M/S. TITAGHUR PAPER MILLS CO. LTD. versus ITS WORKMEN
Supreme Court of India | Decided 5 May 1959 | [1959] SUPP. 2 S.C.R. 1012 | 1959 INSC 56
Key facts
- Decided
- 5 May 1959
- Bench
- SUDHI RANJAN DAS*, NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI, S.K. DAS, P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR, K.N. WANCHOO
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 450/1957
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [1959] SUPP. 2 S.C.R. 1012
- Neutral citation
- 1959 INSC 56
Text of the judgment
1012 SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959) Supp.
I959
M/S. TITAGHUR PAPER MILLS CO. LTD.
May 5.
v.
ITS WORKMEN
•
(S. R. DAS, c. J., N. H. BHAGWATI, s. K. DAS,
P. B.
G.AJENDRAGADKAR and
K. N. WANCHOO, JJ.)
Industrial Dispute-Production Bonus, nature of-Jurisdiction of Tribunal to revise production bonus scheme introduced by
employer-Profit Bonus-If can be awarded in addition to prodi;ction bonus-Available surplus-Deduction for rehabilitation, how
calculated.
In 1949 the appellant framed a scheme called" Tonnage Production Bonus Scheme" whereunder the workmen were to get 13
days' basic wages by way of bonus on a production of 30,000 tons
and thereafter an additional one day's basic wage for every 460
tons produced upto a maximum of 36,000. The scheme was
accepted by the workmen. In 1953 the workmen raised industrial disputes claiming profit bonus for the years 1950-51 and
1951-52 in addition to the production bonus and asked for revi·sion of the production bonus scheme. The Industrial Tribunal,
to which the disputes were referred, rejected both the claims.
On appeal, the Appellate Tribunal awarded profit bonus equal to
one month's basic wage for 1951-52 but dismissed the claim for
1950-51 as having been made too late. It revised the production
bonus scheme by providing for rt day's basic wage for each
increase of 460 tons over 30,000 tons upto 36,000 tons and for 2
days• basic wage for each increase of 460 tons in excess of 36,000
tons. The appellant contended (i) that the Tribunal had no
jurisdiction to vary the production bonus scheme; (ii) that such
a scheme could only be varied by agreement ; (iii) that no proper
grounds had been made out for varying the scheme; (iv) that
prolit bonus could not be awarded in addition to production
bonus; (v) that the production bonus in this case was really profit bonus; and (vi) that there was no available surplus out of
which profit bonus could be paid.
Held, that the Tribunal had jurisdiction to revise the production bonus scheme. Payment of production bonus was
payment of further emoluments depending not upon extra
profits, but, upon extra production, as an incentive to the
workmen to put in more than the standard performance.
Though it was discretionary with the appellants to introduce the scheme, once the scheme was introduced and put
into operation, it became a term of employment of the workmen
and any dispute with respect to such term of employment was
an industrial dispute which could properly be referred to a
Tribunal. The power of the Tribunal in considering the scheme
1'
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1013
I959
was not confined to the question of mala fides etc. of the employer's action but it had power to vary the terms of the scheme
MI s. Titaghur
if circumstances justified it.
Paper Mills
There was no justification for interfering with the scheme upCo., Ltd.
to a production of 36,000 tons in view of the agreement between
v.
the parties. But the scheme did not provide for production
above 36,000 tons and as such there was no agreement with res- Its Workmen
pect to this, and as the production bad gone up beyond 36,000
tons it was necessary to provide for production bonus beyond
this quantity. There were two reasons for increase in the rates
of payment of production bonus, viz., (i) the intensification of the
efforts of the workmen in increasing production, and (ii) the
progressive going down of the labour cost of production per ton
as production increased. The rates had to be increased progressively with production. Consequently, for each 460 tons increase
• in production the proper rates for payment of production bonus
would be ri, I~, If and 2 days' basic wages respectJvely for production between 36,000 and 42,000 tons, 42,000 and 48,000
tons, 48,000 and 54,000 tons and 54,000 and 60,000 tons.
The "Tonnage Production Bonus Scheme" introduced by
the appellant was in fact also a production bonus scheme and not
a profit bonus scheme. The fact that one of the terms of the
scheme empowered the directors to cancel or reduce the payment
of production bonus in case the gross profit was not sufficient to
meet fixed dividends, interest, depreciation charges, taxation
and 10% dividend to ordinary shareholders did not make it a
profit bonus scheme as the circumstances mel)tioned are not the
same that have to be taken into account in arriving at the available surplus according to the Full Bench formula. Nor was the
position altered by the clause in the scheme which empowered"
the appellant to cancel or modify the scheme in case Government enforced by legislation any scheme for bonus or profit
sharing as this did not mean that the scheme itself was for profit sharing or profit bonus. The other clauses of the scheme
clearly indicated that it was for production bonus. If there was
an available surplus of profits according to the Full Bench Formula the workmen were entitled to get profit bonus in addition
to the production bonus.
Mathuradas Kanji v. Labour Appellate Tribunal, A.LR. [1958)
S.C. 899, distinguished.
Held further, that there was available surplus of profits and
the profit bonus equal to one month's basic wages was properly
awarded by the Appellate Tribunal for 1951-52. The claim for
deduction for rehabilitation was made on a wrong basis by the
appellant. In order to arrive at a realistic figure for rehabilitation the total block should be divided into three heads: (i) land,
(ii) buildings, railway sidings and things of that nature which
had a much longer life and where no imports were needed, and
(iii) machinery. In the case of land no replacement was necessary and no provision need be made for rehabilitation. In the
1014
I959
Mjs. Titaghur
Paper /Wills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its fVorkmen
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
case of buildings etc. the multiplier would be smaller while the
divisor would be larger. Machinery had again to be sub-divided
according to when it was purchased so as to arrive at correct
multipliers and divisors. As machinery purchased before the
last war stood on one footing there would be a pre-1939 block.
The second block may be of machinery purchased during the
war and the third of that purchased after the war. The
last two \Vere not rigid divisions. In the circumstances of
the present case, the proper multipliers for these three blc cks
would be 4, 2 and r respectively. As both Tribunals had accepted ro as the divisor that may be accepted as the divisor for the
three blocks. Calculating on that basis the rehabilitation costs
did not wipe out the entire gross profits as claimed by the appellants and there was an available surplus out of which profit
bonus could be paid.
The clerical staff, budli workers and temporary workers
\Vere not entitled to claim attendance bonus as they \Vere different from other workmen.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION:
Nos. 450 & 451 of 1957.
Civil Appeals
Appeals by special leave from the judgment and
order dated July 31, 1956, of the Labour Appellate
Tribunal of India, Calcutta, in Appeals Nos. Cal. 282/55
and 6/56.
C. K. Daphtary, Solicitor.General of India, H. N.
Sanyal, Additional Solicitor-General of India, D. N.
Mukherjee and B. N. Ghose, for the Appellant (In C.A.
No. 450/57).
A. Roy Mukherjee and H. N. Hingorani, for the
respondent (In C. A. No. 450/57.)
M. C. Setalvad, Attorney-General for India, C. K.
Daphtary, Solicitor-General for India and H. N. Sanyal,
Additional Solicitor-General of India, D. N. Mukherjee
and B. N. Ghose, for the appellants (In C. A. No.
450/57).
Sadhan Chandra Gupta, J anardhan Sharma and
M. K. Ramamurthi, for the respondents (In C. A. No.
451/57).
Sadhan Chandra Gupta, Janardhan Sharma and
M. K. Ramamurthi, for the appellant (In C. A. No.
451/57).
•
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1015
M. 0. Setalvad, Attorney-General for India, H. N.
Sanyal, Additional Solicitor-General of India, D. N.
Mukherjee and B. N. Ghose, for the respondent (In
C. A. No. 514/57).
G. D. Ambukar for the Secretary, for the Intervener
No. 1.
Sadhan Chandra Gupta and Janardhan Sharma, for
Intervener No. 2.
1959. May 5. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
• WAN CHOO, J .-These are three appeals by special
leave from the same decision of the Labour Appellate
Tribunal of India and will be dealt with together.
The first two appeals (Nos. 450 & 451) are by Messrs.
Titaghur Paper Mills Co. Ltd., and the third (No. 514)
by its workmen.
Titaghur Paper Mills Co., Ltd. (hereinafter called
company) own two paper mills one at Titaghur (hereinafter called Mill No. 1) and the other at Kankinarah
(hereinafter called Mill No. 2). It appears that there
had been a dispute between the company and its
workmen in 1948, which was referred to the adjudication of a tribunal. That was disposed of by the tribunal on November 5, 1949. Among the matters then
referred was the question of profit bonus for the years
1945-46 and. 1946-47. When that matter was under
the consideration of the tribunal, the company put
forward a scheme of production bonus on the basis of
a minimum production of 30,000 tons of paper in a
year in the two mills together. The basis of the
scheme was that the workmen would get 13 days'
basic wage (this being equivalent to half of one month's
basic wage) by way of bonus on a production of30,000
tons for both mills. Thereafter the workmen were to
get an additional one day's basic wage for e\rery 460
tons produced upto a maximum of 36,000 tons when
the production bonus would .come up to 26 days' basic
wage (which would be equivalent to one month's basic
wage including weekly holidays). The company in
putting forward the scheme said that "as an admittedly rough basis for such a scheme something on the
1959
;\J /s
Titaghur
Paper Mills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ].
1016 SUPREME COURT REPORTS
'959
M/s. Titagltur
Paper Mills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its Work1nen
Wanchoo ].
[1959] Supp.
following lines might, we think, be equitable". It
then gave the scheme mentioned above. The tribunal
dealing with the question of profit bonus for the years
1945-46 and 1946-47 observed that the scheme of production bonus put forward by the company had been
accepted by the union as satisfactory and for the purpose of that proceeding it accepted the scheme as a
measure for awarding profit bonus for the years 194546 and 1946-47. The actual bonus worked out to 17
days' basic wage for 1945:46 and 19 days' basic wage
for 1946-47; (see award of Sri M. 0. Banerji, in the
publication of Government of West Bengal, Labour
Department, 'Awards made by the Tribunals for the
quarter ending December, 1949 '', pp. 130-150). It
further appears that the detailed scheme was later
communicated to the union in July 1950 and as the
principle had already been accepted by the union
before Sri Banerji the scheme was put in operation
from April 1, 1949, and production bonus 1ias all along
been paid in accordance with it after that date.
Disputes, however, arose between the company and
its workmen in 1953. The workmen of Mill No. 2 were
the first to raise a dispute in August 1953, in which
inter alia they demanded profit bonus for the years
1950-51 and 1951-52 and also prayed for certain
changes in the production bonus scheme. The workmen of Mill No. 1 also raised a dispute ?'l.1d presented
a charter of demands to the company in October 1953.
They also c;lemanded profit bonus for the two years
mentioned above and revision of the production bonus
scheme. These disputes were referred by the Government of West Bengal to the Fi.fth Industrial Tribunal,
West Bengal. There were two references, one relating
to each mill. They were heard separately by the
Industrial Tribunal which gave two separate awards
rejecting all the demands made by the workmen.
Consequently, two appeals were preferred by the workmen before the Labour Appellate Tribunal. There
the two appeals were heard together at the request of
the parties and disposed of by the Tribunal by the
same judgment on July 31, 1956.
.
The Fifth Industrial Tribunal rejected the claim of
(2) S.C.R.
·~
\
'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1017
the workmen for revision of the production bonus
scheme and for grant of profit bonus for the years
195'0~51 and 1951-52. It was of opinion that the claim
for profit bonus for the two years was not maintainable as the workmen had been given production bonus
and that met the profit bonus claim of the workmen for
the two years and all claims for profit bonus for these
two years must be taken to have been fully satisfied.
The question of delay in making the profit bonus
claim was also raised; but the Fifth Industrial Tribunal was of the view that the profit bonus claim could
not be defeated merely on the ground of delay. As to
the revision of production bonus scheme, it held that
that scheme had been accepted by the union and no
reason had been shown why the rate of one day's
basic wage as production bonus for every increase of
460 tons over 30,000 tons should be disturbed. It was
also of the view that increased production was not due
to increased efforts on the part of the workmen but
waf3 due mainly to increase in labour strength as well
as installation of new machinery.
On appeal the Labour Appellate Tribunal rejected
the claim for profit bonus for the year 1950-51 on the
ground that it was made too late. It, however, disagreed with the view of the Fifth Industrial Tribunal
that the production bonus scheme fully satisfied the
claim of 'the workmen for profit bonus and therefore
no profit bonus should be given even for the year
1951-52, with regard to which it was of opinion that
the claim was not belated. It, therefore, went into
the figures of profits and arrived at the available surplus in accordance with the formula known as the
Full Bench Formula evolved in The Mill-Owners'
As11ociation, Bombay v. The Rashtriya Mill Mazdoor
Sangh, Bombay (1). Having arrived at the available
surplus it granted one month's profit bonus in addition
to what the workmen were entitled to under the production bonus scheme as revised by it. As to the
production bonus scheme, it was of the view that
there were reasons for revising it and therefore revised
\1) l1950) L.L.J. 1247.
128
r959
M fs. 7itaghur
Paper Mills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ].
1018
.I959
M fs. Titaghur
Paper Mills
Co, Ltd.
v.
Its J.Vorktnen
Wanchoo ).
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
it, providing for 1i days~ basic wage for each increase
of 460 tons over 30,000 tons up to the limit of 36,000
tons and two days' basic wage for each"increase o.f 460
tons in excess of 36,000 'tons. It may be mentioned,
however, that the change in the production bonus
scheme was not made retrospective and would therefore come into force from after the judgment of the
Labour Appellate Tribunal. The appeals of the work·men were therefore allowed in these two respects,
which have led to the two appeals by the company
before us. "The workmen through their union have
also filed an appeal against those portions of the decision of the Labour ~ppellate Tribunal which rejected
their demands.
In the two appeals by the company two matters relating to (i) productiot) bonus and (ii) profit bonus have
been raised before us. We shall first take up these
two matters and then come to the appeal by the
workmen.
The main contentions on behalf of the company with
respect to the production bonus scheme are three-fold,
namely,
(1) The Industrial Tribunal has no jurisdiction
to go into the question of production bonus scheme at
all, for such a scheme by its very nature can only be a
matter of agreement between the employer and the
employees and cannot be imposed by a tribur1al;
·(2) Even where a production bonus scheme is in
force, its terms cannot be varied by a tribunal and
any variation can only be the outcome of an agreement between the employer and the employees, because initiation or introduction of such a scheme is
what may be called a 'management function'; and
(3) Even if an industrial tribunal has the power
to vary the production bonus scheme, no material was
placed on the record in this case on the basis of which
the tribunal could order a variation in the scheme .in
force in the company.
As to the award of profit bonus for the year 1951-52
the attack was two-fold, namely,
(4) It was not open to a tribunal to award both
production bonus and profit bonus and in any case it
(2) S.O.R.
..,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1019
could not be done in the present case as the production
bonus here was nothing more than profit bonus; and
(5) Even if both production bonus and profit
bonus could be awarded, there was no available surplus in this case out of which profit bonus for that
yea,r could be paid.
Re. (J).
. Before we go into the question of jurisdiction of a
tribunal under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
(hereinafter called the Act}, we should like to consider
what production bonus essentially is. The payment
of production bonus depends upon production and it>
in addition to wages. In effect, it is an incentive to
higher production and is in the nature of an incentive
wage. There are various plans prevalent in other
countries for this purpose known as Incentive Wage
Plans worked out on various bases, for example, Halsey Premium Plan, Bedaux Point Premium Plan,
Haynes Manit System and Emerson Efficiency Bonus
Plan; (see Labour Law by Smith, Second Edition,
p. 723). The simplest of such plans is the straight
piece-rate plan where payment is made according to
.each piece produced, subject in some cases to a gua. ranteed minimum wage for so many hours' work. But
'the straight piece-rate system cannot work where the
finishe,d product is the result of the co-operative effort
of a large nqmber of workers each doing a small part
which contnbutes to the result. In such cases, production bonus by tonnage produced, as in this case, is
given. There is a base or standard above which
extra payment is made for extra production in addition to the baf\ic wage. Such a pian typically guarantees time wage up to the time represented by standard performance and gives workers a share in the
savings represented by superior performance. But
whatever may be the nature of the plan the payment in
effect is an extra em·olument for extra effort put in by
workmen over the standard that may be fixed. That
is the reason why all these plans are known as Incentive Wage Plans and generally speaking have little to
do with profits. The extra payment depends not on
1959
M /s. Titaghur
Paper Mills
Co., Ltd.
v
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ] .
-
•,
-•
1020' SUPRE111E COURT REPORTS. [1959] Supp.
1959
extra profits but on extra production. This extra pay.
ment calculated on the basis ofextra production is in a
fl.Ifs. Titaghur
Pap" Mills
case like the present where the payment is made after
co .• Ltd.
the annual production is known, in the nature of emol~v.
__ men ts paid at the end of the year. Therefore generally
Its Workmen
speaking, payment of production bonus is nothing
more nor less than a payment of further emoJ.uments
ivanckoo ].
d epen d ing upon production as an incentive to the
workmen to put in more than the standard performance. - Production bonus in this case also is of this
-nature and is nothing more than additional emolument
paid as an incentive for higher production. \Ve shall
later consider the argument whether in this case the
production bonus is anything other than profit bonus.
It is enough to say at this stage that the bonus under
the scheme in this case also depends essentially on
production and therefore is in the natllre- of incenth'e
wage.
Let us now turn to the question of jurisdiction of the
tribunal under the Act to consider a production bonus
scheme at all. The argument is that the introduction
·of a production _bonus scheme is purely discretionary
with the employer and no tribunal can impose such a
scheme. Whetber there should be increased production
in a particular concern is a matter to be determined
entirely by the employer and depends upon a consideration of so many complex· factors, namely, the state
of. the market, the demand for the product, -the range
of prices, and so on. It is, therefore, entirely for the
efuployer to introduce a _production bonus scheme or
not. There is good deal of force in the argument up to
this point; but the argument goes further and it is
said that even after the scheme is introduced, it is for
the same reasons in the discretion of the employer
whether to continue it or not. Therefore, it is urged
that the tribunal cannot have jurisdiction to consider
a production bonus scheme at all, for the tribunal
would then be doing something which the employer
can set at naught by withdrawing the scheme or by
- nullifying the effect of the tribunal's order by so
arranging that the production does not reach the level
at which production bonus __ becomes payable, for
•
•
;
(2) S.C.R.
...
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1021
example, by not providing enough raw material for
the purpose. It is further urged that if it is entirely
in the discretion of the employer to introduce or not
to introduce a production bonus scheme, the fact that
the employer introduces a scheme will not give jurisdiction to the tribunal to interfere with it in any way,
for otherwise the tribunal would be compelling the
employer in the guise of a revision of the scheme to
do something which the tribunal could not initially
do. Our attention in this connection was drawn to
Shalimar Rope Works Mazdoor Union, Howrah v.
Messrs. Shalimar Rope Works Ltd., Shalimar, Howrah (1),
where it was observed that though a production bonus
scheme may be desirable in the interest of harmonious
relationship between the employer and employees,
there is no obligation on the part of the management
to give production bonus and no decision had been
brought to the notice of the Labour Appellate Tribunal holding that a scheme of production bonus was
obligatory on the part of the company ; (see p. 504).
We are, however, not called upon to decide in this
case whether a demand for the introduction of a
production bonus scheme where there was none before
can be made a subject-matter of industrial dispute as
defined in s. 2 (k) of the Act or whether a scheme of
·p.rnduction bonus can for the first time be imposed on
the.employer by a tribunal under the Act. The problem tha\is before us is whether the tribunal under
the Act w1H have jurisdiction to deal with a production bonus scheme in a concern where it has been
introduced. The answer to this question depends upon
the terms of the Act and not on the consideration
whether the _scheme can be initiated only by the employer in the first instance. In order that the tribunal may have jurisdiction all that is necessary is that
an industrial dispute within the meaning of s. 2 (k) of
the Act should exist or be apprehended and there
should be a reference of such dispute by the appropriate government to the tribunal under s. 10. Now
' industrial dispute ' has been defined in very wide
terms in B. 2 (k) and for our purpose it means any
(1) (r957) L.A.C. 496.
I959
Mjs. litaghur
l'apcr Mills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo J.
1022
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959) Supp.
r959
dispute or difference between the employers and
Jl.J/s. Titoghur workmen which is connected with the employment or
non-employment or the terms of employment or with
Papev Mills
Cf'4, Ltd.
the conditions of labour, of any person. \"! e have
v.
already held that the production bonus scheme in this
Its IVorknien
case is an incentive wage plan and what is paid under
the scheme over and above the basic wage is suppleJVanchoo }.
mentary emolument depending upon annual production. A dispute arising about such an emolument
clearly comes within the words " terms of em ployment ". As soon therefore as an employer introduces
a production bonus· scheme and the same is put in
operation and the workmen accept it, it becomes. a
term of employment of the workmen working under
him and any dispute with respect to such a term of
employment is an industrial dispute and if it is referred to a tribunal under s. 10, as has been done in this
case, it has jurisdiction under s. 15 to "deal with it. The
argument therefore on this head must be rejected and
it must be held that the tribunal had jurisdiction under
the Act to deal with the scheme of production bonus
which had been introduced in this company and was
in force at all material times.
Re. (2).
This brings us to the second question, namely,
where a scheme of this kind is in force and there is a
dispute with regard to it.s terms, what is the extent of
the powers of a tribunal to deal with it. .JThe argument is put in this way. The introduction and continuance of a prClduction bonus scheme is one of tho
functions of management. Therefore, when a question
of revision of such a scheme comes up before a tribunal, all that the tribunal "should look into is whether
this matter is an exclusive managlnnent 'function? If
it comes to the conclusion that it is an exclusive
management function, it should not interfere with the
details of the scheme, unless it also comes to the conclusJon that the employer is guilty of mala fides,
victimization, fraud or unfair labour practice through
the introduction or continuance of the scheme. It is said
that even though the tribunal may have jurisdiction
to consider such a scheme, it should refuse to interfere
•
Ill
•
.
•
.
.
'••''
(2) S.C.R. SUPREME COURT Rb:t ~~TS
'
•
;-.'.~ . '
'
1023
1959
with it as soon as it comes-to the conclusion that it is
an exclusive management function and there is no M fs. Tilaghur
'
question of mala.fides, etc.
Paper Mills
\Ve think it unnecessary for present purposes to
Co .• Ltd.
v.
embark on a discussion of what is and what is not an
exclusive management function. Basically, everything Its lVorkmen
connecte,!l with the management of an industrial JVanchoo ].
concern is a management function, except the internal
affairs of any union which may exist. The Act has .
made no distinction between what may be called
exclusive management functions and others. It is
also well settled that the tribunals under the Act have
power to interfere witli management functions falling
within their purview in the interest of industrial peace
and the Act was enacted with that object. Therefore,
once it is conceded, as is the case here, that the tribunal has jurisdiction to entertain such an industrial
dispute· which comes within the terms of s. 2(k) we see
no reason why the power of the tribunal to take into
consideration an incentive wage plan like a production bonus scheme already introduced should be limited merely to the consideration of the question whether
the employer's action is mala fide, etc. \Vhere a production bonus scheme is in force and has become a
term of employment, there is no reason why the tribunal should not have the power to vary its terms if
circumstances justify it. Nor can the power of revision be denied to the tribunal in respect of a scheme
actually introduced on the grouiid that the introduction of such a scheme was an exclusive management
function and therefore it should be immune from being
touched at all. Therefore, even assuming that the
initiation of a production bonus scheme is an exclusive
management function and the final decision with respect to its introduction rests initially with the management., the right of the tribunal to take into considera.
tion such an initiated scheme (which has become a
term of employment) and to revise it cannot for a
moment bo doubted under the Act. It is true that
the tribunal will not lightly interfere with a scheme.
introduced by the management and accepted by the
union. It is also true that the tribunal would only
•I
•
1024 SUPRElUE COURT REPORT~ [1959] Supp.
make a change in the rates for gciod and sufficient
reasons. There can be no doubt, h~wever, that the
J,J/s. Titaghur
tribunal
. has jurisdiction under the .Act to take into
Puper lltJills
consideration a production bonus scheme which lias
Co., Ltd.
v.
been introduced and is in operation and in proper
Its JV01/lmen
cases to revise it, and if necessary to change the rates
- · · and other conditions on which such bonus is .payable.
J"Vanchoo ].
. Our attention in this connection was dro.\yn to Indian
Iron&: Steel Co. Ltd. v. Their Workmen('), where the
·limits of the power of a tribunal to interfere with an
order of dismissal were considered. That case is in
our opinion of no help to the appellant. It was laid
down there that undoubtedly the management of a concern had power to direct its own internal. administration and discipline ; but the power was not unlimited ·
and when a dispute arose, Industrial Tribunals had the
power to see whether the termination of services of a
workman was justified and to give appropriate relief.
It was further laid down under what conditions the
Industrial Tribunal will interfere with the order of
dismissal. On a parity of reasoning, the Industrial
Tribunal has the power under the Act to revise the
production bonus scheme once it has been initiated. It
will do so only for good and cogent reasons, such as a
material change in method, product, tools, material,
design, or production conditions, or a saving in labour
cost and the like, .maintaining as far as possible the
established relationship between earnings and effort
and avoiding rates w.liich will ·give results out of all
proportion to· the basic wage. "Ve are therefore of
opinion that the argument under this head must also
be rejected .
I959
. Re. (3).
.
'
. 1
•
•
The main contention under this head is that there
was no material before the Appellate Tribunal to ·
justify the increase in the rate which it ordered. We
have already pointed out that the scheme put forward
by the company. was to pay a production bonus of
13 days' basic wage on a minimum production of
30,000 tons. Thereafter one day's basic wage was to
(I) (1958] S.C.R 667.
f
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPOitTS
1025
i959
be paid for every 460 tons produced up to the ~axi
mum of 36,000 tons, the rated capacity of the mills M /s. Titaghur
being then said to be over 36,000 tons. The Appel- Paper Mills
late Tribunal has kept the minimum production at
Co., Ltd.
v
30,000 tons with a bonus of 13 days' basic wage.
Between 30,000 and 36,000 tons it has raised the rate Its Workmen
to 1i days' basic wage for each increase of 460 tons Wanchoo ].
over 30,000 tons to the limit of 36,000 tons, and thereafter to two days' basic wage for each increase of 460
tons in excess of 36,000 tons. It ga:ve two reasons in
support of this increase, namely, (i) that the great
increase in production since the introduction of the
scheme was attributable to a very considerable extent
to the increase of efforts on the part of labour and
therefore a reasonable proportion of the increased income on account of increased production should go to
labour, and (ii) that one day's wage only as bonus for
every 460 tons over 30,000 tons is not commensurate
with the actual increase of income on that increased
block of prod.uction. It is not clear to us what exactly
the Appellate Tribunal had in mind when it talked
of the increase of income as a reason for increase in
the rate. The question of increase in the rate has to
be considered in two stages, namely, (i) the increase
between 30,000 and 36,000 tons and (ii) the increase
when production goes beyond 36,000 tons. It appears
from what Mr. Banerji said in his award of 1949 that
the basic principle of the scheme, as it was put forward before him, was accepted by the union as satisfactory, meaning thereby that the union considered
that 13 days' basic wage for a minimum production
of 30,000 tons and one day's basic wage for every 460
tons beyond that upto 36,000 was· fair to labour. It
has been urged that there was no agreement between
the workmen and the company in connection with this
scheme. It does appear that all the terms, which
were incorporated in the scheme communicated to
labour in July 1950, were not initially evolved with
the agreement of the union ; but so far as the rate of
bonus was concerned that was accepted by the union
as satisfactory. In the company's appeals, we are
129
1026 SUPREME COURT REPORTS
I959
[1959] Supp.
concerned only with the rate. The question therefore
is whether the Appellate Tribunal was justified in
M/s. Titaghur
changing
this rate which was agreed to as satisfactory
Paper Milts
by the union up to a production of 36,000 tons. We
Co,. Ltd.
v.
are of opinion that in view of the agreement between
Its Workmen
the parties up to a production of 36,000 tons there
was no such material before the Appellate Tribunal as
Wanchoo ].
would justify interference with the agreed rate. The
intensification of labour must have been taken into
account when th,!l union agreed to the rate up to
36,000 tons, and there is nothing to show that since
then there has been any change in the conditions to
call for a change in the rate. The order of the Appellate Tribunal so far as it relates to production up to
36,000 tons cannot be sustained, as no material was
placed before it to warrant a change in that agreed
rate.
Then we come to the rate after 36,000 tons. There
the considerations in our view are different. The
scheme only provided _for a production o{ 36,000 tons.
It is true that thereafter the production bas gone up
beyond 36,000, and the company has been paying the
same flat rate of one day's basic wage for every 460
tons for the extra production and the workmen have
been accepting that payment. At the same time there
was no collective acceptance by the union on behalf
of the workmen of this rate being satisfactory or fair
for production above 36,000 tons. Production went
beyond 36,000 tons for the first time in 1951-52 and a
dispute was raised in October 1953 by the workmen
of Mill No. 1 not very long after production for that
year was known. There was no dispute as to the
general revision of· the rate by the workmen of Mill
No. 2 ; but it was conceded on behalf of the company
that the two mills must be treated on the same footing in this matter. The company therefore cannot
say that the Appellate Tribunal should not have
interfered with the rate above 36,000 tons, because
there was a collective agreement by the union on behalf of the workmen and there was no material before
it to change the rate even beyond 36,000 tons. Two
reasons were given by the Appellate Tribunan for the
;
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1027
change it ordered. Of these the second is difficult to
understand as it is not clearly or happily expressed,
though the first reason, (namely, increased effort on
the part of labour) would certainly apply when we
consider production beyond 36,000 tons. It stands to
reason that where the labour force is more or less the
same, production beyond the original target of 36,000
tons would mean more intensification of effort by
labour, for it is not in dispute that the working hours
have remained the same. Other things being equal,
the greater the production by the same labour force
in the same space of time, there is bound to be more
intensification of labour to achieve this result. This
is certainly a matter which the Appellate Tribunal
could take into account in considering whether the
rate after 36,000 tons should be raised. A comparison
of figures of production and labour force employed
between 1948 and 1952 (assuming other factors to be
the same) would show that there must have been
intensification of labour effort to get the increased production. In 1948, total labour force in the two mills
was 5,860 (Exs. F & H). In 1952, it went up to
6,213, an increase of just over 6 per cent. Production
on the other hand was 28,244 tons in 1948-49 while it
was 37,738 tons in 1951-52, an increase of slightly
above 33 per cent. So it is obvious that the increase in
production is much more than the increase in labour
force. It is true that in 1950 a new paper-making
machine was substituted in one of the mills, and some
bamboo-crusli.ers and digesters were also added during
this period and other large amounts spent on machinery, and that fact certainly accounts for a part of
the increase. It is, h<;>wever, not possible to ascertain,
with anything like mathematical accuracy, as to how
much of the increase in production is attributable to
improved machinery and how much of it is referable
to intensification of labour of the workmen. It may
nevertheless be taken as fairly certain that the
increase in production is referable to a great extent to
intensification of the efforts of the workmen, for there
has been no appreciable increase in the labour force.
'Ve have not got the _figures of labour force in the
I959
M Js. Tita,ghur
Paper Mills
Co .• Ltd.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ].
1028 SUPREME COURT REPORTS
I959
Jo.Ifs. Titaghur
Paper Mills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ].
[1959] Supp.
later years, though production has gone on increasing,
till it is said it will reach 54,000 tons mark in 1958.59.
It is apparent, therefore, that there must have been
progressive intensification of labour as the production
rose beyond 36,000 tons, and in the premises that was
a circumstance which the Appellate Tribunal was
properly entitled to take into account when considering a change in the rate for production over 36,000
tons .
. The second ground given by the Appellate Tribunal,
as we have said :ibove, is not quite clear to us. Learned counsel for the workmen have, however, explained
that what the Tribunal means is that as the production increases more and more the labour cost per ton
goes down; and thus there is a saving in labour cost
to the company and the workmen are entitled to share
in this progressive saving of labour cost. The principle
which is inherent in this explanation is in fact the
basis of progressive increase in production bonus rates
as production increases. This will be clear• from an
illustration, which we shall give just now. This illustration is based as nearly as possible on the conditions in these two mills with this difference that we
have taken round figures for facility of multiplication;
the result will be more or less the same if actual
figures are taken. For the parposes of this illustration, we shall assume that the labour force and other
relevant factors remain constant. Let us start with
a basic production of 30,000 tons with a labour force
of 6,000 and an average wage of all kinds at Rs. llO/per mensem (Ex. E). The total labour cost on this
basis for 30,000 tons per year comes to 79·2 lacs, giving labour cost per ton as Rs. 264/-. Now, when production increases to 36,000 tons and a production bonus
of Rs. 25/- per year (Ex. E) is added to the wage,
labour cost for the extra production of 6000 tons
comes to Rs. I ·5 lacs. The total labour cost, therefore,
for 36,000 tons is 80·7 lacs, which works out to slightly above Rs. 224/- per ton. When production goes
up to 42,000 tons, the labour cost increases by 3 lacs,
giving a labour outlay of 82·2 lacs; this works out to
just below Rs. 196 per ton. When production increases
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1029
1959
to 48,000 tons, the extra labour cost is 4·5 lacs, making a total of 83·7 lacs for 48,000 tons; thus the cost M /s. Titaghur
per ton is slightly above Rs. 174/-. When production Paper Mills
goes up to 54-,000 tons, labour cost increases by 6 lacs,
Co., Ltd.
v.
giving a total cost of 85·2 lacs for 54,000 tons, wbi ch
works out to just below Rs. 158/- per ton. When Its Workmen
production reaches 60,000 tons, which is double the JVanchoo ].
basic production, the additional sum paid to labour in
bonus is 7·5 lacs and the total cost 86·7 lacs for 60,000
tons which works out to R.s. 144·5 per ton. This is on
the basis of the production bonus above 36,000 tons
being kept at the same rate at which it is provided in
the scheme in this case. It will be clear, therefore,
that as production increases (if other factors are the
same, namely, labour force and machinery), there is a
progressive increase in the saving of labour cost. This,
in our opinion, makes out a clear case, where one is
dealing with tonnage production bonus, for a progressive increase in the bonus. We know that in this case
there has been an increase, but of a small order, in
the labour force during the period of increased production; we also know that a new paper-making
machine has been put in in the place of an old one and
new bamboo-crushers and digesters have been added;
and we know that during the period from April l,
1948, to April 1, 1959, there bas been a total outlay
on machinery and plant, worth 223·94 lacs including
the above. There is no doubt, therefore, that when
production is expected to reach the figure of 54,000
tons in 1958-59, this outlay on machinery and plant
must also have contributed to it. The increase in
labour force, if any, after April I, 1952, niay also
have made its contribution. But it appears to us that
it is still valid to say that there is saving in labour
cost which increases progressively as production goes
up and labour can therefore legitimately claim a progressively higher rate. Therefore, though the Appellate Tribunal's second reason does not appear to have
been clearly expressed, something like what we have
said above must have been at the back of its mind
when it decided to change the rate above 36,000 tons.
There can be no doubt that the consideration we have
1030
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
set.out above, will be valid to support the view taken
by
the A ppel!ate Tribunal that there should be a
Mfs. Titothur
change in the rate, though it may not necessarily supPaper l\1ills
port the actual change ordered by it. We must not
Co., Ltd.
v.
forget that there was no collective bargaining resultIts Workmen
ing in an agreement between the union and the company so far as production above 36,000 tons is• conJVanchoo J.
cerned as was the case so far as production upto
36,000 tons went. A case has, therefore, been made
out for a change in the rate when production goes
above 36,000 tons.
The next question is whether the flat rate of two
days' basic wage for every 460 tons allowed by the
Appellate Tribunal can be supported. Usually, when
tonnage production bonus is worked out, the rates
progressively increase. We may in this connection
refer to the illustration given in" Payment by Results"
published by the International Labour Office, Geneva,
at p. 102. "'Te think, therefore, that though there is
a case for increasing the rate when production goes
above 36,000 tons, it should be on a progressively increasing system. The present scheme, as we have
pointed out earlier, was evolved as an admittedly
rough basis which was thought to be equitable. Following the same rough basis and using the same block
of 6,000 tons with slabs of 460 tons, we think that on
the data available at present, it would be fair to give
progressive rates for production from over 36,000 tons
up to 60,000 tons. We need not go beyond this for the
present, and if production increases beyond 60,000
tons, the matter can be gone into again. We consider,
therefore, that the rate should be changed as follows
for production over 36,000 tons:(i) From over
H days' basic wage on the same
36,000 tons to
scale as is provided in the sche42,000 tons.
me from 30,000 to 36,000 tons.
l,~ days' basic wage on the same
(ii) From over
42,000 tons to
conditions as above.
48,000 tons.
(iii) From over
48,000 tons to l~ days' basic wage -do54,000 tons.
z959
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1031
(iv) From over
54,000 tons to 2 days' basic wage -do60,000 tons.
We therefore modify the change in the rate ordered
by the Appellate Tribunal as above.
&.~~
.
The contention under this head is that though this
scheme is called a production bonus scheme, in reality
it is no more than a profit bonus scheme; and therefore, the workmen are not entitled to an.')' profit bonus
worked out on the Full Bench formula referred to
a.hove in addition to what they get under this production bonus scheme. In this connection reliance is
placed particularly on clauses (14) and (18) of the
scheme. Let us therefore determine the true nature
of the scheme. The scheme is headed " Tonnage
Production Bonus Scheme" and not a scheme for profit bonus based on the Full Bench formula. It is true
that this nomenclature is not decisive but is nevertheless a factor which may properly be taken into consideration. The primary and basic object of the scheme,
as given in cl. (2), is to stimulate the interests and
endeavours of the clerks and workers of the company
in increasing the production of saleable paper and to
ensure that the workers will get by way of incentive
an increased return for their labour contributing to
the benefits which would accrue from such increased
productivity. This again shows that this is a production bonus scheme and nothing else. Then comes
cl. (4), whi.ch lays down that upto a minimum of
30,000 tons the bonus would be 13 days' basic wage;
thereafter there is increase of one day's basic wage for
every 460 tons till the figure of 26 days' basic wage is
reached for a total production of 36,000 tons. Here
again there is no connection between profits and bonus
that accrues under this clause. If, for example, production falls below the minimum of 30,000 tons, there
will be no bonus at all under the scheme whatever
may be the profits. This one circumstance clearly
brings out the true nature of this scheme, namely,
that it is a scheme of production bonus and not of
I959
M /s, Titaghur
Pap" Mills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ],
1032 SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1959] Supp.
'959
M/s. Titaghur
Paper Mills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ],
profit bonus under the Full Bench formula. That
formula had nothing to do with production. Bonus
under that formula depended entirely on the available
surplus of profits worked out in the manner provided
therein. Then we come to clause (14). That clause
lays down that the scheme will be subject to one most
imp"Ort;tnt general exception, namely, th!tt the profit
earning capacity of the company, irrespective of the
volume of production of saleable paper, remains satisfactory during the financial year. Accordingly the
clause prescribes that the directors may at their sole
discretion either cancel altogether or reduce in scale
of monetary payments the bonus in any one or more
financial years in which the gross profit earned by the
company over the whole financial year is not sufficient to meet fixed dividends and interest, depreciation
charges and taxation and thereafter pay for the whole
year dividend not less than IO per cent. to the ordinary shareholders of the company. It is said that this
makes the scheme a profit bonus scheme. We are
unable to agree with this contention. It is true that
the scale of payment is likely to go down or there
may even be no payment of bonus at all in the circumstances mentioned in cl. (14). But the circumstances
mentioned there are admittedly not the same which
have to be taken into account in arriving at the available surplus according to the Full Bench Formula.
Clause (14) appears to us to be just one condition upon
which the payment of production bonus would depend,
like some other clauses in the scheme. For example,
cl. (5) seems to provide that workers who work for
less than half the total number of working days in the
financial year for which bonus is being paid, shall not
get any bonus, for it only makes those workers who
work for more than half the total number of working
days, worked out according to other rules, entitled to
bonus. Clause (6) says that certain kinds of workers
will not be entitled to bonus, namely, Bungalow servants, Budli clerks or workers, temporary clerks or
workers, casual workers or clerks. It also provides
that any person gumy of any major misdemeanour
may at the sole discretion of the Mill Manager or the
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1033
I959
Cost Accountant not be given this bonus either in part
or in whole as a punishment, and that this would be M /s. Titaghur
done after taking proceedings in writing for the pur- Paper Mills
pose. Clause (7) provides another condition as to what
Co., Ltd,
v
service will count towards earning bonus and what
!Is
Workmen
will not; for example, leave on full or part pay shall
count as bonus service· while leave without pay will Wanchoo ].
not count as qualifying service towards bonus. Again
cl. (8) lays down that a worker will be entitled to the
maximum bonus if he works for all the working days
during the financial year, for which the bonus is
declared. Clause (9) then provides how the maximum
bonus can be reduced, if a worker does not work for
all the working days. Clause (14) therefore is also
another clause which may either lead to no payment
of bonus or less payment than prescribed under cl. (4).
Further the fact that this is not a profit bonus scheme
bu.ta production bonus scheme will also be clear from
what cl. (14) actually provides. It says that if the
conditions mentioned in it are not falfilled, the workers
would not be entitled to bonus or may get less. This
means that if the conditions are fulfilled, workers
would be entitled to bonus. Now, suppose, that the
gross profit in a year is sufficient to meet fixed dividends and interest, depreciation charges and taxation
and 10 per cent. dividend to the ordinary shareholders.
Thereafter the balance of profit left is only (let us say)
Rs. 5/-. But as the conditions of cl. (14) are fulfilled,
the workers would be entitled to production bonus,
though the amount of Rs. 5/- which remains, cannot
possibly meet the claim of bonus. It is clear therefore
that this bonus scheme is not the same as the profit
bonus worked out under the Full Bench formula and
it cannot be called a profit bonus scheme even otherwise. This is nothing more nor less than a pure production bonus scheme based on tonnage, depending on
certain conditions one of which is related to profits
also. The nature of this bonus, therefore, in our
opinion, is entirely different from the nature of profit
bonus under the Full Bench formula and we do not
see why if there is an available surplus of profits
130
•
1034 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1959] Supp.
'959
M /s. Titaghur
Paper Mills
Co .• Ltd,
v.
Its JV01.k1nen
Wanchoo ].
according to the Full Bench formula, the workmen
should· not get profit bonus in accordance with that
formula. The two things, in our opinion, are different.
Under the scheme what the workers get is a supplementary emolument worked out on certain basis.
Under the Full Bench formula, what they get is something out of the profits, ifthete is an available surplus
on the ground that both capital and labour contribute
to the accrual of profits and it is only fair that labour
should get a part of it.
.
In this connection our attention was drawn to
Mathuradas Kanji v. Labour Appellate Tribunal (1),
where it was observed that "one of the categories of
bonus is described as "incentive bonus". The name
indicates that it is given as a cash incentive to greater
effort on the part of the labour. But the essential
condition for the payment of incentive bonus just like
any other kind of bonus, is that the industry concerned must earn profits part of which is due to the contribution which the workmen made in increasing production." That was not a case of production bonus
at all. The bonus dealt with there was included in an
agreement between the government and its contractors
in a contract relating to clearing and transporting of
imported foodgrains. It was provided that if the rate
of discharge from a ship exceeded 1,500 tons per 24
hours and no shed demurrage was incurred, the
government would pay to the contractors remuneration at the prescribed rates plus a bonus of annas four
per ton. The workmen employed by the contractors
claimed that this bonus should be given to them.
That claim was negatived on the ground that the
workers could not claim, on the terms of the contract,
that the bonus of annas four per ton was payable to
them. These observations made in a different setting
have therefore no relevance iu the context of the production bonus scheme with which we are dealing here
and which has become a term of employment of the
workmen.
As for cl. (18), it provides that if during the currency of three years for which the scheme was to
(1) A.I.R. 1958 S.<;. 899.
(2) S.O.R.. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1035
remain in force in the first instance, the government enforced by legislation any scheme or provision for bonus
or profit sh~ring, the company may decide to cancel
or modify the scheme in its entirety. It is urged that
this shows that the scheme was one for profit sharing
or profit bonus, because it was likely to be cancelled
or modified if legislation was introduced with respect
to these. It may be that the scheme might have been
cancelled or modified if such legislation was passed.
But that does not mean that the scheme itself provided for profit sharing or profit bonus. It is one thing
to cancel or modify a scheme because the' legislature
steps in to provide for extra payment for workmen.
But the nature of the provision of law, which was
then expected, cannot be imposed on this scheme,
which must be judged on its own terms; these leave
no doubt that it is not a profit bonus scheme but an
incentive wage plan depending upon production in the
main. The contention therefore that the bonus under
the scheme is a profit bonus and therefore the workmen are not entitled to the profit bonus under the
Full Bench formula must fail.
Re. (5).
The contention under this head is that even if profit bonus is payable in addition to production boims,
there was no available surplus of profits to justify the
Appellate Tribunal in granting one month's bonus.
The workmen had asked for two month's bonus: but
the Appellate Tribunal after working out the available
surplus on the basis of the Full Bench formula granted
them one month's bonus. The Full Bench formula was
evolved in 1950 in connection with a case relating to
the textile industry and bas been since then generally
applied to many other industries. The necessity for
evolving that formula arose in this way: When prices
are stable or falling, there is no necessity of making
further provision for rebabilitatfon for the usual
depreciation, provided for the purposes of the Income-tax Act, is sufficient to build up a fund for
replacement of plant and machinery when they
are worn out; but when prices are rising the usual
depreciation fund is not enough to replace plant and
I959
M /s. Titaghur
Paper Mills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ./.
1036 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1959] Supp.
•959
.P.1 /s. Titaghur
Paper Jl!ills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ].
machinery which become useless. This was particularly so after the end of the last war, when the
question of replacing machinery purchased before the
war, i.e., before 1939, came up before the Full Bench of
the Labour Appellate Tribunal in 1950. In order, therefore, to meet this particular situation arising out of a
steep rise in prices, the Full Bench formula was evol ved to provide for a further sum for rehabilitation out
of the profits besides the statutory depreciation. This
was on a notional basis and depended upon a multiplier which was used to find out the current prices of
machinery to be replaced and a divisor based on the
useful life of the machinery to find out what sum
should be provided each year for what was called
rehabilitation. In order, however, that this sum
notionally provided for rehabilitation each year has a
realistic connection with the amount in fact necessary
for the purpose, it is, in our opinion, necessary that
what is known as the total block of a concern including
land, buildings, plant and machinery, should be properly sub-divided, as otherwise a fiat multiplier at
the same rate for the total block might not give
an accurate amount to be provided for rehabilitation.
It is, therefore, necessary in order to arrive at an
approximately realistic figure for rehabilitation that
the total block should be divided into three heads,
namely, (i) land, (ii) buildings, railway sidings and
things of that.nature which have a much longer life
and where imports are not needed, and (iii) machinery.
In the case of land, no replacement is necessary and
therefore nothing need be provided for rehabilitation
under this head. Even where land is leasehold and
the lease is expiring, any payment for renewal of lease
will be an expense and need not enter into calculations for rehabilitation. Further if there are buildings
belonging to the concern on leasehold land, their rehabilitation charge be will allowable under the head
buildings. In the case of buildings,· railway sidings
etc., the multiplier will be smaller while the divisor
will be larger. As for machinery, there is again the
necessity of further sub-division, according to when the
machinery was purchased. The machinery purchased
~
•
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1037
1959
before the last war stands on one footing and thus
there will be a block of machinery which may be M /s. Titaghur
know as pre-1939. The second block of machinery Paper Mills
may well be that purchased during the war and the
Co., Ltd.
v.
last block that purchased after the war. The last
.
Its
Workmen
two are not rigid divisions; but they indicate that
machinery has to be divided into blocks according to Wanchoo ].
years of purchase to arrive at a correct multiplier and
a correct divisor.
Bearing these principles in mind, let us see how the
Full Bench formula works in this case. We may mention that there is no dispute in this case as to the components of the formula, the only dispute being confined to its actual application. The company claimed
a multiplier of 4·5 and a divisor of 10, and on that
basis gave a chart showing a deficit of 112 lacs in the
amount required for rehabilitation for 1951-52.
Another chart was also filed by the company in which
the multiplier was taken as 3·5 and the divisor as 10,
and the deficit was worked out at 65 lacs. What the
company did was to take the total block consisting of
land, buildings, railway sidings and machinery, valued
at 468 lacs and multiply it by 4·5 or 3·5, making no
distinction between land, buildings and railway
sidings, and machinery. The divisor was also taken
as 10, making no distinction again between these
three categories, and further making no distinction
between the machinery purchased before 1939, during
the last war and after the last war. This, in our
opinion, was a completely unrealistic way of working
out the amount required for rehabilitation, and that
is why the company was able to show in its charts
such a large deficit.
The Appellate. Tribunal did not accept these charts.
It Jeft out of account land altogether, and rightly so.
As for buildings, it applied a different multiplier and
a different divisor, and so far as that is concerned no
dispute has been raised before us. As for machinery,
consisting of plant, machinery, bamboo forest block,
furniture, flotilla and vehicles, it divided the block for
this purpose into two parts, namely, the block as it
existed on April 1, 1947, and the additions made
1038
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
•
t
r959
between April 1, 1947, to March 31, 1951. It applied
a
multiplier of 3 so far as the block upto April 1, 1947,
AI/s. Titaghur
was concerned and took the block of additions after
Paper Mills
Co., Ltd.
1-4-1947 at cost price, thus using one as multiplier. It
v.
is not clear why the Appellate Tribunal did not include
Its Workmen
the additions made in 1951-52. The Appellate Tribunal also accepted the divisor 10 for all this plant,
fV anchoo •].
machinery, etc., and made no difference between the
useful life of the machinery purchased at different
times. Eventually, after making the relevant calculations, it came to the conclusion that there was an
available surplus of profits amounting to 22 la-cs. It,
therefore, awarded one month's profit bonus on basic
normal wage.
It is contended on behalf of the company that
evidence had been produced on its behalf to show that
• the prices of machinery had appreciated 4il; times as
compared to the prices in 1939, and therefore, the
multiplier of 4·5 should have been allowed at least on
t_he block of machinery up to 1939. Thereafter it is
claimed that some multiplier above one should be
given for the block 1939-1947 and also for the block
1947-51. It is further contended that the additions
made in 1951-52 should also have been taken into
account.
It may be mentioned that the Labour Appellate
Tribunal which evolved the Full Bench formula in
1950 had used the multiplier 2·7 in that case for prewar block and that multiplier has been used since then
in many other cases. It is, however, contended on
behalf of the company that that multiplier is not
sacrosanct, and if in fact there has been a greater rise
in price, there is no reason why a higher multiplier
should not be used. It may be acc.epted that if an
employer is able to prove that in fact there has b¥en
. a greater rise in price, he should be given a higher
multiplier. But there has to be good proof tendered
by the employer for the multiplier which he claims.
Let us see, therefore, what proof the company has
tendered in this case for a multipler of 4·5 for the
block upto April 1, 1939. In its written-statement
·the company said that it was a known fact that the
,.
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1039
I959
price of plant and machinery had increased by 300
per cent. to 400 per cent. since before the war. At M /s. Tifaghur
that stage there was no claim that the price had Paper Mills
increased 4~ times e,fter April 1, 1939. The company's
Co., Ltd.
v.
claim, therefore, as put in in the written-statement,
Its Workmen
was for a maximum multiplier of 4 for the block upto
April 1, 1939. In the evidence of Mr. Taylor, who Wanchoo ].
appeared as a witness for the company, however,
claim was made that prices had gone up by 4~ times.
This was based on Ex. D produced by the company
which was compiled on the basis of inquiries about
certain machinery' from certain firms and copies of the
correspondence with the firms were also produced.
Nineteen items were mentioned in Ex. D and the
average multiplier was worked out as 4·56. Among
the items listed in Ex. D were motors, beaters,
machine drive, paper-making machine, turbo-alternator, couch roll, bamboo-crushers, bamboo-digesters, •
boiler, circular tanks and three roaster smelter units ..
The total price of these items was 19 lacs, (we have
converted pounds into rupees for this purpose).
Besides these, there are other items, like steam piping,
steam tee, galvanized bend and steam bends, which are
probably required in large quantities and the price per
foot or per piece has been mentioned. The correspondence which was attached to Ex. D consists of four
letters, one of September 1954 and three of June 1955,
relating to one paper-making machine similar to one
installed in Mill No. 2, a turbo-alternator similar to
one installed in Mill No. 1, a machine drive similar to
one installed in Mill No. 1 and a boiler similar to one
installed in Mill No. 1. Now:, the cost of machinery
block as at April 1, 1939, was of the order of 153 lacs
while Ex. D only deals with machinery of the value
of 19 lacs as mentioned above. Mr. Taylor did not
say in his evidence that Ex. D was a sample and that
other machines were of the same type as mentioned in
Ex. D or that the prices of other machinery had gone
up similarly or to the same extent. Exs. D-1 to D-4
indicate that the price of one out of ten paper-making
machines was ascertained and nothing was ascertained about nine others. Similarly prices of one
1040 SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
turbo-alternator, one machine drive and one boiler of
Mill
No. 1 were ascertained. We do not know how
M/s. Titaghur
many
more such machines are in the two mills ; nor do
Paper Mills
we know that the increase in price~ of these types of
Co., Ltd.
v.
machines is also four and a half times. In the circumIts Wo'k"'"'
stances, we feel that the company has failed to provide
sufficient material on the basis of which it can claim
Wanchoo ],
4·5 as the multiplier. It is the company which is
• claiming that a certain multiplier be used for calculating rehabilitation reserve, and it was its duty to produce good and sufficient evidence as to the correct
multiplier if it wants that multiplier to be used. We
cannot also forget that in its written-statement the
company only claimed a rise of 300 per cent. to 400
per cent. on pre-war price. In the circumstances, the
tribunal was not unjustified in not giving the mu!Liplier of 4·5. 'Ve also feel that in these circumstances
• we shall not be justified in giving the company a
,multiplier higher than 4, for that wa·s the maximum
claim it had put forward in its written-statement. We
should, however, like to make it clear that though we
are using the multiplier 4 for the block as at April 1,
1939, this should not be taken to be a precedent for
future years, even for this company, and it will be
open to either party to adduce proper evidence to
show what the exact multiplier should be for this
block, whether more than 4 or less.
Then we come to the block from April 1, 1939
to March 31, 1947. The Tribunal gave the multiplier 3 for this block also. But that was because
it gave the same multiplier for the entire block
as at 1947, including the pre-war block. As,· however, we are giving a ·multiplier of 4 for the prewar block, the multiplier 3 for the block April 1, 1939
to March 31, 1947, can only be justified, if the company has proved that that was the rise in the prices
after 1939. So far as that is concerned, the company
did not produce any evidence before the Industrial
Tribunal. It seems, ho1vever, that certain documents
were produced before the Appellate Tribunal on June
12, 1956, when the appeals were ready for argument.
The order-sheet of June 12, 1956, shows that the
'959
!
'
(2) S.C.R.
....
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1041
I959
Appellate Tribunal allowed four statements regarding
certain machines given by different firms to be admit- M /s. Titaghur
ted into evidence. Learned counsel for the workmen Paper Mills
Co., Ltd.
object to our looking into these statements on the
v.
ground that they never knew that any such stateIts Workmen
ments had been filed at the last moment before the
Appellate Tribunal and nobody seems to have relied Wanehoo ].
on these statements before the Appellate Tribunal
and the judgment also makes no mention of them.
There seems to be a good deal of force in these contentions. However, looking at these statements, ;which.
have been taken on record, we find that they relate to
ten items. Four of them are of the years 1945-48 and
the increase of price varies from 60 per cent. to 75 per
cent. Two are of 1950 and the increase varies from
15 per cent. to 50 per cent., three are of 1951 and the
increase varies from 99·5 per cent. to 116 per cent.,
and one is of 1954 and the increa.se is 60 per cent.
The increased price is as of 1956. Even taking these
documents into account, we feel that the company
cannot ask for a multiplier higher than 2 for the block
between 1939-1947. But even this will not be -taken
as a precedent for future and it will be open to either
party to give better evidence in order to vary this
multiplier one way or the other.
As for the block after 1947, it appears that the
company added machinery to t;he tune of 87 lacs
between April I, 1949 and March 31, 1952, while the
prices quoted for the years 1950 and 1951 in these documents were only of machines worth 5 lacs. We do
not know whether this machinery is of the same
kind as that mentioned in these documents. They
cannot, therefore, be a guide for a.rriving at any multiplier higher than one for thiS period relating to this
block of 87 lacs. Here again we should like to make
it clear that if in future years better evidence is produced, the question of giving a multiplier higher than
I for this block can be considered.
This disposes of the multipliers on the blocks of
machines divided into three periods. We now come
to the divisor. Both the Tribunals have accepted 10
131
1042 SUPREME COURT ,REPORTS
I959
M /s
Titaghur
Paper Mills
Co .• Ltd
v.
Its H1 orkmen
W11nchoo J.
[1959] Supp.
as the divisor on the evidence of Mr. Taylor. We
must say that it looks odd to us that there should be
the same divisor for pre.1939 machinery, and post1939-but-pre-194 7 machinery, and post-1947-but-pre1952 machinery. It stands to reason that newer the
machinery the larger must be the divisor for the
Del.Ver machinery would have a.longer useful life. However, as both the Tribunals have accepted 10 as the
divisor for the entire machinery in this case, we shall
also have to accept it; but we should like to make it
clear tJiat this should also not be taken as a precedent
for future years and it will be open to either party to
show that the divisor should be different, whether
more or less than 10, for various blocks of machinery
relating to the three periods.
Let us now work out the figures on the basis of the
above considerations. We have taken the basic figures
as supplied to us by the learned counsel for the company:
t
f
REHABILITATION COST
In lacs
In lacs
of Rs.
of Rs.
153·43 x 4 = 613·72
(a) Plant & machinery as
at 1-4.1939:
Machinery added between 22·41 x 2 = 44•82
1-4-1939 and 31-3-1947 :·
87·27 x 1 = 87·27
Additions between
---1-4-1947 and 31-3-1952:
Total. ........ 745·81
13•15
Less 5% breakdown value ...
Balance ......
Less depreciation upto 31-3-1951
Balance ......
Less ReservesGeneral Reserve......
25·49
Plant Replacement ...... 67·98
Balance ......
Dividing by 10 ........... .
---732·66
176·03
---556·63
93•47
---463•16
46•31
"'
....
,
.
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(b) Buildings :
Value of building
as at 31-3-47:
Additions between
1-4-47 and 31-3-52:
Less 5% breakdown
1043
z959
42•85 x 2·5 =
96•41
21·19
21·19
=
Total . . . . . .. .. 117·60
3·20
Balance......
114·40
47·21
Balance......
Dividing by 27..... ... . . .. . ..
67·19
2·48
Less depreciation upto
31-3-1951 :
******
Rehabilitation for(a) Plant & Machinery ...............
...............
(b) Building
46•31
2•48
Total.........
Less depreciation for 1951-52...... ...
48·79
16·50
Balance...... 32·29
Rehabilitation Amount for 1951-52:
32·29
Rehabilitation amount for 1951-52 thus comes to
32·29 lacs. In the charts supplied by the company
the net profits after deducting prior charges other
than rehabilitation cost were worked out at 36·09 lacs.
We find, however, that there is one mistake in this
calculation inasmuch as 76·3 lacs have been included
in working capital, though this was merely a book
entry and there was no cash corresponding to it.
4 per cent. interest was allowed on working capital
and this would mean that the net profits should
increase by 3·05 lacs as that interest was allowed
extra in the company's chart before the Appellate
Tribunal. Thus the amount of net profits available,
before the allowance of rehabilitation charges, comes
to 39·14 lacs (36·09 + 3·05). Deducting 32·29 lacs we
arrive at the available surplus of profits amounting to
6·85 lacs (39·14-32·29), which is to be distributed
equitably between the three sharers mentioned in the
M /s. Titaghur
Paper Mills
Co., Ltd.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ].
1044 SUPREME COURT REPORTS- [1959] Supp.
I959
very decision of the Labour Appellate Tribunal which
evolved
the formula. The total cost of one month's
111 /s. Titaghur
bonus on basic wages allowed by the Appellate TribuPaper Mills
Co •• Ltd.
nal is about 3 lacs. Taking all the circum.stances of
v.
this case into consideration we do not think that any
!ls Worktnen
case has been made out for interference with this
order of the Appellate Tribunal. We may P,Oint out
Wanchoo ].
that we have not taken into account bamboo-mills
and grass.block for reasons given by the Appellate
Tribunal, which commend themselves to us.
This brings us to the appeal by the workmen. Only
three points have been urged before us out of the
many taken in the grounds of appeal, and we shall
deal only with these three. They are(i) The minimum basic wage should have been
raised from Rs. 30 to Rs. 35;
(ii) Clerical staff as well as Budli and tern porary
workers should have been included in the attendance
bonus scheme ; and
(iii) Profit bonus should have been allowed at two
months' basic wages for 1951-52 instead of one
month's.
Re. (i).
Both the Tribunals have rejected the claim for
raising the basic wage on the principle of "Industrycum-Region Rate of Basic Wages". The workmen
relied on the wages paid in the Bengal Paper Mills
Ltd. at Raniganj, which is also a paper-making concern. The minimum basic wage there is Rs. 38-3,
dearness allowance l{s. 35 and the incentive "age is
said to work out to Rs. 7-5-6 per mensem, making the
total Rs. 80-8-6. In the present company, minimum
basic wage is Rs. 30; dearness allowance is Rs. 35;
house allowance is Rs. 2; attendance bonus works out
to Rs. 8 and production bonus is about Rs. 3, making
a total of Rs. 78. It will thus be seen that the
difference is not great. Further, if the production
bonus and incentive wage are not taken into account,
the present company pays Rs. 75 per mensem while
the Raniganj company pays Rs. 73·3. In the circumstances, we see no reason for interfering with the concurrent order of the two Tribunals.
f
\
(2) S.C.R.
SUPREME COUHT REPORTS
1045
r959
Re. (ii).
The Tribunals rejected the claim for extending the Mfs. Titaghur
attendance bonus scheme to clel'ical staff, budli workers Paper Mills
and temporary workers. They were of the view that
Co., Ltd.
v.
these workmen stand on a different footing. For the
Its
Workmen
clerical staff the reason given was that they enjoyed
the advantage of the incremental scales which were Wanchoo ].
till then denied to other categories of mill hands for
whose benefit the attendance bonus scheme was introduced. As for the budli and temporary workers, the
Tribunals said that the scheme could not be applied
to them on account of uncertainty of the tenure of
their service. So far as the .budli and temporary
workers are concerned, the reason given by the Tribunals for treating them differently appears to us to
justify their being excluded. As to clerical staff, it
appears from the correspondence which ensued
between the union and the company on the introduction of attendance bonus scheme that the scheme was
introduced primarily in connection with the installation of a time keeping office. The clerks are obviously in a different category from the workmen engaged
in actual production. In the circumstances, apart
from the considerations which were considered by the
two Tribunals, there is, in our opinion, justification
for treating clerks in a different way from other workmen. The company also told the union that so far as
they knew no scheme of attendance bonus had ever
been applied to clerks, probably because absenteeism
among clerks is not so great as among other workmen.
We see no reason, therefore, to disturb the concurrent
finding of the two Tribunals in this matter.
Re. (iii).
We have already worked out above the available
surplus of profits, from which profit bonus can be
given. The amount of ava.ilable surplus comes to
6·85 lacs and one month's basic wages, which have
been allowed as profit bonus, c0me to about 3 lacs.
The percentage therefore is already sufficiently high
and if profit bonus is allowed at the rate of two
months' basic wages it will come to about 6 lacs and
1046 SUPREME COURT REPORTS
I959
MJs. Titaghur
Paper Mills
Co., Lid.
v.
Its Workmen
Wanchoo ].
[1959] Supp.
would be more or less equal to the entire available
surplus. It is well settled tha,.t the available surplus
bas to be divided in a fair manner between the industry, the shareholders and the workmen. We cannot
forget that the workmen have also got production
bonus for this year. In the circumstances, there is no
scope for grant of any further profit bonus beyond
that allowed by the Appellate Tribunal.
We, therefore, partly allow the appeals of the company and ·vary the production bonus rate in the
manner indicated above. We dismiss the appeals of
the company with respect to profit bonus. We also
dismiss the appeal of the workmen. In view of the
fact that the parties have partly succeeded and partly
failed, we order them to bear their own costs of this
court in all the appeals.
Appeals Nos. 450 and 451 allowed in part.
Appeal No. 514 dismissed.
•
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org