
were different from those of the present case. The
Court was considering the liability of the consignee
for demucrage paid by the ship.owner, on aocount of
the delay in the discharging of the cargo. The suit
was between the ship-owner and the consignee. The
charter-party provided :
"The discharging to take place in eight days ...
The cargo to be brought to and taken from
alongside the ship at merchants' risk and
expense. The ship to deliver the cargo with
such dispatch that unnecessary delay can be
avoided. The ship to discharge over side in the
river or dock into lighters or otherwise, if required by consignees."
Lord Esher, M. R., stated at p. 297 1
--·
•
"Wherever the delivery is to be, the shipowner,
on the one hand, must give delivery. If he
merely puts the goods on the rail of his ship. he
does not give delivery : thatis not enough. 1f,
on the other hand, the consignee merely stands
on the other ship, or on the barge or lighter,
or on the quay, and does nothing, he does not
take delivery. The shipowner has performed
the principal part of his obligation when he has
put the goods over the rail of his ship; but I
think he must do something more-he must put
the goods in such a position that the consignee
(I) [1895] 2 Q..B.D. !M, 296, 297.
1962
TM Tnutm ef
th, Port of Matlra.r
y,
K.P.Y. SW Molri.
Rowlhlr & Co,
Raghubar Dayal, 1.
944
1961
Tlr. Trusttu of
tlu Port of Madras
v.
K.P.Y. Sluik Mohd.
Rowtlur & Co.
Raghflhar Dayal, J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963) SUPP.
can take delivery of them. He must put them
so far over the side as that the consignee can
begin to act upon them; but the mom~nt the
goods are put within the reach of the consignee
he must take his part in the operation. At one
moment of time the ship-owner and the consignee are both acting-the one in giving and the
other in taking delivery; at another moment the
joint act is finished."
These observations apply when the goods are to be
delivered to the consignee alongside the ship and not
when they are handed over to the statutory body,
like the Board, as a sub·bailee. How the delivery
is to be made depends on the terms of the bill of
lading and the custom of the .l'ort. The case is no
authority for the proposition that in all circumstances
the master of the vessel is not responsible for the
performance of the acts subsequent to his placing the
goods in such a position that the consignee can get
them, as contended for the respondents. The delivery
contemplated in these observations, is not, in our
opinion, equivalent to the lanaing of the goods at
the quay as contemplated by the various provisions
of the Act.
We have already discussed that the landing of
the goods by the ship.owner on the quay and placing
them in charge of the Board does not amount to
delivering them to the consignee, even though it
absolves the master of the ship from further responsibility for the loss or damage to the goods.
The case reported as British Ship-owners' Co.
(Limited) v. Grimond ('), is again, not of help, as it
simply held that delivery to the porters, whom the
consignee was obliged by the Harb.iur Regulation to
employ and pay for the purpose of receiving, was
delivery to the consignee. In the present case there
is nothmg to show that the consignees are obliged by
(I) (1876) III Scs. Oases IV Series 968.
,
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
945
the Board to engage the shore· labour. Further, in
the above case, Lord Justice Clerk said at p. 972 :
"The question of delivery is as much one or
-::ommon-sense as of technical rules. The
general rule is that good~ are delivered when
they are so completely in the custody of the
consignee that he may do as he pleases with
them."
When the goods are placed in the charge of the
Board, the consignee is not at liberty to do anything
he likes with them and therefore, in the view expressed by Lord Justice Clerk, the making over of the
go·>ds to the Board does not amount to delivery to
the consignee.
In Sze Hai Tong Bank Ltd. v. Rambler Cycle
Co. Ltd., (1) it was said :
"It is perfectly clear law that a ship-owner who
delivers without production of the bill of lading
does so at his peril. The Contract is to deliver,
on production of the bill of lading, to the person
entitled under the bill of lading ...... The shipping company did not deliver the goods to any
such person. They are therefore liable for
breach of contract unless there is some term in
the bill of lading protecting them. And they
delivered the goods, without production of the
bill of lading, to a person who was not entitled
to receive them. They are therefore liable in
conversion unless likewise so protected."
Clause 2 of the Bill of lading provided :
"During the period before the goods are loaded
on or after they are discharged from the ship
on which they are carried by sea, the following
terms and conditions shall apply to the excluCll [1959] A. C. 576, 5116.
1961
..
Till Tnulus of
th• Port qf Mair&1
K.P .V S/wl.t Mohl.
RowlMr &
.1.
946 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
l!Mt
T6' T""teu qf
1111 h t qf Madru
v.
K.P.V. Shrik Mo/id.
Rowt!uF & Co.
&thuharDayol, J,
sion of any other provisions in this bill of lading that may be inconsistent therewith, viz.,
(a) so long as the goods remain in the actual
custody of the 'carrier or his servants' ... (b)
whilst the goods are being transported to or
from the ship ........ (c) in all other cases the
responsibility of the carrier, whether as carrier
or as custodian or bailee of the goods, shall be
deemed to commence only when the goods are
loaded on the ship and to cease absolutely
after they are discharged therefrom."
It was held that this clause did not protect the shipowner in spite of the width of theJe expressions and
its operation must be limited and modified to the
extent necessary to enable the effect to be given to
the main object and intent of the contract and at least
so as not to permit the carrier deliberately to disregard
his obligation as to delivery against the production of
the bill of lading.
In the present case, it was further contended
that as between the master of the ship and the consignee, the Act made it obligatory that the consignee
gets his goods from th_e Board and not direct from
the master of the ship, and that therefore the Board
acts as the agent of the consignee. We have not
been referred to any provision in the Act which
supports this contention. Assuming, however, that
the consignee cannot take delivery of the goods at
the quay from the ship direct, it does not follow
that the Board receives the goods as the agent of the
consignee. The only reasonable conclusion in the
circumstances can be that the place of delivery is
shifted from the side of the ship to the warehouses
where the Board stores the goods till the consignee
appears to take delivery on the basis of the delivery
order by the steamer-agent which is usually;an endorsement on the bill of lading, and the quay be considered a part of the ship. In Hamburg, it is so
1
,
'-
-
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
947
considered, as would appear from the following
note at p. 37 of the German Law of Carriage of
Goods by Sea, by Sieve King :
1961
TJ,.Trustnsef
ti.. Port of Madr.,
••
K.P.V. Slt1il: Molr4.
"Where goods are shipped from or discharged
on to a quay, the question arises whose agent
the owner of the quay is. This of course
depends upon the wording of the rules and
bye laws regulating the passing of goods over
the quay. As a rule (in Hamburg for instance)
the qua is considered as forminl!' part of the
ship; the owner of the quay is the agent of the
master. The fact of the shipper having handed the goods over to the owner of the quay is
tantamount to a receipt for the same on the
part of the master; th'! goods discharged upon
the quay are considered as still being in the
possession of the master until the consignee has
received them from the quay."
If the Board was an agent of the consignee, it
was bound to deliver the goods to the consignee and
should not have any rights of retaining the goods
till the payment of the rates and other dues for which
it had a lien on the goods. The provision of there
being a lien on the goods for the payme.nt of the
dues of the Board or the freight, make it clear that
the Board did not have the custody of the goods as
an agent of the consignee.
It is further contended that s. 42 draws a distinction between services performed in respect of the
vessel and those performed in respect of the goods; that
the former services are rendered to the master of the
ship and the latter to the consignee, the owner of the
goods. and that service rendered by receiving the
goods from the ship at the quay is therefore service
to the consignee. We do not construe the expression
'any othrr service in respect of ves1el, passengers or
goods' in cl. (e) of s. 42 of the Act in this manner.
Rowtlrn (// Co.
&,hubar Dtf111l, l·
948 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963) SUPP.
Ifft
n. Tnulm ef
Iii Port ef Madru
•
y.
K.P.Y. Sluik Mohd.
Ro1111Mr ill Co.
If it is interpreted as suggested, the Board must
charge the passenger to whom services are rendered.
This is not done. Any charges
so incurred must
be realised from steamer-agents who may, in their
tum, charge the passengers for the same.
1
We do not agree with the contention that the
charges for labour rendered idle are in the nature of
compensation or damages in respect of any loss,
inconvenience or expenses caused to the Board or its
shore-labour in consequence of any default attributecl
to the master of the ship. There is no question of
damages. The labour has been engaged. It is paid
for the time during which it remains idle, for no
fault of its own. Charges for that are levied from
the person who required that labour and is responsible for its remaining idle. Of course, if the idle
time was due to the default of the labour, no such
charges are required to ·be paid by the ship-owner.
We are therefore of opinion that the impugned
charges were rightly levied by scale 'E' on the master,
owner or agent of the vessels and that the Board
could insist on the steamer-agent requisitioning the
shore-labour to express an undertaking in the form
for requisitioning labour that he will pay the charges
laid down in the Board's scale of rates from time to
time in respect of labour rendered idle or not properly utilised and also for working more than one
hook simultaneously at a vessel's hatch.
We therefore allow the appeals with costs here
and the Courts below, set aside the order of the Court
below and dismiss the writ petitions. There will be
one hearing fee.
Appeala allowed.
t_
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org