BASHIRBHAI MOHAMEDBHAI versus THE STATE OF BOMBAY.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 19 April 1960 | [1960] 3 S.C.R. 554 | 1960 INSC 81
Key facts
- Decided
- 19 April 1960
- Bench
- SYED JAFFER IMAM*, A.K. SARKAR
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 55/1955
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1960] 3 S.C.R. 554
- Neutral citation
- 1960 INSC 81
Text of the judgment
554
1960
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960]
13ASHJlZl3HAl il!OHAillEDBHAl
April 19.
v.
Bashirbltai
Mo!tamedbbai
v.
Stale of Bombay
THE STATE OF BOMBAY.
(JAFER brA"I and A. K. SARKAR, JJ.)
Criminal
Law-Attempt to commit offence-Attempt to
cheat-The complainant whether nzust be deceived-Indian Penal
Code, (XLV of 1860), s. 511.
The offence of attempting to cheat n1ay be co1nmittcd even
though the person attcrr ptcd to be cheated does not believe in
the representations made to him and is not misled by them but
only feigned belief in order to trap the offender.
Where misrepresentations had been made and money obtained from the persons sought to be cheated by the misrepresentations, there is an atten1pt to cheat and not increly a preparation
for con1mitting that offence.
CRIMJ:->M. APPELLATE .Jt'RISDtCTJO:->:
Criminal
Appeal No. 55 of 1955.
Appeal by special leave [rom the judgment and
orcler dated August 26, l 967, of the 13ombay High
Court in Criminal Appeal No. 1208 of l 955, arising
out of the judgment and order dated March 81, I 'l:)5,
of the Sessions Juclgc,
Sarkar J.
.. .,
13aroda, i1t
Cri1ni11;tl Appeal
No. 13 of 195:).
M. I<. R11mm11111!11i and ]. 13. Dar/aclwnjl, for the
appellant.
R. Gr111af1_athy Tyer and R. f-1. Dhe/)(/r, for the respondent.
1%0. April l!J. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
SARKAR, J.-The appellant and two others were
convicted by a Magistrate under s. 420 read with
ss. !i l 1 and ~4 of the I nclian Penal Code and each "·as
sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for 12 months and
a fine of Rs. -'iOO and in default: of payment, a further
period of imprisonrnent for four months. On appeal
the accused persons were acyuittecl by a Sessions Judge.
The State then appealed to the High Court at Bombay
and the High Court set aside the order of acquittal and
restored the order passed by the learned Magistrate.
Accused No. I alone has appealed against the order of
the High Court to tbis Court.
The three accused persons approached one Rmnanlal and the third accused tokl Ramanlal that accused
.
-
3 S.C.R.
•
..
'!'.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
555
Nos. 1 and 2 were proficient in duplicating currency
notes and they were prepared to do it for Ramanal
who should take advantage of the offer. The third
accused then asked Ramanlal to think over the matter
and promised to come again. Ramanlal later men-,
tionecl this matter to his friend Champaklal, the complainant, and the two decided to trap the accused
persons disbelieving their (professed) power to duplicate notes. The third accused again came as
promised and met Ramanlal and Champaklal. Champakbl promised to find currency notes for Rs .. 20,000
for duplicating and a elate was fixed when it was lo be
clone. Thereafter Ramanlal and Champaklal informed
the police .. The police hid themselves -in the house of
Ramanlal where it had been fixed with the accused that
the duplicating would be done.
The three accused
arrived duly. The second accu~ed spread bottles, blank
papers, etc., on a carpet and the first ,accused, the appellant, asked Champaklal to produce the currencv
notes. Champaklal who was carrying a bag supposed
to contain the promised currency notes worth
Rs. :20,000, took out two currency notes of Rs. 100
each from the bag and gave them to the appellant.
As soon as the appellant had taken the money,
Champaklal gave the pre-arranged signal and the
police came into the room and arrested all the accused
persons. They were thereafter prosecuted for the
offence of an attempt to cheat upon a complaint lodged
by Cbampaklal with the result already mentioned.
Three points were argued by the learned advocate
for the appellant. First, it was said that the charge
was for an attempt to cheat Champaklal but there was
no evidence to show that any representation had
been made by anyone to Champaklal.
The Courts
below howewr found that such a representation had
been made and we think that the finding is clearly
,;upported by the evidence on record.
The next point taken was that there had been no
attempt to commit the offence of cheating but only a
prep<tration to commit that offence which was not
punishable. It seems to us clear that an attempt to
commit the offence had actually been made. A false
representation had been made, and a stim of Rs. 200
1960
Bashirbhai
Mohamedbhai
v.
State nf BnmhqY,
Sar/.:ar J.
556
1960
Bn1liirbkai
lvluhnmedbl1ai
v.
Stnlt nf Bombny
Sarkqr .J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960]
had been obtained from Champaklal. These clearly
arc acts done towards the commission of the offence
within the meaning of s. 511 of the Indian Penal
Code. In fact t:hc making of the false representation
is one of the ingredients for an offence of cheating
under s. 420 of the Indian Penal Code. So also the
delivery of property is another of such ingredients.
Both these ingredients took place in this case and the
accused brought them about. Therefore it cannot be
said that: the accused had only made a preparation
and not an attempt to commit the offence.
The last point argued was that there was no attempt
to cheat because the complainant had not been
deceived. It is true that the' complainant had not
been taken in. He had never believed that the accused
could actually duplicate currency notes. He feigned
belief only in order to trap the accused. That however clearly makes no difference so far as an attempt to
cheat is concerned. The accused had attempted to
cheat the complainant. That they had failed in their
attempt is irrelevant in considering whether they had
committed the offence of attempting to cheat. This
view of the matter has been accepted in the High
Courts uniformally. In the Government of Brngal v.
Umesh Ch11nrle1· Mitter(') it was observed that "A man
may attempt to cheat, although the person he attempts
to cheat is forewarned, and is therefore not cheated.''
This is clearly the right view.
This appeal is entirely without merit and it ts
cl ism issed.
A jJpenl dismissed.
(1) T.L.R. 16 Ced. 310, 316.
'
..
.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org