ANANT CHINTAMAN LAGU versus THE STATE OF BOMBAY
Supreme Court of India | Decided 14 December 1959 | [1960] 2 S.C.R. 460 | 1959 INSC 161
Key facts
- Decided
- 14 December 1959
- Bench
- S.K. DAS*, A.K. SARKAR, M. HIDAYATULLAH
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 73/1959
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1960] 2 S.C.R. 460
- Neutral citation
- 1959 INSC 161
Text of the judgment
,
,,
. . .....;.' ,
,,
. ·~. -
/
-"·---~r
,'
,,
z959
460'
...
, SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2)]
ANANT CHINTAMAN LAGU
v.
Decem/;er r4
THE STATE OF BOMBAY
~ (S. ·K. DAs,' A. K. SARKAR and M. liIDAYATULLAH, JJ.)
Criminal Law-Murder by poisoning-Circumstantial evidence
-Poison not detecteiJ,in body of deceased-Conduct of accused, both
before and aft_er-Conviction for murder.
At the trial of a person for murder by alleged poisoning, the
fact of death by poisoning is provable by circumstantial evidence,
notwithstanding that the autopsy as well as the chemical analysis
fail to disclose any poison; though the cause of death may not
appear to be established by direct evidence, the medical evidence
of experts and the circumstances of the case may be sufficient to
infer that the death must be the result of the administration to
the victim of some nnrecognised poison or drug which acts as a
poison, and a conviction can be rested on circumstantial evidence
provided that it is so decisive ,that the court can unhesitatingly
hold that the death was not a natural one.
Per S. K. Das and !\I. Hidayatullah, JJ -Where the evidence,
showed that the appellant who was the medical adviser of the
deceased, deliberately set about·first to ingrath1te himself in the
good opinions of his patient and becoming her confidant, found
out all about her affairs and gradually began managing her affairs,
that all the time he was planning to get at her property and had
forged her signature on a dividend warrant and had, obtained
undated cheque from her and then under the guise of helping
her to have a consultation with a specialist in Bombay took hei;
in a train,, and then brought the patient unconscious to a hospital
bereft of all property with which she had started from home and
gave a wrong name to cover her identity and wrong history of
her ailments, that after her death he abandoned the body to be
dealt with by the hospital as an unclaimed body, spread the story
, that she was alive and made use of the situation to misappropriate
all her properties, and that he tried by all means to avoid postmortem examination
and . when questioned gave
false and
conflicting statements, held that if the deceased died in circum. stances which prima facie admit of either disease or homicide by
poisoning,one must look at the conduct of the appellant both
, before and after the death of the deceased, that the corpus delicti
could be held to be proved by a number of facts which render
the commission of the crime certain, and that the medical
evidence in the case and the conduct of the appellant unerringly
pointed to th,e conclusion that the death of the deceased was the
result of the administration of some unrecognised poison or drug
which would act as a poison and that the ,appellant was the
person who administered it.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
461
Per Sarkar, J.-If it could be established in this case that
'959.
the deceased had died an unnatural death, the,conclusion would
Ansnl
be inevitable that unnatural death had been ·brought about by
poison, but the circumstances were not such that from them the Chintaman Lagu
v.
onlv reasonable conclusion to be dra\vn \vas that the deceased
The State of
died an unnatural death. Held, that the prosecution had failed
Bombay
to prm·e the guilt of the appellant.
Regina v. Onufrejczyk, [1955] I Q.B. 388,_ The King v. Horry,
[1952] N.Z.L. III, Mary Ann Nash's case, (r9n) 6 Cr. App. R. 225
an~ Donna/l's case, (r8r7) 2 C.&K. 308n, considered and relied on.
CRDIINAL APPELLATE J URISDICTIO::<r: Criminal.
Appeal No. 73of1~59.
Appeal by special leave from the judgment and
order dated January 16/20th, 1959, of the Bombay
High Court in Confirmation case No. 25 of 1958 with
Criminal Appeal No. 1372of1958, arising out of the
judgment and order dated October 27, l!J58, of the
Sessions Judge, Poona, in Sessions Case No. 52 of le58.
A. S. R .. Ghari,
N. Andley, J. B. Dadachanji. and
Rameshwar Nath, for the appellant.
H. N. Seeri-ai, Advocate-General for the State ·of
Bombay, Porus A ..JJJehta and R.H. Dhebar, for· the
respondent.
1959. December 14. The Judgment of S. K. Das
and Hidayatullah, JJ., was delivered by Hidayatullah, J. Sarkar; J., delivered a separate Judgment.
HIDAYATULLAII J.-This appeal by special leave is Hidaya1u11aA J.
against the judgment of the Bombay High Court
[J.C. Shah, J. (now of the Supreme Court) and V. S.
Desai, J.] by which it maintained the_ conviction of
the appellant, Lagu, under s. 302 of the Indian Penal
Code, and confirmed the sentence of death passed on
him by Shri V. A. Naik (now Naik, J.) Sessions Judge,
Poona.
·
The appellant was tried for the murder of one
taxmibai Karvc, and the charge held proved against
him was that on or about the night between· Novem·
her 12 and 13, 1956, either at Poona or in the course
of a railway journey between Poona and Bombay, he
administered to the said Laxmibai Karve, some unrecognised poison or drug which would act as a poison;
s:
•
I
r..
'
59
462
z959
SUPREME .COURT REPORTS
[l960(2)]
with the intention of causing her death and which did
cause
her death.
Anant
Laxmibai Karve was a resident of Poona where she
Chintaman Lagu
v.
lived at 93-95, Shukrawar Peth. Before her marriage
The State of
she was known as Indumati, Indutai or Indu Ponkshe.
Bombay
In the year 1922, she married Anant Ramachandra
Karve,
a widower with a son by name, Vishnu. On
Hidayatullah ].
her marriage, as is the custom, she was named
Laxmibai by the family of her husband and was
known as Laxmibai Karve. She was also known as
Mai or Mai Karve. From Laxmibai there were born
two sons, Ramachandra (P.W. 1) and Purshottam
alias Arvind, who died in 1954.
Anant Ramachandra Karve was a moderately rich
man, who had been successful in business. He died in
1945 of pleurisy. He was attended till his death by
the appellant and his brother, B. C. Lagu, both of
whom are doctors. Anant Ramachandra Karve left a
will dated February 28, 1944. Prior to the execution
of the will, he had gifted Rs. 30,000 to his son, Vishnu,
to set him up in business. By his will he gave
the house No. 93-95, Shukrawar. Peth, Poona to
Ramachandra with a right of residence in at least
three rooms to his widow, Laxmibai and a further
right to her to receive Rs. 50 per month from the rent
of the house. He assigned an insurance policy of
Rs. 5,000 in her favour. The business was left to
Ramachandra. The cash deposits in Bank, Post
Office and with other persons together with the right
to recover loans from debtors in the Bhor State were
given to Purushottam alias Arvind. Certain bequests
of lands and debentures were made to Vishnu's children. Laxmibai was also declared owner of all her
ornaments of about 60 tolas of gold and nose-ring and
pearl bangles which were described in the will.
In addition to what she inherited from her husband,
Laxmibai inherited about Rs. 25,000 invested in shares
from her mother, Girjabai, and another 60 tolas of
gold ornaments. In January 1954, Purushottam
alias Arvind died at Poona. By Purushottam's death
Laxmibai also inherited all the property held by him.
S.C.R.
T
•
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
463
I959
Thus,. at the time of her death, Laxmibai was
possessed of about 560 shares . in diverse Electric
Anant.
Companies, debentures in South Madras Electric Chintaman Lagw
Supply Corporation and Mettur Chemical and Indusv.
, trial Corporation, a sum of Rs. 7,882-15-0 31t the Bank Ths Slate of
Boinbay
of Maharashtra, a sum of Rs. 35,000 in deposit with
one Vasudeo Sadashiv Joshi, gold and pearl ornaments Hidayatullah ].
and sundry movables like clothes, house hold furniture, radio etc.
In the year 1946, Ramachandra, the elder son,
started living separately. . There were differences ·between the mother and son. The latter had suffered a
loss in the business and had mortgaged the house with
one Shinde, who filed a suit, and obtained a decree but
Vishnu filed a suit for partition claiming that his one,
third share was not affected. Before this, Ramacharidra
had closed his business in 1951, and joined the military.
He was posted at different places, but in spite of their .
differences, mother and son used to correspond with
each other. In May, 1956, Laxmibai arranged and
performed his marriage, arid he went away in June,
1956.
Laxmibai had 8ontracted tuberculosis after the birth
of Purushottam. That was about twenty years before
her death. The lesion, however, healed and till 1946
her health was not bad. From 1946 she suffered from
diabetes. In 1948 she was operated for hysterectomy,
and before her operation, she was getting hysterical
fits. On June 15, 1950, she was examined by Dr. R. V.
Sathe, who prescribed some treatment. In July, 1950,
she was admitted in the Wanless Tuberculosis Sanatorium for pulmonary affection, and she Wai? treated
till November 15, 1950. ·Two stages of thoracoplasty
operations were performed, but she left, though a
third stage of operation was advised. In the operations, her leftside first rib and portions of 2nd to 6th'
ribs were removed. · Laxmibai was, however, treated
with medicines, and the focus, it appears, was under
·
control.
We now come to the events immediately preceding
her death. Laxmibai had, ·through the appellant,
taken an appointment from Dr. Sathe 9f Bombay for·
..
464
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960 (2))
a consultation about her health, for November 13,
1956, at 3-30 p. m. It was to attend this appointment
Anant·
that
she left Poona in the company of the appellant
Chintaman Lagu
by
Passenger
train on the night of November 12, 1956,
v.
The State of
for Bombay. The train arrived at Victoria Terminus
Bombay
Station at 5-10 a. m. thirty-five minutes late. It is an
admitted
fact that Laxmibai was then deeply unHidayatullah].
concious and was carried on a stretcher by the appellant to a taxi and later to the G. T. Hospital, where
she was entered as an in-door patient at 5-45 a. m. She
never regained consciousness and died at 11-30 a. m.
Her body remained at the G. T. Hospital till the evening
of the 14th, when it was sent to the J. ,T. Hospital
morgue for preservation. Later, it was to be handed
over under the orders of the Coroner to the Grant
Medical College for the use of Medical Students. It
was noticed there that she had a suspicious ligature
mark on the neck, and the body was subjected to
post-mortem examination and the viscera to chemical
analysis and then the body was disposed of. Both
the autopsy as well as the chemical analysis failed to
disclose any poison and the mark on the neck was
"
found to be post-mortem.
The appellant was the medical attendant and friend
of the family. He and his brother (also a. medical
practitioner) attended on Anant Ramachandra Karve
tlll his death. The appellant also treated Pnrshottam
alias Arvind for two days prior to his death on January 18, 1954. He was also the medical attendant of
Laxmibai and generally managed her affairs. In
1955, he started living in the main room of the suite
occupied by Laxmibai, and if Ramachandra · is to be
believed, the reason for the quarrel between Laxmibai
and himself was the influence which the appellant
exercised over the mother to the disadvantage of the
son. However that be, it is quite clear that the son
left Poona in Jnne, 1956, and did not see his mother
alive again.
The death of Laxmibai was not known to the relatives or friends. The appellant also did not disclose
this fact to any one. On the other hand, he kept it a
close secret. Soon afterwards, people began receiving
r959
'
•
-
j
S.C.R..
-..
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
465
-r959
mysterious letters purporting to be from Laxmibai,
stating that she had gone on pilgrimage, that she
Anant
_ did not intend to return and that none should try Clrintaman
Lagu
to find her whereabouts. She advised them to comv.
municate with her through the newspaper "Sakal". The State of
Bombay
Laxmibai also exhorted all persons to forget her, as
she had married one-Joshi and had settled at Rathodi,
near Jaipur in Rajasthan. People who went to her H idayatullah ] •
rooms at first found them locked, but soon the doors
were open and the meveable pl'operty was found to
have been removed. Through these mysterious
letters Laxmibai informed all concerned that she had
herself removed these articles secretly and that none
was to be blamed or suspected. It is the prosecution
case that these letters were forgeries, and that the
appellant misappropriated the properties ofLaxmibai,
including her shares, bank deposits etc.
The appellant has admi.tted his entire conduc~ after
the death of Laxmibai, by which he managed to get
hold of her property. His explan~tion was that he
would have given the proceeds to some charitable institution according t9 her wishes adding some money of
his own to round off the figure. He led no evidence to
prove that Laxmibai before she left Poona or at any
time gave such instructions to him in the matter.
Meanwhile, the continued disappearance of Laxmibai was causing uneasiness to her friends and relat- ·
ives. On December 31, 1957, G. D. Bhave (P. W. 8)
addressed a complaint to the Chief Minister, Bombay.
Similarly, Dr. G. N. Datar (P. W. 5) also addressed a
letter to the Chief Minister, Bombay on February 16,
1958, and in both these petitions, doubts were expressed. Ramachandra too made a report, and in_ consequence of a preliminary investigation, the appellant
was arrested on March 12, 1958. He was subsequently
tried and convicted by the Sessions Judge, Poona.
His appeal was also dismissed, and the certificate
of fitness having been refused, he obtained special
leave from this Court and filed this appeal.
The appellant's contention in this appeal is that
the prosecution' has not succeeded in proving that
466
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960 (2))
Laxmibai was poisoned at all, or that there was any
poison
administered to her which would evade detecAnant
tion,
yet
cause death in the manner it actually took
Chint'aman Lagu
place. The appellant contends also that his conduct
v.
before the death of Laxmibai was bona fide and correct,
The State of
Bombay
that no inference of guilt can be drawn from all the
circumstances of this case, and that his subsequent
Hidayatullah ].
conduct, though suggestive of greed, was not proof of
his guilt on the charge of murder.
The conviction of the appellant rests 01;1 circumstantial evidence, and his guilt has been inferred from
medical evidence regarding the death of Laxmibai
and his conduct. The two Courts below have held
that the total evidence in this case unerringly points
to the commission of the crime charged and every
reasonable hypothesis compatible with the innocence
of the appellant has been successfully repelled. A
criminal trial, of course, is not an enquiry into the
conduct of an accused for any purpose other than to
determine whether .he is guilty of the offence charged.
In this connection, that piece of conduct can be held
to be incriminatory which has no, reasonable explanation except on the hypothesis that he is guilty.
Conduct which destroys the presumption of innocence
can alone be considered as material. The con ten tion
of the appellant, briefly, is that the medical evidence
is inconclusive, and that his conduct is explainable on
hypotheses other than his guilt.
Ordinarily, it is not the practice of this Court to
re-examine the findings of fact reached by the High
Court particularly in a case where there is concurrence
of opinion between the two Courts below. But the
case against the appellant is entirely based on circumstantial evidence, and there is no direct evidence that
he administered a poison, and no poison has, in fact
been detected by the doctor, who performed the postmortem examination, or by the Chemical Analyser.
The inference of guilt having been drawn on an
examination of a mass of evidence during which
subsidiary findings were given by the two Courts
below, we have felt it necessary, in view of the extraordinary nature of this case, to satisfy ourselves
r959
•
•
-
S.C.R.
•
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
467
I959
whether each conclusion on the separate aspects of
the case, is supported by evidence and is just and
Anant
·proper. Ordinarily, this Court is not required to enter Chintaman Lagu
into an elaborate examination of the evidence, but we
v.
have depR.rted from this rule in this particular case, The State of
Bombay
in view of the variety of arguments that were addressed to us and the evidence of conduct which the Hidayatullah ].
appellant has sought to explain away on hypotheses
suggesting innocence. These arguments, as we have
stated in brief, covered both the factual as well as the
medical aspects of the case, and have necessitated a
close examination of the evidence once again, so that
we may be in a position to say what are the facts
found, on which our decision is rested.
That Laxmibai died within six hours of her admission in the G. T. Hospital is not questioned. Her
body was identified by persons who knew her well from
her photograph taken at the J.J. Hospital on November 19, 1956. In view of the contention of the
appellant that she died of disease and/or wrong treatment, we have to determine first what was the state
of her health before she went on the ill-fated journey,
This enquiry takes us to the medical papers maintain- .
ed at the institutions where she was treated in the
past, the evidence of some of the doctors who dealt
with her case, of the observation of witnesses who
could depose to her outward state of health immediately before her departure, and lastly, the case papers
maintained by the appellant as a medical adviser.
The earliest record of Laxmibai's health is furnished by Dr. K. C. Gharpure (P. W. 17), who treated
her in 1948. According to Dr. Gharpure, she entered
his Nursing Home on April 6, 1948, and stayed
there till April 24, 1948. Laxmibai was then suffering
from Menorrhagia and Metrorrhagia for about six
years. In 1946 there was an operation for dilatation
and also curettage. She had Diabetes from 1945 and
hysterical fits since · 1939. On admission in Dr.
Gharpure's Nursing Home, her blood pressure was
found ti;> be 140/80 and urine showed sugar + +,
albumin nil. She was kept in the hospital and probably treated, and on the 11th, when a sub-total
468
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
I
[1960(2)~
hysterectomy was performed, she had blood pressure
110/75 and sugar traces (albumin nil) before the
Anant
operation.
According to Dr. Gharpure, the operation
Chintaman Lagu
not
for
hysterical fits, and along with hystewas
v.
The Stale of
rectomy the right ovary was cysticpunctured and
Bombay
the appendix was also removed. A certificate was
issued by Dr. Gharpure (Ex. 121), in which the same
Hidayatullah ].
history is given.
Laxmibai was next examined by Dr. Ramachandra
Sathe (P.W.25) on June 15, 1950. He deposed from
the case file which he had maintained about her
complaints. A copy of the case papers shows that
she was introduced to him by the appellant. At that
- time, her w.eight was 120 lbs. and her blood pressure,
140/90. Dr. Sathe noticed that diabetes had existed
for fq,ur years, and that she was being given insulin for
8 months prior to his examination. He also noticed
hysterectomy scar, and that she had a tubercular
lesion on the left apex 20 years ago. According to
the statement of the patient, she had trouble - with
tuberculosis from May 1949, and her teeth were
extracted on account of pyorrhoea. She was getting
intermittent temperature from September 1949, and
was receiving streptomycin and PAS irregularly. She
was then suffering from low temperature, slight cough
and expectoration. On examination, the doctor found
that there was infiltration in the left apex but no
other septic focus was found. The evidence does
not show the treatment which was given, and the
doctor merely stated that he must have recommended
a line of treatment to the patient, though he had no
record of it.
On July 13, 1950, Laxmibai entered the Wanlesswadi
T. B. Sanatorium, and stayed there till November 15,
1950. Her condition is noted in two certificates which
were issued by the Sanatorium and proved by Dr.
Fletcher (P. W. 16), the Medical Superintendent. In
describing the previous history of the patient, the case
papers showed that she had a history of Pott's disease
(T. B. of the spine) 20 years before. She had diabetes
for five years and history of hysterectomy operation
two years before. It was also noted that she had
I959
•
'
-
S.C.R.
____,.
-<·
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
4S9
z959
T. B. of the lungs 15 years back, but had kept well
for 14 years and a new attack began in or about 1949.
Anant
The certificate describes the treatment given to her in Chintaman Lagu
v.
these words :
State of
"Patient was admitted on 13th July, 1950. The
Bombay
X-Ray on admission showed extensive filtration on
the left side with a large cavity in the upper zone; Hidayatullah ].
the right side was within normal limits. She h'ad
diabetes with high blood sugar which was controlled
by insulin. Two stages of thoracoplasty operations
on the left side were done and there was good clear- •
ing of disease but there was a small residual cavity
seen and the third stage operation was advised.
The patient is leaving at her own request against
medical advice. Her sputum is positive."
From the above, it appears that Laxmibai's general
complaints were menstrual irregularities corrected by
hysterectomy, tuberculosis of the lungs controlled to
a large extent by thoracoplasty and medicines and
diabetes for which she was receiving treatment. In
the later case papers, there is no mention of hysterical
fits, and it seems that she had overcome that trouble
after the performance of hysterectomy and the cysticpuncture of the ovary, for there is no evidence of a
recurrence after 1948. Diabetes was, however, present,
and must have continued till her death.
Next, we come to the evidence of some witnesses
who saw her immediately prior to her departure for
Bombay on November 12, 1956. The first witness in
this connection is Ramachandra (P.W. 1), son of
Laxmibai. He has given approximately the same
description <'If her many ailments and the treatment
she underwent. He last saw her in June, 1956, when
his marriage was performed. According to him, the
general condition of his mother was rather weak, but
before that, her condition· had not occasioned him any
concern and he had not noticed anything so radically
wrong with her as to prompt him to ask her about
her ailments. When' he last saw his mother in June
1956, he found her in good health. Dr. Madhav
Domadhar Bhave (P.W. 9), who knew Laxmibai
60
470
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(2)]
r959
intimately stated that he saw her last in the month of
October, 1956, and that the condition of her health
Anant
Chintaman Lagu was good. No question was asked from him in crossexamination at all. His brother, G.D. Bhave, (P.W. 8),
v.
The State of
who is a landlord, had gone to Laxmibai's house on
Bombay
November 8, 1956, and met her in the presence of the
Laxmibai had then told him that she was
appellant.
Hidayatullah ]·
going to Bombay with the appellant to consult
Dr. Sathe in connection with her health. She had also
stated that she would be returning in four or five days.
, According to the witness, she was in good health, and
was moving about and doing her own work. The
next witness is Champutai Vinayak Gokhale (P.W. ll),
who met Laxmibai on November 10 or 11, 1956.
Champutai is a well-educated lady. She is a B.Sc. of
the Bombay University and an M.A. of Columbia
(U.S.A.) University. She said that she had gone to
Laxmibai's house to invite her for the birthday party
of her son, which was to take place on November 13,
1956. She found Laxmibai in good· state of health,
and Laxmibai promised that though she would be
going to Bombay, she would return soon enough to
join the party. ~
Similarly, Viswanath Janardhan Karandikar,
pleader of Poona, met Laxmibai on November 10 orll,
1956. Laxmibai had herself gone in the afternoon
to him to ask him whether her presence was necessary
in Poona in connection with the suit filed by Vishnu,
to which we have referred earlier. The witness stated
that Laxmibai was in good state of health at that
time, and that he informed her that he did not propose
to examine her as a witness. She was again seen by
Dattatreya Vishnu Virkar (P.W. 6) on the night of
November 12, 1956, an hour before she left her house
for Bombay. Virkar, who is a Graduate in Electrical
Mechanics and in Government service, was a tenant
living in the same house. Laxmibai, according to the
will of her husband, was entitled to Rs. 50 out of the
rents from tenants. She went to Virkar's Block at
8 p.m.. and told him that she was going to Bombay
to consult a doctor in the company of the appellant
and needed money. Virkar $&Ve her Rs. 50 and
'
-
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
471
I959
Laxmibai went back to her Block saying that she
would give a receipt. Later, she brought the receipt
Anant
to Virkar seated at his meals, asked him not to get up Chintaman Lagu
and left the receipt in his room. The receipt signed
v.
by Laxmibai is Ex. 70, and is dated November· 12, The .State of
Bombay
1956. Shantabai (P.W. 14), a servant of Laxmibai,
was deaf and dumb, and her evidence was interpreted Hidayatullah ].
with the help of Martand Ramachandra Jamdar
(P.W. 13), the Principal of a Deaf and Mute School.
It appears that Shantabai had studied Marathi, and
was able to answer questions written on a piece of
paper, replies to which questions she wrote in her own
hand. Some of the questions were not properly
answered by Shantabai, but she stated by pantomime
that on the day on which she left, the appellant had
given two injections to Laxmibai. The learned Sessions
Judge made a note to the following effect :
"In the morning the accused gave Laxmibai one
injection and in the evening he gave the second one.
(The signs were so clear that I myself gathered the
. meaning and the interpreter was not asked to
interpret the signs). "
Next, Laxmibai was seen by Pramilabai Sapre
(P.W. 12) at 8 p.m. on November 12, 1956. Laxmibai
had told the witness that she was going to Bombay to
consult a doctor and Laxmibai again passed her door
at 9-15 p.m., when the witness was at her meals.
Though Laxmibai told her not to disturb herself, the
witness did get up and saw her. The witness stated
that Laxmibai did not suffer from T. B. after the
operation but was suffering from diabetes, and that
she sometimes used to give Laxmibai her injections of
insulin but only till 1953. The last witness on the
state of Laxmibai's he[!,lth is K. L. Patil (P. W. 60),
who saw Laxmibai immediately before her departure
for the station. He saw her standing at the Par in
front of her house with a small bag ancl a small bedding. He then saw the appellant arriving there, and
Laxmibai presumably left in a rickshaw or a tonga,
because there was a staQd for these vehicles in the
neighbourhood. All this evidence was not questioned
•
....
except to point out-that Dr. Datar in his petition to
•
'
the Chief Minister had stated that Laxmibai was a
1
472
.SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960 (2))
fi·ank case of tuberculosis of both lungs and an invalid
(Ex. 68). But Dr. Datar explained that he had so
stated.there, because it was being "circulated" that
1
v.
she had gone on a long pilgrimage alone, and that it
The State of
waEI most improbable. Indeed, Dr. Datar said that
Bombay
Laxmibai was well enough to do all her work and even
cooked
for herself.
Hidayatullah J.
From this mass of evidence given by persons from
different walks of life and most of them well-placed, it
is clear enough that laxmibai was not in such a state
of health that she would have collapsed in the traiu,
unless something very unusual took place. She was
not iu the moribund state in which she undoubtedly
was, when she reached the hospital. Her general
health, though not exactly good, had not deteriorated
so radically as to prevent her from attending to her
normal avocations. She appeared to have been quite
busy prior to her departure arranging for this matter
and that, and she did not rely upon other persons'
help but personally attended to all that she desired.
Right up to 9-15 or so in the night, she was sufficiently
strong and healthy to go about her' affairs, and indeed,
she.must have boarded the train also in a fit state of
health, because there is nothing to show that she was
carried to the compartment in a state of collapse or
unconsciousness.
We have stated earlier that the appellant who was
presumably treating her for her ailments had maintained case papers to show what treatment he was
giving her from time to time. These case papers are
Ex. 305, and commence on February 27, 1956. The
medicines that have been shown as prescribed in these
case papers show treatment for diabetes, general
debility, tuberculosis, rheumatism and indigestion.
Much reliance cannot, however, be placed upon this
dqcument, because these case papers significantly
enough stop 0.11November12, 1956, and continue again
from February 13, 1957, whea Laxmibai was no more.
There are four entries of treatment given to Laxmibai
between February 13 and ~'ebruary 28, 1957, when
Laxmibai had . already died and her body had undergone. post-mortem examination and been cremated.
,
'959
Ch'nt:;;:' Lagu
-
I
\.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
473
The extent to which her treatment, if any, went in
r959
the period covered by the case papers may or may not
be truly described by the appellant in these papers, but Ch' Anant L
we are definitely of the opinion that the entries there intam:_n agu
cannot be read without suspicion, in view of the extra- The State of
ordinary fact described by us here. It appears, howBombay
ever, that the last insulin injection was given to her
on September 27, 1956, though the appellant stated in H'.dayatullah f.
his examination as accused in the case that she was
put on Nadisan tablets for diabetes. The a·ppellant
was questioned by the Sessions Judge as to the State of
her health, and he stated that Laxmibai on the day she
left for Bombay had a temperature of 100 degrees and
was suffering from laryngitis, pharyngitis, and complained of pain in the ear. What relevance this has,
we shall point out subsequently when we deal with the
medical evidence and the conclusions of the doctors
about it.
The next question which falls for consideration is
whether the appellant and Laxmibai travelled in the
same compartment on the train. The tain left Poona
at 10 p.m., and it is obvious enough that it was a
comparatively slow and inconvenient train. We have
no evidence· in the case as to whether the appellant
travelled with Laxmibai in the same compartment, but
both the Courts below have found from the probabilities of the case that he did. The best person to tell
us about this journey is necessarily the appellant, and
reference may now be made to what he stated in regard
to this journey. The appellant had arranged for the
examination of.Laxmibai by Dr. Sathe at Bombay. He
was the family physician and also a_friend. ~axniibai ·
was an elderly lady and the appellant was for some
time previous to this journey living in the main ·room
of her block. There would be nothing to prevent the
appellant from travelling in the same compartment
with his patient, who might need his a.ttention during
the journey. The appellant denied in Court that he
had travelled .in the same compartment, but his statements on this part of tho events have not been quite
consistent. After Laxmibai died and the question
arose about the disposal of her body, the police a~
474
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2)]
Poona were asked to contact the appellant to get some
about her. On November 16, 1956, before
information
Anant
any
investigation
into an offence of any kind was
Chintaman Lagu
started, the appellant was questioned by the police,
v.
The State of
and he gave a written statement in Ex. 365. He stated
Bombay
there as follows :
"I, Anant Chintaman Lagu, occupation Medical
Hidayatullah].
practitioner, age 40 years, residing at H. No. 431/5,
Shukrawar and dispensary at H. No. 20, Shukrawar
Peth, Poona 2, on being questioned, state that on
the night of 12th November, 1956, I left Poona for
Bombay by the train which leaves Poona at 10 p.m.
I reached Victoria Terminus at 5-15 a.m. on 13th
November, 1956. In my compartment I had a talk
with a woman as also with other passengers. On
getting accomodation in the train almost all of us
began to doze and at about 12 p.m. we slept. As
Byculla came, we started preparations for getting
down. At that time one woman was found fast
asleep. From other passengers I came to know that
her name was Indumati Pause, about 36 years old
and she had a brother serving in Calcutta. Other
passengers got down at V. T. The woman, however,
did not awake. I, therefore, looked at her keenly
and found that she was· senseless. Being myself a
doctor, I thought it my duty to take her to the
hospital. I, therefore, took her to the G.T. Hospital
in a taxi. I know that that hospital was near. As
I had taken the said woman to the hospital, the
C.M.O, took my address. I have no more information about the woman. She is not my relation and
I am not in any way responsible for her."
It will appear from this that he was travelling in the
same compartment as Laxmibai, though for reasons of
his own he did not care to admit that he was taking
her to Bombay. Similarly, in the hospital when he
was questioned about the patient he had brought for
admission; he stated to Dr. Ugale (P. W.18), Casualty
Medical Officer, that the lady had suddenly become
unconscious in ·the train. This fact was no.ted by
Dr. Ugale in the bed-head ticket, and Dr. Ugale has
stated on oath that the information was supplied by
r959
...
'
-
475
SUPREME COURT REPORTS·
•
the appellant himself. To Dr. Miss Aneeja, who was
r959
the House Physician on the morning of November 13,
A .
1
the appellant also stated the same thing. Dr. Miss Chinta;;: Lagu
Aneeja had also made a separate note of this, and
v.
stated that the information was given by the appel- . The State of
lant. In view of these statements made by the
Bombay
appellant at a time when he was not required to face a Hidayatullah ].
charge, we think that his present statement in Court
that he travelled in a separate compartment cannot be
,
accepted.
The train halted at various stations en route; and
evidence was led in the case, of the Guard, K. Shamanna (P. W. 37), who deposed from his memo book
(Ex. 214). This train made 26 halts en route before it
arrived at V. T. Statiou. Some of these halts were of
as many as 20 minutes. It is difficult to think that
the appellant would not have known till he arrived at
Victoria Terminus that his patient was unconscious,
and the fact that he mentioned that she became
suddenly unconscious shows that he knew the exact
manner of the onset. Without, however; speculating
as to what had actually happened, it is quite clear to
us that Laxmibai was in the same compartment as the
appellant, a fact which was not denied by the learned
counsel in the arguments before us. If we were to
accept what the appellant stated as true, then Laxmibai lost her consciousness sqddenly. It is, however, a
little difficult to accept as true all that the appellant
stated in this behalf, because he told a patent lie to the
police when he was questioned, that he knew nothing
about the woman or who she was, but took her to the
hospital as an act of humanity when he founcf her
unconscious. There is nothing to show beyond this
statement to the police in Ex. 365 that there were
other passengers in the compartment; but ifthere had
been, the attention of these passengers would have
bel(n drawn to the condition of Laxmibai, and some
one would have advised the calling of the Guard or the
railway authorities at one of these stations at which
the train halted. The circumstances of the case, there. fore, point to the appellant and Laxmibai being in
the compartment together1 and the :prerondera.nce of
S.C.R.
•
J
476
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
•
[1960(2)]
probabilities is that the compartment was not occupied
by any other person.
Anant
We shall leave out from consideration for the present
Chintaman Lagu
the circumstances under which Laxmibai was admitted
v.
in the G. T. Hospital and the treatment given to her.
The State of
Bombay
We shall now pass on to her death and what happened
thereafter and the connection of the appellant with
H idayatullah ] .
the circumstances resulting in the disposal of the
dead body. We have already stated that the appellant
was present iu the hospital till her death. We
next·hear of the appellant at Poona. On the afternoon
of November 13, 1956, Dr. Mouskar (P. W. 40), the
Resident Medical Officer of the Hospital, sent a telegram (Ex. 224) to the appellant, and it conveyed to
him the following information:.
"Indumati expired. Arrange removal reply immediately." The telegram was sent at about 2 p.m. The
appellant in reply did not send a telegram, but wrote
an inland letter in which he stated that the name of
the woman admitted by him in the hospital had been
wrongly shown as "Paunshe", and that there was an
extra "u" in it. He also stated that he had informed
her brother at Calcutta about the death, and that the
brother would call at the hospital for the body of his
sister. The name of the brother was shown as Govind
Vaman Deshpande. The letter also stated that the
appellant was writing in connection with the woman
aged 30 to 35 years admitted in the hospital at 6 a.m.
on November 13, 1955, and who had expired the same
day at 11 a.m. The name of the brother in this letter
is fictitious, because Laxmibai had no brother, much
less~ brother in Calcutta and of this name. Thereafter,
the appellant took no further action in the matter
till the police questioned him on the 16th, two days
after he had sent the letter. It seems that the appellant did not expect the police to appear so soon, and
he thought it advisable to deny all knowledge about
the lady he had taken to the hospital by telling the ·
police that he did not know her. The inference drawn
from these two pieces of conduct by the Courts below
is against the appellant, and we also agree. We
have already stated that from then onwards, the
z959
•
•
S.C.R.
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
477
appellant did not care to enquire from the hospital
r959
authorities as to what had happened to his patient's
Anant
dead ~ody, and whether it had been disposed of Chintaman Lagu
or not. He also did not go to Bombay, nor did he
v.
inform Dr. Sathe about the cancellation of the appoint- The State of
ment. In his examination, he, however, stated that
Bombay
he attempted to telephone to Dr. Sathe, but could not Hidayatullahf.
get through, as the instrument was engaged on each
occasion. One expects, however, that he would have
in the ordinary course written a letter of apology to
Dr. Sathe, because he must have been conscious of the
fact that he had kept the Specialist waiting for this
appointment; but he did not. It is said that the
appellant need not have taken this appointment and
could have told a lie to Laxmibai; but the appointment with Dr. Sathe had to be real because if the plan
failed, Laxmibai would have been most surprised why
she was brought to Bombay. With this ends the
phase of events resulting in the death of Laxmibai.
We shall deal with the events in the hospital later, but
we pursue the thread of the appellant's conduct.
Prior to the fateful journey, Laxmibai had passed
two documents to the appellant. They are Exs. 285
and 286. By the first, Laxmibai intimated' the Bank
of Maharashtra, Poona, that she was going to withdraw
in the following week from her Savings Bank account
a sum of money between Rs.1,000 and Rs. 5,000.
The other document was a bearer cheque for Rs. 5,000,
also signed by Laxmibai but written by the appellant.
The appellant presented the first on November 17
after writing the date, November 15, on it and.the
second on November 20, after writing the date, N ovember 19, and received payment. Prior to this, on
November 12, 1956, when Laxmibai was alive and in
Poona he had presented to the Bank of Maharashtra
a dividend warrant for Rs. 2,607-6-0 to Laxmibai's
account writing her signature himself. This was
hardly necessary if he was honest. The signature
deceived the Bank, and it is obvious that he was a
consummate forger even then. Of course, he put
the money into Laxmibai's account, but he had to if
he was to draw it out again on the strength of these
61
•
478
· SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2))
r959
two documents. The question is, can we say that he
was honest on November 12, 1956? The answer is
Ana11t
His dishonest intentions were, therefore,
Chintaman Lagu obvious.
fully matured even before he left Poona. Thereafter,
v.
The State of
the appellant converted all the property of Laxmibai
Bombay
to his own use. He r<Jmoved the movables in her
rooms including the pots and pans, furniture, clothes,
Hidayafollah ].
radio, share scrips and so on, to his own house. He
even went to the length of forging her signature on
securities, transfer deeds, letters to banks and companies, and even induced a lady magistrate to
authenticate the signature of Laxmibai for which he
obtained the services of a woman who, to say the
least, personated Laxmibai. So clever were the many
ruses and so cunning the forgeries that the banks,
companies and indeed, all persons were completely
deceived. It was only once that the bank had occasion
to question the signature of Laxmibai, but the appellant promptly presented another document purporting
to be signed by Laxmibai, which the bank accepted
with somewhat surprising credulity. The long and
short of it is that numerous persons were imposed upon, including those who are normally careful and
suspicious, and the appellant by these means collected
a sum of no less than Rs. 26,000 which he disposed of
in various ways, the chief, among them being the.
opening of a short term deposit account in the name
of his wife and himself and crediting some other
amounts to the joint names of his brother, B. C.
Lagu, and himself. We do not enter into the details
of his many stratagems for two reasons. Firstly
because, all this conduct has been admitted before us
by his counsel, and next because he has received life
imprisonment on charges connected with these frauds.
Suffice it to say that if the appellant were to be found
guilty of the offence, sufficient motive would be found
in his dealings with the property of this unfortunate
widow after her death. If murder there was, it was.to
facilitate the action which he took regarding her
property. If the finding of his guilt be reached, then
his subsequent conduct would be a part of a v:ery deepseated plan beginning almost from the time when he
•
•
-
-
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPO~TS
479
1959
began to ingratiate himself into the good opinion of
the lady. The fact, however, remains that all this
Ananl
conduct cannot avail the prosecution, unless it proves Chintaman Lagu
conclusively some other aspects of the case.
v.
We cannot, however, overlook one or two other The Stale of
Bombay
circumstances which are part of this conduct. We
have already stated briefly that the appellant caused Hidayatullah ].
all persons to believe that Laxmibai was alive and
living at Rathodi as the happily married wife of one
.Ioshi. Both Joshi and Rathodi were equally fictitious.
In this 2onnection, the pleader, the son, the friends
and the relations of Laxmibai were receiving for
months after her death letters and communications
purporting to be signed by her, though written at the
instance of the appellant by persons, who have come
and deposed before the Court to this fact. These letters
. were all posted in R. M. S. vans, and the prosecution
has successfully proved that they were not posted in
any of the regular post offices in a town or village.
These letters show a variety of details and intimacies
which made them appear genuine except forthe handwriting and the signature of Laxmibai. For a time,
people who received them, though suspicious, took
them for what they were worth, and it appears that
they did not worry very much about the truth. It has
now been successfully proved by the prosecution and
admitted by the appellant's counsel before us that
these letters were all sent by the appellan~ with the
sole object of keeping the people in the dark about the
fact of death, so that the appellant might have time
to deal with the property at leisure. The appellant
asserts that he thought of this only after the death of
Laxmibai. It seems somewhat surprising that the
appellant should have suddenly gone downhill into
dishonesty, so to speak, at a bound. The maxim is
very old that no one becomes dishonest suddenly;
nema fuit repente turpissimus. What inference can be
drawn from his conduct after the death of Laxmibai
is a matter to be considered by us. And in this connection, we can only say at this stage that if some prior
conduct is connected intrinsically, with conduct after
death, then the motive of the appellant would be very
clear indeed.
.480
SUPREME corRT REPORTS
[1960 (2))
We now pass on to the evidence of what happened
in the hospital and the total medical· evidence on the
Anant
cause of death. This evidence has to be considered
Chintaman Lagu
from
different angles. Much of it relates to the condiv.
tion
of
Laxmibai and the treatment given to her; but
The State of
other parts of it relate to the conduct of the appellant
Bombay
and the information supplied by him. There is also
Hidayatullah ]. further evidence about the disposal of the body and
the enquiries made into the cause of death. These
must be dealt with separately. For the present, we
shall confine ourselves to the _pure medical a:spect of
the case of Laxmibai during her short stay in the
hospital.
When Laxmibai was admitted in the hospital,
Dr. Ugale (P.W.18), the Casualty Medical Officer, was
in charge. He made a preliminary examination and
recorded his impressions before he sent the patient to
Ward No. 12. He obtained from the appellant the
history of the attack, and it appears that all that the
appellant told him was "Patient suddenly became
unconscious in train while coming from up country.
History of similar attacks frequently before". It also
appears that the appellant told him that the lady was
liable to hysterical fits, and that was set down by
Dr. Ugale as a provisional diagnosis. So much of
Dr. Ugale's evidence regarding the health ofLaxmibai
as given by the appellant. Now, we tak•' up his own
examination.• According to Dr. Ugale, there were
involuntary movements of the right hand, which he
noticed only once. Only the right hand was moving.
He found corneal reflex absent. Pupils were normal
and reacting to light. So far as central nervous system
and respiration were concerned, he detected nothing
abnormal. According to him, there was no evidence
of a hysterical fit, and he stated that he queried that
provisional diagnosis which, according to him, was
supplied by the appellant. According to Dr. Ugale, the
name of the patient was given as Indumati Paunshe.
The patient was then made over to the care of
Dr. Miss Aneeja (P. W. 19). Dr. Miss Aneeja was then a
raw Medical Graduate, having passed the M.B.B.S. in
June, 1956. She was working as the House Physician,
r959
•
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
481
I959
and was in charge of Ward No. 12. She was summoned from her quarters to the ·ward at 6-15 a.m.
Anant
and she examined Laxmibai. We leave out of account Chintaman Lagu
again the conversation bearing upon the conduct of
v.
the appellant, which we shall view subsequently. He The State of
Bombay
told her also about the sudden onset of unconscious.
ness, and that there was a history of similar attacks Hidayatul/ah J.
before. We are concerned next with the result of the
examination by Dr. Miss Aneeja, bearing in mind that
she was not a very experienced physician. She found
pulse 100, temperature 99·5, _respiration 20. The
skin was found to be smooth and elastic; nails, conjunctiva and t'ongue were pink in colour; lymphatic
glands were not palpable ; and bones and joints had
nothing abnormal in them. The pupils of the eyes
were equal but dilated, and were not then reacting to
light. She found that up to the abdomen and the
sphincter the reflexes were absent. The reflexes at
knee and ankle were normal, but the plantar reflex
was Babinsky on one foot, and there was slight rigidity
of the neck.
It appears that Laxmibai was promptly given a
dose of a stimulant and oxygen was started. Dr. Miss.
Aneeja also stated that she gave an injection of insulin
(40 units) immediately. Much dispute has arisen as to
whether Dr. Miss Aneeja examined the urine for sugar,
albumin and acetone before starting this treatment. It
is clear, however, from her testimony that no blood
test was made to determine the level of sugar in the
blood. A lumbar puncture was also made by Dr. Miss
Aneeja and the cerebro-spinal fluid was sent for chemical analysis. That report is available, and the fluid
was normal. According to Dr. Miss.Aneeja, the Medical
Registrar who, she says, was Dr. Saify, recommended
intravenous injection of 40 units of insulin with 20 c.c.
of glucose, which were administered. According to her,
Laxmibai was also put on glucose intragastric drip.
Dr. Miss Aneeja stated that the urine was examined
by her three times, and in the first sample, sugar and
acetone were present in quantities. The first examination, according to her, was at 6-30 a.m., the next at
8-80 a.m. and the last at 11 a.m. She stated that she
482
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(2)]
had used Benedict test for sugar and Rothera's test for
acetone.
In all the examinations, according to her, there
A.nanl
was
no
albumin
present. Dr. Miss Aneeja also claims to
Chintaman Lagu
have
phoned
to
Dr.
Variava, the Honorary Physician,
v.
Tho State of
at 6-45 or 7 a.m., and consulted him about the case.
Bombay
According to her, Dr. Saify, the Registrar of the Unit,
visited the Ward at 8-30 a.m. and wrote on the case
Hidayatullah ].
papers that an intravenous injection of 40 units of
insulin with 20 C.C. of glucose should be administered.
According to her, Dr. Variava visited the Ward at
11 a.m., and examined Laxmibai, but the patient
expired at 11-30 a.m. We do not at this stage refer
to the instructions for post-mortem examination left
by Dr. Variava which were noted on the case papers,
because that is a matter with regard to the disposal of
the dead body, and we shall deal with the evidence in
that behalf separately. The evidence of Dr. Miss
Aneeja shows only this much that she was put in
charge of this case, examined urine three times and
finding sugar and acetone present, she started a treatment by insulin which was also supplemented by
administration of glucose intravenously as well as by
intragastric drip. Apart from one dose of stimulant
given in the first few minutes, no other treatment
beyond administration of oxygen was undertaken.
She had also noted the observations of the reflexes
and the conditfon of the patient as they appeared to
her on examination.
There is a considerable amount of contradiction
between the evidence of Dr. Miss Aneeja and that of
Dr. Variava as to whether acetone was found by Dr.
Miss Aneeja before Dr. Variava's visit. According to
the learned Judges of the Court below, the first urine.
examination deposed to by Dr. Miss Aneeja and said
to have been made at 6-30 a.m. was never performed.
The other two examinations were made, as the urine
chart (Ex. 127) shows. It is, however, a question
whether they were confined only to sugar and albumin
but did not include examination for acetone. We
shall discuss this point after we have dealt with the
evidence of Dr. Variava.
1959
•
•
S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
4S3
I959
Dr. Variava (P.W. 2l) was the Honorary Physician,
and was in charge of this Unit. According to him, he
Anant
went on his rounds at 11 a.m., and examined Laxmibai Chintaman Lagu
from 11 a.m. to 11-i5 a.m. He questioned Dr. Miss
v.
Aneeja about the line of treatment and told her that The Stale of
Bombay
she could not have made a diagnosis of diabetic coma
without examining urine for acetone. Dr. Variava
deposed that the .entry regarding acetone_ on the case Hidayatullah J.
papers was not made when he saw the papers at
11 a.m. He then asked Dr. Miss Aneeja to take by
catheter a sample of the urine and to examine it for
acetone.
Dr. Miss Aneeja brought the test-tube with urine in
it, which showed a light green colour, and Dr. Variava
inferred from it that acetone might be present in
traces. According to Dr. Variava, Laxmibai's case
was not one of diabetic coma, and he gave two reasons
for this diagnosis, namely, that diabetic coma never
comes on suddenly, and that there are no convulsions
in it, as were described by Dr. Ugale. Dr. Variava
also denied that the phone call to him was made by
Dr. Miss Aneeja. Dr. Variava stated that before he left
the Ward he told Dr. Miss Aneeja that he was not
satisfied that the woman had died of diabetic coma
and instructed her that post-mortem examination
should be asked for.
In connection with the evidence about the examination of the urine, we have to see also the evidence of
Marina Laurie, nurse (P.W. 59), who stated how the
entries in the urine chart came to be made. It may
be pointed out that the urine chart showed only two
examinations for sugar, at 8-30 a.m. and 11 am., and
· not the one at 6-30 a.m. The entry about that was
made on the case papers under the head "treatment"
by Dr. Miss Aneeja, and it is the last entry 'acetone
+ +' which Dr. Variava stated was not on the
papers at the time he saw ~hem. Indeed, Dr. Variava
would not have roundly questioned Dr. Miss Aneeja
about the examination for acetone, if this entry had
been there, and Dr. Miss Aneeja admits a portion of
Dr. Variava's statement when she says that she examined the urine on Dr. Variava's instructions and
484
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960 (2)]
I959
brought the test-tube to him, hi which the urine was of
a light green colour.
Now, the urine chart does not show an examination
of the urine at 6-30 a.m. According to Dr. Miss
The State of
Aneeja, she examined the urine, carried the impression
Bombay
of colour in her mind, and noted the result on the
Hidayatullah . -case papers. She was questioned why she adopted
1
the unusual course, but stated that it often happened
that the urine chart was not prepared and the result
was not taken to the case papers. However it be,
Dr. Variava is quite positive that the entry about
acetone did not exist on the case papers, and an examination of the original shows differences in ink and
pen which would not have been there, had all the
three items been written at the same time. It also
appears that even a.t 8-30 a.m. the urine was examined
for sugar only because the entry in the urine chart
shows brick-red colour which is the resulting colour in
Benedict test and not in Rothera's test. Similarly,
at 11 a.m. the urine chart shows only a test for sugar
because the light green colour is not the resulting
colour of Rothera's test but also of the Benedict test.
Indeed, Dr. Variava was also shown a test-tube con. taining the urine of slight greenish colour, and his
own inference. was that acetone might be present in
traces. There is thus nothing to show that Dr. Miss
Aneeja embarked upon a treatment for diabetic coma
after ascertaining the existence of acetone. All the
circumstances point to the other conclusion, namely,
that she did not examine the urine for acetone, and
that seems to be the cause of the questions put by
Dr. Variava to her. We have no hesitation, therefore,
in accepting Dr. Variava's evidence on this part of
the case, which is supported by the evidence of the
nurse, the urine chart and the interpolation in the
case papers.
From all that we have said, it is quite clear that
the treatment given to her for diabetic coma was
based on insufficient data. There was also no Kussmaul breathing (Root & White, Diabetes Mellitus,
p. ll8) ; her breathing was 20 per minute which was
normal. Nor was there any sign of dehydration,
Ananl
Chintaman Lagu
v.
•
•
-
S;C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
485
•
because· the skin was smooth and elastic, and the
rQ59
Babinsky sign was a contra indication of diabetic coma.
.
.
b
b
h
d'
.
f
D
V
.
Anant
Th
. is is orne out y t ~ . 1agnos1s o . r._ ~nava Chintaman Lagu
himself, who appears positive that Laxmibai did not
v.
·
suffer.from diabetic coma, and is further fortified by The State of
the reasons given by Dr. H. Mehta (P.W. 65), to whose
·Bombay
evidence we shall have occasion to refer later.
Hidayatullah F .
Two other doctors from the hospital were examined
in connection with Laxmibai's stay. The first was
Dr. J. 0. Patel, who was then t_he Medical Registrar of
Unit No. I. It seems that Dr. Saify, the permanent
Medical Registrar, was on leave due to the illness of
his father, and Dr. J. 0. Patel was looking after his
Unit. Dr. J.C. Patel went round with Dr. Variava
at 11 a.m., and in his presence, Dr. Variava examined
Laxmibai. He has no contribution to make, because
he says he does not remember anything. The only
piece of evidence which he has given and which is
useful for our enquiry is that in the phone book
(Ex:. 323) in which all calls are entered, no call
to Dr. Variava on the morning of the 13th was shown.
The evidence of Dr. J. 0. Patel is thus useless, except
in this little respect. The other doctor, Dr. Hiralal
Shah (P. W. 72) was the Registrar of Unit No. 2.
After Laxmibai entered the hopital, Dr. Miss Aneeja
sent a call to him, and he . signed the call book
(Ex. 322). Dr. Hiralal Shah pretended that he did not
remember the case. He stated that if he was called,
he must have gone there, and examined the patient;
but he stated in the witness- box that he did not
remember anything. All the three doctors, Dr. Miss
Aneeja, Dr. Patel and Dr. Hiralal Shah, denied having
made the entry "Insulin 40 units I. V. with 20 0. C.
glucose." Dr. Miss Aneeja says that it was written
by Dr. Saify, who, as we shall show presently, was
not present in Bombay at all on that day.
We do not propose to deal with the cause of the death,
before adverting to the findings of Dr. Jhala (P.W. 66),
who performed the autopsy and Dr. H. S. Mehta
(P. W. 65), to whom all the case papers of Laxmibai
were handed over for expert opinion. Dr. Jhala
performed the post-mortem operation on No.vember 23,
.
•
~
9i
•
486
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2)]
1959
and he was helped by his assistants. Though the body
was well-preserved and had been kept in the air-condiAnant
tioned
morgue, there is no denying the fact that 10
Chintaman Lagu
days had passed between the death and the postv.
The State of
mortem examination. The findings of Dr. Jhala were
Bombay
that the body and the viscera were not decomposed,
and that an examination of the vital organs could be
Hidayatu/lah J.
made. Dr. Jhala found in the stomach 4 oz. of a
pasty meal and! oz.of whitish precipitate in the bladder.
He did not find any other substance which could be
said to have been introduced into the system. He
examined the brain and found it congested. There
were no marks df injury 011 the body; the lungs were
also congested and in the upper Jobe of the left lung
there was a tubercular focus which, in his opinion, was
not sufficient to cause death ordinarily. He also found
Atheroma of aorta and slight sclerosis of the coronary.
He stated that the presence of the last meal in the
stomach indicated that there was no vomitting. He
found no pathological lesion in the pancreas, the
kidney, the liver and any other internal organ. He
gave the opinion after the receipt of the Chemical
Analyser's report that death could have occurred due
to diabetic coma.
It must be remembered that Dr. Jhala was not out
to discover whether any offence had been committed.
He was making a post-mortem examination of a body
which, under the Coroner's order, had been handed
over to the medical authorities with a certificate from a
hospital that death was due to diabetic coma. It was
not then a medico-legal case; the need for post-mortem
had arisen, because the peon had noticed certain
marks on the neck, which had caused some suspicion.
After discovering that the mark on the neck was a
post-mortem injury, all that he had to do was to
verify whether the diagnosis made by the G.T. Hospital
that death was due to diabetic coma was admissible.
He examined the body, found no other cause of death,
and the Chemical Analyser not having reported the
adminisiration of poi"on, he accepted the diagnosis
of the G. T. Hospital as correct. Dr. Jhala, however,
stated that there were numerous poisons which co11ld
'
•
•
..
S.C.R.
-
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
487
not be detected on chemical analysis even in the case
z959
of normal, healthy and undecomposed viscera. He
1
admitted that his opinion that death could h!1ve Chint:~:: Lagu
occurred due to diabetic coma was an inaccurate way of
v.
expressing his opinion. According to him, the proper The State of
way would have been to have given the opinion
Bombay
"death by diabetes' with complications."
Hidayatullah).
As we have said, all these papers were placed before
Dr. H. S. Mehta for his expert opinion. It is to his
evidence we now turn to find out what was the cause
of death of Laxmibai. In the middle of March 1958,
Dr. Mehta was consulted about this case, and he was
handed over copies of all the documents we have
referred to in connection with the medical evidence,
together with the proceedings of the Coroner's inquest
at Bombay. According to Dr. Mehta, opinion was
sought from him about the cause of death of
'Indumati Paunshe' and whether it was from diabetic
·coma, any other disease or the adminiskation of a
poison. Dr. Mehta was categorical that it was not
due to diabetic coma. He was also of the opinion
that no natural cause for the death was di&,closed by
the autopsy, and according to him, it was probably
due 'to the administration of some unrecognisable
poison or ·a recognisable poison which, due to the lapse
oftime, was incapable of being detected by analysis. He
gave several reasons for coming to the conclusion that
Laxmibai did not suffer from diabetic coma. Each of
his reasons is supported by citations from numerous
standard medical authorities on the subject, but it is
unnecessary to cite them once again. Accprding to ·
him, the following reasons existed for holding that
Laxmibai did not suffer from diabetic coma:
(1) Convulsions never occui· in diabetic cuma per se.
According to Dr. Mehta, the involuntary movements
described by Dr. Ugale must be treated as convulsions
or tremors. We are of opinion that Dr. Ugale would
not have made this note on the case papers if he had
not seen the involuntary movements. No doubt, these
involuntary movements had ceased by the time the
pati'ent was carried to Ward No. 12, because Dr. Miss
Aneeja made a note that theY. were not observed in
488
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(2))
the Ward. But Dr. U gale was a much more experienced
doctor than Dr. Miss Aneeja, and it is possible
Anant
that
Dr. Miss Aneeja did not notice the symptoms as
Chintaman Lagu
v.
minutely as the Casualty Medical Officer.
The S'ate of
(2) Diabetic coma never occurs all of a sudden and
Bombay
without a warning. There are premonitary signs and
In the case, there is no
f!idayattdlah J. symptoms of prodromata.
evidence te show how Laxmibai became unconscious.
We have, however, the statement of the appellant
made both to Dr. Ugale and Dr. Miss Aneeja that the
onset was sudden. Dr. Mehta was cross-examined
with a view to eliciting that a sudden onset of diabetic
coma was possible if there was an infection of any
kind. A suggestion was put to him that if the patient
suffered from Otitis Media, then sometimes the unconciousness came on suddenly. It may be pointed
out that the appellant in his examination stated that
on the day in question, Laxmibai had a temperature
of 100 degrees, laryngitis, pharyngitis, and complained of pain-in the ear. That statement was made to bring
his defence in line with this suggestion. Dr. Mehta
pointed out that Dr. Jhala had opened the skull and
had examined the interior organs but found no pathological lesion there. According to Dr. Mehta, Dr.
Jhala would have detected pus in the middle ear if
Otitis Media had existed. The fact that no question
suggesting this was put to Dr. Jhala shows that the
defence is an afterthought to induce the Court to hold
that death. was due to diabetic coma, or, in other
words; to natur.al causes. \Ve are inclined to accept
the evidence of Dr. Jhala that he and his assistants
,
did not discover any pathological lesion in the head
or the brain. Otitis Media would have caused inflammation of the Eustachian tube, and pus would have
been present. No such question having been put, we
must hold that there was no septic focus which might
· have induced the sudden onset of diabetic coma. It
was also suggested to Dr. Mehta that there was a
tubercular infection and sometimes in the case of
tubereular infeetion diabetie coma suddenly supervened. The tuberculosis in this ease was not of such
severity as to have caused this. Dr. Jhala referred
•
•
-
,
S.O.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
489
to the septic focus in the apex of the left lung, but
x959
. he stated that it was not sufficient to have caused the
Anant
death of Laxmibai. Illustrative cases of sudden dia- Ckintaman Lagu
betic coma as a result of tubercular infection were
v ..
not shown, and the condition of Laxmibai, as deposed The State of
to by witnesses right up to 9 p.m. on the night
Bombay
of November 12, 1956, does not warrant the inference HidayatullahJ.
that she .had diabetic coma suddenly as a result of
this infection.
(3) Dr. Mehta also stated from the case papers
maintained by the appellant from February 15, 1956,
to November 12, 1956, that during that time, Laxmibai
did not appear to have suffered from any severe type
of acidosis. The appellant in his examination in
Court stated that Laxmibai was prone to suffer from
acidosis, and that he had treated her by the administration of Soda Bi-carb. In the case papers, Soda Bi·
carb has been administered . only in about 8 to 10
doses varying between 15 grains to a dram. It is
significant that on most of the occasions it was
part of a Carminative mixture. The acidosis, if any,
could not have been so severe as to have been
corrected by such a small administration of Soda
Bi-carb, because the acidosis of diabetes is not the
acid~ty of the stomach but the formation of fatty
acids in the system. Such a condition, as the books
show, may be treated by the administration of Soda;
Bi-carb but in addition to some other specific treatment. (Joslin, Root & White, Treatment of Diabetes
Mellitus, p. 397).
(4) A patient in diabetic coma is severely dehydrated;
(Root & White-Diabetes Mellitus p. 118). We have
already pointed .out that there was no dehydration;
because the skin was soft and elastic and the tongue
was pink. The eye balls were also normal and were
not soft, as is invariably the case in diabetic coma.
Dr. Mehta has referred to all these points.·
· (5) Nausea and vomitting are always present in true
diabetic coma. There is nothing to show either from
her clothes or from the smell of vomit in the mouth
or from · any other _evidence that ,Laxmibai ·had
vomitted in the train. Dr. Jhala who performed the
490
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2)]
post-mortem examination had stated that Laxmibai
could not have vomitted because in her stomach 4 oz.
Anant
of pasty meal was found.
The same fact is also
C}lintaman Lagu
by
Dr.
Mehta.
emphasised
v.
The State of
(6) In diabetic coma, there will be fall of blood presBombay
sure, rapid pulse ; there will be Kussmaul breathing or
air hunger. The respiration of Laxmibai was found
Hidayatullah ].
by Dr. Ugale and Dr. Miss Aneeja to be normal. The
temperature chart in the case, Ex. 129, gives in
parallel columns the respiration corresponding to a
particular temperature, and the temperature of
99·5 degrees (Fahrenheit) found by Dr. Miss Aneeja
corresponds to respiration at 20 .times per minute.
Dr. Variava, Dr. Ugale or Dr. Miss Aneeja also did
not say anything about the Kussmaul breathing,
and the pulse of 100 per minute according to Dr.
Mehta was justified by the temperature which Laxmibai then had. Indeed, according to Dr. Mehta, in
diabetic coma the skin is cold, and there was no
reason why there should be temperature. According
to Dr. Mehta, there was no evidence of any gastric
disturbance, because the condition of the tongue
was healthy. Dr. Mehta also pointed out that the
Extensor reflex called the Babinsky sign was not
present in diabetic coma, while according to Dr. Miss
Aneeja it was present in this case. Dr. Mehta then
referred to the examination of the urine for sugar and
acetone, and stated that the examination for sugar was
insufficient to determine the presence of Ketonuria,
which is another name for the acidosis which results
in coma. We have already found that 1the examination for acetone was not made and there was no
mention of acetone breath either by Dr. Ugale or by
Dr. Miss Aneeja, which would have been present if
the acidosis was so advanced. (Root & WhiteDiabetes Mel!itus, p. 118).
(8) Lastly, the examination of cerebro-spinal fluid
did not show any increase of sugar and no affection in
the categories of meningial irritation was disclosed by
the chemical analysis of the fluid. (Physician's Handbook, 4th Edn., pp. 115-120). The neck rigidity which
was noticed by Dr. Miss Aneeja did not have, therefore,
I959
•
'
'
•
..
S.C.R.
-
•
...
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
491
x959
any connection with such irritation, and it is a question whether such a slight neck rigidity existed at all.
Ananl
These reasons of Dr. Mehta are prefectly valid. Chintaman Lagu
v.
They have the support of a large number of medical
treatises to which he has referred and of even more, The Stale of
Bombay
which were referred to us during the arguments, all of
which we find it unnecessary to quote. We accept H idayatull ah J.
Dr. Mehfa's testimony that diabetic coma did not
cause the death of Laxmibai. It is significant that
the case of the appellant also has changed, and he has
ceased to insist now that Laxmibai died of diabetic
coma. The treatment which was given to Laxmibai
would have, if diabetic coma had existed, at least
improved her condition during the 5 hours that she
was at the hospital. Far from showing the slightest
improvement, Laxmibai died within 5 hours of her
admission in the hospital, and in view of the contra
indications catalogued by Dr. Mehta and accepted by
us on an examination of the medical authorities, we
are firmly of opinion that death was not due
diabetic coma.
We now deal with events that took place . immediately after Laxmibai expired. We have already shown
that at that time Dr. Variava was present and was
questioning Dr. Miss Aneeja about her diagnosis o±
diabetic coma. Before Dr. Variava left the Ward,
he told Dr. Miss Aneeja that he was not satisfied
about the d.iagnosis, and that a post-mortem examination should be asked for. This endorsement was, in
fact, made by Dr. Miss Aneeja on the case papers, and
the final diagnosis was left blank. Dr. Miss Aneeja
says that she left the Ward at about 11-30 a.m. and
was absent on her rounds for an hour, then she returned to the Ward from her quarters at about 1 p.m. and
went to the office of Dr. Mouskar, the Resident
Medical Officer. According to her, she met Dr. Saify,
the Registrar, at the door, and he had the case papers
in his hands. Dr. Saify told her that the Resident
Medical Officer thought that there was no need for a
post-mortem examination, as the patient was treated
in the hospital for diabetic coma. Dr. Saify ordered
Dr. Mi~s Aneeja to cancel the <;indorsement &bout
492
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960 (2)]
post-mortem and to write diabetic coma as the cause
of
death, which she did, in Dr. Saify's presence. This
Anant
is
Dr.
Miss Aneeja's explanation why the post-mortem
Chinlaman Lagu
was not made, though ordered by Pr. Variava.
v.
The Slate of
Dr. Mouskar's version is quite different. According
Bombay
to him, the case papers arrived in his office at 1 p.m.
Hidayatullah J." He had seen the endorsement about the post-mortem
and the fact that the final diagnosis had not been
entered in the appropriate column. Dr. Mouskar
admitted that he did not proceed to make arrangements for the post-mortem examination. According
to him, the permission of the relatives and the Coroner
was necessary. He also admitted that he did riot
enquire from the Honorary Physician about the need
for post-mortem examination. He was thinking, he
said, of consulting the relatives and the person who
had brought Laxmibai to the hospital. Dr. Mouskar
sent a telegram at 2 p.m. to the appellant, which we
have quoted earlier. He explained that he did not
mention the post-mortem examination, because he was
waiting for the arrival of some person connected with
Laxmibai. He further stated that between 4 and
5 p.m. he asked the police to remove the body to the
J. J. Hospital morgue and to preserve it, and sent a
copy of his requisition to the Coroner. According to
him, on the 15th the Coroner's office asked the hospital
for the final diagnosis in the case. He stated that he
asked one out of the three: Honorary Physician, the
Registrar or the House Physician,-about the final
diagnosis, though he could not say which one. He
had sent the papers through the call-hoy for writing
the final diagnosis, and he received the case papers
from the Unit, with the two corrections, namely, the
cancellation of the requisition for post-mortem examination and the entry of diabetic coma as the final
diagnosis. He denied that he had any talk with
Dr. Saify regarding the post-mortem examination.
It would appear from this that there are vital differences in the versions of Dr. Miss Aneeja and Dr.
Mouskar. The first contradiction is the date on which
the case papers were corrected and the second, about
Dr. Saify's intervention in the :matter. Dr, Saify,
<
•
S.C.R.
-
•
I
-I
'-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
493
fortunately for him, had obtained leave orders and
r959
had left Bombay on November 8, 1956, for Indore,
A
where his father was seriously ill. He was, in fact, Chinta;,a:t Lagu
detained at Indore, because his father suffered from
v.
an attack of coronary thrombosis, and he had to The State of
extend his leave. All the relevant papers conne4lted
Bombay
with his leave have been produced, and it seems that
Dr. Saify's name was introduced by Dr. Miss Aneeja Hidayatullah J.
either to avoid taking responsibility for correction, on
her own, of the papers, or to shield some other person,
who had caused her to make the corrections. Here,
the only othoc person, who could possibly have ordered
her was the Resident Medical Officer, Dr. Mouskari
who at 1 p.m. had received the papers and had seen
the endorsement about the post-mortem examination.
Dr. Mouskar's explanation that he sent the telegram
to the appellant for the removal of the body without
informing him about the post-mortem examination is
too ingenious to be accepted by any reasonable person.
Dr. Mouskar could not ordinarily countermand what
the Honorary Physician had said without at least
consulting him, which he admits he did not do. This
is more so, if it was only a matter of the hospital's
reputation. Whether the corrections were made by
Dr. Miss Aneeja in the wards when the call-boy took
the papers to her (a most unusal course for Dr. Mouskar
,to have adopted) or whether they were made by
Dr. Miss Aneeja in the office of Dr. Mouskar, to the door
of which, she admits she had gone, the position
remains the same. Dr. Miss Aneeja no doubt told lies,
but she did so in her own interest. She could not
cancel the requisition about post-mortem examination
on her own without facing a grave charge in which Dr.
Mouskar would have played a considerable part. The
fact that this correction did not trouble Dr. Mouskar
and that his dealings with the body were most unusuai
points clearly to its being made at his instance. :Qr.
Miss Aneeja invented the story about Dr. Saify as a last
resort knowing that unless she named somebody
the responsibility would be hers. The corrections
were made at the instance of Dr. Mouskar, because
Dr. Mouskar admits that he sent the papers to the
63
494
SUPREME COURT l~EPORTS
(1960(2))
Ward for final diagnosis in the face of the endorsement for post-mortem examination, and Dr. Miss
A1ui11t
Aneeja 'admits· making the corrections at the door of
Chintaman Lagu
Dr. Mouskar's office. In our opinion,· both of them
'" of are partly correct. Dr. Mouskar made the first move
The State
Bombay
in getting the papers corrected, and Dr. Miss Aneeja
cor/ected them not at the door of the office, because
Hida:yatullah ].
there was no Dr. Saify there but in the office, though
she had not the courage to name Dr. Mouskar as the
person who had ordered the correction. Dr. Mouskar's
telegram and his sending the body to another morgue
without the post-mortem examination show only too
clearly that it was he who caused the change to be
made. It is also a question whether the correction
about' acetone++' was not also made simultaneously.
We do not believe that the corrections were made as
late as November 15, because his telegram for the
removal of the dead body and its further removal to
the J. J. Hospital would not fit in with the endorsement for post-mortem examination on the case
papers.
.
Now, the question is not whether Dr. Mouskar made
the correction or Dr. Miss Aneeja, but whether the
appellant had anything to do with it. Dr. Miss
Aneeja stated that the appellant was present till the
visit of Dr. Variava was over and this is borne out by
the reply of the appellant, because in the inland letter
he mentioned the time of the death which the telegram did not convey to him and which he could have
only known if he was present in the hospital. We
believe Dr. Miss Aneeja when she says that the appellant was present at the hospital, and the circumstances
of the case unerringly point to the conclusion that he
knew of the demand for a post-mortem examination.
Though Dr. Mouskar and the appellant denied that
they met, there is reason to believe that the appellant
knowing of the post-mortem examination would not
go away without seeing that the post-mortem examination was duly carried out or was given up.
Dr. Mouskar and· the' appellant both admitted that
they were together in the same class in 1934 in the
S. P. College, Poona, though both of them denied that
I959
•
•
•
S.C.:R.
+
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
495
they were acquainted with each other. Dr. Mouskar
z959
stayed in Poona from 1922 to 1926, 19~1. to 1936 and ,
Anant
1948 to 1951. The appellant was practismg at Poona Chintaman Lagu
as a doctor, and it is improbable that they did not get
v.
acquainted during Dr. Mouskar's stay, belonging, as The State of
they do, to the same profession. Dr. Mouskar further
Bombay
tried to support the appellant by saying that at 1 p.m. Hidayatullah ].
when he saw the case papers the entry about acetone
was read by him. He forgot that in the examinationin-chief he had stated very definitely that he had not
read the case papers fully and had only seen the top·
page. When he was asked for his explanation, he
could not account for his conduct in the witness-box,
and admitted his mistake. There are two other
circumstances connected with Dr. Mouskar, which
excite considerable suspicion. The first is that he
mentioned hy'sterical fits as the illness from which
Laxmibai suffered when Dr. Ugale had questioned it
and post-mortem had been asked for to establish the
cause of death. The next is that the call book of the
hospital for the period was not produced by him as
long as he was in office. When he retired, the call
book was brought in by his successor, and it established the very important fact that it was not
Dr. Saify, the Registrar, who was summoned but
Dr. Shah, who had also signed the call book in token
of having received the call. Dr. Mouskar's conduct
as the Resident Medical Officer in having the postmortem examination cancelled was a great lapse, and
it is quite obvious to us that the finding by the two
Courts below that this was done at the request of the
appellant is the only inference possible in the case.
The alternative suggestion in the argument of the
appellant.'s counsel that Dr. Mouskar thought that
Dr. Variava was making "a mountain out of a mole
hill " and that " the reputation of the hospital was
involved " does not appeal to us, because if that had
been the motive, Dr. Mouskar would have talked to
Dr. Variava and asked him to revise his own opinion.
The cancellation of the requisition for post-mortem
examination came to Dr. Varia va as a surprise, because
he stated that he had heard nothing about it.
496
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2)]
From the above analysis of the evidence, we accept
the
following facts: The appellant was present in the
.Anant
Chintaman Lag.U hospital till the death of Laxmibai, and in his presence,
Dr. Variava examin<id Laxmibai and questioned the
v.
The State of
diagnosis of Dr. Miss Aneeja and gave the instructions
Bombay
for the post-mortem examination. Dr. Variava's stay
was only for 15 minutes, and at the end of it,
Hidayatullah J.
Laxmibai expired. The statement of the appellant
that he caught the 10-30 train from Bombay to Poona
because he was asked by the Matron to leave the
female ward, and that he was going back to get a
female attendant from Poona, is entirely false. He
took no action about a female attendant either in
Bombay or in Poona, and he could not have left by
the 10-30 train if he was present in the hospital till
11-30 a.m. We are also satisfied that Dr. Miss Aneeja
did not cancel the endorsement about the post-mortem
examination on her own responsibility. She was
ordered to do so. We are also satisfied that it was
not Dr. Saify who had given this order, but it must
have been Dr. Mouskar, who did so. We are also
satisfied that Dr. Mouskar did not induce Dr. Miss
Aneeja to cancel the post-mortem by sending the case
papers through the call-boy of her Ward, but she was
summoned to the office, to the door of which she
admits she had gone. We are, therefore, in agreement
with the two Courts below that Dr. Mouskar caused
these changes to be made, and that Dr. Miss Aneeja
did not have the courage to name the Resident Medical
Officer, and lied by introducing the name of Dr. Sa.ify.
We are also satisfied that Dr. Mouskar and the appellant were acquainted with each other not only when
they were in College together but they must have
known each other, when Dr. Mouskar was residing at
Poona. The cancellation of the post-mortem examination was caused by the appellant, because Dr.
Mouskar's explanation on this part of the case is .
extremely unsatisfactory, and his failure to consult
Dr. Variava, if it was only a hospital matter, is extremely significant. The appellant's immediate exit from
the hospital and the telegram to him at Poona show
that Dr. M:ouskar knew where the appellant was to be
x959
•
'
•
I·
-
-
•
..
-
-
s.c.R.
497
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
found. The telegram conveyed to the appellant that
z959
the post-mortem was not to be held, because it said
that the body should be immediately removed.
Chitit!a":' Lagu
Now, the appellant, as we have said, took no action
v.
about Laxmibai's death and kept this information to The State of
pimself. He did not also arrange for the removal of
Bombay
the body. He sent an inland letter which, he knew, Hi dayatullah J.
would take a day or two to reach the hospital. He
knew that the body would be lying unclaimed at the
hospital, and that the hospital could not hold the body
for ever without taking some action. The appellant
is a doctor. He has studied in medical institutions
where bodies are brought for dissection purposes, and
he must be aware that there is an Anatomy Act, under
which unclaimed bodies are handed over to Colleges
after 48 hours for dissection. He also knew that the·
cause of death would become more and more difficult
to determine as time passed on, and it is quite clear
that the appellant was banking on these two circumstances for the avoidance of any detection into the
cause of death. He had also seen to it that the postmortem examination would not be made, and he knew
that if the body remained unclaimed, then it would be
disposed of in accordance with. the Anatomy Act. He
wrote a letter which he knew would reach the hospital
authorities, and he named a fiotitioui;; brother who, he
said, could not arrive before the 16th from Calcutta.
This delay would have gained him three valuable days
between the death and any likely examination, and if
the body remained unclaimed, then it was likely to be
disposed of in the manner laid down in the Anatomy
Act. The anticipations of the appellant were so
accurate that the body followed the identical course
which he had planned for it, and i~ is an accident that
ten days later a post-mortem examination was made,
because an observant peon noticed some mark on the
·neck which he thought, was suspicious. But for this,
it would have been impossible to trace what happened
to Laxmibai, because the hospital papers would have
been filed, the body dissected by medical students and
disposed of and the relatives and friends kept in the
dark about the whereabouts of Laxmibai by spurious
letters.
·
·
498
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960 (2)]
This brings us to another piece of conduct which
we
have to view. When Laxmibai boarded the train,
A11ant
Chintaman Lagu she had a bedding and a bag with her, which she
was seen carrying at the Par by Patil (P. vV. 60)
v.
The State of
on the night she left Poona. There is a mass of evidBo»ibay
ence that Laxmibai was in affluent circumstances,
and
always wore on her person gold and pearl ornaHidayatullah ].
ments. There is also evidence that she had taken
Rs. 50 from Virkar the night she travelled, and
presumbly she was carrying some more money with
her, because she had to consult a specialist in
Bombay and money would be required to pay him.
When she reached the hospital in the company
of the appellant, she had no ornaments on her
person, no money in her possession and her bag
and bedding had also disappeared. As a matter of
fact, there was nothing to identify her or to distinguish her from any other indigent woman in the
street. There is no explanation which any reasonable person can accept as to what happened to her
belongings. It is possible that the bag and the
bedding might have been forgotten in the hurry to
take her to the hospital, but her gold ornaments on her person could not so disappear. The
appellant stated that he noticed for the first time in
the taxi that she had no ornaments on her person;
but there would be no need for him to notice this fact
if Laxmibai started without any ornaments whatever.
In view of the fact that Laxmibai's entire property
soon passed into the hands of the appellant, it is
reasonable to hold that he would not overlook the
valuaqle gold and pearl ornaments in this context.
Further, the absence of the ornaments and other
things to identify Laxmibai rendered her anonymity
complete, in so far as the hospital was concerned,
unless information to that end was furnished by the
appellant only. In the event of Laxmibai's death in
the hospital, no complication would arise if she did
not possess any property and the body would be
treated as unclaimed, if none appeared to claim it.
In addition to the stripping of the lady of her
belongings, the appellant took measures to keep her
I959
•
-
S.C.R.
•
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
499
identity a close secret. No doubt, he gave her name
z959
as " Indumati ", but he added to it her maiden surA
name in a garbled form. According to Dr. Ugale, the Chintan;aa:t Lagu
name given was " Paunshe ". In every one of the
v.
other papers, the name appears to have been correct- The state of
ed by the addition of some letter resembling " k"
Bombay
but not in the case papers. Dr. Ugale swore that he
had not heard the name '' Paunshe " before, though Hidayatullah f.
his mother-tongue is Marathi, and he is himself a
Maharashtrian. He, therefore, asked the appellant
to spell the name, and he was definite that the name
was written as spelt by the appellant. There is,
• however, other evidence coming from the appellant
himself to show that he did not give the correct
maiden surname of Laxmibai, becattse in the letter he
wrote to the hospital he only stated that there was an
I
extra "u " in the name as entered in the papers but
did not mention anything about" k ". His solicitude
about the name and its spelling in the case papers
clearly shows that his mind even under the stress of
these circumstances was upon one fact only that the
name should remain either " Paunshe " or " Panshe ''
and not become " Ponkshe ". Indeed, one wi;mld
expect the appellant to have given the name "Laxmibai Karve" or" Indumati Karve" instead of "Indumati Ponkshe ", and much less, " Indumati Paunshe ".
There must be some reason for the appellant choosing
the maiden surname, even if he gave the correct
maiden name. The reason appears to be this: Either
he had to say at the hospital that he did not know
the name, or he had to give some name. If he said
that he did not know the name, it would have caused
some suspicion, and the matter would then have been
entered in the emergency police case register. This
is deposed to by the doctors in the hospital. By
giving the name, he avoided this contingency. By
giving a garbled name, he avoided the identity, if by
chance that name came to the notice of some one who
knew Laxmibai. His intention can only be interpreted in the light of his subsequent conduct and the
use to which he put this altered name. We have
itlready seen th11-t he hid thE;J f~ct of death from every
500
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1960 (2}]
one and wrote to people that the woman was alive.
He had two opportunities of correcting this name
Anant
Chintaman Lagu which he had noticed very carefully on the case
papers. The first was when he wrote the letter to the
v.
The State of
hospital in which he insisted that "u" should be
Bombay
omitted but did not add "k ". The other was when
on the 16th the police questioned him and he stated
Hidayatullah ].
that he did not know who the woman was. He also
gave the age of the woman wrongly, and perhaps,
deliberately :-see the correction and overwritings
in the inland letter he wrote on November 14, 1956.
Immediately after the death of Laxmibai, he misap.
propriated a sum of Rs. 5,000 by presenting two
documents, Exs. 285 and 286, without disclosing to
the Bank that the person who had issued the cheque
was no more. All this subsequent conduct gets tied
to his conduct in giving the name as " Indumati
Paunshe" or "Panshe "; and it shows a foreknow.
ledge of what was to happen to Indumati at the
hospital. It also shows a ·preparation for keeping
the fact of her death hidden from others to facilitate the misappropriation of her property, which
as we know, eventually took place starting from
November 15, that is to say, two days following her
death. No explanation worth considering exists why
this name was given, and the effort of the counsel for
the appellant that he was probably on intimate terms
with Laxmibai and chose to call her by her maiden
name rather than her married name is belied by the
fact that in every document in which the name has
been mentioned by the appellant, he has addessed her
as Laxmibai Karve and not as Indumati Ponkshe.
There is no evidence that this elderly lady was anything more than a foolishly trusting friend of this
man who took advantage of her in every way.
. Then, there is the conduct of the appellant in not
disclosing to the hospital authorities the entire case
history of Laxmibai and the treatment which he had
been giving her as her" medical attendant. Instead
of telling the doctor all the circumstances of her
health, he told him that the woman was suffering
from hysterical fits, which fits, according to the
r959
•
•
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
S.C.R.
•
•
501
I959
evidence in the case, did not recur after 1948. He also
did not give any particulars of the onset of unconsAnant
ciousness in the train. Even the fact that Laxmibai Chintaman Lagu
had suffered from diabetes for some years was not
'v.
mentioned, and this shows that he was intent upon The State of
Bombay
the medical attendants in the hospital treating the
case from a scratch and furn bling it, if possible. To
him, it appears to us, it was a matter of utter indiffer- Hidayatullah J.
ence what treatment was given to her, an attitude
which he continued to observe even after. his patient
had died. In our opinion, therefore, the conduct at
the hospital appears significantly enough to suggest
that he anticipated that Laxmibai was doomed, and
he was intent upon seeing to· it that no one but
himself should know of her death and that a quiet
disposal of her body should take place.
We may mention here one other fact, and that is
that the G.T. Hospital, is situated at a distance of 5
or 6 furl~:mgs from the Victoria Terminus Station,
whereas the St. George's Hospital is said to be only
50 feet away from the main entrance. Why an
unconscious woman was carried first on a stretcher
and then in a taxi to this distant hospital· when she
could have,been carried straight to the hospital on
the stretcher itself, is not explained. There is ofcourse, this significant fact that at the St. George's
Hospital he would not have been able to pull his
weight with the medical authorities, which he was
able to do with Dr. M-0uskar because of his acquaintance with him. This choosing of the hospital is of a
piece with the choosing of an inconvenient train which
would make detection difficult, arrival at the hospital
when it would be closed except for emergency cases,
and the patient likely to be waited upon by a raw and
inexperienced doctor in the early hours of the morning.
We, however, cannot say this too strongly, because it
is likely that Laxmibai herself chose to travel by a
night train. But the whole of the conduct of the
appellant prior to the death of Laxmibai appears to be
of a piece with his conduct after her death, and we arc
satisfied that even before her entry into the hospital,
the appellant had planp.ed this line of conduct.
.
64
502
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1960(2)]
r959
Our findings thus substantially accord on all the
relevant facts with those of the two Courts below,
Chintaman Lagu though the arrangement and consideration of the
v.
relevant evidence on record is somewhat different.
The State of
It is now necessary to consider the arguments· which
Bombay
have been advanced on behalf of the appellant. The
Hidayatullah J. first contention is that the essential ingredients
required to be proved in all cases of murder by poisoning were not proved by the prosecution in this case.
Reference in this connection is made to a decision of
the Allahabad High Court in Mst. Gujrani v. Emperor (1 ) and two unreported decisions of this Court in
Ghandrakant N yalchand Seth v. The State of Bombay(•)
decided on February 19, 1958, and Dharambir
Singh v. The State of Punjab(') decided on November 4, 1958. In these cases, the Court referred to
three propositions which the prosecution must establish
in a case of poisoning: (a) that death took place by
poisoning; (b) that the accused had the poison in his
possession; and (c) that the accused had an opportunity
to administer the poison to the deceased. The case in
Dharambir Singh v. The State of Punjab (') turned
\ .
upon these three propositions. There, the deceased
had died as a result of poisoning by potassium
cyanide, which poison was also found in the autopsy.
The High Court had disbelieved the evidence which
sought to establish that the accused had obtained
potassium cyanide, but held, nevertheless, that the
circumstantial evidence was sufficient to convict the
accused in that case. This Court did not, however,
accept the circumstantial evidence as complete. It is to
be observed that the three propositions were laid down
not as the invariable criteria of proof by direct evidence
in a case of murder by poisoning, because evidently if
after poisoning the victim, the accused destroyed all
traces of the body, the first proposition would be incapable of being proved except by circumstantial evidence. Similarly, if the accused gave a victim something to eat and the victim died immediately on the
ingestion of that food with symptoms of poisoning and
A.nant
-
•
-
(1) A.I.R. 1933 All. 394.
{2) Cr. A. No, 120 of 1957.
(3) Cr. A.. No. 98 of 1958.
'
•
S.C.R.
-
-
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
503
poison, in fact, was found in the viscera, the requirez959
ment of proving that the accused was possessed of the
poison would follow from the circumstance that the Chint:~::'.Lagu
accused gave the victim something to eat and need
v.
not be separately proved. There have been cases The State of
in which conviction was maintained, even though
Bombay
the body of the victim had completely disappeared, Hidayalullah ] •
and it was impossible to say, except on circumstantial evidence, whether that person was the victim
of foul play, including poisoning. Recently, this Court
in Mohan v. State of U. P. (1 ) decided on November 5,
1959, held that the proof of the fact of possession
of the poison was rendered unnecessary, b.ecause the
victim died soc;m after eating pedas given by the
accused in that case, and he had not partaken any
other food likely to contain poison. In Dr. Palmer's
case (2 ), strychnine was not detected, and the accused
was convicted by the jury after Lord Chief Justice
Campbell (Cresswell, J. and Mr. Baron Alderson,
concurring) charged the jury that the discovery of
the poison on autopsy, was not obligatory, if they
were satisfied on the evidence of symptoms that
death had been caused by the ministration of the
strychnine. The conduct of Palmer, which was also
significant, was stressed inasmuch as he had attempted to thwart a successful chemical analysis of the
viscera, and had done suspicious acts to achieve
that end. In Dr. Orippen's case (3 ), the conduct of
the accused after the death of Mrs. Crippen in making
the friends and relatives believe that Mrs. Crippen was
alive was considered an incriminatory circumstance
pointing to his guilt. No doubt, i:c'i. Dr. Orippen's
case (3), the body was found and poison was detected,
but there was no proof that Dr. Crippen had administered the poison to her, that being inferred from
his subsequent conduct in running away with Miss
Le Neve. In the second case of this Court, the poison
was availiable to the victim, and it was possible that
she had taken it to end an unhappy life.
The cases of this Court which were decided, proceeded upon their own facts, and though the three
(1) Cr. A. No. 108 of 1959·
(2) Notable Trials Series.
(3) Notable Trials Series.
504
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(2)]
propositions must be kept in mind always, the suffici- .
ency
of the evidence, .direct or circumstantial, to
Ananl
establish
murder by poisoning will depend on the facts
Chintaman Lagu
of
each
case.
If the evidence in a particular case does
v.
The State of
not justify the inference that death is the result of
Bombay
poisoning because of the failure of the prosecution to
prove the fact satisfactorily, either directly or by
Hidayatullah ].
circumstantial evidence, then the benefit of the doubt
will have to be given to the accused person. But if
circumstantial evidence, in the absence of direct proof
of the three elements, is so decisive that the Court can
unhesitatingly hold that death was a result of administration of poison (though not detected) and that the
poison must have been administered by the accused
person, then the co_nviction can be rested on it.
In a recent case decided in England in the Court of
Criminal Appeal (Regina v. Onufrejczyl~ (1 ), the body
of the victim was not found at all. And, indeed,
there was no evidence. that he had died, much less was
murdered. The accused's conduct in that case which
was held decisive, was very similar to the conduct of
the present appellant. He was in monetary difficulties,
and the victim was his partner, whom he wished to
buy out but did not have the money to do so. One
fine day, the partner disappeared, and his body was
not found, and it was not known what had happened
to him. The activities of the accused after the disappearance of his partner were very remarkable. To
people who enquired from him about his partner, he
told all manner of lies as to how a large and dark
car had arrived in the night and that three men had
carried off his partner at the point of a rnvolver. To a
sheriff's officer he stated that his partner had gone to
see a doctor. He also asked a lady to send him some
sham registered letters and forged other do,cuments.
Lord Chief Justice Goddard stated the law to be that
in a trial for murder, the fact of death could be proved by circumstantial evidence alone, provided the jury
were warned that the evidence must lead to one conclusion only, and that even though there was no body
or even trace of a body or any direct evidence as to
z959
(1) [r955] r:Q.B 388,
-
•
'
--
...
-
-
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
•
505
-
the manner of the death of a victim, the corpus delicti
x959
could be held to be proved by a number of facts, which
· · of th e cnme
·
·
It .is
· ch· AllanlL u
ren d•ered th e comm1ss10n
cert am.
in 1aman ag
pertment to remember that Lord Goddard observed
v.
during the course of argument that there was no The State of
virtue in the words " direct evidence '', and added : •
Bombay
"It would be going a long way, especially in Hidayatullali J.
these days when we know what can be done with
acid, to say that there cannot be a conviction without some proof of a body. If you are right you
have to admit that a successful disposal of the body
could prevent a conviction."
It is obvious that Lord Goddard had in mind the case
of John George Haigh {1 ) who, as is notorious, disposed
of bodies by steeping .them in acid bath, destroying
all traces. It is, in this context, instructive to read
a case from New Zealand to which Lord Goddard also
referred, where the body of the victim was never
found, The King v. Horry {2 ). The statement of the
law as t.o proof of corpus delicti laid down by Gresson,J.
(concurred in by Fair, A.C.J., Stanton, J. and Hay, J.)
was approved by Lord Goddard with one slight
change. The statement of the law (head-note) is as
·
follows:
"At the trial of a person charged with murder,
the fact of death is provable by circumstantial evidence, notwithstanding that neither the body nor
any trace of the body has been found, and that the
accused has made no confession of any participa~
tion in the crime. Before he can be convicted, the
fact of death should be proved by such circumstances as render the commission of the crime morally
certain ahd leave no ground for reasonable doubt:
the circumstantial evidence should be .so cogent and
compelling as to co:p.vince a jury that upon no
rational hypothesis other than murder can the facts
be accounted for."
Lord Goddard did not agree with the words " morally
certain" and stated that he would have preferred to
say " such circumstances as render the commission
of the crime certain."
(1) Notable Trials Series.
(:a) [1952] N.Z.L.R. 111,
506
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960 (2)]
The same test has been applied by Wills in his Book
on Circumstantial Evidence, and the author has quotAnant
ed the case of Donellan (1 ), where the conduct of
Chintaman ~agu
Donellan in rinsing out a bottle in spite of the wife of
Y.
the victim asking him not to touch those bottles, was
The State of
Bombay
treated as a very significant evidence of guilt.
Butler, J., charged the jury that:
Hidayatullah ].
" if there was a doubt upon the evidence of the
physical witnesses they must take into their consideration all the other circumstances either to show
that thei·e was poison administered or that there
was not, and that every part of the prisoner's conduct was material to be considered."
Similarly, in Donnall's case('), Abbot, J., according to
Wills, in summing up, said to the jury that:
"there were. two important questions: first did
the deceased die of poison ? and if they should be
of opinion that she did, then whether they were
satisfied from the evidence that the poison was
administered by the prisoner or by his means. There
were some parts of the evidence which appeared to
him eqnally applicable to both questions, and those
parts were what related to the conduct of the
prisoner during the time of the opening and inspection of the body; his recommendation of a shell and
the early burial; to which might be added the
circumstances, not much to be relied upon, relative
to his endeavours to evade his apprehension. His
Lordship also said, as to the question whether the
deceased died by poison, 'in considering what the
medical men have said upon the one side and the
other, you must take into account the conduct of
the prisoner iu urging a hasty funeral and his conduct in throwing away the contants of the jug into
the chamber utensil'."
In Rex v. Horry('), where the entire case law in
England was presented for the consideration of the
Court, it was pointed out by the Court that there was
no rule in England that corpus delicti must be proved
by direct evidence establishing the death of the person
I959
(I) Gurneys Rep. (1781)
-
(•) (1817) • C. & K. 3080.
(3) [1952] N.Z.L.R. III.
f
-
S.C.R.
.L
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
507
I959
and further, the cause of that death. Reference was
made to Evans v. Evans (1), where it was ruled that
Anant
that corpus delicti might be proved by direct evidence Chintaman Lagu
or by "irresistible grounds of presumption". In the
v.
same case, it has been pointed out that in New Zealand The State of
Bombay
the Court upheld numerous convictions, where the
body of the victim was never found.
Hidayatullah ].
The rule of law stated by Sir Matthew Hale in Pleas
of the Crown Vol. 2, p. 290 that "I would never convict any person of murder or manslaughter, unless the
fact were proved to be done, or at least the body found
dead " was not accepted in this and other cases. Lord
Goddard also rejected the statement as one of universal
application, in the ·case to which we have already
referred.
The case of Mary Ann Nash (2 ) is illustrative of the
proposition that even though the cause of death may
not appear to be established by direct evidence, the
circumstances of the case may be sufficient to infer
that a murder has been committed. In that case, the
prisoner had an illegitmate son, 5 years old. There
was evidence to show that the mother desired to put
the child out of her way. One day in June, 1907, the
mother left the house and returned without the child.
She made several statements as to what had happened
to the child, which were found to be untrue. As late
as April 1908, the body of a child was discovered in a
well. Decomposition had so far advanced that even
the sex of the child could not be determined. There
was nothing therefore to show whether death was
natural or violent, or whether it had occurred before
or after the body was put into the welt The case was
left to the jury. On appeal, it was contended that there
being no proof how death took place, the judge should
not have left the case to the Jury but ought to have
withdrawn it. Lord Chief Justice delivering the judgment of the Court of Appeal referred to the untrue
statements of the prisoner about the wherebouts of
the child, and observed as follows:
" All these statements were untrue. She had an
object in getting rid of the child, and if it had been
(1) 161 E.R. 466, 491.
(2) (19n) 6 Cr. App. R. 225.
•
508
I959
Anant
Chintaman Lagu
v.
The State of
Bombay
Hidayatullah ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1960(2)]
lost or met with an accidental death, she had every
interest in saying so at once. It is said there is no
evidence of violent death, but we cannot accept that.
Mr. Goddard cannot have meant that there must be
proof from the body itself of a violent death. . . .
In view of the facts that the child left home well and
was afterwards found dead, that the appellant was
last seen with it, and made untrue statements about
it, this is not a case which could have been withdrawn from the jury."
There is no difference between a trial with the help
of the jury and a trial by· a Judge in so far as the
appraisement of evidence is concerned. The value
of the evidence in each case must necessarily be the
same. If the case of Jlfary Ann Nash (1 ) could be left
to the jury, here too the case has been decided by the
two Courts below concurrently against the appellant
on evidence on which they could legitimately reach
the conclusion whether an offence of murder had been
established or not.
A case of murder by administration of poison is
almost always one of secrecy. The poisoner seldom
takes another into his confidence, and his preparations to the commission of the offence are also secret.
He watches his opportunity and administers the poison
in a manner calculated to a void its detection. The
greater his knowledge of poisons, the greater the
secrecy, and consequently the greater the difficulty of
proving the case againt him. What assistance a man
of science can give he gives; but it is too much to say
that the guilt of the accused must, in all cases, be
demonstrated by the isolation of the poison, though
in a case where there is nothing else such a course
would be incumbent upon the prosecution. _There are
various factors which militate against a successsful
isolation of the poison and its recognition. The discovery of the poison ca,n only take place either through
a post-mortem examination of the internal organs or
by chemical analysis. Often enough, the diagnosis of
a poison is aided by the information which may be
furnished by relatives and friends as to the symptoms
(1) 161 E.R. 466, 491.
<
S.C.R.
'
--
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
509
r959
found on the victim, if the course of poison has taken
long and others have had an opportunity of watching
its effect. Where, however, the poision is administered ch· 1AnantL
.
d h
. . .
d d
.
in aman
agu
m secrecy an t e v10t1m is ren ere unconsc10us
v.
effectively, there is nothing to show how the deterior- The State of
ation in the condition of the victim took place and if
Bombay
not poison but disease is suspected, the diagnosis of Hidayatullah 1.
poisoning may be rendered difficult. In Chapman's
case (1 ), the victim (Maud Marsh) was sent to Guy's
Hospital, where the doctors diagnosed her condition
to be due to various maladies "including cancer,
rheumatism and acute dyspepsia". It is clear that
doctors can be deceived by the symptoms of poison
into believing that they have a genuine case of sickness on hand. In Dr. Palmer's case (2 ), two medical
witnesses for the defence diagnosed the case from the
symptoms as being due to Angina Pectoris or epilepsy
with tetanic complications.
The reason for all this is obvious. Lambert in his
book "The Medico-Legal Post-Mortem in India"
(pp. 96,99-100) has stated that the pathologist's part in
the diagnosis of poisoning is secondary, and has
further observed that several poisons particularly of
the synthetic hypnotics and vegetable alkaloids groups
do not leave any characteristic signs which can be
I
noticed· on post-mortem examina.tion. See Modi's
Medical Jurisprudence 'and Toxicology, 13th Edn.,
pp. 450-451 and Taylor's Principles and Practice of
Medical Jurisprudence, Vol. II, p. 229. The same is
stated by Otto Saphir in his book" Autopsy" at pp. 71
and 72. In Dreisbach's Handbook of Poisons. 1955, it is
stated that pathological findings in deaths from narcotic
analgesics are not characteristic. He goes further and
says that even the laboratory findings are non-contributory. The position of the pathologist who conducts
a post-mortem examination has been summed up by
Modi in Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology, 13th
.
edn., p. 447 as follows :
"In order to make a probable guess of the poison
and to look for its characteristic post-mortem appearances, it is advisable that a medical officer, before
(r) Notable Trials Series.
65
(2) Notable Trials Series.
510
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960 (2))
I959
commencing a post-mortem examination on the body
of a suspected case of poisoning, should read the
Anant
police report and endeavour to get as much informChifftaman Lagu
v.
ation as possible from the relatives of the deceased
The State of
regarding the quality and quantity of the poison
Bombay
administered, the character of the symptoms with
reference to their onset and the time that elapsed
Hidayatullah ].
between the taking of the poison and the development of the first symptoms, the duration of the
illness, nature of the treatment adopted, and the
time of death. He will find that in most cases the
account supplied by the police and the reiatives is
very meagre, or incorrect and misleading. His task
is, therefore, very difficult, especially when many of
the .poisons except corrosives and irritants do not
show any characteristic post-mortem signs and when
bodies are in a11 advanced state of decomposi-.
tion . . . ".
Similarly, Gonzales in Legal Medicine and Toxicology
states at p. 629:
"The question of whether or not a negative
toxicologic examination is consistent with death by
poison can be answered affirmatively, as may persons
overcome by carbon monoxide die after twenty-four
hours, at which time the gas cannot be determined
in the blood by chemical tests. Likewise, the organs
of individuals who have been poisoned by phosphorus may not contain the toxic substance responsible for death if they have managed to survive its
effects for several days.
Many conditions seriously interfere with the
toxicologic examination, such as post-mortem de·
composition .... ".
We need not multiply authorities, because every book
on toxicology begins with a statement of such a fact.
Of course, there is a chemical test for almost every
poison, but it is impossible to expect a search for every
poison. Even in chemical analysis, the chemical
analyser may be unsuccessful for various reasons.
Taylor in his Principles and Practice of Medical
Jurisprudence, Vol. II, p. 228 gives three possible
explanations for negative findings, viz., (1) the case
•
•
•
•
S.C.R.
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
511
may have been of disease only; (2) the poison may
z959
have b~en eliminated ~y vomittin~ or other m~ans or
Anant
neutralised or metabolised; and (3) the analysis may Chintaman Lagu
have been faultily performed. Svensson Wendel in
v.
Crime Detection has stated at p. 281 that :
The State of
"Hypnotics are decomposed and disappear very
Bombay
quickly-some even in the time which elapses bet- HidayatullahJ.
ween the administration and the occurrence of death.
Circumstantial evidence in this context means a
combination of facts creating a net-work through
which there is no escape for the accused, because the
facts taken as a whole do not admit of any inference
but of his guilt. To rely upon the findings of the
medical man who conducted the post-mortem and of
the chemical analyser as decisive of the matter is to
render the other evidence entirely fruitless. While the
circumstanc.es often speak with unerring certainty, the
autopsy and the chemical analysis taken by themselves may be most misleading. No doubt, due weight
must be given to the negative findings at such examinations. But, bearing in mind the difficult task which
the man of medicine performs and the limitations
under which he works, his failure should not be taken
as the end of the case, for on good and probative
circumstances, an irresistible inference of guilt can be
drawn.
In the present case, the effort of the appellant has
been to persuade the Court that the death of Laxmibd
was possibly the result of disease rather than by
poison. During the course of the case and the appeal,
various theories have been advanced and conflicting
diagnoses have been mooted. The case of the appellant has wavered between-death by diabetic coma and
by hypoglycemia, though relying upon the condition
of the arteries and the aorta and the rigidity of tke
neck, suggestions of coronary complications and renal
failure have also been made. We have shown above
that this was not a case of diabetic coma, because of
the absence of the cardinal symptoms of diabetic coma.
This also is the opinion of Dr. Variava and Dr. Mehta,
though Dr. Jhala, for reasons which we have indicat~ accepted it. The appellant argued again the case
512
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960 (2)]
from the angle of diabetic coma, but later veered in
favour
of hypoglvcemia.
This change noticeable not
.
J
A nant
Chintaman Lagu only m the arguments before us but also throughout
v.
the conduct of the case is merely to confuse the issu~,
Th• State of
and create, if possible, a doubt, which would take the
Bombay
mind away from the surrounding circumstances, and
focus
it only upon the medical aspect of the case.
Hidayatullah· ].
Full advantage has been taken of the findings of
Dr. Ugale and Dr. Miss Aneeja, which suggest partly
an onset of diabetic coma, partly of hypoglycemia, and
partly of renal failure. There is no true picture of
any one disease. The rigidity of the neck was not
reflected in the chemical analysis of the cerebro-spinal
fluid and was negatived, in so far as renal failure is
concerned, by the negative findings about albumin.
Diabetic coma stood ruled out by the presence of the
Babinsky sign and the suddenness of the onset, the
negative aspect of acetone breath and the rather
remarkable failure of the specific treatment given for
it to have worked any change. Driven from these
considerations to such doubtful suggestions as coronary
complications of which no physical evidence was found
by Dr. Jhala, the appellant put his case on hypoglycemia, and relied upon the fact that at the hospital
40 units of insulin intravenously and another 40 units
subcutaneously were administered. Medical text-books·
were quoted to show that in the case of hypoglycemic
coma the introduction of even a small quantity of
insulin sometimes proves fatal. The learned AdvocateGeneral stoutly resiHted this move, which was at variance with the case as set out before the High Court,
because it is obvious <tnough that if one accepted the
theory of hypoglycemic coma, the only injections of
insulin causing such shock would be proved to have
, been given at the hospital and not by the appellant.
Here, the position, however, is not so difficult for the
State, because Laxmibai was found to have 4 oz. of
pasty meal in )ler stomach, and with food inside her, the
possibility of hypoglycemia taking place naturally was
extremely remote. If it was hypoglycemic coma due to
excessive administration of insulin, then it must have
been administered prior to its onset,, and who could have
'959
f
•
...
S.C.R.
__, .
-
•
•
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
513
given it but the appellant ? Even though coma superI959
venes.suddenly, the patient passes through symptoms
A
of discomfort, and Laxmibai would have told the Chinta;::' Lagu
appellant about it in the train. The appellant mentionv.
ed nothing of this to Dr. Ugale. If an excessive dose The State of
of insulin was given by the appellant, the question of
Bombay
intent would arise, and the conduct shows the inten- Hidayatullah ],
tion. There were no pronounced symptoms of
hypoglycemia either. Laxmibai just passed from unconsciousness to death without the manifestation of
any of· the signs associated with the syndrome of
hypoglycemic death. It is also to be remembered that
hypoglycemic coma is generally overcome by the administration of a very small quantity of glucose (5 or
10 grams of glucose orally): Treatment of Diabetes
Mellitus by Joslin, Root and White, p. 350. The 40
units given intravenously were mixed with 20 0. 0. of
glucose and carried the palliative with. them. Even
otherwise, Laxmibai was receiving glucose by intragastric drip, and during the three and a half hours,
there should have been an improvement. The surprising part is that the administration of. the insulin
and glucose brought about no visible symptoms in the
patient either for better or for worse. She passed into
death, and the inference can only be that.she did not
die of these diseases of which she was either suspected
or for which she .was treated but of something else,
which could not answer to the treatment given to her.
Dreisbach in his Handbook on Poisons at p. 27 has
stated that coma also results from the action of several
poisons. Depressants, sedatives and hypnotics all
cause death by coma (ibid. p. 201). The symptoms,
according to the author, are sleepiness, mental confusion, unsteadiness rapidly followed by coma with
slow shallow respiration, flaccid muscles and absent
deep reflexes. The difference between coma due to
disease and coma as the result of poisons is stated by
him in the following words : ·
"Coma from poisoning presumably results from
some interference with ·brain cell metabolism. In
attempting to combat the effects of· drugs which
induce coma, remember that no agents are known
514
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
-
[1960(2)]
which will specifically overcome the metabolic
derangements
of drug-induced coma. The mechanism
Anant
of
action
of
cerebral
stimulant drugs is also unChintaman Lagu
known,
but
these
drugs
presumably act by depresv.
sing
some
inhibiting
function
in the .cell. There is
The State of
Bombay
no evidence that any stimulants specifically oppose
the cellular metabolic depression indµced by the
H idayatullah ] .
depressant drugs such as the barbiturates."
No specific antidote is known for the sedative and
hypnotic drugs. (Ibid. p. 202).
The condition of Laxmibai clearly indicated an
impairment
of the central nervous system. It is no
'
doubt true that in some cases of coronary thrombosis,
coma supervenes ; but it is idle to suggest in the
present case that Laxmibai was affiicted by this type
of coma, because Dr. Jhala who performed the postmortem examination and opened the coronary arteries
found no evidence of thrombosis. According to Otto
Sa phir, a myocardial infarct is easily detected.
(Autopsy, pp. 301-302). Coma in Laxmibai's case, as
we have shown above, was not the result either of
acidosis, hypoglycemia, renal failure or meningial
irritation. Her liver, pancreas and kidney were found
to have no pathological lesions, and it is significant
that no question was even attempted to establish that
the opinion of Dr. Jhala on this part of the case was
incorrect. Learned counsel for the appellant suggested
that the examination by Dr. Jhala might have been
superficial, and might not have included a microscopical examinat.ion of sections of some of the vital
organs normally affected by diabetes. This suggestion,
in onr opinion, ought to have been put forward during
the cross-examination of the witness, and it is unfair
now to suggest that the opinion that no lesions were
found was based on :either improper or inadequate
examination. We hold that Dr. Jhala performed the
examination adequately,-and he was also helped by his
assistants.
Here, we pause to ask a question why the appellant
brought up the question of hysterical fits at all. He
could have said that Laxmibai was a diabetic, and
tha~ it was likely she had coma by reason of that
'959
•
]
'
S.C.R.
•
-
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
515
disease. The suggested diagnosis given by the appellant
I959
was so unlikely that Dr. Ugale questioned it then
A
1
and there. There is nothing in the W anlesswadi Chinta;:: Lagu
T.B. Sanatorium papers or in Dr. Sathe's evidence to
v.
show that Laxmibai had hysterical fits after her The State of
hysterectomy operation. No suggestion was made to
Bombay
the doctors in Court that Laxmibai might have had Hidayatullah ] .
hysterical fits. The condition of the muscles and the
absence of deep reflexes clearly show that this was just
anqther piece of deception. It is not possible to hold
that the appellant gave the full particulars to Dr .
Miss Aneeja. No suggestion was niade to her or to
Dr. Ugale that any information other than what was
noted in the case papers was furnished. There is no
case for holding that Laxmibai had a relapse of
hysterical fits. ·
It would, therefore, appear that Laxmibai's condition was not due to any disease, because diseases
inducing coma generally leave some tr!'Lce behind, and
also respond to medication. No doubt, in some cases
the pathological findings after death from diabetic
coma have been negative, but the question is if this
was such a case. We have, on the one hand, the factthat numerous poisons causing coma leave no identifiable trace in the victim after death, and, on the other,
that sometimes the autopsy does not disclose any discoverable signs in a patient who dies after an attack
of diabetic coma or disease. The appellant can be
presumed to have had knowledge of these poisons. The
appellant challenged the Advocate-General to show
from any standard book that the symptoms found by
the doctors accorded with 1any known poison. Here, it
must also be remembered tliat a man with knowledge
may manipulate not one but more drugs to achieve
his purpose, and the cardinal signs of poisoning on the
victim may, as a result, be either obliterated or, at
least significantly modified. We give one example on
which a certain amount of knowledge is possessed
even by laymen. A poison of which one . of the
symptoms would be the contracting ·of the pupils of
the eyes may be side-tracked by putting into the eyes
of the victim a drug like atropine, which by its local
516 .
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2)]
action dilates the pupils. We give this example,
because most of us know the action of atropine on the
Ananl
eyes,
and because the example also shows how easily
Chintaman Lagu
a
person
with knowledge may confuse the symptoms
v.
The 5itate of
by a simple trick. We are not suggesting that this is
Bombay
what has happened in this case; but when we have to
deal with a case of crime versus natural death, we canHidayatullah J.
not overlook the possibility of some ingenious artifice
having been used to screen the action.
If Laxmibai died in circumstances whichprimafacie
admit of either disease or homicide by poisoning, we
must look at the conduct of the appellant who brought
her to the hospital, and consider to what conclusion
that conduct unerringly points. If the appellant as
an honest medical man had taken Laxmibai to the
hospital and she had died by reason of disease, his
conduct would have been entirely different. He would
not have taken her to the hospital bereft of property
with which she .started from home; he would not have
given a wrong or misleading name to cover her
identity; he would not have given a wrong age and
wrong history of her ailments; he would not have
written a letter suggesting that she had a brother in
Calcutta, which brother did not exist; he would not
have abandoned the corpse to be dealt with by the
hospital as an unclaimed body; he would not have
attempted to convince tlie world that she was alive
and happily married; he would not have obtained her
property by forgeries, impersonation and other tricks
indulged in both before and after her death; but he
would have informed her relatives and done everything in his power to see t.hat she was properly treated
and stayed on to face whatever inquiry the hospital
wished to make into the cause of death and not tried
to avoid the post-mortem examination and would not
have disappeared, never to reappear. His prevarications about where Laxmibai was, make a big and much
varied !is t, and his forgeries cover scores of documents.
In the words of Baron Parke in Towell' s case (1 ):
"Circumstantial evidence is the only evidence
which can in cases of this kind lead to discovery.
I959
(1) (1854) 2 C. & K. 309.
•
-
-S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REf>bRTs
Bl 1
I
•
-
-
There is no way of investigating them except by the
use of circumstantial evidence ; but it most frequently happens that great crimes committed in
secret leave behind them some traces, or are accompanied by some circumstances which lead to the
discovery and punishment of the offender ... Direct
evidence of persons who saw the fact, if that proof
is offered upon the testimony of men whose veracity
you have no reason to doubt is the best proof; but,
on the other hand, it is equally true with regard to
circumstantial evidence, that the circumstances may
often be so clearly proved, so closely ·connected with
it, or leading to one result in conclusion, that the
mind may be as well convinced as if it were proved
by eye-witnesses."
The appellant in this ·case took some risk in taking
Laxmibai to the hospital and in giving his name there;
and these aspects were, in fact, stressed as arguments
in the case. As regards the first part, the argument
overlooks that what appears to us to be a risk might
not have so appeared to the appellant, who might
have been sure of his own ability to screen himself.
To him, the death of Laxmibai at the hospital without
discovery of poison would be the greatest argument in
his favour that he had acted honestly. The second
argument is equally unacceptable to us. The appellant
could not take the risk of a false name and address, if
he was intending that the body should be disposed of
as unclaimed. By giving his own address he could
keep the strings in his own hands. If he gave an
address and no reply came from that address, the
hospital would suspect foul play. If he gave the
address of Laxm1bai, people in Poona would know of
this mysterious death, and they would remember the
death of Purshottam alias Arvind in 1954. At that
time also a post-mortem examination on the body of
Arvind was held· (see, evidence of Ramachandra.
(P. W. 1)), and the explanation of the appellant given
in writing on January 22, 1954, is set ou~ below in his
own words:
"My name is Anant Chintaman Lagu, age ... years,
. residing at No. 431/5, Madi wale- Colony, Poon~., on
()()
1959
An11nl
v.
The St11t• of
Bombay
51$
SUPREME OOURT REPORTS
[1960(2)]
being questioned state that I am the· family doctor
of
Karve family in H. No. 94-95, Shukrawar. The
Anant
deceased
Purshottam Anant Karve belongs to that
Chiµtaman Lagu
family.
He came from Bombay to Poona on
".·
The State of
Saturday, the 16th January, 1954. He had come to
Bombay
me on Sunday, the 17th February, 1954, for medicine for weakness. I treated him for 2 days, on
f!idayatullah ].
17th and 18th. He had neither told me that there
was poisoning in his stomach, nor did I detect any
even when I examined and treated him. He became
unconscious 5 hours before his death. He was taken
to the S:1ssoon Hospital at 9 p.m. on 18th January,
1954. Jie was taken to the Sassoon Hospital because
his disease was increased in unconsciousness and
also because his mother as also myself and Dr.Joshi
were of the same opinion. He died there in about
30 to 45 minutes. The fact that there was deliberate
poisoning by somebody, was neither.revealed in my
examination nor did Purshottam Karve speak to me
anything about it during the time I treated him 2
days before. What exactly was the cause of death
could not be revealed during my treatment. I do
not know if somebody is on bad terms with him.
There are rumours about suicide but there is no
reason or any circumstance whatsoever for doing
so."
A false address would have started enquiries at the
hospital end. Laxmibai's own address would have
started speculation in Poona. It was for this reason
that the appellant had to choose another place and
to trim between fact and fiction so that he might be
able to deal with the matter himself. Of course,
Laxmibai did have an address of her own which could
have been given, and which did not cease to be her
address because she had got an attack of coma, from
which people are known to recover.
These arguments, however, are of no avail, in view
of the appellant's entire conduct now laid bare, which
.conduct has been proved to our satisfaction to have
begun not after the death of Laxmibai but much
earlier. This conduct is so knit together as to make a
pet-work of circurnstances pointing only to his guilt.
1959.
I
-
•
...
-
•
..
s.c.:R.
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
519
I959
The case is one of extreme cunning and premeditation.
The appellant, whose duty it was to care for this
Ananl
unfortunate lady as a friend and as her medical Chintaman Lagu
adviser, deliberately set about first to ingratiate himv.
self in her good opinion, and becoming her confidant,. the State of
Bombay
found out all about her affairs. All this time he was
planning to get at her property after taking her life.
He did not perpetrate his scheme at Poona, where the
death might have brought a host of persons to the
hospital. He devised a diabolical scheme of unparalleled cunning and committed an almost perfect murder.
But murder, though it hath no tongue, speaks out
sometimes. His method was his own undoing ; because
even the long arm of coincidence cannot explain the
multit.ude of circumstances against him, and they
destroy the presumption of innocence with which law
clothed him. In our judgment, the two Courts below
were perfectly correct in their conclusion that the
death of Laxmibai was the result of the administration
of some unrecognised poison or drug which would act
as a poison, and that the appellant was the person who
administered it. We, accordingly, confirm the conviction.
As regards the sentence' of death passed on the
appellant by the Sessions Judge and confirmed by the
High Court, it is the only sentence that could be
imposed for this planned and cold-blooded murder for
gain, and we do not interfere with it ..
The appeal fails, and it will be dismissed.
Sarkar j.
·SARKAR J.-In my opinion this appeal should be
aJlowed.
The appellant was tried by the Sessions J udg~, Poona,
on a charge under s. 302 of the Indian Penal Code
for the murder of Laxmibai Karve on November 13,
1956, by administering poison to her and was convicted and sentenced to death. His appeal to the High
Court at Bombay against the conviction and sentence
failed. He has now appealed to this Court with special
leave.
.
The evidence against the appellant is all circumstantial. The question to be decid~ in this appea.1 i~
•
520
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(2)]
I959
whether that evidence is such that the only reasonable
conclusion
from it is that the appellant was guilty of
Anant
Chintaman Lagu the charge brought against him.
v.
Laxmibai Karve, the deceased, was the widow of
Th• State of
one Anant Karve who was a businessman of Poona.
Bombay
Laxmibai was married in 1922 at the age of eleven to
Anant Karve, then a widower. Her maiden name was
Sarkar].
Indumati Ponkshe. After her marriage she was given
the name Laxmibai but was also called Indumati or
Indutai or Mai Karve or simply Mai. It does not
appear that after her marriage she had been known
by her father's surname of Ponkshe, a fact the significance of which will appear later.
Anant Karve had a son named Vishnu by his first
wife. By Laxmibai he had two sons, Ramchandra and
Purshottam also called Arvind.
Anant Karve died in 1945 leaving a will. By his
will he gave Laxmibai a right of residence in three
rooms in his dwelling house at No. 93-95, Shukrawar
Peth, Poona and a right to receive Rs. 50 per month
from the rent of that house which was in part let out,
and made certain other bequests to her. He devised
the rest of his propertie.s to his sons. Besides what
she had received from her husband, Laxmibai in 1954
inherited the properties of Purshottam who had died
intestate and unmarried in that year. She fort.her
inherited a large sum of money and gold ornaments of
considerable value from her mother, Girjabai, who had
died in 1946 or 1947. She had also considerable
:valuable ornaments of her own. Her total assets
amounted in 1956 to about Rs. 80,000. Part of her
liquid assets were held. in shares and debentures in
limited companies. She had also certain moneys in an
account in her name in the Bank of Maharashtra. A
considerable sum was due to her from one Joshi to
whom she had given a loan.
After the death of her husband, differences cropped
up between Laxmibai and her elder son, Ramchandra.
In 1946 Ramchandra started living separately from his
. mother in the same house and used to take his food in
~ hoteL in October 1952, Ramchandra joined military
'
<-
•
-
....
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
521
service as a craftsman and left Poona. Since joining
I959
service till the death of Laxmibai he was not residing
Anant
at Poona but came there now and then. In May 1956, Chintaman Lagu
Laxmibai got Ramchandra married.
v.
After her husband's death Laxmibai lived in the TheStateof
thr~e rooms in premises No. 93-95, Shukrawar Peth,/ Bombay
Poona, in which she had been.given a right of residence
Sarkar/.
by her husband's will. Her younger son Purshottam
also appears to have gone out of Poona on service in
HJ53, and he died in January 1954. Since then Laxmibai had been living aH by herself. She had however
certain relatives in Poona.
The appellant is a medical doctor. He and his
brother B. 0. Lagu, also a doctor, had been the family
physicians of Anant Karve. during his life time and
attended him in his last illness. After his death the
appellant continued to be Laxmibai's family doctor.
It is clear from the evidence that Laxmibai had great
trust and confidence in the appellant and depended on
him in all matters concerning her moneys and investments. It was he who went to the Bank for withdrawing and depositing moneys for her. In 1955 he
actually took on rent a big hall in premises No. 93-95,
Shukrawar Peth for his personal use and had been in
occupation of it since then.
Laxmibai did not possess very good health. She had
developed a tuberculous lesion some twenty years
before her death but it had healed. She was a chronic
diabetes patient since 1946 and started having hysterical fits since 1939. She suffered from menorrhagia and
metrorrhagia since 1942. On April 11, 1948, Dr. Ghorpure, a surgeon performed an operation on her which
is described in these terms :
Abdomen opened by mid-line sub-umbilical
incision-Subtotal hysterectomy done. Rt. ovary·
cysticpunctured-Appendicectomy. Abdomen closed
after exploring other viscera which were normal.
In 1949 she suffered from pyorrhoea and had her teeth
taken out. In 1950 the tuberculous affection became
active and on June 15, 1950, she consulted Dr. Sathe,
a lung specialist, who found that there was tuberculous
•
\-
..
522
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1960 (2)]
affection of the left lung and he recommended a line
of
treatment. This treatment was carried out by the
Anant
appellant
but apparently did not achieve much result.
Chintaman Lagu
On
July
13,
1950, she got herself admitted into the
v;
Wanlesswadi
Tuberculosis Sanatorium at :M:iraj in
The State of
Bombay
Bombay for treatment of the tuberculosis. Two
thoracoplasty ,operation~, were performed on the left
Sarkar].
lung and she was recommended a third such operation
which she was unwilling to undergo and left the
hospital at her own desire. In the course of these
operations nine of her ribs on the left side were
removed. The report given by this hospital on November 17, 1950, reads thus:
Patient was admitted on 13th July, 1950. X-Ray
on admission showed extensive filtration on the left
side with a large cavity in the upper zone; the right
side was within normal limits. She had diabetes
with high blood sugar which was controlled by
insulin. Two stages of thoracoplasty operation on
the left side were done and there was good clearing
of disease but there was a small residual cavity seen
and the third stage operation was advised. The
patient is leaving at her own request against medical
advice. Her sputum is positive.
There is no evidence that after she left Wanlesswadi
Sanatorium she had any relapse of any of her previous
illnesses earlier recounted. It appears from the evidence
of her relation one Datar, a medical man, that Laxmibai had been completely invalid being a frank case of
tuberculosis of both the lungs but in November 1956,
her health was good and she was cooking her food and
moving about in the house. The other evidence also
shows that she was carrying on her daily avocations of
life in a normal way at that time. After her death her
body was found to be well nourished. She had however
to have ordinary medical attention constantly and the
diabetes had continued though controlled. The appellant treated her all along and the fees paid to him
appear debited to Laxmibai's account.
I have so far been stating the earlier history of the
case and now come to the more immediate events. On
November 8, 1956, Laxmibai had Rs. 5,275-09 in het
I959
-
,,......
•
•
•
-
~.C.R.
•
/.
-
•
-
.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
523.
I959
account· in the Bank of Maharashtra. On a date
between November 8 and 10, she signed two papers
Anant
the first of which was a notice to the Bank reading, Chintaman
Lagu
"I desire to withdraw an amount exceeding Rs. 1,000
v.
up to about Rs. 5,000 in the next week from my The State of
Bombay
savings Bank Account" and the other was a withdrawal
slip or cheque and it read, "Pay Bearer the sum of
Sarkar],
Rupees Five thousand only which please debit to the
account of Laxmibai Anant Karve". None of these
papers bore any date and the bodies of them were in
the appellant's handwriting. These papers were made
over by Laxmibai to the appellant and he did not
present them to the Bank till after her death. On
November 12, 1956, the appellant paid to the credit
of Laxmibai's ·account in the Bank a dividend
warrant dated November 10, 1956, for Rs. 2,607-6-0
drawn in her favour by a company on the Bank of
Maharashtra, after signing her name on the back of it
himself.
The appellant had fixed up an engagement with
Dr. Sathe of Bombay, who has been named earlier, for
November 13, 1956, at 3 p.m. for examining Laxmibai.
On November 8, 1956, Bhave, a relation of Laxmibai,
called on Laxmibai and found the appellant there.
Laxmibai told him that she proposed to go to Bombay
with the appellant for consulting Dr. Sathe for her
health and that she would be returning in four or five
days. On November 10 or 11, she saw a lawyer
Karandikar, also a relation, and informed him that she
intended to go to Bombay with the appellant for consulting a physician. About the same time Champutai,
daughter of Bhave mentioned earlier, came to Laxmibai's house to invite her to attend the birthday party
of her son which had been fixed for November 13.
Laxmibai told Champutai that she was going . to
Bombay and if she was able to come back in time, she
would attend the party. At about 8 p.m. on November 12, Laxmibai went to Virkar, who was a tenant of
the house where she lived, and informed him that she
was going to Bombay by the night train to consult a
doctor and requested him to pay Rs. 50 on account of
the rent then due for meeting- the expenses. of thc;i
5.24
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1960(2)]
journey to Bombay. The amount was paid by Virkar to
her. She told Virkar that she expected to return to
Anant
Poona
after three or four days. About the same time she
Chintaman Lagu
met Pramilabai, another tenant of the house, and told
v.
The Stat". of
her that she was going to Bombay with the appellant
Bombay
by the night train to consult Dr. Sathe. A little later
she was seen by a third tenant Krishnaji, standing in
Sarkar].
front of the house with a small bag and bedding.
Krishnaji also saw the appellant on the road going
away from the house. All these people have said that
they found Laxmibai in a good state of health and
going about performing her normal avocations of life.
There was a passenger train leaving Poona for
Bombay at 10 p.m. Laxmibai and the appellant went
by this train to Bombay on November 12, 1956.
Though the appellant denied this, the Courts· below
have found that they travelled in the same compartment. The train reached Victoria Terminus Station,
Bombay, at 5-10 a.m. on November 13. Laxmibai had
then gone into a comatose condition. The appellant
procured a stretcher and carried her into a taxi with
the help of porters and took her to Gokuldas Tejpal
Hospital, usually called for short G.T. Hospital, which
is about six furlongs from the station. They reached
the hospital at about 5-45 a.m. Laxmibai was taken to
the Outdoor Department where Dr. Ugale, the
Casualty Officer in charge, admitted her into the
hospital. According to Dr. Ugale, the appellant
told him that the name of the unconscious woman
was Indumati Paunshe and her age was forty. The
appellant gave as the address of the patient the
address of his own dispensary at Poona, ·namely,
"C/o Dr. Lagu 20-B, Shukrawar, Gala No. 12,
Poona 2 ". Dr. Ugale said that the appellant at his
request spelt the name "Paunshe" and he took it down
as spelt by the appellant. On enquiry about the
history of the patient by Dr. Ugale the appellant told
him that the patient suddenly became unconscious in
the train while coming from upcountry ·and that there
was a history of similar attacks frequently before.
Dr. Ugale also said that the appellant told him that
he thought that the case was one of hysterical fit from
1959
...
•
•
·S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
525
which she frequently suffered. He did not tell Dr.
·x959
Ugale that the patient suffered from any other disease.
He said that he had brought the unconscious woman ch· tAnant L
to Bombay for getting her examined by a specialisf in a:~n agu
and that she was his patient. Dr. U gale entered in The State of
the appropriate record of the hospital called the case
Bombay
paper, all that the appellant told him and what he
Sarkar f.
himself had noticed. As a result of his own examination Dr. Ugale found that the patient was making
some involuntary movement, the corneal reflex was
absent, the pupils were normal apd reactive. He found
nothing abnormal in the cardio-vascular system or
the respiration. There was a clerk sitting by the side
of Dr. Ugale when the appellant was speaking to him
and he made the necessary entries in another record of
the hospital. In that record the name of the patient
appears as Indumati Pankshe. Dr. Ugale examined the
person of Laxmibai and found no ornament or cash on
her. Within four or five minutes of the time that she
arrived at the Out door Department of the hospital,
Laxmibai was removed to Ward No. 12.
Dr. Anija, a young woman doctor, who had passed
out the previous June, was then the House Physician
in attendance at that ward. The appellant accompanied Laxmibai to the ward -and introduced himself
to Dr. Anija as Dr. Lagu, which is his name. He told
her that while travelling in a train from upcountry
the patient had got unconscious and therefore he had
brought her straight from the station to the hospital
and that before-the journey the 'patient was alright.
He further said / that the patient had similar attacks
before. The appellant also told Dr. Anija that he was
the family physician of the patient and a family
friend and spoke of some of the illnesses from which the
patient had earlier suffered. Dr. Anija made some
notes in the case paper of what she heard from the
appellant and then examined the patient, the result of
which she also similarly noted in the case paper.
Thereafter, according to Dr. Anija, she tested the
patient's urine in a _laboratory attached to the ward
and recor.ded the finding on the case paper. She then
administered some stimulant and oxygen and also
-
-
•
I-
67
..
'
526
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2))
r959
gave an injectii>n of 40 units of insuli'n as she thought,
as
a result of the urine test, that the case was one of
Anant
diabetic
coma. There is some dispute as to whether
Chintaman Lagu
the urine was examined by Dr. Anija at this time and
v.
The Stale of
as to when the entries on the case paper of the results
Bombay
of the examination had been made. This will be discussed later. Dr. Anija examined the urine of the
Sarkar j.
patient for the seconq time at about 8-30 a.m. and
that also disclosed a certain quantity of Sugar. She
said that she then sent a call to the Registrar of the
ward, who was her immediate superior, to come and
see the cas!'. The Registrar came and, according to
Dr. Anija, directed that the patient be given another
40 units ofinsulin with 20 c.c. of glucose by intravenous
injection and that she be also given "intra-gastric
glucose drip" and this was done at about 9 a.m.
At about 11 a.m. the Honorary Visiting Physician,
Dr. Variava, came to the hospital. Dr. Anija told him
that it was a case of diabetic coma. Dr. Variava
then himself examined the patient and thereafter
asked Dr. Anija why she thought it to be a case of
diabetic coma, to which Dr. Anija replied that she
did so because there was sugar present in the urine.
Dr. Variava then asked her whether she had examined
the urine for acetone to which she replied that she
had not. Dr. Variava thereupon reprimanded her
by saying "How can you diagnose a case of diabetic
coma without ascertaining acetone in the urine?"
Thereafter under the directions of Dr. Variava,
Dr. Anija again tested the urine and showed it to
Dr. Variava who thought that the urine contained
a slight trace of acetone. Shortly after this urine
test the patient, that is, Laxmibai expired. It
was then about 11-30' a.m. Dr. Variava then told
Dr. Anija that he did not think that the case was one
of diabetic coma and that therefore he wanted a
post-mortem examination of the body of the deceased.
Dr. Anija then made a note on the case paper stating
" Asked for post-mortem" and put her signature
below the entry. She did not then put down anything in the column there about the final diagnosis.
Dr. Variava did not wait to see the entry about
-.
'
-
•
•
•
•
S.C.R.
-
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
527
I959
post-mortem being made by Dr. Anija but left to attend
other cases. It is clear th~t the appellant was present
Anant
in the hospital up to the time of the death of Chintaman Lagu
v.
Laxmibai though in his statement in the trial Court
he had denied this. There is no evidence as to how long The State of
Bombay
he remained in the hospital after Laxmibai's death but
it is clear that he was in Poona on November 14.
Sarkar].
There was arrangement in the hospital for conducting post-mortem examinations. 'l'he case papers along
with note " Asked for post-mortem" had been sent
by Dr. Anija to the Resident Medical Officer of the
hospital, Dr. Mouskar. It was his duty. to arrange
for the post-mortem exa'mination. The case paper
came to Dr. Mouskar's office at 1 p.m. but he did not
proceed to make any arrangement for havjng a postmortem examination held. Instead, at about 2 p. m.
he sent an official telegram to the appellant at Poona
at the address which he had given to Dr. Ugale and
which was recorded in the case paper. The telegrams
was in these words :
" lndumati expired arrange removal reply immediately."
On November 14, the appellant wrote from Poona a
letter in reply to the telegram. This letter was in
these terms :
"I have already telegraphed to the brother of
Shrimati Indumati Panshe at Calcutta, earliest he
will reach Bombay on the 15th November, 1956,
Thursday. His name is Govind Vaman Deshpande;
he will enquire as Indumati Panshe. I have seen
the name of the patient entered in the Ward Book
as Indumati Pannshe as ' n ' extra. Please correct
_ it. I am writing all these things in connection of
a case woman aged 30-35 years admitted in G. T.
Hospital at 6 a.m. on Tuesday 13th November,
1956, and expired the same day at about 11 a.m.
Shri Govind Vaman Deshpande. will take the body
and do the necessa~y funeral function according tO
Hindu rites."
Laxmibai had in fact no brother of the name of
Govind Vaman Deshpande. and in fact the appe~la~t
528
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2)]
had sent no telegram as he stated in the letter. The
statements
in the letter were all false. The letter was
Anant
received
in
the office of Dr. Mouskar in the afternoon
Chintaman Lagu
of November 15.
v.
'('he State oj
Not having received any reply from the appellant
Bombay
to his telegram, Dr. Mouskar on November 14, at
about 4 p. m., sent the following information to the
Sarkar].
Inspector of Police-A Esplanade P. S., Bombay.
"Sir,
I am to state that Smt. Indumati Paunshe, Hindu,
female, aged 40 years was admitted in Ward No.XII
for treatment of hysterical fits on 13th November,
1956, at 5-45 a. m. She died on the same day at
ll-30a.m.
The address given at the time of admission is as
follows:
Clo Dr. Lagu,
20B, Shukrawar,
• Gala No. 12, Poona-2.
A telegram on the above address has already been
sent, but without any response.
It is therefore requested that the body may
plea~e be removed and taken to the J. J. Hospital
Morgue for a voiding decomposition."
A copy of this letter was sent to the Coroner for
information. The letter was written as in the G. T.
Hospital there was no air conditioned morgue and
there was one in the J. J." Hospital.
On receipt of this letter the police immediately
wrote to the Coroner for permission to remove the
body from the G. T. Hospital to the J. J. Hospital.
The permission was granted by the Coroner at about
7-50 p.m. on the same day. The body was thereupon
removed from the G. T. Hospital to the J. J. Hospital
morgue at about 9 p.m. on November 14.
On the same day, that is, November 14, at about
9-30 p. m. the police again wrote to the Coroner stating
that it had received a report from the Resident Medical
• Officer, G. T. Hospital of the death of one Indumati
Paunshe, referring evidently to the letter which Dr.
Mouskar had earlier on the same day written to the
r959
•
._
-
..,.
S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
529
I959
police, and that Indumati appeared to have no relatives in Bombay and further that the cause of death
Anant
was not certified and requesting in the circumstances Chintaman Lagu
that an inquest over the death might be held. What
v.
happened about this request will be stated later.
The State of
Bombay
On November 15, the Bombay police sent a wireless
i
message to the police at Poona intimating that on
Sarkar].
November 13, one Indumati Paunshe, who had been
admitted to the G. T. Hospital for treatment of hysterical fits, had died on the very day in the hospital and
her address was "Clo Dr. Lagu, 20B, Shukrawar,
Gala No. 12, Poona 2" and asking that enquires
might be made at the above address and the relatives
might be asked to claim the dead body which was
lying unclaimed. Pursuant to this message, the Poona
police interviewed the appellant at Poona on November 16, when he made the following statement:
'
"On November 12 he left Poona for Bombay by
the I 0 p.m. train and had gone off to sleep. Towards
the end of the journey when he started preparing to
get down at Bombay, he found one woman fast
asleep. From other passengers he came to know
that her name was Indumati Paunshe about 35 years
of age and she had a brother serving in Calcutta.
When other passengers got down at Victoria Terminus•Station in Bombay, the womarrdid not awake.
He thereupon looked at her keenly and found her
senseless. Being himself a doctor he thought it his
duty to take her to the hospital and s_o took her to
the G. T. Hospital in a taxi. As he had taken that
woman to the hospital, the Casualty Medical Officer
took his address. He had no more information about
the woman. She was not his relation and he was
not in any way responsible for her."
The statement so made by the appellant was received
by the Bombay police from the Poona police on
November 17.
I now come back to the events that were happening
at Bombay. I have earlier stated that the case paper
had not initially given the final diagnosis as to the
530
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960 (2)]
I959
cause of Laxmibai's death but bore the endorsement
"Asked
for post-mortem"- At some stage, as to
Anant
which
the
evidence is confliuting and which I will
Chintaman Lagu
have to discuss later, the endorsement "Asked for
v.
The State of
post-mortem" was crossed out and the words "diabetic
Bombay
coma" were written on the case paper as the cause
of the death of the patient. Both of these alterations
Sarkar].
had been made by Dr. Anija who put her signature
under the coossed out entry. Dr. Mouskar on November 15, sent to the Coroner a certificate of the death
of the patient Indumati in the G. T. Hospital stating
therein diabetic coma as the cause of her death. By
this time the alteration in the case paper had clearly
been made, crossing out the direction as to post-mortem
examination and stating therein diabetic coma as the
cause of death. On the same day, that is, November 15, the police wrote a letter to Dr. Mouskar,
apparently in ignorance of the death certificate
issued by him, requesting him to send per bearer the
cause of the death of "Indumati ". This letter was
sent with a copy, the idea being that the original
would be retained by the Hospital and the copy
returned with an acknowledgement of the receipt of
the original made on it. Both these were however
produced from the police custody without any endorsement by the hospital acknowledging the rec~ipt of
either. The copy bore the following remark, "Diabetic
coma, Dr. N. S. Variava, G. T. Hospital." It is clear
on the evidence that the endorsement bad not been
made by Dr. Variava. Dr. Anija also denied having
made it though before the police she admitted that
the words "Diabetic coma" had been written by her.
Dr. Mouskar said that neither the original nor the
copy had ever come to him and be thought that
the endorsement "Diabetic coma" might be in Dr.
Anija's hand writing but be could not say by whom
the words "Dr. N.S. Variava, G.'T. Hospital" had been
written adding that the words "Dr. N. S. Variava"
had not been written by Dr. Variava. The question as
to who made the endorsement will be discussed later.
On receipt of the death certificate from Dr. Mouskar,
the Coroner's office made on the letter of the police
,
•
•
(
S.C.R.
-
-
'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
531
!959
dated Novetnber 14, asking. an inquest to be made,
which I have earlier mentioned, an endorsement
Anant
directing that no inquest was necessary as the Resid- Chintaman Lagu
ent Medical Officer, G. T. Hospital had certified the
v.
cause of death and had issued the death certificate. The State of
Bombay
On November 19, the Coroner's office directed that the
dead body might be disposed of as unclaimed after
Sarkar].
taking a photograph of it. A photograph of the dead
body was duly taken on the same day. In the meantime the Grant Medical College had written to the
Coroner on November 17, for authority to take over
certain unclaimed dead bodies lying in the J.J. Hospital mortuary, for dissection purposes and thereupon
the Coroner made an order directing that the dead
.bodies might be made over to the Grant Medical College.
Pursuant to this order, the dead bodies, which included
that of Laxmibai, were then made over to the Grant
Medical College on November 20, 1956. When the
dead body of Laxmibai was about to be taken to the
dissection hall, some scratches on the neck were detected. The Professor of Anatomy of the College did not
thereupon allow the body to be dissected and brought
the discovery to the notice of the police. The police
then wr0te to the Coroner that in view of this, a postmortem and an inquest might be held. Accordingly,
under the instructions of the Coroner, Dr. Jhala, Police
Surgeon, Bombay, held a post-moi::tem examination of
the body of Laxmibai on November 23. He found no
sign of decomposition in the body nor any character- '
istic smell of any recognisable poison. He also found
the scratches on the neck to be post-mortem. Dr. Jhala
sent the viscera to the Government Chemi<'al Examiner
who sent the report of his examination on December 19,
1956, wherein he stated that he was unable to detect
any poison in the viscera. Thereupon, Dr. Jhala
submitted his post-mortem report stating that in his
opinion death could have occurred on account of
diabetic coma. In the meantime, after the post-mortem
examination, the body of Laxmibai had been made·
over to the Hindu Relief Society for cremation on
November 24 and the cremation had been duly carried
· out.
•
'
532
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960 (2)]
It is now necessary to go back to Poona and relate
what the appellant did after Laxmibai's death. To
Anant
describe it summarily, the appellant did not give any
Chintaman Lagu
one the information of Laxmibai's death but on the
v.
contrary, represented that she was alive and moving
The State of
Bombay
about from place to place and in the meantime misappropriated most of her moneys.
Sarkar].
I will now give some details of his activities in
relation to Laxmibai's moneys. It will be remembered
that about November 8, the appellant had taken from
Laxmibai a notice to the. Bank for withdrawal of
money and a withdrawal slip, none of which bore any
date. The appellant inserted on the notice of withdrawal the date November 15, 1956, and lodged it in
the Bank on the same day or soon thereafter. On the
withdrawal slip he inserted the date November 19,
1956, and on November 20, presented it to the Bank
and drew out a sum of Rs. 5,000 from Laxmibai's
account. He subsequently put in to the credit of her
account diverse cheques and by April 1957, had drawn
out by forging her signature practically the whole
amount m her credit totalling about Rs. 10,000
including the sum of Rs. 5,000 withdrawn on November 20, 1956. The appellant also embarked on a
systematic course of forgeries of the signature of
Laxmibai on various fabricated documents, including
share transfer deeds, as a result of which, before the
end of 1957, he misappropriated a large part of the
liquid assets .belonging to Laxmibai's estate. When
some of the forged signatures of Laxmibai had been
doubted by the ;uthorities to whom they had been
presented with the object of being acted upon, the
appellant even went to the length of getting a woman
to falsely impersonate Laxmibai before a Magistrate
and thereby procured the latter to certify forged signatures of Laxmibai as genuine sig1;atures. He also
clandestinely denuded Laxmibai's fiat of its entire
contents. None of her ornaments has been recovered
-after her death. In the meantime, he had been falsely
representing to various persons, including all friends
and relatives of Laxmibai, that he had met her on
several dates after November 13, when she was already
r959
<
•
-.
'
-
S.C.R. . SUPREME COURT REPORTS
533
I959
dead. He manufactured various letters purported to
be written by her from distant places in India and
Anant
addressed to her relatives in Poona stating that she
Chintaman Lagu
was going round on a pilgrimage. Eventually, he
v.
fabricated letters purported to have been written by The State of
her to her relatives in which it was stated that she had
Bombay
married cine Joshi and had settled down in a place
Sarkar].
called Rathodi near Jaipur and did not intend to
return to Poona. There is in fact no place of the name
of Rathodi. His idea in :rn.anufacturing these letters
was to create a false impression in the minds of
Laxmibai's friends and relatives that she was still
alive and this he did with the object of gaining time
to misappropriate her properties. It is not necessary
to go into the details of this part of the conduct. The
substance of it is that he made full use of the situation
arising out of Laxmibai's death to misappropriate by
all kinds of dishonest means most of her properties
and to facilitate the misappropriation assiduously
spread the story that she was alive. It may be stated
that the appellant was put on his trial on charges of
misappropriation and other allied charges and found
guilty and sentenced to imprisonment for life.
The long absence of Laxmibai had gradually made
her relatives grow suspicious about her fate and they
approached the police but no trace of Laxmibai could
be found. Several petitiOns were sent to the higher
police officers and also to the Chief Minister of Bombay.
In the end, the matter was entrusted ·to Mr. Dhonde,
Deputy Superintendent of Police, C. I. D., Poona, for
enquiry. Mr. Dhonde made various investigations
and eventually on March 13, 1958, interrogated the
appellant. The appellant then told him that he had
taken Laxmibai to the G. T. Hospital, Bombay, and
admitted her there, and that she died there on November 13, 1956. The police made enquiries at the G. T.
Hospital and was able to find the clothes which
Laxrilibai wore when she died. These were identified
by Laxmibai's relations. The photograph of the dead
body of Laxmibai also helped to prove her identity.
After certain furthe,r enquiries, the police sent up the
68
/
•
.
534
.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS ~1960 (2))
appellant for trial on a charge of murder of Laxmibai
with the result I have earlier mentioned.
Anant
The prosecution case is that the appellant caused
Chintaman Lagu
the death of Laxmibai by administering to her a poison
v.
1 he State of
which was undetectable. On the evidence in this case
Bombay
it has to be held, as the Courts below have done, that
there are poisons which cause death but are undetectSarkar].
able. I do not wish to be understood as saying that ·
death by poisoning cannot be proved without proof
of detection of poison in the deceased person's system
after his death. I quite agree that the circumstances
may be such that the only reasonable conclusion that
can ,be drawn is that death was an unnatural death.
In this view of the matter, I do not consider it necessary to discuss the cases cited at the bar and in the
judgments of the Courts below. They are all illust.rative of the proposition that a crime can be proved by
circumstantial evidence, a proposition which I fully
accept. In one of them, namely, Regina v. Onufrejczyk( 1 )
guilt was held proved from the circumstances of the
case notwithstanding that there was no body or trace
of a body, or any direct evidence as to the manner of
death of a victim. The legal proposition that arises in
the present case may be put in the words of Wills in
his treatise ~n Circumstantial Evidence which has
been quoted in the judgment of the High Court :
"It would be most unreasonable, ...... and lead
to the grossest injustice, and in some circumstances
to impunity for the worst of crimes, to require, as an
imperative rule of law, that the fact of poisoning
shall be established by any special and exclusive
medium of proof, when that kind of proof is unattainable, and specially if it has been rendered so
by the act of the offender himself. No universal
and invariable rule, therefore, can be laid down;
and every case must depend upon its own particular
circumstances; and the corpus delicti must, like anything else, be proved by the best evidence reasonably
capable of being adduced, and by such an amount
and combination of relevant facts, whether direct or
circumstantial, as to establish th<( factum proband um
'959
{I) [1955] I Q. B. 388•
•
•
S.C.R.
•
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
535
z959
to the exclusion of every other reasonable hypothesis. (7th Ed., p. 385) ".
Anant
In the present cd.se, therefore, the circumstances Chintaman Lagu
v.
must be such that no other conclusion than that
Laxmibai died of poisoning and that the poisol} was The State of
Bombay
administered by the appellant, can reasonably be
drawn. The Courts below have found that the
Sarkar].
circumstances of this case fully establish this. I have
come to a different conclusion. In my view, the
, circumstances are not such that from them the only
reasonable conclusion to be drawn is that Laxmibai
died of poisoning. If that conclusion cannot be drawn,
of course no question of the appellant having poisoned
her arises. I may also say that if Laxmibai could be
said to have died of poisoning, I would have no reason
to disagree with the view of the Courts below that it
was the appellant who had administered the poison.
I proceed now to, consider the question whether
Laxmibai had died of poisoning. I do not suggest that poison had to be found in her system. In my view,
if it could be established in this case that Laxmibai
had died an unnatural death the conclusion would be
inevitaple that that unnatural death had been brought
about by pois8n; no other kind of unnatural death
could be possible on the facts of this case.
The real question in this case then is whether
Laxmibai had died an unnatural death. I think the
Courts below also considered that to be the only
question in this case. I have earlier said that no
poison was detected in the post-mortem examination.
So far as direct evidence of the cause of death goes,
which in this case is all opinion evidence, we have the
evidence of three doctors. All that Dr. Variava said
was that death was not due to diabetic coma. The
Courts below have accepted this evidence and I find.
no reason to take a different view. Then there is
Dr. Jhala, who conduoted the post-mortem examination. He had stated in the port-mortem examination
report that the cause of death was diabetic coma. In
his evidence in Court he said that the opinion stated
in his. report was not based on his pathological findings
and that the proper wiLy of describing the cause of
536
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2))
I959
death would be by stating "death by diabetes with
complications". He also referred to certain complicAnant
Chintaman Lagu ations such as, atheroma of aorta with slight sclerosis
of coronary. In the end he was asked by the Court,
v.
The Slate of
"Would you agree with the view .- . . . . . that the
Bombay
·proper opinion on the pathological data available
before you should have been that the cause of death
Sarkar J.
was not ascertainable or could not be ascertained ?"
·His answer was, "My answer is that on pathological
data I would agree to the answer proposed. We have
however to see the clinical data also. " On the clinical
data he would have said that death was due to diabetes
with complications, but he conceded that that opinion
was somewhat speculative. These two doctors therefore did not suggest that death was due to any
unnatural cause. Dr. Variava did not in his evidence
say that he had directed the post-mortem examination
to be done because he suspected any foul play. It
_would appear that he did not suspect any foul play
for he did not require the case to be marked as a
medico-legal case.
The most important direct evidence as to the cause
of death and on which the prosecution has greatly
relied, is the opinion of Dr. Mehta who appears to be
a medical man of some eminence. All the papers connected with the illnesses of Laxmibai and the postmortem examination report had been given to him and
he had made a thorough study of them. The net result
of this study would appear from his evidence, the
relevant part of which I think it right now to set out.
He said:
"On a careful consideration of the entire material
placed before me I am definitely of the opinion that
the cause of death of Indumati Paunshe as mentioned in the case record and the Coroner's inquest, viz.,
diabetic coma, cannot be true. In my opinion, the
cause of death may probably be due to :
(1) Administration of some unrecognisable poison,
i.e., some poison for the detection of which there are
no definite chemical tests.
·
(2) Administration of some recognisable poison
for which there are chemical tests, but which tests
•
•
-
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
537
could not be obtained on account of deterioration of
z959
the P?ison remainini~ in the. dead bo~y which was
Anant
. kept m the morgue for considerable time after death Chintaman Lagu
without post-mortem being performed and which
v.
was already undergoing decomposition prior to the Th• State of
actual post-mortem examination as is clear from the1
Bombay
absence of rigor mortis. ltigor mortis means stiffenSarkar].
ing of muscles. The above opinion that the probable cause of death may be due to administration of
poison is further fortified by the fact that the postmortem did not reveal any definite pathalogical
I
lesion to account for the sudden rapid death of the
deceased.
r
-
•
-
\-
The question then arises whether she died a
natural death, i.e., due to any other disease or
diseased condition. The post-mortem notes do
not show -anything abnormal beyond congestion of
organs and tubercular focus in the left lung. Congestion of organs occurs in majority of the cases after
death of the person and particularly more so when
so many days' have elapsed between death and postmortem examination. Some decomposition is bound
to be going on.
,
'There is still possibility of death being due to
poison in spite of the fact that the poison was not
detected in the post-mortem examination. Two
reasons can be assigned for non-detection of poison :
(1) There are no definite chemical tests for each and
every poison. There are some poisons which cannot
be detected on chemical analysis. (2) There may be a
recognisable poison in the sense that there are tests
for its detection. But the poison may not be detected
on account of deterioration of the poison remaining
in the body for a considerable time before the postmo~t~m exami.nati.on and it has undergone decomposition or oxidation ....................................... .
The possibility of death being due to poisoning
cannot be ruled out. "
538
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960 (2)]
I do not think that the Conrts below thought that
the
evidence of Dr. Mehta established that death must
Anane
have
been due to an unnatural cause. If they did,. I
Chintaman Lagu
find myself unable to agree with them. The substance
v.
The State of
of Dr. Mehta's evidence is that death may "probably
Bombay
'be due to" some poison," the probable cause of death
may be due to administration of some poison", the
Sarkar].
posibility of death being dne to poisoning cannot be
ruled out. It will have been seen that Dr. Mehta posed
a question whether Laxmibai had died a natural death.
That question he did not answer beyond stating that
the post-mortem examination did not show anything
abnormal beyond congestion of organs and a tubercular
focus in the left lung and that such congestion of
organs occurs in the majority of cases after death.
It is clear that Mr. Mehta could not say with conviction that death had been caused by poisoning nor that
death could not have been due to natural causes. The
net result of the evidence of the medica,l experts is
clearly that it cannot be said with definiteness how
death was caused. In this view, nothing really turns
on the fact that shortly prior to her death Laxmibai
was found to have been in good health; which of course
can only mean as good a health as a confirmed invalid
like her could have. It cannot be definitely inferred
from the fact that she was in good health that she had
not died a natural death. If such an inference was
possible, the doctors who gave evidence would have
given a clear opinion but this they did not.
In this state of the evidence the Courts below have
founded themselves on various circumstances of the
case, most of which I have earlier related, in coming
to the conclusion that Laxmibai had met with an
unnatural death. These circumstances I now proceed
to consider.
The first thing that I wish to discuss is the fact
that after Laxmibai's death the appellant started on
a systematic career of misappropriating her assets. I
am unable to conclude from this that the appellant
had caused her death. It is reasonably possible to
think that he made use of the opportunity that came
his way on Laxmibai's death to misappropriate her
r959
r
,
•
.,
S.C.R.
•
-
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
539
1959
properties and had not caused her death. The fact that
the appellant deliberately kept back the information
Anant
of Laxmibai's death from her relatives and falsely Chintaman Lagu
created the impression in their minds that she was
V.
I
alive, does not advance the matter. This was dearly The State of
Bombay
done with a view to give him time in which to carry
out his scheme of misappropriating her properties.
Sarkar].
I quite concede however tha~ these circumstances
may take on a different colour from otber circumstances, but I have found· no such circumstance .
The next circumstance is the conduct of the appellant in obtaining from Laxmibai her signatures on the
undated notice of withdrawal to the Bank and the
withdrawal slip. The bodies of these documents are
in the handwriting of the appellant. The Courts below
have thought that the appellant obtained the signatures of Laxmibai on blank papers and filled them
in the forms they now stand after the death of
Laxmibai and utilised them to misappropriate her
moneys. They came to this conclusion from the fact
that these documents were admittedly without dates
and had been subsequently dishonestly utilised. It
has been held from this that the appellant had during
her life time a design on her moneys and therefore it
becomes likely that he caused her death. I am unable
to agree with this conclusion. It would be difficult to
hold from the fact that the appellant had a design
on Laxmibai's moneys that he had also a design on
her life or that her death was an unnatural death.
But apart from that there is reason to think that
when Laxmibai signed these documents their bodies
had already been written up. That reason is this.
It will be remembered that on November 12, 1956, the
appellant had put to the credit of Laxmibai's account
in the Bank a dividend warrant in her favour for
Rs. 2,607-6-0. The bala.nce to the credit of her account
on November 12, 1956, became as a result of this
deposit, Rs. 7,882-15. Now it is obvious that if the
appellant had filled in the bodies of the notice of
withdrawal and the withdrawal slip after the death of
Laxmibai he would not have mentioned the amounts
therein as Rs. 5,000 but would have increased it to a
•
540
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2)]
I959
figure nearer the balance because he undoubtedly had
set about to misappropriate the moneys in that
Anant
Chintaman Lagu account and in fact he actually withdrew almost the
v.
entire balance in that account later by forging Laxmi·
The State of
bai's signatures on other appropriate documents.
Bombay
Therefore, it seems to me that the bodies of the notice
of . withdrawal and the withdrawal slip had been
Sarkar j.
written out before Laxmibai put her signatures on
them.
Furthermore, the evidence clearly establishes that
even during Laxmibai's life time the appellant used
to present to the Bank cheques signed by Laxmibai
for withdrawal of moneys and signed on the reverse
of such cheques in acknowledgement of receipt of the
moneys. He also used to deposit moneys in the Bank
to the credit of her account. It is quite possible that
the two documents mentioned had come into the
appellant's possession in the usual course of managing
Laxmibai's banking affairs. The fact that Laxmibai
had not put dates on the documents would indicate
that it was not intended that they would be presented
to the Bank immediately for there is no reason to
think that Laxmibai had not noticed that the docu.
ments did not bear any date. She seems to have been
quite a capable woman managing her own affairs well.
The Courts below have thought that there was no
need for her to have wanted to withdraw such a large
amount. The appellaint said that she wanted to invest
· the money in some fixed deposit which would have
yielded a higher return but he actually lent it to a
friend whom however he refused to name. The Courts
below have disbelieved the appellant's case. Even so
it does not seem to me possible to hold that Laxmibai
did not want to withdraw any moneys and the appellant had fraudulently got her to put her signatures on
blank papers. I have earlier given my reason for this.
It was not necessary for the appellant to have got her
to sign blank papers and there is nothing to show that
she would have done that even if the appellant had
asked her.
I may here mention that no adverse inference can
be drawn from the fact that the appellant put in the
•
•
-
•
S.C.R.
•
..
-
'
't-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
541.
dividend warrant to the credit of Laxmibai's account :
z959
it proves no guilt. But it is said th11t the appellant
A
1
forged the name of Laxmibai on the back of it. The Chinta~== Lagu
High Court thought that this forgery proves that the
v. · •
appellant had during the lifetime of Laxmibai enter- The State of
tained the intention to misappropriate her property.
Bombay
I am wholly unable to see how that conclusion could
Sarkar].
be reached from this 6r how in fact the forgery proves
anything against the appellant. By the forgery, as it
is called, the appellant was putting the money into the
account to which it lawfully belonged; he did not
thereby give it a different destination. Furthermore,
he need not have signed her name himself. In the
normal course Laxmibai would have signed it herself
if asked to do so and given it to the appellant for
being sent to the credit of her account. There is no
reason to think that she· would not have signed it if
the appellant had asked her to do so. The dividend
warrant was in Laxmibai's favour and had been drawn
on the Bank of Maharashtra. It was being put to her
credit in the same Bank. The Bank was therefore
not likely to scrutinise with any care the payee's
· signature on the dividend warrant. That may have
been the reason why it was left to the appellant to
sign Laxmibai's name on the dividend warrant for
putting it into the Bank. But whatever view is taken,
I cannot see how it helps at all in solving any question
that arises in this case. The trial Court found it a
riddle and did not rely on it.
Next, it is said that the appellant falsely denied
that he travelled in the same compartment with
Laxmibai on their journey to Bombay. The denial
:was no doubt false. But it had been made at the
hearing. He had admitted to the doctors at the
hospital and to the Poona police on November 16,
1956, that he and the deceased had travelled in the
same compartment. This falsehood therefore does
not establish that the death of Laxmibai was an unnatural death, a question which I am now investigating. The fact that they travelled in the same
compartment may no doubt have given him an
opportunity to administer poison to her and to that
extent it is of 9ourse relevant,
6~
••
542
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(2)]
It is also said that there was a hospital called
A
St. George's Hospital within a few yards of the
Chinta~::' Lagu Victoria Terminus Station but the appellant took the
•
v.
unconscious Laxmibai to the more distant G. T.
The state of
Hospital with an ulterior purpose. That purpose it
Bombay
is said was that in the G. T. Hospital his friend
Dr. Mouskar, was the Resident Medical Officer and
Sarkar.].
the appellant wanted to secure his help, if necessary,
in preventing the discovery of the crime that he had
committed. The appellant said that he chose the
G. T. Hospital as he was familiar with it but not with
the St. George's Hospital. This seems to me to be
too insignificant a thing. The St. George's Hospital
was no doubt very near, but the G. T. Hospital was
not very far away either. There is nothing to show
that the appellant knew that Dr. Mouskar was on duty
on the day in question. There is neither any evidence
to show how much the two were friendly or how far
Dr. Mouskar would have gone to help the appellant.
Furthermore, as the appellant had administered a _
poison which was undetectable, it is not clear what
help he anticipated he would require from Dr. Mouskar.
Again, he must have known that as the Resident
Medical Officer, Dr. Mouskar Waf! not in charge of the
treatment of patients in the hospital but only performed administrative functions and that the unconscious Laxmibai would have to be treated by other
doctors. It cannot be said that if these other doctors
found anything wrong, Dr. Mouskar could have done
much to help the appellant. So it seems to me impossible to draw any inference against the appellant
from the fact that he had taken the unconscious
Laxmibai to the comparatively distant G. T. Hotpital.
It is then pointed out that when Laxmibai was
admitted to the G. T. Hospital, she had no ornaments
on her person and no moneys with her and even her
bag anq bedding had disappeared. It is suggested that
the appellant had removed them and that this again
proves that he had conceived the idea of misappropriating her properties even during her life time
which supports the theory that he caused her death.
Now the beddin~ and ba~ can be dismissed a,t once,
r959
•
•
-
·s.c.R.
•
-
-
•
-•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
543
There is no evidence as to what they contained. They
r 959.
were of small sizes. It is reasonable to think that in
Anant
the bag Laxmibai had taken a few wearing apparels Chintaman Lagu
which she might need for her stay in Bombay which
v.
the evidence shows she thought would not be of more T"Ji St~te of
than four days. The box and the bedding must,
om ay
. therefore, have been of very insignificant value. As
Sarkar J.
regards ornaments, the evidence is that usually she
wore certain ornaments which might be of some
value. None of the witnesses, however, who saw her
the day she left Poona, has said that they found ornaments on her person. It is not at all unlikely that as
she was going to Bombay and was not sure where she
would have to put up there, she had as a measure of
safety, taken off the ornaments she usually wore,
before she left Poona. Then again, if the appellant
had taken off the ornaments from the person of
Laxmibai he must have done it in the train or while
taking her to the hospital. Now it is too much to
assume that in the compartment in which they were
travelling there were no other passengers. The removal of the ornaments would have been noticed by the
other passengers or if done later, by the stretcher
bearers or the taxi driver. None of these persons
was called. Neither is there any evidenee that any
search for them had been made. Therefore, it seems
to me that on the evidence on record it cannot be
said definitely that the appellant removed any ornaments from the person . of the unconscious Laxmibai.
With regard to the money, she must have brought
some with her to meet her expenses in .Bombay. It
is more than likely that she had entrusted the moneys
to the appellant for safety which the appellant never
returned. There is no evidence that she had more
than Rs. 50 with her and there is no reason to think
that she was carrying a large sum. The disappearance of the money does not prove that the appellant
had conceived the design of getting rid of her.
Then we find the appellant describing Laxmibai in
the• Hospital by the name 'Indumati Paunshe '. It is
said he did this to prevent her identity being discovered after her death and that this shows that he had
•
544
SttPREME COURT REPORTS [1960 (2)]
already poisoned her and knew that she was going to
die. Now, so far as the name Indumati is concerned,
Anant1
that
was one of her names. The papers that the
Chintaman Lagu
appellant
maintained in connection with Laxmibai's
v.
treatment show that he mostly called her by that name
The State of
Bombay
and never called her Laxmibai. He said that he was
used to calling her by her maiden name of Indumati
Sarkar].
Ponkshe and gave that name -to Dr. Ugale by sheer
force of habit. Dr. Ugale however said that as he did
not follow the surname he asked the appellant -to spell
it and took it down as spelt, namely, as "Paunshe ".
The Appellant denies that he gave the name Paunshe
but says he said" Ponkshe ". The appellant's version
receives support from the fact that the hospital clerk
who also took down the name for another record of the
hospital as the appellant was giving it to Dr. Ugale, took
it down as "Indumati Pankshe ". Therefore, there is
some doubt whether Dr. Ugale heard the name correctly. However that may be, I doubt if the name Paunshe
indicates that the appellant gave it with a view to
prevent disclosure of identity. It is said that his plan
was to disappear after Laxmibai's death so that her
body would become unclaimed and be disposed of as
such. If that were so, then nothing would turn on
the name. lt is only when people came to know that
a woman of the name of Indumati Paunshe had died
that the question as to who she was would have
arisen. In view of the fact that the appellant had
. given Indumati's address as care of himself at Poona,
it would be known that she belonged to Poona. I am
very doubtful if an enquiry made at Poona for Indumati Paunshe would have kept back the real identity.
Indumati or Laxmibai had disappeared mysteriously;
her maiden name was Ponkshe. People interested in
her would surely have been led by the name Indumati Paunshe to enquire if it was Laxmibai Karve.
So it seems to me that if the appellant had really
wanted that the woman he took to the hospital should
never be discovered to have been Laxmibai, he would
have used a totally different name. I am unable to
hold that the use of the name " Indumati Paunshe "
is any clear evidence of the guilty intention of the
appellant. In this connection I have tp refer to the
x959
•
'
S.C.R.
--
•
-
-.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
545
r959
appellant's letter of November 14, 1956, to the G. T.
Hospital in which he pointed out that in the hospital
record the name had been taken down as " Pannshe " Ck. 1Anant L
that is, with an extra " n " and this should be correct- in am;n agu
ed. By this time the appellant had clearly conceived The State of
the idea that the news of the death of Laxmibai
Bombay
should be prevented from becoming public. He had
Sarkar],
also misled the hospital authorities by informing
them that Indumati's brother would arrive to take.
over her body ; as already stated, she had no brother.
Therefore this attempted -correction in the name by
deleting the extra " n " is really irrelevant; the extra
"n" would not in any event have made the discovery
of the identity of the dead person easier. What led
the appellant to make this attempt cannot however be
ascertained.
.
Then I have to consider the fact that the appellant
told Dr. U gale that Laxmibai had become unconscious
of a hysterical fit and she had a history of similar
• atpacks before. It is said that this story about
hysterical fit is false and had been conceive<!! to hide
the fact that she had been poisone<l. · The appellant
had denied that he had mentioned hysterical fit to
Dr. Ugale and said that he had only stated that she
had suddenly become unconscious. That he had
mentioned sudden onset of unconsciousness in the train
is admitted by Dr. U gale. It is somewhat curious
that the appellant would have mentioned both
" hysterical fit" and · "patient suddenly became
unconscious in the train". It is significant that
"hysterical fit" was entered in the case paper by
Dr. Ugale under the head "Provisional Diagnosis"
a thing, for which I think, the doctor in charge has
some responsibility. It may also be stated that
Dr. Anija did not say that the appellant mentioned
hysterical fit to her. In these circumstances I have
some doubt if the appellant had in fact mentioned
"hysterical fit" to Dr. Ugale.
I will however proceed on the basis that the appellant did mention hysterical fit to Dr. Ugale. Now,
there is evidence that for nine years upto 1948 Laxmibai had suffered from hysterical fits. There is no
•
546
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(2))
I959
evidence one way or the other whether she had such
fits
thereafter. If she had not, the prosecution could
Anant
have
easily produced evidence of it. The only evidChintaman Lagu
v.
ence on which the prosecution relied was that of
The State of
Laxmibai's son, Ramachandra. All that he said was
Bombay
that between 1943 and 1948 his mother suffered from
and that in 1956 when he had come to Poona for
fits
Sarkar].
his marriage his mother was not suffering from fits.
Now, Ramachandra does not appear to have much
knowledge of his mother's health. He did not even
know what kind of fits these were nor that his mother
suffered from diabetes. Apart from the nature of his
evidence, it has to be remembered that he was living
separtely from his mother since 1946 and was away
from Poona since 1952. It cannot therefore be said
that it would have been improbable for the appellant
to have thought that Laxmibai had a relapse of a
hysterical fit.
I now come to the fact that the address of Laxmibai given by the appellant to the hospital authorities •
was his own address. It is said that he did so
deliberately to ensure all communications concerning
her from the hospital coming to him ; that he knew
that Laxmibai was going to die and wanted that
nobody else would know of her death. I find some
difficulty in appreciating this. I do not see what
communication could be addressed by . the hospital
authorities to Laxmibai after her death or when she
was lying ill in the hospital. Further there was no
other address which the appellant could have giveri.
Laxmibai lived alone in her flat and when she was ·
away, there would be no one there to receive any
communication addressed to her at that address.
Her only son Ramachandra was away from Poona.
She was clearly more friendly with the appellant than
with her other relatives, none of whom was a very
near relative. In these circumstances and particularly
as he had taken Laxmibai to Bombay it seems only
natural that he would give his own address. Again
if he had given Laxmibai's own address, that would
have served his purpose as well for he had a room in
her house and because of his friendly relation with
•
>
•
-(
-
-
S.C.R.
-
•
.,
J
•
....
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
547
I959
Laxmibai, would have been in charge of her :fiat ill
her absence as he in fact was. It would not have been
Anant
difficult for him.to ensure that any letters that came Chintaman Lagu
for Laxmibai would reach him. He could also have
v.
given an entirely falee name and address and disap- The State of
Bombay
peared from the scene altogether; the body of Laxmibai would then, whether there was post-mortem .Sarkar].
examination or not, have been disposed of in due
time as an unclaimed body and nobody would have
ever known what had happened to Laxmibai. Indeed,
it is the prosecution case that this was the appellant's
plan and things happened just as he had planned and
that is why he deliberately brought Laxmibai to the
hospital and gave his own address. What strikes me
is that this plan would have worked with any false
address given. I am therefore unable to think that
the fact that the appellant gave his own address is a
circumstance which can be reasonably explained only
on the hypothesis of his guilt.
I come now to the most important circumstance
on which the Courts below have strongly rested
their conclusion. It is said that the endorsement
made on the hospital case paper reading "Asked for
post-mortem " under the direction of Dr. Varia va had
been crossed out and undor the heading " Cause of
death " in that paper the entry "diabetic coma" had
been interpolated. The Courts below have found that
it is the appellant who had procured these alterations
to be made with the help of his friend Dr. Mouskar.
If this is so, then no doubt it would be a very strong
circumstance pointing to the guilt of the appellant for
the only reasonable explanation of this act would be
that he wanted to prevent a post-mortem examination
which might reveal that Laxmibai had been poisoned.
As I have already said, the alterations had no doubt
been made. But in my view, there is no evidence
whatever to show that the appellant had anything to
1
do with them.
Before I state my·reasons for this view, it is necessary to set out the relevant evidence on this point.
Dr. Anija admits that she made the alterations but
ehe says that iiihe did it in the$e circmpst1;1.uces : Aftef
•
548.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(2)]
she had made the endorsement " Asked for postmortem " on the case paper, she asked the sister in
Anant
Chintaman Lagu charge of the ward to send the case paper to Dr.
Mouskar whose duty it was to do the needful as
v.
The Slate of
regards the post-mortem examinatfon, and herself
Bombay
followed Dr. Variava on a round of the wards, which
took her about an hour. About 12-30 p.m. she proSarkar].
ceeded to Dr. Mouskar's office to make enquiries as to
when the post-mortem examination was to be held.
She met Dr. Saify, the Registrar of Unit No. 1 of the
hospital in which Ward No. 12 was included, outside
Dr. Mouskar's office. Dr. Saify had the case paper in
his hand and he told her that Dr. Mouskar thought
that there was no need for holding a post-mortem
examination as the case had been treated as one of
diabetic coma and also asked her to cancel the direction about the post-mortem examination and to show
in the column meant for cause of death, " Diabetic
coma". As Dr. Saify was her official superior, she
accordingly carried out his directions and made the
alterations in the case paper as required.
I will now refer to Dr. Mouskar's evidence on this
aspect of the case which was as follows: The case
paper relating to Laxmibai came to his office at 1 p.m.
on November 13. At that time the endorsement
" Asked for post-mortem" was still there and diabetic
coma had not been shown as the cause of death.
There was arrangement in the hospital for postmortem examination but he did not proceed to arrange
for it immediately as on the face of it it was not a
medico-legal case nor a road-side case. It was the
in variable practice to ask for the permission of the
Coroner for holding the post-mortem examination in
all ·cases but before doing so it was necessary in nonmedico-legal cases to get the permissiop of the relatives
of the deceased for holding the post-mortem examination. In that view of the matter at 2 p.m. he sent the
telegram to the appellant at his address as appearing
in the case paper. He never met the appellant in the
hospital. On the next day, that is, November 14, about
4 p.m. he wrote to <the police to remove the dead body
to ther air-conditioned morgue in the J. J. Hospital
'959
-
'
•
.
-
S.0.R.
<
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
549
I959
for better preservation as no reply to the telegram had
been received till then. He sent a copy of this letter
Ananl
to the Coroner. On the morning of November 15, Chinlaman Lagu
somebody from the Coroner's office rang him up and
v.
asked him about the final diagnosis. He thereupon Th• Stats of
Bombay
sent the case paper through a ward boy to Unit No. 1
with an oral message either to the Honorary physician,
Sarkar J.
the Registrar or the Assistant Houseman as to whether
they were able to tell him about the final diagnosis and
whether they still insisted on post-mortem examination. He did this as there was no final diagnosis
uptil then and as the physicians often changed their
minds in a non-medico-legal case. After about half an
hour the case paper came back to him and he found
that the final diagnosis had been stated as "Diabetic
coma" and the endorsement "Asked for post-mortem"
had been crossed out. He then wrote out the death
certificate and sent it to the Coroner.
The' Courts below have disbelieved both Dr. Anija
and Dr. Mouskar as to their respective versions regarding the manner in which the case paper had been
altered. It has to be noticed that apart from the
evidence of these two doctors, there is no other
evidence on this question. The Courts below have
held that the alteration was made by Dr. Anija at the
·direction of Dr. Mouskar and that Dr. Mouskar had
been persuaded to give that direction by the appellant
whose friend he was, on a representation that he, the
appellant, was the patient's old family doctor and
knew the case to be one of diabetic coma and that it
would save the family humiliation if the dead body
was ne>t cut up for a post-mortem examination. They
also held that the alteration was made on November 13, soon after the death of Laxmibai and before
the appellant had left Bombay for Poona. They have
further held that Dr. Mouskar got the alteration made
as a friendly act for the appellant and that he was in
no way a conspirator in the crime. There is no direct
evidence to support this finding but it has been inferentially arrived at from the evidence of these two
doctors.
The reasons on which this finding is based may be
thus stated: (a) Dr. Mouskar was an old friend of the
•
•
550
I959
Anant
Chintaman Lagu
v.
The State of
Bombay
Sarkar].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960 (2)]
appellant; (b) both Drs. Anija and Mouskar had lied
with regard to this part of their evidence; (c) Dr.
Mouskar's conduct after the death of Laxmibai and
his evidence in court showed that he wanted to assist
the appellant; (d) Dr. Anija being very much junior
to Dr. Mouskar had been pr.evailed upon by the latter
to give false evidence; and (e) lastly, that no one
excepting the appellant could have been interested in
avoiding the post-mortem examination.
As to the first reason, the only evidence on this
question is that of Dr. Mouskar. All that he said was
that in 1934 he and the appellant had studied Inter
Science in a college in Poona together and that he had
stayed in Poona for three different periods, namely
1922-26, 1931-36 and 1948-51. He also said that while
studying together he had come to know the appellant
by name but had never talked to him and had never
come in contact with him since 1934. The Courts
below have disbelieved the later part of the evidence
of Dr. Mouskar and have held that he and the appellant were friendly. This finding does not seem to me
to be based on strong grounds. No reason has been
given as to why Dr. Mouskar should be disbelieved.
The prosecution led no evidence to show that the two
were friendly. No witness has been found to say that
the two were seen talking to each other in the hospital.
It has not been noticed that the difference in age
between the two was twelve years.
I will take the next three reasons together. They are
that Drs. Anija and Mouskar had both lied and that
the conduct and the evidence of Dr. Mouskar showed
that he wanted to help the appellant and lastly, that
Dr. Anija gave false evidence only as she dared not
estrange Dr. Mouskar who held a much higher position. There is no doubt that Dr. Anija told lies. The
first lie was that she had tested the urine at 6-30 a.m.
for acetone. She also interpolated into the case paper
an entry showing that she had found acetone in the
urine which she said she examined at 6-30 a.m. Dr.
Variava said that he took her to task for diagnosing
the case as diabetic coma without having tested the
urine for acetone, which she told him she had not
done, and that the .entry in the case paper showing
•
~-
•
-
s.c.R.
•
-.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
551
r959
that acetone had been found on the first examination
of urine was not there when he saw it at about 11 a.m.
Anant
The second lie which Dr. Anija said was that she put Chinlaman Lagu
through a telephone call to Dr. Variava about 7 a.m.
v.
and told him about the symptoms she had found and The State of
Bombay
that she had been giving insulin. She said that
Dr. Variava agreed with her diagnosis and asked her
Sarkar].
to continue the treatment she had started. That this
is untrue, will appear from the fact that Dr. Variava
deniec;l that this talk had taken place. Dr. Variava's
recollection is supported by the fact that on arrival at
the hospital he doubted if the case was of diabetic
coma and the treatment given was the correct one.
Further, there is a call book in the hospital on which
telephone calls made by the house physicians are
entered. There is no entry there showing a call having
been made by Dr. Anija on Dr. Variava. The third
lie that she said was that it was Dr. Saify who told
her outside Dr. Mouskar's office to make the alteration
in the case paper. It has been clearly established that
Dr. Saify was not on November 13 in Bombay at all.
He was then on leave and in Indore.
I come now to Dr. Mouskar. No part of his evidence
has been directly found to be false. The Courts
below have disbelieved him on improbabilities. The
first improbability they found was in Dr. Mouskar's
explanation that he did not arrange for the postmortem examination immediately as he considered the
permission of the Coroner and the relatives of the
deceased necessary before holding the post-mortem
examination and that this was the invariable practice
in non-medico-legal cases. I do not know why it should
be said that this practice is improbable. The prosecution did not lead any evidence to show that there was
no such practice as spoken to by Dr. Mouskar. That
the Coroner's permission had to be taken would be
borne out by the fact as appearing in the correspondence, that the police asked the Coroner to hold an
inquest as the cause of death was not known. The
Courts below referred to the telegram that Dr. Mouskar
sent to the appellant at about 2 p.m. on November 13
and observed that if Dr. Mouskar had delayed the
post-mortem examination only in order t? obtain the-
•
552
,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2)]
consent of the relatives, then the telegram would not
have asked the appellant to arrange for the removal
.Anant
Dr. Mouskar said that he had
Chintaman Lagu of the dead body.
intended to ask for the permission to hold the postv.
Tho Stale of
mortem examination when the appellant a,ppeared on
B<»nbay
receipt of his telegram. The Courts below have not
accepted this explanation. It does not seem to me
that this explanation is so absurd that it must be
rejected. No other view would fit in with the circumstances of the case. This I will explain now.
It has to be remembered that the finding of the
Courts below is that Dr. Mouskar was not in any sense
a conspirator with the appellant in the crime. The
learned Advocate General of Bombay, who appeared
for the respondent, also made it clear that he did not
suggest that Dr. Mouskar was in any conspiracy. On
the evidence on the record it would be impossible to
hold that Dr. Mouskar was in any conspiracy with the
appellant. There is no reason whatever for him to
have done that. There is no evidence of such friendship between the appellant and Dr. Mouskar from
which it can possibly be inferred that Dr. Mouskar
would have become a party to secreting a diabolical
crime committed by the appellant. The trial Court
expressly held, " I do not think that at that time
Dr. Mouskar realised that there was anything suspicious about the death of Laxmibai, nor do I think that
he was aiding or abetting the suppression of truth by
cancelling the post-mor_tem examination." The High
Court also took the same view. We then come to this
that if Dr. Mouskar had procured the cancellation of
the direction for post-mortem examination, he had
done so without thinking that there was anything
suspicious about the death of Laxmibai, and only to
oblige his friend, the appellant, by saving the family
of the deceased from humiliation by cutting up her
body. Now that being so, when Dr. Mouskar got the
direction cancelled at the appellant's request, he would
naturally expect the appellant to take charge of the
_body and to remove it for cremation. Evidently, the
appellant had disappeared for otherwise Dr. Mouskar
would not have sent him a telegram to Poona. What
would have been the normal reactions then of an
19.!9
•
•
•
-
S.C.R.
r
·<
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
z959
innocent man in Dr. Mouskar's position? He would
have been very much surprised. He would have
Anant
thought that he had been let down. lt is not too much Chintaman Lagu
to think that he would have grown suspicious. As an
v.
innocent man, as he has been found to be, the only The State of
Bombay
thing he could then possibly have done was to have
restored the direction for post-mortem examination
Sarkar].
and to proceed to take steps to have it held. I cannot
imagine that an innocent man in such circumstances
would have acted otherwise. It will be remembered
that the appellant's reply to the telegram was not
received for over two days and in the meantime
Dr. Mouskar did nothing in the matter. I find it
impossible to hold that Dr. Mouskar, innocent as he
was, would have waited all this time and done nothing
about the post-mortem examination at all. It would
have been impossible for him then to have asked if
the doctors in charge of the case still wanted a postmortem examination as he actually did. If he was
not a party to any conspiracy with the appellant, I
cannot think it possible for him to have sent the telegram to Poona asking the appellant to remove the
body after he had been innocently made to obtain a
cancellation of the direction and found that the appellant had disappeared. I may also add that if the
appellant had duped Dr. Mouskar and procured him
to obtain a cancellation of the direction for postmortem examination, it would be extremely unlikely
for him to have taken the risk of disappearing from
the hospital without making any arrangement for the
•
disposal of the body for then he could not be sure
whether the post-mortem would be held or not. It
would have been more natural for him to have taken
over the body and cremated it. That would noli have
affected his design, as alleged by the prosecution, to
have evidence of the natural death of Laxmibai
created and to have kept back the knowledge of her
death from her relatives. I therefore think that the
· telegram instead of showing that Dr. Mouskar had
already obtained a cancellation of the direction for
post-mortem examination rather indicates that that
direction had not till then been cancelled as is Dr.
Mouskar's own evidence. This makes the explanation
•
554
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960 (2))
I959
of Dr. Mouskar as to why he sent the telegram a very
probable explanation.
Anant
Now, there are other things which would support
Chintaman Lagu
Dr. Mouskar's evidence. On November 14, about 4 p.m.
v.
Ths Stale of
he wrote to the police intimating them that a Hindu
Bombay
female named Indumati Panshe who had been admitted into the hospital on November 13 at 5-45 a.m. for
Sarkar],
treatment of hysterical fits had died the same day at
11-30 a.m. He further stated in that letter that a
telegram had been sent to the address given at the
time of the admission of the patient but without a
response and requested that the dead body might be
removed to the J. J. Hospital morgue. This would
indicate two things. First, that Dr. Mouskar was
surprised at having received no answer from the
appellant to his telegram and that being so, if he had
been innocently induced to get the case paper altered,
he would not have permitted the alteration to remain
there. The second thing it shows is that Dr. Mouskar
even in the afternoon of November 14 referred to
hysterical fits as the illness of the patient. This would
be impossible if the prosecution case is true, namely,
that at about 1 p.m. on November 13, Dr. Mouskar
had procured Dr. Anija to state in the case paper that
the .cause of death was diabetic coma.
The next thing that the Courts below have found
against Dr. Mouskar is that his story of having received
a telephone call from the Coroner's office on the morning of November 15 asking for the final diagnosis of
the case was unbelievable. I find no reason to
disbelieve Dr. Mouskar. His evidence is strongly
supported by the death certificate which he issued on
that date stating diabetic coma as the cause of death.
There is no reason to think that Dr. Mouskar would
have issued this certificate on the 15th unless he had
been asked about the cause of death. Furthermore,
the police on that date had actually wanted to know
the cause of death as will appear from their letter of
November 15. If the police could ask, I do not see
why the Coroner's office could not. In that letter the
police asked Dr. Mouskar to send per bearer the cause
of death to enable them to dispose of the dead body.
I have earlier referred to this letter. It is on a copy
-
S.C.R.
'
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
555
I959
of this that the endorsement " biabetic coma,
Dr. N. S. Variava, G. T. Hospital" had been made.
Anant
There is no other explanation as to why Dr. Mouskar Chintaman Lagu
v.
sent the death certificate on this date and not on any
other date. Indeed, if he was under the impression The State of
Bombay
that the appellant or a relative of the deceased would
come and take charge of the body for cremation, as
Sarkar].
the prosecution case must be, then he would not have
issued the death certificate for that was wanted .only
to enable the police to dispose of the dead body.
Therefore it seems to me likely that Dr. Mouskar had
been asked by the Coroner about the cause of death.
Now if he was so asked, it does not strike me as wholly
improbable that he asked the physicians in charge
whether they were then in a position to state the cause
of death or still insisted on a post.mortem examination. It has to· be remembered that till then no
suspicion attached to the case. Dr. Mouskar said that
he had seen the physicians change their opinion in
such matters and had therefore asked whether a postmortem examination was still required. It has also to
be remembered that Dr. Mouskar had no knowledge
that the direction for post-mortem examination had
been given by Dr. Variava. All that he knew was
that such a direction appeared over the signature of
Dr. Anija. It does not seem to me improbable that
Dr. Mouskar on being asked by the Coroner to state
the cause of death would have enquired of the physicians in charge about it. If this version is not true,
then the only other probable theory would be that the
alteration in the case paper had been made at l p.m.
on November 13, which as I have earlier said, cannot
be accepted in view of the telegram and. the other
records in this case. It was also said that· Dr. Mouskar's
version cannot be accepted for it was not possible for
him to make enquiries about the cause of death
through a ward boy. I think this would be too
insignificant a ground for disbelieving Dr. Mouskar.
I may now deal with the letter of the police dated
November 15 to Dr. Mouskar asking for the cause of
the death. It will be remembered that this letter was
sent along with a copy of it and on the copy the
enclorse:rnent ":Pi!'l.betic com~. Dr. N. S. Vari~va,
556
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960 (2)]
G. T. Hospital" had been made. Dr. Mouskar denied
that these letters ever came to him. The Courts below
Anant
Their view is
Chintaman Lagu have been unable to accept his denial.
that it is Dr. Mouskar who got the endorsement set
v.
The State of
out above, to be made and is falsely denying it. I am
Bombay
unable to appreciate why Dr. Mouskar should falsely
deny
it. He was innocent. He had on that date
SaYkar ].
issued the death certificate. He could easily have
admitted the fact, if he had made the endorsement or
got it made. Now it seems to me that there is no evidence that the letter was poduced before Dr. Mouskar.
In normal course, as spoken to by police Inspector
Kantak, who had written this letter, the original
would have been retained at the office of Dr. Mouskar
and only-the copy would have come back to the police
with an acknowledgment of the receip~ of the original
endorsed on it. That did not happen. Both the copy
and the original were received back by Kantak. The
bearer who was sent to deliver the letter was not
called. There is therefore no evidence whatever that
the letters were actually delivered or what had actually
happened. On the cor.itrary, the return of both copies to
the police would show that they had not been delivered to Dr. Mouskar for if the letter had been deliver- .
ed, then there is no reason why Dr. Mouskar would
not have given a formal reply to it stating that diabetic coma was the cause of death. He would have
had no difficulty in doing so because on the same day
he sent the death certificate mentioning diabetic coma
as the cause of death. He had no reason to take to
subterfuge and to get the words "Diabetic coma. Dr.
N. S. Variava. GT. Hospital" written on the copy by
somebody. It would therefore appear that there is no
reason to disbelieve Dr. Mouskar when he said that he
had not received the letters and had nothing to do
with the endorsement made on the copy of the letter.
What might have happened was that the death certificate having been earlier issued, some clerk in the
office returned these letters and by way of ·an informal
communication of the cause of death made the endorsement on the copy. It may be stated here t' .J.t Dr.
Anija admitted to the police that the words "Diabetic
coma" in the endorsement h11d been written by her
I959
'
'\
•
'
-
.-
S.C.R.
•
.
'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
55'1
but in court she denied that she had written them. This
z959
is another instance which makes me greatly doubt her
A .
veracity. It may be that she had written the words Chinta:a":'Lagu
•tDiabetic coma" and got some one else to write out
v.
the rest of the endorsement.
The Stats of
I come now to the last fact which the Courts below
Bombay
have thought fit to disbelieve, in the evidence of Dr.
Sarkar].
Mouskar. I have earlier mentioned that when Laxmibai
was lying unconscious in Ward No. 12, Dr. Anija had
sent for the Registrar. Dr. Anija stated that the
Registrar whom she sent for was Dr. Saify. This is
untrue for, as I have already said, it has been proved
clearly that Dr. Saify was not in Bombay at all . on
' that day. Now it appears that the hospital kept a ·
call book in which a House Physician wanting to call
the Registrar would make an entry and send it to the
Registrar. This call book was produced on September 2, 1958, and it showed that Dr. Anija had herself
written down the name of Dr. Shah as the Registrar
whom she was calling. What therefore had happened
was that Dr. Saify being away on leave to the knowledge of Dr. Anija, she had sent the call to Dr. Shah.
This call book conclusively proves that Dr. Anija's
statement that she had been told by Dr. Saify, the
Registrar, to make the alteration in the case paper is
false. Dr. Mouskar had said in his evidence that he
could not trace this call book. The Courts below have
thought that he was lying and was deliberately
preventing this call book from coming to light so that ,
Dr. Anija might n6t be contradicted by her own writing that it was Dr. Shah whom she had sent for which
in its turn would show that her story that,_ it was
Dr. Saify who had asked her to make the alteration in
the case paper was false. Now Dr. Mouskar's evidence
was concluded on August 25, 1958, and he had retired
from the office of the Resident Medical Officer on
August 14 preceding. Dr. Aniia's evidence was taken
down on August 18 and August 19, 1958. I do not
see why if the call book was considered to be of that
importance, the police could not produce it after Dr. ·
Mouskar had left office. It was actually produced
from the hospital and must have been lying there all
the time. The next thing to be noticed is that there is
558
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(2)]
nothing on the record to show that Dr. Mouskar was
interested in establishing that Dr. Saify was on duty
Anant
on November 13 and therefore prevented the call boo!r
Chintaman Lagu
from being produced. In fact, Dr. Mouskar in his evidv.
The State of
ence about Dr. Saify stated that "he was not working
Bombay
in the hospital on the 13, 14 and 15 November. I think
also
that he was not staying in his quarters during that
Sarkar j.
period and I did not see Dr. Saify on these days at
all." Therefore, there is no basis for suggesting that
Dr. Mouskar deliberately prevented the production ·of
the call book. I may here state t>hat there is nothing
in the evidence of Dr. Mouskar which goes to show
that he was supporting Dr. Anija in any of her lies.
The Courts below have excused the lies of Dr. Anija
in the view that she had told them as she dared not
estrange Dr. Mouskar. Again, there seems to me to
be no basis for this finding. There is nothing on the
record to show that Dr. Anija expected anything from
Dr. Mouskar or would have been in any difficulty if
she had told the truth even at the risk of putting
Dr. Mouskar in a difficult situation. There is no
evidence that Dr. Anija had any talk directly with
Dr. Mouskar concerning the case of the unconscious
Laxmibai and therefore she could not and did not
directly contradict anything that Dr. Mouskar said.
Again, it is clear from the evidence that Dr. Ariija had
left the hospital on January 31, 1957. She had worked
there without any remuneration. There is no evidence
that she had anything to do with the hospital or its
Resident Medical Officer, after she had left the
hospital. Again, on the date that Dr. Anija gave
evidence, Dr. Mouskar had already retired from his
office at the hospital. In these circumstances, I find
no justification for the conclusion that Dr. Anija
had lied only out of fear of Dr. Mouskar. I might
also point out that the only lie in Dr. Anija's
evidence which the Gourts below thought she said
out of fear or at the persuasion of Dr. Mouskar was
her/ statement that it was Dr. Saify who had told
her that Dr. Mouskar had wanted the direction as to
post-mortem examination crossed out and diabetic
coma written as the cause of death. I have earlier
stated that Dr. Mouskar has gone against this part of
'959
•
'
•
s.c.R.
•
--
SUPREME COt1R'l' REPORTS
5o9
-Dr. Anija's evidence by saying that Dr. Saify was not
r959
in Bombay on the day in question. It is clear thereA
1
fore that it was not Dr. Mouskar who had wanted that Chinta:C.a: Lagu
Dr. Anija should interpose Dr. Saify between him and
v.
her in the matter of the direction for altering the case The State of
paper. Further, if Dr. Mouskar really wanted that
Bombay
Dr. Anija should put the blame for the alteration on
Sarkar J.
somebody else, then Dr. Anija would not have mentioned that Dr. Saify told her that Dr. Mouskar had
wanted the alteration. She would simply have said
that it was at Dr. Saify's order only that she made
the alteration or put the responsibility on Dr. Shah.
The Courts below have been unable to explain why
Dr. Anija brought in Dr. Saify.at all. I think this is
capable-of an explanation as I will show later. The
net position therefore is that Dr. Anija was clearly
lying; there is no clear proof that Dr. Mouskar had
lied at all. On the contrary, his evidence and conduct
would seem to be consistent with the contemporaneous
record and there is no material on which it can be
found that Dr. Anija told the lies as she was afraid of
Dr. Mouskar.
· I come now to the last reason on which the Courts
below found that it must have been the appellant who
procured the alteration in the case paper. It has
been said that no one else W!\-S interested in getting
that done. I take it that this does not mean a finding
that the appellant was interested in getting the
alteration made for then of course his guilt would
already have been assumed. What it means is that if
it is not possible to find reasonably that any one else
was interested in getting the alteration made, then it
would fit in with the theory that the appellant had
committed the crime and therefore was interested in
getting the alteration made: The real question is,
can it be reasonably said on the evidence that there
was no one other than the appellant who could be
interested in getting the alteration made ? I think it
-cannot. On the facts established and without making
any assumption one way or the other, it seems to
me very probable that it was Dr. Anija who was
interested in preventing the post-mortem examination
and therefore in making the interpolations on the case
paper. I will now state my reasons for this view •.
1
060
SUPREME COtJRtr REPORTS
[1960(2)]
I have earlier stated that Dr. Anija examined the
urine of the patient at 6-30 a.m. on November 13.
Ananl
There is an entry with regard to it in the case paper,
Chintaman Lagu
which
reads 'Sugar + + + Albumin-Acetone + + '.
v.
There is little reason to doubt that Dr. Anija did
The State of
Bombay
examine the urine at that time for sugar, for otherwise
she was not likely to have started the insulin injecSarkar].
tions. She gave two of these, one at 6-30 a.m. and
the other at about 9 a.m. Dr. Variava's recollection
is that when the case paper was shown to him about
11 a.m. the entry "Sugar + + + Albumin-" was
there but the entry "Acetone + + '" was not there
and that Dr. Anija told him that she had not examined
the urine for acetone. The entry " Acetone + + " was
clearly interpolated in the case paper later. It was
because she had not tested the urine for acetone but
had none the less started the treatment for diabetic
coma that Dr. Variava had taken her to task and
asked her to test the urine for acetone. All this
clearly shows that Dr. Anija had interpolated the entry
"Acetone + + " at some later time. The trial Court
thought that Dr. Mouskar having invented the theory
of diabetic coma "must have also thought it necessary
to make entries regarding the presence of acE;Jtone + +.
in the case record" to support this false diagnosis.
This is nobody's case. Such a finding would necessarily mean that Dr. Mouskar was in conspiracy with
the appellant to hide the crime by creating evidence
in support of natural death of the patient. The findings of the trial Court that Dr. Mouskar was innocent
and that he had procured Dr. Anija to make the entry
"Acetone + + " cannot stand together. The latter
finding must be rejected as it is purely inferential.
The High Court did not find that the entry "Acetone
+ +" had been made by Dr. Anija at the persuasion
of Dr. Mouskar. But it appears to have taken the
view that Dr. Anija having been induced by Dr.
Mouskar to state diabetic coma as the cause of death,
herself incorporated before the papers were submitted
to the Coroner an entry with regard to the examination of the urine in the case paper and in that entry
included" Acetone++". Whether the High Court is
right in its view that the entire entry as to the result
I959
'
'
1
-
s.c.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
561
of urine test at -6-30 a.m. of November 13, 1956, had .
z959
been made in the case paper later is a matter which I
.
need not discuss. The only question is who made the Chinta~::'Lagu
entry " Acetone + + " and when. I may state here
v.
that the papers were sent to the Coroner at the time of The state of
the post-mortem examination, namely, on NovemBombay
ber 22, -1956. According to the High Court, therefore,
Sarkar].
the entry " Acetone + + " had been made by Dr.
Anija on her own and Dr. Mouskar had nothing to do
with it and that Dr. Anija made the entry not at about
· 1 p.m. on November 13, 1956, when she crossed out
the direction for post-mortem examination and wrote
out diabetic coma as the cause of death but almost
nine days later. The High Court did not· accept that
part of Dr. Mouskar's evidence where he said that he,,
was positive that the entry "Acetone + + " was in the
case paper when it reached him at 1 p.m. on November 13. Earlier he had said that he had not read the case
paper fully when it first came to him. Dr. Mouskar
was plainly making a mistake. It is nobody's case that
it was then there. Even on the prosecution case it was
added sometime later, that is, when after the receipt
of the case paper Dr. Mouskar had. been persuaded
by the appellant to procure a cancellation as to the
· direction for post-mortem examination. We then come
to this that the entry "Acetone + +" had been made
by Dr. Anija on her own. If she did this, she must
have had some reason for it. I cannot imagine that
reason being anything else. excepting to create evidence
in support of . her diagnosis of diabetic coma. The
next lie which Dr. Anija spoke and which I wish now
to refer, is the false story of her telephone talk with
Dr. Variava at about 7 a.m. She said that she then
informed Dr. Variava about the condition of the
patient and that she had started insulin injection and
further that Dr. Variava told her to continue the
treatment.· I have earlier said that this statement
was a clear falsehood and given reasons for this view.
lt is nobody's case, and it could not be, that Dr.
Mouskar had asked her to tell this lie. Why then
did she do so ? Again, the only p9ssible r.eason that
. I can think of is the same that I have given earlier,
namely, that she was keen on creating evidence in
support of the line of treatment that she had given'to
562
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2)]
the patient. She had been treating the patient as a
case of diabetic coma. It is · clear from her evidence
Ananl
Chintaman Lagu and of course from that of Dr. Variava, that he had
reprimanded her for adopting that line of treatment
v.
The State of
without having tested the urine for acetone. She had
Bombay
clearly made a mistake in the treatment of the case
and
this might have put her in a difficulty with the
SaYkar ].
hospital authorities and also in her future professional
career. It was clearly her interest to see that her
mistake was not finally established as a result of the .
post-mortem examination which had been directed by
Dr. Variava. In these circumstances, she was under
a great temptation to prevent the post-mortem examination which might have revealed her mistake. It
, must be remembered that she had just started on her
professional career and was a very young person.
I am unable therefore to hold that apart from the
appellant there was no one else who could have been
interested in crossing out the direction as to postmortem examination and inserting diabetic coma as
the cause of death. In the circumstances that I have
mentioned, it seems quite probable that Dr. Anija had
made the alteration in the case paper entirely on her
own and to save herself from the possible effects of
her mistake. It also seems probable to me that Dr.
Anija had made the alterations on November 15, when
Dr. Mouskar had sent the case paper through the
ward boy for ascertainment of the cause of death.
I have earlier said that Dr. Anija had falsely
introduced Dr. Saify as the person who had told her
that Dr. Mouskar had wanted the direction as to postmortem examination to be crossed out and diabetic
coma to be stated as the cause of death.· I have also
said that Dr. Mouskar did not support Dr. Anija as
to the presence of Dr.·Saify in the hospital on the day
in question. Why then did Dr. Anija introduce the
name of Dr. Saify? I have said that the Courts below
have not been able to find any explanation as to why
Dr. Anija introduced the name of Dr. Saify. It seems
to me that when the alteration which she had made
on her own, was found out in the course of the investigation, she had to give some explanation as to why
she had made it. She thought of saying that she did
it under the orders of Dr. Mouskar who was very
I959
•
'
8.0.R.
•
·---J.
---~
--.-:
--
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
568
much her senior and whom she was bound to obey.
z959
But she also realised that Dr. Mouskar was sure to deny
Anant
that he had asked her to make the alteration and as Chintaman Lagu
against his, her evidence was not likely to be acceptv.
ed. It was. therefore that she hit upon· the. idea of The State of
interposing Dr. Saify in between her and Dr. Mouskar
Bombay
in the hope that Dr. Saify being also a very young
Sarkar .
1
person, there was some chance of her evidence being
accepted as against his. Apart from that there does
not appear to be any other explanation as to why
Dr. Anija introduced the name of Dr. Saify. She had
clearly forgotten while inventing this story -that Dr.
Saify was away on leave but that of course makes no
difference for if she had remembered it, she might
have named somebody else, probably Dr. Shah or Dr.
Patel who worked in Unit No. 2 of the Hospital. Then
it has to be remembered that Dr. Anija admitted to the
'
police that she had written out the words " Diabetic
coma" on the letter from the police of November 15,
asking for the cause of death and this she later denied.
AU this would make more probable the view that it
was Dr. Anija who in order to prevent the detection
of the mistake made by her in the treatment of
Laxmibai had the endorsement "Asked for post- mortem" crossed out and inserted in the case paper
diabetic coma as the cause of death and that she
had not been asked by Dr. Mouskar to make the
alteration in the case paper.
I think it right to state here that it cannot be said
that Dr. 'Shah was also to blame for the wrong
diagnosis of diabetic coma. Dr. Anija said that
pursuant to her call the Registrar came at about
8-45 a.m. and approved of her diagnosis and advised
a further insulin injection of 40 units. She also said
that the Registrar wrote on the case paper th_e words
"Inj. Insulin 40 units Iv. glucose 20 c.c." -By "the
Registrar " she was of course referring to Dr. Saify. It
is clear from the call book that it was Dr. Shah, who
was the Registrar of Unit No. 2 who had been sent
for by Dr. Anija. Dr. Shah said in his evidence that
he must have gone to the patient pursuant to the call
but he had no recollection of the case at all. He
denied that the entry "Inj. Insulin 40 units Iv. glucose
~O c,c." w&.s in his h&ndwriting. Dr. Patel who was
564
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960 (2)]
officiating as the Registrar of Unit No. 1 in the absence
of Dr. Saify on leave, also denied that that entry was
Chinta;:.":'Lagu in his handwriting. Dr. Shah said from the sequence
v.
of time noted iu the call book and the case paper, that
The State of
he must have gone to the ward before 6-30 a.m.
Bombay
According to Dr. Shaw he could not have seen the
case paper when he called because he was not the
Sarkar].
Registrar of Unit No. 1. He admitted that he must
have advised Dr. Anija about the case. What the
advice was we do not know. It is clear however that
Dr. Anija had started treating the case as diabetic
coma and given 40 units of insulin before she sent for
the Registrar. Indeed according to her, the Registrar,
who must have been Dr. Shah, arrived at 8-45 a.m.
So we get that Dr. Anija started treatment of diabetic
coma and gave insulin prior to 6-30 a.m: - and her
statement that the Registrar wrote down the direction
for a second insulin injection of 40 units at 8-45 a.m.
is false. It is therefore clear that the treatment given
to the unconscious Laxmibai had been under the
judgment of.Dr. Anija alone. It would follow that Dr.
Shah had no responsibility for that treatment. This
is also supported by the fact that Dr. Anija did not
tell Dr. Variava that Dr. Shah had also thought it to
be a case of diabetic coma.
'
There is another circumstance against the appellant
which must now be noticed, and that is that the appellant left the hospital soon after the death of Laxmibai
without showing the least care as to what happened
thereafter. This conduct considered with ·the appellant's Jetter of November 14, 1956, stating falsely that
"lndumati's" brother would come to take over her
body and further considered with the subsequent conduct of the appellant in fraudnlently misappropriating the deceased Laxmibai's money clearly indicates
that immediately after the death of Laxmibai the
appellant had conceived the idea of misappropriating
her properties. It has been suggested that it would
be somewhat strange that the dishonest intention
cropped up in the appellant's mind so suddenly and
therefore it is reasonable to think that he had entertained that design even during the lifetime of Laxmibai. The Courts below have accepted that suggestion.
I cannot say that that is an unreasonable view to take.
r959
A
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
565
I959
But supposing the appellant had during Laxmibai's
lifetime cast a covetous eye on her properties, would
Anant
that be enough to justify a finding that her death had Chintaman Lagu
been an unnatural death ? I do not think it would.
v.
The design may provide a motive for murder; but the The State of
murder, that is, in this case an unnatural death, canBombay
not be proved by it. That design does not exclude the
Sarkar].
possibility that Laxmibai died a natural death and the
appellant made full use of the opportunity thereby
provided to carry his design into effect.
_
I think I should mention-here one other aspect of
the case. The trial Court observed that the symptoms
found in the record as to the last illness and death of
Laxmibai all clearly pointed to the conclusion that
death was due to hypoglycemia and that hypoglycemia
might be one of the possible causes of her death. The
trial Court however held that there was nothing to
show in the symptoms that hypoglycemia could have '
been of spontaneous origin though the matter was not
very clear. It would seem that the trial Court thought
that the hypoglycemia had been induced by two injections of insulin given by the appellant to Laxmibai
sometime on November 12. The trial Court for this
purpose relied on the evidence of Shantabai a maid·
servant employed by Laxmibai, who said that on
November 12, the appellant gave Laxmibai two injections. This maid servant was deaf and dumb and her
evidence must be of doubtful value. However that
may be, there is nothing to show that death was caused
by hypoglycemia brought about by the two injections
given by the appellant, assuming that he had given
them. It has to be remembered that in the hospital
Laxmibai was given two further injections of insulin
of 40 units each. It may be that these injections
really caused her death. That is a possibility which
on the finding of the trial Court cannot be brushed
aside. Now, if that is so, then clearly the appellant
is not responsible for the death of Laxmibai. He had
done nothing to induce Dr. Anija or any of the.other
doctors in the hospital to give more insulin to Laxmibai.
There is no evidence to that effect. Dr. Anija was
clear in her evidence that she never consulted Dr. Lagu
regarding the diagnosis that death was due to diabetic
,,
coma. . I need not go further into this aspect of the ·
•
566
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960 (2)]
matter for all that I wish to point out is that the
trial Court had thought that hopoglycemia might
Anant
be
the cause of dea,th. The High Court thought that
Chintaman Lagu
it
was
not possible in view of the absence of evidence
v.
about
the
time taken for insulin, to induce hypoglycemia
The State of
that
death was due to hypoglycemia induced
to
hold
Bombay
by a massive dose of insulin. It seems to me that
Sarkar J.
if there was no evidence, that was the fault of the
prosecution and not of the appellant. In all cases and
particularly in a case of this kind, it is the duty
of the prosecution to prove that the death. was an
unnatural death a,nd exclude by evidence completely,
the possibility of death having been caused by some
instrumentality other than the appellant. This is
another reason for saying that it has not been clearly
established in this case that Laxmibai's death was an
unnatural death or has been caused by the appellant.
I have so long been discussing the facts which are
supposed to lead towards the guilt of the appellant.
I propose now to deal with some of the facts which
seem to be in his favour. The prosecution case is
that the appellant had in the train administered to her
an undetectable poison which caused her death. Now,
if the appellant had done that, he must have made· a
plan for it befom he started on the journey to Bombay
with her from Poona. It seems unlikely that if he
had done that, he would have made no effort to keep
it a secret that he was .taking her to Bombay. The
evidence is clear that he made no such effort. The
next fact that has to be faced by the prosecution is
that the railway compartment would be a most unusual
place in which to administer a poison. The appellant
could not have expected that there would be a compartment for Laxmibai and himself in which there
would be no other passenger. Indeed the trial Court
thought that there must have been other passengers
in that compartment. That being so, it becomes
improbable that the appellant had planned to poison
her i_n the train. Again, it has been proved as a
fact by Dr. Sathe himself that the appellant had
made an appointment with him for November 13.
Was it necessary for him to have done this if he
knew that Laxmibai would die before the hour fixed
with Dr. Sathe ? Further, if he had administered
'959
1
'
S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
• 567
z959
a poison to Laxmibai, would hejiave taken her to a
public hospital? That would have been impossible
Anant
unless the appellant was perfectly certain that the Chinlaman Lagu
v.
poison was absolutely undetectable. That requires a
great deal of knowledge of poisonous drugs which The State of
Bombay
there is no evidence to think the appellant possessed.
But assume that the appellant was SQ certain that the
Sarkar],
poison would never be detected, why then should he
have worried about the post-morte:qi examination at
all? If it is found that the appellant had not prevented the post-mortem examination being held, there
would be very little on which to base his conviction
for the murder of Laxmibai by poisoning. Nor can it
be said that the appellant was not sure whether the
poison would be detected or not, but none the less took
the risk of taking the unconscious Laxmibai to the
G. T. Hospital in the hope that if any difficulty arose,
he could rely on Dr. Mouskar to help him. There is
no evidence on which we can hold that Dr. Mouskar
would have helped him if any suspicion as to Laxmibai's death having been caused by poision hag arisen .
It has to be remembered that Dr. l\fouskar was not
doing the work of a physician in the hospitaf but was
in charge only of the administration. All these are
very strong circumstances indicating that the appellant
had not administered any poison to Laxmibai on the
train. Very cogent reasons would be required to
dispel the presumption in favour of _the appellant
arising from them. I find no such reasons in the case.
In the net result the circumstances appear to me to
be these. First, the appellant had a design during
Laxmibai's lifetime .to misappropriate her properties.
This only supplies the motive for causing her death
but does not prove that the death which occurred, was
an unnatural death. Secondly, the appellant did not
give to the hospital the correct name of Laxmibai : the
name given however was not such as from ·it her
identity could never have been discovered. Thirdly,
the appellant gave his own address instead of that of
Laxmibai. It seems to me that that was a natural
thing for him to have done in the circumstances
of the case for there would have been no one in
Laxmibai's fiat to receive her letters and there
was no other address which the appellant could have
•
568 •
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(2))
given. Further, the address given necessarily connected the appellant with the last hours of Laxmibai's
Anant
Chintaman Lagu life-a conduct not very probable iri a person who had
brought about her death. The theory that that
v.
The State of
address was given only to ensure that communications
Bombay
from the hospital concerning the dead Laxmibai should
reach the appellant is not very plausible. It is clear
Sarkar J.
that if the appellant had not given his own address,
the only other address he could possibly have given
would have been Laxmibai's address. I am unable to
appreciate what communication the hospital could
have sent to Laxmibai at her address after her death
or when she lay in the hospital. In any event, the
appellant would have had no difficulty in getting hold
of any such communication sent to Laxmibai's own
address. Fourthly, the appellant told Dr. Ugale that
Laxmibai' had had a hysterical fit. It is doubtful
whether he said so, and also whether, if he did, it was
purposefully false. What purpose it served is not
clear. The appellant did not mention hysterical fit to
the doctor in charge of the treatment nor did he do
anythini. to induce her to take a different line of
treatment from that which she had adopted. He did
nothing to induce any idea in her mind as to the cause
of the illness or the disease. In these circumstances
it does not seem possible to hold that hysterical fit had
been mentioned by the appellant to prevent detection
of the fact that Laxmibai had been poisoned. Lastly,
come the series of the appellant's acts from immediately after Laxmibai's death indicating his intention to
acquire her properties and the acquisition thereof by
deception and forgery. These cannot prove that
Laxmibai died an unnatural death. Considering them
all together, I am unable to think that the only
reasonable conclusion possible is that Laxmibai died
an unnatural death.
In my view the prosecution has failed to prove the
guilt of the appellant.
In the result I would allow the .appeal.
BY COURT. In accordance with the opinion of
the majority, the appeal is dismissed.
Appeal dismissed.
I959
J
•
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org