DEWAN BAHADUR SETH GOPAL DAS MOHTA versus THE UNION OF INDIA AND ANOTHER.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 21 October 1954 | [1955] 1 S.C.R. 773 | 1954 INSC 97
Key facts
- Decided
- 21 October 1954
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN*, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, GHULAM HASAN, NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI, T.L. VENKATARAMA AIYYAR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 315/1994
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1955] 1 S.C.R. 773
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 97
Text of the judgment
S.C.R.
J
1
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
773
to direct the issue of any of the writs the issue of which
1s discretionary with this Court. When this position
was put to Mr. Sen, the learned counsel for the
petitioner, he very fairly, and, in our opm10n, rightly
conceded that it was not possible for him to com~at
this position.
For the reasons given above this petition is bound to
fail and it is accordingly dismissed with costs.
1954
Laxmanappa
HanurMntaaPfia
v.
Union •f India
Mahajan C. ].
Petition dismissed.
DEWAN BAHADUR SETH GOPAL DAS MOHTA
1954
"·
Oclo6w 2 1.
THE UNION OF INDIA AND ANOTHER.
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.J., s. R. DAS,
GH?LAM HASAN, BHAGWATI
and VENKATARAMA AYYAR JJ.]
·~
.•
~
•
Co11stitution of India, Art. 32-Taxation on Income (Investigation Commission) Act, 1947 (XXX of 1947) s. 5(1)-lnvestigation
and Report by Commission in respect of profits made by assessee and
tax payable by him-Mutual. settlement
between assessee and
Government-Petition under Art. 32-Whether competent.
The petitioner, a business man, was alleged to have made
huge profits during the years of War and the Central Government
acting under s. 5( 1) of the Taxation on Income (Investigation Commission) Act, 1947 (XXX of 1947) referred his case to the Investigation Commission for investigation and report.
During the
pendency of the investigation the petitioner's application for
settlement under the provisions of s. 8-A of Act XXX of 1947 was
accepted by the Central Government and in pursuance thereof the
tax was made payable by instalments and the claim for evaded
income-tax was thus finally settled by mutual agreement. When
the instalments in the sum of Rs. 4 lacs odd still remained due the
petitioner preferred the. present petition under Art. 32 of the
Constitution alleging that the entire proce~dings under Act XXX
of 1947, were illegal, ultra vires, void and unconstitutional, that the
Income-tax authorities were not competent to recover the amount
due from him and that ss. 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the Act were ultra vires
as they infringed Arts. 14, 19(1) (£) and 31 of the Constitution.
Held, that the petition under Art. 32 was not competent as
whatever had already been paid or whatever was still recoverable
from the petitioner was being recovered on the basis of the
774
1954.
Seth!Gopal Diis
Mohta
v.
Union of India
and .A.1wt!ur
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
settlement between him and the Government. Article 32 is not
intended for relief against the voluntary actions of a person.
Suraj Mall Mohta & Co. v. A. V. Visvanatha Sastn' (A.LR.
1954 S.C. 545) referred to.
• ORIGINAL JURISDICTION : Petition No. 315 of 1954.
Petition under article 32 of the Constitution for
enforcement of Fundamental Rights.
H. f. Umrigar, Narain Andfry, f. B.
and Rajinder Narain for the petitioner.
Dadachanji
M. C. Setalvad, Attoreny-General for India, and
C. K. Daphtary, Solicitor-General for India ( G. N. Joshi,
Portis A. Mehta and P. G. Gokhale, with them) for the
respondents.
1954. October 21. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.J.-The. petitioner in this
matter is a resident of Akola in the State of Madhya
Pradesh and carries on business in various lines, i.e.,
oil mills, banking, money lending, etc. It is alleged
that during the war years he made huge profits but
evaded payment of tax. In the year 1948 the Central
Government, acting under section 5(1) of the Taxation
on Income (Investigation Commission)
Act, 1947,
referred his case to the Investigation Commission for
investigation and report, in respect of the profits made
by him during the period commencing with 1st of
January, 1939, and ending on 31st of December, 1947.
The Commission, after investigation, reported on the
28th of February, 1951, that the income of the
petitioner concealed and withheld from taxation was
in the sum of Rs. 27,25,363 and the tax payable by
him amounted to Rs. 18,44,949.
During the pendency of the investigation the petitioner applied for settlement under the provisions of
section 8-A of Act XXX of 1947. This application was
forwarded along with the report by the Commission to
the Central Government. In the settlement application
the applicant proposed that he was prepared to pay the
sum of Rs. 18,44,949 as under :
,-t
S.C.R.
-
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
775
On or before 25-6-1951-Rs. 3,44,949
On or before 25-3-1952-Rs. 5,00,000
On or before 25-3-1953-Rs. 5,00,000
On or before 25-3-1954-Rs. 5,00,000
:and that he be given credit for a sum of Rs. 32,034-4-6
:already paid by him1 The Central Government accepted
this proposal and the claim for evaded income-tax was
thus finally settled by mutual agreement. The assessee,
subsequently, asked for more time to pay these
instalments and this was also granted from time to
time.
Commencing from 16th of July, 1951, and till the
10th April, 1954, the petitioner paid a total sum of
:about Rs. 14,00,000 towards discharge of the liability
voluntarily agreed to by him on account of the tax
evaded. A sum of Rs. 4,50,000 still remains due and
is payable in instalments up to the 25th of March,
1955. By one of the terms of the settlement the petitioner undertook not to transfer, mortgage, charge or
:alienate or encumber m any manner whatsoever any of
his movable or immovable properties, barring stock-intrade of the business, except with the permission of
the Commissioner of Income-tax and except for the
purpose of the , payment of the tax due under the
:settlement.
In June, 1954, after the decision by this Court of
Suraj Mal Mohta v. A. V. Visvanatha Sastri and
Another(!), the petitioner preferred this petition under
the provisions of article 32 of the Constitution alleging
that he had been advised that the entire proceedings
under the Act which had resulted m the imposition
upon him of a· liability of Rs. 18,44,949 and in the payment already made of an aggregate amount of
Rs. 13,99,175 were wholly illegal, ultra vires, void and
unconstitutional and that the Income-tax authorities
the amount of
were not legally entitled to recover
Rs. 4,50,000 from him. In the grounds of the petition
it was stated that sections 5, 6, 7 and 8 of Act XXX of
1947 were invalid and ultra vzres m so far as they
contravene the provlSlons of articles 14, 19(1) (f)
and 31 of the Constitution and that under the Act
(1) A. I. R. 1954 S. C. 545·
1954
Seth Gopal Das
Mohla
v.
Union of India
and A11other
Mahajan C. J.
776
1954
Se1h Gopal Das
Moh ta
v.
Union of India
and Another
Mahajan C. J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955}
there was no reasonable or equitable basis for classification, and that the Act gave to the executive
unrestrained and absolute right to pick and choose and
to differentiate between the same class of taxpayers ..
It was also alleged that the procedure prescribed
by the Act for discovering concealed profits wassubstantially different and was more prejudicial to the
assessees than the procedure prescribed uncier the
Indian Income-tax Act by section 34. In the concluding paragraph of the petition it was prayed that an
appropriate writ or direction be issued quashing the
entire proceedings, and all orders passed under the Act
by the Central Government and the respondent Commission, and restraining them from taking any
proceedings whatsoever under the Act against the
petitioner. It was further prayed that a direction be
issued for restoration to the petitioner of a sum of
Rs. 13,99,715-10-6 with interest at 6 per cent., and
that the respondents be further restrained from taking
any action against the petitioner for the recovery of
the sum of Rse 4,50,000 with interest.
In our judgment this petition is wholly misconceived.
Whatever tax the petitioner has already paid, or what-·
ever is still recoverable from him, is being recovered on
the basis of the settlement proposed by him and;
accepted by the Central Government. Because of his.
request for a settlement no assessment was made
against him by following the whole of the procedure of
the Income-tax Act. In this situation unless and until
the petitioner can ·establish that his consent ·was improperly procured and that he is not bound thereby he
cannot complain that any of his fundamental
rights
has been contravened for which he can claim relief
under article 32 of the Constitution. Article 32 of the
Constitution is not intended for relief against the
voluntary actions of a person. His remedy, if any,
lies in other appropriate proceedings.
The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that
apparent! y the application for a settlement seems t<>
have been made under the pressure of circumstances
and in view of the coercive machinery of Act XXX of
1947 and the settlement arrived in such circumstances
-
•
•
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
777
was not binding and could not be enforced. Whatever
1954
be the merits of such a contention, it obviously cannot
Seth Gopal Das
Moh/a
be raised in an application made under the provisions
of article 32 of the Constitution. The forum for
investigating such allegations is elsewhere.
The result is that this petition fails and is dismissed
with costs.
v.
Union of India.
and Anolhtr
Mahtifan C. ].
Petition dismissed.
THE STATE OF BOMBAY
v.
BHANJI MUNJI AND ANOTHER.
1954
I MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.J., MuKHERJEA,
October 12.
VIVIAN BosE, JAGANNADHADAS
and VENKATARAMA AvYAR JJ.]
Constitution of India, Arts. 19(1) (f), 31(2)-Bombay Land
Requisition Act, 1948 (Bombay Act XXXIll of 1948), ss. 5(1) and
6(4) (a) as amended by Bombay Act II of 1950 and Bombay Act
XXXIX of 1950-Whether ultra vires the Cons1;1e<tion-Requisition of premises under s. 4(3) of the Act-Validity-Onus-Statute
- l-F hether must contain in express terms the publtc purposeI<cqurstiiu,, af 1u·orn1,,-Validity.
Sections 5(1) and 6(4) (a) of the Bombay Land Requisition Act,
194/i (Bombay Act XXX!II of 19t8) as amended are not ultra
vr;·.J Arts. 19( I) (f), and 31 (2) of the Constitution.
Article 19(1) (£) read with clause (5) postulates the existence
of property which can be enjoyed and over which rights can be
exercised because otherwise the reasonable
restrictions contemplated by clause (5) cannot be brought into play. In ·the present
case the right to occupy the premises has gone, as also the right to
transfer, assign, let or sub-let. What is left is merely the husk of
title in the lease-hold. Art. 19(1) (£), therefore, is not attracted.
The Bombay Larid Requisition Act, 1948, provides for compensation in s. 8 and the requisitions were made for a public
purpese. Therefore, the provisions of Art. 31(2) of the Constitution are complied with .
.. ,
. A statute is_ not in~~l!d for .the reason that the purpose for
which prol":r'Y is reqmslt!oned 1s not stated in express terms in
the statute 1:self provided from the whole tenor and intendment
of the Act it can_ be gathered that the property is acquired either
for th_c: p.irpose ot the State or for any public pnrpose and that the
mtentlo1' was to benefit the community at large.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org