MOHD. HANIF QUARESHI & OTHERS versus THE STATE OF BIHAR
Supreme Court of India | Decided 23 April 1958 | [1959] 1 S.C.R. 629 | 1958 INSC 50
Key facts
- Decided
- 23 April 1958
- Bench
- VIVIAN BOSE*, T.L. VENKATARAMA AIYYAR, S.K. DAS, P.B. GAJENDRAGADKAR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 58/1956
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [1959] 1 S.C.R. 629
- Neutral citation
- 1958 INSC 50
Text of the judgment
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
629.
MOHD. HAN!]' QU ARES HI & OTHERS
v.
THE STATE OF BIHAR
(and connected petition)
(S. R. DAs C. J., VENKATARAMA AIYAR, S. K. DAs,
GAJENDRAGADKAR .and VIVIAN BosE JJ.)
•
~
•
•
·~
Cow slaughter-Legislation placing total ban-If Constitutional
-Directive Principles of State Policy, value of-Fundamental rights
-Reasonable restrictions--Test-Intervention in Supreme Court
proceedings, when permissible-Bihar Preservation and Improvement
of Animals Act, r955 (Bihar II of r956)-U. P. Prevention of
Cow Slaughter Act, r955 (U. P. I of r956)-C. P. and Berar Animal
Preservation Act, r949 (C. P. and Berar Lll of r949)-Constitution
of India, Arts. r4, r9, 48-Supreme Court Rules, 0. XLI, r. 2.
The Bihar Preservation and Improvement of Animals Ac':,
l95S, put a total ban on the slaughter of all categories of animals
of the species of bovine cattle. The U. P. Prevention of Cow
Slaughter Act, 1955, put a total ban on the slaughter of cows
and her progeny which included bulls, bullocks, heifers and
calves. The C. P. and Berar Animal Preservation Act,
1949, placed a total ban on the slaughter of cows, male
or female calves of cow, bulls, bullocks, and heifers and
the sla1,1ghter of buff;lloes (male or female, adults or calves) was
permitted only under a certificate granted by the proper authorities. No exception was made in any of these Acts permitting
slaughter of cattle even for bow1 fide religious purposes. These
three Acts were enacted in pursuance of the directive principles
of State policy contained in Art. 48 of the Constitution. The
petitioners, who were engaged in the butcher's trade and its
subsidiary undertakings, challenged the constitutional validity
of the three Acts on the grounds that they infringed their funda- ·
mental rights guaranteed under Arts. 14, r9(r)(g) and 25 of the
Constitution. The respondents contended that the impugned
.Acts were constitutional and valid as they were made in consonance with the directive principles of Art. 48 ·which were
superior to the fundamental rights and that the impugned Acts
did not offend Art. 14, l9(1)(g) or 25 :
. Held, (i) that a total ban on the slaugh.ter of cows of all
ages and calves of cows and of she-buffaloes, male and female,
was quite reasonable and valid;
(ii) that a total ban on the slaughter of she-buffaloes or
breeding bulls or working bullocks (cattle as well as buffalo~).
as long as they were capable of being used as milch or draught
cattle, was also reasonable and valid; and
.
•
(iii) that a total ban on the slaughter of she-buffaloes, bulls
April 23.
630
SUPR.EME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
, 95 s
and bullocks (cattle or buffalo) after they ceased to be capable
of yielding milk or of breeding or working as draught animals
/lt!ohd. Hanif
was not in the interests of the general public and \vas invalid.
Quarcshi
The directive in Art. 48 for taking steps for preventing the
v.
. slaughter of animals is quite explicit and positive and contemThe- State 0! Biha~-plates a ban on the slaughter of the several categories of animals
specified therein, namely, CO\VS •and calves and other cattle
which answer the description of milch or draught cattle. The
protection is confined only to cows and calves and to those animals which are presently or potentially capable of yielding milk
or of doing work as draught cattle but does not extend to cattle
\Vhich at one ti1ne were milch or draught cattle but which have
ceased to be such. The directive principles of State policy set
out in Part IV of the Constitution have to conform to and run as
subsidiary to the fundamental rights in Part III.
State of Madras v. Smt. Champakam Dorairajan, [1951]
S.C.R. ·525, followed.
The ban on the slaughter of cows even on the Yd ~irban
day did not violate the fundamental rights of the petitioners
under Art. 25 as it had not been established that the sacrifice of
a cow on that day was an obligatory overt act for a Mussalman
to exhibit his religious belief and idea.
Ratilal Panachand Gandhi v. The State of Bombay, [1954]
S.C.R. 1055, applied.
The impugned Acts which affected only the butchers who
slaughtered cattle and not the butchers who slaughtered sheep
or goats, did not offend Art. 14 of the Constitution. The
different categories of animals being susceptible of classification
into separate groups on the basis'of their usefulness to society,
the bntchers who kill each category may also be placed in distinct classes according to the effect produced on society by the
carrying on of their respective occupations. This classification
is based on an intelligible differentia which places the petitioners in a well defined class and distinguishes them from those
who slaughter sheep or goat~ and this differentia has a close
connection with the object sought to be achieved by the impugned Acts, namely, the preservation, protection and improvement of livestock.
In determining the question of the: reasonableness of restrictions imposed •m the fundamental rights conferred by Art.
r9(r)(g) the Court cannot proceed on a general notion of what is
reasonable in the abstract or even on the consideration of what
is reasonable from the point of view of the person or persons on
whom the restrictions are imposed. What the Court has to do
is to consider whether the restrictions imposed are reasoll'able in
the interests of the general public. The test of reasonableness
lias been laid down in State of Madras v. V. G. Row, [1952] S.C.R.
597 at 602. It should also be remembered that the legislature
~.-.
•
f
•
S.C.R.
•
~
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
631
is the best judge of what is good for the community. Though a
r958
constitutional question cannot be decided on the grounds of the
sentiment of a section of the people, it has to be ta){en into Mohd. Hanif
consideration, though only as one of the elements, in arriving at
Quareshi
a judicial verdict as to the reasonableness df the restrictions.
v
The effect ~f the impugned Acts on the fundamental rights The State of Ilihar
of the petitioners under Art. r9(r)(g) is direct and instantaneous
as soon as the Acts are brought into force, and it has to be
determined whether they can be justified under cl. (6) of Art. 19.
The country is in short supply of milch cattle, breeding bulls
and working bullocks, and a total ban on the slaughter of these
which are essential to the national economy for the supply of
milk, agricultural working power and manure is a reasonable
restriction in the interests of the general public. But a total
ban on the slaughter of useless cattle, which involves a wasteful
drain on the nation's cattle feed which is itself in short supply
and which would deprive the useful cattle of much needed
nourishment, cannot be justified as being in the interests of the
genend public.
Under 0. XLI, r. z, of the Supreme Court Rules intervention is permitted only to the Attorney-General of India or the
Advocates-General for the States. There is no other provision
for permitting a third party to intervene in the proceedings
before the Supreme Court. In practice, however, the Supreme
Court, in exercise of its·inherent powers, allows a third party to
intervene when such third party is a party to some proceedings
in the Supreme Court or in the High Courts where the same or
similar questions are in jssue, for the decision of the Supreme
Court will conclude the case of that party.
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Petitions Nos. 58, 83, 84,
103, 117, 126, 127, 128, 248, 144 & 145 of 1956 & 129
of 1957.
Petitions under Article 32 of the Constitution of
India for enforcement of ]'undamental Rights.
H.J. Umrigar, N. H. Hingorani and A. G. Ratnaparkhi, for the petitioners in all the petitions except
Petition No. 103 of 1956. The impugned Acts infringe
the fundamental rights under Art. 19(l)(g;J of the peti-
·,.
tioners who are butchers, tanners, gut merchants,
curers and cattle dealers to carry on their respective
tr!i.des. Where, as in the present case, the enactment
on th~ . face of it violates a fundamental right the
burden lies on those who support it to show that
it falls within the purview of cl. (6) of Art. rn. Saghi1~
Ahmed v. The State of U.P., ([1955] 1 S90.R. 707 at 726);
-··
•
632
x958
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
Chiranjitlal Chowdhuri v. The Union of India, ([1950]
Mohd. Hanif S.C.R. 869 at 891-892).
The impugned Acts put a
Quareshi
total ban on the trade and business of the petitioners
v.
who kill only cattle. Total prohibition of a trade
The State of Bihar which is not immoral or obnoxious can never be
reasonable restriction within the meaning of cl. (6) of
Art. 19. Chintaman Rao v. The State of JJ1~adhya
Pradesh, ( [1950] S.C.R. 759 at 765); R. M. Sheshadri
v. The District Magistrate ( [1955] 1 S.C.lt. 686 at 689,
690); Coovei:jee B. Bhar-ucha v. The Exc·ise Commissioner, ( [1954] S.C. R. 873); Rashid Ahmed v. The
llfunicipal Board, Kairana, ( [1950] S.C.R. 566).
Total ban on the slaughter of cattle is not in the
interests of the general public. Animal husbandry
will suffer by a totc;l ban. There is shortage of fodder
and pasture in the country and the useless anp uneconomic cattle will depri vc the useful cattle of these
things. Setting up of Gosadans for the uneconomiu
cattle will be a tremendous waste of public money.
[Counsel referred to Yarious official reports in t.his ·
connection.]
The impugned Acts create an odious discrimination
between butchers and persons dealing solely in cows,
bulls, etc., and those dealing in sheep and goats, and
offend Art. 14. Those Acts which single out the petitioners' community which kills only cows, bulls, etc.,
are hostile and discriminatory legislation. Ye Cong
Eng v. Trinidad, (70 L. Ed. 1059 at 1071); Fowler v.
Rhode Island, (97 L. Ed. 828); Lane v. Wilson, (83
L. Ed. 1281 at 1287); Ligget Go. v. Baldrige, (73 L. Ed.
204).
The impugned Acts '1lso contravene Art. 25 as they
prohibit the M ussalmans from performing the religious
practice of the community to sacrifice the cow on the
· occasion of. Bakr Id. Ratilal Panachand Gandhi v.
The State of Bomba.y, ([19,'54] S.C.R. 1055 at 1063).
The directive principles of State policy set out in
Art. 48 can never override fundament'11 rights. 11he
State of JJ!ladras v. Sm. Chainpakani Dorairajan,.([1951.J
.S.C.R. 525 at 530); Saghir Ahmed's Case, ( [1955] l
S.C.R. '/07 at 727). The impugned Acts traverse
beyond th? diructi ve principles in Art. 48.
&
..
("
r
S.C.R.
•
·~
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
633
The Bihar and the Madhya Pradesh Acts which
z958
affect inter-State trade in cattle and beef offend Art. Mohd. Hanif
301 and are void as the assent of the President was
Quareshi
not taken before enacting them.
v.
Frank Anthony and ](. L. Mehta, for the petitioners The State 0! l'ihar
in Petition No. 103 of 1956. Section 9 of the U. P.
Prevention of Cow Slaughter Act makes the slaughtering of cattle a cognisable and non-bailable offence.
This and other provisions of the Act are ex facie restrictions on the right of the petitioners to carry on
their trade. The onus is on the respondents to show
that the restrictions are reasonable restrictions in the
interests of the general public. Chintaman Rao v.
The State of Madhya Pradesh, ( [1950] S. C. R. 759 at
763); Saghir Ahmed v. The State of U. P., ( [1955] 1
S. C, R. 707 at 726). The legislation is colourable and
mala fide and is inspired by religious motives. State of
Madras v. 'V. G. Rao; ( [1952] S. C. R. 59.7). Article 48
in so far as its imposes blanket ban on cow would have
to yield to Art 19 (1) (g). The restrictions in the Act
amount to total prohibition and extinction of the trade
of beef butchers. Saghir Ahmed's case; Dwarka
Prasad Laxmi Narain v. The State of U. P., ( [1954]
S.C.R. 803), Fairmout Creamery Co. v.111innesota, (71 L.
Ed. 893 at 897). The impugned Act offends Art. 14
as it discriminates against the beef butchers. These
butchers have a legal right to slaughter cow for food
or sacrifice. Naubahar Singh v. Qadir Bux, (A. I. R.
1930 All. 753); Shahbazkhan v. Umrao Pilri, (I. L. R,.
30 All. 181); Emperor v. Mirhammad Yakub, (I. L. R.
32 All. 571).
C. K. Daphtary, Solicitor-General of India, with
Mahabir Prasad, Advocate-General of Bihar and S. P.
Varma (respondent in Petitions Nos. 58, 83 and 84 of
1956), and with R. H. Dhebar, for the State of Bombay
(respondent in Petition No. 117 of 1956). The legislature has thought fit that slaughter of cattle should
be stopped in the interests of animal husbandry and
publiC"policy. It is not for the Court to say that such
a policy should not have been adopted. Bot.h on th~
question of policy and the ex1ent of the restrictions
634
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959)
the Uourt should interfere only if it is convinced that
in
n'o view of the matter could the restrictions be
iitohd. Eanif
Quareshi
reasonable. There are two conflicting opinions on
v.
this controversial matter, i. e., whether there should be
The State of Bika•·total ban or only partial ban. In such a case the
opinion of the legislators must prevail and the Court
should not interfere where there is controversy as to
facts. State of 1l1adras v. V. G. Rao, ( [1952] S. C. R.
597 at 606); The State of Bihar v. Maharajadhiraja
Sir Kameshwar Singh, ( [1952] S. C. R. 889 at 941);
Arumughwn v. State of Madras, (I. L. R. [1953] Mad.
937). Unless it can be said that the restrictions have
no bearing on the object sought to be achieved the
legislation must be upheld. Article 37 enjoins the
State to apply the directive principles of State policy
in Part IV. of the Constitution in making laws. , The
legislation is in accordance with the direction givei1 in
Art. 48 .•
.
The objeut of the legislation is not to c()ntrol any
trade or industry but to improve the breed of cattle
and to· organise animal husbandry and agriculture.
Unless the legislation directly hits trade or business it
does not infringe Art. 19 (1) (g). A. K. Gopalan v. The
State, ( [1950] S. C. R. 88 at 101); Ram Singh v. The
State of Delhi, ( [1951] S. C. R. 451 at 455-457); R. S.
Ram Jawaya Kapur v. The State of Punjab, ( [1955] 2
S. C.R. 225); State of Bombay v. R. M. D. Chamarbaugwala, (A. I. R. 1957 S. C. 699 at 721).
B. Sen and R. H. Dhebar, for the State of Bombay
(respondent in Petitions Nos. 126 to 128 and 248 of
1956), and for the State of Madhya Pradesh (respondent in Petition No. 144 of 1956).
JJ1. Adhicai·y, Advocate-General .for the State of
Madhya Pradesh and I. N. Shroff, for the State of
Madhya Pradesh (respondent in Petition. No. 145 of
1956), adopted the arguments of C. K. Daphtary.
H. N. San1Ja.l, Additional Solicitor-General of India,
G. C. Ma.th·~r and G. P. Lal, for the State of U. P.
(respondent in Petitions Nos. 103 of 1956 and '129 of
l957). T.he provisions of the U. P. Act have a reasonable relation to the purpose in view i.e. the directive
S;C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
635
r958
in Art. 48 and consequently the Act .cannot be said to
offend Art.19 (1) (g). Chintaman Rao v. The State of
Madhya, Pradesh, ( [Hl50] S. C. R. 759 at 763). Accord- Mohd. Hanif
ing to t.he facts and figures given in the Gosamvardhan
Quamhi
Enquiry Committee's Report the cattle population The stat:· of Rihar
was actually decreasing and total ban on slaughter
was necessary to protect and preserve the cattle. The
State of U. P. had made ample provisivns for looking
after the decrepit cattle, and such cattle also was not
une9onomic as it yielded hides and manure.
The U. P. Act which prohibits the slaughter of
cattle but not that of buffaloes does not offend Art. 14
as the discrimination is based upon proper classification. The buffalo does not require any protection.
The female buffalo is in no danger as its yield of milk
is very high. The he-buffalo is not very useful for
draug"ht purposes and there is no, need to protect it.
Besides, the buffalo population is steadily increasing.
The u: P. Act does not violate Art. 25. Article 25
of our Constitution is similar to Art. 8 of the Irish
Constitution. There is no religious compulsion on the
Mussalmans to sacrifice a cow on Bakr Id Day.
Thakurdas Bhargava, as amicus curiae. The directive principles of State policy in Part IV of the Constitution are superior to fundamental rights and the
enactments which are in pursuance of the directions
given by Art. 48 are va.lid and constitutional even
though they may infringe the fundamental rights of
the petitioners. The total ban on cow slaughter in
the impugned Acts is justified and is in the interest:>
of the general public. The facts and figures given in
the official reports are inaccurate, and there is no
real shortage of fodder or pasture land. There is
shortage of milk in the country and it is essential to
protect the cow. The bullock takes the 11J.rgest share
in meeting the power requirement for our agricultural
production. Cow dung manure contributes about
rupees 63 crores per year to our national income.
H.J .. Umrigar, in reply.
Frank Anthony, also replied.
Bi
.......•
636
!t!ohd. Hanif
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1958. April 23.
delivered by
[1959]
The Judgment of the Court was
Quareshi
DAS C. J.-These 12 petitions under Art. 32 of our
v.
.
Constitution raise the question of the constitutional
1
T h e State
· 1a t ive
·
_ of Bi •ar val1'd1'ty of three severa1 1eg1s
enac t ments b ann. Das c. J.
•
ing the slaughter of certain animals passed by the
States of Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh
respectively. The controversy concerning the slaughter of cows has been raging in this country for a
number of years and in the past it generated considerable illwill amongst the two major communities resulting even in riots and civil commotion in some places.
We are, however, happy to note that the rival
contentions of the parties to these proceedings have
been urged before us without importing into them the
heat of communal passion and in a rational and
objective way, as· a matter involving constitutional
issues should be. Some of these petitions come from
Bihar, some from U. P. and the rest from Madhya.
Pradesh, but as they raise common questions of law,
it will be convenient to deal with and dispose of them
together by one common judgment.
Petitions Nos. 58 of 1956, 83 of 1956 and 84 of 1956
challenge the validity of the Bihar. Preservation and
Improvement of Animals Act,. 1955 (Bihar II of 1956),
hereinafter referred to as the Bihar Act. In Petition
No. 58 of 1956 there are 5 petitioners, all of whom are
Muslims belonging to the Quraishi community which
is said to be numerous and an important section of
Muslims of this country. · The members of the community are said to be mainly engaged in the butchers'
trade and its subsidiary undertakings such as the sale
of hides, tannery, glue making, gut making and blooddehydrating, while some of them are also engaged in
the sale and .purchase of cattle and in their distribution over the various areas in the State of Bihar as
· well as in the other States of the Union of India.
Petitioners Nos. 1 and 2 are butchers and meat vendors who, according to the petition, only sl~ghter
cattle and not sheep or goats and are called " Kasais"
in contradistinction to the "Chicks" who slaughter
S.CJ.R.
SUPREME. COURT REPORTS
637,
only sheep and. goats. After slaughtering the cattle
r958
these petitioners sell the hides to tanners or hide Mohd .. Hanif
merchants who are also members of their community
Qttareshi
and the intestines are sold to gut merchants. It is
v.
said that there are approximately 500 other Kasais in The State of Bihar.
Patna alone apart from 2 lacs of other Kasais all over
the State of Bihar. The correctness of these figures is
Das c. J.
not admitted by the respondent State but we do not'
doubt that the number of Kasais is considerable.
Petitioner No. 3 is the owner of a tanning factory and
Petitioner No. 4 is a gut merchant, while Petitioner
No. 5 is the General Secretary of Bihar State Jamiatul
Quraish.. In petition No. 83 there are 180 petitioners
residing at different places in the State of Bihar who
are all Muslims whose occupation is that of Kasais or
cattle dealers or exporters of hides .. In Petition No. 84
there are 170 petitioners all residents of Patna District
who are also Muslims belonging to the Quraishi community and who carry on business as Kasais or dealers
of cattle.. All the petitioners · in these three petitions
are citizens of India.
The Bill, which was eventually passed as the Bihar
Act, was published in the Bihar Gazette on April 20,
1953. The scheme of the Bill, as originally drafted,
was, it is said, to put a total ban only on the slaughter
of cows and calves of cows below three years of age.
The Bill was sent to a Select .Committee and it!? scope
appears to have been considerably enlarged, as will be
seen presently. The Bill, as eventually passed by the
Bihar Legislature, received the assent of the Governor
on December 8, 1955, and was published in the Official
Gazette on January 11, 1956, Section 1 of the Act
came into force immediately upon such publication,
but before any notification was issued under sub-s. (3)
of s. 1 bringing the rest of the Act or any part of it
into force in the State'or any part of it, •the present
petitions were filed in this Court challenging the consti- ·
tutional validity of the Act. On ap:elications for an
~nterim order restraining the State of Bihar from issu"
ing a ntitification under s. 1(3) of the Act bringing the
Act into operation having been made in these petitions, .
• the respondent State1 . by and through the learned
638
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
Solicitor General of India, gave an undertaking not to
issue
such notification until the disposal of these petillfohd. Hanif
Quam/,,
tions and, in the premises, no order was considered
v,
necessary to be made on those applications.
The Slate of Bihar
Petition N 0. 103 of 1956 has been filed by two
petitioners, who are both Muslims residing in Uttar
Da' c. J.
Pradesh and carrying on business in that State, the
first one as a hide merchant and the second as a
butcher. Petitioners in Petition No. 129 are eight in
number all of whom are Muslims residing and carrying
on business in Uttar Prad.esh either as gut inerchants
or cattle dealers, or Kasais or beef vendors or bone
dealers or hide merchants or cultivators. All the
petitioners in these two applications are citizens of
India. By these two petitions the petitioners challenge
the validity of the Uttar Pradesh Prevention of Cow
Slaughter Act, 1955 (U. P. I of 1956), hereiirnfter
referred to as the U. P. Act and pray for a writ in the
nature of mandamus directing the respondent State of
Uttar Pradesh not to take any steps in pursuance of
the U. P. Act or to interfere with the fundamental
rights of the petitioners.
Petitions Nos. 117 of 1956, 126 of 1956, 127 of 1956,
128 of 1956, 248 of 1956, 144 of 1956 and 145 of 1956
have been filed by 6, 95, 541, 58, 37, 976 and 395 petitioners respectivly,allof whom are Muslims belonging
to the Quraishi Community and are mainly engaged in
the butchers' trade and its subsidiary undertaking
such as the supply of hides, tannery, glue making, gutmaking and blood-dehydrating. Most of them reside at
different places which, at the dates of the filing of these
petitions were parts of the State of Madhya Pradesh,
but which or parts of which have, in the course of the
recent re-organisation of the States, been transferred
to and amalgamated with the State of Bombay. In
consequence of such re-organisation of the States the
State of Bombay has had to be substituted for the
respondent State of Madhya Pradesh in the first five
petitions and to be added in the sixth petition, for ·a
part of the district in which the petitioners resill.ed had
. been su transferred, while the ·State of Madhya
Pradesh continues to be the respondent in the seventh
r958
S.U.R.
..
•.
·,,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
639
petition. By these petitions the petit.ioners all of
:r:95a
whom are citizens of India, challenge the va.lidity of Mnhd. Hanif
the G. P. and Berar Animal Preservation Act, 1949
Quare.lti
(C. P. and Berar LII of 1949), as subsequently
v.
amended.
The State of Bihar
In order to appreciate the arguments advanced for
ana." against the constitutional validity of the three
Das c. J.
impugned Acts ~t will be necessary to refer to the
relevant provisions of the · Constitution under or
pursuant to which they have been made. Reference
must first be made to Art. 48 which will be found in
Chapter IV of the Qonstitution which enshrines what
are called the directive principles of State policy.
Under Art. 37 these directive principles are not enforceaJ;>le by any court of law but are nevertheless fundame:qtal in the governance of the country and are to
be applied by the State in making laws. Article 48
runs thus:48. The State shall endeavour
" Organisation
of agriculture · and to organise agriculture and
animal husbandry. animal husbandry on mbdern and
scientific lines and shall, in particular, take step§ for preserving
and improving the breeds, and
prohibiting the slaughter, of cows
and calves and bther milch and
draught cattle."
The principal purpose of this articlt>, according to
learned counsel for the petitioners, is to direct the
State to endeavour to organise agriculture and animal
husbandry on mod~rn and scientific lines, and the rest
of t~e provisions of that article are ancillary to this
principal purpose. They contend that the States are
required t.o take steps for preserving and improving
the breeds and for prohibiting the sl~ughter of the
animals specified therein ~nlly with a view to implement that principal purpose, that is to say, only as
parts of the general scheme for organising our agriculture and animal husbandry oh modern and scientific
lines.• Learned· counsel for the petitioners refer to the
marginal nofo to Art. 48 in support of their contention
on this part of the case. · They also rfly on entry 15
,
•
640
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
in List II of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution.
That
entry reads: "Preservation, protection and im~·
l\<Johd. Iianif
Qnare,J,i
provement of stock arid prevention of animal diseases;
v.
veterinary training and practice." There is no
The ·''"'' 0! B;~., separate legislative head for prohibition of slaughter
D -.
of animals and that fact, they claim, lends support to
"' c. J.
their conclusion that the prohibition of the slaughter
of animals specified in the last part of Art. 48 is only
ancillary to the principal directions for p1'eserv:i,tion,
protection and improvement of stock, which is what
is meant by organising· agriculture and animal
husbandry. Learned counsel for., the respondents :i,nd
Pandit Thakurdas Bh:i,rgava, who appears as amicus
cnriae, on the other hand, m:i,intain that the article
contains three distinct and separate directions, each
of which should, they urge, be implemented indel'eiidently and as a separate charge. It is not necessary
for us, on this occasion, to express a final opinion on
this question. Suffice it to say that there is no conflict
between the different parts of this article and indeed
the. two last directives for preserving and improving
the breeds and for the prohibition of slaughter of
certain specified_ animals represent, as is indicated by
the words "in particular", two special aspects of the
preceding general directive for organising agriculture
and animal husbandry on modern and scientific lines.
\Vhether the last two directives· are ancillary to the
first as contended for by learned counsel for the petitioners or are separate and independent items of directives as cbimcd by counsel on the other side, the
directive for taking steps for preventing the slaughter
of the anim11ls is quite explicit and positive 11nd conte111,pl11tes a ban on the slaughter of t,he several ca.tegories of a.nimals specified therein, namely, cows and
rnilves and otper cattle which answer the description
of milch or draught cattle. The protection recommended by this part of the directive is, in our opinion,
confined only to cows and calves and to those :i,nimals
which are presently or potentially capable of yielding
milk or of doing work as draught cattle but doe's not,
from the' very nature of the purpose for which it is
obviously recommended, extend to cattle which at
,958
.
,
...
•
'
~·
..
.F
S;C.R.
•
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
641
one time were milch or draught cattle but which have
r958
ceased to be such. It is pursu1J.nt to these directive
principles and in exercise of the powers conferred by M~d. a;~if
Arts. 245 and 246 of the Constitution read with entry
ua~~s"
15 in List .II of the Seventh Schedule thereto that the The State of Bihar
Legislatures of Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and Madhya
Das c. J.
Pradesh have respectively enacted the statute$ which
are challenged as unconstitutional. In order properly
to appreciate the meaning and scope of the impugned
Acts it has to be borne in mind that each one of those
Acts is a law with respect to "preservation, protection
and improvement of stock '', and their constitutional
validity will have to be judged in that context and
against that background. Keeping this consideration
in view, we proceed now to examine the relevant
provisions of the three Acts.
Tlte title of the Bihar Act is "An Act to provide for
the preservation and improvement of certain animals
in the State of Bihar." Sub-section (3) of s. l provides
that that section shall come into force at once and the
remaining provisions of the Act or any of them shall
come into force on such date as the State Government
may, by notification, appoint and-that different dates
may be appointed for different provisions and for
different areas. Section 2 is the definition section and
the following definitions are to be noted:
"(a) "Animal" means(i) bull, bulloc1', cow, heifer, buffalo, calf,
sheep, goat and any other ruminating animal;
(ii) poultry ; and
·
(iii) elephant, horse, camel; ass, mule, dog,
swine and such other domesticated animals as may be
specified in this behalf by the State Government bv
notification in the Official Gazette;
"
. {b) ............................... ~················· .. •··••········•••
(c) "bull" means an uncastrated ma!e above the
age of three years belonging to the species of bovine
cattle;
•
.
(d) "bullock" means a castrated male above the
age of ~hree years belonging to the species specified in
clause (c);
{e) "calf" means a female or a ·Castrated or
•
642
·1 958
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19591
uncastrated male, of the age of three years and below
belonging to the species specified in clause (c) ;
!vlohd. lian1f
Quamhi
(f). · · · ·" ·''' """' "'""' · · ·' · · ·' · · ·' •·" ••· ""'" •"' "" · ••
v.
(g) " cow " means a female above the age of three
The State of Biha. years belonging to the species specified in clause (c);
Das C. j.
...................................................................
Section 3, which is the principal section for the purposes of the Bihar Petitions, runs as follows :
"3. Prohibition of slaughter of cow, calf, bull or
bullock.
Notwithstanding anything contained in any law
for the time being in force or in any usage or custom
to the contrary, no person shall slaughter a cow, the
calf of a cow, a bull or a bullock ;
Provided that the State Government may, by
general or special order and subject to such conditions
as it may. think fit to impose, allow the slaughter of
any such animal for any medicinal or research purposes."
Section 4 provides for penalties for contravention or
attempted contravention or abetment of contravention of any of the provisions of s. 3. The remaining ·
provisions in the following three chapters are not
material for our present purpose. It will be noticed
that the words" bull", "bullock"," calf" and" cow"
have been defined in els. (c), (d), (e) and (g) of s. 2 as
belonging to the species of bovine cattle. The expression "species of bovine cattle" is wide enough to include and does in ordinary parlance include buffaloes,
(male, or female adults or calves). Therefore, the
corresponding categories of buffaloes, namely' buffalo
bulls, buffalo bullocks, buffalo calves and she-buffaloes
must be taken as included in the four defined categories of the species of bovine cattle and as such within
the prohibitiDn embodied in s. 3 of the Act. It is to
be noted, however, that the allegations in the petitions
and the affi~avits in opposition proceed on the assumption that buffaloes (male or female adults or calves)
were not within the protection of the section and,
. indeed, when the attention of learned counsel for the
petitionel's was drawn to the reference to the " species
of bovine cattle '.' in each of the four definitions, they
S.C.R.
r
,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
643
st.ill made an attempt to support the latter view by
Ig58
suggesting that if buffaloes wore to be included within
the words defined in els. (c), (d), (e) and (g), then there M~:~,::;•if
v.ras no necessity for specifying it separately in the
v.
definition of" animal" in cl. (a). This argument does The State of Bihar
not appear to us to be sound at all, for, then, on a
parity of reasoning it was wholly unnecessary to
Das c. J.
specify "heifer" in the definition of ",animal".. If
" heifer " is not to be included in the definition of
"cow" because "heifer" is separately enumerated in
the definition of" animal " then an astounding result
will follow, namely, that the operative part of s. 3
will not prohibit the slaughter of " heifer " at all-a
result which obviously could not possibly have been
intended. The obvious reason for the enumeration of
the different categories of animals in the definition of
"animal" must have been to provide a word of wide
import so that all those sections where tho wider word
"animal" is used may apply to the different kinds of
animals included within that term. If the intention of
the Bihar legislature was to exclude buffaloes (male or
female adults or calves) from the protection of s. 3
then it must be said that it has failed to fulfil its
intention.
The U. P. Act is intituled "An Act to prohibit the
slaughter of cow and its progeny in Uttar Pradesh."
The preamble to the Act recites the expediency "to
prohibit and prevent the slaughter of cow and its progeny in Uttar Pradesh". Although the U. P. Act
has been made under entry 15 in List II and presumably pursuant to the directives contained in Art. 48
nowhere in the Act is there any express reference
whl).tever to the "preservation, protection or improvement of stock." Section 2 defines "beef" as meaning
the flesh of cow but does not include the flesh of cow
contained in sealed containers and imported as such in
Uttar Pradesh. Clause (b) is very important, for it
defines "cow " as including a bull, bullock, heifer, or
calf. Section 3, which is the operative section runs
thus: •
.
" 3. Notwithstanding anything contained in any .
82
•
-
.j
644
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
other law for the time being in force or any usage or
custom to the contrary, no person shall slaughter or
Mohd. Hanif
cause to be slaughtered or offer or cause to be offerQttareshi
v.
ed for slaughter any cow in any place in Uttar
The State of Bihar Pradesh."
Two exceptions are made by s. 4 in respect of cows
Das c. f.
suffering from contagious or infectious disease or
which is subjected to experimentation in the interest
of medical or public health research. Section 5 prohibits the sale or transport of beef or beef products in
any form except for medicinal purposes and subject to
the provisions of the exception therein mentioned.
Section 6, on which counsel for the State relies, provides for the establishment, by the State Government
or by any local authority wherever so directed by the
State Government, of institutions as may be nec~ssary
for taking care of uneconomic cows. Under s. 7 the
State Government may levy such charges or fees, as
may be prescribed for keeping uneconomic cows in the
institutions. Section 8 provides for punishment for
contravention of the provisions of ss. 3, 4 and 5.
Section 9 makes the . offences created by the Act
cognisable and non-bailable. Section 10 gives power
to the State Government to make rules for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of the Act.
It should be noted that the U. P. Act protects the
" cow", which, according to the definition, includes
only bulls, bullocks, heifer and calves. There is no
reference to the species of bovine cattle and, therefore,
the buffaloes (male or female adults or calves) are
completely outside the protection of this Act.
The C. P. and Berar Act of 1949 was originally
intituled " An Act to provide for preservation of
certain animals by controlling the slaughter thereof,"
and the pi;eamble recited that it was " expedient to
provide for the preservation of certain animals by
controlling the slaughter thereof." " Animal" was
defined in s. 2 as meaning an animal specified in the
schedule. The schedule specified the following categories of animals, namely, (1) bulls, (2) bullocks, (3) cows,
(4) calves, (5) male and.female buffaloes and (6) buffalo
calves. Sectiqn 4 originally prohibited the slaughter
r958
•
.
S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
645
of an " animal " without certificate. There was then
r958
no total ban on the slaughter of any animal as defined.
In 1951, the C. P. and Berar Animal Preservation Act, M~~~.::;;nif
1949, was amended by the Madhya Pradesh Act
v.
XXIII of 1951. By this amending Act the words The State of Biliar
" by prohibiting or " were added to the long title and
the preamble before the word " controlling " and a
Das c. J.
new clause was added to s. 2 as cl. (i) (a) defining
"cow" as including a female calf of a cow and subs. I of s. 4 was amended so as to read as follows :
"(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any
other law for the time being in force or in any usage
to the contrary, no person(a) shall slaughter a cow; or
(b) shall slaughter any other animal unless he
has obtained in respect of such other animal a certificate 1n writing signed by the executive authority and
the veterinary officer for the area in which the animal
is to be slaughtered that the animal is fit for
slaughter."
Thus a total ban was imposed on the slaughter of
cows and female calf of a cow and the male calf of a
cow, bull, bullock, buffalo (male or female adult or
calf) could be slaughtered on obtaining a certificate.
The Act was further amended in 1956 by Act X of
1956 substituting for the amended definition of" cow"
introduced by the amending Act of 1951 as cl. (l)(a) of
s. 2 of the C. P. and Berar Animal Preservation Act,
1949, a new definition of " cow " as including a male
or female calf of a cow, bull, bullock or heifer and a
new schedule specifying only (1) cows, (2) male and
female buffaloes and (3) buffalo calves was substituted
for the original schedule to the Act. Shortly put the
position in Madhya Pradesh has been this: while
·under the C. P. and Berar Animal Preservation Act,
1949, as it originally stood, the slaughter• of all categories of animals mentioned in the original schedule
were only controlled by the requirement of a certificate from the appropriate authority before the actual
slaughter, by the amending Act XXIII of 1951, a total
ban was imposed on the slaughter of "cows:' which·
was then defined as including only a ~emale calf of a
•
646
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959)
-
'95 8
Mohd. Hanif
Quamhi
cow and the slaughter of all other categories of
animals coming within the original schedule was controlled and finally after the amending Act X of 1956,
v.
there is now a total ban on the slaughter of" cows"
The State of Bihar which by the new definition includes a male or female
calf of a cow, bull, bullock or heifer so that the male
Das c. J.
and female buffaloes .and buffalo calves (male and
female) can still be slaughtered but on certificate issued
by the proper authorities mentioned .in the Act. The
Madhya Pradesh Act X of 1956, amending the C. P.
and Berar Animal Preservation Act, 1949, received
the assent of the Governor on · May 18, 1956. The
C. P. and Berar Animal Preservation Act, 1949, as
amended up to 1956, is hereinafter referred to as the
Madhya Pradesh Act.
To sum up, under the Bihar Act there is in the
State of Bihar a total ban on slaughter of all categories
of animals of the species of bovine cattle. In Uttar
Pradesh there is, under the U. P. Act, a total ban on
the slaughter of cows and her progeny which include
bulls, bullocks, heifer or calves. The buffaloes (male
or female adults or calves) are completely outside the
protection of the Act. In the present Madhya Pradesh and the districts which formerly formed part of
Madhya Pradesh but have since been transferred to
the State of Bombay and where the Madhya Pradesh
law including the Madhya Pradesh Act still applies,
there is a total ban on the slaughter of cow, male or
female calves of a cow, bulls, bullocks, or heifers and
the slaughter of buffaloes (male or female adults or
calves) are controlled in that their slaughter is permitted under certificate granted by the proper authorities mentioned in the Act. No exception has been
made in any of these three Acts permitting slaughter
of cattle even for bona fide religious purposes such as
has been made, say, in the Bombay Animal Preservation Act, 1948 (Born. LXXXI of 1948).
As already stated the petitioners, who are citizens
of India, and Muslims by religion, mostly belong to the
Qnraishi community and are generally engaged in the
· butchers' trade and its subsidiary undertakings such
as supply of h~des, tannery, glue making, gut making
•
~
S.C.R.
•
,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
647
and blood de-hydniting, Those, who carry on the
r95S
butchers' trade, are mostly~ Kasais \vh.o, the l?etitioners
L
h l
Mohd. Hanif
say, kill only cattle uut not sheep or goat w ic l are
Quareshi
slaughtered by other persons known as Chicks. Learnv.
ed counsel appearing for the petitioners challenge the The State of Bihar
constitutional validity of the Act.s respectively a pplicable to them on three grounds, namely, that they
Das c. J.
offend the fundamental rights guaranteed to them by
Arts. 14, 19(1)(g) and 25. Learned counsel appearing
for the respondent States, of course, seek to support
their respective enactments by controverting the
reasons advanced by learned counsel for the petitioners. Bharat Go-Sevak Samaj, All India AntiCow-Slaughter Movement Committee, Sarvadeshik
Arya Pratinidhi Sabha and lVI. P. Gorakshan Sangh
put in petitions for leave to intervene in these proceec!ings. Under Order XLI, rule 2, of the Supreme
Court Rules intervention is permitted only to the
Attorney-General of India or the Advocates-General
for the States. There is no other express provision
for permitting a third party to intervene in the proceedings before this Court. In practice, however, this
Court, in exercise of its inherent powers, allows a third
party to intervene when such third party is a party to
some proceedings in this Court or in the High Courts
where the same or similar questions are in issue, for
the decision of this Court will conclude the case of
that party. In the present case, however, the petitioners for intervention are not parties to any proceedings and we did not think it right to permit them
formally to intervene in these proceedings ; but in
view of the importance of the questions involved in
these proceedings we · have heard Pandit Thakurdas
Bhargava, who was instructed by one of these petitioners for intervention, as amicus cY,riae. 'Ve ate
deeply indebted to all learned counsel <1ppearing for
the parties and to Pan~it Thakurdas Bhargava for
the valuable assistance they have given us.
Before we actually take up and deal with the alleged
infraotion of the petitioners' fundamental rights, it is
necessary to dispose of a preliminary question raised
by Pandit Thakurchi.s Bhargava. It will be recalled
•
648
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
that the impugned Acts were made by the States in
discharge of the obligations laid on them by Art. 48 to
l\fohd. Hanif
Quareshi
end eavour to organise agricu1ture an d animal husbanv.
dry and in particular to take steps for preserving and
The State of Bi/1ar improving the breeds and prohibiting the slaughter of
certain specified animals. These directive principles,
Das c. J.
it is true, are not enforceable by any court of law but
nevertheless they are fundamental in the governance
of the country and it is the duty of the State to give
effect to them. These laws having thus been made in
discharge of that fundamental obligation imposed on
the State, the fundamental rights conferred on the
citizens and others by Chapter III of the Constitution
must be regarded as subordinate to these laws. The
directive principles, says learned counsel, are equally,
if not more, fundamental and must prevail. We are
unable to accept this argument as sound. Article •13(2)
expressly says that the State shall not make any bw
which takes away or abridges the rights conferr.ed by
Chapter III of our Constitution which enshrines the
fundamental rights. The directive principles cannot
over-ride this categorical restriction imposed on the
legislative power of the State. A harmonious interpretation has to be placed upon the Constitution and
so interpreted it means that the State should certainly
implement the directive principles but it must do so in
such a way that its laws do not take away or abridge
the fundamental rights, for otherwise the protecting
provisions of Chapter III will be " a mere rope of
sand ". As this Court has said in the State of Madras
v. Smt. Champakam Dorairajan (1) , "The directive
principles of State policy have to conform to and run
as subsidiary to the Chapter on Fundamental Rights".
Coming now to the arguments as to thll violation of
the petitioners' fundamental rights, it will be convenient to take Ul' first the complaint founded on Art. 25(1).
That article runs as follows :
"Subject to public order, morality and health and
to the other provisions of this Part, all., persons are
equally entitled to freedom of conscience and the
right free,ly to profess, practise and propagate religion".
x958
(1) [1951) S.C.R. 525, 531 .
•
-
S.C.R.
.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
649
8
After referring to the provisions of cl. (2) which lays
I95
down certain exceptions which are not material for Mohd. Hanif
our present purpose this Court has, in Ratilal PanaQuamhi
chand Gandhi v. 'l'he State of Bombay (1) explained the
v.
meaning and scope of this article thus:
The State of Bihar
"Thus, subject to the restrictions which this
article imposes, every person has a fundamental right
Das c. f.
under our Constitution not merely to entertain such
religious belief as may be approved of by his judgment
or conscience but to exhibit his belief and ideas in
such overt acts as are enjoined or sanctioned by his
religion and further to propagate his religious views
for the edification of others. It is immaterial also
whether the propagation is made by a person in his
individual capacity or on behalf of any church or
institution. The free exercise of religion by which is
meant the performance of outward acts in pursuance
of relgious belief, is, as stated above, subject to State
regulation imposed to secure order, public health and
morals of the people. "
What then, we inquire, are the materials placed before
us to substantiate the claim that the sacrifice of a
cow is enjoined or sanctioned by Islam ? The materials before us are extremely meagre and it is surprising that on a matter of this description the allegations
in the petition should be so ·vague. In the Bihar Petition No. 58 of 1956 are set out the following bald
allegations :
"That the petitioners further respectfully submit
that the said impugned section also violates the fundamental rights of the petitioners guaranteed under Article 25 of the Constitution in-as-much as on the
occasion of their Bakr Id Day, it is the religious practice of the petitioners' community to sacrifice a cow on
the said occasion. The poor members of the community usually sacrifice one cow for every 7 members
whereas it would require one sheep or one goat for
each member which would entail considerably more
expense. As a result of the total ban imposed by the
impugned section the petitioners would not even be
allowed to make the said sacrifice which is a practice
(1) [1954] S.C.R. 1055, 1062-1063.
•
650
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
and custom in their religion, enjoined upon them by
the
Holy Quran, and practised by all Muslims from
!i1ohd. Hanif
Quamhi
time immemorial and recognised as such in I.ndia. "
v.
The allegations 'in the other petitions are similar.
The State of fahar These are met by an equally bald denial in pn.ra. 21 of
the affidn.vit in opposition. .No affidavit has been
Das C. ].
filed by any person specially competent to expound
the relevant tenets of Islam. No reference is made in
the petition to any particular Surah of the Holy Quran
which, in terms, requires the sacrifice of a cow. , All
that was placed before us during the argument we.re
Surah XXII, Verses 28 and 33, and Surah CVIII.
What the Holy book enjoins is that people should
pray unto the Lord and make sacrifice. We have no
affidavit before us by any l\faulana explaining the
implications of those verses or throwing any lig~t on
this problem. \Ve, however, find it laid down in
Hamilton's translation of Hedaya Book XLIII at
p. 592 that it is the duty of every free Mussulman,
arrived at the age of maturity, to offer a sacrifice on
the Yd Kirban, or festival of the sacrifice, provided he
be then possessed ofNisab and be not a traveller. The
sacrifice established for one person is a goat and
that for seven a cow or a camel. It is therefore,
optional for a Muslilll; to sacrifice a goat for one
person or a cow or a camel for seven persons.
It does not appear to be obligatory that a person
must sacrifice a cow. The very fact of an option
seems to run counter to the notion of an obliga.
tory duty. It is, however, pointed out that a person
with six other members of his family may afford
to sacrifice a c9w but may not be able to afford
to sacrifice seven goats. So there may be an econo.
mic ·compulsion 'although there is no religious compul.
sion. lt is als,p pointed. out that from time immemorial
the Indian Mussalmans have been sacrificing cows and
this practice, if not enjoined, is certainly sanctioned
by their religion and it amounts to their practice 6f
religion protected by Art. 25. While the petitioners
claim that the sacrifice of a cow is essential, the State
denies the obligatory nature of the religious practice.
The fact, emph~sised by the respondents, cannot be
•
.
-
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
651
disputed, namely, that many Mussalmans do not
r95s
sacrifice a cow on the Bakr Id Day. It is part of the Mohd. Hanif
known history of India that the Moghul Emperor
Quareshi
Bahar saw the wisdom of prohibiting· the slaughter of
v.
cows as and by way of religious sacrifice and directed The State of Bihar ·
his son Humayun to follow this example. Similarly
Emperors Akbar, Jehangir, and Ahmad Shah, it is
Das c. J.
said, prohibited cow slaughter. Nawab Hyder Ali of
Mysore made cow slaughter an offence punishable
with the cutting of the hands of the offenders. Three
of the members of the Gosamvardhan Enquiry Committee set up by the Uttar Pradesh Government in
1953 were Muslims and concurred in the unanimous
recommendation for total ban on slaughter of cows.
We have, however, no material on the record before
us which will enable us to say, in the face of the foregoing· facts, that the sacrifice of a cow on that day is
an obligatory overt act for a Mussalman to exhibit his
religious belief and idea. In the premises, it is not
possible for us to uphold this claim of the petitioners.
The next complaint is against the denial of the
equal protection of the law. It is thus formulated:
The petitioners are Muslims by religion and butchers
(Kasais) by occupation and they carry on the trade of
selling beef. The impugned Acts prejudicially affect
only the Muslim Kasais who kill cattle but not others
who kill goats and sheep and who sell goats' meat and
mutton. It is, therefore, clear that only the Muslim
Kasais, who slaughter only cattle but not sheep or
goats, have been singled out for hostile and discriminatory treatment. Their further grievance is that the
U. P. Act makes a distinction even between butchers
who kill cattle and butchers who kill buffaloes and the
Madhya Pradesh Act also makes a like discrimination
in that slaughter of buffaloes is permitte~, although
under certificate, while slaug):iter of cows, bulls,
bullocks and calves are totally prohibited. In the
premises the petitioners contend that the law which
permits such discrimination must be struck down as
violativ~ of the salutary provisions of Art. 14 of the
Constitution.
83
652
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
The meaning, scope and effect of Art. 14, · which is
the equal protection clause in our Constitution, has
iWohd. H anif
been explained by this Court in a series of decisions in
Quareshi
v:
cases beginning with Ohiranjitlal Choudhury v. The
T'he State of Bihar Union of India (1 ) and ending with the recent case of
Ram Krishna Dalmia and . others v. Sri Justice S. R.
Das c. J.
Tendolkar ('). It is now well established that while
Art. 14 forbids class legislation it does not forbid
reasonable clitssification for.the purposes of legislation
and that in order to pass the test of permissible classification two conditions must be fulfilled, namely, (i)
the classification must be founded on an intelligible
differentia which distinguishes persons or things that
are grouped together from others left out of the group
and (ii) such differentia must have a rational relation
to the object sought t·o be achieved by the statute in
question. The classification, it has been held, may be
founded on different bases, namely, geographical, or
according to obj°ects or occupations or the like aud
what is necessary is that there must be a nexus
between the basis of classification and the object of
the Act under consideration. The pronouncements of
this Court further establish, amongst other things, that
there is always a presumption in favour of the constitutionality of an enactment and that the burden is upon
him, who attacks it, to show that there has been a
clear violation of the constitutional· principles. The •
courts, it is accepted, must presume that the legislature understands and correctly appreciates the needs
of its own people, that its laws are directed to problems made manifest by experience and tliat its discriminations are based on adequate grounds. It must be
borne in mind that the legislature is free to recognise
degrees of harm and may confine its restrictions to
those cases where the need is deemed to be the clearest
and finally that in ord('r to sustain the presumption of
constitutionality the Court may take into consideration matters of common knowledge, matters of common
report, the history of the times and may assume every
state of facts which can be conceived existing" at the
· time of legislation. We, therefore, proceed to examine
1958
•
(1) [1950] ~.C.R. ~9·
(2) [1959] S.C.R. 279.
'
S.C.R.
,
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
653
the impugned Acts in the light of the principles thus
x958
enunciated by this Court.
The impugned Acts, ·it may be recalled,. have been Mohd. H::•if
made by the States in discharge of the obligations imQu:;es '
posed on them by Art. 48. In order to implement the The State. of Bihar
directive principles the respect.ive Legislatures enacted
the impugned Acts in exercise of the powers conferred
Das c. J.
on them by Art. 246 read with entry 15 in List II of
the Seventh Schedule. It is, therefore, quite clear
that the objects sought to be achieved by the impugned Acts are the preservation, protection and improvement of livestocks. Cows, bulls, bullocks and calves
of cows are no doubt the most important cattle for the
agricultural economy of this country. :Female buffaloes
yield a large quantity of m~lk and are, therefore, well
looked after and do not need as much protection as
cows yielding a small quantity of milk require. As
draught cattle male buffaloes are not. half as useful as
bullocks. Sheep and goat give very little milk compared to the cows and the female buffaloes and have
practically no utility as draught animals. These
different categories of animals being susceptible of
classification into separate groups on the basis of their
usefulness to society, the butchers who kill each category may also be placed in distinct classes according
to the effect produced on society by the carrying on of
their respective occupations. Indeed the butchers,
who kill cattle, according to the allegations of the
petitioners themselves in their respective petitions,
form a well defined class based on their occupation.
That classification is based on an intelligible differentia
which places them in a well defined class and distinguishes them from those who kill goats and sheep and
this differentia has a close connection with the object
sought to be aqhieved.by the impugned ~ct, namely,
the preservation, protection and improvement of our
livestock. The attainment of these objectives may
well necessitate that the slaughterers of cattle should be
dealt with more stringently than the slaughterers of,
say, go ats and sheep. The impugned Acts, therefore,
have adopted a classification on sound and in.telligible:
basis and can quite clearly stand the t~st laid down in
0
654
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
the decisions of this Court. Whatever objections
Mohd. Hanif
there may be against the validity of the impugned
Quareshi
Acts the denial of equal protection of the laws does
v.
.
not, prima facie, appear to us to be one of them. In
The State 01 Biha• any case, bearing in mind the presumption of constiDa-;-;;_ J. tutionality attaching to all enactments founded on the
recognition by the court of the fact that the legislature correctly appreciates the needs of its own people
there appears to be no escape from the conclusion that
the petitioners have not discharged the onus that was
on them and the challenge under Art. 14 cannot,
therefore, prevail.
Learn\ld counsel for the petitioners then take their
final stand on Art. 19(1)(g). Immediately learned
counsel for the respondents-counter the charge by saying that Art. 19(1}(g) can hit only the law which, purports to directly violate its provisions. The impugned
Acts, we are reminded, have been made in implementation of the directive principles laid down in Art. 48
and are laws with respect to matters set forth in entry
15 of List II and it is emphasised that the sole purpose
of these enactments is to secure the preservation, protection and improvement of stock and that its real aim
is not to take away or abridge the rights guaranteed by
Art. ·19(1 )(g). If at all, these enactments may only
indirectly and incidentally affect those rights but that
circµmstance cannot alter their real nature and purpose. Reliance is placed in support of this contention
on the following observations of Kania C. J. in A. K.
Gopalan v. The State (1).
" If there is a legislation directly attempting to
control a citizen's freedom of speech or expression, or
his right to assemble peaceably and without arms, etc.,
the question whether that legislation is saved by the
relevant savjng ·clause of artiqle 19 will arise. If,
however, the legislation is not directly in respect of any
of these subjects, but as a result of the operation of
other legislation, for instance, for punitive or preventive detention, his right under any ·of these sub-,clauses
is abridged, the question of the application of article
:19 does not arise. The true approach is only to consider the directness of the legislation and not what will
z95B
• (I) [1950JS.C.R.' 88, IOI.
c
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
655
be the result of the detention otherwise valid, on the
I958
mode of the detenue's life. "
Mohd. Hanif
This part of the argument advanced on behalf of the
Quareshi
respondents is further sought to be reinforced by the
v.
fact that the above observations of Kania C. J. had The State of Bihar
subsequently been adopted by this Court in Ram Singh
v. The State of Delhi (1 ). Those observations of Kania
Das c. f.
C. J. should, in our opinion, be read in the context of
the facts of those cases. It should be remembered that
both these cases arose out of orders made under the
Preventive Detention Act, 1950. Article 22, which is
to be found in Chapter III of the Constitution, recognises the necessity for preventive detention, however
odious it may be. The purpose of the Act under whicl'i.
the detention orders had been made in those cases, was
to wevent the persons concerned from acting in any
manner prejudicial to one or other of the three important matters specified therein. The effect of the execution of the orders was to deprive those persons of their
liberty according to procedure established by law.
Preventive detention, like punitive detention, having
taken away the personal liberty of those persons they
could not claim the rights under Art. 19(l)(a)to (e) and
(g) for those were the rights of free men. It was, therefore, considered that the primary and direct object of
the Preventive Detention Act, 1950, being, inter alia,
to secure the security of the State and maintenance of
law and order, its impact on the fundamental rights
was indirect and, therefore, the Act could not be challenged for breach of the fundamental rights under Art.
19(1). The position in the cases now before us is quite
different. The last part of the directive principles
embodied in Art. 48 require the State to take steps for
prohibiting the slaughter of the specified animals and
this directive can only be carried out br prohibiting
the petitioners and other butchers (Kasais) from slaugh-·
tering them. There can be no mistake about the
directness of these legislations vis-a-vis the petitioners
and other butchers and the effect of these legislations
on their rights is direct and instantaneous as soon as
they are brought into force. The title of the'U. P. Act
(1) (1951] S.C.R. 451, 456-457.
•
\
656
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
'95 8
[1959]
does not even attempt to conceal the directness of its
impact on the butchers of Uttar Pradesh. The arguQuamhi
ment of learned counsel for the respondents on this
v.
point cannot be accepted and the question of the alleg7Ae Slate of Bihared violation of Art. 19(l)(g) has to be dealt with on
merits.
Das C. ].
The complaint of the petitioners under Art. 19 (1) (g)
is that the impugned Acts, if enforced, will compel
them at once to close down their business and will, in
effect, amount to a complete denial of their right to
carry· on their occupation, trade or business in spite of
the mandatory provisions of Art,. 19(l)(g). The objection iS elaborated thus: The livelihood of a butcher of
battle depends on the existence of many factors. First
he has to purchase the cattle which he will slaughter.
The statistics will show that a large number of ,.attle
are slaughtered for food every year. According to
Table II on p. 24 of the Report on the Marketing of
Cattle in India 18,93,000 heads of cattle and 6,09,000
buffaloes were slaughtered in the year 194.8. Taking
that 7 goats are the equivalent in flesh of 1 cow or
buffalo these butchers who slaughter 25,02,000 bovine
cattle will have to find 7 times that number of goats
or sheep, that is to say, they will have to have
1, 75,14,000 extra goats and sheep per year. This it is
said, is not available in India. Then the butchers will
have to find buyers for this enormous quantity of
goats' meat or mutton the price of which, according to
the figures given at p.12 of the Expert Committee's
Report, is very much higher than that of beef. Poorer
people may afford to buy beef occasionally but goats'
meat Or mutton will be beyond their reach and consequently there will not be a market for sale of the
meat of so many goats and sheep and the butchers will
have to reduce the number of goats and sheep for
purposes of slaughter and that will reduce their income
to a negligible figure. Further, what will they do with
the skins of so many goats, and sheep ? They will not
have ready sale in the market as hides. of co,ys and
buffaloes have, for the latter are used in the manufacture of. boots, shoes, suit cases, belts and other leather
goods while the.skins of goats and sheep will be. useless
Mohd. Honif
•
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
657
for such purpose. The same considerations will apply
r9ss
to the guts. There is, therefore, no escape, say learned Mohd. Hanif
counsel for the petitioners from the inevitable concluQuareshi
sion that a total ban on the slaughter of all· animals
v.
belonging to the species of bovine cattle will bring The State of Bihar
about a total prohibition of the business and occupation of the butchers (Kasais). Clause (6) of Art. 19, no
Das c. f.
doubt, protects the operation of the existing laws in so
far as they impose and do not prevent the State from
making any law imposing, in the interest of the general public, reasonable restrictions on the exercise of
the right conferred by Art. 19(l)(g). But restrictions,
they say, cannot extend to total prohibition and reference is made to the observations to be found in some of
the decisions of this Court. The contention is that the
State may regulate but cannot annihilate a business
which. a citizen has a right to carry on.
The rival contention is thus formulated: The
dictionary meaning of the word " butcher " is " slaughterer of animals for food, dealer in meat". It is one
of the three well-known occupations included in the
homely phrase, " the butcher, the baker, the candlestick maker". 'The expression" butcher", as popularly
understood now, has no reference to any particular
animal. The term is now applicable to any person
who slaughters any animal for food. Taken in this
larger sense, the facts alleged in the petitions do not,
according to learned counsel for the respondents,
indicate that any of the impugned Acts has the effect
of completely stopping the petitioners' businesses.
They seek to illustrate their point thus : Take the case
of piece-goods merchants. · Some may deal in country
made piece-goods and others may import and sell
piece-goods manufactured, say, in England or Japan.
Some may deal in dhotis and saris and others may
confine their activities to the purchase anti sale of long
cloth or other varieties of piece-goods. They are,
however, all piece-goods merchants. Suppose in the
interest of our indigenous textile industry and to
protect the best interests of the general public it
becomes necessary to stop the import of fore,ign cloth.
altogether. Such stoppage will not prevent any cloth
•
658
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
merchant f~om carrying on his trade or business as
cloth merchant, for he can still deal in cloth and pieceM olid. Ha1uf
£
Quamhi
goods manu actured in India. Will any piece-goods
v.
merchant, whose business was only to import foreign
The State of Bihar piece-goods for sale in India, be heard to complain
that the stoppage of import of foreign cloth has
Da> c. J.
completely prevented him from carrying on business
as a piece goods merchant and, therefore, such stoppage
of import of foreign cloth being more than a mere
restriction .violates his fundamental right under
Art. 19(l)(g)? Where, they ask, will the argument
lead us ? Suppose that the import of one particular
variety of piece-goods, say saris, is stopped but import
of dhotis and all other varieties of piece-goods are
allowed. On a reasoning at par with that urged in
the last case-should not a dealer who imports only
that variety of piece-goods the import of which' has
been stopped be entitled to say that his business has
been completely stopped ? Suppose the State in the
interest of Khadi and cottage industries imposes a ban
on the manufacture or sale of cloth of a very fine count,
will a merchant who deals only in fine cloth be entitled to say that as he deals only in fine cloth, the ban
haR completely prohibited the carrying on of his business? The truth of the matter, they submit, is that
the ban on the import of foreign cloth or on the manufacture of cloth of very fine count is only a restriction
imposed on the piece-goods business, for the ban
affects one or :more of the segments of that business
but leaves the other segments untouched. . There is,
therefore, only some restriction imposed on piece-goods
merchants in that they cannot deal in certain kinds of
piece-goods, but they are not wholly prevented from
carrying on piece-goods business. The position, they
say, is the same in the case of butchers (Kasais)." The
butchers' bustness, they point out, has several segments and a ban on one segment may be complete
prohibition of the activities of that segment, for restriction is complete as far as it extends, but in the larger
context of the butchers' business such a ban,· they
&ubmit, operates only as a restriction. Far less, it is
said, can a dealer in hides, complain that the ban
'958
•
..
c
S.C.R.
'
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
659
imposed on the slaughter of cattle and buffaloes
I958
prevent him from carrying on his business as a hide
merchant, for he can still carry
on his business in Mohd.
Hanif
Quareshi
fallen hides. Indeed the statistics collected in the
v.
l~eport of Marketing of Hides in Intlia, Second Edition, The State of Bihar
p. 9, show that the percentage of fallen hides to the
total cattle population is 8.8 whereas the percentage
Das c. f.
of slaughtered hides to the total cattle population is
1.4. The same argument has been advanced regarding
gut merchants and other dealers in subsidiary things.
It is not necessary for us to dilate upon or to express
any opinion on the rival contentions as abstract propositions. The matter has to be dealt with objectively.
What do the Acts actually provide ? In Uttar Pradesh
the petitioners can freely slaughter buffaloes (male or
female adults or calves) and sell their meat for food.
It is• also open to them to slaughter goats ,and s4eep
and sell the meat. Therefore, so far as the butchers
of Uttar Pradesh are concerned, there is obviously no
total prohibition of their occupation but only some
restrictions have been imposed on them in respect
of one part of their occupation, namely, the
slaughter of cows, bulls, bullocks, and calves of cows.
In Madhya Pradesh the Act, it is true, totally
forbids the slaµghter of cows including bulls, bullocks
and cows but perll!its the slaughter of buffaloes (male
or female adults or calves) under certain conditions.
Therefore, in Madhya !Pradesh also there is no law
totally prohibiting the carrying on of the business of
a butcher. In Bihar there is, no doubt, a total ban
against the slaughter of all animals belonging to the
species of bovine cattle which includes buffaloes (male
or female adults or calves) but it is still possible for
the butchers of Bihar to slaughter goats and sheep and
sell goats' meat and mutton for food. As will be seen
hereafter the total ban on the slaugliter of bulls,
bullocks, buffaloes (male or female adults or calves)
irrespective of their age or_ usefulness is, in our view,
not a reasonable restriction imposed on the butchers
(Kasais) in the interest of the general public and that
being, therefore, void, no question can arise, even iu.
81
••
660
958
'
Mohd. Ha>1if
Quareshi
Th
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
Bihar, of any total prohibition of the rights of ·butchers
to carry on their occnpatioh or business. · In this view
of the matter we need express no final opinion on the
s1 .v. 'f B"h vexed question as to whether restrictions permissible
' · ~
' ••under cl. (6) of Art.'19 may extend to total prohibition.
Das c. J. . That question: was left open by this. Court in Saghi1·
Ahmed v. '/.'he State of U. P. and others (1) and in The
State of Bombay v. R. Jf. D. Chamarbaugwala (') and
in the view we have taken on the facts and construction of the several Acts under consideration, does not
call for an answer _in disposing of these :petitions.
The question that calls for an· answer from us is.
whether these restrictions are reasonable in the
interests of the general public.·
Clause (6) of Art. 19 protects a law which imposes
in the interest of the general public reasonable re~tric
tions on the exercise of the right · confeiTed by sub.
cl. (g) of cl. (1) of Art. 19. Quite obviously it is left tO
the court, in case of dispute, to determine the reason.
ableness of the restrictions imposed by the law. In
determining that question the court, we conceive, cannot proceed on a general notion of what is reasonable
in the abstract or even on a consideration of what is
reasonable from the point of view of the person or
persons on whom the restrictions· are imposed. The
right conferred by sub-cl. (g) is expressed in general
language and if there had been no qualifying provision
like cl. (6), the right so conferred would have been all
absolute one. To the person who ·has this right any
·restriction will be irksome and Iimy well be regarded
by him as unreasonable. But the question cannot be
decided'on that basis. 'Vhat the court has to do is
to consider whether· the restrictions imposed are
reasonable in the interests of the general public. .In
the State of. Madms v. V. G. Ro:w (') this court has
laid dO\vn the test of reasonableness in the followihg
terms:
·
" It is important in this context t.q. bear ih 1i1iiid
that the test of reasonableness, wherever prescribed,
sl).on1d be applied to each individual statute impug1ied,
(1) [1955J 1. S.C.R. 707, 724. . .
(2f[1957] S:C:R. 874. . ..
• (~) [1952] S.C.R. 591, 607.
'
-
S.O.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
661
· and no abstract standard, or general pattern, of reasonz958
ableness can be laid dowi1 as applicable to all cases. Mohd. Hanif
The nature of the right alleged to have been infringed ,
Quareshi
the underlying purpose of the restrictions imposed, the
v.
extent and. urgency of the evil sought to be remedied The State of Bihar
thereby, the disproportion of the imposition, the prevailing conditions at the time, should all enter into the
Das c. I·
judicial .verdict. In evaluating such elusive factors
and forming their own conception of what is reasonable, in all the circumstances of a given case, it is
inevitable that the social philosophy and the scale
of values of the judges participating in the decision
should play an important part, and the limit to their
interference with legislative judgment in such cases
can only be dictated by their sense of responsibility
and self-restraint and the sobering reflection that the
Constitution is meant not only for people of their way
of thinking but for all, and that tho majority of the
elected representatives of the people have, in authorising the imposition of the restrictions, considered
them to he reasonable."
These observations have been adopted by this Court
in later cases, e.g., The State of West Bengal v. Subodh
Gopal Bose (1 ) and Ebrahim, Vazir Mavat v. The State
of. Boinbay (2). In this connection it will also be well
to remember the observation of ~Iahajan J. in The
State of Bihar v. Maharajadhiraj Sfr Kaineshwar Singh
of Dharbnngha Ci), namely, that "the legislature is the
best judge of what is good for the community, by
whose suffrage it comes into existence.... ". This should
be the proper approach for the court but the ultimate
responsibility for determining the validity of the law
must rest with the court and the court must not shirk
that solemn duty 'cast on it by the Constitution. We
have, therefore, to approach the problem now before
us in the light of the principles laid down by this
Court.
The avowed object of each of the impugned Acts is
to ensure the preservation, protection, and improvement 01' the cow and her progeny. ·This solicitude
(2) [1954] S.C.R 933, ~49-950.
(3) (195·•] S.C.R. 889, 941.
(1) [1954) S.C.R. 587, 627.
•
662
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
'95 8
a.rises out of the appreciation of the usefulness of cattle
in
a predominantlv. agricultural societv.
Early Aryans
Mohd. Hanfj
.J
Quareshi
recognised its importance as one of the most indispenv.
sable adjuncts of agriculture. It would appear that in
The state of Bihai Vedic times animal flesh formed the staple food of the
people. This is attributable to the fact that the cliDas c. J.
mate in that distant past was extremely cold and the
Vedic Aryans had been a pastoral people before they
settled down as agriculturists. In Rg. Vedic times
goats, sheep, cows, buffaloes and even horses were
slaughtered for food and for religious sacrifice and
their flesh used to be offered to the Gods. Agni is
called the " eater of ox or cow " in Rg. Veda (VIII. 43,
11). The slaying of a great ox (Mahoksa) or a "great
Goat" (Mahaja) for the entertainment of a distinguished guest has been enjoined in the Satapatha Brahmana
(Ill. 4. 1~2). Yagnavalkya also expresses a similar
view (Vaj 1. 109). An interesting account of
those early days will be found in Rg. Vedic Culture
by Dr. A. C. Das, Ch. 5, pp. 203-5, and in the History
of Dharmasastras (Vol. II, Part II) by P. V. Kane at
pp. 772-773. Though the custom of slaughtering of
- cows and bulls. prevailed during the Vedic period,
nevertheless, even in the Rg. Vedic times there seems
to have grown up a revulsion of feeling against the
custom. . The cow gradually came to acquire a special
sanctity and was called " Aghnya" (not to be slain).
There was a school of thinkers amongst the Rsis, who
set their face against the custom of killing such useful
animals as the cow and the bull.. High praise was
bestowed on the cow as will appear from the following
-•
verses from Hg. Veda, Book· VI, Hymn XXVIII
(Cows) attributed to the authorship of Sage Bhardvaja :
"1. The kine have come and brought good fortune; let .them rest in t!ie cow-pen and be happy near
us.
Here let them stay prolific, many coloured, and
yield through many morns their milk for Indra.
6. 0 cows, ye fatten e'en the worn and wasted,
and make the unlovely beautiful to look on.
Pros.per my house, ye with auspicious voices, your
power is glorifie:J. in our assemblies.
.
c
·-
S.C.R.
,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
663
7. Crop goodly pasturages and be prolific ; drink
1958
pure sweet water at good drinking places.
Never be thief or sinful man ymu master, and Mnhd. Hanif
•
Qua res hi
may the dart of Rudra still avoid you."
v.
(Translation by Ralph Griffith). Verse 29 of Hymn 1 Thi; State of Bina,
in Book X of Atharva Veda forbids cow slaughter in
the following words :
·
Das c. J.
"29. The slaughter of an innocent, 0 Kritya, is
an awful deed, Slay not cow, horse, or man of ours."
Hymn 10 in the same Book is a rapturous glorification
of the cow:
"30. The cow is Heaven, the cow is Earth, the
cow is Vishnu, Lord of life,
The Sadhyas and the Vasus haYe drunk the outpourings of the cow.
34; Both Gods and mortal men depend for life
and being on the cow.
.
She hath become this universe; all that the sun
surveys is she. "
P. V. Kane argues that in the times of the Rg. Veda
only barren cows, if at all, were killed for sacrifice or
meat and cows yielding milk were held to be not fit
for being killed. It is only in this way, according to
him, that one can explain and reconcile the apparent
conflict between the custom of killing cows for food
and the high praise bestowed on the cow in Rg. Vedic
times. It would appear that the protest raised against
the slaughter of cows greatly increased in volume till
the custom was totally abolished in a later age. The
change of climate perhaps also make the use of beef as
food unnecessary and even injurious to health.
Gradually cows became indicative of the wealth of the
owner. The Neolithic Aryans not having been acquainted with metals, there were no coins in current use
in the earlier stages of their civilisation, .hut as they
were eminently a pastoral people almost every family
possessed a sufficient number of cattle and some of
them exchanged them for the necessaries of their life.
The value of cattle (Pasu) was, therefore, very great
with tne early Rg. Vedic Aryans. The ancient Romans also used the word pecus or pecu (pasu) in the
sense of wealth or money. The .English words,
664
SUPREME COURT .REPORTS
[195!)]
"pecuniary " and " impecunious'', are derived from
the Latin root peens or peen, originally meaning cattle.
·2\f ohd. Ii aiirf
rl'h o possession
· of cattl e in those days denoted wealth
Quamhi
v.
and a man was considered rich or poor according to
Tho State of Bihar the large or small number of cattle that he owned. li1
the Ramayana King Jan1ika's wealth ·\vas described
Dus c. J.
by reforcnce to the large number of herds that he
owned. It appears that the cow was gradually raised
to the status of divinity. Kautilya's Arthasastra has
a special chapter (Ch. XXIX) dealing with the "sµperintendent of cows" and the duties of the owner of
cows are also referred to in Ch. XI of Hindu Law in
its sources hy Ganga Nath Jha. ·There can be no
gainsaying the fact that the Hindus in general hold
the cow in great reverence and· the idea of the slaugh,
ter of cows for food ·is repugnant to their notions· and
this sentiment has in the past even led to comn"mnal
riots. It is also a faqt. that after the recent partition
of the country this agitation against the slaughter of
cows has been forth er intensified. W h~le we agree
th!tt the constitutional question before us cannot be
decided on grounds of mere sentiment, however passionate it may be, we, nevertheless, think that it has .to
be taken into consideration, though only 11s one of
many clements, in arriving at a judicial verdict as to
the reasonableness of the restrictions.
Cattle in India, it is said, has a treble rnle to play,
namely, (i) to produce milk for food, (ii) hulls for
draught and (iii) manure. for agriculture. It is neccssary to advert to the arguments advanced under each
head. According to the 1951 census there were
15,60,00,000 heads of cattle and 4,00,00,000 of buffaloes making a total of 19,60,00,000 or roughly
20,00,00,000 of animals belonging .to the species of
bovine cattle. In India there are 123 heads of cattle
including lmlfaloes per square. mile and,43 heads to
every 100 persons. Out of the total cattle population
of 15,60,00,000 and buffalo population of 4,00,00,000
there were in Bihar 1,52,97,000 cattle and 33,16,000
buffaloes, in Madhya Pradesh 1,48,58,000 hends of
.cattle and 26,00,000 buffaloes and in Uttar Pradesh
2,35,13,000. heads of cattle and 92,50,000 buffaloes .
'958
•
'
-
S.0.R.
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
The toth.l distribut.ion of cattle and buffaloes, accord;
ing to age,' s~·x and work, was as follows:Mohd. Ha1iif
Quareshi
H4faloes
11'1 ales
Cattle
:Breeding bulls
6,52,000
3,06,000 T'' ~ v • .t·e·;,·
60 ,:3 6 ,000 · '" ,,fate o1 . 1 a•
vVorking bullocks
ti,88,18,000
Bulls and bullocks over three
Das C.·j.
years not in use for breed4,66,000
. ing· and work, i e., useless. . 27,35,000
28,70,000
Young stock under one year. 97,63,000
Young stock one to three
23,84,000
1,22,57,000
' years of age.
Total
8,42,25,000
Females
Breeding CO\\:R, i.e., cows, over
· 3 yiJars kept for breeding
4,6 7,23,000
or milk production.
Cows over 3 vears used for
"
23,17 ,000
• work.
Cows over 3 · years not in
use for work or breeding
12,02,000
pµrposes, i. e., useless.
9:3,05,000
Young stock over 1 year.
Y,6.ung stock 1 to 3 years of
age.
1,25,44,000
•
GG5
1,20,02,000
2,10,08,000
.5,34,000
- 3,15,000
42,02,000
52,83,000
Total
7,20,91,000
3,13,42,000
.(}rand total
15,63,16,000 4,:33,44,000
As .stated. in the Report on the Marketing of Cattle in
India isslrnd by the Directorate of Marketing and
Inspection, Ministry of Pood and Agriculture, Govern~neiit of India, 1956, the proportion of males in cattle
i('l a little more than half of the total cattl~ population
whilst in the 'case of buffaloes, females predoniinate
and are about 3/4 of the total. Por agricultural purposes
male cattle are generally preferred for their compara-.
tive lirrhtness and active nature. Of the total
39,57,080 unserviceable heads of cattle in India there
were 5,35,000 in Bihar, 1,55,000 in Madhya Pradesh
~nd l 184lQOO iri. Vttc;1.r Pp;i.desh. · Of the. tota.l 7181 1000
•
•
666
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
unserviceable buffaloes there were 1,20,000 in Bihar,
15,000 in Madhya Pradesh and 28,000 in Uttar
Mohd. Hanif
Pradesh.
Quareshi
.
_
.
v.
Although, accordmg to the census figures given
n, stat< of Biliar above, our cattle wealth is, in number, the highest in
the world the milk production is perhaps the lowest.
Das c. J.
According to the figures given in the Second Five Year
Plan, at the beginning of the First Fiv!) Year Plan the
milk output was over 1,80,00,000 tons. The average
yield of milk per cow in Ii1dia was 413 pounds which
is about the lowest of any country iti the world as
against 8,000 pounds in the Netherlands, 7,000 pounds·
in Australia, 6,000 pounds in Sweden and 5,000 pounds·
in the U.S.A. Out of the total yield she-buffaloes give
54% while cows give only 42%. Buffalo milk is richer
in fat, 6 to 7% as compared to 4·5% of fat in the cow's
milk. But cow's milk is richer in other importaut contents and is more easily digestible. The average per
• capita consumption of milk and milk products was
\vorkecl out by t.he First Five Year Plan at 5·5 ounces,'
i.e., about 2·5 chhataks or 1/6 of a seer per day, though
10 ounces are recommended by nutrition experts. In
the 'B'acts and ]'igures about Bihar published in 1955
by ·the Department of Public Relations, the average
annual milk yield is stated to be 620 lbs. per cow and
1,526 lbs. per buffalo-. · It is recognised in Human
Nutrition vis-a-vis Animal Nutrition in India, a
Memorandum prepared by the Nutrition Advisory
Committee of the Indian Council of Medical Research
and the Animal Comni.ittee of the Indian Council of
Agricultural Research that the performance of Indian
milch animals, particularly of cows, is extremely poor
and that from a mere economic point of view there
does not seem to be any justification for maintaining
animals yielding 2 pounds of milk or less per day and
perhaps these animals would better be eliminated.
But, as the Memorandum also says, one should realise,
before such a drastic action is takei1, the consequences
that may follow from the adoption of this policy, for if
the animals giving 2 pounds or less of milk a.re con. demned,as unsuitable it will mean elimination of more
than 90% of the' present day milch cows and loss of
about 70,00,000 tons out of 97,001000 tons of annual
•
x958
c
.'
S.C.R.
,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
667
r958
gross production of milk from this group, besides a
large number of bullocks that they will bear. Accord- Mahd. Hanif
ing to the table of the human food requirement recomQuareshi
mended by the Nutrition Advisory Committee of the
v.
Indian Council of Medical Research 10 ounces of milk The State of Bihar
per adult unit per day is necessary to make up a
balanced diet. The total human population, accordDas c. I·
ing to 1951 census, was 35,68,00,000 which, at the
current rate of increase, was eRtimated to have reached the figure of 37,76,00,000 in 1956. Treating children
below 10 years of age as 0·83 of adult value, the total
adult unit is calculated at 31,30,00,000. At the rate of
10 ounces of milk per adult per day we would require
3,23,00,000 tons of milk per annum. It is clear, therefore, that in India, where a large section of the population <lOnsists of vegetarians, there is a huge shortage in
the supply of milk. Cows and other milch cattle, therefore, are of very great value to this country.
If milk yielding capacity were the only consideration
the comparatively smaller number of female buffaloes
which produce 54% of the total milk supply of our
country would obviously have deserved a far greater
preference over the cows in our estimation. But, as
pointed out by Pandit Thakurdas Bhargava, there is
another important consideration which is perhaps
more important from the standpoint of human food
supply. It is the bullock that takes the largest share
in meeting the power requirements for our agricultural
production. Based perhaps on age old experience
Indian agriculturists habitually prefer a cow bullock
to a buffalo bullock. As a result of the evolutionary
process of trial and error, we find in this country about
10 cow bullocks for every buffalo bullock as is shown
by_ the 1951 census figures set out above. If this
relative distribution is considered unavoidable for our
crop production, we may expect no change in the
existing ratio in the population of the two species
unless . a. revolution can be brought about in our
method.s and practice of land cultivation. A.ccordihg
to the Report on the Ma1•keting of Cattle in India,
1956, p. 22, animals are utilised in India unuer four.
heads: (1) used for cultivating-6,54,.22,00.0 (2) usec\
85
668
SUPREME COURT .REPORTS
[1959]
for carting in urban areas-11,80,000 (3) used as pack
animaLs-67,705 and (4) used in oil crushers, etc.Mohd. Hanif 4,30,000,
making up the total of 6,70,99,705. As
Qua1·eshi ,
v.
against this we have, according to the 1951 census
Th, s1.a1e of Biha• figures set out above, 5,88,18,000 working bullocks
and 60,36,000 working he-buffaloes, aggregating to
Das c. J.
6,48,54,000. There is therefore a shortage of 22,45, 705
bullocks including buffaloes which presumably repre- .
sent the dry cows and female buffaloes put to agricultural labour, as shown ill the Second :Five Year Plan
at pp. 281-282. It is true that tractors have begun to be
used but they are still of a negligible number and for
many years to come the country will have to depend
upon animal power for her agricultural operations in
order to grow enough food for meeting the demands of
the fast growing human population. In Uttar Pradesh,
according to the 1951 census, there were 2,35,12,839
heads of cattle and 92,50,488 buffaloes, making a total
of a,27,63,327. The total area. of Uttar Pradesh was
7,22,78,809 acres out of which 4,92,30,120 acres were
under cultivation. If a pair of bullocks can be taken
on an average to cover 10 acres the total area under
cultivation will require 98,46,000 bullocks. The 1951
census figures show 1,15,00,000 of bullocks which are
slightly in excess of the number of bullocks required
for the purposes of cultivation only. Indeed both in
Uttar Pradesh and in Bihar, according to the First
Five Year Plan, p. 247, there was a surplus of about
40,00,000 of bullocks while in the Punjab and Pepsu
the number available was just adequate to meet
the demands. If, however, account is taken of the
other purposes for which bullocks may be used, namely,
for carting or as pack animals or for working oil crushers or drawing water from the wells for irrigation
purposes, thj' total available animal power will fall
short of the requirements. In addition to that we have
to keep in view the necessity for further expansion of
the cultivated area to meet the food requirements of
the fast growing population, and in that case the
deficit will go up still further. In Bihar, accoraing to
the Facts and Figures, 1956, the total number of animal
I!opulation .of t!J.e bovine species were:1958
'
s:c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
669
Cattle
Cows and oxen (adults)
Cows and oxen {young stock)
1,15,64,310.
37,33,166
Buffaloes
Buffaloes (adult)
23,78,293
Buffaloes {young stock)
9,37,582
The number of working cattle and buffaloes works out
to one for every 6 acres of net area under cultivation.
It follows, therefore, that our working animals are
perhaps just about sufficient to supply the power to
keep our agricultural operations up to the necessary
standard, but the demand for food is growing and
more lands will have to be brought under cultivation
and we shall require a far larger number of these
animals.
T)lere are in India, 6,50,000 breeding bulls and
3,10,000 breeding buffaloes. There are 4,63,40,000 breeding cows and 2,09,90,000 breeding buffaloes. According to the First :ll'ive Year Plan, p. 27 4, approximately
750 farm bred bulls of known pedigree are distributed
annually by the Government in different States for
developing and improving the draught as well as the
milch breeds. Besides there are some approved bulls
belonging to private owners. But the existing number
of private bulls meets less than o· 15'Yo of the total
requirements of the country. According to the Report
on the Marketing of Cattle in India, p. 9, service bulls
number approximately 6,52,000 or about o· 4% of the
total cattle in the countrv. In the absence of an
arrangement to castrate or" remove the inferior bulls
before a pedigree bull is 100ated in an area, the progeny
of the pedigree bulls have access to scrub, which
nullifies the efficiency achieved in the finit gene~ation.
It is, therefore, clear that t.he breeding bulls (cattle and
buffaloes) are insufficient to meet the requirements. It
is true that the practice of artificial insemination has
been introduced in some centres but for many years to
come Indian animal husbandry will have to depend
011 th~ ordinary breeding· bulls. We are in short supply
of them.
_ The third utility of these animals {cattle and buffa~
loes) is the dung. The First Five Yel}r Pl~n at p. 255
Mrih4. Hanif
'Q11aie<hi
v.
The State of Biha
Das C. J.
670
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
records that 80,00,00,000 tons of dung are available
per annum. h 50% of this is used as fuel by cultillfolid. llanif
Quam/ii
vators and t c other 50% is used as manure. lf suitv.
able supplies of fuel could be made available to the
The s1a1e of lhhnr cultivators then the entire quantity of dung could be
used for manure. It is doubtful, however, if the cnltiDa> c. J.
vators would be in a position to pay for the fuel and
utilise the entirety of the dung for manure. Cattle urine
is also useful for the nitrogen, phosphates and potash
contents in it. In terms of money the dung and the
urine will account for a large portion of the agricultural income in India. Indeed Pandit Thakurdas
Bhargava appearing as ainicus curiae has claimed
Rs. 63,00,00,000 per year as the contribution of the
dung of these animals to the national income.
The discussion in the foregoing paragraphs clearly
establishes the usefulness of the cow and her progeny.
They sustain the health of the nation by giving them
the life giving milk which is so essential an item in a
scientifically balanced diet. The working bullocks are
indispensable for our agriculture, for they supply
power more than any other animal. Good breeding
bulls are necessary to improve the breed so that the
quality and stamina of the future cows and working
bullocks may increase and the production of food and
milk may improve and be in abundance. The dung
of the animal is cheaper than the artificial manures
and is extremely useful. In short, the backbone of
Indian agriculture is in a manner of speaking the cow
and her progeny. Indeed Lord Linlithgow hafl truly
said-" The cow and the working bullock h11,ve on
their patient back the whole structure of Indil n agriculture. " (Report on the Marketing of Cattle in India,
p. 20). If, therefore, we are to attain sufficiency in the
production of food, if we are to maintain the nation's
health, the efficiency and breed of our Cattle population must be considerably improved. To attain the
above objectives we must devote greater attention to the
preservation, protection and improvement of the stock
and organise our agriculture and animal husbandry
on modern and scientific lines. \Ve have, therefore, to
examme 'the provisions of the impugned Acts and
r958
S.C.R.
r
. '
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
671
ascertain whether they help in achieving the sai<i
r958
objectives, or are calculated to hinder ihat process. Mohd. lianif
In that context all the considerations above alluded to
Qu1Jreslti
must enter the judicial verdict and if the impugned
v:
Acts further the aforesaid purpose then only can the The State of Bih1tr
restrictions imposed by the impugned Acts be said to
Das c. J.
be reasonable in the interest of the general public.
'Ve turn now to the other side of the picture. In
examining the conspectus of the problem the Court
cannot overlook the fact, emphasised in the petition,
that the petitioners and a very large number of similarly situated persons, even if their 11umber does not
come up to the figure mentioned in the petition, are
butchers (Kasais) by occupation and make an income
of about Rs. 150 to Rs. 200 per month and that they
will be seriously affected, if not completely thrown out
of ocriupation, by the impugned Acts. It is true, for
reasons hereinbefore stated, that they cannot complain
that they have been completely deprived of their occupation or business but the enactments, if valid, will
compel them to make fresh arrangements for the
supply of animals which are permitted to be slaughtered for food. Theoretically it may not be impossible
for them to do so, but in practice it is more than likely
to cause considerable inconvenience to them and may
even involve extra expenses for them. The hide merchants, who, they say in the petition, have made their
arrangements for the supply to them of hides of
slaughtered animals up to 95 % of their requirements,
may find it difficult to make fresh arrangements for
procuring fallen hides. The same observations may
be made about the gut merchants. The immediate
effect of the operation of these Acts is to cause a
serious dislocation of the petitioners' business without
any compensatory benefit. In Saghir Ahmad v. The
State of U. P. (1), at p. 727 this Court observed, with
respect to the persons engaged in running buses for
carrying passengers :
"One thing, however, in our opinion, has a decided
bearing on the question of reasonableness and that is
the immediate effoct which the legislation is.likely to·
(1) (r955] r S.C.R. 707, 724.
672
' 195
8
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
prodnco. Hundreds of citizens are earning their liveli.hood
bv
oarryinir
on this business on various routes
Mohd ..Hanif
J
'--'
Q•w<'i,;
within the State of Uttar Pradesh. Although they
v.
carry on the business only with the aid of permits,
TkState of B;/wnvhich are granted to them by the authorities under
the Motor Vehicles Act, no compensation has been
v., c. J. allowed to them under the Statute. "
Similar inconvenience may easily be supposed to have
befallen the petitioners and others of their class and
the immediate and possibly adverse impact of the impugned Acts on their occupation or business must,
therefore, be taken into account as one of the important factors in judging the reasonableness or otherwise
of the said Acts.
There is also no getting away from the fact that
beef or buffalo meat is an item of food for a larg,e section of the people in India and in particular of the
State of Bihar and Uttar Pradesh. Table 11 at p. 24
of the Report on the Marketing of Cattle in India
shows that in the year 1948 the annual demand for
cattle and buffaloes for purposes of food was: 18,93,000
heads of cattle and 6,09,000 buffaloes. These figures
indicate that beef and buffalo flesh arc used for food
by a large section of the people in India. l t is well.
known that poorer sections of Muslims, Christians and
members of the Scheduled Castes and Tribes consume
beef and buffalo flesh. There is also a limited demand
for beef by the foreign population. Buffaloes yield
comparatively coarse and tough meat of inferior
quality and consequently the demand for beef is
greater than that for buffalo flesh. :Further the price
of the buffalo flesh is 20 to 40% less than that of beef.
The prices of beef and buffalo "meat are much cheaper
than that of mutton or goat's meat and consequently
beef and buffalo flesh come within the reach of the
poorer peopl~ perhaps for a day or two in the week.
According to the figures given in the Report of the
Expert Committee at p. 12, in 1938 in Bombay the
prices were Rs. 0-3-9 per pound of beef, Rs. 0-2-0
per pound of buffalo flesh and Rs. 0-5-6 for mutton
·and goats' flesh. In 1950 these prices went up respec.
tively to Rs. 0-12-0, Rs. 0-11-0 and Rs. 1-3-0.
...
S.C.R.
r'
•
'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
673
The comparatively low prices of beef, and buffalo flesh~
1958
which are nearly half of that of mutton or goats' flesh, M ohtf, Hanif
is the main reason for their demand. Habit is perh aps
Qiwresh~
secondary. Learned counsel for some of the petition"
v.
ers cited the case of the boys and girls residingin The State -0f.FJihai£
boar9.ing houses attached to the Anglo-Indian schools
where the only meat which the boarding school ail.tho.-:
Das C.J:.
rities can afford to supply as part of the diet. of the
growing children is beef and that only on.a day or:tw.o
in the week. The Acts, if enforced, will prevent them
from having even this little bit of nourishment: an~·
amenity. It is true that after the partition of the
country the Muslim population has decreased and
further that some Muslims may not habitually take
beef or buffalo flesh, but even so a large section of the
poorer people belonging to the Muslim, Christian .and
Scheduled Castes communities do commme beef and
buffalo flesh. And this is not merely a matter of
amenity . or luxury but is at any rate partially, a
matter of necessity. Table VII set out at p. 32 of the
Memorandum on Human Nutrition vis-a-vis Animal
Nutrition in India recommends one ounce of meat
daily whereas the available quantity is much less and
the attainable quantity under the new plan may be
1/3 ounce or a little more. Poorer people, therefore,
who can hardly afford fruit or milk or ghee are likely
to suffer from malnutrition, if they are deprived of
even one ounce of beef or buffalo flesh which may·
sometimes be within their reach. This aspect of the
matter-must also be taken into account in assessing•
the reasonableness of the provisions of the impugned.
Acts.
The number of cattle and buffaloes not fit for breed-·
ing or working has already been set out. Further
particulars in detail are available from Appendices II
and III to the Report on the Marketing• of Cattle in
India. The figures given there show that according
to the 1951 census the total number of unsei·viceable
male cattle was 27,35,000 and that of female cattle
was 1'2,02,000. Out of these there were in Bihar
2,93,000 male and 2,42,000 female, in Madhya Pradesh,
J,24,000 male.aJJ.d 31,000 female and i? lJttar Pradesh
674
7 95 8
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1959]
1,63,000 male and 21,000 female. The unserviceable
buffaloes
in the whole of India, according to 1951 cenA-fohd. llanif
Quamhi
sus, were 7,81,000 out of which 4,66,000 were males
v.
and 3,15,000 were females. Out of the total there
The State of Bihar were in Bihar 61,000 male buffaloes and .59,000 fem;i,Je
buffaloes, in Madhya Pradesh 10,000 11111le ti.nd 5,000
Das c. f.
female, in Uttar Pradesh 16,000 male and 12,000
female. According to the Fi1°Kt Five Year Pla,11,
p. 273, the overall estimates made by the Cattle Utilisation Committee show that about 10 % of the cattle
population in India or roughly 1,14,00,000 adults were
unserviceable. or unpl'oductive. The Report of the
Cattle Preservation and Development Committee also
put the figure of old, decrepit and unproductive cattle
at 10% of the total popufation. Pandit Thakurdas
Bhargava does not accept the correctness of these
figures. It is difficult to find one's way out of the
labyrinth of figures and it will be futile for us to
attempt to come to a figure of unserviceable agricultural animals which may even be approximately correct.
For .our purpose it will suffice to say that there is a
fairly large number of cattle and buffaloes which are
not of any use for breeding or working purposes. The
position may be accepted as correctly summed up at
p. 274 of the :First Five Year Plan where it is stated,
inter alia, that there is a deficiency of good milch cows
and working bullocks and that there exists a surplus
of useless or inefficient animals.
The presence of a large number of useless and inefficient cattle in the midst of the good ones affect our
agriCultural economy in two ways. In the first placeand this is the crux of the matter-this surplus stock
is pressing upon the scanty fodder and feed resources
of the country and is an obstacle to making good the
deficit. As pointed out by the expert Committee
Report at p. o9 the greatest handicap in improving
our cattle wealth is the lack of resources in feeding
them. Any effort to improve cattle will fail unless
they are properly fed. 'fhe table set out on that very
page of that Report records a deficiency of 6,oo;oo,OOO
.tons, i. o., 33% in straw or Kadbi 10,40,00,000 tons,
i.e., 13% in gre~n fodder and 2,65,20,000 tons, i. e.,
S.C.R;
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
675
70% in concentrates (i. e., oil cakes, bran, oil seeds,
r958
maize, barley and gram, etc.). It is pointed out that Mohd. Hanif
the figures shown against green fodder are not the
Quareshi
quantities which are presently available but which
v.
can be made available if forest resources are fully The State of Biha~
tapped. According to this Report even if the forest
resources are fully utilised there will still be a deficiDas c. f.
ency of 13% in the supply. The actual availability
of this item is limited by the fact that green fodder is
only1available during the monsoon months and much
of tliis is wasted by the lack of country-wide arrangements for its conservation. The estimated requirements and the present supply of food stuffs for animals
is also given in Table V at p. 23 of the Memorandum
on Human Nutrition vis-a-vis Animal Nutrition in
India which tallies with and is more or less about the
same as those given in the Report of the Expert
Committee above referred to. Table V also shows a
deficiency of 6,00,00,000 tons of straw or Kadbi
1,78,00,000 tons of green fodder. The shortage of
concentrates, i. e., oil cakes, maize, barley, gram, cotton
seed and bran vary between 8,50,000 to 71,17,000 tons.
According to the estimate given in the First Five Year
Plan at p. 273 the quantity of fodder available is
about 75% of requirements while availablB concentrates of feeds would suffice only for about 28% of the
cattle. The figures given at p. 24 of the report of the
Gosamvardhan Enquiry Committee set up by the
Uttar Pradesh Government are interesting. The total
cattle ·and buffalo population in U ttar Pradesh is
estimated at 3,27,63,327. The scientific food requirements of this total population, according to the
Western standard, .are first set out. Then begins a·
process of scaling down, for the above scale is considered to be somewhat lavish for our low sized village
cattle. The Indian standard, according to this report,
will require much less and the figures, according to
Indian standards, are next set out. Evidently these
figures a!so show a very big gap be.tween requirements
and the available quantities'. So the report says that
even this may be reduced and what is significantly
•
..
86
676
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
described as the " critical limit " is then set out. It is
not quite intelligible why an Indian cow should not
M~:~,::,nif require even an Indian standard of ration. Be that
v.
as it may, even for the " critical limit " the quantity
The state of Bihar available is far too short. The gap between the
critical limit and what is available is respectively
Das c. J.
1,80,00,000 tons of dry matter, 15,00,000 tons of
protein and 28,61,70,00,000 therms. It is conceded
that the requirements of mixed population of
3,27,63,327 heads of animals may be taken as representing 2,71,30,000 adult units and with the present
available supply of straw, green feed and concentrates
these adult units cannot be fully fed even on the
critical limit standard. The available supply can
support only 1,59,20,000 adult units leaving 1,12,10,000
units unfed. It is recognised by this Report thii.t with
an increase in cattle population and better prophylactic treatment against contagious diseases, the trend
of population will be towards an increase and the
deficiency in nutrition will become still more pronounced. The remedy suggested is that attention be
paid urgently towards the production of more fodder
from cultivated land and utilisation of all marginal
and sub-marginal land for augmenting food and
fodder sources.
With a large population of animals in which the
majority is not yielding adequate and prompt returns
to the owners, the animals are naturally allowed to
fend for themselves and to subsist on whatever the
agriculturist is able to provide from his scanty sources
for the maintenance of his stock. Naturally, therefore, the problem of substantial precentage of uneconomical cattle has cropped up along with that of stray,
wild, old, diseased and uneconomical animals. These
old and useless animals roaming about at pleasure in
search of food are a nuisance and a source of danger in
the countryside. They grow wild and become a
menace to the crop· production. As pointed out by
the Report of the Expert Committee, the dan,ger was
actually seen by the members of that Committee in
Pepsu where, it is significant to note, the slaughter is
banned cqmpletely.
r958
S.C.R.
..
•
.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
677
The presence of a large number of old and useless
r95B
animals also has a bad effect on the quality of the Mohd. Ha,iif
breed. There is a tendency for this population to
Quareshi
multiply and bring into being progeny of a very
v.
inferior kind which is bound to adversely affect the The Slate of Bihar
production of milk or bullock power. It is absolutely
necessary that this surplus cattle should be separated
Das c. J.
from the good and robust animals and a total ban on
slaughter of cattle and buffaloes will contribute
towards worsening the present condition.
The Cattle Preservation and Development Committee set up by the Government of India in 1948 at
p. 47 of its l~eport recommended, as a panacea for the
evil menace of useless cattle, a scheme for the establishment of cattle concentration camp for the old and
useless cattle. It is this scheme which subsequently
came "to be known by the name of Gosadans. At
pp. 48 and 49 are set out the estimates of cost of
establishing and running a camp to house 2,000 cattle.
The non-recurring cost on land, cattle sheds, staff and
servants' quarters is shown at Rs. 32,000 and the
recurring cost, namely, salary of manager, stock-man,
chaukidars 1md others on the establishment together
with allowances is shown at R,s. 13,000 per year and it
is hoped that a sum of Rs. 5,000 will be derived from
the sale of hides, manure, etc. According to the
Report of the Expert Committee each Gosadhan
housing 2,000 heads of cattle would have to have
4,000 acres of land which would permit of a rotational
and controlled grazing practice and provision has to
be made for the surplus grass during the rainy season
to be preserved for the scarcity months. There should
be thatched sheds for protection of the cattle agai.nst
weather and wild animals and fodder is to be cultivated on a small part of the 4,000 acres. By the end of
1954, when the Report of the Expert Comtnittee came
to be made, the cost had gone up from what they were
in 1948 when the Cattle Preservation and Development Committee Report had been made. The estimated bost,, according to the Report of the Expert
Committee, of establishing and running of a Gosadan .
for 2,000 heads of cattle is shown as:. non-recurring
678
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
a
Rs. 50,000, and recurring Rs. 25,000 per year. On
this basis the recurring cost alone will work out
Mohd. Ha~if at Rs. 12•50 per head of cattle per annum for preservQu•:~'"'
ing useless cattle. The figures given in the GosamThe 5 101 ,' 01 Biha, vardhan Enquiry Committee's Report are interesting.
Taking the total number of catties in Uttar Pradesh
Das c. J.
not used for breeding or work at 1,83,276 in 1951, the
State will require 91 Gosadans each with a housing
capacity for 2,000 heads of cattle. Even taking one
acre per animal instead of two acres per animal as
recommended by the Expert Committee Report, 91
Gosadans will require nearly 2,00,000 acres of land.
The cost of 91 Gosadans will be non-recurring
Rs. 45,50,000 and recurring Rs. 22,75,000 per annum.
It appears from the revised model for Gosadans for
500 heads of cattle to be run by the State Governments
set out in Appendix II to the Proceedings of the F'ifth
Annual General Meeting of the Central Council of
Gosamvardhan held at New. Delhi on February 21,
1957, that the non-recurring cost will be Rs. 39,000
and the recurring running cost will be Rs. 12,000. It
is estimated that there will be an income of Rs. 2,500
from the sale of hides, etc. Allowing this, the net annual
recurring cost will be Rs. 9,500 for 500 heads of
.cattle which works out at Rs. 19 per head of cattle per
annum. As regards Gosadans to be run by private
institutions, it is said in the same Appendix II
that those institutions will be given a subsidy of Rs. 18
per head per annum out of which 75% would be
contributed by the Centre and the remaining 25% by
the State. Thus for the preservation of the useless
cattle the country will pay Rs. 19 or Rs. 18 per head
of such useless cattle per annum, whereas our total
national expenditure on education (Central and States
including local bodies) in 1955-1956 was only Rs. 4'9
per capita as against Rs. 104·6 per capita in the United
Kingdom and Rs. 223•7 per capita in the United States
of America and our target for 1957-1958 works out at
Rs. 5 per capita per annum. It will be noticed that
in none of the schemes is even a pice provided for
. fodder .• The idea evidently is that the cattle will be
left there to fend for themselves on whatever grass or
, 95
0
S.C.R.
•
•
•
•
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
679
other green foed they can 'get by grazing. If one
1958
remembers that though green fodder may be available
in the monsoon months, there will be a dearth of them MoQhd. Hanif
. t h e d ry mont h s, one w1'11 a t once see th at t.he segre.
uareshi
m
,;:
gating of the cattle in the concentration camp will The state of Bil•ar
only be to leave them to a fate of slow death. The
very idea that these animals should eke out their
Das c. J.
livelihood by grazing and that Gosadans should be
located in out of the way places, appeared to the
authors of the Memorandum on Human Nutrition
vis-a-vis Animal Nutrition at p. 47, to belie the
humanitarian considerations on the basis of which the
scheme was conceived.
Theory a.part, the Gosadan scheme has been tried
and the result is not at all encouraging. The First
:Five Year Plan, obviously as an experimental measure,
provided for the establishment of 160 Gosadans each
housing 2,000 heads of cattle, at a cost of about
Rs. 97,00,000. The Planning Commission recognised
that these measures would touch only the fringe of the
problem and the success of the movement would depend
on the amount of public support, especially from
charitable institutions that it received. The sheer
weight of the figures of expenses compelled the
Gosamvardhan.Enquiry Committee to recognise that
if the unwanted and uneconomic cows and their
progeny have to be effectively saved from slaughter,
the responsibility had to be shared by the individual,
the community and so on, for it would be utterly
impracticable to expect that the burden of collection
of such animals from villages and transporting them
to the Gosadans would be within the exclusive means
and competence of the State. That Committee
certainly expected the State to share a particular portion of the expenditure which legitimately fell in its
sphere of respon1::1ibility, but the Committee felt, and
said so in so many words, that by far the most substantial portion of the responsibility should rest on the
owners and the community itself for it was but equitable to expect that if the cow had to be really saved
from slaughter the cost on this account .should b.e
equitably borne by the people and the State. This
680
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
part of the Report of the Gosamvardhan Enquiry
Committee reads like wishful thinking and amounts to
Quamhi
only hoping for the best. When the conscience of the
v.
individual or the community did not prevent the Hindu
The State of B;ha, owner from selling his dry cow to the butcher for a
paltry sum of R.s. 30 to Rs. 40 per head, •.vhen the
Das c. J.
Hindu sentiment for the divinity and sanctity attributed to the cow has to be propped up by legislative
compulsion, when according to its own Report at p. 41
the Dharmada and Brit collected by the Hindu businessmen on each commercial transaction ostensibly
for the benefit of the cow is not made available in full
and finally when Goshalas have had to be closed down
for want of funds and public support, when the country
cannot spend more than Rs. 5 per capita per annum on
the education of the people, it seems to be somewhat
illogical and extravagant, bordering on incongntity,
to frame a scheme for establishment of Gosadans for
preserving useless cattle at a cost of Rs. 19 or Rs. 18
per head per annum and which will, for its success,
admittedly have to depend on the same elusive and
illl!sory public support or 75% subsidy from the
Central Government.
What has been the result of the experiment ?
According to the Report of the Expert Committee since
the ]'irst ]'ive Year Plan only 17 Gosadans had been
started in Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, Pepsu, Coorg, Bhopal,
Kutch, Vindhya Pradesh, Tripura and Saurashtra put
together. Not even one of these 17 establishments is
fully stocked. There are only about 5,293 animals in
these 17 Gosadans instead of 34,000. According to
the Gosamvardhan Enquiry Committee's Repo~t, only
two Gosadans had been established up to the date of
that Report in Uttar Pradesh. The Second Five Year
Plan (p. 283) shows that out of the 160 Gosadans for
which provisid'n had been made in the First ]'ive Year
Plan, only 22 Gosadans had been established. According to the Facts and ]'igures about Bihar, 1955, p. 88,
three Gosadans had been established at Berwadih,
Nirmali and Monghyr where there were about• 700
uneconom~c animals at that time instead of 6,000
which should have been there as per the estimated
capacity for .each ·Gosadan.
z95B
Mohd. Han;/
•
..
•
S.C.R.
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
681
What, in the view of the several committees, is the
r958
conclusion ? According to the Memorandum on Human Mohd. Hanif
Nutrition vis-a-vis Animal Nutrition in India, p. 4, the
Quareshi
present scheme of establishing Gosadans for segregatv.
ing old and useless animals can serve only a limited Tiie State of Bihar
purpose and if extended countrywide, it is likely to
hinder rather than help the problem of disposing of Das c. I·
the surplus animals. At p. 47 the authors of this
Memorandum appear to have felt that in advocating
the adoption of Gosadan Scheme on a countrywide
basis, sufficient consideration had not been given to its
practical aspects. It is pointed out that according to
the present estimate the total number of useless
animals is four times the number the Second ]'ive
Year Plan had estimated and that consequently
havjng regard to the huge size of our cattle population
the existing number of the useless section would remain
unchanged for many years to come and that a sum of
Rs. 3,04,00,000 will be required only for pounding such
animals. The Expert Committee's Report is quite definite and emphatic. Paragraph 133 of that Report at
p. 62 clearly expresses the opinion that Gosadans do
not offer a solution to the problem. To house and
maintain all these animals, thousands of Gosadans on
lakhs of acres of land would be needed. In addition
to the hugenon-redurring expenses, a very high recurring annual expenditure would have to be incurred.
_In view of this and in view of the indifferent response
from the States in setting up Gosadans, the Expert
Committee came to the conclusion that the Gosadan
scheme was not likely to offer any solution for the
problem of useless cattle and that it would be far more
desirable to utilise the limited resources of the country
to increase the efficiency of the useful cattle.
The Report of the Cattle Preservatioq and. Develop-·
.ment Committee did not recommend the immediate
total . ban on the slaughter of all cattle. They
recommended the establishment of concentration
camP.s, later on euphemistically called Gosadans, and
though total ban was the ultimate objective, it did not,
for the moment, prohibit the slaughter of animals over
the age of 14 years and of anin!als ?f any age·
682
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
permanently unfit for work or breeding owing to age
or
deformity. In para. 134 of the Expert Committee's
Mohd. 11an if
QuamM
Report at p. 63 it is stated clearly that the total ban
v.
on the slaughter of all cattle would not be in the best
The State of Bihar interests of the country as it is merely a negative and
not a positive approach to the problem. They consider
Das c. J.
that a constructive approach to the problem will be to
see that no useful animal is slaughtered and that the
country's resources are fully harnessed to produce
better and more efficient cattle. Neither the First Five
Year Plan nor the Second Five Year Plan accepted the
idea of a total ban on the slaughter of cattle. Indeed,
according to the Second Five Year Plan, a total ban
will help the tendency for the number of surplus cattle
to increase . and, in their view, a total ban on the
slaughter of all cows, calves and other milch iJ-nd
draught cattl" will defeat the very .object of the directive principles embodied in Art. 48 of the Constitution.
We find from para. 6 on p. 283 of the Second :Five.
Year Plan that the Gosadan scheme did not make any
real or satisfactory progress and that altogether 22
Gosadans housing only 8,000 cattle had been establish. ed by the States up to the date of that document and
even then many of the States had encountered difficulty
in securing the areas of land needed for their operations. The Planning Commission considered that it
would be impossible to establish enough of these
Gosadans and they reached the conclusion that in
defining the scope of the ban on the slaughter of cattle
the States should take a realistic view of the fodder
resources available in the country and the extent to
which they can get the co-operation of voluntary organisations to bear the main responsibility for maintaining unserviceable and unproductive cattle with a
measure of assistance from the Goverment and general
support from • the people. As already stated, the
Memorandum on Human Nutrition vis-a-vis Animal
Nutrition at p. 4 expressed the view that the Gosadan
scheme can serve only a limited purpose and, if extended countrywide, was likely to hinder rather than ·help
the problem of disposing of the surplus animals, apart
fyom the huge ini~ial cost. A large concentration of
x958
-.
•
•
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
683
useless animals within a restricted area, the authors of
z 9ss
that Memorandum feared, might lead to considerable Mohd. Hanif
soil erosion due to overgrazing and there might be
Quareshi
every possibility of contagious and parasitic diseases
v.
spreading from these animals to the surrounding area. The State of Biha~
It is only the Gosamvardan Enquiry Committee which
had recommended an immediate total ban on the
Das c. 1 ·
slaughter of all cattle, irrespective of age or sex. It
should, however, be noted that even that Committee
did not recommend such a total ban as a measure
independent of all other considerations. Its recommendation in this behalf was linked up with and was
a part of a scheme which depended, for its success, on
a variety of imponderable matters, like public enthusiasm and support for the establishment and
maintenance of Gosadans in a high state of working
efficiency, the capacity of the State to bring more lands
under cultivation, reclamation of the jungle lands and
the like. It may be noted also that although in s0me
of the States total ban has been imposed on the
slaughter of cattle, many of the States have not considered it necessary to impose such a blanket ban.
Thus the Assam Cattle Protection Act, 1950, the
Bombay Animal Preservation Act, 1948, the West
Bengal Animal Slaughter Control Act, 1950, the
Hyderabad Slaughter of Animal Act, 1950, the
Travancore-Cochin Notification permit slaughter of
cattle and buffaloes over specified years of age. Even
the Madhya Pradesh Act, as originally enacted, did
not place a total ban on the slaughter of all cattle.
In earlier times there being enough of pastures and
smaller human and cattle population and restricted
needs, it was possible to rear large and valuable herds
and organise a system of balanced economy as far as
agricultural development was concerned. Thus, while
the country was producing enough grain for the
requirement of the human population there was an
adequate area available for plentiful . grazing of
animals, which, supplemented by fodder available from
agricul'tural production, assisted in developing the
types of quality animals required for the needs of the.
87
684
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
times and the area in question (Report of the
Gosamvardhan Enquiry Committee). The position has
Mohd. Ha1lif
considerably changed since then. There has been a
Quareshi
v.
large increase in human population and famines and
The State of Biharepidemics having been largely brought under control,
there has been an increase in the animal population
D•s c. J.
also. Already there is a competition between man and
the animal for the available land. The growing human
population needs more food for which more land is
required. The refugee problem has yet to be solved
and sufficient land has to be found for settling the
refugees therein. With organised facilities for artificial fertilisers and the introduction of scientific
methods of cultivation agricultural production is
expected to increase and the problem of food for
human consumption may be capable of a satisfactory
solution. But as regards the cattle feed the gap between the requirement and the available quantities is
so wide that there is little possibility, in any foreseeable future, of the country producing enough to feed
them adequately.
To summarise: The country is in short supply of
milch cattle, breeding bulls and working bullocks. If
the nation is to maintain itself in health and nourishment andget adequate food, our cattle must be improved. In order to achieve this objective our cattle
population fit for breeding and work must be properly
fed and whatever cattle food is now at our disposal
and whatever more we can produce must be made
available to the useful cattle which are in presenti or
will infuturo be capable of yielding milk or doing
work. The maintenance of useless cattle involves a
wasteful drain on the nation's cattle feed. To maintain them is to deprive the useful cattle of the much
needed nourishment. The presence of so many useless
animals tends to deteriorate the breed. Total ban on
the slaughter of cattle, useful or otherwise, is calculated to bring about a serious dislocation, though not a
complete stoppage, of the business of a considerable
section of the people who are by occupation btrtchers
.(Ka.sais),. hide merchants and so on. Such a ban will
also deprive a l~rge section of the people of what niay
I95B
•
S.C.R.
•
"
.J
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
685
be their staple fooQ.. At any rate, they will have to
r958
forego the little protein food which may be within
their means to take once or twice in the week. Preser- Mohd.
Hanif
Quareshi
vation of useless cattle by establishment of Gosadans
v.
is not, for reasons already indicated, a practical pro- The State of Bihar
position. Preservation of these useless animals by
sending them to concentration camps to fend for
Das c. J.
themselves is to leave them to a process of slow death
and does no good to them. On the contrary, it hurts
the best interests of the nation in that the useless
cattle deprive the useful ones of a good part of the
cattle food, deteriorate the breed and eventually affect
the production of milk and breeding bulls and working
bullocks, besides involving an enormous expense
which could be better utilised for more urgent national
need§.
We are not unmindful of the fact that beef and
buffalo flesh from calves under one year of age, heifers
and young castrated stock yielding meat of a superior
quality fetch comparatively higher prices in the
market and, therefore, the tendency of the butchers
naturally is to slaughter young calves. This circumstance clearly warns us that calves, heifers and young
castrated stock (cattle and buffalo) which will in future
supply us milk and power for purposes of agriculture
require protection. We also do not fail to bear in
mind that for very good and cogent reasons cows also
require protection. Cows give us milk and her progeny
for future service. Unfortunately, however, the average
milk yield of a cow, as already stated, is very much
less than that of a she-buffalo. As the Gosamvardhan
Enquiry Committee's Report points out, despite all the
veneration professed for the cow, when it comes to the
question of feeding, the she-buffalo always receives
favoured treatment and the cow has to be satisfied with
whatever remains after feeding ,the she-buffaloes,
bullocks, and calves in order of priority. The growth
of cities and heavy demand for milk in the urban areas
have contributed to the slaughter of good stock. For
want of space no freshly calved animal can be brought
in without getting rid of one that had gvne dry. ·
Salvage facilities·not being available ~r, if available,
686
'95 8
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
being uneconomical, the professional gowalas, who are
mostly, if not wholly, Hindus, find it uneconomical to
Mohd. Hanif
QHareshi
maintain the cow a f ter sh e goes d ry and consequent1y
v.
sell her to the butcher for slaughter at Hs. 30 to Hs. 50
Tl" State of Bihar per head, irrespective of her age and potential productivity, and import a fresh cow. The veneration pro.
Das c. f.
fessed for the sanctity attached to the cow does not
i)revent them from doing so. In big towns the municipal regulations are stringent and slaughter is permitted only of unserviceable and unproductive animals.
Instances are not uncommon, however, that to get an
animal passed for slaughter, the teeth or the rings
round the horns of the animal are tampered with and
sometimes a cow is even maimed in order that she may
be passed by the veterinary inspector as fit for
slaughter. Cows, which are rejected by the insp¥ctor,
are taken out of the limits of the cities and slaughtered
in the rural areas. As slaughter is not confined to
registered slaughter houses, the number of useful
animals which are slaughtered cannot be given accurately. It is estimated in the Heport of the Expert
Committee at p. 2 that at least 50,000 high yielding
cows and she-buffaloes from cities of Bombay, Calcutta
and Madras alone are sent annually for permature
slaughter and are lost to the country. The causes
of slaughter of useful cattle are enumerated at pp. 2, 3,
and 9 of that Heport, namely, lack of space in the
cities and suburban areas, long dry period, want of
arrangement for breeding bulls at the proper time, the
anxiety to get as much milk out of the cow as possible,
the high cost of maintenance of cows in the cities and
the difficulties in the matter of obtaining adequate
fodder. For these reasons many animals are sent to
the slaughter houses through sheer economic pressure
and are re2laced by fresh animals imported from
breeding areas. T4e danger of such premature slaughter is greater for the cow, for being an animal with a
scanty yield of milk it does not pay the owner to
maintain her through the long dry period and hence
there is an inducement for adopting even crue! prac.tices to get her passed by the inspectors. But a dry
she-buffalo is well worth preserving and maintaining
S.C.R.
t
I
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
687
in expectation of rich return at the next lactation.
r958
Besides, buffaloes for slaughter will not fetch as Mohd. Hanif
good a price as cows would do. Likewise there will
Quareshi
not be much inducement to the agriculturist or other
v.
owner to part with the breeding bulls or working Tlte State of Bihar
bullocks (cattle and buffalo) as long as they are serviceable. For their sheer usefulness and their high market
Das c. f ·
value as breeding or working animals the breeding
bulls and working bullocks, as long as they are fit, are,
.to the agriculturists, worth more than the price of
their flesh in gold. There can hardly be any inducement for maiming valuable animals which, as breeding
bulls or working animals, can at any time fetch from
. the agriculturists a price higher than what the maimed
ones will fetch from the butchers. The breeding bulls
and working bullocks (cattle and buffaloes) do not,
theretore, require as much protection as cows and
calves do.
The next question is as to what should be the scope
of the ban on the slaughter of animals. One view is
that the slaughter of all animals (cattle and buffaloes)
of all categories should be regulated by the State and
that animals below a specified age or not suffering
from some natural deformity should not be allowed to
be slaughtered. Drastic and stringent ·regulations
have been imposed by municipal laws and have been
tried but experience shows that they are not sufficient
at least to protect the cow. It has been found to be
extremely difficult to enforce the regulations for inadequacy of staff and veterinary inspectors, little or no
check on the veterinary inspectors who succumb to
the pressure or inducements of the butchers and pass
animals not really useless as and for useless and aged
animals. A large percentage of the animals not fit for
slaughter are slaughtered surreptitiousl.Y. outside the
municipal limits. For reasons of economy rapacious
gowalas or callous agriculturists find it uneconomical
to maintain the dry cow and even resort to cruel
practices and maim the cow in order to get her passed
for sl~ughter. As already stated, the she-buffalo
and the breeding bulls and working bullocks (both · •
cattle and buffaloes) for their valu~, pr~sent and
688
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
future, do not run 'the same amou1it of danger as a dry
cow does. Regulation of slaughter of animals above
Mohd. Hanif
Quareshi
a specified age may not be quite adequate protection
v.
for the cow but may be quite sufficient for the breedTh• State of Bihar ing bulls and working bullocks and the she-buffaloes.
These considerations induce us to make an exception
Das c. J.
even in favour of the old and decrepit cows. The
counsel for the petitioners, be it said to their credit,
did not contend otherwise.
After giving our most careful and anxious consideration to the pros and cons of the problem as indicated
and discussed above and keeping in view the presumption in favour of the validity of the legislation and
without any the least disrespect to the opinions of the
legislatures concerned we feel that in discharging the
ultimate responsibility cast on us by the Consti~ution
we must approach and analyse the problem in an
objective and realistic manner and then make our
pronouncement on the reasonableness of the restrictions imposed by the impugned enactments. So
approaching and analysing the problem, we have
reached the conclusion (i) that a total ban on the
slaughter of cows of all ages and calves of cows and
calves of she-buffaloes, male and female, is quite
reasonable and valid and is in consonance with the
directive principles laid down in Art. 48, (ii) that a
total ban on the slaughter of she-buffaloes or breeding
bulls or working bullocks (cattle as well as buffaloes)
as long as they are as milch or draught cattle is also
reasonable and valid and (iii) that a total ban on the
slaughter of she- buffaloes, bulls and bullocks (cattle or
buffalo) after they cease to be capable of yielding milk
or of breeding or working as draught animals cannot
be supported as reasonable in the interest of the
general pu bli&W e now proceed to test each of the impugned Acts
in the light of the aforesaid conclusions we have
arrived at. The Bihar Act, in so far as it prohibits
the slaughter of cows of all ages and calves of cows
and calves of buffaloes, male and female, is va!ia. The
'.Bihar Ac't makes no distinction between she- buffaloes,
bulls and J;mllooks (cattle and buffaloes) which are
'958
S.C.R.
•
,,.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
689
useful as milch or breeding or draught animals and
r958
those which are not and indiscriminately prohibits Mohd. Hanif
slaughter of she-buffaloes, b u11s and b uIIocks (cattI e
Quareshi
and buffalo) irrespective of their age or usefulness. In
v.
our view the ban on slaughter of she-buffaloes, breed- The State of Bihar
ing bulls and working bullocks (cattle and buffalo)
Das c. J.
which are useful is reasonable but of those which are
not useful is not valid. The question as to when a
she-buffalo, breeding bull or working bullock (cattle
and buffalo) ceases to be useful and· becomes useless
and unserviceable is a matter for legislative determination. There is no provision in the Bihar Act in
that behalf. Nor has our attention been drawn to
any rule which may throw any light on the point. It
is, therefore, not possible to apply the doctrine of
severability and uphold the ban on the slaughter of
she-b"uffaloes, breeding bulls and working bullocks
(cattle and buffalo) which are useful as milch or breeding or working animals and strike down the ban on
the slaughter of those which are useless. The entire
provision banning the slaughter of she-buffaloes, breeding bulls, and working bullocks (cattle and buffalo) has,
therefore, to be struck down. The result is that we
uphold and declare that the Bihar Act in so far as it
prohibits the slaughter of cows of all ages .and calves
of cows and calves of buffaloes, male and female, is
constitutionally valid and we hold that, in so far as it
totally prohibits the slaughter of she-buffaloes, breeding bulls and working bullocks (cattle and buffalo),
without prescribing any test or requirement as to
their age or usefulness, it infringes the rights of the
petitioners under Art. 19 (1) (g) and is to that extent
void.
As regards the U. P. Act we uphold and declare, for
reasons already stated, that it is constitutionally valid
in so far as it prohibits the slaughter Of cows of all
ages and calves of cows, male and female, but we hold
that in so far as it purports to totally prohibit the
slaughter of breeding bulls and working bullocks
without prescribing any test or requirement as to their
age or usefulness, it offends against Art. 19 (1) (g) and.
is to that extent void.
690
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1959]
As regards the Madhya Pradesh Act we likewise
that it is constitutionally valid in so far as it
declare
Mnhd. Hanij
Quareshi
prohibits the slaughter of cows of all ages and calves
v.
of cows, male and female, but that it is void in so far
The State of Biha• as it totally prohibits the slaughter of breeding bulls
and working bullocks without prescribing any test or
Da' c. J.
requirement as to their age or usefulness. W c also
hold that the Act is valid in so far as it regulates the
slaughter of other animals under certificates granted
by the authorities mentioned therein.
In the premises we direct the respondent States not
to enforce their respective Acts in so far as they have
just been declared voitl by us. The parties will bear
and pay their own costs of these applications.
z958
~
'
Petitions partly allowed .
•
BADRIDAS DAGA
April :15.
v.
THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX
(VENKATARAMA AIYAR, GAJENDRAGADKAR and
A. K. SARKAR JJ.)
Income Tax-Deduction-Misappropriation by employee-Loss
incidental to the conduct of the business--Indian Income-tax Act,
I922 (II of I922), s. IO(I), (z)(xi), (z)(xv).
The appellant engaged an agent for the purposes of carrying
on his business and conferred on him large powers of manage~
ment including authority to operate on bank accounts. While
acting under such authority the agent \vithdrew moneys from
the bank and used them for the discharge of his personal debts.
The appellant was able to recover from the agent only a parl of
the amount misappropriated by him, and the balance had to be
written off at the end of the accounting year as irrecoverable.
The question ~as \vhether the amount which was misappropriated and found~·irrecoverable was allowable as a deduction under
the Indian Income-tax Act in determining the profits of the
appellant:
Held, that the amount in question is not allowable either as
a bad debt under s. 10(2)(xi) or as a business expenditute under
. s. 10(2)(x") of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922. It can, however,
be deducted in computing the profits of the appellant under
•
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org