L. N. MUKHERJEE versus THE STATE OF MADRAS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 19 April 1961 | [1962] 2 S.C.R. 116 | 1961 INSC 164
Key facts
- Decided
- 19 April 1961
- Bench
- K. SUBBA RAO*, RAGHUBAR DAYAL
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 119/1960
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1962] 2 S.C.R. 116
- Neutral citation
- 1961 INSC 164
Text of the judgment
116
SUPRE..'1E COURT REPORTS
[1962]
addressed to the appellant's firm is not proved to have
returned to the dead-letter office or to the Chief ConPur11slintlttmdaJ
troller
of Imports and Exports. If it was delivered by
l>almitt
the postman at the Shop Xo. 16, ordinary courteRy
v.
Slttle of
requires that that shop would have Rent over the
W esl Rengal
letter to thl' neighbouring Shop Xo. 19. The appell1int's conduce in not ta.king any action to find out
Ragltubar
w'ia.t was the result of his rrprcsentation to the Chief
D•y•I ] .
Controller of Imports and Exports is consistent with
the view that he did receive the reply of the Chief
Controller of Imports and Exports. In the l'ircumstance8, an expression of opinion t}rn.t. t lie let tor would
have reached the appt•llant cirnnot. b,. said to amount
to a misdirection.
Tho learner! Judge is perfectly justified to ask the
jury to take into consideration the probabilities of a.
case, whore no definite evidence, in connection with
an incidental matter, exists.
We do not consider that the contentions raised do
a.mount to misdirections.
In view of the above, we see no force in this appoal
a.nd accordingly dismiss it.
Appr.al dismi.ised.
L. N. MUKHERJEE
t'.
April i9.
THE STATE OF MADRAS
(K. SuB!lA RA.o and ltao1n:llAR DAYAL, JJ.)
Criminal Trial- Jurisdiction-Court having jurisdictio>t to
tr1: offences cammitted in pursua11ce of conspiracy, •f can try the
oJJence of criminal conspiracy-Code of Cmnii:al Proctdure, 1898
(V of 1898), ss. 177, 239-lndian Penal Code, 1860 (Act X LV of
1860). ss. 120-B, 420, 463.
The appellant was committed to the Court of Session at
trial under s. 120-B read with s. 420 of the Indian
Penal Code and for committing the offence o! forgery in pursuance of that conspiracy. The Criminal conspiracy was alleged
to have been cvmmitted at Calcutta, while the other offences in
~iadras for
.''
I
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
117
196r
pursuance thereof were committed at Madras. It was urged on
behalf of the appellant that the ;iiadras Court had no jurisdicL. lV. 111ukherje6
tion to try the offence of crirninal conspiracy.
V,
H cld, that the court having the jurisdiction to try the
State of 1'+1adras
offences committed in pursuance of the conspiracy, has also th(!
jurisdiction to try the offence of crin1inal conspiracy, even though
it \Vas committed outside its territorial jurisdiction.
Purushottamdas Dalmia v. State of West Bengal, [IC,62]
2 S.C.R. ror, applied.
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION:
Criminal
Appeal No. 119 of 1960.
Appeal by speoia.I leave from the ju<lgment and
order dated April 14, 1960, of the i\faclrns High
Court in Cr. Misc. Petition No. 246 of 1960.
D. N. J[ ukherjee, for the appellant.
M. S. K. Sastri and T. 111. Sen, for respondent.
1961. April 19. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
RAGRUBAR DAYAL, J.-This appeal, by special
leave, is against the order of the Madras High Court
dismissing the application for quashing the commitment of the case against the appellant, to the Court of
Session, for trial of offences of criminal conspiracy to
cheat under s. 120-B read with s. 420, Indian Penal
Code, and for the offence of forgery committed in pursuance of that conspiracy. The criminal conspiracy is
alleged to have been committed at Calcutta. The
other offences in pursuance of the conspirncy are
alleged to have been committed within the jurisdiction
of the Court of Session at Madras. The quashing of
the commitment was sought on the ground that thP
Courts at Madras had no jurisdiction to try the offence
of conspiracy. The High Court did not accept the
contention and dismissNI f,he application.
The sole question for cunsideration in this appeal is
whether the offence of conspiracy alleged to have been
committed at Calcutta can be tried by the Court of
Session at Madras.
We have held t,his day, in Purushottamdas Dalmia
v. The State of West Bengal(') that the Court ha,•ing
(1) [1962] 2 S,C,R. IOI.
llaghubar
Dayal J.
f
f
118
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1962]
jurisdiction to try the offence of criminal conspiracy
can
also try offences committed in pursuance of that
L. N. Muklt1rjr•
conspiracy
even if those offences were committed out •
••
St till of M odrtis side the jurisdiction of th st Court, ss the provisions of
s. 239, Criminal Procedure Code, sre not controlled by
Raghuba"
the provisions of s. 177, Criminal Procedure Code, which
Doyol j.
do not crestP a.n absolute prohibition against the trial
of offences by s Court other than the one within whose
jurisdiction the offence is committed. On s parity of
reasoning, the Court having jurisdiction to try the
offences committ~d in pursuance of the conspiracy,
ca.n try the offence of conspiracy even if it we.a committed outside its jurisdiction. We therefore hold
that the ordn under appeal is correct snd, accordingly, dismiss this sppesl.
Appeal dismissed.
JAGANNATH AND OTHERS
April ao.
v.
UNION OF INDIA
(P. n. GAJENDRAGADKAR, A. K. SARKAR,
K. N. WANOJIOO, ICC. DAS GUP'l'A, snd
N. RAJAOOPALA AYYANGAR JJ.)
Excise Duty-Tobacco-Diffrrenl rates for 111llole leaf and
broken leaf-If discriminatory-Central Excises and Salt Act,
1944 (/ of z944), First Schedule Entry 4(I) Items 5 and 6-COll·
stitution of India, Art. 14.
Item 5 of entry 4(1) of the First Schedule to the Central Excise and Salt Act, 1944, itnposes an excise duty of I{s. I-Io nP. per
kilogram on tobacco other than flue cured and not actually used
for the manufacture of cigarettes, smoking mixtures for pipes
and cigarettrs or biris in the whole leaf form. Item 6 imposes
a duty of Rs. 2-20 nP. per kilogram on tobacco in the broken
leaf form. The petitioners who dealt in tobacco in the broken
leaf form contended that their tobacco could not be distinguished on any rational basis from the whole leaf form in Item 5 and
the imposition of a double tariff on their !obacco was invalid
as it was based on unconstitutional discrimination, the tariff
being on the basis of use to which the tobacco was put.
r
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org