AST INDIA COMMERCIAL CO., LTD., CALCUTTA AND ANOTHER versus THE COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS, CALCUTTA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 4 May 1962 | [1963] 3 S.C.R. 338 | 1962 INSC 210
Key facts
- Decided
- 4 May 1962
- Bench
- A.K. SARKAR*, K. SUBBA RAO, J.R. MUDHOLKAR
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 383/1960
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1963] 3 S.C.R. 338
- Neutral citation
- 1962 INSC 210
Text of the judgment
I
338
Moy I.
SUPREME COURT REPOR'fS [1963]
EAST INDIA COMMERCIAL CO., LTD.,
CALCUTTA AND ANOTHER
v.
THE COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS, CALCUTTA
(A. K. SARKAR, K. SmrnA RAo 11.nd
J. R. MunnoLKAR, JJ.)
Import-Law enabling Government to iasue notifications
prohibiting or restricting Import-Import licence-Breach of
conditions-If amounts to import without licence-Law deo/ared
by High Oourt-lf binding on authorities or tribunals under its
superintendence-Sea OUBtnma Act, 1878 (8 of 1878), ss. 19,
167;8)-Imports and Exports (Oontrol) Act, 1947 (18 of 1947),
••· 3, ti-Oomtitution of India, Arts. 226, 227.
On October 8, 1948, the appellant company was granted
a licence to import from the U. S. A. a large quantity of
electrical instruments. The licence was issued subject to the
condition that the goods would be utilised only for consumption as raw material or accessories in the licence holder's
factory and that no portion thereof would be sold to
any party. After the goods arrived in India in FebruaryMarch, 1949, the company took delivery of them on payment of customs duty. On information alleged to have been
received by the authorities concerned that the goods
were being sold in the market io breach of the conditions of
the licence, the Police, after obtaining a search warrant from
the magistrate seized a large stock of the goods from the
godown of the appellant. On January 12, 1951, the customs
authorities filed a complaint before the Magistrate under s. 5
of the Imports and Exports (Control) Aet, 1947, against the
second appellant, who was a director of the company, and
others, on the allegation that the accused persons had, in
violation of the conditions of the licence, disposed of portions
of the goods covered by it. The Magistrate discharged the
accused and his order was confirmed by the Hi~ h Court on
March 3, 1955, on the ground thats. 5 of the Act penalised
only a contravention of an order made or deemed to have
been made under the said Act, but did not penalise the
contravention of the conditions of licence issued under the
Act or issued under a statutory order made under the Act,
On January 16, 1953, the High Court made an order
directing the seized goods to be sold and the sale proceeds
kept with the Chief Presidency Magistrate. On August 28,
3 S.C,R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
339
19(1
1955, the Collector Cuatoms served a notice on the appel·
!ants under s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act, 1871, read
Ea1t lniia
with s. 3 (2) of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 19-4-7
Comm1rcial Co.,
to show cause why the moneys lying with the Chief
Ltd., CalcJttta
Presidency Magistrate representing the imported goods
y,
should not be confocated and also why penalty should not Co/hctQr of Curt1m•
o.tcutta
be imposed on them, inasmuch as they had infringed the
conditions of the licence issued to them by selling a portion
of the goods imported to others. The appellants filed an
application under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India
before the High Court of Calcutta praying for a write of
prohibition restraining the respondent from proceeding with
the enquiry on the ground that it was without jurisidiction.
Held, (Ptr Subba Rao and Mudholkar, JJ., Sarkar, J.,
dissenting), that: (I) that the application under Art. 226 of
the Constitution was maintainable, because, if on a true
construction of the provisions of law under which the notice
was issued, the respondent had no jurisdiction to initiate
proceedings in respect of the acts alleged to have been done
by the appellants, the respondent could be prohibited from
proceeding with the same.
~-;
(2) under s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act, 1878, read·
with s.3(2) of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947,
only the goods imported in contravention of an order under
the latter Act were liable to be confiscated, but the section did
not expressly or by necessarly implication empower the
authority concerned to consficate the goods imported under a
valid licence on the ground that a condition of the licence
not imposed by the order was infringed or violated. The
infringement of a condition in the licence was not an infringement of the order and did not, therefore, attract s.167(8) of
the Sea Customs Act.
(3) public notices issued by the Government of India
governing the issue of import licences were not orders issued
under s. 3 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act.
(4) in the present case, as the goods were imported
under a valid licence they could not be considered as goods
either prohibited or restricted within the meaning of s. 167 (8)
of the Sea Customs Act and, therefore, the Collector of
cu~toms had no jurisdiction to proceed with the enquiry
under that section.
Per Subba Rao and Mudholkar,JJ.-The law declared
by the hi~hest Col\rt iq the Stat"' w~s binding on '\Uthoritie~
340
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
11161
or tribunals under its superintendence and that they could
not ignore it either in initiating a proceeding or deciding on
East India
the rights involved in such a proceeding. Consequently, the
Commercir:d Ct'.,
High
Court of Calcutta, having by its order dated March 3,
Ltd., Calcutta
1955, held that a contravention of a condition imposed by a
Oo/lector of Cu•lorns, licence issued under the Act was not an offence under s. 5 of
C11lculta
the Act, the notice dated August 28, 1955, signifying the
launching of proceedings contrary to the law laid down by
the High Court, was invalid.
••
Per Sarkar, J.-(1) The application under Art. 226
of the Constitution was not maintainable, because the Collector had jurisdiction t<> decide what was a breach of an
order and, therefore, whether the breach of a condition of a
licence was breach of an order.
(2) Even assuming that the decision of the High
Court dated March 3, 1955, was binding on the Collector,
that would not afftct his jurisdiction in the present case to
deci<fe whether the goods were liable to confiscation.
··~
(3) A breach of a condition of a licence issued under
an order made under the Imports and Exports (Control) Act
1917, was a breach of the order itself.
(4) Where after crossing the customs barrier lawfully,
goods are disposed of in contravention of a restriction duly
imposed, they must be considered to have been imported
contrary to the restriction.
"~
C:rvIL APPELLATE JURI!!DICTION : Civil Appeal
No. 383 of 1960.
Appeal by Rpeoial leave from the judgment
and order dated January 5, 1959, of the Calcutta
High Court in Appeal from Original Order No. 54
of 1957.
A.V. Vishvanatha Sastri, E. R. Mayer, Noni
Kumar Ghakrawrti and B. P. Maheshwari, for the
appellants.
Daulat Ram Prem and D. Gupla, for the respondent.
1962. May 4. Sarkar J. delivered his own
Judgment and the judgment of Subba Rao and
Mndholkar! JJ.~ was delivered b! Subba Rao~ J,
1--·.
3 S.O.R.
•
--',
SUPREME COO.RT REPORTS
341
S.utJUJl., J.-The a.ppellants had brought into
India from the U.S.A. a lit.rge quantity of electrical instrument11 under a. licenre. The respondent,
the Collector of Customs, Calcutta, started uroceedings for confiscation of these goods under· s.167(8)
of the Sea Customs Act, 1878. The appellants contend that the proceedings are entirely without
jurit1diction as the Collector can confiscate only
when there is an import in contravention of an
order prohibiting or re1tricting it and in the present
case the Collector was proceeding to confiscate on
the ground that a condition of the licence under
which the goods had been imported had been
disobeyed. The appel1ants, therefore, ask for a
writ of prohibition directing the Collector to stop
the proceedings. The question is, has the Collector
jurisdiction to adjudicate whether the goods are
liable to be confiscated? '1 he decision of that question, however, depends on certain statutory provisions and the fact of the case to which, therefore,
I shall immediately turn.
Sub-section ( 1) of I!!. 3 of the Import and Export& (Control) Act, 1947, provide!!! that the Government may by order prohihit, restrict or otherwise
control the import of goods. By Notification No.
23-I.T.C./43 issued under r. 84 of the Defence of
India Rnles which by virtue of s, 4 of the Act of
1947 is to be deemed to have been issued under that
Act, it waR ordered that no electrical instrument
could be brought into India except under a licence.
By another order made under B. 3 of the Act and
contained in Notification No. 2-ITC/48, dated March
6, 1948, it was provided that the licence to import
electrical instruments might be issued suject to the
condition that the goods would not be disposed of
or otherwise dealt with witho~t the written permission of the licensing authority.
The first appellant is a company and thll se9ond appellant, one of it~ dµ-e"Otors. On October 8,
1961!
Ea1t I niia
Cornrn••ciaJ C•.,
Lrtl., C"/cuttc
v.
Co//eotor •f Cu1lom•
Calcutta
Sarkar J.
/___,..
-
342
1962
Ea.at India
Commdrcial Co.,
Ltd., CalcuUa
v.
Colltctar ofCUlltoms,
Calcutta
Sarkar J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
1948, a licence was granted to the appellant to import from the U.S.A. a large quantity of electrical
instruments, namely fluorescent tubes and fluorescent fixtures. In the application for the licence it
was stated that the goods were not required for
sale but for modernising the lighting system of the
appellant's factory at Ellore in Madras. The licence
was issued subject to the condition that the goods
would be utilised only for consumption as raw
material or accessories in the licence holder's
factory and that no portion thereof would be sold
to any party.
The goods duly arrived in India and were
cleared out of the customs sometime about the end
of February, 1949. Soon t,hereafter, the authorities
concerned are said to h'1ve got information that the
goods were being sold in the market in breach of
the condition of the licence. Thereupon the police
took steps and after obtaining a search warrant
from a Magistrate in Calcutta on August, 12, 194!),
seized a large stock of the goods from the godown
of the appellents.
Thereafter on January 12, 1951, two proceedings were started. One of them was a prosecution
of various officers of the appellant company including the second appellant under s. 420 read with s.
120 of the Indian Penal Code on the allegation that
the licence had been obtained on false and fraudulent representations as there was no intention at
any time to use the goods for any factory. After
certain proceedings to which it is unnecessary to
refer, the accused persons were discharged by a Presidency Magistrate of Calcutta on July 27, 1953
under s. 253 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and
the prosecution under ss. 420 and 120B of the Penal
Code came to an end. The learned Magistrate held
that it had not been proved that the licensing authority had been deceived by any representation of
the a,ocu.sed o~cers of the oompan~ nor that "ri~ht
·~
1:· ~
......
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
343
from the time of applying for the licen0e, the intention was to sell the goods or part thereof''.
Ea.& .India
Oommercial Co.,
....
The other proceeding was a prosecution of the
Ltd., Calcutta
second appellant and another person under s. 5 of Coll~c:or v.
of Customs,
the Act of 1947. That section provides that "if
Calcutla
any person contravenes any order ... under this Aot,
Sarkar J.
he shall ... be punishable with imprisonment ... ". It
was alleged that the accused persona had in violation of the conditions of the licence disposed of
portions the goods covered by it and, therefore, com·
mitted an offence under s, 5 of the Aot of 1947. Thia
proceeding resulted in a acquittal by the trial Court
which was confirmed by the High Court at Calcutta
on March 3, 1955. Sen .r., who delivered the judgment
of the High Court said that it was difficult to hold
that a condition of the licence amounted to an order
under the Act and unless the penal section included
the contravention of the condition as an offence it
could not be held that such a contravention amounted to an offence under the section.
,
While these prooeedings were pending an
order was made by the High Court on January 16,
1953, directing the seized goods to be sold and the
sale proceeds kept with the Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta. Pursuant to this order the goods
were sold for a sum of Ra. 4,15,000 and the sale
proceeds have since been lying with the Chief Presidency Magistrate.
After the aforesaid proceedings had come to
an end, the Collector of Customs, Calcutt.a on August 28, 1955, served a notice on the appellant to
show cause why the moneys lying with the Chief
presidency Magistrate representing the imported
goods should not be confiscated under s. 167(8) of
the Sea Customs Act read with a. 3(2} of the Act of
1947 and why further penalty should not be imposed on them under these provisions. It is this notice
which gave rise to the proceedings with which w~
(_
344
199
East India
Ct>mtMrolal Co.,
Lid., Calcutea
v.
Collulot' oj Cu1tomB,
Ca/Mia
Sarkar J,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
are concerned. The notice stated that a prohibition
on the import of the goods except under a special
licence and subject to the conditions stated in it
was imposed under s. 3( l) of the Act of 1947 and
that by virtue of this prohibition the importation
of the goods would be deemed to be illegal unless
"(I) at the time of importation of goods were covered by a valid special licence which had not been
caused to be issued by fraudulent misrepresentation,
(2) after importation the goods or any part of them
were not sold or permitted to be utilised by any
other party, except the importers for consumption
as raw material." It also stated that investigation
had revealed that portion of the goods were sold by
the appellants to other people.
After receipt of the notice the appellants
moved the High Court at Calcutta under Art. 226
of the Constitution for a writ of prohibition prohibiting the respondent, the Collector of Customs,
Calcutta, from taking any proceeding pursuant to
the notice under ss. 167 and 182 of the Sea Customs Act against the appellante. The application
was first heard by Sinha, J,, and was dismissed.
An appeal by the appellants to an appellate bench
of the High Court also failed. The appellants
have now approached this Court in further appeal
by special leave.
:I
Sub-section (2) ofs. 3 of the Act of 1947 provides that "all goods to which any order under
sub-section (1) applies shall be deemed to be
goods of which the import or export has been prohibited or restricted under s. 19 of the Sea Customs
Act, 1878 and all the provisions of that Act shall
have effect accordingly". Section 19 of the Sea
Customs Act is contained in Chapter IV of that
Act. Section 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act states
the "If any goods, the importation or exportatioq
,,
',
__
..... ,
---·
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS
345
of which is for the time being prohibited or restricted by or under Chapter IV of this Act, be imported into or exported from India contrary to such
prohibitinn or restriction . . . such goods shall be
liable to confiscation; and any person concerned
in any such offence shall be liable to a penalty".
Section 182 of this Act authorises various Customs
Officers including a Customs Collector to adjudicate on questions of confiscation and penalty
under s. 167(8).
As earlier stated the question is one of jurisdiction. The contention of learned conusel for the
appellant is that under s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act read withs. 182 of that Act under which
the Collector of Customs is proceeding, he has jurisdisction only to decide whether goods have been imported contrary to the prohibition or restriction imposed by an order made under s. 3( I) of the Act of 1947
but he has no jurisdiction under these sections to
decide any question of confication of goods for
breach of a condition of a licence issued under
suoh an order. It is said that it 'Lppeared from
the notice served by the Collector that he was
proceeding to decide whether the goods were liable
to confiscation because they had been disposed of
in breach of the condition of the licence under
which they had been imported which he has no
jurisdiction to do and hence the appellants were
entitled to a writ of prohibition which they sought.
For the purpose of this argument the appellants
proceed on the assumption that there has been a
breach of the condition but this they do not, of
course, admit.
--
1962
East India
Co111,,.,,cial Co.,
Lid., 0 o/&utta
v.
Co//ecto, of Customs,
CalouUa
Sarkar J.
-
The basis of the appellant's contention is the
proposition that a breaoh of the conditions of a
licence is not a breach of the order under which
the licence was granted and the condition imposed
and that no offence under s. 167(8) of the Sea
Cqstoms Act is committed if a condition of the
'
'
•
;
'
•f
I.
346
Eutlndii
Comrnlf'&iaZ Co.,
Ltd., Calcutta
••
Collutor of Oustoms,
Ca/culta
SarkarJ.
! .
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963)
licence is contravened. In my view this proposition is not well founded. But assume it is correct.
Even so it sJems to me that there is no lack of
jurisdiction in the Collector in the present case .
He has admittedly jurisdiction to decide whether
there has been a. breach of an order. l t follows
that he has jurisdiction to decide what is a breach
of an order and, therefore, whether the breach of
a condition of a. licence is breach of an order. To
say that the breach of a condition is not a breach
of an order is only to set up a defence that the
goods cannot be confiscated for such a breach.
Such a contention does not oust the jurisdiction
of the Cullector to decide whether the breach of
a condition is breach of an order. If the Collector
decides that the breach of a condition is a breach
of an order. his decision, on the assnmption that
I have made, would be wrong but it would not be
a decision made without jurisdiction. This is the
view which all the learned Judges of the High
Court took and it seems to me to be the correct
view.
Further I think in the present case one of
the allegations in the notice is that the goods had
been imported without a licence and therefore in
direct violation of an order made under s. 3(1) of
the Act of 1947. Clearly, the Collector has juris·
diction to decide the question raised by such an
allegation. Now the notice served by the Collector on the appellants contains a statement that
an importation of goods would be illegal unless it
was covered by a licence which has not been procured by fraudulent misrepresentation and that
in the present case the licence had been obtained
by fraudulent misrepresentation. '.l'he notice hence
alleges that the goods had been imported really
without a licence, that is, in breach of an order.
Even if it be assumed, as the appellants contend
H1at an importation -qnder a licence fraq.dulently
I
•
1-
,... -
!
3 S.d.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
347
procured is not an importation without & licence,
that would only show that there has been no
importation without a licence, that is, in breach
of an order, but it would not deprive the Collector of his jurisdiction to decide that question.
Likewise the fact that a Magistrat~ has decided
that the licensing authority had not been deceived
by the appellants in the matter of the issue of the
licence which, if binding on the Collector, would
only show that the licence had not been fraudulently procured and cannot affect the Collector's
jurisdiction in any way.
It is also said that the decision of a. High
Court on a point of law is binding on all inferior
Tribunals within its territorial jurisdiction. It
is, therefore, contended that the Collector is bound
by the decision of Sen. J., to which I have earlier
referred, that the breach of a condition of a licence
is not a breach of the order under which the licence
was issued and the condition imposed, As at present advised I : m not prepared to subscribe to
the view that the decision of a High Court is so
binding. But it seems to me that the question
does not arise, for even if the decision of the High
Court was binding on the Collector, that would not
affect his jurisdiction. All that it would establish
is that the Collector would have, while exercising
his jurisdiction, to hold that the breach of a condition of the licence is not a breach of an order.
Its only effF .i would be that the appellants would
not have to establish independently as a. proposition of law that a breach of a condition of a licence
is not the breach of an order under which it had
been issued but might for that purpose rely on
the judgment of Sen, J.
I think, therefore, that the Collector has
jurisdiction in this case to decide whether the
goods were liable to confiscation. If he has this
jurisdiction, he has clearly also the jurisdiction to
East India
Oommercial Co.,
Ltd , C•l•uUa
v.
CollUlor of Ousto1nr
Catoulla
Sarkar J,
348
1152
lla1t /n,ia
0tmmllf'eial Co.,
Lid., Caiculla
••
Colltelor ol Custom1,
StJPltEME 00Ult1' REPoRTS (196:lJ
decide whether the appellants are liable to have a.
further pecuniary penalty imposed on them under
s.167(8) of the Sea Customs Act. If this is the
correct view, as I think it is, then the appellants
are not entitled to the writ.
Ca/OUlla
Sarkar .1.
But suppose I am wrong in what I have said
so far about the Collector's jurisdiction. Suppose
as the appellants contend, he had in this case no
jurisdiction to decide whether the goods are liable
to confiscation. That would be because the breach
of a condition of a licence is not a breach of an
order under which it was issued and the Collector
has no jurisdiction to decide whether it is so or
not. This is how the appellants themselves put it.
It has not been contended, and indeed it cannot
be, that if the breach of a condition of a licence
is the breach of an order under which it was issued,
the Collector would have jurisdiction to decide
whether in the present case the goods are liable
to confiscation.
I am unable to agree that the breach of a condi·
tion of a licence issued under an order made under the
Actofl947 is not a breach of the order. In my view,
euch a breach is a breach of the order itself. Sub·
section ( l) of s ;{ of the Act of 1947 empowers
the Government. to make orders prohibiting, restricting or otherwise controlling the import of
goods. Now clearly, one method of restricting or
controlling the import of goods would be to regu.
late their use or disposition after they had been
brought into India. Therefore, under the Act of
1947 the Government has power to restrict or control imports in this way; it could lawfully drovide
that the goods would not after import be dealt
with in a certain way. It would follow that Notification No. 2-ITC(48 was quite competent and
intra vires the Act and, therefore, the condition in
the licence issued in this case that the goods
would not be sold after they had been brought
-
8 S.C.R.
SUPRElME OOURT REPORT$
349
into Iodia had been legitimately imposed. The
contrary has not indeed been seriously contended.
Ea•t India
Co ,
When, therefore, such a condition is contravened, Commerci•l
Ltd. Q•leulla
,,,
it is really the order authorising its imposition
that is contravened. That aeems to me to be the Oell11:tor oJOuatoms,
Cal<ulla
clear intention of the legislature for otherwise the
Sarkar J.
efficacy of the Act of 1947 would be largely destroyed. That Act was intended to preserve and
advance the economy of the State on which the
welfare of the people depended. In such a statute
large powers have to be given to the Government
and they were undoubtedly so given in the present
case. The statute clearly intended and it 11hould
be so read that these power could be e.ffeotively
exercised. Therefore the breach of a condition of
a licence legitimately imposed in exercise of that
power has to be read as a breach of the order by
which the power was exercised and the condition
imposed. It follows that the Collector has jurisdiction to decide whether there has been a breach
of a condition of a licence and whether, therefore
confiscation should be ordered under s. 167(8) of
the Sea Customs Act and further penalty imposed.
-
••
I
I observed that Sen, J., in dealing with the
argument advanced on behalf of the customs
authorities that a breach of a condition of a licence
imposed under an order issued under the Act would
be a. breach of that order said that there might be
some substance in it in the present case, if notification No. 23-ITC/43 which provided that electrical instrument could not be imported without a
licence had itself provided that the licence might
impose condition as to how the goods were to be
dealt with after they had been brought into India
but that that had not been done. I am unable to
appreciate this reasoning. Notification No. 23-ITC/
43 has to be read along with Notification No.
2-ITC/48. The latter provided that a licence to
import might hfl issued subject to a condition like
§50
SUPREME CouRT REPORTS [1963]
llOI
the one which we have in the present case. The
licence
that was issued in this case was subject to
l!lu• lndia
these notificB.tions and was issued under both of
Cmm8""6l 60,,
Lil., OtiletAla
them. The position, therefore, is the same as if
v.
that the goods could
C4U"~ oj Ousto1111, one order had provided
Ciilcutta
not be imported except under a licence which
could impose the condition. I am unable to agree
Sa1la,. J.
with Sen, J., and also Sinha, J., who expressed
the same view without giving any reason to
support it.
I find that the view that I have taken is
supported. by authority. WiUingale v. Norris (1 )
is a case fully in point and is a much stronger case
That oa.se dealt with a prosecution under s. 19 of
the London Hackney Carriages Aot, 1853, which
provided that "for every offence against the provisions of this Act for which no special penalty is
hereinbefore appointed the offender shall be liable
to a penalty not exceeding forty shillings." A cab
driver was prosecuted under the section for breach
of a regulation made under s. 4 of the Hackney
Carriages Act, 1850. Section 21 of the Hackney
Carriages Act, 1853, provided that the Acts of 1850
and 1853 were to be considered as one Act. The
driver was held liable to be penalised under s. 19
of the Act of 1953. It was observed at p. 66.
"How a.re the words 'against the provisions of the Aot' to be read ? The two statutes
a.re to be construed as one. In my opinion,
to break the regulations made under the authority of a statute is to break the statute itself,
and therefore s. 19 of the London Hackney
Carriages Act, 1823 must be read thus: 'For
every offence against the regulations promulgated under these two Aet, which are to
be read as one, a penalty not exceeding forty
shillings may be imposed'."
(I) [ 1909] I K .B. 57, 66.
,<Ii
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
351
That case received the full approval of the House
of Lords in Wicks v. Director of Public Prosecutions (1)
where Viscount Simon said,
,
'
I
1961
Ealt India
Conim11cial Co.,
Ltd., Calcutta
'f.
"There is, of course, no doubt that when
C•ll1ctor of Cull•ms'
a statute like the Emergency Powers (Defence)
Caloutt,
Act, 1939, enables an authority to make regu·
Sttrler J.
lations, a regulation which is validly made
under tbe Act, i. e., which is intra vires of
the regulation-making authority, should be
regardod as though it were itself an enactment."
I think these observations fully apply to an Act
like the Imports and Exports (Control) Act. Then
I find that in our country too the same view has
been taken. Thus in Emperor v. Abdul Hamid(&),
Mullick, J., observed,
"When a notification is issued by an
executive authority in exercise of a power
conferred by statue, that notification is as
much a part of the law as if it had been
incorporated within the body of the statute
at the time of its enactment."
It has, therefore, to be held that where an order
passed under the Act authorises the impostion
of a condition a breach of the condition would be
punishable as a breach of the order under the Act.
I might now notice another argument. It
was this: Under s. 167 (8) of the Sea Customs Act,
it was the import in contravention of the restriction
that was an offence. The contention was that once
the goods hai been imported validly, tb.at is to say,
once they had been aliowed to cross the Customs
barrier under a valid licence, there could not be an
import contrary to any prohibtion or restriction.
It seems to me that this il!I taking too narrow a
view of s. 167 (8). Suppose the order under s. 3 (1)
of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act had itself
(I) [1947) A.C. S62, 365.
(2) A.I,R. 1923 Pat. I.
352
1962
East lnditJ
Commercial Co.,
Ltd., Calcutt·i
••
Colltclor of Customs
CalcutttJ
Sarkar J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
said that goods imported shall not be sold in the
market without the permission of a certain authority and the goods imported were notwithstanding
this sold without such permission. It would to my
mind make nonsense of s. 167 (8) if it were to be
said even in buch a case that the goods had not
been imported in contravention of the restriction
imposed by a legitimate order duly made. I have
earlier stated that the coditions in the licence have
to be treated as conditions contained in an order
issued under the Act of 1947 itself. Therefore,
the breach of such a condition would amount to a
contravention of an order restricting the import
of goods. Such a contravention is clearly punishable under s. 167 (8). The word "import" has not
be< n defined in the Sea Customs Act. In order
that the Act of 1947 does not become infructuous,
which result the legislature could not have intended,
it must be held that where after crossing the Customs barrier lawfully, goods are disposed of in
contravention of a restriction duly imposed, they
have been imported contrary to the restriction.
It remains only to consider the argument
that under the Sea Customs Act only the goods
imported can be confiscated and therefore, the
money now lying with the Presidency Magistrate
cannot be confiscated. I think this argument is
wholly untenable. The money represents the goods.
The order for sale was made by the High Court
with the consent of both the parties because the
goods were deteriorating. Therefore there can be
no doubt that the sale proceeds of the goods which
could be confiscated, can also be confiscated.
I think that the appeal fails and should be
dismissed.
Suoba Rao J.
SUBBA RAO, J.-This appeal. by special leave
is directed against the judgment of a division Bench
of _the High Court at Calcutta dated Janu!lry
'
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
353
5, 1957, confirming the order of a single Judge of
that Court dismissing the petition filed by the
appellants under Art. 226 of the Constitution.
The dispute which culminated in this appeal
has had a tortuous career and had its origin in
the year 19~8. To appreciate the contentions of
the parties it is necessary to survey broadly the
events covering a long period. The appellants are
Messrs. East India Commercial Co., Ltd., a company
having its registered office in Calcutta and the
Director of that Company. On September 27, 194~,
the appellant-Company filed an application with
the Chief Controller of Imports, New Delhi, for
the grant of a licence to import 20, 000 fluorescent
tubes and 2,000 fluorescent fixtures from the United
States of America. The application was accompanied by a covering letter. In the application it
was mentioned that the goods were required for
the Company's own use as industrial raw material
or accessories; but in the covering letter it was
stated that the goods were required primarily for
their mills at Ellore in the Madras Presidency where
they whe~e planning to arrange for an up-to-date
lighting system. The Chief Contoller of Imports
issued a special licence to the appellants on October
8, 1948. The licence granted was in respect of
fluorescent tubes and fixtures of the approximate
CIF value of Ra. 3,33,333 equivalent to $100,000
and the shipment was to be made within one year
from the date of issue of the licence. The licence
issued had a rubber stamp which ran thus:
"This licence is issued subject to the condiJff tion that the goods will be utilised only for consumption as raw material or accessories in the
licence holder's factory and that no portion
thereof will be sold to any party."
The licence did not impose any restriction as
regards the number of tubes and fixtures to be
1962
East India
OommerciuJ Oo.,
Ltd., Calcutta
v.
Collector of Customs,
Calcutta
Subba Rao J.
354
1962
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
+
imported, but a ceiling was placed on the value of
the goods as stated supra. Between March 21,
East India
Commercial Co.,
1949, and March 26, 1949, the appellants took
Ltd., Oalcvtt1
delivery
of the said tubes and fixtures of the speciv.
Col/tctor of Customs, fied value and cleared them on payment of customs
Calcutta
duty. The numbet of tubes and fixtures imported
was larger than that mentioned in the application,
Subba Ii ao J.
but it is common case that the value did not
exceed the ceiling fixed under the licenne. On
information alleged to have been received by the v
Chief controller of imports that the appellant-Company was selling the goods to various parties, the
matter was placed before the Special Police Establishment Government, of India, New Delhi. On
August 31, 1949, the said Police establishment
obtained a search warrant from the Chief presidency Magistrate, Calcutta, and seized, among
others, from the appellants' godown a large stock
of fluorescent tubes and fixtures, and left them
with the appellants on their executing a bond, It
may be mentioned at this stage that the value of
the stock imported was a.Lout Rs· 4,66,000 i. e.,
the purchase price of Rs. 3,33,333, together with
the customs duty paid on the said goods. In the
sale subsequently made at the instance of the High
Court, the stock seized fetched a sum of Rs.
4,15,000. On December 9, 1951), the aµpellants \
filed an application before the Chief Presidency
Magistrate, Calcutta, for the return of the seized
goods, whereupon the learned Magistrate called
for a report from the Special Police Establishment,
New Delhi. On January 9 12, 1951, the said Police
Establishment submitted a Challan against appellant No. 2 and others for alleged offences under
s. 420/120B of the Indian Penal Code and the same
was registered as Case No. C. 121 of 1951. On the
same day, the Assistant Collector of Customs filed
a complaint before the said Magistrate against
appellant No. 2 and others for committing an
~ s.c.R.
;.
.,.
-f
I
I
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
355
1961
offenne under s. 5 of the Imports and Exports
(Control) Act, 1947 (hereinafter called the Act, for
East Ind'a
having sold a portion of the stock of fluorescent Commercial Co.,
Ltd., Calcutta
tubes and fixtures in contravention of the terms of
v.
the licence and the same was registered as Case Colltetoroj Cuatoma,
Calcutta
No. C. 120 of 1951. On June 28, 1951, the learned
Presidency Magistrate discharged all the accused in
S11bba Rao J.
both the cases under s. 253 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure after holding that no prima facie
case had been made out against any of them.
Two revisions were filed against that order in the
High Court-one by the State and the other by the
Customs Authorities. Chunder, J., who heard the
revisions, set aside the orders of discharge made
by the Presidency Magistrate and remanded the
cases for fresh disposal. On June 8, 1952, the
appellants filed an application before the Chief
presidency Magistrate for the release of seized
goods on the ground that they were deteriorating,
but that was dismissed. But in a revision against
that order, the High Court on January 16,1953,
directed the goods to be sold by the Presidency Magistrnte and the sale proceeds to be kept in his custody .
The goods were sold .accordingly and they fetched
a sum of Rs. 4, 15,000 and the money has since
then been in the custody of the said court. After
remand, the Presidency Magistrate took the evidence of innumerable witnesses for the prosecution
and for the defence, considered a number of documf1nts and discharged appellant No. 2 in· both the
cases. He held that appellant No. 2 was neither
guilty of the offence under s. 420 of the Indian
Penal Code, as, in his view, there wi:.s no fraudu·
lent or dishonest inducement at the time the application for licence was made, nor of any contravention of the provisions of the Act. Though he
discharged appellant No. 2. he did not make over
the sale proceeds to him. though the said appellant
filed an application for payment of the same: the
learned Magistrate adjourned the said application
356
1962
East lr.dia
Commercial Co.,
Ltd, Calcutta
v.
Collector of Customs,
Calcutta
Subba Rao J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
till August 29, 1953. The Assistant Uollector of
Customs filed a revision to the High Court against
the order of discharge of appellant No. 2 passed in
case No. C. 120 of 1951' and the same was registered as Criminal Revision No. 1124 of 1953; he
also obtained an interim stay of the return
of the money to appellant No. :I.
Bnt no
revision was filed against the order of the
Presidency Magistrate discharging appellant No- 2
of the offence under s. 420, Indian Penal Code.
The Criminal Revision (No. 1124 of 1953) came up
before a division Bench of the Calcutta High Court,
Consisting of Mitter and Sen, JJ., and the learned
Judges, by their judgment dated March 3, 1955,
dismissed the revision holding that there had been
no contravention of the order made or deemed to
be made under the Act. The learned Judges construed s. 5 of the Act and held that the said section
penalised only a contravention of an order made
or deemed to have been made under the said Act,
buL did not penalise the contravention of the conditions of licence issued under the Act or issued
under a statutory order made under that Act, and
dismissed the revision. On March 24, 1955, the
appellants filed an application before the Chief
Presidency Magistrate for making over the aale
proceeds to them; and the said Magistrate issued
a notice to the Assistant Collector of Customs and
also to the Delhi Special Police Establishment to
~how cause on or before April 19, 1955. On April
19, 1955, the Superintendent, Special Police Establishment, did not show cause, but th11 Assistant
Collector of Customs asked for an adjournment and
the same was granted till May 7, 1955; and again
on May 7, 1955, he took another adjournment of
the hearing of the application on the ground that
depart.mental proceedings were pending against the
appellants. On May 9, Hi55, the appellants filed
a revisio111 in the High Court, presumably, against
the order adjourning the application and the said
revision was numbered as Hevision Case No. 582
of 1955 and it was adjourned from time to time at
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COtJR'r REPORTS
357
1962
the request of the respondent. On May 28, 1955,
the respondent started a proceeding purported to
East Ind a
Commerc.al Co.,
be under s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act, read Ltd.,C1lcu
ita
' with s. 3(2) of the Act and called upon the appel·
'·ofCustoma
!ants by notice to show cause within seven days Collector
Calcutta
from the date thereof why the said proceeds,
Sub/J.; Rao J,
namely, Rs. 4,15,001) should not be confiscated
and also why Penal action should not be taken
against them. It was stated in the notice that
the special licence was issued on the express condition that the goods covered by the said licence
should be utilised for consumption as raw material
or assessories in the factory of the licence holder
and that no part thereof should be sold or permitted to be utilised by any other party, that the
appellants sold a potti on of the goods imported
under the said licence to others in Breach of the
said condition and that, as the appellants infringed
the said condition, the goods, or the money substituted in its place, were \\a.ble to be confiscated.
On June 3, 1955, the appe\\ant fi.\ed an application
in the High Court at Calcutta under Art. 226 of the
Constitution for the issue of an appropriate writ,
including a writ in the nature of prohibition,
against the Collector of Customs from continuing
with the proceedings initiated by him. Ths application, in the first instance, came up before Sinha,
J., who by his order dated March 18, l!:J,)7, dismissed the application as premature; but, in the
course of his judgment. the learned ,Judge ngreed
with the earlier division Bench, which disposed of
the revision against the order of discharge, that a
breach. of a condition alone would not be a violation of the order passed by the Central Government,
but he observed that the learned Judges on the
earlier occasion did not decide the question as to
what was permitted to be imported: he drew a
distinction between a licensee who imported goods
perfectly bona fide for his own consumption but
358
SUPREME G'OURT REPORTS [1963)
who later changed his mind and a licensee who,
even from the inception, knew that he did not
Eatt lnd!a
require the goods for his own use, but entered into
CtJmmercial Co.,
Ltd., Calcutta
the transaction fraudulently; in the second situa••
Cttlfutor of Customi, tion, he learned Judge proceeded to state, the
Calculta
goods imported were never goods required for the
petitioner's company for its own use. The appeSubba Rlio J,
llants preferred an appeal to a division Bench of
of the High Court, consisting of Das Gupta, C.J.,
and Bachhwat, J. 'rhe learned Judges dismissed
the appeal solely on the ground that it was within
the jurisdiction of the Collector of Custums to
ascertain whether there had been a contravention
of the relevant provisions of the Act as would
entail an order of confiscation and that, therefore,
Sinha, J., was right in refusing to issue a writ; but
they made it olear that all the questions raised in
the oase were left open for decision by the Chief
Controller of Imports.
Hence the present
appeal.
1962
Mr. Vishwanatha Sastri, learned counsel for
the appellants, raised before us the following
points: ( 1) The Assistant Collector of Customs has
no jurisdiction to initiate proceedings under
s. 167 ( 8) of the Sea Customs Act, 1878, read with
s. 3(2) of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947,
in the circumstances of the case, and therefore, the
High Court should have issued an order in the nature
of a writ of prohibition restraining him from proceeding with the said inquiry. (2) A division Bench
of the High Court of Calcutta in Criminal Revision
No. 1124 of 1953, to which the respondent was a
party, declared the law on the construction of the
provisions of s.5 of the Act, read with s.3(2) thereof,
viz., that it penalizes only a contravention of an
order made or deemed to have been made under
the Aot and not a contravention of a condition imposed by the licence issued under the Act or issued
under a statutory order made. under the Act; and
3 S.O.R.
'y
I
r
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
359
after that declaration, which is binding on all the
1962
authorities and tribunals within the territorial jurisEast Indi•
diction of that court, the respondent has no juris- Commeroiol Co.,
'
. h a Ltd , Caloutla
d iction
to ignore t h e sa1'd or der an d proceed wit
v.
fresh inquiry in direct contravention of the law SO Oolloc·or of Custom•
0
declared. (3) That apart, the proposition so laid
~C::..C:.:
down by the said division Bench is sound and, if Su bba Rao J.
so, the respondent could not initiate proceedings
under s. 167(8) of the <:lea Customs Act in respect of
a contravention of a condition of the licence, as it
is neither a part of an order nor a condition laid
down by the Order within the meaning of s. 3 of
the Act. (4) The chief Controller of Imports has
no jurisdiction to take action under s. 167(8) of the
Sea Customs Act on the ground that a condition
inserted in a licence is subsequently infringed by an
importer, for it is said, the rule only enables the
Customs Authorities to confiscate the goods imported without a license whereas in the present case
the goods were imported under a valid subsisting
licence. (5) Clause (8) of s. 167 of the Sea Customs
Act does only authorize the confiscation of goods
so imported and not the sale proceeds of the said
goods, for the reason that the said money could not
conceivably be goods in any sense of the term.
Mr. Prem, learned counsel for the respondent,
argued contra. His argument may be summarized
thus: ( 1) The Collector of Customs has jurisdiction
to consider under s. 167,8) of the Sea Customs Act
whether the goods are imported contrary to the
restrictions imposed under the Act, and, therefore,
the High Court could not issue a writ of prohibition
against the said authority from proceeding with the
inquiry. (2) The notice issued is not a statutory
notice but is only an intimation to the appellants of
the initiation of the proceedings and, therefore, the
question of jurisdiction could not be decided on
the contents of the said notice. (3) The Customs
Authorities have a concurrent jurisdiction with t.he
360
196:
EaJt India
Oommer.:i!Jl Co,,
Lid., CtJlcuttri
••
Colleofor of Curfoms,
Cr.lcutta
.•ubba Rao J,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
criminal Court to deal with matters entrusted to
them under the Acts and, therefore, the findings of
a criminal court or even of a High Court on the
same or similar matters could not bind them and
they could come to a different conclusion of their
own both on the question of law as well
as on facts from those of criminal courts,
though the decision of the High Court may
have persuasive influence on them. (4) The
condition imposed in a licence is under the
relevant order issued by the Central Government in
exercise of its power under s. 3 of the Act, and, as
the appellants infringed that condition, the goods
imported are liable to be confiscated under s.167(8)
of the Sea Customs Act, read with s.3(2) of the Act.
( 5) As the appellants imported goods on a misrepresentation, in law the import must be deemed to
be one made without a licence and therefore the
goods imported are goods either prohibited or restricted within th11 meaning of s. 167(8) of the Sea
Customs Act. (tl) The Customs Collector has jurisdiction to confiscate goods after they have left the
customs barrier, and, as the money in deposit in
court is the proceeds of the sale directed to be held
by the High Court in the interest of both the
parties, it represents the said goods, and, in any
view, as the order of the High Court is binding un
both the parties, it is not open to the appellants to
plead that the goods are not represented by the
said money,
The first question is whether the petition filed
by the appellants under Art. 226 of the Constitution for the issue of a writ in the nature of prohibition is maintainable in the circumstances of the
case. A writ of prohibition is an order directed to
an inferior Tribunal forbidding it frrm contivuing
with a proceeding therein on the ground that the
proceeding is without or in excess of jurisdiction or
a s.o.R.
'>1
.'
y
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
361
1962
contrary to the laws of the land, statutory or other·
wise: Maclconochie v. Lord Penzance(1) and Halsbury's
East India
Laws of England, 3rd Edn: Vol. 11, p, 52.
Commercial Co.,
Ltd., Calcutta
v.
The argument of learned counsel for the
of Customs,
appelllilnts is that on the face of the notice dated Collector
Ca/cutlu
May '28, 1955, issued by the respondent, the latter
Subba .Qao J,
has no jurisdiction to initiate proceedings under
s. 167(8) of the Sfla Customs Act, read with s.3(2)
of the Act. Learned counsel for the respondent
argues that the said notice is not a statutory notice
but only a memorandum informally sent to the
appellants intimating them that proceedings have
been started against them, that the said notice is
neither full nor exhaustive and that jurisdictional
facts could be ascertained only by the Customs
Collector in the course of the said proceedings on
full inquiry, We do not see any justification for
this argument, The respondent proposed to take
action under s. 167(8} of the Sea Customs Act, read
with s. 3(2) of the Act. It cannot be denied that
the proceedings under the said sections are quasijudicial in nature. Whether a statute provides for
a notice or not, it is incumbent upon the respondent
to issue notice to the appellants disclosing the circumstances under which proceedings are sought to
be initiated against them, Any proceedings taken
without such notice would be against the principles
of natural justice. In the present case, in our view,
the respondent rightly issued such a notice wherein
specific acts constituting contraventions of the provisions of the Acts for which action was to be
initiated were clearly mentioned. Assuming that
a. notice could be laconic, in the present case it was
a speaking one clearly specifying the alleged act of
contravention. If on a reading of the said notice,
it is manifest that on the assumption that the facts
alleged or allegations made tht>rein were true, none
of the conditions laid down in the specified sections
(1) (I8Btl 6 App. Cas. 424.
362
1968
East India
Commt!rcial Co.,
Ltd., Calcutta
~.
Coll ecfor of Custom8,
Oalcutta
Subba Rao J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963]
was contravened, the respondent would have no
jurisdiction to initiate proceedings pursuant to that
notice. To state it differently, if on a true oonstruction of the provisions of the said two sections the
respondent has no jurisdiotion to initiate proceedings or make an inquiry under the said sections in
respect of certain acts alleged to have been done
by the appellants, the respondent can certainly be
prohibited from proceeding with the same. We
therefore, reject this preliminary contention.
The next question is, what is the true construotion of the provisions of the relevant sections?
It would be convenient at this stage to read the
relevant parts of ss. 3 and 5 of the Act and eli. 19
and 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act..
Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947
Section 3. (1) The Central Government
may, by order published in the Official Gazette,
make provisions for prohibiting, restricting
or otherwise controlling, in all. cases or in
specified classes of cases, and subject to suoh
exceptions, if any, as may be made by or
under the order:(a) the import, export, carriage coastwise
or shipment as ship stores of goods of any
specified description,
( b) the bringing into any port or place in
India of goods of any specified description
intended to be taken out of India without
being removed from the ship or conveyance
in which they are being carried.
(2) All goods to which any order under
sub-seotion (1) applies shall be deemed to be
goods of which the import or export has been
prohibited or restricted under section 19 of
the Sea Customs Act, 1878 (VIII of 1878) and
•
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
363
all the provisions of that Act shall have effect
1962
E 181 India
accordingly, except that section 183 thereof Commerciul Co.,
Ltd., Cale 1tt"
shall have effect as if for the word "shall"
v.
Colle.tor of Customs,
therein the word "may" were substituted.
Calcutta
Section 5. Penalty-If any person contravenes or attempts to contravene. or abets
a contravention of any order made or deemed
to have been made under this Act, he shall,
without prejudice to any confiscation or penalty
to which he may be liable under the provisions
of the Sea Customs Act, 1878 (VIII of 1878), as
applied by sub-section (2) of section :.i, be
punishable with imprisonment for a term
which may extend to one year, or with fine,
or with both.
The Sea Customs Act, 1878.
Section 19. The Central Government may
from time to time, by notification in the Official Gazette, prohibit or restrict the bringing or
taking by sea or by land goods of any specified
description into or out of India across any
customs frontier as defined by the Central
Government.
Section I 67. The offences mentioned in the
first colnmn of the following schedule shall be
punishable to the extent mentioned in the third
.!ubba Rao J.
364
J9l2
Eajt India
Cvmme•ciul Co,
Ltd, Calcutta
••
Collec.'01 of CuB/oms,
Ca!outta
Suoba RaoJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963]
column of the same with reference to such
offences respectively : Offences
Section of this
Act to which
offences has
reference.
8.Ifany
goods, the
importation
or exportation of which
is for the 18 and 19
time being
prohibited or
restricted by
or
under
Chapter IV
of this Act,
be imported
into or exported from
India contrary to such
prohibition or
restriction.
Penalties
such goods shall
be liable to confiscation, and any
person concerned
in any such offence shall be liable
to a penalty not
exceeding
three
times the value of
the goods, or not
exceeding
one
thousand rupees.
The essence of the offence is a contravention
of any order made or deemed to have been made
under the Act. All orders under this Act can only
be made by the Central Government in exercise of
the power conferred upon it by S· 3 of ·the Act, and
"1111 orders made under r. 84 of the Defence of India
Rules or that rule as continued in force by the Emergency Provisions (Continuance) Ordinance, 1946
(XX of 1946 ), and in force immediately before the
oommencement of this Act, shall continue in force
and be deemed to have been made under this Act".
The contravention of only these two categories of
orders attracts. the provisions of s. 19 of the Sea
>'
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
365
Customs Act. By rea.son of s. 3(2) of the Act, all
goods to which any order under sub-s. (I) of s. 3
itpplies shall be deemed to be goods of which the
import or export has been prohibited under s. 19
of the Sea Customs Act and all the provisions of
the Sea Customs Act, with some modificationswith which we are not concerned now-shall apply.
This provision in its turn atbracts. along with others
s. 167 (8) of the Sea Customs Acts, and under that
section, read withs. 3(2) of the Act, the goods imported in contravention of an order under the Act
shall be liable to be confiscated. But ·the section
does not expressly or by necessary implication empower the authority concerned to confiscate the
goods imported under a valid licence on the ground
that a condition of the licence not imposed by the
order is infringed or violated. If that be the true
construction of the said provisions, the question
arises whether in the instant case the allrgations
made in the notice bring the goods imported within
the scope of th€ provisions of s. 167(8) of the Sea
Oustoms Act. We shall now proceed to deal with
that question.
As we have already noticed in the earlier
stage of the judgment, the notice issued by the res·
pondent charges the appellants thus :
<.
"One of the conditions of the special
licence was that the goods would be utilized
for consumption as raw material or accessories in the factory of the licence-holder and no
part thereof would be sold to other parties,
but in contravention of that condition the
appellants sold a part of the goods imported
to a third party and as the goods had been
caused to be issued by fraudulent misrepresentation, they were liable to be confiscated under
s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act."
--
East fndia
Commercial Co.,
Ltd., Oalcutta
v,
Collecto» of C:ustom 8 ,
<..al cut ta
--
Sub I 'J Rao J,
I
366
SUPREME COURT .REPORTS (1963]
J90t
Seotion 167 (8) of the Sea Customs Act can be
invoked only if an order issued under s. 3 of the
EaJt India
Commucirrl Co.
Act
was infringed during the course of the import
Ltd , Calcutta
or
export.
The division .Bench of the High Court
v.
Collec or of Cu rloms, held that a contr11.vention of a condition imposed
Calt;.urta
by a licence issued under the Act is not an offence
Subba R<io J.
under
s. 5 of the Act. This raises the question
.
whether a'! administrative tribunal can ignore the
law declared by the higheRt court iu the State and
initiate proceedings in direct violation of the Jaw
so declared. Under Art. 215, every High Court
shall be a court of record and shall have all the
powers of such a court including the power to punish
for contempt of itself. Under Art. 226, it has a
'
plenary power to issue orders or writs for the enforcement of the fundamental rights and for any
other purpose to any person o~ authority, including
in appropriate cases any Government, within its
territoriai jurisdiction. Under Art. 227 it has jurisdiction over all courts and tribunals throughout
the territories in relation to which it exercise jurisdiction. It would be anom'1lous to suggest that
a tribunal over which the High Court has superintendence can ignore the law declared by that court
and start proceedings in direct violation of it. If
a tribunal can do so, all the sub-ordinate courts can
equally do so, for there is no specific provision, just
like in the case of Supreme Court, making the law
declared by the High Court binding on subordinate
courts. It is implicit in the power of supervision
conferred on a superior tribunal that all the tribunals subject to its supervision should conform to the
law laid down by it· Such obedience would also be
conducive to ,their sm.ootb working: otherwise there
would be confusion in the administration of law and
respect for hw would irretrievably.suffer. We, therefor, hold t.hat the law declared by the highest court
in the State is binding on authorities or tribunals
under its supreintenden<ie, and that they cannot
.
I
•
-.·.,
\
3 S.C.R.
-f
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
367
ignore it either in initiating a proceeding or decid•
ing on the rights involved in such a proceeding.
If that be so, the notice issued by the authority
signifyin~ the launching of proceedings contrary to
the law laid down by the High Court would be in·
valid and the proceedings themselves wonld be
without jurisdiction.
We shall now proceed to consider the merits.
Sub-section (2) of s. 3 of the Act clearly lays down
that all goods, to which an order under sub-s. (1)
thereof applies, shall be deemed to be goods of
which the export or import has been prohibited or
restricted under a. 19 of the Sea Customs Act.
Therefore, s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act can be
attracted only if there was a contravention of the
order issued under s. 3 of the Act. Does any order
so issued by its own force impose i:mch a condition ?
The Import Trade Control Notification dated July
1, 1943, reads thus:
,.
--,.
'
The notification of the Government of
India in the late Department of Commer1}e
No. 23 ITC/43, dated the Ist July, 1943, incorporating all amendments upto the 25th
November, 1951.
In exercise of the powers conferred by
sub-rule (3) of rule 84 of the Defence of India
Rules the Central Government is pleased
................................. to prohibit the bringing into British India by sea, land or air from
any place outside India of any goods of the
descriptions specified in the Schedule hereto
annexed except the following, n,amelyi
• • • •.I •I I I I I
I I I
I
I'•••• I I I I I Io I I
I I I
I I
I
I I
I
I I
I
I I I
I
I I
I
I I I
I
I
I
I
I
I I
I
(.xiii) any goods of the descriptions spe·
cified in the schedule which a.re covered by a
special licence issued by any officer specially
1962
East IndiJ
Comm1rciot Go.,
Ltd. Ca/cu;tci
"·
Collectvr of Customs,
Calcutta
--
Subba Ra• I,
368
1952
East India
Commercial Co.,
Ltd. Calcutta,
v.
Collector of Cu1tom•,
Calctdta
Subbu Rao J.
SUPREME COUR'l' REPORTS (1963]
authorised in
Government.
this
behalf
by the Central
It is not disputed that the goods imported in
the present case were specified in the schedule.·
This order prima Jacie does" not impose a condition
in the matter of issuing a licence for the specified
goods. On March 6, 1948, another notification No.
2-ITC/48 was issued by the Ministry of Commerce.
The relevant part of it reads:
In exercise of the powers conferred by
sub-section (I) and sub-section (3) of section
3 of the Imports and Exports (Controll Act,
1947 (XVIII of 1947), the Central Government is pleased to make the following order,
namely :(a) any officer issuing a licence under
clauses (viii) to (Xiv) of the Notification of
the Government of India in the late Department of Commerce No. 23-ITC/43, dated the
Ist July 1943, may issue the same subject to
one or more of the conditions stated below :
\
(i) that goods covered by the licence shall
not be disposed of or otherwise dealt with
without the written permission of the licensing authority or any person duly authorised
by it;
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
o 0 o 0 0 0 00 0 o o o 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 o o 0 0 I 0 o 'o o 0 0 0 0 o o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o
(v) that such other conditions may be
imposed which the licensing authority considers to be expedient from the administrative
point of view and which are not inconsistent
with the provisions of the said Act.
(b) Where a licensee is found to have
contravened the order or the terms and conditions embodied in or accompanying a licence,
r
'
a s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
369
the appropriate licensing authority or the
Chief Controller of Imports may notify him
that, without prejudice to any penalty to
which he may be liable under the Imports and
Exports (Control) Act, 1947 (XVIII of 1947),
or any other enactment for the time being in
force, he shall either permanently or for a
specified period be refused any further licence
for import of goods.
It will be seen from this order that it does not
provide for a condition in the licence that subsequent to the import the goods should not be sold.
Condition (Y) of cl. {a) only empowers the licensing
authority to impose a condition from an administrative point of view. It cannot be suggested that
the condition, with which we are now concerned, is
a condition imposed from an administrative point
of view, but it is a condition which affects the rights
of parties. Learned counsel for the respondent
argues that a public notice issued by the Government on July 2o, 1948, is an order made in exercise
of the power conferred on the Central Government
under s. 3 of the Act and that the order directs the
imposition of a. condition not to sell to a third
party the goods permitted to be imported and that
that condition was contravened. The public notice
dated July 26, 1948, was published in the Gazette
on July 29, 1948. The relevant part of it reads :
Government of India
MINISTRY OF COMMERCE
PUBLIC NOTICES
New Delhi, the 26th July, 1948
Subject :-Principles governing the issue
of import licences for the period July•
December, 1948.
No. I (13)-I.T.C./47 (i). The following
decisions made by the Government of India
1962
East India
Commercial Co.,
Ltd. Ca/cntla
v.
Collector of Custom•,
.Calculla
Subba Ra1 J.
370
1961
Ee.rt India
~Commercial Co.,
Ltd. Ca!culla ·
-··
C1lt1clor of Customs,
Calcutta
, Subbo Rao J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
governing the issue of import licences for
goods falling under Parts II to V of the
Import Trade Control Schedule for the licencing period July-December, 1948 are hereby
published for general information.
These
decisions do not apply to goods falling under
Capital Goods and H.E.P. Licensing procedure
which has been prescribed in the Public
Notice issued on 10th April, 1948.
Under paragraph 5, importers are requested
to study the Appendix carefully and avoid making
applications for import licences for articles which
will not be licensed; para. 7 prescribes the form of
application; para. 8 says that in the case of articles
which are subject to overall monetary limits, where
goods are raw materials and accessories used in
Industrial concerns, applications from actual consumers of goods will receive consideration, and that
actual consumers should clearly specify in their
application their past and estimated consumption
of the article concerned as required in par.i.. 6 of
the form of application. Paragraphs 6 to 10 deal
with would-be applicants. Paragraph 11 s:tys that
no time limit has been fixed for receiving applications from importers who are actual consumers of
industrial raw material and accessories and who
have imported tbe commodities concerned during
any financial year between 1938-39 and 1947-48
(inclusive) and that it is hoped to deal with these
applications chronologically as and when received.
Paragraph 13 describes the authorities to whom
applications should be made. A perusal of this
notice shows that it is intended to give information
to the public as regards the procedure to be followed in the matter of filing of applications by different
categories of applicants. It not only does not on
its face purport to be a statutory order issued under
s. 3 of the Act. but also the internal evidence furnished by it clearly shows that it could not be one
3SC.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORT8
371
under that section. That apart, this order does not
amend the previous orders or direct the imposition
of a condition on an importer not to sell the go?ds
to a third party or provide for a penalty for domg
so.
Learned counsel for the respondent asserts that
the said public notice is A.n order made in exercise
of the power conferred on the Central Government
under s. 3 (1) of the Act. On the other hand,
learned counsel for the appellants contends that
public notices are not such orders but only information given to the public for their guidance.
l!,irstly, the said notice does not purport to
have been issued under s. 3 (1) of the Act, whereas
the orders referred to earlier, that is, notifications
Nos. 23-ITC/43 and 2-ITC/48 and similar others,
were issued by the Central Government in exercise
of the power conferred on it by sub-r. (3) of r. 84 of
the Defence of India Rules or s. 3 (3) of the Act,
as the case may be. The Central Government itself makes a clear diAtinction in the form adopted
in issuing the notice. Secondly, while the notifications issued under s. 3 of the Act are described as
orders, the notices are de1:1cribed as "public notices";
while the notifications under s. 3 of the Act regulate the rights of parties, the public notices give
information to the public regarding the principles
governing the issue of import licences for specified
periods. It is also clear that the orders issued
under s. 3 of the Act, having statutory force, have
to be repealed, if the new order in any manner
modifies or supersedes the provisions of an earlier
order; public noticeH are issued periodically without
repealing or modifying the earlier notices or notifications. For instance, on December 7, 1955, the
Central Government in exercise of the power conferred by ss. 3 and 4-A of the Act made an order
and under cl. 12 thereof the orders contained in
J.961
East India
Commercial c•. ,
Ltd, Calcutta
v.
C1/ltotor of Customs,
Ca/cut ta
Sub&a Rtu J.
372
19611
Ea1t India
ComtrUrcial Co.,
Ltd. Calcutta
••
C•Jlector of OuJtoms,
Calcutta
6'ubba Ra1 J.
SlJPREMll: COURT REPORTS [1963)
Sohedule IV were repealed; Schedule IV only
mentiOned five notifioations issued under s. 3 of the
Aot, but no public notice was included in that list.
To put it differently, orders made under s. 3 of the
Act have statutory force, whereas publio notices
are policy statements administratively made by
the Government for publio information. The foreword to the Import Trade Control Hand-book of
Rules and Procedure, 1952, under the signature of
the Secretary to the Government of India, in the
Ministry of Commerce and Industry brings out thia
distinction thus :
"In the past the half-yearly publication
on Import Control, popularly known as the
"Red Book", has inoluded not only a statement of policy for the ensuing six months
but also a reproduction of various notifications relating to Import Control anci detailed
information on points of procedure".
It is true the Chief Controller made an affidavit in
the High Court that the policy-statements are
issued under s. 3 of the Act. But, as we have said,
that is only on information which has no support
either in the form adopted or the practice followed
or the matter incorporated in the notifications.
We have no hesitation in holding that public notices
are not orders issued under s. 3 of the Act.
It follows from the above that the infringement of a condition in the licence not to sell the
goods imported to third parties is not an infringement of the order, and, therefore, the said infringement does not attracts. 167 (8) of the Sea Custom&
Act.
Nor is there any legal basis for the contention
that licence obtained by misrepresentation makes
the licence non est, with the result that the goods
should be deemed to have been imported without
I
-
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
373
J962
licence in contravention of the order issued under
s. 3 of tb.e Act so as to bring the case within ol. (8)
Ea1/ lndia
of s. 167 of the Sea Customs Act. Assuming that Comm1 rcial C1.,,
Lttl. Ca/cult•
the principles of law of contract apply to the issue
,
of a licence under the Act, a licence obtained by 01!/eclor of Cu1tom1,
Ca/c'Ulte
fraud is only voidable : it is good tiJI avoided in
the manner prescribed by law. On May 1, 19181
Subba R•• J.
the Central Government issued
an order
in exercise of the power conferred on it by
s.3 of the Act to provide for licences obtained by
misrepresentation, among others, and it reads:
.
•
"The authorities mentioned in the Schedule hereto annexed may under one or other
of the following circumstances cancel licences
issued by any officer authorised to do so under
clauses (viii) to (xiv) of the notification of the
Government of India in the late Department
of Commerce, No. 23-ITC/43, dated lst July
1943, or take such action as is considered
aecessary to ensure that the same is made
ineffective, namely:(i) when it is found l!lubsequent to the
issue of a licence that the same has been
issued inadvertently, irregularly or contrary
to rules, fraudulently or through misleading
statement on the part of the importer concerned; or
x
(iii) when it is found that the licensee
has not complied with any one or more of
the conditions subject to which the licence
may have been issued.
374
SOPREME COURT REPORTS (1963]
191B
East lndi11.
Cornmerciol C'tJ.,
Lti. Calcuitc
SCHEDULE
Clauses
••
1
Licensing
Authority
Cancelling
authority
Any officer authorised
by the Central Government.
Chief Controller of
Imports
and/or
Government
of India.
firlllect•r tJj Customs,
CG7cutls
Clause (xiii)
This order, therefore, authorised the Government
of India or the Chief Con troll er of Im ports to
cancel such licences and make them ineffective.
The specified authority has not cancelled the licence
issued iu this case on the ground that the conditiop
has been infringed. We need not consider the
question whether the Chief Controller of Imports
or the Government of India, as the case may be,
can cancel a licence after the term of the licence
ha.s expired, for no such o:moellation has b'len made
in this case. In the circumstances, we must hold
that when the goods were imported, they were
imported under a valid licence and therefore it is
not possible to say that the goods imported
were those prohibited or restricted by or under
Ch. IV of the Act within the meaning of
cl. (8) of s. 167 of the Sea Customs Act.
"
'
j
It follows that on the assumption that the .
allegations made in the notice are true, the tribunal
has no jurisdiction to proceed with the inquiry under
a. 16 7(8) of the Sea Customs Act.
Learned counsel for the appellants further
contends that s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act
applies only to an act done before or during the
course "of an import or export into or out of India
in contravention of the prohibition or restrictions
,...
3 S.0.R.
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
375
J96!
imposed under s.3 of the Act and that, as in the
instant case the breach of the condition was comEast l ntlia
niitted subsequent to the importation of the concernCommercisl ro.,
Ltd. Ca/cu1ta
ed goods, the said goods could not be confiscated
v.
under the &aid section. But we do not propose to Collector of Cusl•mr,
Oatculla
expre11s our opinion on this question, as it does not
a.ri11e in view of our findings on other questions
Subba Rao J.
raised in the case.
Before closing we may briefly notice one more
contention raised by learned counsel for the appellants. It is said that, a.s the goods imported were
converted into money, the Customs Collector has no
jurisdiction to confiscate the same and that he can,
at the best, only trace the goods in whosesoever hands
they may be. We have pointed out that the goods
were sold only at the instance of the court in the
interest of both the parties, as they were deteriorating. The order is binding on the parties. The
sa]e proceeds are preserved for the benefit of the
party who final1y succeeds. In the circumstances
it is not open to the appeUants to argue tha.t money
deposited in the court does not represent the
goods.
In the result, the order of the High Court is
set aside and the appeal is alJowed with costs.
There wil1 be an order of prohibition restraining the
Customs Authority from proceeding with the inquiry
under s.167(8) of the Sea Customs Act.
BY COURT: In view of the majority opinion of
the Court, the appeal is allowed with costs. There wiU
be a.n order of prohibition restraining the Customs
Authority from proceeding with the enquiry under
s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act.
Appeal allowed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org