AMAR SINGH versus CUSTODIAN, EVACUEE PROPERTY, PUNJAB
Supreme Court of India | Decided 29 March 1957 | [1957] 1 S.C.R. 801 | 1957 INSC 28
Key facts
- Decided
- 29 March 1957
- Bench
- NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI*, B. JAGANNADHADAS, SYED JAFFER IMAM, P. GOVINDA MENON, J.L. KAPUR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 351/1954
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1957] 1 S.C.R. 801
- Neutral citation
- 1957 INSC 28
Text of the judgment
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
801
AMAR SINGH
v.
CUSTODIAN, EVACUEE PROPERTY, PUNJAB
(BHAGWATI, jAGANNADHADAs, jAFER IMAM, GovINDA
·
MENON and ]. L. KAPUR JJ.)
Evacuee
property-Allotment-Displaced
land-holders-Quasi"
permanent
allotment-Cancellation-Violation
of
Fundamental
Rights-Constitution of India, Arts. 19(1)(f), 31(1), 31(2)-Administration ef Ev!lcuee Property Act, 1950 (XXXI of 1950).
The petitioners, who were displaced persons from Pakistan
owning land therein, were also co_-sharers in a joint khata owned by
some evacuees in a suburban village in East Punjab. On their
displacement they were in the first instance temporarily allotted
agricultural land in that village. Subsequently, a.s a result of the
readjustment of allotments of the suburban land amongst the
various groups who had quasi-permanent allotments therein,
which had to be carried out according to certain rules and instructions, the allotments of the petitioners were cancelled. The case
of the petitioners was that the allotment to them was on a quasipermanent basis and that, therefore, they had acquired certain
rights in the land which constituted property, and they contended
that the order cancelling the allotment was in violation of their
fundamental rights to property under Arts. 19(1)(f), 31 (1) and 31 (2)
of the Constitution of India. Though the petitioners were allottees
of agricultural land on the basis of a quasi-permanent allotment
it was admitted that they were not able to get a sanad under the
rules for the lands originally allotted to them, when only they
could obtain permanent property in the land. It was not disputed
that the cancellation of the allotment was under the purported
exercise of powers under the provisions of the Administration of
Evacuee Property Act, 1950, and the rules framed thereunder
taken with some executive instructions.
Held, that the interest of a quao;i-permanent allottee does not
constitute 'property' within the meaning of Arts. 19(1)(f), 31(1) or
31 (2) of the Constitution of India, and accordingly the orders
cancelling the allotments could not amount to violation of fundamental rights under those Articles.
The basic features of the interest of a quasi-permanent
allottee ·are that the ultimate ownership of the land is still
recognised to be that of the evacuee and the allotment itself is
l~ble to resumpt!o? or ~ancellation with reference to the exigencies of the adm1mstration of evacuee law. The interest
so
"recognised is, in its essential concept, provisional though with a
view to stabilisation and ultimate permanence. An interest in
land owned by another in such a situation cannot be fitted into
any concept of property in itself.
1957
March 290
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1957
Amar Siffl~
v.
Custr.Jian, ECJ(Jcutt
Prop<rty, Ptajab.
. Julius v. Lord Bishop of Oxford, (188o) 5 A.C. 214, distinguished.
Property in order that it may fall within the scope of A1t.
19( 1)(f) must be capable of being the subject matter of "acquisition
and disposal". But tJ:ie interest of a quasi-permanent allottee
arises by statutory grant to a person of a specified class and is not
capable of being acquired by an ordinary citizen in any of the
normal modes. Nor is it capable of b6ng disposed of by the
allottee himself by way of sale, mortgage, gift or will.
Consequently, Art. 19(1)(f) cannot apply to the case.
In order that Art . 31 ( 1) may apply it is not enough that there
is deprivation, but such deprivation must be \\-·ithout the authority
of law. In the present case the quasi-permanent allotments of
the petitioners were cancelled in enforcement of a right
of
resumption or cancellation which is an incident of such property,
and hence the Article has not been infringed.
The interest of a quasi-permanent allottee cannot ho brought
within the scope of Art. 31(2) as it stood prior to the an1endment.
The words "taking possession" or "acquisition" there are in~.ppro
priate in respect of the rights which constitute quasi-permanent
tt"nurc.
In vie\v of the word "deemrd" occurring in Art. 31 (2A) it
appears likely that the amendment to Art. 31(2) was inlenrled to
be retrospective, but even then the amended Article taken w~th
Art. 31 (2A) is equally inapplicable as it contemplates acquisition
or requisitioning (and taking possession) as a result of transfer of
the ownership or of the right to possession.
Suraj Parkash Kapur v.
The State of Pu,Yab, (1957) LIX
P.L.R. 103, in so far as it purported to t:ecide that the interest in
the land allotted to a quasi-permanent allottee constitutes
"property" which attracts the protection of fundamental rights
under the Constitution, is disapproved.
Thc·ugh a quasi-permanent allotm~nt does not carry with it
a fundamental right to property under tl:e Constitution, the
rights of the allottee as recognised in the statutory rules
are
important and constitute the essential basis of a satisfactory
rehabilitation and settlement of displaced land-holders. Until
such time as the land-holders obtain sanads to the lands, these
rights are entitled to zealous protection of the constituted authorities according to administrative rules and instructions binding on
them and of the courts by appropriate proceed~ngs where there is
uswpation of jurisdiction or abuse of exercise of statuto1 y po\\o·ers.
ORIGINAL juRISDICTION : Petition No. 351 of 1954.
Petition under Article 32 of the Constitution for the
t>nforcement of fundamental rights.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
N. S. Bindra, Udhai Bhan Choudhury and Gopal
Singh, for the petitioners.
S. L. Pandhi and K. L. Mehta, for the Intervener.
1957
Amar Singh
CustodU.:; Evacwe
Prop111Y, Punjab.
1957, March 29. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
JagannmDwdasJ.
JAGANNADHADAS J.-This is an application under
Art. 32 of the Constitution by the petitioners, Amar
Singh and four others, in the following circumstances.
All these five are displaced persons who owned land in
the non-suburban village of Chak. No. 159-RB, Tahsil
Jaranwala, District Lyallpur in Pakistan. They were
also co-sharers in a joint khata owned by some evacuees
in village Sultanwind, a suburb of Amritsar in East
Punjab. On their displacement, they were in the first
instance temporarily allotted agricultural land
in
Sultanwind. Having regard to their original position
in the village, they were allotted in the year
1949 a
total area of 38 standard acres and 13 units of agriThis allotment had to
be
cultural land therein.
disturbed under the following circumstances. The
Director-General of Relief and Rehabilitation (Additional Custodian) directed by an order dated January
7, 1950, that out of the 1,263 standard acres and
1£ units of suburban land of Amritsar, 142 standard
acres and 5 units were to be allotted to allottees of
Provincial Gardens. This necessitated readjustment
of allotments of the suburban land of Sultanwind
amongst the various groups who had quasi-permanent
allotment therein. As a result of this readjustment
which had to be carried out according to certain rules
and instructions the allotment of these five petitioners
(as also of some others) was proposed for cancellation
by the order of the Deputy Custodian, Amritsar, dated
July 31, 1951. This proposal was approved by the
Custodian (Financial Commissioner, Relief and Rehabilitation) on February 6, 1952, and the 1allotment was
cancelled. The proposal and the order of cancellation
are said to have been passed without notice to the
petitioners. Being aggrieved thereby they moved the
Custodian-General of Evacuee Property for revision
thereof under s. 27 of the Administration of Evacuee
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1957
Amar Singh
v.
Custodiun, Evacuee
Proptr!J, Punjab.
JagannadhadrM J.
Property Act, 1950 (XXXI of 1950). This was dealt
with by the Deputy Custodian-Genera] who dismissed
the same by a fairly elaborate order dated May 1, 1954,
after hearing the parties. The petitioners have come
up to this Court by this application under Art. 32 of
the Constitution.
The case of the petitioners is that the allotment to
them was on quasi-permanent basis and that, therefore,
they have acquired certain rights in the lands which
constitute 'property'. They urge that the order of the
Custodian cancelling the allotment and that of the
Deputy Custodian-General affirming the same are in
violation of their fundamental rights to property under
Arts. 19(1)(f), 31(1) and 31(2) of the Constitution.
They accordingly contend that they are entitled to have
these orders quashed and their rights to property
declared and protected. That the petitioners are
allottees of agricultural land on the basis of what has
come to be known as quasi-permanent allotment is not
disputed. It is
also not disputed that cancellation
thereof was under the purported exercise of powers
vested in the Custodian under certain provisions of the
Administration of Evacuee Property Act, 1950 (XXXI
of 1950) and the rules framed thereunder taken with
some executive instructions. It may be mentioned that
the term "quasi-permanent allotment" appears to be a
term which has come into vogue in later statutory rules
and has at no time been specifica!Iy defined, though it
appears to be now fairly well-understood. The two
substantial questions that arise, therefore, for consideration are ( 1) whether the rights of a quasi-permanent
allot tee constitute property within the meaning of the
articles above referred to, and (2) whether the orders
of the Custodian and Deputy Custodian-General cancelling the quasi-permanent allotment amount
to
violation of fundamental rights contemplated by the
above articles. Both these questions require a review
of the Evac.uee Property Law in so far as it relates to
the allotment of agricultural lands of the evacuees to
displaced !and-holders and an appreciation of the
background of the circumstances that necessitated it.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
805
1957
The Declaration of Independence and the partition of
India into Pakistan and India on August r 5, r 94 7, was
Amar Singh
accompanied by mass migrations of Non-Muslims from Custodian,v. Ev(l(,uee
West Punjab to East Punjab and of Muslims from Proper(Y, Punjab.
East Punjab to West Punjab. These mass migrations
were on a stupendous scale. About five million persons Jagannadhadas ].
are said to have moved from each side to the other.
This was done in a state of panic generated by
communal riots. Migrants from West Punjab reached
East Punjab almost destitute. This unprecedented
situation brought in its train gigantic problems of
administration relating to rehabilitation and resettlement of these persons. One of such problems was that
relating to agricultural immovable property left on
either side by the migrants. For purposes of convenience
persons who crossed over from East Punjab to '\'est
Punjab are referred to as evacuees and persons who
came over from West Punjab to East Punjab are referred
to as displaced persons. The displaced persons are said
to have left in Pakistan lands of the extent of about 67
l,akh acres. The evacuees seem to have left in East
Punjab and Pepsu, lands of the extent of about 47 lakh
acre'. This meant a deficit of over 20 lakh acres for
resettlement.
It would appear that in the earlier stages there were
attempts to settle the question by way of mutual
exchanges either in iPdividually or at the govermental
level and by means of inter-dominion conferences bet.ween India and Pakistan. But for one reason or other,
these attempts appear to have failed. The various :.teps
and administrative measures taken to settle
the displaced agricultural population who came over from
West Punjab, on the hurriedly abandoned lands of the
evacuees from East Punjab, are to be found described
in the Land Resettlement Manual by Shri Tarlok Singh
who was the Director-General of Relief and Rehabilitation (hereinfter referred to as the Resettlement
Manual). In Dunichand Hakim v. Deputy Commissioner
(Deputy Custodian, Evacuee Property), Karnal (1 ), this
book has been referred to by this Court as having the
stamp of authority. It can be usefully referred to not
(t) [1954] S. C.R. 578.
806
1957
Amtu Singh·
v.
Custodian, Evactltt
Property, Purg"ab.
Jagannadhadas].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1 957
necessarily as an authority for every statement of fact
or law contained therein but as a guide to appreciate
the background of the problems which the administration had to face in that unprecedented situation,
how the administration attempted to solve the same,
what were the rules and practice which the administration normally followed and considered binding on
itself, and what ideas inspired the course of legislation
in this behalf. It appears therefrom that within about
a month after the partition of India, the Government
had to take an emergency decision to allot evacuee
lands to groups of displaced persons on temporary
basis. But this was found not to satisfy the displaced
landholders. There was insistent pressure from them
for such allotment as would enable them to settle on
the lands of the evacuees on a permanent basis. This
led to the abandonment of the policy of temporary
allotments and the introduction of a system of allotment which came to be known as quasi-permanent
allotment. This policy was announced by the Government of East Punjab in its Press Communique date.cl
February 7, 1948, which is reproduced at pages 28
and 29 of the Resettlement Manual. The following
extract therefrom is instructive :
"The East Punjab Government propose to replace
the present system of temporary allotments of evacuee
lands by a new system of allotments which will take
account of the holdings of evacuees in ',yest Punjab.
The new allotments will not confer rights of ownership
or permanent occupancy, but the possession of allotted
will be maintained. Claims of allottees will be dealt
with in accordance with decisions reached eventually
regarding the treatment of evacuee property.
In the new scheme of allotments, land will be
allotted only to those who, in West Punjab, were
owners, occupancy tenants under the Punjab Tenancy
Act, and tenants under the Colonization of Government Lands Act and to certain other classes of grantees
and holders of land in West Punjab to be specified by
Government. It is proposed to give to small holders
allotments of equivalent areas, while in the case of
larger holders there will be graded cuts. The definition
'
'·
I
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
of the "Small Holders" and the details of the graded
1957
cuts will be determined when detailed information
Amar Singh
regarding the available areas in East Punjab and the
v.
EvatU•
East Punjab States, the areas held by the population Custodian,
Properly, Punjab.
to be settled in East Punjab and the East Punjab States,
Jagannadhadas J
and other relevant information becomes available.
It is intended to complete the new
system of
allotments in the East Punjab and the East Punjab
States, not later than the 31st May, 1948. Government
are, however, anxious to introduce the new scheme as
early as may 'be feasible and steps to this end will be
taken at once.
Arrangements for collecting complete information
regarding the land available for allotment in East
Punjab and the East Punjab States and the land
abandoned by individual evacuees will be taken in
hand without delay and it is hoped also to make
arrangements on a reciprocal basis to secure information from records ofrights in \'\'est Punjab.
To ensure accurate information an Ordinance will
shortly be promulgated prescribing punishment for
false information regarding claims to land and action
by way of forfeiture and otherwise in respect of
allotments taken on false information. Claims to
land will be invited on a form to be prescribed by
Government.
Until the new system of allotments can be
introduced, the present system of allotments will
continue and allotments made to the present holders
will be maintained subject to a complete scrutiny of
ex1stmg allotments, cancellation of unauthorised and
excessive allotments, dispossession from illicit occupation and such other adjustments as may be necessary
including adjustments in the unit of allotment decided
upon by Government."
To facilitate the process of resettling the displaced
persons on evacuated land on this new basis of allotment various steps became necessary. They are roughly
the following.
1. Registration and verification of land claims.
2.
Assessment and valuation of such claims.
808
1957
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(I 95 7}
3. Classification of the villages and of lands of
evacuees available for allotment.
4. Allocation of the claims to various areas with
Custodian, Evacuee
reference to such classification.
Property, Punjab,
5. Allotment of lands to individuals with reference
Jagannadhadas J.
to the valuation of their claims, guided by various
considerations, priorities and preferences and so forth
administrati\"elv determined.
The basic 'idea which inspired and regulated these
measures was that the displaced landholder is to be
allotted (subject to graded cuts) such lal!ds out of the
evacuee agricultural Lrnd which, in its extent, quality
and other rdc1·ant features, bear some reasonable
relation and correspondence to the lands left by him
in \\'est Punjab. All these steps involved very elaborate administrati1·e measures as indicated above. \ \' e
are concerned in this context to trace the lcg;islation
which brought about these steps and to examine
whether and to what extent such legislation recognised
property rights in the displaced land-holders. But
before tracing the legislative measures which brought
about the quasi-permanent allotments of evacuee lands
in favour of displaced land-holders from \\'est Punjab,
it will be convenient to have a brief survey of the
present Jaw in its aprlication to administration of
evacuee property of all kinds in general with the
history of such of the provisions therein as arc relevant
for. our purpose and then to consider the rekv<mt
legislati1·e measures taken specifically with reference
to agricultural land.
The earliest legislative measure in this behalf i; the
East Punjab Evacuees' (Administration of Property)
Ordinance, 1947, (E.P. Ordinance IV of 1947) dated
Sertember 14, 1947, which was a simple measure
defining- the terms 'evacuee', 'evacuee property', and
'Custodian of evacuee property' and other terms, and
authorising the appointment of a Custodian. It gave
the Custodian power to take possession of evacuee
property and to take all measures necessary and
expedient for preserving such property. It vested in
him extensive powers of management thereof. This
was an emergency measure which appears to have
Amar Singh
v.
S.C.R.
SUPREi\1E COURT REPORTS
809
been meant to get possession of the properties as a
1957
care-taker. This was superseded and followed by a
Amar Si11gh
series of legislative measures which underwent modifi'" Evacuee
cations from time to time. These legislati\'e measures Custodian,
Proper!)'. Punjab.
were in the first instance Provincial, ~i·i:;.., East Punjab
Evacuees' (Administration of Property) Act, 1g47 Ja.r;annadhada~ ].
(E.P. XIV of 1947) ; East Punjab £,·acuees' (Administration of Propert\') (Second Amendment) Ordinance,
19.1B (E.P. Ordinance XVI of 1948) ; East Punjab
E\·acuees' (Administration of Property) (Second Amendment) Act, 1948 (E.P. XLIX of 1948 ) ; and East
Punjab Evacuee Property (Administration) Ordinance,
1949 (E.P. Ordinance IX of 1949). These Provincial
measures were repealed and superseded by Central
legislation, viz.,
:\clrninistration of Evacuee Property
Ordinance, 1949 1,0rdinancc XX.VII of 1949) amended
by the Administration of E\'acuee Property (Amendment) Ordinance 19'.)0 :Ordinance IV of 1950). These
were repealed and superseded by the Administration
of Evacuee Property Act, 19,50 \XXXI of 1950).
The main prm is ions of Central Act XXXI of 1950,
\\·hich, \\·ith some modifications, is at present in force,
may now be noticed so far as they arc relevant.
U ndcr ss. 5 and 6 of the Act an administrative machincn· consisting of Custodians, Additional, Deputy and
Assistant Custodians of EYan1cc Property,. is set up
for each State by the State Gm·crnment thereof. Tltey
are under the general superintendence and control of
a Custodian-General appointed by the Central-Government \\·ho has, for his assistance, Deputy and Assistant
Custodian-Generals, who are also appointed by the
Central Government. The terms 'evacuee' and
'eYacuee property' arc defined in s. 2ld) and (f) and
the Custodian is gi,-cn power to determine and notify
e\'acuec property under s. 7. :\II property declared
as 'evacuee property'. becomes yested in the Custodian
under s. 8. The Custodian has under s. 9 the power
to take possession of all the 'evacuee property' so
vested in him. Section· 1 o enumerates the powers and
810
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
duties of the Custodian generally and declares that he
may
take such measures as he considers necessary or
Amar Singh
v.
expedient for the purposes of securing, administering,
Custodian, Evocue1
Property, Punjab. preserving and managing any evacuee property and
generally for the purposes of enabling him satisfactorily
JagannadhadlU J. to discharge any of the duties imposed on him by or
under the Act, and may, for any such purpose as aforesaid, do all acts and incur all expenses necessary or
incidental thereto. One of the duties laid on the
Custodian is the maintenance of accounts under s. 15.
Section 15( 1) says that the Custodian shall maintain a
separate account of the property of such evacuee,
possession whereof has been taken by him, and shall
cause to be made therein entries of all receipts and
expenditure in respect thereof. Section 16 provides
for restoration of property to the evacuee on his application and enjoins the Custodian to furnish the evacuee
on demand with a statement containing an abstract of
the account of the income received and expenditure
incurred in respect of the property. The general
powers of management vested in the Custodian under
s. 10 enable him to grant leases and make allotments
out of evacuee property in favour of displaced landholders. This is subject to the power vested in him
under s. 12(1) to vary or cancel leases or allotments
of evacuee property. There are a number of other
substantive and incidental provisions, which it is
unnecessary to refer to for the purposes of this petition.
Thus, the broad features of the administration of
evacuee property law, as indicated from the provisions
above noticed, are the following :
1.
All evacuee property is vested in. the Custodian.
2.
He .has the duty of managing the property
and maintaining accounts for such management and
has large adn:iinistrative powers.
3. As incidental to ·such management he can
grant leases and make allotments.
4. He has the power to vary or cancel leases and
allotments.
1957
S.C.R.
SUPREME dOURT REPORTS
8r l
1957
5. The evacuee can come forward and apply for
return of the evacuee property and such property is
Amar Singh
liable to be restored to him.
v.
Custodian, Evacuee
6. The Custodian, presumably on such restora- Properry, Punjab.
tion, has to furnish to the evacuee on demand a Jagannadhadas J.
statement containing an abstract of the account of the
income received and expenditure incurred in respect of
the property.
In addition to large administrative functions for
the purposes of the Act, the Custodian has. also the
function of deciding various matters of a quasi-judicial
nature, such as (r) whether a person is. an evacuee or
whether certain property is evacuee property ; (2)
whether a transfer of evacuee property is or is not to be
confirmed ; (3) whether a lease or an allotment is or
is not to be cancelled or varied ; anrl (4) whether
property is to be restored to the evacuee and so forth.
The actions of the Custodian and his subordinates in
exercise of their administrative .as well as of quasijudicial functions are subject to appeal and revision by
the higher authorities under the Act as provided under
ss. 24 to 27. Section 28 provides that orders made
under the above sections shall be final and shall not be
called in question in any original suit, application or
execution proceeding. Section 46 bars the jurisdiction
of the civil or revenue courts in respect of any matter
which the Custodian-General or the Custodian is
empowered by or under the Act to determine.
The history of some of the above statutory provi- ·
sions as traceable from the corresponding provisions
of the earlier legislation is significant. The provision
vesting· evacuee property in the Custodian was not
enacted in the earlier East Punjab Ordinance IV of
r 94 7. But it was enacted by the next legislative
measure, East Punjab Act XIV of 1947, which declared
the vesting of evacuee property, and provided that the
property "shall continue to be so vested until
the
Provincial Government by notification otherwise
directs." This last clause was substituted in 1948 by
an Amending Act, by the clause "until it }s returned
to the owner in accordance with the provisions of
812
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 195 7]
section 12". This clause as to the duration of such
vesting was omitted in the later Central legislation and
Amar Singh
was
substituted by the phrase "shall continue to so
v.
Cwtodian, Evat:JUe vest".
(See Central Ordinance XXVII of 1949 and
l+opmy, Pu'!l"ab.
Central Act XXXI of 1950). The earliest provision
Jagannadhadas ]. for return of evacuee property to the evacuee is in
East Punjab Ordinance IV of 1947. Section 12 thereof
provided that the owner of any property in the possession or control of the Custodian shall be entitled to
restoration thereof upon application to the Custodian
and on payment of excess, if any, of expenditure over
receipts from the management of such property by the
Custodian. In East Punjab Act XIV of 1947 which
superseded this Ordinance, this right of restoration to
the evacuee was qualified by virtue of s. 12 ( 1) thereof
which is as follows :
1957
"On being satisfied that evacuees have returned
or are returning to the Province, the Provincial
Government may by notification in the Official Gazette
authorise return of their immovable property to the
owners in accordance with this section."
Sub-section (2) of s. 12 provided that any person
claiming to be entitled to any such property may
apply in writing to the Custodian who, after giving
public notice and holding an enquiry, will make a
formal order declaring the person to whom possession
of the property may be delivered. In Central Ordinance XXVII of 1949 and in Central Act XXXI of
1950, the provision for restoration of property to the
evacuee in s. 16 thereof is that the Custodian may, on
application by the evacuee or his heir, restore to him
the property subject to such terms and conditions as
he may think fit to impose provided that the applicant produces a certificate from the Central Government that the property may be so restored if he is
otherwise entitled to it. Thus it will be seen that while
the earliest East Punjab Ordinance of 1947 recognised
almost an unrestricted right in the evacuee to obtain
restoration of property this was changed shortly thereafter by the East Punjab Act of 1947 which required
that such'-return by the Custodian can only follow a
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
813
notification by the Provincial Government as to its
being satisfied that evacuees have returned or are
returning and authorising the return of the property.
The Central legislation of 1949 and of 1950 however
lessened the rigour of it by requiring only a preliminary
certificate from the Central Government by the individual applicant concerned.
Next, it may be noticed that neither East Punjab
Ordinance IV of 1947 nor East Punjab Act XIV of
l 94 7 which replaced it refer to or define either the word
'lease' or 'allotment'. These two words were for the
first time defined only by the amending East Punjab
Ordinance XVI of 1948 and it was made clear therein
that an allotment was different from a lease. From
the historical background it would appear likely that
the word 'allotment' was used for the grant of property
to displaced land-holders while 'lease' was intended to
denote a temporary grant to other displaced persons.
But even so the temporary character of the right
involved in the word 'allotment' was specified by
defining 'allotment' as meaning the grant by the Custodian of a temporaiy right of use and occupation of
evacuee property to any person otherwise than by way
of lease. This temporary character of the right was
reiterated also in East Punjab Ordinance IX of 1949
and in Central Ordinance XXVII of 1949· It is only
in Central Act XXXI of 1950 that by s. 2(a) thereof
the word 'temporary' in the definition of the word
'allotment' was dropped and 'allotment' is defined as
meaning the grant by a person duly authorised of a
right of use or occupation of an immovable evacuee
property to any other person but does not include a
grant by way of a lease. Thus the legislation of l 950
for the first time contemplated that allotment may be
otherwise than temporary. This Act as well as the
previous Central Ordinance completely omitted the
definition of the word 'lease'. These changes were
apparently necessitated by the fact that, in between,
Punjab Government notification dated July 8, 1949,
came into operation providing for what has become
subsequently known as quasi-permanent allotment.
1957
Amar Singh
v.
Custodian, Evaciu,
Property, Punjab.
Jaganrwdhadas
],
SUPRE11E COURT REPORTS
The provisions of that notification and the legal effect
thereof will be noticed in due course.
1957
Amar Singh
v.
We may next trace the provisions in the various
Acts relating to the power of cancellation of allotJ. ments in so far as they appear from the body of the
main Ordinances and Acts themselves, leaving
aside-for the time being-the rules framed thereunder. It may be mentioned that in the rest of the
judgment in noticing the statutory provisions which
deal with leases and allotments together, all reference
to leases are omitted for the sake of simplification.
The earliest provision in this behalf is s. 9-A of East
Punjab Act XIV of 1947 which was inserted into it by
East Punjab Ordinance XVI of 1948 replaced by East
Punjab Act XLIX of 1948. Sub-section (2) of s. 9-A
provides that notwithstanding anything contained in
any enactment for the time being in force, the
Custodian may cancel any allotment or amend the
terms of any agreement on which any evacuee property
is held or occupied by any person, whether such agreement was entered into before or after the coming into
force of East Punjab Ordinance XVI of 1948. It is
further provided by sub-ss. (3) and (4) thereof, that if
a person is in unauthorised possession of any evacuee
property the Custodian may treat such person either
as a tenant or as a trespasser and that a person
treated as a trespasser, on concellation of allotment,
shall, on demand surrender possession to the Custodian.
The subsequent East Punjab Ordinance IX of lr49,
Central Ordinance XXVII of 1949 and Central Act
XXXI of 1950 contain substantially the same provisions relating to cancellation of allotments. It may
be mentioned that all these legislative measures had a
section relating to rule-making power right from the
time of East Punjab Act XIV of 1947 and also a
provision that the provisions of the Act and the rules
made thereunder shall have effect notwithstanding
anything inconsistent therewith in any enactment
other than that Act. (See ss. 2~ and 18-B of Esta
Punjab Act XIV of 1947 and ss. 55, 56 and 4 of
Central Act XXXI of 1950.) By virtue of this
Custodian, Evacuee
Profurty, Pury°ab,
Jagunnadhadas
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT R"'.PO'!'.rs
rule making power, the Provincial Government and
the Central Government made rules from time to time,
-,.-~which will be noticed presently.
1957
Amar Singh
v.
CustoC.ian, Eva.:11e8
Property, Punjab.
· From the above history of alterations at short
intervals in some of the main relevant provisions, it is Jagannadhadas
clear that the legislation was being adjusted from
time to time with reference to the exigencies and
difficulties of the different problems which had to be
grappled with, both in the matter of internal administration as also on account of inter-dominion conferences
between Pakistan and India. It may be mentioned
that during the two year period between the first
. Provincial legislation in 1947 and the first Central
Y.legislation in 1949 there were as many as six-inter
dominion conferences, i.e., in January 1948, April
1948, July 1948, December 1948, April 1949 and June
1949·
Stopping here it will be seen that the position, m
its general aspect, is that all evacuee property is
vested in the Custodian. But the evacuee has not
lost his ownership in it. The law recognised his ultimate ownership subject to certain limitations. The
evacuee may come back and obtain return of his
property, as also an account of the management there_..of, by the Custodian. Such return which
was
~ originally contemplated without any restriction, is
subsequently dependent on a notification or a certificate of the Central Government. Until such return
the Custodian may manage the property by granting
allotments in favonr of displaced persons. The nature
of an allotment is clear from its definition that it is
grant of the right of use and occupation. This in the
first instance was contemplated as being only temporary. By a later definition, it was made wider so as
not to be restricted to a temporary use and occupation.
But the allotment is clearly subject to the power of
•
~~cancellation thereof vested in the Custodian, which
1 will entitle him to obtain its possession.
Such rules
were undergoinl"0 alterations from time to time. In
such a situation it would prima facie be difficult to·
7-99 s.c.!./59
].
816
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1957
recognise the allottee of any evacuee property in so
far as his position is governed by the main pr~visions
v.
of the Evacuee Property Administration Acts (unaffectCustodian, Evacutt
ed by any specific rules applicable to any particular
Prop!rty, Punjab.
class
of property or any specific arrangement or
Jagannadhadas J.
contract), as a person having some kind of property
or having a recognised interest therein which by itself
constitutes 'property'. It is ;nore in the nature of a
licence which is liable to be cancelled by the grantor.
It may be mentioned that there appear to be certain
rules made by the East Punjab Government dated
August 6, 1948, under East Punjab Act XIV of i :14 7
as amended in 1948 relating to cancellation of allotments. But the text of these rules was not available
to us. However this may be, it is urged that certain
other legislative measures and sta>utory rules maue in
exercise of the statutory powers, have made a differef!ce
in the position arising in respect of allotments of
agricultural lands granted in favour of displaced
persons in East Punjab who left landed property in
West Punjab. It is, therefore, necessart to review the
same.
Am!Zr Singh
The first measure for the resettlement of the displaced land-holders of \'\'est Punjab on evacuee lands
was the East Punjab Refugees (Registration of Land
Claims) Ordinance, 1948 (E.P. Ordinance VII of 1948)
which was replaced by East Punjab Refugees (Registration of Land Claims) Act, 1948 (E.P. XII of 1948).
It is in pursuance of the rules framed under this Act
that what is known as the Parcha claim and the form
therefor were standardised calling for accurate information as regards quite a large number of details
which had to be taken into consideration in determining the land to be allotted to a displaced land-holder.
This was followed by the East Punjab Displaced
Persons (Land Resettlement) Ordinance, 1949 (E.P.
Ordinance XIV of i949) which was replaced by the
East Punjab Displaced Persons (Land Resettlement)
Act, 1949 (E. P. XXXVI of r949). This Act was meant
"to provide for the allotment of evacuee lands in East
Punjab". The right of an allottee to possession of the
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
817
land allotted subject to payment of rent, etc., to the
1957
Custodian or his right to a share in the rent from the
All"ar Singh
present holder thereof (that is, the cultivating occupant),
v.
Evacuee
if any, and other incidents arising from such posses- Custodian,
Property, Punjab.
sion were specifted in this Act. In between these two
Acts, notification No. 4892/S dated July 8, 1949, was Jagannadhadas J.
issued by the Punjab Government in exercise of the
rule-making power vested in it under els. (f) and (ff)of
sub-s. (2) of s. 22 of East Punjab Act XIV of 1947 as
amended in 1948. This notification sets out the
statement of conditions on which the Custodian could
grant allotments of land vested in him. This notification is virtually the charter of the rights of allottees.
It is the basis of what has come to be known as the
quasi-permanent allotment. In the rules set out i11
this notification a 'displaced person' i~, defined as 'a
land-holder in West Punjab etc.' and it is specified that,
"an allotment sha11 be made in favour of a displaced
person and for a period for which the land remains
vested in the Custodian." The word 'allottee' is
defined as including "heirs, legal representatives and
lessees of the allottee. It ma-,r be mentioned in this
context that East Punjab Displaced Persons (Land
Resettlement) Act, 1949, mentioned above, which was
passed shortly after these rules were notified also
defines the word 'allottee' and says that allottee
means "a displaced person to whom land is allotted
by the Custodian under the conditions published with
East Punjab Government notification No. 4.892/S
dated July 8, 1949 and includes his heirs, legal
representatives and sub-lessees." Thus the definitions
of the word 'allottee' in the rules of July 8, 1949 and
under the Act passed shortly thereafter recognise not
only that an allotment is to be in favour of a displaced
land-holder for the period the land is vested in the
Custodian but that it enures for the benefit of his heirs
and legal representatives. Therefore, the first incident
of allotment implicit in this is the heritability of the
rights of the allottee which constitute quasi-permanent
allotment nuder the above mentioned notification of
July 8, 1949. Various other rights are specified in
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
els. 3, 4, 5, 7 and 8 of the said notification. These
will be summarised later. But it is to be noticed that
Amar Singh
the
allotment itself is subject to resumption under
v.
Custodian, Evacuee cl. (6) thereof.
Before considerii:ig the nature of the
Property, Pu11jab.
interest which these various clauses of the notification
Jagannadhadas J. confer on the quasi-permanent allottee, it is necessary
to see how far this notification of July 8, 1949, is
affected by subsequent legislation and the rules framed
thereunder.
Now the East Punjab Evacuee Property Administration Acts were repealed and replaced by Central
Ordinance XXVII of 1949 and Central Act XXXI of
i 950.
Both the Central Ordinance and Central Act
had each a section, s. 53 and s. 55 respectively, under
which the Central Government may delegate its rulemaking power to the State Government. In exercise of
such delegated power the State Government issued a
notification No. 1554-Cust. dated February 6, 1950
the relevant portion of which is as follows :
'
"The Provincial Government is pleased to notify
that Statement of Conditions issued by the Custodian
and published ·under the notification No. 4.891/S and
4892 /S dated the 8th July, l 949, shall be deemed
to be and shall continue to remain in force as rules
framed by the Provincial Government under sub-section
(z) of section 53 of the Central Ordinance No. XXVII
of 1949 under delegation from the Central Government
under Notification No. 3094-A/Cus/49 dated 2nd
December, 1949, subject to the following modifications
and amendments :
(i) The rules as stated in the Statement of Conditions under notification Nos. 4891/S and 4892/S dated
the 8th July, 1949, shall be called the Administration
of Evacuee Property (Rural) Rules, 1949·
(ii) Definition. (a) The word 'ACT' defined m
!he said Statement of Conditions shall mean the
Adm~nistration of Evacuee Property Ordinance, 1949
\Ordmance No. XXVII of 1949).
1957
............................................................... ,,
The above rules of July 8, 1949, have, therefore,
cominued to be operative as rules made under the
•
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
819
Central Ordinance. On the repeal of the Central Ordi1957
nance by Central Act XXXI of
of
, s· h
. 1950 and
b .by virtue
fi
n.maring
1 contmue
s. 58 t h ereof h
t ese rues
to e 1n orce as
v.
tho'ugh they are rules made under the Central Act of Custodian,
Eva_cuee
Property, Pun;ab.
1950. Further, the Central Government framed rules
on .September 28, l 950, entitled Administration of Jatannadhadas J.
Evacuee Property (Central) Rules, 1950, v,·hich will be
noticed presently. Later, in exercise of the delegated
rule-making power vested in the Provincial Government under s. 55 of the Central Act, the Punjab
Government framed rules dated August 29, 1951,
entitled "Instructions for review and revision• of land
allotment." These two sets· of subsequent rules w<;mld
affect the rules of July, 1949, to the extent that any
of them are inconsistent with the earlier rules. A
comparison of the subsequent rules with the earlier
rules of July 8, 1949, shows that the later rules do not
concern any of the matters provided by the earlier
rules of l 949 (and l 950) excepting as regards the
provisions relating to resumption-which virtually is
cancellation-of allotments. Hence the rules of July
8, 1949, continue to be in force except to that extent,
if any. The portion which has undergone, if any,
variation by subsequent rules may now be noticed.
The provision for resumption in the rules published
by the Punjab Government in its notification of July
8, l 949, is as follows :
"6., The Custodian, or as the case may be, the
Rehabilitation Authority shall be CO{llpctent to resume,
amend, withdraw, or cancel the allotment on any of
the following grounds :
(a) It is contrary to the orders of the East Punjab
Government, or the instructions of the Financial Commissioner, Rehabilitation, or the Custodian, Evacuee
Property, East Punjab ;
(b) The allottee has infringed or appears to be
preparing to infringe any of the terms of allotment ;
(c) The allotment was obtained by false declaration
or insufficient information or is contrary to the purpose
of rehabilitating the displaced persons ;
820
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1957 J
(d) The area allotted or occupied by the allottee
is
more
than he was authorised to take on allotment or
Amar Sin5h
v.
occupy under the instructions issued by the East
Custodian, Evacuee
ProjJttty, Punjab. Punjab Government or the Financial Commissioner,
Rehabilitation, or the Custodian, Evacuee Property,
Jagannadhadas J. East Punjab ;
.
(e) V.'here the claims of other parties with respect
to the land have been established or accepted by the
Custodian or the Rehabilitation Authority ;
(f) \\Then the allottee has been convicted of an
offence under the Act ; or
(g) If the allottee fails to take possession of the
land within the time as may be allowed by the Custodian or the Rehabilitation Authority, or after having
taken possession, fails to cultivate the land or a part
thereof."
1957
The next set of rules arc those made nnder Central
Act XXXI of 1950. Rule 14 of Central Rules, 1950, is
the following :
"14. (1). ·················································· ...
(2) In case of an allotment granted by the Custodi:rn
himself, the Custodian may eYirt a person on any
ground justifying eviction of a tenant under any la\\·
relating to the Control of Rents for the time being in
force in the State concerned, or for any violation of
the conditions of the allotment.
(3) The Custodian may evict a person who has
secured an allotment by misrepresentation or fraud or if
he is found to be in possession of more than one e\'acuee
property or in occupati011 c•f accommodation in excess
of his requirements.
(4) ........................................••......•........... "
It wi'H b~ seen that the above proYisions are not in
themseh·es pm,·ers of cancellation or modification of
allotment bHt are supplementary thereto authorising
eviction of an allottcc nndcr the circumstances indicated
therein. The next set of rules in this connection are
rules dated August 29, 1951, enacted by the Punjab
Government in exercise of powers delegated to it by
the Central Government under s. 55 ( r) of Central Act
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
XXXI of 1950. In so far as these rules relate to allot1957
ment~ els. (a) to \g) of r. ( 1) thereof are virtually the
Amar Singh
same as those relating to resumption in the notification
v.
Evacute
of July 8, 1949. The additions thereto in the I 95 r Custodian,
Property, Punjab.
rules are the following :
" ( 1) The Custodian shall be competent to cancel Jngannadhadas ] •
or terminate any allotment or vary the terms of any
allotment or agreement and evict the allottee in any
one of the following circumstances :
. )
. \
(a, to (g1 .............................................. , ...... .
(h) that it is necessary or expedient to cancel or
vary the terms of an allotment for the implementation
of resettlement schemes and/or rules framed by the
State Government ; or for such distribution amongst
displaced persons as appears to the Custodian to be
equitable and proper : or
(i) that it is necessary or expedient to cancel
or vary the terms or an a llntment for the preservation,
ur the proper administration, or the management of
such property or in the interests of proper rehabilitatim1 of displaced persons.
(2)' Anything done or any action taken in exercise
of any power confcrrecl by the previous rules shall be
deemed to have been done or taken under these rules,
as if they were in force on the day on which such thing
was done or action was taken."
A dose scrutiny will show that as regards resumption
or cancellation of (quasi-permanent) allotments made
under the notification of July, 8, r 949, the Central Rules
of 1950 do not make anv alteration by r. 14 then of
but gi\'e only supplementary powers of eviction in
certain contingencies. The rules of August 2q, 1951,
made by the Punjab Go\'ernment under delegated
authority will be fou11d on comparison to be substantially the same as those enumerated in cl. (6) of July,
8, 1t149, 11otification under the heading 'Resumption'
with th<' addition of els. (h) and (i) and ·with an additional clause gi\'ing retrospective operation to the new
rules.
Rule 14 of the Central Rules, l 950, has been subsequently modified by notification No. S. R. 0. l 722 dated
/
\
SCPREME COURT REPORTS
October 29, 1951, by adding sub-r. (6) which 1s as
follows
:
.A.mar Singh
v.
"V\'herc any State Government has, in exercise of
Custodian, Er'acuu
cmy rules under
Proptrty, Punjab. the powers delegated to it, made
clause (i) of sub-section (2) of section 56 of the Act
which are inconsistent with this rule, surh rules sl:all
prevail over this rule."
This obviously is intended to indicate that if there is
any inconsistency as regards the power of cancellation
between the Central Rules and the latter delegated
State Rules, the State Rules are to override the
Central Rules. No\':, all these rulrs relating to the
power of c&ncdlation which derive their authority
from the rule making power given by the P10vincial
and Central Acts must, according to the ordinary rules
of construction be read so as to harmonise with the
powers of cancellation under ·the Act itsel( It follows
that r. (6) relating to resumption of allotments under
the notification of July, 8, 1949, as it originally stood
until February 6, 1950, must be read with s. 9-J\ of
East Punjab Act XIV of 1947 as amended in H)4B, in
so far as it relates to allotment. Similarly Central
Rules of 1950, and the delegated State Rules of 1950
and 1951 must be read to harmonise with s. 12 of
Central Act XXXI of 1950, in so far as they relate to
allotments made urn.icr the notification of July 8,
1949· Reading these powers of cancellation under the
Act and the Rules together, it will be found that the
power of cancellation of such allotments is wide and
varied and depends to a substantial extent on administrative orders and c'onsiderations. Rule 14 of Central
Rules, 1950, underwent alterations in July, 1952, and
February, 1953· These are subsequent to the date of
cancellation of the allotment in the present c;o.se and
have no direct bearing on the present case.
Pausing here and summarising the pe:.ition as it
obtained till July 22, 1952 (when further relevant rules
were framed) as regards the rights under the (quasipermanent) allotment scheme introduced by notification of July 8, 1949, may be stated thus. (References
given as against each are to the relevant provisions of
the notification of July 8, 1949).
1957
)
'-
:S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
r. The allottee is entitled to right of use and
·occupation of the property until such time as the
property remains yested in the Custodian. (Clause
3 (I).
2.
The benefit of such right will enure to his heirs
and successors. (Definition of 'allottee'.)
3. His enjoyrr.ent of the property is on the basis
of paying land-revenue thereupon and cesses for the
time being. Additional rent may be fixed thereupon
by the Custodian. If and when he docs so, the allottee
is bound to pay the same. (Clause 3(3).)
4. He is entitled to quiet and undisturbed enjoyment of the property during that period. (Clause 8.)
5. He is entitled to make improvements on the
land with the assent of the Custodian and is entitled
to compensation in the manner provided in the Punjab
Tenancy Act. (Clause 7.)
6. He is entitled to exchange the whole or any
part of the land for other evacuee land with the consent of the Custodian. ::Clause 5.)
i· He is entitled to lease the land for a period
not exceeding three years without the permission of
the Custodian and for longer period "·ith his consent.
But he is not entitled to transfer his rights by way of
sale, gift, will, mortgage or other
private contract.
(Clause 4(c).)
8. His rights in the allotment are subject to the
fairly extensive powers of cancellation under the Act
and rules as then in force prior to July 22, 1952, on
varied administrative considerations and actions such
as the following Clause 6 and subsequent rules of
195r.) : (a) That the allotment is contrary to the orders
of the Punjab Gov"ernment or the instructions of the
Financial Commissioner, Relief and Rehabilitation,
or of the Custodian, Evacuee Property, Punjab ;
~
(b) That the claims of other parties with respect
to the land have been established or accepted by the
Custodian or the Rehabilitation Authority ;
Amar Singh
v.
Custodian, Evacuee
Property, Punjab.
Jagannadhadas ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(c) That it is necessary or expedient to cancel
or vary the terms of an allotment for the implementa- Y
v.
tion of resettlement schemes and/or rules framed by
Custodian, Evacuee
the State Government ; or for such distribution amongst
Proper~y, Punjab.
displaced persons as appears to the Custodian to be
Jagannadhadas ].
equitable and proper ;
(d) That it is necessary or expedient to cancel or
vary the terms of an allotment for the preservation, or
•
the proper administration, or the management of such
property or in the interests or proper rehabilitation of
displaced persons.
It is noteworthy that the powers of cancellation
include the liability of the allotment to be cancelled, if~
it is secured by false declaration or insufficient information, and also if the allottee is convicted under the
provisions of the Evacuee Property Administration
Acts. (Clause 6(c) and (f).).
Taking all the above incidents together as to the
position of a displaced land-holder to whom evacuee
agricultural land has been allotted under the notification of July 8, 1949, there can be no doubt that he
is in a definitely better legal position than the allottee
of other kinds of property under Central Act
XXXI of 1950 and the Central Rules of 1950, who, as
already shown, is more or less in the position of a 'f-licensee.
But even so, it is still far short of what can be
considered as being in itself 'property' either in the
widest sense or in a limited sense. It is very strenuously
urged that though this might appear to be so if one
has regard only to the legislation and to the statutory
rules up to July 22, 1952, the position of such an
allottee emerges more definitely and clearly in the
light of further legislation and subsequently amended
rules. It is urged that this later legislation was in
implementation of the original Press CommuniqueT
dated February 7, 1948, which was understood to hold
out the assurance of allotments conferring permanent
property. On this contention the later legislation has
also been brought to our notice. In view of the
insistence with which this contention has been urged
1957
Amar Singh
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
and the importance of the question it is desirable to
notice the same and to consider the effect thereof
without deciding whether the later legislation and the
Press Communique are relevant for the decision of the
matters involved in this case.
The earliest change in the pre-existing situation, as
above noticed, was brought about by two notifications,
S. R. 0. 1290 dated July 22, 1952, and S. R. 0. 351
dated February 13, 1953, as a result of which sub-r. (6)
of r. 14 of the Central Rules of 1950 stood amended
by the substitution of a new sub-rule which is as
follows :
"(6) Notwithstanding anything contained in this
rule, the Custodian of Evacuee Property in each of the
States of Punjab and Patiala and East Punjab States
Union shall not exercise the power of cancelling arry
allotment of rural el'aruee property on a quasi-permanent
basis, or varying the terms of any such allotment,
except in the following circumstances :
(i) where the allotment was made although the
alluttee owned no agricultural bnd in Pakistan ;
(ii) where the allottee has obtained land in
.excess of the area to which he was entitled under the
scheme of allotment of land prevailing at the time of
allotment ;
(iii) where the allotment is to be cancelled or
varied(a) in atcordance with an order made by a
competent authority under section 8 of the East
Punjab Refugees (Registration of Land Claims) Act,
1948 ;
(b) on account of the failure of the allottee to
take possession of the allotted evacuee property within
six months of the date of allotment ;
(c) in consequence of a voluntary surrender of
the allotted evacuee property, or a voluntary exchange
with other available rural evacuee property or a
mutual exchange \\ith such other available property ;
(d) in accordance with any general or special
order of the Central Government ;
1957
Amar Singh
V,
Custodian, Evacuee
Propm;·, Punjab.
Jagannadhadas ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1 957
Provided that where an allotment is cancelled or
varied under clause (ii), the allottee shall be entitled to
V.
retain such portion of the land to which he \rnuld
Custodian. Er·acuee
have been entitled under the scheme of quC>siPropert_v. Punjab.
permanent
allotment of land :
Jaganno.1hadru J.
Amar Singh
Prodded further that nothing in this sub-rule
shall apply to any application for rcTision made
under section 26 or section 27 of the Act, within the
prescribed time, against an order passed bv a lower
authority on or before 22nd July, 1052."
This amendment has undoubtedly the effect of modif)·ing the po\\·er of resumption or cancellation vested
in the Custodian authorities in respect of quasipermancnt allottees by virtue of tl:c pre-existing rules
and to confine such power within narrow limits as
specified therein. But whether the restrictions
on this power of cancellation can be harmonised with
the power to vary or cancel allotments vested in the
Custodian under s. 12 of Central Act XXXI of 1950 is,
a matter not without some difficulty.
It may, however
be assumed that if possible, the latest amendment of r. 14
of Central Rules, 1CJ.'JO, by the insertion of the amended
sub-r. ~6) therein will ha,·e to be harmonised with the
main section by a proce s nf construction so as not to
nullify the beneficient provisions specifically enact<!d
in mandatory language. It i., noteworthy that the
language of the new sub-r. (6) of r. 14 operates only as
a restraint on the exercise of the power of cancellation
vested in the Custodian and not as a negation of the
power itself and it may, therefore, well be that there
is no inconsistency. The choice of the language appears
to be intentional. On the other hand it may be noticed
also in this context that there have been some amendments in 1953, 1954 and 1956 of s. 16 of Central Act
XXXI of 1950 relating to return of the evacuee
property to the evacuee which continue to recognise
his right to return of the property and have made
some alterations in the details of the procedure appli. cable thereto. The continuance of the right of return
may well imply the continued existence of the power
to cancel the allotment.
S.C.R.
.,,
SUPREME COURT RVPJRTS
r957
The next important legislative . measme is the
Amar Singh
Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation)
V,
_'fAct, 1954 (XLIV of 1954). By s. 12 of this Act it is CUstodian,
Evacuee
Property, Punjab.
provided as follows :
"If the Central Government is of opinion that it Jagannadhadas ].
is necessary to acquire any evacuee property for a
public purpose, being a purpose connected with the
relief and rehabilitation of displaced persons, including
payment of compensation to such persons, the Central
Government may at any time acquire such evacuee
\
property by publishing in the Official Gazette a notification to the effect that the Central Government has
decided to acquire such evacuee property in pursuance
of this section.
)(2) On the publication of a notification under subsection ( r), the right, title and interest of any evacuee
in the evacuee property specified in the notification
shall, on and from the beginning of the date on which
the notification is so published, be extinguished and
the evacuee property shall vest absolutely in the
Central Government free from all encumbrances.
(3) ........................................................... .'
It may be noticed that by virtue of Central Government
notification No. S.R.0.697 dated March '24, 1955, under
sub-s. ( 1) of this section, all evacuee property allotted
. under the Punjab Government notification dated July 8,
--Y1949, has been acquired by the Central Government
excepting certain specified categories in respect of which
proceedings were pending. It does not appear that the
properties which are the subject matter of the present
application have been acquired under this notification,
probably because the dispute about them is still
pending. Section r 3 of the Act provides as follows :
"There shall be paid to an evacuee compensation in
respect of his property acquired under section r 2 in
accordance with such principles a.nd in such manner as
may be agreed upon between the Governments of India
4,-and Pakisthan."
Section 14 makes provision for constituting a compensation pool for the purpose of payment of compensation
and rehabilitation grants to displaced persons.
The
828
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
evacuee property acquired under s. 12 forms part of
this compensation pool. Section 1o is important and
provides inter alia that where any immovable property
has been allotted to a displaced person by the Custodian under conditions published by the notification of
Jagannadhadas J.
the Government of Punjab Ko. 4.892-S dated July 8,
1949, and such property is acquired under the provisions of tht; Act and forms part of the compensation
pool, the displaced person shall, so long as the property
remains vested in the Central Government, continue in
possession of such property on the same conditions on
which he held the property immediately before the date of
the acquisition. It is further provided that the Central
Government may for the purpose of payment of compensation to such diJjJlaced j1erson, transfer to him such
property on such terms and conditions as may
be
prescribed. Section 40 provides for the rule-making
power. Sub-section 1 (a) thereof enables the Central
Government to make rules providing for the form and
manner in which and the time within which, an
application for payment of compensation may be made
and the particular; which it should contain. It may
be noticed that "compensation" referred to in s. 10.
in so far as it relates to a displaced person, obviously
refers to the compensation for loss of his property in
Pakistan and is not the recognition of a right to compensation for deprivation of his interest, if any, in the
allotted propcrtv by cancellation. Rules have been
made by the Central Government called the Displaced
Persons Compensation and Rehabilitation Rules, 1955
published by notification dated May 21, 1955. Rules
7 1 and 73 relate to verified claims which do not seem
to refer to agricultural
lands. "Verified claims"
relate to urban immovable property as the definition
thereof in the Displaced Persons (Claims) Act, 1050
(XLIVof 1950) shows. Rule 72 (1) relates to an allot tee
of agricultural land having- no verified claim and is
relevant. Rule 72(2) provides that if the Settlem~nt
Officer is satisfied that the allotment is in accordance
with the quasi-permanent scheme, he may pass an
order transferring the land allotted to the allottee in
1957
Amar Singh
v,
Custodian, Evacuee
Property, Punjab.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1957
permanent ownership as compensation and shall also
issue to him a sanad in the form specified in the
Amar Singli
Appendix XVII or XVIII, as the case may be, granting Custodian,v. Evacuee
him such rights. A scrutiny of the sanad which is Proper(y, Punjab.
printed at page 70, Appendix VII, of the Displaced Jagannadhadas J.
Persons Compensation and Rehabilitation Rules, 1955
issued by the Government of India, Ministry
of
Rehabilitation , shows that it is only under this sanad
that an allottee obtains permanent property in the land
which originally belonged to the evacuee and which
was allotted to him under the quasi-permanent allotment scheme. This sanad is the culmination of the
hopes and expectations of allottees held out under the
Press Communique dated February 7, 1948, and
confirms, if any, the view that until such s'tage
has
been reached the allottee has no such interest in the
evacuee lands which can by itself constitute "property"
within the meaning of the protected fundamental
rights. It is admitted by the learned counsel for the
petitiOners that the petitioners in this case have not
yet been able to obtain any sanad under these rules for
the lands originally allotted to them and cancelled by
the impugned orders of the Custodian and the Deputy
Custodian-General. He urges, however, that having
regard to the whole scheme and on the assumption
that the or.ders of cancellation, which he challenges,
are erroneous, they would in the ordinary course have
obtained the sanad for the lands that and the right to
relief under Art. 32 must be determined on that footing.
Great stress is laid on the fact that under the scheme
of Central Act XLIV of 1954, even if evacuee property
is acquired under s. 12 thereof, the quasi-permanent
allottee is entitled to continue in possession of the
property under s. 1 o on the same conditions as before
so long as the property remains vested in the Central
Government. Stress is also laid on the fact that he can
apply for transfer of the property to himself under
r. 72(2) of the rules made under the Act in payment
of compensation payable to him in lieu of his property
left in West Punjab and that such application for
transfer is normally to be granted and a sanad issued
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1957}
to him. In this context, learned counsel for the petitioners relies on the well-known principle, viz., where a
Amar Sinth
discretionary power is vested in a statutory authority,
v.
Custodian, Evacuee to act in certain circumstances for the benefit of certain
Property, Punjab.
person or class of persons (as in s. 1 o of Central Act
Jagann adhadas ]. XLIV of 1954 and r. 72(2) of the rules thereunder) the
exercise of such power in favour of such a person,
where the requisite conditions exist, is obligatory and
not optional, as laid down in the case ·in Julius v. Lord
Bishop of O)fford ('). This principle, however, has no
application in the present case. While it is true that
under s. IO an allottee under the quasi-permanent allotment scheme has the benefit of continuing in possession
thereof and may obtain transfer on application, such
benefits are subject to the.powers exercisable under s. 19
of the same Act and r. 102 of the rules framed thereunder. It may be noticed that in respect of the evacuee
property which has been acquired under s. 12 and which
forms part of the compensation pool under s. 14, the
Central Government may appoint under s. 16 of the Act,
for the management thereof, Managing Officers or
Managing Corporations.
Section 19 of the Act
further provides as follows:
1957
"19. Powers to vaiy or cancel allotment of any
property acquired under this Act.
( 1) Notwithstanding anything 'contained m any
contract or any other law for the time being in force
but subject to any rules that may be made under this
Act, the managing officer or managing corporation
may cancel any allotment or amend the terms of any
allotment under which any a evacuee property acquired
under this Act is held or occupied by a person, whether
such allotment was granted before or after the
commencement of this Act.
"
Rules !02 of the rules framed under the Act is as
follows:
"102. Cancdlation of allotments:
A managing
may
in respect of
officer or a managing corporation
(1) (1830) 3 App. C:1·;. 21.i.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
57
the property in the compensation pool entrusted to
9
-'f him or to it, cancel an allotment or vary the terms of
Amar Singh
any such allotment if the allotteeCmtcdia:; Evacur~
(a) has sublet or parted with the possession 0 f Prop"''· Punjab.
the whole or any part of the property allotted to Jagannadhadas J.
him without the permission of a competent author1
ity, or
(b) has used or if. using :.uch property for a
purpose other than that for which it was allotted
to him without the permission of a competent authority, or
(c) has committed any act which is destructive
). of or permanently injurious to the property, or
1
\,,j
(d) for any other sufficient reason to be recorded
in writing.
Provided that no action shall be taken nnder this
rule unless the allottee has been given a reasonable
opportunity of being heard."
These are in terms wide enough to include quasipermanent allotments. This shows that notwithstanding the previlege of the quasi-permanent allottee to
continue in possession under s. IO and the scope he has
for obtaining a transfer under the same section and
r. 72(2) of the rules made thereunder, his allotment
itself is liable to be cancelled under s. 19 and
r.102. Hence he has no such right to obtain a transfer
which can be given effect to within the principle of
Bishop of Oxford's case (1). He does not, therefore,
appear to have an indefeasible right to obtain transfer
of the very land of which he is the quasi-permanent
allottee, if such land is acquired under s. r 2 of the
Act. Thus the position,; of quasi-permanent allottee,
whether before July 22, 1952, or after that date, is
that his rights, such as they are, either under the
notification of July 8, r 949, or under s. IO of Central
-f Act XLIV of i954, are subject to powers of cancellation exercisable by the appropriate authorities in
:iccordance with the changing requirements of the
evacuee property law and its administration. Hence
the quality of the interest of the displaced allottee in
(r) (1880) 5 App. Cas, 214.
8-99 s. c. I./59.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1957
Amar Singh
v.
Cus!oiian, El•acuee
Proper:y, Punjab.
Jaganna.Jhat/as J.
[ 1 957
J
evacuee agricultural land allotted to him appears to be
substantially the same for the present purpose and the
real question is whether such interest constitutes
"property" within the meaning of Arts.. 19, 31 ( 1) and
3 1(2) of the Constitution.
The above detailed consideration of the various
incidents of a quasi-permanent allotment show clearly
that the sum total thereof does not in any
sense
constitute even qualified ownership of the land allotted.
At best it is analogous to what is called jus in re aliend
according to the concept of Roman Law and may be
some kind of interest in land. The basic feau>.res of
that interest are that the ultimate ownership of the
land is still recognised to be that of tile evacuee and
the allotment itself is liable to resumption or canctlllation with reference to the exigencies of the administration of evacuee law. The interest so recognised, is
in its essential concept, provisional, though with a
view to stabilisation and ultimate permanence. The
provisional characteristic of this interest emerges from
the fact that there have had to be a series of interDominion conferences to settle on governmental level
the· problems arising out of evacuee property in either
country. The stabilisation had to await the results of
such conferences. Thus both with reference to the
internal necessities of the administrative problems
inherent in the process of settling the displaced
persons on the evacuee lands with reference to various
considerations and policies and the external problem of
arriving at understandings between the two governments, these rights had to be so regulated from time
to time '1nd had an element of unstability, thou.!\"h
they were being prcgressively invested with the
characteristics of stability. An interest in land owned
by another in such a situation cannot be fitted into
any concept of 'property' in itself. The concept of
a bundle of rights in agricultural land constituting by
itself 'p,roperty' is the outcome of a stable and settled
state of affairs relating to such bundle of rights.
Historical jurisprudence shows that even the concept
of individual property in agricultural ·land was the
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1957
outcome of stable and settled conditions of society.
It is also relevant to observe that the incidents of
Amar Singh
quasi-permanent allotment are entirelly statutory.
Custodian, Evacuee
Subjection to the power of cancellation by the Custo- Property, Punjab.
dian in whom the property is vested is one of such
Jagannadhadas J.
incidents and determines the quality thereof. Therefore, having given our best consideration, we are
unable to hold that the interest a of quasi-permanent
allottee is 'property' within the concept of that
word so as to attract the protection of fundamental
rights.
••
Property, to fall within the scope of Art. 19(1) (f),
must be capable of being the subject-matter
of
"acquisition and disposal". The interest of the quasipermanent allottt:e arises by statutcry grant to a.
specified class of persons and is not capable of acquisition by the ordinary citizen in any of the normal
modes. Nor is it capable of disposal by the allottee
himself in the normal modes by way of sale, mortgage,
gift or will. Neither is the interest of the quasi-permanent allottee such as can be brought within the scope
of Art. '.:i r ( 2). Article 3 r ( 2) as recently amended,
taken with Art. 3 r ( 2A) contemplates acquisition or
requisitioning (and taking possession) as a result of
transfer of the ownership or of the right to possession.
It is true that the recent amendment came into operation on April 27, 1955, and the impugned orders of the
Cwtodi;:m and Deputy Custodian-General are
on
February 6, 1952, and May l, 1954. But in view of
the word "deemed" in the amended Art. 3 I ( 2A) it
appears likely that the amendment was intended to be
retrospective. Even assuming that it is not so, the
words "taking possession" or "acquisition" in Art.
31 (2) prior to the amendment are wholly inapt and
inapplicable to the bundle of rights of the nature
detailed above which constitute quasi-permanent
tenure and it is difficult to apply to it the protection
under Art. 31 (2) either as it stood before the amendment or after te amehndment.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has urged that
even if Arts. 19(1) (f) and 31{2) are not applicable, the
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1957 J
petitioners can invoke the protection of Art. 31(1)
which says that no person shall be deprived of his
. "·
property save by authority of law. He relies on the
c;,;'j,:,"(j,· /,,~';' judgment of one of us reported in the State of West
'
· Bengal v. Subodh Gopal Bose ('), where it was stated as
.Jagaonadlwdas ]. follows :
1957
A•w Singh
"The word 'property' as used in Article 31 ( 1)
may have been intended to be understood in a wider
sense and deprivation of any individual right out of a
bundle of rights constituting concrete property may
be deprivation of 'property' which would require the
authority of law."
This is a view which was not shared by the other
members of the Court in that decision. In any case
it is clear that in order that Art. 3 I ( 1) may apply, it
is not enough that there is 'deprivation' but it must
also be deprivation without the authority if law.
What has happened, however, in this case is not
deprivation of the property without the authority of
law even assuming that the bundle of rights constituting such an interest in land is 'property'. It is the
working out of the right of resumption or cancellation
which was one of the incidents of the property. The
cancellation by the Custodian authorities was under
the very law which created those rights. Even if the
exercise of that authority can be made out to be
wrong, it is still not open to question having regard to
ss. 28 and 46 of Central Act XXXI of 1950. It is not
an illegal usurpation of jurisdiction by the authorities
concerned so as to constitute negation of the authority
of law. In the present case what has happened is that
the quasi-permanent allotment of the petitioners has
been cancelled in order to work out readjustments
consequent upoµ the order of the higher authority.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has strenuously
urged that under the qusi-permanent allotment
scheme the allottee is entitled to a right to possession
within the limits of the relevant notification and that
such right to possession is ·itself 'property'. That
may be so in a sense. But it does not affect the
(•) [•954] S.C R. 587,673,
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1957
question whether it is property so as to attract the
protection of fundamental rights under the Constitution.
Amar Singh
v.
If the totality of the bundle of rights of the quasiEva&1Jtt
permanent allottee in the evacuee land constituting an Custodian,
Property, Pu'!iab.
interest in such land, is not property entitled to
protection of fundamental rights, mere possession of Jagannadluidas ].
the land by virtue of such interest is not on any higher
footing.
Learned counsel has also drawn our attention to a
number of Acts and notifications of the Punjab
Government to show that a quasi-permanent allottee
has been treated as being in the same position as an
owner of land itself for various purposes. Thus in
r. 5 of the Land Revenue Rules under the Punjab
Land Revenue Act, 1887 (Punjab Act XVII of 1887),
a quasi-permanent allottee is classed with other land
owners as being eligible for appointment as 2 aildars.
Similarly by virtue of rules framed under the East
Punjab Holdings (Consolidation and Prevention of
Fragmentation) Act, 1948 (East Punjab Act L of 1948),
a quasi-permanent allottee is liable to pay the cost of
consolidation if such consolidation comprises lands in
his occupation. These and other such provisions,
however, have no bearing on the question at issue
before .us.
After the close of the arguments before us a recent
decision of the Punjab High Court reported in Suraj
Parkash Kapur v. The State oj Punjab ( 1 ) has been
brought to our notice and we have given our careful
consideration to the same. That decision may be
right on its merits, a matter about which we express
no opinion. But, with respect, we are unable to agree
with the view expressed therein that a quasi-permanent
allottee has such an interest in the land allotted
to him as to constitute "property", if it is meant to
convey thereby that it is property which attracts
the protection of fundamental rights under the Constitution.
For all the above reasons we are unable to hold that
any fundamental right of the petitioners has been
(1) (1957) LIX P.L.R. 103.
~ S. C. lndiaJ59
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1957
Amar Singh
[ 195 7l
infringed. This petition is accordingly dismissed but,
in the circumstances, without costs.
v.
In holding that quasi-permanent allotment does not
carry with it a fundamental right to property under
]aga'(lnadhadas J. the Constitution we arc not to be supposed as denying
or weakening the scope of the rights of the allottce.
These rights as recognised in the statutory rules are
important and constitute the essential basis of a
satisfactory rehabilitation and settlement of displaced
land-holders. Until such time as these land-holders
obtain sanads to the lands, these rights are entitled to
zealous protection of the constituted authorities
according to administrative rules and instructions
binding on them, and of the courts by appropriate
proceedings where there is usurpation of jurisdiction
or abuse of exercise of statutory powers.
Custodian, Evacuu
Property, Punjab.
Petition dismissed.
GIPN-2S-99 S. C. India/59-6-7-61-1,000
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org