STATE OF MADRAS AND ANOTHER versus K.M.RAJAGOPALAN
Supreme Court of India | Decided 27 September 1955 | [1955] 2 S.C.R. 541 | 1955 INSC 45
Key facts
- Decided
- 27 September 1955
- Bench
- VIVIAN BOSE*, NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI, B. JAGANNADHADAS, BHUVNESHWAR PRASAD SINHA, SYED JAFFER IMAM
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 203/1954
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1955] 2 S.C.R. 541
- Neutral citation
- 1955 INSC 45
Text of the judgment
2S,C.lt
SUPREME COUllT REPOR'I'S
541
1!155
and that it invades no fundamental rights of the
Shri Klihan Singli
landlord.
/llUl lllltds
For the reasons given above, we must hold that the
v.
TM Stille ef
scheme embodied in sections 81 to 86 of the Act docs
ilJJJflltltan
not transgress any of the Constitutional limit:rtions,
others
and is valid.
Venkalarama
..tyyar J.
In the result, the petitions are dismissed but in the
circumstances, without costs.
°"'
STATE OF MADRAS AND ANOTHER
v.
K. M. RAJAGOPALAN
[VIVIAN
BosE, BHAGWATI, JAGANNADHADAS,
B. P. SINHA and }AFAR IMAM JJ·]
Indian Independence Act, 1947 (10 and 11 Geo. VI, C. 30)s. 10(2) (a)-The India (Provisional Constitution) Order, 1947Article 7(1)-Inde.pendence, Conferral of-Automatic and legal termination of service-Persons holding civil posts in India-Previous to
Independence-Whether deemed to have been appointed and continue
in service after Independence-Government of India Act, 1935, ss. 240
(2) and 247.
The respondent was recruited to the Indian Civil Service by
open competition in 1936 and joined duty in the Province of Madras
in October 1937. Since then he was serving under the Government
of Madras in various capacities, his last office being Sub-Collector of
Dindigal. He went on leave in June 1947. While on leave he received
a letter from the Government of India asking him whether he was
willing to continue in the service of the Government after the then
contemplated transfer ot power from the British Government to the
Dominion of India on the 15th August, 1947. He sent a reply expressing his willingness to continue in service. On 9th August, 1947
he received a letter from the Government of Madras dated 7th August,
1947 signed by the Chief Secretary thereof stating that it w.as decided not to retaip his services from and after the 15th August, 1947,
and that his services would be terminated with effect from the afternoon of the 14th August, 1947.
The respondent filed a suit against the State of Madras and the
Union of India for a declaration that the order issued by the Chief
Secretary to the Government of· Madras on the 7th August, 1947
purporting to terminate his services was null, void and inoperative
and that he should be deemed to continue in service. The High Court
granted the declaration prayed for accepting the respondent's contention that the order terminating his service was in violation of the
1955
S1pumber27
542
!955
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
statutory guarantee relating to his service under s. 240 of the Government of India Act, 1935 which remained in force till the midnight
of the 14th August, 1947.
T/,. Stale ' ef
Madras and
another
Held, I. The conferral of .Independence on India brought
v.
IL. M. Rajagopalan about an automatic and legal termination of service on the date of
Independence.
Reilly v. The King ([1934 J A.C. 176) and Nokes v. Doncaster
Amalgamated Collieries Ltd., ([1940] A.C. 1014), followed.
2. But all persons previously holding civil posts in India arc
deemed to have been appointed and hence to continue in service, except those governed by "general or special orders or arrangements"
affecting their respective cases: vide Article 7( I) of the India (Provisional Constitution) Order, 1947 read with section !0(2)(a) of the
Indian Independence Act and sections 240(2) and 247 of the Government of India Act as adapted.
3. The guarantee about prior conditions of service and the previous statutory safeguards relating to disciplinary action continue
to apply to those who are thus deemed to continue in service but
not to others.
4. Those previously holding civil posts in India had the right>
and were in fact given the option, of declining to "continue in service" under the new regin1e and in the event of their exercising that
option they ceased to serve on and from the date of the passing of
the Constitution.
5. Equally the new GoYernment had the right to refuse to
continue them in service and intimation of this fact given to persons
ahead of time came into operation and had legal effect from the moment the new Government assumed office on 15-8-1947.
6. As the petitioner was informed that his services would not
be required after 14-8-1947 his services terminated on that date because this was a special order within the meani_qg of Article 7(1) of
the India (Provisional Constitution) Order, 1947.
Accordingly
there was no continuance of service in his case after 14-8-1947
under the deeming provisions of that Order.
La/l's case (1948) F.C.R. 44 West Rand Central Gold Mining
Co. Ltd. v. The King (1905) 2 K.B. 391, Virendra Singh v. The
State of Uttar Pradesh (1955) I S.C.R. 415, Raj Rajendra Malojirao
Shitole v. The State of Madhya Bharat (1954) S.C.R. 748, Ladore v.
Bennett (1939) A.C. 468 and Govindan Sel/appah Nayar Kodakon
Pillai v. Punchi Banda Mudanayake (1953) A.C. 514, referred to.
Crv1L
APPELLATE
Juruso1cTION : Civil Appeal No.
203 of 1954.
On appeal from the Judgment and Order dated
the 30th March 1954 of the Madras High Court in
C. S. No. 216 of 1952.
2 S.C.R.
543
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
M. C. Setalvad, Attorney-General of India, V. K. T.
Chari, Advocate-General of Madras (R. Ganapathy Iyer,
Porus A. Mehta and P. G. Gokhale, with them), for the
appellant.
M. K. Nambiar (C. V. L. Narayan, with him), for
the respondent.
1955. September 27.
Court was delivered by.
The
Judgment
of
the
JAGANNADHADAS
J.-'"fhis IS an appeal by the
State of Madras and the Union of India against the
judgment and decree of the High Court on a certificate granted by that Court under article 133 of the
Constitution. The appeal arises out of a suit filed by
the respondent herein, who was a member of the
Indian Civil Service, for a declaration that the order
issued by the Chief Secretary to the Government of
Madras on the 7th August, 1947, purporting to terminate his services as from the afternoon of the 14th
August, 1947, is null, void and inoperative and that
he must be deemed to continue in the Indian Civil
Service as a Member thereof. The suit was filed on
the original side of the High Court of Madras and
after having been partly tried by a Single Judge who
recorded the evidc:nce, was thereafter heard by a
Bench of two Judges in view of the important constitutional question that arose for consideration in
the case. The Bench found in favour of the plaintiff
and decreed the suit and hence the appeal by the
State to this Court.
The case for the plaintiff is short and 5imple. He
was recruited to the Indian Civil Service by open
competitive examination in 1936 and joined duty in
the then Province of Madras in October, 1937. Since
then he was serving under the Government of Madras
.in various situations. The last office he held was as
Sub-Collector and Joint Magistrate at Dindigal. On
the 2nd June, 1947, he went on leave. While on leave,
he received a letter from the Government of India
dated the 19th June, 1947, wherein he was asked
whether he was willing to continue in the service of
Slate of Madra.
and another
v.
K. M. Rajagopalata
SUPREME COURT llEPORTS
1955
[19551
the Government after the then contemplated transfer of power from the British Government to the
Dominion of India on the 15th August, 1947. The
v.
K. M. Rajago;o/a• plaintiff sent a reply expressing his willingness. On the
9th August, 1947, however, he received a communicaJ4gannadhadas ].
tion from the Government of Madras dated the 7th
August, 1947, and signed by the Chief Secretary
thereof, stating that it was decided not to retain him
in service from an<i after the 15th August, 1947, and
that his services would therefore be terminated as on
the afternoon of the 14th August, 1947. He was
directed, therefore to apply for extension of leave for
which he was then eligible so as to avail himself of
the full period of leave which was to his credit.
On receiving the order of termination of his services,
he made attempts to get it cancelled, by interviewing
the Chief Secretary and the Chief Minister of the
Madras State at the time. But the attempts proved
futile. In the course of these interviews he says he .
wa$ given the impression that the order of termination, though issued under the signature of. the Chief
Secretary to the Government of Madras was in fact so
issued under the sanction of the Secretary of State for
India, which, according to him, subsequently turned
out not to be a fact. Being then under that mistaken
impression, he reconciled himself to the situation and
availed himself of the full period of leave and accepted the compensation which was awarded for premature termination of services and also began drawing
his pension. Later on he came to know from one
Shri Seshadri, another young Civilian, who was in a
similar plight and who had also filed a similar suit
that certain documents produced in the course of that
suit showed that these orders were passed without
the sanction of the Secretary of State for India. He
accordingly brought these matters again to the notice
of the Government and made further attempts to get
the order in his case reversed. These again proved
futile. He thereupon filed an application for a writ in
the High Court on the 7th November, 1951, to quash
this alleged illegal order against him. But the High
Court rejected it on the ground of there having been
S- ef Modral
""'.,..,,,,,
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
loqg delay since the passing of the orders sought to
be quashed: The plaintiff thereafter gave the requisite notice to the Government under section 80 of the
Civil Procedure Code and filed this Suit on the
15th July, 1952. In the plaint h~ made the offer to
refund the amount of compensation paid to him after
making such adjustments asi may be called for
towards his claim for salary for the intervening
period.
The plaintiff's claim is based on the contention
that the termination of his services by the order
dated the 7th August, 1947, . is in violation of the
statutory guarantee relating to his service under section 240 of the Government of India Act, 1935, which
continued to be operative till the midnight of the
14th August, 1947, and he relies on Lall's case(1 ). To
this suit both the State of Madras and the Union of
India were impleaded as defendants and their defence
was substantially the same. It is to be found in
paragraph 6 of the written statement filed by the
State of Madras which is as follows :
"This defendant states that on the transfer
<>f power to the newly constituted Dominion of
India m pursuance of the Indian Independence
Act .as and from the appointed day, viz., 15th August,
1947, the tenure of the service of the plaintiff came to
an end and he had no legal claim to continue in service thereafter.
The; plaintiff was holding office only during His
Majesty's pleasure. When His Majesty's Government
decided to transfer its power to the Dominion of India
as and from
the 15th day of August, 1947, the career
of the plaintiff under covenant with the Secretary of
State came to a legal termination \ as and from the
15th day of August, 1947. It is, therefore, not correct to state that there was any termination by
the Government of Madras and that there has been
. utter lack of legality in the order passed by the said
Government. It is further submitted that the alleged
termination of the plaintiff's services was only from
the 15th August, 1947, and that on such date the
11) [1948] F.C.R. 44.
195!t
Sia# of Modrtu
arrd onollwr
v.
K. M. RqjagopaJa11
Jaztllllllll/hadtl$ ].
546
1955
Stal• of Madras
and anotlur
v.
Jr. M. Rajagopo/an
Jagannadhadas J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955}
Province of Madras acting under the instructions from
the Government of India were competent to decline
to accept the offer to continue in service made by the
plaintiff".
There were other minor pleas such as estoppel, etc.
which, it is unnecessary to notice at this stage. The
High Court negatived the defence of the State and
accepted the contention of the plaintiff and granted
him the declaration prayed for.
The main contention of the learned AttorneyGeneral before us appearing for the State is that the
plaintiff has misconceived the legal position, that
what happened in this case was not a wilful order of
termination of the services of the plaintiff which fell
within the scope of section 240 of the Government of
India Act,. 1935, and whose validity was liable to be
tested with reference thereto. According to him the·
political changes which came into force from the 15th
August, 1947, operated in law to terminate the set·
vices of all persons in the position of the plaintiff as
and from the 15th August, 1947, that in that sitilation
it was open to the new Dominion Government of India
or the Governments of the various Provinces either
to invite such persons to continue to be in their respective services or to intimate that they were no
longer required, and that it was in the exercise of
this option that the Government of Madras com·
municated to the plaintiff an advance intimation on
the 7th August, 1947, that he would not be retained
in service as and from the 15th August, 1947. The
substantial question therefore, for our decision is
whether this contention put forward by the learned
Attorney-General is correct. It may be mentioned
that, as appears born their judgments, the learned
Judges of the High Court appear to have been under
the impression that this defence of automatic termination of the services was abandoned during the
course of the arguments before them by the learned
Advocate-General of Madras. This impression seems
to be erroneous.
In any case there is nothing to preclude the question which is purely one of law being
reopened before us with our leave in view of its being
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
547
one of considerable importance.
The learned Attorney-General has based his contention as regards automatic termination of such services on three grounds :
(1) The political change which came into operation on the 15th August, 1947, resulted in creating a
new Sovereign State of India and on the creation of
such Sovereign State, the pre-existing contracts of
service under the previous Government became automatically terminated.
(2) The contract between the Secretary of State
for India and the plaintiff being one of service became
terminated on the Secretary of State ceasing to have
control in respect or the services contemplated under
the contract.
(3) The statutory changes which came into operation as from the 15th August, 1947, by themselves
brought about a termination of such services and the
p~otection of section 240 of the Government of India
Act, 1935, was no longer available to a person in the
situation of the respondent.
For the purpose of appreciating the above arguments it is necessary to notice the various events
that lead up to the political changes, and the statutory provisions by which they were brought about, in
so far as they relate to the class of services with which
we are concerned in this case. The starting point of
these changes was the announcement of his Majesty's
Government dated the 20th February, 1947, that
power would be transferred to Indian hands by His
Majesty's Government by June, 1948, in accordance
with the Cabinet Mission Plan of May, 1946. Since
then the attention of the Government was engaged
in the various. steps to be taken to bring about the
transition as smoothly as possible. One of the steps
taken in this directiQll, in so far as it concerns this
case, was the announcement by His Excellency the
Viceroy on the 30th April, 1947. That announcement
purported to relate to "grant of compensation for
premature termination of their service in India to
Members of Civil Services app0inted by the Secretary
of State and to regular officers and British Warrant
1955
Stal• of Madra£
and another
v
Ir. M. Rq,agopaku.
Jagannadhadas J.
548
1955
Stoll qf Mi111ras
v.
""""""""
ICM. R4jagopalan
]4gamwJ/uldas ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
Officers of the Indian Naval and Military Forces",
and was inter alia as follows :
"I. His Majesty's Government have announced
their intention that the British Government's authority in India will be finally transferred to Indian
hands by June, 1948. It is the aim of His Majesty's
Government that the transfer of power should be
effected in an orderly and regulated manner so that
the new authorities may assume their responsibilities
in conditions conducive to the best interests of India
and maintenance of good relations with Great Britain.
His Majesty's Government are confident that during
this period of transition the Services and all those
who man them, whether British or Indian will respond to this call.
2. To those serving under covenant or other
form of agreement with the Secretary of State for
India or who hold commissions from His Majesty the
King, the transfer of power will mean premature
termination on that date of a career under the ultimate
authority of His Majesty's Government and the British
Parliament; and for many there is added to the heavy
call of present duty the burden of anxiety ·for their
QWn future and that of those who depend on them.
3. The Government of India are naturally and
rightly most anxious and His Majesty's Government
share their anxietv that the administration shall not
be weakened by the loss of experienced officers. To
this end, Government of India undertake that those
members of the Secretary of State's Services who continue to serve under the Government of India after the
transfer of power shall do so on their present terms as
to scales of pay, leave, pensionary rights, and safeguards in matters of discipline and that provisions to
this effect should be made in the Treaty to deal with
matters arising out of the ·transfer of power. The
Government of India will now propose to Provincial
Governments that they should give similar assurances
to members of the Secretary of State's $Crvice who
agree to join Provincial services.
4. The Government of India recognise that some
[ndian members of the Secretary of State's services
~
s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
549
19$5
may be genuinely anxious about their prospects under
the Provincial administrations where they are at
St(#f of M/JIJNI
qnif !lfllllhlr
present employed, and every effort will be made to
V•
arrange suitable transfers in such cases.
fl. M. Jl4jagf1J4la"
5. The Government of India agree that compen- ]ago'fltWfihatlas J.
sation should be payable to such Indian Officers of
these services as( 1) are not invited to continue to serve under the
Government of India after transfer of power; or
(2) can satisfy the Governor-General that their
actions in the course of duty during their service prior
to the transfer of ,power have damaged their prospects,
or that the appointments offered to them are such as
cannot be regarded as satisfactory in the altered circumstances; or
(3) can show to the satisfaction of the GovernorGeneral that they have legitimate cause for anxiety
about their future in the Province where they are now
serving, and that no suitable transfer can be arranged.
B\lt the Government of India feel that sentiments
of patriotism will naturally impel Indian Officers to
continue to serve their country and that, in the light
of the undertaking that they have given, and the consideration that in fact Indian members of the Ser·
vice will have improved prospects, there is no ground,
save in these special cases, for payment of compensation to Indian officers on account of the transfer
of power.
6. His Majesty's Government have · been reviewing the whole position. They have noted the undertaking which the Government of India have given in regard to officers whom they desire should continue to
serve under the Government of India. They recognise
the force of Government of India's arguments,
and they agree that to Indian Officers compensation
should not be admissible except in the cases which I
have just mentioned. Many Indian members of the
Secretary of State's services will however become
members of provincial services and in their cases His
Majesty's Government's agreenient that they need not
be compensated is conditional upon the Provincial
Governments guaranteeing the existing terms of scr-
550
1955
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
vice. If they are not prepared to do so His Majesty's
Government reserv.e the right to reconsider the
matter.
v.
.K. M. Rajagopalan
7. With these reservations I am now authorised
by
His
Majes~y's Government to inform members of
Jagannadhadas J.
the Secretary of State's services that they accept the
obligation to see that they are duly compensated for
the termination of their careers consequent on the
transfer of power ................ "
After this announcement was issued, His Majesty's
Government, for various political reasons, decided to
advance the date of transfer of power and made an
announcement on the 3rd June, 1947, detailing various steps which were proposed to be taken to bring
about an early transfer of power. Paragraph 20 of
that announcement ran as follows:
"The major political parties have repeatedly emphasized their desire that there should be the earliest
possible transfer of power in India With this desire
His Majesty's Government are in full sympathy, and
they are willing to anticipate the date of June, 1948,
for the handing over of power by the setting up of
an independent Indian Government or Governments
at an even earlier date. Accordingly, as the most
expeditious, and indeed the only practicable way of
meeting this desire, His Majesty's Government propose to introduce legislation during the current session
for the transfer of power this year on a Dominion
Status basis t'o one or two successor authorities according to the decisions taken as a result of this announcement. This will be without prejudice to the
right of the Indian Constituent Assemblies to decide
in due course whether or not the part of India in
respect of which they have authority will remain
within the British Commonwealth".
In persuance of what was indicated herein, the Indian
Independence Act was passed on the 18th July, 1947.
In pursuance of the power vested in the GovernorGeneral thereunder a number of legislative orders
were passed by him. The relevant provisions of the
Indian Independence Act as well as of some of the
legislative orders will be presently noticed. But it
Stat1 of Madras
and another
.2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
551
will be convenient at this stage to state the further
steps taken by the Government relating to the services
of the kind we are concerned with, in pursuance of
their plan announced on the 3rd June, 1947, to speed
up the transfer of power. Within about two weeks
after the announcement of His Majesty's Government
dated the 3rd June, 1947, a circular letter was issued
by the Government of India to the Chief Secretaries
of all the Provincial Governments on the 18th June,
1947, which inter alia stated as follows :
"That in view of the latest announcement of His
Majesty's Government (dated the 3rd June, 1947), it
is essential to ascertain with the least possible delay,
the wishes of individual officers to whom His Excellency the Viceroy's announcement of the 30th April
1947 applies in regard to continuance in service after
the transfer of power. This will enable Government
to decide which officers they should continue to retain in service after the transfer of power and to
make arrangements to replace officers who desire to
quit service, of their own accord or whom Government
may not wish to continue in service".
The Chief Secretaries were accordingly asked to make
arrangements "to send immediately to every officer
belonging to any service specified in the schedule, and
serving under the Provincial Government, a copy of
the enclosed letter from the Government of India to
the officers concerned, where!_>y the officer was asked
to communicate within ten days of the receipt of the
letter whether he wishes to continue in the service of
the Government or whether he desires to retire from
service". The circular letter of the Government of
India to the Chief Secretaries further asked them that
in forwarding the replies received thereto from the
individual officers, they may inform them, in case cl.
persons who have decided to quit service, the earliest
-date on which the Government will be in a position
to release the officer and in case of persons who offer
to continue in service, whether for any reason, they
would prefer him not to continue in the service, notwithstanding the officer's desire to remain in the
1955
StaMqfMabu
and ono#wr
v.
r;, M. RajagoJoltm
Jagannadhatlas J.
552
l!lS5
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
service and pointed out that in the latter case the
Provincial Government will be incurring liability to
andonotltn
pay compensation. In pursuance of these instruc..
v.
K. M. Rajogopalan tions the individual letters to the officers concerned
J•g-..UU. .., J. were presumably sent and replies were obtained, and
the necessary orders were passed in respect, at any
rate, of such of the officers whom the various Governments were not prepared to retain in service after the
transfer of power. Pausing here, it will be seen that
the announcement of the Viceroy dated the 30th April,
1947, and the circular letter issued by the Govern·
ment of India to the Chief Secretaries on the 18th
June, 1947, as well as the individual letters issued by
and under the authority of the Government of India
to those officers on the same date asking for information from them as to their desire to continue in service
or not, were all based on the assumptions clear!,
stated or indicated therein, (1) that transfer of power
brings about an automatic premature termination of
the services, (2) on such termination, it woulJ be open
to the servant concerned either to decline to continue
in the service of the new Government or to offer to
continue his services, and (3) that in case the individual servant intimated his desire to continue in
service, it was open to the Government either to accept
the offer or not. Thus the continuance of service was
contemplated only in respect of such ·of the previous
servants who intimated their desire for the continuance of their services and whose offer in this respect
was accepted. While, therefore, discontinuance of
service was to be brought about by the option of
either of the parties and on such discontinuance the
servant was to become entitled to compensation the
continuance of the service was a matter which would
depend upon the mutual consent of both, viz., the individual servant and the Government concerned.
That the position so taken up must have been perfectly within the knowledge of every one of the persons to whom these circular letters were sent is virtually admitted by the plaintiff himself in his evidence
and also appears clearly froni the fact that a copy of
the Vic~roy' s announcement dated the 30th April,
Sl.U of Muas
2.S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
553
1947, appears to have been enclosed with the individual letters dated the 18th June, 1947, sent to each
of the officers by the Government of India. The
plaintiff himself in his letter dated the 2nd July, 1947,
to the Chief Secretary to the Government of Madras,
wrote as follows :
"I am in receipt of your Memorandum No. 2738
of 1947-4, Public (Special) Department, dated 5th
June, 1947, enclosing the announcement of His Excellency
the Viceroy. I wish to state that I desire to continue
to
serve the Madras Government and that I
desire no transfer to any other Province". (The
reference to the date 5th June, 1947, is probably
a mistake since it is clearly admitted in the
plaint that the plaintiff intimated his desire to
continue in service in reply to the letter dated the 18th
June, 1947.)
To complete the course of events as regards the
imlividual case of the plaintiff, the further facts may
be stated. After receiving this reply ·from the plaintiff
dated the 2nd July, 1947, the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Madras wrote to him a letter dated
the 7th August, 1947, as follows:
"I am to say that with reference to your reply
to the letter cited electing to continue in service after
the transfer of power, the Government have decided
not to retain you in service after 15th August, 1947.
Your services will he terminated on the afternoon of
14th August 1947 and you may proceed on leave (your
present leave will be automatically converted into
leave) preparatory to retirement as from 15th August
1947. You may therefore apply for the leave (extension of leave) for which you arc eligible direct to Government. The Accountant-General is being asked to
certify the amount of leave for which you are eligible.
A formal communication will issue to you shortly
from the Government of India terminating your services as from 14th August, 1947 A.N.
I am to express regret that the decisions in your
case has been delayed so long".
This is clearly an advance intimation that the termination of the services of the plaintiff would become
I 7-83 S. C. India./59.
1955
Sla/4 of Madrt11
Olldoaothlr
v.
E. M. Rqjagopala•
JagaMalllulllas J.
554
1955
Sim of Madras
and anothu
v.
K. M. Rlgagopalan
Jagannadluzdas ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
operative at the very moment when the transfer of
power comes into force, i.e., on the midnight of 14th/
15th August, 1947. The mention of the termination
on the afternoon of the 14th August, 1947, was clearly
because of the official practice that a person who
hands over charge of his office in the afternoon of a
particular day, continues in service and draws the
salary for that day. (Vide Audit Instruction (1) at
page 163 of the Fundamental Rules, 3rd Edition). A
letter was immediately addressed by the Chief Secretary to the Government of Madras under date 8th
August 1947, to the Under Secretary of State for India,
India Office, London, and ;i copy thereof was sent to
the plaintiff. The letter runs thus:
"I am directed to say that Mr. K. M. Rajagopalan, I. C. S. proceeded on three months' leave on the
3rd June, 1947, and that as he will not continue in
the service of Government in India, al;ter the transfer
of power, he will be entitled to compensation or settlement grant, as the case may be, as from the 15th
August, 1947".
On the 8th August, 1947, a formal Government Order
No. 377 was passed which is as follows :
"Mr. K. M. Rajagopalan, I.C.S. proceeded on
three months' leave on the 3rd June, 1947, and that
as he will not continue in the service of Government
of India after the transfer of power, he will be entitled
to compensation or resettlement grant, as the case
may be, as from the 15th August, 1947".
This order was published in the Fort St. George
Gazette dated the 19th August, 1947. Presumably this
order (along with other similar orders) was also intimated to the Government of India and the Government of India sent a telegram to the Government of
Madras on the 14th August, 1947, as follows: •
" ...... No objection to your proposal to terminate
services of .......... Rajagopalan".
On the 29th September, 1947, the Government of
Madras pas<ed a G. 0. sanctioning pavment of
£4,500./ as compensation for the plaintiff and ordered
disbursement thereof by the Accountant-General. This
compensation was drawn by the plaintiff in April,
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
555
1950. In the light of this background it is now necessary to notice the various statutory prov1S1ons which
brought about the political change and particularly
those which relate to the services.
The instrument which brought about the transfer
of power from the British Government to the Dominion Government of India in a.:cordance with the
announcements of His Majesty's Government dated
the 20th February, 1947 and the 3rd June, 1947, is
the Indian Independence Act, 1947, (10 & 1i Geo. 6,
Ch. 30) passed by the British Parliament and which
became law on the 18th July, 1947. The preamble
thereto is as follows :
"An Act to make provision for the setting up in
India of two independent Dominions, to substitute
other provisions for certain provisions of the Govern~
ment of India Act, 1935, which apply outside those
Dominions and to provide for other matters consequential on or connected with the setting up of those
Dominions".
By section 1 of the said Act two independent Dominions to be known respectively, India and Pakistan,
were to be set up in India as from the 15th day
of august, 1947, with territories assigned to each of
them as indicated in sections 2, 3 and 4 thereof. Under
section 5, there was to be a Governor-General for each
of the Dominions to be appointed by His Majesty who
was to represent His Majesty for the purposes of the
government of the Dominion. By section 6 it was
provided that Legislature of each of the new Dominions was to have full power to make laws for that
Dominion including laws having extra-territorial operation and laws which would be valid notwithstanding any repugnancy to the law of England or to the
provisions of any existing or future Act of the Parliament. It was also provided that the assent to the
laws as made by the Legislatures, was to be given by
the Governor-General in the name of His Majesty
without any power of disallowance by His Majesty
and without any power of reservation of laws for the
significance of His Majesty's pleasure. By section 7,
:it was specifically provided that as from the 15th
!955
Stat• of Madras
and onothn
v.
K. M. Rajagopalon
Jagannadhat!as J,
556
1955
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19551
August, 1947, His Majesty's Government in the United
Kingdom was to have no responsibility as respects
and anotktr
the Government of any of the territories which, imv.
Ir. M. Rqjagopalan mediately before that day, were included in British
Temporary provisions as to the Government
]agOIUladMdas J. India.
of each of the new Dominions as from the 15th
August, 1947, until such time that each of the two
Dominions evolves its own independent Constitution
were made by sections 8 and 9. By Section 8(1) the
respective Constituent Assemblies of India, and Pakistan which had already come -into existence and
were functioning for the purpose of evolving a new
Constitution for each of the Dominions, the first by
virtue of the Cabinet Mission Plan of May, 1946, and
the second by reason of the announcement of His
Majesty's Government dated the 3rd Tune, 1947, were
recognised as interim Legislatures for each of the
Dominions. By section 8(2) the pre-existing Government of India Act, 1935, with modifications and
adaptations to be made by the Governor-General and
subject to any other provision or alteration to be
made by the Constituent Assembly functioning as the
interim Legislature, was to continue in force. By
section 9 of the Act, the Governor-General was given
various and extensive powers to make provisions in
order to bring the provisions of the Indian Independence Act into operation and for removing difficulties
arising in connection with the transition of power
from the British Government to the Dominions and
to carry on the business of the Governor-General in
Council in the interim period. It was specifically provided that the Governor-General's power in this behalf was to be retrospective as from the 3rd June,
1947.
It will be seen that by virtue of the Indian Independence Act a completely independent Dominion of
India was set up with a wholly independent Lcgisl:lture and with a COl?lpletcly independent Government
free from any kind of fetters as regards thcit functioning, either from the British Parliament or from
the British Government. The Government of the
Dominion, however, was still to be carried on in the
Slal1 of Madras
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
557
name of His Majesty the King of Great Britain, by
the Governor-General of India to be appointed by
His Majesty. The learned Attorney-General strenuously contended that these changes resulted in the
emergence of India as an independent Sovereign State
and that it followed therefrom, on well-recognised
principles of international law, that this brought about
automatic termination of the contracts of service
between the prior Government and its servants. In
support of this principle of international law, the
k1rned Attorney-General cited a number of authorities as also the case in West Rand Central Gold Mining
Co. Ltd. v. The King(1), which was quoted by this
Court in Virendra Singh v. The State of Uttar
Pradesh(2). On the other hand, Shri Nambiar for the
respondent stressed the fact that however independent the new Dominion Government may be as regards the functioning
of its Legislature and of its
executive Government, the new Government was still
to function in the name of His Majesty the King of
Great Britain and that, therefore, the Dominion is
not on the same footing as an independent sovereign
State, which obtains sovereignty over a new country
by virtue of conquest or cession. He urged that the
principle of international law relied upon would not
apply to such a case. In support of his contention he
drew our attention to various other provisions in the
Indian Independence Act and to the various legislative orders passed by the Governor-General by virtue
of powers vested in him under section 9 of the Indian
Independence Act as also to adaptations
made in
respect of various existing laws. The question as to
whether the Indian Independence Act brought about
a full oovereign State for each and every purpose is
one of considerable importance and is not free from
difficulty. We do not wish to decide that question on
the present occasion. It appears to us that the present
case has to be decided with reference to the question
as to what exactly has been brought about by the
Indian Independence Act and the subsidiary legislatirn.1 which followed thereupon, in so far as they relate
(!) [1905] 2 K. B. 391.
(2) [1955] I S.C.R. 415, 427.
!955
Stall of MaJro.r
and anotMr
v.
K. M. R.ajagopalaa
Jagannadhado.r J.
558
1955
Stale of Madras
and .,.,,,,,,.
v.
K. M. ll<efa10/Jflkm
-JaganMdhada1 J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955}
to the tenure of persons in the position of the plaintiff.
For this purpose it is necessary in the first instance
to have a clear idea as to what was the tenure of
service of the plaintiff prior to the 15th August, 1947
Persons in the position of the plaintiff were recruited
directly by the Secretary of State for India by virtue
of the powers conferred on him under section 244(1)
of the Government of India Act, 1935 (or under the
corresponding provisions in the prior Government of
India Acts). The persons so recruited, were appointed to the service called the Indian Civil Service.
Each person so recruited had to enter into a covenant
by means of an indenture between himself and the
Secretary of State. The indenture (whose form is to
be found as Appendix I of the Indian Civil Service
Manual) recited that the person was appointed by the
Secretary of State to serve His Majesty as a Member
of the Civil Service of India and that such service was
to continue during the pleasure of His Majesty, to be
signified under the hand of the Secretary of State for
India with liberty for the covenantor to resign the
said service with the previous permission of the
Secretary of State or of the Government under which
he was, for the time being, serving. The indenture incorporated various covenants by the appointee with
reference to the exercise of his functions during the
period of h_is service such as, (1) general fidelity,
(2) obedience to orders of general nature, (3) keeping
of regular accounts, preservation and due delivery
and
production of private accounts, ( 4)
not to
misapply or employ for improper purposes the prcr
pcrty entrusted to his care, (5) not to divulge secrets, ( 6) not to accept corrupt presents or to make
corrupt bargains, (7) not to trade contrary to law or
regulations, (8) not to quit India without leave and
to satisfy all debts due to His Majesty before departure, and (9) to make prescribed payments towards
pension, etc. Apart from these covenants, his tenure
was regulated by a number of statutory provisions
under the Government of India Act.
Section 240.•
while affirming that the service was at the pleasure
,
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
559
of His Majesty provided that dismissal or reduction
in rank should be preceded by a reasonable opportunity for showing cause against the action proposed
and that dismissal (or removal) from service could
only be by an authority not subordinate to the appointing authority-which in the present case meant
that the appellant could be dismissed or removed only
by the Secretary of Sta~e. The Government of India
Act contained also a number of provisions specially applicable to a person recruited by the Secretary of State.
The conditions of his service as regards pay, leave,
pension and other matters were to be such as may be
prescribed by the rules to be made by the Secretary of
State and (in the absence of any specific rules by the
Secretary of State) by the rules to be made by the
Governor-General or the Governor of a Province in
accordance as he was in service under. the Government of India or the Provincial Government [section
247 (1) ]. In the matter of promotions or leave exceeding three months or in the matter of an order of suspension, he was to be directly under the authority of
the Governor-General or the Governor, as the case
may be, exercising their respective individual judgments [sections 247 (2) and (3) ]. No award of pension
less than the maximum pension under the rules could
be made except with the consent of the Secretary of
State [section 247 (6) l· He had the right to approach
the Governor-General or the Governor in the exercise
of tbeir individual judgment if he had any grievance
or complaint in respect of his service and a right
of
appeal to the Secretary of State as against the order
of any authority which punished or formally censured
him or interpreted any rule to his disadvantage (section 248). The Secretary of State had to make rules
specifying the number and character of the civil posts
under the Crown which were to be reserved for and to
be filled by persons belonging to the Indian Civil
Service recruited by him (section 246). If the conditions of the service were adversely affected by reason
of anything done under the Act or for any other reason
which might have appeared to the Secretary of State
to justify payment of compensation, he was entitled
1955
Stau qf Madr,M
and anothw
v.
IC. M. Rajagopallltl
JagtJtltl4dhadtU J.
560
1955
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
thereto, the compensation being such as the Secretary
of State might fix. The said sum was payable from
the revenues of the Government of India or the Prov.
K. M. Rtgaaopolan vincial Government as the case mav be (section 249).
It will be seen from the above that· the tenure of an
JaglllllltJdiiadtu ].
Indian Civil Servant was basically contractual but
with conditions and prospects of such service regulated by statute. A person recruited to such service
was in a very special position, in comparison with
persons holding other civil posts of the Government
of India or the Provincial Government. He enjoyed
a number of rights and privileges attached to him by
virtue of the fact that he belonged to a specially
recruited service with certain high posts reserved for
him and having the right of appeal to the Secretary
of State in respect of matters relating to his service
by virtue of sections 244, 246, 247, 248 and 249. Thus
the Indian Civil Service was a specially privileged
class of service under the Crown with the essential
characteristic of direct and ultimate protection by
the Secretary of State representing His Majesty's
Government.
.
Now it is necessary to notice the fundamental
changes brought about in this behalf by the Indian
Independence Act. In the first instance the Secretary ·
of State who, as a Member of British Cabinet, acting
in the name of the Crown and responsible to the
British Parliament, was exercising such control as was
vested in him in respect ot the affairs of India and in
particular as regards these services, completely disappeared. It was specifically provided by section 7
(1) (a) of the Indian Independence Act, 1947, that as
a consequence of the setting up of the new Dominions
as from the appointed day (15th August, 1947) "His
Majesty's Government in the United Kingdom have
no responsibility as respects the Government of any
of the territories which, immediately before that day
were included in British India". There was a further
specific provision by way of section 10 in the Indian
Independence Act as regards the Secretary of State
services which was as follows:
"10. Secrettwy of State's services etc.
SlaU qf Madt-tu
W OMl/tu
•
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
561
( 1) The provisions of this Act keeping in force
provisions of the Government of India Act, 1935,
shall not continue in force the provisions of that Act
relating to appointments to the civil services of, and
civil post~ under, the Crown in India by the Secretary
of State, or the provisions of that Act relating to the
reservation of posts".
Now the India (Provisional Constitution) Order of
1947, which was issued by the Governor-General on
the 14th August, 1947, under the power of adaptation
vested in him under section 9( 1)( c) of the Indian
Independence Act and which was to come into operation simultaneously with it, gave effect to the above
two provisions, viz., section 7(1)(a) and section 10(1)
of the Indian Independence Act, by specifically deleting from th,e Government of India Act, 1935, the
various sections relating to the Secretary of State and
his services, i.e., sections 244, 246, 248 and 249 and 278
to 284-A (vide schedule to the India (Provisional
Constitution) Order, 1947). Changes were also made
by the same order in sections 240 and 247 relating to
conditions of service which will be noticed presently,
whose chief purpose was. to withdraw the responsibility of the ·Secretary of State as regards matters
covered by these sections. The resultant position was
clearly this. (1) There was no. further recruitment to
a special covenanted service by the Secretary of State.
(2) There was to be no statutory reservation of posts
to be made by the Secretary of State. (3) The conditions of service as made by the Secretary of State
no longer continued in operation. ( 4) No :right of
;ippeal or approach to the Secretary of State for redress of any personal grievances relating to such servants, or right of compensation, etc. for any adverse
action to be, determined by the Secretary of State,
continued to subsist. True, some of the conditiom of
service previously governing these persons ·were continued . by section 10(2) of the Indian Independence
Act and the adaptations made thereunder which will
be noticed presently. But apart from the question
whether such continuance is available to all the previous members of the service-a matter which will be
!955
State of Madras
anti anothtr
v.
K. M. Rajagopalan
Jagannadhadas J.
562
1955
Slate of Madras
and anot!:tr
v.
K. M. Rajazopalan
Jagannadhadtu].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
dealt with presently-the ultimate responsibility for
the framing and maintenance of the conditions of
service· was no longer with the Secretary of State. It
is also true that in respect of such of these civil
servants whose services were retained by the new
Dominion Government the service continued to be
under the Crown (as shown by the adaptation of section 240 of the Government of India Act). But this
was only because in theory the new Government of
India was still to be carried on in the name of His
Majesty. This was no more than a symbol of the continued allegiance . to the Crown. The substance of the
matter, however, was that while previously the Secretary of State's services were under the Crown in the
sense that the ultimate authority and responsibility
for these services was in the British P\}Iliament and
the British Government, this responsibility and authority completely vanished from
and after the 15th
August, 1947, as envisaged in the Viceroy's announcement of the 30th April, 1947, and as specifically affirmed by section 7(1) (a) of the Indian Independence Act.
Thus the essential structure of the Secretary of State
services was altered and the basic foundation of the
contractual-cum-statutory
tenure
of th~ service
disappeared. It follows that the contracts as well as the
statutory protection attached thereto came to an
automatic and legal termination as held by the Privy
Council and the House of Lords in somewhat analogous
situations in Reilly v. The King(') and Nokes v. Doncaster Amalgamated Collieries Ltd.(2).
To repel the above view of the change brought about
by the Indian Independence Act. learned counsel for
the respondent relied
on certa;n
other provisions
which may now be noticed. These provisions far from
supporting the contention of the respondent, clearly
confirm , the above view. The first of these is section
10(2) of the Indian Independence Act, which is as
follows:
"10. (2) Every person who(a) having been appointed by the Secretary of
State, or Secretary .of State in Council, to a civil
(I) [1934j A.C. 176.
(2) (1940} A.C. 1014.
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
563
service of the Crown in India continues on and after
the appointed day to serve under the Government of
either of the new Dominions or of any Province or
part thereof;
shall be entitled to receive from the Governments
of the Dominions and Provinces or parts which
he is from time to time serving .................. ..
the same conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension, and the same rights as respects disciplinary matters or, as the case may be, as
respects the tenure of his office or rights as similar
thereto as changed circumstances may permit, as that
person was entitled to immmediately before the appointed day".
The contention of the learned counsel is that this
prov1s10n
clearly indicates that persons
previously
appointed by the Secretary of State to the Indian
Civil Service continue under the new Government and
that they are entitled to similar conditions of service
as they had before. According to him the order of
termination of plaintiff's service being invalid, he
must be deemed to continue in service. But, it is to
be noticed that the above provision does not say that
all persons previously appointed shall be continued
in service. It is very carefully worded and merely
guarantees the same conditions of service, etc. to persons who ·"having been appointed by the Secretary
of State ................ rnntinue on and after the appointed day to serve under the Government ........ ".
This section has nothing to say as to who are the persons who continue in service and receive the benefit.
That was obviously left to be provided by delegated
legislation in the shape of orders of the GovernorGeneral by virtue of section 9(1) (a) of the Indian
Independence Act. The India (Provisional Constitution) Order, 1947, referred to above deals with this
matter in article 7(1) thereof which runs as follows :
"Subject to any general or special orders or
arrangements affecting his case, any person, who immediately before the appointed day is holding any
civil post under the Crown in connection with the
1955
State of Madras
and another
v.
K. M. Rajagopalan
Jagannadhadas J.
564
1955
Stat1 of Madras
and another
v.
K. M. Rajagopalan
JagaMadhadas J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
affairs of the Governor-General or Governor-General
in Council or of a Province other than Bengal or the
Punjab shall, as from that day, be deemed to have
been duly appointed to the corresponding post under
the Crown in connection with the affairs of the Dominion of India or as the case may be, of the Province".
The Schedule to this Order also shows the adaptations made in respect of sections 240 and 247 of the
Government of India Act to give effect to section
10(2) of the Indian Indepoodence Act above quoted.
Now section 247 of the Government of Indi.a Act as
adapted is as follows:
"The conditions of service of all persons who,
having been appointed by the Secretary of State or
the Secretary of State in Council to a civil service of
the Crown in India, continue on and after the date of
the establishment of the Dominion to serve under the
Government of the Dominion or of any Province,
shall( a) as respects persons serving in connection
with the affairs of the Dominion, be such as may be
prescribed by rules made by the Governor-General;
(b) as respects persons serving in connection
with the affairs of a Province( i) in regard to their pay, leave, pension, gen~
ral rights as medical attendance and any other
matter which immediately before the establishment
of the Dominion was regulated by rules made by the
Secretary of State, be such as may be prescribed by
rules made by the Governor-General; and
(ii) in regard to any other matter, be such as
may be prescribed by rules made by the Governor of
the Province".
Section 240(2) as modified is as follows:
"No such person as aforesaid (referring to the
persons mentioned in section :240(1) which includes
persons appoirited by the .Secretary of State) who
having been appointed by the Secretary of State or
the Secretary of S~ate in Council continues after the
establishment of the Dominion to serve under ~he
Crown in India shall be dismis.sed from the savice of
His Majesty by any authority subordinate to the
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
565
1955
Governor-General or the Governor according as that
person is serving in connection with the affairs of the Stalt of Madraa
anti anothtr
Dominion or of a Province, and no other such person
v.
as aforesaid shall be dismissed from the service of His K. M. Rajagopalatt
Majesty by any authority subordinate to that by Jagannadhadas J.
which he was ·appointed".
Taking these various provisions together, it is clear
that the guarantee of the prior conditions of service
and the previous statutory safeguards relating to the
disciplinary action are now confined to such as continue
in service on and after the establishment of the
Dominion to s,erve under the Crnwn, i.e., of the Government
of the Dominion or of a Province, as the case
may be. Who the persons are who fall within the
category of persons so continuing is clearly indicated
by implication in article 7(1) of the India (Provisional
Constitution) Order, 1947, already quoted, which says
that any person who immediately before the appointed day is holding any civil post under the Crown
in connection with the affairs of the Governor-General
or Governor-General in Council or of a Province, shall,
as from that day, be deemed to have been duly appointed to the corresponding post under the Crown in
connection with the affairs of the Dominion of India
or, .as the case may be, of the Province. It is clear
that the continuance contemplated by section 10(2) (a)
of the 1ndian Independence Act and by section 240(2)
and section 247 of the Government of India Act, as
adapted, is the continuance impliedly brought about
by this deeming provision in article 7(1) of the India
(Provisional Constitution) Order. But it has to be
noted that this provision is specifically preceded
by the qualifying phrase "subject to any general or
special orders or arrangements affecting his ta3e".
Thus all persons who were pteviously holding civil
posts are deemed to have been appointed and hence
to continue in service, excepting those whose case is
governed by "general or special orders or arrangements affecting his case". Now, omitting "general
orders" which has no application in this case, there
can be no reasonable doubt that the special orders or
arrangements contemplated herein, in so far as the
566
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1955
[19551
member. of the Secretary of State's services are concerned,
are the special orders or arrangements which
State of MadraJ
and anothn
followed
on the Viceroy's announcement dated the
; .... v.
30th
April,
1947, in pursuance of which the individual
K. M. R•jagopal1111
civil servants had been circularised and their wishes
Jagamurdhadu J.
ascertained, and the Governments concerned had
finally intimated their option not to invite the
continuance of the service of particular individuals
as has happened in the case of the present plaintiff.
To repel this conclusion, the learned counsel for the
respondent urges ( l) that .the "special orders or
arrange1I)ents" contemplated by article 7 ( 1) of the
India
(Provisional Constitution) Order, 194'.7, must
be valid orders or bilateral valid arrangements made
by the appropriate authority, amongst which category
according to him, the order of termination of the
service of the plaintiff-respondent, issued by the Chief
Secretary to the Government of Madras on the 8th
August, 1947, does not fall, and (2) that the previous
history commencing from the announcement by the
Viceroy is not admissible .to construe the meaning
and effect of the Indian Independence Act and the
legislative orders made by the Governqr-General
thereunder. As regards the ·first objection above, there
is no reason ,to. think that the words "special orders
or arrangements" . indicate either. a valid order or a
bilateral and valid arrangement. In view of the his
t!Jry as set out above and the extreme urgency with
which all these steps had necessarily to be· taken before the appointed day in order to facilitate a smooth
transition, the legislative authorities concerned must
be taken to have proceeded on a recognition of the
factual situation as it then existed. .For a similar
approach in a similar situa):ion see for instance Raj
Rajendra M alojirao Shitole "· The. State of Madhya
Bharat(') where this Court held that article 385 of the
Constitution proceeded on_ a recognition of the factual
situation, at the time, relating to the matter involved,_
Even apart from _-this answer to the objection, the
.objection itself appears to be based on a misapprehension. It is true there is no clear evidence in the
(1) [1954) s.c.R. 748, 757.
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
567
case that the order of termination of the service of
the plaintiff was one made with the sanction of then
Secretary of State. It may also be that the decision
not to retain his services as and from the 15th August,
1947, was based on his past record as admitted in the
written-statement and works serious hardship in view
of his not having had an opportunity to shpw cause.
But it was an order to come into operation at the
precise moment when the Indian Independence Act
came into force. At that moment the Secretary of
State's concern with this matter was at an end. There
i:s no reason to think that an order of this kind with
the sanction of the Central Government, not purporting to exercise a power of termination of services, but
acting on the assumption implicit in the Viceroy's
announcement that the services would come to an
automatic termination and intimating the decision of
the appropriate Government not to retain the services
of the plaintiff as and from the 15th August, 1947, is
not within the competence of the: very Government
under whose service, the plaintiff wanted to serve. The
very nature of the situation demanded the taking of
such anticipatory decisions and the communication of
the same to the person concerned, in order to become
operative at the crucial moment of the transition of
power. As regards the second objection, it appears to
us that the contention as regards the inadmissibility of
reference to the announcement of the Viceroy and the
action taken thereupon by the Central and the Provincial Governments, both in its general aspect as
also with reference to -individual cases like that of th.e
plaintiff, is without any substance. The phrase
"special orders or arrangements affecting his case" in
article 7(1) of the India (Ptovisional Constitution)
Order, 1947,. <:an on:ly refer to. this and similar other
material culminating in the orders and arrangements
relating, to the -concerned individuals. That there
were any other kind of special orders or arrangements
contemplated by this provision concerning' the Secretary of State's servites has not been suggested and it
is clear there were none. That such pre':'iOU'li material
which led up to the particular legislative prov $ion is
1955
Stat• of Mtidt1JS
~ IDWl/tn
....
Ir. Al. lllljagopalan
Ja1atlllihadas ].
568
1955
Slatt of Madras
and anolher
v.
K. M. Rajagopalan
Jagannadhadas J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
admissible in evidence has been so held in Ladore v.
Bennet(') which was held valid in Govindan Sellappah
Nayar Kodakan Pillai v. Punchi Banda Mudanayake( 2 ).
As pointed out by Lord Atkin in the case in Ladore v.
Bennett(') at page 477, such documents indicate the
materials which can be taken to have been before the
Governor-General when he
passed
the
relevant
legislative order. This material indicates quite clearly
that while the initial option to continue or not in
service was with the servant concerned, the final
option to continue him or not to continue him was
with the appropriate Government and that the special
orders or arrangements contemplated were the action
taken in pursuance of that final option.
It was faintly suggested that the Viceroy's
announcement of the 30th April, 1947, was before His
Majesty's- Government decided' to advance the date
of transfer of power by nearly a y~ar and that the
original announcement contemplated a treaty between
the British Government and the future Dominion
Government to regulate all these matters and that
since no such treaty has in fact been entered into,
the announcement was not admissible in evidence.
The fact that the transition of power took the form
of legislation by the British Parliament and not of a
regular treaty between the two Governments in view
of the changed circumstances is not a matter which
can in any way effect the situation so far as it relates
to the particular matter with which we are con·
cerned. It is that very announcement that has been
acted upon after the further announcement of the
3rd June, 1947. This appears clearly from the fact
that the circular letter of the Government of India to
the various provincial Chief Secretaries referred to
this very _announcement a:nd from the further fact
that the letter which was sent to each and every individual civil servant was accompanied by a copy of
the said announcement.
It is clear, therefore, from the above discussion
that apart from the fact that the Secretary of State
(1) (1939) A.C. 468.
(2) (1953] A.C. 514, 528.
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
569
and his services disappeared as from the 15th August,
1947, section 10(2) of the Indian Independence Act
and article 7 ( 1) of the India (Provisional Constitution)
Order proceeded on a clear and unequivocal recognition of the validity of the various special orders and
the individual arrangements made and amount to an
implicit statutory recognition of the principle of automatic termination of the services: brought about by
the political change. In our opinion, therefore, the
services of the plaintiff came to an automatic termination on the emergency of Indian Dominion. The
special order and arrangement affecting his case that
was made in pursuance of the Viceroy's announcement resulted in his service not being continued from
and after the 15th August, 1947, and the plaintiff is
not entitled to the declaration prayed for.
The learned Judges of the High Court in corning to
the conclusion they did, have with respect, missed
the significance of the phr~se "special orders or
arrangements affecting his case" used in article 7(1)
of the India (Provisional Constitution) Order, 1947,
and failed to appreciate that this was to be construed
in the light of all the relevant events that proceeded,
commencing from and following upon the -announcement of the Viceroy dated the 30th April, 1947.
The result is that the appeal is allowed, but in the
circumstances without costs.
18-83 S.C.India/59
1955
Slal1 of Madrar
and. anat/rer
v.
K. M. Rqjagopaltm
Jagannadhatlas J ~
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org