BHATARAJU NAGESHWARA RAO versus THE HONBLE JUDGES OF THE MADRAS HIGH COURT AND OTHERS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 3 December 1954 | [1955] 1 S.C.R. 1055 | 1954 INSC 119
Key facts
- Decided
- 3 December 1954
- Bench
- BIJAN KUMAR MUKHERJEA, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, VIVIAN BOSE
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 146/1954
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1955] 1 S.C.R. 1055
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 119
Text of the judgment
S.C.R.
1055
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
superior Courts of orders passed by the Subordinate
Courts. In such circumstances, there is hardly any
ground for · apprehending any capnc1ous discrimination by judicial tribunals.
On the facts and circumstances of this case we find
<>Urselves in agreement with S. K. Das, J., and Reuben,
C.J., and hold that no case of infringement of fundamental right under Article 14 has been made out. In
the circumstances, we dismiss this appeal. .
Appeal dismissed.
1
Bihar
Das].
Dectmber 3
It is wrong and inappropriate to implead the Judges of the High
"" Court as respondents in an appeal preferred to the Supreme Court by
an Advocate against whom .an order of suspension was passed by the
High Court under s. 12 of the Indian Bar Councils Act, 1926. In
such appeal the proper respondents are the complainant if any, the
Bar Council or Secretary thereof and the Advocate-General of the
State concerned.
CIVIL
APPELLATE
No. 146 of 1954.
.,.:;
TheSta~'oj
fl.
Procedu·re-Supreme Court-Suspension of Advocate by High
Court-Appeal to Supreme Court-Respondents to be impleaded in
such appeal-Indian Bar Councils Act (XXXVIII of 1926), s. 12.
·-+
Budhan GhOudhry
and Others
v·.
1954
[MuKHERJEA, S. R. DAs and VIVIAN BosE JJ.]
..
954
BHATARAJU NAGESHWARA RAO
THE HON'BLE JUDGES OF THE MADRAS
HIGH COURT AND OTHERS.
y
1
JURISDICTION :
Civil
Appeal
Appeal by Special Leave from the Judgment and
Order dated the 17th day of December, 1952, of the
High Court of Judicature at Madras in Referred Case
No. 45 of 1952 arising out of the Report dated the
27th day of March, .1951, of the Court of District
Judge, Krishna in C.M.P; No. 123 of 1951.
S. P. Sinha, (K. R. Chaudhary and Sardar
dur, with him), for the appellant.
Baha-
R. Ganapathy Iyer and P. G. Gokhale, for
dent No. L
respon-
1056
'.954
, ·Bhataraju
N ageshwara Rao
v.
The· !/qn'bleJudgts
of t!M Madras
High. Court and
Qtlurs
Das J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[.1955]
T. Satyanarayana and P. G. Gokhale, for re'spon·
dent No. 3•.
1954.' December 3. The Judgment of the Court
was delivered by
DAs J.'-This is an appeal by special \eave frorri an
order made by a Special Bench of the High Court of
Judicature at Madras under section 12 of ·the Indian
Bar Councils Act· (Act XXXVIII of 1926) debarring
the appellant from practising as ah advocate for a.
period of ·five years.
The material facts are these. T~~ appellant before
us is an advocate ordinarily ·practismg at Masaulipatam. In Calendar Case No. 1 of 1949 on the file of
the Additional First Class Magistrate's Cqurt at
Masaiilipatam nin'e · persons · were :charged · with the
offence of cortveying rice from the village to other
villages without permits. Accused .Nos. 2 and 4 were
not represented by any · advocate. Accused Nos. 1, 3,
5, 6 and 8, all cart-men, were defended by .. the. appellant. Accused No.· 7, who initiated the proceedings:
out of which ·the present appeal arises and who is;
hereinafter referred to as "the petitioner", was defended· by · another ad vacate. The case was disposed'
•of on the 30th September, · 1949. Accused Nos. 1, 3,
5 and 6 were acquitted. Accused No. 2
convicted·
and sentenced to a fine of Rs. 20 and m default of
payment of fine to undergo simple imprisonment for
one month. Accused No. 4 and the petitioner, accused'.
No. 7; were also convicted and sentenced to pay a fine
of Rs. 300/- each and in default of payment of firie toundergo simple imprisoll1I)ent for six months. · Accused
No. 8 was sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 100/-. and in
default of payment of the fine, to simple' imprison-·
rnent for three months.· Accused No. 2 paid . the fine·
but the other three convicted persons . did ·not. The
four convicted persons including the petitioner there-.
after .engaged the appellant to prefer an appeal to the
Sessions ·Court. ·The appeal was presented before the
Sessions Court on the 8th October, 1949 and. on the
same-day a. petition was filed on ..behalf of'. accused
Nos. 4, 7 (petitioner) and 8 for an order staying the,
•
I
was
•
S.C.R.
'
---.'
'
-
-+ ..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1057
.realisation of the . fine. . , That application . for . stay
came up. before the learned Sessions Judge· on· the 10th.
October, 1949 when .notice was directed . , to· :issue . ta
the Public · Prose~utor. On, the. 11th. ·October,. 1949 ·the
learned. Judge passed ·the .following order: .
'
"Suspended pending disposal ·of this :petition.
Call on .14. 10''.
On the 14th October, 1949 •the following. further order
was passed :"Execution . of sentences ·suspended· ·'till disposal
of appeal".
The. appeal was posted ·for .hearing on . the 25th
November, 1949 and was adjourned from time · to time.
Eventually, it was .finally heard on the · 13th July,
1950 wl).en the appeal.was allowed 'and the conviction
and sentences of all the appellants were set .·.aside.. · On
the 25th January, 1951 . the petitioner caused. a registered notice (Ex. A/2) to be sent. to the appellant
alleging that on the 11th October, 1949 the appellant
had represented to him that the Court had refused to
suspend the 'sentences . and that ·unless the amount· of
fine was deposited the petitioner would be sent to jail.
It was further alleged . that on such representation the
petitioner had on that day paid to the appellant . · a
sum of Rs. 300 for which the . appellant·· had passed to
the petitioner a chit (Ex. A/l.) under his own signature acknowledging receipt of the said sum. The chit
(Ex. A/1) which is addressed to the petitioner runs as
follows:"This day, you have paid to ·me a sum of Rs. 300
(three hundred rupees only)".
It is signed by the appellant and below his signature
appears the date 11th October 1949 and the time 5-15
P.M. is also mentioned below the signature.
The allegation in the registered notice further was that the
appellant had concealed from the petitioner the · fact
that the order for payment of fine had been suspended
until the hearing of the appeal and also that the appeal had eventually been allowed. . The notice. ended
with a threat that if the appellant failed. to rehlrn the
sum of Rs. 300 together with interest . at. . 12 per cent.
per annum . from the 11th · October 1949 up ;to date of
1954
Bhataraju .
Na'grshwara Rao
' ,. .ll.·
- '
Tlui Hon'ble Judge:;
qf the Madras
'High Court and
Others
Das J.
1058
1 954
Bhataraju
Nageshwara Rao
v.
"[he Hon'ble Judges
of the Madras
High Court and
- Others
Das J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
payment the petitioner would be constrain~d, · in addition to such other proceedings as he .may be advised
to take for recovery of the said amount, to complain
against the appellant and his unprofessional conduct
to the High Court and the Bar Council. This notice
was received by the appellant on the 12th February
1951 and on the next day, 13th February 1951, the
appellant issued three registered notices Exs. A/3, A/4
and A/5 to the petitioner. In Ex. A/5 the appellant
complained that the petitioner had been evading payment of the agreed fee of Rs. 150 and on firm demand
having been made by the appellant on the 21st January 1951 for payment of such fee before the 25th
January 1951 the petitioner had issued the registered
notice Ex. A/2. In Ex. A/4 the appellant alleged that
the petitioner instructed the appellant to file a stay
petition as the · petitioner was unable to pay the fine
and that the appellant filed the petition accordingly
and obtained a stay order about which the petitioner
was fully aware. In those circumstances the allegations contained in the petitioner's notice Ex. A/2
were false ·and highly defamatory. He further alleged
that the petitioner was also present in Court on the
13th July 1950 when the appeal was allowed. In the
circumstances, there was no need for ·the petitioner
to pay any money to the appellant for the purpose
of paying the fine. The appellant called upon the
petitioner to withdraw the allegations and tender an
unqualified apology immediately. In Ex. A/3 the
appellant stated that the petitioner had come to him
on the 6th October 1949 to engage him as his advocate
for filing an appeal. Seeing that the appellant· was
then pressed for money for payinent of an instalment
of a loan No. 616 to the Land Mortgage Bank, Pedana;
the petitioner volunteered to arrange for a loan of
Rs. 300 for the appellant at Pedana. and asked him to
give a chit in his favour and to send the appellant's
derk with the petitioner. The petitioner did not, however, succeed in arranging for any money but the chit
Ex. A/1 remained with him. There was a denial that
there was any consideration for the chit Ex. A/I. On
the 7th March 1951 the petitioner sent a reply generally.
•
I
y
S.C.R.
•
'
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1059
Jg54
denying the allegations contained in the three several
notices sent by the appellant to the petitioner. That
Bhataraju
Rao ·
reply was received by the appellant on the 13th March Nageshwara
v.
1951 and on the 14th March 1951 the appellant issued The Hon'ble Judg.s
qfThe Madras
a further rejoinder Ex. A/7 denying the allegations
High Court and
in the petitioner's reply and stating that the stateOthers
ments in his three notices were true. It was further
Das J•
alleged that when the petitioner failed to supply the
amount mentioned in the chit Ex. A/1 the appellant
asked him to return the chit but the petitioner said
that the chit was missing and that he would search
for it and return it subsequently and so saying the
petitioner gave the appellant on the 16th October 1949
a hand letter (Ex. D /8) admitting that the petitioner
was unable to supply the amount of Rs. 300 mentioned
in the said chit as promised. The petitioner did not
send any reply to this letter in spite of the fact that
the appellant had therein referred to a hand letter
(Ex. D/8) dated the 16th October 1949 which totally
nullified the value of the chit Ex. A/I.
The petitioner then on the 27th March, 1951 sent a
petition to the High Court making a complaint against
the appellant of professional misconduct and praying
that the Hon'ble High Court might be pleased to order
an enquiry into the allegations made in his complaint and to take such action against the appellant
as was necessary and expedient in the circumstances
of the case. Along with the petition were submitted
a photograph of the chit Ex. A/1 and copies of the
registered correspondence that passed
between the
petitioner and the appellant. Even in this pet1t10n
the petitioner did not refer to the hand letter (Ex.
D/8) of the 16th October 1949 and did not specifically
deny having written the same. Upon the presentation of the petition the appellant submitted a written
explanation before the High Court. The High Court,
under section 10 of the Indian Bar Councils Act, referred the matter to the District Judge to enquire into the allegations made in the petition and to submit
a repo1t.
The District Judge issued a notice to the appellant
setting forth the following charges :-
1060
1 954
Bhataraju
Nages_hwara ·RdO.
v.
The Hon'ble Jndges
ofthtMadras
High Court and
Others)
pas J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS.
[i9551
"l. That you have · suppressed · fraudulently the
order 0£ the Additional Sessions Judge, Krishna at
Masaulipatam, suspending payment of fine of Rs. · 300
and made in Crl.. M. P. No. 180 of 1949 in C:A. No. 82
of 1949 preferred against the conv1Ct1on and sentence
passed by the Additional First Class Magistrate,
Bandar, in C.C. No. 1 of 1949, on his file, against the
petitioner, who is the seventh accused therein ;
2. That you,
having
fraudulently
suppressed
the above stated fact, have represented to the petitioner that the amount of fine of Rs. 300 had to be
deposited into Court on pain of the pet1t10ner being
sent to jail and received the said sum of Rs. 300 from
him and passed a· receipt in his favour for the same;
3. That you, even though the above said C.A. No.
82 of 1949 on the file of the Additional Sessions Judge,
Krishna at Masaulipatam was allowed by the judgment dated 13-7-1950, having all knowledge about it
did not inform the petitioner that the said C.A. No.
82 of 1949 was disposed of, and later on informed him
that it was dismissed, and the conviction and sentence were confirmed ;
4. That you, therefore, wrongfully withheld the
amount of Rs. 300 belonging to the petitioner without depositing into Court as represented by you and
also without refunding it to the petitioner even after
the said appeal was allowed in spite of repeated requests and demands made by him, and
5. That you have falsely set up a plea of not having received the said sum of Rs. 300 from the petitioner, for which you have passed a receipt in his
favour, and later on set up that you wanted to borrow
the said amount from him during the subsistence of
the relationship of advocate and client, which (borrowing from a client) itself is prohibited by law".
The petitioner examined himself (P.\V. 1) and his
brother Potharaju (P.W. 2) as his witnesses in support of the allegations in the petition. The appellant
examined himself (R. W. 1) and his clerk D Venkatarangam (R. W. 2), Kameswararao, the secertary of the
Vadlamannadu Co-operative Land Mortgage Bank at
•
..
'<
I
y
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1061
~
Pedana (R.W. 3) and Venktadri, clerk of an advocate
·
··
(R.W. 4) in support of his defence.
On a consideration of 'the entire evidence the learned District Judge found that the testimony · of the
petitioner and his brother was not credible and acceptable and that there was' no · reason. to reject the
._ ·-( testimony of the appellant and his clerk and other
"" " witnesses and he came to the conclusion that it had
not been satisfactorily proved that the ·appellant' was
guilty of any of the charges· framed against him. The
'
District Judge sent a report accordingly.
The matter was placed before a Special Bench of
the Madras High Court. The Special Bench had no
hesitation in agreeing with the findings of the learned
r
District Judge on charges 1, 2 and 3. In their opinion
' much reliance could not be placed on the veracity of
the complainant himself. The High Court, in agreement with the learned District Judge, held that the
appellant was not guilty of the first three · charges.
Coming to the last two charges the learned Judges
were struck by several facts, namely, (i) the passing
of two receipts for two sums of money each of Rs. 300
"
which were identical with the amount of fine imposed
...., on each of the accused Nos. 4 and 7 (petitioner) and
(ii) the date of payment, namely, the 11th October
1949 on which date the petitioner and the fourth accused had to deposit the. fine. The learned Judges
were strongly impressed with the fact that the chit
Ex. A/1 had been allowed to remain with the petitioner. The High Court also noted that if the arrange-+ ment was that the appellant's clerk would pass a
' formal stamped receipt after getting the money there
'
was no necessity to issue an informal receipt in favour
of the petitioner in advance. The learned Judges further pointed out that in none of the three notices
dated the 13th February 1951 any reference had been
made by the appellant to the hand letter (Ex. D/8)
dated the 16th· October 1949. The High · Court concluded that the failure to mention this hand letter in
~· the earliest reply by the appellant cast considerable
doubt on the genuineness of the document and consequently the Court could not act on the basis that it
-
...
Bhataraju
N ageshwara Rao
v.
The Hon' bit Judges
of the Madras
High Court and
Others
DasJ; ·
t
I
1062
1954
Bhataraju
Nageskwara Rao
v.
Th< Hon'ble Judges
of the Madras
High Court and
Others
DasJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
contained a true statement of facts admitted by the Y
pet1t1oner. The High Court also referred to several
other minor points suggesting the improbability of
the appellant's story. The High Court held that the 1
appellant had received a sum of Rs. 300 from the
",
petitioner on the 11th October 1949 as acknowledged
by the appellant in the chit Ex. A/1. The High Court _,'r..
accordingly held that charges Nos. 4 and 5 had been
proved against the appellant and passed orders against
the appellant debarring him from practising as an
advocate for five years. The appellant has now ·preferred this appeal after having obtained special leave.
from this Court.
We have been taken through the evidence by learned advocates appearing on both sides. It appears to
"
us that while there are some facts which cast some I
doubt on the version of the appellant there are other •
material facts completely overlooked by the l;:ligh
Court which nevertheless have a material bearing""' on
the truthfulness or falsity of the complainant's story.
It is true that the appellant did not refer to the hand
letter (Ex. D /8) in his replies Exs. A/3, A/4 and
A/5 to the petitioner's letter Ex. A/2, but the appely
!ant did refer to it in his rejoinder Ex. A/7' of the 14th •·
March 1951. It is significant that the petitioner did
not send any reply to this last rejoinder and deny the
allegations definitely made by the appellant. It is
further significant that the petitioner did not deny
the genuineness of the hand letter Ex. D /8 even in his
petition. In his evidence the petitioner admits the
signature on the hand letter to be his own but states
•+
that it must have been made out by the appellant on ;
a blank paper on which he had induced the petitioner
·;
to put his signature on the representation that the
same would be used as a Vakalatnama. It is very difficult to accept this story because the petitioner knew
from his experience as an accused in thf trial Court
that no Vakalatnama was required in a criminal case.
Nor has any of the other appellants been produ~ed as
a witness to say that any such signature was taken
from any of them on blank paper.
Further, the peti- ,i.,.
tioner was present in Court on the 11th October when
.,.
·•.f
..
-
r
~·
S.C.R.
_.,.•
0
'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1063
the interim stay order was made. Ex. A/1 bears the
Bhatara;u
hour 5-15 P.M. below the signature of the appellant
N'ageshwarM Rao
which shows that that chit came into existence after
v.
court hours. It is utterly impossible to believe that the The Hon' bl< Judgs
of the Madras ~
petitioner would deposit Rs. 300 with his new advoHigh Court and
cate in spite of the fact that in the earlier part of the
Others
day the interim order for stay had been made. It is
Das].
also significant that accused No. 4 who is also
alleged to have paid Rs. 300 to the appellant for a
similar purpose has not been called as a witness to
corroborate the evidence of the petitioner and his
brother. The question of the ability of the petitioner
to advance Rs. 300 is one of great importance in this
case. The petitioner is not a man of means. He
alleged that he had raised the sum of Rs. 300 by selling some miscellaneous gold. No goldsmith or shroff
was called to produce his books and give evidence m
corroboration of the petitioner and his brother. Indeed, the petitioner could not even mention the name
of any shroff to whom he is supposed to have sold his
gold.
The High Court completely overlooked this
aspect of the matter and in the absence of satisfac~
tory evidence showing that the petitioner was in a
position to pay the sum of Rs. 300 it will be extreme1y risky to hold that the fact of payment of Rs. 300
by the petitioner to the appellant has been proved
only because there are some weaknesses in the appellant's story. The appellant's story that he required
Rs. 600 to be paid to the Land Mortgage Bank is
supported by the secretary of the Land Mortgage Bank
(R.W. 3) who stated i:hat the appellant had informed
him that he had raised Rs. 300 only and that a person who had promised to arrange for a loan of Rs.
300 had failed to do so and that the appellant had
asked his advice as to what he was to do. The
" secretary then told the appellant that as he had made
an excess payment in 1948 towards and on account
of the principal it would be enough if he paid the
amount of Rs. 377/9/- which the appellant had. It is
significant that the Bank's records show that the
appellant had paid only- Rs. 377/9/- into the Bank on
the 4th November, 1949. If the petitioner had paid
12--89 S. C. India/59
1064
1 954
Bhataraju
Nagesfzwara Rao
v.
The Hon'ble Judges
of the Madras
High Court and
Others
Das].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19551
Rs. 300 to the appellant there would have been no
reason why the appellant should not have paid the
entire Rs. 600 towards his liability to the Bank. The
learned District Judge who had the advantage of seeing the witnesses and hearing the evidence disbelieved
the evidence of the petitioner and his brother and
we see no compelling reason to take a different view
of it. On the facts and circumstances of this case we
think that charges 4 and 5 have not been brought
home to the appellant or, at any rate, the appellant
is entitled to the benefit of the doubt. In the circumstances, we hold that the order passed by the
High Court should be reversed and we direct that the
complaint against the appellant do stand dismissed
as not proved.
Before parting with this appeal we desire to say
that it appears to us that it was wholly wrong and
inappropriate for the appellant to have made the
Honourable Judges of the Madras High Court respondents to this appeal. It appears that in some cases
involving contempt of Court the Honourable Judges
have been made parties. It is not necessary for us to
express any opinion on this occasion as to the propriety of that procedure in contempt cases but we are
clearly of the opinion that in· an appeal arising out of
a proceeding under the Bar Councils Act the appropriate parties should be the advocate concerned, the
complainant, if any, the Bar Council or the secretary
thereof and the Advocate-General of the State concerned to whom notices have to be issued u,,;der section 12(3) of the Indian Bar Councils Act.
,•
..
Appeal allowed.
Ir
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org