THE NEW MANECK CHOWK SPINNING AND WEAVING CO., LTD., AHMEDABAD AND OTHERS versus THE TEXTILE LABOUR ASSOCIATION, AHMEDABAD
Supreme Court of India | Decided 7 December 1960 | [1961] 3 S.C.R. 1 | 1960 INSC 244
Key facts
- Decided
- 7 December 1960
- Bench
- P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR*, A.K. SARKAR*, K. SUBBA RAO, K.N. WANCHOO, J.R. MUDHOLKAR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 351/1960
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1961] 3 S.C.R. 1
- Neutral citation
- 1960 INSC 244
Text of the judgment
t
THE SUPREME COURT REPORTS
THE NEW MANECK CHOWK SPINNING AND
WEAVING CO., LTD., AHMEDABAD
AND OTHERS
v.
THE TEXTILE LABOUR ASSOCIATION,
AHMED ABAD
(P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR, A. K. SARKAR,
K. SUBBA RAO, K. N. WANCHOO and
J. R. MUDHOLKAR, JJ.)
i
Industrial Dispute-Profit bonus-Agreement between Labour
and Mill-owners-Full Bench Formula, whether contravened by
Agreement-Tribunal's competence to extend Agreement.
The respondent, the Textile Labour Association at Ahmedabad, entered into a five years pact with the Ahmedabad MillOwners' Association, representing the member mills, in regard
to payment of bonus to the employees of the mills for the years
1953,57. The Labour Unlon demanded bonus for the year 1958
on the basis of the pact, but the mill-owners claimed that the pact
was contrary to the formula evolved by the Full Bench in Mill
Owners' Association, Bombay v. The Rashtriya Mill M azdoor Sangh,
Bombay, [1950] 2 L.L.J. 247, which was approved by the Supreme
Court in The Associated Cement Companies Ltd. v. Its Workmen,
[1959] S.C.R. 925, inasmuch as (1) rehabilitation provided in
the Agreement differed vitally from rehabilitation as explained
in that decision, (2) the_ Agreement provided for payment of a
minimum bonus even though there may be no available surplus
and even though the particular mill might have made actual
loss, and (3) while the Full Bench Formula, as approved by the
Supreme Court treated a particular year as a self-sullicient
unit, there was provision for set-off and set-on in the Agreement.
The Industrial Tribunal to which the dispute was referred in
t4e form of sixty-six references, one relating to each mill, took
the view that the pact did not in any· way run counter to the
law. laid down by the Supreme Court, ·and that the extension of
the agreement for one more year would help in promoting peace
in the industry in Ahmedabad.
·· Held (Subba Rao, J'.-ditsenting), thaf the Agreement in
question departed from the Full ·Bench, Formula in the. matter•
of bonus,, in certain vital aspects and that the' Tribunal when it·
extended the Agreement for the_.year 1958 was.ignoring the law
as laid down by the Supreme Courtas to what profit boiius waa
and how it should be worked out.
I
1960
Decnnber 7.
2
New Manech
Chowk Spg. <!>
Wvg. Co. Ltd,
v.
Te%tife Labour
Association
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961]
f
The Tribunal had no power by extending the Agreement to
make it possible for payment of a minimum bonus for the year
1958 even when thel'I> was either insufficient available surplus
to pay bonus or no available surplus at all or even actual loss.
The jurisdiction of the Tribunal was limited by its terms of
reference, which was not on industry-cum-region basis, but one
for each mill to consider the question of bonus for each mill for
the year 1958 and, consequently, it had no jurisdiction to apply
the principle of set-off and set-on to be found in the Agreement
in respect of payment of bonus or take into account the profits
of the industry as a whole in Ahmedabad.
Per Gajendragadkar, Sarkar, Wanchoo and Mudho1kar, JJ.It is open to an industrial court in an appropriate case to impose
new obligations on the parties before it or modify contracts in
the interest of industrial peace or give awards which may have.
the effect of extending Agreement or making new one, but this
power is conditioned by the subject matter with which it is
dealing and also by the existing industrial law and it would not
be open to it while dealing with a particular matter before it to
overlook the industrial l.a.w relating to that matter as laid down
by the legislature or by the Supreme Court.
Western India Automo.bile Association v. Industrial Tribunal,
Bombay, [194g] F.C.R. 3i1, Rohtas Industries Limited v. Brijnandan Pandey, [1956] S.C.R. Boo and Patna Electricity Supply Co.
v. Patna Electric Supply Workers' Union, [1959] Supp. 2 S.C.R.
761, relied on.
Per Sobba Rao, J.-(r) The impugned five years pact was
not contrary to industrial law as laid down by the Supreme
Court. (2) The pact also did not infringe the principle that
bonus depends upon profits; but it applied the same by evolving
a formula of set-off and set-on to a complicated situation of the
entire industry in a particular area for a number of years. (3)
The Full Bench Formula in regard to rehabilitation was not contravened by the pact. The decisions of the Supreme Court did
not preclude employers' and employees from agreeing to a particular valuation of the block having regard to the circumstances
obtaining at the time of the agreement. (4) Neither the Full
Bench Formula nor the decisions of the Supreme Court affirm·
ing it precluded the Tribunal from extending the terms of the
pact by another year if that was· necessary to maintain industrial peace.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION:
Nos, 351-356 and 358-369 of 1960.
Civil Appeals
Appeals by special leave from the Award Pa.rt I of
the Industrial Court, Bombay, in References IC,Nos.
261, 297, 238, 241, 248, 263, 266, 271, 301, 302, 257,
237 296, 299, '300, 283 and 284 of 1959. ·
'
.
).
t
3 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
3
N. A. Palkhivala, I. M. Nanavati, S. N. Andley,
{
J.B. Dadachanji, Rameshwar Nath and P. L. Vohra,
for the appellants in C. A. No. 351 of 1960.
N. A. Palkhivala, J. B. Mehta, S. N. Andley, J. B.
Dadachanji, Rameshwar Nath and P. L. Vohra, for the
appellants in C.As. Nos. 352 and 358 of 1960.
R. J. Kolah, J.B. Mehta, S. N. Andley, J. B. Dadachanji, Rameshwar Nath and P. L. Vohra, for the
appellants in C.As. Nos. 353 and 362of1960.
New Manetk
Chowk Spg. &
Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
Texttl~ Labour
Association
I. M. Nanavati, S. N. Andley, J. B. Dadachanji,
Rameshwar Nath and P. L. Vohra, for the appellants
in C. As. Nos. 354, 356, 363-365, 367 and 369 of
1960.
J. B. Mehta, S. N. AnQ,ley, J. B. Dadachanji,
Rameshwar Nath and P. L. Vohra, for the appellants
in C. As. Nos. 355, 359-361, 366 and 368 of 1960.
S. R. Vasavada, for the respondent in C. As. Nos.
351, 352, 355, 358, 360-364, and 368 of 1960.
N. H. Shaikh, for the respondent in C. As. Nos. 353
and 365 of 1960.
N. M. Barot, for the respondent in C. As. Nos. 354, ·
359 and 367 of 1960.
J(. L. Hathi, for the respondent in C. As. Nos. 366
and 369 of 1960.
1960. December 7. The Judgment of Gajendragadkar, Sarkar, Wanchoo and Mudholkar, JJ. was delivered by Wanchoo, J. Subba. Rao, J. delivered a
separate Judgment.
WANCHOO, J.-These eighteen appeals by special Wanchoo ].
•
leave raise a common question and will be dealt with
by this judgment. The appellants are certain cotton
textile mills in Ahmedaba.d while the respondent in
each appeal is the Textile Labour Association,
Ahmedabad, which is a representative union of the
cotton textile workers in Ahmedabad. The total
number of cotton textile mills in Ahmeda.ba.d is 66;
therefore, 66 references under s. 73-A of the Bombay
Industrial Relations Act, No. XI of 1947 (hereinafter
called the Act), were made to the industrial court for
arbitration of disputes arising out of notices of change
4
r960
New Maneck
Chowk Spg. b
Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
Textile Labour
Association
Wanchoo ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961)
given by the respondent making a demand for bonus
for employees of textile mills in Ahmedabad. It
appears that there was an agreement between the
Textile Labour Association and the Ahmedabad Millowners' Association representing the member-mills on
June 27, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as the Agreement), with respect to payment of bonus by the mills
to their employees. The Agreement was to remain in
force for a period of five years, beginning with
January 1, 1953, and ending with December 31, 1957,
and related to bonus for the five calendar years from
1953 to 1957 (both inclusive). When the Agreement
came to an end disputes arose about bonus for the year
1958. The Agreement was not extended and a notice
of change under s. 42 of the Act was given by the
Textile Labour Association to the Ahmedabad Millowners' Association on July 21, 1959, claiming that all
the employees employed during the year 1958 in the
member-mills be paid an adequate amount of bonus
having regard to the volume of profits, if any, or some
bonus irrespective of profits to fill the gap between the
existing wage and the living wage so as to avoid
unrest among the employees. It further appears th;>t
notice in the same terms was given to individual mills
about the same time. As no agreement was arrived
at between the parties, 66 references with respect to
the sixty-six mills were made to the industrial court
as already mentioned above. The industrial court
considered all the sixty-six references together and
came to the conclusion that the Agreement of 1955
had worked fairly to both sides and was substantially
in accord with the long-standing practice in the
industry in Ahmedabad even before the Agreement
and that its extension for one year was essential for
keeping industrial peace. It therefore ordered the
extension of the Agreement for the year 1958 and
directed the parties to file within six weeks from the
date of· the award calculations of bonus payable for
the year 1958 in the light of the decision and thereafter the court would proceed to award appropriate
bonus in the case of each h~_dividual mill. Thereupon
there were fifty-two applications for special leave to
•
•
'
..
3 s.c.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
5
appeal to this Court in which special leave was granted. Thirty-four of the appeals arising out of the New Man!'ck
special leave petitions have been withdrawn and only Chowk Spg. &eighteen now remain for decision. It appears that the Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
remaining fourteen mills accepted the decision of the
Textile Labour
industrial court, so that now forty-eight mills are out Assoc·iaJion
of the picture and only eighteen are before the Court.
The main contention of the appellants before the ~Vanchoo ].
industrial court was that in view of the law laid down
as to bonus by this Court in the Associated Cement Companies Ltd. v. The Workmen (1 ), it was not open to it to
extend the Agreement for the year 1958 as that would
be against the concept of bonus as understood in
industrial Jaw. The same point is being urged before
us and the question that falls for decision is whether
the industrial court was right in law in extending the
Agreement for another year.
In order to appreciate the dispute between the parties with respect to the extension of the Agreement
we may refer to the salient terms of the Agreement.
Before we do so, we may mention that the Agreement
was "without renouncing the general principles enunciated in decisions and awards of the arbitration
boards, the industrial court, the Labour Appellate
Tribunal and the Supreme Court in respect of bonus
or the rights and privileges created thereunder". It
was entered into only with a view to creating goodwill among workers and for the purpose of maintaining peace in the industry and without creating a precedent for the future. The Agreement in the first
place provided that the claim of the employees for
bonus would only arise if there is an available surplus of profit after making provision for all the prior
charges. These prior charges were: (i) statutory depreciation and the development rebate; (ii) taxes; (iii)
reserve for rehabilitation, replacement and modernisation of block as calculated by the industrial court
(basic year 1947); (iv) six per centum return on paid-up
capital including bonus shares; and (v) two per cent.
return on reserves employed as working capital. After
the available surplus was determined thus, a mill
(I) [1959] S.C.R. 925.
6
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961)
having an available surplus of profit had to pay to its
employees
bonus which would in no case be less than
New ~1aneck
Chowh Spg. & an amount equivalent to 4•8% of basic wages earned
Wvg. Co. Ltd. during the year; nor wa!\ it to exceed an amount
v.
equivalent to 25% of the basic wages earned during
Textile Labof:4r
the year. It was also provided that in case ~he availAssociation
able surplus was more than sufficient for granting
bonus at a higher figure than the ceiling of twentyWane/Joo j.
five per centum of basic wages earned during the year
and the maximum bonus of 25 per centum was paid,
such a mill would be deemed to have set a.side a part
of the residue of available surplus after grant of maximum bonus not exceeding 25 per cent. of the basic
wages earned during the year as a reserve for bonus
for purposes of "set on" (adjustment) in subsequent
years. Secondly it was provided that where in the
case of a mill, the available surplus was not more
than the ceiling of 25 per cent. of basic wages fixed
for bonus, the bonus would be fixed after deducting at
least Rs. 10,000 from the available surplus. Further
it was provided that if a mill had an available surplus
of profits which would suffice to 'pay bonus at a rate
lower than the minimum of 4'8 per cent. it would pay
the minimum and would be entitled to set off the
excess amount thus paid against the available surplus
in a subsequent year or years and there were provisions how this set-off would be worked out. Lastly
it was provided that if the profits of a mill were not
sufficient to provide for all prior charges as mentioned
above, though it had made profits, or where the mill
had actually suffered a loss, such a mill would as a
special case for creating good will among its workers
and for continuing peace in the industry but without
creating a precedent pay to its employees the minimum bonus equivalent to 4·8 per cent. of the basic
wages but would be entitled to set off this amount towards any available surplus in any subsequent years,
subject, however, always to a payment of a minimum
bonus at the rate of 4·8 per cent. of basic wages earned during the year.
It has been contended on behalf of'the appellants
that the formula under the Agreement departs in
•
•
•
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
•
7
some vital aspects from what is known as the Full
Bench formula evolved by the Labour Appellate Tri- New Maneck
bunal in The Mill-owners' Association, Bombay v. The Chowk Spg. b
Rashtriya Mill Mazdoor Sangh('), which has been Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
approved by this Court in the Associated Cement Companies' case (') and is thus the law of the land so far Te~tile Labour
as bonus is concerned. It is urged therefore that in- Association
asmuch as the formula under the Agreement departs Wanchoo ].
from the Full-Bench formula which is now the law of
the land, it was not op{ln to the industrial court to extend the Agreement in the face of the decision of this
Court in Associated Cement Companies' case(') and in
so far as the industrial court has done so it has gone
against the law relating· to bonus and therefore the
award should be set aside.
·
Two questione immediately arise in this connection:
the first relates to the jurisdiction of the industrial
court to impose new obligations upon the parties and
the second is whether if the industrial court has jurisdiction to impose new obligations it could do so in a
matter of this kind considering the concept of bonus
as laid down by the decisions of this Court.
So far as the first question is concerned (namely,
the general power of an industrial court to impose
new obligations upon the parties), the matter is now
well-settled by the decisions of the Federal Court and
also of this Court. It was held by the Federal Court
in Western India Automobile Association v. Industrial
Tribunal, Bombay and Others (') that"adjudication does not in our opinion mean adjudication according to the strict law of master and
servant. The award of the tribunal may contain
provisions for settlement of a dispute which no
court could order if it was bound by ordinary law,
but the tribunal is not fettered in any way by these
limitations."
The Federal Court also approved the view of Ludwig
Teller that"industrial arbitration may involve the extension
of an agreement or the making· of a new one, or in
(I) [1950] 2 L.L.J. 1247.
(2) [1959] S.C.R. 925.
(3) [1949] F.C.R. 321.
'
8
New Maneck
Chowk Spg. O>
Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
T~~tile Labour
Association
Ji'l"anchoo j.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961)
general the creation of new obligations or modification of old ones while commercial arbitration generally concerns itself with interpretation Of existing
• obligations and disputes relating to existing agreements (see p. 345)."
This Court also in Rohtas Industries Ltd. v. Brijnandan Pandey (1) held th!l.t"a court of law proceeds on the footing that no
power exists in the courts to make contracts for the
people; and the parties must make their own contracts. The Courts reach their limit of power when
they enforce contracts which the parties have made.
An industrial tribunal is not so fettered and may
create new obligations or modify contracts in the
interests of industrial peace, to protect legitimate
trade union activities and to prevent unfair practice
and/or victimisation (seep. 810)."
In Patna Electric Supply Oo. v. Patna Electric Supply
Workers' Union('), this Court held that"there is no doubt that in appropriate cases
industrial adjudication may impose new obligations
on the employer in the interest of social justice and
with the object of securing peace and harmony between the employer and his workmen and full cooperation between thei:n (see p. 1038)."
and approved of the decision of the Federal Court in
Western India Automobile Association's case ('). There
is no doubt therefore that it is open to an industrial
court in an appropriate case to impose new obligations on the parties before it or modify contracts in
the interest of industrial peace or give awards which
may have the effect of extending existing agreement
or making a new one. This, however, does not mean
than an industrial court can do anything and everything when dealing with an industrial dispute. This
power is conditioned by the subject-matter with which
it is dealing and also by the existing industrial law
and it would not be open to it while dealing with a
particular matter before it to overlook the industrial
(1) [1956] S.C.R. Boo.
(2) [1959] Supp. 2 S.C.R. 761.
(3) [111-49] F.C.R. 321.
•
..
'
..;._,.
~
-;
;
3 S.O.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
9
law relating to that matter as laid down by the legislature or by this Court.
New A1antck
This brings us to the second question; which is the Chowk Spg. b
real question in dispute in this case, namely, whel} Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
dealing with a bonus case, like the present, was it
open to the industrial court to overlook the law laid Te.tlile LaboH1
down by this Court in Associated Cement Companies' Association
case(') and make an award extending the Agreement Wanclloo ].
for a further period of one year?
In order to determine this question, we have to
look at the concept of bonus as evolved in the industrial law of this country by industrial tribunals and
_now by the decision of this Court. So far as we can
see, there are four types of •bonus which have been
evolved under the industrial law as laid down by this
Court. Firstly, there is what is called a production
bonus or incentive wage (see Titaghur Paper Mills v.
I ts Workmen (') ); the second is bonus as an implied
term of contract between the parties (see Messrs.
lspahani Ltd. v. lspahani Employees' UniQn (')); the
third is customary bonus in connection with some
festival (see The Graham Trading Go. v. Its Workmen(')) and the fourth is profit bonus which was evolved by the Labour Appellate Tribunal in The Millowners' Association Bombay v. The Rashtriya Mill
Mazdoor Sangh, Bombay (6 ), and which has been considered by this Court fully in two cases. We are in the
present case dealing with bonus of the fourth kind,
namely, profit bonus and what we say subsequently
refers only to this kind of bonus.
What is the concept of profit bonus with which we
are concerned in this case, for it is this concept which
will determine whether it was open to the industrial
court in this case to exter.d the Agreement for 1958?
In Muir Mills .Go. Ltd. v. Suti Mills Mazdoor
Union (6 ), this Court pointed out that"There are two conditions, which have to be satisfied before a demand for bonus can be justified and
(1) [1059] S.C.R. 9Z5
(3) [1960] I S.C.R. :24.
(5) [1950] :z L.L.J. 1247,
(2)
[t9)9] Supp. 2 S.C.R. 1012.
(-4) [1q60] I S.C_R. 107.
(6) [1955] 1 S.C.R. 991.
IO
l\rew Ma,uch
Chowk Spg. ii-·
lf"vg_ Co. Ltd.
v.
Textile labour
Association
~Vanchoo
J.
SUPREME COURT. REPORTS
[1961]
they are: (1) when wages fall short of the living standard, and (2) industry makes huge profits part of
which are due to the contribution which the workmen make in increasing production. The demand
for bonus becomes an industrial claim ............ The
basis for the claim .is that labour and capital both
contribute to the earning of the industrial concern
and it is fair that labour should derive some benefit, if there is a surplus after meeting prior or necessary charges ............... The surplus that remained
after meeting the aforesaid prior charges would be
available for distribution as bonus."
The matter was again considered by this Court in t.he
Associated Cement Companies' case (1) where the Full
Bench formula evolved by the Labour Appellate Tribunal was gone into at length. The workmen contended in that case that the formula required revision as
the employers were becoming increasingly more rehabilitation-conscious and their appetite for the provision
for rehabilit.ation was fast growing with the result
that in most cases, after allowing for rehabilitation,
there was no surplus left for the purpose of bonus and
the main object of the formula was thus frustrated.
It was further contended for the workmen that the
whole of rehabilitation expenses should not be provided for out of trading profits and that the claim for
rehabilitation should be fixed at a reasonable amount
and the industry should be required to find the
balance from other sources. It was there held that"though there may be some force in the plea
made for the revision of the Full Bench formula,
the problem raised by the said plea is of such a
character that it can appropriately be considered
only by a high-powered commission and not by this
Court, while hearing the present group of appeals."
This Court also held that" the Full Bench formula had on the whole worked fairly satisfactorily in a large number of industries all over the country, and the claim for bonus
should be decided by the Tribunals on the basis of
this formula without attempting to revise it. The
(1) [1959] S.C.R. 925.
(
'
I
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COUR'l' REPORTS
1
11
formula. was elastic enough to meet reasonably the
claims of the industry and labour for fair-play and ~vew Mantck
justice ............ It was based on two considerations: Chowk Spg. &
first, that labour was entitled to claim a share in the H'ug. Co. Ltd.
v.
trading profits of the industry, because it had partially contributed to the same; and second, that Textile Labour
Association
labour was enhtled to claim that the gap between
its actual wage -a.nd the Ii ving wage should within H'a~ichoo J.
reasonable limits be filled up."
The Full Bench formula provided for arriving at the
available surplus after meeting prior charges, namely,
(i) depreciation, (ii) taxes, (iii) return on paid-up
capital, (iv) return on working ca.pita.I a.nd (v) rehabilitation. The formula further dealt with the claim
for bonus on the basis that the relevant year is a. self.
sufficient unit and appropriate accounts have to be
made in respect of the said year. Finally, it wa.s pointed out that it was only after all the prior charges ha.d
thus been determined and deducted from the gross
profits that the available surplus could be a.sserta.ined
for payment of bonus, and that when the ava.il~ble
surplus had been ascertained, there were three parties
entitled to claim shares therein, namely, (i) labour's
claim for bonus, (ii) industry's claim for the purpose
of expansion and other needs, and (iii) the shareholders' claim for additional return on the capita.I invested by them; the ratio of distribution would necessarily depend on several factors. It would thus be
clear that the essential concept of profit bonus is that
there should be an available surplus determined according to the principles laid down in the cases mentioned above for distribution. If there is no such available surplus for distribution, there can be no case for
payment of profit bonus. This is the industrial law
as laid down by this Court with respect to this kind
of bonus in Associated Cement Companies'- case ('). It
would in onr opinion he not open to an industrial
court or tribunal to ignore this law as to bonus and
to ~xtend an agreement for payment of bonus, which is
ag~inst the basic concept of bonus as laid down by
the decisions of this Court on the ground that an
(1) [1959] S.C.R. 925.
12
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961]
industrial court has power generally to extend agreements or to create new obligations. As :ilready poinNew .11aneck
ted
out, that power has to be exercised keeping in
Chowk spg . .s.
view the subject-matter before the triounal and the
Wvg. Co. Ltd.
law la.id down by the legislature or by the decisions
Textil~ Labour
of this Court, with respect to that subject-matter.
Association
The industrial court in this case was not unaware of
this
position, viz., that it was departing from the law
Wandoo J.
laid down in the Associated Cement Companies' case (1)
and other bonus cases; but it held that this Court was
dealing in those cases with individual units, and not
with a case where there were numerous concerns in
an industry at one centre, with its particular historical
back-ground, where previous awards had been on an
industry-wise basis. It therefore held that the decisions of this Court could not apply in their entirety to
the dispute before it and that this Court could not
have intended that in a case where there was the additional circumstance that the parties had themselves
voluntarily modified the bonus formula in some respects by a long term agreement, that could not be
extended by an industrial court. It is the correctness
of this view which has been strongly disputed before
us by the appellants.
Before we deal with this matter, we should like to
point out that the fact that there are numerous concerns in a particular place can have no relevance in
considering the question whether the Full Bench formula can apply to cases like the present. Even though
this Court was dealing with the case of one concern,
namely, the Associated Cement Companies, it pointed
out that the Full Bench formula had worked fairly
satisfactorily all over the country and should continue
to be applied without revision till such time as a highpowered commission went· into the question. There
is in our opinion no question of industry-cum-region
approach in the matter of a bonus dispute of this
kind. There is no doubt that in many matters, like
wages, conditions of service, over-1.ime allowance,
dearness allowance, gratuity, and so on, industry-cumregion approach has been made by industrial courts
1960
..
(t) [1959] S.C.R. 9•5.
,
1
f
•
3 S.C.R.
"
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
13
in this country and, rightly so. But there is, in our
opinion, no scope for an a pp roach of this kind in the J.\Tew Maneck
case of bonus, the basic concept of which is that pay- Chowk Stg . .S.
ment depends on surplus of profits available according Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
to some formula in the case of each industrial concern.
Nor can it be said that the Agreement in this case is Textile Labour
dealing with bonus in what is known as industry-cum- A.~socialicnt
region basis. Its salient terms as set out above will iv anchoo J,
show that it deals with bonus according to available
surplus of each mill, so that bonus paid by each mill
depends on its own available surplus and the sixty-six
mills situate in Ahmedabad may pay different
amounts of bonus varying from a minimum of 4·8 per
cent. of the basic wages to 25 per cent. of the basic
wages. Similar differences will arise if the Full
Bench formula is applied to the sixty-six mills in
Ahmedabad. Thus the Agreement which has been
extended, is not based on industry.cum-region approach, as it is understood. That approach, say, with
respect to wages means that wages of all concerns
situate in a particular area engaged in a particular
industry should be the same. On that approach the
bonus of all these sixty-six mills should also be the
same percentage for each mill in that area; but that
is not the basis on which the Agreement was arrived
a.t. The basis of the Agreement is that each individual mill is treated as a. separate unit and its available
surplus worked out according to the formula in the
Agreement itself. This is also the basis of the Full
Bench formula. and the available surplus of each unit
is worked out according to that formula, though the
result of the application of the two formulae in each
case may not be the same. There is in our opinion therefore .no justification for the view that the Full Bench
formula approved by this Court in the Associated
Cement Companies' case (1) can have no application
where there are numerous concerns of one nature a.t
one centre. Some bonus awards were brought to our
notice to show that they were on industry-cum-region
basis, namely, The Sugar Mills of Bihar v. Their
Worktnen(') and The Sugar Mills, Uttar PradMh v.
(1) (195~! ~C.R. 925.
14
New Maneck
Chowk Spg. o;.
Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
Textile Labour
Association
~ranchoo
].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961)
Their Workmen('). These awards related to sugar
industry in Uttar Pradesh and iu Bihar. As we read
these decisions, we do not find real industry-cumregion approach which would result in uniform bonus
for all the mills dealt with by these two awards. What
we find is that a different formula was worked out for
awarding profit bonus linked with production on the
basis that there were profits; but when the formula is
worked for each mill the bonus would differ from mill
to mill acco~ding to its production. Further, we find
that in the Uttar Pradesh case there. were certain
exemptions granted to certain factories, presumably on
the ground that they were not in a position to pay
bonus for want of sufficient profits. It jg true that in
the Bihar case it was said that the question of bonus
could be considered on industry-wise and not on unitwise basis, but that only meant that one formula was
evolved for the whole of Bihar and applied to every
mill in that area. That is what exactly the Full Bench
formula also has done, for it is the same formula
which applies to all industrial eoncerm. all over the
country now after the decision of this Court. In the
Bihar case, an argument was addressed to apply the
Full Bench formula, but that was not accepted on the
ground that balance sheets and profit and loss accounts
were not reliable and therefore bonus wa8 linked with
production. In the Bihar case also some factories
were exempted from paying bonus presumably on the
ground that they were unable to do so not having
made profits. These cases therefore are not instances
of real industry-cum-region approach. Reference was
also made to The Textile M ill8 in Ooimba,tore Distr·ict
v. Their Workmen(') relating to Coimh~tore textile
mills. In that case the industrial court considered
whether bonus at a flat rate for all the mills should be
awarded or whether a distinction should be made
between mills and mills. It held that the mills themselves when they paid bonus observed or maintained
no distinction; therefore in the peculiar circumstances
of that case a uniform rate of 33-1/3 per cent. was
awarded for all the mills as specially all the mills had
(1) [1952] 1 L. L. J. 615.
(2) [1950] 2 L ..L. J. 203.
'
•
•
3 S.C.R. SUPREME- COURT REPORTS
'
15
1960
without exception made unique profits. As we have
said already the basic concept of profit bonus, as it New Mane&k
appears from the judgments of this Court, is that Chowh SP:. b
there should be an available surplus of profits in a Wvg. Co. Lid.
v.
particular concern in a particular year, to which the
bonus relates and on this basic concept there is no Textile Labour
scope for an approach on the basis of industry-cum- Association
region in the matter of bonus in the sense that every Wanchoo ].
mill in a region should pay the same bonus. There is
therefore no question of industry-cum-region approach
in the present case, and even the formula in the Agreement is not on a real industry-cum-region approach and
has to be worked out from mill to mill, which is like
the Full Bench formula. The reasons therefore which
led the industrial court in this case to distinguish and
depart from the decision of this Court in The Associated Cement Companies' case (1 ) do not appear to us to
be substantial and there was therefore no ground for
departing from that decision for those reasons.
This brings us to a consideration of the formula.
as provided in the Agreement and the Full Bench
formula as approved by this Court.. It was urged on
behalf of the respondent that the two formulae were
basically the same; both provided for prior charges and
in both bonus was to be paid on the availability of
surplus profits, though it was admitted that in certain
respects there were differences. Now if these differences were merely of detail and did not affect some
of the vital aspects of the Full Bench formula it might
be said that there ,was no ignoring of the law as laid
down by this Court and therefore the tribunal was not
unjustified. in extending the Agreement for a year.
But a comparison of the formula in the Agreement
with the :Full Bench formula shows differences in three
vital aspects. In the first place, rehabilitation provided in the Agreement differs vitally from rehabilitation as explained in The Associated Cement Companies
case (1 ). In the second place, the formula in the Agreement provides for payment of a minimum bonus even
though there may be no available surplus and even
though the particular mill might have made actual
(1) [1959] S.C.R. 925.
16
SUPREME COURT· REPOR'rS
[1961]
loss. Thirdly, while the Full-Bench formula as approved by this Court treats a particular year as a self.
New l'v! a neck
sufficient
unit, there is provision for set-off and set-on
Chowk Spg. &
Wvg. Co. Ltd. in the formula in the Agreement. Can it therefore be
v.
said that the formula in the Agreement which departs
Tc;rJile Labottr in these vital particulars from the Full Bench formula
Associalio11
in the matter of bonus could be extended for another
year
by the industrial court in the face of the decisions
Wanchoo J.
of this Court laying down the law as to what profit
bonus is and how it should be worked out? The tribunal therefore when it extended the formula in the
. Agreement which departed from the Full Bench formula in certain vital aspects was undoubtedly ignoring
the industrial law as laid down by this Court and
going against it. It was its duty when dealing
with the question of profit bonus to apply the
Full Bench formula, as approved by this Court and
then arrive at the quantum of bonus to be awarded in
the case of each mill. In particular by extending the
Agreement the tribunal made it possible for payment
of a minimum bonus even when there was either
insufficient available surplus to pay bonus or no available surplus at all or even act11al losB; the tribunal
was thus definitely going against the industrial law
relating to bonus as laid down by this Court. It had
in our opinion no power to do so and the reasons .
which it gave for departing from the law laid down by
this Court are unsubstantial and do not commend
themselves to us. In these circumstances the order
of the trib,unal extending the Agreement for a year
cannot be upheld.
Further it was urged that in any case the Agreement contemplates payment of bonus out of profits of
the industry at Ahmedabad. as a whole and that is
why it has provided for set-off and set.on. Whatever
may be said about this provision on a long term basis,
the tribunal's jurisdiction was limited by its terms of
reference. There was not one reference before the
tribunal on industry-cum-region basiB but sixty-six
separate references, one relating to each mill. It was
required to consider the question of bonus for each
mill for the year 1958 only and thus had nothing to
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
•
17
do with set-off and set-.on or the profits of the industry
as a whole at Ahmedabad. The tribunal was only con- New Maneck
cerned with 1958 and no consideration as to what Chowk Spg. &
happened before that year or what may happen after Wvc. Co. Ltd.
v.
1958 could enter into its decision of the question of
bonus for the year 1958. The principle of set-off Te:rtile Labour
Association
and set-on therefore to be found in the Agreement
could not convert payment of bonus for 1958, say, by Wanchoo ].
a loss making mill into profit bonus as laid down by
the decisions of this Court. The tribunal's award in
this case therefore would clearly be against the law as
to bonus laid down by this Court, for its jurisdiction
was confined only to the year 1958 and no more.
It was however urged on behalf of the respondent
that there is a fifth kind of bonus, namely, goodwill
bonus and that the Agreement when it provides for
a minimum bonus irrespective of availability of
profits provides for such bonus in the interest of industrial peace. It is enough to say that so far as what is
called goodwill bonus is concerned it pre-supposes that
it is given by the employer out of his own free will
without any compulsion by an industrial court. As
its very name implies it is a bonus which is given by
the employer out· of his free consent in order that
there may be goodwill between him and his workmen;
but there can be no question of imposing a goodwill
bonus by industrial courts, as imposition of such a
bonus is a contradiction of its very concept. We have
already referred to four kinds of bonus which prevail
in the industrial law in India and which can in certain
circumstancei> be imposed by industrial tribunals; but
there can be no question of the imposition of the socalled goodwill bonus, for. that bonus depends upon
the good will of the parties and on their' free consent.
In the absence of such free consent, there can be no
question of any goodwill bonus.
Before we part with these appeals, however, we
must briefly advert to the general considerations which
have been pressed before us very strongly by Mr.
Vasavada for the respondents and Mr. Ambekar for
the intervening parties. It has been urged before us
••
3
.......
·
18
z960
AT ew M aneck
Chowk Spg. &
Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
Te:J. tile Labour
Association
H'anchoo ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961)
that we should be reluctant to interfere with the agreement because it has worked satisfactorily in Ahmedabad, and the reversal of the award under appeal may
lead to discontent in a very important centre of textile
industry in this country. It has also been strenuously
argued that the Agreement offers a very reasonable
solution to the vexed problem of bonus and the pattern set by it has been copied in Bombay, Madhya
Pradesh and Coimbatore. If the pattern thus set for
determining the textile employees' cla.im for bonus
has been adopted by a substantial part of the textile
industry in this country, the Court should desist from
disturbing the smooth working of the said pattern unless it is compelled to do so: It may be conceded that
some features of the Agreement are undoubtedly very
reasonable and in the interest of the industry as a
whole. The agreement has put a ceiling on bonus and
that is a term very mucJ,i in favour of the employer,
because in some cases where the available surplus is
very large, then under the working of the .Full Bench
formula the employees arc tempted to claim, and
industrial tribunals are justified in awarding, a proportionately .substantial amount as bonus reaching or
even exceeding in some cases the level of basic wages
of even 8 or 9 months. This trend has been controlled
by the Agreement. It is true that the Agreement
requires the payment of the minimum bonus but this
provision is intended to work as a part of the larger
agreement spreading over some years and the employer has agreed to pay the minimum bonus even
though in a particular year he may have no available
surph~s, because he and his employees expect or anticipate that the employer ma.}I have available surplus in
the succeeding year. The working of the Agreement
is really intended to spread over a number of years
and the account between the employers and the employees in that behalf is conceived as a continuing
and running account. These features of the Agreement may be regarded as commendable.
The problem of rehabilitation which has assumed .a
complex form has also been attempted to be solved
by the Agreement in a practical way. The solution
•
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
...
i
'
19
adopted by the Agreement in that behalf, it is claimed, is based on the historical and factual genesis of
the original formula evolved by the Full Bench of the
Labour Appellate Tribunal when it dealt wit.h the
problem of the textile industry in Bombay. The
argument is that until 1962, the Agreement should be
allowed to work when the position may be reviewed
at length. Since this Court delivered its judgment in
the case of The Associated Cement Companies (1) it has
come to our notice that in cases where the employer
claims an exaggerated amount for rehabilitation, or
where a reasonable claim made by the employer in
that behalf is unreasonably challenged by the employees, the dispute is protracted. The trial of the issue
·tends to become complicated, and that leads to bitterness between the parties. It has been urged before
us that time has now come when the industrial courts
will have to face the problem of radically changing
the formula. It is argued that modern economic
thought does not encourage the theory that the whole
of the rehabilitation amount must come from the
current profits of the industry, and it was stated before us that Government may have gradually to step
in to assist the industry by advancing sufficient loans
on reasonable terms to enable the industry to meet
the demand of its rehabilitation. However, as we
pointed out in our decision in the case cf The Associated Cement Companies(') these matters can be properly
and effectively decided by an industrial court if the
major representative industries in the country and
their employees are brought before it with a proper
reference, or it can be tackled more appropriately by
a high-power commission appointed in that behalf.
We were told that the Government of India has taken
a decision to appoint such a commission, and that it
wou1d soon resolve this problem on a more rational
and scientific basis. During the course of the hearing
of these appeals we suggested to the parties that in
view of the pending appointment of the commission,
parties may settle the present dispute amicably and
that the appellant-mills may fall in line with the rest
(1) [1959] S.C.R. 925.
New llf aneck
Chewk Spg. &
Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
Textile Labour
.1ssociation
Wa11choo
J.
20
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961]
of the mills in Ahmadabad, but despite their best
efforts the parties could not settle the dispute and
New Maneck
Chowk Spg. & wanted a decision from this Court on the points of
Wvg. Co. Ltd. law raised in the present appeals; that is why we
v.
have had to decide the points of law, and in doing so
Tex tile LabOur
inevitably general considerations to which we have
Association
just adverted cannot play a material part.
In the course of the argument reference was made
Wanchoo ].
by Mr. Ambekar to the concept of goodwill bonus;
that again is a matter which may be evolved by
agreement between the parties or decided by a highpower commission. If the matter has to be decided
according to law as has been laid down by this Court
then the conclusion would be inevitable that on
essential points the Agreement departs from the Full
Bench formula, and however commendable it may be
on the whole it can continue only by agreement and
cannot be enforced by industrial adjudication against
the will of any of the parties; that is why we have
come to the conclusion, though not without regret,
that the appeals must be allowed and the matter must
be sent back to the tribunal for disposing of the issue
before it in accordance with law. We direct that the
tribunal should proceed to try the question whether
any bonus should be awarded to the employees of the
eighteen mills before us on the basis of the Full Bench
formula as interpreted by this Court in the case of
The Associated Cement Companies (1 ).
In the circumstances there will be no order as to
costs.
Subba Rao].
SUBBA RAO, J.-I have had the advantage of perusing the judgment prepared by my learned brother,
Wanchoo, J. I regret my inability to agree. As mine
is a solitary dissent, it may not serve any useful purpose to elaborate on the question raised at great
length. I would, therefore, briefly refer to the relevant facts which have already been fully stated by
my learned brother and express my views concisely
on the question presented before us.
These appeals raise a dispute between the Textile
Labour Association, Ahmedabad, the representative
(1) [1959] S.C.R. 925. ·
...
...
•
..
.
I
'.
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
21
union of the textile industry in Ahmedabad, and the
various textile' inills in that area in respect of the New Maneck
bonus payable for the year 1958. The said Labour Chowk Spg. &
Union entered into a five-year pact with the Ahmeda- Wvg. Co Ltd.
v.
bad Mill-Owners' Association, representing the memTextile Labour
ber mills, in regard to payment of bonus for the years Association
1953 to 1957. The Labour Union demanded bonus for
the year 1958 on the basis of the said pact. The mill- Subba Rao].
owners claimed that the said pact was contrary to the
law laid down by the decision of this Court in the
case of The Associated Cement Companies Ltd., Dwarka
Cement Works, Dwarka v. Its Workmen(') and that, if
the rehabilitation cost was calculated on the basis of
the principles laid down therein, there would not be
any "available surplus" to sustain the claim for bonus.
The Industrial Court to which the dispute was referred elaborately considered the arguments advanced
and came to the conclusion that the five-year pact
which originated in Ahmedabad was not only fair in
itself but also an important contribution to industrial
peace, and that it did not in any way run counter to
the law laid down by the Supreme Court. On that finding it extended the operation of the pact for one more
year and directed the parties to file within six weeks
from the date of the award calculations in respect of
the bonus payable Tor the year 1958, in the light of its
decision and on the footing that the five-year pact
was for six years.
The main question in the appeals is whether the
said pact violates the law laid down by this Court.
Before considering this contention it would be convenient to notice the terms of the said pact. The said
pact is a lengthy document, though precisely drawn,
and to read it in full is to unnecessarily burden the
judgment. I shall, therefore, briefly summarize its
terms.
The contracting parties were the Textile Labour
Association of Ahmedabad, a representative union for
the local area ·of Ahmedabad on the one part, and the
Ahmedabad Mill-Owners' Association, Ahmedabad,
representing its local member mills, on the other part.
(1) [1959] S,C.R. 925,
22
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961]
It was executed on June 27, 1955, to cover a period of
five years from 1953 to 1957, inclusive of both years,
New Manu.k
for grant of bonus to the employees of the Cotton
Chowk Spg. 6
Textile Mills of Ahmedabad. The object of the agreeWvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
ment was to create good will among the workers and
Textile Labou1 for the purpose of maintaining peace in the industry.
Association
The basis of the agreement was that it applied for the
entire
Ahmedabad Textile Industry and for a period
Sobba Rao ].
of five years. The "available surplus" of each mill
was ascertained in accordance with the Full Bench
Formula laid down by the Labour Appellate Tribunal
in Mill-Owners' Association, Bombay v. The Rashtriya
Mill M azdoor Sangh, Bombay (1 ). The maximum bonus
payable by every mill of the said area was fixed at
25 per cent. of the total basic wages earned during the
year, and the minimum was fixed at 4·8 per cent. of
the said basic wages. If in a particular year a mill
had an "available surplus" adequate for granting
bonus at a higher quantum than the ceiling of 25 per
cent. of the basic wages, it would notionally set aside
the part of the residue of the "available surplus" after
the grant. of the maximum bonus not exceeding an
amount equivalent to 25 per cent. of the basic wages
earned during that year as a reserve for bonus for the
purpose of "set-on" (adjustment) in subsequent years.
If the "available surplus" was adequate only to grant
bonus at a rate lower than the ceiling, the quantum
of bonus would be fixed in such a manner that there
would remain with the mill at least a minimum of
Rs. 10,000. If in respect of any year a mill had an
"available surplus" adequate to pay bonus at a rate
lower than the minimum rate, it would be entitled to
"set-off" the excess amount of bonus that would be
payable in a subsequent year or years. In setting off
the said amount of bonus that would be payable
against subsequent year or years, if the surplus was
adequate only to grant bonns at a rate lower tha.n the
maximum rate, the mill would first set aside out of
the "available surplus" an amount of Hs. 10,000 and,
then out of the balancP, it would further take out the
excess amount paid by it as bonus in the previous
(•) (1950] 2 L.L.]. 247.
'
'
..
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
I.
_.
'
23
1960
year, and then it would distribute the remainder as
bonus. Even if a mill had made a loss in a par- !>.'ew A-I aneck
ticular year, it had to pay the minimum bonus, Chowk Spg. <Sbut it would be entitled to "set.off" the amount Wug. Co, Ltd.
v.
thus paid against the amount of bonus that would be
payable in the subsequent year or years, in the same Textile Labour
Association
manner as in the case of a surplus adequate to grant
bonus only at a rate lower than 25 per cent. of the Subba Rao ].
basic wages. In short, when the surplus was adequate to pay bonus at 25 per cent. of the basic wages
earned during the year, a mill had to pay the maximum of 25 per cent. of the basic wages. When it was
adequate only to graut bonus of less than 25 per cent.
of the basic wages, it would pay the said bonus after
reserving a sum of Rs. 10,000 for itself. If there was
loss, it would pay the minimum bonus. Whatever
amounts were paid were adjusted on the principle of
"set-on" and "set-off" in the subsequent years. There
was also a provision that after the prescribed period
all the outstanding liabilities under the formula of
"set- on" and "set-off" would come to an end. Three
principles clearly underlie the entire scheme, namely,
(i) that though for the purpose of ascertaining the
surplus, the profits of a particular mill were taken as
the criterion, the position of the entire Ahmedabad
Textile Industry was taken into consideration; (ii) that
the beneficent features of the scheme could be gathered only by its long term operation; and (iii) that
though in a particular year in the case of a particular
mill there might not be "available surplus'', the principles of "set-on" and "set-off" indicate that the bonus
was linked with profits. As reasonable men trying to
settle their disputes, both the parties, representing
their respective associations, adopted an optimistic
attitude and proceeded on the basis that the entire
indestry would make a profit and that every mill
could be expected to make reasonable profits in at
least some of the five years, though it might incur
loss in other years. The validity of the agreement
should be judged on the basis adopted.
In the Ahmedabad Textile Industry, it is in evidence, the average monthly wage for workers in 1957
24
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961]
was Rs.· 54. Fifteen days' basic wages, i.e., the minimum
bonus prescribed under the pact, would come to
New Maneck
an average total wages for 5 days; and 3 months' basic
Chowk Spg. &
Wvg. C•. Ltd. wages would come to 19 days' total wages on the
v.
average. Prima facie the bonus fixed is very reasonTt;flile Labour
able and cannot be said to be oppressive to the millAssociation
owners.
The said bonus agreement, by its reasonableness and
Subba Rao J.
beneficent effects on the industry, attracted the attention of other mills throughout India. Exhibit U-2
shows the particulars of other mills which have adopted the agreement. The Bombay Textile Industry,
The Madhya Bharat Mill-owners' Association, The
Modi Spinning & Weaving Mills, Modinagar, and the
cotton mills at Surendranagar (Saurashtra), Sidhpur,
Viramgam Nadiad and Petlad, Cambay Baroda, Surat
adopted the said scheme with suitable modifications.
The silk industry in Bombay and the plantation industry in Madras also accepted the principles underlying
the said agreement~ We are told that even the
Coimbatore area has recently adopted a similar agreement.
The fact that the said five year pa.ct was followed
by so many other mills is a fair indication that it was
basically sound and capable of yielding good results.
Experienced members of the Industrial Courts spoke
highly of the pact. Late Shri S. H. Naik, a Member
of the Industrial Court, adopted the pact in a dispute
between the Bombay Mill-Owners' Association and
the Ra.shtriya. Mill Mazdoor Sangh, and in making an
award in terms of a similar pact, made the following
observations:
"This award, based upon an agreement arrived
at as a result of persistent and continued efforts ori
the part of both the parties, keeping in view the
prosperity of the employers as well as the well-being of the employees, will go down in history as a
significant landmark in collective bargaining. It
augurs well for the future of the industry, as well as
those employed therein, particularly in view of the
ambitious Second Five Year Plan on which the
country will shortly launch. It also a voids, for
f
t
••
...
3 s.c.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
'
'•
25
some time, and let us hope for all time to come,. the
bonus dispute which cropped up every year since
1947. I congratulate both the parties and compliment them on the successful termination of their
efforts to bring peace to the industry and set an
example to the employers and employees in · the
country."
The said weighty observations apply mutatis mutandis
to the agreement in question. Shri H. V. Divatia,
another experienced Member of the Industrial Court,
in his award on the bonus dispute of the Ahmedabad
Textile Mills for 1952 observed:
"Ever since the former practice of taking all the
textile mills in one centre as one unit for the pur·
pose of determining the bonus was given up, there
has been dissatisfaction on both sides on the bonus
question every year and in my view this change as
well as the formula set up by the Labour Appellate
Tribunal have made the bonus issue a very complicated one resulting in bitterness on both the sides
instead of promoting peace and harmony between
the employers and workers. I hope the whole
matter is reconsidered at the highest level. If bonus
is to be given, it must be awarded in such a way
that it does not defeat its purpose."
The agreement did nothing more than reverting to
the former practice of taking all the textile mills in
one centre as one unit for the purpose of determining
the bonus, though for ascertaining the quantum of
bonus payable the balance-sheets of individual units
were taken into consideration.
1n makil'g the present award the Industrial Court
on a consideration of the entire material placed before
it came to a definite finding that on the whole the
five- year pact had worked fairly for both the parties
and that the extension of the said agreement for one
more year would help in promoting peace in that
industry in Ahmedabad and that owing to the goodwill created by the five-year bonus pact, the industry
also benefited by schemes of rationalization. It was
also brought to our notice that in the textile industry
•
Naw Ma'INt:k
Chowk Spg. a;.
Wvg. Co. Lid.
•.
Tt#lilt LoboNr
As-so&iation
Subba Rao·].
ll6
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961)
in Ahmedabad area there were never any strike and
the disputes in the recent years were settled amicably
New Ji/ a~eck
·across
the table.
Chowh Spg. &
In such a situation this Court was asked under Art.
Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
136 of the Constitution to set aside the a ward and to
Te~lile Labour
bring about· chaos where peace existed and to
Association
introduce unrest and disharmony where stability and
harmony prevailed. It was said that this Court had
Svbba Rao}.
no option but to do so as the agreement was contrary
to law as laid down by this Court. I shall now examine briefly the relevant decisions laying down the
principle governing bonus to ascertain whether the
impugned agreement is in any way inconsistent with
them.
In .Muir Mills Go. Limited v. Suti Mills Mazdoor
Union, Kanpur(') this Court defined the term "bonus"
and laid down the conditions which would give rise
to the claim for bonus. Bhagwati, J., after considering the relevant decisions and text books on the subject, accepted the following definition of "bonus"
given by the Textile Labour Inquiry Committee:
"The term bonus is applied to a cash payment
made in addition to wages. It generally represents
the cash incentive given conditionally on certain
standards of attendance and efficiency being attained."
The learned Judge then proceeded to state at p. 998
thus:
'
"There are however two conditions which have to
be satisfied before a demand for bonus can be justified and they are: (1) when wages fall short of the
living standard and (2) the industry makes huge profits part of which are due to tho contribution which
the workmen make in increasing production. The
demand for bonus becomes an industrial claim when
either or both these conditions are satisfied."
The learned' Judge then referred to the formula evolved by the Full Bench of the Labour Appellate Tribunal in the Mill-Owners' Association, Bombay v. Rashtreeya Mill Mazdoor Sangh, Bombay(') and narrated
the first charges on the grosB profits as )aid down by
1960
(•) [1955] I s.c.R. 991.
(>) [1950] • L.L.J. 247.
..
~=
'>
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
27
1960
that decision. The learned Judge then expressed his
view thus at p. 999:
·
N1w Ma.,,,cl
"It is therefore clear that the claim for bonus can CAollik Sf>t· <So
be made by the employees only if as a result of the Wv1. Co. L14.
y.
joint contribution of capital and labour the industrial concern has earned profits. If in any parti- Te~lil1 Lobo•'
cular year the working of the industrial concern has A ssociolion
resulted in Joss there is no basis. nor justification for Subba Roof•
a demand for bonus. Bonus is not a deferred wage.~'
This decision lays down in clear terms that the pay.
ment of bonus is linked with profits. But this deci·
sion was given in a dispute between one specified mill,
namely, Muir Mills Co. Limited and the Union, representing its employees. This Court was not ·considering a case of a bonus claim on industry-cum-region
basis. The principle of the decision, namely, that the
claim for bonus is linked with profits, may equally
apply to such a case; but the working. of the· principle
must necessarily depend upon the peculiarities of such
a claim. Industrial law is in the process of evolution
and 'it cannot be put in a straight jacket, but must ·
be allowed to grow to meet varying situations that
present themselves to industrial tribunals, subject of
course to the statutory provis~ns •and the general
principles laid down by courts. The application of
the principles laid down by this decision to a bonus
claim on industry-cum-region basis would, to some
extent, be different from its application to a single
unit. I shall consider this aspect at a later stage of
the judgment. It is unnecessary to consider the other .
decisions on this subject except the recent decision of
· this Court in The Associated Cement Companiea Ltd.,
Dwarka Cement Work8, Dwarka v. !ta Workmen (1).
That decision reviewed the entire law on the sµbjeot
vis-a-vis the profit bonus. It accepted the principles
laid down by the said Full Bench Formula and elaborately considered the mode of application of the principles for ascertaining the "available surplus." Gajen.
dragadkar, J., who spoke for the Court, referred to
the earlier decision and restated the basis for awarding bonus ~hus at p. 995:
(I) [1959] S.C.R. 925,
28.
N..t.w Maneck
ChowA Spg. &
Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
T exJile Labour
AssociaJion
Subba Rao }.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961]
"We hav.e already noticed that the formula for
awarding bonus to workmen is based on two considerations: first, that Jabour is entitled to claim a
share in the trading profits of the industry because
it has partially contributed to the same; and second,
that Jabour is entitled to claim that the gap between
its actual wage and the living wage should within
reasonable limits be filled up."
Then the learned Judge, after referring to the earlier
decisions, gave the various amounts th:i,t should be
deducted from the bonus.year's profits and the manner in which they should be done to ascertain the
"available i:.urplus." According to the learned Judge
the following items have to be deducted:
"(1) Depreciation, which should be the notional
normal depreciation.
(2) Income.tax.
(3) A return on paid-up capital as well as working capital. Tho;.igh the usual rates were mentioned,
it was made clear that the rates were not inflexible
but would vary according to the circumstances of
each case.
(4) Rehabilitation: For ascertaining the amount
necessary for rehabilitation, it was pointed out
that a multiplier and divisor should be adopted; the
former to ascertain the probable price which may
have to be paid for the rehabilitation, replacement
or modernization of ni.achinery, and the latter in
order to ascertain the annual requirement of the
employer in that behalf year by year."
Out of the balance, which was described as "available
surplus", it was stated that three parties, namely, the
Jabour, the industry and the shareholders, were entitled to claim shares. This is the broad picture drawn
by that decision for fixing the bonus. That decision,
therefore, restated the pre-existing law and reaffirmed
the doctrine that bonus is linked with profits and
also the Full Bench Formula for ascertaining the
"available surplus". That decision was also not concerned with a claim for bonus on industry-cum-region
basis, but only with a claim in regard to a particular
unit. It also did not lay down that employer and
{
r
'
\
'
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
29
employee could not agree in regard to the distribution
of the available surplus or in respect of the amount New }..faneck
required for rehabilitation. It also did not purport Chowk Spg. <1>to prevent the parties from agreeing on the payment Wvg. Co. Lid.
v.
of bonus linked with profits on industry-cum-region
Textile Labout
basis spread over a number.of years. Some of the Association
observations in the judgment indicate the consciousness of the court that the formula accepted or the Subba Rao J.
directions given therein could not meet every conceivable situation that might arise in the complicated field
of industrial relations.
Does the impugned pact contravene the law laid
down by this Court? It is contended that it infringes
the law mainly in three respects, namely, (i) bonus
was payable thereunder by a mill incurring loss; (ii)
the pact did not provide for rehabilitation of the
post-1947 block; and (iii) the depreciation and the interest on the reserves allowed were not in accordance
with the formula.
The first objection appears to be plausible and has
also been upheld by my learned brethren. But, in
my view, there is a fallacy underlying it. The contention invokes the law of bonus laid down in respect
of an industrial claim for bonus for a particular year
made by the employees of a single mill and seeks to
apply it to a case of an agreement evolving a scheme
of bonus on the basis of industry-cum-region spread
over a reasonable period of time. Though the fundamental principle, namely, that bcnus is linked with
profits, applies to both, the application of the same to
two different situations must necessarily differ. The
short question is whether under the impugned agreement the claim for bonus was not based on profits.
The agreerr.ent was a multilateral one involving mutual
obligations. It was on industry-cum-region basis,
that is, it was entered into between the employers
of the entire industry and the employees thereof. The
basis of the agreement was that the entire industry
would make a profit. For the purpose of convenient
payment of bonus it was worked ou~ on the unit basis.
All the parties to the agreement, the employers and the
30
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961]
employees of different mills in Ahmedabad, desired in- .
dustrial peace in order to build up the textile industry.
Chowk Spg. b
The industry comprised many units with varying
Wvg. Co. Ltd. prospects and different strata of financial stability
v.
and prosperity. Some mills may earn profits throughTeNtile Labowr
out
the period, some may earn profits in some years
Association
and incur loss in other years, and under extremely
Subba Rao]. unfortunate and unexpected circumstances, a mill may
incur loss throughout. Though a particular mill may
earn abnormal profits, another mill may be just able
to make its both ends meet and another may have a
narrow··margin of profits or even incur loss. But all
of them were sincerely interested in the general prosperity of the industry as a whole in the said area
which would have its repercussions on individual
units. A mill which earns large profits may have to
pay .more than 25 per cent. of basic wages for the
year as bonus and a mill which incurs loss may not
have to pay bonus at all. The employees of a particular mill may be entitled in a particular year, having
regard to the profits, to get bonus far in excess of 25
per cent. of the basic wages. But in the general
interest of all concerned, they were all willing to make
a little sacrifice for the common good. Each mill
undertook the liability to pay bonus to its employees
with a minimum and· maximum limits in consideration of a similar undertaking of liability by other
mills. So too, the employees, in consideration of a
minimum bonus being guaranteed to them, a.greed
not to claim more than the maximum fixed and
the mills as a whole guaranteed payment of the
minimum bonus. But what is important to remember is that the entire scheme of payment of
bonus was linked with profits. It would be paid
on the basis of profits earned or to be earned by a
mill. If a mill did not make profits in a particular
year, bonus would be paid on account to be adjusted
in subsequent years. The formula of "set-on" and
"set.off" emphasizes the integral connection between
bonus and profits, and the fact that the total loss
incurred by a particular mill during the entire period
may break that formula. does not affect the basis of
New Manech
I
'
(
\
'
I.
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
31
the agreement. In effect and substance, under the
agreement, each of the mills agreed for a consideration on the happening of a contingency to treat certain amounts as notional profits adequate to pay the
minimum bonus with a right to "set-off" in subsequent years against larger profits, if any, earned by
them. In the premises, it is not correct to state that
bonus is not linked with profits for four reasons,
namely, (i) the agreement was between the employers
and employees of the entire textile industry in
Ahmedabad; (ii) the basis of the agreement was that
the industry as a whole would make a profit; there is
nothing illegal in parties to the agreement, who had
intimate knowledge of the financial position of the
entire industry, from accepting that position; (iii)
instead of the profits of the entire industry being
ascertained and bonus paid to all th.e employees,
under the agreement, each mill for a consideration,
namely, obligations undertaken by other parties.
agreed to pay bonus ranging between a maximum and
a minimum; and (iv) each mill also agreed for a consideration, even if in fact it incurred a loss in a parti,
cular year, to set apart a notional amount as profits
adequate to pay the minimum bonus with a right to
readjust i,ts bonus account in subsequent years. In
this view the impugned pact does not contravene the
law of the land for the simple reason that· there is no
decision of this Court which prevents the making of
such agreements so long as the fundamental principle
is not violated; and in this case, for the reason given
by me, I am of the view that the said principle, viz.,
that bonus should be linked with profits has been
adhered to in the agreement.
Now let us see whether the Full Bench Formula in
regard to rehabilitation has been contravened by the
impugned pa.ct. The main emphasis is on the want
of a provision in the agreement in regard to valuation
of the block subsequent to 1947. In The Associated
Cement Companies' case(') this Court observed at
p. 971 thus:
"It has also been observed by the Labour Appel.
late Tribunal that if an appropriate multiplier and
I•> [19,9J s.c.R. 9•J·
-1960
New Maneck
Chowk Spg. 0Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
Textile Labour
Association
Subba Rao ].
32
ig~o
New Maneck
Chorpk Spg. o;.
Wvg. Co. Lid.
v.
T:ixtild Labour
AS.Soiiation
S~bba
Rao j.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961)
divisor are determined they are generally used
because the tribunals take the view that the reconsideration of the said multiplier and divisor should
not be hastily undertaken and could be justified
only on the basis of a stable character extending
or likely to extend over a sufficient number of years
so as to make a definite and appreciable difference
in the cost of replacement."
The Industrial Court in the bonus case of the textile
industry at Ahmedabad for the year 1949 fixed the
cost of replacement of the block of the entire industry
at Ahmedabad at Rs. 33·89 crores spread over 15
years from 1947. The Industrial Court, on the material placed before .it, fixed the multiplier at 2·7 and
the divisor at 15. The result is that the cost of the
machinery and building as it existed in 1947 was
multiplied by 2·7 and after making the necessary
deduction therefrom, such as that of depreciation and
reserves available and the breakdown value of machinery, divided the surplus by 15 years. Ordinarily,
change in the said multiplier and divisor, as laid
down by this Court, should not be hastily undertaken
and could be justi.fied only on the basis'Of a substantial change of a stable character extending or likely
to extend over a sufficient number of years. In the
impugned pact the parties agreed to abide by the said
multiplier and divisor and they did not think fit to
revise the same. The decisions of this Court do not
preclude employers and employees from agreeing to a
particular valuation of the block or to their agreeing
to a particular multiplier and ·divisor having regard
to the circumstances obtaining at the time of the
agreement.
·
Nor does the agreement infringe any of the principles laid down by the Full Bench Formula in the
matter of fixing the prior charges. A perusal of paragraph 2(a) of the agreement shows that the prior
charges mentioned therein are only those that are
stated in the Full Bench Formula, though there is
certainly a difference in the particulars under different
heads, such as, interest, etc. Certainly the decisions
of this Court do not preclude the parties from
.I
\
I
3 s.c.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
33
agreeing to certain amounts or to certain rates under
different heads of prior charges.
As the agreement does not infringe the law laid
down by this Court, it cannot be contended that the
Industrial Court could not extend the said agreement,
if it is necessary to secure industrial peace for another
year. In effect and substance, the Industrial Court
adopted the said agreement as a part of the award by
giving it a span of six years instead of five years;
with the result that the entire formula of "set-on"
and "set-off" would automatically apply in the sixth
year. Courts have held that Industrial Courts have
power to extend a.greements in appropriate circumstances.
The Federal Court of India in Western India Automobile Association v. Industrial Tribunal, Bombay (1)
explained the scope of industrial adjudication and the
functions of an industrial tribunal in labour disp1,1tes
thus at p. 345:
"Adjudication does not, in our opinion, mean
adjudication according to the strict law of master
and servant. The award of the Tribunal may contain provisions for settlement of a dispute which no
Court could order if it was bound by ordinary law,
but the Tribunal is not fettered in any way by
these limitations. In Volume I of 'Labour Disputes
and Collective Bargaining' by Ludwig Teller, it is
said at page 536, 'that industrial arbitration may
involve the extension of a.n existing agreement or
the making of a new one, or in genera.I the creation
of new obligations or modifications of old ones,
while commercial arbitration generally concerns
itself with interpretation of existing obligations and
disputes relating to existing agreements'. In our
opinion, it is a true statement about the functions
of an Industrial Tribunal in labour disputes."
The same view in different phraseology has been expressed by this Court in Rohtas Industries LimitW, v.
Brijnandan Pandey("), S. K. Das, J., speaking for the
Court, observed a.t p. 810 thus:
(1) [1949] F.C.R. 321.
(2) [•956] S.C.R. Boo.
s
,
New Maneck
Chowk Spg. ~
Wvg; Co. Ltd.
v.
T1xtile Labour
Association
Subba Rao ].
34
New Maneck
Chowh Spg. &
Wvg. Co. Ltd.
v.
Textile tabour
Associalion
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961]
"A Court of law proceeds on the footing that no
power exists in the courts to make contracts for
people; and the parties must make their own contracts. The courts reach their limit of power when
they enforce contracts which the parties have made.
An Industrial Tribunal is not so fettered and may
create new obligations or modify contracts in the
interests of industrial peace, to protect legitimate
trade union activities and to prevent unfair practice
or victimization. We canuot, however, accept the
extreme position canvassed before us that an
Industrial Tribunal can ignore altogether an existing agreement or existing obligations for no rhyme
or reason whatsoever."
This Conrt again reiterated the same principle in the
case of Patna Electricity Supply Co. Limited(') thus
at p. 1038:
"There is no doubt that in appropriate cases
industrial adjudication may impose new obligations
on the employer in the inLerest of social jnstice and
with the object of securing peace and harmony between the employer and his workmen and full cooperation between them. This view about the
jurisdiction and power of Industrial Tribunals has
been consistently recognized in this country since
the decision of the Federal Court in Western India
Automobile Association v. Industrial Tribunal, Bombay (')".
These authorities clearly establish the proposition
that an Industrial Tribunal can extend an existing
agreement or make a new one if, for good reasons, it
comes to the conclusion that such extension promotes
industrial peace. If, as I have held, the impugned
pact was lawful and did not contravene the law laid
down by this Court, the Industrial Court in the present case was certainly within its rights to extend
that pact for another year for the very good reasons
given by it for doing so.
I shall now state my view in the form of the following propositions: (1) Neither the :Full Bench Formula
nor the decisions of this Court affirming it preclude an
(1) [1959] Supp. 2 S.C.R. 761.
(2) [19~9] F.C.R. 321.
.
3 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(
,
35
Industrial Court in appropriate cases from extending
the terms of a pact by another year if that was neces- ,Vew Manech
sary to maintain industrial peace. (2) The law laid Chowh Spg. 6down by the Federal Court and the Supreme Court Wvg. Co. Lid.
v.
recognizes such a power in an Industrial Court.
Testile
Labout
(3) The fact that the subsequent block has not been
A ssociali.on
valued does not affect the question, for the parties can
certainly agree, for various reasons, that the value of SubbtJ Rao ].
the existing block should govern the situation for a
specified period. (4) The impugned five-year pact is
not contrary to industrial law as laid down by this
Court; indeed, it expressly followed the principles laid
down in the Full Bench Formula which was subsequently affirmed by this Court in the case of As.Yociated Cement Companies (' ). (5) The impugned pact also
does .not infringe the principle that bonus depends
upon profits; but it applied the same by evolving a
formula of "set-on" and "set-off" to a complicated
situation of the entire industry in a particular area for
a number of years.
For the foregoing reasons, and in view of the aforesaid definite findings of the Industrial Court, I hold
that this is eminently a fit case for extending the
agreement for the bonus year 1958.
Before closing I must express my appreciation of
the way in which the impugned pact was brought
about between the parties. It is in the interest of both
the employers and the employees-while the employees of every mill are assured of payment of a minimum bonus, the employers of every mill also are
assured protection against extravagant claims. The
agreement avoided complicated and acrimonious disputes in courts every year in regard to bonus. The
working of this agreement certainly helped the mills
to achieve the introduction of schemes of rationalization. The agreement has become a model one for
other mills. Ironically the Full Bench Formula,
affirmed by this Court in the case of Associated Cement
Companies Limited (1 ), mainly evolved to fix the
amount required for rehabilitation in the interest of
industrial peace, turned out to be the sheet-anchor for
(1) [1959J s.c.R. 925.
36
N f!W !vi a neck
Chowk Spg. &
Wvg. Co. I.Id.
v.
TaNlile Labour
Association
Subba Rao ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[I!l61]
the employers to depart from the path of negotiation
and agreement which they were following all these
years and to enter the arena of open fight with the
employees. It may be, though it may turn out to be
wrong, that they are under the belief that the Full
Bench Formula, if strictly followed, would not leave
any surplus and that they need not pay any bonus to
the employees.
This attitude is neither reasonable nor in the interest ·of industrial peace. I hope and trust that the
parties, in spite of the temporary success in these
appeals, would see better light and settle their disputes as they had been doing all these years.
In the result, the appeals fail and are dismissed
with costs.
BY COURT : In accordance with the opinion of the
majority, the appeals are allowed and the matter sent
back to the Tribunal for disposing of the issue before
it in accordance with law. We direct that the Tribunal should proceed to try the question whether any
bonus should be awarded to the employees of the
eighteen mills before us on the basis of the Full Bench
Formula as interpreted by this Court in the case of
The Associated Cement Companies (1 ).
In the circumstances, there will be no order as to
costs.
Appeals allowed.
Cases remanded to the Tribunal.
(1) (1959] S.C.R. 925.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org