KRISHAN LAL DHAWAN AND ·ANOTHER versus DELHI ADMINISTRATION
Supreme Court of India | Decided 15 February 1962 | [1962] SUPP. 3 S.C.R. 209 | 1962 INSC 56
Key facts
- Decided
- 15 February 1962
- Bench
- J.L. KAPUR*, K.C. DAS GUPTA, RAGHUBAR DAYAL
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 196/1960
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1962] SUPP. 3 S.C.R. 209
- Neutral citation
- 1962 INSC 56
Text of the judgment
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
209
be precluded from making the present application on the ground of res judicata. At the
highest, a plea ofres judicata may perhaps be raised
against the third respondent but that would not
be effective in view of the fact that in the present
case, an application has been made by the
fourth respondent as well. That is why Mr.
Mehta did not seriously press the point of res
judicata before us.
The Fine ILnittint
Co., Ltd.
v.
The fndustrial Court,
Bombay
Gojentlr•zadk•r J.
In the result, fails the appeal and is dismissed
with costs.
Appeal dismissw.
KRISHAN LAL DHAWAN AND ·ANOTHER
v.
DELHI ADMINISTRATION
(J. L. KAPUR, K. C. DAS GUPTA and RAGHUBAR
DAYAL, JJ.)
Criminal Trial-Trial by Special Judge-Another •pecial
Judge conducts further proceedings-Conviction-Valid-ityCode of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (Act 5 of 18.98), s. 350Criminal Law Amendment Act, 1952 (46 of 1952). s. 8,
sub's. 3.
The appellants were charged under ss. 120B and 420
Indian Penal Code ands. 5 (I) (d) read withs. 5 (2) of the
prevention of Corruption Act. The trial of the appellants was
commenced before a 15pecial Judge who heard the prosecution
evidence. 'fhereafter the trial was taken up by another special
Judge who examined the defence witnesses. and finally
convicted the appellants. The appellants appealed to the
High Court and the High Court upheld the conviction and
sentence. The appellants thereupon appealed to the Supreme
Court by special leave.
The sole question which was raised by the appellants
was that in view of the fact the trial commenced before
one Special Judge and another Special Judge took up the
proceedings
are
incompetent. . . The
respondent ·
relying on s. 8, sub-s. (3), of the Cnmmal Law Amendment
196S
210
1962
Kris/um Lal Dhawan
v.
D1lhi AdminiJtration
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1962] SUPP.
Act, 1952, contcncltcl that trial \Vas competent and thr
conviction and sentence \\'<·re V<did in lav.•.
Held, that s. 350 of the Co:le of Criminal Procerlure
is not applicable \\·hen one spcr.ial Judge is succeeded hy
another. Neither dor~ .<;, 3 (a) of 1he Criminal Law
Amendment Act, 1956, make the applicability of s. 350 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure to a trial by a special Judge
retrospective.
Pai1are T.al "· Sl'lle of Punjab, ( 1962; 3 S. C.R. 328,
followed.
CnnrCTAT. APPELLATE ,Jumsmcnox: Criminal
Appeal !'\os. l!l6 and l!l7 of 60.
Appeal by snecial leave from thll ju<l!!ment
and orrlor date<l l\Iwv 12, l!lii8, of the Punjab Higoh
Court (Circuit B~nch) at Delhi in Criminal Appeals
·
Nos. 3-D and 1-D of 1958.
A.S.R. Chari, :lf. K. Rarnamurthi, R. K. 011rq,
n. P. Shl{]h and 8. C. Aqnrwal, for the appellant
(in Cr. A. No. 1!!6/60).
N. S. Uindra, I. M. Lal and A.G. Ratna.pml.·hi
for the aprwllant (in Cr. A. Ko. I!l7 /fl0).
If. R. Khanna., R. Ji. Dhebar and P. D. Menon,
for the respoude11ts.
1962. February 15. The Judgment of the
Court was dcliverPd by
0
KAPl"H, J.-Thrse two appeals are directed
agoainst the judgm<'nt and ordn 1Jf the Punjab
High Court confirmin~ the con~ietion of the appellants under sH.120 B ancl 421l; Indian Penal Cod<>,
and s.5(1 )(cl) rPad with s. 5(:2) of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 194-7; and sentmwing each of them
to an aggregate Henknce of six mrmth8' rigorous
i m prisonmrn t.
It is unnecessarv to set. out the fac:ts in cletnil but to put them briefly. 'J he app"1lant;
Albert llfosscs was the Princ:ipal incharge of the
Rehabilitation Cc>ntrc, i\falviya Nagar and Kalkaji
-
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
211
J96Z
under the Ministry of Rehabilitation. The appel·
!ant, K. L. Dhawan, was a partner in the firm Krishan Lal Dhawan
v.
named M/s. Dhawan & Co. apd they supplied a
Delhi Adrninistratian
surface plate for a sum of Rs. 1,950/- to the Works
Centre of which the a,ppellant Albert Moses was
Kapur J.
the Principal.
The trial of the appellants and R. P. Dhawan,
who has been acquitted, commenced in the Court of
Mr. Jawala Das, Special Judge, Delhi, and he
heard the case from the date of the institution
of the proceedings on May 21, 1956 to October
26, 1956. He heard the prosecution evidence
which was closed on October 2n, 1956. The case
was then ta.ken up by Mr. P. D. Sharma, Special
Judge, Delhi, from December 20, 1956. He
cx:amined defence witnesses and finally convicted
the appellants of the offences already mentioned
and acquitted R. P. Dhawan.
Against the conviction and sentence .an appeal
was taken to the High Court but the conviction
was upheld and also the senten~es and against
that jud~ment and order these two appeals by
special le1tve have been brought by the two con·
victed persons. The sole question which has been
raised in this Court is th1tt in view of the fact the
trial commenced before one Special Judge and
another Special Judge took up thf' proceedings
after December 20, 1956, the proceedings are :qot
competent and, therefore, the conviction ahd the
s<Jntence cannot be upheld. Counsel relies upon
a judgment of this Court in Payara Lal v. State
of Punjab(') in which it was held that "s. 350 is not
applicable when one Special Judge is succeeded by
another". In that view of the matter Mr. P.D.
Sharma was not Competent to proceed with the
trial from the stage at which it was left by Mr .
•Jawala Das.
rI) [1962] 3 S.C.R. 328.
•
212 SUPRE1\fR COURT REPORTS [Hl62] Rt'PP.
1961
Kris/um I.at DluJwan
y,
D1/lri Admini1lration
Kapur J.
Counsel for the respondent rcliPs on sn h·s.(3) of
s. 8 of tho Criminal Law Amendment Act (Act 4n of
Hl52) which makes tbe provisions of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, in so far' aR th<:>V are not inconsistont with that Act, a.pp.licable to pro<'ecrlings
before a. Special .Judge and a )so provides t.hat a
Special .Judge shall be deemed to be a Ccurt of
Session when trying a case under the Criminal
Law Amendment Act (46 of l!J52). Ilnt this
question was considered in thf' case d1>cidcd hy
this Court in P11aralal's wse~') in whi<'h it was held
that sub-s.(3) of s. 8 of Act 46 of 1952 did not
contemplate thats. 350 of tho Criminal Proeedun•
Code becomes npplirable to proceedings hefore a
Special Judge.
It was also held in the case that th" amendment made in the Criminal Law Amendmr·nt Act
by Act 2 of 1956 by which s. 3(a) was adrled to it
making the provisions of s.:{50 of the Code appJi.
cable to a trial by Special Judg<•s has Iio retrospective effect. In this view of the matter, tho
conviction of the appellants must. therefore be set
a.Ride. The case will be disposed of in accordance
with law.
App ra/ ul/cu·rd.
(I)
•
•
[1%2] 3 ~.C.R.
328 .
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org