CHANDI PRASAD SINGH versus THE ST ATE OF UTTAR PRADESH.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 7 December 1955 | [1955] 2 S.C.R. 1035 | 1955 INSC 72
Key facts
- Decided
- 7 December 1955
- Bench
- VIVIAN BOSE*, T.L. VENKATARAMA AIYYAR
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 143/1954
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1955] 2 S.C.R. 1035
- Neutral citation
- 1955 INSC 72
Text of the judgment
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1035
CHAND! PRASAD SINGH
1955
v.
Dee1mber7.
THE ST ATE OF UTT AR PRADESH.
[VIVIAN Bos£ and VENKATARAMA AYYAR JJ.]
Trial before Sessions Tudge for an offence under s. 409, l.P.l.
with the aid of asses;·ors for misappropriating certain sums of money
from three different persons-Received by appellant as Secretary of a
Company-And for an offence under s. 477-A, l.P.C. for falsifyi11t a
minute book-With the aid of Turv-Same persons acting as assessors
and iurors-V~rdict of not guilty in respect of both charges-Disagreement with verdict of jury under s. 477-A and reference to the
High Court under s. 307 of the Code of Criminal Procedure-Dis11greement with the opinion of assessors under s. 409 and conviction of
accused-Appeal to the High Court-Appeal and reference both heard
together and disposed of by one judgment by High Court-Sessions
Tudge whether contravened any provision of law or committed illegality in acttnf!; as he did-Appellant's status-Whether that of a servant 01· tnat of an age11t--S::.'·11ant and agent-Distinction betweenAppellant charged with three offences under s. 409, l.P.C. and one offence under s. 477-A; l.P.C.-Whether contravention of s. 234 of the
Code of Criminal Procedurc-S. 255 of the Code of Criminal Procedure-Applicability of.
The appellant was tried bv the Sessions Judge with the aid of
assessors tor an offence under s. 409, I.P.C. for misappropriating certain sums of money recei·;ed as promoter of a Company from three
different persons for the purpose of allotment of shares and omitted
to be brought into the Company after it was formed, and also for an
oflence under s. 477-A, I.P.C. by the same Sessions Judge with the
aid of a jury for the offence of falsifying a minute hook, the same
persons acting both as assessors and jurors. They rc~urned a ve1 Jict
of not guilty in respect of both the charges. The Sessions Judge, disagreeing with the verdict of the jury under s. 477-A, referred the
matter to the High Court under s. 307 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. .Disagreeing also with the opinion of the assessors in respect
of the charge under s. 409, I.P.C. he held the appellant guilty and
sentenced him to 4 years' regorous imprisonment. Against this conviction the appellant appealed to the High Court. Both the reference
under s. 307 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the appeal were
heard togethef by the High Court. which confirmed the appellant's
conviction under s. 409 and the sePtence passed by the Sessions
Judge and disagreeing with the veidict of the jury it held him guilty
under s. 477-A and sentenced him to two years' rigorous imprisonment. Oil appeal by special leave to the Supreme Court :- Held (i) that the contention that when the Sessions Judge disagreed with the verdict of the jury and the opinion ot the assessors,
l l-3'i S. C. Ind a/59
1036
1955
Ci1a:1di PrastSd
Singh
v.
Ti1t State of
Uttar Prad•sh
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1955 i
he shoul<l have referred the \Vhole case under s. 301 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure to the High Co!1rt and not merely that part ot
it \\'hich related to the charge under s. 477-A, l.P.C. was without
force because the Sessions judge had contravened no provision of
law and committed no illegality in deciding the case which related
to the charge under s. 409, l.P.C. That s. 307, Code of Criminal Pmcedure appiies in terms only to trials by a jury and the Sessions
Judge had no po\ver under that section to refer cases tried with the
aid of a:;sessors for the decision ot the High Court. In the present
case there \VJS the further fact that both the appeal against the conviction under s. 409, LP.C. and the r:.:ference under s. 307 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure in n::spect of the charge under s. 477-A WC'I?
disposed of by the same judgment ;
(ii) that the contention that the appellant's true status was
that of a serv;.i.nt and not that of= an agent and that he should have
been tried not under s. 409, l.P.C. but under s. 408, I.P.C. ·was also
without force inasmuch as his status \Vas that of an agent and not
that of a servant in view of his duties as Secretary of the Society.
The distinction betv:een the t\VO is this a s~rvant acts under the
direct control and supervision of the master, and is bound to conform to all reasonable orders given to him in the course of his work
.. An agent though bound to exen·ise his authority in accordance
with all lawful instruction~ \.Vhich may be given to him from time
to time by his princip:ii, is not subject in its exercise to the direct
control or supervision of the principal ;
(iii) that the contention that there h1-::. been violation of s. 234
of the Cod.: of c:riminal Procedure ir. that the appellant had been
charged with three offcn..:es under s. 409i l.P.C. and one under s.
477-A was also \vithout force as the case was governed by s. 235 ot
the Co<lc 0£ Criminal Pru;:edure as the several offences under s. 409,
I.P.C. and s. 477-A, 1.P.C. <irose out of th~ same acts and formed
part of the san1e transaction.
EmpEror v. Haria Dhobi, (A.LR. \937 Patna 662), Pachaimuthu
In 1·e, ([1932] l.L.R. 55 Ma<l. 715), Emperor v. Lachrnan Gangota,
(A.LR. 1934 Patna 424), Emperor v. Kalidas ([1898] 8 Born. L.R.
599), Emperor v. Vyankat Sing {fl907] 9 Born. L.R. 1057) and
Emperor v. Chanbasappa (A.LR. 1932 Born. 61), referred to.
CRIMINAL
APPELLATE
JURISDICTION :
Criminal
Appeal No. 143 of 1954.
On appeal by leave from the judgment and order
dated ·the 23rd March 1954 of the Allahabad High
Court (Lucknow Bench) in Criminal Appeal No. 112
of 1953 connected with Criminal Reference Register
No. 15 of 1953 arising out of the judgment and order
dated the 24th February 1953 in Sessions Trial No. 5
of 1952 of the Sessions Court at Lucknow.
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1037
B. B. Tawakley, (K. P. Gupta and A. D. Mathur
with him) for the appellant.
S. P. Sinha (K. B. Asthana and C. P. Lal with
him) for the respondent.
1955. December 7. The Judgment of the Court
was delivered by
VENKATARAMA AYYAR J.-This is an appeal by
special leave against the judgment of the High Court
of Allahabad affirming the conviction of the appel1:1.nt by the Sessions Judge, Lucknow under sections
409 and 477-A of the Indian Penal Code.
On 12-2-1949 a Society known as the Model Town
Co-operative Housing Society, Ltd., was register.~d
under the provisions of the Co-operatiYe S'J<.:ieties
Act (II of 1912), its object being to acquire vacant
sites in the town of Lucknow and to al\ot them to its
members so as to enable them to build houses of their
own. The appellant. was the chief promoter thereof,
and collected monies from prospective shareholders
by way of share money. The first general body meeting of the :Society was held on 1-3-1949. At that
meeting, the · appellant was elected Honorary Secretary and one Sri Munna Lal Tewari as Treasurer. The
latter having resigned, one S. C. Varma was appointed
Treasurer in his stead. On 22-4-1949, there was a
meeting of the Managing Committee, at which the
appellant was directed to hand over the accounts of
the Society and its funds to its Treasurer. The appellant gave a list of 38 persons as members of the
Society, delivery cheques issued by 13 of them as
their share money, and paid a sum of Rs. 3,500 being
the amount stated to have been received by him from
the other 25 members as share money. The Society
did not function thereafter.
On 16-7-1949 some of the members wrote a letter to
the Registrar of Co-operative Societies pointing out
that the Society had not functioned ever since its
incorporation, and asking that steps might be taken
for examination of its accounts and, if necessary, for
its being wound up. On this, there was an investigation of the affairs of the Society by two Assistant
1955
Chandi Prasad
Singh
v.
The Stat. of
U tlar Pradtsli
1038
1955
Chandi Pra5od
Si1ish
v.
The State of
Uttar Pradesh
Vrnkatarama
Ayyar ].
SUPREME COURT .REPORTS
[1955]
Registrars, and on the basis of their reports dated
22-2-1950 and 18-5-1950 the present prosecution was
started against the appellant charging him under sections 409 and 477-A of the Indian Penal Code. The
charge under section 409 was that he had received a
sum of Rs. 500 from one Sri Chaturvedi, a sum of
Rs. 100 from Dr. 0. P. Bhanti and another sum of
Rs. 100 from Dr. R. S. Seth, all as share money in
December 1948, and that he had misappropriated the
same. The charge under section 477-A was that on
22-4-1949 the appellant acting as the Secretary of the
Society falsified the minute book, Exhibit P-18, by
omitting to show therein the share money received
from the three persons above mentioned. The defence of the appellant: was that the three amounts
aforesaid were paid to him not as prospective Secretary for the purpose of allotment of shares, but were
deposited with him in his individual capacity for purchasing shares, in case the Society worked well.
The trial of the offence under section 409 was held
with the aid of assessors and that under section
477-A with the aid of a jury, the same persons acting both as assessors and jurors, and they returned a
verdict of not guilty with reference to the charges
under both the sections. The Sessions Judge, disagreeing with the verdict of the jury under section
477-A, referred the matter to the High Court under
section 307 of the Code · of Criminal Procedure. He
also disagreed with the opinion of the assessors with
reference to the charge under section 409, and held
that the appellant: was guilty and sentenced him to
four years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs.
1,000. Against this conviction, the appellant preferred
an appeal to the High Court. Both the reference under
section 307 and the appeal were heard together by
the High Court, which agreed with the Sessions Judge
that the appellant had received the three amounts as
share money and in his capacity as Secretary, and
accordingly confirmed his conviction under section
409 ahd the sentence passed by the Sessions Judge.
Disagreeing with the verdict of the jury, it also held
him guilty under section 477-A and sentenced him to
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1039
two years' rigorous imprisonment. The present appeal by special leave is directed av,ainst this judgment.
Mr. Taw2,kley firstly contended that the finding of
the courts below that the amounts paid by Sri Chaturvedi, Dr. Bhanti and Dr. Seth were paid :is share
money was erroneous, and in support of this contention relied on a letter written by one of them, Dr.
Seth, to 'the appellant on 3rd May 1951 (Ex. D-5) in
which it was stated that the amount was paid on the
express understanding that if the Society ran, a share
would be allotted to him and otherwise the monev
would be returned. This letter was written long afte~·
proctedings had been taken by the Registrar, and
the courts below did not attach much importance to
it. On the ot!1er hand, Dr. Seth himself gave evidence
in these proceedings which deprives Exhibit D-5 of
very much of its value. Exhibit P-10 is the receipt
gra·;iL· l to Sri Chaturvedi. It expressly recites that
Rs. 500 was received as share monev fm five shares
in the Society. Notices were also is~ued to both Sri
Chaturvedi and Dr. Bhanti to ~lttend the general
body meeting of the Society to be held on 1st March
1949 for electing the President and members of the
Managing Committee of the Society, and Dr. Seth
and Dr. Bhanti actually attended it. Sri Chaturvedi
and Dr. Bhanti have also given evidence that they
paid the amounts only as share capital. The courts
below accepted the above evidence, and held that the
moneys were not paid to the appellant in his individual capacity. There are no grounds for disturbing
that finding in special appeal.
It is now necessary to deal with the several contentions of law urged by Mr. Tawakley in support of
this appeal. His first contention was that when the
Sessions Judge disagreed with the verdict of the jury
and with the opinion of the assessors, he should have
referred the whole case under section 307 for the decision of the High Court and not merely that part
it which related to the charge under section 477-A,
and that his failure to do so vitiated the conviction.
He argued that when the same facts constitute two
or
1955
Chandi Prasad
Singh
v.
The State ef
Uttar .frad;sh
Ve~atarama
4,yyar J.
104-0
1955
Chandi Prasad
Singh
v.
Th£ St,te of
Uttar Pracb.sh
Y enkatarama
Apar J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
distinct offences one of which is triable with the aid
of jurors and the other with assessors, and the accused
is charged with both, the reference under section
307 must relate to both the- charges, if inconsistent
findings by different courts with reference to the
·;ame matter is to be avoided. What would happen,
he asked, if, in the present case, the appellant did
not file an appeal against his conviction U<lder section 409, but the High Court came to the conclusio!\ in the reference under section 307 that Sri
Chaturvedi, Dr. Bhanti and
Dr. Seth did not
pay the amounts to the appellant as share money,
and tlldt no offence had been committed by him under
section 477-A ? The conviction of the appellant under
section 409 based on the finding of the Sessions
Judge that those amounts were paid as share money
would stand, notwithstanding that it would be against
the decision of the High Court. This anomaly could
be avoided, it is argued, by holding that the reference
under section 307 must be of the whole case.
Reliance is placed in support of this contention on
the observations in Emperor v. Haria Dhobi('). We
are unable to agree , with this contention. If the
procedure adopted by the Sessions Judge is to be held
to be illegal, it can only be on the ground that he
contravened some provision of law which requires
him to refer the whole case to the High Court. It is
conceded that the only provision of law dealing with
this matter is section 307. But that section applies
in terms only to trials with the aid of a jury. There
is therefore no power in the Sessions Court to refer
cases tried with the aid of assessors for decision of the
High Court under that section. That was the view
taken in Pachaimuthu In re('), where it was held that
the Assistant Sessions Judge had no jurisdiction to
refer under section 307 the whole case to the High
Court, that he should himself dispose of the charges
which were triable with the aid of assessors, and that
the reference in
respect of those charges was bad,
This decision was followed in Emperor v. Lachman
(1) A. I. R. 1937 Patna 662.
(2) [1932] l. L. R, 55 Mad. 715.
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1041
Gangota(1}. The same view has also been taken by the
1955
High Court of Bombay in a number of cases : Vide
Emperor v. Kalidas( 2 ), Emperor v. Vyankat Singh( 3 )
and Emperor v. Chanbasappa( 4 ). We are accordingly
of opinion that the Sessions Judge had contravened
no provision of law, and had committed no illegality
in deciding the case, in so far as it related to the
charge under section 409, himself. In this case there
is the further fact that the appellant preferred an
appeal against his conviction under section 409 by the
Sessions Judge, and that appeal was heard along with
the reference under section 307 in respect of the charge
under section 477-A, and that they were both of them
disposed of by the same judgment.
It was next contended that the true status of the
appeilant was that of a servant and not of an agent,
and that he should have been charged not under
section 409 but under section 408. The substance of
the charge against the appellant is that as the promotor of a Society he lawfully received the amounts
paid by Sri Ch:nurvedi, Dr. Bhanti and Dr. Seth, but
that after its incorporation, when he failed on
22-4-1949 to hand over those amounts to the Treasurer
aad to include their names as shareholders in the minutes book, he committed offences under sections 409
and- 477-A. Now, what is the status of the appellant
as Secretary of the Society in which capacity he cQmmitted the offences, servant or agent ? The distinction
between the two is thus stated in Halsbury's Laws of
England, Volume 22, page 113, para 192:
"A servant acts under the direct control and
supervision of the master, and is bound to conform to
all rea~onable orders given _him in the course of his
work ...... An agent though bound to exercise his authority in accordance with all lawful instructions which
may be given to him from time to time by his principal, is not subject in its exercise to the direct control
or supervision of the principal".
Having regard to the nature of the duties of the
appellant as the Secretary of the Society, we are clearly
Chandi Prasad
Singh
(3) A. I. R. 1934 Patna 424.
(l) [1907] 9 Bom. L. R. 1057.
(2) [1898] 8 Born. L. R. 599.
(4) A. I. R. 1922 Bom. 61.
v.
The State of
Uttar Prades!t
Venkatarama
Ayyar J.
1042
1955
C/1a·1rli Prasad
Singh
v.
T, 1t State of
1
Uttar Prades:1
Vcnkatarama
Ay;·ar J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
of opinion that his status was that of an agent and
not a servant. Moreover,
whether the
appellant
shouid be charged under section 408 or section 409 is
of no importance in the present case, as the sentence
imposed on him under section 409, viz., ~our years'
rigorous imprisonment could be mairna:Pe<I even
under section 403. It was argued by the appellant
that an offence under section 408 was triable with the
aid of a iury, whereas that under section 409 was
triable with the aid of assessors, and that he had
been prejudiced in that he had lost the benefit of a
tria I by jury. But this objection was not taken in the
trial court, and is not now open. Vide section 536
of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
It is next contended that there has been a violation
of section 234 of the Code of Criminal Procedure in
that the appellant had been charged with three
offences- under section 409 and one under section 477-A.
But the case is Governed by section 235, as the several
offences under sections 409 and 477-A arise out of the
same acts and form part of the same transaction.
Moreover, the appel.lant has failed to show any prejudice as required by section 537. This objection must
accordingly be overruled.
It was finally contended that there had been_no
proper examination of the appellant under section 342,
and that therefore the conviction was illegal. Thio
objection was not raised in the Courts below, and is
sought to be raised in this Court by a supplemental
proceeding. We find no substance in this obiection.
In the result, this · appeal fails and is dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org