RAJ RAJENDRA SARDAR MALOJI versus SRI SHANKAR SARAN AND UH.S.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 30 April 1962 | [1963] 2 S.C.R. 577 | 1962 INSC 178
Key facts
- Decided
- 30 April 1962
- Bench
- J.L. KAPUR*, A.K. SARKAR*, K.C. DAS GUPTA, N. RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR, J.R. MUDHOLKAR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 24/1960
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1963] 2 S.C.R. 577
- Neutral citation
- 1962 INSC 178
Text of the judgment
2s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
577
RAJ RAJENDRA SARDAR MALOJI
MARSINGH RAO SHITOLE
f).
SRI SHANKAR SARAN AND UH.S.
(J. L. KAPuR, A. K. SARKAR, K. C. D..\s GuPTA,
N. RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR and J. R •.
MuDHOLKAR, JJ.)
. ~ -';
Foreign Decree-Decree pa&Std in Gwalior in Nooembu
1948-Transfer for execulion to U. P. in September 1951-Exe·
cation application in U. P .-Maintainability of-"Civil Court
in a Part B State," connotation of-Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 (V of 1908), ••· 2 (5), 2 (6), 13, 38, 39, 43 and 44-Code
of Civil Procedure (.Amendment) .Act, 1951 (II of 1951)-Con·
. stitution of India, Art. 261 ( J).
.
The appellant instituted a suit for the recovery of
money against the re1pondents in a Court in Gwalior State
in May 1947. The respondents who were resident! in U. P.
did not appear before the court and in· November 1948 the
Gwalior Court passed an ex parte decree. On September
14, 1951, the Gwalior Court transferred the decree for execution to Allahabad, and on October 16,, 1951, the appellant
filed an application for execution of the decree before the
Allahabad Court. The· respondents contended that the
decree being a decree of a Foreign Court to whose jurisdiction
they had not submitted was a nullity and the execution
application in respect thereof was not maintainable.
'
Held, that the decree was not executable at Allahabad.
~
Per Kapur, Ayyangar and Mudholkar, JJ.-The decree
of the Court in Gwalior State sought to be executed was a
foreign decree which not change i.ts nationality in•pite of
subsequent constitutional changes or amendments in the Code
of C.ivil ·Procedure. On the day on which it passed the
decree the Gwalior Court was a foreign Court . within the
meaning of s. 2 (5) of the Code. None of the conditions
necessary to give its judgment extra-territorial validity
existed (i) the respondents were not the subjects of Gwalior;
(ii) they were not residents in Gwalior at the time the suit
was filed, (iii) they were not temporarily present in Gwalior
when the proc""s was ·served upon them, (iv) they did not
select the forum which passed the decree against theni, (v)
they did not voluntarily appear before the court, and (vi)
they had not contracted to submit to the jurisdiction of the
1162
'''" 31.
578
SUPREME OOURT REPOR'.i.'S [1963]
,..
IHI
foreign rnurt. The Gwalior court wu therefore not a court
of competent jurisdiction and ita decree was a nullity outtide
Raj Rofa""" 6G10•• the United State ( Madhya Bharat ) of which Gwalior was
/tf aloji M•rsifeilt.
a part on the date of the decree. The United State did
Ra. ~il10U
not become a part of the "territory ot India" till the Con••
stitution came into force. The effect of the judgment obtaiS.lodorSeron
ned did not change with the constitutional changes unlthcre was some specific provision to that effect. The decree
was foreign when it was born and It continued to be so as
there was no procas or procedure for its becoming a naturalised Indian decree. Clause 20 of the Adaptation Order,
1950 preserved the rigb.ts and liabilities under the decree
as thcv were before the Corutitution came into force. It
was not correct to say that the decree which was a nullity
before the Constitution ·came into force suffered only from
the defect of un-enforcibility by execution; a. 13 of the Code
created substantive rights and defences which were open to
the respondents under that section were not taken away by
any constitutional changes.
..
Sirda-t Gurdgal Singh v. Raja of Faridltol, (1894) L. R.
21 I. A. 171, Rao Shio Baha<Jvr Singh v. TM. Stal#. of
Vindhya Pracluh, ( 1953) S. C. R. 1188, VirtMra Singh v.
Stak of U. P. ( 1955) 1 S. C. R. 415, Prem Nalh Kaul v.
State of Jammu di K1J1lmir, ( 1959) Supp. 2 S. C. R. 270,
Sauce v. Ameer R..Ur Sadiq Mohamma<J of &Mwanlpur, (1952)
2 Q. B. 390, Ja,,,.r<Jhan 11'4411 v. Suau of Hyd•rabad, (1951)
S. C. R. 344, Laclm&and.,. K<walram Ahuja v. Stal#. of Bom·
bay. (1952) S. C.R. 710, KMha'"'" Madha!IG .Me"°" v. 8141<
of Bomba11, (1951) S. C. R. 28S, Kiahori Lal v. Shanti Dev.
A. I. R. (1953) S. C. 441, Lazmi 0Aan4 v . .Mii. Tipvri
I. L. R. 1956 Raj. 236, Shah Kanti Lat v. DOMinion o}
India, A. I. R. 1954 Cal. 67, F. Radhuham Roalran Lal
v. Kundanlal Mohanlal, I. L. R. 1956 Punj. 434 and Ra,,..
kia/l.an Janakilal v. S<lh Harmv/di.ari Lachminarayan, A. I. R.
1955 Nag. 103, referred to.
The Indian Code of Civil Procedure was made app Ji.
cable to Madh}a Bharat by Act II of 1951, which came
Into foice oti April 1, 1951. Under a. 20 of that A~t, which
preserved the rights and liabilities of parties accrued under
the decree paued previously, the decree passed by the
Gwalior Court continued to be enforceable in Madhya Bharat.
But the decree could not be validly transferred for execution
from Gwalior to Allahabad. Section 39 of the Code empowcrs the court which pa.:aed the decree to transfer It for
execution to another court. The Gwalior court which transferred die decree lil September 19~1, when it waa governed
~
..
'2 S.CJ;:R..
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS
579
-
1H2
by the Indian Code, was a different court from that which
passed the decree under the Local Code, and was not the Raj Raj.,j,/,a Satla'
court which passed the decree within the meaning of S. 39. Malqj; J11111i.,,.
Sections 37 to 42 of the Code deal with execution of decrees
ltoo 8/Ulol,
.;.
passed by the courts governed by the Indian Code. The .
decree could not be executed under the provisions of s. 43
of the Code at any time. After its adaptation in June 1950,
8. 43 applied to "a decree passed . by a C!Vil Cow-t in .a
Part B State". There were no Part B States at the tlaie
when the decree was passed and theee · words <;o!Jld not
.be read as "a decree passed by a dvil court in what became
a Part B State". · Nor could the decree be executed under
s. 44 as that section was also inapplicable to this decree.
Article 261 (3) which provides that the final judgments or
orders of Civil Courts in any part. of the territllry of India
shall be capable of execution anywhere within that territory
is inapplicable to the decree of the Gwalior court as the
provision is prospective and not retrospective.
Per Sarkar and Das Gupta, JJ.-Even in the decree
passed by Gwalior Court was not a foreign decree the Allaba·
bad Court had no. power to execute it either under s. 3_8 or
under ss. 43 or 44 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Section
. 38 provides that a decree.may be executed either by the
court which passed it or by the court to which it is sent· for
execution. The Allahabad Court was not the court ·which.
passed the decree.
Section 39 empowers · the . court
which passed the decree to transfer it for execution to .anot•
her court; The word ''court" in the phrase "dourt which
passed the .decree" in s. 39 contemplates only c:Ourts gover·
ned by the Indian Code of Civil Piocedure. The Gwalior
Court which was governed by the Owalior Code when It
passed the decree had a ·distinct identity from the. court at
Gwalior after it ,came. to be governed by the Indian Cod_e.
The Court which. transferred the decroe was accordingly
not the court -..hich passed the decree and th~ order of
transfer was not valid order.
Section 43 of the Code provided f~r the execution of
decrees passed by the Civil _Courts in places where the Indian
Code did not extend., The decree. of the Gwalior Court did n 0t
fall within this aection as it stood before the Constitution.
After the adaptation in 1950 the section applied to a decree·
passed "by a Civil Court i_n a Part B Suite". These .words
could. not be read as "by a civil court in an Indian State
which has later been included in a Part B State". -The
Gwalior Court which pa 'sed. the decree wa• not a Civil
Court in a· Part B $fate. Section 44 was equall11 inapplicable to the decree. The section after adaptadon in 1950
s,.,,,,,,., s-
•.
a
MIO SUPREME OOURT REPORTS [1963)
lffl
IWl.f~S..U.
Noi.,; ..,_.,,
It•• v.S1tl•1l1
Slkllkar • .,.,.
applied only to de<nCS of revenue courts. Before the adaptation it could apply only if there was a notification issued
by the U. P. Government but no such notification wa• issued.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal
No. 24 of 1960,
Appeal from the judgment and decree dated
August I, 1957, of the Allahabad High Court in
Special Appeal No. 249 of 1955.
B. Sen, P. W. Sahaarabudhe and J. N. Shroff,
for the appellant.
G. S. Patook and G. C. Mathur, for the
respondenta.
1962. April 30. The Judgment of Kapur,
Ayyangar and Mudholkar, JJ., wae delivered by
Kapur, J. The .Judgment of Sarkar and De.a
Gupta, JJ., was delivered by Das Gupta, J.
KAPUR, J.-This is an appeal age.inst the
Judgment and order of the High Court of Allahabad
holdin& that the execution of the decree passed by
the Additional District Judge, Gwalior, dated
November 18, 11148, in favour of the appellant
against the respondents wa.a not excouta.ble at
Allahabad. The appellant in this oourt is the
deoree holder and the respondents are the judgment
debtore.
For the decision of this appeal it is necessary
to deal with the various Statutes, Order!' and
agreements as a result of whioh the eretwhile
Indian State of Gwalior became a pa.rt of tho
teritories of the Union of India. governed by one
Civil Procedural law. It will also be neceasa.ry to
refer to the various changes in the law of oivil
procedure applicable at the various eta.gee of the
litigation leading to this appeal.
We shall first deal with the integration of the
Indian Stat11 of Gwalior with the Indian Union.
,..
..
,,
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
581
Upto August 15, 1947, i.e. before the independence
of India under the Indian Independence Act (10 &
11 Geo, Ch. 30) Gwalior was what was termed
under the Government of India Act of 1935 an
Indian State and its Courts. were •foreign courts'
within s. 2 (5) of the Indian Code of Civil Procedure. After independence by s. 7 (i) (b) of that Act
the suzerainty of the Briti~b Crown lapsed and so
also all treaties, agreements and obligation which
had previously .been entered into ·between the
Rulers of Indian States and the British Crown.
The second question can conveniently be dealt with
at a later and appropriate stage.
By the Instrument of Accession which by
August 15, 1947, (p. 36 of White Paper on Indian
States) was entered into between the Ruler of the
State of Gwalior and the Dominion of India certain
subjects mentioned in the schedule to that lnstru·
ment were transferred to the Dominion of India
but Civil Procedure was not one of them. By a
covenant signed in April I 948, the Rulers of
Gwalior, Indore and certain other States in Central
India formed the United State of Gwalior, Indore
and Malwa which was termed United State (Madhya
Bharat).. By a fresh Instrument of Accession
executed on July 19, 1948, the United State acceded to the Dominion of India and when the Consti·
tution came into force it became Madhya Bharat& Part B State-and was governed by the provi·
sions of the Constitution as applicable to such
Statea. This then was the prooeSB of transforma·
tion of the Indian State· of Gwalior inti) a part of
the Republic of India.
On May 15, 1947, the appellant instituted a
snit in the Court of the District Judge, Gwalior, for
recovery of Rs. 6,92,236-15·0 against the respondents, who are the sons and legal representatives of
the late Munshi Ishwar Saran.
The writs of
summons were served on the respondent& on
1962
Raj qajtntlra SardGr
Msl,j& Ma1stnrh
Boa Shteol
'·
SAanlisr Saran
582
190~
Roj Rojt'lir• Strrtl~
Malo;ii Marsingh
Bao SAJtole
••
SAan.tar Sar•
,..,., J.
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS [1963]
September 12, 1947, but they did not appear in the
Court of the Additional District Judge who actually
tried the suit. On November 18, 1947, the trial
Judge ordflr\ld suit to pror.eed ex par/£ and on N ovember 18, 1948, the claim was decreed with costs and
interest. On August 9,"1949, the appellant made
an application to the Court of the .Additional District Judge praying for transfer of the· decree for
execution to the Court of Civil Judge: Allahabad,
where the properties of the father of the respondents were situate. On April :!5, 1950, the Court
passed the following order:"I order transfer of this execution case,
A certificate of transfer relating to non-satisfaction of decree be issued tn the Civil Judge,
Ist Class, Allahabad, for execution proceedings. This execution cas(I be dismissed".
On September 14, 1951, another order wao
made sending the decree for execution to the Court
of the Civil Judge, 1st Grade, Allahabad. Along
with it a copy of the order dated April 23, 1950,
was also sent. The order wa~ as follows :"Order dated 14th September, 1951 for
transfer of decree to another court for
execution".
Whereas in the above mentioned case the
applicant submitted that tho JudgmentDebtor resided or held property within the
local limits of the jurisdiction of the court of
Civil Judg~. lst Grade, Allahabad and prayed
for the sending of a certificate to that court
for execution of the said decree and it being
consider11d necessary and proper, the said
certificate be sent' to that court under Order
XXI, Rule VI.
A copy of this order along with copies of
decree, certificate of non-payment of decretal
'-
..
2 s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
583
amount and other orders passed in connection
with execution be
forwarded directly
to the court of the Civil Judge, Ist Grade,
Allahabad.
Dated 14th September· 1951.
Enclosures:1.
Certificate.
2. Application of the decree 'holder
3. Copy of decree in the case.
4. Copy of order, dated 25th April, 1950.
Sd. B. K. M:ehra..
Addi. District & Sessions
Judge, District Gwalior,
Madhya . Bharat". .
..
The parties were not in accord as· to which of
these orders was the real order for transfer. It is
unnecessary to resolve this controversy because we
shall proceed on the assumption that . the. ·order of
transfer was the later OJ:le which the appellant
has relied upon i.e. of Sep~ember 14, 1951.
On October 16, 1951, the appellant filed in the .
Court of Civil Judge, Allahabad, an Application for
execution of the decree for realisation of the amount
due under it which by then had amounted to Rs. 8,98,
_,_i l!57-7-0. This was registered as.Execution lJaseNo.47
of 1951. The respondents filed their objections tinder
s. 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure on February 8,
1952. They pleaded that the Gwalior Court was a
Foreign Court, to the jurisdiction of which, they had
not submitted and the decrefl was, therefore, an absolute nullity; that the decree was not iu accordance
-• with law and that the application for exec:ution was
not maintainable. By an order of the High Court
under s. 34 of the Civil Procedure Code, the execution case was transferred to the High Court and
'1962
Raj Rajendra Sard111
Maloji Marsingh
..
Rao Bhitole
· $hanka_r ·saran
Kapur J.
5S4
I Hr
Raj Rojatha Sla'in
M •I-Ji U ..1ia1A
Ru Bhfltl•
••
SAlflllorSaraa
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
registered ae Extraordinary Miscellaneous Case , No. l of 1!!54. The matter was heard by Brij
:Mohan Lal J., who hold that the decree was paeeed
by a Foreign Court, to the jurisdiction of which,
the respondonds had not subsisted; that the decree
was not binding on the respondents and could not
be executed in the territories ·of Uttar Pradesh.
The execution application was, therefore, dismi88ed.
On appeal a.go.inst that judgment the Appeal Court
upheld the judgment of the learned Single Judge hol- ' ·
ding that the rule in Sirdar Gurdial Singh v. Maharaja of Faridkot (1) was applicable to the case; that
Gwalior was a foreign State on the date of the
decree and its eta.tus as a foreign Mate was not
affected by the lndia.n Independence Act, 194 7, the
Standstill Agret1ment, 1947, the First Instrument of
Acceesion 1947, the 1948 Covenant by which the
United State of Madhya Bharat which included
Gwalior was formed, or the Second Instrument of
Accession, 1948, and that Gwalior State ceased to
be a foreign State only on the coming into force of
the Constitution of India on Ja.nuary 26, 1950. It
also held that the District Judge's court pa.ssing the
decree W88 a foreign Court at the time of the suit.
As the appellant had not submitted to the juriedfo.
tion of the Gwalior District Judges Court the decree
passed by it was an absolute nullity;that even if the
Gwalior law authorised t.he pa.ssing of such a decree,
the decree wa.e a nullity and it wa.e not correct to
eay that a.e a result of the various constitutional ,_
changes, the impediment in the way of its execution
wu removed; that there wa.e no provision of law by
which & decree pa.seed by the Gwalior Court could
be executed in Uttar Pradesh; that Art. 261 (3) of
the Constitution wBB not retroactive and did not
operattl on the decree in queetil'n to ma.ke it executable; that's. 43 of the Indian Civil rrocedure Code .
a.i 'it stood after the Amendment Act II 0£1951 waa ~
inapplicable; that the right resist t.he e:r.eou~
(I) l l • l I..• II I. A,. 171.
'o
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
585
-
of the decree· on the ground that it was a-nullity
was not taken away by the palitica.I changes and, llaJ llOjalirtl S•rU..
therefore, the judgment of the lea.med Single Judge 111.i.}>.Jlanq1'
R.. 8/liltl~
was upheld. Against this judgment and Order the
v•.
II"""'"" 8ar111
appellant has come in appeal · to this Court on
a certificate under Art. 133(i)(a) and (o) of the
Constitution.
-
f ,..
The vital question for decision is whether the
decree passed by the Gwiillor Court .on November
18, 1948, was executable in the State of Uttar
Pradesh which, was at one time,- a pa.rt of what was
British India, Gwalior at the relevant time being a
pa.rt ·of the United State aforesaid. For this
purpose, the questions that arise a.re:1. Was the decree a decree of a foreign
court?
2. Could the Court at Gwalior order the
transfer of the decree for execution in the
Allahabad Civil Court?
3. If it could not, then was the decree executable at Allahabad under ss. 43 & 44 of
the Code of Civil Procedure? and
4. Could the respondents-judgment debtors
take an objection to the execution of the
decree ori the ground that it was an
absolute nullity, being the decree of a
foreign Court?
.
)
We shall first . enquire into the nationality of the
depree passed m favour of the appellant which
necessitates a determination of the Court passing
the decree i.e, whether it. was or was not a Court
falling within s. 2 ( 5) of the Indian Code of Civil
Procedure (Act V of 1908) which shall hereinafter
be termed the •Indian Code'.
At the t~e when the suit was broupt i. e,
586
IHI
110; llojuut.a
s_,
Jfolo;i Mar1fft1h
Rao Sllilole
"·
8Mu.... su·in
SUPitlt;ME OOURT REPORTS (1963)
May 15, 1947, the definition of "Foreign Court" in
s. 2(5) of the Indian Code was:-
'-
" •.<Foreign Court" means a court situate
beyond the limits of British India which has no
authority in British India and is not established or continued by the Central Government
or the Crown representative."
As a result of the Adaptation Order of March 23,
1948, the definition was:" "Foreign Court" means a court situate
beyond the limitll of provinces which has no
authority in the provinces and is not established or continued by the Central Government."
..
By the Adaptation Order of January 26, 1950,
there was a further change in the def:~ ition of
"Foreign Court" and it then stood as follows:" "Foreign Court" means a court situate
beyond the limits of the States which has no
authority in States and is not establi@hed or
continued by the Central Gov~mment."
After Aot II ofl95l came into force on April 1,
1951 the section read as follows:" "Foreign Court" means a ·court. ~1tuate
outside India and not established or continued b) the authority of the Central Government."
At the time of the pa88iog of the decree on Novemder 18, 1948 the definition of the Foreign Court
was as amended by the Adaptation Urder of
March 23, 1948 i. e. a court situate beyond
the limits of the provinces which means the
provinces of what was British India and which
had no authority in the provinces (of British IndiB)
and was not established or continued by the
Central Government. The court at Gwalior fell
'
2 .S.C.R. ·
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
587
within this definition· and . therofore on a plain
reading of the definition it was a foreign court .and
a judgment passed by it wuuld be a foreign judgment
as detined in s. 2(6) where the expression "foreign
judgment'' iS defined as the judgment of a foreign
·court.'"
..
· Under the India~Code the judgment obtained .
by the appellant in Gwalior court would be governed by s. 13 of that Code ~nd its conclusiveness is
governed by cl. (a) to cl. (f) of that section. The
rules laid down in that section are rules of substantive Jaw and not inerely of procedure. It is to be
noted that in the present case the respondents did
not submit to the jurisdiction ofthe Gwalior Court.
In Halsbury'il Laws of England Vol. VIII, p.144,
paragraph 257 (3rd Ed.) conditions necessary for
giving jurisdiction to a foreign court are set out and·
at ·1east one of them is required to be satisfied
before a foreign judgment is regarded as having
extra· territorial validity. Nooe of them was satisfied in the present case .. Firstly the respondents
were not the subjects of Gwalior; .they did, not owe
any allegiance to the Ruler of Gwalior and therefore
they were under nO' obligation to accept ·the judg· ·
ments of the courts of that Mate. Secondly they
were not residents in that State when the suit was
instituted. Thirdly . they were not temporarily
present in that State when the process was served .
on them. Fourthly they did not in their character
as plaintiffs in the foreign action themselves selected
the forum where the judgment was given against
them. Fifthly they did not voluntarily appear in
that court. Sixthly they had. not contracted to
submit to the jurisdiction of the foreign court. 1:he
Gwalior Court therefore was not a.court of competent jurisdiction. .The judgment of Gwalior Court
was therefore a nullity . outside t4e United State .·
(Madhya Bharat). See Gurdyal
Singh·
v. Raja
.
.
1961
Raj Rojendra S1rtI.1
Maloji Marsinih ·
Rao Shitole
"·
. Shlnhar s.,an
KapurJ.
688
JHI
Bod BajeN/to '"""'
Malo;i II· rsiflih
11ao
SAIJll/rcu s •...,,.
s""°"
••
KapurJ,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS fl963J
of Faridkot (1 ).
Lord Selborne there observed aa
follows:"Under these circumstances there was,
in their Lordships' opinion, nothing to take
this e&11e out of the general rule, that the
plaintiff most one in the court to which the
Defendant is Aubject at the f:ime of suit
(" Actm sequitor farum rai"); which is rightly
stated by Sir Robert Phillimore (International
Law, Vol. 4, s. 891 to "lie at the root of all
international, and of most domestic, jurisprudence on this matter". All jurisdiction is
properly territorial and "extra territorium jus
dicenti, imprime non paretur". Territorial
jurisdiction attaches (with special exceptions)
upon all persons either permanently or temporarily resident within thEl territory while
they are within it; but it does not follow them
after they a.re living in another independent
country. It exists always as to land within
the territory and it may be exercised over
moveables within the territ_ory; and, in
questions of status or suoceBBion governed by
domioil, it may exist as to persons domiciled,
or who when living were domiciled, within the
territory. As between different provinces
under one severeignty (e.g., under the Roman
Empire) the legislation of the sovereign may
distribute and regulate jurisdiction; but no
territorial legislation can give jurisdiction
which any foreign Court ought to recognise
against foreigners, who owe allegiance or
obedience to, the power which so legislates".
But it was submitted by the appellant that the
Court at Gwalior .ceased to be a foreign court
because firstly aa a consequence of the constitutional documents executed by the Rulers of Indian
States the UniWl St.ate (Madhp. :BlulrM) had
(I) (I. .)"'&. 211.A.111.
'-
• •
..
,..
'
I
,,'
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
589
1961
become .a. pa.rt of the Dominion of India. and, therefore a decree passed by a court of the State could &; Rajltldra SoldM
Jlarsingh
not be the decree of a foreign court; secondly as a Maloji
Rao.Blritoh
result of the coming into force of the ·Constitution
v.
BhaMarB<f'on
of India what was United State (of Manhya Bharat)
became a Part B State, of the Union of India and
KopvrJ.
therefore a decree passed by the Gwalior ·Court
even though a nullity in the erstwhile province
. of U. P. ceased to be so and took Indian nationality
and thus bees.me executable in the State of U. P.
Thirdly it was submitted that the deoree passed
by the Gwalior Court was a valid decree in the
United State (Madhya Bharat) and therefore was .
not an absolute nullity but there was in impediment
to its executability.which was removed as soonas
the United State (Madhya Bharat) became a part
of the Union of India and fourthly it was submitted
that subsequent changes in the Indian Code
consequent upan the promulgation of the Adaptation
Order of January 26, 1950 under Art. 372 of that
Constitution and subsequent amendment of the
Order of June 5, 1950, whioh became retrospectively
c:iperative from ·January 26, 1950 and by a
subsequent Act (G'ivil Procedure Amendment Act
(Act II of 1951 )) ihe _Gwalior Court became
competent to transfer its decrees for execution
to the Court at Allahabad; and under the provisions
· of the Indian · Code relating to execution amended
from time to time the decree sought to . be
executed became executable by the Court at
Allahabad.
The first contention is unsustainable because
the constitution.al changes did not effect any ohange
in the status or nat~onality · of the Gwalior Court
till after the passing of the decree of November 18,
1948 and there being no specific provision to the
contrary those changes left the decree unaffected.
The United State (Madhya Bharat) had not become
" pan of tbe Dom~on of lndia deapit.e ~ variOlla
690
Raj Bo.fmt/N S•dm
M•loji MotJi.ngll
Ru S/,iloll
••
Shan'ar Sor n
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963)
constitutional documi·nts executed by the Rulers of
the Indian StateR. The flffrot of these constitu·
tional documents was examined and decided
in Rao Shiv Baliadur Singh v. The Stare
of Vindhya Pradesh(l); Virendra Singh v. The State of
Uttar Pradesh('} and Prem Nath Kaul v. The Stare of
Jammu & Kasltmfr(').
In Rao Shiv Bahadur Singh's case it was held
that in spite of'the Instrument of Accession by which
all subjects enumerated in Lists I and III rf Sche·
dule VII of the Government of India Act 1935 were
handed over to the Dominion Government and in
spite of the Covenant by which the Rajpramukh
had declared that the Constitution of India which
was to be adopted by the Constituent Assembly of
India shall be tho Constitution for Vindhya Pradesh
and specifically superseded and abrogated other con·
stitutional provisions inconsistent therewith which
were then in force in tho Statf', those arrangements
brought about an integrated United State of Vindhya Pradesh within the framework of the Dominion
of India "but only by way of accession".
..
In Virendra Singh's case Bose J., observed as
follows:"Despite the readjustment, the sum total
of the sovereignties which had resided in
each (ruler) before the covenant now resided
in the whole and its component parts; none of
it was lost to the Domiaion of India". Ip. 4 l!J)
A somewhat similar view was taken by the
Court of Appeal in Sayco v. Ameer Ruler Sadiq
Mohamrrw.d of Bahawalpur where an objection was
~ken by the Ruler of Bahawalpur State that he still
retained his independent status and the State of
Bahawalpur was not within His Majesty's Dominion
<1) (1953] l s.c.R. 415, 418, 419.
(2) [19<9] Supp. 2 S.C.R. 275.
(S)
[l952J 2 Q. B. s~o. 394.
(
1 S.C.R.
. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
591
in spite of the Ruler of Bahawalpur having acceded
to the Dominion of Pakistan.
At the relevant date i.e. on November 18,
1948, the various constitutional' changes did not
affect the position and status of thE' United States
(Madhya. Bharat)1 which comprised Gwalior also; it
did not become a part of the Dominion of India but
continued to retain its status. The United State
(Madhya Bharat) was not cqmprised in the "Territory of India" till after tht'i Constitution came into
force on January 26, 1950. This Court has held
that the Constitution is prospective and not retros'.
pective: Janardhan Reddy v. The State of Hyder<;1· ·
bad('); Lachamanilas Kewal Ram Ahujav; The.State of
Bombay (2 ); Keshavan Madhva Mel'I01i v. State of
Bombay(•). Before the Constitution, Madhya Bharat
was not a Part.B St~te but becam~ one ail a consequence of the Constitution. Therefore the decree
which was sought to be .executed remained a decree
of a foreign court as dt>fined i.li i!, .2(5) of the India.Ii
Code then applicable a.n.d its judgment h~d to be
enforced in the manner that foreign judgments were
.enforceable·i. .e. either· as tit had to be brought on
the l;asis of that judgment or ifthere was a provision in the fo.dian Code it had to· be . executed in
accordance with tliat provision; Mull's C. P. C. p.96;
Dicey, Conflict of Laws, Rule 162(7th Ed.). A
Judgement which is governed by the rule in Sirdar
Gurdyal Singh' s(') case not being' by a court of· .com.. petent · ju.risdiction in the inter11·ational sense i. e..
· according to the principles of International Law
(Cl?-eshire, . Private International Law; pc 641, 6th
Ed.) and the respoµdent not having submitted to
its jurisdiction is a nullity outside, the te1,ritory of
th!I. ctate in which the court passing the decree is
situate. In that case it was sa.id:
(2) (1952) S. c. R. 710. 730.
(!) (19<1) S c, R. 344. 368,
(3) (1951 I S.·C.'R. 288 •.
\4) (1894) L.R. 21 I.A. 171. .
1962
~-
Raj Rnjirnlra
s,,,,,
Jlaloji Marsinth
Bao s1.itole
••
Sll<m.l"" StmJn
IrlfJIUrJ.
I
1192
1HI
Raj ilolMdt• S...W
M 11,jt' M•rli1111t
II. Slliul•
••
Slt.aJi.,StmJtt
SUPDEME OOURT REPORTs [1963]
"Jn a pel'80nal action to which none of
these causes of jurisdiction apply, a decree
pronounced in ah.!entem by a foreign Court, to
the juriadfction of which the Defendant baa
not in any way submitted himself, is by international law an absolute nullity. He Is under
no obligation of any kind to o'.>ey it; and it
must be regarded as a. mere nullity by the
Courts of every nation except (when author.
ised by special local legislation) in the country
of the forum by which it wBB pronounood".
•·
"
On the bBBis of auoh a decree therefore no action
could be brought in what was British India. the
decree being of a. Court in a.n Indian State.
By ol. 27 of the Adaptation of Laws Orrler .
ma.de on January 26, 1950, the previous operation
of or anything done or suffered under any existing
law or any ri~ht, privilege, obligation or liability
already acquired, acorued or incurred remains un
a.1focted. Thia Order was subsequently amended on
June 5, 1950 and ol. 27 WBB numbered a.s 20 but
there was no change in its language. Therefore by
a change ma.de in the definition of 'foreign court' or
other cha.nJleB introduced in the Indian Code the
effect of and righte and liabilities under the decree
sought to be executed, no fresh rights accrued to
the appellant nor were any fresh liabilities incurred
by the Respondents and if the decree waa a nullity
outside the United State (Madhya Bharat) it
remained a. nullity and Adaptation Order did not
•.
change its efficacy. The eft'eot of Act II of 1951 by
whioh the Indian Code was applied to Madhya
Bharat WIMI no different qua. the rights and lia.bili·
1ies under previous Orders and decrees; see s. 20 of
that Aot which will be more fully discueaed later in
this judgment.
In this connection we may refer to the judge·
,...
ment of this Court in KW&ori Lal v. Shanti
S.O.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
593
Devi('). There, an order under s. 488, Criminal Pro-
)
/
IHI
cedure Code, had been passed by a Magistrate at Raj Rajmt!ra Sariar
Lahore before the Partition of India and th't.t was .Jlaloji .U llfain1h
Bao Shi'ole
sought to be enforced under s. 490 of the Criminal
Procedure Code in a Magistrate's Court at Delhi. Shan/car'· Saran
An objection was raised that the order was unforceKaflur J.
able as it was the order of a •foreign court' i. e. of
a court which had subsequently become a Pakistan
Court. This Court held that the order was of an
Indian Court when made and was at the time of its
enforcement in the Delhi Court stm an order of a
domestic tribunal. In the absence of any specific
bar there was no reason why it should lose its
Indian nationality simply because Lahore was no
longer a part of India. Bose J., at p. 442
observed:" A number of enabling prov1s1ons were
passed after the partition to meet certain
special cases of this kind and of course, where
there is specific legislation, effect must be
given to it. But where, as here, there is nothing then in the absence of a specific bar we
hold that an order which was good and com·
petent when it was made and which was
passed by a tribunal which was domestic at
the date of its making and ,which could at
that date, have been enforced in an Indian
Court, does not lose its· efficacy by reason of ·
the partition".
This no doubt is the reverse case of the present one
but. the principle laid down there that the effect of
tho judgment obtained before the constitutional
changes does not change unless there is a specific
provision to that effect is applicable to this case
also. Following the decision in Kishori lal'a( 1 ) case
Wanchoo J., (as he then was in Laxmi OMnd v.
MBt. Tipuri( 1) held that the crucial date for determin·
ing the validity or enforcibility of an order or a
(1) A.l.R; 1953 S. C. 441.
(2)1. L. &.1136 Raj. i36.
594
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963)
decree is the date when it waa made. Therefore if
a decree was unenforceable in a particular court at
&J
Mal•il Mor1U.,• thP time it waa passed, it would not l,iecome enforceRao Sllil>I•
able and valid simply because of the political
••Saran changes
Sn,dar
that took place unless there is a specific
provision to the contrary. The Calcutta High Court
,..pv.J.
in Shah Kanti Lal v. Dominion of India (1) hdcl that
t)lere is no retrospective effect of the Constitution
including its definition of the words "Territory ,,f
India" which hae the effect of converting what was
a foreign judgment before the Constitution of India
to a dnmestio judgment after the Constitution. The
argument raised against the decree of the Gwalior
Court being a nullity and not remaining so after
the Constitution must therefore fail. ·
The next argument raised was that the decree
pa&1ed by the Vourt at Gwalior on November 18,
1948, was not a nullity as under the Madhya
Bharat Code of Civil Procedure it was a valid decree
and there was only an impediment to its execut·
ability which was removed as a consequence of the
constitutional changes and the subsequent amendments of the Indian Code. Thie ~rgument is also
not well founded. The decree was, in the international sense a nullity outside Madhya Bharat
even though aooording to the law in that State it
was not so. We have already held that the decree
was foreign when it wM born in Gwalior and it
oontinued to be so as there was no process or procedure for its becoming a naturalised Indian decree.
The decree being a nullity outside the c.iurtll of the
United State (Madhya Bharat), in the abeenoe of
any specific provision, it could not be enforced in
the United State (Madhya Bharat). It will not be
correot to say that the decree which was a nullity
before the Constitution came into force suffered only
from the defeat of enforcibility by execution Section 13 creates substantive rights and is not merely
Ba..,,.. """"
(I) A.J.R. 19'4 Cal. 67.
..
..
r
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME OOUR.T REPORTS
595
1962
procedural and therefore defen<'es which were open
to the Respondents wero not taken a.way by any Raj B11j1nba.Siif'dat
constitutional changes in the absence of a specific Maloj1: N0,;ngh
R_ao Sh(tole
provision to the contrary. It is erroneous to say
Sbanlcar Soran
t.herefore t'hat the decree of the Gwalior Court was
unenforceable when passed because of some impediKapur J.
ment which the suhequent constitutional changes
bad removed; but that decree suffered from a more
fundamental defect of being a nullity and the riglits
a.nd liabilities created under it remained unaffocted
by subsequent. changes. That, in our opinion, is the
d'ect of the judgment of this Court in Kishori
Lat's case( 1). See also E. Radhesham Rosh.an Lal
v. Kundanlal Mohanlal(') where it wee held that the
right of the judgment-debtor to plead that the
decree is a.. nullity, is not a procedural matter but is
a vested right in the judgment debtor and it ca.nnot
be taken away by the provision of law which is not
retrospective. The Nagpur High Court in Ram
Ki.shan Jankilal v. Beth •Harmukharai Laihmi
N arayan(o) also held that a decree by the Indore High
Court prior to the constitution was of a. court without
jurisdiction a.nd merely beeause Indore became a
pa.rt of the "Territory of India" after the Consti·
tution did not retrospectively clothe the oourt at
Indore with jµrisdiotion in order to make the decree
which was a nullity,. into a vii.lid decree;
It was next argued that as a result of au bee·
quent changes in the provisions of the Indian Code
·resulting from constitutional changes in the country,
and amendments in the Indian Code the decrees of
the Courts in Madhya Bharat became executable
under the provisions of the Indian Code and the
Gwalior Coul't could therefore transfer the decree
for execution to the Court at Alla.ha.bad.
We shall t.herefore discuss the power of the
Court at Gwalior to make the order of transfer
dated September 14, 1951, assuming without decid-
..
-
11) A.LR. (1953) S.C.441.
(2) l.L.R.1950Punj.434.
(3) A.l.R. 1955 Naa. 103.
.
-
596
JHt
bj RejtMI• Sarthr
11.i.ji Mar.1~•·
Bat ShiJot.
••
IJlan,tur SotiM
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
ing that that order whfoh the appellant relies upon
was a judicial orders of transfer. At the time when
the suit was filed i.e. May 15, 1947, the law relating
to oivil procedure applicable to Gwalior IState was
the Gwalior Civil Procedure l'ode (Gwalior Act I of
Samvat 1966 i. e. 1909). The relevant provisions
of that Code dealing with transfer of decrees were
1!8. 227 a.nd 229 the former oorresponding to s. 38 of
the Indian Code of Civil Prooedure and the latter
to s. 39 of that Code. Sub-section (') of s. 229
correeponds to s. 41 of the Indian Code of Civil
Procedure. By the (Madhya Bbarnt) Indian Civil
Procedure Adaptation Aot (Madhya Bharat) Aot 70
of Sam vat 2006 or 1949 the Indian Code was adapted
in Madhya Bharat (and thia !'odapted Code will here·
inafter be referred to aa the Madhva Bharat Code).
It was to come into force on Janu~ry 23, 1950, i. e.
15 days after its publication in the Gazette. By
s. 3 the Indian Code was adapted, and it mutatis
mutandis came into foroe in Madhya Bharat. It
was also provided therein that whatever and whenever amendments would be made in the said Indian
Code they would be applioable to Madhya Bharat
with neceSBary alterations. By s. 4 of Madhya
Bharat Code above mentioned the previous Codea
in foroe in the various States comprising Madhya
Bharat were repealed and it was provided inter alia
that all (lecrees pa.seed and judgments given in
aooordance with the repealed Code as well as other
aots done thereunder would have tl:e ea.me foroe a11
if they were iSBued- or made by a competent
authority under the Madhya Bharat Code. Thus
on January 23, 1950, the Indian Code with necessary amendments and adaptations was made appli·
oalile to the State of Madhya Bharat but this was
under the orders of the legislative authority of
Madhya Bharat, which could only legislate for and
in the territories of that State. As we have already
said on January 26, 1950, the adaptation of Laws
.-
;
'
2 S.C.R.
1
\
_)
591
Order was promulgated under Art. 372 of the
Constitution of India by the President of India.
Under that Order existing laws were adapted as
mentioned in the Schedule to the Order. Clause 27
of that Order provided that "Nothing in this Order
shall affec~ the previous operation of, or anything
duly done or suffered under any existing law or any
right, previlege, obligation or liability alraady
,a.cqnired, accrued or incurred under any such la,w, or
·any penalty,. forfeiture or punishment incurred in
respect of any offence already committed against
any such law". As a result of this adaptation,
eerta.in .changes were ma.de in the Indian Code·.
But it did not affect any act already done or any
liability already incurred. Thus it left the operation of decrees previously passed unaffected. On
June 5, 1950, the President promulgated the adaptation of Laws (Amendment) Order, 1950, but gave it
a retrospective effect, so that it was deemed to have
come into force on January 26, 1950. Under the
a.mended ·Adaptation order certain changes were
made in the Indian Code which will be discussed
later in this judgment. . But. it did not affect the
operation of cl. 27 above set out. Under the a.dap;
ta.tion of Lawa (Third Amendmen\) Order of April
4, 1951, cl. .27 was renumbered as cl. 20. The
Indian Code was amended by the Code of Civil
Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1951, (II of 195l)which
ca.me into force on April 1, 1951. By that Act, the
Indian Code was extended to the whole of India
excepting certain territories mentioned in s. 2 which
are not relevant for the purpose of this appeal.
Thus it became applicable to Madhya Bharat which
was then a. Pa.rt B State and consequently it became
operative in what at one time was the Indian State
of Gwalior. Section 20 of this Act provided for
repeals and savings. That secti on runs as
follows:-
Kapur J.
698
Ji.fl
l?.oj I oj1ntlra Son/ar
4'f•lf?j• MarsingA
.Hoo 8\tf.11
••
SAtinkor Soran
Ir... J.
S. 20 (I) "Repe11l.~ and Sa1;i11gs. If. immediately
before the date on whkh the Aaid Code
comc·s inlo forcf in ~ny Part B ~tate,
corrn~ponding to th• ~id Co<lP, that
Jaw shall on that datP stand n·pealed:
Provided th .. t the repeal shall not affect( a) the previous operation of any law HO
repealed or anything July done or
suffered thereunder, or
(b) any right,
priviltJgl', obligation or
liability accrutd or incurred under
any law so repealed, or
( o) any investig~tion, legal proceeding or
remedy in resp<>ct of any surh right,
privilege, obligation, liability, penalty
forfeiture or puui~hment as aforesaid
and any such invcstigat.ion, legal
proceeding or remedy may be instituted, continued or enforoed, and any
such penalty, forfeiture or punishment may be imposed as if this Act
had not been paSBed.
(2) Subject to the provisions contained
in subsection (I) notifications published, declaration and rules ma.de,
placca appointed, agreementa filed,
scales prescribed, forms framed,
appointments made and powers conferred under any enactment hereby
repealed shall, so far as they are
consistent with the said Code, have
the same force and effect a.a. if they
had been respectively published,
ma.de, appointed, filed prescribed,
frn.m<>d and <>onferroo under the said
Corle and by the an thority empowered thereby in suoh heh&lf.
t
'
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
699
1962
(3) In every law or notification passed or
issued before the commencement of Raj Bajmdra Sard~r
this Act in which reference is made M aloji Jtar,ingh
Rao Shitole
to or any Chapter or section of any
law hereby repealed, such reference
SluJnhar Saran
shall so far as may be practicable be
KapurJ.
taken to be made to the said Code or
its corresponding Part, Order, section
or rule." ·
On the coming into force of Act II of 195 l
aforesaid the rights that were acquired or accrued
under the decree passed previously remained
' nimpaired and unaffected by the repeal and all
rights and privileges acquired or accrued under the
decree continued as before so also all liabilities or
obligations incurred thereunder. And all such
rights and privileges were enforceable as if the Act
had not been passed. Therefore the decree of the
Gwalior Court dated November ll, 1948 continued
to. be enforceable as decree under the Madhya
Bharat Codi'.
As we have said before we shall assume for the
purposes of this appeal that the order of transfer
by the Court .at Gwalior was the. one passed on
September 14, 1951. By then by 1he operation of
Act II of 195L thtire was one Civil Procedure Code
for what was Gwalior and U. P. and indeed for the
whole of India.
••
_.-\
_
The question then is, was the order dated
September l4, 1951, transferring the .decree for
execution to the Civil Judge, Allahabad an effective
order to which as. 38 and 39 of the Indian Code
applied and could the decree so trapsferred be
executed by the execution Court at Allahabad ? It
was contended on behalf of the appellant that it
could be executed as it was a decree which fell
w~thin ss. 38 and 39 of the Indian Code, which
the Gwa.lio~ Court had the power to transfer and
600
lt.j R•jendl• Ba ri•r
Jlaloji M•si'ttgll
Ru Sltil/•
v.
Slla,,hr S•r•
,..,,., J.
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS [1963]
which the Allahabad Court had under the law the
authority to execute. We think it is not so.
The main provisions for execution of decrees
a,re contained in Part II ••Execution" in the Indian
Code and minor rules are contained in Order 21.
0( these provisions ss. 36 to 42 deal with Courts
which can execute decrees, can transfer decrees and
the power of executing Courts in regard to transferred decrees. The present ss. 43 to 45 deal with
execution of decrees passed by Civil Courts in
place to which the Indian Code does not extend,
execution of decrees passed by-revenue courts, by
the courts in the United Kingdom and other reciproca.ting territory and execution of decrees in
foreign territories.
.-
>-·
Section 38 of the Indian Code provides that
a decree may be executed by the Court which
passed it or by the court to which it is sent for
execution. Court which passed a decree is defined
in s. 37 and s. 39 provides for the transfer of
decrees for execution. It reads : 8. 39 (I) •'The court which passed a decree
may, on t.he application of the decree
holder send it for execution to another
Court".
Section 40 of the Indian Code provides for the
transfer of a decree to a court in another State
where it he.a to be executed in such manner as m-ty
be prescribed by Rules in force in that state and s.
42 lays down the powers of the Court in ext'cuting
transferred decree. It provides that the power of
the Court in executing decrees shall be the some as
if it had been pa11sed by itself. These are tho relevant provisions which deal with the transfer to and
execution of decrees in .other courts and to courts
of another State and powt>rs of such oonrts in exe- ·
outiop and the procedwe to be followed by thein.
·~
..
2 S.C.R.
:-'\
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS
601
The jurisdiction of the Allahabad Court
to execute the decree sent to it by the Gwalior
Court can be examined from two angles :,(1) Was
the court at Gwalior a court which could under s.
39 of the Indian Code transfer its decree to the
Allahabad Court for execution; and (2) was the
decree sent for execution a decree which a court
governed by the Indian Code as was the Allahabad
Court, such that it could be executed by the transferee court.
We are unable to aee'how the Gwalior Court
could send under s. 39 decrees which it had passed
when it was not governed by the Indian Code. It is
fallacious to think that the court at Gwalior governed by the Indian Code was identical with the court
which was governed by another Code. In our opinion, the Gwalior Court which made, the order of
transfer of September 1951 when it was governed
by the Indian Code was a different court from what
it was at the time it passed a decree when functioning under a differ1mt Code of Civil Procedure. The
Court which ,made the order of transfer in Septem-' '
ber, 1951 ,was thus not the court which passed the
decree within the meaning of s. 39.
The decrees in the sections dealing with execution of decrees i.e. ss. 37 to 42 are decrees which
were passed by courts governed by the Indian Civil
Procedure Code because those sections relate to
decrees passed in suit under the provisions of that
Code. The preamble to the Indian Civil Procedure
Code_ie "whereas it is expedient td consolidate and
amend the Jaws relating to the procedure of the
Courts of Civil Judicature". Under s. 1 (3) as it
exists now the Code 11xtends to the whole of India
except certain Tribal Areas etc. Prevfous to the
Amendment Act II of 1951 above referred to, s. 1
(3) of the Indian Civil Procedure Code re~ alt
~:-,
Raj &jtlllN,S.~r
Ma/oji Marn.,i.
B .. Bhii.11
••
Bllankar Saran
KapurJ,
602
Jfft
J f._il1'<ijmdr• SAFd.r
Ma/oji Mar•inili
lino Shii.h
v,
b'hankar Saran
•.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963]
S. I ( 3) "Thia sec:tion and sections 155 to 158
<Jxtend to the wholo of India. except Part
H States; the rPst of the Corle extends to
the whole of India. f'Xccpt Patt B States
and the ~oheduled District.ti"
Thei efc.rc the Indian Code was not then applicable
to those States which becamo Part B States as a
result of the Constitution of India. "Decree" in
the Indian Code is defined to mean the formal expr~8sion of an adjudication whieh, so far RB regards
the Court expressing it, conclusively detRrmint•s the
rights of the parties with regard to all or any matter~ in controversy in the suit ....... "
.-
I
It means, therefore, that a decree which Is to
be executed under the Indian Code by a transferee
Court is a decree passed in a suit i.e., in civil proceeding which is instituted by the presentation of a
plaint under s. 25 of the Code. Tht:rcfore the
decree which is referred to in Pa.rt II dealing with
cx~cution i.e. ee. 37 to 42 in a. decree which iii paeeed in a suit commenced in the manner provided In
the Indian Code, is conducted and decided under
the provisions of tho Indian Code, and there is
nothing in Act II of 1951 above reforred to which
has changed that position.
Reference was made by counsel for the appel.lant to sub-a. (2) of s. 30 of Act II of 1951 but that
section does not apply to judgments and decrees
passed but applies to the other matters therein
mentioned e.g., notifications, dcclaratinn~, rules and
appointments etc. It has no reference_ to decrees
passed .or Orders made under the local Cod rs of Civil
Prccedure. That section therefore is net. of any
assistance to the appellant. Whatever rights or
privileges the appellant had acquired or wbatnrr
rights or ~rivileges had ~C<'1urd to him were c·ontiuu1·d ~JHl rt cannot be satd that the d~cree pa~ft·d
1111der the Madhya Bharat Code became a decree
r
I
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS
603
under the Indian Code by virtue of s. 20 of Act II
of 1951. On the other hand by cls. (b) and (c) of Roi Raj1rulra Sudar
Marsingh
sub-s. ( l) of that section· the decree continued to be Malojf
Rao Shiloh
.decree governed by the Madhya Bharat Code and
execut11ble under it. The Gwalior Court therefore Shankar siran
had no power under ss. 38 and 39 to · transfer
Kapur J,
the decr.ee of November 18, 19i8,.and consequently
the Allahabad Court acquirednopowerto execute it.
It was next con.tended that if the Court at
Gwalior that passed the decree had no power
under as. 38 to 42 of the Indian Code to transfer
the decree for execution and the· Court at Allahabad
was not empowered to execute. that decree then.
the decree could be executed under the provisions
of SS. 43 and 44 of the Indian Code. Of course
the decree waa not sought to be e:X:Ejcuted - under
either of these two provisions. But we shall examine these sections of the Indian · Code as applicable to the Courts at Allahabad at the relevant
time. Prior to the Indian Independence (Adaptation of Central Acts and-Ordinance) Order of 19!8
promulgated on March 23, 1948, which will hereinafter be termed the Adaptation Order I 948, the
relevant portion of s. 43 was as follows:-
. Execution of decre.es passed by British
Courts or in plaoes to which this part rloes not
extend or inforeign . territ.ory.
Any decree passed by a Civil Court established in any part of British India to whioh
the provisJ,ons relating . to execution do not
extend or by any Court established or continued by th11 authority of the Central Government or the Crown Representative in the
territories of any foreign Prince or State,
may, if it cannot be executed within the juri,sdiction of the court by which it pasaed, be -
,,,,
&j Raj1Mrv.Sudar
Jlaloji Jlani.,A
R.. SAll>I•
v.
Shanlrar Soran
Kapvr./.
604
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS [1963)
executed in manner herein provided within
the jurisdiotion of any court in Britillh India·•.
After the Adaptation ()rder 1948 the provisions
essentially remained the same and there was only
a change in nomenclature. Instead of British
India the expression "the provinces of India" and
in plaoe of ''territories of any Foreign Prince or
Ste.te" "in any Indian State" were substituted.
After the coming into force of the Constitution
Adaptation of Le.we Order of January 26, 1950
was promulga'.ed. There agaiu the change in a.
43 was nominal and in place of "Provinoe of
India." the word "State" was substituted. Thus
there was no change which is material for the
present appeal till the Adaptation of Laws
(Amendment) Order dated June 5, 1950, which
had retrospective effect as from January 25, 1950
and a. 43 we.a amended as follows :-
"E:cecutian of decrees passed by Gi11il Gourla
in Part B States, in places to which thiR Part
does not e:ctend or in forei,gn territmr.
Any decree passed:
(a) by a Civil Court in a. Part B State, or
( b) by a Civil Court in any area within a
Pa.rt C State or Pe.rt B State to which
the provisions relating to execution do
not extend, or
( c) by a Court established or continued by
the authority of the Central Government
outside India,
may, if it cannot be executed within the
jurisdiction of the Court by which it
was passed, be executed in a manner herein provided within the jurisdiction o{
ui;y cc,OJt in the Stat•"
, ..
·-·
..
...
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS
605
By the operation· of Act II of 1951, s. 43 was
further amended and it then read as follows :-
. Execution of decrees paBSed by Civil Courts
in places to which this Code doe,s not extend.
•
J
.J
Any decree passed by any Civil Conrt,
established in any part of India to which
the provisions of this Code do not extend,
or by any Court established or continued
by the authority of the Central Government
outside India, may, if it cannot he executed
within the jul'isdiction of the Conrt by which
it was passed, be executed in the manner
herein provided within the jurisdiction of
any Court in the territories to which this
Code extends".
Thus after the Constitution came into force
by virtue of the Adaptation Order, a decree which
was passed by a Civil Conrt in a Part B State
could be executed in the manner provided, within
the jurisdiction of any Court in what were the
States of India i. e. Part A, B & C States.
; .. ...J
It was submitted on behalf of the .appellant
that the words in s. 43 of the Code ali adapted
by the Adaptation Order of Jilne 5, 1950, "Any
decree pa.seed · by a Civil Court in a Part B State~
must be read as "a Civil Court in what became a
Part B State". We are unable to accept this contention. This would mean that the Constitution
is retrospective. But it has been held by this Court
that the Constitution is prospective. Madhya
Bharat, before the Constitution of India i. e. before
January 26, 1950, was not a Pa.rt B State. It
became one as ·a. consequence of the Constitution.
As a matter of fa.ct there were no Pa.rt B States,
before the Constitution.
'l'herefore a deoree
pasBed,
..
.
1968
Raj Ila}mdm Sll<IGr
Maloji Marringh
B.. Shilol•
••
·Shankar Saran
KopurJ.
606
196t
Raj Rujencl1a Sattl11r
AlaJoj1 .1.\lursJWA
Rao Shitole
v.
Shanl:iu Saran
Kop1'r J,
SUPREME OOU.RT REPORTS ll963J
before the Constitution 1'y a Ci vii Court in
Madhya Bharat cannot be considered as a decree
by a. Civil Court in a Part B State.
• • t
Aftor the Indian Code came into foroe in
Part B States as a result of Act II of 1951 under
s. 43 only those decreas could be executed which
were p<tssed by Civil Courts established in Parta
of India to which the provisions of the Civil Procedure Code "do not extend" or by Courts est!\b·
Iished or continued by the authority of the Centre.I
Government outside India, and in none of these
categories does the decree passed by the Gwalior
Court after the establishment of Madhya Bharat
fall. It was not a decree passed by a Court in a
part of India to which the Indian Code "does
not extond''. Those areas were set out in s. I (:J)
of tho Indian Code. Therefore, undPr the provisions of s. 43 of the Indian Code of Civil Proce<lure the deoree could not be executed.
'
We shall not takes. 44 of the Code:S.44
"Execution of decrees pMSM by Caurts of
Indian Stat,es.-The Provincial Goverment
may, by notification in tho Official Gazette declare that the decrees of any Civil
or Revenue Courta in any Indian State
not being Courts eatablished or continued by the authority of the Central
Government or of the t,'rown Representative. or any cln.as of such decrees, may
be executed in the Province as if they
had been passed by Courts of British
India.
By tho Adaptation Order of 1948 in place
of the wm·ds "British India" "that Province" were
substituted. By the Ad~ptation Order of January
26, 1950 tbe section read &II follows:-
~-
2.SC.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
607
1962
Execution of decrees passed by Courts of
Part B States.-The State Governme11t may by
Rajendra Sarda f'
notification in the Official Gazette declare RMijal"oji
Mor; ing'h
Rao Shitole
that the decrees of any Civil or Revenue
Courts in any Part B State, or any dass of Shunkarv. Suran
such decrees, may be executed in the State
Kapur J.
aa if they had been passed by Courts of
that State".
·
This section was . again amended by the
Adaptation Order of June 6, 1950, which gave it
retrospective effect as from January 26, · 1950. It
then read as follows:-
\
Exeoution · of decrees passed · by Reve:nue
Court Part B States.-The Government of a
Part A State or Part C State may by notification in the Official Gazette, declare that
the decree of any Revenue Courts in any
Part B State or any claBB of such decrees may
be executed in the. Part A State or Part C
State, as the case may be, as if they h11.d be.en
passed by· Courts of that State''
Finally after Act U of 1951 which came into
force on April I, 1Q51, s. 44 is as follows:-
Exeeution of decree,/! passed 1Yy Revenue
Cq'Urts in plUOe,/J to which this Oode does net exte:nd.
The State .Government may, by· notification
in the Official Gazette, declare that the decrees
of any Revenue Court in any part of India to
which the provisions of this Code do not extend ·Or any class of suoh de..,rees may be
executed in the State aa if they had been
paased ·by courts in. that State"
At the time when the decree was sought
to be executed in the Execution Court at
Allahabad, s. 44 of the Code was · what was
008
SUPREME COURT REPo.RTS [1963]
•
'
1961
substituted by Ao~ II of 1951 and that oertsinly
Raj RajMtltt Sarhr could not he a.va.1led of by the appellant as it
Ma~ji Ma,.Jiraih
had no a.pplioati<>n fo decrees of Civil Courts
Rao Shilol1
and the argument in regard to decrees of Part B
••
S/ianior Saran
States is tho same as in tho case of e. 43 of the
Code
whioh has been discussed above.
KapurJ.
It was next argued that in construing the
words "the decree of a oivil court in a Part B State"
we should have rega.rd to the faot that at the time
s. 43 wa.1 amended in this manner s. 44 was also
amended in suoh a way that it was no longer
poBBiblc for a State Government to ieeue a notifi·
cation-as it could have dontl hut for such amend·
ment-declaring that the decrees of civil courts in
an Iudian State might be executed in the State as
if they ha.ve been passed in the courts of that State.
It is said that this took away ~be whatever chance
a decree made by an Indian State had of being
made executable in other parts of India. So, it
is argued we should interpret the words "the decree
of a civil court in a Pa.rt B State" to inolude deer·
eeR made by a civil court in what later became
Part B State at a time when it was an Indian State.
It could not, it is urged, hnve been the intention
of the legislature in making the amendment of June
3, 1950 to tote.Hy destroy this oha.noe of execut·
ability which was poBBible under the law as it stood
before. We do not think this is a relevent con·
sidera.tion. If the legislature had intended to save
this chance of exeoutability under a possible future
notification it oould have easily made the necessary
provision. It has to be remembered that the right
of executability which had attached to a decree on
the basis of a notification already made would
continue after the date of amendment. Only, if
the Jaw had not been· changed as it was by the
a.vnendment on June 3, 1950, there would have ex·
ieted a cha.nee that the decrees of oourts of Inilia.n
••
--
•
2 S.C.R.
... )
_
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS
609
States in respect of which no notifiCa.tioli ha.d been
ma.de under s. 44 could have become executa.·ble by
a. notification ma.de · in future thereunder. The
power to make such a. notification in respect of
decrees of civil ceurts in Indian States w.a.s however deliberately taken a.way and it is useless and
irrelevant to worry about the resultant loss of
cha.nee of exeouta.bility by a possible future ·notification that might have existed under the old
la.w.
It was finally contended that by virtue of
Art; 261, the decree passed by the Gwalior Court
was executable. The first clause of Art. 261 provides for full faith and credit to be given throughout the territory of India to judicial proceedings
of the Union and of every State.. Clause 3 of Art.
261 was as follows:
'l
"Final judgments or orders delivered or
passed by Civil Courts in any pa.rt of the
territory of India shall be capable of execution anywhere within that territory aocording
to law''.
The .first matter to be considered in regard
to Art. 261 is that the Constitution is prospective
a.nd not retrospective and it applies to deoreini which
were pa.8Bed after the coming into force of the
Constitution and not before and, therefore, neither
clause· 1 nor clause 3 can have any . application .to
the decree sought to be executed.
'
In our opinion, therefore, the deoree of the
Gwalior Court sought to' be executed was a decree
of a. foreign court whi<ih did not change its nationality in spite of subsequent constitutiona.l changes
or amendments in the .Code. The Gwalior Court
could not transfer' the decree for execution to the
Court at Alla.ha.bad under lis. 38 and 39 nor oould
1962
Raj Rajendra Sa tdar
Maloji Maraingh
Rao Shitole
••
Shankar Saran
Kop,,,.J,
.. ~10
_196~
Raj Rajtnrfr4 ~auUr
. · J,f aloji M•~rstn'h
~
Rao Slailol1
the Court of Allahabad execute the decree without
such transfer. The provisions of ss. 43 and· 44 of
.the Code, also were not applicable in this case. .
~
.. ·For these reasons the appeal fails
SAadarSaran
K•;u• J •
'SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1063j
-: . .
missed· with costs. .
,.
'
and is dis- ·1',
·
'DAS GUPTA, J.-This appeal is . by a decree.. holder ''whose application for execution of the
· --·· · ··
decree has been unsuccessful: ··The decree ·was
passed on .November 18, 1948, by the Court· of the
DistriCt Judge, Gwalior, in Gwalior State. It was .
parte, the defendants-the respondents in the
.Present appeal-who are residents 0· ,the United
Provinces, now Uttar. Pradesh, not having appeared
in the Gwalior' Court. On August 9; .1949, the
'decree-h'older applied to the Gwalior Court for
transferring the decree to the Court of· the Civil
·.Judge; Allahabad, for execution. On ·April 25, 1950,
the Gwalior Court passed an order for transfer of
·.the. decree for the execution· to the Civil Judge,
'First Grade, Allahabad. It needs to be mentioned
that on the date when th" suit was instituted, i.e.,.
May 15, 1947; the date on which the decree was
. . . passed, November 18, 1948; the date on which the
application was :made for ·transferring the ·decree,
. August 9, 1949; as also the· date April 2;i, 1950,
. when the order, for transferring the decree was
made by the Gwalior Court, the Code of.Civil Procedure which is in force in India did not apply to .
the Gwalior Court. ·For, even though the Gwalior
State had acceded to. the Domini<ra of India by an
··Instrument of'Acceasion by the fluler of the· State
made on August 15, 1947, and'after that the United
"State (Madhya Bharat) of which Gwalior became a
·pa.rt by a covenant signed in April 1948, acceded to
the Dominion of India. on July 19; 1948, ·by a fresh
· ····instrument of Accession· and after the Constitutiori
. :of India came into'force this United States (Madhya
Das Gupta J. • .
.·ex
1
•
2 s.c.R.
SUPREME COU!tt REPORTS 611
Bharat) became part of the territory of India as
M1tdhya Bharat being a Part B State, the Indian
Code of Civil Procedure did not. become applicable
to the Courts in Gwalior till after the enactment of
Act II of 1951 which came into force on April l,
1951. From this date the Indian C de of Civil
Procedure became applicable to the. Courts of
Gwalior alRo.
·
We have already mentioned that on April 25,
1950, an order for transfer of the decree had been
made by the Gwalior · Court. The further action
which has to be taken under O. 21 r. 6 of tbe Indian
Code
Civil Procedure by the court sending a
decree for execution was not however ·taken till
September 14, 1951. On that date an order was
made by the Gwalior Court certifying that the
amount of the decree had "not been paid or reali·
sed by execution" and ordering that the certificate
be sent to the Civil Judge, First Grade, Allahabad
under O. 41 r. 6. This· orper closed with the sentence
"a copy of this order along with copies of
decree p11Ssed in connection with the i>xeoution
be forwarded directly to the court of the Civil
Judge,· First Grade, Allahabad." The application
for execution was made · in the Court of the Civil
Judge at Allahabad on Ootoher Hi, 1951. To this
application the judgment-debtor raised objectioDI!
under s. 47 of the Code . of Civil Procedure. This
application was ultimately heard by a single Judge
of the High Court of Allahabad who dismiBBed the
application being of opinion that the decree
obtained by the appellant
a nullity and
on that ground inexecutable at Allahabad.
This view was upheld by the same High Court on
appeal.
of
was
Three questions have been raised in this appeal.
The first is: whether vis·a-vis the Allahabad
Court the decreed sought to be executed was a
1962
Raj Rajetuira SarJar
M aloji M arsingh
Raa 1-'hitole
y,
--
ShmeKar Soran
Das Gupta./.
612
R•j R•famd'• Sorclar
Mui.ji Mar•ingh
Rao Shilol1
••
Slttuabar Saran
v., GU/JtoJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS tlll63]
foreign decree which the Allahaba.d Court rightly
considered to be a nullity and on that account
inexecutable in Allahabad Courts. The second
quostion raised before us is whether, even
assuming that this was not a foreign decree
the Allahabad Court was a Court to which it
could be sent for execution within the meaning
of section :J7 and 31! of the Indian Code of Civil
question is whether
Procedure. Tb" third
e. 43 or s. 44 of the Code of Civil Procedure made
the decree executable in the Allahabad Courts.
' .
It is uonece88&ry in our judgment to invosti·
gate the first question. The objection raised on the
nullity of the decree could be raised c.nly in
the Allahabad Court where the decree was sought
to be executed. But before that question would
arise the Allahabad Court must have power to
execute the decre1Hiither on transfer of the d ecree
to it under s. 38 or under tho provisions of s. 43 or
s.44 of the Code. I!'or reasons to be presently stated,
we do not think that there could be valid transfer
of the decree to the Allah a bad Court or that it had
any power to execute the decree under s. 43 or s.44.
'•hat is why we think that the question how far the
decree was a nullity does not fall for our decision in
I.hill case. With other modes of enforcement of a
foreign decree this case has no concern.
In solving the problems raieed by the eerond
and the third queetionH it is neceseary fint to have
an idea of the scbeme of the Indian Code of Civil
Procedure aa regards what courts in India can
execute decreea. We find in Part II of the Civil
Procedure Code which relates to the execution of
decrees, onlv three sections dealing with this matter.
They are
311. 43 l\nd 44. Sections 38 provides
that a decree may be executed either by the Court
which p888ed it, or by the Court to which it is sent
i~
ea.
,..
. SUPREME OOUR'r REPORTS
t s.c.R.
613
for execution. Section 43 as it stands a.t present
proviries that:-
Raj Rojendr• 6ari•
Maloji Marsinzh
I
.
" Any decree passed by any civil court
established in any part of India to which the
provisions of this Code do not extend, or by any
court est~blished or continued by the authority of
the Central Government outsirle India, may, if it
cannot be executed within the jurisdiction
of the Court by which it was passed
be executed in the manner herein provided within
the jurisdiction of any court· in the territories to
which this Code extends." We shall have later
to refer to the several changes which s. 43 has
undergone between the time the decree w1>s made
and the present day. Section 44 provides that
'•the State Government may, by notification in the
Official Gazette, declare tlia.t the decrees of any
revenue court in any part of India. to which the
provisions of this Code do not extend, or any class
of such decrees, may ·be executed in the State as
if they had been paBSed by courts in that State."
This section has also undergone some change during
the relevant period. To this change 'We shall
later refer.
Let Ull first examine whether the Allahabad
Court where the decree-holder is seeking to execute
the decree is a court by which the decree can be
executed under s; 38. Obviously, it is not the Court
which passed the decree. The controversy js whether
it is a Court to which the decree was sent for
execution. The provisions for sending a decree
for execution to another Court by the Court
which passed the decree are contained in s. 39
of the Code of Civil procedure. According to the
decree-holder the decree was sent by the Gwalior
Court to the Allahabad Court by its order dated
September 14, 1951. The Judgment-debtors'
contention on the other hand is that the only
Rao Shilole
v.
Sh a11kar St1ran
--
Dai Gupta J.
614
llltlt
R•j Rr;je.,/r• Strrdnr
Alal1jl Marsiltflh
Ra1 Sltitolt
v.
Sh"ankar Sar m
Das tlupta J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1963)
order of transfer was that of April 25, 1950. If the
,Judgment-debtors' oontention is correot it would
follow tha.t there was no orrfor for transfer
under s. 3!l, aR on that date th!.' Gwalior Court
was not governed by the Indian Code of Civil
Procedurt•- Learned Counsel for the decree-holder
appellant has contended that the directions that
were given on September 14, 1951, really a.mount~d
to an ordt'r for transfer under s. 39. According
to tho lea.med Counsel the Indian Courts should
ignore the or cl er of April 21i 1950, a.s non-exietent,
so that it was open to thl'I Gwalior Court to make a
fresh orcler in the matter on September 14, 1951,
when it was governed by thl' Indian Code of Civil
Procedure. Therefore, it is argued, though it might
be true to say that if the order of April 25, 1950,
had been made under the Indian Code of Civil
Procedure, wh11,t w~s ordered on September U 1951;
was merely a direction under 0 21 r. 6 of the Civil
Procedure Code for the ministerial oa.rrying out
of the order under s. 39 already made, that is, not
the position here as the first order of April 25, 1950,
was admittedly not under the Indian Code of Civil
Procedure. The matter is by no means free from
difficulty; but let us assume that this order of September 14, 1951, was the order by which the
Gwalior Court then governed by the Indian Code of
Civil Procedure, purported to transfer the decree to
the Alla.ha.bad Court for execution. The question
still remains. Was it an order within the meaning of
s. 39 of the Code of Civil Procedure? The a.newer to
this question dflpends on weather the Gwalior Court
which was functioning on Septemoor 14, 1951, was
"the Court which pa.seed the decree."
Under the Indian Code of Civil Procedure the
right to exeoute a. deoree a.rises as soon as a. decree
is made. Immediately on the making of the decree
the Court which pa.880d the decree has jurisdiction
'
·'
.
'
2 s.c.R.
I
-
·~
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
615
1962
to execute it and at that very point of time that
very Court has the jurisdiction to transfer it Raj Rojendta Bariat
to another court governed by the Indian Maloji ,Jfarsinp
Rao Shillll•
Code of
Civil F'rocedure for
'execution.
••
It is reasonable to think that in speaking of ''courts"
Shankar Saf'tln
in the phrase, "courts which passed the decree''
nas Gupta J.
s. 3 7, as well as s. 39 contemplate only courts
governed by the Indian Code of Civil Procedure.
For, it is with the procedure of such courts only
that this Code is concerned. On the date the present decree was made the Indian Code of Civil Procedure did not apply to the Gwalior Court. In
other words, it was not a "uourt" for the purposes
of the Indian Code of Civil Procedure. Later on,
it is true, from April 1951, the Indian Code of Civil
procedure became applicable to the Gwalior Court.
It will be. proper, in our opinion, to think that the ·
court when governed by the Gwalior Code of Civil
Procedure had a distinct identity from the court
at Gwalior after it came to be governed by the
Indian Code of Civil Procedure. The Court which
made the order of transfer in September · 14, 1961
was therefore not "the Court which passed the
decree" within the meaning of s. 39. It is clear
therefore that the Allahabad Court had no power
to execute the decree under s. 38 of the Civil Procedure Code as there was no valid transfer to it from
the "court which passed the decree."
It remains to consider whether s. 43 or s. 44
are of any assistance to the decree-holder. Coming
to s. 44 first, it has to be mentioned that upto March
2l\, 1948 the section ran thus :-"The Provincial
Government may by notification in the Official
Gazette declare that the decree of any Civil or
Revenue Courts in any Indian State, not being
courts established or continued by the authority of
the Central Government or of the Crown Representative, or any class of such decrees, may be
eI.OOlltOO in \be Province as if they bad been paaaed
616
Ifill
--
rloj R•j1aiba SarUr
M .i.;; .Vtrrsi"IJi
Ra. ~laitot.
•·
S"""""' SON•
D.s ll.Pto J.
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS [19ll3)
by courts of British India." The section was mat.
erially amended on June 3, 1960 with retrospect·
ive effect. from .January 26, 1950. On amendment
the sedion ran thus :-"The Government of a Pa.rt
A State or Part B States may, by notification in
the Official Gazette declare tha.t the decrees of any
Revenue Court in any Part B State or any class of
such decrees may be executed in the Pa.rt A State
or Part C State, as the <'aBe may be, as if they ha.d
been passed by courts, of that State." It is obvious
tha.t the decree·holder ca.n get no benefit from s. 44
after this amendment. If however there ha.d been
a notification by the U. P. Government under
s. 44' as it originally stood in respect of de<'reee of
Civil Courts in Gwalior State the present decree
would have been executable in Allahabad Courts
on Ja.nua.ry 26, 1950, and that right of exeouta.bil·
ity would ha.ve continued upto the present time.
There was however no suob notifka.tion. It ia clear
therefore tha.t s. 44 is of no assistance to the decree.
bolder.
It is equally clear that s. 43 is als
; no
assistance to him. Section 43 as it origins.Ji; stood
was in these worde : "Any decree pa.eeed by a.ny civil court
establiRhecl in a.ny pa.rt of British India to
which the provisions relating to execution do
not extend, or by any court established or
continued by the authority of the Central
Government or the Crown Representative in
the territories of any foreign prince or State
outside India.. may if it cannot be executed
within the jurisdiction of the Court by which
it was passed, be executed in the manner
hnein provided within the jurisdiction of any
court in British India."
The decree of Gwalior Court did not fall within
tbis. The section wae amended after March 23,
..
~,.
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME OOUR'l' REPORTS
617
1962
1948, and for the words "in any part of British
India" the -words "in any area within the provinces . Raj Raimtha S!Wdar
of India'' were substituted. This change could not Malojl MMlint•
Baa Shih/•
however bring the decree of a Gwalior State within
v.
9'nanla,. Saran
the sect.ion. The next change, which it is .necessary
to mention was made by the amendment of June 3,
Dae Gupta J.
1950, with retrospective effect from January 26,
1950. On this amendments. 43 ran thus:-
"Any decree passed,
(a) by a 1 ivil Court in a part B State or
(b) by a civil court in any area within a part
A State or part C State to which the
provisions relating to execution do not
extend, or
'
(c) by a court established or continued by the
authority of the Central Government out
side India, may, if it cannot be executed
within the jurisdiction of the Court by
which it was passed, be executed in-a
manner provided within the jurisdiction
of any court in the States,"
.,
It has been strenu;iusly contended on.behalf
of the decree-holder that rhe decree passed by the
Gwalior Court on November 18, 1948, is a decree
passed by a civil court in a Part B State. It is true
that Gwalior became Part of a Part B State from
January 26, 1950, and civil -0ourts in. Gwalior were
from that 4ate civil courts in any Part B State.
Every decree made · by a court in Gwalior after
January 26, 1958, would get the benefit then of
s. 43 as amended. We are unable to see however how
the decree passed by a civil court in Gwalior before
that date could get any such benefit. The agree··
ment of the appellant's council that a decree paseed
by a civil .court in Gwalior before Gwalior become
jncluded in a Part B StAte ifl a decree palilled by a ·
818
J!Jt;;Z
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1963]
civil court in a Pa.rt B State really asks us to consRaj Rajendra Sardor true the words "by a civ ii court in a. pa.rt B State"
-~Ulojl M111Ji11gh
as by a "civil court in a.n Indian State which has
Heu Shitolt
later become included in a Pa.rt B :State." For such
••
Shankt11 Saran
a construction we cannot see any justification.
It was urged by the learned Counsel that it
DnJ C.uplo J
could not have been the intention of the legislature
to make any radical departure in the scheme of
ma.king decrees of courts of Indian States executable in as courts in Indian provinces. It is pointed
out that under s. 44 as it originally stood such
a decree would have become executable in the
courts of the provinces if the Pro >incia.l Govern·
ment ma.de the neces8ary nutification under s. •14.
The position was safe when there was such a
notification. But, even when there was no such
v:itification there was always the probability of
such a notification being ma.de. Tlmt probability
disa.ppe'a.rcd with the amendment of e. 4-1 on June 3,
l!);Jl). It is reasunable to think, argues the lea.t·ned
Counsel, that when at the same time s. 44 was thus
being a.mended the legislature used the words: ··•any
decree passed by a civil court in a. Part B Sta.to",
its intention was to include within tho~e words
"decrees made by a civil court in an Indian State
which later become a Part B State." In
our opm10n,
tho words actually used by
the legislature do not admit of such an interpretation.
If it was the l~gislature's intention to preserve
for the decrees of the Indian States this cha.nee
of executability it could have easily made the nec!'ssary provision by using suitable phraseology either
ins. 43 ors. 44.
On a proper con8truction of the words that
were ·actually used, viz., "any decree passed by a.
civil court in a. pa.rt B State'". we see no reason to
think that thl' legislature intended to use to mean
"deoree11 made by a civil court in au Indian State
which later became a Part B State... Sootiou 43
..
1
'
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
619
therefore as i• stood after the amendment of June
3, 1951 is of no assistance to the decree-holder.
Section 43 was further amended by Act IC of
195! and the words as they stand at present have
already been set out. The appellant rightly does
not contend that s. 43 as it now stands applies to
the present decrees ..
1962
Raj Raj"end,a Sardar
Maloji Marsingh
Rao Skito,/1
y
Shankar Saran
Das Gupta J.
Our conclusion therefore is that the Allahabad
Court bad no power to execute the decree either
under sections 38 or under ss. 43 or 44 of the Code
of Civil l'rocrdure. Therefore, eTcD if the deeree was
not a foreign decree, the decree-holder's application
for execution was rightly dismissed.
Tbe appeal is accordingly dismissed with
costs.
Appeal dismissed.
HANSRAJ NATHU RAM
1962
v.
A/1ri/ 30.
l.ALJI itAJA & SONS OF BANK.URA
(J. L. KAPUR, A. K. SARKAR, K. c. DAS
GuPTA, N. RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR and
J. R. MUDHOLKAR, JJ.)
Execution of Decree-Trans/e"' to a court UJ/iere Indian
Cnde of Civil Proceaure not extentle<l -If exeoutabk-Foreign
aecre.e-Foreigners Act, 1946 (31of1946), s. 2(a) (iii)-Coae
of Civil Procedure (Act V of 1908), 81. 38, 39, 43, 44.
A decree passed in favour of the respondent by a
Subordinate Judge of West Bengal was transferred for execu·
lion ·on August 28, 1950 to the Court of the Additional
District Judge of Morena in what was originally Gwalior
State and subsequently became a part of the United States of
'Madnya Bharat· and aftn the Constitution State of Madhya
Bharat. On the date when the decree wa. transferred, IJle
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org