SHRI V. V. GIRI versus DIPPALA SURI DORA AND OTHERS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 20 May 1959 | [1960] 1 S.C.R. 426 | 1959 INSC 91
Key facts
- Decided
- 20 May 1959
- Bench
- BHUVNESHWAR PRASAD SINHA*, SYED JAFFER IMAM, J.L. KAPUR, P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR, K.N. WANCHOO
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 539/1958
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1960] 1 S.C.R. 426
- Neutral citation
- 1959 INSC 91
Text of the judgment
426
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1}]
SHRI V.
1959
V. GIRI
v.
DIPPALA SURI DORA AND OTHERS
(B. P. SINHA, JAFER IMAM, J. L. KAPUR,
P. B. GAJENDRAGADKAR and K. N. WANCHOO, JJ.)
Election-Double member constituency-Reserved seat-Scheduled Tribe candidate for reserved seat, if can be declared elected to
general seat-- Provisions permitting sud• course, whether 11ltra vires
-Hindu Law-Member of Scheduled Tribo or Caste-Whcncan
attain higher caste--Representation of the People Act, I95I (43 of
I95I), s. 54(4)-Delimitation Commission Act, z952 (BI of z952). s. 8.
In a double member Parliamentary constituency one seat
was reserved for the scheduled tribes and the other was general.
Four persons filed their nominations for the election, Gr and G 2
for the general seat and Sr and Sz for the reserved seat. At
the polls the number of votes received by the candidates were
in the following order: Sr, Sz, G1 and Gz. In accordance with
the provisions of s. 54(4) of the Representation of the People Act,
1951, Sr was declared elected to the reserved seat and S2, who
had received the largest number of votes out of the remaining
candidates, was declared elected to the general seat. Gr filed
an election petition for a declaration that the election of S2 was
void and for a farther declaration that he had himself been duly
elected to the general seat. The petition was based on three
grounds, viz., (i) that upon a proper. interpretation of s. 54(4) a
candidate who had filed his nomination for the reserved seat
could not be declared elected to the general seat; (ii) that if the
interpretation be otherwise then s. 54(4) was 11/tra vires; and
(iii) that S2 had ceased to be a member of ··a scheduled tribe at
the relevant time and his nomination was improperly accepted.
Held,. (Kapur, J., dissenting) that, Sz was properly and
validly declared elected. The provisions of the Constitution and
of the Act show that the election in a double member constituency was held for the whole constituency and not for the seats
and a candidate who had filed nomination as a member of the
scheduled tribes was entitled to contest for both the seats. On
a fair and reasonable construction of s. 54(4) of the Act there
could be no doubt that in a case like the present, after S1 was
declared duly elected to the reserved seat, the votes secured by
the remaining three candidates had to be considered before declaring the election for the general seat. A member of the
scheduled tribe or caste did not forego his right to seek election to the general seat merely because he availed himself of the
additional concession of standing for the reserved seat by making
the prescribed declaration for that purpose. It was not necessary for him to file two nomination papers for the two seats.
Section 54(4) of the Act did not offend Art. 14 or Art. 330 of
the Constitution and waii not uncon•titutional.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
427
Held, further, that the appellant had failed to establish that
z959
S2 had ceased to be a member of the scheduled tribe and had
v. V. Gfri
become a Kshatriya. Whatever may have been the origin of
Hindu castes ,and tribes in ancient times, gradually castes came to
"·
be based on birth alone. A person who belonged by birth to a Dippala Suri Dora
depressed caste or tribe wouid find it very .difficult, if not imposand Others
sible, to attain the status of a higher caste by virtue of his volition,
education, culture and status. The caste status of a person had to
be determinedin the light of the recognition received by him from
the members of the caste into which he sought an entry ; unilateral
acts of such a person asserting a higher status were not enough to
establish the higher status. It is to be hoped that this position
will change, and in course of time the cherished ideal of castless
society truly b.ascd on social equality will be attained under the
powerful impact of the doctrine of social justice and equality proclaimed by the Constitution and sought to be implemented by the
relevant statutes and as a result of the spread of secular education
and the growth of a rational outlook and of proper sense of social
values ; but at present it would be unrealistic and utopian to ignore
the difficulties which a member of the depressed tribe or ai.ste
has to face in claiming a higher status amongst his co-religionists.
Per Kapur, J.-The election of S2 to the general seat was not
valid. When a member of the scheduled tribe or caste offered
himself for election to a reserved seat he could be elected only to
that seat and not to the general seat. The provisions of the Constitution and of the Act show that the election in a constituency
was for filling of a seat in the constituency and not for a constituency. When a candidate offers himself for election in a constituency, he does so for election to fill a seat in the constituency.
Therefore, if a candidate wanted to contest both the seats he had
to file two nomination papers one for the general seat and the
other for the reserved seat and he had to make two deposits.
Section 8(2) of the Delimitation Commission Act, 1952 destroyed
the effect of s. 54 of the Act.
Caste in Hinduism had its origin not on the basis of birth but
of gima, karma and subhavana (quality, actions and character).
Caste is nothing but division of labour. Hinduism might have
become static at one time; it is no longer so and it is wrong to
say that caste is dependant upon birth and not on karma i.e.
action. S. 2 had by his actions raised himself to the position of a
Kshatriya and he was no longer a member of the scheduled tribe
or caste.
CIVIL APPEI.LATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal
No. 539 of 1958.
Appeal by special leave from the judgment and
order dated March 13, 1958 of the Andhra Pradesh
High Court in Special Appeal No. 4of1957, arising out
of the judgment and order dated November 18, 1957,
428
I959
Y. Y.Giri
v.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
of thll Election Tribunal, Hyderabad in Election Petition No. 83of1957.
N. 0. Chatterjee, A. N. Sinha and T. Satyanarayana,
DippalaSu'iD°'• for the appellant.
GM Others
R
nJi/.,
·
. .
for respondent
P. ama R~11 an d R. Mahalingaiyer,
No. I.
S.S. Shukla, for respondent No. 2.
1959. May 20. The judgmentofB. P. Sinha, Jafar
Imam, P. B. Ganjendragadkarand K.N. Wanchoo, JJ.
was delivered by P. B. Gajendragadkar, J. J. L.
Kapur, J. delivered a separate judgment.
G•jl'illl,•gadka,J.
GAJENDRAGADKAR J.-This appeal by special leave
arises from an election petition filed by Mr. V. V. Giri
(hereinafter called the appellant) in which the validity
of the. election of Mr. Dippala Suri Dora (hereinafter
called respondent 1) w:Ls challenged. The Parliamentary
Constituency of Parvatipuram in the State of Andhra
Pradesh is a double-member constituency; one seat is
reserved for the scheduled tribes and the other is
general. In the General Election to the House of the
People held in 1957 four candidates had been nominated from the said constituency. The appellant and
Mr. B. Satyanarayana Dora (hereinafter called respondent 2) were adopted by the Congress Party, while
respondent 1 and Mr. V. Krishnamoorthy Naidu
(hereinafter called respondent 3) were the candidates
of the Socialist Party. For this constituency polling
took place between February 25 and March 19, 1957,
and the counting of votes disclosed that the appellant
and the three respondents had securedl,24,039, 1,24,604,
1,26,792 and 1,18,968 votes respectively. The result
of the election was declared on March 19, 1957. It was
announced that respondent 2 had been elected to fill
the reserved seat and respondent I the general seat.
On April 16, 1957, the appellant filed the present election petition No. 83of1957 challenging the validity
of respondent l's election. He alleged that respondent I
had offered himself as a candidate for the reserved
seat and as such he was not entitled to be elected for
the general seat. In the alternative he urged that
8.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
respondent 1 wa.s not a. member of the scheduled tribe
zgsg
a.t the ma.teria.l time a.nd so the deola.ra.tion ma.de by
him in that beha.lf wa.s fa.lse. According to the appelv. ~.Gin
la.nt respondent l's nomination ha.d, therefore, been Dippala S•ri Dor11
impropiirly a.ccepted a.nd it ha.d ma.teria.lly affected the ...a. 0111.rs
election. That is why the a.ppella.nt cla.imed a. two- .
fold decla.ra.tion. He wanted the tribunal to decla.re Ga1""''11'"""" J.
that the election of respondent 1 under the Representa.tion of the People Act, 1951 {Act 43 of 1951) (hereinafter called the Act) wa.s void a.nd that he had himself
been duly elected to the House of the People from the
Pa.rva.tipura.m Parlia.menta.ry Constituency for the
genera.I a.nd non-reserved sea.t. These a.llega.tions were
denied by respondent 1.
Broadly sta.ted the ma.in pa.rt of the a.ppella.nt's
case rested on two grounds. He relied on the fact
that both the Congress a.nd Socia.list Parties ha.d adopted two ca.ndida.tes ea.ch, one for the reserved sea.t-a.nd
the other for the genera.I seat. Respondent 1 had been
a.dopted for the reserved seat and in the nomination
forms filed on his behalf he ha.d ma.de the requisite
decla.ration that he was a member of the scheduled
tribe. He conducted his election campaign on the
be.sis tha.t he was a. candidate for the reserved seat a.nd
the voters must ha.ve voted for him on the sa.me basis.
If it is found that his rive.I candidate for the sa.id
reserved sea.t (respondent 2) secured a. larger number
of votes and so he wa.s decla.red elected to fill the said
sea.t, it is not open to respondent 1 to cla.im election
for the genera.l seat. If a candidate offers himself for
one seat, how can he claim to be elected for the other,
asks the appellant.
The appellant concedes that the reservation of sea.ts
for the scheduled castes or tribes is a. special concession
shown to the members of the said castes and tribes in
view of the fa.ct that they a.re educationally socially ·
and financially very ba.ckwa.rd ; it is also conceded
that members of the scheduled castes or tribes a.re
entitled to contest election for the genera.I seat; but
the argument is that a member of a scheduled tribe
must make up his mind and decide which seat he wishes
to contest. If he wants to contest the general seat he
430
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1}]
may do so and in that event he should not make the
prescribed declarations on his nomination form; on the
v. v. Gin
other hand, if he wants to contest the reserved seat he
Dippala~uriDora should elect to do so, make the necessary declaration
and others
and then concentrate his attention on the reserved
seat. Having once made his election he cannot subseGajendragadk•r J. quently fall back upon his right to he elected for the
general seat. Thus presented the argument no doubt
appears to be plausible and even attractive.
Respondent 1, however, dispute the validity of this
contention. His case is that the reservation of seats
is intended as an additional and special concession to
the scheduled castes or tribes. That, however, does
not affect the right of the members of the said castes
or tribes to claim along with the other citizens of the
CYmtry the right to be elected to the general seat. In
other words, according to respondent 1, a member of
the scheduled tribe is entitled to claim election either
to the reserved seat or to the general seat in a doublemember constituency, where one seat is reserved for
the scheduled triues or castes. ·when a member of the
scheduled tribe makes a declaration about his status
on his nomination form it merely means that he claims
the additional benefit of being eligible for election to
the reserved seat. If in the fight for the reserved
seat his rival candidate defeats him, that cannot detract from, or affect, his right to claim election to the
general seat; and if the voters in the constituencies
have expressed their confidence in him by putting him
at the top amongst the remaining candidates, he is
entitled to claim election to the said general seat. The
object of reserving seats obviously is to create confidence in the minds of the hackward castes and tribes
and to give them an assurance about their welfare and
future in the political set up of the country. This
object necessarily implies that the members of the said
castes and tribes should have a double opportunity of
seeking election from a double-member constituency.
B,espondent 1 does not concede that he contested the
election solely for the reserved seat. It is admitted on
his behalf that he did make the necessary declaration
and he may have brought it to the notice of the voters
z959
..
S.C.R.
431
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
-
that he was a member of the scheduled tribe. That
.r959
was inevitable since he was claiming to be elected for
the reserved seat. It is, however, urged that if in law
v. v~.Giri
election took place for the constituency as a whole, DippalaSuriDora
and not for separate seats, the fact that his nominaand Others
tion paper referred to " the reserved constituency"
· stat emen t s d urmg
·
th e course of ·h.is Gajendragadkar J ·
an d some of 'ms
election campaign mentioned the fact that he was ~~
member of the scheduled tribe would not prcjurliciaJly
affect his right to claim election for the general seat. ·
Incidentally respondent 1 claimed that the declaration
of his election to the general seat in fully consistent.
with the express provisions of s. 54(4) of the Act,
whereas the appellant pleaded in reply that the construction sought to be placed upon the provisions of
s. 54(4) by respondent 1 was unreasonable and if not
the said provision was ultra. vires.
On the three major points which thus arose for decision in the present election petition the Election
Tribunal at Hyderabad and the High Court of Andhra.
Pradesh have differed. The Tribunal upheld the
appellant's contentions, mad0 the two declarations
claimed by him and allowed his election petition w·ith
costs. On appeal to the High Court the point.s made
by respondent 1 have been accepted, the findings ma.de
by the tribunal and the declarations granted by it
have been reversed and the appellant.'s election petition dismissed with costs throughout. The appellant's
application for a certificate was dismissed by the High
Court. Thereupon he applied to this Court and
obtained special leave to appeal. That is how this
appeal has come before us.
What then is the true constitutional and legal position with regard to the election to the House of the
People from a double-member constituency where one
seat is reserved for the members of the scheduled
tribes or castes ? The answer to this question would
depend upon the effect of the relevant provisions of
the Constitution and the Act respectively. Let us
first examine the relevant articles of the constitution.
Article 325 provides that there shall be one general
electoral roll for every territorial constituency for
432
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
-
election to either House of Parliament and that no
..
person shall be ineligible for inclusion in any such roll
v. Y. Gin
or claim to be included in any such electoral roll for
DippaJav~vriDora any such constituency on grounds only of' religion,
.,;,, Others
ra.ce, caste, sex or any of them. Article 326 which
dee.ls inter alia with the elections to the House of the
Gajfflllracadkar J. People la.ys down tha.t the said elections shall be on
the basis of adult suffrage, that is to say, every person
who is a citizen of India and who is not less than
21 years of .age at the relevant date and is not otherwise disqualified under the Constitution or any law
made by the appropriate Legislature on the grounds
specified shall be entitled to be registered as a voter at
any such election. It is thus clear that the electoral
roll is prepared on a purely secular basis without any
reference to religion, race, caste or sex and that the
qualification for being included as a voter on the said
electoral roll is likewise wholly secular and of general
application to all citizens in the country.
Let us then refer to the articles that deal with the
composition of the House of the People and qualification for membership of Parliament. Article 81 (1)
provides that subject to the provisions of Art. 331 the
House of the People shall consist inter alia of not more
than 500 members chosen by direct election from
territorial constituencies in the States. This article
contemplates the division of the States into territorial
contituencies and it provides for the election of 500
members from these constituencies to the House of
the People. Article 84 deals with the question of
qualification and it provides that a person shall not be
qualified to be chosen to fill a seat in the Parliament
unless he is (a) a citizen of India, (b) in the case of a
seat in the House of the People not less than 25 years
of age, and (c) possesses such other qualifications as
may be prescribed in that behalf by or under any law
made by Parliament.
It is by virtue of Art. 84(c) that the Parliament has
passed the two relevant statutes. They are the Representation of the People Act, 1950 (Act 43 of 1950)
and the Act. We will presently refer to the relevant
provisions of the Act. Meanwhile we would like to
1959
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
433
refer to another article of the Constitution which is
i959
very important. It is Art. 330. It occurs in Pt. XVI
v. v. Giri
of the Constitution which deals with special provisions
v.
relating to certain classes. It provides for the reserva. Dippala. Suri Dora
tion of seats for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes and Others
in the House of the Pe?ple. Article 331 lays down that Gajend-;;:;;.dkar J.
seats shall be reserved m the House of the People for
the three categories enumerated in (a), (b) and (c). In
the present case we are concerned with the second
category which deals with the scheduled tribes.
Article 330(2) provides inter alia that the number of
seats reserved in any State for the scheduled tribes
under sub-Art.(l) shall bear as nearly as may be
the same proportion fo the total number of seats allotted to that State in the House of the People as the
population of the scheduled tribes in the State or part
of the State as the case may be in respect of which
sea.ts are so reserved bears to the population of the
State. In providing for the members of the scheduled
tribes the special concession by way of reservation of
seats the Constitution has adopted the fair, just and
equitable method of fixing the number of the said
reserved seats on the basis of the proportion mentioned
in Art. 330(2). Whilst we a.re referring to this article
we may incidentally mention Art. 334 which provides
that the reservation of seats provided by Art. 330 shall
cease to have effect on the expiration of a period of ten
years from the commencement of the Constitution
subject to the proviso.
Thus it is clear that election to the House of the
People even from a,, double-member constituency where
one seat is reserved for the members of the scheduled
tribes in one, and though the Constitution shows just
anxiety to afford necessary protection to the members
of the scheduled tribes, it deliberately refused to adopt
the system of separate ele<'torates. The constituency is
one and election is held to the said constituency from
one joint electoral roll prepared on the basis of qualifications which are of general and uniform application.
In regard to. double-member constituencies like
Parvatipuram the Constitution has not even adopted
the course of providing for a special constituency
5~
434
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1960(1)]
confined to the members of the scheduled tribe. All that
is done is to provide for the reservation of seats for the
v. v~.Giri
members of the said tribes or castes in the manner
Dippala Suri Dora already indicated. Even for the reserved seat all
and Othm
voters in the constituency are entitled to vote. The
reservation of a seat in a double-member constituency
Gajendr•gadkar J. cannot, therefore, affect the main basic position that
the constituency is one and for returning representatives to the House of the People it is the same joint
electorate that goes to the poll.
Let us now proceed to consider the position under
the relevant provisions of the Act. It is necessary to
begin with the definitions of parliamentary constituency
and election. Section 2(f) of the Representation of the
People Act, 43 of 1950, defines a "parliamentary
constitutency" as meaning a constituency provided by
law for the purpose of elections to the House of the
People; whereas s. 2(d) of the .A:ct defines "election"
to mean an election to fill a seat or seats inter alia in
House of Parliament. These definitions show that it
is a parliamentary constituency that sends the representatives to fill the seats in the House of the People.
Elections are held from such constituencies and
candidates declared duly elected fill the seats in the
House of Parliament to which they are elected. Section 4
prescribes qualification for membership of the House
of the People. Section 4(b) provides that a person
shall not be qualified to be chosen to fill a seat in the
House of the People unles~ in the case of a seat reserved for the scheduled tribes he is a member of any of
the scheduled tribes and is an elector for any parliamentary constituency. This section expressly provides
what was clearly implicit in the relevant articles of the
Constitution that before a person can claim to be elected to fill a seat reserved for the scheduled tribes he
must be a member of the said tribes besides being an
elector for the parliamentary constituency in question.
Section 32 deals with the nomination of candidates for
election and it provides that any person may be nominated as a candidate for election to fill a seat if he is
qualified to be chosen to fill a seat under the provisions of the Constitution ;i,nd the Act. The next section
'959
.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
435
to consider is s. 33. It deals with the presentation of
r959
nomination papers and prescribes the requirements for
v v c· .
a valid nomination. Section 33(2) is relevant for our
· ~. •ti
purpose. It provides that any constituency where any Dippala Suri Dora
seat is reserved a candidate shall not be deemed to be and Others
qualified to be chosen to fill that seat unless his nomin- , ation paper contains a declaration by him specifying Ga;endragadkar J.
the particular tribe of which he is a member and the
area in relation to which the tribe is a scheduled tribe
of the State. Section 33(6) lays down that nothing in
this section shall prevent any candidate from being
nominated by more than one nomination paper for
election in the same constituency. The effect of s. 33(2)
is that unless a member of the scheduled tribe makes
the required declaration he would not be entitled to
claim election to the reserved seat. In other words, if
a member of the scheduled tribe does not want to be
considered for election to the reserved seat he need
not make the said declaration; and in that case he
would be entitled to contest the election only for the
general seat. But it does not follow that if a scheduled tribe candidate makes the said declaration he forfeits
his right to contest for the general seat. It is necessary
to point out at this stage that the prescribed nomination paper (F'orm 24) is common to all the candidates.
In regard to the candidates contesting for the reserved
seat, however, the form prescribes the declaration
which they are required to make. In the matter of
deposits required by s. 34 another concession is made in
favour of the members of the scheduled castes or
tribes ; whereas in the case of an election from a
parliamentary constituency a candidate is required to
make a deposit of Rs. 500 the amount is fixed at
Rs. 250 in the case of members of scheduled castes or
tribes. It is significant that this concession is not
confined to members of the scheduled tribe contesting
the election only for the reserved seat. It is available
to them even if they want to contest only for the
general seat. Section 35 requires a notice of nominations and a time and place for their scrutiny to be
published ; and s. 38 requires a list of contesting candidates to be published. The two prescribed forms for
436
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
the said notices are Forms 3A and 4 ; they make no
reference to the two respective seats and give the
V. V. Giri
v.
particulars about all the candidates in the respectDippala St1ri Dora ive columns. It is true that in col. (6) of ]'orm
and Otilers
3A particulars of caste or tribe of candidates belonging
G . k
to scheduled castes or tribes are required to be men•J•naragad •r f. tioned. That is consistent with the requirement of
s. 33(2). It would thus be seen that the scheme of the
relevant provisions of the Act, like the scheme of the
relevant articles of the Constitution, is clear. The
election to the House of the People from a doublemember constituency is held as an election from the
whole of the constituency as such. It is on that basis
that the nomination papers are required to be filed.
The notifications about the nominations are published
and the list of the validly nominated candidates is
announced on the same basis. The counting of votes
is similarly made by reference to all the candidates.
It is only when the result of the election is prepared
for declaration that the votes of candidates who have
made the prescribed declarations are first taken into
account and the result of the election in respect of the
reserved seat is first determined, and then the votes
secured by the remaining candidates are ta.ken into
account and the result of the election for the other
general seat is determined and declared.
Section 63 of the Act would also assist us in deciding the point in dispute between the parties. Section 63 (1) pro".ides for the method of voting and it
lays down that in plural-member constituencies other
than Council constituencies every elector shall have
as many votes as there are members to be elected but
no member shall give more than one vote to any one
candidate. It is not disputed that voters in a doublemember constituency are not bound to vote in reference to the two seats. If the Act had intended that
the election in such a consituency should take place
by reference to the two respective seats, it would have
provided for voting by the electors on that basis, and
would have required the voters to cast their two votes
respectively by reference to the two seats. Section
63(1) on the other hand allows voters to cast their two
'959
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT H.EPORTS
437
votes to any two candidates of their choice whether
· r959
both of them claim to be elected to the general seat or
V. V. Giri
to the reserved seat or one of t Iiem claims one seat
v.
and other claims the other. This method of voting is Dippala Suri Dora
inconsistent with the appellant's case that the election
and Others
to the double-member constituency is held· seat.wise.
.
h . ll b ,
h
. Gajendragadkar ],
Sect10n 54(4) emp atwa y rmgs out t e same position. Section 54 (1) provides that it shall apply in
relation to any election in a constituency where the
seats to be filled include one or more seats reserved
for the scheduled castes or scheduled tribes. Subsection (4) reads thus:" If the n~mber of contesting candidates qualified to be chosen to fill the reserved seats exceeds
the number of such seats, and the total number of
contesting candidates also exceeds the total number
of seats to be filled, a poll shall be taken ; and after
the poll has been taken, the returning officer shall
first declare those who, being qualified to be chosen
to fill the reserved seats, have secured the largest
number of votes, to be duly elected to fill the reserved seats, and then declare such of the remaining
candidates as have secured the largest number of
votes to be duly elected to fill the remaining
seats."
On a fair and a reasonable construction of this provision there can be no doubt that in a case like the
present, after respondent 2 was declared duly elected
to the reserved seat, the votes secured by the remaining
three candidates had to be considered before declaring the election for the unreserved scat and that is
precisely what the returning officer has done when he
declared that respondent I had been duly elected to
the said seat. The illustration to this sub-section
makes this position absolutely clear. This is how the
illustration reads:" At an election in a constituency to fill four
seats of which two are reserved there are six
contesting candidates A, B, 0, D, E an4 P, and they
secure votes in descending order, A securing the
largest number, B, C and D are qualified to be
chosen to fill the reserved seats, while A, E and .I!'
438
SUPREME COURT REPOR'l'S [1960(1)]
are not so qualified. The returning officer will first
declare B and C duly elected to fill the two reserved
V. V. Giri
seats, and then declare A and D (not A and E) to
Dippala v~uri Dora
fill the remaining two seats."
and Others
In our opinion s. 54(4) and the illustration are wholly
. consistent with the relevant provisions of the ConGa;endragadkar J. stitution and of the Act.
Whilst we a.re dealing with s. 54 we may incidentally
refer to the appellant's argument based on s. 6(2) (c) of
the Delimitation Commission Act, 1952 (81 of 1952)
which provides that in every two-member constituency
one seat shall be reserved either for the scheduled
castes or for the scheduled tribes, and the other seat
shall not be so reserved. It is urged that in view of this
provision the case contemplated by the illustration to
s. 54 (4) is not likely to occur any more and in that
sense the illustration has become otiose. That may be
true. But .even so the significance of the illustration
lies in the fact that it clarifies and explains concretely
how the reservation of seats for the depressed castes
and. tribes will actually work out in elections in the
relevant constituencies.
There is another argument which may be noticed.
It was faintly suggested by the ·appellant that s. 54 (4)
is ultra vires since it is inconsistent with Arts. 14
and 330 of the Constitution. One has merely to recall
the provisions of Art. 15 (3) and·(4) to reject the argument thats. 54(4) offends against Art. 14. As regards
Art 330 it is obvious that the reservation of seats as
therein specified is intended to guarantee a minimum
number of seats to the scheduled castes and tribes; therefore if members of the said castes and tribes secure
additional seats by election to general unreserved
seats there would be no repugnancy at all. There is
no substance in the contention that s. 54 (4) is ultra
vires.
There is one more section of the Act to which reference must be made. It is s. 55. For the avoidance
of doubt this.section declares that a member of the
scheduled castes or scheduled tribes shall not be disqualified to hold the seat not reserved for members
of those castes or tribes if he is otherwise qualified to
z959
S.C.R
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
439
hold such seat under the Constitution and the Act.
r959
If the appellant's contention is upheld then the proviv v a· .
sions of s. 55 would be inapplicable to a member of
· ~ "'
the scheduled tribe solely because he has made the Dippala s~ri Dora
prescribed declaration in his nomination form in order and Others
to claim the benefit of the concession of the reserved
seat in his constituency. We see no justification for Gajendragadkar J.
adopting such an artificial and restricted construction
of s. 55. In our opinion s. 55, like s. 54(4), is consistent with the other relevant provisions of the Constitution and the Act. A member of the scheduled tribe is
entitled to contest for the reserved seat and for that
purpose he can and must make the prescribed declaration; but it does not follow that because he claims the
benefit of the reserved seat and conforms to the statutory requirement in that behalf, he is precluded from
contesting the election, if necessary, for the general
seat. Once it is realised that the election is from the
constituency ljl.S a whole and not by reference to two
separate and distinct seats there would be no difficulty
in accepting the view taken by the returning officer
when he declared respondent 1 to have been duly
elected for the general seat.
It is true that some articles of the Constitution and
some sections of the Act refer to seats in connection
with election to the House of the People. ]'or instance,
when Art. 81 (2) (b) provides for the same ratio
throughout the State between the population of each
constituency and the number of seats allotted to it, it
does refer to seats, but in the context the use of the
word " seats" was inevitable. Similarly Art. 84
which lays down the qualification for the members of
Parliament begins by saying that a person shall not be
qualified to be chosen " to fill a seat" in Parliament
unless he satisfies the tests prescribed by its els. (a),
(b) and (o). Here again the expression "to fill a seat"
had to be used in the context. The same comment
can be made about the use of the 'word " seat " in
Arts. 101 (2) and in 330. There is no doubt that when
a candidate is duly elected from any constituency to
the House of the People he fills a seat in the House as
an elected representative of the said constituency ;
440
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
and. so the expression "filling the seat " is naturally
used whenever the context so requires.
v. v~.Giri
The position in regard to the sections of the Act
DippalaSuriDora which.use the word "seat" or the expression "fill the
am! others
seat" is exactly similar. Section 32 of the Act says
that any person may be nominated as a candidate for
Gajendragadkar J. election to "fill a seat" if he is qualified in that behalf.
This section does not mean that the nomination of a
person as a. candidate for election is for a seat; such
nomination is for the constituency. After the election
is over the elected candidate is qualified to fill a seat
in the House of the People to which he is elected. It
is in that sense that the .expression " a candidate for
election to fill a seat" is used in this section. The use
of the same expression in ss. 33(2), 53(2), 54, and 55
bears the same interpretation. The use of the said
expression or the reference to "seat" in some of the
articles of the Constitution or the sections of the Act
does not, therefore, mean that election to the. House
of the People from a double-member constituency is
held not for the constituency as a whole but by reference to the two seats.
There is no doubt that in the case of double-member
constituencies recognised political parties usually adopt
two candidates, one for the general seat an.d the other
for the reserved seat; and it does appear that under
the relevant statutory order issued by the Election
Commission the symbol reserved for the party is
allotted to both such candidates with the only difference that the symbol allotted to the scheduled caste or
the scheduled tribe candidate of the party is the
particular symbol enclosed within a thick black circle.
This order has been issued for convenience in order to
enable the very large number of illiterate and uneducated voters to identify the political affiliations of the
candidates for election; and to show which of the
candidates are eligible for the reserved seat; but the
said order cannot affect the nature of the election nor
does it purport to do so. Similarly a candidate who
has made the prescribed declaration under s. 33 may
withdraw his candidature under s. 37 which would
mean that he is no longer contesting any seat in the
'959
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
441
constituency ; but that again cannot justify the inferz95f
ence that his candidature was in regard to a reserved
v. ~.Girl
seat for which election was seperately intended to be
held. In fact, in regard to a double-member con- DippalaSuriDora
stituency election recognises no compartments at all ; and Others
it is one general election with reservation of seats ;
that is all.
Gajmdraiadkar J.
It was then contended by the appellant that even if
it may be open to a member of the scheduled tribe to
seek election either for the reserved seat or failing that
for the general seat he ought to file two nomination
papers in that behalf. In our opinion this contention
is not wellfounded. It is conceded that there is no
provision for the presentation of two nomination
papers for two different-seats in the same constituency.
Indeed such an assumption would be inconsistent with
the basic character of the election from a doublemember constituency. In our opinion, the true position is'that a. member of a scheduled caste or tribe
does not forego his right to seek election to the
general seat merely because he avails himself of the
additional concession of the reserved seat by making
the prescribed declaration for that purpose. The claim
of eligibility for the reserved seat does not exclude the
claim for the general seat ; it is an additional claim ;
and both the claims have to be decided on the basis
that there is one election from the double-member
constituency.
In this connection we may refer by way of analogy
to the provisions made in some educatio'nal institutions
and universities whereby in addition to the prizes and
scholarships awarded on general competition amongst
all the candidates, some prizes and scholarships are
reserved for candidates belonging to backward communities. In such cases, though the backward candidates
may try for the reserved prizes and scholarships, they
a.re not precluded from claiming the genera.I prizes and
scholarships by competition with the rest of the candidates. We are, therefore, satisfied that the High
Court was right in rejecting the appellant's contention
that respondent 1 could not have been validly elected
56
442
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
r959
for the general seat from the constituency of Parvativ v G'.
puram.
· · '"
That takes us to the alternative contention raised
Dippala~uriDora by the appellant against the validity of respondent l's
and others
election. That contention is that respondent 1 had
ceased to be a member of the scheduled tribe at the
Gajendragadkar J. material time because he had become a kshatriya. In
dealing with this contention jt would be essential to
bear in mind the broad and recognised features of the
hierarchical social structure prevailing amongst the
Hindus. It is not necessary for our present purpose
to trace the origin and growth of the caste system
amongst the Hindus. It would be enough to state
that whatever may have been the origin of Hindu
castes and tribes in ancient times, gradually castes
came to be based on birth alone. It is wellknown that
a person who belongs by birth to a depressed caste or
tribe would find it very difficult, if not impossible, to
attain the status of a higher caste amongst the Hindus
by virtue of his volition, education, culture and status.
The history of social reform for the last century and
more has shown how difficult it is to break or even to
relax the rigour of the inflexible and exclusive character of the caste system. It is to be hoped that this
position will change, and in course of time the
cherished ideal of casteless society truly based on social
equality will be attained under the powerful impact of
the doctrine of social justice and equality proclaimed by
the Constitution and sought to be implemented by the
relevant statutes and as a result of the spread of
secular education and the growth of a rational outlook
and of proper sense of social values; but at present it
would be unrealistic and utopian to ignore the difficulties which a member of the depressed tribe or caste
has to face in claiming a higher status amongst his co.
religionists. It is in the light of this background that
the alternative plea of the appellant must be considered.
The evidence adduced by respondent 1 shows that
all the documents from 1885 to 1928 consistently
described him as a Mukka Dora or a member of the
scheduled tribe. The appellant has, however, produced
documentary evidence which indicates that from 1928
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPOR.TS
443
onwards respondent 1 has described himself and the
r959
members of his family as beloncting
to
the
kshatriya
G' ·
I!>
• v. v. '"
caste. Oral evidence led by the appellant is intended
v.
to show that respondent 1 has for some years past Dippala Suri Dora
adopted the customs and the rituals of the kshatriya and Others
caste. It shows that marriages in the family of
respondent 1 are celebrated as they would be amongst Gajmaragaakar f.
the kshatriyas, and homa is performed on such .occasions. It is also attempted to be shown that the family
of respondent 1 is connected by marriage ties with
some kshatriya families, that a Brahmin priest officiates
at the religious ceremonies performed by respondent 1,
and that he wears a sacred thread. The High Court
has held that even if the documentary and oral
evidence adduced by the appellant is accepted at its
face value, it falls far short of establishing his plea
that respondent 1 had become a kshatriya at the
material time. The caste-status of a person in the
context would necessarily have to be determined in the
light of the recognition received by him from the
members of the caste into which he seeks an entry.
There is no evidence on this point at all. Besides the
evidence produced by the appellant merely shows some
acts by respondent 1 which no doubt were intended to
assert a higher status; but unilateral acts of this
character cannot be easily taken to prove that the
claim for the higher status which the said acts purport
to make is established. That is the view which the
High Court has taken and in our opinion the High
Court is absolutely right. Therefore the alternative
plea made by the appellant cannot succeed.
In the result the appeal fails and is dismissed with
costs in favour of respondent 1.
KAPUR J.-I regret I am unable to agree with the
Kapur J.
judgment prepared by my learned brother Gajendragadkar and I shall proceed to give my reasons for my
dissent.
In an election for Parliament the candidate asks for
the votes uf the electors by offering himself for a seat
in a parliamentary constituency and it is a funda- _
mental principle of elections that the voters exercise
their suffrage in favour of a candidate who is standing
444
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1))
for a particular seat in a single or in a two ,member
constituency. The language used in the Constitution as
V. V. Giri
well as in the Election Laws tends to show that the elecDippaza"suri Dor• tion though in a constituency is for the filling of a seat
•.a Others and it is for the filling of that sea.t tha. t the voters in a
constituency exercise their right to vote. The ConstituKapur].
tion itself shows that the election is for filling a sea.t in
a coJJ.stituency.
The scheme of the Constitution itself when it deals
with Parliament a.nd election to Parliament supports
this view. Pa.rliament, its composition and qualification for membership of Parliament are dealt with
in Chapter II of Part V of the Constitution. Article 81
deals with the composition of the House of the People.
Sub-cl. (a) of cl. (1) of Art. 81 lays down that there
shall be not more than 500 Members chosen by direct
election from territorial constituencies and not more
than 20 Members to represent Union territories.
Clause (2) of Art. 81 provides that to each State shall
be allotted a certain number of seats in the House of
the People in such manner that the ratio between the
number and population of the State is the same for
all States and sub-cl. (b) provides that the State shall
be divided into territorial constituencies in such manner
that the ratio between the population of each constituency and the number of seats allotted to it is the
same throughout the State. Article 84 provides for the
qualifications of persons to be chosen to fill a seat in
Parliament and in cl. (c) it is laid down that the
qualifications shall be such as may be prescribed by an
Act of Parliament.
Part XV deals with Elections. Under Art. 324 there
is one general electoral roll for every territorial constituency and there is no exclusion from such roll on the
ground only of religion, race, caste, creed, sex or any
of them. Article 327 confers on Parliament the power
to make provision with respect to elections to Legislatures. Part XVI of the Constitution make special
·provision relating to certain classes and under Art. 330
seats are reserved in the House of the People for
Scheduled Castes a.nd Scheduled Tribes and it also provides for the proportion that these sea.ts shall bear to the
I959
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
445
total number of seats allotted to any State and the
z959
reservation of seats and special representation are to
..
cease after 10 yea.rs (Art. 334). These provisions show
v. v. Gm
that the emphasis is on seats. The. nu~ber seats is Dippala~uriDor•
fixed so also reserved seats and elect10n is to fill a seat and Others
and for that purpose qualifications of candidates are
prescribed by Parliamentary legislation.
Kapur J.
A perusal of those various articles mentioned above
shows that there is no separate electoral roll and. that
the elections are on the basis of joint electorate.
Although there is reservation of seats for the Scheduled castes there is no exclusion of Scheduled Castes
or Scheduled Tribes from what are called general seats
and every citizen without any consideration of caste,
creed or sex is entitled to vote as well as stand for
election provided he is otherwise qualified. The reservation of of seats was a concession given to the Scheduled
Castes and Tribes because of their social and educational
backwardness and it had to have only a temporary
existence and it must be conceded that although there
is a reservation of a certain number of seats for the
Scheduled Castes and Tribes the members of these castes
or tribes .are not excluded from contesting general
seats.
In order to carry out the intention of the Constitution in regard to elections two Acts were enacted by
the Parliament. The Representation of People's Act,
1950, (43 of 1950) (hereinafter called the 1950 Act) and
the Representation of People's Act 1951, {43 of 1951),
(hereinafter called the 1951 Act). The object of the
1950 Act was to provide for allocation of seats and
delimitation of constituencies for election and the
object of the 195l Act was to provide for· the conduct
of elections to the Houses of Parliament etc. and the
qualifications and disqualifications for membership.
In s. 2{f) of the 1950 Act a Parliamentary constituency
is defined as a constituency provided for the purpose of
election to the House of the People. In Part II of that
Act provision is made for the allocation of sea.ts in the
House of the People and for reservation of sea.ts in
that House for Scheduled Castes and Tribes for filling
up of sea.ts in that House and all these provisions
446
I9$9
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1960(1))
show that the seats in the House of the People allotted
to the various States have to be filled by direct elecv.
tions. It is significant that in all these provisions the
Dippal4 suriDora word used is 'seat' and the election is to fill a seat.
att4 Olhers
Coming to the 1951 Act, election is defined in s. 2(d)
to
mean an election to fill a seat or seats in either
Kapur J.
House of Parliament ........... In s. 2(e) an elector
means the person whose name is entered in the electoral
roll of a constituency. Section 4 of the 1951 Aot lays
down the qualifications for membership of the House
of the People and a person is not qualified to be chosen
to fill a reserved seat in the House unless he is a member of a Scheduled Caste or Tribe and he is an elector
for any Parliamentary constituency. In the case of
any other seat the only qualification required is that he
is an elector in a Parliamentary constituency. Part V
of 1951 Act deals with nomination of candidates.
Section 31 provides for public notice of elections and
s. 32 for nomination of candidates for election. Under
this section no person may be nominated as a candidate for election to fill a seat unless he is qualified to
fill that seat. Section 33 deals with presentation of
nomination papers and the requirements for a valid
nomination. Under sub-s. (1) a nomination paper
completed in the prescribed form and signed as·required under that provision· has to be presented to the
Returning Officer and under sub-s. (2) where in a
constituency any seat is reserved the candidate is not
qualified to be chosen to fill that seat unless his nomination papers contain a declaration by him specifying
the caste or tribe to which he belongs and sub-s. (6)
provides that a candidate can file more than one
nomination paper for election in the same constituency.
Under s. 34 for a valid nomination for election a
deposit has to be made which ill the case of members
of Scheduled Castes or Tribes is Rs. 250 and in other
cases Rs. 500.
The contention. raised on behalf of the appellant
was that these various provisions of the 1951 Act show
that the election is for filling a seat and therefore when
a member of the Seheduled Caste or Tribe contests an
election he has to make a choice as to which seat he is
:.Giri
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
447
r959
contesting. There is no prohibition against his standing for election for the general constit.uency but if he
v. V.Giri
. d icate to t he electors t hat
wants to do so he has to m
v.
he is so standing because when the electors vote they DippalaSuriDora
vote for the election of the candidate to that particular and Others
seat and to no other. This is made further clear by
Kapur].
the fact that only one vote out of the two which every
elector has the right to cast can be polled in favour of
one candidate.
Every candidate has to have a symbol the necessity
for which arises because of the illiteracy of the general
electorate. Each party has allotted to it a symbol. In
the present case the successful candidate Mr. Dippala
Suri Dora was standing for the reserved seat on behalf
of the Socialist Party and had been allotted the symbol
of a tree which was his party symbol. In the case of
a reserved seat the distinguishing feature is the black
circle round the symbol so that the electors would
know where to cast their vote in the case of a Scheduled Caste or Tribe candidate. It is true that the
Form 2A is the same whether the candidate is contesting a reserved seat or a general seat but in the case of
a person contesting a reserved seat there is a further
declaration to be made that he belongs to Scheduled
Caste or Tribe. It is also true that in F'orm 3A when
notice of nomination is given the :Form used is the same
for both the seats but in column (6) of this :Form the
particulars of the caste or tribe are to be given presumably to show which of the candidates belongs to a
Scheduled Caste or Tribe otherwise indicating the caste
is meaningless. Similarly in F'orm 7A which is for
the final list of contesting candidates after withdrawals
have taken place the names of candidates are given
a.long with their addresses and symbols allotted to them
but candidates belonging to members of the Scheduled
Castes or Tribes are distinguished by separate special
marks against their names. All these distinguishing
features have been provided so that electors when they
ca.st votes for the various candidates know which of
them is contesting the reserved seat and which is
contesting the general seat. If that is not the object
the giving of the caste would be meaningless, if not
against the idea.I of castelessness. .
448
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
It was contended that s. 32 only deals with nominations for election to fill a seat but it has nothing to
v. :.Giri
do with qualifications which are la.id down ins. 33 and
Dippala Suri Dora that sub-ss. (2) and (6) of s. 33 showed that the election
and Oth4rs
was for a constituency and not for a seat but this
argument ignores the definition of election which means
Kapur J.
election to fill a seat and therefore where the word
' election ' in a constituency is used it is to be construed
as election to fill a seat in a constituency. Besides
sub-s. 2 of s. 33 makes it clear that a candidate cannot
be qualified to be chosen to fill a reserved seat in a
constituency unl~ss he makes a particular declaration.
The emphasis is again on a seat. It is true that a
candidate has to make a deposit for due nomination
constituency but here again the
for election from
word ' election ' must be read as election to fill a seat
from a constituency. These various sections indicate
therefore and particularly the definition of the word
election in s. 2(d) of the 1951 Act that when a candidate offers himself for election in a constituency he
does so to fill a particular seat in a constituency.
At a pole every elector can cast one vote in favour
of one candidate and another in favour of another.
It was contended that it was open to an elector to cast
both his votes in favour of the two candidates standing
for a general seat or the two candidates for the reserved
seat or one for. the general seat and the other for
reserved seat and that there was no law which enjoins
an elector to cast one vote for the general seat and the
other for the reserved seat. But this will lead us
nowhere because if there are only four candidates as
they were in the present case two belonging to Scheduled Castes or Tribes and two non-Scheduled Caste
candidates then the voter who casts both his voteR
one for one Scheduled Caste and the other for the
other or one for the non-Scheduled Caste and the other
for the other non-Scheduled Caste candidate would be
wasting his votes. One has to presume that the elector
when he takes the trouble of going to the polling
booth and to vote is not going to waste his votes.
1959
a
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
449
I95f
In the present case the party which set up
Mr. Dippala Suri Dora set him up as a candidate for
.
. cIear f rom v. v.v. Giri
the Schedu1e d Caste constituency
wh ich is
the application on behalf of the party setting him up. Dippala Suri Dora
The final list of candidates for Parliament Ext.P3(c) atttl 011tm
also shows that Mr. Dippala Suri Dora was a candidate
Kapvr ].
for the reserved seat in Parvatipuram double-member
constituency. The nomination papers filed by him
also show that he was being nominated for election
from the ~arvatipuram reserved parliamentary constituency. Thus as far as Mr. Dippala Suri Dora was
concerned he had made it quite clear to the electorate
that he was seeking their suffrage for filling a reserved
seat in the constituency and in this view of the matter
as far as he and the electors were concerned the contest
was for the reserved seat and not the general seat and
the people voted for him for filling the reserV'ed seat
and not the general seat.
Counsel for the ·respondent Mr. Dippaia Suri Dora
submitted that the mere fact that that respondent
filed his nomination papers in a particular manner
does not give a different interpretation to the various
provisions of the law and if under the law a nomination
like that of the respondent Mr. Dippala Suri Dora was
a. nomination for both the sea.ts the mere fact that he
had filled his form differently would make no difference.
This contention is correct but as I have indicated
above the election is to fill a seat in the constituency
and the nomination must be taken to fill that seat
and no other.
Reliance was next placed on ss. 53, 54 and 55 of the
1951 Act to support the case put forward on behalf of
the respondent Mr. Dippala Suri Dora. No doubt in
sub-s.(4) of s. 54 it is laid down that in a case where
the number of contesting candidates qualified to be
chosen to fill the reserved seat exceeds the number of
such seats and the total also exceeds the total number
of seats to be filled, then after the poll has been taken
the qualified candidate receiving the largest number
of votes for the reserved seat has to be declared elected
and then such of the remaining candidates as have
secured the largest number of votes have to be declared
57
450
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1)]
elected to fill the remaining seats and there is an illustration added to the section which supports the case of
v. v~.Giri
the respondent.. BYt. in view of s. 8 of the Delimitation
mppala s.,; Do'a Commission Act, 1952, which makes provisions for
and Othm
readjustments and delimitations it is doubtful if the
provisions of s. 54(4) retain their efficacy. Under
Kapur f.
s. 8 cl.(2) of Delimitation Act it is provided that all
constituencies have to be single mrmher constituencies
or two member corntituencies and whl'rever practicable seats may be reserved for Scheduled Caste or
Tribe in a single member constituency but in every
two memb~r constituencv one seat has to be reserved for
Scheduled Caste or Trib~. This provision destroys the
effect of s. 54. If in a single member constituency a seat
can be reserved which means that only· a Scheduled
Caste candidate can be elected to that seat the effect of
reservation of seat in the double member constituency
will also be that when a member of the Scheduled
Caste offers himself for election to a reserved seat he
can be elected only to that seat and to no other. This
is also supported by the definition of electoral rights
in s. 79 of the 1951 Act which is defined as a right of
a. person to stand or not to stand as a candidate at an
election, i.e., an election to fill a seat in either House of
Parliament. The electoral right which a citizen has is
to stand for election to fill a seat and a successful
candidate is one who is elected by securing the largest
number of votes cast for that seat. This necessarily leads
to the conclusion that the respondent Mr. Dippala
Suri Dora who offered himself for election to fill a
reserved seat could only be elected to that seat and
not to the general seat.
The next content.ion raised on behalf of the appellant
was that if a member of the Scheduled Caste or Tribe
wants to contest both the seats, i.e., general and
reserved he would have to file two nomination papers
and pay two deposits. In view of what has been said
above and in view of ss. 32 and 33 and the definition
of the word ' election' such candidate has to file two
nomination papers one for the general seat and the
other for the reserved seat setting out the necessary
qualifications which are required under the law
z959
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
451
I959
Similarly he will have to make two deposits under
s. 34 for the same reason.
Y. V. Girl
A question of some importance has been raised as to
v.
whether a member of Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Dippala Suri Dora
Tribe can by his own act transform himself into a
and Otllers
different and higher caste. That depends upon the
Kapur J.
view one takes of the caste system and whether caste
is dependent upon birth or it varies as a consequence
of Guna, Karma and Subhavana that is merit or
qualities, actions and character. In Hinduism caste
had its origin in vocation and was not dependent upon
birth. Birth as the sole criterion of caste h1 a much
later development and caste became rigid and hereditary when vocations became hereditary. Caste was
nothing but division of labour. There is a high
authority to support the view that in Hinduism caste
was dependent upon actions and not on birth. In
Bhagwat Gita in the fourth Discourse it is stated :
"Th!" four castes were created by me in accordance
with their aptitude and actions; know me the author
of these castes, though I am actionless and inexhaustible."
There are Verses in the Mahabharta also which go to
support this. One such Verse is given as follows:" Truth, Charity, fortitude, good conduct, gentleness, austerity and compassion-he in whom these
are observed is a Brahmana. If these marks exist
in a Sudra and are not found in a twice-born, the
Sudra is not a Sudra nor the Brahmana a Brahmana"
(Teaching given by Yudhisthira)
Even in Bhagwata Purana it is stated :" One becomes a Brahmana by his deeds and not
by his family or birth ; even a Chandala is a Brahmana, if he is of pure character".
In the Chandogya Upanisad there is the interesting
incident of Satyakama who was raised to the position
of a Brahmana because he had spoken the truth. Thus
it was his character and not his birth which determined his caste. Amongst the Hindus many !,.ave
raised themselves to the position of Brahmana by
their good qualities and one such instance is of Sage
452
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1960(1))
Malanga who was a Ohandala. Vishva Mitra was a.
Kshtriya and became a Brahman. Hinduism might
· : '" have become static at one stage but its modern history
Dippala ~"''Do,. shows that this is not so now and it would not be
•Kd Othm
wrong to say that caste in Hinduism is not dependent
upon birth but on actions. The whole theory of karma
K•P..• J.
is destructive of the claim of caste being dependent
upon birth..
In.my opinion Mr. Dippala Suri Dora had by his
actions raised himself to the position of Kshtriya and
he was no longer a member of the Scheduled Caste or
Tribe and on that ground also his election cannot be
supported.
I would therefore allow this appeal, set aside the
order of the High Court and restore that of the Tribunal. The appellant will be entitled to costs of this
Court as well as of the Courts below.
v
x959
G'.
ORDER.
In view of the majority judgment of the Court the
appeal is dismissed with costs in favour of Respondent
No. I.
.A.:p:pe,al, diBrnissed.
KRISHAN KUMAR
I959
v.
May ar.
THE UNION OF INDIA
(JAFER IMAM and J. L. KAPUR, JJ.)
Criminal Trial-Misappropriation-Servant receiving goods
but failing to account to master-Proof of conversion, if necessaryF alse explanaJ.ion by servant, whether can be taken into consi.Iera·
tion-Prevention of Cormption, r947 (II of r947), s. 5(r)(c).
The appellant was employed as an Assistant Store Keeper
in the Central Tractor Organisation, Delhi. He took delivery of
a consignment of iron and steel received by rail for the Organisation and removed them from the railway siding. The goods did
not reach the Organisation. The appellant absented himself
from duty on the following days and when he was called he gave
a false explanation that he had not taken delivery of the goods.
The appellant was tried for misappropriation of the goods, under
s. 5(1)(c} of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947. At the
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org