STATE OF PUNJAB versus JOGINDER SINGH
Supreme Court of India | Decided 16 November 1962 | [1963] SUPP. 2 S.C.R. 169 | 1962 INSC 328
Key facts
- Decided
- 16 November 1962
- Bench
- BHUVNESHWAR PRASAD SINHA*, K. SUBBA RAO, K.N. WANCHOO, J.C. SHAH, N. RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 388/1962
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1963] SUPP. 2 S.C.R. 169
- Neutral citation
- 1962 INSC 328
Text of the judgment
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
169
STATE OF PUN.JAB
1962
v.
Novmoln, 16,
JOGINDER SINGH
(B. P. SINHA, C. J., K. SuBBA RAo, K. N. WANCRoo,
J.C. SHAH and N. RAJAGOPALA AYYA?\'GAR, JJ.)
Equality of Opportunity-Puhlic Employment-State Cadre
of teachera-Provincia!ised cadr. formed of DistricJ Board
teachers-Equal pay srales and allowances-Difference in opportunity of promotion-I/ discriminatory-Power of Government
to constitute parallel services-Punjab Educational Service
(Provincialised Cadre) Cta..s Ill Rules, 1961, rr. 2, .1-Constitution of India, Arl8. 14, 16.
Of the •junior teachers' in the Punjab State cadre 15%
were put in the "middle scale" and 85% in the "lower scale".
From Qctoher 1, 1957, the junior teachers in the District Board
and Municipal Board schools were made Government employees
and formed into a "Provincialised Cadre". They were divided
into Hmiddle scale" and "lower scale" in the same proportion
and were given the same scales of pay as th,. teachers in the two
scales in the «State Cadre". The Government decided to keep
the two cadres distinct and made the Punjab Educational
Service (Piovincialised C'!dre) Class III Rule;, 1961, which
laid down the manner in which promotions in the two cadres
from the lciwer to the middle grades were to be made. These
Rules were made effective from October I, 1957. These Rules
made the Provincialised Cadre a diminishing class by providing
that no further recruitment would be made to it and that all
vacancies occuring therein would be transferred to the State
Cadre. The result was that those recruited to the State Cadre
had a progressively larger chance of getting into the selection
grade of that cadre than the corresponding member of the
Provincialised Cadre. 1~hc respondent, a lower scale teacher
of the Provincialised Cadre, contended thttt there was a com-
plete integration of all the junior teachers, that the Rules
violated Arts. 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution as they discriminated between the two cadres in respect of the opportunity
of promotion to the middle scale and that the State could not
consistently with Art. 14, constitute two parallel services consisting of employees doing the same work but subject to different conditions of service.
Held, (per Sinha C. J., Wanchoo and Ayyangar, .JJ., Subba
Rao, and Shah, lJ., disseming) ihat the Rules did not violate
Art. 14 or Art.. 16. The two Services started as jndependen t
170 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP:
1962
S11111 of l'vf!i•b
·•·
lopd.r Silfth
services and the Government never integrated them into one
service. They started dissimilarly and they continued dissimilarly and the dissimilarity in their treatmeni by the Rules
was not a denial of equal opportunity. The two distinct cadres
existed independently of the Rules. The question of denial
of equal opportunity could ari•e only as between members of
the same class. Further, it was open to the Government to
constitute two distinct services of employees doing the same
work but subject to different conditions of service. The assumption that equal work must -receive equal pay was not correct.
Nor was it correct to say that if there was equality in pay and
work there must be equality in conditions of service.
Kisliori Mohanla7 v. Unirm, A. I. R. (1962) S. C. 1139,
relied on.
•'
Per Subba Rao, and Shah, JJ.-The Rules in so far as
they provide for differential treatment between the members of
the State Cadre and the Provincialised Cadre in the matter of
promotion are invalid. Though there were two Cadres they
were differentiated only for purposes of future promotions. There
was no valid basis for classification so as to justify a differential
treatment between their members inter "' for the purposes of
promotion. The Government in fart having given the same
terms of employment to the two Cadres and having in cll"ect
constituted a . single grade of teachers, the disrrimination bet·
ween the members of that grade based merely on the source of
recruitment cli:arly infringed Art. 16(1) and (2).
General Manager So!llMrn Rly. v, Rangachari, [1962]
2 S.C.R. 586. All India Station Maater•' And A ..istant Station
Masters' A38ociation v. General Manager, C.R. [1962] 2 S.C.R.
311 and Kishori Mohan/al Bakshi v. Uuion of India, A. I. R.
(1962) S. C. 1139, referred to.
CmL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal
No. 388 of 1962.
Appeal by special leave from the judgment and
order dated October 3, 1961, of the Punjab High
Court, Chandigarh in Civil Writ Petition No. 1559
of 1960.
0. K. Dapht,ary, Solioitor General of India,
L. D. Kaushal, Additional Advooate-General, Punjab,
N. 8. Bindra and R.H. Dhebar, for the appellant.
0. B. Agarwal.a a1Jd A. N, Goyal. for the ~
pondent.
.Iii
J
-'
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
171
1962. November 16. The Judgment
of
Sinha, C. J., Wanchoo. and Ayyangar, JJ., was
delivered by Ayyangar J. The Judgment of Subba
Rao and Shah, lJ., was delivered by Shah, J.
AYY.ANGAB, J .-This is an appeal by special
leave against the judgment .of the High Court of
Punjab dated October 3, 1961. That.Judgment was
rendered in a petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution filed by the respondent-:Jogendra Singh
and by their order allowing the said petition in part,
the learned Judges struck down r. 2 (d) & (e) and a
part of r. 3 of the Punjab Educational Service
(Provincialised cadre) Class III Rules 1961, which
for convenience we shall call the impugned Rules,
on the ground that those clauses were violative of the
rights guaranteed by Art. 14 & Art. 16 (I) of the
Constitution.
Certain facts have to be stated in order to
appreciate both the manner in which the question
was raised as well as the decision of the learned
Judges now under appeal.
The respondent was before October J, 1957,
working as a "Junior vernacular teacher" in a
District Board High School in District Hoshiarpur.
The points in controversy in this appeal turn on the
precise changes which were effected in the status
and conditions of service of teachers like the respondent employed .in District Board and Municipal
Board Schools by certain executive instructions issued
by the Punjab Government in September 1957, to
take effect from October I, 1957, by reason of which
these teachers became State employees, but before
proceeding to the details of these changes, it would
be convinent to set out the position and conditions of
service of teachers employed in Stat!'! schools which
prevailed Oil that date.
IH2
S.I' of PratJtd
••
l•,W1r SU.,A
172 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963)SUPP
1962
S11Jt1 of Pu•jab
v.
Jo1indl1 Sing/a
.A.nan1•, J.
At that date teachers in State employ were
governed by· rules framed under Art. 309 of the Con·
stitution which had been promulgated on M;ay 30,
1957. These rules were entitled "The Puajab
Educational Service Class III School Cadre Rules,
1955". We shall have occasion to refer to these
Rules in detail after narrating the facts which have
given rise to the present appeal. For the present
it is sufficient to state that these rules prescribed_
inter alia the qualification for appointment, the
recruiting authority, the conditions of service and
seniority inter se of members of the Service. The
appendices to these rules specified the scales of
salary to which teachers falling within the various
grades which were specified would be entitled. The
scales of pay of these State teachers were revised as
as result of the acceptance by government of the
recommendation of a committee for pay revision and
under an order of government dated July 23, I9i;7,
"junior teachers" in the State service, the class of
officers with whom we are now concerned were split
up into .three grades: (a) Head Masters, (b) those in
the middle scale, and (c) those in the lower scale.
This Government order fixed the percentages of the
teachers to be comprised in each group. It would
be seen that so far as Head Masters were concerned,
there could be no definite ·number because that
depended upon the number of schools in which they
could function but for teachers other than Head
Masters i. e., 'in what has been termed "the junior
teacher grade", 15 per cent of the total strength of
junior teachers were put in the "middle scale" on
a salary scale of 120-5-175 and this percentage
included the head masters also though they were on
a still higher scale of salary, while the rest of the
85 per cent were to be in the "lower scale" on a
salary scale of 60-4-80/-5-100/5-120. This government order further directed : "Fifteen per cent of
teachers in t.his group should straight.away be pro.moted to the IJ)idclle class by selection basecl on
1
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
173
seniority and merit while the rest should be given the
lower scale". These were the rules governing the
category called "junior teachers in the State Cadre"
on October 1, 1957.
1962
$1011 of P..ja6
v.
Jo1indtr SU.,h
.4y)Wn1•r1 / .
By an Executive instruction dated September
27, 1957, (to be effective from October 1, 1957), in
the form of a communication from the Secretary to
the Education Department of the State to the Director
of Public Instruction, a change was made in the
terms and conditions of service of teachers in the
District Board and Municipal Board Schools. It
might be mentioned that the executive action was
later ratified by legislation in 1959 which was to have
retrospective effeet from October 1, 1957, but as
nothing turns on the terms of this enactment relevant
to the points in controversy before us, it is not necessary to make any further reference to it. As the
decision of this appeal hinges on the proper construction and the legal effect of the "Provincialisation"
effected by this executive direction, it would be
necessary to scrutinize its terms with reference to the
then existing state .of circumstances in some detail.
But to this we shall revert a little later, but will at
the present stage be content to mention that under
this order the· schools theretofore run by Municipal
Boards and District Boards in the Ambala and
Jullundur Divisions were taken over by the Education
Department of the Punjab Government with effect
from October 1, 1957. The teachers then employed
in these schools were also taken over, becoming
State employees. The order recites that on October
1, 1957, there. were, in the class of"junior teachers"
in the schools taken over with whom we are concerned, 20709 teachers. Applying to them the same
proportion of 15 : 85 of "lower" and "middle" class
which applied to junior teachers in the State cadre
dealt with hi the government order dated July 23,
1957, 3184 teachers were placed in the higher grade
entitled to the higher emoluments and 17525 in the
174 SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963] SUPP.
1962
s1111 ef PriU•6
v.
lo1U.d1r Sin1h
"lower" grade drawing the minimum salary open to
junior teachers. This order also stated generally
that the junior teachers employed in Local Body
Schools which were being "provincialised" would
be given "the same grades of pay and other allowances as were given to their counterparts in government employment."
It is in evidence that subsequent to October 1,
1957, the government had under consideration three
questions:
(1) whether the "provincialised" teachers had
to be kept in a cadre separate and distinct from the
cadre of teachers in the State cadre or whether the
two cadres were to be integrated into one; (2) if they
were to be integrated, how their inter 86 seniority
was to be determined; (3) if they were not to be
integrated, what was to be the relationship between
the teachers in the two cadres and similar allied
questions.
The conclusions which the government arrived
at were published arid given effect in the form of a
letter dated Ja.mary 27, 1960, from the Secretary
to the Government, Punjab, to the Director, Public
Instruction, Punjab, Briefly stated, the decision was
that the two cadres-of "provincialised" teachers and
teachers in the State cadre-were to be kept distinct,
and principles were formulated according to which
promotions in the two cadres from the lower to the
middle grade were to be determined. It is the
validity of the terms of this decision that is challenged
in this appeal by the respondent. The decision. and
directions contained in it were given effect to in
the case of all employees belonging to the
"provincialised" schools and thereupon the
resPondcnt filed the petition under Art. 226 impugning the Constitutionality of this direction on
various grounds. One of these grounds was that
\
2 s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
175
the direction contained in this communication
dated January 27, 1960, did not have any statutory
force since the same was not and did not purport to be
a rule framed under Art. 309 of the Constitution.
To obviate this objection the Government
of the Punjab promulgated the Punjab Educational
Service (Provincialised Cadre) Class III Rules,
1961, on February 13, 1961. These rules
conformed to the formal requirements of Art.
309 but were otherwise in the same terms
as and operated in the same manner and from the
same date as the impugned directions ofJanuary 1960.
The petition by the respondent before the High Court
was therefore converted into one challenging the
constitutional validity of the Rules of February,
1961 instead of the government communication of
January 1960.
The arguments in support of the challenge to
the validity of these rules could briefly be
formulated thus: On the provincialisation of the
District Board and the Municipal Board Schools on
and from October 1., 1957, all the teachers theretofore serving in these schools became the employ·
ees of the State. On the date when they attained
this status there were teachers in schools run by
the State who were governed by the rules
published in May, 1957, with the scales of pay
and grades revi~ed under the orders of July 23, 1957.
Whether or not the goverment had the power to keep
these "provincialised" teachers, in a separte category,
the goverment did not do so but by the orders that
they passed on September 27, 1957, they were
granted the "same grades and scales of pay and
other allowances" as those applying to the teachers
in the then State cadre. This ·necessarily implied
a complete integration of the. two cadres with the
result that the two became a single class of teachers
and thereafter the fact that the "provincialised"
teachers had been previously employed in District
Board or Municipal Board Schools and not in
1!162
Stak of l'u•Jd
y.
Jo1irui" Sir11h
A1Janpr1 J.
1'76
i962
St•t,./ Punjab
v.
Joginder Singh
..1,,..,.,, J.
SUPREME COURT RE:PO.RTS [1963] SUPP.
schools run by the State was merely of historical
interest and carried no legal significance. Any
later order of government therefore which drew any
distinction between the class of "provincialised"
teachers and teachers in the State cadre to the
prejudice of the former was discriminatory and void
under Art. 14 of the Constitution. As all the
schools as and from October 1, 1957, were being
run by the State, all teachers employed in them,
whatever their previous history, belonged to the
same class, since they performed the same functions,
were entitled to the same salaries and had as such
to be governed by the same rules and conditions of
service. On this basis it was urged that the impugned rules discriminated against the "junior teachers"
in the "provincialised" cadre in two ways : (1) as
regards their right or opportunity to obtain promotions and proceed to the "middle" scale, and (2) disparity in the rules relating to pension. It was
contended that the discrimination. as regards promotions was violative of Art. 16 (1) and that as regards
pension on tqe broader ground of an irrational classification violating Art. 14. The learned Judges of
the High Court acceded to the prayer of the respondent as regards the first objection in these terms :
"The 1961 rules in so far as the same create
two cadres of persons in the same service and
in so far as the same create inequality of opportunity for promotion in between the two cadres
by providing the formula of promotion are
void rules and in particular those rul~s are No.
2, in so far as it relates to the definitions of
two cadres, and No. 3, in so far as it provides
for the effect of two cadres on the matter of
promotion in the same."
but they rejected that in re~pect of pension on being
satisfied that Art. 14 was not violated in that·regard.
It is from this judgment .that the State has preferred
this appeal with special leave.
\
-
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTg
177
This will be a convenient stage where we might
sununarise briefly the provisions of the impugned
rule and their impact on the right to promotion of
the respondent and the other "junior teachers" of the
"provincialised" service to which he belongs. Before
however, doing so it is necessary to mention a preliminary objection that was taken to the hearing of
the appeal. Along with the. respondent Jogindra
Singh there were three others who had filed similar
petitions and sought the same relief. Writ Petitions
161 and 162 of 1961 were by "junior teachers" like
the responpent, while Amrik Singh petitioner in the
remaining petition (Petition 163of1961) was a Head
Master among the "provincialised" teachers. All
the four petitions were dealt with together and were
disposed of by a common judgment so that relief
accorded to Jogindra Singh the respondent before us
in Writ Application 1559 of 1960 was also granted
to the other three petitioners. The State however
has preferred no appeal against the orders in the
other three petitions, and Mr. Agarwal, learned
Counsel for the respondent, raises the contention that
as the orders in the other three petitions have become
final, any order passed in this appeal at variance with
the relief granted in the other three petitions would
create inconsistent decrees in respect of the same
matter and so we should dismiss the present appeal
as incompetent. We, however, consider that this
would not be the legal effect of any order passed by
the Court in this appeal and that there is no merit in
this objection as a bar to the hearing of the appeal.
In our opinion, the true position arising, if the
present appeal by the State Government should
succeed, would be that the finality of the orders passed in the other three writ petitions by the Punjab
High Court would not be disturbed and that those
three successful petitioners would be entitled to retain
the advantages which they had secured by the
decision in their favour not being challenged by an
appeal being filed. That however would not help
1962
Stat1 of i'wljab
v.
Jo1ind1r Sinzlt
Ay.,.,,gar, J.
178 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
1962
St•lt •! l'u•jd
v.
Jotind•r Sin1A
~_,,,,,,.,,
J,
the present respondent who would be bound by our
judgment in this appeal and besides, so far as the
general law is concerned as applicable to everyone
other than the three writ petitioners (who would be
entitled to the benefit of decisions in their favours
having attained finality), the law will be as laid
down .by this Court. We therefore overrule the
preliminary objection.
The impugned rules are entitled "Punjab
Eduf'ational Service (Provincialised Cadre) Class III
Rules, 1961" and they were deemed to have come
into force from October 1, 1957 i. e.; the date when
the "pr.ovincialised" cadre was formed. Rule 2 contains the definitions and of these those relevant to the
present context, which have been struck down by the
High Court in their jugdment under appeal are cls.(d)
& (e) which respectively define the word "Service" as
meaning "The Punjab Educational (Provincialised
Cadre) Class III Service" and cl. (e) defining 'State
Cadre' as meaning "The Punjab Educational (State
Service) Class III (School Cadre)". Rule 3 with
which Part II headed 'Conditions of Service' starts
is the vne which is. the most relevant for the points
arising in this appeal. It reads :
3. Number and character of posts :(1) The service shall comprise the posts shown
in Appendix 'A' but shall be a diminishing one.
The number of posts in various cadres of the
Service shall be regulated in the following
manner:(i) All the posts created for any provincialised si:l.t>ol subsequent to its being taken
over by the Government, whether on
account of its being upgraded to a higher
~taJ)dard, removal of congestion tW,rein
2 s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
179
or for any other purpose shall not consti ·
tute a part of the Service but will be borne
on the State Cadre or such other Educa·
tional State Service as may comprise
similar posts at the time of their creation.
(ii) (a) All such posts of Headmasters as
well as of Masters or Teachers, in selection
grades of the Service, as were vacant on
October 1, 1957, shall continue to be
borne on the Service but an equal number
of posts in ordinary pay scales in the rele·
vant cadres of the service falling vacant as
a result' of promotion to the posts of Head·
masters, Masters and Teachers in the selection grade shall be transferred to the Sete
Cadre.
(b) All such posts of Masters and
Teachers, in ordinary pay scales of the
Service, as were vacant on October 1,
1957, shall be transferred to the State
Cadre.
(iii) The posts in various cadres of the
service falling vacant due to the normal
incidence of promotions, retirements or
any other cause subsequent to the date of
provincialisation of local authority schools
shall be adjusted in the following
manner:(a) All vacant posts of masters as well as
of Junior Teachers in the Service shall be
separately split up into blocks of seven and
six posts by rotation. All selection grade
posts in the first six vacancies in each
block of seven and first five vacancies in
each block of six shall continue to be borne
on the Service but an equal number of
postJ in ordinary pay-scales of Masters or
1962
S"'lf •f P..fa!
v.
lo1ittdn Siogl
..1,,..,.,, J.
180 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
19i2
Stal• of Pu'liab
y.
logind11 Singh
...,,.,"'' J.
Junior Teachers as the case may be,
together with other vacancies in ordinary
pay-scales in each block shall be transferred
to the State Cadre. The last vacancy in
each block shall be transferred to the State
Cadre:
Provided that if the last vacancy in
the block is not in the selection grade one
other post in the selection grade from within that block shall be transferred to the
State Cadre, and if adjustment within the
same block is not possible it shall be made
in the next following a block but in no
case in any block thereafter :
...................................................,,
The other rules which have some materiality are rr. 4, 5, 8 and 9 and we shall set out the
relevant portiom of these :
"4. Liability to transfer: Members of the
Service who are borne on a statewise cadre
may be posted in any Government or provincialised school throughout the State and
members of the Service who are borne on
district-wise cadre may be posted in any
Government or provincialised school throughout that district. ................. "
"5. Confirmation: Members of the Service
who were confirmed prior to the provincialisation of local authority schools shall be
deemed to have been confirmed in the
Service:
..................................................."
"8. Method of Recruitment : (I) Posts in
Selection grades left over after the transfer
2 S.C~R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
181
of posts to the State Cadre as specified in
rule 3 shall be filled by promotions from
lower grade of the Cadre :
Provided· that no member shall be pro·
moted to selection grade of the Service un·
less he possesses the qualifications and
experience as specified in Appendix 'B'.
"
The only thing to be noted in regard to the
qualifications set out in the Appendix 'B' as regards
"junior teachers" with whom alone we are concerned
is . that for appointment to the selection grade
(Rs. 120/175) they were not required to be matriculates this being a minimum qualification prescribed
by the rules under the State Cadre, but it was suffi·
cient if they were "junior trained" or "junior basic
trained" or "special certificate teachers" with five
years teaching experience in which case they were
elig~ble to·be appointed to the "selection" grade.
"r. 8(2) All promotions, whether from one
grade to another or from one class of service to
another, shall be made on the basis of senioritycum-merit and no person shall .be entitled to
claim promotion on the basis of seniority alone",
Rule 9 lays down how the inter .se seniority of mem·
hers 'of.the service shall be determined as on October
1, 1957.
We shall briefly summarise the effect of these
provisions on the class of "provincialised" teachers:
(1) They were treated as falling under a cadre separate and clistinct from teachers in the State cadre
governed by the .rules promulgated on May 30, 1957.
(£) Though the proportion of selection grade teachers
to the total 'strength, viz., 15 : 85 was the same in
both the cadres, it operated differently as regards the
1Jf2
SUII• •f P1111ju
v.
J•z"'"' so.1h
182 SUPREME COURT REPORTS[l963]SUPP.
1962
Stal1 of Punjab
v.
Jogini1r Singh
Ayyangar, J.
members in the two services. This was due to the
fact that the government decided that the "provincialised" teachers were to be a diminishing class to
become extinct in course of time, whereas a number
equivalent to that which the provincial cadre Jost was
added to the State cadre. When the provincialisation
of Local Board and Municipal Board teachers was
effected by the Government Order of September 27,
1957, there were, as we have pointed out, 20709
"junior teachers" of whom, by applying the 15 per
cent rule, 3184 were to be in the "sell!'ction grade"
drawing the higher salary, while the rest of the 17,525
were in the ordinary or the "lower" scale. The
corresponding figures for the State Cadre teachers on
the same day, i. e., October I, 1957, was 107 of
whom 15 per cent would have been in the selection
grade. The "provincialised" cadre being marked
out for extinction, there was to be no further recruitment to that cadre and became, so to speak, closed
at one end. All vacancies arising by retirements,
deaths etc. in the. provincialiscd cadre were to be
replenished by direct recruitment to the State Cadre.
The consequence of this would naturally be that the
selection grade of 15 per cent in the State Cadre
would be progressively increasing in strength which
was determined by the total cadre stren~th, while the
selection. grade in the "provincialiscd' cadre would
be progressively decreasing in strength for the con·
verse reason. As the cadres were kept separate
the result would be that those recruited to the State
Cadre would have a progressively larger chance
of getting into the "selection" grade of that cadre
than the corresponding member of the "provincialis·
ed" service. Thus a member of the State cadre who
possessed the minimum educational qualifications
required for appointment to the selection grade and
also the minimum service prescribed as qualification
therefor stood a better chance of promotion to the
selection grade than did a teacher of the "~ei·
alised" cadre getting into the selection grade of his
-
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
183
cadre. The rigour of this rule was, however, greatly
tempered by the division into blocks under r. 3 itself
by reason of which roughly 11/13 of. the total
vacancies in the selection grade were directed to be
filled by "provincialised" teachers leaving only the
balance for those in the State Cadre. It is the disparity in the chances of promotion existing between
the members of the State cadre and the teachers in
the "provincialised" cadre that ha:l been held to be
discriminatory and violative of Arts. 14 and Hl(l) of
the Constitution by the learned Judges of the High
Court. The summary of .the rules that we have
given earlier would show that this disparity has been
caused (a) by the impugned rule treating the "provincialised" teachers as belonging to a cadre different
and distinct from the teachers in the State cadre and
not providing for any inter-se seniority as between the
two groups, and (b) the "provincial ised" cadre being
a diminishing cadre to be extinguished in course of
time, the State cadre being selected for expansion and
perpetuation by becoming the sole cadre in which
recruitment for vacancies could take place. The reason
why we are stating the position in this form is that
though the learned Counsel for the respondent based
his argument to sustain the plea of a violation of
Arts. 14 and 16(1) on the "division" of the two
services as distinct cadres whereas in law they were
one and ought to have been so treated, the "provincialised" teachers could have had no complaint if
theirs was not made a vanishing cadre, for if the two
services had been kept uistinct and the vacancies in
each filled up so as to replace the loss in the strength
of each cadre, there would have been no scope for any
complaint of discrimination.
The main basis upon which the learned 11dges
of the High Court have rested their Judgment is that
the order dated September 27, 1957, which wa~ brou·
ght into force on October 1,1957, by which the teachers in the erstwhile District Board and Mu 'cipal
1962
Stal• •f Pajd
v.
Jo1i11i1r s;.,h
,_,,.,.,.,, J.
184 SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963) SUPP.
1962
St•te of Punj•h
v.
Joginder Si,,1h
bJO"gar, J,
Board schools were "Provincialised" and made State
employees, effected a complete integration of these
teachers with the then existing members of the State
Educational Service governed by the rules of May 30,
1957. It would be manifest that unless this step were
established there could be no basis for the contention
that the impugned rules which procedcd on the basis
that the Provincialised teachers were not in the State
cadre violated Art. 14 or Art. 16(1). The first step
in the enquiry has therefore to be whether this order
of September 27, 1957, effected a complete integration between the two services. This question can, in
our opinion, be solved not by hypothetical or theoretical considerations but by a careful examination of
the terms of the order dated September 27, 1957, with
a view to find out whether such a result was intended
to be or was brought about. The justification for this
observation of ours is because of the line of argument
addressed to us by learned Counsel for the respondent.
He submitted that there might have been differences
in the qualifications of persons entitled to he recruited as teachers in the erstwhile Board schools as
compared to the qualifications to be possessed by or
the machinery set up to recruit teachers in the State
cadre. When once the "provincialisation" took
place, the argument ran, they became teachers emplo·
yed directly by the State, the schools in which they
were formerly employed having been taken over by
the State. Under the order ·dated September 27,
1957, their pay-scales were rendered the same as
those applicable to teachers in the State cadre.
Besides, they could be transferred to State schools
and teachers in the State cadre transferred to work
in former Board schools, i. e., there was complete
interchangeability so far as posts were concerned.
If, it was contended, they did the same work, drew
the same pay as the teachers in the State cadre and
the members of the two Services were freely liable
to transfer inter se nothing more remained to effect
a complete integration. In further reinforcement
'
...
2 s.c.R.
;
:
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
185
of this submission reliance was placed on a paragraph
of the memorandum of September 27, 1957, under
which these teachers were taken over into State
employ which ran :
"All the incumbents of the Local Body schools
to be provincialised with effect from the 1st
of October, 1957 will be given the same grades
of pay and other allowances as are given to
their counterparts already in government
employ. Their pay will be fixed under the
rules and there will be no drop in their present
emoluments."
and from all this it was urged that 11.-complete in·
tegration of the two services was intended to be and
was brought about from and after October 1, 1957.
Besides the above there was a subsidiary argument
that consistently with Art. 14 the State could not
create or maintain two parallel services of employees
for doing the same work but with differences either
in their emoluments or in their conditions of service.
This however was on the basis that the submission
about a complete integration having been effected
was not acceptable, and so we shall consider this
further argument later.
We shall now proceed to examine the primary
contention, viz., that there was a complete integra·
tion of the two Services by the Government order
which-had effect from October I, 1957, and that it
was the impugned rules which brought about a
division of this united or unified service by the crea·
tion of two new cadres with differences between
members of the Service based on no inteliigible
diffcrentia which was violative of Art. 14, and as the
same adversely affected the chances of promotion
of the "provincialised" group vis-a-vis the State
Cadre teachers infringed Art. 16 (1).
We do not find, it possible to accede to the
contention. that the .memorandum dated September
1962
Stat1 of l'urtjGi
,,,;,,.4,, su.,.
~.
Ayyaa1ar, J.
186 SUPREME COURT MPORTS [1963) SUPP.
1961
St•f1 of Punjab
v.
Jotinthr Sittgh
Ayµngaf, J.
27, 1957, integrated the "provincialised" teachers with
the teachers governed· by the Punjab (Educational
Service) Class III School Cadre Rules, 1955. In the
first place, it is conceded that the rules as to pension
applicable to the State cadre employees are not
applicable to the "provincialised" teachers. The
Government framed rules as regards the pension of
the "prpvincialised" teachers in October 1958, which
were distinct and different from the Pension Rules
applicable to teachers in the State cadre. A
complaint was made on this score by the respondent
in his petition before the High Court but the same
was rejected and there has been no appral from that
portion of that order. It must also be pointed out
that the pension of the State Cadre teachers is
determined by para. 11 of the Class III School Cadre
Rules, 1955 and it is common ground that the said
provision does not govern the conditions and qµan·
tum of pension of the "provincialised" teachers.
(2) The inter se seniority of members ofthe
State Cadre Service is determined by r. 9 of the
Rules which contain elaborate provisions for its
determination. The first paragraph of the rule
runs 1
"The semor1ty inter ae of the members of the
Service holding the same class of posts and in the
same or identical grades of pay shall be deter·
mined by the dates of their confirmations in
such posts."
We do.not find it possible to read r. 9 as governing
the inter se seniority between the "provincialised"
and the State Cadre employees. The date of con·
finnation in the Service is the crucial date for
determining such seniority under r. 9 and the order
dated September 27, 1957, cannot, by any stretch
of language, be read as confirming all the pro·
vincialiscd teachers in the State Cadre on October
"'
'
2 S.d.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
187
1, 1957, on which date it is said they were brought
into the service. In the normal and ordinary course
it would be possible that teachers had been working
in the erstwhile Board Schools on probation and
they had not been confirmed in their appointments
on October l, 1957, when they were taken over.
It cannot be that all the teachers who had not even
completed their probation were straightaway treated
as confirmed in the. State Cadre so as to permit a
determination of their seniority inter ae with members
of the State Service.
(3) Notwithstanding the par~aph quoted
earlier conferring on the "provincialised" teachers
"the same grades of pay and allowances as are allowed to their counter-parts already in government
service" there is no specific provision or term in the
govemment order expressly pointing to an intention
to integrate it with the existing State service. On
the other hand, the very specification that the grades
of pay and allowances of the provincialised teachers
would be the same as of the others is, to say the
least, more consis~nt with the absence of an intention. to integrate, for if integration were intended,
they would have the same pay and allowances by
virtue thereof and no separate provision thereof would
be necessary;
(4) It is an admitted fact that of the twenty
thousand and odd teachers falling within this category nearly 12 or 13 thousand were unqualified in
the sense that they· had not even passed the Matriculation examination. To apply to them the State
Cadre Rules particularly as regards promotion to
the selection grade would have meant considerable
hardship to them and this is certainly a circumstance
that has to be home in mind before drawing an
inference that a complete integration was intended,
or was brought about. In fact, as has · already been
pointed uut, while in the case of the State
1962
Stall ef l"njt/j
v.
Jo1it<Mr Siat•
Ayy1111•r1 . J.
188 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
1962
Si.II ef Pu•ju
y,
l•ti•I" Sinp
A.,J01tlM1 J.
cadre teachers a minimum educational qualification
of Matriculate with five years teaching experience is
prescribed for appointment to the selection grade, the
requirement as to being a Matriculate has been dispensed with in the impugned rules in the case of the
"provincialised" cadre. The conclusion we rea:ch
from the above analysis is that by the order dated
September 27, 1957, which came into effect from
October 1, 1957, teachers in the erstwhile Board
schools became employees of government and were
given the s?me scales and grades of pay as were
applicable to their counterparts in the State cadre, but
exce{'t this equality of grade and pay there v.:as
nothmg more that was contemplated or provided for
by that order.
We consider therefore that there is force in the
submissions made to us on behalf of the appellant
that the determination of the precise status of.the
"provincialised" teachers and their relationship
vis-a-vis the teachers in the State Cadre was
the subject of consideration by the government which
resulted in the promulgation of the impugned rules.
In the document marked as Ex. R-1 which was in
the nature of a memorandum explaining the impug·
ned rules, the State Government stated :
"Consequent upon the provincialisation of
Local Bodies' Schools the staff working in such
schools was :taken over into Government
Service. It was necessary to determine dicit
seniority vis-a-vis the old Government staft'.
The followin~ three alternatives with regard
to the integrauon of the two servicerwcre COii·
sidered : (a) Grouping formula· i. e,, counJeng of full
service of the local body tea rs for the
determination of joint seniority list;
(b) Integration of the two serviceiHnto a joint
cadre on the basis of counting service of
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
189
the local body teachers from the date of
provincialisation on grade to grade and
cadre to cadre basis ;
(c) Keeping separate cadres of the provincial·
ised staff and of the staff of the erstwhile
Government schools."
The government considered that the third alternative
was the best to be followed in the interests of a
sound educational policy and also in the interests of
these very teachers and r. 3 of the impugned rules
which we have· set out earlier was evolved in order
to reconcile the conflicting and divergent interests of
the two Services which it was decided should be
kept apart.
Apart from questioning the validity of the
impugned rules we did not understand the respondent
to deny that the government had considered this problem in the manner set out between 1957 and
January 1960.
If, as we hold, there was no integration (and
integration has no meaning unless it is complete, for
there is no such thing as partial integration) either
expressly or by necessary implication, it would follow
that it was not the impugned rules that created the
two distinct cadres but that they existed independently
of the rules and the only charge 1that could be laid
against the rules in this respect was that they fail.yd to
effect an integration. There .was some argument
before the High Court that the mere existence of two
Services with similar grades and scales of pay and
almost similar other eonditions of service was itself
illegal as amounting to discrimination prohibited by
Art. 14. In the counter-affidavit which was filed by
the State the Writ Petition of the respondent it
was stated that there were very wide differences in the
qualifications possessed by, the members of the two
1!162
Slal1 of Prmjab
v.
l•tindn Sintlo
.dJJanpr, J,
190 SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963] SUPP.
JY62
Stolt of Pajab
v.
J01i11d1r Sinth
A)Ja1u, J.
Services and great disparity in the methods of recruitment. There were minimum educational qualifications
prescribed by the
Educational Service Class
III Rules, 1955 as well as the rules as they
stood as notified on May 30, 1957 under which
teachers in the State cadre were recruited. Besides,
they were recruited after interview by the Public
Service Commission, but this was not the case in
the Board schools, between which even there were very
great variations both in · the minimum qualifications
to be possessed and in the1methods of recruitment. In.
view of these differences ~e counter-affidavit by the
State averred that the "provincialised" teachers and
the State teachers could not be said to form the same
class as to require identity of treatment. The. facts
stated in this respect were not controverted before the
Hi~h Court by the respondent and by those whose
petitions were disposed of along with his and it was
for this reason that counsel for the ·respondent specifically abandoned before the High Court all argument
about the differentiation of the two Servicea per ae not
amounting to a discrimination within Art. 14. The
reasons therefore which underlay the abandonment of
any argument regarding Art. 14 would negative any
submission that the recognition of the two Services as
independent cadres was itself discriminatory, once the
argument about their having been integrated by the
Government Order of September 27, 1959 be rejected.
It would therefore follow that if the respondt'nts cannot sustain their contention that the order dated
September 27, 1957, effected a c;:omplete integration
of the two Services, there could be no basis for the
submission that the "provicialiscd" teachers and
teachers in the State Cadre formed the same class so
as to enable a comP.laint to be made under Art. 14 if
they were treated differently.
It now remains to consider a point which was
raised that the State cannot constitute two Services
CO!JSis~ of employees doing the same work but wiib
,.
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
191
different scales of pay or subject to different conditions
. of service and that the constitution of such services
would be violative of Art. 14. Underlying this submission are two postulates : (1) equal work must receive
.equal pay, and (2) if there be equality in pay and
work there have to be equal conditions of service. So
·far as the first proposition is concerned it has been
definitely ruled out by this Court in Kishori llfohanlal
v. Union of lndia(1). Das Gupta, J., speaking for the
Court said :
"The only other contention raised is that there
is discrimination between Class I and Class II
officers inasmuch as though they do the same
kind of work their pay scales are different. This,
it is said, violates Art. 14 of the Constitution. If
this contention had any validity, there could be
no incremental scales of pay fixed dependent on
the duration of an officer's service. The abstract
doctrine of equal pay for equal work has nothing
to do with Art. 14. The contention that Art. 14
of the Constitution has been violated. therefore,
also fails."
The second also, is, in our opinion, unsound. If, for
instance, an existing service is recruited on the basis
of a certain qualification, the creation of another
service for doing the same work, it .might be in the
same way but with better prospects of promotion
cannot be said to be unconstitutional, and the fact that
the rules framed permit free transfers of personnel of
the two groups to places held by the other would not
make any difference. We are not basing this answer
on any theory that if a government servant enters into
any contract regulating the conditions of his service
he cannot call in aid the constitutional guarantees
because he is bound by his contract. But this conclusion rests on different and wider public grounds, viz.,
that the government which is carrying on the administration has necessarily to have a choice in the
constitution of the services to: man tl,ie <14mini11tr.ati!>,IJ
(I) A.IA. (11162) S, Q, JISll·
I
,
. 1962
Stall of Punjab
v.
Jogind1r Singh
Ayyongar, J,
192 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]SUPP.
1962
St•I• of P•n}ab
••
Jogintler Sin1ll
Ayyt1111ar, J.
and that the limitations imposed by the constitution
are not such as to preclude the creation of such services.
Besides, there might, for instance, be temporary recruitment to meet an exigency or an emergency which
is not expected to last for any appreciable period of
time. To deny to the government the power to recruit
temporary staff drawing the same pay and doing the
same work as other permanent incumbents within the
cadre strength but governed by different rules and
conditions of service, it might be including promotions,
would be to impose restraints on the manner of administration which we believe was not intended by the
constitution. For the purpose of the decision of this
appeal the question here discussed is rather academic
but we are expressing ourselves on it in view of the
arguments addressed to us.
Besides the disparity in the chances of promo·
tion between teachers of the provincialised and the
State Cadre created by r. 3 of the impugned rules,
the learned Judges of the High Court have held that
there was a further disparity by reason of the teachers
of the State Cadre being borne on a Divisional list,
while under the rules the inter se seniority and promotions of "provincialised" teachers was determmed
district-wise. It was pointed out by the learned
Solicitor General for the appellant that the State
Cadre was kept on a Divisional basis because of the
ve-ry small number of the members of that Service,
whereas it was found administratively inconvenient
to have a similar geographical classification of
members of the provincialised service and for that
reason and no other, district-wise seniority, promotion
and transfers was laid down for provindalised
teachers. Learned Counsel for the respondent did
not rely on this reasoning of the learned Judges of
the High Court in deciding the case now under
appeal. We therefore do not consider it nece11sary I<•
make any further reference to it.
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
t
-
193
As we have stated already, th!' two services
started as independent Services. The 9.ualifications
prescribed for entry into each were different, the
method of recruitment and the machinery for the
same were also different and the general qualifications
possessed by · and large by the members of each
class being different, they started as two distinct
classes. If the government order of September 27,
1957, did not integrate them into a single service,
it would follow that the two remained as they started
as two distinct services. lf they were distinct services,
there was no question of inter se seniority between
members of the two services, nor of any comparison
between the two in the matter o.f promotion for founding an argument based upon Art. 14 or Art. 16(1).
They started dissimilarly and they continued dissimilarly and any dissimilarity in their treatment
would not be a denial of equal opportunity, for it is
common ground that within each group there is no
denial of that freedom guaranteed by the two
Articles. The foundation therefore of the judgment
of the learned Judges of the High Court that the
impugned rules created two classes out of what was
formerly a single class and introduced elements of
discrimination between the two, has no factual basis
if, as we hold, the order of September 27, 1957, did
not effectuate a complete integration of the two
Services. On this view it would follow that the
impugned rules cannot be struck down as violative of
the Constitution.
Before concluding it is necessary to point out
that, as explained earlier, the source of the
prejudice caused by the impugned rules to the "pro·
vincialised" teachers lies not in the. fact that the two
cadres were kept separate but on account of the fact
that the "provincialised" cadre was intended to be
gradually extinguished. The real question for con~ideration wou Id therefore be whether there was any·
thing unconstitutional in the Government decision in
Stale of Punjab
v.
Jogind1r Sing~
A,,agnar, J.
~
194 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963) SUPP.
1962
Sl4l1 qf P•nfrr6
v.
Jo1indlf w,,,h
A..JJUI•'· J.
Shala, J.
the matter. In other words, had the respondent and his
class any fundamental right to have their cadre strength maintained undiminished? This is capable of being
answered only in the negative. If their cadre strength
became diminished, the proportion thereof who could
be in the grade, viz., 15% of the total strength being
predetermined, there must necessarily be a progressive
reduction in the number of selection posts. In other
words a mere reduction of the cadre strength would
bring about that result and unless the respondent
could establish that the Government were bound in
law to fill up all vacancies in the proviucialised cadre
by fresh recruitment to that cadre and thus keep its
strength at the level at which it was on October l,
1957, he should fail. It is manifest that such a
contention is obviously untenable.
There could not be anydispute that the impugned rules which enable vacancies in the selection grade
of the State Cadre to be filled in part by teachers
belonging to the "provincialised" service by the
devise of the block system greatly improves their
position. Tlte claim in the memorandum accompany·
ing the impugned rules Ex. RI that the sy~tem has
been framed so as to improve their conditions should
therefore be considered to have some justification.
The appeal is accordingly allowed and the
order of the High Court striking down r. 2(d) and (e)
and r. 3 in so far as it relates to promotions is set
aside. In the peculiar circumstances of this case we
consider that there should be no order as to costs in
this appeal.
SHAH, J.-In this appeal the validity of the
Puajab Government Notification No. 12832-ED-II·
59(2935 dated January 27, 1960, and the Rules
framed under Art. 309 of the Constitution by the
Governor of Punjab, on February 13, 1961 in so
far as· they purport to prescribe a scheme. for Pro·
motion of "provincialised" junior teachers to the
selection grade is challenged.
2 S.C.R.
I
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
195
On the re-organisation of the State of Punjab
on November 1, 19q6, the Patiala and East Punjab
States Union which was a part 'B' State was merged
with the State of Punjab, but for administrative
purposes, in so far as it related to matters educational,
· the area was maintained as a separate division and
the teachers serving in that region were maintained in
a separate cadre. In this appeal we are not concerned
with the rights and obligations of those teachers.
On July 23, 1957, the Government of the State of
Punjab issued a scheme of revision of scales of pay of
low-paid public servants. By paragraph 3 which
applied to employees in the Education Department it
was directed that all teachers according to their qualifications be placed in two broad categories~ategory
'A' and Category 'B'. Teachers in Category 'B' were
divided into three. classes, Lower Rs. 60-4-80/5-100/ii120. Middle Rs. 120-5-175, and Upper Rs. 140-10250. It was decided that "with a view to providing
incentives, posts falling in these groups should be in
the following percentages : Group I-Lower scale
...... 85 per cent
Middle scale
...... 15 per cent
15 per cent of teachers in this group should
straightway be promoted .to the middle scale by
selection, based on seniority and merit, while the
rest should be given the lower scale."
We are not concerned with Group II and Group IJI
in this appeal.
Before October 1, 1957, in the State of Punjab
(excluding the territory of the Patiala and East Punjab
States Union which had merged with the State on re·
organisation of the States on November I, 1956) there
were two sets of schools-schools maintained by the
District and Municipal Boards and schools maintained
by the State. On September 27, 1957, the Government
1962
St1:11 of PU1tjU
v.
Jo,U.dl'f s;.1•
Sholl, I.
196 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
1952
Stall of Pujab
v.
Jogindtr Singh
Shih, J.
of the State of Punjab issued a Notification
"provincialising" all District Board and Municipal
Board schools with effect from October l, 1957, and
took over the management of those schools. The
number of schools to be taken over and the posts to
be created in respect of the teaching and other staff
in the various grades were set out in paragraph 2 of
the scheme. Out of the 'provincia!ised teachers'
3016 (J.V.S, J.T.S, and J.B.F.S, and others) were to
be absorbed in the grade of Rs. 120-5-175 and 17123
in the grade of Rs. 60-4-80/5-100/5-120, and it was
recited in the Notification that "all the incumbents of
the Local Body Schools to be provincialised with
effect from lst October, 1957 will be given the same
grades of pay and other allowances as are given to
their counter-parts already in Government employ.
Their pay will be fixed under the rules and there will
be no drop in their present emoluments'',
The Government of Punjab thereafter appointed
a Committee for framing rules for fixing inter-State
seniorHy of the 'provincialised teachers' and the State
Schooh teachers, the terms of pension and other allied
matters. By letters d_at{d January 27, 1960, from the
Secretary, Education Department, the Director of
Public Instructions was informed that it had been
decided, inter alia, that "the staff of provincialised
schools and the erstwhile Government schools will be
kept in separate cadres. All new entrants into service
after the .date of provinciali.sation will be deemed to
have joined the ranks of the staff of erstwhile Government schools. The provincialised staff cadre would
be a continuously diminishing cadre and would in
course of time completely vanish leaving in the field
only one cadre i.e. the cadre of Government staff. It
is considered that this would ensure the same chances
of promotion to the staff of erstwhile Government
schools as existed before provincialisation whereas the
provincialised staff would get the benefit of promotion
to a large number of posts created directly as a result
I
l.
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
197
of provincialisation. There would be no administrative difficulty with regard to the transfers of teachers
borne on both the cadres from one school to the other
irrespective of the fact whether it is a provincialised
school or a Government school, inasmuch as the two
cadres would be ~eparate only for the purpose of future
promotions". It was also stated that "the two separate
cadres will be known as "State Cadre" and "Provincialised Cadre". All the vacancies arising out of the
normal incidence of retirements, promotions, etc. etc.
in the Provincialised Cadre, will be transferred to the
State Cadre. In the State Cadre, the posts will be
split up in the ratio of 15 (Rs. 250-300 and 250-350):
85 (Rs. 110-250) in the case of Anglo- Vernacular
Teachers; and 15 (Rs. 140-220) : 35 (Rs. 120-175) : 50
(Rs. 60-120) in the case of Vernacular staff. - The
number of posts in the higher grades released as a
result of retirements, promotions etc. in the provincialised cadre minus those created on the State Cadre
will be utilized for the promotion of teachers on the
provincialised Cadre from lower to higher grades".
The respondent Jogendra Singh who was a
District Board Junior Vernacular teacher addressed a
memorandum to the Government of the State that
the bifurcation of the Junior vernacular teachers into
two categories was "unnatural" and put the teachers
from the 'provincialised schools' to a great disadvantage and that the treatment being discriminatory
"was wholly illegal, unreasonable and invalid and
offended Art. 14 of the Constitution". It was submitted that the scheme should not be introduced
without promulgation by the Governor of the State
of Punjab rules under Art. 309 of the Constitution.
The respondent and others having failed to obtain
any relief filed petitions under Art. 226 of the Constitution being petitions Nos. 1559 of 1960 and 61,
Hi2 and 16:! of 19Gl for writs or orders or directions
quashing the Punjab Government
Notification
No. 12832-ED-11-59/2935 dated January 27, 1963.
1962
SllJt. of Pu•ju
••
Jogilllhr Singh
Shah, J.
198 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963) SUPP.
1962
SIOll'Of Punjab
v.
Jogind1r ,'\inth
Shah, J.
Subsequent to the institution of the petitions
the Governor of Punjab published rules on February
13, 1961, under Art. 309 of the Constitution setting
up a separate cadre of 'provincialised' teachers and
regulating conditions of service of the teaching staff
taken over by the State Government from the Local
authorities consequent upon 'provincialisation' of the
Board schools. Simultaneously with the publication
of the rules, a 'policy statement' explaining the reasons
for setting up a distinct cadre, and· the scheme for
promotion to higher scale and other matters was
also published. It wa5 recited in the 'policy statement' that after considering three alternative schemes
one of grouping, other of integration of the two services
into a joint cadre and the third of keeping separate
cadres of provincialised staff and the staff of the
erstwhile Government schools, the following
important 'policy decision' was taken by the Government"(i) The st.aft' of the provinciali5ed schools and
the erstwhile Government schools will be
kept on separate cadres;
All higher posts created on 1st October,
1957 directly due to the provincialisation of
Local Body schools will be filled up by
promotion from amongst the staff borne
on the provincialised cadre
(iii) Provincialised Cadre will be a diminishing
cadre and all future recruitment will be
made on the State Cadre ;
(iv) All the vacancies arising out of the normal
incidence of retirements, promotions, etc.
in the Provincialised Cadre will be transferred to the State Cadre. x x x x
The number of posts in the higher grades
released as a result of retirements, promotions, etc. in the Provincialised Cadre
minus those transferred to the State Cadre
(ii)
I
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME GOUR T REPORTS
199
will be utilised for promotion in the Pro·
vincialised Cadre,"
In dealing with the Vernacular Junior teachers it was
stated : There are the following two grades in this
section and the posts were divided in the ratio of
15: 85 (a) Rs. 120/175: 15 per cent and (b)
Rs. 60/120 : 85 per cent. Before a teacher is promoted from category (b) to (a), he/she must have at least
five years' service to his/her credit."
By rule 2(d), the expression 'service' was defin·
ed as meaning the Punjab Educational (provincialis·
ed Cadre) Class III Service. 'State Cadre' was de·
fined as meani,ng the Punjab Educational State
Service, Class III (School Cadre). By rule 3 it was pro·
vided that the Service shall comprise the posts shown
in the Appendix which shall be a diminishing cadre
and the number of posts in various cadres of the
Service shall be regulated in the manner set out
therein. Sub-rule 1 (i) provided that all posts created for any 'provincialised' school subsequent to its
being taken over by the Government shall not con·
stitute a part of the Service but shall be borne on
the State Cadre. By sub-rule 1 cl. (iii) it was pro·
vided that the posts in various cadres of the Service
falling vacant due to the normal incidence of promotions, retirement or any 'Other cause subsequent
to the date of 'provincialiiation' of local authority
schools shall be adjusted in the manner detailed
therein. Sub-rule (2) provided that all posts in the
Service shall be borne on a State-wide cadre except
the posts of Vernacular and Classical Teachers,
J. A. V., or J. S. T. Teachers and Junior Teachers
which will be borne on District-wise Cadres.
After promulgating the Rules and the Policy
Statement, the Government of Punjab filed their
written statement to the petitions and contended,
inter ali-1, that they were competent to take the
decision even after 'provincialisation' with regard to
1962
Sl•l1 •f Plll!iab
v.
l•tl•d" S0.11
Shah-I.
200
1962
S"114 of Punjab
v.
Jogindn Siogh
SMh, ·1.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
the service conditions of the 'provincialised' staff:
that all the service rules including rules of seniority
did not become automatically applicable to the
'provincialised' staff on October l, 1957, and as the
'provincialised' staff formed a separate cadre for
the purposes of promotion, there was reasonable
classification and no discrimination between the
State Cadre and the 'Provincialised' Cadre.
The High Court of Punjab rejected the plea
raised by the State of Punjab and held that the
teachers of the 'provincialised' cadre, and State cadre
were "Government servants of the same class" and
the former were deprived by the Rules and the
scheme equality of opportunity of promotion, and a
discriminatory treatment was accorded to the 'pro·
vincialised' staff by keeping them in a separate cadre
and treating recruitment to the vacancies accuring
in the 'provincialised' cadre as in the State Cadre
and at the same time maintaining a uniform ratio
of 15 and 85 per cent between the teachers drawing
higher scale and the lower scale salary. The High
Court accordingly declared that the Rules of 1961 in
so far as they created two cadres created inequality
of opportunity for promotion in the 'provincialised'
cadre and in particular Rules 2 and 3 to the extent
as stated above were void and inoperative against the
petitioners. The Government of Punjab acquiesced
in the order in three out of the four petitions, but for
some reason which is not apparent on the record and
none is furnished by counsel for the State filed an
appeal only against the present respondent. That,
however, is not a ground on which we may be justified in refusing to consider the appeal on the mcri ts as
submitted by counsel for the State.
It is undisputed that there were more than
20,000 teachers in the "provincialised schools" out of
whom 15 per cent were under the scheme of 'provincialisation" to be immediately posted in the higher
scale and the remaining in the lower scale. In the
2 s.c.R.
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
201
State Service there were only 107 posts before
October 1, 1957. The State teachers, and the provincialised teachers were by the rules and the statement made in the policy decision formed into two
separate i cadres, though they were given the same
grades of salary, performed the same duties, and were
liable to be transferred so as to interchange their posts.
The vice of the scheme lay in the provision that all
the vacancies in the provincialised cadre were not to be
filled by entrants to that cadre but new entrants were
to be treated as entrants to the State Cadre. The
practical effect of that provision was that the 'provincialised' cadre was gradually diminishing cadre which
would be extinguished in approximately about 30 years
whereas the State cadre was an expanding cadre. By
maintaining the uniform ratio of 15 to 85 in both the
cadres between the higher scale and the lower scale
some teachers in the; "provincialised" cadre and in the
lower scale were relegated to a perpetual state of
remaining juniors even to new enirants in the State
cadre. This is manifest from a simple illustration. Assuming that 3 per cent of the total strength fall vacant
at the end of each year on account of death, retirement,
resignation and other causes, their would be approximately 630 vacancies in the first year of the operation
of the scheme 630 new appointments would therefore
be made in the State Cadre, in that year, and the 'provincialised' Cadre would be reduced by that number.
The State Cadre which consisted of 107 on October 1,
1957, would on October 1, 1958, be a cadre of 737
teachers, and because of the uniform ratio of 15 to 85
per cent in each cadre between the higher scale and
the lower scale 15% of 737 teachers would have to be
placed in the State cadre in the higher scale. That
would mean that practically all the teachers in the
State Cadre would be.promoted to the higher scale at
the end of the year irrespective of their seniority
provided they satisfied the requirement of the rule
relating to educational qualifications and the requisite
qualifying length of service. Assuming that all the
1962
S1<1t1 of Pmu'ab
v.
Jogindtr SU.th
Shah, J.
202 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
1962
Sla/1 of Punjab
v.
Jogintkr Singh
Shah J.
107 teachers possessed those qualifications all the
members of the old State Service would be promoted
to the higher scale. At the end of the year ending
September 30, 1959 the scheme would break down,
because in the State Cadre there would be a total
strength of 1345 out of whom more than 201 would
be in the higher scale. For that purpose more than
a hundred would have to be promoted to the higher
scale, and the Government would have to draw upon
the junior scale of the State Cadre who may not have
satisfied the requirement as to the duration of service.
If the condition of length of service is waived about
100 teachen who are new entrants in the State Service .
would ·be promoted to the higher scale, whereas a
large number of 'provincialised' teachers would still
continue to remain in the lower scale even though
they would be many years senior to the new entrants
and may otherwise have the requisite qualifications
for promotion. That this would be the result of
complying with the terms of the scheme, is not
disputed by the Solicitor-General who appeared on
behalf of the State.
Article 16 (1) of the constitution provides :
"There' shall be equality of opportunity for all citizens
in matters relating to employment or appointment to
any office under the State". This Court in dealing
with the extent of protection of Art. 16 (l) observed
in General Manager Southern Rly. v. Rangachari('),
"it would· be clear that matters relating to employment cannot be confined only to the initial
matters prior to the act of employment. The
narrow construction would confine the application of Art. 16 (1) to the initial employment
and nothing else ; but that clearly is only one of
the matters relating to employment. The other
matters relating to employment would inevitably be the provision as to the salary and
periodical increments therein, terms as to leave,
as to gratuity, as to pension and as to the age of
(IJ
[19oZJ 2 s.c.R. 586.
-
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
203
superannuation. These arc all matters relating
to employment and they are, and must be,
deemed to be included in the expression 'matters
relating to employment' in Art. 16 (1) xx xx
What Art. 16 (1) guarantees is equality of
opportunity to all citizens in respect of all the
matters relating· to employm<>nt illustrated by
us as well as to an appointment to any office
as explained by us. x x x x The three
provisions (Art. 16 (1), Art. 14 and Art. 15 (1))
form part of: the same constitutional code of
guarantees and supplement each other. If that
be so, there would be no difficulty in holding
that the matters relating· to employment must
include all matters in relation to employment
both prior, and subsequent, to the employment
which are incidental to the employment and
form part ·Of the terms and conditions of such
employment."
Dealing with Art. 16 (1) the Court observed:
"Art. 16 (2) 'prohibits discrimination and thus
assures the effective enforcement of the fundamental right of equality of opportunity guaranteed by Art. 16 (1). The words 'in respect of
any employment' used in Art. 16 (2) must,
therefore, include all matters relating to employment as specified in Art. 16 (1). Therefore, we
x promotion to
are satisfied that x x
selection posts is included both under Art. 16. ( 1)
and (2)." .
Ex facie, by the promulgation of the rule and
the implementation of the scheme of promotion the
fundamental right of the junior teachers in the
'provincialised' cadre and in the lower scale is infringed. But the Solicitor-General appearing on behalf
of the State of Punjab contended that the 'provincialised Cadre' was a newly created cadre, and it was
19'2
Stat1 of Punjab
v.
Jogirul1r Sin1~
Shah, J.
204 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [HJ63J SUPP.
1962
Stat• of Punjab
•• Singh
Jagind1r
Skal1. J.
open to the Government of the State to offer such
terms of employment as they thought proper to the
new entrants in the Service when the District Board
and Municipal Board i.chools were 'provincialised'.
The Government in exercise of their admitted right,
said counsel, offered terms of service which though
substantially similar to the terms by which the 'State
Cadre' was governed, differed in two important
respects (i) that the transfer of junior teachers was
to be within the District and (ii) that the right of
promotion was restricted in the manner prescribed,
and the provincialised teachers having accepted those
terms, they formed a separate grade with different
terms of employment and they could not be deemed
to belong to the same class as members of the State
Cadre, and therefore the case of the respondent was
one covered by the decision of this Court in All India
Swticm Masters' & Assistant Stat·ion Masters' Association v. General Manager, G. R. (') and Ki.Yhori
Molianlal Bakshi v. Union of India ('). Counsel
relied upon the principle enunciated by this Court in
All India Staticm Masters' case (') that ··'the question
of denial of equal opportunity required sericus consideration only as between the members of the same
class. The concept of equal opportunity in' matters
of employment, does not apply to variations in provisions as between members of different classes of
employees under the State. Equality of opportunity
in matters of employment can be predicted only between persons who are either seeking the same employment, or have obtained the same employment.
Equality of opportunity in matters of promotion,
must mean equality as between members of the same
class of employee and not equality between members
of separate, independent classes"; and in Kishori
Mohanlal Bakshi's case(') that "inequality of opportunity for promotion as between citizens holding different posts in the same grade may, therefore, be an
infringement of Art. 16". That no such question can
arise at"all when the rules make the members of two
(I] [1960] 2 S.C.R. Sil.
(2) A.I.R, (1962) S.C. 1139.
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
205
grades eligible for promotion to different posts, there
is in strict sense, no denial of equality of opportunity
as among citizens holding posts of the same grade.
As between citizens holding posts in different grades
in Government service there can be no question of
equality of opportunity and that Art. Hi does not
forbid the. creation of different grades in the Govemmen t service.
The crucial point falling for determination in
this case is whether the members of the 'Provincialised Cadre' belong to the same grade as the members
of the 'State Cadre.' It is true that two separate
cadres-the State Cadre, and the Provincialised
Cadre-were formed by the Government, but in our
judgment the division into two cadres was not decisive of the question whether there was denial of equal
opportunity. The same scales of remuneration were
paid to members of both the cadres. They performed the same duties and functions and held the same
posts. Posts occupied by State Cadre teachers could
be occupied by the 'Provincialised' school teachers
and vice versa. It is admitted in the letter dated
January 27, 1960, addressed by the Secretary to the
Government of Punjab, Education Department to the
Director of Public Instructions, which formed the
basis or the setting up of the two cadres, that the two
cadres u:ere separate only for the purposes of future
promotion. We are in the circumstances unable to
hold that between the members of the State Cadre
and the 'Provincialised' Cadre there was any valid
basis f r classification so as to justify a differential
treatmc nt between their members inter se for the
purposes of promotion without infringing the Consti·
tutional guarantee of equality of opportunity in the
matter of employment. In the· All India Station
Master's case (') there were two distinct classe$ of
Railway employees-Roadside Station Masters and
Guards. These two elasses of employees performed
distinct duties : each class had separate rules fixing
(I) [1960] 2 S.C.R. Sil.
1962
Slol1 of Punjab
v.
Jogiruier Si,,gh
Shalt, J.
206 SUPREME GOUR T REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
1962
StaU of Punjab
v.
Jogfttd6r Singh
Shah, J.
the number of personnel of each class, posts to which
the men in that class will be appointed, questions of
seniority, pay of different posts, the manner in which
promotion will be effected from the lower grades of
pay to the higher grades. It wa~ the view of the
Court that they could be reasonably considered to be
separate classes each in many matters an independent
entity with its own rules of recruitm~nt, pay and
prospects and other conditions of service varying considerably from another.
In Kishori Mohanlal Bakshi's case ('), the
Income-tax services were reconstituted. One of the
features of the reconstitution was that in place
of a single class of Income-tax Officers. two
classes came into existence, one consisting of Incometax Officers of Class I Service and the other
class in which all the then existing Income tax
Officers were placed forming the Class II Officers.
Class I Officers were eligible to be promoted
to the higher posts of Commissioners and Assistant
Commissioners ; Class II Officers were not however
digible to be directly promoted to the higher posts,
A percentage of the vacancies in the posts of Class
I Officers was to be fillrd by promotion of Class II
Officers and the rest bv direct recruitment. The
two classes of Officers did undoubtedly perform the
same kind of work but their pay scales were different.
The Court on those facts held that there was no
denial of equal opportunity among citizens holding
posts of the same grade. In the present case, it cannot be said that the grades of the 'Provincialistd'
teachers and the State Cadre were different. It may
be true that in some cases, a lower degree of ~fficiency
may have been insisted upon at the time of recruitment to the service which ultimately becamt> the
'Provincialised' Cadre. But once the District Board
and Municipal Board school teachers were taken
over by the Government of Punjab and an amalgamated Educational Service was evolved, any special
(I) A.LR. (1962) S.C. 1139.
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME ·coURT REPORTS
207
provision relating to promotion depending solely upon
the source of recruitment and upon no other ground
seriously affected the rights of the members of the
'Provincialised' Cadre to promotion, and infringed
Art. 16 cl. (1) of Constitution. It may be noticed
that for promotion to the higher grade the conditions
in respect of b\'.)th the State Cadre and the 'Pro·
vincialised' Cadre are the same namely that the
teacher must be a Matriculate and must have put ·-in
service for five years in the Education Department.
Therefore persons not possessing the prescribed educa·
tional qualifications admitted to the District Board
and Municipal Boards as teachers will have no right
to promotion.
It was submitted on behalf of the State that
it was open to Government to give to the members
of the 'Provincialised '· Cadre such terms as they
thought proper and the Government was not bound
to give the 'Provincialised' Cadre the same grades
as were in fact given and therefore it was not open
to the members of the 'Provincialised' Cadre to raise
a dispute about the validity of the provisions relating
to promotions. Bllt if the Government in fact gave
the lame termq of employment and have in effect
constituted a single grade of teachers State and 'provincialised', any discrimination between the member,;
of that grade based on the source of recruitment so
as to treat persons who have subsequently entered
the service differently
would clearly infrin~e
Ari. 16 (1) and (2). It was doubtless open tothe
Government at the initial stage to give to the 'Pro·
vincialiset1' Cadre different terms and not to constitute them into a service with the same grade as
the State Cadre, but the Government did give the
same terms to the 'Provincialised' teachers, and it
was not then open to the Government to make rules
relating to prowotion so as to diqcriminate between
the 'l'rovincialised' teachers and the State Cadre
teachers.
N62
•.
Stall of P"njab
Jogindd Siifh
Shah, J.
208 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963] SUPP.
1962
S1at1 of Pu'ljab
••
Jog;,,,/" Singh
Shah, J.
It was also suggested that if the Government
had treated all the teachers equally, the teachers
who were absorbed from the Pepsu region would have
taken precedence over the 'Provincialised' teachers
and the members of the 'Provincialised' Cadre would
not have even the slender chance of promotion to
which they are entitled under the present scheme.
It is unnecessary to consider as to what would have
happened under a different scheme if adopted by the
Government. It is common ground that the teachers
who were absorbed from the Pepsu region were formen into a separate Cadre, distinctive character of
which has been maintained;' We are concerned in
this case with the 'State' teachers and the 'Pro·
vincialised' teachers under the scheme which came
into effect on October l, 1957 and in that scheme
teachers absorbed from the Pepsu region have not
been integrated. It is problematical whether 'Provincialised' teachers would have stood to gain by
being integrated into a common service with the
teachers in the Pepsu region. That is a question
which.does not fall to be determined in this appeal.
Finally, it was contended that the rules having
been given retrospective operation from October l,
1957, it was open to the Government to accord to
the new entrants such terms as the Government
thought proper and thereby no right of the new
entrants was infringed. But it cannot be forgotten
that in the firsffostance Government of the State
admitted the 'Provincialised' teachers into a single
unit of employment and thereafter by retrospective
provision they .have sought to provide a dif\erential
treatment between the two sections constituting one
unit. It is against this differential treatment that
the protection of Art. 16 is claimed and in our judgment avails.
In our view the High Court was right in holding that the rules in so far as they provide for diffe·
rential treatment between the members of the 'State
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
209
Cadre' and the 'Provincialised Cadre' in the matter
of promotion to the higher scale must be regarded as
invalid. The appeal must therefore fail.
BY COURT : In view of the opinion of the
majority, the appeal ,is allowed and the order the
High Court striking down r. 2(d) and (e) and r. 3
in so far as it relates to promotions is set aside.
There will 'be no order as to costs in this appeal.
of
J!ln
SIMI of hl}ob
' 'v.
l•ri"'" SilltA
··SW,I.
COMMISSIONER OF· INCOME-TAX, BOMBAY
1961
v.
N-"', 16,
ROBERT J. SAS
(S. K. DAS, J. L. KAPUR, A. K. SARKAR;
M. HIDAYATULLAH and RAOHUBAR DAYAL, JJ.)
Inwme Tax-Notico of ·as•umaent-Limitalicm forIncome deemed lo be distributed as dfoidtnd-Indian I~z
Act, 1922 (11of1922), 88. 23 A(l), 34,
The asscssccs were the three sharcholden of a private
company. The company made profits in the calendar year
1947, but did not declare any dividend at the shareholders
The Income-tax
mreting· held on December 4, 1948.
Officer passed an 01 der under s. 23 A (I) of the Income·tax Act
whereby the income of the company was dccrncd to have been
divided amongst the· three shareholders. He issued notices to
the as'ICSSCCS which were served on them on April 1, 1954. The
asscssecs contended that the notices were served beyond the
period of four }can allowed by s. 34 (1) (b),
Held, that the notices served under s. 34 (1) of the Act
were beyond time . and the Income-tax Officer had no jurisdiction to assess the asses.secs. Under s. 23A ( 1) the dividend was
to be d~med to, have been. distnbuted not on June 30, 1949,
by which date the company should have distributed the
dividend, but on the date of the general meeting i.e., December,
4, 1948 within the accounting year 1948 and asscssmeut year
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org