THE TROPICAL INSURANCE CO LTD. & OTHERS versus THE UNION OF INDIA & ANOTHER
Supreme Court of India | Decided 22 September 1955 | [1955] 2 S.C.R. 517 | 1955 INSC 43
Key facts
- Decided
- 22 September 1955
- Bench
- SUDHI RANJAN DAS*, N. CHANDRASEKHARA AIYAR, NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI, T.L. VENKATARAMA AIYYAR, SYED JAFFER IMAM
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 186/1954
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1955] 2 S.C.R. 517
- Neutral citation
- 1955 INSC 43
Text of the judgment
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
517
chand Nipani and Shri Maniklal Chunanlal Baroda
were not liable to pay any tax on these transactions
nor could any such liability for tax be transferred to
the petitioners by virtue of such declarations. If,
therefore, there was no basis for any such liability,
the declarations
by themselves cannot create any
new liability and the petitioners cannot be held liable
to tax even by the operation of section 4(6) of the
Act, the very basis of the liability sought to be imposed therein having disappeared.
The result, therefore, is that the Respondents will be
restrained from enforcing the Central Provinces and
Berar Sales Tax Act, 1947, and its provmons against
the petitioners and from imposing a tax in respect of
the transactions in question and in particular from
imposing a tax on the purchase price of goods purchased on the declarations under Rule 26 being goods
specified in the registration certificate as intended for
use as raw material in the manufacture of goods for
sale by actual delivery in Madhya Pradesh for the
purpose of consumption in that State but utilised for
any other purpose under the provisions of section
4(6) of the Act. The Re~ondents will pay the petitioners' costs of this petition.
1955
Mmrs Mohdll/al
J/argovind Das,
Bidi Merthanls,
Jabalpur (M. P.)
THE TROPICAL INSURANCE CO LTD.
& OTHERS
1955
v.
THE UNION OF INDIA & ANOTHER
(and connected petition.)
[S. R. DAS, ACTING C.J., BHAGWATI, VENKA1'ARAMA AYYAR, JAFER IMAM and CHANDRASEKHARA AYYAR JJ.)
Insurance-Insurer doing life insurance business along with
general insurance business-Power of Central Government to appoint
Administrator-Such power, if confined exclusively to life insurance
business-Grounds not taken in petition under Art 32, if can be
urged at the hearing-Insurance Act (IV of 1938), s. 52-A-Constitution of India, Art 32.
v.
Tht Stale of
Madhya Pradesh
and anothtr
Bhagawati J.
Sep11m/Jel 22
518
SUPREME COL'RT REPORTS
[19551
1955
The petitioners, two Insurance Companies, carrying on business
both in life insurance and general insurance, questioned the
Tht Tropical
Insurance Co. Ltd, validity of notifications issued against them under s. 52-A of the Inand otlurs
surance Act for appointment of Administrators to take ov~r managev.
ment of their affairs on the ground, inter alia, that s. 52-A was exTM Union of India clusively restricted to life insurance business and the Government
and anotlur
had no power to take over n1anagement of general insurance business.
Held, that the Insurance Act of 1938 no doubt makes a distinc·
tion between life insurance business and general insurance business,
but its main concern is to protect life insurance polic·y-holdcrs.
Although s. 52-A of t~e Act has no application to an insurer who
carries on husiness in general insurance alone, it undonhtedlv applies
to an insurer who combines both and gives the Central Government the powe-r, on the report of the Controller, to appoint an
Administrator to take over the management of the entire business
of the insurer including general insurance business when such insurer
is found to act in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the life
policy-holders.
That grounds not specifically taken in petitions under Ait.
32 cannot be urged at the time of the hearing.
ORIGINAL JuRisDICTioN : Petitions Nos. 186 &
of 1954.
195
Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India for
the enforcement of Fundamental Rights.
S. C. Isaacs, (Mohan Behari Lal and P. K. Ghosh,
with him) for the petitioners in both petitions.
M. C. Setalvad, Attorney-General of India (Porus
A Mehta and P. G. Gokhale, with him) for the respondents.
1955. September
Court was delivered by
22. The
Judgment
of
the
IMAM J.-These petitions under article 32 of the
Constitution of India question the validity of the notifications issued under section 52-A of the Insurance
Act of 1938 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) and
the appointment of an Administrator. In the case of
the Tropical Insurance Company Ltd. an Administrator was appointed under notification dated the 14th
of July, 1951 and in the case of the Jupiter General
Insurance Company· Ltd. another Administrator was
appointed under notification dated the 10th of July,
2 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
519
1951. These two insurance companies do insurance
business of life insurance and general insurance. Admittedly previous to the appointment of the Administrators the Controller issued notices under section
52-A to the petitioners and the Finance Ministry of
the Central Government sent letters to them pointing
out the allegations in the report of the Controller to
which they replied.
The learned Counsel for the petitioners has candidl y stated that he coultl not raise any constitutional
point after the fourth amendment to the Constitution
of India. He assumed, therefore, that the provisions
of sections 52-A to 52-G of. the Act were constitutional
but he urged that the notifications under section 52-A
and the taking over of the management of the affairs
of the companies were invalid inasmuch as they were
in excess of the powers conferred by section 52-A of
the Act and that the notifications appointing
the
Administrators do not fix the period of management
as required by law. He further urged that the provisions of the section 52-B of the Act had not been
complied with and in consequence the management
by the Administrator had been excessively prolonged
and thus had become unlawful. There has, therefore,
been a violation of the "fundamental rights of the petitioners. Finally it was urged that there was no authority either under the provisions of the Act or of any
other law by which the Government was empowered
to take over management of the affairs of the company with respect to its general irtsurance business.
The power of the Government under section 52-A was
restricted exclusively to life insurance business.
As to the first two contentions, they were urged in
Petitions Nos. 94 of 1954 and 183 of 1954 but were
not allowed to be put forward by this Court as these
questions had not been specifically raised in the petitions under article 32 of the Constitution and they
were accordingly dismissed. The position is simila~
in this respect so far as the present applications are
concerned and consequently it must be held that the
. petitioners cannot be allowed now to urge grounds
which they had not taken in their petitions.
66
1955
T"4 Tropical
Iruurance Co. Ltd.
and others
v.
The Union of Indio
and another
Imam].
520
1955
The Tropical
Insurana Co. IJd.
and others
v.
4
T/11 Union oj India
and another
Imam].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
L1955J
There remains, however, to consider the last contention urged on behalf of the petitioners. It was
pointed out by Mr. Isaacs that the petitioners are insurance companies doing both life insurance business
and general insurance business.
He contends that
section 52-A of the Act, on a true interpretation of its
provisions, applies only to the life insurance business
carried on by an insurer and not to the general insurance business done by him. The Administrator appointed under section 52-A Gf the Act could therefore
take over management only of the life insurance business done by the insurer. The notifications authorising him to take over the management of the insurance
business of the insurer including his general insurance
business were thus beyond the powers conferred on
Government under section 52-A of the Act and such
taking over of the management of the general insurance business of the petitioners by the Administrator
was, therefore, without lawful authority.
In view of the submission made by the learned Counsel, it is necessary to set out the relevant provisions
of the section 52-A. Sub-section (1) of that section
states:"If at any time the Controller has reason to believe that an insurer carrying· on life insurance business is acting in a manner likely to be prejudicial to
the interests of holders of life insurance policies, he
may, after giving such opportunity to the insurer to
be heard as he thinks fit, make a report thereon to
the Central Government".
Sub-section (2) states:"The Central Government, if it is of opinion after
considering the report that it is necessary or proper
to do so, may appoint an Administrator to manage
the affairs of the insurer under the direction and control of the Controller''.
Sub-section ( 4) states :"The management of the business of the insurer
shall as on and after the date of appointment of the
Administrator vest in such Administrator, but except
with the leave of the Controller the Administrator
shall not issue any further policies".
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
521
Section 52-B of the Act is concerned with the powers
and duties of the Administrator. Under this section,
the Administrator shall conduct the management of
the business of the insurer with the greatest economy
compatible with efficiency and shall, as soon as may
be possible, file with the Controller a report stating
what specified courses unde:r the section should be
taken which would be most advantageous to the
general interest of the holders of life policies. One of
the courses specified is the winding up of the business
of the insurer. Section 52-D of the Act is concerned
with termination of the appointment of the Administrator. Section 53 of the Act is concerned with the
winding up by the Court and it enable the Controller
to apply to the Court for winding up of an insurance,
company on certain grounds, one of them being that
the continuance of the company would be prejudicial
to the interests of the policy-holders·
Mr. Isaacs urged that the Act made a clear distinction between life insurance business and general insurance business of an insurer. He referred to various
sections of the Act with reference to Registration,
Separation of Accounts and Funds and Balance-Sheets.
It was also pointed out by him that the Act defines
"general insurance business" and "life insurance business" and these two kinds of businesses are quite distinct. There could be little doubt that the Act does
regard "life insurance business" as something distinct
from "general insurance business". It seems to us.
however, that while keeping this distinction in mind,
we have to give to the words used in section 52-A(l)
their ordinary and natural meaning. "Insurer" has
been defined in section 2 of the Act. The definition
speaks of an insurer cc.rrying on an insurance business. This business may be either a life insurance
business or a general insurance business or both.
Under section 7 of the Act deposits have to be made
by every insurer other than an insurer specified in
sub-clause ( c) of clause (9) of section 2. The section
specifies µie amount of deposit to be made where the
business done is life insurance only.
Similarly it
specifies the deposit to be made in the case of business.
15-93 S.C. India/59
1955
TlllTropieal
11u.,_ Co. Ltd.
11114 al/urs
•.
v.
""" ,,..,
Thi Ullin of India
1-J.
522
1955
Tht Tropical
Iruurance Co. [Jr!.
and others
v.
The Union of Ilfdia
and ,,,.,,,,,,.
1-1.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
done which comes within the description of general
insurance business only. It also contemplates a combination of life insurance business and general insurance business and specifies the deposit to be made in
such event. It is clear that section 52-A ( 1) does not
apply to an insurer doing only general insurance business. The question . for decision is does it apply to
him when he also does along with such business life
insurance business? Section 52-A(l) speaks of "an
insurer carrying on life insurance business". It does
not speak of "only life insurance business".
It is
permissible for an insurer to combine in his insurance
business both life and general insurance business. If
he acts in a manner which is likely to be prejudicial
to the interests of the holders of the life insurance
policies with him, he makes himself amenable to the
provisions of the section 52-A of the Act and the Controller is authorised to make a report to the Central
Government. The Central Government, after considering the report, may appoint an Administrator to
manage '.'the affairs" of th~ insurer and the management of "the business" of the insurer shall vest in the
Administrator.
The words "the affairs" and "the
business" of the insurer are wide enough to empower
the Central Government to take over the management of the entire business of the insurer including
his general insurance business.
To hold otherwise
would be to give an unnatural meaning to the words
used in section 52-A of the Act. In the present case
the insurers are public limited companies and it is
difficult to conceive that the Act intended to vest in
the Administrator the management of only the life
insurance business while the insurers would be free to
manage the general insurance business, because under
section 52-B the Administrator may suggest to the
Controller for the winding up of the company after
managing
its insurance busines.s economically and
efficiently.
Under section 53 a Court may order a
winding up of an insurance company if on an application by the Controller, it is satisfied that the continuance of the company is prejudicial to the interests
of the policy-holders. The winding up of the com-.
2S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
523
pany would be concerned with its entire insurance
business including life and general insurance business,
because there could be no partial winding up of a
company. It is not difficult to imagine that the affairs
of the company with reference to its general insurance
business may be in such a hopeless state that winding
up may be the only course to be taken to protect the
interests of the life . policy-holders. When the provisions of the Act are closely examined, it will be noticed
that its main policy has been to safeguard the interests of life policy-holders, who are deeply affected
by the manner in which the insurance business of an
insurer is carried on. We have no difficulty in interpreting section 52-A(l) to mean that where an insurer
is carrying on insurance business of various kinds
which includes life insurance business, he becomes
amenable to the provisions of section 52-A if he is
acting in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the
holders of life policies and he would have to suffer the
consequences following the report made by the Controller and the appointment of an Administrator by
the Government.
The provisions in the Act making
a distinction between life insurance business and
general insurance business, the keeping of separate
accounts :md balance-sheets have been enacted for the
safeguard of the holders of life insurance policies and
they provide an over-all picture of the business done
by the insurer showing the exact state of affairs concerning !he life insurance business of the insurer. These
provisions cannot and do not aflect the provisions of
of section 52-A of the Act.
These pet1t1ons are accordingly dismissed with
costs to be paid by Petitioners 2, 3 and 4 in Petition
No. 186 of 1954 and Petitioners 2 and 3 in Petition
No. 195 of 1954.
1955
Tiu Tropical
Insurance Co. !Jd.
and olhtrs
v.
Tiu Union of India
and anothtr
/11111m].
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org