NARAYAN BHAGWANTRAO GOSAVI BALAJIWALE versus GOPAL VINAYAK GOSAVI AND OTHERS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 22 September 1959 | [1960] 1 S.C.R. 773 | 1959 INSC 118
Key facts
- Decided
- 22 September 1959
- Bench
- SUDHI RANJAN DAS*, S.K. DAS, M. HIDAYATULLAH
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 261/1955
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1960] 1 S.C.R. 773
- Neutral citation
- 1959 INSC 118
Text of the judgment
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
S.C.R.
773
NARAYAN BHAGW
ANTRAO GOSA VI
f'
BALAJIWALE
v.
GOPAL VINAYAK GOSAVI AND OTHERS
(S. R. DAS, C.J., S. K. DAS and M. HIDAYATULLAH, JJ.)
Charitable and Religious Trust-Test-Inference drawn from
documents, if and when a question of law-Burden of proof, meaning
of-Admission, evidcntiary value of-Frame of suit-Deity, if a
necessary party-Charitable and Religious Ti•usts Act, z920 (I4 of
z920), s. 5(3).
The question for determination in this appeal, arising out of
a suit filed by the appellant under s. 5(3) of the Charitable and
Religious Trusts Act, 1920, was whether the ancient temple of
Shri Balaji Venkatesh at Nasik and its Sansthan constituted a
charitable and religious trust within the meaning of the Act.
The deity was Swayambhu and revealed itself in a dream to one
Ganapati Maharaj who. at its behest, brought the deity from the
river Tambraparni and installed it in his house. Ganapati's rnn
Timmaya, who removed the deity to Nasik, took the idol to the
courts of Rulers and acquired the properties in suit consisting of
lands and cash. Timmaya's eldest son obrained an extensiv.e
plot of land as a gift from the Peshwa and thereon built a vast
temple with a Sabha Mandap which could accommodate no less
than 600 persons and installed the deity in the first floor with a
staircase leading straight to it. The Hindu public has been
worshipping at the temple for more than 200 years and there was
no evidence to show that they had ever been excluded from it
and any gift had ever been refused. The ceremonies performed
in the temple were appropriate to a public deity. It was admitted
by the sons of Timmaya in Tahanama, executtd by them in 1774·
that the Inam villages were granted for the wor,hip of the deiry
and the temple belonged to the Sansthan, none of t~em having
any share in it. In the Tharav Y adi of 1800, the maintenance
allowance provided by the said Tahanama for the different
branches of the family was described as 'Vetan'. The Inam
Commissioner, functioning under Act II of 1852, recorded the
Inam villages as permanently held Debasthan inams at the
instance of t1.e then Sthanic and on the basis of original sanads
filed by him, reversing the decision of the Assistant Inam
Commissioner who had recorded them as personal inams. Those
sanads were not filed in the suit. In 1931 the appellant published
a history of the Sansthan wherein it was clearly stated that the
Sansthan was not a private or family property but was the
property of the deity, the members of the family being merely
the managers. The deity was not made a party to the suit
although representatives of the Hindu public were joined as
98
r959
September 1111
774
z959
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1))
parties under 0. r, r. 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The
High Court, while it concurred w1\h the trial Judge in holding
Natayan
that the deity was a public deity and that its Sansthan constituted
Bhagwantrao
a public trust, was. however, inclined to hold that some of the
Gosavi Balajiwale
properties might be per>onal properties of the appellant but
v.
refused to grant any such declaration on the ground that no
G11pal
effective decree could be passed against the deity in its absence.
Vinayak Gosavi
It was contended on behalf of the appellant in this court that
the courts belo'v had misconstrued the document and were wrong
in drawing the inferences they did and that the burden of proof
had been wrongly placed on the appellant to prove by positive
evidence that the deity was a family deity and the properties his
private properties.
Held, that the courts below were right in coming to the
conclusion they reached, and the appeal must fail.
A mistaken inference drawn from documents is no less a
finding of fact, if there is no misconstruction of the docnments
and no misconstruction of documents having been proved, the
appellant could not succeed.
An admission is the best evidence that an opposing party can
rely upon, and, although it is not conclusive. is often decisive of
the matter unless it can be successfully withdrawn or proved to
be erroneous.
The expression "burden of proof " means one of two things
(r) that a party has to prove an allegation before it is entitled to
a judgment in its favour, or (2) that the one or the other of the
two contending parties has to introduce evidence on a contested
issue. The question of onus is material only where the party on
which it is placed would eventually lose if it failed to discharge
I
the same. Where issues are, however, joined, evidence is led and
such- evirlence can be weighed in order to determine the issues,
the question of burden becomes academic.
In the present case, if the onus lay on any party, it was
clearly on the appe!Jant to prove by cogent evidence that the
admissions made by his predecessors-in-title and by him were
either erroneous or unavailable and this he had failed to do. The
earlier sanads, admittedly in his possession, not having been
produced and those produced not being in any way inconsistent
with the said admissions or the revenue records, no question of
any misconstruction of documents could arise.
Babu Bhagwan Din v. Gir Nar Saroon, (r939) L.R. 67 I.A. I,
held inapplicable.
Srinivasa Chariar v. Evalappa Mudaliar, (r922) L.R. 49 I.A.
237, applied.
The entries made in the Inam Register prepared under Act I I
of r852, were entitled to great weight and although they could
not displace actual and authentic evidence in an individual case,
it was well-settled that, in absence of such evidence, they must
prevail.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
775
Arunachalam Chetty v. Venkatachalapathi Guru Swamigal,
(1919) L.R. 46 I.A. 204, referred to.
Held, further, that the vastness of the temple, the mode of
z959
Narayan
its construction, the long user by the public as of right, grant of Bh~gwant~ao
land and cash by the Rulers, taken along with other relevant Gosaw Bala;iwale
factors were consistent only with the public nature of the endowGv.
ment.
. opal
•
.
. .
V 1nayak Gosa1
Narayanan v. Hindu Religious Endowments Board, A.LR.
1938 Mad. 209, relied on.
The absence of a dome or Kalas on the temple was not by
itself a decisive factor as to its public/ character, nor was consecration imperative of a deity that was Swayambhu.
Nor is the temporary movement of the idol from place to
place inconsistent with its public character.
Ram Soondur Thakoor v. Taruk Chun~er .Turkoruttum, (1873)
19 Weekly-Reporter 28; Hari Raghunath v. Apantii Bhikajii,
(1920) I.L.R. 44 Born. 466; Prematha Nath Mullick v. Pradyumna
Kumar Mullick, (1925) L.R. 52 I.A. 245 and Venkatachala v.
Sambasiva, A.I.R. (1927) Mad. 465; 52 M.L.J. 288, considered.
The defect in the frame of such a suit resulting from the
omission of the deity as a party to it, cannot be remedied by the
subsequent addition of the representatives of the Hmdu Public as
parties to it, and no effective decree could be passed against the
deity in such a suit.
CIVIL .APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No.
261 of 1955.
Appeal from the judgment and decree dated April 22,
1949, of the Bombay High Court, in Appeal No. 403 of
1945, from Original Decree arising out of the judgment
and decree dated August 14, 1945, of the Civil Judge
Senior Division, Nasik, in Special Civil Suit No. 5 of
1943.
Purshottam Tricumda,s, Mrs. E. UdayaratMm and
S. S. Shukla, for the appellant.
R. GaMpathy Iyer, K. L. Hathi and R. H. DhelJar,
for respondent No. I.
W. S. Barlinge, Shankar Anand and A. G. RatMparkhi, for respondents Nos. 6 and 7.
1959. September 22. The Judgment of the Court
was delivered by
Hrn!.YATULLAH J.-This appeal with a certificate· Hidayatulfnh ./.
of the High Court of Judicature, Bombay, has been
filed against the judgment and decree of that Court
776
SUPREME COUR'l' REPORTS
[1960(1)]
dated April 22, 1949, in First Appeal No. 403 of 1945,
confirming the judgment and decree of the Civil Judge,
Naraya,n
Senior
Division, Nasik, in Special Suit No. 5 of 1943,
Bh agwan rao
.
A
H.
Gosavi Balajiwale de01ded on
ugust 14, 1945. The 1gh Court made a
v.
slight modification in the matter of costs, to which we
Gopal
shall refer later.
Vinayak Gosavi
The plaintiff, who is the appellant here, is the desHidayatullah J. cendn,nt of one Gan pati Maharaj, who was a devotee
of "Shri Venkatesh Balaji ". Ganpati Maharaj died in
1701 at the ripe age of 98. When Ganpati Maharaj
was 72 years old, it was vouchsafed to him in a dream
that an image of Venkatesh Balaji would be found by
him in river Tambraparni in Tirunelveli District. He
found the image, brought it to his house in Junnar
(Poona District) and installed it. The worship of
Shri Venkatesh Balaji was carried on by him, and
when he died, he left behind him three sons and a
daughter. His eldest son, Timmayya, at the time of
his death was 12 years old. Timmayya succeeded
Ganpati Maharaj and lived till 1768, when he died at
the ripe age of 79. During his lifetime, Timmayya
obtained several properties as presents and gifts. The
present suit concerns those properties which are described in the schedules attached to the plaint. The
appellant is the direct descendant of Ganpati in the
eldest male line, and respondents 1 to 4 are the desc.indants from Ganpati's daughter, Nagubai.
On April 23, 1942, the first four respondents made
an application to the District Court under s. 3 of the
Charitable and Religious Trusts Act, 1920 (No. 14 of
1920), hereinafter called the Act, against the appellant
and two others asking that the appellant be directed to
furnish full particulars of the properties and their
application and for accounts of the income as also of
the properties during the three preceding years. The
appellant in reply denied that there was a trust, much
less a public t1·ust, and claimed the idol and the properties as private. He understook to bring a suit
under s. 5(3) of the Act, and the suit out of which the
present appeal arises, was filed on March 21, 1943.
He claimed in the suit three declarations, which were
as follows :
z959
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
777
(1) It may be declared that 'Shri Vyankatesh
z959
Balaji Deity' and 'Shri Vyankatesh Balaji Sansthan'
N
arayan
are not legal trust as al1eged by the Defendants an d Bhagwantrao
their nature also is not such as alleged by the Gosavi BalajitHll
Defendants.
v.
(2) If the court holds that a trust in the matter of
Gopal
'Shri Vyankatesh Balaji Deity' and 'Shri Vyanka- Vinayak Gosavi
tesh Balaji Sansthan' exists, then it may be declar- Hidayatullah ;.
ed that the said trust is not a public one, that the
same has not come into existence for the religious
and charitable purposes and that the Religious and
Charitable Trusts Act (sic.)(No. 14 of 1920) is not
applicable to the same.
(3) It may be declared that the Defendants for
themselves or as the representatives of the entire
Hindu Community have no right and authority
whatever over 'Sri Vyankatesh Balaji Devta' and
Shri Vyankatesh1Balaji Sansthan' and that they or
the entire Hindu Community has no right a.nd
authority whatever in any. capacity whatever to
interfere in the matter of 'Devta: (deity) and
' Sansthan ' or to ask for the ' Yadi ' (list) of the
properties or accounts in respect of the income thereof and to a.sk for reliefs mentioned in prayer claases
of the Miscellaneous Application No. 19 of 1942."
The trial Judge framed eight issues. The first two
involved the declarations sought. Three others concerned the position of defendants I to 4, 6 and 7 in
respect of maintenance, share in the right of customary
worship and management. One issue raised the question whether the liluit was bad because the deity was
not joined and the remaining two were consequential.
The trial Judge decided all the issues against thti
appellant. He held that the suit properties were not
the personal or private properties of the appellant,
that the plp.intiff was estopped from making such a
claim, th.at the deity itself was not a family or private
deity, and that the deity Shri Venkatesh Balaji was
the owner of the properties, and that there was a
public, religious and charitable trust in respect of
them. It was, however, held that the appellant was
entitled as the hereditary &kebait to manage them.
778
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1960(1))
The trial Judge also gave a finding that the first four
Narayan
defendants were e.ntitled to customary wor~hip. an?Bhagwantrao
emoluments as might be fixed by the Pu;adhikaris
Gosavi Balajiwale descended from the eldest branch of Bapaji Buva and
v.
could be removed for failure to perform the duties
Vina~;f~osavi assigned to them. The application unde~ s. 3 of the
Act was held to be competent, and the suit was also
Hidaya1ullah J. held to be bad in the absence of the deity.
In the
result, the trial Judge dismissed the suit, a warding
two sets of costs to the defendants. It may be pointed out that after the suit was filed, a public notice
under 0. 1, R. 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure was
issued and other defendants were joined, representing
the Hindu Community. During the early stages of
the suit, the first four defendants raised the question
whether the deity was not a necessary party to s1,1eh
a :; ;iit, and desired that the deity should be joined,
represented by an independent guamian-ad-litem. This
application was opposed by the appellant, who stated
that inasmuch as his case was.that the deity and the
properties were his personal properties, there was
no need to join the deity because of an averment by
the defendants that the temple was a public one and
the properties were public religious endowments. The
trial Judge after expressing some surprise that the
plaintiff should have taken this stand, acceded to his
contention and did not join the deity as a party. He,
however, warned the appellant by his order that in
case the deit.y was found to be a necessary party, the
suit might have to be dismissed for that reason alone.
Against the decree dismissing the suit, an appeal
was taken to the High Court of Bombay. The learned Judges of the High Court (Rajadhyaksha and
Chainani, JJ.), dismissed the appeal but modified the
order about costs, directing that only one set of costs
be paid to the defendants in the suit. The learned
Judges traced the history of the various properties
and how they were acquired, and concluded that in
respect of some of the properties there was no doubt
that they formed religious endowments of a public
nature, but in respect of others, though they were
inclined to hold that they were personal properties,
'959
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
779
they held that no declaration could be given, since the
z959
deity was not a party to the proceedings. They, however, gran~ed i:" certificate ?f fitness under Art. l::t3 of B/:,,;::~;ao
the Const1tut10n, read with ss. 109 and llO of the Gosavi Balajiwala
Code of Civil Procedure, and the present appeal has
v.
been filed as a result.
Gopal
Before dealir.g with the appeal proper, it is nece,s- Vinayak Gosavi
sary to refer to certain landmarks in the history of Hidayatullah J.
Shri Venkatesh Balaji and this family. As we have
stated earlier, the deity was placed in his house by
Ganpati Maharaj at Junnar in Poona District. Ganpati Maharaj did not acquire any property, but in the
lifetime of his son, the deity was moved from J unnar
to Nasik. A tradition in the family says that this was
the result of a dream by Timmayya, who was warned
that Junnar would be burnt to ashes and the deity
must be removed. Timmayya soon acquainted the
people of the locality with the miraculous powers of
the deity, and not content with this alone, he took the
deity to the Courts of the various Rulers and also from
place to place acquiring the properties in dispute, cash
allowances and gifts. After Timmayya died his eldest
son, Bapaji Buva, obtained a plot of land in. gift from
the Peshwa near the bank of the Godavari river at
Nasik and built a temple on it. The deity was installed
in that temple, and has continued in that abode
ever since. Bapaji Buva had raised a loan for the
construction of the temple, and a substantial portion of
it was paid off by the Peshwa and other Rulers like
Holkar and Scindia. In Bapaji's Buva's time, a large
Sabha Mandap was built in the premises of the temple
. to accomodate about 600 persons at the time of darshan
and worship of the deity.
In 1774 family disputes arose and a Tahanama
(Ex. 121) was executed, whereby the right of management was vested in the eldest male member of the
senior branch of the family, and provision was made
for the maintenance of that branch as well as the
junior branches. Again in 1800, further disputes took
place in the family and a Tharav Yadi (E~ 122) was
drawn up. By that agreement, instead of the cash
allowances for the maintenance of the branches certain
780
59
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(1)]
villages were assigned to them. Next came the Inam
Na,ayan
Commission under the. Bombay Rent-free Estates
Bhagwanfrao Act, 1852 (Born. 11of1852), by which in accordance
Gosavi Balajiwale with the policy laid down by Lord Ben tick, all jagirdars
v.
and inamdars were required to prove the sources of
. Gopal
. their titfo and the conditions on which the jagirs· or
Vsnayak Gosam mams
•
- t ant I nam Comm1ss10ner
· ·
were h el cl • The Ass1s
Hidayatullah J. recorded the grant of the villages under R. 3 of Sch. B.
to that Act as personal inams. Damodar Maharaj who
was then the Pujadhikari or Sansthanik appealed to
the Inam Commissioner, and contended that the
villages were not held a$ personal inams but were
Devasthan inams and could only be recorded under ,
R. 7 of Sch. B. The difference between the two Rules
was that whereas personal inams could be held only
so long as the family survived, Devasthan inams were
held permanently and were to be recorded as such.
The Inam Commissioner accepted this contention, and
caused the entries to be changed from personal inams
to Devasthan inams in respect of the villages.
Damodar Maharaj died in 1885, and was succeeded by
Krishnarao Maharaj, who died in 1893, whose eldest
son, Bhagwantrao Maharaj died in 1900 and was
succeeded by the appellant, during who8e minority the
property was managed by a guardian appointed by
Court. The appellant became major in 1921, and took
over the management of these properties. In 1929,
the appellant caused a history of the deity to be
written and it was published by him. A reference to all
these documents will be necessary hereafter to consider
the argument whether there was a religious endowment of a public nature, or whether the properties in
dispute were privately owned.
,
As pointed out already, the two Courts below have
concurred in holding that the deity was not a mere
fa.milydeityin which the public had no interest, and that
the properties given to the deity constituted a religious
and charitable endowment of a public nature. Ordinarily, such a finding is a finding of fact not open to
further scrutiny by this Court, but the appellant contended that the legal inference drawn from the proved
facts in the case was erroneous and a point of law
'9
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
781
therefore arose. A mistaken inference from documents
z959
is no less a finding of fact, ifthere is no misconstruction
Naraya"
of the documents, and this principle should be applied Bhagwantrao
to the discussion of the documentary evidence in this Gosavi Balajiwale
case, because if there was no misconstruction of the
v.
documents,-the concurrent findings would be not of Gopal Vi~yak
Gosav•
law but of fact and the error, I'f. any, equally of fact.
Both the Courts below have analysed at length the Hi!l,,yatullah J.
documents which number several hundreds, and have
pointed out that there was nothing inconsistent in
them with the contention of the respondents that
there was a religious and charitable endowment of a
public character in favour of the deity. Before us,
the attempt of the appellant was to show that this
conclusion was not correct and that the documents
pointed to grants in favour of individuals for the time
being managing the affairs of a family deity. In
addition to the examination of the documents, the two
Courts below relied strongly against the appellant on
the admissions made by his predecessors-in-title from
1774 onwards. Learned counsel for the /appellant
contended that the documents were misconstrued and
thus, the inference from them in which these so-called
admissions were contained, was exactly the opposite
of what the Courts have deduced. In this appeal,
therefore, all that is necessary is to see whether the
inferences are vitiated by a misconstruction of the
documents as such.
The appellant contended that this was a special suit
under s. 5(3) of the Charitable and Religious Trusts
Act, 1920, and that the burden lay upon the respondents to prove that there was a religious and charitable
trust of a public character in favour of the deity. He
contended that the two Courts below had placed the
burden of proof upon him to show by positive evidence
that the deity was a family deity, and that the properties were his private properties. According to him
the defendants ought to. have proved their case, and
if they failed to prove affirmatively that case, then
the suit ought to have been decreed in his favour.
The expression "burden of proof" really means tw-o
different things. It means sometimes that a party ilJ
119
782
'
959
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(1)]
required to prove an allegation before judgment can
Narayan
be given in its favour; it also means that on a contBha~wanirao
ested issue one of the two contending parties has to
Gosavi Balajiwale introduce evidence. Whichever way one looks, the
v.
question is really academic in the present case,
Gopal
becanse b oth par t'1es have m
· t ro d uce d their
· ev1'd ence
GosVinayak
.
""'
Hidayatullah J-
on the ques~ion of the nature. of the deity and the properties and have sought to establish their own part of
the case. The two Cburts below have not decided the
case on the abstract question of burden of proof; nor
could the suit be decided in such a way. The burden
of proof is of importance only where by reason of not
discharging the burden which was put upon it, a party
must eventually fail. Where, however, parties have
joinea issue and have led evidence and the conflicting
evidence can be weighed to determine which way the
issue can be decided, the abstract question of burden
of proof becomes academic. ·
In the present case, the burden of proof need not
detain us for another reason. It has been proved that
the appellant and his predecessors in the title which he
claims, had admitted on numerous occasions that the
public had a right to worship the deity, and that the
properties were held as Devasthan inams. To the
same effect are the records of the revenue authorities,
where these grants have been described as Devasthan,
except in a few cases, to which reference will be made
subsequently. In view of all these admissions and
the revenue records, it was necessary for the appellant
to prove that the admissions were erroneous, and did
not bind him. An admission is the best evidence
that an opposing party can rely upon, and though not
conclusive, is decisive of the matter, unless successfully
withdrawn or proved erroneous. We shall now
examine these admissions in brief and the extent to
which they went and the number of times they were
repeated.
The earliest admission that the property belonged
to the Devasthan and that there was no private
ownership is to be found in the Tahanama (Ex. 121) of
the year 1774. This Tahanama was entered into by
the sons of Timmayya Maharaj in the presence of
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
783
Pancha.s long before the present dispute arose. It is
.c959
stated there that "Shrimant Pant Pradhan and other
N
Sardars of (both) Nizam and Deccan (States) have Bha;;:~;ao
granted in Inam villages for the purposes of Seva Gosavi Balajiwal•
(worship) of Shri (deity)." It was again stated that
v.
the Shri's temple which was newly built on the banks Gopal Vinayak
of the river Ganga (Godavari) belonged to Shri's
Gosavi
Sansthan and nobody had a share therein. By the Hidayatullah J.
Tahanama, the three brothers set a part a certain sum
for the Seva (worship) of the deity in accordance with
their practice which sum was not to be diminished
under any circumstance. They, however, took a small
portion of the income as their own N emnuk (maintenance), which N emnuk was to be reduced if the income
was not sufficient to meet the expenses of Shri (deity).
Learned counsel for the appellant stated that the
Tahanama was misconstrued by the two Courts below.
He contended that this was a private temple, and if
anything could be spelt out from this document, it
was that the three brothers constituted a private
trust in favour of the deity. According to him, the
brothers were dividing the income which was theks.
into two parts, namely, (1) for the Seva of the deity
and (2) for their maintenance. This, in our opinion,
is a strained reading of the document as a whole.
This deity was " Swayambhu " and not a consecrated
idol. If none .of the members of the family had any
interest in the Shri's temple or any shares in the properties thereof, obviously the properties were not
private properties, nor the idol a family idol. The
document clearly shows that the deity was regarded
as the owner and the family were its servants. This
is made clear by the subsequent document, which is
the Tharav Ya.di of 1800; the N emnuk allowance which
the members of the family had taken out of the income
was described as Vetan (remuneration) for, doing service
to the deity and " Sansar Begmi " for themselves. The
use of the word " Vet,an " does not indicate ownership,
but on the contrary, paid service. Even as far back
as 1774 to 1800, the predecessors of the appellant considered themselves as the servants of the deity, and all
that they did was to make a stable arrangement for the
784
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(1)]
application of the funds, so that the deity could enjoy
its own property and the servants were regularly pa.id.
Bhawantyao
When the Inam Commission was established to enGosavi Balajiwale quire into the jagirs and inams which ha.d passed into the
G
';;· . k territory of the East India.Company, Act No. 11 ofl852
1
op~ 0 ,;:•>a was passed. The Ina.m Commission purported to be
established under tha.t Act and for purposes of enquiry
Hidayatullah J. as laid down under that Act. The Assistant Inam
Commissioner at that time held tha.t the inam was a
personal one, and ordered that it be recorded as such.
This was in the years 1857 to 1859. Damodar at that
time went up in appeal to the Ina.m Commissioner,
complaining against the record of the ina.ms as persona.I, and claimed that they should be recorded as
Devastha.n ina.ms. His appeal is Ex. D-643 . dated
March 5, 1858. He stated therein tha.t the moka.BB
Amal and the jagfr and Sardeshmukhi in the villages
were granted " for the expenditure on account of the
Shri ". He relied on the Sana.ds, in which it was
stated that the .Amals (revenue shares) were for the
purpose of worship and N aivedya (food offering) to the
Devasthan of Shri Venkatesh. He referred to the
earlier documents to which we ha.ve referred, a.nd
claimed tha.t the order of the Assistant Inam !Jommisioner was erroneous, because the ina.ms must be
recorded in the name of the deity under R. 7 of Sch. B
to the Act of 1852 and not under R. 3, as was ordered
by the Assistant Inam Commissioner. We ha.ve
already pointed out the different effect of the two
Rules, and proviso (6) to R. 7 stated that no personal
ina.m could be recorded permanently under R. 7. The
effect of this appeal was to claim on behalf of the
deity a. perma.nent recognition of its rights to the
inam properties without any share on behalf of the
family, apart from remuneration such as the Pujadhikaris might from time to time settle, in accordance
with the Tahanama and the Tharav Y adi of the earlier
times. The Inam Commissioner acceded to this
contention, and after examining all the Sana.ds that
had been produced in the case, ordered that,
" the order issued by Meherban, Assistant Ina.m
Commissioner be annulled and under Section 7 (Bic.)
z959
Na•ayan
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
785
Supplement No. 2· of Act 11 of 1852 the remaining
z959
portion of this village .. ·. to remain as perpetual
N
Inam with the Devasthan of Shri yyankatesh... Bha;;::;ao
and the management do ·remain continued from Gosavi Bijlajiwal1
generation to generation of the lineal c\escendv.
ants with the male descendants of Timaya ,Gosavi Gopal Vinayak
bin (i.e. son of) Ganesh Gosavi and Apatia bin (~.e.
Gosavi
son of) Konher Gosavi."
Hidaya11'Uah .
1
The effect of all these documents therefore was to get
recognition in invitum of the right of the deity as the
owner. It also indicated that in the family of Bapaji
Buva there were the hereditary Puja4kikaris or
Sheba.its of the deity who were not entitled to anything more than reasonable remuneration for their
services of the deity,
In the year 1907 when the plaintiff 'was still a
minor, his mother made a deposition as a witness.
She stated that. there were Annackatra and Sadavarat
Kulkarni Inams and other Ina.ms, but that they all
belonged to the Sansthan, and that there was "no
private (or personal) property a.tall". Even the gardens
were described by her as belonging to the deity and
not to any individual. The guardian alSo took the same
stand throughout the minority of the plaintiff. Even
earlier, in 1899 the father and uncle of the present
appellant stated that the village,. Savergaon, one of
the items of the properties of the Devasthan, was not
in the private mynership of any person. It was stated
on this occasion as follows :
"Except this Shri Vya.nka.tesh deity no one else has
anyright; interest or ownership with regard to the
village andthe Sansthan. We both are the managers of the aforesaid Sansthan and we have been
looking after all the affairs of the Sanstha.n and in
that collJlection we a.re carrying on the management
of the aforesaid vill!'lige."
The statement was made in Suit No. 515of1898~
Again, .in Ex. 700, the written statement hy the guard,ia.n of the plaintiff, in Civil Suit No. 295 of 1920, it
was stated as late as November 6, 1920, as follows:
"It is denied that Da.modar Timmayya or any
other " particular individual owned the Balaji
786
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[f960(1))
Sansthan at any time in his individual capacity.
The temple of Balaji belongs to the Sansthan and
Narayan
several
villages are granted to Balaji Sansthan
Bhagwanlrao
purely for temple purposes by Sanads granted by the
Gosavi_Balajiwale
v.
British Government and the Defendant's family is
Gopal Vinayak
appointed only the vahiwatdar."
Gosavi
The said Damodar Timaya had no separate property
of his own."
Hidayatullah J.
To the same effect is the application made by Rama.bai, the mother of the present appellant, in Ex. 702.
These later documents may n:ot bind the appellant,
who was a. minor at the time, but as late as December 1, 1927, the appellant himself stated tha.t village
in question (Savergaon) wa.s a Deva.sthan ina.m, and
was alieIJ.ated to the deity, Shri Venkatesh, who was
the owner. . He also referred to the family settlement
of 1801, and stated that the other villages were also
similarly given to the deity. He observed that
in the case of Devasthan inam the idol was the grantee
a.nd the real owner, and since the property had to be
managed by a human being, the so-called manager
therefor managed the villages on behalf of the deity.
He claimed only to be the manager of the village for
and on behalf of the deity, Shri Ba.Jaji, and did not
claim any private ownership. At that time, he refer.
red to the Land Alienation Register and produced a.
certified copy of the Register to show that Shri
Venkatesh wa.s shown a.s the alienee.
Ex. 634 is the genealogy filed by the plaintiff wherein Bhagwant Annaji, uncle of Damoda.r Timma.yya.,
wrote against the name of Timmayya. that he ha.d
acquired nine villages, and wa.s the founder of Puja
Naivooya, Utsav, Annachhatra and Badavarat dedicated
to Shri Venka.tesh. It wa.s stated there that the
villages were grants to the deity. Similar a.re the
admissions in the Yadi, Ex. 626 dated December 15,
1886, by the Mamlatdar addressed to Krishna.ra.o
Damoda.r and in a letter, Ex. 199, by the plaintiff
himself addressed to Ma.nkarnika.ba.i, wife ofKrishna.rao Damoda.r in 1922. In several suits which others
filed, the defendant there wa.s described a.s " Shri
I959
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
787
Venkatesh Balaji Sansthan, N asik, through manager"
r959
that is the appellant. He represented as manager the
NrJrayan
owner, namely, the deity.
Bhagwantr1Jo
Lastly, there is the history of this Sansthan publish- Gosavi Balajiwale
ed by the appellant himself and written from original
v.
documents supplied by him. This was in 1931. The GopalGosavi
Vinayak
appellant in his deposition admitted that he was intimately connected with this writing and its publication. Hidayatullahf.
This history is Ex. 642. It gives an account of the
idol and the temples, and describes how from time to
time Peshwas and various Sardars granted villages to
the" Shri" and dedicated them to the deity. The conclusion alone need be stated, because the document is a
long one and the admissions are contained in numerous
places in it. This is what was stated ;
"The reader of the present history will have
observed that the sansthan belongs to the deity and
(the members of the house of) Timaya Maharaj a.re
merely the managers and administrators of the
same .............. .
The management of it shall not be like that of a
private property."
As a result of the Faisa.lnama.s of the Inam Commission which are to be found in Exs. 135 to 144, 634and
644, the record of rights showed the deity as the owner
and the jagirs and inams as Devasth~.n. Learned
counsel for the appellant contends that these admissions do no prove anything more than this that the
entire establishment of Balaji Mandir was described as
a Sansthan and the ownership thereof was in the members of the family. We cannot accept this contention,
which runs counter to the plain tenor of tho.se documents. In these documents, the ownership of the
family over the temple, the deity and the properties
of the deity is not only not admitted but is denied. On
the other hand, the assertion always has been that the
members of the family were merely the servants of the
deity getting remuneration for their services and that
the ownership vested in the deity and none other.
In view of these admissions, the question of burden
of proof, as we have already pointed out, is really
788
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1000(1)]
academic, and if any burden lay upon any party, it
was upon the appellant to displace by cogent and conBnag;anirao
vincing evidence that these admissions were erroneous
Gosavi Balajiwale and. need not be accepted in proof. These admissions
v.
are two-fold ; they concern the nature of the properGopal YinayllA ties in dispute and the nature of the idol.
Added to
Gos•vi
these are the decisions of the Inam Commissioner in
Hidayatullah 1. respect of the villages, which .were recorded as Devas-·
than inams at the instance of Damodar, who appealed
against the order to record them as personal ina.m.s.
The value to be attached to the decisions of the Inam
Commissioner had come up for consideration before
the Judicial Committee in a series of cases. It is sufficient to refer to only one of them. In Arun1J,Cke1J.am
Oketty v. VenlcatackeU.apatki Guru Swamigal ('), the Judi~
cial Committee while dealing with the Inam Register
for the year 1864 which had been produced for. their
inspection, attached the utmost importance to it. It
observed:
" It is true that the making of this Register was
. for the ultimate purpose of determining whether or
not the lands were tax-free. But it must not be
forgotten that the preparation of this Register was
a great act of State, and its preparation ·and contents were the subject of much consideration under
elaborately detailed reports and minutes. It is to be
remember,ed. that the Ina.m Commissioners through
their officials made enquiry on the spot, heard evidence and examined documents, and with regard to
ea.ch individual property, the Government was put
in possession not only of the conclusion come to as
to whether the land was tax-free, but of a statement
of thti history and tenure of the property itself.
While their Lordships do .not doubt that such a
report would not displace actual and authentic evidence in individual cases; yet the Board, when ·such
is not. available, cannot fail to attabh the utmost
importance, as part of the history of the· property;
to the infol'mation set forth in the Inam Register."
The natul'e and quantum Qf the right and interest in
the land was thus gathered from the Inam Rej!isters
r.nd enquiries, which ·preceded the;m.
z959
N• •r•n
(1) (1919) 1..R. 46 LA. ""f·
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
789
Thus, it was doubly necessary for the appell~nt to
r959
bring before the Court all the documents in which his
n
title was created, recognised
. or confirmed. . Hef has, BhNaraya
agwan1rao
however, filed only a selection, and has reframed rom Gos,,,vi Balajiwala
bringing into evidence all the material in his possession
v.
which as late as 1931 was available to him. We have Gopal Vinayak
pointed out above that in 1931 he caused a history
Gosavi
of the Sansthan to be published, and it refers to Hidayatullah 1.
numerous documents, which have not found their way
into Court. The learned Judges of the High Court
also menti tDed this fact, and stated that in view of
the failure of the appellant to prove conclusively that
a higher title than the one made out before the Inam
Commission was available to him, no reliance could be
placed upon such doruments as had been exhibited.
We have to see whether this statement is correct in all
the circumstances of this case.
The property in the case consists of eleven villages,
ca.sh allowances and other urban properties to which
separate reference will be made. All the eleven villages were the subject of an enquiry by the Inam Commission, and the decisions were uniform, except in one
case where a technical ground came in the way. We
were taken through documents relating to two such
villages as indication of the kind of title enjoyed by the
appellant. It may be pointed out here that the appellant himself made no distinction bet.ween one property
and another, and stated that all the properties were
held by him under an identical title. At the hearing
of the appeal, he attempted to show that these properties were granted to him, impressed with service of the
deity. But that was not the case he had made out
either before the District Court under the Charitable
and Religious Trusts Act or in the plaint· filed in this
case. It is not opPn to him now to change his plea
with regard to his ownership, and the case must be
decided only on the contention that the properties
were private.
The first batch of documents to which our attention
was drawn, concerns mostly Vihitgaon. It consists of
Exs. 200 to 206. The first four are letters written to
Mukadams, Kamavisdars and Mamlatdars to continue
IOO
790
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(1)
the Mokasa, Sahotra or Inam to Timayya, to whom
the village was given as Madade-Mnash. The earliest
Bha;r;;;:i:.0
of them is of 1714 an? the last is o~ 1755. Exs. 204 and
GosaviBalajiwale 206, however, ment10n even earlier sanads and the
v.
latter particularly mentions the original grant of the
Gopal Vinayal• ruler, Mahomed Shah, under his own seal.
Those
Gasavi
sanads, however, have not been produced, as also
H idayatullah J. some of the sanads of the Peshwas, which were mentioned by the Inam Commission in Ex. 135. None of
these documents shows the terms on which the original
grant was made, and in view of the meagreness of
this evidence and its inconclusive nature, the High
Court was justified in accepting the finding of the
Inam Commission that the grant was to the Devasthan
and constituted a Devasthan Inam.
The next village of which the documents were shown
to us is Belatgaon. Here too, the documents are of
later dates, the original grant not being produced. In
connection with this village also, the lnam Commission
held that the village was a Devasthan inam, and the
documents produced in this case do not show anything
to the contrary. These documents are merely letters
and so-called sanads and direct the Mukadams, etc.,
to pay a share of the revenue to Timayya. Learned
counsel for the appellant stated that the documents in
respect of the other villages were also of 11imilar
character. On an examination, we have found them to
be so. In all the orders made by th11 Inam Commission in respect of each and every village, there is a
reference to oth11r sanads of earlier dates, which have
not been produced before us. The respondents had,
in the Court of First Instance, served a notice upon
the appellant to produce all the sanads admittedly in
his possession and mentioned in Ex. 642, but the
appellant avoided doing so by pretending that the
demand was vague. In this view of the matter, it
cannot be said that there has been a misconstruction
of any documents. On the other hand, the judgments
in the two Courts below have proceeded on the ground
that the appellant having an opportunity to prove his
case against the findings of the lnam Commission and
the admissions made from time to time, had suppressed
r959
N
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
791
the original documents conferring villages upon him
z959
as he alleged, and had produced letters and so-called
N
. h
.
th
araya11
sanad sof later d at~s, wh ic w~r~ no mo~e
an mere Bhagwantrao
pay-orders to contmue the pnv1lege wh10h had been GosaviBalajiwal~
granted by the rulers in the earlier documents. We
v.
do not therefore find any misconstruction of the docu- Gopaz Vinayak
ments such as have been produced, and we hold that
Gosavi
the admissions and the revenue records remain un- Hidayatullah ].
contradicted.
This brings us to the cash allowances, which were
granted from the villages to the predecessors-in-title
of the appellant. These documents number a few
hundreds. They too are merely letters written from
time to time to the ~Jukadams, Kamavisdars and
Maml,atdars to pay the arrears of annuities, Varshashan,
Aivaj to Haribakthi Parayana Raj~shri Timayya
Gosa vi. In almost all the documents, there is a refer.
ence that the original sanads had been filed, but the
original sanads have not been produced. The respondents, on the other hand, produced some of these
documents to show that the original grant was to the
Devasthan and that in some of them, there is specific
mention that it was for the expensmrnf" Shri ". These
are Exs. 228, 229, 639, 230, 231 and.233. The respondents connect these documents with the history of
Shri Venkatesh Balaji Sansthan (Ex. 642) to show
that similar documents exist with regard to the· grant
of all the villages and the cash allowances but have
not been produced. The appellant also admitted in
Ex. 151 that his ancestors had received these grants in
order to do Puja Archa, Sadavarat, etc., of the deity.
The two Courts below have from these circumstances
drawn the conclusion that the grant cannot be considered as personal but must be regarded as one made
in favour of the deity or the Sansthan. It is for this
reason also that th~ appellant stated that all the properties including the temple and the idol go in the name
of' Sansthan ', and that this word was used compendiously to describe the properties and the Vahiwatdar.
In our opinion, the appellant was conscious of the
weakness of his case, because the grants to Sansthan
or to the "Shri" could not be regarded as grants to a.n
792
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1960(1)]
r959
individual, and he therefore included himself and the
Narayan
deity in the expression •Sansthan', so as to be able to
Bhagwantrao
show that the g.rants to the Sansthan were grants to
Gosavi Balajiwal• him as much as to the deity.
The appellant, however, contended that this case
was covered by the decision of the Privy Council in
Babu Bhagwan Din v. Gir Har Saroop (1 ). That case
Hidayatullah f. was entirely different. There, the grant· which was
a single one, was made to an individual and his heirs
in perpetuity from generation to generation, and there
was no evidence otherwise. The Judicial Committee
interpreted the grant in favour of the individual, and
stated that it was made to one Daryao Gir and his
heirs in perpetuity. It observed :
" Had it been intended as an endowment for an
idol it would have been very differently expressed ;
the reference to the grantee's heirs, arid the Arabie
terminology 'naslan ba'da naslin wa batnam ba'da
batnin' (descendant after descendant and generation
after generabion) are not reconcilable with the view
that the grantor was in effect making a wakf for a
Hindu religious purpose, even if it be assumed that
this is not otherwise an untenable hypothesis."
Though, in that ease, the origin of the idol . was not
completely traced, the grant itself disclosed the existence ·of a sanyasi, with an idol in a mud hut, to whom
and not to the little temple the grant, in effect, was
made. The history of this deity is well-known, and it
shows the manner in which the gr.ants were made from
time to time. To apply that case to the facts here is
impossible. In our opinion, the principle to apply to this
case is the one stated by the Privy Council in Srinivasa
Ohariar v. Evalappa M udaliar (•). It was there observed:
" T!J.eir Lordships must dissent entirely from the
view that where the discoverable-origins of property
show it to be trust property the onus of.establishing
that it must have illegitimately come into the trustee's own right rests upon the beneficiaries. Upon the
contrary, the onus is heavily upon the trustee to show
by the clParest end most unimpeachable evidence the
the legitimacy of his personal acquisition."
v.
Gopal V inayaA
Gosa.n
(1) (1939) L.R. 67 I.A. 1.
(•) (19oa1 L.R. 49 I.A, a37.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
793
The appellant next argued that those properties in
.r959
respect of which the High Court felt disposed to giving
Narayan
a finding that they were priv:ate, should at least be Bltagwantrao
declared as private properties, He also made an Gosavi Balajiw..U
application in this Court for joining the deity as a
v.
party to the appeal, and requested that this Court Gopal ViuyaA
should send down an issue for a finding by the Court
Gosavi
of First Instance in the presence of the deity, whether Hidayalullah 1.
these properties were private. We shall deal with
these matters a little later, because it is necessary at
this stage to decide whether the public have any right
of worship in the temple. Both the Courts below have
agreed that the deity and the temple were public.
The High Court correctly pointed out that the matter
has to be judged in accordance with the dictum of
Varadachariar, J., in Narayanan v. Hindu Religious
Endowments Board(1). In that case which arose under
s. 9 of the Hindu Religious Endowments Act, the
definition of a 'temple' meant a place.used as a place of
public religious worship and dedicated to, or for the
benefit of, or used as of right by the Hindu community,
or any section thereof as a place of religous worship.
The learned Judge observed as follows :
" The question of intention to dedicate the place
for the use of the public or of the user by the public
being as of right is necessarily a matter for inference
from the nature of the institution and the nature of
the user and the way the institution has been
administered ... once a long course of user by the
public for the purpose of worship is et1tabli:shed, and
the fact of a separate endowment in trust for the
deity is also proved, it is fair to infer that the institution must have been dedicated for user by the
public (unless the contrary is established)-particularly when the character of the temple, its construction, the arrangement of the various parts of the
temple and the nature of the deities installed there
are similar to what obtains in admittedly public
temples. Similarly, when user by the public generally
to the extent to which there is a worshipping public
in the locality is established, it is not unreat1ona.ble to
(r) A,I.R, 1938 Mad, 2og.
794
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1))
presume that the user by the public was as of right,
unless there are circumstances clearly suggesting that
Narayan
the
user must have been permissive or that the authoBhagwantrao
rities
in charge of the temple have exercised such
Gosavi Balajiw:Jle
v.
arbitrary power of exclusion that it can only be
·Gopal Vit11:iyak
ascribed to the private character of the institution."
Gosavi
The two Courts below reached the conclusion that
Hidayatullah J. the public had a right in the temple and the idol from
a number of considerations. Shortly, they are as
follows: The building of the temple is public in
character inasmuch as the staircase leads straight to
the idol, and the public are admitted throughout the
day between 7 a.m. and 10 p.m. There is no evidence
to show that the public or any member of it were ever
excluded from the worship. There is only on'l instance
when a member of the family was excluded, but that
was because he had used abusive language towards
the mother of the present appellant. Indeed, the
public are invited to worship the deity, and no gift
is ever refused. The merchants of the locality keep
a separate khata in the name of the deity, in which
they set apart a portion of their earnings as kangi,
which is paid regularly to the temple. The extent of
the ceremonies performed at the temple also indicates
the existence of a deity in which the public are interested rather than a family deity. There are celebrations,
Ut8avs etc., and daily a large number of Brahmans
and others are fed and at the time of the festivals all
the visitors are also fed. The deity ·also goes out on
such occasions in processions through a marked route,
and there are ten carriages in which it· rides for ten
days. These festivals are celebrated with great e'clat,
and the public not only of Nasik but of other parts
of the country freely join in them. Even the daily
routine of the deity is of a form uncommon in the
case of family deities. The appellant himself admitted that the idol was being worshipped with Rajopchar.
Jt may be mentioned that for playing music or performing the services, the deity has conferred hereditary
ina.ms upon those who attend to them. There is also
a collection box placed at the temple where the public,
who are so minded, are invited to place their offerings.
z959
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
795
No doubt, the Privy Council in Babu Bhagwan
x959
Din v. Gir Har Saroop(1) stated that th~ m~re fact
Narayan
that offerings were accepted from the public might not Bhagwantrao
be a. safe foundation on which to build an inference Gosavi Balajiwale
that the deity was public. Still, the extent to which
v.
the offerings and the gifts go, may be a fair indication Gnpal Vinayall
not merely of the popularity of the deity but of the
Gosavi
extent of the public right in it. As has been pointed Hidayatul/ah 1
out above, the Judicial Committee was dealing with a
single grant which was made to the Mahant in perpetuity, and the temple itself was a mud hut. Herc,
the temple covers several acres of land, and has a vast
structure. There is a Sabha Mandap, which accommodates 600 persons. It is inconceivable that such
a big temple was built only for the use of the family.
It indicates that there was an invitation to the public
to use it as of right, and user and continuous user for
200 years, without let or hindrance, by the public has
been proved in the case beyond doubt. It is also
unusual for Rulers to make grants to a family idol.
The fact that many Rulers have made grants of land
and cash allowances to the deity for sei·a, puja etc.,
is itself indicative of the public nature of the trust.
We think that the extensiveness of the temple and
of grants to it are pertinent circumstances to be taken
into account in judging the nature and extent of the
public right. It may be remembered that in the
documents to which we have referred in an earlier
portion of this judgment, there is reference to special
endowments for festivals. These endowments would
not be made if the deity was a family deity. In the
Gazetteer dealing with Nasik District, there is a full
description of the temple and the deity. Extracts
from it have been quoted by the two Courts below,
and they show that the temple is a public one. Indeed,
the history of the deity written, at the instance of the
appellant himself (Ex. 642) indicates the public right
in the deit.y.
As against these, the appellant contended that there
were other circumstances which indicated that the
deity was a family diety. He examined Dr. Kurtkote,
(1) (1939) L. R. 67 I.A. I.
796
1959
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
who gave some reasons for an opinion that the temple
Narayan
was not a public one but a mere Deva-ghar. He stated
B/Jagwan1,.,,
that the idol of Ba.Jaji did not appear to have been
Gostwi Balajiwal• firmly installed, that it was installed on an upper floor,
v.
that householders resided in the temple and that daily
Gopat Vinayak worship was suspended when there was a birth or
Gosavi
death in the family, and last of a.II, he stated that the
Hldayalullah J. deity being mova.blE>, must be regarded as a family
deity. It may be pointed out here that the deity is
sometimes invited to private residences at the time of
festivals, for dinner. This circumstance was also
pleaded as indicating that the temple is private and
the deity a family deity. We shall now briefly examine
these reasons to see whether they outweigh the
evidence of the public character of the deity, which we
have analysed above.
We begin with a very small point which was ma.de
that the temple of Balaji at Nasik has no dome or
Kala8. This is an admitted fact, but Va.sudev (P. W. 12)
admitted that there was no dome or Kala8 at Ba.Jaji
temple at Deva.Igaon ,Raja, which is a public temple.
So also other temples mentioned in the case. It seems
that nothing really turns upon the existence of a dome
or Kalas, and no authority has been cited before us to
·show that it i• a conclusive circumstance in deciding
that the temple is public.
It must be remembered that this idol was found in
a river and did not need consecration ceremonies,
which a.re-necessary for a new idol, which is set up in
a, new ttJmple. It was first placed inside the house of
Ba.pa.ji Buva. at Junna.r, and was removed from that
place ,as a result of instructions vouchsafed by the
deity itself to Ba.pa.ji Buva.'s successor. It was then
installed at Na.sik, where a big temple has grown. No
doubt, in some portions of this building the family of the
Pujadhikaria reside without any objection from any person. The extensiveness of the building makes it impossible to think that they a.re residing within the tern pie, or
that the Thakur1Jari is within their 'private residence.
Indeed, the description of the temple as given in the
Gazetteer clearly shows that the temple in quite distinct
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
797
from the residential quarters, and that also is the
z959
evidence of the appellant himself. With regard to the
R
installation of the idol on the first floor, we have Bha';:~:ao
already mentioned that the staircase from the ground Gosavi Balajiwah
leads direct to the sanctum. It was, however, admitv.
ted by Dr. Kurtkote that the deity at Bindu Madhav Gopal Vinayak
temple at Benares in also installed on the upper storey,
Gosavi
though he explained that beneath the idol there is a HidayalullallJ.
solid stone pedestal, which runs right from the ground
to the first floor.· No question was put to him as to
whether the deities there, were firmly· installed or
moveable, He, however, admitted that the text of
Prathista Mayukha did not mention that the idol
should not be installed on an upper storey. In our
opinion, in the absence of any text prohibiting the
installation of the deity on an upper floor, we cannot
draw any inference that the temple is private.
The real ground on which the claim has been made
that the deity is a family deity is that it is capable of
being moved from one place to another, and, in fact,
is so moved. Evidence was led to show that in the
early history of this temple the Pujad,hikaris took the
deity on visits to the various ruling chiefs. Document.a
have been filed to show how arrangements were made
for the journey of the deity and instructions issued. to
all concerned to give all facilities for it. It is also in
evidence-and is indeed admitted-that when the deity
is invited on festive occasions to private residences, a.
substitute idol is also left at the main temple for the
public t.o worship. Further, all these removals are
temporary, and the deity is brought back and installed
in its abode afterwards. The deity at the Jaganath .
temple at Puri is also shifted for periodic processions,
and is brought back to its place. Dr. Kurtkote stated
that the installation of an idol can be either in a movable form (chala) or stationary form (sthira), and· that
it is so mentioned in the Prathista Mayukha. He also
admitted that it could not be said that the idol was
not installed because it could be moved from one place
to another. No other authority was cited before us
a.t the hearing as to whether an idol cannot at a.Ube
JQJ
798
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
moved from the place where it is installed, even
though
it may be installed in a movable form (cluila).
Naraya•
There
are, however, cases in which this matter has
B/lagwanlrao
Gosavi Balajiwak come up for consideration before the Courts. In Ram
v.
Sooodur Thakoor v. Taruck Chunder Turkoruttun-f),
Gopal Vi""Yak
there was a destruction of the temple by the erosion of
Go!avi
the river on the banks of which the idol was installed.
Hidayolullah ]. The suit was filed by the plaintiffs for a declaration of
their right to remove the idol to their own house and
to keep it there for the period of their turn of worship.
This claim was decreed. On appeal, Dwarknath
Mitter and Ainslie, JJ., interfered only to the extent
that the lower Court ought to have defined the precise
period for which the plaintiffs were entitled to worship
the idol before it could make the declaratory decree,
which it had passed in their favour. They also directed
that if it was found by the lower appellate Court that
the plaintiffs and the 'defendants were jointly entitled
to worship the idol during any part of the period
mentioned by the plaintiffs, the lower appellate Court
should not allow the plaintiffs to remove the idol to
their own house at Khatra for that portion of time.
It appears from the judgment that though the plaintiffs
were allowed to remove the idol to their own house,
they were to re-convey it at their own expense to the
place where it was at the time of the institution of the
suit. The learned Judges, however, qualified their
judgment by saying that it was not contended in the
case before then that the idol was not removable
according to the Hindu Shastras.
In Hari Raghunath v. Anantji Bhikaji ('), the temple
. was a public one. It was held by the High Court that
under Hindu law, the manager of a public temple has
no right to remove the image from the old temple and
iitstal it·in another new building, especially when the
removal is objected to by a majority of the worshippers. It is interesting to note that in this case Dr.
P. V.' Kane appeared, and in the course of his argu'
ment, he stated as follows :
" According to the Pratishtha-Mayuk"ha of
Nilkantha. and other ancient works an image is to
Z959
(1) (•87$) 19 Woekly Reporter 28.
(•) (1920) I.L.R. 4• Bom• .j66.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
799
be removed permanently only in case of unavoidable
z959
necessity, such as where the current of a river
N
carries away the image. Here the image is intact. Bha;:~:ao
It is only the temple that is dilapidated. For Gosavi Balajiwal1
repairing it, the image need not necessarily be
v.
removed. Even if it may be necessary to remove Gopal Vi.ayaA
the image, tha.t will be only temporarily. The
Gosavi
manager has under Hindu law no power to effect HirlayatullaTs J.
permanent removal of an image in the teeth of
opposition from a large number of the worshippers.
In the instances cited by the appellant, worshippers
had consented to the removal. Permanent removal
of an image without unavoidable necessity is against
Hindu sentiment." (Italics supplied)
Shah, J. (Crump, J. concurring) observed as follows:
" It is not disputed that the existing building is in
. a ruinous condition and that it may be that for the
purpose of effecting the necessary repairs the image
may have to be temporarily removed. Still the
question is whether the defendant as manager is
entitled to remove the image with a view to its
installation in another building which is near the
existing buikli.ng. Taking the most liberal view of
the powers of the manager, I do not think that as
the manager of a public temple he can do what he
claims the power to do, viz., to remove the image
from its present position and. to instal it in the new
building. The image is consecrated ·in its present
position for a number of years and there is the
existing temple. To remove the image from that
temple and to insta.l it in another building would be
pra.ct~cally putting a new temple in place of the
existing temple. Whatever may be the occasions on
which the installation of a new image a.a a substitute
for the old may be allowable according to the Hindu
law, it is not shown on behalf of the defendant that
the ruinous condition of the existing building is a
ground for practically removing the image from its
present place to a new place permanently. We a.re
not concerned in this suit with the question of the
temporary removal which may be necessary when
the existing building is repaired."
800
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
The case is an authority for the proposition that the
idol cannot be removed permanently to another place,
becaqse that would be ta~tamount t~ establishing a
0
Gosat1i Balajiwale new temple.
However, if the pubhc agreed to a
v.
temporary removal, it could be done for a valid
Gopal Vinayak reason.
Gosavi
In Pramatha Nath Mullick v. Pradyumna Kumar
Hidayatullah J. M uUick (1), the deed of trust created an injunction
against the removal of the deity. The following
quotation from that deed of trust shows the powers of
the manager :
"Shall be for ever held by the said Jadulal
Mullick, his heirs, executors, administrators and
representatives to and for the use of the said Thakur
Radha Shamsunderji to the intent that the said
Thakur. may be located and worshipped in the said
premises and to and for no other use or intent
whatsoever provided always that if at any time
hereafter it shall appear expedient to the said
Jadulal Mullick, his heirs, executors, administrators
or representatives so to do it shall be lawful for him
or them upon his or their providing and dedicating
for the location and worship of the said Thakur
another suitable Thakur Bari of th~ same or greater
value than the premises hereby dedicated to revoke
the trusts herein before contained and it is ·hereby
declared that unless and until another Thakur Bari
is provided and dedicated as aforesaid the said
Thakur shall not on any account be removed from
the said premises and in the event of another
Thakur Bari being provided and dedicated as aforesaid the said Thakur shall be located therein, but
shall not similarly be removed therefrom on any
account whatsoever."
The Privy Counllil analysed this provision, and stated
that the last condition made the idol immovable,
except upon providing for the dedicatee another
Thakur Bari of the same or larger value. It observed:
" The true view of this is that the will of the idol
in regard to location must be respected. If, in the
course of a proper and unassailable administration
•959
N
Bha;r;::,:.
(1) (1925) L.R. 52 I.A. 245.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
801
1959
of the worship of the idol by the She bait, it be
thought that a family idol should change its location,
N;;;;an
the will of the idol itself, expressed through his Bltagwantrao
guardian, must be given effect to."
Gosavi Balaji111ale
Their Lordships ordered the appointment of a disinv.
terested next friend, who was to commune with the GopalGosavi
Vinayak
deity and decide what course should be adopted, and
later the instructions of the deity vouchsafed to that Hidayatullah J.
representative were carried out. In this case, there
was a family deity and there was a provision for
removing the idol to another better and more suitable
Thakur Bari, if it appeared necessary. The wishes of
the deity were considered and consulted. The case,
however, is not quite clear as to whether in all circumstances the idol can be removed from one place to
another.
The last case on the subject is Venkatachala v.
Sambasiva (1). The headnote quite clearly gives the
decision, and may be quoted here :
"Where all the worshippers of a temple, who are
in management of it, decide to build a new temple,
the old one being in ruins and the site on which it
stood becoming insanitary and inconvenient for
worshippers, then, unless there is clear prohibition
against theii: demolishing the old temple and building
a new temple, the Court is not entitled to prevent
the whole body from removing the temple with its
image to a new site in the circumstances."
Devadoss, J., quoted passages from Ka!llika Agama,
and referred to Prathista Mayukha by Nilakanta,
Purva Karana Agama.m and Nirnaya Sindhu. He,
however, relied upon certain passages from Purva
Thanthiram by Brighu, Kamika Agama, Siddhanta
Sekhara and Hayasirsha Pancharatra, and came to
the above conclusion. The effect of the decision is that
the whole body of worship,pers, if they are of one mind,
can even permanently remove an idol to 'another
habitation.
In the present case, the idol was not permanently
removed except once when it was taken away from
Junnar and installed at Nasik. As we have already
(I) A I.R. 19z7 Ma,d. 465; ,52 M.L.J. 288.
802
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
pointed out, that was at the behest of the deity itself.
Afterwards, the deity which is installed in a removable
Bka;:~::.. form (chala) has been temporarily removed for purGosavi Balajiwale poses of processions, invitations to dinner and visits to
v.
other parts of India, so that worshippers may have a
Gopal Vinayak chance of making their devotion. This has continued
Gosavi
for over 250 years, and has not been objected to at
Hidayatullah J. any time. · Indeed, a huge concourse of worshippers
always followed and follows the deity every time it is
taken out temporarily for the purpose of affording the
votaries chances of worship at close quarters. This
appears to be a custom which has received recognition
by antiquity and by the consent of the worshipping
public. It may be noted that the deity is brought
back to the old site after its temporary sojourn at
other places, and that further during the absence of
the deity, a substitute idol is placed, so that the
dedicatee is never out of possession of the temple.
In view of these circumstances and the cases to
which we have referred, and iu view, further, of the
fact that no text or authority was cited against such
course of conduct with the consent of the worshipping
public, we do not see any reason for holding that the
temple was private and the deity, a family idol.
The appellant raised a special argument in respect
of certain properties, which, he stated, were private.
He relied upon the observations of the learned Judges
of the High Court that they were inclined to hold that
these properties were private but refrained from
giving a declaration in view of the fact that the deity
had not been joined. These nroperties are jat inams,
recently built properties, namely, the Ba.Jaji temple
and the 'Shree Theatre', and an allowance which goes
in the name of Kulkarni commutation amounting to
Rs. 24 per year. The difficulty in the way of the
appellant is real. He refrained from joining the deity,
if not as a necessary, at least as a proper party to the
suit. If he had joined the deity and the deity was
represented by a disinterested guardian, necessary
pleas against his contention could have been raised
by the guardian, and it is likely that some evidence
would also have been given. The appellant seeks to
1 959
N
"'
S.C.R.
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
803
cover up his default by saying that the suit was one
z959
under 0. 1, r. 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and
N
that the Hindu public was join~d and .the deity w~s Bha;'.::~~ao
adequately represented. In a suit of this character, it Gosavi Balajiwale
is incumbent to have all necessary parties, so that the
v.
declaration may be effective and binding. It is obvi- Gopal Vinayak
ous enough that a declaration given against the
Gosavi
interests of the deity will not bind the deity, even Hidayatullah 1.
though the Hindu Community as such may be bound.
The appellant would have avoided circuity of action,
if he had acceded to the very proper request of the
respondents to bring on record the deity as a party.
He stoutly opposed such a move, but at a very late
stage in this Court he has made an application that
the deity be joined. It is too late now to follow the
course adopted by the Privy Council in Pramatha
Nath Mullick v. Prad,yumna Kumar Mullick (1 ) and
Kanhaiya Lal v. Hamid Ali (2 ), in view of the attitude
adopted by the appellant himself and the warning
which the trial Judge had issued to him in his order.
There is yet another reason why the case cannot be
re-opened, because the appellant himself did not
choose to make any distinction between one property
and another as regards the claim of his ownership.
He stated that each item of property was acquired
and owned in the same manner as another.
Arguments were addressed with regard to the
Balaji Mandir, which is situated on S. Nos. 1353 and
1354. This land was granted to one of the appellant's
predecessors by Ex. 571 by the Peshwa. At that time
3 bighas of land were given to Bapaji Buva, son of
Timayya, because he was a "worthy and respectful "
Bi;ahman, for the express purpose of building a
temple. No doubt, in Exs. 878 and 153 the name of
the Vahiwatdar has been mentioned, and the latter is
a sanad of the Governor of Bombay confirming the
grant free from land revenue. The original grant was
obviously made not to the Brahman concerned but for
the express purpose of building a temple upon the
land. We have already held that the public have a
right in the deity and the temple is also public and
(1) (1925) L.R. 52 I.A. 245.
(2) (1933) L.R 66 I.A. i63.
804
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1))
that, therefore, the grant must be regarded also as pa.rt
of the property of the deity. It is significant that
: ao
after the temple was buil1; with borrowings from others
Gosavi Balajiwale a sum of no less than Rs. one lakh was paid the
v.
Peshwas and other Rulers to satisfy them. The
Gopal Vinayak finding of the learned Judges of the High Court could
Gosavi
not therefore given in the absence of the deity, and
we think that we ~hould only say that in view of the
Hidayalullah 1· case as pleaded, the declaratfon should have been refused without any comments adverse to the deity. A
Court should not, in a case which goes by the board
on a cardinal point, decide matters which cannot arise
in it but may be pertinent in another case between
different parties. We are, however, clear that no
declaration can now be granted in respect of this
property.
The next property which was specially mentioned
for our consideration is the "Shree Theatre", in which
the appellant claims to hold a third share. Here also,
the extracts from the property register have been filed,
and the appellant has drawn our attention to Ex. 290,
which is a deed of purchase and Ex. 691, the permission by the Municipality to build upon the land. It
was necessary for the appellant to show that this
Theatre was built from monies derived from a private
· source and not from the income of the Devasthan. He
has not furnished satisfactory evidence, and in describing the source of money he referred to the, sale of one
property, the price whereof according to 'him was
utilised for the Theatre. It, however, appears from
the record of the case that with that money Ba.Jaji
Vihar was purchased, and the case made before us
was that it was the sale proceeds of Balaji Vihar
which were used to build the Theatre. If that be so,
then the evidence to connect the Theatre with Balaji
Vihar ought to have been tendered and a plea to that
effect taken. We cannot accept the argument in lieu
of plea and evidence, and we think that, the appellant
has neglected to bring the necessary evidence to reach
a finding, This matter also suffers from the same
defects, namely, the failure to join the deity as a.
party and also not making a. distinction between one
z959
N
Bha;:;:1
=
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
805
kind of property and another. Here too, the High Court
z959
should not have expressed any opinion adverse to the
Narayan
deity, without the deity being a party. The same has Bha&wantrao
to be said of items 3 to 10 in the first part of Sch. A Gosa•iBalajiwal•
annexed to the plaint and three survey numbers of
v.
Belatgavan, Deolali and other Jat inams. No useful Gopal Vinayah
Gosavi
purpose will be served in examining in detail the
evidence relating to these properties in the absence of Hidayatullah J.
the deity. It may also be pointed out that the appellant maintained no separate accounts for these properties, and made no distinction between them and the
other properties to which we have referred earlier.
A trustee must not mix private property with trust
property, because if he does so, he undertakes a heavy
burden of proving that any particular property is his,
as distinct from the trust. See 'Lewin on Trusts, 16th
Edn., p. 225. To the same effect are the observations
in Srinivasa Ohariar v. Evalappa Mudaliar(1).
The result is that the declaration which the appellant
sought in his suit that the temple, the deity and plaint
properties were all of private ownership, was rightly
refused by the Courts below. The trial Judge gave a
declaration that defendants I to 4 are entitled to customary worship and maintenance. Strictly speaking,
such a finding was not necessary in a case of this character, and other matters concerning rights of individuals
should not have been gone into in a suit filed under
s. 5(3) of the Act. The appellant is partly to blame.
He set up a case of private ownership with all rights
centred in himself, and defendants I to 4 therefore not
only raised the plea that the appellant was a mere
manager but also asserted their rights in the property.
We think that the Courts below might have refrained
from pronouncing upon the rights of the defendants,
because all that they had to do was to decide whether
the property was trust of a public nature. We, however,
do not wish to give any direction in the matter,
because the suit, as a whole, as laid by the plaintiff
has been dismissed, and to make any observations
might lead to further litigation, which is not in the
interests of the deity.
0
(1) (1922) L. R. 49 I.A. 237.
102
806
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
1959
Respondents 6 and 7 raised before us the question of
costs.
They stated that the trial Judge had given two
Narayan
sets
of
costs,
which was changed to one set by the
Bhagwantrao
Gosavi Balajiwale High Court. These resp'.mdents should have crossobjected on this point against the judgment of the
v.
Gopal Vi1iayak High Court, and in the absence of any such cross-objecGo5avi
tion, no relief can be granted to them. For the same
reason, no relief can be given to respondent 7, in
Hidayatullah ].
respect of whom the finding that he had no right of
performing the seva and getting emoluments attached
to that right, as respondents 1 to 4, has not been
vacated, as was done in the case of respondent 6. In
view of our observations that these matters were alien
to the suit which had been filed, we do not propose to
deal with them.
In the result, the appeal is dismissed. The appellant
will personally pay the costs of Respondent 1. The
other set of respondents will bear their own costs.
Appeal dismissed.
1959
September z4
THE PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK, LTD.
v.
ITS WORKMEN
(B. P. SINHA, P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR and
K. SuBBA RAo, JJ.)
Industrial Dispute-Dismissal by employer pending adjudication
-Omission to hold proper enquiry or obtain permission of the
Tribunal-Su.ch dismissal, if wholly void- Jurisdiction of Tribunal,
Scope of-Pen-down strike-Legality-If disentitles a dismissed
employee to reinstatem'ent-Ind·ustrial Disputes Act, I947 (I4 of
I947), SS. 2(q), IO, 33, 33A.
The employees of the appellant Bank commenced pen-down
strikes, which were followed by a general strike, pending arbitration of an industrial dispute between them. The Government of
India intervened and as the result of an agreement that followed
the Bank reinstated all the employees except lSO, against whom
it had positive objections, and the Government referred their
cases under s. IO of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1047, to the
Industrial Tribunal for arljudication. The two issues before the
Industrial Tribunal were whether the rso employees had been
wrongly dismissed and what wages and allowances would the
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org