MANAGEMENT O.F THE D.C.M. CHEMICAL WORKS versus THEIR WORKMEN
Supreme Court of India | Decided 1 March 1962 | [1962] SUPP. 3 S.C.R. 516 | 1962 INSC 78
Key facts
- Decided
- 1 March 1962
- Bench
- P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR*, K.N. WANCHOO
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4/1962
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [1962] SUPP. 3 S.C.R. 516
- Neutral citation
- 1962 INSC 78
Text of the judgment
516 SUPREME COURT REPORT~ [1942] SUPP.
1962
lifa1ch I.
.tlANAGEMENT O.F THE D.C.M. CHEMICAL
WORKS
v.
THEIR WORKMEN
(P. B. GAJE1'DHAGADKA!t and K. N. WANCHOO, JJ.)
Industrial Di.•1mte-Company underlnlcinq several conc•rns
-If independent unit•-IVage "'ruclure-lncremenlal scale8Mini1num u;age and fair 11:age, di.i1tinction--Oratuity in addition
lo Provident Pund -&heme for-If can be framed.
The disputes between the appellant, the management of
the D.C.M. Chemical Works which was a constituent unit of
the' Delhi Cloth and General Mills Limited (the Company),
and its workmen related, inter alia, to \Vage scales and gratuity.
The workmen claimed that the chemical works was ail integral
part of the Company and, therefore, the over-all position of
the Company should be takr.n into account in fixing the wagestructurc. The Industrial Tribunal to which the matter was
referred held that in the circumstance~ of the case the chemical
works should be treated as an indrpendent unit and that the
wage-slructur9 etc .• could not be fixed on the basis of the over.
all position of the Company. The facts showed that though the
Company \\'as a single limited concern O\vning and control!ing
various industrial units of different kinds under it. There were
certain features 'vhich \\'ent to show that the various undertakings carried on by the Company had been treated as independent concerns and could not lead to the conclusion that
ti.icy were one integrated whole. It was found that (i) each
unit had separate book• of account and separate profit and
loss account, (ii) each unit had separate muster rolls for its
employees, and transfers from one unit to the other usually
took place with the consent of the employees concerned, (iii)
each unit had its own separate wages and dearness allowance
and bonus was also paid differently in each concern,(iv) wh<re
sales took place from one unit to another they were at marke[
price and not at cost price, and (v) each unit had its own
separate management. The evidence showed that throughout
the cour!e of its existence sincr: 1942 the chemical works had
made profits only in two years and that for the rest of the time
it had been making losses which had to be met by the Company out of the profits of other uniLs.
Held, that on the facts found in the present case, there
\Vas no nexus of integration be.tween different lines of business
carried on by the Company and that the Tribunal was right ~
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
5i 7
its conclusion that the .chemical works was an independent
unit and that, therefore, in fixing the wage structure etc., one
had to look to the position of the chemical works only and
could not integrate it with other units.
-
The Associated Cement Companies Limited, Chaiba~sa
Cement Works,Jhinkpani v. Their Workmen, (1960) I S.C.R.
703, Pratap Press etc. v. Workmen, (1960) 1 L.L.J. 497: Pakshiraja Studios v. Workmen, (1961) 2 L.L.J. 380 and Hony. Secretary, South IndiaMiilowners' Association v. Secretary, District
Coimbatore District Textile Workmen Union, (1962) (2) S.C.lt.
(Supp.) p. 926 relied on.
Fine Knitting Co. Ltd, v. Industrial Court, Bombay,
(1962) (3) S.C,R. (Supp.) p. l 96, applied.
Held further, that in making a direction for the fixation
of an incr~ased fair wage on an incremental scale, the present
financial condition of the concern and its stability are both
nece_ssary to be considered.
There is a difference between a minimum wage and fair
wage which is above the bare minimum wage. In the former
case the tribunal could insist that the employer paid minimum
wages even out of capital.
Messrs Crown Alvminium Works v. Their Workmen, (1958)
S.C.R. 651, referred to.
Held, also, that it is well settled that both gratuity as
well as provident fund schemes can be framed in the same
concern if its financial position allows it, and that though the
financial position of the chemical works had not been found to
be good and stable enough to warrant an incremental wage
structure the direction given by the Tribunal for the fram:ng
of a grat~ity scheme was not erroneous, as it was a long term
provision and there was .D.o reason to suppose that in the long
run the appellant would not be in a flourishing condition.
Crvn. APPELLATE JURISDIOTION : Civil Appeals
Nos. 4 and 5 of 1962.
Appeals by special leave from the award dated
January 25, 1960, of the Industrial Tribunal, Delhi
in I.D. No. 40 of 1957.
A. V. Viswanatha Sastri, A. N. Sinha, and S.
Venkatakrishnan for the appellant (in C.A. No. 4 of
62) and the respondent (in C.A. No. 5 of 1962).
1962
Managenunt of t~e
D.C.i1f. Chemiclll
Wsrks
••
Their Workmen'
)·
.
\..
~
I
'
'
.
'
•
•
•·
· 518 SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1962) SUPP.
1962
.1.ll 41111gamnl of the
D.C.~M. Cllemical
Works
••
Tht fr Workmtn
ivanchoo J.
A. S. R. Chari, R. K. Garg, D. P. Singh, S. C.
"'!yarv·ala ~ml M.K. Ramamurthi for the respon<l<'nts
(m C.A. No. 4 of 62) and the appellants (in C.A.
No. 5 of u2).
1962. March l. The Judgment of th<i Court
was delivered by
WAXCHOO, J.-These two appeals by special
leave arise out of the ~ame award of the Industrial
Tribunal, Delhi, and will be dealt with together.
Appeal :N'o. 4 is by the management of the D.C.M.
Chemical Works while appeal No. ii is by the workmen. The management hereinafter will be referred
to as the appella.nt for tho purposes of both appeals
and the workmen will be referred to as respondents.
A dispute arose between the parties with respect to
various matters including wage scales, dearness
allow!lnce and gratuity. As the parties could not
come to terms it was referred to the industrial
tribunal for adjudication and there were i>s muny as
eleven iSBues which were the subject-matter of refer·
ence. The main point howev<>r on which the
parties differed was whether in determining the
wage-structure etc. of thl' chemical works which is a
constituent unit of the Delhi Cloth and General
Mills Limited (hereirtafter called the Company), the
over-all position of the Company should be ta ken
into account or only the po~ition of this one unit,
namely, the chemical works.
The respondents
contended that the chemical works was an integral
part of the Company and therllforo the over-all
position of the Company should be taken into
acoount and the wage-structure etc. fixed accordingly; in particular it was pointed out that there were
difforonces in wage-structure etc.· between the
various units which were controlled and ow1wd by
tho Company and which wore all situate in the same
area in Delhi and that thPso differences should be
eliminated and all the enterprises in Delhi controlled
by the Company should be treated on the same
footing. On the other hand the oontentio11 of ·lie
-
-
•
-
3 s.b.k.
-
SUPREME COURT Ril:PORTS
519
appellant was that though the chemical works was
one unit of a large number of industries controlled
by the Company, some of which were situate
in the same area in Delhi, the various units
were independent industries and each unit had to be
considered on its own and the wage-structure etc.
fixed on the basis of the financial position of each
unit ; in particular, it was urged that two of the
main units in Delhi were the textile mills run by
the Company and the claim of the respondents that
the ch!lmical works should in all matters be treated
on a par with the textile units was untenable, on
the ground, among others, that it would be against
the principle of industry-cum-region. Before therefore we take up the particular matters raised in the
two appeals before us, we shall first have to consider
whether the claim of the respondents that the overaU position of the Company should be taken into
account in fixing the wage-structure etc.· of the
chemical works is sound ; for if that position is
accepted, the award may have to be set aside as the
tribunal has held tha.t in the circumstances of this
case the chemical works should be treated as an
independent unit and that the wage-structure etc.
therein cannot be fixed on the basis of the over-all
position of the Company.
In order to appreciate the various contentions
put forward by the parties on this question it may
be useful to look into the history of the Company
and how it has grown. The Company came into
existence in 1889 with a modest capital of about
Rs. 10 lacs. It seems that the policy of those in
control of the Company was to plough back a substantial part of the profits into the industry itself
and to create a reserve for that purpose. Originally
the Company started with a textile mill but in
course of time with the help of ploughed back profits
and also with the aid of further capital, the Company set up a large number of other industrial
1163
11lanag1rruntofthe
D.C.M. Chemic<I
Works
••
Their Wor/mun
Wcnch~o J.
520 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1962] SUPP.
1912
.U anagemtnl of tM
D.C. M. Ch.mica/
w.,A,
v.
Theif,Worknl6n
rfanchoo J.
concerns in Ddhi and elsewhere. In Delhi it~elf,
the Company now has the Delhi Cloth Milla, thr
Swatantra Bharat Mill~ which a.re both textile
concerns, the D.C.~i.. Tent J<'a.ctory ostahlishcd in
I 940, and the chemical works with whioh we are
eoncernod in the present appeals.
Beside~. there
a.re other industrial concerns owned and controll.,d
by the Company outsido Delhi, a.s for example, the
Da.urala Sugar Works established in 1932, the Lyallpur Cotton Mills in 1934 and the :IIawana Sugar
\Vorks in 1940.
The chemical works wore started in l9<12 and
the only line of production a.t that time was sulphuric acid. In 19,13, an a.luru plant was set up, in
1944 a. soap plant, in l\J45 a superphosphate plant
and in 1946 ~contact sulphuric acid plant. In 1947 a
vanaspati plant was established and also ·a. power
house was erected in order to meet the requirements
of tho vanasp<1ti plant. In 1948-49 a caustic soda
plant was added so that what began a.s modest
subsidiary to the textile mills ha8 now expanded
into a. full fledged unit fur production of chemicals
and vanaspati. The total capital which was originally about Hs. 10 lacs when the Company started
in 1889 has now grown to Ha. 4 crores. Even so
the capital employed in the chemical wcrks has
always been found from the rnserves of th·. Company and is now of the order of over a. crorc. It is
also not in dispute that very little out of the production of the chemical works is used in the textile
mills of the Company and that by far most of tho
production is sold in the open market.
Furth~r
even the small part of the production that is used
by other units is charged at market rates and not at
cost price, so that for all practical purposes the
chemical works is being run a.s an independent
unit.
Certain features hi.vc however been pointed
out by the respondents to show th9.t the over-all
-
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
52i
1962
position of the Company should be taken into
account in determining the wage-structure etc. of M anagemenl of the
Chemi<al
the chemical works which should be treated as an D.C.M.
Works
integral part of the entire industry of all kinds
v,
Their·· Wor.imm
carried on by the Company. These features are:
no unit has any separate paid up capital and there
Wanchoo J.
is no separate depreciation fund or reserve fund for
each unit ; the Company publishes one balance-sheet
showing the total profits . of all the undertakings
after taking into account losses incurred in any
undertaking ; the shareholders of the Company are
the shareholders in all the units ; the Company has
got one board of directors and a common managing
agency and the policy of the various units is determined on ,th~ basis of the Company as one integrated
unit ; the p:·ofits of the Company are all pooled
together and the profits in any undertaking are not
earmarked for expenditure in that undertaking; the
dividends are paid from to profits of the Company as
a whole; the Company.has a single provident fund for
all its employees in all its units and the Company
has established various units from the profits earned
by the Company as a whole in the past and incometax is paid on the entire profits of the Company
made by all the units after taking into account the
losses, if any, incurred by a particular unit. It is
urged therefore on behalf of tbe respondents that
these features are sufficient to establish that all the
different industries carried on by the Company are
one integrated whole and therefore in fixing the
wage-structure etc. for the chemical works this overall position should be taken into account. There is
however in our opinion a very cogent reply to these
features pointed out on behalf of the respondents,
and t-hat is that the Company is a single limited
concern owning. and controlling various industrial
units of different kinds under it and therefore under
the Company Law as the Company is one legal
entity these features are bound to be common and
may not to enough to lead to the conclusion that
~22 SUPREME COURT REPOl~TS [l!JB2] SUPP.
Jy1;-;
J/ tJMKtmwnl of Che
D.C.M. C"""ical
JVork1
v.
T!wfr Wor.bnen
Wonchoo J.
the vttriou8 undertakings carried on by the Company
are one intograted whol" and therefore when wa.gestrueture etc. hM to be fixed in any particular unit
the over-all po~ition of the Company as a whole
must be taken into account.
On the other hand there are certain features
which havo been pointed out by the tribunal and .
which are not in dispute which go to show th'.Lt the
Company bas been treating its various unitll as inuepcndent concerns in actual practice. Each unit
bas separate books of account and separate profit
and l<iss account Hhowing how each particular business is faring. Each unit has separate muster-rolls
for illl employees and transfers from, o~c unit to
the other, even wbero such transfers,,. are possible
considering the utterly different kinds of business
that the Company is <>.arrying on, usually take place
with the consent of the employees concerned.
Further each unit bas got its own separate wa.ges
and separate dearne88 allowanco and other different
allowancell and bonus is also paid differrntly in
e11eb concern. Further even where eales take place
from one unit to anothl'f tht1y take place at market
rate and not at cost price and are adjusted on this
basis in the books of account. Lastly though there
is a common board of directors and a common
managing agency of tho Company. each unit has its
own separate management as it is hound t-0 be for
tho businc..'18 carried on by ditr'erent units is in many
cases utterly different.
It is on theso facts that we have to seo whether
the chemical works can he said to bo so integrated
with the other units of the Company as to justify
the conclusion that it is part of the samo business,
and the entire business carried on the Company is one establishment, and therefore it would
not be right to have different wage·structure, dear_
nese allowance, etc., in the same est'lbli!lhment•
'I
I
·'
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
529
This matter was considered by this Court in con1962
nection with lay-off in The Associated Cement ComM anagemmt of thd
panies Limited,Chaibasa Cement Works, Jhinkpani v, D.C. u. Chemical
Works
Their Workmen(1), where tests were laid down for
v.
determining whether. a particular unit is pa.rt of a
Thei.r Workmen
bigger establishment. These tests included geograWanchoo J.
phical proximity, unity of ownership, management
and control, unity of employment and conditions of
service, functional integrality and general unity of
purpose. But it was pointed out that it is was impossible to )1,y down any one test as an absolute
and invariable test for all cases and the real purpose of these tests was to find out the true relation
between the parts, branches, units. If in ti:; ir true
relation they constitute one integrated whole, then
the establishment is one ; if on the contrary they
do not constitute one integrated whole, each unit
is then a separate unit. How the relation between
the units ·will be judged must depend on the facts
proved. Thus in one case the unity of ownership,
management and control may be the important
test, in another case, functional integrality or general
unity may be. the important test; and in still
another case, the important test may be the unity
of employment. It was pointed out that in a
large number of cases several tests may fall· for
consfoleration at the same time and the difficulty of
applying these tests arises because of the complexities of modern industrial organisation. The matter
was considered again by ·this Court in Pratap Press
etc. v. Workmen (2 ), Pakshiraj Studios v. Workmen( 3 ),
Hony. Secretary, South India Millowners' Association
v. Secretary, District Coimbatore District Textile Workmen U nio.n (') and Fine Knitting Co. Lti/,. v. Industrial Court, Bombay('). In the case of Fine Knitting
Co., this Court was considering one limited company but it was held in t.he .circumstances that even
though there was unity of ownership, management ·
and control the two parts of the same concern were
(1) [1960] 1 s.c.R. 703.
(2) [1960] l L.L. J. 497.
(3) [1961] 2 L. L.J. 380.
(4) C. A. 419 of 1960, decided on 1-2-62.
(5) C.A. S06 of 1961, decided on 15-2-1962.
fi24 SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1962] SUPP.
llltil
/Jl cinogm:ent of thtD .C.M. Ct..mical
Wor.i:s
Y,
Their ff'orkmm
Wane/Joo J.
diffrrcnt uuits as th<'re waR no functional integrnlity between them. It is on the basis of these tests
that we havti to consider whether the tribunal WM
right in its conclus10n that the ohcmical works has
to be treated as an independent unit.
The common features which have been emphasised on behalf of t.ho respondents are in our
opinion clearly capable of Pxplanation on tho
ground that the Company is a limited concern and
carries on different kinds of business. But as in
law under the Companies Act, the Company being a
limited concern is one legal entity, the Common
features on which the respondPnts rely follow from
that one single cirrumetancc, namely, that the
Company is a limited concern governed by the
Company Law. It would thorefore in our opinion
be not right to emphasise these · common features
and to hold on their basis only that the various
buRinesses carried on by the Company have to be
treated as one integrated whole for the purposes of
waµe-Rtrncturc etc. The outstanding fact in the
present case is that though a large number of businesses is being carried on by the Company their
nature in many caaes is utterly different and one has
generally speaking nothing to do with tho other. The
three main lines of business whioh the Company is
carrying on are Rugar, textiles and chemicals. It
is obvious that there is nothing common between
these three- different lines of business and there
can be 110 question of one depending upon the
other and there cannot be functional integrality
generally speakin!! between these three lines of
business. There might be some connection speaking between the nhcmieal works and the
textile mills of the Compa11y inasmuch as some of
the chemicals might be used in the textile mills; but
· the evidence shows that a very small proportion of
tho chemicalR produced in the chemical works is
used in the textile mills and that most of the production is sold in the open market. It cannot
therefore be eaid that the ohemical worka 88 it now
I
3S.C.R.
-
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
525
exists is therefor the purposes of the textile mills
and is thus integrated with the textile mills. Even
in the matter of employment. the evidence is that
there is separate recruitment of labour for the
different units and each unit has separate
muster rolls of employees and this is quite
natural considering that different skill is required
for the three lines of business carried on by the
Company. It cannot also be said that there is any·
essential dependence of the chemical works on the
textile units or that one cannot be operated without the other. Further the way in which the
Company has been dealing with different units in
the past also shows that they have been treated as
independent units. Each unit has its own separate
labour union and separate agreements are entered
into between the Company and its unions with
respect to the conditions of service which are also different for different Units. Even in thematter of bonus
there are differnnces between the different units and
these differences sometimes arose out of different
agreements between the various units and their
unions. It appears that even in the case of units
carrying ori the same business, as for example,
textile, the workmen themselves contended in an
earlier adjudication that the Delhi Cloth Mills and
the Swatantra Bharat Mills were two distinct and
separate units of the Company. In any case whatever may be said as to the units in the same line of
business it is in our opinion perfectly clear that
there is no nexus of integration between different
lines of business carried on by the Company on the
facts which have been proved in this case. We are
of opinion therefore that the ratio of the decision
in the Fine Knitting Co.'s case(') applies to the facts
of this case and it must be held that the chemical
works is an independent unit and therefore in
fixing the wage structure etc. we have to look to
the position 9f the chemical works only and cannot
(o) C.i\. 306 ofl961, decided on 15-2-1962.
1962
Management ofche
D.C.M. Chtmital
Work•
••
Their Workmen
Wanchoo J.
.526 SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1962] SUPP.
integrate it with other units and consider its wage
qi llk structure etc. on the basis of such integration.
/J. ',\!. Ch<no<41
}if 1114.('tmtnl
Jf' PtkJ
v.
7 li.~lr U-'or.bntn
IVanchooo,J.
It is in the background of the above finding,
namely, that the chemical works is an independent
unit that we now come to the specific points raised
in the two appeals. We shall first take the appeal
by tho workmen. The following four contt-ntions
'only were pressed before us on their behalf:-
(i) Even considering the chemical works
aa tin independent nnit, the tribunal should
have fixed a wage structure including incremental scales ;
(ii) The trihunttl should have given the
same minimum scales to the workmen cmplo·
yed in t-he canteen a.A are being given to the
oth!'r workmen in this concern ;
(iii) The t.ribuna.l ghou ld have madn those
members of the dvil engineering department
who had been working for more than one
year permanent and shou J<I h>tve given them
t.l1e same wrms and conditions of ~ervice n.s
are enjoyed by other workmen of the concern ;
(iv} The tribunal ~hould have awarded
rurther bonus to the workmen.
Re. (i).
The contention on behalf of the respondents in
this respe<:t is thatthere are no incremental scales in
this concern and the tribunal should have at any
rate made a beginning by fixing some inoromental
scales for the workmen. The tribunal however
baa refused to
incremental scales on the g-round
that the concern htts neither financial ability nor
stability to justify the fixing of inercme11ta.I scale,a at
the ~resent ti~e. It is not in dispute that throughou~
fix
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
527
196!
the course of its existence the chemical works has
made profits only in two years and that. for the rest M ant1gemmt of lh e
of the time it has been making lossos which had to D.C.M. Chemical
Workr
be met by the Company out of the profits of other
v.
units. Reliance in this <:onnection has been placed Their Workmen
on behalf of the respondents on certain observations
Wanchoo J.
in the Tariff. Commission Report and on a book
called "Fertilisers Statistics in India" to show that
the chemical industry has a very prosperous future
in front of it. Reliance has also been placed on a
communication addressed by the appellant to the
respondents in which it has been said that judging
from sound business principles the chemical works
had not yet turned the corner of losses, but the
position appeared brighter, and it was hoped that
with the co-operation of labour the chemical works
would be an asset to the D. C. M. family. Our
attention has also been drawn to various annual
reports in which an optimistic picture has been
painted by the directors for the benefit of the shareholders. We agree however with the tribunal that
in spite of the possibility that in time to come the .
chemical works might acquire stability and prove
a source of increasing profit to the. Company,
the fact remains that upto now the chemical works·
has been running at a loss except for two years and
one cannot be certain that it will start earning pro ..
fits soon. In these circumstances it seems to us
that the tribunal was justified in not framing rm
incremental scale of wages at the present juncture
as that would put a heavy strain on the finances on
the chemical works which has yet to attain financial stability. At the present moment the losses
incurred in this unit have to be met from the profits
earned in other units of the Company and in this
situation we do not think that the tribunal was
wrong in refusing to frame incremental scales.
It is however urged on behalf of the respondents
that if in the co~rse of the last twenty years the
capital invested +n tl!e c~e!llical worJ-s bas ~urea.seq
'
528 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1962) SUPP.
19~1
M anag"""" of th1
D.C•.\f. Chemical
Work4
••
Their Workmen
Wanchoo J.
tremendously as compared to the modest amount
with which it was started in 1942 and if the Company can find capital for the purpose of expansion,
it should be able to pn.y incremental scales of wages
by dipping into tho same source from which
it has b~en able to find ca.pit.al. In effect this
argument means that even though the concern may
be making losers year after year it should find
money for p:iying the labour force higher wageR in
spite of tho circumstance that that may load it into
incurring further losses. The argument seems to
ho that even though there may be losses the concern must pay higher wages to the workmon and
if necessary pay them out of what may be called
capital. Now this argument would in our opinion
bo unanswerable if the cla.im was for what is called
mumnum wage: (Seo Messrs Ctown Alu.miniwn
Works v. '/'heir Workmen ('). If tho wages paid by
tho appellant in the present case were below tho
minimum wage t.ha.t the tribunal would eertainly
be justified in ordering it to pay the minimum wage,
for no industry can have a right to exist if it cannot pay wages at the bare subsistence level. Where
it is a case of payment of minimum wago, the tribunal can insist on the same being found, if necessary,
even out of. ca.pita!. But this is not a case of hare
minimum wage and we are dealing with a case of
fair wage which is above the bare minimum wage.
It is not even the case of the respondents that they
are not getting the bare minimum wage. !'heir
case is that they should he given a fair wage, and
that the present wage~, though above the bare
minimum wage, arc still not fair cnou!h and therefore should b"e increased and an incri;mental scale
should be fixed. In such a situation we are of
opinion that the present financial condition
of the concern and its Rtability
are both
necessary to be considernd before an irwr<'ased fair
wage can be given. Both tho present capacity of
(I) [1958] S.C,R. 651.
8 s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
529
of the employer to pay the increased rates of incremental wages and its future capacity have to be
taken into account in determining an increased level
of fair wages based on an incremental scale. Thus
both financial ability at present and financial stability in the near future must be there to justify fixation of an increased fair wage on an incremental scale.
We do not think it will be right to insist on an
increased fair wage on an incremental scale in a
case where the financial capacity and the financial
stability as judged by business principles are both
lacking. Nor would it in our opinion be right to
compel the employer to bear the burden of an
increased fair wage on an incremental scale and
tell him to find money from what may in effect be
capital, for such a situation in ordinary cases can
lead only to one result, namely, the closure of the
business concern, which may be more detrimental
to the workmen. Therefore carr,,ying on with the
present scale of fair wages and hoping that the
financial ability and stability of the concern will
improve, with the result that increased fair wage
on an incremental basis may be fixed in future is
the only alternative at present even in the interest
of the workmen employed in this concern. We
therefore agree with the tribunal that in the circumstances no case has been made for fixing an incremental scale of wages at the present juncture. The
contention on this head must therefore be rejected.
Re. (ii).
-
As to the canteen workmen, it appears that
the canteen is run by the appellant departmentally
on a no-profit-no-loss basis. The workmen employed in the canteen are the workmen of the appellant and their number is sixteen or seventeen. The
minimum basic wage for unskilled workmen in this
concern at the relevant time was Rs. 38.plus Rs. 55
i.e. Rs. 93; but. the workmen. in the .canteen get
consolidated wages and all of them (except one) get
1962
Management pf the
D.C.M. Chtmical
•
Works
v.
Their Workmen
Wanchoo J.
530 SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1962] SuPP.
1962
Managttnt11i of the
D C.M. Chemirfl/
Works
v.
Thftr Worknwi
W411thoa J,
much lesa than the minimum, the figures v·uying
from Rs. 50 to Rs. 78. The tribunal ha.a held that
there is no reason why the conditions of surviec of
the workmen in the oa.nteen should not b., brought on
a. par with tho conditions of service of the rest of
tho workmen. It therefore ordered tha.t the workmen in the can teen wou Id be en titled to the samo
facilities relating to leave, provident fund, bonus,
and gratuity etc. a.s are available to the other workmen in the chemical works ; but so far a.s wages
and dearness allowance are concerned, it has not
given them cve.n the minimum as indica.ted a.hove.
'1:he case of the the appellant was tha.t oven if the
minimum was paid to the workmen in the canteen
the price of the various food-stuffs supplied by the
canteen to the workmen would go up substantially
and it wa.s on tha.t ground that the appellant resisted
the increase in the wages of those workmen in the
canteen who a.re getting less than the minimum of
Rs. 93. The tribunal ha.a hehl-a.nd we think
rightly-that the fa.et that the bettering of the
conditions of service of the workmen in the canteen· may lead to a. rise in the price of things sold
there is no reason for refusing the demand of the
workmen ; but it has not carried into effect fully
the implications of this observation. It has ordered
that·samc conditions as to leave facilities etc. should
be extended to the canteen workmen but has stopped short of giving them the sa.me wagos a.nd
dearness allowance. The reason why the tribunal did not give the workmen the same wages and
dearness allowance is that thero wa.a no satisfactory
material before it to permit it to fix wages and
dearness allowance for the· workmen in the canteen.
We are of opinion tha.t there is no reason why the
tribunal should not ha.ve at least granted the
minimum which is pa.id to the other workmen in
the ('.Once£n to those workmen in the canteen
who are getting less than . the minimum. We
can see no reason for not giving them a.lso the
I
1.
-
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
-
-
53i
mimmum wages as indicated above. This will
certainly result in bringing the fifteen workmen
who are getting between Rs. 50 and Rs. 78 per
mensem as consolidated wages into an equal position, for each will then get the minimum, namely,
Rs. 38 plus Rs. 55 and may remove part of the
discontent. In the circumstances that is all that
can be done in the absence of the material to which
the tribunal has referred. Therefore the wages
of those fifteen workmen who are getting less than
the minimum should be brought to the same level.
There is no reason why they should not get such
benefits as may be due to them, by their wages
being brought to the same minimum as the wages .
of the other workmen in the concern. We therefore disagree with the tribunal with respect to the
workmen employed in the canteen and order that
the wages of those workmen who are getting less
than the minimum paid to the other workmen in
the concern should be brought to the same minimum level. The rest of the award on this head
will stand. The minimum wages as above will be
paid from the date the tribunal has ordered its
award to come into force.
Re. (iii).
The claim of the workmen in this connection
was that there were 300 workmen employed in
1he civil. engineering department and that they
should be made permanent. The tribunal however rejected this contention and pointed out that
most of the workmen were.· temporarily engaged
to carry on construction work which was of a
temporary nature and therefore they could not be
made permanent simply because the construction
had Jasted for more than a year. This view of
the tribunal is in our view correct in so far as the
claim put forward with respect to all the three
hundred workm,.n was concerned. It appears however that at the time when the tribunal recorded.
1962
Managemem of the
D.C.M.. Chmical
Works
v.
Their W orkmePI
WdJJ&hoo J.
532 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [l!l62J
1962
Alan-.gtm1n1ojtht
D C.M. CA,mical
Works
v.
7 Am W ur/mun
H'anthoo J.
suPP.
evidence tho large majority of these 300 workmen
had been discharged because they were no longer
required and only about Ci5 remained in service.
It appears from th" evidencc of thP Joint Works
~Ianager that a skelt>ton st<iff on the civil ongine<'ring side is kept for maintenance of buildings and
this skeleton staff is of a more or less permanent
nature. The argument therefore before us is that
at any rate this skeleton staff should be made
permanent. It was however urged on behalf of
the appellant that this was not the way in which
the matter was put before the tribunal. The poRition now is however clear that a skeleton staff
is kc, pt on a pt•rmanent basis for the ci vii engineering department and it seems to us fair that the
appellant should be directed to make this skeleton
staff permanent and give them the same facilities
and wages etc., as are given to the other workmen.
We therefore direct that the appellant shall make
such of the skeleton staff as is maintainod for civil
engineering purpose permanent and give them tho
same conditions of service including the same minimum wages etc. as to the rest of the workmen.
It is however left to the discretion of the appellant
to determine· what should bo tho strength of this
staff and which persons should Lo rerained as
permanent employees. We say this because tho
matter was not gone into from this point of view
before the tribunal and wo have no material on
which we ourselves can determine the strength of
the skeleton staff and the persons who should be
made permanent on that account. The direction
will be given effect to within throe months of this
judgement.
Re. (iv):
The W<>rkmen have been given 2 1/2 months
basic wages as bonus for tho years in dispuk,
namely, 1!153-54 and 1954-55. They have claimed
additional bonus. It is however conceded fairly
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
5S3
on behalf of the respondent that if the chemical
works is treated as an independent uuit their case
for additional bonus on the basis of the Full-Bench
formula cannot succeed. The demand for additional bonus was rightly rejected by the tribunal,
considering the chemical works as an independent
unit. We may add that this case is distinguishable from the case of Hony. Secretary, South India
Mill-oUJMrs Association, (1) for here the two lines of
business are distinct and have nothing to d0 with
each other.
This brings us to the appeal by the appelJant.
Five points hiive been urged on behalf of the
appellant. They are: (i) dearness allowance; (ii)
uniforms, (iii) acid and gas allowance. (iv) leave
facilities, and (v) gratuity. We shall deal with
them one by one.
Re. (i).
,..
-
So far as dearness allowance is concerned,
the tribunal has ordered that the dearness ·allowance in the chemical works shall be fixed at the
same rate as it is in the power house which is a
part of the chemical works. It may be m3ntioned
that dearness allowance at the relevant tim11 in the
chemical works was Rs. 55 per mensem while in
the power house it was Rs. 66 per mensem. Tbe
contention on behalf of the appellant in this connection is that the reason why there was this difference between the dearness allowance in the
power house and in the rest of the chemical works
is historical. It is further pointed out that though
the difference in the two dearness allowances is
Hs. 11 the actual difference in the total wage packet was only Rs. 3 inasmuch as the minimum. basic
wage in the power house was Rs. 30 while in the
chemical works it was Rs. 38 at the relevant time.
Thus the minimum that an employee was getting
in the power house was Rs. 96 while the minimum
for the rest of the workmen was Rs. 93,. and it is
Pl C.A. 41U of I W 1, <l•cid<d OD l-2·1962.
1962
111an1gement of tht
LJ.C.M. Chemical
JVorks
v.
Their Workmen
~V anchoo J.
534 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1962) SUPP.
1962 •
Monagttn#nl of the
D.C .lit. Chnnical
U'orks
v.
Their H orlmen
'Vanchoo J.
urged that the difference is not serious. The
reason that the tribunal gave for increasing the
dearness allowance for the other workmen in the
concern was that there was no ground for dis·
criminating between the workmen in the power
house and the rest of the workmen. In increasing
the dearness allowance on this sole ground the
tribunal ignored firstly the historical reason why
there was this difference between the dcarn088
allowance for the power house staff and for the
rest of the workmen and also ignored the difference in the basic minimum wages in the power
house and for the rest of the workmon. It further s<'ems to have ignored its own earlier finding
.that the chemical works was running at a loss and
did not have the financial capacity to bear further burden. As a matter of fact it appears that
but for this discrimination which the tribunal
found between the rate oC dearness allowance for
the powor house employees and the rest of the
workmen it may not have made any change in the
dearness allowance payable to the rest of the workmen. It may be mentioned that the system of
dearness allowance in the concern is to allow
neutralisation at the rate of 2-l/2 annas (now 17
nP.) for each point rise over the workir:ig class
cost of living index treating the base as 100 for
the year 1939. It may also be mentioned that
since the reference was ma.do there has been a
voluntary increase in tho dearness allowance for
the rest of the workmen at the rate of Ra. 6 per
mensem.
The reason why this difference is existing
between the rate of dearness allowance for the
power house employees and rest of the workmen
is that for sometime the power house was integrated with the Swatantra Bharat Mills. Therefore as an integral part of the cotton textile industry tho rates of basic wages and dearness allowance
....
-
3 s.c.R.
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
535
1962
in the power house were the same as in the cotton
textile business of the company. Thus the rates Management flj lhe
there at the relevant time were, as we have already D.C.M. Chemical
Works
said, Rs. 30 basic wage and Rs. 66 dearness allow••
Their Workrrun
lance. At that time the minimum .wage in the
chemical works was Rs. 38 basic plus Rs. 55
Wanchoo J.
dearness allowance i.e. Rs. 93 in all. It appears
however that there wa.s some objection by the
Excise Departmel\t of the Government as there
was a gate between the Swatantra Mills and the
chemical works. The Excise Department wanted
this gate to be blocked iu order to have better control over the excisable articles produced in the
chemical works. The appellant therefore had to
block up this gate in 1950 a.nd therefore the power
house which existed on the chemical works side of
this gate was transferred from the Swatantra ~fills·
to the chemical works. However as the. power
· house workmen were getting the textile rates, the
Company assured them that though they would
thereafter be under the control of the chemical
works they will be governed for tho purposes of
pay scales and dearness allowance etc. by the
rules of the Swatantra Mills. It is this circumstance which has resulted in different scales for the
power house staff and the rest of the workmen of
the chemical works. It further appears that there
was some retrenchment in the power house in 1957
and the retrenched workmen were absorbed as far
as possible in others units. At thn,t time there
was an agreement between the Company and
the power· house workmen and it was agn:ed
that these workmen would be absorbed in other
units but they would accept the conditions of
service etc. of those units where they were absorbed, with the result that only those who are left in
the power house continue on the textile scales of
the Swatantra Bharat Mills. These circumstances
however were not taken into account by the tribunal ·
at all when it ordered that the power house scale of
536 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1962] SUPP.
1962
,\fa11a:cmP'll of the
/) .C. ~1. r:~emical
1r 01A:s
'.
?"htir If orknu111
dearness allowance. should be introdueed for the
rest of the workmen also. The power house 8 cale
is really the textile scale and the appellant contended that it would lead to a good deal of complication if the textile scale of dearness qllowauce is
ordered to be introduced for tho chemical works.
We are of opinion that thero is force in this contention raised on behalf of the appellant and tho ·
tribunal was not juRtified in increasing the dearness
allowance for the chemical works merely because of
this fortuitous circumstance a.rising out of historical
reasons. In any case the number of the power
house workmen is very small, say about 30/40, who
who are getting a difforent rate of dearness allowance. l•'urthcr it appears that there was not much
difference between the total wage packet for
the power house workmen and for the rest and that
was another reason 'why the tribunal should not
have introduced the power house scale for tho rest
of the workmen. [t has however been urgPd on
behalf of the re~pondonts that the difforonce in the
basic minimum wages between the power house
workmen and tho rest of the workmen in the chemical works has <lisappe,ircd afwr the recommendations of the Textile Wage Board by which the
minimum ba.~ic wage for textile workers has been
increased by Jis. 8 and it became Rs. :!8 from
January l, l\l60. Therefore, it is urged that there
is no reaRon why tho tribunal's award with respect
to making the dearness allowance for the rest of.
the workmen the same as the workmen of the power
house should not be allowed to stand. Superficially,
this argument looks attractive ; but if one examines
it in the light of the T0xtile Wage Board's recommendations it will be found that the linking of tho
dearness allowance for tho chemical work's workmen
with the power house workmen would load to endless complications, for the power house workmen
would be entitled to the same dearness allowance
etc. 118 would govern the tox;tile workmon in the
..
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT Rl!]PORT3 , 537
Swatantra Bharat Mills. The Textile Wage Board
report shows that it recommended not only that the
basic wage should be increased but also that a large
part of the dearness allowance should be merged
with basic wage, the remainder alone remaining as
dearness allowance. It'is submitted on behalf of
the appellant that it has carried out the recommendations of the Textile Wage Board and the result
of the same has been that the basi9 wages of the
textile workmen which would apply to the power
house workmen would be fhed at about Rs. 88 or
Rs. 8ll and the dearness allowance would be reduced
, to about Rs. 15.
It is urged that the practical
linking of the dearness allowance :(or the rest of the
workmen with the dearness allowance in the power
house whioh has been ordered by the .tribunal on
the ground that there should be no discrimination,
would result in endless trouble, apart from the
question whether in view of the earlier finding of
the tribunal as to the financial capacity of the
appellant it would be possible for the appellant
to bear the extra burden of the increased dearness
allowance. The operative order of the tribunal is
that the. ';"Orkmen of the chemical works, excluding
the workmen who are governed by Ex. W/2,
should be paid dearness allowance at the rate at
which it is being given to the workmen of the power
house, and this undoubtedly in our opinion would
lead to endless trouble now that the recmnmendations of the Textile Wage Board will for historical
reasons apply to the workmen in the power house.
We are therefore of opinion that the ground
on which the tribunal ordered the rate of dearness
allowance for the other workmen of the chemical
works to be paid on a par with the rate for the
power house is not sustainable and the tribunal
went wrong in not giving due weight to the historical reasons for the rates prevailing in the power
house. Further we are of opinion that the increase
is not sustainable on its own merits on the ~rounq
. 1962
M anagtment of tht
D .C .M. Chemical
W01ks
v,,"
Thir WOrkm en
--.-
,WanC~oo',J~
538
1962
M anog"""'1 •f •At
D.C.M. Chemical
Works
Y.
Tluir Workmen
Wane.loo J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1962] SUPP.
of tho financial capacity of the concern, which the
tribunal itself found was not sound. as tho conrern
had been running at loss practically sinrc it camo
into existence except for two years. The contention
therefore on behalf of the appellant 011 this head
must be accepted and the order of the tribunal
increasing the dearness allowance set aside.
Re. (ii).
As to uniforms, we see no reason to differ from
the view takC'n by the tribunal. The roason's given
by tho tribunal for ordering that uniforms should be
given to certain category of workmen are in our 1
opinion sound. But the tribunal has made a mistake when it went on to order that protective
equipment ahould also be given in addition to
uniforms, to the persons found entitlP-d to w1iforms
The
according to the directions of the tribunal.
tribunal seems to have overlooked the difference
between uniforms and protective equipment; which
is provided in the Delhi Factory Rules. So far as
protective equipment is concerned, it is given for
certain specific purposes to be found in tho ltules
and has no connection with uniforms which employers are ordered to supply to their workmen, for
reasons entirely different. We are thereforn of
opinion that the direction of the tribunal that
proteotiye equipment should also be supplird to
persons founct entitled to uniforms under its order,
is not correct and should be set aside. So far as
protective equipment is concerned, it will only be
supplied to those who are entitled to it under tho
Delhi Factory Rules and not necessarily to all to
whom µniforms may have to be supplied under the
orders of the tribunal. We order accordingly.
Re. (iii).
As to aci<l and gas allowance, the tribunal ha.A:
ordered the faymcnt of Rs. 3 per month to certais
categories o workmen. It appears that originalln
".1
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
539
the appellant used to pay Rs. 5 as acid and gas
allowance in the Nitric acid gas plant and Rs. 3 in
the contact plant. Later, however, this gas allow. ance was merged in pay. But it appears that gas
allowance is still being paid to the workmen in the
nitric acid gas plant. It is contended on behalf of
the appellant that this was because the gas allow·
ance in the case of these workmen was not merged
in pay. There is, however, nothing on the record
to prove this. As the record stands we have no
reason to hold that the gas allowance which was
originally paid to the workmen of the nitric acid gas
plant was not merged in their pay. On the whole
therefore the reasons giv!'n by the tribunal for
making the allowance of Rs. 3 to those workmen
who are engaged in the manufacture of chlorine,
sulphuric acid, caustic soda and hydrochloric acid
appear to us to be sound end we see no reason to
·interfere with that part of the award.
I
'
-
Re. (iv).
So far as leave facilities are concerned, the
tribunal has awarded that privilege should be
granted as provided under the Factories Act. It
has further provided that casual-cum-sick leave
should be granted for twelve days in the year. We
do not think that this award is in any way unreasonable. The tribunal has however gone on to deal
with festi v.al holidays, and that in our opinion the
tribunal had no jurisdiction to do. The reference
was in these terms : "Whether leave facilities
should be increased, and if so, to what extent".
There was no reference with respect to holidays.
The tribunal has however taken the view that
holidays are. covered within the words ·"leave
facilities" used in the order of reference. We are
of opinion that this view is incorrect. . Holidays
are entirely different from leave fadlities. On a,
'
1962
Managemenl oftht
D. C. M, Chemical
Works
v.
Tluir W11kmen
Wanchoo J,
540
1962
SUPREDU'.: COURT REPORT3 [1962] SUPP.
holiday the entire business is closed and no one
works while leave faoilities deal with leave for
individual workers while the busin•ess as a wholo is
running. \Ve may in this connection refer to item
4 of tl1•3 1'ilir,i SJhedule to the Ind11strial Disputes
Act (~o. l-1- of L9!7), which is in theso terms : ·
"Leava witl1 wages and holidays". This shows that
holidays stand on a different footing altogether
from leave with wages and a reference with respect
to leave facilities cannot include a consideration of
holidays. The tribunal's order with respect to
holidays is set aside.
M •MfltmMI af the
JJ. C. M. ChtmiCal
Works
v. '•
Thrir 0Wrkm1n
Wandlao J,
Re. (v).
Lastly we come to the gratuity scheme sanctionrd by the tribunal. It is true that in this
concern there is already a provident fund scheme
in force. But it is now well settled that both
gratuity a.s well as provident fund schemes can
he framed in the same concern if its financial
position allows it. It is true that the financial
position of the chemical works has not been found
to bo good and stable enough to warrant an inoremental wage-structure ; but gratuity is a long term
provision and there is no reason to suppose that in
the long run tho appellant 'viii not be in a flourishing condition. As to the burden of tho scheme, we
do not think that, looking at it from a practical
point of view and taking into account the fact that
there are about 800 wotkmen in all in the ooncern,
the burden per yoar would be very high, considering
that tho numbor of retirements is between three to
four por centum of the total strength. Fnrther we
find that in this very concern there is a gratuity
schem-3 for clerks who number between 100 and 200
and aro part of tho labour force. \Ve can .see under
the circumstanco1< no reason why a similar gratuity
~cheme should not be framed for the rest of the
'
•
a s.c.R. SUPREl\lE COURT REPORTS
~
' I
541
·
We therefore see no reason
to interfere
wor k men.
·.
t
with the order of the tribunal in this respec ·
We therefore allow the appe~ls .in par~ and
dismiss them in part in the manner md1?ated m the
course· of this judgment. In . the mrcumstances
parties will bear their own costs m both the appeals.
1962
Managtment of the
D. c. M. Chmiical
Works
v.
Tluir W•rkm1n
Wonohoo J,
Appeals allowed in part.
PRATAPRAY MANMOHANDAl::i ·
v.
BOMBAY BULLION AS~OCIATION LTD.
(J. L. KAPUR, K. 0. DAS GUPTA and RAGHUBAR
.
DAYAL, JJ.)
Bullion Association-Member owing amount to creditorPailure to submit Kapli (voucher) for amount - Committee
declaring him a defaulter-Legality of -Giving of opportunity
to •ubmit Kapli if denied-Bombay Bullion . Asaociation Bye
Laws 155 (4).
-
The appellant was a member of the Bombay Bullion
Association Ltd. He entered into certain forward transactions
with certain other persons. According to the bye-laws of the
Association the appellant had to submit a balance sheet and
to give kaplis (vouchers) for the amounts due from him, but
the appellant did not include the amounts due from him in
the balance sheet nor did he give the kaplis on the ground
that these transactions were fictitious and illegal. On the
settlement day the Clearance House committee called upon
the appellant to appear before them. Before the Committee
the appellant took the stand that they had no jurisdiction to
proceed with the matter as he was claiming arbitration. Th
committee passed a resolution declaring him a defaultere
The: appellant filed a suit challenging the resolution. inter alia.
on the ground that the Committee, after its decision, was
bound, under bye-law 155 (4) to give him an opportunity to
give the kaplis before it could declare him a defaulter. The
bye-law provided:-
1962
March 2.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org