MUIR MILLS CO., LTD. versus SUTI MILLS MAZDOOR UNION, KANPUR.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 19 November 1954 | [1955] 1 S.C.R. 991 | 1954 INSC 111
Key facts
- Decided
- 19 November 1954
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN*, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI, T.L. VENKATARAMA AIYYAR
- Bench size
- 4
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 135/1951
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1955] 1 S.C.R. 991
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 111
Text of the judgment
..
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
991
_part of the working or operational expenses of the company. It was an expenditure made for the purpose of
:acquiring an appreciated capital asset which would no
doubt by reason of the undertaking given by the lessor
make the capital asset more profit yielding. The
period of 5 years over which the payments were spread
did not make any difference to the nature of the acquisition. It was none the less an acquisition of an advantage of an enduring nature which enured for the benefit
of the whole of the business for the full period of the
lease unless terminated by the lessor by notice as
prescribed in the last part of the clause. This again
was the acquisition of an asset or advantage of an
enduring nature for the whole of the business and was
of the na~ure of capital expenditure and thus was not
an allowable deduction under section 10(2) (xv) of the
Act.
We are therefore of the opinion that the conclusion
reached by the Income-tax authorities as well as the
High Co_urt in regard to the nature of the payments
was correct and the sums of Rs. 40,000 paid by the
company to the lessors during the accounting years
1944-45 and 1945-46 were not allowable deductions
under section 10(2) (xv) of the Act.
The appeal therefore fails and must be dismissed
with costs.
Appeal dismissed .
MUIR MILLS CO., LTD.
"·
SUTI MILLS MAZDOOR UNION, KANPUR.
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.J., S. R. DAs,
BHAGWATI and VENKATARAMA AYYAR JJ.]
Bonus -Meaning of-Necessary conditions for the demand
. thereof-Industrial claim-Principles for the grant of it-Social
Justice-Meaning of-Industrial Tribunals-Whether
Tribunal.<
within the meaning of Art. 136 of the Constitution.
The term bonus is applied to a cash payment made in addition
to wages.
It generally represents the cash incentive given conditionally on certain standards of attendance and efficiency being
attained.
1 954
Assam Bengal
Cement Co., Ltd.
v.
Commissioner of
Income-tax,
West Bengal.
Bhagwati],
1 954
November 19.
992
1 954
Muir
Mills Co., Ltd.
v.
Suti .Mills
Mazdoor
Union, Kanpur.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
There are two conditions, which have to be satiRfied before a
demand for bonus can be justified and they are, ( 1) when wages fall
short of the living standard and (2) the industry makes huge pro·
fits part of which are due to the ·contribution which the workmen
make in increasing production, The den1and for bonus becomes an
industrial claim when either or both these conditions are satisfied.
The formula for the grant of bonus is as follows : As both labour and capital contribute to the earnings of the
industrial concern, it is fair that labour should derive some benefit~ if there is a surplus after meeting prior or necessary charges ..
The first charges on gross profits are ( 1) provision for depreciation.
(2) reserves for rehabilitation, (3) a return J.t 6 per cent. on the
paid up capital and ( 4) a return on the working capital at a lesser
rate than the return on paid up capital. The surplus that remained:
after meeting the aforesaid deductions would be available for distribution as bonus.
The claim for bonus can be made by the employees only if as.
a result of the joint contribution of capital and labour the indus·
If in any particular year the
trial concern has earned profits.
working of the industrial concern has resulted in loss there is no
basis nor justification for a demand for bonus. Bonus is not adeferred wage. If it were so, it would necessarily rank for precedence before divid~nds. The dividends can only be paid out of
profits and unless and until profits are made no occasion or question
can arise for distribution of any sum as bonus amongst the
employees.
Social justice is a very vague and indeterminate expression
and no clear-cut definition can be laid down which will cover aU
the situations.
The concept of social justice does not emanate frqm the fanci·
ful notions of any particular adjudicator but must be founded on
a more solid foundation.
Industrial Tribunals are Tribunals within the meaning of
Art. 136 and Art. 136 has vested in the Supreme Court exceptional
and overriding power to interfere where it reaches the conclusion
that a person has been dealt with arbitrarily or that a Court or
Tribunal within the territory of India has not given a fair deal to
a litigant.
In re Eddystone Marine Insurance Co. (L.R. [1894] W.N. 30),
Sutton v. Attorney-General ([1923] 39 T.L.R. 294), National Association of Local Government Officers v. Bolton Corporation (L.R. 1943
A.C: 166), Kenicott v. Supervisor of Wayne County ([1873] 83
U.S. 452: 21 L. Ed. 319), Great Western Garment Co. Ltd. v.
Minister of National Revenue ([1948) 1 D.L.R. 225), Mil/owners'
Association, Bombay v. Rashtreeya Mills Mazdoor Sangh, Bombay
({1950] 2 L.L.J. 1247), Nizam Sugar Factory Ltd., Hyderabad v.
Their Workmen ([1952] 1 L.L.J. 386), Textile Mills, Madhya Pradesh
v. Their Workmen ([1952] 2 L.L.J. 625), Famous Cine Laboratory v.
Their Workmen ([1953] 1 L.L.J. 466) and Bharat Bank Ltd., Delhi
t-
~ -~
?'
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
993
v. Employees of the Bharat Bank Ltd., Delhi, ([1950] S.C.R. 459),
referred to.
CIVIL
APPELLATE
No. 135 of 1951.
JURISDICTION:
Civil
Appeal
Appeal by Special Leave granted by the Supreme
Court of India by its Order dated the 21st of May, 1951,
from the Judgment and Order dated the 19th February, 1951, of the Labour Appellate Tribunal of India,
Allahabad in Appeal No. 136 of 1950.
C. K. Daphtary, Solicitor-General of India (!. B.
Dadachanji, Rajinder Narain and Devinder Swarup,
with him) for the appellant.
S. C. Isaacs ( C. P. Lal,
pondent.
with. him)
for
the res-
M. C. Setalvad, Attorney-General for India, (Rajin-,
der Narain and Devinder Swarup, with him) for the
Intervener (All India Organisation of Industrial Employers).
S. C. .Isaacs (Mohan Lal Saxena and C. P. Lal,
with him) for the Intervener (State of U.P.).
1954. November 19.
was delivered hy
The
Judgment of the Court
BHAGWATI J.-This appeal with special leave is
directed against the judgment and order of the Labour
Appellate Tribunal of India in a dispute regarding the
workers' claim for bonus.
During the year 1948 the appellant made a profit of
Rs. 11,97,648-11-9. It paid 24! per cent. dividend on
ordinary shares, being the maximum that could be
paid under the Public Companies (Limitation of
Dividend) Ordinance of 1948 and also paid to the
workers their full share of bonus at annas 4 in a rupee
of their basic ean~ings. During the Year 1949 the
selling rates for cloth and yarn were controlled by the
Government ·and were ::tpproximately 4 per cent. below
those obtained in 1948. The basic wages were increased
from the 1st December, 1948, by order of the Government of Uttar Pradesh and the total wages paid were
therefore higher· than those in the previous year. There
Muir
Mills Co., Ua.
v.
Suti Mills
Mazaoor
Union, Kanpur.
994
1
954
Muir
Mills Co., Lid.
v.
Suti Mills
Mazdocr
· .Union, Kanpur.
Bhagwali :J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
was moreover indiscipline amongst the workers and
· production suffered. There was a strike in the month
of October and the mills were closed for nearly a month.
Further the management were unable to secure cotton
which resulted in the curtailment of the working hours.
As a result of all these circumstances the appellant
suffered a trading loss of Rs. 5,02, 563-1-10. A sum of
Rs. 2,50,000 being the excess reserve for taxation was
written back and a sum of Rs. 10,01,871-13-5 being the
amount of reserve transferred from the investment
account was also brought in. An aggregate sum of
Rs. 12,51,871-13-5 was thus brought into the balancesheet by these two transfers. The trading loss was
deducted from this amount leaving a credit balance of
Rs. 7,49,308-11-7 and that amount was shown as the
profit for the year 1949 in the balance-sheet for that
year. The balance which had been brought forward
from the previous year was added thereto and a
dividend of 24~ per cent. was paid to the ordinary
shareholders. The appellant also paid ex gratia to the
workmen bonus at the rate of annas 2 per rupee of
their basic earnings making it clear by their notification dated the 7th April, 1950, that the directors had
sanctioned the payment at that rate in spite of the
appellant having suffered a trading loss for the year,
that it was being paid entirely at the discretion of the
appellant and was not related to or connected with any
contract of employment of any worker.
On the 4th May, 1950, the Secretary of the respondent Union petitioned to the Provincial Conciliation
Officer (Textile) that there was more production in
1949 than in 1948, that there was no reason · to hold
that the profit in 1949 was less than in the previous
year and that the rate of bonus was wrongly reduced
and asked that bonus for 1949 should also be paid at
the rate of annas 4 per rupee. The industrial dispute
which thus arose was referred for enquiry and recording of an award to the Regional Conciliation Board
(Textile), Kanpur. The Conciliation Board by a majority decision repelled the contention of the appellant
and awarded the payment of bonus at annas 4 per
rupee. On an appeal taken by the appellant to the
;
S.C.R.
-
•
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
995
Industrial Court (Textiles and Hosiery), Kanpur, the
Industrial Court accepted the contention of the appellant, allowed the appeal and set aside the award. The
respondent thereupon appealed to the Labour Appellate
Tribunal which substantially agreed with the Industrial Court on questions of fact as well as the general
position in law but imported considerations of social
justice and treating this as a special case "where social
justice would demand that labour should have bonus
for the year where for that very year capital had
had not only a reasonable return but much in excess
of that", allowed the appeal and directed the appellant to pay to the workmen bonus at the rate of annas 4
per rupee within six weeks of their decision. The
appellant filed this appeal against that decision after
obtaining special leave from this Court.
Both the Industrial Court as well as the Labour
Appellate Tribunal found as a fact that there was a
trading loss of Rs. 5,02,563-1-10 during the year 1949
and also that the dividend of 24! per cent. to the
ordinary shareholders was distributed after transferring the aggregate sum of Rs. 12,51,871-13-5 from the
reserves. The question which therefore arises for our
consideration is mainly whether the workers are
entitled to the payment of a bonus in spite of the
employer having worked at a loss during the year and
incidentally whether the workers have any right, title
or interest in the reserves and the undistributed profits
of the previous years.
The primary meaning of the word "bonus" according to the definition given in the New English Dictionary
is :-"A boon or gift over and above what is nominally
due as remuneration to the receiver and which is
therefore something wholly to the good". This definition was adopted by Stirling J. in In re Eddystone
Marine Insurance
Co.(i)
Webster's
International
Dictionary defines bonus as "something given in addition to what is ordinarily received by or strictly due to
the recipient".. The Oxford Concise Dictionary defines
it as "something to the good, into the bargain (and as
an example) gratuity to workmen beyond their wages".
(1) L.R. (1894) W. N. 30.
1 954
Muir
Mills Co., Ltd.
v.
Suti Mills
Mazdoor
Union, Kanpur.
Bhagwati].
996
1954
MUir
Mills Co., Ltd.
v.
Suti,Mills
Mazdoor
.Union, KarJpur.
Bhagwati].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
Corpus Juris Secundum, Volume XI, at page 515
ascribes the following meanings to the word bonus :"An allowance in addition to what is usual current or stipulated ; a sum given or paid· beyond what is
legally required to be paid to the recipient; something
given in addition to what is ordinarily received by or
strictly due to the recipient"
and adds:
"It has been said to carry the idea of something
uncertain and indefinite, something which may or may
not be paid depending on varying circumstances and
under particular conditions has been said to imply a
benefit accruing to him who offers it and an inducement to the offeree."
This imports the conception of a boon, gift or a
gratuity otherwise described as an ex gratia payment.
The word 'bonus' has however acquired a secondary
meaning in the sphere of industrial relations. It is
classified amongst the methods of wage payment. It
has been used especially in the United States of
America to designate an award in addition to the contractual wage. It is usually intended as a stimulus to
extra effort but sometimes represents the desire of the
employer to share with his workers the fruits of their
common enterprise. (Vide Encyclopaedia Britannica,
Volume III, page 856).
The Pocket Part of the Corpus · Juris. Secundum,
Volume XI, under the heading "As Compensation for
Services" quotes the following passage from AttorneyGeneral v. City of Woburn (') :"The word 'bonus' is commonly used to denote an
increase in salary or wages in contracts of employment.
The offer of a bonus is the means frequently adopted
to secure continuous service from an employee to
enhance his efficiency and to augment his loyalty to
his employer and the employee's acceptance of the offer
by performing the things called for by the offer binds
employer to pay the bonus so called."
It also gives another meaning of the word 'bonus',
viz., "increased compensation for services already
(1) 317 Mass. 465.
'.
>
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
997.
rendered gratuitously or for a prescribed compensation
where there is neither express or implied understanding
that additional compensation may be granted."
•
'
•
\
-~..1.l'
i\
..I
, ___....,
....
'r
This imports the conception that even though the
payment be not strictly due to the recipient nor legally
enforceable by him, a claim to the same may be laid by
the employee under certain conditions and if such claim
is entertained either by an agreement with the employer or by adjudication before a properly constituted
Tribunal as on an industrial dispute arising, the same
would ripen into a legally enforceable claim.
This position was recognised in Sutton v. Attorney·General( 1 ), where the Earl of Birkenhead observed:"The term 'bonus' may of course be properly used
to describe payments made of grace and not as of
right. But it nevertheless may also include, as here,
payments made because legally due but which the parties contemplate will not continue indefinitely",
and in National Association of Local Government
·Officers v. Bolton Corporation (2) :~
"This payment, if made, cannot properly in my
·opinion be regarded as a mere gratuity. Though there
is an element of bounty in it the bounty, if granted, is
.given for good reasons of national policy .......... I do
not see why this does not fall within the definition of
trade dispute just as much as a dispute as to the rate
·of wages or salary."
To a similar effect are the observations in Kenicott v.
Supervis'ors of Wayne County (3) :"But second, the meaning of the word 'bonus' is
not given to it by the objection. It is thus defined by
Webster. 'A premium given for a loan or a charter or
other privilege granted to a company ; as, the bank
paid a bonus for its charter; a sum paid in addition
to a stated compens.i:ion'. It is not a gift or gratuity,
but a sum paid for services, or upon a consideration in
addition to or in excess of that which would ordinarily
be given",
(1) (1923) 39 T.L.R. 294, 297.
(2) [1943] A.O. 166, 187.
(3) (1873) 83 U.S. 452; 21 L. Ed. 319.
1954
Muir
Mills Co., Ltd.
v.
Suti Mills
Mazdoor
Union, Kanpur,
Bhagwati].
998
1954
Muir
Mills Co., Ltd.
v.
Suti Mills
Mazdoor
Union, Kanpur.
BhagwatiJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955}
and also in Great Western Garment Co. Ltd. v. Minister
of National Revenue (') :"A bonus may be a mere gift or gratuity as a
gesture of goodwill and not enforceable, or it may be
something which an employee is entitled to on the
happening of a condition precedent and is enforceable
when the condition is fulfilled. But in both cases it is
something in addition to or in excess. of that which is
ordinarily received."
· ..
The Textile Labour Inquiry Committee defined
•
'bonus' as follows :"The term bonus is applied to a casli payment
made in addition to wages. It generally represents the
cash incentive given conditionally on certain standards
of attendance and efficiency being attained."
,
There are however two conditions which have to be
satisfied before a demand for bonus can be justified and
they are, ( 1) when wages fall short of the living standard
· and (2) the industry makes huge profits part of which
are due to the contribution which the workmen make
in increasing production. The demand for bonus
becomes an industrial claim when either or both the..e
conditions are satisfied.
The principles for the grant of bonus were discussed
and a foi:mula was evolved by the Full Bench of the
Labour Appellate Tribunal in Millowners' Association,
Bombay v. Rashtreeya Mill Mazdoor Sangh, Bombay ( 2 ) :
"As both labour and capital contribute to the earnings
of the industrial concern, it is fair that labour should
derive some benefit, if there is a surplus after meeting '
prior or necessary charges" and the following were
., ' ~prescribed as the first charges on gross profits, viz.,
(1) Provision for depreciation,
(2) Reserves for rehabilitation,
(3) A return at 6 per cent. on the paid up capital.
( 4) A return on the working capital at a ·lesser
rate than the return on paid up capital. · '
.
The surplus that remained after meeting the afore-.
said deductions would be available for distribution as
bonus.
,~,
"t
.1
(1) (1948) D.L.R. 225, 233.
(2) (1950) 2 L. L.J. 247.
-
.
.
S.C.R.
-
-
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
999
It is therefore clear that the claim for bonus can be
made by the employees only if as a result of the joint
contribution of capital and labour ·the industrial concern has earned profits. If in any particular year the
working of the industrial concern has resulted in loss
there is no basis nor justification for a demand for
bonus. Bonus is not a deferred wage. Because if it
were so it would necessarily rank for precedence before
dividends. The' dividends can only be paid out · of
profits and unless and until profits are made no occasion or question can also arise for distribution of any
sum as bonus amongst · the employees. If the industrial
concern has resulted in a trading loss, there would be
no profits of the particular year available for .distribution of dividends, much less could the employees claim
the distribution of bonus during that year. This has
been clearly recognised even in the various decisions of
the Labour Appellate Tribunal, e.g., Nizam Sugar Factory Ltd., Hyderabad v. Their Workmen(1), Textile Mills,
Madhya Pradesh v. Their Workmen(2) and Famous
Cine Laboratory v. Their Workmen(3). This was also
the basis of the demand of the respondent in the case
before us; its case being that the appellant had reaped
· substantial profits during the year 1949. This case was
·negatived by the Industrial Court as well as the Labour
Appellate Tribunal, both of :whom held that the working of the appellant during the year 1949 had resulted
. in a loss. Whereas the Industrial Court declined to
grant the respondent any relief because the working of
the appellant during the year had resulted in a loss,.
_. • the· Labour. Appellate Tribunal made a special case for
the respondent in spite of its concurrence with that
finqing of the Industrial Court. It is significant to
observe that this principle was accepted by the Labour
Appellate Tribunal itself.
"As at present advised a claim for bonus which
had been rested on profits earned should ordinarily be
determined on the basis of the profits earned in the year
under' claim and that the scale of bonus should be
determined on the quantum of profits earned in the .
(1) (1952) I L.L.J. 386.
'(<1) (1952) 2 L.L.J. 625 .
8-89 S. C.India/59
!3) (1953) I L.L.J. 466.
1 954
Muir
Mil/J Co. Lta.
v.
SutiMiJ/s
Mazaoo
Union, Kanpur.
Bhagwati].
1000
1
954
Muir
Mill• Go. Lid.
v.
Suti Mi'lJJ
Mazdoor
Unio'f, Kanpur.
Bhagwati].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955] -'!
year. So, it would follow that if there is trading loss
in the year under claim, bonus should not ordinarily
be awarded."
j
It however observed :
"But, in our opinion, that should not be the
universal rule. Considerations of social justice cannot
.
be disregarded altogether, in relations between capital
and labour. There }Ilay be special cases, and we consider the case before us to be one, where social justice
would demand that labour should have bonus for the
year where for that very year capital had had not only
a reasonable return but much in excess of that."
The Labour Appellate Tribunal did not accept the
contention of the respondent that bonus should be
linked to dividends nor did it rest its decision on the
respondent having a right, title and interest in tl1e
reserves and the undistributed profits of the appellant.
Linking of bonus to dividend would obviously create
difficulties. Because if that theory was accepted a
company would not declare any dividends but accumulate the profits, build up reserves and distribute those "
profits in the shape of bonus shares or reduce the Y
capital in which event the workers would not be
entitled to claim anything as and by way of bonus.
The workers not being members of the company would
also not have any right, title and interest in the reserves
or the undistributed profits which would form. part of
the assets of the company. Even on a winding up of a
company the property of the company would be applied ,.
in satisfaction of its liabilities pari passu and, unless the '
articles of association of the company otherwise provided, in distribution amongst the members according
to their rights and interest in the company. The
employees would in no event be entitled to any share
or interest in the assets and the capital of the company.
A transfer of moneys from these reserves or the
undistributed profits would therefore not enure for the
benefit of the workers. The shareholders only would ;./.
be entitled to such benefit and the mere fact that
dividends were declared and paid to the shareholders
out of such reserves and undistributed profits would
r
S.C.R.
"'·
•
--
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1001
not entitle the workers to demand bonus when in fact
the working of the industrial concern during the particular year had showed a loss.
It has also got to be remembered that the labour
force employed in an industrial concern is a fluctuating
body and it cannot be predicated of the labour force in
a particular year that it represents the past and the
present workers, so that it can claim to demand bonus
out of the reserves or undistributed profits of the
previous years. On the accounts of each year being
made up and the profits of the industrial concern being
ascertained the workers during the particular year have
their demand for bonus fully satisfied out of the
surplus profits and the balance of profits is allocated
and carried over in the accounts. No further claim for
payment of bonus out of those reserves or undistributed
profits can therefore survive. To admit the claim for
bonus out of the reserves transferred to the profit and
loss account would tantamount to allowing a second
bonus on the same profits in respect of which the
workers had already received their full bonus in the
previous year. The labour force which earns the profits
of a particular year by collaborating with the employers is distinct from the one which contributed to
the profits of the previous years and there is no continuity between the labour forces which are employed
in the industrial concern during the several years. The
ratio which applies in the case of the shareholders who
acquire the right, title and interest of their predecessorsin-interest does not apply to the labour force and the
fact that the shareholders get a dividend by transfer
of funds from the reserves and undistributed profits of
the previous years would not entitle the workers · to
demand bonus out of those funds if the working of
the industrial concern during the particular year has
resulted in a trading loss.
The considerations of social justice imported by the
Labour Appellate Tribunal in arriving at the decision
in favour of the respondent were not only irrelevant
but untenable. Social justice is a very vague and
indeterminate expression and no clear-cut definition
can be laid down which will cover all the situations.
1 954
Muir
Mills Co. Ltd.
v.
Suti Mills
Mazdoor
Union, Kanpur.
Bhagwati].
1002
1954
Muir
Mills Co. Ltd.
v.
Suti Mills
Mazdoor
Union, Kanpur.
BhagwaJi].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
Mr. Isaacs, the learned counsel for the respondent,
attempted to give a definition in the following terms :"social justice connotes the balance of adjustments of
the various interests concerned in the social and
economic structure of tlie State, in order to promote
harmony upon an ethical and economic basis" and he
stated that there were three parties concerned here,
viz., the employers, the labour and the State itself, and
the conception of social justice had to be worked out
in this context. Without embarking upon a discussion
as to the exact connotation of the expression "social
justice" we may only observe that the concept of
social justice does not emanate from the fanciful
notions of any particular adjudicator but must be
founded on a more solid foundation. Indeed the Full
Bench of the Labour Appellate Tribunal evolved the
abovequoted formula with a view to dispensing social
justice between the various parties concerned. It
adopted the following method of approach at page
1258 of that judgment :"Our approach to this problem is motivated by
the requirement that we should ensure and achieve
industrial peace · which is essential for the. development
and expansion of industry. This can be achieved by
having a contented labour force on the one hand, and
on the other hand an investing public who would be
attracted to the industry by a steady and progressive
return on c;apital which the industry may be able to
offer."
This formula was reiterated in Textile Mills, M. P.
v. Their Workmen('), and Famous Cine Laboratory v. -• -i.
Their Workmen('), and in the latter case it deprecated
the idea of adjudicators importing considerations of
social justice which were not comprised in that
·formula :"And what is social justice ? ·Social justice is not
the fancy of any individual adjudicator; if it were so
then ideas of social justice might vary from adjudicator
to adjudicator over all parts of India. In our Full
Bench decision (See 1950, 2 L.L. J., p. 1247), we carefully considered the question of social justice in relation
(1) (1952) 2 L.L.J. 625.
(2) {1953) 1 L.L.J. 466.
..
-
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1003
to bonus, and there we equated the rights and liabilities
of employers and workmen with a view to achieving a
just formula for the computation of bonus. That Full
Bench decision stands, and this tribunal and all other
tribunals are bound by it."
~
Without committing ourselves to the acceptance
of the above formula in its entirety we may point out
that the Labour Appellate Tribunal did not apply its
own· formula to the facts of the present case. It is also
significant to note that even while importing considerations of social justice the Labour Appellate Tribunal
was oblivious of the fact that it was bv their own acts
of indiscipline and strike that. the ~orkers of the
appellant company themselves contributed to· the
trading losses incurred by the appellant and it hardly
lay in their mouth then to contend that they were
none the less entitled to payment of bonus commensurate with the dividend paid to the shareholders out of
the undistributed profits of the previous years. . The
Labour Appellate Tribunal also overlooked the fact
that but for the Public Companies (Limitation of
Dividend) Ordinance of 1948 the whole of the profits
of 1948 c01,1ld have been distributed after paying the
of four annas in the
workers bonus in that year
rupee.
---
-
•
~ ,
"'
We may before concluding refer to an argument
which was addressed to us by Mr. Isaacs, the learned
counsel for the respondent, that this. Court under article
136 should not interfere with the decisions of the
tribunals set up by the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
This contention can be shortly answered by referring
Delhi v.
to our decision in Bharat Bank Ltd.,
Employees of the Bharat Bank Ltd., Delhi(1), where we
held that the Industrial Tribunals were tribunals
within the meaning' of article 136 and further that
article 136 has vested in this Court exceptional and
overriding power to interfere where it reaches the
conclusion that a person has been dealt with arbitrarily
or that a Court or tribunal within the territory of
India has not given a fair deal to a litigant. (Vide
(1) [1950] S.C.R. 449.
Muir
Mills Co. Ltd.
v.
&ti Mills
Mazdoor
Union, Kanpur.
Bhagwati].
1004
1954
Muir
Mills Co, Lttl.
v.
Suti Mills
Mazdoor
Union, Kanpur.
BhagwatiJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
Dhakeswari Cotton Mills Ltd. v.
Income-tax, West Bengal(').
[1955J
Commissioner
of
The result therefore is that the decision of the
Labour Appellate Tribunal appealed against must be
reversed and that of the Industrial Court (Textiles and
Hosiery), Kanpur, restored. The appeal will accordingly be allowed with costs.
Appeal allowed.
SAKHAWAT ALI
ti.
THE STATE OF ORISSA.
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.J., MuKHERJEA,
S. R. DAs, VIVIAN BosE, BHAGWATI
and VENKATARAMA AYYAR JJ.J
•
Constitution of India, arts. 14. 19(1) (g)-Orissa Municipal Act
1950 (Orissa Act XXlll of 1950), ss.1(3), 1(5), 16(1)(x)-Nomination
filed and rejected, effect of-Disqualification for nomination if
violates fundamental right-Orissa General Clauses Act, 1937 ( Orissa
Act I of 1937), s. 23-Scope of.
The provisions of section 16(l)(x) of the Orissa Municipal Act,
1950, by which a paid legal practitioner on behalf of or against
the Municipality is disqualified for election to a seat in such
Municipality do not violate the fundan1ental rights guaranteed to
such legal practitioner under article 14 or under article 19( 1) (g) of
the Constitution of India.
The Orissa Municipal Act, 1950, having received the Gover·
nor's assent on November 7, 1950, all preliminary steps
specified
in section 1(5) of the Act whic.:h were taken for the purpose of a
Municipal election after such assent are valid even though the
Act itself had not then come into force in terms of section 1(3).
Accordingly a nomination filed on March 15, 1951, was validly
subjected to the test of disqualification contained in section 16( 1)
(x) of the Act and the rejection of such nomination on March 25,
1951, was not defective though the Act came into force on April 15,
1951, in the area to which the rejected
nomination
relates.
Section 23 of the Orissa General Clauses Act, 1937, does not
authorise the making of rules or bye-laws, which are to come into
(1) [1955] l S.C.R. 94r.
'
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org