RAGHAV PRAP._ANNA TRIPATHI versus THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH
Supreme Court of India | Decided 4 May 1962 | [1963] 3 S.C.R. 239 | 1962 INSC 204
Key facts
- Decided
- 4 May 1962
- Bench
- S.K. DAS*, J.L. KAPUR, A.K. SARKAR, M. HIDAYATULLAH, RAGHUBAR DAYAL
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 72/1962
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1963] 3 S.C.R. 239
- Neutral citation
- 1962 INSC 204
Text of the judgment
3 ~.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
239
RAGHAV PRAP._ANNA TRIPATHI
•
v.
THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH
(S.K. DAs,J. L. KAPUR, A.K. SARKAR, M. HIDAY.A.·
' TULLAR and RAGHUBAR DAYAL, JJ.)
"1f!Y•
....
Oircu'f118tantial evidence-Murder-No direct evidenceSufficiency of proof-Inference from abscnnding-lriference from
non-recovery of jup-lnference from presence of accused i11
houae where murder wa,/i alleged to have taken place-Indian
Penal Ooae, ss. 176, 201, 302..
·
The appellants were prosecuted and ·Committed to the
Sessions for trial. Raghav was convicted ·and sentenced to
death under s. 302, I.P.C. He and Jai Devi, his mother,
Ramanuj Das, Mohan SinJl'h and Udham Singh were convic·
ted under section 201 IPC. Ramanuj Das was also convicted
under section I 76 IPC. Their appeals were dismissed by
the High Court. They came to this court by special leave.
The appeal of Rar:hav, Mohan Singh and Udham Sinfl'h was
> ·allowed by majority, that of Ramanuj Das and Jai Devi for
·~ • offence under s. 201, IPC was allowed unanimously and appeal
'
of Ramanuj Das for offence under s. I 76 IPC was allowed by
a majority.
.. . ,
Helli (Kapur and Hidayatullaha, J J dissentin!?) that there
the· murder
• • .,.. of ~amla and Madhusudan. There was no direct evid,nce
".~. ". •. abmtt his carryin!! away their dea<l bodies in the jeep. There
',. 1:-·was no direct evidence about Ramanuj Das or anv other
-' · accused being a party to the removal of the dead bodies from
·the house. 'The entire case· was based on circum•tantial
evidence. Th~ circumstances proved a~ainst Raghav were
not sufficient to support the finding that he had committed the
;
murder. The mere abscondinl( may lend weir:ht to the other
\
evidence establi•hing the guilt of the accused but bv itself
that is hardly any evidence of guilt. It was too much to
conclude from the non-recovery of the jeep that if it had been
recovered it would have afforded evidence of existence of
human
bl~od-stain anrl of its having been used to remove
l
evidence of murder. -That circumstance had no evidentiary
'
value. There was no evidence about the part Ramanuj Das
or .Tai Devi played in the removal of the dead bodies. The
· fact that they were in the hou•e and could have possibly
known of the removal of the dead bodies,.?f that was a fact
;~:'."";"'"Wl\:<;J. .no direct evidence ahout Rae;hav committinrt
.
'
(.
J.68
May4 •
240
1961
Raghav Prapannc
Trlpathi
••
Stale of U. P.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963)
would not by itself establish that they assisted in the removal
vf the bodies. The conviction of the appellant was not
justified on the material on record.
Per Kapur and Hidayatullah JJ. The strained relaand wife, the motive to escape the
giving of money and land as maintenance to the wife or child,
suddenly leaving the village at night with two others and
almost sirr1ultaneous disappearance of ;Kamla and her son,
no search for her and absolute callousness on the part of
Raghav, giving of false explanation later on and his absconding were circumstances from which the Courts below were
justified in concluding that Kamla and her son were murdered
and Raghav had a predominant motive to commit the
murder. The inculpatory facts proved against Raghav were
not capable of explanation on any other hypothesis except
his guilt. The Courts below had applied correct principles
and found Raghav guilty and there was no reason to disagree
with their conclusions. The non-production of the jeep
was ·a circumstance against Raghav which the Courts below
Were entitled to take into consideration. Articles like jeeps
do not just disappear in thin air and 'Yhen they do disappear
and cannot be traced and when the allegation is that they
have been used for carrying away the dead bodies, their nonproduction or their not being found is a circumstance which
a·Court can take into consideration in d...'!termining the g"'Uilt
of an accused person.
tion~ between husband
•
No case under section 20 I of the· Indian Penal Code
had been made out against Ramanuj Das and Jai Devi.
What section 201 requires is causing any evidence of the
commission of the offence to di<iappear or giving any inform a ..
tion respecting the offence which a person knows or believes
to be false. It was not proved that the two appellants had
caused any evidence to disappear. There may be a strong
suspicion that if from the house dead bodies were removed or
blood was washed, the persons placed in the position of the
two appellants must have had a hand in it, but .still that
remains a suspicion, although a strong suspicion. There
mere absconding would not fill the gap or supply the evidence
which was necessary to prove the ingredients of section 201.
\t(
Anant Okintaman Lagu v. Tke State of Bombay, (1960]
2 S.C R. 460, Govinda Reddy v. The State qf Mysore, A.I.R .
•1960 S.C. 29, Stephen Seneviratnan v. Tke King. A.I.R. 1936
P.C. 289, Powell's case, (1854) 2 C & K 309, Rex v. Horry,
(1952] N.Z.L.R. 111, Regina v. Onufrejczyk, (1955) 1 Q.B:· 338,
.:y
relied upon~ ·
3 S.O.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
241
Rex v. Hoage, (1833) 2 Lew. 227, referred to.
CRIMINAL:APPELLATE JURISDICTtON: Criminal
Appeal No. 72 of 1962,
Appeal by Apeoial leave from the judgment
and order dated February 8, 196·!, of the Allahabad
High Court in Criminal Appeals Nos, 1728 and
1739of1961 and Referred No. 125of1961,
1961
Raghau Prapanna
T.ipa11,;
v.
State of U. P.
Jai Gopal Sethi. A.N. Jfulla, J.B. Geyal, O.L.
Sareen and R.L. Kohli, for the appeJJants.
G.O. Mathur and O.P. Lal, for the respondent,
1962. M1ly 4. The Judgment of Das. Sarkar,
Dayal, JJ,, was delivered by Dayal, J. The Jurlgment of Kapur a.nd Hidayatullah, JJ., was delivered by Kapur, J.
RAGHUBAR DAYAL, J.-Raghav Prapanna
Tripathi, hereinafter called Raghav, Ramanuj
Das, Jai Devi, Mohan and ('dham Sin!!'h, appeal
.,.
by special leave against the order of the High Court
of Allahabad, dismissing their appeal against their
conviction by the l'essions Jurlge, Etawah. Raghav
was convict.ad and sentencerl to death under s. 302
I. P . C. He and the other apppellants were ali:m
convicted of the offe11ce under f!. 201 I. P. C.
Ramanuj Das was convicted of the offence under
Y s. 176 I. P. C. also.
The prosecution caf!e, in brief, is that Raghav
shot dead his first wife Kamla, and thdr son
Madhusudhan, aged about .4 years, at about sunset
on April 5, 1961, at their house in village Hamirpur
R.oora, DiAtri<'t Etawah. The motive for this conduct is said to be Raghav's :not caring for Kamla
and ill-treating her after his marrying one Bimla
-...... in l 954. Kamla had to go to her father's place
and stay there for ubout two years on account of
the all,.ged ill-treatment she got at her husband's
I
Raghubar Dayal J.
242
1962
Baghav Prapanna
Tripaihi
••
State of U. P.
Raghubar Dayal J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963]
hands. She was, howe'\"er, brought back by Ramanuj Das, in 1960. He assured her father that she
would be well looked after and· that he.would
transfer 90 bighas of land to her and pay her
Rs. 10,000/·.
•
It is also alleged that earlier in the day on
April 5, 11161, Ramariuj Das had ultimately promised to Lakhan Prasad that he would execute the
necessary tranRfer deed on Monday following and
that Ra11hav left the place during their conversation in this regard. It is alleged that he did so as
he resented the idea of so much property and cash,
which would have ultimately benefited him, being
made over to Kamla. This resentment is said to
have prompted Raghav to murder his wife and son
that evening.
We may now mention facts to show the connection of Ramanuj Das and other accused with
Raghav which is said to have led them to be
parties to the disappearance of the evidence about
the murders in order to protect Raghav from legal
punishment and thereby to commit the offence
under s. 201 I. P. C. Lachman Das was the Mahant
of the temple in village Harnirpur Roora. Narayan
Das, father of Raghav, and Ramanuj Das were his
disciples. On Lachman Das, death, .l:taroanuj Das
succeeded him as Mahant, though Narayan Das was v
the senior disciples, as Narayan Das had taken to
secular life. Ramanuj Das, Raghav, J ai Devi,
mother of Raghav. Raghav's wife Kamla, and
Madhusudhan, all lived as a joint Hindu family in
the house in which there was the temple. Mohan
Singh was a servant of Ramanuj Das.. Udham
1-ingh was also alleged to be a servant of Ramaauj
Das.
'
Raghav mostly lived at Lucknow with Bimla
and his sisters who were studying there. He is
-<
\
3 s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
243
a law graduate. He possessed a jeep oar whose
registration number was U. S. J. 3807.
No information was conveyed by anyone to
the police about the numbers for about two days.
Khushali, Chaukidar, lodged a report at 9.20 a. m.
on April 7, 196 L, at police station Airwa Katra,
District Etawah. The Station Officer was not
present at the police station. This report may be
usefully quoted here:
_,
-·
"Day before yesterday in the night
Raghav of my village, who is a son of Narain
r>as, has murdered his wedded wife and son
by firing at them with the gun of Mahant
Ramanuj Das. He has gone somewhere with
the two dead bodies in a car. There is a
rumour about it in the whole of the village.
Having heard of it, I went to the Mahant
who is also the Pradhan of my village. I
asked him to give me something in writing,
so that I would go to the Police i::ltation and
make a report. The Mahant then asked me
to wait and to go only after Thakur Dalganjan Singh had come, I did not listen to
him, although he kept on forbidding. I have
come to make a report."
Sub-Inspector . Brij Raj Singh Tomer, Station
Officer, Airwa Katra, received the copy of the first
information report at 11 a. m., and immediately
proceeded to the spot and reached there at 2 p. m.
He inspected the house of Ramanuj Das and prepared the site plan. He suspected blood stains at
about 11 places in the house and took the stained
plasters from those places and put them in different
packets. All the 11 packets were then sealed m
a single bundle.
.
The Chemical Examiner found the plasters
in 5 of the-e packets to be stained with blood. The
1969
Ragh"v Prapanna
'Iripathi
"·
Stat• of U. P.
Raghubar Dayal J,
244
RaghalJ Prapanna
Tripathi
v.
Sta•e of U. P.
Boghubar Doyal J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
Serologist could not determine the origin of the
blood on account of its disintegration.
The positions of the plasters found blood·
stained are not clearly made out from the variOus
documents, but, in view of the fact that 11, stained
plasters were taken in possession from over the
door in the front wall of the southern outer room
or from its floor or its wall, that at least 2 of the
blood s.tained plasters were from the southern outer
room portions, even if the other three blood stained
plasters were from the outer wall of the northern
room, the roof of the temple and the floor of the
southern inner room.
Sub-Inspector Brij Raj Singh Tomer did not
find any of the appellants in the village.
On April 12, 1961, Bashir Hussain, Deputy
Superintendent of police, vfsited the spot
and recovered suspected blood-stained earth
frooo
the . parnalas of the roof of the
house and also from the land on which the water "of
the parnalas fell. He took 7 samples of such earth,
put them in 7 packets and sealed them in a bundle.
The Chemical Examiner found the earth of two
such packets to be stained with blood. Again, the
Serologist could not determine the origin of blood
due to dis-integration.
. On April 16, 1961, Bashir Hussain recovered
Raghav's shirt and pyjama from ISnowhite, Cleaners & Dyers at Lucknow, as they were suspected to
be stained with blood. No blood was detected on
the pyjama. The Chemical Examiner found blood
stains on the shirt. The Serologist could not
diitect the origin of the blood.
The police failed to discover the dead bodies
of Kamla and Madhusudhan .and also the jeep car.
'
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
245
.___,
,
r
Raghav surrendered in the Court of the
Magistrate at Barabanki on April 20. Mohan was
arrested on April 9, Rananuj Das surrendered in
the Court of the Judicial Officer, Bidhuna, on
April 24, 1961,
Jai Devi applied for bail on
April 27, presumably, she surrendered on that day.
As a result of the investigation, ·the appel·
lants were sent up for trial. All the appellants
denied that they committed the offences with and
stated that they had been falsely implicated.
There is no direct evidence about Raghav's
committing the murder of Kamla and Madhusudhan. Neither is there direct evidence about his
carrying away the dead bodies of Kamla and
Madhusudhan in the jeep that night from village
Hamirpur RoOl'a as aileged for the prosecution.
There is no direct evidence about Ramanuj :Qas or ·
any other accused being a party to the removal
of the dead bodies from the house. The entire
case against the appellants depends on circumstantial evidence. ·
We may deal with the circumstances
which the learned t:)essions Judge and the High
Court found established and from which they
concluded that Raghav murdered Kamla and
Madhusudb,an and that thereafter, Raghav, Mohan
and Udham Singh, with the connivance of Ramanuj Das and Jai Devi, carried away the dead bodies
in the jeep and disposed of them.
These circumstances are1. On April 6, 1961, Kamla and Madhusudhan were in the house of Ramanuj Das.
2. Kamla and Madhusudhan were la.st
seen alive on April 5, 1961, in the evening.
3. On April 5, 1961, Raghav Prapanna
was also in the house of Ra.ma.nuj Das.
1962
Roghav Prapanna
Tripathi
v•
. StateofU.P.
Raghubar Dayal J
246
1962
Raghav Prapanna
Tripathi
••
Stale of U. P.
/laghubaT Dayal J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963]
4. On April 5, 1961, at about 5 or 6
p. m. three gun shots were fired on the roof
of Hamanuj Das.
5. On April 5, 1961, at about 9 or 11)
p. m. Raghav Prapanna, Mohan and Udham
Singh left village Hamirpur Roora on the
jeep of.Raghav.
6. On April 5, 1961, at about 11 p. m.
Raghav Prapanna purchased petrol from
Bidhuna Petrol Pump.
7. On April 6, 1961, at about 8. 30 a. m.
Raghav Prapanna crossed Rawatpur barrier
in Kanpur.
8. On April 6, 1961, Raghav Prapanna
got a post card sent by his sister that Kamla
had reached Lucknow safely.
9. On April 7, l 96i, blood-stained earth
was recovered from the house of Ramanuj
Das from 11 different places.
10. On April 14, 1961, blood-stained
earth was recovered from the house of Ramanuj Das from 7 different plaoes.
11. All the accused absconded. after the
alleged murder.
pyjama
12, Blood-stained shirt and
belonging to Raghav Praparina were recovered from the possession of Snow-white
Dyers and Cleaners, Lucknow.
13, The police could not trace out the
jeep of Raghav Prapanna in spite of best
efforts.
On behalf of the appellants it is not dispute
that the circumstances numbered 1, 2, 7, 9, 10, 1
....
3S.C.R.
...
-
I
-r
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
247
and 13 have been established. It is contended for
the appellants that the other circumstances have
not been proved and that, even if proved, all the
aforesaid circumstances are insufficient to lead to
the sole conclusion that Raghav committed the
murders of Kamla and Ma.dhusudhan and that he
and the other appellants were parties to the removal of the dead bodies.
Karola and Madhusudhan were in the house
on April 5, 11!61. They were not seen after the
evening of April 5, 1961,
The third circumstance is disputed, Ragha.v
states that he had left Hamirpur Roora on April 4,
This finds support from the statement of Sri Ram,
P.W. 3, that he had seen Raghav pass via Samain
in a jeep that night. He saw this on Tuesday,
April 4, 1961 was a Tuesday. Even if he was in
the village on April 5, his presence in the house
does not put him in such a position that his omission
to furnish information about the whereabouts
of Kamla and Madhusudhan or as to what happened
to them should point to his committing their
murders. He was not the only person in the house
to know of what happened to them. There were
other persons in the house. It is true that the
circumstance of his presence in the house and the
absence of any activity on his part to make enquiries about Kamla and Madhusudha.n when they
were not seen in the house on April 6, is a conduct
which is not expected from a. husband, even if the
relations between the husband and the wife be
strained.
The fourth circumstance that three gun shots
were fired from the roofs of Ramanuj Das at about
5 or 6 p.m. on April 5, cannot lead reasonably to
the only conclusion or even to a reasonable suspicion that Raghav did fire those shots, that he
1962
Ragha• Prapann•
Iripathi
9.
State of U. P.
Bathubar Dayal J.
248
1962
Raghav Prapann1
Tripathi
v.
State of U. P.
Raghubar po.ya/ J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963]
fired them in the room and that he shot dead his
wife and son by that firing· The. conn{ ction between the firing of gun shots from the side of the
roof of Ramanuj Das and the alleged murders,
seems to us to be too remote to arrive at the
conclusion that Raghav had killed his wife and
son.
In this connection, reference may also be
made to circumstances Nos. 9 and 10, relating to
the recovery of the bloodstained earth from the
house. The blood-stained earth has not been pro·
ved to be stained with human blood, Again we a.re
of opinion that it would be far-fetched to conclude
from the mere presence of blood-stained earth
that that earth was stained with human blood and
that the human blood was of Kamla and
Madhnsudhan. These circumstances have; therefore, no evidentiary value.
'; -.
The facts that Kanila. and Madhuaudhan have
not been seen since the evening of April 5, 1961,
and that blood stains, not proved to be of human·
origin, were found in that room, are not sufficient
for holding that they must have been murdered,
however strongly one may suspect it in view of
the unlikelihood of their having left the house
for ally other place.
In this connection, reference may also be
made to circumstance No. 8. Exhibit ·Ka-7 ~as
addressed by Govind Kumari, sister of Raghav, to
Rama.nuj Das on April 6, 196 l, from Lucknow. It
is stated in this post.ca.rd that 'Raghav etc., had
arrived safely and that as 'bhabi' had also arrived,
it was n·ot necessary for her to cook food etc.'.
Thia letter, according to the post-mark, reached
Samrin Post Office on April 10, and was not deli·
vered till April 13, to the addressee, as he was
not present, and was ultimately handed over to
..
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
249
19111
the Deputy Superintendent of Police, in compliance with the orders of the Magistrate under Ragl.ao p,apanna
Tripathi
s. 95, Cr. P. C. It is alleged that this letter was
v.
written at the instigation of Raghav in order to State of U. !'.
prepare evidence about Karola's reaching Lucknow
on April 6. There is however no evidence on record Raghurhar Da.>al J.
about Raghav's having a hand in the sending of this
letter by Govind Kumari. She was not examined
to prove the contents of her Jetter and to explain
to whorn she referred to as 'bhabi'. Raghav has
stated that he had gone to Lucknow along with
Rama Sewak's wife, whom he also called 'bhabi'.
That may be true or not. The fact remains that
there is no evidence that Govind Kumari wrote
this postcard with a purpose and at the instigation
of .Kaghav. The evidentiary value of this postcard
is nil and the conclusions that Raghav got this
letter sent is not justified when there is no evidence
to that effeot and there is no definite proof that
the expression 'bhabi' referred to Kamla.
Support for the inference that the expression
'bhabi' referred to Kamla has been found, by the
Court below, from complete omission to Govind
Kumari's sending wishes to Kamla and Madhusudhan, as it is expected that if she knew that they
were at Hamirpur Roora, she would have conveyed her wishes to them. One can normally expect
this, but it is in the statement of Lakhan Prasad,
P. W. 6, that there could not have been good
relations between Govind Kumari and Karola.
Lakhan Prasad deposed that on his asking Kamla
the cause of her unhappiness for the last four
years, she told him that one Sub-Inspector Iqbal
visited her father-in.law's place and had iJlicit
connection with Govind Kumari and that these
persons, together with Raghav, used to take wine
and meat in the temple. She further told him that
her complaint to her mother-in-law iii this respect
250
1962
Raghori Proponna
Tri'jJathi
••
State ofU. P.
Raghubor Dayal J.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
went un-heeded. It follows, therefore, that omission of the usual courtesies in the postcard from
Govind Kumari need not lead to the conclusion
that it was on account of the attempt to show,
when need be, that Kamla and her son had reached
Lucknow and were alive on April 6, 1961Circumstances 5 and 6, by themselves, are
not sufficient to lead to the conclusion that Raghav
had taken the corpses of Kamla and .Madhµsudhan
in the jeep from the village on the night of April
5, 1961, when there is no evidence of any witness
about seeing any such things in the jeep which
might reasonably lead to the inference that they
contained the dead bodies.
The 7th circumstance, does not in any way
go against Raghav, as he himself admits to have
gone to Lucknow from village Bhuwain on April
6, 1961. In_ doing so he would pass Rawatpur
barrier. This circumstanoe, in a way, supports
his version and has nothing incriminating in itselfThe 11th circumstance, as stated, is not quite
correct. All the accused did not abscond after
the alleged murders. Ramanuj Das himself was
in the village till the morning of April 7, according
to the statement of Khushali, Chowkidar, who lodged the first information report. If he and others
left the house after knowing of the report lodged
by the chowkidar, that is understandable. The
mere absconding, however, may lend weight to
the other evidence establishing the guilt of the
accused, but, by itself, is hardly any evidence
of guilt.
The 12th circumstance, is about Raghav's
shirt being found to be stajned with blood by the
Chemical Examiner. The bloodstain has not been
proved to be "of human origin. In the circumstances, this circumstance has no evidentiary value in
l
.Y
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
251
connecting Raghav with the offence of murder.
Further, the shirt wa.s recovered from the Dry
Cleaners on April 16. It was given to them on
April 9. The murder is said to have taken place
on April 5. Bloodstain on the shirt could have
been due to reasons other than Raghav's taking
part in the murder of his wife and son.
_, 't
In this connection, reference must be made
to the statement of Babu Lal, P. W. 7, the proprietor of the Snowhite Cleaners & Dyers to the
effect that when Raghav gave hiip. the shirt for
washing it was not blood-stained. He has also
stated that even when the Sub-Inspector took it
in possession, it was not blood-stained. The High
Court oonsidered Babu Lal's statement to be untrue
as he had signed the recovery list which staterl
that the shirt had stains suspected to be washed
bloodstains. There was no statement that the
shirt had bloodstains on April 9 when it was given
for washing. Further, if the signing of the recovery
list by Babu Lal as a witness to the recovery be
taken to be his statement about the correctness
of its contents. that statement would be inadmissible in evidence in view of s. 162, Cr. P. C.
The last circumstance, as a piece of evidence
against the accused, is that the police could not
trace out the jeep of Raghav in spite of best
efforts. The inability of the police to find the jeep
does not prove that thP jeep, if found, would have
furnished evidence against Raghav' by showing
the existence of human blood-stains on its parts
and thereby indicating that it was used in removing the corpses. If it had been recovered and
human bloodstains had been found on it, there
would have been some evidence against the accused a.bout the jeep having been used for removing
the dead bodies. But it is too much to conclude
from the non-recovery of the jeep that if recovered
1962
Raghav Pra~anno
T1ipathi
v.
StateafU. P.
Raghubar Doyal J.
252
Raqha'O Prop3nna
Tripalhi
v.
Stale a/ U. p.
Raghubar Doyal J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
it would have afforded evidence of existence of
human bloodstains and thus of its having been
used to remove evidence of murder. This circumstance has therefore .no evidentiary value.
In this connection, we must refer to the unusual conduct of the Magi•trate in forwarding the
letter of request by the Investigating Officer under
s. 94 Cr. P. C., to the Jailor, requiring Raghav to
convey information in whose charge he left his
jeep No. 3807 while surrendering in Court at Barabanki, and the whereabouts of the jeep at the
time. The Investigating Officer could have interrogated the accused in jail, as is usually done, of
course, with the permission of the Magistrate.
But, to attempt to get written replies from the
accused, is unusual, if not unwarranted under the
Code of Criminal Procedure,. Any way, any rPply
given by the accused to such a query of the Investi11ating Officer, cannot be used in evidence in
view of s. 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
We have now dealt with the pieces of circumstantial evidence which were accepted by the
Courts
below and
are of opinion that
those circumstances are not sufficient to support
the finding that Ral!'hav committed the murder
of Kamla and Madhusudhan.
The facts allPl!'ed to const.itute mot.ivEi for
Raghav to commit the murders do not nereeR•.rily
provide such a motive. R>Lghav married Bimla in
1954 and for seven yAars he appAars tn have conti
nued his marital relations with Kamla as well.
Madhusudhan was born in 1957. He mav not be
showing the same affection tci Karola after his
marriage with Bimla as before. There mi11ht have
been something of an estrangement in his relations
towards her. But all this would not afford a
motive for murdering her, and also their son Madhusudhan. 'Ihe suggestion to Ramanuj Das to· pay
'
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME
COURT REPORTS
I
253
196t
Rs. 10,000/- to Kamla and also to transfer 90 Bigha.s
of land to her, even if true, need not have caused Raghao Prapanna
Tripathi
such a resentment to Raghav as to decide on
murdering his wife and son. There is nothing on
'· U. P.
SI.le of
the record to indicate how such a transfer of ca.sh Raghubar Dayal J.
and property would affect the toti;Ll property of
Ramanuj Das, and how, ultimately, Raghav would
be affected by it. Apparently, Raghav would have
no claim to the property left by Ramanuj Das as
a mahant of the mutt or temple. The propnty
would go to the successor of Ramanuj Das.
Raghe.v who was leading a secular life, will not
succeed to the Ma.hantship, just as his ftther Narain
Das, though a senior disciple of Lachman Das, did
not succeed to it. His leaving the place when
Ra.manuj Das was approached by La.khan Das to
transfer cash and land to Karola, does not necessarily indicate that he left a.<.1 he resented the
suggestion. 'l'here is no evidence that he raised any
protest at the time or indicated by any expresPion
that Rama,nuj Das should not do so. We do not
corn~ider it reasonable to conclude, from the mere
fact of his leaving the place, that he did so on
account of such keen resentment as would make
him commit the murders of hi11 wife and son.
t
....t
..
Lastly, there is no such circumstantia.1 evidence which would establish that the appellants
had removed and concealed the dead bodies. We
have alreadv referred to the absence of evidence
a.bout the ·dead bodies being carried in the jeep
that night by Raghav. There is no evidence a.bout
the part which Ra.manuj D11.s or Jai Devi played in
the removal of the dead bodies. The fact that
they were in the house and could hav~ possibly
known of the removal of the dead bodies, if that
was a fact, would not by itself establish that they
. assisted in the removal of the bodies. We are
therefore of opinion that no offence under s. 201
•
SUPREME OOURT REPOR'l'S [1963]
254
1962
Raghati Prapanr.a
Tripathi
.
I. P. C. has
lants.
been established against the appel-
Further, no offence under s. 176 I. P. C. can
be held proved B!!'ainst Ramanuj Das when there
is no proof' that Kamla and Madhu•uilhan were
Raghubar Doyal J,
murdered. As a member of' t.he villaq;e Panchavat
he was bound to convev inf'orm'l.tion to the near·
P-•t Magistrate or Officer:in-charge of thA nearest
Police Station about the commission of' an offence
under s. 302, I. P. C., onlv when .a murder had
. been committed and he knew about it.
The conviction of the appellants for the
various offences is therefore not iustified on the
material on record. We therefore allow the
appeal, ~et aside their oonviction and acquit them
of the offences thev have been convicted of. They
will be released forthwith from custodv, if not
required to be detained under any other process
of law.
.
v.
Stale of U. P.
Kapur J.
KAPUR, J.-This is an appeal against the
judgment and order of the High Court of AJ.lahabad confirming the conviction and sentences
passed on the appelh.nts. Of the appellants
Raghav Prapanna Tripathi
was convicted
of murdering his wife Kamla and his son M>tdhusudhan on the evening of April 5, 1961 at
Hamirpur Roora and was sentenced to dflath.
He and other appellants were also convicted
under s. 201, Indian Penal Code for causing
the disappearance of' the evidence of the crime and
were sentenced to five years' rigorous imprisonment. Appellant Ramanuj Das was further con.victed under s. 176, Indian Penal Code and sentenced to 3 months' rigorous imprisonment.
The conviction is based on circumstantial
evidence. This Court in Anant Ghintaman Lagu
v. The State of Bombay(') bas laid down the princi(ll (1960)2 s.c.a. «o .
•
+
,-
-k,
3 s.c;R.
•
...
. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
255
ples which govern such cases.
In that case
Hidayatullah J., at p. 516 quoting the observations
of Baron Parke in Towell's case( 1 ) where the learned
Baron laid down the principles applicable to such
cases observed that any circumstance which destroys
the presumJi>tion of innocence, if properly established can be taken into acco1.1.nt to find out if the
circumstances lead to no other inferenc'l but of
guilt. Thus what we have to see is whether taking
the totality of circumstances which are held to
have been proved against the appellants it can be
said that the case is established against the
appellants i.e. the facts eRtablishecl are inconsistent with the innocence of the appellants and
incapable of explanation on any hypotheRis other
than that of guilt. See also Govind Reddy V•
State of Mysore(2). It may also be observed here that
ordinarily this court does not reassess the evidence
and re-examine the findings reached by the courts
below pa,rticularlv where there are concurrent
findings of fact, 'but it was urged before us that
this iR one of those cases where the rule laid down
bv the Privy Council in Stephen Seneviratne v.
ThP. king(') applifls i. e. on the evidence taken Rs a
whole no t,rib1ma! could as a . matt.er of
legitimate infncnce arrive at the conclnsion that
the appdlants are guilty. The inference of guilt of
the appellants hris been drawn from a number of
circumstances which, according to the aopellants, do
not, leftd to the irresistible conclution that thev are guilty anrl whioh, aocorrliog to the submi~sion of the respondent, lead to only one oonclusion and one alone
that the appellants have been rightlv con_victed and
sentenced. In order to satisfy ourselves at to the
guilt of the appellflnts we have found it expPdient
in this case to go into the evidence and see whether
the conviction is rightly based.
(l 1 (IR'il) 2 S <.R. 31)).
(2) A.LR, l960S.C. 29.
(Sl A.! R. 1931 p,r:, W9, 2~9.
19()2
Raghav Prapanna
TrifJalhi
v.
8tal1 DJ '(J. P.
--
Kapur J,
.--
256
1962
. . RsJ!hav Prap"ana
Tr;p111h;
••
Stale of U. P.
Kapur J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
In village Hamirpur Roora which is in Itawah
district there is a reli!!ious institution of which
Lachhman Das was the Mahant. He had two chelas
(disciples) the elder was ·Narain Das and the younger
Ramanuj Das who is one of the appellants in the present case. Narain Das got married and was therefore
excluded from succession. His wife is Jai Devi
who is also an appellant and they has several child· ren amoD"gst whom is their son Raghav who is
another appellant in the case and they have got
younger sons and some daughters amongst whom we
need only · mPntion Govind Kumari who is
M.A.LL.B. of the Lucknow University but she ia
neither a witness nor an accused in the case. The
other two accused are Mohan Singh and Udham
Singh who are retainers of the Mahant. Ra.ghav in
the year 1950 was married to Kamla who was the
daughter of Ram Sarup, a. well-to-do gentleman
living in another village. In 1954 Raghav married
another girl who is also an M.A., LL.B. and she
and Raghav with Govind Kumari and other sisters
were living at Lucknow in a flat in Shankarpuri.
The case for the prosecution is that after the marriage the relations between Kamla, the first wife,
and Raghav were Atraiued and she wits ill-treated
by h0r husband and Kamla harl to leave her fatherin-law's house and to go and Jive with her father in
his village. Bflfore this Kamla aud Raghav
had a son Madhusudhan who was 'oorn in 1957.
While Kamh was staying with her father, P.W.
Lakhan Prasad intervened and suggested to Rama.nuj Das appellant to give to Kamla Rs. 1(1,000 in
cash and 90 bighas of land and this waa agreed to
by Ramanuj Das and on this assurance Ramanuj ·
Das went to Kamla's father's hous~ and brought
back Kam la after the Bi<lai ceremony was pflrformerl. It has been stated in the evi<ltnce of Ram
Sarup which has been accepted by the High Court
that Ramanuj Das himself had told him (Ram
Sarup) that the money and the land would be given.
3 S.C.R.
-
•
-
•
-
'
-..i.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
25'1
Somet.imes in February 1961 i.e. about a month and
half before the <late of the alleged occurrenoe Ram
Sarup WPnt to the house of Ramanuj Das along with
Lakhan Prashad P.W. He asked .Hamanuj Das to
execute the document in respect of the property
and also in regard to the money and they were told
by Ramanuj Das that after Raghav returned from
Lucknow "this would be done. After having this
talk Ramanuj Das, Ram Sarup and Lakhan Prasad
met KamJa in the house of Ramanuj Das and apprised her of this arrrangement. On April, 4, 1961
Lakhan Prasad came to know about the arrival of
Raghav and on the following day i.e . .April 5, 1961
he want to Kamanuj Das as he had been instructed·
by Ram Sarup and there he found both Ramanuj
Das and Raghav. Lakhan Prasad then asked Ramanuj Das that thi> promise in regard to Rs.10,000
and 110 bighas of land should be c11.rried into effect.
Thereupon it is statPd that Raghav got up abruptly
and left the place but Ramanuj Das promised
to execute the document on the day Ram Sarup
could come. . Lakhan Prasad told Ramanuj Das
that he would go to R11m Sarup on Saturday i.e.
April 8,· 1961 and bring him on the following day i.e.
April 9,1961 and then the document could be exf>cuted on Monday, April 10,1961. This arrangement
was accepted by Hamanuj Das. Lakhan Prasad
then went and informed Karola about it.
.According to the prosr.cution both Kamla and
Ma<lhusudan were murdered with gun-shots sometime in the evP.ning of April 5, 1961, the day the above
talk took place. These gunshots were heard by
three wit.nesses. The same evening Raghav left
Hamirpur Roora by jeep accompanied by appellants
Mohan Singh and Udham Singh 'l'hey were seen
passing through the village Samain at about
9 O'cloek by P.W. Sri Ra.m. TbPy then proceeded
to Bidhuoa where petl'ul was purchased from the
shop of ontl Ram Bb.ajan P. W. This was at about
1961
Raglav P,npanna
Tr pothi
v.
Slate of U. P.
EapurJ.
258
1.962
Raghav Propanqa
'Iripathi
v.
Stai. of U: P.
ICapur J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
11 P.M. Ram Bhajan saw two other persons in the
jeep whjch was being driven by Ragbav. 'Jhey then
crossed the Ganga at Kanpur at the Rawatpur
Barrier at 8.30 a.m. and from there proceeded to
Lucknow. A post card was sent from Lucknow on
April 6, 1961 by Govind Kumari in ri-gard to the
arrival of Raghav and others.
It is not disputed thitt Karola and !lfadhusudan
werl" not seen alive after the evening of April
5,1961. As a matter of fact it is admitted that she
became "traceless" after Raghav left Hamirpur
Roora. On April 7,1961, Khushali Chowkidar of
. the village made a First Information Report at the
police station to the following effect.
"Day before yesterday in the night Raghav of
my village, who is son of Narain Das, has
murdered hiR wedded wife and son by firing of
them with the gun of Mabant Ramanuj Das.
He has gone some where with the two dead
bodies in a car. There is a rumour about it
in the whole of the village. Having heard of
it, I went to the Mahant who is also the
Pradhan of my village. I asked hini to giv!3
me somethin.!!' in writing, so that I should go
tn the Polico Station and make a report. The
Mahant then asked me to wait and to go only
after Thakur D;1,lganjan t:;ingh had come.
I did not listen to him, although he kept on
forbidding. I have come to make a report".
The Sub-inspector-in-charge of the Police Station
had gone in connection with some official duty
and therefore the above. information was sent to
him by the police. He came to Hamirpur Roora at
ahout 2 p.m. and inspected the house where the
deceased was residing. According to his statement
he did not find any one iu the house; he took some \...
witnesses along with him and made a search of "
the house and there he found some patches
I
....
'
3 S.O.R.
8tJPHEME COORT REPORTS
259
which !ooked like blood on the terra-ce and in the
rooms of the first floor. He prepared a site plan
and made a memorandum of what he saw there.
This site plan and the memorandum that he prepared have been proved. He took into possession blood
stained plaster pieces from 11 places from insidethe room, put them into separate packets and
made the packets into a bundle and sealed it. On
April 12, 1961 Police Deputy Superintendent Bashir
Hussain took in and the investigation and came
to the place of the ocourrenoe and found seven
other places where there were marks which looked
like blood marks and he took the earth into possession. These included places like Parnal,as (water
spots). These were also made into a sealed par·
eel but unfortunately all these t1.rticles were not
sent to the Chemical Examiner till May 25, 1961
and when examined out of 11 -pieces which had
been collected by the Sub-Inspector five were found
to be bloodstained and of out seven pieces collected
by Deputy Superintendent Bashir Hussian only two
were found to be bloodstained. When these arti, cles were sent to the Serologist the origin of the
blood could not lre ascertained as the blood by that
time had disintegrated.
1
The Sub-Inspector searched for the accused
persons but could not find any one at the house or
at other places. On April 10, 1961 he arrested
Mohan Singh appellant but the others could not be
traced. They excepting Raghav surrendered themselves on different dates in the Magistrate's court
in the district of Etawah Rama.nuj Das on April 24
and Jai Devi on April 27. The Sub-Inspector
started a search for Raghav, looked for him in
different places in Lucknow but he could not find
him nor was his jeep found. April 20, 1961 Raghav surrendered in the court of the Magistrate at
1962.
Raghau P1opanna
T1ipatJ.i
\'.
State of U. P.
KapurJ.
260
W62
Bsglav Prapaffr,a
Tripaihi
v.
Stat,.JU. P.
Kapur J.
SUPREME COURT REPOR'fS (1963]
Nawabganj in the district of Barabanki.
application he stated aR follows:"2.
In the
That brimati Kamla daughter of Ram
Swarup of village Manchhana, P. S.
Kotwali District Mainpuri, residing in
my house has become traceless along
with her minor son and in this connection a strong rumour has been set afloat
by the enemies of the applicant's family
to the effect that she has been murdered.''
He also stated that his name was being associated
with the murder because of enmity. An Affidavit
was filed in the court of the Magistrate by Govind
Kumari sister of the appellant in which it was
stated that Kamla had run away from the house
of Ramanuj Das aftu stealing ornaments. The
jeep in which Raghav had left Hamirpur Roora
was never found in spite of the best efforts of the
Police.
-
During the course of their investigations the
police recovered from 'the laundry of on Babula!
1'.W. in Lucknow a shirt and a pyjama belongin~
to appellant Raghav. The police thought tha
there were blood marks both on the shirt as welt
as the pyjama but the Chemical Examiner only!
found three minute size bloodstains on the shirt
but the origin of this blood also could not be discovered as the blood had disintegrated. The
appellants were then tried before the learned
Sessions Judge who convicted them as has been
said above. The conviction was upheld by the
High Court and the appellants have come to this
court by special leave.
It may be remarked that the dead body of·
· Kamla or her son Madhusudan was never found and
this is a case where there is no direct proof of
corpus delicti. The question is whether in a cas:i
,,
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
261
like this and on the evidence which we are going
to discuss, it can be st1id that a case of murder
has been proved and it has also been proved
as to who committed the murder and further whether a case under s. 2Ql has been made out.
There are certain facts in this case which are
not in controversy. The apf>ellant Ra!(hav after
having been married to Kamla for about four years
married a second time. His second wife is Vimla
who is a graduate of the Lucknow University. It
is not disputed. th it some time in 1959 Kamla with
her son Madhusudan who was born in 1957 went to
, live with her parents, her father being a well to-do
resident of another village. She stayed with her
parents for about two years and was brought back
to Hamirpur Roora some time in 1960. The prosecution case is that t.bis was on the promise that
she will be given Rs. 10, 00~ in cash and 90 bighas
of land but this is denied by the defence. The
High Court ha.~ found this fact proved. There is
again no dispute about their (Ka.mla and her son
Madhusudan) being alive upto the evening of April
5, 1961. On the night between April 5 and April
6, both Kamla and Madhusudan disappeared. They
were not seen at the house of Ramanuj Das where
they were residing and where also were residing
her father in-law and his family and her husband
whenever he came to the 'l'illage from Lucknow
where he was a·University st-udent and where he
had a flat of his own for his residence and th'lt o.f
his secon·d wife Vimla and his sisters. It is also
• clear on this record that none of the members of
the family i.e. Ramanuj Das, Jai Devi or any other
made the slightest attempt to trace the whereabout
of Kamla and her son after their disappearance.
No report was made to the Police, no search was
made. On the other hand when the chowkidar of
the village Khushali P. W., asked Ramanuj Das
1962
Raghao P1apanna
Tripo#i
v.
Stale of U. P.
Ka;urJ,
·'
262
1962
Ragh110 Pr1Jpanna
1'ripa1h;
v.
St.ti of U. P.
Kapur J.
SCJP.REM:E COU.Rr REPORrs [1963]
to give something in writing so that he could in·
form the Police regarding thtJ rumour which was
afloat in the village about the murder of Kamla
and her son he told· him to wait till Dalgajan
Singh came. It was after this that the chowkidar
made a report at the Police Station.
.
The first question is as to whether Kamla
and her son were murdered and the murder was
committed in the house of Hamanuj Das as alleged
by the prosecution. A>. we have said above both
Kamla and her son were see11 alive till the evening
of April 5, 1961 and they were not seen thereafter.
Both the courts below have found and there is
evidence on the record that relations bet ween
Kamla and he husbanrd Raghav were strained and
it was for that reason that she had ~one away to
. her parents house. !tam Swarup, Kamla's father
has deposed to this and so has Lakhan Prasad who
deposed that whenever he met Kamla he found her
to be unhappy. Ordinarily amongst families such
as that of the appellant daughters-in-law do. not
go away to stay at their parents house unless there
is reason for it. The High Court has considered
this evidence in regard to the relations between the
husband and the wife at great length and it is not
necessary to reprat those statements of the witnesses which have been ri:iferred to in the judgment of
the High Court. We are sati9fied that on this
evidence the High Court has rightly found that the
relations between the two were unhappy. In those
circumstances it has to be enquired as to how and
why Kamla came back to the house of her in-laws
along with her son. For that the evidence again
is of Ram Swarup and Lakhan Prasad. Somewhere
in 1960 Lakhan Prasad went to Ram Swarup and
asked him that Kamla should be sent to Hamirpur
Roora and that there would be no further trouble.
we also told Ram Swarup that Ramanuj Das had
decided to give Kamla a sum of Rs. 10,000 in cash
...
,'f'
3 S.C.R.
SUPRlU.ME COURT REPORTS
263
and 90 bighas of Land for cultivation on the understanding that she would reside at Hamiipur Roora.
On this condition Ramanuj Das came and took
Kamla with him after tho bidai ceremony. · On that
occasion, according to Ram Swarup, Ramanuj Das
told him that he would settle the money and the
Li.nd . as pnmised. Sometime in February 1961
Ram Swarup accompanied by Lakhan 1 rasad went
to the house of Ramanuj Das and asked . him to
perform his part of the promise to which Ramanuj
Das replied that be would do so on the arrival of
Raghav from Lucknow.
•
1962
R•ghav Pr.pann•
Tripolhi
v.
Stale of U. P.
KapurJ.
On April 5, 1961, the date of the alleged murder, Lakhan Prasad went to the house of Ramanuj
Das and there he had a talk with Ramanuj Das,
Ragbav was also sitting near l{amanuj Das. When
Lakhan Prasad start6'd talking about this matter
· Raghav got up and went away but Ramanuj Das
promised that h'e would execute the document on
Monday April 10, 1961 and it was arranged that
Ram Swarup would also be present by them and
Lakhan .Prasad informed Kamla of this fact. The
deftJnce has deni:ed this part of the prosecution case
and before us the evidence of La.khan Prasad was
8evor~ly criticised and reliance was placed on the
criticism of this witness by the learned Sessions
Judge. It appears that the learned Sefisions Judge
has been unduly StJvere on Lakhan Prasad merely
because of a post caret which wll.s produ0ed by
H.amanuj Das and proved by defence witnesses that
tho marriage between Karola and Ragloav was not
brought about by Lakhan Pras1.d but by DaJadar
Singh. Lakhan Prasad had deposed that he had
brought about the marriage. It was also said that
Lakhan Prasad was unable to recognise the photograph of Govind Kumari and other children and
thus could not be very familiar with the family.
But the evidence of Lakhan Prasad gets strong corroboration from the evid nce of Ram Swarup. The
0
'
)
264
1962
R, gha-;; Prapanna
Trr'pathi
••
State t1f U. P.
Kapur J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963)
High Court was satisfied that on that day Ramanuj
Das had agreed that he wo<Ild exeo<Ite such a dncu·
ment and we see no reason to differ from the finding
of the High Court,
The fact that Rama.nuj Das was present for
the settlement of money and land in favour of
Kamla is amply proved on this record and it is equally clear that when this matter wae broached in
the presence of Raghav he suddenly left the place
from which an inference might well be and has
rightly been drawn t.hat he was not very happy
about this settlement.
On the same evening threA shots were heard
by three witnesses P. W., Narain Singh, P.W. Lallu
Singh and P. W. Babu Singh. Both the courts
below have accepted the testimony of these wit·
nesses .. We have gone through the evidence of these
witnesses and altho<Igh there may be certain points
on which the testimony of these witnesses may leg·
itimately be subjected to criticism, those points are
not sufficient to detract from their evidence that
they did hear three shots being fired. The defence
had put forward the theory that it was the firing
of a toy gun by the younge,r brother of Raghav
which these witnesses heard on that day but this
plea has rightly not been accepted by the High
Court.
The question then arises whether Raghav
was in the village on April 5, the date of
the murder. 'l'b.e case for Ragbav is that he
had left on the 4th and that he was not in the
village on the 5th. One ·fact· which has been
taken· into consideration against this plea is the
statement of Lakhan Prasad when he states
that in the presence of Raghav the question of
·settlement of land and of money was discussed
and Raghav got up and went away. This, according to Lakhan Prasad, was on the 5th. Then
•.
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
265
)
'
there is the evidence to show that the jeep of
appellant Raghav was seen in the house of Ramanuj
Das on the evening of . th. This evidence is of
P. W. Narain Singh who saw the jeep in the house
a.nd of P. W. Lallu Singh who saw the jeep of
Raghav going towards the north at about 9 or 10
O'Clock on 1he evening of April 5, 1961 and finally the evidence of P. W. Babu Singh who says
that on the same evening he heard the sound of
car at about 10 p. m. He also stated tl.at the only
person who had a jeep or a car was l{aghav. These
witnesses have been believed and after going
through their evidence we are of the opinion that
they have been rightly believed. There is then
the evidence of P. W. Sri Ram who says that
on April 5, at about 10 p.m. he saw the jeep of
:kaghav in village Samain which is at a distance
of a mile and in that jeep there were the appellant
Raghav &nd the two appellants Mohan Singh and
Udham Singh bnd that the back curtain of the
jeep was drawn. This evidence was criticised on
the ground that this witness had made a mistake
as to the date which wa.s 4th and also that he
did not meet the a.ppellant's jeep there but at
another place on the canal bank and it is argued
that the statement of this witness is compatible
with the case of the defence. It appears to us
that Sri Ram has made a mistake about the date.
He was deposing after a long time but corroboration is from another source and that shows that
Sri Ram must have seen the jeep on the 5th and
not the 4th. The jeep was seen at Hamirpur H.oora
on the 5th by two witnesses. Raghav was seen at
the house on the 5tb by Lakhan Prasad and his
further movement8 have been traced also. Raghav
took petrol from P. W. Ram Bhajjan who states
that the petrol was purchased about 10-30 p. m.
or 11 p. m. and considoring the distance between
Bidhuna and Samain that would proba.bly be the
1962
Raghav Prapann<J
Tripath1
v.
Stalt of U. P.
EapurJ.
266
1962
Ra~h"v Prapanna
Trlpat•·i
V,
St,te of U. P:
KopUrJ.
SUPREME COtJRT REPORTS (1963]
time when Raghav would be in Bidhuna. The
evidence of this witness was also criticiaed that
he made a mistake' in regard to time and that petrol
was brought at 2 p. m. and not in the night. It
was argued that other cash memos had not been
taken from Ham Bhajjan which, if they had been
taken, would have shown that the petrol was taken
not at 10-30 p. m. or l1 p. m. but earlier in the.
afternoon. This witness has given good reasons
why he remembered the time when petrol was taken
by him. .He stated that two days later he heard
the rumour and then remembered the time and
the date on which Ragba.v had bought petrol from
him. He was criticised for not remembering the
time when Raghav bought petrol on the 4th but
then he had no reason to recall that visit. In our
opinion the testimon v of this witness has been
rightly accepted by the courts below. On the mor·
niiig of 6th the jeep was seen at the barrier at
the river Ganga at Kanpur at 8-30 a. m. and then
li.aghav went to Lucknow. From the evidence of
demand of Lakhan Prasad for the i:lettlement of
land on Kamla on April 5, 1961 in the presence
of Raghav from the fact that the jeep of Raghav
was seen in the village in the evening and his jeep
was seen going from village Hamirpur Roora and
again at Samain and Bhidhuna an inference has
rightly been drawn that appellant Raghav was present in village Hamirpur Roora on April 5 and his
plea that he left that village on the 4th is false.
The police was informed about the rumour
in the village of the murder of Kamla and her son
on April 7 and the Sub-Inspector Brijraj Singh
Tomar came to the house of Ramanuj Das at about.
2 p.m. He went into the house and inspected the
place of occurrence and prepared a site plan and
memo showing as to what he saw. This, he has
sworn to be correct and thtire is no reason to doubt
his testimony. According to his statement he found
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
•
267
what appeared to be blood at different places in the
rooms and he took the plaster from those places.
As we have said above the origin of this blood has
not been proved because of disintegration but the
fact is that blood was found in the rooms.
The case put forward by appellant Raghav was
that he started from the village on April 4 and want
to his mother's father's house at Shah Nagla. From
there he took with him his Dada Ram Sewak and
the wife of Ram Sewak whom he called Bhahhi.
He started from that place on April 5, 1961 at
abo•1t 12 noon, took pet;rol from Bidhuna and
reached Samain, which he wants us to read as
Bhawain. where his mother's sister iR married and
where he want to condole because the f11.t,her-in-l!!,w
of his mother's sister had died and from there he
started from Lurknow on April 6, 1961 after taking
refreshments. All these facts were capable of
easy proof if facts they Wflre. Neither the Dada
nor the Bhabhi were examined The two persons
who saw the appellant go in the j<>ep are P. W. Sri
Ram and P. W. Ram Bhajan. The testimony of
these witness1>s has been believed by the courts ·
below and with that we have agreed. Neither of them
says that they saw a woman in the jeep. If the
appellant left with Mohan Singh and CTdham Singh
then there shoulrl have been four individuals in the
jeep besides the appellant at the petrol pump. That
iR vot the statement of P. M. Ram :J3hajan nor is
there any proof that as a matter of fact the fatherin· Jaw of the appellant's mother's sister (.llfassi) had
died or th<tt the appellant had gone there for the
purpose of condoling or that he went there at all.
We are unable to accept t,his explanation given by
tbe appeUant in view of the tf'stimony of the witnesses who have been discussed above. Thus after
the three gunshots Wflre fired and heard by th<:i
three witnesses, the appellant's jeep was seen
leavi~g the village. It was seen in Samain with
1968
Ragh.v P,apanna
T. ipat1.i
v.
State of U, P.
Kopu, J.
26B
1962
Raghao PropanntJ
Tripathi
Y.
-
Stul• oj U P.
KapuT J.
SUPR~ME COURT REPORTS [191)3]
the two appellants Mohan Singh and Udham Singh
and it was then seen at Bidhuna "with two persons
sitting at the back". This was on April 5. The
AXnlanation given by the appellant, therefore, is
false.
·
Wheni the""appellant rmi.ohed Lucknow his
si•ter wrote a letter saying that the appellant
etc. ha,d arrived and that Bhabhi had also come
a.nd "as Bha bhi has come over here so I have not
to worr:v about cooking nf food". The defenoe
euLmit that wnat was meant bv Bhahhi waR Vim la
or it mav be Dada'e wife an<'! therefore it C>tnnot. he
said that there was any oblique motive in the
writing of t.hiR post card so as to create evidence in
re!l'11ril to Karola hPing alive on April 6. l!l51. The
prosecution has rightly ar®Pd tha.t, in thiR poRt CA.rd
tbore is no mention of 'K~mJa. ThA fathPr, UUC]e
and mother and three yoongflr children are mentioned but not Kamla or MadhuRUdan. To this the
reply of counsel for the appellant was that there
was not much love lost between Kemla and Govind
Kumari and for that reason her name was not
mentioned. But there was nothing against, the
little bov who could have been ment.ioni-d as the
other children. Even if Govind Kumari's dista~te
be true that is an additional reason for Raying t.bat
Kamla was not a very welcom" member oft.he
family of her in-laws.
The appellant then was found to be absconding. According to Snb·Inspector Tom>ir efforts
were made to search for him in different places
where he would ordinarily be in the town of
Lnnknow or elsewhere bnt he was not found.
Ultimately he went to Nawabganj in the district of
Barabanki where on April 20, 1961 he surrendered
himself before a MagistratP. In the application that
he made for surrendering himself he stated, as has
been said above, that Kamla d/o Ram Swarnµ who
was living in his house was missing and it was being
'
,.
\-
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
269
said by his enemies that she had murdered and that
his name had been mentioned in that conneotiOn
due to enmity and that a warrant had issued against
him although he was wholly unaware of her disappearance. This is rather a.n extraordinary conduct
on the part of a husband. There is nothing to
indicates that any attempt was made by the husband to search for the missing wife and the child or
anything was done by him in regard to that matter.
He may not have worried about the moth0r but
what a.bout the child? The allegation of the prosecution that he was absconding and that when they
searched for him they could not find him is satisfactorily established on this record. We are aware
that the burden of proving everything against the
appellant is on the prosecution and tber" is no
burden on him to disprove any<,bing but in a case
of circumstantial evidence where there are circmnstance of the kind which are proved in this case the
cumulative effect has to be seen by placin~ together
proved fact,s and conclusion drawn therefrom and
in the absence of any exphnation all that one has
to consider is the proseeution evidence.
There is another h1portant circumstance.
A shirt of the appellant was recovered from a
laundry on April Hi. It was found to be bloodstained although the origin of the blood has not
been proved hy the prosecution. The fact remains
that at three places this shirt which was given by
the appellant on April 9, 1961 was found to be
blood-stained. Counflel for the appellant argued
that this was a most innocuous circumstance because
there is no proof that there was blood nn the shirt
on April 9 when it wafl given to the laundry and
that merely three sp~cks of blood bein~ found on
the 16t,b i.e. seven days later is not a circumstance
which can be taken agaiDAt the appellant. With
this we do not agree. The appellant must consider
himself lucky that the shirt was washed or it would
1962
Rag~av
Pr,panna
Tripathi
v.
State ~f U. P.
KapurJ.
270
1962
Roghav Ptapanna
Tripnthi
••
State of U. P.
Kaput J,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [19'13]
have cleared him or inculpated him still more. The
fact that the blood was not visible to Babula! when
the shirt was taken is not a circumstance whioh goes against the prosem1tion case because books on
medical jurisprudence show that blood•t.ains are
sometimes faint and invisible by ordinary li1Zht. The
shirt was given to be laundered and Babula] will
look for tears and damage and not for stain3 or dirt
for which the shirt was given to be cleaned. The
colour of the shirt was khaki and it is likelv that
the small stains would go unnoticed. After
the
shirt was given for a wash. It is true that the blood
was found on April 16, 1961 and there is no proof
that it was there on April 9, 1961 but we see no
reason why blood should suddenly appear seven
days later on the shirt of Raghav. When· he was
asked in regard to this blood•tained shirt, his
answer was "I do not know''. In the circumstances
the courts were justified in taking this to be a
circumstance in the chain of circumstane.es which
have to be placed together in order to determine
whether the case has been m11de out against the
appell11.nt or not.
v
~
all
Another very striking circumstance again;it the
appellant is that the jel·p in which Ragbav trav•' llu<l
fnm the village to Lucknow has vanish"d from
the face of this earth. In spite of the best pfforts
of the police it has not been found. Evidently the
police wanted to interrogate th!l appellant in regard
the whereabouts of the jeep but it appeltrs th:tt by
en order dated April 28, 1961 the M •gist rate ordered
that the Investigating Officer should issue a written
order requiring Raghav to produce the jeep "as well
a~ to interrogate the accused'', that the accused i~
at liberty to say whatever be likes and he could not
be compelled either to producP the thing or to tPll
its whereabouts as this is his privilege under the
law. It iA then that the police made an order calling upon the appellant (Raghav) to produce the
\
'1"
\--.
3 S.C.R.
y
_,
SU~REME
COURT REPORTS
271
jeep a.nd of course it was never produced nor found.
His reply cannot be rearl under s. 162 Criminal
Procedure Code and we lea.ve have it out of account
altogether. Every possible place was searched and
it is significant that it has not been found till today
and even when the evidence was being led about
its disappearance the evidence was not contradicted
by drivin~ the jeep to the court house and .saying
here it is. This, in our opiQion, is a circumstance
which can be taken into consideration in order to
determiQe tbe guilt or otherwise of the appellant.
In the opinion of the High Court the jeep hns not
been produced because it must be bloodstained, on
account of the dead bodies having been carried in it.
It is quite obvious that however much the jeep be
washed the chances would be that in some crevice,
in some joint or in some bolt nut or screw, blood
may still remain adhearing. But if the jeep is not
producerl there can be no risk of detection and the
inferencfl from itR disappearance can be countered
by arguments as it has actually been. The nonproduction of the jeep is a strong circumstance
against appellant R<tghav which the courts below
Wf'tre entitled to take into consideration. Articles
like jeeps do not just disappear in this air and whfln
they do disappear and cannot be traced as they
h~ve not been traced in this caF1e and when the
allegation i'I that t.bey have been used for carrying
away the dead bodifls their non-production or thPir
not being found is a circumstance which a court can
take into com~ideration in determining the guilt of
an accused person.
.
19611
Bagha~ Prapanni
T,;pa1hi
.
••
Slal1 of U. P.
It may also he addfld that the other appellants
were alflo absconding. Why the whole household
went away is not just a coincidence. If the girl and
the child bad disappeared in innocent circumsta.nceE<
there was hardl v reason for all of them tn panic.
None of them proved why, t.hey Wf\re so difficult to
get at or what was the urgent business which had
..
272
1961
Ragh'a'IJ Prapanna
Tf'1patlli
<.
.
v.
State ·of u. P •
K1JpurJ,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963)
·called them away. Mohan Sin11h was arre!ted on
April 9, Ramanuj Das surrendered on April 24,
and in his application he stated that he had been
informed by A. P. Dubey that he was wanted. Jai
Devi surrendered on April 27, 1961 and claimed
to be a purdanashin lady and her appearance in
court was excused and she was re leased on bail.
Thus. all the accused persons were found to be
absconding a.nd except one the other four were not
arrested but they surrendered in the court of the
Magistrate and of them 3 were released on bail.
We have therefore the following circumstances
which the Courts have taken into considerations
(1) strained relations between Raghav and hie wife
Kamla; (2) there was an agreement by Ramanuj
Das c.f making a settlement of land and money in
favour ofKamla and on the insistence of Ram
Swarup father of Kamla, Ramanuj Das had agreed
that the document :wonld he executed on Monday
i. e April 10, 1961 ; (3) it is also proved that when
the matter was discussed in the presence of appellant Raghav whose arrival was .awaited for fina.lis·
ing the arrangement he got up and went away; and
it is also established that Kamla had been brought
from the house of hn parents nn tha exprees condi ·
tion that such a settlement would be made; (4) on
April 5, 1961 appellant Raghavwas in village Hamirpur Hoora and on that evening three gunshots
were fired and some time later Raghav left in his
jeep with two other appellants Moh-in Singh and
Odham Singh and after Raghav lef.t Kamla and her
son were found missing from the house; (5) although
this fact was discovered the next day no attempt
· was made to search for Kamla and her son; (6)
Appellant Raghav and his two companions travelled
by night from village Hamirpur Roora according to
·witnesses he was in a hurry and were found on the
6th morning at Kanpur and tha 2ame day they
· reached Lucknow as the post card written by
Y'
. \-
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
273
Govind Kumari shows. In that post card it is stated that the avpellant and others had arrived at
· L~cknow. The expla.na.tion of the appellant was
that he left on the 4th and took his Dada and hill!
:Bhabhi along with him but this explanation has not
been accepted and is a false explanation; (7) thereafter the appellant made himself scarce and the
police could not trace him till he surrendered himself in the court of a magistrate atNawabgunj "'here
he made an application stating that one Karola was
found missing and that he was being suspected of
murdering her; (8) why he should have gone to
Nawabgunj is not quite clear and of course neither
he nor any of his relatives made any attempt to
look for Karola; (9) when the chowkidar of the
village told Ramanuj Das a.bout the rumour in the
village of the murder of . Kamla he was asked by
Ramanuj Das not to make the report till Dalganjan
Singh had arrived (Dalganjan 1'ingh we are told is
an Up-Pradhan of the Panchayat) the report was
made by the chow kidar on the 7th and the police
came the same day and inspected the house of
Ramanuj Das ; ( 10) In the rooms upwtairs blood
was found at 5 places. According to the memo
prepared and deposed to in Court there were marks
of blood having been wiped off at many placti!I and
the Chemical ExaminPr found t'ie marks on these
various'places of plaster which had been taken into
possession by the sub-Inspector to be of blood but
its origin could not be determined·due to disintegration; \ l l) on April 12, D. Sp. Bashir Hussain found
the blood at 2 places more • in the house of the
Ramanuj Das. The origin of this blood has also
not been proved due to disintegration; (12J on April
16, a bloodstained shirt of Raghav was found from
a l>tundry; (l:3) no explanation is given of this blood
0 n Lhe shirt and ( l4) on April 5, 1961 both Kain la
nrl her son disapp<iart'd from the fact of this earth
nd no bocly has heard of them and no attempt has
en made to find out as to what happened to them
RaghatJ Prapanna
Tripath1
v.
Stale oJ U. l".
KapurJ,
2i4
1961
Ragh!JV Prapanna
•.
Tr;p.ihi
-,.-
St~te of U. P.
Kapur J~
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
and instead false explanation was given that Kamla
had left with her child and a suggestion was made
in the cross-examaination that she had eloped with
one Chander ShPkhar and thus had vanished from
the house. It may he stated that there is no reason
why she should have disappeared when according
to evidence sh!' was going to get land and money
and when she had her father who could look after
her and was in affluent circumstances; (I 5) Coupled
with this is the fact of disappearance of jeep in
which the appellant travelled from his villag J to
Lucknow; (16) and a wholly false explanation was
given as to the movement of the appellant Raghav.
From these circumstances the courts below came to
the conclusion that the murder was committed
at the house of Ramanuj Das. We find no
reason to disagree with the conclusions drawn
from the evidence that Kamla and her son Madhu·
sudhan are Clead and they met their death by
violence in the house of Ramanuj Das.
In king Horry (1) the headnote states the law
as follows:" At the trial of a person uharged with
murder, the fact of death is pro.vable by
circumstantial evidence, not withstanding that
neither the body nor any trace of the body
has been found and that the accused has
made no confession of any participation in
the crime. Before he oan be convicted, the
fact of death should · be proved by such <iir·
cumstanoes as render the commission of the
crime morally certain and leave no ground
for reasonable doubt; the circumstantial
evide'nce should be so cogent and compelling
as to convince a jury that upon no raticnal
hypothesis other than murder can the facts
be accounted for."
(I) [1952] N.Z.L.R. Ill.
'(
'
•
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
275
This statement of the law was approved in Regina v.
Onufrejczyk( 1 ) except as to moral certainty and that
statement of the law has received approval of this
court in Anant Ohintarnan Lagu v. The State of
Bombay(2). It was also said in King v. Horry('):
"That the jury, viewing the evidence as
a whole, was entitled to regard the concur·
ranee of so many separate facts and circums·
tances themselves establisned beyond all
doubt, and all pointing to the fact of death
on or about July Ia, 1942-as excluding any
reasonable hypothesis other than the death
of the person alleged to have been murdered
and as having, therefore sufficient probative
force to establish her death."
In this connection it would be apposite" to
quote from the judgment in Lagu's case (2 ) at
page 506 where it was observed:"In Rex v. Horry [1952] N.Z.L.R. 111
where the entire case law 'in England was
presented for the consideration of the Court.
It was pointed out by the Court that there
was no rule in England that corpus delicti
must be proved by direct evidence establishing the death of the person and further the
cause that death. Reference was made to
Evans v. Evans 161 E.R. 466, 491. Where
it was ruled that corpus delicti might be
proved by direct evidence or by "irresistible
grounds of. presumption". In the same case
it has been pointed out that in New Zeland
the Court, upheld numerous convictions,
where the body of the victim was never
found."
The two cases referred to above i.e. King v. Horry(')
and Regina v. Onufrejczyk (1) are oases of conviction
(I) [\9,5] i Q.B. 38~. 3 l4.
I'.!) 1960 12 S.C.R. 460.
(3) [195i] N.Z. L.R. Ill.
196!
Raghav Prap 1nn<1
T1ipathi
v.
State of U. P,
KapurJ.
•
276
1962.
RagAao Pr11;anna
Tripa1lii
v.
State of U. P.
Kapu,.J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
no doubt by juries on evidence which was wlrolly
circumstantial but in both those cases neither the
body. was found nor any trace of the body was
found and there was no confession by the accused
of any participation in the crime and the conviction
was based on the occurrence of so many separate
facts and circumstances all pointing to the fact of"
death on or about a particular date and excluded
any reasonable hypothesis other than the death of
.the per&on alleged to have been murdered and this
was held to be of sufficient probative force to
establish death. In the present case the circumstances which have been proved and to repeat the
circumstanctis are, strained relations between the
husband and wife, motive to escape the giving of
money and land or maintenance to the wife or the
child, suddenly leaving the village at night with
two others and almost simultaneous disappearance
of Kamla and her son, no search for her and absolute callousness or the pa.rt of Kaghav, subsequent
false explanation being given and his absconding
are all circumstances from which the courts
below were justified in concluding the Karola and
her son were murdered and that Jtaghav had a predominent motive to commit the murder. The
High Court found that·Ra.ghav had a strong motive
to commit the murder and after taking all the
circumstances into consideration ca.me to the conclusion that the Sessions Judge had rightly convicted Raghav of murder. No two cases can have
the same facts but the principles applied in placing
the various . links in the chain of events and
circumstances by the High Court are, in our opinion
wholly correct and they have rightly drawn the
conclusion that the appellant Ragha.v was guilty
of the offence with which he was charged. The
inculpa.tory facts which have been proved were,
in the opinion of the High Court, inconsistent with
the innocence of the appellant and a.re not capable
of explanation or any other. hypothesis except his
•
y
..
r
.J
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
277
guilt and a3 was said by th;is Court in Govinda v.
State of Mysore( I ) .
-+
"In cases where the evidence is of circumstantial nature, the circumstances from which
the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should in
the first instance be fully established and all
the facts so established should be consistent
only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the
-accused. Again the circumstances should be of
a conclusive nature and tendency and they
should be such as to exclude every hypothesis
but the one proposed to be proved. In other
words there must be a chain of evidence so
far complete as not to leave any reasonable
ground for a conclusion consistent "with the
innocence of the accused and it must be such
· as to ehow that within all human probabilities
the act must have been done by the accused.
The principle that the inculpatory fact must be
inconsistant with the innocence of the accused
and incapable . of explanation on any other
hypothesis than that of guilt does not mean
that any extravagant hypothesis would be
sufficient to sustain the principle, but that
the hypothesis suggested must be reasonable."
The evidence in this case and the inferences drawn
from the evidence by the courts below do not fall
in what was said by Baron Alderson in his charge
to the jury in Rev. Hodge(2) where it was said:"The mind was apt to take a pleasure in
adapting circumstances to one another, and
even in straining them a little, if need be, to
force them to form parts of one connected
whole ; and the more ingenious the mind of
the individual the more likely was it,
considering such matter, to overreach and
(I) A.I;R.1960S.C. 29.
(2) [1838] 2 Law 227.
f:aghav Prapanna
Tripathi
v.
Stal• of U. P.
EapurJ.
278
1962
Bagltao Prapanna
Tripaehi
••
Btale oJU. P.
Kapur J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [ 1963]
v
mislead itself, to supply some little !ink that
is wanting, to 'take for granted so~e fact
consistent with its previous theories and
necessary to render them complete,"
Therefore in our view the courts below having
applied correct principles and having found the
oironmstances, to be ~uch which can only he explained on the hypothesis of the guilt of appellant
Raghav ·have rightly found the appellant ~o. be
guilty. He had the immediate motive to rid himself of the wife. His child was just as undesirable
and indeed the child could not be kept back and
the mother murdered. Jai Devi as the murderer
by gun shots was out of the question. Ramanuj
•
Das was trying to placate Kamla by promising
·money and lands. The servants had no reaso11 to
murder their mistress. It is manifest that the shots
must have been fired by Raghav who took steps also
to rid the bodies and the jeep which carried them.
If the jeep was not connec',ed it would have come
forth if not in the investigatien at least during the
y
trial.
We therefore dismiss the appeal of Raghav
and see no reason to disagree with the opinion of
the oourts below that no sentence other than death
was called for in ·this case. The murder . was a
venal one and had been committed to get rid of an
inconvenient wife and her child~
Then the question arises whether a case is
made out s. 20 l of the Indian Penal Code and if so
against whom ? The two appellants Mohan Singh
and Udham Singh were with the appellant (Raghav)
in his jeep and if the dead body was taken away
in his jeep as it has been held by the Courts below
that they were then the case against these two appellants is proved. It is said tha.t no one saw the dead
bodies being carried. That may be so but the tconclusion drawn is from circumstantial evidence
i.e. series of events which lead to the conclusion of
•
i
,.
'•
·--+
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
279
guilt. We have alre11.dy said that murder was
committel in tile hou ;e of R"l.manuj DJ.s on the
evening of April 5, 1961. There was disappearance
of Kam la and Madhusudan and sudden departure of
Ragha.v and these two appellan~s. They were in a
hurry and the back curtains of jeep were drawn. They
travelled all night and took almost 11 hours to reach
the barrier at Kanpur. There is no trace of Kamla
and her child. No one has seen them since their
disappearance on April 5. · From these proved facts
the courts drew the inference of an offence under
s. 20 l Indian Penal Code which in our opinion was
correct. Thus these two appellants have been
rightly convicted and their appeals are dismiBBed.
In regard to the case of Ramanuj Das and
Jai Devi the finding of the High Court is that the
dead bodies of Karola and her son Maclhusudan
were not found in the house of Ra.manuj Das and
they must·· have therefore been removed ; that an
attempt was made to wash out the bloodstains from
inside the rooms and also outside on the roof ; that
the dead bodies could not have been ·removed without the knowledge and active cooperation of
Ramanuj Das and Jai Devi and further that both
Ramanuj Das and Jai Devi absconded. On this
basis the conviction of these appellants was held by
the High Uourt to be justified. It is true that the
murder was committed in the house of Ramanuj
Das and that there is the evidence to show that the
blood inside and outside the Jiving rooms was
washed and an attempt was made to obliterate any
sign of it though it was unsuccessful. It also may
bd that both Ramanuj Das and Jai Devi had
knowledge of the removal of the dead-bodies but
·what s. 201 requires is causing any evidence of the
commission of the offence to disappear or for giving
any information respecting the offence which a
person knows or believes to be false. In this case
there is ll) evidence of either. It is not shown that
196S
Raghau Pr•1panna
Tripathi
v.
Stat1 of U. P.
KapurJ.
280
196Z
Raghau Prapanna
i1ipathi
v.
8tat1 of U. p,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [lg63]
•
these two appellants caused any evidence to disappear. There m'.ly be a. very strong suspicion
that if from the house dead .bodies are removed or
blood was washed, person placed in the position of
the appellants must have had .a hand in it but still
that reniains a suspicion even a str.ong suspicion at
that. It is true that they were ab3conding but
merely absconding will not fill the gap or supply the
evidence which is necessary to prove the ingredients
of section ~01 of the Indian Penal C ide. In our
opinion the case against J:tamanuj Das and Jai Devi
has not been made out. There appeals must thern·
fore be allowed and they be set at liberty.
We have found that the murder was committed in the house of Ramanuj Das and that disappearance of the dead b idies took place from that
house. Ramanuj Das did have the knowledge of
the commission of the murder and· he to ik no steps
t•) inform the police about it. In these circumstances he has been rightly convicted undPr s. 176
of the Indian Pen!tl Code and his appeal in regard
to oonviotion under .that section is dismissed.
BY COURT. The appeal of Raghav Pmp•mna
Tdpathi, Mohan and udham Singh is allowed by
majority and that of Ramanuj Das and Jai Devi for
offence under s. 201 of the Indian Penal Code is
allowed unanimously. The appeal of Raman:ij
Das for offence under s. 176 of the Indian Penal
Code is allowed by majority.
y
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org