SRI SINNA RAMANUJ JEER AND OTHERS versus SRI RANGA RAMANUJA JEER AND ANOTHER.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 27 April 1961 | [1962] 2 S.C.R. 509 | 1961 INSC 193
Key facts
- Decided
- 27 April 1961
- Bench
- BHUVNESHWAR PRASAD SINHA*, K. SUBBA RAO, RAGHUBAR DAYAL, J.R. MUDHOLKAR
- Bench size
- 4
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 244/1958
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1962] 2 S.C.R. 509
- Neutral citation
- 1961 INSC 193
Text of the judgment
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
509
SRI SINN A RAMANUJ A JEER AND OTHERS
v.
SRI RANGA RAMANUJA JEER
AND ANOTHER.
(B. P. SINHA, c. J., K. SUBBA RAO, RAGHUBAR DAYAL
and J. R. MunHoLKAR, JJ.)
Temple Honour-S1'il by aradanaikar and trustee of temple
for declaration of right to first theertham-Maintainability-TestCode of Civil Procedure, r908 (Act V of r908), s. 9.
The respondent as the aradanaikar and trustee of the
Emberumanar temple, dedicated to Sri Ramanujacharya, which
was one of the group of temples built around the main temple
of Athinathalwar in the Tirunelveli District, brought the two
suits, out of which present appeals arose, for declaration of his
right to the first theertham and other honours and perquisites in
precedence over all other worshippers in the temple of Athinathalwar and his case was that he was entitled to them by virtue
of his office in the Emberumanar temple. The matters came up
to the High Court. There was a remand order and the Subordinate Judge who tried the suits thereafter held that the Emberumanar temple was a sub-shrine attached to the main temple
and as such the plaintiff was virtually an office-holder in the
main temple and the precedence claimed by him was attached to
that office as part of the remuneration and decreed the suits. On
appeal the District Judge, on a review of the entire evidence, set
aside the findings arrived at by the trial court and dismissed the
suits as not maintainable. The appeals to the High Court were
heard by a single Judge who, on a reconsideration of the evidence, reversed the findings of the District Judge and affirmed
those of the Subordinate Judge and decreed the suits. It was,
further, held by the High Court that, as one of the theerthakars,
the appellant could be considered to be the holder of the office
of arulipad in the main temple.
Held. that although it was not permissible under s. 9 of the
Code of Civil Procedure for a civil Court to entertain a suit for a
declaration of religious honours and privileges simpliciter, it
could entertain a suit to establish one's right to an office in a
temple and to the honours and privileges attached to such office
as its remuneration or perquisites. But the essential condition
for the existence of an office was that its holder must be under
a legal obligation to discharge the duties attached to it and be
liable to penalty on failure to do so.
So judged, there could neither be an independent office of
theerthakar, for he had no obligatory duties to perform, nor that
of an arulipad, since that word only connoted that the names of
theerthakars were called out by the archaka in a particular order.
65
April a7.
510
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962]
The question whether first theertham or any other honours
shown to a person were merely as a mark of respect on the
Sri Sinna
occasion of his visit to the temple, or were part of the remuneraRani1,nuja jeer tion attached to his office, must in every case be decided on
v.
evidence and in the latter case such honours must be shown to
Sri Ranga
have formed an integral part of the ritual to be performed by
Ramanuja jeer the recipient as the holder of the office.
Athan Sadagopachariar Swamigal v. E layavalH Srinivasachariar, (r9r3) M.W.N. 289, approved.
Striman Sadagopa v. Kristna Tatachariyar, (r863) I M.H.C.R.
3or, Sri Rungachariar v. Rungasami Buttachar, (r909) I.L.R. 32
Mad. 29r and Vathiar Venkatachariar v. P. Ponappa Ayyangar,
(r9r8) 45 I.C. 959, referred to.
Sri Emberumanar ] eer Swamigal v. The Board of Commissioners for Hindu Religious Endowments, Madras, (r936) 7r M.L.J.
588, considered.
Held, further, that it was well settled that the High Court
had no jurisdiction to entertain a second apreal on the ground
of erroneous finding of fact, however gross the error might seem
to be. In the instant case, the High Court was clearly in error
in reversing the finding of the District Judge, which was one of
fact, that the Emberumanar temple was neither subordinate to,
nor~part of the Athinathalwar temple and no office-holder of the
former could, therefore, become an office-holder of the latter.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeals
Nos. 244 and 245 of 1958.
Appeal by special leave from the judgment and
decree dated February 19, 1953, of the Madras High
Court in Second Appeals Nos. 2120 and 2121 of 1947.
A. V. Viswanatha Sastri and M. S. K. Iyengar, for
the appellants.
K. N. Rajagopala Sastri and M. S. K. Sastri, for
respondent No. IA.
S. V. Venugopalachari and R. Gopalakrishnan, for
respondent No. SA in Appeal No. 244 and respondent
No. 7A in Appeal No. 245.
1961. April 27. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
Subba R:ao ].
SuBBA RAO, J.-These two appeals are directed
against the judgment of the High Court of Madras
dated February 19, 1953, setting aside that of the
District Judge, Tirunelveli, and restoring that of the
Subordinate Judge, Tuticorin, in 0. S. Nos. 45 and 46
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
511
r96r
of 1945 on his file, and they raise the question of
maintainability of a suit in regard to honours and
Sri S·inna
perquisites in the temple of Athinathalwar in Alwar Ramanuja ] e1r
Tirunagari.
v.
At Alwar Tirunagari in Tirunelveli District there
Sri Ranga
is a famous temple called Athinathalwar temple. The Ramanuja j eey
presiding deity in the temple is Lord Vishnu. Its
origin is lost in antiquity. In the 10th and 11th cen- Subba Rao ].
turies Vaishnavite saints, called Alwars and Acharyas, who were ardent devotees of Lord Vishnu, worshipped at the temple and sang in praise of the Lord.
As time passed by, 20 smaller temples were erected
to commemorate the lives of Alwars and Acharyas.
Within the compound of the main shrine, there are
three minor shrines of Nachiar, Nammalwar, and
Garuda; the rest of the smaller shrines are outside the
premises of the main temple. Each of the said temples
has its own manager, archakas and separate endowments; but, presumably because of the fact that the
Alwars and Acharyas, whose idols are installed in the
smaller temples, were originally devotees of Sri Athinathalwar, an interesting and novel practice of
mutual and regular exchange of visits between the
idols in the smaller shrines and the idol of Athinathalwar has grown over the years. During certain specified occasions in the year, the idols in the minor
temples are brought to the main temple for worship;
so too, on specific occasions the idol of Athinathalwar
is also taken to the minor shrines; such visits being
reminiscent of the days when the Alwars and Acharyas
worshipped in the temple of Athinathalwar.
Sri Ramanujacharya was one of the greatest of the
devotees of Lord Vishnu and is well known throughout this vast country as the progenitor of an important schoool of Indian philosophy. He died in the
year 1127 A. D. In the 13th century a shrine was
built in his honour and his idol was installed therein.
Sri Ramanujacharya is also known as Udayavar or
Emberumanar and the shrine built in his dedication
is known as Emberumanar temple. The manager and
archaka of the said temple is known as Emberumanar
512
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1962]
Jeer. Emberumanar temple also is outside the pre.
cincts
of the temple of Athinathaiwar. There are also
Sri Sinna
mutual
visits between the idol of Emberumanar and
Ratnanuja ] eer
the idol of Athinathalwar to each other's temple. The
v.
Sri Ranga
present Emberumanar Jeer is the plaintiff in the suits
Ramanuja jeer out of which the appeals have arisen.
There is a mutt called the Vanamamalai Mutt in the
Subba Rao ].
said District and the head of the mutt is known as
Vanamamalai Jeer. He is a sanyasi held in reverence
by Vaishnavites of South India. He is the first
defendant.
The heads of the Ahobilam Mutt and the Tirukkurungudi Mutt are the second and third defendants
respectively. The fourth defendant is the Executive
Officer of the temple of Sri Athinathalwar and he was
appointed by the Hindu Religious Endowments
Board, Madras.
The records disclose that, at any rate from the
middle of the last century, there have been disputes
between the various Jeers and others as regards the
order of priority in which certain honours have to be
distributed among the said Jeers when they attend
the temple of Sri Athinathalwar for worship. In the
ghoshties (group of worshippers in front of the deity)
both on ordinary and special days the said Jeers are
shown honours befitting their rank. The honours
consist of distribution of theertham, thulasi, satari and
viniyogam, and a few more similar items. Each of
the said Jeers is allotted a particular place in the
ghoshti and a certain order of precedence is observed
inter se between them. This order of precedence in
the matter of receiving honours has become an unending source of bickering between the religious heads;
with the result, the Madras Hindu Religious Endow.
ments Board, constituted under Act 1 of 1923, with
jurisdiction to administer the endowments in the
Madras State, had to interfere and settle the disputes
inter se between the various Jeers. On May 12, 1927,
the said Board fixed the order of precedence for
honours between the various Jeers to be observed
both on ordinary and special days. By the said order
the Board recognized the Emberumanar Jeer's right
i·
2 s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
513
Ig6r
to the honours and perquisites in precedence over the
other Jeers on all the days other than Vaikasi festival
Sti Sinna
days, except the 7th day, and as regards the other Ra»ianuja jeer
days of the festival, namely, 1st to 6th and 8th to
v.
Sri Ranga
10th days, the Board directed that the other Jeers
should be shown on the respective days both the ordi- Rainanuja ] eer
nary and special honours in precedence over the rest
Subba Rao ].
of the Jeers, including the Emberumailar Jeer. Not
satisfied with the said order, the Emberumanar Jeer
filed 0. S. No. 320 of 1933 in the Court of the District
Munsif, Tirunelveli, which was later transferred to
the Court of the Subordinate Judge, Tuticorin, as
0. S. No. 45 of 1945, against the other Jeers and the
Hindu Religious Endowments Board, for the declaration of his right to the first theertham and other perquisites in precedence over all the others in the ghoshties of Sri Athinathalwar temple on the ground that
he was entitled to them as the office-holder of the
temple of E,mberumanar. Subsequent to the filing of
the suit, the Board, by its order dated May 15, 1935,
altered the order of precedence giving the Vanamamalai Jeer precedence over the Emberumanar Jeer;
and this led to the Emberumanar Jeer filing another
suit 0. S. No. 201 of 1941 in the Court of the District
Munsif, Srivaikuntam, for a declaration of his right
to the first theertham, etc., in precedence over all the
others. This suit was later transferred to the Court
of the Subordinate Judge, Tuticorin, as O. S. No. 46
of 1945, to be tried along with 0. S. No. 45 of 1945.
To the suits the Emberumanar Jeer, the Vanamamalai Jeer, the Ahobilam Jeer and the Tirukkurungudi Jeer, and the Executive Officer of the Hindu
Religious Endowments Board were made parties.
These suits have had a chequered career. But we shall
briefly refer only to those stages of the long drawn
litigation which have some bearing on the questions
raised in the present appeals. 0. S. No. 320 of 1933
was finally numbered as 0. S. No. 66 of 1936 and
was disposed of on March 25, 1941, by the District
Munsif, Tirunelveli. The learned District Munsif dismissed the suit on the ground that it was not maintainable, as the plaintiff had no legal right in respect
514
r96I
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962)
of which he could seek relief in a civil court. On
appeal,
the learned Subordinate Judge, Tirunelveli,
Sri Sinna
came
to
the conclusion that, as the plaintiff had come
Ramanuja ] eer
to court to establish his right of precedence to receive
v.
Sri Ranga
the theertham, etc., as forming part of the emoluments
Ramanuja Jeer of his office of aradanaikar in the suit temple, the suit
could not be dismissed on the preliminary ground that
Subba Rao J.
it was barred under s. 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure; on that basis, he set aside the decree of the District Munsif and remanded the case for trial on other
issues arising in the case. Both the parties preferred
appeals to the High Court of Madras and they were
numbered as C. M. As. Nos. 1 and 155 of 1943; on
January 31, 1945, Chandrasekara Aiyar, J., dismissed
both the appeals. The learned Judge propounded
alternative theories, and he expressed himself thus:
"Of course, before he (plaintiff) can succeed in the
suit, the plaintiff has to make out that he being the
Aradanaikar and trustee of the Emberumanar temple amounts to his holding an office in the suit
temple."
The learned Judge agreed with the Subordinate Judge
that the suit could not be dismissed in limine without
deciding the said question of fact. On remand, the
learned Subordinate Judge, Tuticorin, to whom the
said suit and the connected suit, being renumbered
0. S. Nos. 45 and 46of1945, were remanded came to
the conclusion that the Emberumanar temple was a
sub-shrine attached to the main temple of Sri Athinathalwar, and that that the plaintiff, who was the
aradanaikar of the sub-shrine, would be virtually an
office-holder in the main temple. He further held
that the privilege of first theertham was attached to
the said office as part of its remuneration and, therefore, the suit was one of civil nature falling under 8. 9
of the Code of Civil Procedure; in that view, having
held on the merits that the plaintiff had established
his right of precedence, he decreed both the suits. As
many as six appeals were preferred against the decrees
in the two snits by the aggrieved parties· to the District Court; and the learned District Judge in a common judgment disposed of them on January 23, 1947.
2 s.c.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
515
1961
The learned District Judge, on a review of the evidence in the case, held that the institutions were not
Sri Sinna
interdependent or intimately connected in such a way Ramanuja Jeer
that an office-holder oft.he Emberumanar temple was
v.
Sri Ranga
necessarily an office-holder of the Athinathalwar temple. On that finding, he held that the plaintiff was Ra1nanuja ] eer
not an office-holder of the Athinathalwar temple
Subba Rao ].
and, therefore, he was not entitled to file a suit with
regard to his rights of precedence in being given the
theertham, etc. In the result he allowed the appeals
and dismissed both the suits with costs throughout. Against the said judgment, the plaintiff preferred second appea.ls to the High Court of Judicature at
Madras, being Second Appeals Nos. 2120 and 2121 of
1947. They were heard by Krishnaswami Nayudu, J.,
who on a reconsideration of the evidence disagreed
with the finding arrived at by the learned District
Judge and accepted the finding given by the learned
Subordinate Judge. Not only the learned Judge
accepted the finding of the learned Subordinate Judge
that the plaintiff as the aradanaikar or the archaka of
the sub-shrine was virtually an office-holder in the
main temple, he also went further and held that, as
one of the theerthakars, the plaintiff could be considered to be the holder of the office of arulipad in the main
temple. In the result the learned Judge set aside the
decree of the District Judge and restored the decrees
of the learned Subordinate Judge. As leave to appeal
to a division bench was not given by the learned
Judge, the first defendant, i.e., the Vanamamalai
Jeer, in the suits, by special leave, has preferred these
appeals against the judgment of the High Court.
Mr. A. V. Viswanatha Sastri, learned counsel for
the appellant, raised before us the following points:
(1) A suit for a declaration that the plaintiff is entitled to honours in a temple would not lie unless he
establishes that he holds an office in the said temple
and that the said honours form part of the perquisites
attached to the said office, and that, as in the present
case the plaintiff claimed that he was an aradanaikar
and trustee of only the Emberumanar temple and as
such entitled to honours in Athinathalwar temple,
516
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962]
the suits should have been dismissed in limine on the
ground
that the plaints did not disclose any claim of
Sri Sinna
civil
nature
falling under s. 9 of the Code of Civil
Ramanuja jeer
Procedure. (2) The Courts were not justified in allowv.
Sri Ranga
ing the plaintiff to make out a new case not disclosed
Ramanuja Jeer in the plaints, namely, that the Emberumanar temple
was a subordinate shrine of the Athinathalwartemple
Subba Rao ].
and, therefore, the plaintiff was the office-holder of
the latter temple; assuming that there was justification for the courts in allowing the plaintiff to develop
a new case at a very late stage of the proceedings,
there was a clear finding of the District Court based
on the evidence adduced in the case that the Emberumanar temple was not a sub-shrine of the Athinathalwar temple, and the High Court had no jurisdiction
to set aside that finding in second appeals.
Mr. Rajagopala Sastri, learned counsel for the respondents, contended that the plaintiff's alternative
case was not really a new one, but all the relevant
facts in support of that case were disclosed in the
plaints, and that the finding of the District Judge was
not a finding of fact but was either a legal inference
from proved facts or a mixed question of fact and law.
He argued that the contention of learned counsel for
the appellant ignores the religious background and
ideas of the class of persons with which we are now
concerned, and that, if the matter is approached from
a correct perspective, as the High Court did, it would
be realized that there was such an association between the two temples as it could be said that one is
subordinate to the other leading to the only irresistible inference that the plaintiff, the office-holder of the
sub-shrine, could claim honours in the main temple of
which the sub-shrine is only a part in the larger
sense.
At the outset it would be convenient and necessary
to notice briefly the law pertaining to the maintainability of suits in civil courts in respect of honours in
temples. Section 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure
describes the nature of suits which a court has jurisdiction to entertain. It can entertain every suit of a
civil nature excepting suits of which its cognizance is
I96I
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
517
r96t
either expressly or impliedly barred. As a corollary
to this, it follows that a court cannot entertain a suit
Sri Sinna
which is not of a civil nature. Prima facie suits rais- Ramanuja Jeer
v.
ing questions of religious rites and ceremonies only are
Sri Ranga
not maintainable in a civil court, for they do not deal
with legal rights of parties. But the explanation to Ramanuja Jeer
the section accepting the said undoubted position says Subba Rao j.
that a suit in which the right to property or to an
office is contested is a suit of civil nature notwithstanding that such right may depend entirely on the
decision of a question as to religious rites or ceremonies. It implies two things, namely, (i) a suit for an
office is a suit of a civil nature; and (ii) it does not
cease to be one even if the said right depends entirely
upon a decision of a question as to the religious rites
or ceremonies. It implies further that questions as to
religious rites or ceremonies cannot independently of
such a right form the subject-matter of a civil suit.
Honours shown or precedence given to religious dignitaries when they attend religious ceremonies in a temple cannot be placed on a higher footing than the religious rights or ceremonies, for they are integral part
of the said rites or ceremonies in the sense that the
said honours are shown to persons partaking in the
ceremonies. Prima facie honours, such as who is to
stand in the ghoshti, in what place, who is to get the
tulasi, etc., in which order, and similar others, cannot
be considered to be part of the remuneration or perquisites attached to an office, for they are only tokens of
welcome of an honoured guest within the precincts of
a temple. One would have thought that it would even
be a sacrilege to claim a right of precedence in the
presence of the Almighty God, for all go .before him
as humble devotees to earn his blessings and not to
assert their self importance or claim their right to preferential treatment. But a century of case law in that
part of the country has recognized certain rights of
different grades of devotees and they and their innumerable followers began to cherish them or even to
fight for them in criminal and civil courts. This
Court, therefore, does not propose to reconsider the
66
518
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962]
question of honours on first principles but only will
resurvey the law on the subject with a view to ascerSri Sinna
tain,
and if possible to clarify, the legal position.
Ramanf4ja jeer
The earliest decision is that in Striman Sadagopa v.
v.
Sri Ranga
Kristna Tatachariyar (1). There, the plaintiff was the
Ramanuja Jeer gurukkal of Sri Ahobilam Mutt and he sued the
trustees of Sri Devarajaswami temple at Conjeevaram
Subba Rao ].
for damages for injuries done to him by withholding
from him certain honours and emoluments and also
sought to have his right to such honours and emoluments established for the future. Two Schedules were
attached to that plaint and they showed inter alia
that what was claimed as honours were such as garlands, cocoanuts, prasadams and other paraphernalia
attending the ceremonial recitation when the gurukkal
visited the temple. Scotland, Q.J., formulated the legal
position thus:
" ......... these clearly show that every one of the
matters in respect of which the suit is brought is
purely a matter of religious and sacred observance
in connection with the worship and ceremonials at
the pagoda, and is claimed by the plaintiff as a
matter of devotional respect and display due to his
priestly rank or as a votive offering made to him
whilst passing in procession through the temples,
and when brought to the presence of the principal
idol."
Then the learned Chief Justice proceeded to state:
"He (the plaintiff) is not officially connected in
any way with the management or control of the
pagoda, or its property or funds; and the alleged
dues of his office have no doubt been owing to the
great reverence at one time entertained for his
sacredotal rank in the Hindu religion, and the importance from a religious point of view of his mere
presence at the pagoda."
He concluded thus:
"Such honours and emoluments cannot in any
respect be considered as remuneration for duties or
ministrations performed by the plaintiff in the secular affairs or religious services of the pagoda."
(•) (1863) I M.H.C.R. JOI, 3o6.
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
519
This decision, which has stood the test of time, clearly
lays down that a suit to enforce the rights of persons
Sri Sinna
holding offices connected with the management and Ramanuja
Jeef
regulation of temples and for honours and emoluments
v.
connected therewith would lie in a civil court; but a
Sri l?anga
suit by a plaintiff, who does not hold an office in the Ramanuja jeer
temple, claiming honours customarily shown to him as
a matter of devotional respect and display due to his Subba Rao J.
rank is not of a civil nature. The principle laid down
in this case and restated in subsequent cases has been
applied by a division bench of the Madras High Court
to a claim for first theertham, etc., in Sri Rungachariar
v. Rungasami Buttachar(1). That decision was given
in an appeal arising out of a suit for a declaration that
the plaintiffs had a hereditary miras right to the
offices of Sthalathar, Kutumba First Theertham, Muntrapushpam, V edaparayanam and Adyapakam from
times immemorial in the temple of Sri Parimala Ranganathaswarni at Tiruvilandur, and, by virtue of such
right, were entitled to a fourth share of the honours
and emoluments due to their offices as detailed in
schedule A of the plaint. The learned Judges, on the
evidence, came to the following conclusion:
" ......... the plaintiffs as hereditary Sthalathars are
bound to perform, besides the duties of superintendence attached to their office of Sthalathar, the ceremonial duties of vedaparayanam, etc., and are entitled to receive remuneration for the performance of
those d11ties. Included in this remumeration is 'the
privilege of first theertham' from which the plaintiffs are called 'theerthakars'."
Then the learned Judges proceeded to observe:
"Taking the findings to be, as we do, that the
privilege of the first theertham is attached to the
hereditary office of the plaintiffs as a part of the
remuneration of the office, the Court must, to protect the plaintiffs in the enjoyment of the office,
declare what is the honour to which they are
entitled."
This decision recognizes that a suit for a declaration
of a plaintiff's right to an office and for the honours,
(1) (1909) l.L.R. 32 Mad. 291, 298.
520
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962)
such as first theertham, etc., as part of the rem uneration will lie in a civil court.
Sri Sinna
Athan Sadagopachariar Swamigal v. Elayavalli SriRanzanuja Jeer
nivasachariar (1) is a decision relating to honours in
v.
Sri Ranga
Athinathalwar temple itself. The plaintiff in that
Ramanuja Jeer case was a trustee of a temple called Pillalokacharyar's
temple. The principal object of the suit was to preSubba Rao J.
vent the first defendant from claiming to be one of
the Adhyapaka Mirasidars in the temple of Nammalwar and Adinathar in Alwar Tirunagari. It was contended that the first defendant was one of the seven
Adhyapaka Mirasidars in the temple and his rank in
the ghoshti was just above the plaintiffs. Sadasiva
Aiyar, J., posed the question raised and gave his
answer thereto thus:
"The legal question I wish to say something
about is whether a suit for the honours mentioned
in the second item of the 2nd Schedule to the plaint
is maintainable in a Civil Court. It is clear that if
those honours are not attached to any office in the
temple, no such suit could lie. The first branch of
the question, therefore, is a question of fact, viz.,
whether these honours are attached to the Adhyapaka Miras office in the temple."
After considering the evidence and other relevant
decisions, the learned Judge came to the following
conclusion:
"I see no difficulty whatever in holding on the
evidence in this case that the plaintiffs and the 1st
defendant and the 5 other Adhyapaka Mirasidars
get their rank in the Goshti and their rank in the
distributions of prasadams not because those honours are part of the Adhyapaka Miras office to
which they are entitled but because of their being
Acharya Purushas or of their families having been
very respectable religious families for long or because the mere respect due to their offices has been
considered as making them fit in a social, and religious point of view to obtain such honours."
That would be enough to dispose of that appeal, but
the learned Judge proceeded to make certain observations even on the assumption that the said honours
(1) (1913) M.W.N. 289, 299, 300, 301.
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
521
had been attached to emoluments so far as the 7
Adhyapaka Mirasidars were concerned. The obserSri Sinna
vations of the learned Judge, though obiter, deserve to Ramanuja Jeer
be quoted not only because of his vast experience in
v.
matters of Hindu religion but also because of his well Sri Ranga
known reformative zeal to remove the cobwebs that Ramanuja ] eer
shroded the Hindu religion by superstitious ignorance and perverted imposition. The learned Judge Subba Rao J.
says:
" ......... the next question of law is whether such
honours to be shown in the presence of God can be
legally attached to the office as emoluments, in
other words, can honours be legally claimed by
anybody as receivable by him in a temple? When a
trustee chooses to parade the temple elephants and
dancing girls before a high official or any other person and gives him prasadams, etc., he does it in order
to show 'honours' to that person and when he does
it without prejudice to the conduct of the rituals and
ceremonies in the temple, he always says that the .
God of the temple Himself condescends to treat the
official or other persons as God's guest and shows
him these 'honours'. Such persons to whom respect
is shown cannot in my opinion claim such 'honours'
as a legal right, but as a favour shown by the temple Deity. Such honours in the strict eye of the
Shastras cannot be called honours at all but as doles
condescendingly given by the temple Deity as a
'favour'. One of the honours, as is well known,
shown to a Hindu in a Vaishnava temple is to place
the impression of the feet of the Deity upon
the head or shoulders of the devotee. Another is
the distribution of the 'leavings' of the food offered
to the Deity to the distinguished devotee. The sandal
paste of the feet of the Deity and the leaving of his
food and the garland worn by the God are given as
marks of pure grace and not as rights and honours
claimable by the devotee ............ This clearly shows
that while we ought to humbly accept the Deity's
leavings given through the trustee or an archaka, a
claim for •honour' to be shown in the presence of
God is a sinful claim and is illegal and unshastraic.
522
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962]
I would therefore respectfully confine the decision
in
Sri Rungachariar v. Rungaswami Buttachar( 1) to
Sri Sinna
cases in which the receiving of the first theertham
Ramanuj a Jeer
by an office-holder has become indissoluble part of
v.
Sri Ranga
the ritual to be performed by the recipient as an
Ramanuja Jeer
office-holder and the extension of the principle
should
be carefully guarded against."
Subba Rao].
These are weighty observations and if they were
appropriate in the year 1913 they should be much
more so in the year 1961. We respectfully accept
these observations as laying down the correct proposition, namely, that a party claiming an honour like first
theertham, etc., has to prove not only that he is an
office-holder of the temple and that he has been receiving the first theertham in the Ghoshti but also that the
receipt of the first theertham, has become an integral
part of the ritual to be performed by him as an officeholder; for, the receipt of the first theertham would be
consistent with its being shown as a grace from the
Lord and also as its being a part of the remuneration
to the office. Another division bench of the Madras
High Court in Vathiar Venkatachariar v. P. Ponappa
Ayyengar (') had to consider the question of a claim to
a religious honour which consisted of receiving theerthams and prasadams in the temple in certain order of
precedence. This case also relates to Athinathalwar
temple and to the question of precedence among the
theerthakars. The first question raised was whether
there was such an office as theertham office in the
temple. Krishnan, J., delivering the leading judgment, in rejecting that there was such an office
observed:
"It may be mentioned that among the Theerthakars there are some 5 or 7 in number, who are
called Adhyapakamdars, whose special duty it is to
recite these Prabandams and they are remunerated
by Inam lands given to them. They are what may
be called the official reciters in this temple."
Adverting to the question raised, the learned Judge
proceeded to observe:
"It is clear that,, to constitute an office one, if not
(I) (t909) I.L.R. 32 Mad. 29'. 298.
(2) (r918) 45 LC. 959, 961, 96•.
I
"
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
523
the essential, thing is the existence of a duty or
duties attached to the office which the office-holder 5,i Sinna
is under a legal obligation to perform and the non- Ratnanuja jeer
performance of which may be visited by penalties
v.
Sti Ranga
such as a suspension, dismissal, etc."
Applying the test in the case of Theerthakars and Ra1nanuja Jeer
other Adhyapakam<lars, the learned Judge said:
Subba Rao ].
"The only difference between the outsiders and
the Theerthakars, as shown by the evidence, is that
the Theerthakars have special places allotted to them
in the temple to stand and recite and they a.re
given the honour of Theertham and Prasadam,
before the outsiders get them; and they have what
is called an 'Arulapad', that is, their names are
called out by the Archaka in a certain order, when,
if present, they have to respond by saying
'Nayinde', meaning 'lam here'. This does not seem
to show that they are anything more than a recognized and privileged class of worshippers who are
shown special consideration by having places allotted to them in the temple and by being given the
honours before the ordinary worshippers in an order
of precedence fixed by the usage of the temple."
On a consideration of the evidence in that case, the
learned Judge stated:
"On the evidence as set out it must be held that
the plaintiffs have not made out the existence of
any obligatory duty on the part of the Theerthakars
or of any office called the Theertham office."
This judgment, therefore, establishes that there is no
office called the theertham office in the temple, as there
is no obligatory duty on the pa.rt of the said theerthakars in the temple. As the claim to the said
honour was not established to have been attached as
emoluments to the religious office the suit was dismissed. Sri Emberumanar Jeer Swamigal v. The Board of
Commissioners for Hindu Religious Endowments,
Madras.(') is a decision of a single Judge of the
Madras High Court in a writ petition filed by Emberuma.nar Jeer questioning the order of the Religious
Endowments Board which is the subject-matter of
(1) (1936) 71 M.L.J. 588, 591.
524
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1962)
the present appeals. That writ petition was dismissed on the ground that the Board's order related to
Sri Sinna
administrative
matter and, therefore, a writ of
Ramanuja jeer
certiorari would not lie to quash the same; but in the
v.
Sri Ranga
course of the judgment, Pandurang Row, J., made
Ramanuja Jeer certain relevant observations and they are:
"What was determined by the Board was the
Subba Rao J.
order of distribution of theertham and honours connected with theertham. This matter cannot in my
opinion be regarded as a determination of any
rights of subjects. The rights of subjects referred
to in the rule are rights which can be legally
enforced and not mere honours or precedence
claimed or recognized as a matter of courtesy or
usage. It is not seriously disputed that the right
to obtain the theertham or honours in a particular
order of precedence is not a civil right which can
be enforced or declared in a Civil Court."
After citing the observations in Sriman Sadagopa v.
Kristna Tatachariyar (1), the learned Judge observed:
"Indeed the rule that Ci vii Courts cannot take
cognizance of claims to mere honours or privileges
of the nature referred to above has been unquestioned for many years and every attempt to evade
that rule has met with failure."
The observations of the learned Judge are rather
wide, for, as the earlier decisions show, though a suit
for privileges or honours per se may not lie in a Civil
Court, if they are annexed to an office, they can be
agitated therein. This judgment was taken in appeal
to a division bench of the High Court, consisting of
Leach, C. J., and Somayya, J., who confirmed the
same. They observed:
"lt is acknowledged that a question relating to
the distribution of theertham or other temple
honours cannot be made the subject-matter of a suit
as it is not a question which affects a legal right."
The remarks we made in regard to the observations
of Pandurang Row, J., would equally apply to these
observations. They do not represent the entire law
on the subject, but only a part of it.
{•) (1863) I M.H.C.R. 301.
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
525
It is not necessary to refer to further citations, for
the decisions already cited lay down the relevant
Sri Sinna
principles of law clearly. For convenience of refer- Ramanuja Jeer
ence we may summarize the law on the subject thus:
v.
(1) A suit for a declaration of religious honours and
Sri Ranga
privileges simplicite1· will not lie in a. civil court. (2) Ra1nanuja ] eer
But a suit to establish one's right to an office in a.
Subba Rao ].
temple, and to honours and privileges attached to the
said office as its remuneration or perquisites, is maintainable in a civil court. (3) The essential condition
for the existence of an office is that the holder of the
alleged office shall be under a legal obligation to
discharge the duties attached to the said office and
for the non-observance of which he may be visited
with penalties. (4) So judged, there cannot be an independent office of theerthakar, for a theerthakar has no
obligatory duties to perform; nor can there be an office
of arulipad; the said word only connotes that the
names of the theerthakars are ca.lied out by the archaka
in a certain order. (5) Even if theertham is given or
.other honours a.re shown in a. particular order to a
person holding an office, it does not necessarily follow
that the said honours are part of the remuneration
attached to the office; but it is a question of fact to
be ascertained on the evidence whether the said
honours are attached to the office as part of its perquisites in the sense that they have become an integral part of the ritual to be performed by the recipient
as the office-holder or are only shown to him as a.
mark of respect on the occasion of his visit to the
temple.
Having regard to the said principles, let us now
look at the contentions raised in this case. The first
submission of learned counsel for the appellant is that,
in view of the said principles, the suit should have
been dis missed in limine on the basis of the allegations
in the plaint. In paragraph 4 of the plaint in 0. S.
No. 45 of 1945, the claim of the plaintiff to the office
is s ta. ted th us:
"The plaintiff is the present Emberumanar Jeer
and as such the aradhanaikar itnd trustee of the said
67
526
r96r
5,i Sinna
Ramanuja jeer
v.
Sri Ranga
Ratnanu}a Jeer
Subba Rao ],
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1962]
Emberumanar temple having been appointed and
nominated by his predecessor Sri Sadagopa Ramanuja Jeer who died in 1930."
In paragraph 7 of the plaint, his claim to the honours
is stated thus:
"In his capacity as holder of the office of aradhanaikar and trustee of the Emberumanar temple and
as emoluments attached to the said office, the
Emberumanar Jeer is by immemorial usage and
custom entitled to receive, in the ghoshties that al"e
formed before all the sannidhies in the Adhinathalwar temple on all occasions of each day on all the
days of the year without exception, the first theertham and other honours described in Schedule I
below and the perquisites described in Schedule II
below."
In paragraph 9 it is further stated:
"In his capacity as holder of the office of Aradhanaikar and trustee of Emberumanar temple and as
emoluments attached to the said office the Emberumanar Jeer is entitled to receive on the 7th day of
Vaikasi festival in the Athinathalwar temple, in
addition to and along with the honours and perquisites described in Schedules I and II, certain other
honours such as the tying of the silk gear, etc., more
particularly described in Schedule III hereto. These
are known as special honours while the honours
described in Schedules I and II are known as ordinary honours."
It is clear from the said allegations that the claim of
the plaintiff to the ordinary and special honours in
the A.thinathalwar temple is based upon his capacity as
office-holder as Aradhanaikar and trustee of Emberumanar temple. There is no allegation that he is an
office-holder in Athinathalwar temple. In the writtenstatements filed by the defendants the claim of the
plaintiff to the said honours is denied.
In O.S. No. 46 of 1945 also the claim of the plaintiff
to the honours is based upon the same allegations that
are made in the plaint in 0. S. No. 45 of 1945. In the
written.statement filed by the defendants the said
olaim is denied. Indeed, the original issues reflected
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
527
196r
only the allegations found in the pleadings. If the
courts had directed their minds to the pleadings, as Sri Sinna
they should have done, instead of travelling beyond Ramanuja JeeY
them in search of some plausible basis to sustain the
v.
Sri Ranga
plaintiff's claim the suits would have been dismissed for
the simple reason that on the allegations in the plaint Ramanuja ] eet'
the plaintiff was not an office.holder in the temple of Subba Rao ].
Athinathalwar and, therefore, he could not claim the
honours shown to him in the said temple as perquisites
attached to his office; but unfortunately this was not
done, and we think that it is too late to dismiss the
suit on that ground when all the parties adduced voluminous evidence on the alternative ground and took
the decision of the courts. We shall, therefore, proceed to consider the case on the alternative basis on
which the claim has been put forward on behalf of the
plaintiff in the courts below.
To appreciate the said basis, it is necessary to recapitulate the relevant facts. Originally, the Dist~ict
Munsif dismissed the suit 0. S. No. 320 of 1933 (0. S.
No. 45 of 1945 on the file of the Court of the Subordinate Judge, Tuticorin) on the ground that the plaintiff has no legal right in respect of which he could seek
relief in a civil court. But on appeal the learned
Subordinate Judge set aside the decree and remanded
the suit for trial. In paragraph 18 of his judgment,
the learned Subordinate Judge stated:
"In view of the above authorities I am of opinion
that when the present plaintiff has come to Court
with a specific case set out in paragraphs 7 and 9 of
his plaint that his right of precedence to receive
theertham, thulasi, safa,ri, prasadam and other perquisites forms part of the emoluments of his office
of aradanaikar in the suit temple, the suit cannot
be dismissed on the preliminary ground that it is
barred under Section 9, Civil Procedure Code."
There is an obvious mistake in this statement, for in
the paragraphs mentioned therein it is not alleged that
the plaintiff has an office in the Athinathal war temple.
Presumably this mistake lead the learned Judge to
come to the conclusion which he did. On appeal, in
the High Court it was pointed out to the court that
528
St1PREME COURT REPORTS
[1962]
the plaintiff held no office in the Athinathalwar
temple.
But Chandrasekara Aiyar, J., for the first
SYi Sinna
the plaintiff to make out a new case.
time,
allowed
Ra1nanuja Jeer
The learned Judge stated the said case in the followv,
SYi Ranga
ing words:
Ramanuja jeet'
"One view to take up in this case is what was
adopted
by the District M11nsif, namely, that as the
Subba llao ].
plaintiff admitt.edly holds no office in the Athinathalwar temple he cannot claim these honours. The
other view which found favour with the Subordinate
Judge is that owing to the alleged associations of
the two temples, their interlinking and their interdependence, the Aradanaikar and trustee of the
Emberumanar temple might claim to be regarded
as an office-holder in the Athinathalwar temple."
The learned Judge did not decide the point, but he
observed:
"But the idea of two temples or Mutts, of equal
rank and co-ordinate and independent authority or
where one is the primary institution and the other
its subsidiary or adjunct being linked together for
certain purposes of worship and observance of
rituals cannot be said to be entirely foreign to
Hindu notions."
He concluded thus:
"Of course, before he can succeed in the suit, the
plaintiff has to make out that he being the Aradanaikar and trustee of the Emberumanar temple
amounts to his holding an office in the suit temple."
The question whether the origin of this new case
is found in the judgment of the Subordinate Judge or
that of Chandrasekara Aiyar, J., need not detain us.
This is a new case not disclosed in the plaint; but
after remand both the parties directed their attention
to this question and adduced all the relevant evidence
pertaining thereto.
On remand, the learned Subordinate Judge in an
elaborate judgment considered the said aspect of the
case. He considered the evidence under three heads,
namely, (i) historical, (ii) administrative, and (iii)
financial. On the first head after considering the origin
of the two temples, the learned Judge came to the
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
529
conclusion that the idea that the Emberumanar te'm.
ple was historically connected with Athinathalwar Sri Sinna
temple could not be "poopoohed". Under the adminis- Ra1nanuja jeer
trative head, he found that till 1926 Emberumanar
y.
temple was merely a sub-shrine attached to the bigger Sri RangtJ
Athinathalwar temple, and the trustees of the latter Ratnanuja Jeer
temple were exercising administrative control over it Subba Rao j
as such. Coming then to the financial side, he found
that there was sufficient evidence to justify the inference that the two were intimately connected even
financially. Passing on to the question of ceremonial
and religious association between these two temples,
the learned Judge found that there was similarity in
the mode of routine and day-to-day worship in the two
temples; but there was no interlinking or interdependence between them in that matter. Then the learned
Subordinate Judge pointed out that notwithstanding
that there was no interlinking and interdependence in
that maf>ter, they were so intimately associated with
each other in other religious rites and ceremonies as
to lead to the inference that the Emberumanartemple
was after all only a sub-shrine attached to the main
temple of Athinathalwar. Then he pointed out that
the question in the said form was not before Chandrasekara Aiyar, J., but thought that it was open to him
to go into the said question. After going into the
evidence, he finally came to the conclusion that apart
from historical and secular association, there had been
also ceremor..ial and religious association between the
two temples and, therefore, the Emberumanar temple
was nothing but, a sub-shrine attached to the main
temple of Athinathalwar. On that finding he further
held that the plaintiff who was admittedly the araiJ,hanaikar of the said temple was virtually an office-holder
in the main temple. In the appeals filed by the
various parties against t.he decrees of the learned
Subordinate Judge, tho learned District Judge of
Tirunclveli reviewed the evidence once again under
the said three heads and came to a contrary conclusion. On the administrative side he found that the
Emberumanar temple was not subordinate to the
530
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962]
temple of Athinathalwar, in the sense that the authorities of the latter temple could give orders to the
Sri S1nna
authorities
of the Emberumanar temple, that is, the
Uatnanuja jeer
former
was
not subordinate to the latter temple
v.
Sri Ranga
administratively. On the financial side, he was equally
lla1nanuja ]<ier emphatic that the two institut.ions were not interdependent. On the religions or ritual aspect, the
Subba llau J.
learned District Judge held that, as both the institutions were constructed in the same place, there must
have been some connection between the two and in
that sense in a general way the Emberumanar temple
might be described as a sub-shrine. On the said facts,
the learned Judge posed the following question for
his consideration: "What is the inference to be derived? On the evidence, he answered the question thus:
"I hold on the evidence that these institutions
are not interdependent or intimately connected in
such a way that an office-holder of Emberumanar
tern pie is necessarily an office-holder of the Athinathal war temple. I hold therefore that the plaintiff is not an office-holder of the Athinathalwar
temple and therefore he is not entitled to file a suit
with regard to his rights of precedence in being
given theertham."
This finding is certainly a finding of fact based upon
the entire evidence in the case.
In the second appeal, the learned Judge of the
High Court, on a review of the evidence, disagreed
with the learned District Judge and accepted the finding of the learned Subordinate Judge, and held, for
similar reasons, that the plaintiff was virtually an
office-holder in the main temple; he further held that
the plaintiff could also be considered to be the holder
of the office of arnlipad and, in that capacity also he
was entitled to the first theertham and other honours.
The first question is one of fact. The learned District
Judge, though he differed from the Subordinate
Judge, held, on a consideration of the entire evidence
that the plaintiff was not an office-holder in the Athinathalwar t,emple. It has now been well settled that
the High Court has no jurisdiction to entertain a
second appeal on the ground of erroneous finding of
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
531
fact however gross the error may seem to be. The
judgment of the learned Judge does not disclose that
Sri Sinna
there are any permissible grounds for interference Ramanuja Jeer
with the finding of the District Judge. The second
v
ground of decision of the High Court is based upon a
Sri Ranga
case that was raised for the first time before it. Ra111anuja Jeer
Nowhere in tho plaints or before the two subordinate
courts the plaintiff attempted to sustain his claim on Subha Rao j.
his being the holder of the office of arulipad. The
High Court, therefore, was not justified in allowing
the plaintiff to set out any such claim for the first time
in the second appeal. That apart, it does not appear
that there is an office called arulipad. A division
bench of the Madras High Court in Vathiar Venkatachariar v. P. Ponnappa Ayyengar (') had an occasion
to define the word "arulipad". There, a claim was
ma,de to the office of Theerthakar. On the evidence it
was held that the plaintiffs had not made out the
existence of any obligatory duty on the part of Theerthakar in the temple. In that context Krishnan, J.,
observed thus:
" ............. the Theerthakars have special places
allotted to them in the temple to stand and recite
and they are given the honour of Theertham
and Prasadam, before the outsiders get them; and
they have what is called an "Arulipad", that is,
their names are called out by the Archaka in a certain order, when, if present, they have to respond
by saying 'Nayinde', meaning 'I am here'."
It is, therefore, clear that there is no office designated
as "arulipad", but that word only describes the duty
of the archaka to call their names to ascertain whether the theerthakars are present in the ghoshti. There
is no evidence in this case that the plaintiff, as a
theerthakar, has any obligatory duty in the Athinathalwar temple to perform and, therefore, it is not possible to treat him as an office-holder in that capacity
in the said temple.
This leads us to the argument of the counsel for
the respondent that, though it cannot be said that the
Emberumanar temple is a part or a subordinate of
the Athinathalwar temple in the sense that all the
(1) (1918) 4S I.C. 9S9•
532
Ig6I
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962]
office- holdei;s of the former are the office-holders of
the latter, there is sufficient ritual connection between
Sri Sinna
the
two which in the consciousness of the religious
RamanHja Jeer
public
is treated as sufficiently intimate to make the
v.
Sri Hanga
one subordinate to the other. This intimate religious
Ramanuja Jetr connection, the argument proceeds, flows from the
historic.al, administrat,ive and financial ties, however
Subba R<lo ] .
loose they may be, that have existed for over a century between the said two temples. This argument
may have some validity in a theological discussion or
an ecclesiastical court, but cannot obviously be accepted in a civil court. Krishnaswami N ayudu, J., sum.
marizes the facts in his judgment which, in his view,
support the conclusion that the Emberumanar Jeer
was virtually an office-holder in the Athinathalwar
temple. As the correctness of the said facts is not
questioned before us, it will be convenient to extract
them in the words of the learned Judge:
"In all Vaishnavite temples, the Al wars and the
Acharyas take a prominent place in the religious
ceremonies and observances of the temple. An
attempt was made to show that there has been an
interlinking and interdependence of the ritual and
ceremonies between these two temples, but, as
rightly found by the learned Subordinate Judge, in
the matter of routine and day-to-day worship and
rituals such interlinking and interdependence have
not been satisfactorily made out. The rituals or
the manner of performing divine service are uniform
in every Vaishnavite temple. But, as found by
the learned Subordinate Judge, though a ritual in
the main temple is not dependent upon the ritual
in the sub-shrine, the Emberumanar deity being an
Acharya is intimately associated with the deity in
the main temple in all the important festivals, the
most important of which are the Margali and
Vaikasi festivals and other religious ceremonies.
There are several Mandagapadis for the Athinatha
Al war in the Emberumanar temple. There is Sethu
Thirumanjam for the Athinatha Alwar and Emberumanar deities on three occasions, two of them
in the Emberumanar tem]Jle and one in the main
2 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
533
temple. Then there is what is called Alwar Sayanam which has to take place on the 10th day of the
Sri Sinna
M argali festival and which is performed in the Ramanuja Jeer
main temple. There are several other similar reliv.
Sri Ranga
gious observances, where the two deities meet and
certain rituals and religious ceremonies are gone Ramanuja jeer
through. The daily ritual in a Vaishnavite temple Subba Rao ].
is a routine matter and on occasions, for instance,
in the months of Margali and Vaikasi and on other
festival days, there is necessity for the Al wars and
the Acharyas to meet the main deity and ceremonies suitable to the occasions are performed. It is
not possible to imagine a temple where God Vishnu
is installed without the presence of the Al wars and
Acharyas. Alwars and Acharyas are devotees of
God Vishnu who have received divine recognition
in their lives and the festivals in relation to them
depict incidents of such manifestation of divine
grace to his devotees.
It may also be mentioned that the installation of
each Emberumanar Jeer, who it may be stated is
a Sanyasi, is in the Athinatha Al war temple under
its Dwajasthamba, the flag staff, and the declaration
of the status of the succeeding Jeer is made only in
the presence of the deity of the main temple."
We may also add to the said facts that at one
time the share of tasdik allowance to the Emberumanar temple was paid through the trustee of Athinathalwar temple and there was also an occasion
when a trustee of the Emberumanar temple was dismissed by the trustee of the Athinathalwar temple.
On the other hand, both the temples are under different managements, they have their separate officeholders, distinct rituals, different budgets, and separate endowments; and in the year 1926 on an application filed by the Emberumanar Jeer, the Religious
Endowments Board declared the temple as an excepted temple indicating thereby that the Emberumanar
temple was a separate legal entity and that the said
Jeer was its hereditary trustee. The only question,
therefore, is whether the said facts enable a court to
08
534
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962]
hold that one temple is subordinate or part of the other
temple, so that the office-holders of one temple would
Sri Sinna
become the office-holders of the other. The facts
Ramnnuja jeer
clearly
establish that in fact and in law the two instiv.
Sti Rangri
tutions are different legal entities. In the past, the
Ramanuja jeer trustees of Athinathalwar temple might have disbursed tasdik allowances contributed by the Gove"rnment
Subba Rao J,
to the various temples, including the Emberumanar
temple, but it is well known that for convenience of
administration the services of the trustees of a larger
temple were very often utilized by the Government
in that regard; it might have been that sometimes the
amounts payable to the smaller temples were allowed
to lapse, but there is nothing on the record to show
that it was not out of negligence of the trustees of
the minor shrines in not making any pressing demands
on the trustees of Athinathalwar temple; it might
also have been that the trustee of the bigger temple,
in his supervisory capacity, dismissed once in a way
the trustee of a smaller shrine in the locality, but
that could be explained by the paramount position of
the trustee of the bigger temple in the locality compared to that of the minor temples. These and such
acts may show that the trustee of the Athinathalwar
temple had exercised similar supervisory control in
the past over the minor temples; but that in itself
does not make the trustee of the temple of Emberumanar an office-holder in the bigger temple. It is
well known that in the past the temples were under
the supervision of the Revenue Board and later on
under various temple committees. It cannot be suggested that on that account the trustees of the minor
temples were officers in the Revenue Boi.rd or the
temple committees, as the case may be. We cannot
also appreciate how the mutual visits of the idols to
the other's temple and the honours shown to the idols
on such visits could have any bearing on the question
to be decided, though they reflect the intimate relationship that exists between the Lord and his ardent
devotee Ramanuja in the public consciousness. But
such cordial relationship existing between two independent temples cannot in the eye of law make th(;
'I
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
535
one a part of the other. Two independent institutions
legally cannot, Lxcept in the manner known to law, Sri Sinna
be amalgamated into one institution by developing Ramanuja jeer
merely sentimental attachment between them. This
v,
argument was rightly rejected by the learned District Sri Ranga
Judge, and the High Court went wrong in accepting Ramanuja Jeer
it.
Subba Rao ],
Before we close we must make it, clear that by this
judgment we have not in any way intended to express
our view in the matter of honours that are customa..
rily shown to one or other of the parties in these
appeals in the temple of Athinathalwar.
In the result we hold, agreeing with the District
Judge, that the suits were not maintainable in the
civil court. The appeals are, therefore, allowed with
costs throughout.
Appeals allowed.
ROTA VENKATA SURYA SIVARAMA SASTRY
v.
STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH
(P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR, A. IC SARKAR,
K. c. DAS GUPTA, N. RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR
and J. R. MUDHOLKAR, JJ.)
Abolition of Estates-Enactment providing for State taking over
estates by notification-Part of estate outside the operation of enactment-Legislation extending its operation-Notifications in respect
of estate, each part separately-Legality-Madras Scheduled Areas
Estates (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Regulation, 1951
(Regulation 4 of 1951), s. 2-M adras Estates (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act, 1948 (Madras 26 of 1948), ss. 1(4), 3, 25,
The areas in question which were parts of two estates
belonging to the appellants, called Gangole A and Gangole C,
were situated in what was known as the Godavari Agency tract
which was governed by the Scheduled Districts Act, 1874, By
s, 92 of the Government of India Act, 1935, no Act of the Provincial Legislature was applicable to certain areas in which the
Godavari Agency was included, unless the Governor by public
April z8.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org