CAPTAIN GANP ATI SINGHJI versus THE STATE OF AJMER AND ANOTHER.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 3 December 1954 | [1955] 1 S.C.R. 1065 | 1954 INSC 117
Key facts
- Decided
- 3 December 1954
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN, BIJAN KUMAR MUKHERJEA, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, VIVIAN BOSE, NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI, B. JAGANNADHADAS, T.L. VENKATARAMA AIYYAR
- Bench size
- 7
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 43/1954
- Disposal
- Amount Awarded
- Citation
- [1955] 1 S.C.R. 1065
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 117
Text of the judgment
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
)!
1065
CAPTAIN GANPATI SINGHJI
r954
o.
Derembdr 3
THE STATE OF AJMER AND ANOTHER.
'·
-
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C. J., MuKHERJEA,
S. R. DAs, VIVIAN BosE, BHAGWATI, JAGANNADHADAS
and V:ENKATARAMA AYYAR JJ.]
Ajmer Laws Regulation of 1877 (Reg. III of 1877), s. 40Chief Commissioner empowered to make rules for establishing a system
of conservancy and sanitation at fairs-First three sub-rules of Rule
1 prohibit the holding of fair except under a permit issued by District
Magistrate who is required to satisfy himself that applicant can
establish a proper system of conservancy-Fourth sub-rule empowering District Magistrate to revoke permit without assigning any reason
or without previous notice--Sub-rules-Whether ultra vires the Regulation.
Under s. 40 of the Ajmer Laws Regulation of 1877 (Reg. III of
1877) the Chief Commissioner is empowered, among other things, to
make rules about " ............ the establishment of a proper system
of conservancy and sanitation at fairs .................... ". The
first three sub-rules of Rule 1, framed by the Chief Commissioner
prohibit the holding of a fair except under a permit issued by the
District Magistrate and the District Magistrate is enjoined "to satisfy himself, before issuing any permit that the applicant is in a
position to establish a proper system of conservancy, sanitation and
·
watch and ward at the fair".
The fourth sub-rule empowers the District Magistrate "to revoke
any such permit without assigning any reasons or giving any previous notice',.
The appellant's application for a permit to hold a fair was refused by the · District Magistrate on the ground that no more permits
were to be issued to private individuals.
Held, that under the Regulation it is the Chief Commissioner
and not the District Magistrate who has power to frame rules, that
the Chief Commissioner had no authority to delegate that power
and that the Rules made by the latter are therefore ultra vires;
Held further, that the Rule is also ultra vires for the reason
that in authorising the District Magistrate to revoke a permit granted
"without giving any reason or previous notice" it invests him with
a power to prohibit the exercise by the citizen of the constitutionally
protected right to hold fairs.
The District Magistrate's order, which in effect prohibits the
holding of the fair, is therefore bad, for, without the aid of these
rules or ~ome other law validly empowering him to impose the ban,
he has no 'power in himself to do it.
)
1066
1 954
Captain Ganpati
Singhji
v.
Tiu Stat< of Ajm<r
and Anoth"
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
Per JAGANNADHADAS J. (DAs J. concurring):The impugned order of the District Magistrate is bad:(i) because the rules do not authorise him to reject an application on the ground on which he has done;
(ii) because the net effect of the rules is to establish a system
of ad hoc control by the District Magistrate through the issue of. a
permit and by the vesting of other powers in him under the rules.
This result is not within the intendment of the section which autho~
rises the making of the rules.
Tahir Hussain v. District Board, Muzafarnagar (A.I.R. 195+
S.C. 630) referred to.
C1VIL APPELLATE
43 of 1954.
..
·
JuR1so1cTION: Civil
Appeal No.
Appeal under Article 132(1) of the Constitution
of India from the Judgment and Order dated the 22nd
November 1952 of the Judicial Commissioner's Court,
Ajmer, in Misc. Petition No. 226 of 1952.
N. C. Chatterji (I. N. Shroff,
appellant.
with
him)
Porus A. Mehta and P. G. Gokhale for the
dents.
for
'<
/
the
respon-
1954. December 3. The judgment of Mehr Chand
Mahajan C.J., Mukherjea, Vivian Bose, Bhagwati and
Venkatarama Ayyar JJ. was delivered by Bose J.
The judgment of Das and Jagannadhadas J. was
delivered by Jagannadhadas J.
Bose J.-The appellant 1s the Istimrardar of
Kharwa. According to him, he has he1d a cattle fair
on his estate every year for some twenty years. On
8-1-1951 the Chief Commissioner of Ajmer framed
certain rules for the regulation of cattle and other
fairs in the State of Ajmer. He purported to do this
under sections 40 and 41 of the Ajmer Laws Regulation
of 1877 (Reg. III of 1877). One of the rules required
that persons desiring to hold fairs should obtain a permit from the District Magistrate. Accordingly the appellant applied for a permit. This was refused on the
ground that no more permits were to be issued to
private individuals. The appellant thereupon .applied
under article 226 of the Constitution to the Judicial
..
.
S.C.R.
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1067
Commissioner's Court at Ajmer for the issue of a writ
directing the authorities concerned to permit the appeilant to hold his fair as usual. He contended that
his fundamental rights under the Constitution were
infringed and also that the rules promulgated by the
Chief Commissioner were ultra vzres the Regulation
under which he purported to act.
The learned Judicial Commissioner refused to issue
the writ but granted leave to appeal under article
132 ( 1) of the Constitution m the foilowing terms:
"I am of opinion that the question whether the
regulation and the
bye-laws framed
thereunder
to
a
reasonable
restriction
on
the
appeilant's
amount
fundamental right to hold a cattle fair m his own
land involves a substantial question of law as to the
interpretation of the Constitution".
The leave is confined to the vires of the Regulation
and the bye-laws but we allowed the appellant to attack the validity of the District Magistrate's action
as well.
_,
It is admitted that the land on which the fair 1s
normally held belongs to the appellant. That being
so, he has a fundamental right under article 19(1) (£)
which can only be restricted in the manner permitted
by sub-clause (5). The holding of an annual fair is
an occupation or business within the meaning of article 19(1) (g), therefore, the appellant also has a fundamental right to engage in that occupation on his land
provided it does not infringe any law imposing "reasonable restrictions on that right m the interests of
the general public", or any law
"relating to( i) the professional or technical
qualifications
necessary for
practising . ......... or carrying on"
the
occupation or business in question. (Article 19(6) as
amended in 1951).
The only law relevant here 1s sections 40 and 41 of
Regulation III of 1877. Under section 40, the Chief
Commissioner is empowered, among other things, to
make rules about-
1954
Captain Ganpati
Singhji
v.
The State of Ajmer
and Another
Bose].
1068
' 1954
Captain Ganpati
Singhji
v.
Th< State of Ajmer
and Another
-l
Bose:J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955}
" (a) the maintenance of watch and ward, and the
establishment of a proper system of conservancy and
sanitation at fairs and other large public assemblies;
(b) the imposition of taxes for the purposes mentioned in clause (a) of this section on persons holding
or joining any of the assemblies therein referred to ;
( e) the registration of cattle".
Section 41 provides for penalties m the following
terms:
"The Chief Commissioner may, in making any
rule under this Regulation, attach to the breach of it,
in addition to any other consequences that would enure from such breach, a punishment, on conv1ct1on
before a Magistrate, not exceeding rigorous or simple
imprisonment for a month or a fine of two hundred
rupees, or both".
These sections were not impugned in the argument
before us nor were they attacked in the petition made
to the Judicial Commissioner, so we will pass on to
the rules made by the Chief Commissioner.
The first three sub-rules of Rule 1 deal with permits.
They prohibit the holding of a fair except under a
permit issued by the District Magistrate, and the
District Magistrate is enjoined to-"satisfy himself, before issuing any permit, that
establish a proper
the applicant is in a position to
system of conservancy, sanitation and watch and
ward at the fair".
The fourth sub-rule empowers the District Magistrate
to
"revoke any such permit without ass1gnmg any
reasons or giving any previous notice".
When the appellant applied for a permit on
9-7-1952, the District Magistrate replied :
"It has been decided that as a matter of policy
permits to hold fairs will be issued only to local bodies
and not to private individuals. It is, therefore, regretted that you cannot be permitted to hold the fair
and you are therefore requested to please abandon
the idea".
In our opinion, the rules travel beyond the Regn-
'
S.C.R.
·''
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1069
lation in at least two respects. The Regulation empowers the Chief Commissioner to make rules for the
establishment of a system of conservancy and sanitation. He can only do this by bringing a system into
existence and incorporating it in his rules so that
all concerned can know what the system is and make
arrangements to comply with it. What he has done
is to leave it to the District Magistrate to see that
persons desiring to hold a fair are in a position "to
establish a proper system of conservancy, etc." But
who, according to this, is to determine what a proper
system is: obviously the District Magistrate. Therefore, in effect, the rules empower the District Magistrate to make his own system and see that it is
observed. But the Regulation confers this power on
the Chief Commissioner and not on the District Magistrate. therefore the action of the Chief Commissioner
in delegating this authority to the District Magistrate
is ultra vires.
Further, under the fourth sub-rule of Rule 1 the
District Magistrate is empowered to revoke a permit
granted "without assigning any reasons or giving any
previous notice". This absolute and arbitrary power
uncontrolled by any discretion is also ultra vires. The
Regulation assumes the right of persons to hold fairs,
and all it requires is that those who do so should have
due regard tor the requirements of conservancy and
sanitation; and in order that they may know just
what these requirements are, the Chief Commissioner
(not some lesser authority) is given the power to draw
up a set of rules stating what is necessary.
If they
are in a position to observe these rules, they are, so
far as the Regulation is concerned, entitled to hold
their fair, for there is no other law .restricting that
right. Therefore, the Chief Commissioner cannot by
Rule invest the District Magistrate witl1 the right
arbitrarily to prohibit that which the law and the
Constitution, not only allow, but guarantee.
As these sub-rules of Rule 1 are ultra vires, the
District Magistrate's order, which in effect prohibits
the holding · of the fair, is also bad for, without the
aid of these rules or of some other law · validly
Captain Ganpati
Singhji
v.
The State of Ajmer
and Another
Bose].
1070
1 954
Captain Ganpati
Singhji
v.
The State of AjrMr
and Another
Bose].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955j
empowering him to impose the ban, he has no power
in himself to do it. The matter is covered by the
decision of this Court in Tahir Hussain v. District
Board, Muzafarnagar(').
The appeal is allowed and the order of the Judicial
Commissioner is set aside. We declare that the rules
are void to the extent indicated above and we quash
the order of the District Magistrate dated 18-9-1952.
But we make no order about costs because the point
on which we have proceeded was not taken in proper.
time in this Court.
]AGANNADHADAS
J.-The order
of the
District
Magistrate dated the 18th September, 1952, declining
to grant a permit to hold the cattle fair on the ground
that it has been decided to issue permits only to local
bodies and not to private individuals is bad for two
reasons.
1. The rules under which he is to grant ·or refuse
permits in this behalf only authorise him to satisfy
himself that the applicant is in a position to establish a proper system of conservancy, sanitation and
watch and ward at the fair and also to impose such
terms and conditions as he may deem fit. But they
do not authorise him to reject an application on the
ground on w111ch he has done.
2. The rules themselves under which the permit
has been asked for and with reference to which the
District Magistrate declined to grant the permit are
not within the ambit of the rule-making power. These
rules purport to have been framed in exercise of the
powers conferred by sections 40 and 41 of the Ajmer
Laws Regulation, 1877. Section 40 authorises the
framing of the rules "for the maintenance of watch
and ward and the establishment or a proper system of
conservancy and sanitation at fairs and other large
public assemblies". But the actual rules as framed
are to the effect ( 1) that no such fair can be held
except under a permit of the District Magistrate, (2)
that before issuing a permit the District Magistrate
1s to satisfy himself
that the applicant is in a position
(1) A. I. R. 1954 S.C. 630.
,
:s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1071
to establish a proper system of conservancy, sanitation and watch and ward at the fair, (3) that when
issuing a permit the District Magistrate can impose
such terms and conditions as he may deem fit. The
net effect of these rules is merely to establish a system
·of ad hoc control by the District Magistrate through
the issue of a permit and by the vesting of other powers
in him under the rules. These cannot be said to be
rules which in themselves constitute a system of con.servancy, sanitation and watch and ward. Thus the
result that is brought about is not within the intendment of the section which authorises the making of
the rules. A system of ad hoc control of responsible
·officers may, possibly be one method of regulating
the sanitary and other arrangements at such large
.gatherings. But if it is intended to
constitute a
system of ad hoc control with reasonable safeguards,
the power to make rules in that behalf must be granted
to the rule-making authority by the legislative organ
in appropriate language.
The impugned order of the District Magistrate being bad on both the above grounds, this is enough to
dispose of the appeal and it is not necessary to express any opinion as to whether the impugned order
infringes also the appellant's fundamental
rights
under article 19. The appeal must accordingly be
:allowed.
Appeal allowed.
-
DUNI CHAND RATARIA
v.
BHUWALKA BROTHERS LTD.
.'
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.J., BHAGWATI, JAGANNADHADAS and VENKATARAMA AYYAR JJ.]
West Bengal Jute Goods Future Ordinance, 1949, s. 2(1) ( b) (i)
-Actual delivery of possession-Whether includes symbolical as well
as constructive delivery of pos.<ession-lndian Sale of Goods Act, 1930
(111 of 1930), s. 2(2)-Delivery-Meaning of.
Delivery has been defined in s. 2(2) of Indian Sale of Goods
Act, 1930, as meaning voluntary transfer of possession from one per-
1 954
Captain G{lflpati
Singhji
v.
The State of Ajmer
and Another
Jagannadhwfas J.
1 954
December 3
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org