THE UNION OF INDIA versus THE COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER, WEST BENGAL AND OTHERS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 19 December 1955 | [1955] 2 S.C.R. 1076 | 1955 INSC 77
Key facts
- Decided
- 19 December 1955
- Bench
- SUDHI RANJAN DAS*, VIVIAN BOSE, NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI, B. JAGANNADHADAS, BHUVNESHWAR PRASAD SINHA
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9/1954
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1955] 2 S.C.R. 1076
- Neutral citation
- 1955 INSC 77
Text of the judgment
1076
1955
Rajalzmundry
Eketric Supp/;!
Corporation Ltd.
v.
A· Nageswara Rao
and others
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
appointed to manage its affairs, when action is taken
under section 153-C. This contention must accordingly be rejected.
In the result, the appeal fails and is dismissed
with costs, of the first respondent. The costs of the
administrator will come out of the estate.
1955
THE UNION OF INDIA
D1tnnbt' 19.
v.
THE COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER, WEST
BENGAL AND OTHERS
(WITH CONNECTED APPEAL)
[S, R. DAs, ACTING C. J., VIVIAN BosE, BHAGWATI,
JAGANNADHADAS and B. P. SINHA JJ.]
Sales Tax-Sale of hessian to the Ministry of Industry and
Supplies of the Government of India-If exempt from payment of
sales tax-Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941 (Bengal Act VI of
1941), s. 5(2)(•)(iii).
.
-Per S. R. DAs,
JAGANNADHADAS
AcTING
C.J.,
V1v1AN
BosE,
BHAGWATI
AND
JJ., SINHA J. · dissenting.-The exemption created
by the provisions of s. 5(2)(a)(iii) of the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax)
Act of 1941 must be construed strictly and cannot be extended to
sales to Government departments other than those mentioned there-
in.
The Department of Industries and Supplies,
which was subse-
quently rcdesignated as the Ministry of Industries and Supplies, was
not ·the same as the Indian Stores Department or the Supply Dc-partmcnt of the Government. of India and~ consequently, sales _made
to the Ministry of Industries and. Supplies are not exempt from pay~
ment of sales tax under that section.
In a welfare State with ever expanding activities in different
fields including trade and commerce, Government departments arc
often entrusted with the performance of well~defined activities and
are authorised to deal with the outside world and enter into transactions in the .same way as an ordinary person or a Company may do
and may well be. regarded as distinct units or quasi-legal entities for
µie ·purpose for which they are created.
0
Consequently, the. sales _of hessian made to the Ministry of
Industries and Supplies of the Government of India by the appellant Mills were hot exempt from payment of sales tax under the
Act and the State of West Bengal was entitled to levy the same.
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
um
1955
Per S1NHA J.-The language of a statute has sometimes to be
construed in a modified form in order to give effect to the real inten- Thi Union of India
tions of the legislature where, as in the present case, the language is
v.
The Commneial
only of a descriptive nature and not a definitive one.
T tJJt Ojfim, Wut
Miller v. Salomons ([1852] 7 Exchequer 475), referred to.
B1ngal and otlwrs
Commissioners of Inland Revenue v. Forest ( [1890] 15 A. C.
334 ), held inapplicable.
The terms of s. 5(2)(a)(iii) indicate that the exemption created
attaches to a particular function of the Government of India described by a certain name.
The change of nomenclature was, therefore, of no consequence
so long as a particular department continued to discharge that func·
tion, namely, that of purchasing articles including hessian for the
Government of India.
History of the department shows that the Ministry of Industry
and Supply is a lineal descendant of the Tndian Stores Department
and was at the time of the contract discharging its function on behalf of the Government of India and, consequently, the sales made
to it must ~ held to be exempt from payment of sales tax.
A department of the Government is neither a natural nor a
legal person but is one of the many functions of a Government
placed in charge of a hierarchy of officials with the head of the department at the apex.
CIVIL APPELLATE
Nos. 9 and 10 of 1954.
JuRISDICTION:
Civil
Appeals
On appeal from the Judgment and Order dated
the 9th day of June 1952 of the Calcutta High Court
in Appeal No. 26 of 1952 arising out of the Order
dated the 6th day of December 1951 of the said High
Court exercising its Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction in Matter No. 110 of 1950.
C. .K. Daphtary, Solicitor-General of India, (R.
Ganapathy Iyer and R. H. Dhebar, with him) for the
appellant in C. A. No. 9 of 1954 and respondent No.
3 in No. lO·of 1954.
S. Chowdhury, (S. N. Mukherji, B. N. Ghosh and
A. K. Bose, with him) for the appellant in C. A. No.
10 of 1954.
S. M. Bose, Advocate-Genera/. of West Bengal, (B.
Sen and P. K. Bose, with him) for respondents Nos. 1
and 2 in both appeals.
1078
19!>5
The Union of India
v.
T!w Commercial
T 4" Officer, West
Bengal and others
-SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
1955. December 19.
DAs AcTING C. J.-The only question canvassed
before us in the above appeals, which have been
heard together, is whether certain sales of goods made
by Shri Ganesh Jute Mills, Ltd. (hereinafter referred
to as the Mills) to the Government of India, Ministry
of Industry and Supplies are to be deducted from the
taxable turnover of the Mills so as to be exempt
from sales tax dernanded by the Commercial Tax
Officer of the State of West Bengal. The relevant
facts are stated beki.w.
On the first of September 1948 the Government of
India, Ministry of Industry and Supplies, in Calcutta,
placed with the Mills a confirmatory order in writing
bearing No. Cal/J-1/2001/103 for the supply to the
Government of India of a large quantity of hessian
cloth of different descriptions at
different prices
therein mentioned. It was stipulated that the contract would be governed by the conditions of contract
specified in Form WSB 133 as amended up-to-date. It
was specifically mentioned that the goods ordered
were required to meet an international obligation of
the Government of India and as such the execution
of the contract in accordance with the programme of
deliveries as given in the schedule attached thereto
was essential. The agreed prices were stated to be
exclusive of the Bengal Sales Tax and it was stipulated that the Government of India would arrange
direct payment of sales tax to the Government of
West Bengal if it was ultimately found that Sales
Tax was payable in respect of that contract. Pursuant
to the aforesaid contract, the Mills supplied goods to
the Government of India of the aggregate value of
Rs. 2,10,040 calculated at the prices agreed upon.
The Commercial Tax Officer, Beadon Street, District II Charge, claimed that the
aforesaid sales
should be included in the taxable turnover of the
Mills and assessed to sales tax. The Mills, on the
other hand, claimed exemption under section 5 of the
Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941 (Bengal Act VI
of 194.1). The relevant portion of section 5 ran as
follows:-
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME -COURT REPORTS
1079
"5. (1) The tax payable by a dealer under this
Act shall be kYie,\ at the rate of one quarter of an
anna in the rupee on his u:uble turnover ;
(2) In thi.; Act the expression "taxable
turno\'cr" means tlut part of a dealer's gross turno\'cr
during any period \\"hich renums, after deducting
r hcrdrom( a) his tunwYer during th:1t period 011(i) .................. ..
(ii) .................. ..
(iii) sales to the Indian Stores
Department:
the Sul'Ph
Department tli. the CoYc·rnment of India,
:md any r;1ilway or water transport ::,lministration ;
(iY) ................... .
(Y) ........ .° .......... .
(Yi) ................... .
1.__\,) .•.•••.••••••••••••• "
The J-.[ills further rnntended tlut if anv sales tax was
at all payable the same was payable l1\; the Government of Jn,\ia and not bv them. The Commercial
Tax Officer o\'erruk,I both· these obiections an,\ on
the 8th November 1950 he assessed the Mills to sales
tax in respect of the· supplies made by the Mills to
the Government of India under the aforesaid contract an,\ demanded a sum of Rs. 9,401-10-6.
On the 6th December 1950 the Mills filed a petition
under article 226 of the Constitution of India before
the High Court at Calcutta. In the petition the Mills
impkadeJ as n:spondents the Commercial Tax Officer,
the State of West Bengal and the Union of India.
The Mills praved for a writ of m1111dam11.r on the respon,knts to cancel an,l/or reca II :md/or forbear from
acting or giving effect to the demand date,! the 8th
Nm-ember 1950 and from realising tht· sum of Rs.
9,401-10-6 an,\ for a writ of cer!ion1ri for production
of the records and proceedings before the Commercial
Tax Officer an,! for quashing the same and for other
incident:il reliefs. On the same day a rule was issued
on the respondents to show cause why the orders
prayed for should not be made.
The Commercial Tax Officer filed an affidavit m
opposition disputing the contentions put forward by
1955
Tht l,"nim1 ~( ln.Jia
\".
T ht ctmmztrcial
Tax OJfim·, Wes!
Ben~:al and othtrs
Dru Actg. C.].
1080
1955
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
the Mills in support of their claim for exemption and
maintaining that sales tax was due and had been
legitimately assessed and demanded. On behalf of
the Union of India was filed an affidavit affirmed by
Bengal and others one M. P. Pai, the then Joint Secretary in the
Ministry of Works, Production & Supply. It was
D., Actg. C.J.
therein stated that a department of the Government
of India named the Department of Supply came into
existence in the month of September 1939 immediately on the commencement of World War II and
before the enactment of the Bengal Finance (Sales
Tax) Act, 1941 (Bengal Act VI of 1941). It was
averred that before the 7th January 1946 the said Department of Supply was charged with the procurement of Stores from all places In India including
Bengal and that it also directed the work of Indian
Stores Department in the United Kin~dom and of the
India
Supply Mission in the United States of
America. It was added that by Resolution No.
227/45-Pub(c) dated the 31st December 1945 the Governor-General in Council announced the creation with
effect from the 7th January 1946 of the Department
of Industries & Supply in place of the existing Department of Supply and of Industries and Civil Supplies. It was claimed that the powers and functions
of the Department of Industries and Supplies were
the same as those of the Department of Supply and
that there was no variation in the nature of the said
functions whatsoever.
The rule came up for hearing before Bose, J., who
took the view that the newly created Department of
Industries & Supplies was charged with the same
work of procurement of stores for Government as had
been entrusted to the Department of Supply and·
certain additional works and that later on the name
was again changed to Ministry of Industry and
Supply. The learned Judge pointed out that although
there was a change in the designation of the Indian
Stores Department and the Supply Department of
the Government of India, section. 5(2) (a)(iii) was not
amended in any way until 1949 ·when by an amending Act (West Bengal Act X of 1949) the exemption
Tiu Union of India
v.
Th1 Comm"cial
T 6't Officer, Wtsl
2 S.C.:R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1081
granted under section 5(2)(a)(iii) was withdrawn.
The learned Judge appears to have regarded this continuance of section 5(2)(a) (iii) in the Bengal Finance
(Sales Tax) Act, 1941 as indicative of the fact that
in view of the State of West Bengal the Ministry of
Industry & Supply was the same as the Indian Stores
Department and the Supply Department of the Government of India referred to in the section. The
learned Judge accordingly held that the Mills were
entitled to the benefit of the exemption and were not
liable to pay sales tax in respect of the supplies in
question. He accordingly, on the 3rd January 1952,
made the rule absolute.
The Commercial Tax Officer and the State of West
Bengal went up on appeal from the said judgment
and order of Bose, J. The appeal came up fot hearing
before a Bench consisting of K. C. Das Gupta, J. and
P. N. Mookerjee, J. In separate but concurring judgments both the learned Judges rejected the preliminary objection taken by the Mills and the Union of
India as to the maintainability of the appeal. On the
merits both of them held that the Department of
Industries & Supplies was not the same as the Indian
Stores · Department or the Supply Department of
the Government of India. The old departments
ceased to exist and a new department combining some
of the functions of these departments and some new
functions was created and that, therefore, sales to
the newly created department could not be deducted
from the taxable turnover under section 5(2)(a)(iii).
In the result, the Appeal Court allowed the appeal
with costs, set aside the order of Bose, J. and dismissed the application of the Mills under Article 226.
The Mills as well as the Union of India have now
come up on appeal before us with a certificate of fitness granted by the High Court.
In view of the• decision of this Court in National
Sewing Thread Co. Ltd. v. fames Chadwick & Bros.
Ltd.( ), the question of maintainability of the appeal
before the High Court has not been raised before us.
The appeals have been fought out on the merits only.
(I) [1953] S. C.R. 1028.
1955
T!.. Union of lrulia
v.
Thi Commercial
Tax Ojjicer, W tsl
Bengal and ot/urs
D1J1 Aclg. C. J.
'. \. "
lOSi
. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
. [1955]
The appeals came: up before this·. Court for hearing
on the 22nd and -_ 23rd September 1955: After going
The c~ _.through the r~cords ·.it-was • felt that the materials on
Tax Off~"• w,, 1 record were not sufficient to enable the Court to· deBmgal. mu! ot"4rs c_ termine . tlie .real •point - of · controversy ' between the
Das A-;;:C.-j• . \parties.-· The appeals were accordingly adjourned and
directions were· - given for the filing of sup_plementary
affidavits· ·,setting . out the facts relied on by the parties
·
respectively•. -Fresh affidavits have since been filed.
It . appears from the affidavit of· · one - A. R. Iyer,
Deputy· · . Director, Directorate ' General of Supplies
and Disposals, under the Ministry of Works, Housing
& Supply, that in 1918 a department called · the Contracts Directorate had been - constituted · as _ a purchasing organisation ·for the needs of the Army. : With
effect from - the -lst January 1922 the Indian ·stores
· Department ..was constituted . as - a result of .the recommendations of the Stores Purchase Committee. The
functions of this department were to" act as a purchasing and inspection agency .in. respect of -. certain
commodities including textile goods for· ~ll Central
departments and minor Local · Governments and such
other authorities as might desire to avail themselves
of the services of this · department. · Annexure III to
the ~davi.t _of Iyer indicates that it was not obligatory - on the · other departments to inake purchases
through • the Indian s;ores Department. Originally
this department . was constituted for a period of two
years but by Resolution No. S. 217 of the Government of India, dated the 6th May 1924, · -it was placed
on a permanent basis and continued to discharge the
-same functions. Rules 5 and 6 -attached to this Resolution -. show that purchases could - also be made
' locally. by other departments in case of emergency or
.
for convenience.
- _
- In 1939 when the outbreak of World War II was
depart. -. - -- - imminent the necessity for- creating -a
ment was keenly felt and the Governor-General in
Council _ by a. Resolution:· of the-- Home Department
dated the 26th August 1939 (Annexure V to Iycr's
affidavit) announced the creation from that date of a
department of Supply "to deal directly with ques1955
Th• Union ,j India
new
)
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1083
tions concerning supplies of all kinds required for
the prosecution of war".
Annexure VIII to Iyer's
affidavit shows that the control of the Indian Stores
Department and all other matters relating to the
purchase of stores in India which were being then
dealt with in the Department of Commerce were to
be dealt with in the department Supply as a temporary measure for the duration of the war. That
the Indian Stores
Department and the Contracts
Directorate did not lose their identity, is shown by
the Office Memorandum dated the 3rd August 1940
(Annexure X,
Clause 4) and Office Memorandum
dated the 2nd December 1941 (Annexure XI, Clause
1(a) and Clause 4). It is thus clear that up to the
end of the year 1940 purchases used to be made for
and on account of the Government of India by the
Contracts Directorate, the Indian Stores Department
and the Department of Supply and that purchases
were also made locally by other departments.
It was
then that on the 1st July 1941 the Bengal Legislature
passed the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941
which by section 5(2) (a)(iii) exempted sales to the
Indian Stores Department, the Supply Department
of the Government of India and any railway or water
transport administration from
sales
tax. Sales to
other departments of the Government of India were
not so exempted.
By a Press Note dated the 2nd September 1941
issued by the Government of India in the Supply
Department (Annexure XIII to Iyer's affidavit) a
purchase branch of the Supply Department for the
duration of the war was created with effect from the
1st August 1941 and it shows that the Contracts
Directorate and the Indian Stores Department had
then "ceased to exist as separate entities" for the
duration of the war and a new branch was being organised in their place.
Then came the Office Memorandum dated the
23rd December 1941 issued by the Government of
India in the Department of Supply (Annexure XIV)
which superseded the previous office memorandum
dated the 13th December 1940 (Annexure XII). The
14-85 s. C. lndia/59
1955
The Union of India
v.
The Commercial
Tax Officer, West
Bengal and others
Das Actg. C. J.
1084
195.'l
Tiu Union o.( Indict
v.
The Comm<"r..ial
T°'" Offeer, Jl'e.rt
Bengal and
ffthl'rs
Das A~·t_i;. (.'. J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
r1955J
authorities under the Central Governmellt concerned
with the production, manufacture and p_urchase of
supplies were shown in Statement I annexed thereto.
is clearly mentioned therein that departments
It
other than the ones referred to therein were and, in
the absence of orders to the contrary, would remain
independent of the department though working in
close touch with it (Clause 3). Powers of local purchase were also not disturbed in any way (Clause 4).
Statement I indicates that purchases of various supplies, e.g., medical and veterinary supplies, coal and
coke for Railway and other civil and military authont1es in India, etc., and Printing and Stationery
stores, were independent of the Supply Department.
It is thus clear that the Indian Stores Department
and the Supply Department of the Government of
India were not the only departments which had authority to make purchases for and on behalf of the Government of India in its various departments.
On the 21st April 1943 came Notification No. 2rBNo. 107/43-Pub(c) whereby the Governor-Gcnrral in Council announced the creation, from the 22nd
April 1943, of a Department of Industries and Civil
Supplies to deal with (i) Statistics and Research, (ii)
Development and (iii) Controls.
Shortly thereafter
Office Memorandum No. E4(179) dated the 14th May
1943 issued by the Department of Supply intimated
that the Governor-General in Council had decided
that the Department of Industries and Civil Supplies
would, with effect from the 15th May 1943, take over
responsibility for the procurement of cotton textiles
and cotton textile stores (Annexure XVI to Iyer's
affidavit). So this Department of Industries and Civil
Supplies became another purchasing organisation of
the Government of India apart from the Department
of Supply.
The Government of India Resolution dated the 31st
December 1945 announced the creation, with effect
from the 7th January 1946, of the Department of
Industries and Supplies in place of the existing Department of Supply and the Department of Industries
and Civil Supplies. By this Resolution the Indian
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1085
Stores Department
and the
Contracts Directorate
which during the war had been brought under the
Supply Department, were incorporated in the newly
created department. It will be noticed that this newly
<:reated department had assigned to it the work of the
procurement of stores for the Government of India
which was formerly assigned to the Department of
Supply and the Department of Industries and Civil
Supplies. In addition to these duties this department
was authorised also to deal with other things, namely,
development of industries, administration of Government factories not allocated to specialised departments, Disposals of Surplus and Civil Supplies. The
nature and volume of the purchases made by this
newly created department became obviously different
from and larger than those of the two departments it
replaced. It is also noteworthy that the Department
of Supply which was created for the prosecution of
war was abolished as soon as the war was over (Annexure XVII to the affidavit of Iyer).
The Resolution of the Government of India dated
the 2nd September 1947 published in the Gazette of
India
dated the 6th September 1947 (Annexure
XVIII) announced, amongst other things, that with
effect from the 29th August 1947 the Department of
Industries and Supplies would be re-designated as
.the Ministry of Industries and Supply.
From the summary of the annexures to the affidavit
of Iyer filed in these proceedings it is quite clear that
while the Ministry of Industries and Supply was a
new designation of the Department of Industries and
Supplies, the Department of Industries and Supplies
cannot be regarded merely as a new designation of
the Department of Supply and the Department of
Industries and Civil Supplies. Indeed, the Resolution announced the "creation" of the Department of
Industries and Supplies in place of the two existing
departments mentioned above. This newly created
department had wider powers and was a new department altogether. The exemption granted by the
Bengal Finance (Sales-Tax) Act, 1941 was given to
two departments by name. It was not given to the
1955
The Union of India
v.
The Commercial
Tax Oificer, West
Bengal and others
Dar Aclg. C. ].
•,\
1086
·. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19551
.-·-
sales to· ilie·. Government 'of India in alh itS' departments. It is true that the Indian Stores· ·Department
and the ·Supply ·Department of the Govetnment of
o.ou:':'"W,,, . India were not corporate bodies but. they evidently
Bengal and •thtrs - were . sufficiently well defined
organisations to be
Das Jct&· C.J \ . referred to as. "entities" in some of the· Press Notes
and Resolutions mentioned above and even· in the
affidavits filed .. in· these. proceedings. Further, the
Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941 . by section· 5
(2)(a)(iii) certainly dealt with these two departments
as if they were distinct entities. · The Act, in a
manner, conferred ' on these . two departments the
status, as it were, of well defined and distinct entities
at least for the purposes of that Act, namely for
making sales to them exempt from the tax.. If it were
the object of the Bengal Legislature to give exemption to all sales to all departments of the Government
of India it would ·have been quite easy · for it to frame
sub-clause (iii) in a general way as sub-clause (iv)
had been framed. Further,· if sales · to these two
departments were to be regarded as covering sales to
·all departments of the Government of India then the
sales to the Railways which at that time mostly, if
not wholly, belonged to the Government of India
·need not have been separately mentioned in _the way
it · has been in sub-clause (iii). As - already stated,
there were, at the date when the Act was passed,
various other departments of the Government of
India which were concerned with purchase of stores
but quite dearly t)le exemption conferred by the
section was not intended to extend to the sales to
those departments. Therefore, the reference ·to these
two . particular departments in the section cannot
·possibly be read as a reference to the Government of
India generally.
·
It has · been urged that the real object of section
5(2)(a)(iii) was to give exemption not to the parti·cu1ar departments but to the sales of such goods as,
. at the date of the Act, used to -be made to those de,
partments ·and, therefore, sales · of those goods made
to any department of the Government of India which
came to be charged with the duty of purchasing those
1955
Th4 U•ionofl•dia
.
TM
1
Tax
c:· .
·-
+
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1087
goods should also come within the purview of the
section and be entitled to the benefit of the exemption conferred by it. We are unable to accept this
line of reasoning. This
interpretation will unduly
narrow the scope and ambit of the exemption by limiting it to sales of only those goods as, at the date of
the Act, used to be sold to those two departments
and sales of other goods even to those two department',, however necessary for the prosecution of the
war, would not get the benefit of the exemption. Such
could not possibly be the intention of the legislature
as fxpressed by the language med by it in framing·
the section. According to the section the exemption
is given to all sales made to those two deparunents,
no matter whether the sales were only of the kind of
goods which used to be sold to them at the date of
the Act or of other kinds of goods. The suggested
interpretation involves
the addition of
qualifying
words to the section which ordinarily it is not permissible for the court to do. Further, the press notes
and the resolutions of the Government of India summarised above clearly indicate that there were other
purchasing departments which were independent of
the Indian Stores Department or the Supply Department of the Government of India and that the authority of other departments of making local purchases
was not interfered with by t~e creation of these · two
departments. Therefore it may well have been that,
at the date of the passing of the Act, same or similar
kinds of goods used to be sold to these two departments as well as to other departments but surely it
cannot be contended, in view of the language of the
section, that the exemption was intended to extend
to the sales of the same or similar kinds of
goods to those other departments also. It is not
necessary for us to pronounce any opinion as to the
validity or soundness of the extreme position taken
up by the learned Advocate-General of West Bengal
namely _that as the exemption is given by a statute to
sales made to two departments eo nomine it will not
extend to sales made to the same department redesignated by a new name. It is enough for our present
1955
The Union of lndi•
v.
The CommtrciaJ
Ta, Ojf1ur, w,.i
&ngal and olhm
Da< A<tg. C.J.
1088
1955
Tht Union of India
v.
The Commtrcial
Tax Olficer, We.\'t
Bengal and others
Das Artg. C.J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955}
purpose to say that the Department of Industries
and Supplies which was subsequently re-designated
·as the Ministry of Industries and Supply was not the
same as the Indian Stores Department or the Supply
Department of the Government of India under a different name. The scope and volume of the work entrusted to the Department of Industries and Supplies
was much wider and larger than that with· which the
two departments which it replaced had been charged.
Unlike those of the two departments, its purchases
were not confined to goods necessary for the prq_secution of the war. To extend the benefit of the statutory exemption to the sales made to the newly created
department of Industries and Supplies, of goods not
required for war purposes but, say, for meeting international obligations as in the present case, will necessarily widen the scope of the exemption and impose
greater loss of revenue on the State of West Bengal
than what the Act by its language intends to do. In
view of the ever expanding activities of the modern
welfare State in different fields including that of trade
and commerce, the Government departments are
often entrusted with the performance of well defined
activities and are authorised to deal with the outside
world and to enter into contracts of sale and purchase
and other transactions in the same way as an ordinary person or company may do. Such Government
departments, therefore, may well be regarded as distinct units or quasi legal entities, at least for the
particular purposes for which they are created. At
any rate, the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941 by
providing for the deduction of the sales to the two
named departments from the taxable turnover certainly treated those two departments as distinct
entities. This exemption is the creation of the statute
and must be construed strictly and cannot be extended to sales to other departments. The fact that
the section was not amended until 1949 does not at all
indicate that the Bengal Legislature intended to extend the benefit of the section to any but the departments specifically mentioned in the section. In our
opinion the conclusion arrived at by the Appeal
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1089
Court, namely that the sales tax is payable on the
sale in question is correct and these appeals must be
dismissed with costs.
S1NHA J.-I regret to have to differ from my learndetermination of the only quesed brethren in the
tion involved in these appeals, namely, . whether the
sales by the appellant in Civil Appeal No. 10 of
1954 (Messrs Shrcc Ganesh Jute Mills Ltd.) to the
appellant in Civil Appeal No. 9 of 1954, the Union of
India (the Government of India at the time of the
transactions in question) were liable to payment of
<,a]es tax under the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act,
1941 (Bengal Act VI of 1941), to be referred to hereinafter as " The Act".
The farn leading up to these appeals may shortly
be stated as follows : The Government of India in the
Ministry of Industry and Supply (which for the sake
of brevity may be called "The Government" entered
into a contract on the 1st September 1948 with Messrs
Shree Gane<,h Jute Mills Ltd., which may be designated "The Mills", for the supply of hessian at certain rates and of certain
description appearing in
Exhibit A to the affidavit filed on behalf of the Mills.
With reference to the question of sales tax the
contract contains the following stipulation :"The prices shown above are exclusive of the
Bengal Sales Tax. The Government of India will
arrange direct payment of sales tax to the Government of Wt'>t Bengal if it is ultimately found that
sales tax is payable in respect of this contract".
It is also provided that "This contract will be governc:.d by the conditions of contract specified in Form
WSB. 133 as amended up to date". This contract
was entered into and '>igned by "A Huq, Deputy
Director of Supplies, for and on behalf of the Governor-General of India". In pursuance of the aforesaid
contract the Mills rnpplied hessian goods to the Government of India of a certain valuation on which the
:~ommercial Tax Officer of Bengal, the main contesting respondent, made a demand of Rs. 9,401-10-6 as
.sales tax from the Mills.
The Mills demurred to the
Tht~Union of
\'.
India
'f ht Commtrcial
Tax Ojfuu, Wt>I
Bl!ngal ari.rl othtrJ
Do• Actg. C.J.
1090
1955
The U11io11 of India
v
The CfJmmercial
Tax O.fficer, H'est
IJengal and others
Sinha].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
payment and contended that the sales in questjon
were exempt from payment of the sales tax demanded in view of the provisions of section 5(2)(a)(iii) of
the Act. Eventually the Mills moved the High Court
of Calcutta for an appropriate writ under article 226 of
the Constitution against the contesting respondents.
The matter was heard by a Single Judge of that Court
who by his judgment dated the 6th December 1951
held that the Mills were not liable to pay the sales
tax demanded and cancelled the notice of demand
and directed the respondents 1 and 2 to forbear from
enforcing the demand. Respondents 1 and 2 went
up in appeal under the Letters Patent. The appeal
was heard by a Division Bench which came to the
contrary conclusion. The major portion of the judgment of the Letters Patent Bench was devoted to the
discussion of the question whether the judgment of
the learned Single Judge in the writ matter was
amenable to the
appellate jurisdiction
under the
Letters Patent. That question has not been pressed
during the arguments and is therefore no more in
controversy. The only question that was canvassed
before us was the applicability of section 5(2) (a) (iii)
of the Act which contains the exemption, the benefit
of which is being sought by the appellants in each
case. The exemption is in these terms :"Sales to the Indian Stores Department, the
Supply Di'partment of the Government of India, and
any railway or water transport administration".
It has been contended on behalf of the appellants
that the sale of hessian by the Mills to the Government of India in the Ministry of Industry and Supply
is within the terms of the exemption quoted above.
On the other hand, it is contended on behalf of the
Sales Tax Department of the Government of \Vest
Bengal that the sales in question were not covered by
the aforesaid exemption clause. It is therefore necessary to go into some detail of the formation and
development of the Department in question.
The supplementary affidavit filed on behalf of the
Government and sworn to by Shri A. R. Iyer, Deputy
of Supplies &
Director of
Directorate
General
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1091
Disposals, discloses the following facts. The Indian
Stores Department was constituted with effect from
the 1st January 1922 as a result of the recommendations of the Stores Purchase Committee which had
been constituted by the Government of India to examine the whole question of the constitution of an expert agency to carry out on a large scale purchase of
supplies required for the public services, as recommended by the Indian Industrial Commission, with
the object of encouraging the purchase · of articles
made in India for Government requirements.
The
scope and functions of the Department, inter alia,
were to act as a purchasing and inspection agency,
and in an advisory capacity in all matters connected
with the purchase of stores fqr the public services, on
behalf of all Central Departments of the Government
and of the minor local Governme11ts and also on behalf of such major local Governments, Companyworked Railways, Corporations, Port Trusts, Municipalities and quasi public bodies and Indian States as
might desire to avail themselves of the Department's
assistance. The activities of the Department consisted
in the purchase and inspection in India of a large
variety of goods and articles including "textile goods",
so that the purchase of hessian which is the particular
commodity involved in this case, would be included
in the activities of the Department. The Department
had been constituted in the first instance for a period
of two years. But by a Resolution of the Government of India dated the 6th May 1924 it was placed
on a permanent basis. It continued to discharge the
same functions as before. It made purchases not only
for the needs of the civilian departments of the Government of India but also of all the requirements of
the Army. Hessian which had been purchased from
the Mills in this case was one of the products which
the Government of India used to purchase only
through the Indian Stores Department whenever
needed for Government purposes. A Department called
the "Contracts Directorate" had been constituted in
1918 as a purchasing organization for the needs of the
Army. But after the constitution of the Indian
1955
The Uni.on of India
v.
Thi Commercial
Tax Officer, Wtst
Bengal and others
Sinha J.
1092
1955
The (/nifJn qf India
v;
TM Commtrcial
1·ax O.fficer, WtJl
IJ~ngal and r1lhtn
Sinha J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
Stores Department in 1922 the Army authorities alsr>
began to utilize the services of the Indian Stores Department for procurement of several categories of
stores required by them. By a Resolution of the
Home Department dated the · 26th August 1939, apparently to meet the demands of the imminent second
world war, the Contracts Directorate and the Indian
Stores Department were in· 1940. amalgamated with
the Department of Supply so that in 1941, when the
Act was passed, the ·position was that the Department of Supply as reorganized on the 3rd August 1940
included
amongst its activities
and functions the
purchase of stores for the needs of the Government.
This branch of its activity was administered by the
Directorate General, Supply Branch, located at New
Delhi. Jute products and textiles including hessian
had to be purchased only by placing. indents by the
department concerned with the Directorate General
of Supply, New Delhi. Thus this Department absorbed for the duration of the war the purchasing sections of
the Indian
Store's Department and the
Contracts Directorate which were placed under completely
self-contained
organizations empowered
to
procure all supplies, whether for war purposes or
otherwise. All authorities requmng supplies to be
procured in India had to place their indents or
demands on the Directorate General concerned. With
effect from the 1st August 1941 the Contracts Directorate and the Indian Stores Department ceased to exist
as separate entities in the Supply Department and became one purchasing organization in the said Department. This organisation arranged for supply of all
.classes of stores for purposes of Government, such as
textiles, leather goods, etc. Thus hessian which came
under the head of "textiles" which was being purchased in the first instance only by the Indian Stores
Department continued to be purchased by the Supply
Department
when
the Indian Stores Department
came under the control of the Supply Department.
By a notification dated the 21st April· 1943 issued by
the Government of India in the Home Department,
Department
called
the
Industries
and
another
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1093
Civil Supplies Department was created. This Department was primarily concerned with statistics and
research and development of
industries,
as
also
controls on civil supplies (other than foodstuffs).
\Vhen this Department was first created, it had no
purchasing
activity.
But
with effect
from
the
15th May 1943 the Government directed that the new
department should take over responsibility for the
procurement
of cotton textiles and cotton textile
stores which till then were being dealt with by the
Indian Stores Department which later came under
the Supply Department as aforesaid. Purchase of jute
and woollen textiles continued to be the responsibility of the Supply Department. By a Resolution of
the Government of India dated the 31st December
1945 the Department of Industries and Supplies in
place of the existing Departments of Supply and of
Industries and Civil Supplies was created with effect
from the 7th January 1946. From that date the
Department of Industries and Supplies became responsible for the procurement of stores from all places
in India in the same manner as the Department of
Supply had been doing previously to its amalgamation with the new Department. The powers and functions of the Department of Industries and Supplies
in the matter of procurement of stores continued as
before. The Department continued to procure and
purchase only the same kinds of articles as the Department of Supply had been doing before the coming
into existence of the Department of Industries and
Supplies so that the creation of the Department of
Industries and Supplies did not make any difference
in its activities relating to purchase of stores. There
was no addition to or subtraction from its functions
in the matter of purchase of stores.
From what has been stated above, it is clear that
the purchasing functions of the Government of India
with special reference to the procurement of textiles
including hessian with which we are immediately concerned were discharged by the Indian Stores Department from 1st January 1922. Those functions were
taken over by the Department of .Supply m 1940.
1955
The L'11ion of lndi,o
''·
T ht Commercial
Tax Offim, Wr.<i
Bmgnl and othrn
Si11ha].
1094
1955
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
The Department of Supply itself merged m the
Tht Union Qf India Department of Industries and Supplies with effect
v.
from the 7th January 1941\. By a notification of the
The Cornrntrcial
2nd September 1947 the Department of Industries
Tax Officer, J.Vest
Btngal and others
and Supplies was redesignate<l as the Ministry of Industry and Supply with effect from the 29th August
Sinha J.
1947 as a result of the emergence of India as an
Independent State. Thus the Ministry of Industry
and Supply is a lineal descendant of the Indian Stores
Department, of course, with an added volume of work
and functions, but the original activity of purchase
of stores remaining the same in bulk and in character.
It has already been noticed that the Indian Stores
Department
was
concerned
with the
function,
amongst others, of purchasing stores of a large variety
of articles and goods on behalf of all Central Departments of the Government of India and Local Governments, Railway Companies, Corporations, Port
Trusts, Municipalities and other quasi public bodies,
as also Indian States if they availed of the services of
the department. Thus
the infant Indian Stores
Department has grown in stature and volume in the
course of the last about 25 years. The same sapling
has grown into a shady tree but its function as the
sole purchasing agency of the Government of India
and other Governments for a large variety of goods
and commodities ·has contiilued. The nomenclature
has undergone successive changes, but the function
of purchasing agency on behalf of the Central and
other Governments and public bodies as aforesaid
has remained the same. Furthermore, the purchase
of hessian, which is the subject-matter of the demand
in question has continued in the same organization,
though under a different name.
It is well settled that the provisions of a statute
have to be construed with reference to the state of
affairs as they existed at the time the statute was
passed. In the year 1941 there was in existence the
Supply Department of the Government of India which
had
incorporated
the
Indian Stores Department.
According to the affidavit referred to above, the main
activities of purchase of
goods
and commodities
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1095
required by the Government of India and other Governments, local bodies, etc., except for · purchases of
small values, that is to say, not exceeding Rs. 100 in
each case and of certain specified commodities, like
foodstuffs, forage, lethal stores, etc. referred to !n
para. 7 of the affidavit (at p. 18 of the supplementary
paper book) were carried on by the Supply Department. That is the reason why the exemption to the
Government of India was worded as it stands in section 5(2)(a)(iii). As stated above, the Supply Department existed as a separate department up to the
6th January 1946. With effect from the 7th January
the Department of Industries & Supplies came into
existence
which
later
was
re-designated as the
Ministry of Industry & Supply. The judgment under
appeal is based chiefly on the consideration that the
exemption clause in question does not in terms refer to
the newly created department which now goes by the
name of the Ministry of Industry & Supply. But
this di:partment in so far as it deals with industry,
is not concerned with the main purchasing activities
of the Government of India. The exemption was
granted in respect of the purchasing activity of the
Government of India and that function continues to
be assigned to the Supply Department which has
now become a wing of the newly created department
of the Government. The question therefore arises
whether in those circumstances the Government of
India could claim the benefit of the exe.mption. The
High Court in answering that question in the negative ha,s gone upon mere nomenclature. It has emphasize1l the
change in the name and overlooked
the sub1;tance of the matter.
After all, what is a Department of a Government ?
It is not a mere name, whatever else it may be. It is
not a person, either natural or artificial. A Department of Government is a particular function. The
Government has so many functions and each of its
functious or a group of functions is placed in charge
of a particular Department which may be made up
of a number of clerks organized in a group, whose
work Is supervised by a hierarchy of officials with
1955
The (. /nion of /ndit;
v.
T ht Commercial
Tax Officer, lf'"est
Bengal and others
Si,,hn ].
1096
1935
'!ht Union of India
v.
T ht Commercial
Ta.-r Offutr, ~Vest
Brngal and others
Sinha].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
the head of the department at the apex. A department may therefore consist of a single function out
of the many functions of the Government, or it may
.comprise several functions placed in charge of a single
departmental head. The Indian Stores Department
which came to be incorporated in the Supply Department of the Government of India and later merged
in the larger Department of the Ministry of Industry
& Supply, could have continued its separate existence
as it did until 1939 or could have become part of a
larger department as it did after the 3rd August
1940, or the 7th January 1946, or the 29th August
1947 ; and conversely, its activities could be split up
into a number of sub-departments under different
heads classified according to the nature of the commodities to be purchased. But, in my opinion, the
change in the nomenclature in either direction should
not matter so long as the function, namely, of purchasing articles and commodities required by the
Government of India and other Governments continued to be the same. It is a matter of substance
and not of form.
The Department concerned cannot be' equated with
a natural person. Nor can it be raised to the level
of a legal person. I am not aware of any principle of
jurisprudence which would justify placing a department of Government on the pedestal of a legal person.
There is no tertium quid between the two positions.
Though tbe High Court has not said so in so many
words, it has treated the department either as a legal
person or as something in between a legal person and
a natural person. That, in my opinion, is not sound
logic. Nor is there any legal basis for treating a
department of Government either as a legal person
or as a natural person. In my view, the terms of s.
5(2) (a) (iii) show that it was an exemption granted to
a particular function of the Government of India
described by a certain name. And one might feel
inclined to exclaim with the great poet Shakespeare
"What is in a name !" It is but a description of the
main purchasing activity of the Government of India,
as the history of the department above set out shows.
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1097
Sometimes the language of a statute has to be construed in a modified form in order to give effect to
the real intentions of the legislature where, as in the
present case, the language is only of a descriptive
nature and not a definitive one. An instance of this
is furnished by the case of Miller v. Salomons( 1 )· In
that case the question arose whether a person of
Jewish persuasion who was returned to Parliament
as a Member of the House of Commons was entitled
to sit without taking the prescribed oath. The form
of the oath as given by 6 Geo. 3, c. 53, mentioned
the name of "King George" only. It was argued on
behalf of that member that the oath was confined to
.the name of a sovereign who bore that name. But it
was held by the Court that it was a mere description
and that the intention of the statute was to include
all sovereigns who came after King George III. The
relevant portion of the observations of the Court are
in these terms :
"The second question arising on the construction
of the Act is, whether, as the form of the oath given
by the 6 Geo. 3, c. 53, mentions the name of King
George only, the obligation to administer it ceased
with the reign of that Sovereign, because it was
applicable to no other than to him. I think this argument cannot prevail. It is clear that the legislature
meant the both to be taken always thereafter, for
the enactment is general-that it shall be taken without limit of time-and the oath is not confined to
the existing monarch, but mentions 'the successors' ;
and as it could not be taken in those words during
the reign of a Sovereign not of the name of George,
it follows that the name George is merely used by
way of designating the existing Sovereign ; and the
oath must be altered from time to time in the name
of the Sovereign, iq the manner it was when actually
administered in this case, in order to carry the obvious meaning of the enactment into effect. This is an
instance in which the language of the legislature must
be modified, in order to avoid absurdity and inconsistency with its manifest intentions".
(]) [1852] 7 Exch~quer 475: 155 E.R. 1036, 1068.
1955
The C.:nion of India
'"
The Commercial
Tax Officer, West
Bengal and others
Sinha .J.
1098
1955
The Union of India
v.
Tht Commercial
Tax Offiar, VVtJt
Bengal and others
Sinh11}.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
The High Court referred to the observation of
Lord Halsbury in the case of Commissioners of Inland
Revenue v. Forrest(!) to the effect that exemptions
from taxation should be strictly construed because
otherwise the burden of taxation will fall on other
members of the community. Those observations, in
my opinion, have no relevance to the facts and circumstances of the present controversy, because we
know that the exemption was granted to the Government of India in the department dealing with
purchase of certain commodities and articles without reference to quantity. As already pointed out,
the Indian Stores Department was concerned with
purchase of stores for public services on behalf of all
Central Departments of Government and local Governments, etc., and the Government of Bengal as
then constituted was one of the Provinces of India
which have been receiving subsidies and subventions
to make up the deficit in their budget~. As a matter
of fact, as stated on behalf of the Bengal Government the concesswn was granted in order to enable
business communities within the Province of Bengal
to compete on favourable terms with others outside
Bengal in the matter of supplying the needs of the
Government. Hence there is no question of liberal
construction of the exemption resulting in throwing
a greater burden on other citizens. On the other
hand, the larger the sales in the Province of Bengal
2s it used to be, the greater the benefit to the bminess community doing business within that Province.
It -was therefore stated at the Bar that though the
present case involved taxes amounting to less than
Rs. 10,000, the question
arising for · determination
in this case affected much larger amounts because
such sales within the Province amounted to several
crores. I should have thought that the business community in the Province of Bengal having had the
advantage of the transactions of sale, the Government of Bengal in all fairness should have allowed
the purchasing agency of the Government of India
the benefit of the exemption until that benefit was in
(I) (1890] 15 A.C. 334.
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1099
terms withdrawn some time in the beginning of 1949.
The matter can be looked at from another point of
view also. We are concerned here with the sale of
hcssian. As ,pointed out in the affidavit filed on beof India, the purchase of
half of the Government
hessian has all along been the concern of the Supply
Department, now incorporated in the Ministry of
lndustry & Supply. Sab tax is a tax on sale of goods
and tax on hessians falls :within the contemplation of
the law granting the exemption if the sales were
effecteJ through the purchasing agency of the Government of India. The beneficiary certainly was not
an amorphous body like a department but the Goveniment of India, because it is the Government of
hdia which could be a unit for purposes of the Act.
In this connection our attention was invited to the
last clause of the exemption covered by the words
"and any
Railway or water transport administration". The argument was that if the Government of
India as such was to be the beneficiary, then there
was no necessity for the words just quoted. But this'
argument overlooks the fact that a railway or a
water transport administration need not necessarily
be a department of Government because there were,
and still are, rai~way systems or water transport
systems which are owned and administered by corporate bodies other than the Government of India.
Sales even to those public or semi-public bodies were
within the terms of the exemption. Those words
therefore are
not words of limitation but words
which widen the scope of the exemption in so far as
the same may be available to railways and water
transport administrations not owned and carried on
by the Government of India.
Another reason which may be adduced m answer
to the contention that there was nothing to prevent
the Legislature from stating that the exemption was
granted in respect of all purchases by the Government
of India is that the Indian Stores Department and its
later substitutes had to make purchases not only for
the Government of India but also for local governments and other public bodies. Hence the exemption
15-85 S. C. India/59.
1955
The Union o,( bu!ia
\'
The Commercial
Ta., Officer, We-11
Ben,~al and othen
Sin:.a J.
1100
1955
Tht Union ef India
v.
T Ju Commtrdal
Ta:it Officer, Wesl
Btngal and olhtrs
Sinha ].
SUPREME COURJ' REPORTS
[1955!
in the terms in which it occurs in section 5(2) (a) (iii)
was not an exemption in favour of the Government
of India only but also to other Governments and public bodies which could avail themselves of the facilitv
of purchase through that department.
·
Another argument was urged to meet the appellant's case that really the exemption was meant for the
Government of India in its function of purchase of
stores and
commodities,
discharged through the
Indian Stores Department and
later through the
Supply Department. It was argued that if the legislature meant to grant the exemption to the Government of India, then the easiest thing to do would
have been to say that sales to the Government of
India were exempt from the tax. But it has not been
the contention of the appellant that all sales to the
Government of India are within the terms of the exemption.
Only the sales
transacted through the
purchasing department 9f the Government of India
were so exempt. In para. 7 of the affidavit referred
to above it has been stated on behalf of the Government that the different departments were entitled to
make local purchases of small values, .that is to say,
not exceeding Rs. 100 and of certain specified commodities like foodstuffs which were not within the
purchasing activity of the departments aforesaid of
the Government of India. Hence, in my opinion,
there is no validity in this argument either.
It was also suggested during the argument that if
the exemption were to be related to only such commodities and articles as were within the purview of
the Stores Department and later of the Supply Department, then such an interpretation would involve
addition of qualifying words to the section which is
not ordinarily within the function of the courts. But,
in my opinion, this argument also suffers from the
infirmity that it equates the departments mentioned
in the exemption clause quoted above with a legal
person,-an argument which has already been dealt
with. · 'In my opinion, there is no escape from the
conclusion that those are mere words of description
and are not words with defined connotation, because
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1101
neither the Act nor the rules framed thereunder define
those departments. If the nomenclature only matt·ered, then there is no escape from the conclusion
that whatever articles and commodities were purchased by the Indian Stores Department or its later
substitutes, of whatever magnitude and value, would
be within the mischief of the exemption clause in
question. But that, in my opinion, was not the intention of the framers of the Act. They knew what
the activities of the Government through those departments were and the exemption was granted
only in respect of those functions of the Government,
as already indicated.
1955
The UniMi of l•dia
v.
Tiu CatRmucia
Tax Ojfiar, Wis
B•ngal and othtTJ
Sinha J
For the aforesaid reasons I would allow these appeals, set aside the orders of the Letters Patent Bench
and restore the orders passed by the Single Judge of
the Calcutta High Court, with costs throughout.
BY THE COURT.
in accordance with the Judgment of the majority
the appeals are dismissed with costs.
P. L. LAKHANPAL
1955
v.
D1ctmher 20.
THE STATE OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR.
ls. R. DAS, ACTING C.J.,
BHAGWATI,
DAS, B. P. SINHA and }AFER IMAM
}AGANNADHA-
JJ.]
Constitution of .India, Arts. 13, 21, 22 and 35(c)-/ammu and
Kashmir Preventive Detention Act, 2011 (Act VI of 2011), s. 3(1)
(a )(i) and s. 8(1) Proviscr-Constitution (Application to /am mu and
Kashmi,.) 01·der, 1954-Detention order under the provisions of ss. 3
(J)(a)(i) and 8(1) Proviso of the Act-Whether violates fundamental
.-ights guaranteed under Arts. 21 and 22 of the Constitution-Nonsupply of grounds of detention to Detenu-Whether violates his fundamental right-Addition of clause (c) to Art. 35 of the ConstitutionEffect of.
The petitioner was detained in Kothibagh sub-jail in Srinagar
by the order of Jammu and Kashmir Government under the provisions of s. 3(1)(a) (i) of the Jammu and Kashmir Preventive Deten·
tion Act, 2011.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org