M/S. UNIVERSAL IMPORTS AGENCY AND OTHERS versus THE CHIEF CONTROLLER OF IMPORTS AND EXPORTS AND OTHERS. (AND CONNECTED PETITIONS)
Supreme Court of India | Decided 23 August 1960 | [1961] 1 S.C.R. 305 | 1960 INSC 130
Key facts
- Decided
- 23 August 1960
- Bench
- BHUVNESHWAR PRASAD SINHA*, SYED JAFFER IMAM*, A.K. SARKAR*, K. SUBBA RAO, J.C. SHAH
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 123/1957
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1961] 1 S.C.R. 305
- Neutral citation
- 1960 INSC 130
Text of the judgment
l S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
305
foreign judgment. (4) Clause 3 of art. 4 is in the nature
r960
of a deeming clause and makes the decree of the Th A .
· b) a decre~
·
e ssocialed
.
P a k istan
co?r t .(W. es.t p U~Ja
of a c_ourt of Hotels
of India,
competent iunsdwt1on m East Puniab (India). (5) Ltd. & An~ther
Situs of the decree is not in Pakistan alone but the
v.
legal fiction applies to that also, and (6) the evacuee R. B. Jodha Mal
laws of Pakistan do not affect the effectiveness of the
Kuthalia
decree in India.
Kapur ].
I would therefore allow this appeal and set aside
the judgment and order of the High Court. The
appellants will have their costs throughout.
BY COURT: In view of the majority Judgment,
the appeal is dismi8sed with costs.
·
Appeal dismissed.
M/s. UNIVERSAL IMPORTS AGENCY
AND ANOTHER
v.
THE CHIEF CONTROLLER OF IMPORTS
AND EXPORTS AND OTHERS.
(AND CONNECTED PETITIONS)
(B. P. SINHA, c. J., JAFAR IMAM, A. K. SARKAR,
K. SuBBA RAO and J.C. SHAH, JJ.)
French Establishments-Agreement to import goods-De facto
transfer of administration to India-Confiscation of goods imported
-Validity-" Things done or omitted to be done", meaning a/French Establishments' (Application of Laws) Order, r954, cl. (6)Sea Customs Act, r878 (8 of 1878). s. 167(8).
In pursuance of an agreement dated October 2r, r954, entered into between the Government of India and the Govern. ment of France whereby there was a de facto transfer of the
administration of Pondicherry and other French Settlements to
the Government of India as and from November I, r934, a notification dated October 30, 1954, was issued by the Government
of India called the French Establishments' (Application of Laws)
Order, r954, by virtue of wlfich certain enai:tments specified in
column (3) of the Schedule which included the Sea Customs Act,
August a3.
306
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1961)
1878, the Imports & Expdrts Trade (Control) Act, 1947, and the
Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1947, were extended to
U•i11ersal
Pondicherry. Paragraph 6 of the Order provided: "Unless
f.t11porls Agem:y otherwi.e specilically provided in the Schedule, all laws in force
v.
in French Establishments immediately before the commenceCAie/ Ctmlroller ment of the Order, which correspond to enactments specilied m
of 1...pa.1, 6- the Schedule, shall cease to have effect, save as respect things
EMporls
done or omitted to be done before such commencement".
Shortly prior to the transfer of the administration of l'o:idicherry to India, the petitioners had entered into certain agreements with foreign suppliers for the import into Pondicherry
of diverse goods. Pondicherry was, pnor to the transfer to
India, a free port without any restrictions on imports, except on
a few items, and the importers could acquire foreign exchange
either at the official rate in respect of some transactions or at
the open market in respect of others. The petitioners had with
the consent of the French authorities obtained through the banks
foreign exchange from the open market to finance their imports
and had, with the foreign exchange so acquired, opened irrevocable letters of credit in favour of their foreign suppliers un account of the price of the goods to be supplied. On or about
November l, 1954, the goods covered by the aforesaid imports
were in different stages o( shipment and arrived at the port of
Pondicherry in January and February 1955· The Collectur of
Customs treated the imports of the goods as unaut110rised and
confiscated the same and gav•! the petitioners an option to pay 111
lieu of confiscation a penalty, on the ground that the petitioners
had not obtained a licence for bringing the goods into Pondicherry and that s. 167(8) o( the Sea Customs Act, 1878, was ·
contravened. The petitioners claimed, inter alia, that the transactions entered into by them with the foreign dealers wore
"things done" within the meaning of para. lJ of the l'rench
Establishments' (Application o( Laws) Order, 1954, and that
therefore the imports by the petitioners were within the saving
clause of that paragraph.
Held, (Per Sinha, C.].. Imam and Subba Rao, JJ. Sarkar
and Shah, JJ .. dissenting): (1) that on its proper interpretation,
the express10n " things done " m para. 6 o( the French Establishments' (Application of Laws) Order, 1954· was comprehensive
enough to take in not only things done.but also the effects or the
legal consequences flowing therefrom:
[he Que"n v. justices of the West Riding of Yorkshire, (1876)
l Q.ll.D. 220 and Heston and /slewortil Urbat> District Co1mcil v.
Grout, [1897) 2 Ch. 306, relied on.
(2) that the bringing of the goods into India and the relevant contracts entered into by the petitioners with the foreign
dealers formed parts o( a same transaction, and therefore, the
imports _were the effect or the legal consequence of the " things
done", ·i.e., tho contracts entered into by the petitioner;
1960
..
.
II
'j
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
307
r960
State of Travancore-Cochin v. The Bombay Co. Ltd., [1952]
S.C.R. u12 and State of Travancore-Cochin v. Shanmugha Vilas
Universal
Cashew Nut Factory, [1954] S.C.R. 53, relied on.
Imports Agency
(3) that para. 6 of the order saved the transactions entered
v.
into by the petitioners and that, therefore, the Collector of Cus- Chief Controller
toms had no right to confiscate their goods on the groun<\ that of Imports &they were imported without a licence.
Exports
Per Sarkar, J.-(r) The mere making of the contracts and
the opening of the letters of credit without the bringing of the
goods into Pondicherry would not amount to an "import" and,
therefore, the imports by the petitioners would.not be within the
saving clause in para. 6as things done before the commencement
of the Application of Laws Order. (2) In the absence of the
necessary words to extend the application of French laws to the
effect of things done or rights acquired frorri the doing of them,
the saving clause in para. 6 could not protect the imports made
by the petitioners from the operation of the Indian laws applied
to the French Establishments.
Per Shah, J.-(1) Steps preliminary to import, eveu if
they are closely integrated therewith, are not included in the
concept of import, in dealing with the provisions of the Sea
Cnstoms Act and the Imports and Exports Trade (Control) Act.
(2) By the use of. the expression "things done or omitted to· be
done befgre such commencement " in cl: 6 of the French Establishments' (Application of Laws) Order, 1954, French law applies
to acts and omissions before November I, 1954• and not to legal
consequences of those acts and omissions ensuing after that date,
and hence import of goods across the customs frontier in the
Pondicherry Port after November I, 1954, without a licence in
that behalf is contrary to the provisions of the Sea Customs Act
and the Import and Exports Trade (Control) Act.
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Petitions Nos. 123 to 125
of 1957 and 118 of 1959.
Petitions under Article 32 of the Constitution of
India for enforcement of Fundamental Rights.
N. 0. Chatterjee and S. 0. Mazumdar, for the petitioners (In Petns. Nos. 123 to 125 of 1957).
A. V. Viswanatha Sastri, R. Ganapathy Iyer and
G. Gopalakrishnan, for the petitioners (In Petn. No. 118
of 1959).
H. J. Umrigar, B. R. L; Iyengar and T. M. Sen, for
the. Respondents (In all the petitions).
Harnam Singh and Sadhu Singh, for Intervener
No; 1 (B. S. 8.nd Co.)
40
308
SUPREME COURT REPORT8
[ 1961]
D. R. Prem and Sadhu Singh, for Intervener No. 2
(French
India. Importing Corporation).
Universal
Impo,ts Agtncy
1960. August 23. Tho ,Judgment of B. P. 8inha,
v.
C. J., Imam and 8uhba. Rao, JJ., was delivered by
0
c~~·~m~o;,:; 1);' Subba. Rao, J. Sarkar, J. and Shah, J., delivered
Exp 0 , 1,
separate Judgments.
Iy6o
Subba /lao ].
SuBBA gAO J.-These four petitions are filed underf
Art. 32 of the Constitution for quashing the orders o
the Assistant Controller of Imports and Exports. the
Collector of Customs and Central Excise, Pondicherry,
the Board of Revenue, a1~d the Government of India,
and for an appropriate direction requiring the respondents to refund the amount realised from the petitioners.
Messrs. U niversa.l Im ports Agency and the proprietor of the agency are the petitioners in the first
three petitions and Messrs. Victory Traders are the
petitioners in the la.st one. The Chief Controller of
Imports and Exports, Pondicherry, tho Collector of
Customs and Central Excise, Pondicherry, the Central
Board of Revenue and tho Government of India. are
the respondents in all the petitions.
Messrs. French India. Importing Corporation and
Messrs. B. S. & Co. intervened in the Writ Petitions.
Pondicherry was a. French Possession in India.. On
October 21, 1954, the Government of India. and the
Government of France entered into a.n agreement
(hereinafter called the Indo-French Agreement), whereunder there was a. defacto transfer of the administration
of the French Settlements to the Government of India
(hereinaft-0r called the merger) a.s and from November
1, 1954. The de jure transfer was postponed.
Messrs. Universal Imports Agency are a proprietary
concern registered with the Services Des Contribution,
Pondicherry, having its principal place of business at.
Pondicherry. Sri Moha.nla.l B. Gandhi is the proprietor
of the said Agency. They are established importer~
and genera.I merchants dealing in ball bearings, mill
stores, porcelain ware, glass marbles, beltings and
various other goods. They commenct-'<l their business
at Pondicherry on or about April 14, 1954, under
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
309
"patente" No. 70 of 1954 issued by the Controller of
'9 60
the Contributions Department of· the .French Governuniversa
. 1
ment at Pondicherry. In the middle of August 1954, Impo•ts Agency
they placed Sindents with Messrs. Shimada Trading
v.
Co., Ltd., Osaka, Japan, for importing porcelain wares, Chief Cont•oller
glass marbles and beltings and the total value thereof of Imports &
amounted to Rs. 57,418.12.0. .About the end of ·Exports
August 1954, they opene,d three irrevocable Letters of Subba Rao J.
Credit with Messrs. Banque De L ' lndo-Chine in
favour of the said suppliers. The bankers obtained
authorization from· the Bureau Des Alfa.ires Eoonomique, Pondicherry, for the requisite foreign exchange
from the open market and sold the same to the petitioners for the amount involved in the Letters of
Credit. .The petitioners made full payment for the
said foreign exchange and the said Bank kept the said
foreign exchange and credit irrevocably available with
their Overseas Agent at Japan for the benefit of the
suppliers against full set of shipping documents. All
the said Letters of Credit were valid for three months
and under the agreement"the suppliers were to ship the
goods within the said time. On or about November
1, 1954, the said goods were in different stages of shipment; in some cases they were in the course of
shipment, and in others awaiting shipment in a matter
of a few days and indeed a large part of the goods had
already been placed on board " S. S. Shillong " and
" S. S. Camliodge " and the balance of the goods were
in the course of being loaded in " S. S. Sunda ". In
January and February, 1955 and thereafter the goods
arrived at the Port of Pondicherry. The Collector of
Customs confiscated all the goods on the ground that
they were imported without a licence and gave an
option to the petitioners to pay in lieu of confiscation
fine amounting to l~s. 30,390/-. The petitioners took
up the matter with the Government of India without
any success and finally they paid the said penalty
under protest and cleared the goods.
On or about September 1954 the petitioners placed .
several indents with their overseas suppliers, Messrs.'Shimada Trading Co., Limited, Osaka., Japan, and__
others and the total C. I. F. value thereof amounted
310
SUPRE:\iE COURT REPORTS
[1961]
to Rs. 40,470-14-0. They a.rra.nged for the full payment of eight cheques to the sa.id suppliers of t.he
l/'lit'ersal
lmporls A,:rncy value of the goods through the Banque De L' lndo.
Chine. Their bankers. duly obtained a.uthoriza.tion
v.
Ch"/ co,,t•oller from the Burea.11 Des Affairs Economique, Pondio/ 1..po.is &
cherry, for the' requisite foreign exchange and sold the
Expo.is
same to.the petitioners for the a.mount involved in the
cheques, a.nd the sa.id foreign exchange was kept available to the suppliers. On or a.bout November 1, 1!)54,
the goods ordered were in different stages of shipment.
and in some cases the goods were in the course of
shipment a.nd in others a.waiting shipment in a matter
of a. few da.ys. In January a.nd February, 1955, the
goods arrived a.t the port of Pondicherry. The Collector of Customs treated the imports of the goods a.s
unauthorized a.nd confiscated the same and gave the
petitioners an option to pay in lieu of confiscation a
penalty a.mounting to Rs. 20,700/-. The petitioners
carried the matter to the Government without any
success. Ultimately the petitioners pa.id the penalty
under protest and cleared the goods.
The petitioners a.gain in the middle of August 1954
placed severe.I indents with their oversea.a suppliers
for importing hair belting, torches, belt fasteners,
electric lighting torch bulbs and primus stoves, and
the total C. I. F. value was Rs. 52,572-12-0. They
opened irrevocable Letters of Credit and issued
cheques age.inst full a.d..-a.nce remittance in favour of
their suppliers through the said Banque De L' Indo.
Chine. Their bankers arranged through the Bureau
Des Affairs Economiquu, Pondicherry, for the requisite
foreign exchange from the open market and sold the
same to the petitioners for the a.mount involved in the
sa.id Letters of Credit and cheques. The petitioners
ma.de full payment for the said foreign exchange and
the said bank kept the said foreign exchange a.nd the
Letters of Credit irrevocably a.vaila.ble with their overseas a.gents for the benefit of the suppliers age.inst full
set of shipping documents and the cheques issued by
the ba.nk on overseas banks were sent to the suppliers
a.s full a.d va.nce remittance a.gs.inst the contra.eta. In
Ja.nua.ry a.nd February, 1955, the goods arrived at the
l S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
. 311
I960
port of Pondieherry. The Collector of Customs confis- .
cated the goods and gave the petitioners an option to
Universal
pay in lieu of confiscatii>n fine amounting to Rs. 24,210. Imports Agemy
Though the petitioners took up the matter with the
v.
Government of India, nothing came out of it. They Chi~/ Controller
paid the penalty under protest and cleared the goods. of Imports &
Exports
Messrs. Victory Traders, the petitioners in Petition
No. 118 of 1959, are carrying on business of import Subba Rao J.
and export and general merchandise in Pondicherry
from the year 1949. The petitioners were importing
into Pondicherry a number of a.rticles frpm various
countries under "patente" No. 126 of 1954 gra.nted
by La Controleur, Pondicherry. On August 20, 1954,
they a.pplied to the Chief Bureau Economique, Pondicherry, requesting them to gra.nt pe.rmits to import
goods from foreign countries. The said Burea.u replied that no import licence wa.s required for goods to
enter the territory. Thereafter the petitioners pla.ced
orders with foreign dealers. In the middle of August,
1954 and early in September, 1954, they placed a.
number of indents with their principa.ls in foreign
countries for importing fan belts, corn emery, ,soda.
wa.ter bottles, gla.ss ma.rbles, etc., of value £ 13,870.
The orders were backed by full pa.yments in many
cases a.nd at lea.st ha.If the pa.yments in others. These
pa.yments were ma.de by demand dra.fts issued by the
Banque De L' ludo-Chine. In Janua.ry a.nd February,
1955 a.nd tharea.fter the goods arrived a.t the port of
Pondicherry, and they · were confisca.ted by the
Collector of Customs who ga.ve the petitioners a.n
option to pa.y in lieu of oonfisca.tion fine a.ggrega.ting
to Rs. 91,100. After filing a.ppea.ls to the. Centre.I
Board of Revenue and, thereafter, a. revision to the
Government of India with no success, the petitioners
clea.red the goods a.fter pa.ying the pena.lty under
protest.
It is clea.r from the foregoing facts tha.t the petitioners entered into, before the merger, firm contra.cts of
sales by import with foreign sellers, made a.va.ila.ble
foreign excha.nge either under Letters of Credit or
otherwise, and the goods were shipped either before or
after the merger, though they rea.ched their destina.tion
312
Sl:PRE)IE COURT REPORTS
(1961)
after the merger. The said goods were confiscated
by the Collector of Cudtoms under the following
f; ,ur·er~a 1
.
d
h Ld
A
Impo'ts A•rncy circumstances.
Un er t e In o.French greement,
v.
tho entire administration of the French Settlements
Chi•/ Co.,i,011" was vestt•d wit.h the Government of India from
of lmpo,ts <S- NoYember l, 1954, though dejure transfer had been
Export.•
postponed. In pursua.nce of the Indo-French Agreement,
the Ministry of External Affairs 1mblished a.
Subba Rao J.
Notification No. S. R. 0. 3315 dated October 30, 1954,
purporting to be under s. 4 of the Foreign Jurisdiction
Act, 1947, and called the French Establishments'
(Application of Laws) Order, 1954, (hereinafter referrnd
to as tho Order). Under paragraph 3 of the said
Order, the Sea Customs Act, 1879, the Resen·o Bank
of India Act, 1934, the Imports & Exports Trade
(Control) Act, 1947, the Foreign Exchange Regulation
Act, 1947 and the Indian Tariff Act, 1934, were
extended to Pond icherry. On N ovemher l, 1954, the
Government of India. appointer! a Controller of Imports & Exports for the French E;,tahlishments, and
paragraph 4 of the same notification gave the following information and guidance to the public:
"As regards orders placPd outside the Establishments a.nd finalis1,d through tho grant of licence by
the competent French Authorities in accordance with
the Laws and Regulations in force prior to lst
~overnber, 1954, licence-holders a.re advis('d to apply
to the Controller of Irnporlg & ExportR for validation
of licences held hy them. No foes will be charged for
theso applications. The applications should be accompanied by the original licence and should give particulars about ......... ".
"Licence-holders are advised not to arrange for
shipments of goods until the licences held by them
have been validated by the Controller of Imports and
Exports at Pondicherry."
The petitioners by way of ahund11.nt caution applied
t.o the Chief Controller of Imports & Exports for
licences for clearance of goods, but they we.re all rejected
and the petitioncrH were told that their goods would be
treated as unauthorized imports and they were advised
to approach the Collector of Customs and Central Excise
i96o
• .
0
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
313
r960
for conditions ·regarding their release. As stated
supra, after the goods a_rrived at the port of PondiUniversal
cherry, the Collector of .Customs and Central Excise Impo,i$ Agency
made the various orders confiscating the goods and
v.
giving the petitioners option to pay penalties in lieu Chief Controller
of confiscation. All of theil'.l paid the penalties, under of Imports &,..
protest, and cleared the goods. The appeals filed to ~ Exports
the Central Board of Revenue were dismissed and the Subba Rao ].
revisions filed against the orders of the Central Board
of Revenue to the Government of India were also
dismissed. The petitioners filed· the petitions under
Art. 32 of the Constitution questioning the validity of
the orders of confiscation.
·
The respondents in their counter-affidavits claim
that the orders ma.de by them a.re valid and in accordance with law.
Learned counsel for the petitioners raised many
contentions in support of their petitions. It is not
necessary to enumerate them as the petitions can
effectively be disposed of on the basis of one of the
contentions. The said contention may briefly be.
stated thus: The petitioners have the fundamental
right to hold and to carry on their import trade and
that the Notification No. S. R. 0. 3315 dated October
30, 1954, on the basis of which the orders of confiscation were issued has a saving clause which excludes
the operation of the said Notification in respect of
transactions whereunder the confiscated goods were
purchased and imported. The said saving clause
embodied in paragraph 6 of the Order reads:
"Unless otherwise specifically provided in the
Schedule, all laws in force in the French .Establishments immediately before the commencement of the
Order, which correspond to enactments specified in the
Schedule, shall cease to have effect, save as respect
things done or omitted to be done before such commencement".
Relying on this paragraph, it is contended that the
transactions entered into by the petitioners with the
foreign dealers were "things done " within the meaning of this paragraph and, therefore, they were saved
from the operation of this Order. For the respondents
314
SCPRE'.llE COURT REPORTS
[1961]
it is e.rgue<l that e.s the confiscated goods were brought
into India. after the commencement of the Order,
Universal
Imports Agericy the goods confiscated were outside the pa.le of the
v.
saving clause. The question raised fa.118 to be decided
Chief Controller on a true interpretation of the terms of para.graph 6
of !Pnports 6of the said Order.
Exports
In order to apply the said para.graph 6 to the prebent case, the following fact:; he.•~ to be ascertained:
(1) What a.re the laws specified in the Schedule? (2)
What were the laws in force in the French Establishments before the commencement of the Order corresponding to the enactments so specified ? (3) What
were the " things donc " or omitted to be done under
the said laws?
It is not necessary to enter into any elaborate
survey of the laws specified in the Schedule. Broadly
stated, the Imports & Exports (Trade Control) Act
enables the Central GovtJrnment to make e.n order
ma.king provisions for prohibiting, restricting or otherwise controlling the import or export of goods of any
specified description. It makes the infringement of
such restrictions an offence and a. person contravening
the same is punishable with imprisonment for a. term
which may extend to one year or with fine or with
both. The Act further says that the goods imported in
violation of the restrictions she.II be deemed to be
goods the import of which ha.a been prohibited or
restricted under s. 19 of the See. Customs Act. In
exercise of the powers conferred by s. 3 and s. 4A of
the Imports & Exports (Trade Control) Act, the
Central Government me.de an order dated December 7,
1955. Under s. 3 of that order, no person shall import
any goods of the description specified in Schedule l,
except and in accordance with a. licence or a. customs
clearance permit granted by the Centi-a.I Government
or by any authority specified in Schedule 2 to that
order. There a.re also provisions prescribing the procedure for obtaining licences, the eonditio.is of the
licences a.nd for their ca.ncella.tion or modification. It
is, therefore, clear that under the ea.id Act, no goods
ea.n be imported into India. without a. licence obtained
in the prescribed manner · from the prescribed
'
•
1· S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
315
authorities. The Sea Customs Act provides for the levy
r96o
of sea customs duty, imposes prohibitions and restricu . 1
tions on imports and exports in respect of certain Impo;t•;·~;,.,Y
goods and imposes punishment for infringement of the
v.
provisions of the Act. Under s. 167(8) of the said Act, Chief Controller
read with s. 3(2) of the Imports and Exports Trade of Imports &
(Control) Act, 1947, if any goods, the importation or
Exports
exportation of which is prohibited or restricted, are Subba Rao ].
imported into or exported out of India contrary to
such restrictions or prohibitions, the goods concerned
are liable to be confiscated and the persons involved •
are also liable to pen!tlty. The Foreign Exchange
Regulation Act, 1947, ·provides for the regulation of
payments, dealings in foreign exchange and securities,
and the import and e~port of currency and bullion. It
prohibits dealings in foreign exchange except by persons authorized to deal in the same and it further
provides penalties for contravention of any of the
provisions of the Act. Briefly stated, the Indian law
as disclosed by the aforesaid Acts is that imports into
India without a licence are prohibited, the goods so
imported in contravention of the restrictions imposed
are liable to be confiscated and that foreign exchange
cannot be obtained otherwise than under the provisions of the Act. Persons infringing the laws are
liable to prosecution in addition to confiscation of the
goods involved.
.
What was the pre-existing law in Pondicherry corresponding to the enactments specified in the Schedule?
Neither the Acts governing the imports nor any
authoritative text-books disclosing the relevant law
have been placed before us. But from the affidavits
filed in the case the state of law corresponding to the
.relevant Acts referred to in para. 3 of the Order can
easily be ascertained. Pondicherry had been a free
port, there being no restrictions on imports except on
a few items like gold, roc~-salt etc. For effecting pay-·
ment for the imports, the importers of Pondicherry
could . acquire foreign exchange either at the official
rate or at the open market rate, whichever might be
conveniently available, both methods being recognised
ft
316
SC'PREME COURT REPORTS
(1961]
i96o
by the French Government as valid. In the counteru . 1
affidavit filed by the State the manner of acquiring
Impo;;;·,~;""Y the foreign exchango for imports has been clearly
'"
stated. Two kinds of permits for obtaining official
Cf.oef Co•t•oll" exchange by importers were issued by the Chief Como/ Tmpo"s c~ missioner in Pondich,Jrry, which were known as authExp"'''
oriza.tion a.nd attestation respectively. They were
Subba Rao ;. signed by the Governor-Genera.! of the French Indian
Establishments himself or by his Secretary-Genera.!.
Tho Government of France used t-0 make an overall
allotment of foreign exchange t-0 the French territories.
Apa.rt form that allotment, it ma.de other currency
allotments in tho light of trade agreements entered
into by France with other countries. Authorizations
were issued in respect of goods imported from countries with which France had entered into trade agreements a.nd attestation8 in respect of goods imported
' from France and other French colonies. Further, in
respect of other transactions exchange was arranged by
importers through banks doa.ling in foreign exchange.
The Department of Alfa.ires of Economics used to
authorize the ba.nkH in respect of such transactions.
Shortly stated, Pondicherry wa.s a. free port without
any restrictions on imports, except on a. few items, and
the importers could acquire foreign exchange either at
tho official rate in respect of some transactions or a.t the
open market in respect of others.
What were the "things done" by the petitioners
under the Pondichorry law ? Tho petitioners in
the course of their import trade, having obtained
authorization for the foreign exchange through their
bankers, entered into firm contracts with foreign
dealers on C. I. F. terms. In some cases irrevocable
Letters of Credit were opened a.nd in others bank
drafts were sent towards the contracts. Under the
terms of the contracts the sellers ha.d to ship the goods
from various foreign ports a.nd the buyers were to have
physical deli very of the goods after they ha.d crossed
the customs barrier in India. Pursuant to the terms
of the contracts, the sellers placed the goods on boa.rd
the various ships, some before and others after the
merger, a.nd the goods arrived a.t Pondicherry port
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
317
after its merger with India. The prices for the goods
z96o
were paid in full to the foreign sellers and the goods
u .
· ·
niversa1
were taken de11. very of by t he b uyers a f ter exammmg
Imports Agency
them on arrival. Before the merger if the Customs
v.
Authorities had imposed any restrictions not auth- Chief Controlle1·
orized by law, the affected parties could have enforced 0! Imports &
the free entry of the goods in a court of law. On the
Exports
said facts a short question arises whether paragraph 6 subba Rao J.
of the Order protects the petitioners. While learned
counsel for the petitioners contends that " things
done " take in not only things done but also their
legal consequences, learned counsel for the State contends that, as the goods were not brought into India
before the merger, it was not a thing done before the
merger and, therefore, would be governed by the enactments specified in the Schedule. It is not necessary
to consider in this casa whether the concept of import
not only takes in the factual bringing of goods into
India, but also the entire process of import commencing from the date of.the application for permission to
import and ending with the crossing of the customs
barrier in India. The words " things done " in paragraph 6 must; be reasonably interpreted and, if so
interpreted, they can mean not only things done but
also the legal consequences flowing therefrom. If the
interpretation suggested by the learned counsel for the
respondents be accepted, the saving clause would become unnecessary. If what it saves is only the executed contracts, i.e., the contracts whereunder the goods
have been imported and received by the buyer before
the merger, no further protection is necessary as ordinarily no question of enforcement of the contracts under
the pre-existing law would arise. The phraseology
used is not an innovation but is copied from other
statutory clauses. Section 6 of the General Clauses
Act (X of 1897) says that unless a different intention
appears, the repeal of an Act shall not affect anything
duly done or suffered thereunder. So too, the Public
Health Act of 1875 (38 & 39 Viet. c. 55) which repealed
the Public Health Act of 1848 contained a proviso to
s. 343 to the effect that the repeal " shall not affect
anything duly done or suffered under the enactment
318
SUPRE:\1E COURT REPORTS
[!961]
hereby repealed". This proviso ca.me under judicial
scrutiny in The Queen v. Justices of the West Ridina of
L'11>vrrsal
Imports .'lgrnry Yorkshire('). There notice was given by a local board
of health of intention to make 11. rnte under the Public
v.
Chief Co"troller Health Act, 1848, and amending Acts.
Before the
of J,nports &
notice had expired these Acts were repealed by the
Exports
Public Health Act, 1875, which contained a saving of
S1tbba Rao _/. "anything duly done" under the repealed enactments,
and gave power to make a similar rate upon giving a.
similar notice. The boa.rd, in ignorance of the repeal,
ma.de a rate purporting to be ma.de under the repenlcd
Acts. It was contended that as the rate was ma.de
after the repealing Act, the notice givPn under the
repealed Act was not valid. The learned Judges held
that as the notice was given before the Act, the making of the rate was also saved by the words "anything
duly done" under the repealed enactments. This case
illustrates the point that it is not necessary that an
impugned thing in itself should have been done before
the Act was repealed, but it would be enough if it was
integrally connected with and was a legal consequence
of a thing done before the said repeal. Under similar
circumstances Lindley, L. J ., in Heston and I slewortli
Urban District Couw:il v. Grom(') confirmed the validity of the rate ma.de pursuant to a notice issued prior
to the repeal. Adverting to the saving clause, the
learned Judge tersely states the principle thus at
p. 313: "That to my mind preserves that notice and
the effect of it ". On that principle the Court of Appeal
held that the rate which was the effect of the notice
was good.
It is suggested that the phraseology of the saving
clause of the English Statutes and of the General
Clauses Act of 1897 a.re of wider import than that of
para.graph 6 of tho Order and, therefore, the English
decisions a.re not of any assistance in considering the
scope of the saving clause of the Order. It is further
stated that the English decisions apply only to a
sa. ving clause of an Act which repeals another but
preserves the right created by the latter. We do not
see any reason wby the same construction cannot be
(1) (1876) I Q.B.D. 220.
(2) [1897] 2 Cb. 3o6.
•
1 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
319
placed upon the wording of paragraph 6 of the Order
which is practically similar in terms as those found in
Universal
the relevant saving clause of the English Statute and Imports Agency
that of the General Clauses Act.
v.
Nor can we find any justification for the second cri- Chief Controller
ticism. In the instant case the legal position is ex- of I1nports &
Exports
actly the same. By reason of the Indo-French Agreement the Government· of India made the Order under Subba Rao ].
the Foreign Jurisdiction Act applying the Indian laws
to Pondicherry. The effect of that Order was that the
French laws were repealed by the application of the
Indian laws in the same field occupied by the French
laws subject to a saving clause. The position is analogous to that of a statute repealing another with a
saving clause. If the English decisions apply to the
latter situation, we do not see how they do not apply
to the former. In both the cases the pre-existing law
continues to govern the things done before a particular date. We, therefore, hold that the words " things
done" in paragraph 6 of the Order are comprehensive
enough to take in a transaction effected before the
merger, though some of its legal effects and consequences projected into the post-merger period.
Now what was the inter-relation between the said
" things done " and the act of import or bringing of
the goods into India ? The· effect of the contracts
under the pre-existing law was that the terms thereof
could have been implemented without any customs
bar placed against the import. This Court had, in
the context of Art. 286(l)(b) of the Constitution, to
consider the connotation of the words " in the course
of export or import " in State of Travancore-Cochin v.
The Bombay Co. Lfd. (1). Patanjali Sastri, C. J., described the nature of export sale thus at p. 1118:
" Such sales must of necessity be put through by
transporting the goods by rail or ship or both out of
the territory of India, that is to say, by employing the
machinery of export. A sale by export thus involves
a series of integrated activities commencing from the
agreement of sale with a foreign buyer and ending
with the delivery of the goods to a common carrier for
(1) [1952] S.C.R. III2.
320
SUPRE;\IE COURT REPORTS
[ 1961]
transport out of the country by land or sea. Such
a
salo cannot be diBsociated from the export without
(:' uivrrsal
which
it cannot be effectuated, and the sale and resulImports A.1;nuy
tant
export
form parts of a single transaction."
v.
Chief C1J10frol!er The same principle has been restated by the learned
of lt11port~ &
Chief Justice in State of Tramncore-Cochin v. ShanmuE:rp:Jrts
gha Vilas Cashew Nut Factory (' ). The learned Chief
.Justice stated at p. 63 thus:
"The phrase" integrated activities" was used in
the previous decision to denote that a sale, that is, a
sale which occasions the export, cannot be dissociated
from the export without which it cannot be effectuated and the sale and resultant export form parts of a
single transaction".
Applying tho said principles to an import sale it
may be stated that a purchase by import involves a
series of integrated activities commencing from the
contra.ct of purchase with a foreign firm and ending
with the bringing of the goods into the importing
country and that the purchase and resultant import
form parts of a same transaction. If so, in the present case the bringi11g of tho goods into India and the
relevant contracts entered into by the petitioners with
the foreign dealers form parts of a same transaction.
The imports, therefore, were the effect or the legal
consequence of the "things done", i.e., the contracts
entered into by the petitioners with the foriegn dealers.
This conclusion is e.lso min forced by the terms of
the Indo-F'rench Agreement. It is common case that
the terms of the said Agreement cannot be enforced in
a municipal court in India. We aro only referring to
it as the terms thereof throw some light on the proper
understanding of the saving clause. By Art. 17 of the
Agreement, in so far aH material for our purpose, all
orders placed outside the Establishments and finalised
through the grant of a. licence by competent authorities in accordance with laws and regulations in force
prior to the date of the defacto transfer were to be fulfilled by the Government of India and the necessary
foreign exchange granted if the goodH were imported
19fio
(1) [1954] S.C.R. 53·
·-
1 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
321
within the period of validity of the relevant licences
z960
subject to payment of customs duty and other taxes
.
normally leviable at Indian ports. That is, orders 1 Puntive~al
placed outside the Establishments and finalised through m or 'v. $•ncy
the grant of a licence were to be honoured by the Chief Controller
Government of India. The word "licence " in this of Impor/s &
Article may be construed rather widely to take in a
Exports
permit or an authorization ; otherwise it would lead to
the anomaly that when a licence, strictly so called, is Subba Rao f.
required for a transaction and therefore obtained, the
transaction is protected by the Article, whereas the
transaction which requires only a permit is excluded
therefrom. It may be recalled that the petitioners
obtained authorizations of the Economics Department
in respect of their orders. This Article indicates the
intention of the two Governments that the orders so
placed outside the Establishments should be honoured.
If paragraph 6 of the Order is construed in the manner suggested by the State, we would be imputing to
the framers of the Order a conscious breach of the terms
of the Agreement between the two countries, for
even the;orders covered by Art. 17 of the Agreement
would be excluded from the operation of the saving
clause.
·
We would, therefore, hold that paragraph 6 of the
Order saves the transactions entered into by the petitioners and that the respondents _had no right to confiscate their goods on the ground that they were
imported without licence. In this view, no other question arises for consideration.
In the result, the orders of the respondents 2, 3 and
4 are quashed and they are directed to refund to the
petitioners the amounts illegally collected from them.
The petitioners in all the petitions will have their
costs.
SARKAR J.-I think that these petitions should fail.
Sometime in the latter half of 1954, the petitioners
had in Pondicherry, then a French establishment in
India, entered into certain agreements with foreign
suppliers for the import into Pondicherry of diverse.·
goods. It is said that at that time lioenoes were not
S•rka•
J.
322
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1961]
required for such imports from the French authorities.
It appears however that these authorities granUniversal
ted
a
certain a.mount of foreign exchange for the
Imports Agency
imports.
The importers who failed to secure an allotv.
Clrief Controller ment of foreign exchange from the French authorities
of Imports &
often obtained it from the open market through banks.
E:¥potls
The French authorities however prohibited the banks
in Pondicherry with effect from July I, 1954, from
Sarkat j.
acquiring without their permission, foreign exchange
in the open market for their constituents for financing
imports. The petitioners had with the consent of the
French authorities obtained through the banks fo~ign
exchange from the open market to finance their
imports and had with the foreign exchange so acquired; opened irrevocable letters of credit in favour of
their foreign suppliers on account of the price of tho
goods to be supplied. They did this shortly prior to
the transfer of administration of ·Pondichcrry and
other French establishments in India on November 1,
1954, to India pursuant to an agreement mad<; on
October 21, 1954, between the Governments of France
and India. The goods covered by the aforesaid imports
were shipped and arrived in Pondicherry port after
November l, 1954, and were confiscated by the Government of India who had by that time taken over the
administration of Pondicherry. The orders of confiscation gave an option to the petitioners to obtain a
release of the goods by payment of e. fine which option
we.a e. vailed of by them.
These petitions have been filed under Art. 32 of the
Constitution challenging the validity of the confiscation and claiming a refund of tho fine paid on the
ground that the confiscation was an illegal violation
of the petitioners' rights under the Constitution to
hold property a.ud to carry on business.
The orders of confiscation had been made under
s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act, 1878. That section
authorised the confiscation of goods imported in contravention of orders prohibiting imports ma.de under
e. 19 of the same Act. Section 3 of the Im ports and
Exports (Control) Act, 1947, also authorised the Central Government to prohibit by orders ma.de by it,
1 S.C.R.
'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
323
60
imports of goods of any. specified description and
'9
provided that the goods to which the orders applied
u .
1
would be deemed to be goods of which the import had Impo:,·:··~;,ncy
been prohibited under s. 19 of the Sea Customs Act ,
v.
and that the provisions of the latter Act would have Chief Con,,oller
effect accordingly. Section 4 of the Imports and Ex- 0 f ImP 0 "s '"'
ports (Control) Act provided that all orders made
Exports
under r. 84 of the Defence of India Rules and in force
Sarkar J.
immediately before the commencement of the Act,
would be deemed to have been made under the Act.
There. was an order made by the Government of
India under r. 84 of the Defence of India Rules by
Notification of the Department of Commerce No. 23
I.T.C. 43 dated July l, 1943, which prohibited the
import of the goods which the petitioners had imported.
The orders of confiscation would be unexceptionable
if the statutes and Or.der mentioned in the preceding
pa.rngraph applied to these imports. That they
applied to Pondicherry as from November 1, 1954,
would sePm to be plain from the Order passed by the
GovernllJeiit of India. on October 30, 1954, under the
Foreig'n Jurisdiction Act, 1947, to take effect from the
date of the transfer of administration, namely,
November 1, 1954, called the French Establishments
(AppUcation of Laws) Order and being Ministry of
External Affairs Notification No. S.R.O. 3315. This
Order had been passed in view of the Inda-French
agreement and the transfer of administration provided
thereby. Its validity is not challenged. Paragraph 3
of the Order provided that the enactments mentioned
in the Schedule to it and all Orders made under those
enactments and .in force on November l, 1954, would
apply to the French Establishments subject to the
subsequent provisions of the Order. The enactments
mentioned in the Schedule included the Sea Customs
Act and the Imports and Exports (Control) Act. It is
not in dispute that the Order under the Defence of
India Rules mentioned earlier was in force on this
date.
The Application of Laws Order therefore made the.
42
324
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1961]
Sea. Customs Act, the Imports and Exports (Control)
Act a.nd the Order made under the Defence of India.
UnitJersal
Rules applicable to l'ondicherry as from November 1,
Imports Agency
1954.
The petitioners have however contended-for
v.
Chief Controller reasons which I will examine presently-that the
of Imports 6- Ordor made under the Defence of India. Rules had not
Exports
been applied to the French Establishments by the
Application of La.ws Order, but they have not disSarkar ].
puted tha.t the Sea. Customs Act and the Imports a.nd
Exports (Control) Act were applied to Pondicherry.
The petitioners rested their ca.se ma.inly on the saving
clause contained in paragraph 6 of the Application of
La.ws Order which so fa.r a.s ma.teria.l, wa.s in these
terms:
"All la.ws in force in the French Establishments immediately before the commencement of this
Order, which correspond to the enactments in the
Schedule, sha.II cease to ha.ve effect sa.ve as respect
things done or omitted to be done before such commencement".
The petitioners ha.ve raised three points, two of
which ca.n be disposed of a.t once. It is sa.id tha.t the
Order ma.de under the Defence of India. Rules did not
apply to the French Establishments for only Orders
ma.de under the enactments mentioned in the Schedule
were applied to them by pa.ra.gra.ph 3 of the Application of Laws Order, and the Defence of India. Act a.nd
Rules were not enactments mentioned in the Schedule. It is true that the Defence of India Act a.nd
Rules a.re not mentioned in the Schedule. llut a.s
a.lrea.dy stated, under s. 4 of the Imports and Exports
(Control) Act, Orders ma.de under r. 84 of the Defence
o{ India. Rules are to be deemed to ha.ve been ma.de
undor that Act. I am unable to accept the contention that a.n Order which has to bo deemed to be ma.de
under the Imports a.nd Exports (Control) Act is not
an Order made under the Act for tho purposes of
paragraph 3 of the Application of La.ws Order. It
seems to me tha.t when an Order is required to be
deemed to have been ma.de under an enactment, it is
as good a.a an Order ma.de under the enactment. If it
were not so, the deeming provision would lose much of
z960
-
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
325
its value. That being so, para. 3 would make the
'9 60
Order applicable to Pondicherry.
u . ·z
' 1s
' sat'd t hat t h e 1mpor
'
t s were mad e be1ore
"
nwma
Th en it
Imports
Ageney
the commencement of the Application of Laws Order
v.
because the contracts in respect of them had been Chief Controller
concluded and the letters of credit opened before then of Imports &
though the goods had not been taken across the cusExports
toms barrier at Pondicherry by that time. Therefore, Sarkar J.
it is said, the imports by the petitioners would be
within the saving clause in paragraph 6 as things
done before the commencement of the Application of
Laws Order, to which the Sea Customs Act, the Imports and Exports (Control) Act and the Order made
under the Defence of India Rules would not apply.
This argument also seems to me to be ill-founded.
These Acts and the Order were applied to Pondicherry as from November 1, 1954. The effect of that
was t'o prohibit imports thereafter and to render the
goods imported in contravention of that prohibition
liable to confiscation. What is an import-and this
is what. was prohibited-has therefore to be' decided
by reference to these Acts and the Order. They
defined import as bringing goods into India, which in
the present case would include the French Establishments by virtue of paragraph 4 of the Application of
Laws Order. Therefore goods brought across the customs' barrier into Pondicherry would be goods imported into Pondioherry. To the goods so brought into
Pondicherry after· November 1, 1954, the Acts and the
Order made under the Defence of India Rules must
apply irrespective of whether the goods were brought
under contracts concluded and letters of credit opened,
before that date. It is not in my view permissible to
ascertain the meaning of the word 'import' for the
purpose of this case by reference to other statutes or
notions and to contend that there has been an import
by the making of the contract and the opening of the
letter of credit without the bringing of the goods into
Pondicherry as the learned counsel for the petitioners
sought to do.
The main argument on behalf of the petitioners is
however, that the words 'save as respects things done
326
Sl'PHEME COl'RT REPORTR
[ 1961]
or omitted to be done' in paragraph 6 of the Applicat.ion of Laws Order saved not only the things done
V11n·er.~al
prior to the commencement of the Order, that i8, the
Imports Ai:t"cy
placing of the indents and the opening of the let tcrs of
v.
Chu/ Contro!lrr credit hut also the effect thereof and the rights
of lmf.·vrr.~ &
accrued therefrom. It is said that the indents ha.cl Leen
l~x/uirt s
h·gally placed and the letters of crodit legally opened
with foreign exchange acquired with the ex1Jress perSa,Jtay .f.
mission of the French Administration which foroign
exchange could not have been acquired without such
permission. It. is contended that the saving clause
would make the French laws applicable to the imports
which were the effect of these things done Lefore
November I, 1954, and al8o protect the rights acquin:d
from the things so done, from the operation of tho
Indian laws. So it is said that the confiscations under
the Indian laws were wholly illegal.
~ow it has to be noted that the Ba.Ying clause does
not say that the French laws would apply to the
effect of things ~arlier done or protect rights accrued
therefrom. I see no warrant in the absence of the
· necessary words to extend the application of the
French laws to the effect of things done or rights
acquired from the d<!ing of tli~m. 1t was said that
otherwise the saving clause would be idle. I am unable to agree. If any que8tion as to anything earlier
dune arose after the transfer, that question would
under the saving clause have to he decided by the
French laws. In the absence of the saving clause it
would have been open to argument what the effect of
tho transfer was with regard to things previously
done. J. may also point out that 8. ti of the Genera.I
Clauses Act provides that. when one euaetment is
repealed by another, ti.Jen, in the absence of a differeut
intention, the repeal shall not affect anything duly
done or suffered under the repealed enactment nor
any right accrued thereunder. It strikes me that if
tho saving of a. thing done u11<.lor the repealed enactment also necess1~rily saved what is ca.lied the effect
of it or rights acquired from it, it would not have been
necessary to expressly provide also for the 8aving of
the rights acquired under the repealed enactment.
..
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
327
r960
Therefore, it seems to me that the saving of things
done does not automa.tically save the effect of them
Universal
or rights acquired therefrom.
Imports Agcucy
The argument that the saving clause operated to
v.
protect the imports was based on two English cases, Chief Co11troll"
namely, The Queen v. Justi'ces of the West Riding of 0 .f Imports &
Yorkshire(') and Heston and Isleworth Urban District
Exports
Council v. Grout('). These cases considered the terms
Sarkar ].
of statutes analogous to s. 6 of our General Clauses
Act, providing that a repeal of one enactment by
another shall not affect anything duly done or suffered
under the repealed en11-ctment or any right acquired
thereunder. These provisions were therefore materi·
ally different from the saving clause now before us, as
·they expressly saved rights acquired under a repealed
statute. The first mentioned case held that as the
two statutes were substantially for the same purpose,
namely, making a rate, the notice to make a rate
under the repealed Act should have effect after the
repeal in view of the saving clause, as it could have
been given under the repealing Act for the same purpose. It would be difficult to apply the principle of
this case where two statutes have not the same purpose. Apart ·from the fact that we ha.ve here no two
statutes, the Indian enactments with which we are
concerned, would seem to have made a complete dep.arture from the position existing on the same subject
during the French Administration. In the other case
it was held that when a thing duly done under a
repealed enactn.ient was saved by a saving clause in
the repealing Act, the effect of it was also saved. But
the effect of the thing done would be saved by the express 'provision contained in the Raving clause, namely,
that the repeal ·.shall not affect any right acquired
under the repealed enactment and the judgment in
this case was also based on this express provision to
remove any doubts that might arise as to the other
reasoning employed. The thing done in this case was
the giving of a notice by a local authority to certain
house owners to sewer and m~,ke up a private street.
The effect saved was the recovery by the local authority fr9m the owners of the expenses of the sewering
(i) (i876) 1 Q.B.D. »o.
(2) [1897] 2 Ch. 306.
328
SVPRK\IE COURT REPORTS
[1961]
and making of the street which it had to incur on the
owner's failure to carry out the terms of the notice.
Unirersal
Imports A.<'"''' These things naturally took time and in the meant.ime
v.
the Act under which the notice was given had ceased
Chaef Controller to he applicable.
The observation made in this case
of lmpo.rs 6- cannot be applied to a case like the present.
Exports
Then again it seems to me that there is considerable
difference between the terms of the saving clause, conSorka1· j.
sidered in the English cases and the Having clause
with which we are concerned. The saving clause in
the Fnglish cases a.s also s. 6 of our General Clauses
Act., a :·plies where a. subsequent statute repeals a. previous ota.tute passed by the legislature of the sa.mo
country. That is not the position here. We have
here laws of the Indian legislature replacing French
laws. Indeed it is at least arguable whether without
more, the French laws would have been of force a.ftor
the transfer; it would seem that this difficulty wa.s
realised and so it was expr!'ssly provided by para.graph 5 of another Order called the French Establishments (Administration) Order, ma.de by Notification
No. 3314 dated October 30, 1954, issued by the External Affairs Ministry of the Governm~nt of India, that
all laws in force in the French .Establishments and not
repealed by para.. 6 of the Application of La.w~ Order,
would continue to be in force until repealed.
Further, the saving clauses considered in the .English cases preserved unaffected by the repeal, only
things done under the repealed enR.ctment and the
rights a.cquired thereunder. Tho saving clause that
we a.re considering saves things done before the commencement of the Application of Laws Order whether
the thing was done under a.ny law or not; it does
not purport to pr<'scrvo a right acquired under a
statute repealed. In Hamilton Gell v. White('), it was
observed that s. 38 of the English Interpretation Act,
1889, which corresponds to s. 6 of our Genera.I Clause~
Act, " wa.s not intended to preserve the abstract rights
conferred by the repealed Act. ........ It only applies to
specific rights given to an individual upon the ha.ppeniug of one or other of the events specified in the
(I) [19:12] 2 K.B. 422, 431 .
1 S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
329
60
statute." Likewise in Abbott v. Minister for Lands (1) it
'9
was observed about a saving clause which protected
Universal ,
rights accrued under repealed enactments, that, "the Imports Agency
mere right (assuming it to be properly so called) existv.
ing in the members of the community or any class of Chief Co~t•oller
them to take advantage of an enactment, without any of Impo•ts &
act done by an individual towards a~a.iling himself of
Expo•ts
the right, cannot properly be deemed a " right acoruSarkar J.
ed " within the meaning of the enactment". The
principle of the English cases on which the petitioners
relied would not apply except to protect rights acquired under repealed statutes. In the cases before us the
petitioners could not sa.y that they ha.d acquired a.ny
right under a.ny French law, to import the goods.
There wa.s admittedly no law which gave the petitioners any right to import any goods. The position was
only that there was an absence of laws prohibiting
import. That clearly did not give the petitioners any
right and certainly not a right under a statute which
was repea.led. All that the French authorities had
done was to permit the petitioners to acquire foreign
exchange in the open market for financing their imports. n would be impossible. to say that thereby the
petitioners acquired any right under any French law
to import any goods.
Lastly, the principle of the two English cases applies admittedly only where there is no intention to the
contrary. Now it seems to me that here there is indication of an intention to the contrary. Clause 17 of
the agreement between India and France provided
that imports finalised through the grant of licence
prior to the transfer would be fulfilled but the goods
would be liable to customs duty normally leviable in
Indian ports. Clearly, therefore, it wa.s not intended
that after the transfer, Pondicherry would remain a
free port in respect of imports ma.de even under agreements concluded prior to the transfer under a licence.
On such imports duty ha.d to be pa.id afte.r the transfer.
The right to import freely was not therefore intended
to be preserved. If so there could have been no intention, in any event, to protect a. right to import freely
(1) [1895) A.G. 425. 431.
SUPRK.\IE COCRT REPORTS
[l96l]
under an agreement made prior to the transfer, where
thPn• was no licence granted for the import. Admittedly, the petitio11cr8 had not obtained a.ny such
licrnce.
.
"·
C4itf Co11/rf'll~r
For 11,ll thesp, reasnns it sPems to m11 thM the Engl)j lmp1nts .._r.,,
lish decisions relied on art1 of no a.ssista.uce in the
f;·xport<
present case. I a.m unn.bl1i to read the saving clause
in this casl· as if it is the Hn.me a.s s. 6 of our Genera.I
Clauses Act or the corresponding clause in the Engli~h
Interpretation Act, 1889, and to obtain guidance from
the decisions based on these statutes. I have therefore como to the conclusion that the sa. ving clauRe in
para.graph 6 of the Application of Laws Order docs
not protect the imports ma.de by the petitioner8, from
the operation of the Indian laws applied to the French
Establishments.
I would dismiss these petitions.
U 11i1:n sal
J 1n pnr/ < A i:enc·,
Shah j.
1
SHAH ,J.-Petit.ion Xo. 123 of 1957:
Prior to
November 1, 1954, Ponclicherry was one of the French
Establishments in India administered by the Government of France. Under the French administration,
except specified ra.tegories like gold, rock-sa.lt and certain medicinal preparations, a.II commodities could be
imported into the Poudicherry Port without a licence.
The French Administration Pxercised coutrol on import of commodities into l'ondicherry indirectly by
ma.king allotment of the requisite foreign exchange.
The Government of France made an O\'erall allotment
of foreign exchange for the French Estiiblishments in
India, and persons desiring to import goods in Pondicherry and other French Indian settlements were, on
applications addressed to the Chief Commissioner,
French Settlements, granted foreign exchange facility
for financing imports, out of that allotment. B'esides
the allotment of foreign exchange for financing imports into the French Establishments in India, certain
other currency allotmeuts wero made by the Government of France in the light of Trade Agreements
between the French Government and other countries.
The Chief Con11nissioner of Pondicherry isgued permits
for the import of commodities specified in the Trade
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
331 .
Agreements upto the current ceilings fixed in the
z96o
Two ~inds of permit~ for obtaining o~Universal
ma! exchange by 'Importers were rnsued by the Chief Imports Agency
Commissioner which were known as "Authorisation"
v.
and " Attestation". " Authorisation " was issued for Chief Controller
import of goods from countries with which France h1;1.d of Imports &
Trade Agreements and "Attestation" for import of
Exports
goods from France and from countries with which the
Shah J.
Government of France had not made Trade Agreements. By issuing " Authorisation" and " Attestation'', the Government undertook to provide foreign
exchange· for financing the imports made pursuant
thereto. Since. April 1, 1954, the Chief Commissioner
of Pondicherry allowed intending importers to purchase foreign exchange in the open· market for financing imports of merchandise. The Department of
Affairs, Economiques, endorsed "authorise " on the
application submitted by the importers' banker in
respect of such transactions, but the Government did
not undertake thereby to provide foreign exchange.
As official exchange for imports was freely released,
only a few imports were financed before July 1954
with the aid of exchange purchased in the open
·
market.
Negotiations were proceeding between the Government of India and the Government of France for
transfer of the French Establishments in India to the
Union of India, and when it came to be known that
the transfer w:.as imminent, there was feverish activity .
to import goods into the French Settlements with the
aid of foreign exchange purchased in the open market,
and in the months of August, September and October
orders were placed by importers with foreign suppliers
for purchase of commodities of the value of Rs. 280
lakhs to be financed by foreign exchange procured
from the open market .. Traders who were not normally
doing business in Pondicherry and who had no· .business interest in French Establishments also opened
offices in Pondicherry and started indenting goods, .to
be financed with the aid of foreign exchange in the
open market.
~greements.
43
332
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1961]
An agreement for the de facto transfer of the a.dministration of the French Establishments in . India.
Imports Age•<y wa.s executed between the Government of India. a.nd
v.
the Government of France on October 21, 1954. This
CAieJ Co•troll" agreement became effective on November l, 1954. In
0! r..ports <>exercise of the powers conferred by s. 4 of the Foreign
Exports
Jurisdiction Act, 1947, on October 31, 1954, the
Government
of ln<lia. istmed two orders-S. R. O. 3314,
Sh•h j.
the French Establishments (Administration) Order,
1954, a.nd S. R. 0. 3315, the French Establishments
(Applica.tion of La.ws) Order, 1954. By S. R. 0. 3315,
certain enactments specified in column (3) of the Schedule which included the Sea. Customs Act, 1878, The
Reserve Ba.nk of India. Act, 1934, The Im ports a.nd
Exports Trade :(Control) Act, 1947, The Foreign
Exchange Regulation A·Jt, 1947 a.nd The Indian Ta.riff
Act, 1934, were applied to the French Establishments
of Pondicherry, Ka.ra.ikal, Ma.he and Ya.naru, with the
modification tha.t references in the enactments, potific&·
tions, orders a.nd regulations which were a. pplied to the
French Establishments, to India or to the Sta.tea were
to be construed a.s reforr ing to the French Establishments a.lso. These orders ca.me into force on N ovember 1, 1954.
The petitioners who carried on trade in diverse commodities in Bombay opened a. place of business in
Pondicherry on April 14, 1954, a.nd placed eight
indents with Messrs. Shimada. Trading Co., Ltd., Osaka.,
J a. pa.n, for importing procela.in ware, gla.~s marbles a.nd
beltings. On a.n application submitted by Ba.nkque
D. L' lndo-China on behalf of the petitioners, the
Bureau Des Affairs Economique, Pondicherr), endorsed "authorise" for the requisite foreign exchr.nge purchased in the open market. This exchange wa.s sold
to the petitioners for the •~mount involved in the letters
of credit. Between August 28, 1954, a.nd August 31,
1954, three irrevocable :titters of credit of the a.ggrega.te
value of£ 12,850 were opened by the petitioners a.nd
pursuant to these letters, M/s. Shim'.>da. Trading Co.,
Ltd., shipped goods to Pondicherry. On November 30,
1954, the shipping doouments were received by the
petitioners from Me8Brs. Shimada. Trading Co., Ltd.
z96o
u.;vm•l
I S.C.R .. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
333
Admittedly the goods were shipped by the foreign
I96o
suppliers after the de facto transfer of Pondicherry.
u . 1
The applications submitted by the petitioners for the Impo;,;·~;enc·
issue of customs· permits sanctioning clearance of the
v.
·
goods· were rejected by the Controller of Imports and Chief. Controlle
Exports at Pondicherry. On January 5, 1955, the 0! Imports &
Chief Controller of Imports and Exports issued a public
Exports
notification that on a consideration of the. representaShah 1.
tions made by some of the importers asking for permission to import goods for which necessary foreign
exchange had been obtained in the open market
through bankers in Pondicherry and in consultation
with the authorities concerned, it was " clarified for
information" that open market transacti011s of the
nature referred to in the representations::were not
covered by the Inda-French Agreement, and. that the
import of goods against open market transactions after
November l, 1954, must be treated as unauthorised;
but 411.ving regard to the hardship likely to be caused
to genuine importers who had placed orders in pursuance of their normal trading operations, the Collector
of Customs, Pondicherry, was being authorised to
· accord certain concessions to genuine importers. By
one of such concessions, goods shipped before November 1, 1954, were permitted to be cleared "without
penalty" irrespective of their origin and value, and
consignments fully paid for in foreign currency and
shipped after November l, 1954, and ordered before
August 15, 1954, were also permitted to be cleared
"without penalty ".
The goods indented by the petitioners were .confiscated by the customs authorities exercising powers
under s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs Act, on the-groimd
that the same had been imported without a vanalicence and in contravention of the Department of
Commerce and Industries Notification No. 43-1 T.C./43
dated July 1, 1943, (as amended) read with sub-s. 2 of
s. 3 of the Imports and Exports Trade (Control) Act,
1947. The petitioners were by orders passed between
February 28 and March 4, 1955, given an option to
clear the goods for " home _consumption " on payment
of customs duty and fine specified in the order. These
334
SUPRE)fE COURT REPORTS
[1961]
orders were confirmed in appeal by the Board of
Revenue and by the Government of In<lia in exercise
UJ1.":crsal
of
revisiona.l jurisdiction. In the meanwhile the petiImport.( Ageiuy
tioners
pa.id tho duty and the fine imposed bv the
'".
Chief c~n1!roller customs authority and cleared the goods.
'
of lmp()rfs 0·
The Union Government having rejecte<l the HeviExports
sion applications, the petitioners Rubmitted this petition under Art. 32 of the Constitution for a writ or
Sha Ii } .
direction in the nature of certiorari requiring and commanding the Chief Controller of Imports and Exports,
Pondicherry, the Collector of Customs and Central
Excise, Pondicherry, the Central Hoard of Hevenue
a.n<l the Union of India and quashing the orders passed
by the Customs authorities and the UHion of India
and for a mandamus requiring the respondents to
forbear from giving effect to or otherwise a.ct.ing upon
tho orders passed by the CuHtoms authorities and the
Union of India, and for a further writ or order directing the respondents to restore to the petitioners tho
sum of Rs. 30,890 pa.id as penalty for releasing the
goods.
Undoubtedly, the petitioners had before ~ovember
1, 1954, placed indents for importing goods of dirnrse
descriptions from foreign suppliers and for that purpose, they had acquired foreign exch:inge through
their bankers in the open market. The petitioners had
also opened irrevocable letters of credit in favour of
the Japanese suppliers. It. may be assumed, even
though there is no clear evidence in that behalf, that
the petitioners were after opening irrovoca.ble letters
of credit, unable to cancel the indents. Section 167,
cl. (8), of the Sea Customs Aot, in so far as it is mat~
ria.l, provides that if any goods, tho importation of
which is for the time being prohibited or restricted by
or under Chapter 1 V of the Act, aro imported into
India contrary to such prohibition or restriction, such
goods shall be liable to confiscation. By s. 3 of the
Imports and Exports Trade (Control) Act, XVIII of
1947, the Central Government is authorised by order
published in the official Gazette to prohibit, restrict or
otherwise control in a.II cases or in specified classes of
cases, the import, the bringing into any Port or place
I
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
335
1960
in India· of goods of any specified description. By s. 4,
all orders made under r. 84 of the Defence of India
Universal
Rules or that rule. as continued in force by the Emerg- Impo1'ts Agency
ency Provisions (Continuation) Ordinance, 1946, ·and
v.
in force immediately before the commencement of the Chief Controller
Act, in so far as they were not inconsistent with the of Iinports &
Exports
provisions of that Act, continued to remain in force
and were to be deemed to have been made thereunder.
Shah ].
Under the rules framed under the Defence of India
Rules, the import of goods of the description indented
by the petitioners, was; it is not disputed, prohibited,
and the rules framed under the Defence of India Rules
continued in force by the operation of s. 4 of the
Imports and Exports Trade (Control) Act, 1947. The
rules and orders made under r. 84 of the Defence of
India Rules were on November 1, 1954, operative as
if they were made under the Imports and Exports
Trade (Control) Act., 1947, and when that Act was
extended to the French Establishment of Pondicherry,
these rules and orders became also applicable to that
area. By s. 19 of the Sea Customs Act, the Central
Government may by notification prohibit or restrict
the bringing by sea, goods of any specified description
into India across any customs frontier as defined by
the Central Government. By s. 2(b) of the Imports
and Exports Trade (Control) Act, 1947, import is
defined as bringing into India by sea, land or air.
Import of goods therefore means carrying goods across
the customs frontier declared by the Government of
India. There is no dispute thaL under s. 19, the Port
of Pondicherry was declared a customs frontier.
Admittedly, the goods indented by the petitioners
were brought into India, i.e., imported into India
after November 1, 1954. Importation of these goods
without a licence in that behalf being prohibited under
a notification under the Imports and Exports Trade
(Control) Act, by bringing the goods into the Pondicherry Port, prima facie s. 167(8) of the Sea Customs
Act was contravened.
But the petitioners contend that in view of the
agreement between the Government of India and the
Government of France and the two orders issued in
336
SCPREME COCRT REPORTS
[1961]
exercise of the powers conferred by s. 4 of the Foreign
.
Jurisdiction Act, 1947, the provisions of the Sea.
Unw.rAsal
Customs Act a.nd the orders ma.de or deemed to be
I n1ports
gency
v.
ma. de un d er t he I mports a.n d E xports T ra.de (Control)
Chief co .. froll" Act, 1947, did not apply to the goods in question. By
of Imporis 6· cl. 3 of the agreement dated October 21, 1954; the
Exports
Government of India. succeoded to the rights and ob]i.
ga.tions resulting from suoh acts of the French
Shah f.
Administration in these Establishments a.s were binding on the territory. By para.. 5 of Art. 10, acts or
deeds constitutive of rights established prior to the
date of the de facto transfer in conformity with French
la.w retained tho value and v;~]idity conferred a.t that
time (by the same law). By Art. 17, in so far a.s it is
material, a.11 orders placed outside the establishments
and finalised through the grant of a. licence by competent authorities in accordance with tho laws and
regulations in force prior to the date of the de f a<;to
transfer wero to be fulfilled by the Government of
India. who were to grant the requisite foreign currency,
if the goods were imported within the period of validity of the relevant licenoo subject to payment of
customs duty and other taxes normally levia.ble a.t
Indian Ports. This agreement is between the Government of India. and the Government of France, and
the covenants thereof do not purport to and cannot
confer any rights enforceable at the instance of
citizens of Pondicherry or of India.. By s. 3, certain
obligations enforceable age.inst tho French Administration were undertaken by tho Government of India.,
but no obligations thereby enforceable were undertaken by the Indian Government which the petitioners
could enforce. Para.. 5 of Art. 10 falls in the chapter
headed "J udicia.l Matters" and only declares that
a.eta and deeds which constitute rights in conformity
with the French Law shall rE1ta.in the same va.luo after
merger with the Union of India and by Art. 17, the
obligation is unaertakon by the Government of India.
to fulfil the orders placed outside the Establishments
and finalised through the gre.nt of a licence by compe.
tent authorities. But the petitioners had obtained no
license from any competent, authority for importing
or even for indenting the goods.
r96o
1 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
'.
337
It· was urged that the orders S. R. 0. 3314 and
S. R. 0. 3315 issued under the Foreign Jurisdiction
Act should be construed in the light
orts
gency
. of the
d agreement 1mPUniverAsal
between the Government of I ndta an the Governv
ment of France. By S. R. 0. 3314, provision is made Chief c~ntroller
by the Government of India for the administration of of Imports &
the erstwhile French Establishments. By cl. 5 of
Exports
that notification, all laws in force in the French EstaShah].
blishments or any part thereof immediately before the
commencement of the order and not repealed by cl. 6
of the French Establishments (Application of Laws)
Order, 1954, shall continue to remain in force until
repealed or amended by a competent authority. The
law, if any, relating to the import of goods into India
applicable in the French Establishments prior to
November l, 1954, stood expressly repealed by cl. 3
of S. R. 0. 3315 which provided that the enactments
specified in column 3 of the Schedule as in force before
the commencement of this order shall be applied to
and shall be in force in the French Establishments
subject to (a) any amendments to which the enactments ate for the time being generally subject in the
territories to which they extend; (b) the modifications, if any, specified in column 4 of the schedule ;
and (c) the subsequent provisions of the order. By
column 3 of the schedule to this order, the Sea
Customs Act, the Reserve Bank of India Act and the
Imports and Exports Trade (Control) Act were expressly a pp lied to the French Establishments, and under
the provisions of these Acts and notifications issued
thereunder as from November 1, 1954, no person could
without a license in that behalf import goods of the
nature indented by the petitioners. By cl. 6, it was
enacted that " unless otherwise specifically provided
in the schedule, all laws in force in the French Establishments immediately before the commencement of
this order, which correspond to the enactments specified in the schedule, shall cease to have effect, save as
respects things done or omitted to be done before such
commencement". The Sea Customs Act and the ·
Imports and Exports Trade (Control) ·Act were expres- ·
sly made applicable to the French Establishment of
338
SUPRE)IE COURT REPORTS
[1961]
Pondicherry and all corresponding law in that terri.
.
tory ceased to have effect save as respects things done
Universal
•
d
Imports Agency or om1tte
to be done before such commencement.
v.
Clause 6 does not authori:ie the doing of things
Chief Controller expressly forbidden by tho provisions of the Acts made
of Imports 6- applicable by schedule 3 in the Pondicherry Establish.
Exports
ment, and by the use of the expression, "things done
or
omitted to be done". in the clause, to the rights or
Siah J.
legal consequences which may but for the application
of the enactments specified in schedule 3 have flown
from the acts done or omitted to be done the French
law does not continue to apply. Tho clause undoub.
tedly protects French laws which correspond to the
enactments specified in schedule 3 in so far as they
concern things done or omii;ted to be dono before the
commencement of S. R. 0. 3:115. In superseding the
French law in force on the prescribed date, the cl. 6
emphasises that the enactments spec'i!ied in schedule 3
have no retrospective operation, and a.s counterpart
thereof provides that a.II transactions which have been
concluded before November 1, 1954, will continue to
be goV"ered by the French law notwithstanding the
enactment of the Acts specified.
Since the date of the defacto transfer of the .French
Establishments to the Indian Union, all imports of
goods acroBB the customs frnntier a.t Pondicherry were
subject to the provisions of the Sea. Customs Act and
the Imports and Exports Trade (Control) Act; and
goods shipped after November 1, 1954, in pursuance
of indents before that date were not expressly saved
from the operation of tho restrictive provisions of
those Acts. On and from November 1, 1954, the law
if e.ny relating to the import of goods operative in the
'French territory was superseded and the goods having
been brought into the Pondicherry Port after .Novem.
ber 1, 1954, the import was governed by the Sea.
Customs Act and tho Imports and Exports Trade
(Control) Act and not by any law of the French territory. The supersession of the :French laws by the
application of the statutes 30t out in schedule Ill was,
on November 1, 1954, complete, "save a.s respects
things done or omitted to be done". Does the ex pres.
sion " things done " include consequences whi oh may
196o
1 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
339
have ensued iu future but for the supervention of the
merger agreement? Ex facie, by cl. 6, the French law
Universal
is kept alive in respect of" things done or omitted to Itnports Agency
v.
be done ", i.e., things done or omitted to be done in
Chief
Controller
the past; it has not the effect of keeping alive that
&
law in respect of things to be done or omitted to be of ImpoYts
Exports
done in future. All transactions completed after
November 1, 1954, will, on the plain words of cl. 6,
Shah ].
be governed by the statutes made applicable by
virtue of cl. 3 of S. R. 0. 3315.
· Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, has in
terms no application when the court is called upon to
ascertain the effect of supersession of French law by
the application of the specified statutes by cl. 6 of
S. R. 0. 3315. In terms s. 6 of the General Clauses
Act applies to the effect of repeal of enactments of
the Indian legislature, and there is nothing in S. R. O.
3315 which supports the plea that the section applies
as if the French law in operation before merger of the
·French Establishments is to be regarded as a statute
enacted by the Indian legislature. In that premise,
it is difficult to appreciate how the principle of cases
decided by the courts in England on the words of s. 38
of the Interpretation Act, 1889 (52 and 53 Viet. ch. 63)
-which are substantially the same as those used in
s. 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, can lend any
assistance in interpreting the meaning of the expression " things done or omitted to be done " in cl. 6 of
S. R. 0. 3315. By enacting S. R. 0. 3315, the French
law after its supersession has not been expressly kept
alive in respect of any right or privilege acquired or
accrued under the things done under that law; and it
would be an unwarranted incursion into the field of
legislation to attempt to extend the protection of that
law to transactions which have taken place after the
prescribed date relying upon the General Clauses Act.
Nor is the interrelation between the agreement of
purchase with a foreign seller, and the various processes leading to the delivery of goods to a common
c.arrier and the ultimate import of goods sufficient to
include within the expression " things done " used in
H
340
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1961]
cl. 6 of S. R. 0. 3315 consequences of the things done
which ma.y ensue in future. Within the expression
1
Inopo;,~···~;,., 1 "in the course of import of the goods into the territory
v.
of India." used in Art. 286(1) (b) of t.he Constitution,
CA••! Controll" a. series of integrated activities resulting in the taking
of Imports .s. of goods a.cross the customs frontier ma.y be involved.
E•ports
But import a.s defined in the Imports a.nd Exports
Shoh J.
Trade (Control) Act is bringing a. commodity in the
territory of India.; preliminary steps even-if they a.re
closely integrated therewith a.re not included in that
definition. If steps preliminary to import a.re not
included in the concept of import, in dee.ling with the
provisions of the Sea. Customs Act a.nd the Imports
a.nd Exports Trade (Control) Act, it would be difficult
to afford protection of the French la.we expressly
granted by virtue of cl. 6 of S. R. 0. 3315 to such of
the preliminary steps a.s have ta.ken place before the
prescribed date, and to create an exemption in favour
of imports consequential upon those preliminary steps,
which the legislature ha.s d13clined to do.
In my view, therefore, by the use of the expression
"things done or omitted to be done before such commencement" in cl. 6 of S. R. 0. 3315 French la.w
applies to acts and omissions before November 1, 11154,
and not to legal consequences of those acts and omissions ensuing after that date, and hence import of
goods across the customs frontier in the Pondicherry
Port after November 1, 19:54, without a. licence in that
behalf is contrary to the provisions of the Sea Customs
Aot a.nd the Imports and Exports Trade (Control)
Act.
The provisions of the Sea. Customs Act and the Imports and Exports Trade (Control) Act whereby restrictions are imposed upon the import and export of
goods a.re not by themselves unreasonable. If the
petitioners are not entitled to the benefit of cl. 6 of the
Indo-French Agreement, there is no other ground on
which they ca.n eucceBSfully impugn the validity of
the orders imposing duty a.nd penalty.
I am therefore of the view that this petition should
be dismissed with costs.
'96°
u .
1 S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
341
For reasons set o~t in the principal petition, petitions Nos. 124 and 125 of 1957 and 118of1959 should
Universal
also be dismissed with costs.
Imports Agency
BY COURT: In view of t.he majority Judgment,
v.
the petitions are allowed.. The petitioners in a.II the Chief Controller
of Imports~
petitions will have their costs.
Exports
Petitions allowed.
VASANTLAL MAGANBHAI SANJANWALA
v.
THE STATE OF BOMBAY AND OTHERS •.
(AND CONNECTED APPEAL)
(B. P. SINHA, c..J., J. L. KAPUR,
P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR, K. SuBBA RAO and
K. N. WANCHOO, JJ.)
Agricultural Tenancy, Regulation of-Enactment emptn11ering
Government to fix lower rate of maximum rent by notification-If
vitiated by excessive delegation-Notification, validity of-Bombay
Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, r948 (Bom. LXV II of z948),
s. 6(2),
Section 6(1) of the Bombay Tenancy anc;I Agricultural Lands
Act, 1948 (Born. LXVII of 1948), provided that the maximum
rent payable· by a tenant shall not in the case of irrigated land
exceed one-fourth and in the case of any other land exceed one
third of the crop of such land or its value as determined by the
prescribed manner. Section 6(2) of the Act read as follows," The Provincial Government may, by notification in the
Official Gazette, fix a lower rate of the maximum rent payable
by the tenants of lands situate in any particular area or may fix
such rate on any other suitable basis as it thinks fit."
By a notification under that section the Government of Bombay,
in supersession of all other notifications prescribed a rate of
maximum rent which was very much lower than the one previously fixed. The petitioners challenged the vires of the said
section and the validity of the notification under Art. 226 of the
Constitution, but the High Court found against them. The
. question for determination in these appeals was whether s. 6(2)
conferred unguided power 011 the Government and was void by
reason of excessive delegation of legislative power.
Shah ],
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org