THE ASIATIC STEAM NAVIGATION CO., LTD. versus SUB-LT. ARABINDA CHAKRAVARTI
Supreme Court of India | Decided 12 January 1959 | [1959] SUPP. 1 S.C.R. 979 | 1959 INSC 1
Key facts
- Decided
- 12 January 1959
- Bench
- SYED JAFFER IMAM*, S.K. DAS, J.L. KAPUR
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 229/1954
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1959] SUPP. 1 S.C.R. 979
- Neutral citation
- 1959 INSC 1
Text of the judgment
(1) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
979
no material on the record by which it can reasonably
be said that the provisions of sub-s. (2) of s. 14 of the
Act applied to the present case.
It was urged that the act of Veeravva in adopting
the second defendant was to bring in a stranger and
this action of hers could be questioned by a reversioner,
as any aVenation made by her, during her life time.
Reference was made to s. 42 of the Specific Relief Act,
Illustration (f). In our opinion, this is of no avail to
the appellant, because Illustration (f) obviously refers
to a Hindu widow's estate and has no reference to a
full owner. The right of a reversioner as one of the
heirs under s. 42, Specific Relief Act, is limited to the
question of preserving the estate of a limited owner
for the benefit of the entire body of reversioners; hut
as against a full owner, the reversioner has no such
right. In our opinion, under the Act Veeravva becoming a full owner of her husband's estate, the suit could
not succeed and the appeal must accordingly fail.
In our opinion, the appellant's suit was not maintainable~ having regard to the provisions of s. 14 of
the Act, even if it be assumed that there was no valid
adoption of the second defendant. The appeal accordingly fails and is dismissed with costs.
Kolturuswami
v.
Veeravva
Imam].
Appeal dismissed.
THE ASIATIC STEAM NAVIGATION CO., LTD.
x959
V•
January u.
SUB-LT. ARABINDA CHAKRA V ARTI
(SYED JAFER IMAM, S. K. DAS and J. L. KAPUR, JJ.)
Shipping-Collision-Negligence-" Standing on" vessel" Giving way" vessel-Rights and duties-Nautical assessorsAdvice not binding on Court-Merchant Shipping Act, I894 (57 &
58 Viet. c. 60) Regulations of I9IO, Arts. 2I, 23, 25, 27, 29.
On December 13, 1940, in the afternoon, a cargo ship, N,
left Madras harbour bound for Calcutta heading for the open
sea. She was being navigated in a swept channel outside the
980 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1959] Supp.
harbour and was on her proper, namely the starboard side of the
channel. At that time a patrol ship, K, was on an opposite
Th~ Asi~tic _Steatncourse making for Madras harbour and entered the channel at
Nav•gatwn
about 6-25 p. m. At 6-30 p. m. N decided to overtake K by goCo., Ltd.
ing port on an erroneous assumption that K was going in the
v.
same direction as N and was not an ?TI-coming ship. By about
Sub-Lt. AYabinda 6-45 p.m. when K sighted N on the port bow the two ships were
ChaA.avarti
opposite each other near about the mid-line of the channel, the
distance between the two being then a little more than a mile.
N continued her port course and went over the mid-line into the
wrong side of the channel and at about 6-48 p. m. the distance
between the two ships was less than I a mile. K noticed at that
moment that N was converging on her and accordingly in order
to avoid a collision K turned to hard port and gave a signal to
that effect. N, however, took starboard action to get back to the
right side of the channel and get out of the way of K. At about
6-49 p. m. finding that a collision was imminent the commander
of N ordered full speed astern, but it was too late and a collision
took place at about 6-51 p. m.
The appellant, the owner of N, instituted a suit for damages
against the respondent, who was one of the officers in charge of
and responsible for the navigation of K, on the plea that the
collision was caused by the negligent navigation of K. .The t~ial
judge who had been assisted by nautical advisers, held that K
wrongly altered her course at the moment when she did, and if
any step had to be taken she should have altered not to port
but to starboard, and if any other action was necessary, she
should have put her engines full speed astern. On appeal, the
High Court, which also had the assistance of two assessors,
-reversed the findings of the trial court and dismissed the suit.
On appeal to the Supreme Court, the appellant contended that
I): should have anticipated that sooner or later N would correct
her mistake and go to the starboard side of the channel and,
therefore, as the "standing on" vessel, K should have kept her
course and speed as required by Art. 21 of the Regulations of
1910, made under the Merchant Shipping Act( 1894, and that if
she had done so, there would have been no collision. As in the
lower courts, this Court also had the assistance of two assessors.
Held, that K was justified in taking port action at, 6-48 p. m.
when a collision seemed iinminent, in view of Arts. 27 and 29
of the Regulations under which when a vessel finds herself so
close to another vessel that a collision cannot be avoided by the
action of the "giving way" vessel alone, she must also take
such action as will best aid to avert collision:
Held, further, that it was an act of negligence on the part
of N to take hard starboard action, instead of following the
provisions of Art. 23, as the "giving way''. vessel, by slackening
the speed of or reversing N between 6-45 p. m. and 6-48 p. m.
"The Tioga", (1945) 78 LI. L. Rep. l and " The Empire
Brent", (rg4JS) 81 LI. L. Rep. 306, distinguished.
'959
. .
'(·
r
•
~
(1) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
981
The function of nautical assessors is to advise the court
•959
upon nautical matters but the decision of the court rests entirely
with the court and even in purely nautical matters the court is The Asiatic :i!cam
not bound to follow the advice of the assessors, but on questions
Navi.(alio11
of nautical science and skill great attention must be paid to the
Co., Lid.
opinion of the assessors since they are the only source of inforv.
mation on these points anc1 some reason must be given for SZ<b-Lt. AmuiH<la
disregarding them.
Cha1mivarti
The assessors in an appeal court are not substituted for
those consulted in the trial court; they are <nlditional to them;
and if one adviser or two advisers are to be p,refcrrcd, it is
because in the judginent of the court the advice given is such as,
in itself, is the more acceptable.
The relevant articles of the Regulations of 19ro, made
under 1h~ Merchant Shipping Act, 1894, arc set out in the judgment.
Cn.-u, APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No.
229 \,f 1954.
Appeal from the judgment and decree dated
February 28, 1952, of the Bombay High Court in
Appeal No. 34 of 1952, arising out. of the judgment.
and decree dated February 5, 1951, of the said High
Court in Admiralty Suit No. 1 of 1943.
S. O. Isaacs, P. N. Bhagwati, S. N. Mukherjee and
B. N. Ghosh, for the appellants.
E. E. Jhirad and T. M. Sen, for the respondent.
1959. January 12. The Judgment of the Court
was delivered by
S. K. DAS, J.-This appeal on a certificate given
by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay is from
the decision of a Division Bench of the said High
Court in Appeal No. 34 of 1951, da.ted February 27
and 28, 1952, by which it reversed the decision of a
single Judge of the said High Court in Admiralty
Suit No. 1 of 1943 dated August 8, 1950.
The appellant., Asiatic Steam Navigation Company
Ltd., is a company incorporated in the United Kingdom with its registered office in London and has an
office in Calcutta. The respondent i.s ex-Sub-Lieutenant Arabinda Chakravarti, who at all material times
was a commissioned officer in the then Royal Indian
Navy with its headquarters at Bombay. The action
which the appellant brought arose out of a collision in
s. [(. Das J.
982
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
a swept channel, a little distance outside the Madras
harbour,
on December 13, 1940, at about 6-51 p.m.
1
5
;.~;~:;io:••m The two ships concerned in the collision were the
ca .. Ltd.
cargo vessel, S. S. Nizam of 5,322 gross tons and
v.
H. M. S. Ka/,awati, a patrol ship of 1,185 tons. For
Sub-Lt. Arauinda the sake of brevit.y and convenience, these two vessels
Chakrnv•rli
will be referred to in this judgment as the N izam and
s. K. va, J. Ka/,awati. At all material times, the appellant owned
the Nizam and the respondent, it was stated, was one
of the officers in charge of and responsible for the
navigation of the Kalawati . One F. C. H. Mason was
the Chief Officer of the Nizam and the Master was
Malcolm John McLure. Henry Lee was the Commander of the Ka1awati and Arabinda Chakravarti, as
stated above, was one of the officers in charge of and
responsible for the navigation of the Kalawati at the
relevant time.
The case set out by the appellant in the plaint was
this. On December 13, 1940, in the afternoon the
Nizam, which was then under charter to the Ministry
of Shipping, left Madras harbour bound for Calcutta
carrying a cargo. She was then tight, staunch, strong,
well manned and in every respect sound and fit. A few
minutes after 6-45 p.m. when the weather was fine,
clear but cloudy, the moon full, the wind moderate,
the sea calm and the set of the tide from north to
south, the Nizam was being navigated in a swept
channel outside the Madras harbour. The swept
channel was approximately about one mile wide and
seventeen miles long. The Nizam was heading for
the open sea on her proper course to Calcutta and was
being navigated in a proper and seamanlike manner
and was on her proper, namely the starboard side of
the channel. The Kalawati was on an opposite course
making for Madras harbour. The Nizam having the
Kalawati about one point on her starboard bow star.
boarded with the result that the two vessels were
about one mile apart on courses which would result in
their passing from port to port with a distance of
about half a mile between them. At that time, the
Kalawati made a " light " signal to the Nizam ; the
signal was not legible and the N izam sent a signal
'959
n,
-:--;-:
•
I
(1) S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
•
'
983
which asked for a repetition of the signal of the Kalax9 59
wati. The N izam continued hard to starboard, but The Asiatic Steam
the Kalawuti altered course to port with the result Navigation
that the Kalawati wa.s converging on the course
co., Ltd.
of the Nizam. The Nizam continued to go to
v.
.
fltarboard and the Kalawati to port ; thel'eafter, Sub-Lt. Arabi~da
•.
d
.
.
h N.
Chakravatli
w h en a coII1s1on seeme very immment, t e
izam
was put full speed astern, but the Kalawati was navi- s. f{. Das J.
gated across the bows of the Nizam and the result
was that the starboard quarter of the Kalawati came
into collision with the bows of the Nizam. The Kalawati then pivoted round the bows of the Nizam and
again came into collision with the latter. After alleging the facts stated above, the appellant pleaded in
the plaint that the collision was ca.used by the negligent navigation of the Kalawati and the following
particulars of that negligence were given: (a) alteration of the Kalawati's course to port so as to t&ke her
a.cross the bows of the Nizam; (b) failure of the Kalawati to stop or to go a.stern and/or to put her helm
ha.rd a-starboard when there was yet time for her to
do so and avoid a. collision; (c) in breach of the Regulations for the Prevention of Collisions at Sea the
Kalawati failed to keep to her proper side, namely,
the starboard side of the channel, when it was her
duty to do so, and further the Kalawati failed to keep
out of the way of the Nizam when it was her duty to
do so and (d) a proper look-out was not kept on board
the Kalawati. The total claim which the appellant
preferred for the damage sustained was a sum of
Rs. 88,000 ·and odd and particlars of the claim were
set out in sch. B of the plaint.
In his written statement the respondent denied any
liability for the damage sustained by the Nizam. The
case of the respondent as set out in his written statement was, to put it briefly, this. The re&pondent said
that at about 6-45 p.m. on December 13, 1940, he was
the officer on watch and the Kalawati was steering a
course north 800 west keeping to the Kalawati's
proper side of the channel. The N izam was sighted
at about that time, about 20' on the port side and
about 2i miles away, heading for the open sea and
984
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (1959] Supp.
'959
steering eastwards and running a parallel and op-:--t.
st
posite course. Due to certain wartime regulations, the
Th e A sia ic
eam .
Novigation
lights of both the vessels were blacked out. Accord.
Co., Ltd.
ing to the courses which the Nizam and the Kalawati
v.
were then pursuing they would have passed each
Sub-Lt. Arabinda other clear port to port and the respondent signalled
ChakravarU
to the N izam with a portable Aldis Lamp and asked
s. K. Das J. for her identity. The Niiam replied with one long
flash indicating that she was ready to receive signals
from the Kalawati. As the respondent was about to
continue signalling, he noticed that the Nizam altered
her course to port in such a. manner that she was
converging on and crossing the course of the Kalawati.
The respondent then stopped signalling and a.s the
Nizam continued on the wrong course ta.ken by her
until her bows were fine on the port bows of the
Kalawati, a collision seemed imminent, the two vessels
then being about two cables a.pa.rt. In order to avert
the imminent risk of collision the respondent ordered
the Kalawati to be put ha.rd· aport and simultaneously
indicated to the N izam the a.Iteration of the Kalawati' B
course. The Nizam, however, instead of keeping to the
course already ta.ken by her and passing the Kalawati
on the-;itarboard side, erroneously attempted to correct
the earlier wrong course ta.ken by her and attempted to go back to her proper side of the . channel. The
N izam then altered her course to ha.rd starboa.rd with
the result that the two vessels were in such a position
that it was not possible to avert a. collision either by
slackening the speed of the Kalawati or by going
astern. In substance, the case of the respondent was
that the collision was ca.used by the circumstances
(a) that the N izam failed to keep to her proper side of
the channel, (b) that she continued to port in such a
manner a.s to put the Kalawati in a perilous position
and the Kalawati had to take avoiding action and
finally (c)' the Nizam was negligent in altering her
course to hard astarboard after being made a.ware
repeatedly that the course of the Kalawati had
been altered to port. Therefore, according to the
respondent, the action of the N izam in steering starboard after Kalawati had ta.ken port action, was the
proximate and effective cause of the collision.
(1) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
985
On the pleadings stated above, several issues were
r959
framed but the principal question for decision by the The Asiat"c Steam
learned trial Judge was if it was the negligent action
Navig:tion
of the Nizam or of the Ka'lawati which caused the
Co., Ltd.
collision. Issues 1, 2 and 3 were the issues which
v.
related to this question. A further question was raised Sub-Lt. Arabi~da
by issues 4 and 6 and that related to contributory Chakravaro
negligence, and in case it was found that both the s • K. Das 1 •
vessels were to blame for the collision, the question
raised was in what proportion the negligence of the
Nizam and of the Kalawati contributed to the collision. The learned trial Judge found in favour of the
present appellant on the principal question and expressed his finding in the following words :"I' have come to the finding that the first helm
action was taken-and rightly taken-at the crucial
time by the Nizam going hard a.starboard, and the
Kalawati turned to port when there was no question
of the imminence of any collision. . ........ In these
circumstances, as a standing on vessel the Kalawati
turned - and wrongly in my opinion - to port and
but for her turning to port, there was no question of
the two vessels coming .into a perilous position. In
these circumstances, I am of the opinion that the
Nizam was justified in starboarding. The Kalawati
had to keep her course under the rule being a standing
on vessel, and should have maintained her course in
that manner until the last safe moment, but to my
mind she turned to port much before any such occasion
arose. On this point, I may say that had the Kalawati to take any action at all, the normal action would
have been going to starboard, and this would have
completely a.voided the collision. On this point I may
state that the nautical advisers whom I have had
occasion to consult are in agreement with the view I
am adopting.
I may also state that in my opinion the Nizam put
its engines full speed astern a.t the earliest opportunity,
looking to the situation. The Nizam was put full
speed astern at least 2i minutes approximately before
the collision took place, and even if the statement of
124
986
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1959] Supp.
McLure that she was dead slow before the collision is
n A -.-.
a slight overstatement it must follow that the back of
5
'N;::;;,; 0 ~'"mthe momentum of the Nizam hadalready been wholly
co, Ltd.
broken and there is evidence that she was doing about
v.
3 to 4 knots instead of her 9 to 10 knots normal speed.
Sub-Lt. Arabinda On the other hand, I am clearly of the opinion that it
Cha.\.-avai-ti
was fundamentally wrong for the Captain of the
Kalawati
not to put her engines full speed astern
S. K. Das ].
immediately he saw the l!itua.tion was perilous. In
fact, instead of doing so, he went full speed ahead.
To my mind, that was not only a wrong judgment but
a judgment inspired by desperation, namely, that by
putting them full speed ahead, with a bit of luck, he
would have cleared himself of the DOie of the Nizam.
I have, therefore, come to the conclusion that the
Kalawati wrongly altered her course at the moment
when she did, and if any step had to be taken she
should have altered not to port b11t to starboard, and
if any other action was necessary, she should have put
her engines full speed a.stern."
In view of the aforesaid findings, the learned trial
Judge expressed the view that the question of coutri·
butory negligence did not a.rise, as also the question in
what proportion ea.ch contributed to the collision.
The question of damages was, by agreement, held over
until the findings on the question of negligence and,
after the learned trial Judge had given the necessary
findings on the question of negligence, the damage
sustained by the N izam was assessed at Rs. 76,893-2-8
and a decree waR passed for that a.mount with interest
thereon at four per cent. per annum from June 19,
r959
1941.
The respondent then preferred a.n appeal and the
appeal was heard by Cha.gla., C. J., and Bhagwati, J.
Like ,the trial Judge, the Judges who heard the appeal
also had the assi"tauce of. two assessors. On the
principal question as to whether the collision wa11
caused by the negligent action of the N iuim or of the
Kalawat·i, the learned Judges who heard the appeal
reversed t.he findings of the learned trial Judge. They
said:
"Tlwrl'fol'c, in our opinion, on this evidencf!, we
,•
(1) S.C.R. SUPH.EME COURT HEPOHTS
987
must find as a fact that the N izam did not alter her
z959
course to starboard at 6-45 p.ro., but she did so much r' , -.-. ,,
as1at1e ,,.awm.
Iatcr an d very lI"k·ely at 6 -48 p.m. wh en s h e gave one ''e Naviaatio"
blast to indicate the change of course. Now, if that i:-;
co .• ~u.1.
the fact we find, we have to consider what bearing
v.
that finding of fact has upon the question of the 'iu 11 -Lt. Arabir.<1;1
defendant's negligence. The question is whether the Chakravarti
defendant was justified in turning his ship to port at S. R. Das].
6-48 p.m. if at t l iat moment the N izam was still
steering to port. The question is whetper at 6-48 p.m.
there was a reasonable probability of a collision which
justified the Kalawati in changing her course to port in
order to avoid that collision. We have the plan before
us and we have the evidence before us, put as this
question of fact involves a question of nautica.l
skill we have availed ourselvtJs of the assistance of
the assessors. Commander Kale is emphatically
of the opinion that at 6-48 p.m. if the N izam
was pursuing the same course that she was doing
from 6-38 p.m., there was a reasonable probability
of a collision which it was the duty of the defendant to
avoid as best as he could, and according 1.o Commander Kale, the only way he could have. possibly
avoided it was by steering his ship to port. Capt.
Malcolm does not agree with this view. He takes the
view that the Kalawati should have raLher turned to
stal'board than to port, and his opinion is based on the
consideration that the Kalawati should have assumed
that at sometime or other the Nizam would turn starboard and taking that possibility into consideration
she should have gone to the right side and not to the
wrong side. With respect to Capt. Malcolm, we are
inclined to prefer the opinion given by Commander
Kale as to what should have been done under the
circumstances ... Now, as the Nizam was the" giving
way" vessel, there was the primary obligation upon
her if necessary to stop the ship or to go n.stern, and
on the evidence it is difficult to resist the conclusion
that the order to go full speed astern, could have been
given earlier either by the Captain himself or by
Mason. On this point both the assessors have expressed their opinion that as a matter of naucical skill
988
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
it would have been possible and indeed it should ha.ve
been done, viz., that the ship
should have been ordered
-:--,.
Th e A sia tc 51 eam
.
Navigation
to go full speed astern earlier than 6-49 p.m.
co.. Ltd.
In our opinion, therefore, there a.re these two facts
v.
which have definitely contributed to the collision
Sub-Lt. habinda taking place at 6-52 p.m. The first is the failure on
Chakravarti
the part of the N izam to give the signal that she was
s. K. Das 1. going starboard, even assuming that we accept the
plaintiffs' case that she starboal'ded a.t 6-45 p.m. If
she had given. the signal then it would have given
proper and full warning to the Kalawati as to what
the Nizam was doing or going to do at that momeut.
The other fact which has also contributed in our
opinion to the collision is the failure on the pa.rt of the
Nizam to go full speed a.stern earlier than 6-49 p.m."
In the result, t.he appeal was allowed a.nd the action
of the appellant was dismissed with costs throughout.
We have already stated that the High Court of
Bombay gave a certificate of fitness under Art. 133 of
the Constitution and the present appeal ha.s been
brought to this Court in pursuance of that certificate.
Two assessors, Capt. J. A. Cleeve and Commodore
A. K. Chatterjee, have assisted us. At the very out.
set, it is necessary to clarify two points. Firstly, it
appears that the learned Judges who heard the appeal
in the Bombay High Court did not base their findings
on the evidence of the respondent or his witnesses;
nor did the learned trial Judge attach any great
importance to the evidence of the respondent or his
witnesses. The learned Judges said:" We do not blame the learned Judge because,
when the evidence of both these witnesses was laid
before us, we also felt that the evidence was not given
in a manner which would inspire confidence."
Learned counsel for the appellant has placed before us
in full the evidence of the appellant and its witnesses.
He has also placed before us such portions of the
evidence of the respondent and his witnesses as, in his
opinion, support the case of the appellant. In arriving
at our conclusions we have also proceeded on the footing that as the courts below did not consider the
evidence of the respondent's witnesses to be reliable,
1 959
r
--
'.
(1) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
!J89
the principal question of negligence must be decided
'959
on the evidence of the appellant's .witnesses. The trial r' A-_-_ 5
· an d t h e Jd
siatic team
.
Jd
u ge too k one view
ofthat ev1"d ence
u gos "' Navigation
who heard the appeal took another view. There being
co., Ltd.
no concurrent finding~, we allowed learned counsel for
v.
the appellant to place the entire evidence of the appel- Sub-Lt. Arabinda
lant's witnesses before us in support of his contentions. Chakruva>ti
The other point relates to the assessors. It has not
been disputed before us that the function of nautical s. K. Das J.
assessors is to advise the court upon nautical manners
and as Scott, L. J., said in The Olan Lamont.('):
" •.....•..... their ad vice is expert evidence, admissible in Admiralty Courts, on all issues of fact about
seamanship."
·
The de~ ision of the case, however, rests entirely with
the court and even in purely nautical matters the
court is not bound to follow · the ad vice of assessors,
but on questions of nautical science and skill great
attention must obviously be paid to the opinion of the
assessors since they are the only source of information
on these points and some reason should be given for
disregarding them. In the Australia(') Lord Dunedin
deprecated putting to assessors a question that is
tantamount to asking them whether they would find
for the plaintiff or the defendant and repudiated the.
idea that the views of the assessors in an appeal court
are entitled to more respect than those of assessors
below. The assessors.in an appeal court are not substituted for those previously · consulted; they are
additional to them; and if one adviser or two advisers
are to be preferred, it is because in the judgment of the
court the advice given is such as, in itself, is the more
acceptable. There can be no question of any appeal
from one set of assessors to another. \Ve have followed
the same principles with regard to the advice of the
assessors given in this case and we shall refer to such
advice in the course of this judgment when it has a
hearing on the questions at issue before us.
The principal point for determination in this case is
which of the two, the Nizam or the Kalaicati, was
(1) (1946) 79 LI. L. Rep. ,521, 524 (Lloyds List Law Reports). (2) [1927] A. C. 145.
990
SUPltEME COURT REPORTS
[1959) Supp.
responsible for the collision; and if both were responsible,
what is the extent of the responsibility of ea.ch ?
1 e Asiatic Steam F
. t'10n of th ese questions
.
. 1s
. necessary
N avigvtion
or a d e t ermma
1t
co:, Ltd.
first to find what courses the aforesaid two boats were
v.
following at the relevant time and what changes of
Sub-Lt. habinda course were made by them. These facts have to be
Chakravarti
determined first and in doing so we must keep in mind
some of the Regulations made under the Merchant
s. K. Das J. Shipping Act, 1894. It h~s been admitted by counsel
for both parties that these H.egulations apply, and we
are concerned with the Hegulations of 1910, namely,
those made by an Order in-Council dated October 13,
1910. They embody rules which were to be followed
at the relevant time by all vessels upon the high seas,
and in all waters connected therewith, navigable by
sea-going vessels. Articles 17 to 27 of the 1910 l~egu
lations relate to steering and sailing rules. Article 17
applies to sailing vessels, and Art. 18 to steam vessels.
Article 18 says in effect that when two steam vessels
a.re meeting end on or nearly end on so as to involve
risk of collision, each should alter her course to star.
board so that each may pass on the port side of the
other. Article 19 is in these terms:
Art. 19. " When two steam vessels a.re crossing,
so as to involve risk of collision, the vessel which has
the other on her own starboard side shall keep out of
the way of the other."
The vessel which has to keep out of the way of the
other is called the " give way " vessel and the other is
ca.lied the " standing on " vessel. In the case before
us there is no dispute that the N izam was the give
way vessel and the Kalawati the standing on vessel.
Article 21 · has some bearing 011 the question at is>uo
before us and is in these terms :
Art. 21. " Where by any of these ltules one of
two vessels is to keep out of the way, the other shall
keep her course and speed."
Article 23 says :
"Every steam vessel which is directed by these
Rules to keep out of the way of another vessel shall,
un approaching her, if.necessary, slacken her speed or
stop or reverse."
1 959
.h
. .
.
t
I
(1) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
991
Article 24 sa.ys inter alia that notwithstanding a.nyr959
thing in the Rules, every vel!Sel overtaking another Th 1 ns1a1tc
, ~
5 t1am
shall keep out of the way of t he overtak en vesse1. NaviKatio"
Article 25 is very important for our purpose, as learnco., I.td.
ed counsel for the a.ppella.nt ha.s pla.ced great reliance
v.
on it. This Article must. be quoted in extenso.
Sub-Lt. Arabi"d"
Art. 25. " In narrow channels every steam vessel Cltaltravarli
shall, when
it is sa.fe and practicable, keep to that side 5 • K. Das 1•
1
of the fairway or mid-channel which lies on the starboard side of such veB&el."
There ha.s been considerable difficulty in defining a
"narrow channel", and in the trial court the present
respondent denied that the awept channel outside the
Madras harbour was a narrow channel within the
meaning ·Of Art. 25 aforesaid. The courts below proceeded, however, on the footing that the channel in
question was a narrow channel within the meaning of
the said Article and we have also proceeded on the
same footing. Article 27 is t.lso important for our
purpOse. It says:
Art. 27. "In obeying and construing these Rules,
due regard shall be had to all dangers of navigation
and collision, and to any special circumstances which
may render a departure from the a.hove Rules necessary in or<ler to a.void immediate danger."
Art.icles 29 a.nd 30 are two 1·esidua.ry Articles. Article
29 inter alia says that nothing in the Rules shall
exonerate any vessel from the consequences of any
neglect to keep a. proper look out or of the neglect of
any precaution which may be required by the ordinary
pra<:tice of sea.men, or by the special circumstances of
the case, and Art. 30 says that nothing in the Rules
shall interfere with the operation of a special rule,
duly ma.de by a. local authority, relative to the navigation of any harbour, river or inland waters.
We proceed now. to a consideration of the evidence
with regard to those facts on which the determination
of the question of negligencEl depends in this case. We
do not propose to embark on a. very detailed third
review of the evidence given in the case, but shall confine ourselves to those salient points which, in our
view, arc determinative of the principal question at
992
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
issue between the parties, namely, that of negligence
for the collision which took place at about 6.51 p. m. t
The NAsfat;',. Steam on December 13, 1940.
We shall for that purpose
oviga ion
r
h
"d
f
co., Ltd;
re1er to t e ev1 ence o Mason, McLure and Abdul
v.
N abi, three witnesses for the appellant. As to the
Sub-Lt. Arnbinda effect of the evidence of these three witnesses, the
Chakravarti
learned Judges who heard the appeal in the Bombay
High Court came to conclusions different from those
s. f(. Das 1 · of the learned trial Judge and one of the points for our
consideration will be if the appellate Court gave good
and convincing reasons for differing from the view of
the evidence which the learned trial Judge took. It t
may be stated here that the aforesaid three witnesses
were examined by Blagden, J., in April, 1945, and
February, 1946, and that learned Judge made some
notes as to the manner in which the three witnesses
gave their evidence. Our attention has been drawn
to those notes by learned counsel for the appellant.
Blagden, J., however had ceased to be a Judge of the
Court before the suit was tried. The respondent and
his witnesses were examined in 1950 by Coyajee, J.,
who tried the suit and gave judgment in favour of the
•
appellant.
It appears from the evidence that at about 4-45 p.m.
on December 13, 1940, the Nizam took the pilot on
board and proceeded to sea. At about 5-22 p.m. the
pilot was dropped and she proceeded at full speed
under McLure's orders up the swept channel, the
speed being about 10! knots. McLure handed over to
Mason at about 5-55 p.m. and the Nizam was then
steering a course north 86° east, making some allowance for the leeway to port for the set of the tide from
north to sOLith. At about 6 p.m. the third officer relieved Mason; Mason returned to the bridge at
6-30 p.m. and took over from the third officer. Mason
said that be had checked the bearings of the Nizam
just before he left the bridge a.t 6 p. m. and she was
then two ca.hies on the proper side of the channel.
Soon after 6-30 p.m. Mason saw a vessel about two
~
points on the starboard bow of the Nizam at a. distance of about three miles. Mason's evidence was
that he thought then that the Nizam was overtaking
r959
(1) S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
993
1959
that other vessel which must have been the Kalawati.
At 6-38 p.m. Mason altered the course of the N izam ne Asiatic Steam
8° to port, because he thought that the Nizam and the Navigation
Kalawati were on converging courses. At 6-43 p.m.
Co., Ltd.
the
look-out
on
the
Nizam
rang
the
bell
twice
i11dicatv.
•
S<1b-Lt. Ar.1bi11da
mg a. vessel viz. the Kalawati on the starboard side. Chakrava,ti
Mason then said that at about 6-45 p.m. the Kalawati
was about one mile on the Nizam's starboard bow and s. K. Das J.
was clearly seen to be crossing to starboal'd port. The
Kalawati then ma.de an .Aldis lamp' signal and Mason
replied I.M.I. with a torch which asked for a. repetition of the signal. Mason then ordered ha.rd a.starboard; he did this because under certain wartime
orders a merchant vessel had to turn away from any
ship that signalled. At 6-47 p.m. the Kalawati was
several points on the port bow of the N izam and near
a.bout 6-48 p.m. the Kalawati altered her course to
port and indicated the alteration by two short blasts.
Mason replied by one short blast indicating that the
Nizam was turning to starboard. At a.bout 6-49 p.m.
McLure came on board and he rang full speed astern.
By about 6-51 p.m., however, the collision took place.
The above gives in brief a. summary of the events
which, according to Ma.son, led to the collision.
McLure's evidence was that he returned to the bridge
at about 6-48 p.m. on hearing two short blasts from
the Kalawati, and on coming to the bridge he saw that
the Kalawati was turning to port. McLure at once
ordered full speed a.stern and ca.used three short blasts
to be given; but the collision occurred within about
two minutes. Abdul Na.bi was the Quarter Master of
the N izam. His evidence was to the effect that Mason
ca.me on the bridge at about 6-30 p.m. and at that
time the N izam was steering a course north 86° east.
At about 6-40 p.m. (Abdul Na.bi said that it was ten
miriutes after Mason came on the bridge) he received
an order to steer 8 ° to port and he did so. Some five
or ten minutes after he received another order to go to
starboard, that is, to the Nizam's former course.
Then came the la.st order to hard a.starboard and this
was at about the time when Abdul Nabi heard two
125
994
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1959] Supp.
bla~ts from the Kalawati. It may be here remarked
that Abdul Nabi's evidence differs essentially from
5
Th•NA"~'",.
''"mthat of Mason as to the time when
the Nizam went t
aviga ion
h
f
co .• Ltd.
hard a.starboard and also as to t e sequence o events
v.
which led to the alteration of the Nizam's course from
Sub-Lt. Arabinda north 86 ° east to 8 ° port first, then to her former
Chakravarti
course and then again to hard a.starboard. We shall
later return to these discrepancies.
s. K. Das J.
The three circumstances, however, which stand out
from the evidenc~ of Mason are-(a) that the Nizam
was on the proper side of the channel at about
6-45 p.m.; (b) she turned to ha.rd a.starboard at about r
6-45 p.m. in order to present her stern to the Kalawati
in compliance with certain wartime orders; and (c) the
Kalawati turned to port at a.bout 6-48 p.m. after she
had seen the N izam turn to ha.rd a.starboard some
three minutes earlier. If Mason's evidence is correct
with regard to the aforesaid three circumstances and
the Kalawati turned to port after she had seen the
N izam turn to ha.rd astarboard and if at the time the
Kalawati. was on the wrong side of the channel, then
there can be very little doubt as to where the responsi- t
bility for the collision should lie. Coyajee, J., accepted Mason's evidence with regard to the aforesaid three
circumstances and held that the responsibility for the
collision lay on the Kalawati, because she turned to
port at the time she did after having seen the Nizam
turn to hard a.starboard some three minutes earlier.
The learned Judges who heard the appeal did not
accept as correct Mason's evidence that the Nizam
turned to hard a.starboard at about 6-45 p.m. in order
to present her stern to the Kalawati ; on the contrary,
from the evidence of McLure and Abdul Na.bi read
with the evidence of Mason, they ca.me to the conclusion that it was impossible to accept the appellant's
case that the Nizam turned starboard at 6-45 p.m.
and it was more likely that she turned to starboard at
about 6-48 p.m. after she had heard the signal of the
Kalawati that she ~was turning to port. In other ~
words, the learned Judges found that the Kalawati
had turned to port first in order to avoid an imminent
risk of collision and it was then that the N izam
'7959
-.-.
(1) S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
\
995
altered her course to starboard in order to get to the
z 9s9
~ proper side of the channel.
The Asia;. Steam
The question before us is which of these two views N•vigation is correct. On a careful consideration of the evidence
co., Ltd.
and the submissions made thereon by learned counsel
v.
.
for the parties we are of the opinion that the view of Sub-Lt. Arab•~•da
'
.
Chakravarti
the l earned Judges who heard the appeal 1s the correct
view. According to the evidence of Mason, he checked s. K. Da$ J.
the bearings of the Nizam before he left the bridge at
6 p.m. and on checking the bearings from the Madras
Light House and a. conspicuous white house on the
north side of the harbour, he found that the Nizam
was two cables on the proper side of the channel. It
appears that there should have been a dan buoy in
mid-channel to mark the mid-line. Mason said that
he looked for it, but did not find it. There was a fairway buoy at the end of the channel, that is, near the
mouth of the channel from the open sea. It is not
disputed that the Kalawati entered the channel south
of the fairway buoy and was at the time of the entry
into the channel on the wrong side. The question,
however, is what was the position of the two boats at
the relevant time, namely, at about 6-45 p.m. when
the distance between the two boats was about a mile
or so. Mason's evidence itself shows that at about
6-45 p.m. both the boats were near about the mid-line
of the channel. It is to be remembered that though
the N izam was about two cables on the proper side of
the channel at about 6 p.m., she had altered her
, course 8° to port, even according to Mason, at about
6-38 p.m. Abdul Nabi's evidence indicated that the
N~zam had altered her course to pOI't by about 10°.
Even allowing for the set of the tide, if the Nizam
had continued in her port course in order to overtake
the Kalawati (as Mason was then under the impression
that the N izam was overtaking the Kalawati), she
would cross the mid-line and go into the wrong side of
~ the channel. It is worthy of note that in the plaint
there was no mention of the circumstance that the
N izam altered her course to port in order to overtake
the Kalawati, on the wrong impression that both the
bua.ts were go_ing in the same direction. But be that
996
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
as it may, it is quite clear that the Nizam did alter
Tha. Asiatic Steam h.er COdur.se tho port at aboiJult 6b·38 p. m , and if hshe cond. t
Navigation
tmue m t at course t
a out 6 · 48 p.m., s e wou 1
co., Ltd.
be near the mid-line of the channel or just across it at
v.
the relevant time. Mason admitted this and said in
Sub-Lt. Arabinaa cross-examination : " At 18-45 I was just about in the
Ch•A•••••li
mid-channel and the Kalawati was then steering a
s. K. Das 1. crossing course". Mason prepared a chart to show
the position of the two boats and this was marked as
Ext. A. This chart also showed that at about 6·45
p.m. the Nizam was on the mid-line and if the Nizam
f
had continued her port course she would be on the
wrong side of the channel at about 6-48 p.m. Even
though the Kalawati had entered the channel south of
the fairway buoy, which was her wrong side, she was
steering a course north 80° west, making an allowance
for a southerly drift of about 1 or I ·5 knots. By
steering that course the Kalawati would also be near
the mid-line of the channel at-about 6-45 p.m. She
would be on her right side of the channel at 6-46 p.m.
This is also made clear from the chart, Ext. A.
Learned counsel for the appellant repudiated the
correctness of the chart, Ext. A, but it is a chart prepared by his own witness and so far as the position
of the Nizam was concerned, the chart must have
been prepared on the position and course of the
Nizam as given by the appellant's own witnesses. We
see no good reasons for discarding the chart, Ext. A.
At our request the assessors also prepared a chart
showing the position of the two boats on the following
assumptions: (a) Nizam's speed about 10·2 knots,
(b) J(alawati's speed a-bout 11 knots, (c) the set of tne
tide about ·71 knots and (d) length of the swept channel about 18 miles. This chart also showed that at
about 6-45 p.m. the Nizam was on the mid-line and
the Kalawati had crossed the mid-line into her right
side of the channel. If the set of the tide was two
knots or three knots, I'S some of the witnesses said, ;
then both the Nizam and the Kalawati would be outside the swept channel, and if the Kalawati was sighted two points·on the starboard bow of the Nizam she
would be further south of the southern limit of the
z959
.
(l) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
997
swept channel. On a 1onsideration of the evidence
I959
in the case it appears to us that at the relevant time, Th • A-.-.
siallc 5 team
namely, 6-45 p.m., both t he boats were near about t he Navigation
mid-line, may be a little on the right or wrong side
co., Ltd.
of it, and the distance between the two boats was
v.
a.bout one mile at that time. The very elaborate Sub-Lt. Arabinda
argument of learned counsel for the appellant based Chakravarti
on Art. 25, which requires every steam vessel in a S. K.- Das].
narrow t:ha.nnel to keep to the starboard side of the
channel, loses much of its force when we remember
that at the relevant time the two boats were near the
mid-line of the channel and, according to Mason, the
Kalawati was then crossing to starboard port. One of
the assessors, Commodore Chatterjee, gave as his
opinion that if the Kalawati was coming from the
south, it would be easier for her to enter the channel
south of the fairway buoy and he would not consider
it as a breach of the. rules of the road unless the
Kalawati was embarrassing another ship coming out
of the channel. Capt. Cleeve said that as a merchant
ship captain he would never ~o it, but as a naval ship
c~ptaiQ he might do it and although it might be
against the spirit of the regulations, it would not be a
breach of them. It is to be remembered again that the
Kalawati entered the channel at about 6-25 p. m.
and at the time the N izam was about seven miles
away. We do not, therefore, think the circumstance
that the Kalawati entered the swept channel south of
the fairway buoy decisive on the issue of negligence.
As we have remarked earlier the decisive question is
what was the position of the two boats at the relevant
time, namely, at a.bout 6-45 p. m.? The evidence
leaves no room for any doubt that at the relevant
time the two boats were near about the mid-line of
the channel.
The question is what happened thereafter? Mason
said that from 6-38 to 6-41 p.m. he assumed that he
was overtaking the Kalawati ; from 6-41 to 6-45 p.m.
he was in two minds and when at 6-45 p. m. the
Ifolawati signalled the N izam, then Mason came to
know that the Ka'lawati was steering a crossing course.
Mason said that he then changed to hard starboard.
998
z9s9
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1959) Supp.
This part of the evidence of Mason is flatly contradict-
Th• A•;;;. 51
ed by Abdul Nabi and is further not supported by
Navii•tio• ,.,,. several circumstances to· which we shall presently
t
co., LJ4.
refer. It is true that none of the witnesses gave the
time with the precilion of a watch and what they
5 •h-l.i. Ar•bi""• said about time was more or less approximate. Abdul
Chak•••••li
Nabi was, however, very definite that Mason first
s. x. Dru 1. ordered the Nizam to steer 8° to port; then there was
a second order to go to the former course and lastly
there was an order to go hard astarboard. If Abdul
Nabi is telling the truth, then even making due allowance for the approximate nature of the times which
he mentioned, the evidence of Mason that he changed
the course of the Nizarn to hard astarboard at about
6-45 p.m. cannot be correct. Then, take the following
circumstancea one by one. If Muon had changed the
courae of the Nizam to hard utarboard, why did he
not give a 1ignal to indicate the change of course ?
The evidence is very clear. on this point. It was the
Kalawati which gave two short blasts at about 6-48
p.m. to indicate that she was changing to port. Thereafter the Nizam replied by one short blast indicating
that she was changing to starboard. If the Nizam
had changed to starboard three minutes earlier, why
was no signal given ! It is necessary to refer here to
Art. 28 which says that when vessels ate in sight of
one another a steam vessel under way shall indicate
the course taken by her. Mason madiw an attempt to
say in his evidence that Art. 28 was not adhered to
in wartime; but then he had to admit that only a
few minutes after, the Nizam did give one short blast
in reply to the two short blasts of the Kalawati. It is
obvious that Art. 28 was not abrogated during wartime and it was the duty of the Nizam to indicate by
one short blast that she was changing to starboard,
if she actually did so at 6-45 p.m. We are, however, .
of the opinion, in agreement with the learned Judges
of the appellate Bench, that the N izam did not change
her course to starboard at 6-45 p.m. as Ma.son wants us
to believe; on the contrary, the N izam continued her
port course till about 6-48 p. m. and she changed to
starboard only after she had heard the two blasts from
•·
t
t
(1) S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
999
the Kalawati. This, we think, is clear from two very
'959
important circumstances. McLure admitted .in. his evi- Th e A-:---,.
sia tc 51 eam
dence that at the speed and under the cond1t1ons preNavigation
vailing immediately before the collision, it would take
co., Ltd.
the N izam about 2i minutes to swing 90° with her helm
v.
ha.rd over. If actually Mason had altered the course Sub-Lt. Arabi~da
of the Nizam to hard a.starboard at 6-45 p.m., then Chakravarlt
she would be heading back towards Madras at the S. K.- Das].
time when the collision took place. Even McLure
said: "If Ma.son's statement is correct, I should have
expected my ship to be heading at right angles to her
former course." That was not, however, the position
of the Nizam when the collision took place. The assessors were agreed that once the wheel had been
placed hard starboard, it was not possible to put the
wheel further to starboard. If actually more than five
minutes had passed, after the N izam had been put
hard starboard, she would be swinging starboard a.II
the time and she would take a. turn of about 180°
within five minutes. In any event, by about 6-48 p.m.
she would be at right angles to her former course, as
stated by McLure. We think that McLure's evidence
on this point destroys the ca.se of Ma.son that he had
altered the Nizam's course to hard a.starboard at
6-45 p.m. Then there is the second important circumstance that McLure admitted that he knew nothing
a.bout any helm action of the N izam from 5-55 p.m.
to 6-48 p.m. McLure said :
" First I heard at 6-43 p.m. two bells indicating
an object on the starboard bow. I was still in my
ca.bin at the time. I was reading Admiralty messages.
I heard two blasts from the other ship at 6-48 p. m.
I have no recollection of feeling any helm action of
my ship before that. I immediately went up on the
bridge. The N izam did not sound one blast till I had
reached the top of the ladder. That would normally
suggest that the Kalawati had turned to port first".
McLure further said that when a ship alters course
and signals, the alteration and the signal must be
simultaneous. It would be surprising indeed that
McLure would not notice the helm action to hard starboard if actually the Nizam had been put hard
1000 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1959] Supp.
'959
starboard at 6-45 p.m.
The assessors were asli:ed
Th• A;;;;. Steam abo~t this matter and Commodore Chatterjee said that
• Navigation
if the helm was put ha.rd over, he would feel it even if
Co., Ltd.
he was asleep. Capt. Cleeve said that the master of
v.
a fast .ship would feel the helm action sooner than the
Sub.Lt. Arabinda master of a slo.w ship, probably· twenty to thirty
Chakravarti
s. K. Das J.
seconds sooner. McLure, however, felt no helm action
at all up till 6-48 p.m. This also shows that the story
of Mason that he changed the course of the Nizam to
hard a.starboard at 6-45 p.m. was not correct.
The reason which Ma.son gave for altering the
course of the Nizam hard a-starboard at 6-45 p. m.
was an alleged war-time order that a merchant vessel
when challenged must turn away from the challenging vessel. This reason is far from convin-Oing. No
such war-time order was produced in evidence. In
Ex. C (Surveyor's report dated January 27, 1941) the
reason for the starboard action was stated thus : " At 6-45 p. m. the other vessel appea.rd to be
about one point on the starboard bow and a.bout one
mile distant and to be heading to cross the bows of
s. s. "Nizam ". The helm put ha.rd a.starboard in
order to pass astern of the other vessel."
There was no reference to any wartime order or regulation then. McLure said in his evidence :
"The rule about turning away from 11 challenging
vessel was a secret matter and I did not think it fit to
mention it even to my Managing Agents. Mason told
me he originally steered to starboard in order to pass
port to port."
Even Mason was far from being firm as to the reason
which .Jed him to turn ha.rd a.starboard at 6-45 p. m.
Having said that the only reason was the alleged
wartime order, he changed and said that he turned
hard starboard because he was dazzled with the
Aldis lamp signal and the Kalawati was too close. He
admitted that he knew then that the Kalawati was a.
patrol vessel which was not hostile; yet he wanted to
turn astern, as the Nizam had a gun mounted astern!
Again, he changed and g~ve a third reason for going
bard starboard, namely, ·be wanted to get out. of the
way of the Kalawati. In this state of the evidence, it is
(1) S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
,
1001
impossible to place implicit reliance on Mason's evid.r959
ence that he turned hard starboard at 6-45 p. m. for The Asiatic steam
the reason that a so-called war-time order required
Navigation
him to do so. Learned counsel for the appellant drew
Co., Ltd.
our attention to the respondent's evidence on this 5
v.
·
t
Th
d
"d
ub-Lt. Arabinda
pom .
e respon ent sa1 :
Chak a 1;
"When a ship is challenged she gives her name
' var
and turns round but not in the swept channel or in s. K. Das J.
the harbour.
I do not agree that in the swept channel when a
ship was challenged to give her name she would have
to turn round. I did state before the Marine Enquiry
that when a merchant ship is challenged she would
turn a.bout necessarily by starboard movement and
give her name and the turning about would be action
preparatory to running away and that owing to war
these regulations were in force. I say that I was
trapped into giving answers by vague questions."
We agree that the respondent's evidence is not very
ingenuous; but it cannot be accepted as an admission
which relieved the appellant from proving the existence of a war-time order or regulation of the kind and
nature suggested by Mason in his evidence. Mason's
evidence taken as a whole seems to indicate that the
order to turn ha.rd starboard came m'uch later than
6-45 p. m. and the reason for the order was to get
back to the right side of the channel and to get out of
the way of the Kalawati, if possible. Unfortunately,
the action was taken too late and after the Kalawati
had already turned to port. ·On the evidence, we are
unable to hold that the Nizam took starboard action
before the Kalawati turned to port.
The question now arises-why did the Kalawati
turn to port at about 6-48 p. m. and in doing ao, did
she commit an act of negligence or an act which in
any way contributed to the collision ? On behalf of
the appellant, it has been argued that even if we find
on the facts that the Kalawati took port action first,
this action was wholly unjustified and wrong and, in
a.ny event, the Kalawati could and should have gone
to starboard to avoid the collision; therefore, she was
wholly to blame. Alternatively~ it has been argued
1a(i
1002 SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
that she was mostly to blame and the blame should r
be apportioned. We shall deal with the alternative
Thi Asiatie Steam
I
Nav;gation
argTument at. a ~ter sthaged"d l K l
.
t
co., Ltd.
he quest10n 1s-w y 1 t ie .a .awati turn to por
v.
at about 6-48 p. m. ? We think that Mason's own
Sub-Lt. Arabinda evidence furnishes an answer to the question. We
Chakravarti
know from the Kalawati's log book that she entered
,
K.
Das
J.
the swept channel at about 6-25 p. m. south of the
5
fairway buoy and she was then steering a course of
north 80° west; by about 6-45 p. m. she was on the
mid-line of the channel when she sighted the ;
Niz.am on the port bow. The Niz.am had already
altered her course to port. Ma.son summarised the
position at 6-45 p. m. thus : " At 18-45 she {meaning
the Kalawati) was about one mile on my starboard bow
and was crossing to starboard port." Capt. Clecve
thus explained the meaning of the aforesaid statement:
" That means that the distance between the two
boats was one mile, and she (Kalawati) was a mile off
to my (Nizam's) starboard bow and she was crossing
from my starboard to my port. " Mason further f
clarified the position by saying that the two boats
were then steering crossing courses and it was not
correc.t_ to say that if both ships had kept their course
and speed as it was at 6-43 p. m., they would have
passed port to port. Mason also said that " the two
boats were on converging courses at 18-45 hours ".
Obviously, there would ha. ve been a collision, if no
a.voiding action was taken by either boat. That is
why Mason was at pains to point out in his evidence r
that he took starboard action at 6-45 p. m. to get out
of the way of the Kalawati and if both the ships had
kept their courses as they were immediately after
Ma.son had starboarded at 6-45 p. m., they would have
passed port to port with a.bout half a. mile to spa.re.
We have found, however, that Mason's statement that
he had starboarded at 6-45 p. m. was not correct. The
position, therefore, was that the two boats were on f
crossing courses in a narrow channel and when the
Kalawati signalled with the Aldis lamp, she found
that the N izam was still steering to port. The Aldis
lamp has a small telescope attached to it and from a
demon$tration made in Court., it became obvious that
z959
-
(1) S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
'
1003
the respondent was in & po11ition to see through the
z959
telescope what coorse the N izam was taking. At Tll• Asiati& 51.,..,.
about 6-48 p. m. the distance between the two boats Navigation
was less than half a mile, and unless the Kalawati
co.• Ltd.
took a voiding action, a collision was imminent. Therev.
.
fore the Kalawati took port action and indicated her Sub-Lt. habusda
· ' · by t he necessary signs.
· l. Tbe JUS
• t"fi
Cllallrava1ti
1 ca. t"ion
d irection
for the port action of the KaZawati was the continu- s. K. Das J.
a.nee of the Nizam on a. port course-a. course which
was not only ta.king the N izam over the mid-line into
the wrong side of the channel but was also making
her converge on the course of the Kalawati. The
Kalawati was the standing on vessel, and it was the
duty of the N izam to get out of the way. Ins~ead of
doing th,at, the N izam persisted in her port course
and· changed to hard starboard after the Kalawati had
justifiably ta.ken port action to avoid an imminent risk
of collision. It has been argued before us that the
Kalawati should have anticipated that sooner or later
the N izam would correct her mistake and go to the
starboard side of the channel and, therefore, as the
standing on vessel, the Kalawati should have kept her
course and speed as required by Art. 21, and if she
had done so, there would ha.ve been no collision.
This argument fails to take note of the perilous
position in which the Kalawati was placed by the continuance of the Nizam in a port course till about 6-48
p. m. and furthermore ignores Arts. 27 and 29 under
which when a vessel finds herself so close to another
vessel that a collision cannot be avoided by the action
of the giving-way vessel alone, she must also take
such action as will best a.id to avert collision. The
Kalawati was, therefore, justified, in taking port action
at 6-48 p. m. when a collision seemed imminent and
perhaps the collision would have been averted if the
N izam had not taken the unfortunate action of hard
starboarding after the Kalawati had taken port action.
McLure realised the position as soon as he came on
tlie bridge at 6-49 p. m. and ordered full speed astern.
Unfortunately, it was too late then. If Ma.son had
followed the provisions of Art. 23 and had slackened
the speed of or reversed the Nizam between 6-45 p. m.
and 6,48 p. m. the collision might have been averted.
1004 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1959) Supp.
Instead, however, he ordered the Nizam to be put
hard starboard at about 6-48 p. m. This, in our opini1
1
The ~"~ "/ '"m on, was an act of negligence, which wa.s primarily
;:'.g~1 ~'.n responsible for the collision. The findings of the lea.rnv.
ed trial Judge were, in our view, vitiated by re a.son of
Sub-Lt. A<abinda the circumstance that he accepted a.s correct Ma.son's
Ch•A•••••ti
evidence that he had put the N izam ha.rd a.starboard
at 6-45 p. m. in the teeth of circumstances which
s. K. Das J. showed clearly enough that Mason's evidence about
starboarding at 6-45 p. m. could not be correct. These
circumstances were-(!) if Mason had put the Ni~am
hard starboMd at 6-45 m., the N izam would be 90"'
to her former course by 6-48 p. m. and by 6-49 or 6-50
p. m. she would be turning towards Madras; (2)
McLure did not feel any such helm action at 6-45
p. m.; (3) the N izam gav.e no signal of starboarding
at 6-45 p. m. but gave such signal after the Kalawati
had turned to port soon after 6·48 p. m.; and (4) the
reason which Mason gave for starboarding at 6-45
p. m. did not stand the test of scrutiny. In the court
of appeal below, one of the assessors, Commander
Ka.le, said definitely tha.t the only war-time restrictions in 1940 were with regard to lights and wireless
communication. He sa.id that signals had to be given
by ships when they decided to change their course,
and the more so when ships were in restricted waters
and there was another vessel coming ahead. We think
that the learned Judges who heard the appeal rightly
emphasised the importance of the circumstances stated
above, and having given them due weight, rightly
reversed the findings of the lea.med trial Judge.
To summarise our conclusions now: (I) we accept
the position that the Kalawati entered the channel at
6-25 p. m. on the wrong side and the Niza·ll? was two
cables on the right side at about 6 p. m.; but by 6-45
p. m., the two boats were opposite each other near
about the mid-line of the channel, the distance between the two being then a little more than a mile ; (2)
the Nizam did not take any hard starboard action at
6-45 p. m.- rather she continued to steer to a port
course till a.bout 6-48 p. m. and .probably went over
the mid-line into the wrong side of the channel ; (3)
when the Kalawati signalled with the Aldis lamp, she
r959
-.-.
p.
}
(1) S.C.R. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
.1
1005
noticed that the N izam was steering to port and was
x959
on a course converging on the Kalawati and at about Th A -:--..
1"
• by turn- I Navigatiou
SI« 1IC 51 etml
6-48 p. m. t he K aw,wati
took avo1"d"mg act10n
ing hard to port and gave a. signal to that effect; (4)
co., Ltd.
the N izam then took starboard action to get back to
v.
the right side of the channel and get out of the way Sub-Lt. Arabinda
of the J{alawati; and (5) when McLure came on the Chakravarti
bridge at about 6-49 p. m. he ordered full speed astern s. I<. Das J. .
-but it was too late and the collision took place at
about 6-51 or 6-52 p. m.
On the aforesaid findings there is little difficulty
left in adjudging where the responsibility lies for the
collision. As we have said earlier, the responsibility
lies with the N izam.
It ii; necessary to notice now, very briefly, two
decisions on which learned counsel for the appellant
has relied: "The Tioga" (1) and the "Empire
Brent " (2). In the Tioga the question for consideration was the liability for damages in respect of a collision which occurred in the swept channel of the
N. E. Coast of England between the Pundit, a ship in
the port column of a south- bound convoy of eight
ships, and the Tioga, an independent north-bound ship.
The decision proceeded on the footing that south
bound ships were under a strict duty to keep within the
western half of the channel and north-bound within
the eastern half, thus passing each other port to port.
Down the centre of the channel there was a line of
flashing buoys four or five miles apart. There was a
general prohibition of navigation lights, which made
the strict observance of the rule of the road in the
swept channel exceptionally imperative. The night
was overcast and dark, and there was drizzling rain
diminishing visibility. In those circumstances, it was
found that the Pundit, instead of keeping to her right
water, trespassed into the Tioga's water, and furthermore when she first saw the Tioga's red at a
quarter of a mile away, her instant duty was to starboard out of the Tioga's way so as to pass port to
port. This the Pundit failed to do. Therefore, the
Pundit was held responsible on two grounds, which
Scott, L. J., explained in the following words :(1) (1945) 78 Ll. L. Rep. l (Lloyd's List Law Reports).
(2) (1948) 81 LI. L. Rep. 306 (Lloyd's List Law Reports).
1006 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [1959) Supp.
I9J9
"The two ships were either meeting or crossing;
-:-. St
and
in
either case it was the Pundit's duty to pass the
Th A 1
' Navigation
Sia'·'
eam T'ioga por t t o por t . If th ey were crossing
· s h'1ps it
· was
co., Ltd.
also her duty to keep out of the way of the Tioga and
v.
go under her stern ; if meeting ships, simply to starSub·LI. Arabfoda board her helm. In addition, there was the special
11
Chakrnv••
duty of the Pundit in that channel to regain her right
s. K.- Das j.
water. She had been blundering out of it and endangering north-bound traffic ; and I entirely agree
with the learned Judge's view that for that reason
alone she was seriously to blame ; and that position of
itself would entitle the Tioga to expect her to be
actually on a starboard helm, correcting her error, at
the moment she put her lights on".
We do not think that the decision in the Tioga is of
any great assistance to the appellant. On our findings,
it was the duty of the Nizam to keep out of the way
of the Kalawati; and at 6-48 p.m. the N izam was in
all probability in her wrong water and the Kalawati
in her right water - at any rate - both were near the
mid-line of the channel, and in these circumstances, the
Nizam's action in starboarding after she had seen the
Kalawati, turn to port cannot be justified either on the
principles laid down in the decision aforesaid or on the
provisions of the rule of the road in a narrow channel.
In the Empire Brent the collision took place in the
river Mersey between the steamship Starmont and the
steamship Empire Brent. It was found that so far as
the Starmont was concerned, she deliberately set a
course which meant that for most of the way up the
river she was necessarily proceeding on the wrong
side of the river for her. The Empire Brent had just
left the Princes Landing Stage when she had to cope
with the situation created by the approach of the
Starmont. In these circumstances it was held that the
Starmont was wholly in the wrong for coming up on
the eastern side of the river and for breaking in that
way the narrow channel rule which prevails in the
Mersey. Willmer, J., said:.
" I find it difficult to find words sufficiently strong
to condemn the action of a man who persists in coming
up on the wrong· side of the river-especially as this
)
-
(1) S.C.R.
•.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1007
action of the Starmont was quite deliberate &nd was
z959
merely for the purpose of her own convenience."
Th A . .
1
sutsc 5 te11m
Dealing with the alternative case that the starboardNavigation
ing action of the Empire Brent was the whole cause
Co., Lt4.
of the collision even if the Starmont was wrong in
v.
coming up on the ea.stern side of the river the learned Sub-Lt. Arabintla
'
CllaAravarti
J udge observed :
" That alternative way of putting . the case s. K. Das J.
has become academic, having regard to my finding
that the vessels were green to green at any rate up to
the time when they were about three-quarters of a. mile
apart. But, lest it should be thought that I agree
with it, I should like to take the opportunity of saying
that I regard that contention as wholly wrong. As I
understand the principles which apply in narrow
channels, it has been la.id down for many, many yea.rs
that, although the crossing rule does from time to
time have to be applied in narrow channels (when, for
instance, a vessel which is crossing the channel has to
act in relation to a vessel which is proceeding up or
down the channel), nevertheless, when vessels are
approaching each other, navigating respectively up
ancl down the channel, it is Art. 25 of the Collision
Regulations which applies and applies exclusively.
There is no room in such a situation for applying the
provisions of the crossing rule at the same time as the
provisions of the narrow channel rule, because the
requirements under the rules a.re different. I have no
hesitation in saying that as between a vessel coming
up and a vessel going down, approaching each other
in that way in a narrow channel like the Mersey, the
narrow channel rule, and the narrow channel rule
only, is the rule which has to be applied. However,
that is a digression, because, having regard to my
findings of fact, the point is academic."
Learned counsel for the appellant has placed strong
reliance on the aforesaid observations and has contended that in the present case also the provisions of
the narrow channel rule should apply and not those of
the crossing rule. We do not see how a strict or
exclusive application of the narrow channel rule will
help the appellant in the present case. We have found
that the N izam was in her right water at about 6 p.m.
1008
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959] Supp.
but she had altered her course to port later and at a.!iout
Th
6-45 p.m. she was near the mid-line and at 6-48 p.m.
'N;:;g:~ioneam when she starboarded in answer to the Kalawati's port
co .• Ltd;
action, she was in a.II probability in tho wrong water.
v.
The N izam cannot, therefore, say that if. the narrow
Sub-Lt. Arnl>inda channel rule only applied, sho is bound to succeed.
Cl•akravarli
We do not, therefore, think that the ratio of the decision
in the Empire Brent helps to establish the case of
S. l<. Das].
the appellant.
In view of our findings, we consider it unnecessary to
deal with the alternative claim of the appellant as to
an apportionment of the blame for the collision in
question. We do not think that the Kalawati was to
blame for ta.king port action when she did, and we
have already stated our reasons therefo1·. There is a.
further difficulty in the way of the appellant. It is
true that the question of contributory negligence was
one of the issues before the learned trial Judge, but in
the view which he took of the evidence, he considered
it unnecessary to decide it. The appeal was decided
on the footing that the Kalawati was not guilty of
negligence and the entire liability for the collision was
that of the Nizam. The appellant has no doubt contested the correctness of the findings arrived at by the
learned Judges of the appellate bench; but neither in
the memorandum of appeal nor in the atatemelj.t of the
case presented to this Court did the appellant raise the
alternative claim which it has now raised. During
the course of the hearing of the appeal in this Court, a.
petition was made for adding a. fresh ground of appeal
in order to raise the alternative claim of an apportionment of liability for the collision under tho rules for
the division of loss prescribed under the Moiritime
Conventions Act, 1911. We do not think that the
prayer for an alternative claim can be allowed at this
stage, because on our findings there is no case for an
apportionment of the blame.
In the result, the appeal fails and is dismissed with
costs. We have already passed orders for the payment of the fees of the two assessors, and no fresh
orders thereon are necessary.
r959
A --:-; St
)
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org