GIAN SINGH versus THE STATE OF PUNJAB
Supreme Court of India | Decided 11 September 1961 | [1962] 3 S.C.R. 515 | 1961 INSC 259
Key facts
- Decided
- 11 September 1961
- Bench
- P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR*, K. SUBBA RAO, M. HIDAYATULLAH, J.C. SHAH, RAGHUBAR DAYAL
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 515/1960
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1962] 3 S.C.R. 515
- Neutral citation
- 1961 INSC 259
Text of the judgment
3 :i.O.R..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
5115
GIAN SINGH
v.
THE 8TATE OF PUNJAB
(P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR, K. SUBBA RAO,
M. HrnAYATULLAH, J. C. SHAH and
RAGHUBAR DAYAL, JJ.)
-
Public Servant-T•h•ildar in Punjab--R•flV>f!fJl /roM
servict-Financial Oommis&ioner, if competent to rttnotJt-Pu1tjab
Land R•venue Act, 1887, 8,9,-Punjab Teh•ildari Rulei, 1932floi:ernmrnt of India Act, 1935 ( 25 & 26 Ged. 5 ch,42) •· 241Go1Jfrnment of India (Co nmencement and Tran&itory Proviaion~)
Vrd.r, 1936 cl. 15 (2)-Adaptation of Indian Laws Order, 1937.
The Punjab Tehsildari Rules, 1932, were framed under
s. 9 of the P.rnjab Land Revenue Act, 1837, by the Financial Commissioner. They conferred authority upon the
Financial Commissioner to appoint and to rernove Tehsila
d:ir~ from service. Aftt:r the enactment of the Government
of India Act, 1935, '· 9 was amended by the Adaptation of
Indian laws Order, 1937, and the pfJwer of the Financial
Commissioni:-r to make such rules was abrogated.
The
appellant, who was a Tehsildar, was dismissed by the
Financial Commissioner in 1953. The appellant contended
• that the Financial Commissioner was not competent to
remove him from service as his p')wers to make rule'
regarding appointment and rrmoval from se1vice ofTehsildars
were abrogated and the Tehsildari RHles lost their vitality
a• they .were not preserved by the Government of In.d ia Act,
1935, or by the Adaptation 01 der.
Hfld, (per Gajendragadkar, Subba Rao, Hidayatullah
and Shah,JJ., Dayal, J., contra.) that notwithstanding the
abrogation of the powers of the Financial Commissioner to
frame rules, the "fehsildari rules, 1932 continued in force and
the Financial Commissioner was competent to re-move
the appellant from Service. By the combined operation of
cl. 15 (2) of the Government of India (Commencement and
Tran .itory Provisions Order, 1936, and the Adaptation Order,
1937, the condition of service app 1icab1e to civil servants re··
mained unaltered, until other provisions were made under the
Government of India Act, 1935. !"hough s. 241 of the Govern~ ment of India Act, 1935 provided that the conditions of service
.. of persons serving in connection with the affairs of a province,
were to be such a~ may be prescribed by rules made by the
Governor, or by persons authorised by him, s. 241 was itself
Subject to cl. 15(2) of the 1936 Order. It was not shown that
1961
11
516 '
lfMJ
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1962J
Gia11 Sinth
th'Se rules were superseded or abrogated by the Civil Service
Rules made by the Government of Punjab in 1941.
Th, Statt of
Pun1al>
Per, Dayal, J.-The Financial Comn1issioncr was not the
competent authority to remove the appellant from service.
v.
)>,.
Section HI (IJ wh;ch provided that the Governor would be
the appointing and consequently the dismissing authority
for all civil servants in the service of the Province abrogated
the Tesildari Rules which \\'ere inconsistent with it and
cl. 15 (2) of the Transitory Order, 19%, did not save them.
Even if rl. 15 (2) preserved these Rules, the reference to the
Financial Commissioner th.rein had to be read as reference to the Governor in view of para. i of the Adaptation
Order. The Civil Service Rules framed by the Government in 1941 governed the conditions of service of Teh•ildars
and Naib Tehsildars and the Tehsildari Rules ceased to be operative from 1941 even if they continued to be effective till then in
vie\\• of the provisions of the Transitory Order.
From April I,
1953, the Punjab Civil Service Rules, 1953, were in foree
which applied to the case and the Financial Commission"
\¥as not sho\vn to be one of the authorities prescrib~d by the
Government in the rules regulating the appointment and
conditions of service of Tehs;ldars and Naih Teh•ildan.
C1nL APPELLATE JumsmcTroN : Civil Appeal
1960.
~o. 515 of
Appeal from the judgment and order dated
Septcm her 3, 1958, of tho Punjab High Court in
Letter8 Patent A ppcal No. 82 of J9ij7.
lihagat Singh Chau:lri ancl K. R. Choudhri, for
the appellant.
SW].
.
S. M. Sikri, Aduowte-Geneml for the State of
Punjab, Gop~l Singl1 and P. n. Menon, for the
rcilpondcnts.
HHi I. Dcccm her 11. The .Judgment of Gajondragadknr. Subba Rao, Hiclayatullah and Shah, JJ.,
was dcliverf'd by
SHAH, .J.-Sardar Gian Singh-hereinafter
Called the appellant-was recruited in I 92i as a
Naib Tehsildar m the Revenue department of the
._
Province of Punjab. He was confirmed in that • ·
rank m l!l39. In l!l46, he was promoted to the
rank of officiating Tehiildar and was posted as
-
3 S.C.R.
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
517
Tehsildar at Hansi in the district of Hissar on
September 22, 1947, and since then he held the post
of Tehsildar at diverse places.
On August 20, 1952, the appellant was served
with a charge sheet by the Financial Commissioner,
Punjab containing eleven heads of charges of
misappropriation, misconduct, irregularities and
dereliction of duties committed by him. The Deputy
Commissioner, Hissar was appointed to hold a
departmental enquiry into those charges. On
August 28, 1953, the n,ppellant was served with a
notice to show cause why on the findings recorded
by the enquiry officer, he should not be dismissed
from service. The appellant submitted his explanation. The Financial Commissioner by order dated
October 26, 1953 ordered that the appellant be
dismissed from service. An appeal preferred against
that order was dismissed and application to the
Government of Punjab to revise the order of the
appellate authority also proved infructuous. The
appellant then presented a petition under Art. 226
of the Constitution to the High Court of Punjab
for an order quashing the order of dismissal contending inter alia that (a) reasonable opportunity
was not given to the appellant either before the
enquiry officer or before the Financial Commissioner
to rebut the allegations contained in the charge
sheet, and (b) that the Financial Commissioner was
incompetent to pass the order of dismissal. Bishan
Na.rain, J., who heard the petition rejected the first
plea, but in the view of the learned Judge, the
Financial Commissioner ceased to have any power
to make rnles regnlating the appointment and dismissal of Tehsildars because of the amendment of
the Punjab Land Hevenue Act, 1887 by the Government of India (Adaptation of Indian Lawe) Order,
1937 and the authority derived by the Financial
Commissioner under those rules to dismiss Tehsildars
was also abrogated, and therefore the order of the
Financial Commissioner dated October 26, 1953
was void and of no effect. In appeal under cl. 10
1961
Gian Sinlh
v.
Tltt State of Punjab
Shah].
518
J9~1
Gian Si•ith
y,
Tiu Stutr of p,,,,jtzb
Shoh J.
SUPRE.\IE COlJRT REPORTS
(1962]
of th•· Letters Pat.mt, a Division .B<·nch of the
High nuurt reversed the order passed hy the Rishan
~arnin, .J. Th<' High Court hclcl th~,t. by virtue of
els. 9 anrl l 0 of tlw Gowrnment of India (Adaptation
of Indian Laws) Order', l!J37, the rules framed under
the Punjab Land lt('venuc Act, 1887 continued
to remain in op<,ration even after the Act was
amond,,<l hy the Adaptation of Indian Laws Order,
1937 and the Financial Commiosiun .. r rem:dned
inveHt<·d with tlw power to dismiHs th<, appellant
from sn\•ice. Th" High Court accordingly dismissed
the potition of the' :ippellant. The appellant h:ui
appt!aled tu this Conrt against the order of tho
High Court, with <'crtificates of fitnrs~ under
Art. 133 of the Constitution.
....
Section 9 of the Punjab Land I~ev<•nuo
Act, 1887, as it wa.;r originally enacted, stood a.s
follows :
"The Provincial Government "hall fix: the
number of Tehsildars and Naib Tchsildars to
be <Lppoint<-cl, and the Financial Commis~ioncr
may make ruli·s for thnir appointment and
dismiHsal".
Under s. 9 read with R. 28 oft.he Act, rules Wl'rc
framed in 1932 bv the Financial Commi&~ionrr
Punj:ib, and authority to appoint Tehsildars and
to remove them from ttervico w.·1s, by these rulee,
oonfcrr"d upon thn Financial CommisHioner. After
the enactment of the Govcrnmont of India Act, 1935,
s. 9 of the Pwijab Land Revenue Act was amended
by the Adaptation of Indian Laws Order, 19a7, and
the power of the Financial CommiHsioncr to mako
rules under B. 9 was abrogated by t lw deletion of
the- words in that section following the word
"appointed". &,ction 28 which authorised the
Financial CommisHioner to make rules to rcgulato
appointments, duties, l'molumcntfi, µuniHhmcnt<i etc.
of officers amouget others of Kanungos, Zaildars,
Inamda.rs and village officers, wa.s also a.mended
... ..
,. ,
..
I
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
519
and that power was entrusted to the Provincial
Government. Undoubtedly, by the amendment of
s. 9, the Financial Commissioner was deprived of
the power to make rules for appointment and
removal of Tehsildars and Naib Tehsildars, and on
account of the repeal, except as to transactions past
and completed, the power may in the absence of a
provision to the contrary, be considered as if it
had never existed. But the vitality of the Tebsildari
Rules and of the powers of the authorities competent
thereunder after the Government of India Act, 1935
was enacted, rested upon certain provisions made
by virtue of the authority conferred by that Act.
By s.310 of the Act, to facilitate the transition from
the Government of India Act, 1915 and from the
provisions of Part XIII of the Act of 193fi to the
provisions of Part II, power was conferred upon
His Majesty, by Order-in-Council among others to
direct that the provisions of the Government of
India Act, 1935, shall, during such limited period as
may be specified in the order, have effect subject
to such adaptations and modifications as may be so
specified. In exercise of this power, on July 3, 1936,
the Government of Indirt (Commencement and
Transitory Provisions) Order, 193G was promulgated
and by cl. 15(2) it was provided:
-
"Uutil other provision is made under the
new Act, the conditions of service applicable
to any person or any class of persons appointed or to be appointed to serve His Majesty
in a civil capacity in fodia shall be the same
as were applicable to that person or, as the
case may be, to persons of that class immediately before the commencement of Part III
of the new Act."
:i
~,
By cl. l2(d) of the Adaptation of Indian Laws
Order, 193 i issued in exercise of authority granted
by s. 293, it wa~ provided, in so far as it is material,
that:
1961
Gian Singh
v.
The State of Punj.si
Sh•h ].
520
SUPRE~IE OOURT REPORTS
(1962)
"No repeal effected by this order shall
affect
the operation of sub-paragraph (2) of
GimSinth
v.
·paragraph fifteen of the Government of India
Thi State of Punjab,
(Commencement and Transitory Provisions)
Shah ]. , ,
Order, 1936."
'·
· By the comblned operation of cl. 15(2) of the
' Commencement. and Transitory Provisions Order,
. 1936 and. the . Ada.ptation of Indian Laws Order,
,· 1937, the conditions ·.of service applicable to civil
servants continued to<remain unaltered, until other
/I
:·provisions were made under the Government of
j
India Act, 1935. Again, the Adaptation of Indian
.Laws Order, 1937 expressJy·provided by-01. 9 that
.the rules framed under the Act-adapted or modi. fied-shall not be rendered invalid. -By that clause
l'
which provided :
"The provisions of this order whiCh adapt
or modify Indian laws so as to· alter the
manner in ·which, the authority by which,
or• the law under or in accordance with
which, any powers are· exercisable, shall ·not
· render-· invalid · any notification, · order,
commitment; attachment, bye-law, rule or
regulation duly ·made or issued, or anything
duly done,·before the commencement 'of ·this
order; ... ·~~················~·····4·····''
Notwithstanding the abrogation of the powers of
the Financial Commissioner ·to frame rules, the
Tehsildari Rules,_1932 remained in force.
1961
---~-----
-
/
· Ancl by cl. 10 which provided:
~'Save as provided by this order, all
·powers 'which under any law in force in
·British 1India, or in any part of British India,
were immediately before the commencement
. of part III of the Government of India Act,
' 1935 vested in, or exercisable by, any person
or authority shall continue to be so vested or
exercisable until other provision is made by
\";-:
~
;i
S.C.R, SUPREME COURT REPORTS
521
some legislature or authority empowered to
regulate the matter in question."
The authority of the Financial Commis_sioner under
the mles which remained in force by virtue of cl. 9
was exercisable except as provided by the Adaptation of Indian Laws order, 1937. By s. 241 (2)
of the Government of India Act, 1935, the conditions of service, in the case of persons serving in
connection with the affairs of a Province, were to
be such as may be prescribed by rules made by
the Governor, or by persons authorised to make
rules for that purpose. But this provision was,
till other provisions were made, subject to cl. 15 (2)
of the Commencement and Transitory Provisions
Order, 1935. Clause 7 of the Adaptation of
Indian Laws Order on which reliance was placed
by counsel for the appellant in support of his
contention that the Governor alone could exercise
the powers of dismissal under the Rules because he
was the corresponding authority, does not also
assist the appellant. The clause applies only to
those cases where an authority competent at the
date of passing of any Indian law, to exercise any
powers or authorities or discharge any functions,
ceased to exist and a corresponding new authority
was constituted by or under any Part of the
Government of India Act, 1935 : the clause did not
apply where only the powers of an authority were
vested in another authority, the former authority
not otherwise ceasing to function. The condition
of service of civil servants having remained unaltered even after the Government of India Act, 1935
was brought into operation by virtue of the
Commencement and Transitory Provisions Order
1936, and the Adaptation of Indian Laws Order
h~ving made express provision saving the rules as
well as the authority granted under the rules
to the Financial Commissioner, the order of the
Financial Commissioner dismissing the appellant
from service was not unauthorised.
1961
Gian Sinth
v.
The State •f
Punjalt
Sh.J.J.
522
Gi1111 Sin:h
v.
TM St•lc •!
PurJ•i
Sh•h ].
SUPREME COURT HEPOHTS
[1962]
The contention of counsel for the appellant IC
that by tho enactment of s. 241 of the Government
of India Act, Hl35, civil scrvant8 serving a. Province
could be dismi~se<l after that Act was brought into
operation only by the Governor of the ProYince and
by no other authority has therefore no fo rec.
Counsel submitted that in anv event, fre11h
rules govorning the civil snviccs ·in the Punjab
having beon frnmPd in l!J.11 by the Gov<'rnrnent
of th" Province of Punjab, the Tchsildari Rules,
I!l32 even if they w1.•rc· not superseded by the amendment made by the Adaptation of Indian Laws
Order, I 937 in the Punjab Land Hcvcrnie Act, 1887
stood expressly repealed, and the powers of the
Financial Commissioner to dismi8s a. Tchsilda.r
could not thereafter, be exercised. But the plea.
that fresh rules wern framed in Hl41 in superncssion
of the Punjab Teshsildari Rule8, 1932 was not
adv1mced in the High Court. In I 941, fresh Civil
Services Rules applicable to the Punjab were undoubtrrlly promulgated; it is however unnecessary
to consider whether under the Punjab Civil Service
Rules, 1941 th<~ Governor alone waR competent to
dismiss from S!'rvice a public servant of the Provincial Service or subordinate Sen· ice or officers
holding special posts or any other Government servant or class of Government servants to whom
thoee rules applied. It. was exprcRsly enacted in
r. 1.4 that the Civil Services Rules were not to
apply to any person for whose appointments and
conditions of service special provision was made
by or under any law for the time \,ping in fore!'.
Special provision did iu fa<·t f'Xist for the appointments and Conditic>n of sen ice of Tehsildars under
the law for the time hcing in force and those
rules arc not shown to han: been superseded
or abrogated by the Civil Services Rules. Counsel
for the appellant asscrt<:cl that Tchsildars be- ·~
longed to the Subordinate Services, Class III, and
the rules framed in 1941 under s. 241 of the GovernmeH t of India Act superseded tho Tchsildari Rules,
I
•
•
I
I
>
3 S.C.R.
).
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
523
of 1932. The Advocate General appearing for the
State of Punjab submitted that Tehsildars were
GieJn Sin:h
not included in the Subordinate Services, because Tht Stattv.•f 1'1mja.i
no notification in that behalf was issued. As we
Sh•h ].
have already observed, the question as to the .
effect of the rules framed in 1941 under s. 241 of
the Government of India Act was never raised or
argued before Bishan Narain, J., nor before the
High Court in appeal. It is difficult for this Court
to entertain any plea depending for its adjudications on notifications said to be issued by the
Government from time to time, raised for the first
time in appeal, when such notifications have never
been brought to our notice.
On the whole, we are of the view that the
record does not support the contention that the
Punjab 'l'ehsildari Rules were not in operation at
the date of dismissal. There is also nothing to
show that the Financial Commissioner was not
invested at the material time with the power to dismiss a Tehsildar.
The appeal therefore fails and is dismissed
with costs.
RAGHUBAR DAYAL, J.-I regret my inability Rqhu,ar Dtr.,J•l J.
to agree with the view that the Punjab Tehsildari
Rules of 1932 applied to the service of Tehsildars
and Naib Tehsildars in 1953.
The appellant was an officiating Tehsildar in
1953 in the State of Punjab, when he was dismissed
by the Financial Commissioner, Punjab, on October
26, 1953. Having failed to get the order changed
as a result of his appeal and a revision to the
Government, he field a petition under Art. 226 of
the Constitution in the High Court of Pnnjab and
prayed for his reinstatl1ment from the date of his
dismissal by the issue of an appropriate writ.
Among the grounds in support of his prayer, the
petition mentioned that the Financial Commissioner was not competent authority to order the
dismissal of a Tehsildar in view of Rule 2.14 of the
Punjab Civil Services Rules, (hereinafter called
the Civil Services Rules), read with Chapter XV,
•
524
1961
Gitm Sinzh
v.
Th. State of l'unj•I
R11Jwhar D11J·a{ ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
the Rules being framed under Art.
Constitution.
[1962)
30!l of the
It wall contended on behalf of the Stat-0 that
the petitioner's terms aml conditions of service were
governed by the Punjab Tehsildari Ru lcs, Hl32
(hereinafter called the Tchsildari Rules) which
empowered the Financial Co.lmllissioner to appoint
and dismiss Tchsildars.
Bishan Kamin, J., who heard the petition,
allow!'cl it holding that the Tc·hsilclari Hules ceasPd to
operate since the amcn<lmcnt of~. !l of the Punjab
Land Revenue Act, 188i (Act XVII of 1887), hereinafter called the Revenue Act), by the Government
of India (Adaptation of Indian Laws) Order, l!l3i,
(hcrei"aft.er called the adaptation Order), which
dclctl'd that part of the .section which empowered
the Financial Commissioner to make rules for the
appointment and removal of Tehsil<lars and Na.ib
Tehsildars, and in the exercise of which power tho
Tehsildari Rulos had been made bv the Financial
Commissioner, there being nothing in the Government of India Act, 1935, (hereinafter ca.lied the
Act) or in the Adaptation Order proscrving the
validity of these Rules notwithstanding the ·repeal
of the relevant provision in s. 9 of the Revenue Act.
He observed in his order :
J.
0
•
"It is nobody's case tha.t the Punjab
Civil Service Rules made after the 1935 Act
Contain any provision which keeps these rules -"
of 1932 alive an<l in force. Neither is it the
respondent's case that after the amendment
of Section !l of the Punjab Act tho Governor
or the Provincial Government ever delegated
the power of appointments and dismissals of
Teh8ild11rs and ~aib Tchsildars to the Financial Commissioner."
'l'he Tchsi ldari Rules, therefore, according to him, ,.}
being inoperative after lhc commencement of the
Act, could not have become operative under the
•
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
525
Constitution, by virtue of the provisions of
Art. 372 of the Constitution. Holding that the Civil
Services Rules which governed all States services
governed the services of Tehsildars and Naib
Tehsildars and that nothing in those Rules em·
powered the Financial Commissioner to appoint or
dismiss a Tehsildar, he allowed the petition,
ordering that the appellant's dismissal was void
and of no legal effects.
The State preferred a Letters Patent Appeal.
The grounds of appeal mentioned that the Tehsildari Rules were in force on January 25, 1950, in
view of ss. 292 and 293 of the Act and also s. 18 (3)
of the Indi1tn Independence Act, and thereafter
under Art. 372 of the Constitution, and that the
finding that the conditions of service of Tehsildars
were governed by the Civil Services Rules was
wrong.
The appellate judgement considered that the
Tehsildari Rules were made either in the exercise
of the powers conferred by the Government of
India Act, 1919, or in the exercise of the powers
conferred by the Revenue Act, and came to the
conclusion that in the former case they. continued
to be effective rules in view of s. 276 of the Act,
and Art. 313 of the Constitution, it being not
shown that those rules had been replaced by another set of rules or those rules were inconsistent
with the provisions of the Act or the Constitution and that in the latter case the rules continued to be in force by virtue of paragraphs 9 and
10 of the Adaptation Order which made it clear
that the Financial Commissioner who had the
power to appoint or dismiss a Tehsildar continued
to exercise those powers, those powers having been
not abrogated or withdrawn. The Letters Patent
Appeal was consequently allowed and the writ
petition was dismissed. It is against this order
that the appellant has filed this appeal by certificate granted by the High Court.
1961
Gian Sin:h
v.
1'he State of Pu'!jai
Raihuh•r D•v•l ].
526
Jlfl
Gian Sinzh
v.
Tht St•tr 1,f Pu'!J·••
lf.a1J111••r Dtt,"l•l J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962)
It is contended for the appellant that the Teh·
eildari Hules ceased to be operative from the commencement of the Act and in Any case, ceased to
be opcrati,·c from the 1st of April 1941 when the
Civil Services Rules madt> by the Governor came
into force and th11t therefore the Financial Com· .
missioner was not competent to dismiss the
appellant.
It has not been urged for the respondent in
this Court that the Tchsildari Rules were fram<'d
under the Govemm<'nt of India Act of 1919 and
that therefore thev continued to he in force i11
view of s. 27G of the Act, and Art. :ll 3 of the
Constitution. The cont!'ntion, even if it had hr!'ll
raised, coul<l not h:n-c succeeded, aR a Rule
empowering a financial Commissioner to appoint
and dismiss Tehsildars could not have been consistent with the provisio1rn of s. 241 of the Act
which laid down that, except as expressly provided by the Act, appointments to the Civil Herviccs
or any civil po8ts under the Crown in India would
be made in the c11so of ser1•ices of a province
and posts in connection with the affairn of a pro·
vinco by the Go,·crnor or such persons as he may
direct.
It hM not been urged before us, that the
Gov<>mment did, subsequent to the {'nforccm<'nt of
the Act pass any order <'mpowcring the Financial
Commissioner to appoint and dismiss Tchsildars.
The order of the Financial Commissioner
was supported on behalf of the State on the pro·
visions of paragraphs fl and 10 of the Adaptation
Order of rn:n and rule I. 4 of th<· Civil Services
Rules, 1941, and at the further hearing, in connection with the effect of paragraph 7 of that Order
to which no roforcnce hacl been made at the first
hearing, on the provisions of cl. (2) paragraph lfi
of Government of India (Commencement and
Transiton Provisions) Order, 1936 (hereinafter
1
38.C.R.
SUP~EME
COURT REPORTS
527
called the Transitory Order), and paragraph
12 of the Adaptation Order. The contention
really is that the Tehsildari Rules continued to be
valid both in view of paragraphs 9 and IO of the
Adaptation Order and the Transitory Order till
such time as the Governor made the new rules
and that the Tehsildari Rules continued to be in
-( force after the 1st of April 1941 since the Tehsildars were persons for whose appointment and
conditions of service special provision had been
made under those rules.
J(
I shall first deal with the effect of the provisions of the Adaptation Order on the Tehsildari
Rules.
Section 292 of the Act reads :
"Notwithstanding the repeal by this Act
of the Government of India Act, but subject
to the other provisions of this Act, all the
Jaw in force in British India immediately
before the commencement of part III of this
Act shall continue in force in British India
until altered or repealed or amended by
a competent Legislature or other competent
authority."
Section 293 .of the Act reads :
"His Majesty may by Order in Council
to be made at any time after the passing
of this Act proviie that, as from such date
as may be specified in the Order, any law in
force in British India or in any part of
British India shall until repealed or amended by a competent Legislature or other
competent authority, have effect subject
to such adaptations and modifications as
appear to His Majesty to be necessary or expedient for bringing the proTisions of that
law into accord with the provisions of this
Act and, in particular, into accord with the
1911
Gian Sinth
v.
Tht Statt 1/
Pwijafl
528
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1962]
l!MI
provisions thereof which reconstitute under
difforent names governments and authorities
in India and prescribe the distribution of
Tlit Stalt 1J
P'llnja;
legislative and executive powers between
the
Federation and the Provinces :
R.,Jzi;~ar D•yt:l ].
Provided that no such law as aforesaid
shall be made applicable to any Federated
State by an Order in Council marlc under
this rnction.
In this section the expression 'law' does
not include an Act of Parliament, but incJu.
dt·s any orclinance, Order, byc-la.w, rule or regulation having in British India. the force of law.
It is in tho exercise of the power conferred by thi11
section that tho Adaptation Order was issued. Such
provisions of the existing Ja.w were to continue in
force as were consist<mt with the Act. Power was
vested in His Majesty under s. 293 of the Act to
modify the provisions of existing l1tws in such manner as may be ncces~ry for bringing them into
accord with the proYisions of tho Act and, in parti·
cular, to bring them into accord with the pro\"isions
of the new Act which ro-constituted under different
names, governments and authorities in Im!i1t.
Gian Sinth
v.
Paragraph 3 of the Adaptation Order provided
that tlw laws mentioned in the Schedules would
have effect subject to the adaptations and modifications directed by those Schedules until they are
repealed or amended by a competent authority or
by a competent Legislature.
Section 9 of the Revenue Act was modified
Before such modificatione, it read:
"The Provincial Government. sh11.ll fix the
number of Tehsil<larR and Naib Tebsildars to
he appointed and the Financial Commissioner
mAY make rules for their appointment and
.
l" •
"'"''''lVQ
by the Adaptation Order.
-)I.
-
•
~$.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
02!)
'£he Adaptation Order substituted the word 'State'
for the word 'Provincial' and omitted the word11
after the word 'appointed.' It follows that the
power of the Fin.ancial Commissioner to make rules
for the appointment of Tehsildars and Naib Tehsildars did not exist any longer, the provisions for
such :i. power having been repealed by the Adaptation Order. The consequence of such a repeal is
that such a power would be deemed to have never
existed in the Financial Commissioner and that the
rules framed by him would be deemed to be rules
framed without any jurisdiction to make them.
This is not really disputed and has the support of
the observations in Watson v. Winch('). 'fhe Revenue
Act, after amendment, did not provide about the
appointment of Tehsildars and Naib Tehsildars.
This must have been in view of the statutory provi·
sion existing for the purpose in sub-s. 1 of s. 241 of
the Act whose relevant portion is:
"Except as expressly provided by this
Act, appointments to the civil services of, and
civil posts under, the Crown in India, shall,
after the commencement of Part III of thi1
Act, be made:x
x
x
x
x
x
(b) in the case of services of province, and posts in connection with the
affairs of a province, by the Governor or
such person as he may direct."
It is to be noticed that the modifications made by
the Adaptation Order to ss. 7 and 8 deleted the
provisions empowering the State Government to remove the officers it could appoint under the provisions of those sections.
Paragraph 9 of the Adaptation Order
reads: "The provisions of this Order which
. adapt or modify Indian laws so as to alter thr
manner in which, the authority by which, or
the law under or in accordance with which ,
(1)
(1916) I K. B. 688.
1961
Gian Sinzh
v.
Tiu Staie of Pw:ijab
Ra/l,OObar J>ayal ].
530
1961
CimiSinth
v.
'l'ht SWe of Punja)
11.thub" Dayal ].
SUPHEi\IE COURT REPORTS
[1962j
any powers arc cxcrcisRble, shall not render ,..
invalid any notification, order, commitment,
attachment, bye-law, rule or regulation duly
made or issuer!, or anything duly rlone, before
the commencement of this order; and any
such notification, ordC'r, commitment, attachment, bye-law, rule, regulation or thing may be
revoked, varier! or undone in the like manner
to the like extent and in the like circumstanc<'s as if it had been made, is8ued or done
after the commencement of 1his Order by the
competent authority and under and in accor·
dance with the provisions then applicable to
such a case."
The A'la.ptation Order modifies the law under ••
which the Tehsilda.ri Rules were framed. The result
of the pro·l"isions of paragraph !I of Adaptation
Order is that the Tehsildari Rules were not renrlerod
inn1lid, and that, for the purpose of revoking, varyin<>
or undoing the rules, they were to be dcem1>d to b;:
ma.de undor the Act.. There is nothing in this paragraph t~ provide thnt the rules must continue in
the same form in which they exist, even if they
were inconsistent with tho provisions of the Act. •
Such could not have been provided by the Adaptation Order and has not been provided. The provisions of this paragraph apply when specified modifications aro ma.de by the Order not when the Act
itself affcctl! similar· provisions of the Indian L11w.
If something contrary to the rule has already been
provided in the act, no further occasion for making II.
that change in the rule by a competent Lcgisla.turo
or authority a.rises. A subsequent change by a
competent authority is contemplated only when no
chauge has already been made in those rules on
account of thn prodsions of the Act. The Tchsildari Rules therefore became inoperative in BO far
as they provid<'d that the Financial Commissioner
could appoint and dL~miss Tchsildars and Naib, •
T<'hsildara, llR such a provision was inconsistent
...
38.d.R.
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS
531
I. with the provisions of s. 241 of the Act, which vests
the power of appointment in the Governor or in any
other person in accordance with his directions. The
power of appointment carries with it the power of
dismissal.
In Pradyat Kumar v. Chief Justice of Calcutta(')
this Court had to consider whether the Chief Justice
-( of the Calcutta High Court had power to dismiss
an employee of the High Court. In this connection,
it was not disputed that the Chief Justice was the
.;
authority for appointing the appellant. But it was
contended that he had not the power to dismiss.
The contention was that the appellant was a public
servant governed by the Civil Services (Classifica__. tion, Control and Appeal) Rules of 1930, as
' amended from time to time and that those rules
continued to apply even after the Government of
India Act, 1935, and later when the Constitution
of India came into force. It was not disputed that
'dismissal' was a matter falling within 'condition
of service' of a public servant as held by the
Privy Council in North West Frontier Province v.
Suraj Narain Anand('), and that the power of making
_. rules relating to the conditions of service of staff of
the High Court was vested in the Chief Justice of
the High Court under s. 242(4) taken withs. 241 of
the Act and also under Art. 229(2), of the constitution. It was however contended that the Chief
Justice of the High Court bad not framed any such
,-._ rules and that therefore, by virtue of s. 276 of the
Act and Art. 313 of the constitution, the Civil
Services Rules continued to apply to the appellant.
In considering the contention raised, this Court
11aid at page 288 :
"It will be noticed that cl. 8 (of the
Letters Patent of the High Court, 1865, as
amended in 1919) speci:fically vests in the
\
Chief Justice the power of appointment, but
makes no mention of the power of removal
(I) A~I.R. 1956 S.C. 235.
(2) A.J.R, 1949 P,C. 112.
· 1961
Giari $ing'1
v.
The State of hnj•b
Raghuba\ Da,Yal ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1961
GiaJt. Sinth
v.
Tli• Slat"/ PWtjab
Rag/lobar D...,.J ].
[1962]
•
or of making reglllutions or provisions. Rut
it is obviouR from the last portion of cl. 4 that
such power was taken 1o he implicit under
cl. 8 and presumably as arising from the powor
of appointment."
It was again said at the same page in considering
the powers of the Svprcme Court of Calcutta under
the Charter of 177+ :
•
"The power of removal or of taking other
disciplinary action as regard~ such appointees
was not. in tBrms granted. Rut there is
historical evidence to show that the power of
appointment conferred under tho Charter was
always understood as comprising the above ~
powers."
And a.gain, it wa.s said :
"Thus it is clear that both under tho
Charter of the Supreme Court as well as
under the Letters Patent of the High Court,
the power of appointment was throughout
understood as \'esting in the High Court or
the Chief Justice, the complete administrative•
and disciplinary control over its staff, inclu.
cling the power of dismissal."
It was further said, at pa.ge 201:
"It must be mentioned, at this stage, that
so far as the power of dismissal is concerned,
tho position under the Constitution of ID~
is not open to any argument or doubt.
Article 229(1) which in terms vcst,s the power
ofmppointm~nt in the Chief .Justice is equally
cffocti<:c to yest in him the power of
<lismissal.
This results from s. 16, General Clauses Act
which, by virtue of Article 367( I) of th~
Constitution applies to tho construction of tho
word 'appointment' in Art. 229(1). Section
16( l) General Clauses Act, clearly provides
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
533
1961
that the power of 'appointment' includes the
Gian Sin~h
power 'to suspend or dismiss'.
v.
Paragraph 7 of the Adaptation Order reads:
The Sia" of Punjab
--·
"Subject to the forgoing provisions of this Raghubar Dayal J.
order, any reference by whatever form of
,.,-ords in any Indian Law in force immediately
before the commencement of this order to an
authority competent at the date of the pasliing of that law to exercise any powers or
authorities, or discharge any functions, in any
part of British India shall, where a correspon ·
ding new authority has been constituted by
or under any Part the Government of India
Act, 1935, for the time being in force, have
effect until duly repealed or amended as if it
were a reference to that new authority."
I am of opinion that in view of paragraph 7
of the Adaptation Order quoted above, reference to
to the Financial Commissioner in the Tehsildari
Rules dealing with the appointment and removal of
Tehsildars aud N aib Tehsildars be taken to be a
reference to the new authority constituted under the
A. Act for their appointment and dismissal.
The
authority for appointment and dismissal was the
new
Financial
Commissioner. Corresponding
authority, i. e., a new authority whirh has power
to appoint and dismiss the Tehsildars and Naib
Tehsildars, is the Governor, in view of s. 241 of the
Act, and therefore, reference to the Financial
~ Commissioner in the Rules should be taken to be a
reference to the Governor, or to such authority as
be appointed by the Governor for the purpose, so
long as those rules continued to be in force subsequent to the commencement of part III of the Act,
i.e., till they are repealed or amended by new rnles.
I do not agree with the contention for the State
that since the office of the Financial Commissioner
{ did continue to exist; the provisions of paragraph
'7 of the Adaptation Order cannot be applied. The
worq 'qew' wjtq reference to the authority, doe~
SUPP.E~IE COURT REPORTS
1981
GiaSirz~
v..
Tiu Sl4te of P<Jnj11b
[l!l62]
not necessarily lead to the conclusion that the office "
in which a particular authority was veeted under
the old law must cease to exist and that it is only
thC'n that any reference to that old authority
would be taken to Le a reference to the ne'"
authority on which that power is conferred. Jn
m,v opinion, the expression 'corresponding new
authority' means a new authoritv on which the •
power \l:hich was exercised Ly the ~&rlier authority
harl been conferred.
Paragraph lO of the Adaptation Order rt'a.ds:
"Save as provided by this order, all
powers which ur,der any law in force in
British India, or in any part of British India,
were immcdiatclv boforo the commencement
of Part III of th~ Government of India Act,
1935, vested in, or exercisa.Lle by any pcreon
or authority shall continuo to Le so vested
or exercisable until othor provision is made
Ly some legislature or authority empowered
.to regulate the matter in question."
•
·-
The only paragraph which has a bearing on the .,
exercise of powers in this Order is paragraph 7.
The result of reading paragraphs 7 and I 0 together
is that if a new authoritv had been constitutt>d
for the exercise of any powers or discharge of any
functions, those powers will no more remain vested
in the old authority, but when no such correspondin"'e new authoritv
• has been constituted, the old .,,
authority will continue to exercise those powers till
other provision is validly made.
I am therefore of opinion that the provisions of
paragraph IO of the Order arc not to Le constructed
in a. wav to make tho old authority continue to
exercise that power, when the Government of India
Act itself constitutes another authority for that L
purpose. If the Adaptation Order be so conRtrucd, ,.
the adaptation made by the Order would hardly
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS - 535
-:t be in furtherance of the provisions of s. 293 of the
Act.
1911
Gian Si.nth
v.
In this connection I may quote the very
apposite observations in Pradyat Kumar v. Chief
Justice of Calcutta (1) at page 290 :
"The continued application of the Civil
Services Rules without such adaptation
would result in the anomalous position, that
although the 1935 Act specifically vests in the
Chief Justice the power of appointment and
of framing rules regulating conditions of service including the power of dismissal and
hence thereby indicates the Chief Justice as
the authority having the power to exercise
disciplinary control, he has no such disci·
plinary control merely because he did not
choose to make any fresh rules and was con·
tent with the continued application of the old
rules."
The same anomaly would arise under the present
case if in spite of the Act vesting the power of
appointment and of making rules in the Governor,
he be deemed to have lost that power merely
because he did not frame any fresh rules.
Section 310 of the Government of India
Aot, 1935 reads thus :
"( 1) Whereas difficulties may arise in
relation to the transition from the provisions
of the Government of India Act, to the provisions of this Act, and in relation to the
transition from the provisions of Part XIII
of this Act to the provisions of Part II of
this Act :
And whereas the nature of those difficulties, and of the provision which should
be made for meeting them, cannot at the
date of the passing of this Act be folly for<:•
seen:
\I) A.I.R. 1956 S.C. 2~1i:
The State of Pajab
Raghuliar D•yal J.
536
19~/
Gian Sin.(h
V.
Tiu Sta!t of Prmjal
Ra:huO•r Da)·•l ].
SUPRE!llE COURT REPORTS
[1962)
Now therefore, for the purpose of facilitating each of the said transitions His l\Iajesty
may by Order in Council-(a) direct that this Act and any
provisiom of the Government of India
Act still in force shall, during Ruch limited pcriocl n.s may he specified in the
Orclcr, have effect subject to such adaptations nncl notifications as may he so
specified :
(h) make, with respect to a limited
period so specified such temporary provision as he thinks fit for ensuring that,
while the transition is being effected and
during tbc period immediately following
it, there are availn.ble to all governments
in India nnd Burma sufiicient revenue to
enable the business of those governments
to he carried on ; and
(c) make, such other temporary proviRions for tho purpose of removing any
such difficulties as aforesaid as may be
specified in the Order.
(2) No Order in Council in relation to
the transition from the provisions of Part
XIII of this Act to the provisions of Part II
of this Act shall be made undn this section
after tho expiration of six months from the
establiohmcnt of tho Federation, and no
other Order in Council shall be made under
this section after tho expiration of six months
from the commencement of Part III of this
Act."
J·
•
Paragraph I:) o{ tho Transitory Ordrr rcad11 :
"( l) For a period of twolvo months from
the date of the commencement of Part III of
the new Act a person who immediately before
the said date was holding an office under th8
Crown in rntli11o shall not be disqualitied
•
L
3.S.0.R.
SUPERME COURT REPORTS
537
I
from continuing to hold that office by reason of the fact that he is not a British subject
and that no declaration entitling him to
hold the office has been made under
section two hundred and sixty-two of the new
Act.
(2) Until other provision is made under
the new Act, the conditions of service applicable to any person or any class of persons
appointed or to be appointed to serve His
Majesty in a civil capacity in India shall
be the same as were applicable to that
person or, as the case may be, to
persons of that class immediately before
the commencement of Part III of the new
Act."
The provisions of cl. (2) of the above paragraph are
in furtherance of the provisions of cl. (c) of sub-s.( 1)
of s. 310, and not in view of cl. (a) of sub-s. ( 1)
of s. 310, as those provisions do not direct in
any way that any provisions of the Government of
India Act 1935, or of the Government of India Act
of 1919 would have effect subject to certain specified adaptations and modifications and during any
limited period. It follows that these provisions
do not affect the operation of s. 241 ( 1) of the
Act empowering the Government to make appointment. In fact its operation could be affected
only by any express provision in the Act itself.
Power of appointment includes power of dismissal.
It is true that the conditions of service include the provisions prescribing the circumstances
in which a government servant be dismissed or
removed from service. But the previous conditions
of service will continue only till such time as other
provision is made under the Act. When the Act
already provided by s. 241 (1) that the Governor
would be the appointing authority, the natural
consequence of which was that the Governor would
pe the 11-uthority to dismiss, there was nothing in
1961
Gian Singh
v.
The State of Punjab
Raihubar Dayal J.
538
19~/
Gian Sin:h
v.
Thi Statt o_f PtJ'IJah
RaghrJ;ar Da;·al ].
SUPRE:\IE COURT REPORTS
[1962]
tho provisions of this sub-paragraph for tho conditions of service relating to dismissal to be opora.tivo
sn bsequent to the coming into force of tho Aot.
E1·en if it be construed that the provisions of this
sub paragraph justified the continuance of the
Teh~ildari Rules till other pro\·isions were made
undm· the Act referoncc to the Financial Commistioner in these Huleti will be taken to ho reference
to the Governor in \·iew of paragraph 7 of the
Adaptation Order ns already held by me. It is
contended for the State that nothing in the Adaptation Order will affect these provisions in vim1'
of el. (d) of paragraph 12 of the Adaptation Order
whieh reads :
"(For tho avoidance of doubt it is herebv
declared that)•
no repeal effected by this order shall affect
the operation of sub.paragraph (2) of paragraph fifteen of the Government of India
(Commencement and Transitory Provisions)
Order, I 936."
This clause simply provides for the provisions of
snb·paragraph(2) of paragraph lG of the Transitory
order to he not affected hy any repe:il made by the
Adaptation Order, but docs not provide that the
provisions of this sub-paragrnph would not he
affected by the pro1'i8ions of the Act itself or of the
Adaptation Order which do not repeal any law. It
follow~ therefore that in the construction of the
rules !:tying down the conditions of service, the
provisions of paragraph 7 of the Adaptation Orcler
which do not repeal any law will have to be applied
and that therefore reference to the Fin:incial
Commissioner in these rules will he tnken to be a.
reference to the Governor.
E1'cn if the contention for the State about
the effl'ct of snb-paragrnph (2) of paragraph 15 of
the Tramitory Or<l<'r imrl of the \'arions paragrnphs
of the Adaptation Order be accept<'d, the Tchsildari
Rules will continue only ti!) other ruJes are µiad~
..
'
.. _
-.
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
539
1961
by the Governor in the exercise of his power under
a.241(2) of the Act.
Gian Singh
v.
The Governor of Punjab made the Punjab
Civil Services Rules under s. 241 of the Govern·
ment of India Act, 1935. These rules came into
force from April l, 1941. The learned Single Judge
held that these rules applied to the appellant and
said that it was nobody's case that the Civil Service
Rules, made after the 1935 Act, contained any
provisions which kept those Rules of 1932 alive
and in force, The judgment under appeal does not
eay to the contrary. In fact it makes no reference
to these rubs at all.
The learned Advocate General for the S~te
submitted that these Rules did not apply to the
appellant in view of cl.(ii) of r. 1.4. I do not agree
with this contention. Rule 1.2 reads :
....'
"(a) Except as otherwise provided in rule
1.4 infra, or in any other rule or rules, these
ru Jes shall apply to all Government servants
belongi~g to the categories mentioned below,
who are under the administrative control
of the Punjab Government and whose pay
is debitable to the revenue of the Punjab:(1) Members of Provincial Services;
(2)
Members of Subordinate Services ;
(3) Holders of Special Posts; and
(4) Any other Government servant or
class of Governme!lt servant~ to whom the
competent authority may, by general or
spemal order, make them applicable.
(b)
These rules shall also apply-
(1) to the persons serving on (i)the staff
attached to the High Court, Lahore and (ii)
Secretarial staff of. the Governor, in' respect
of whom powers to frame rules have been
-
•
•
•
'
•
<
'
'
•
"
The State of Punjab
Ra:hubar Dayal}.
SUPREl\IE COURT REPORTS
19Gl
Gian Singh
v.
T1te Stttte of Punjab
Raz/.,la' Dayal J.
[1962]
vest~d in the Chief J usticc and the governor
under sections 242 (4) and 305 ( 2) of the
Government of India Act, l!J35, respectively; and
(2) to tho subordinat-0 ranks of tho Punjab Police forces appointee! under special
Acts relating to those forces in so far 11.'3
they arc not inconsistent with the provisions in those Acts (virle s. 2·13 of the
Gov~rnmcnt of India Act, l 93;i )".
Rule 1.3 provides for the competent authority to
make rules inconsistent with these mies in certain
condition~ by agreement with tho person appointed.
Rulo 1.4 reads.
"Theso rules shall not apply to(i) Any Government servant between
whom and the Gevernmcm , a specific
contract or agrccmont suboists in respect
of auy matter dealt with herein to the
extent upto which specific 1n·oyision is
made in the contrnct or :igrccmcnt ( vide
rule 1.3);
(ii) any person for whose appointment and conditions of s"n·ice special
provision is made by or under any law
for the time being in force; uml
(iii) any Government servant or
cll\8s of Go\'ernmcnt serv3nts to whom
the competent authority may, by general
or special order, direct that they sh~ll
not apply in whole or in part. One of
such classes of Government servants is
that employed only occasiormlly or which
is subject to discharge a.t one month's
notice or less, A list of such Government servants is given in Appendix!!."
Reliance for tho State, as already mentioned, is
placed on cl. (ii) of thj.a rqJe, lt i• coqtcndoll
• -
-
"'
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
54i
1961
_..,
I
that the provisions under the Tehsildari Rules for
the appointment and conditions of service of Tehsildars and N aib Tehsildars amount to special provisions made by or under any law for the time
being in force. If rules existed for any service,
and I presume that they existed for almost all
services, prior to the coming into force of the Civil
Punjab, the
interpretation
Services Rules,
sought to be put on cl. (ii) would make such rules
special provisions contemplated by that clause, and
to my mind, the Civil Services Rules would not
then apply to most of the services and persons
holding posts. Such could not have been the
intention of the rule-making power, and such a
construction ought not to be put on cl. (ii), unless
there be something which compels such a construction to be placed on this clause, and which I do not
find anywhere in these rules. I am of opinion
that Tehsildars and Naib Tehsildars do not come
under this exception. They, according to the Tehsildari Rules, constitute the Punjab Service of Tehsildars and N aib Tehsildars. Clause (ii) does not
refer to services as such, but contemplates individual persons for whose appointment special provision is made by or under any law for the time
being in force. It speaks of special provisions with
respect to a person. I find it difficult to hold that
rules applicable to a service come within the special
provisions applicable to a member of that service.
The special provision contemplated by this clause
ought to be made under some law or under the
provisions of some law which has force when the
Civil Services Rules apply to the services and that
person. To hold that the Tehsildari Rules amount
to such law will presume that they continued in
force after the Civil Services Rules, 1941, have
come into force. No such presumption can be
made when this is the point to be determined.
The Tehsildari Rules were nut made under
any law which was in force during the perio<~
f
Gian Singh
v.
Th. State of Punja&
Raghubar Dayal J,
542
1961
Gian Si1.gh
v.
The Stale of Punjab
11.agn.bar Dayal].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19621
subsequent to the criming into force of the Civil
Rules. Thc>v were made under R. certain
pru\·isiun of the Punfab Lund Revenue Act. That
pro\'ioiun \\·as n:pcalccl Ly the A<lapta.tion Order
in l!J:J7, and therefore, those rules cannot Le said
to ban' been ma<le under anv Jaw which was in
force for the time being, since· the enforcement of
the Civil Services Rules. I am therefore of opinion
that clause (ii) of r. 1.4 does not apply to the case
of the appellant. and that therefore his case is gov·
erned by rule 1.2.
r
Service~
The persons who are cont~mplated under
cl.( ii) of rule 1.4 are those with respect to whom the
Act or other statutes in force lay down provisions
for appointment and conditions of service.
The Act itself provides in s. 243 that the
conditions of service of the subordinate r&nks of
the various police forces in India shall be such as
may be determined by or under the Acts relating
to those forces respectively, notwithstanding anything in the foregoing provisions of the Act. Reference to this provision is made in sub-cl. (2) of
cl. (b) of rule I.'.!. There may be holdt"rs of spcci&l
posts mentioned in it<>m No. (3) of cl. (a) of rule 1.2
and other officers under tJw administrative control
of the Punjab Government to whom the provisions
of s. 244 to 247 of the Act may apply and be thus
put out of th'" Ruic making power of the Punjab
Government. There may bo other Acts which lay
down special provisions for the appointment and
conditions of service of persons in tbe service of
the Punjab Government.
Reference may also be made to Chapter XIV
of the Civil Services Rul<>s, Punjab. Ruic 14.l reada
thus:
"Besides the All-India Services which are
under the rule making control of the SecM·
tary of Sta(.(' the services under the 11dminis-
I
•
;.
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
543
trative control of the Punjab Government
consist of the following classes :(i) the Provincial Services; and
(ii) the Subordinate Services."
It is clear that every service under the Administrative control of the Punjab Government comes
either under the Provincial Services or under the
Subordinate Services. The Services of Tehsildars
and Naib Tehsildars contemplated by the Tehsildari
Rules must therefore come under the Subordinate
Services for the purpose of rule 14.1. This is also
clear from rules 14.5 and 14.6.
The Tehsildari Rules are with respect to the
recruitment and appointment of Tehsildars and Naib
Tehsildars and also deal with the seniority of the
mem hers of the service and the penalties, including the penalty of dismissal, whi?h can be imposed
upon any member of the servrne by the authorities mentioned in it, after following the procedure laid down. The rules, it is obvious, do not
refer to many a matter which affect the service
and which are.dealt with by the Civil Services Rules
in addition to appointment and dismissal of government servants. In matters not covered by the
Tehsildari Rules, the Tehsildars and Naib Tehsildars must be governed by the Civil Services Rules.
I cannot contemplatA that there are no rules to
govern them in respect of those matters. It cannot
be that these Civil Rules will apply to Tehsildars
and Naib Tehsildars in certain matters and not
in
matters of appointment and dismissal.
Clause (ii) of rule 1.4 does not make the rules
partially not applicable to the persons contemplated by it. This consideration supports my
interpretation of this clause to the effect that it
does not cover the case of Tehsildars and Naib
Tehsildars.
I find certain rules specifically referring to
Tehsildars and Naib Tehsildars, and this, in my
1961
.- Gian Singh
v.
The Stal• of Punjab
Ra:hubar Doyal J.
I
544
.961
Gian Singh
v,
Tlte Stall of Punj~b
R.,,,. •• , Da,yal ].
SUPREllfE COURT REPOR'fS
[1962]
opinion, leaves no room for doubt that the Civil
Service Rules apply to Tehsildars and Naib
1'ohsihl1>rs.
lfole 2. ]() defines 'dutv'. Clause (b) of this
rule strttes that a Govcrnm~nt servant 1s also
treated a.s on duty under the circumstances specified in the schedule to Chapter II. The schedule
referred to mentions in cl. (4) of item II that a
Tohsildar or a. NaiL Tehsildar, in certain circumstances specified therein, will Le treated to be on
duty, even though he may have spent time beyond
his Hphcre of duty.
Rule 5.35 deals with circumstances in which
a competent authority may grant rent-free accommodation to any government servant. Appendix
7 gives the list of government servants granted
rent-free quartern, as referred to in Note 6 to rule
5.35. Tehsil<lars and Na.ib Tehsildars are included
among such servants accordinr; to Serial entry
No. 3.
Huie 8.23 deals wit.Ji tho authorities com petent to grant certain typo of
leave. These
authorities are mentioned in Appendix 12. At serial
No. 7 the cntrv shows that Commissioners of Divi·
sions can grant· such leave to Tchsildars and Naib
Tehsildars. Appendix 17, referred to in rulo 8.61
authorises tho Deputy Commissioners to grant
casual leave to Tchsildars and Naib Tehsildars.
Appendix 23 deals with Government Servants'
Conduct Rules, l!J35, referred to in rule 14.8.
I am therefore of opinion that the Civil Service Hules of l!J4l governed tho conditions of
service of 'fehsildars and Naih Tehsildars and
that the Tchsildari Hules of l!J32 ceased to be
operative from April I, 1941 even if thoy continued
to Le effective till that date in view of the
provisions of tho Transitory Order and the Adaptation Order. Tho '.l'ehsildari Rules, therefore
wero not in force immediately before the
,.
Ill
'
~
&:Si0.R.
SUPRm.m COURT REPORTS
545
~ coming
into force of the constitution and therefore
could not have continued in force itfter January
26, 1950. Article 313 provided for the continuance
of such Jaws which were in force immediately
before the commencement of the constitution
and which were applicable to any public service
and which service continued to exist after the
-¥. commencement of the Constitution. Such laws
were to continue until other provisions were made
in that behalf under the constitution. The Governor of the Punjab, in the exercise of hi1 powers
under the proviso to Art. 309 of the Constitution
made the Punjab Civil Service Rules which were
to come into force from April 1, 1953. The
' rules corresponding to the rules of 1941 referred
/r. to by me are similar and therefore, in view of
my opinion that the Civil Services Rules of 1941
applied to the services of Tehsildars, and Naib
Tehsildars also apply to that service.
I may just mention that rule 1.2 describes
the categories of services under the administrative
control of the Punjab Government diffe'rently from
rule 1.2 of 1941. Members of Provincial Services
~ were placed in three categories. Those of classew I
and II in the first category, those of class III iu the
second and those of class IV in the third category
and schcdnle to rule 14.5 gives the list of services
d&clared as Provincial Services, Classes I and II.
Rule 14.6 states that the Specialist Services shall
con&ist of such Services (other than All India and
· Provincial Services, Class I and II) as the Government.may from time to time by notification in the
Punjab Gazette declare to be Specialist Services,
and rule 14. 7 then provides that Provincial Services,
Class III and IV, include persons to whom those
rules apply and who are not already included in
the Provincial Services Class I and Class II and the
,;Specialist Services. The Tehsildars and Naib Teh~""llildars thus come either in the Provincial Services
C1ass III or Class IV. The appellant was dismissed
>--
1961
Gian Sinth
v.
The State of Punj«b
Raghubar Dayal J.
'
-~
SUPRE!IIE COURT REPORTS
11111 I
Gian Sin1h
v.
TJu St<J/t of PJmjab
Paalbt~11rl D'!_Ja/ J.
[1962]
by an order of tbe Financial Commissioner dated
October 26, 1953, when the Punjab Civil Services f'
Rules which came into force on April I, 1953 were
in force. Rule 14.!l provides that a competent
authority may issue rules specifying the penaltiea
which may be imposcrl on members of the services
and the procedur<> for preferring appeals against
the imposition of such penalties. Appendix 24 to
theRIJ rules giv<·s the Punjab Civil Services (Punish- ~
ment and Appeal} Rules, l!J52. Rule (j of those
rules atat.es that subject to the provisions of
oln.use(I) of Article :n 1 of tho Constitution of India,
the authorities competent to impose any of the
penalties specified in rule 4 upon the persons to whom
these rules apply, shall be such as may he pres·
cribed by Government in the rules regulatiniz the "'
appointmPnt and conditions of service of such
persons. It has not been shown that the Financial
Commissioner is one of the authorities prescribed
by the Governnrnnt in the mies regulating the
appointment (Llld conditions of eervice of Tohsildars
and N'aib TehoildarH. It follows therefore that the
Financial Commissioner cannot be held to bo a.
Competent (LU\hority to dismiss Tehsildars, in 1953.
I :i.m therefore of opinion that the dismis11&l •
of th('! app·llant by the Fimrncial Commissioner is
illegal. I would therefore allow. the appeal with
co&ts, sot aside the ordor under appeal and restore
•
thC' order of the l<.'arned Single Judge, dated April
4, 1957.
BY Con:T: In Yicw of thr opinion ofm!\jority, -...J..
the appeal is dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
;,
-
.•
-{_
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org