THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE, HAPUR, AND THREE OTHERS versus THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH AND TWO OTHERS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 18 October 1954 | [1955] 1 S.C.R. 838 | 1954 INSC 94
Key facts
- Decided
- 18 October 1954
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN*, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, GHULAM HASAN, NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI, B. JAGANNADHADAS
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 309/1953
- Citation
- [1955] 1 S.C.R. 838
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 94
Text of the judgment
·----- --838
: . "SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955)
in England ~an argument which· we have already
·discarded.
The argument founded on an assumed
]tlavinchandt'a
legislative
practice
being thus out of the way, there can
Mafatla_l
v.
be no difficulty in applying its natural and grammatical
Th• Commission~ meaning to the ordinary English word "income." As
ofl•come-taz. · already observed, the word should be given it widest
Bombay c.1y. connotation in ·view of the fact that it occurs in a
n.,;. Iegislativ"e head conferring legislative power.
'
For reasons stated above we are of opinion that Act
XXII of 1947 which amended the Indian Income-tax
. Act by enlarging the definition of the term income in
section 2(6-0) and introducing a new head of income in
section 6 and inserting the new section 12-B is int·ra
vires the powers of the Central Legislature acting under
entry 54 in List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Govern~
merit of India Act, 1935. In this view of the matter it
, I
is unnecessary for. us to consider or express any opinion
as to the meaning, scope and ambit of entry 55 in that
List. ·The appeal is accordingly dismis8ed with costs.
Appeal dismissed. ·
I954.
October I8.·
THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE, HAPUR, AND
THREE OTHERS
v.
THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH AND
T\VO OTHERS.
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.J., s. R. DAS,
GHULA~I HASAN, BHAGWATI and JAGANNADHADAS JJ.]
Uttar Pradesh Food-grains (Futures and Options Prohibition)
Order, 1951-Uttar Pradesh Food-grains (Futures and Options
Prohibition) Order, 1945-Restrictfons on dealings in pulses other
thangram,....:.1,. both orders-Order o/'1951 partlu declared ultra
vires by Supreme Court-Not so s. 9 thereof which repealrd Order of
-1945-Whether Order of 1945 still fo force-Proper procedure for
' clarification of the matter• .
Uttar Pradesh Food-grains (Futures and Options Prohibition)
Order, 1951, made it illegal and a punishable offence for any
· person to enter into any fntures in pulses other than gram, or to
pa.y or receive or to agree to pay or receive a.ny margin rel.a.ting to
such futures. Bys. 9 of that Order the Order of 1945·conlaining .
similar provisions was repealed. An application qnd~r Art. S2 of
s.c.R.
•
..
SUPREl\IE COURT REPORTS
839
the Constitution presented by several persons (including the
z954
present petitioners) for the enforcement of their fundamental right
under Art. 19(l)(g) of the Constitution to carry on their business The Chamber of
and restraining the State from enforcing the Order of 1951 in so Commerce,Hapur.
far as it related to· pulses other than gram and for a declaration and three Others
that s. 2(o) of the Order read with items 6, 7, 8 and 9 of the
v.
schedule thereto was illegal and ultra vire1 the State Government
The State of
succeeded in the Supreme Court and . the State of Uttar Pradesh Uttar Pradesh
was directed by the Supreme Court by its judgment dated the 15th. and two Others
1Iay, 1952, to abstain from giving effect to it.
On the 10th June, l953, a lett~r (Exhi.bit B to th~ petition)
was addressed by the Deputy Commissioner, Food, Uttar Pradesh,
to all Regional Food Controllers and Deputy Food Controllsrs and
all District Magistrates in Uttar Pradesh instructing them to
regard all futures in foodgrains mentioned in the Schedule to the
1945 Order including pulses other than gram as punishable. ·· It was contended on behalf ~f the State (i) .that section 3 of 1946
Act which reproduced s. 3 of the 1946 Ordinance conferred on the
Central Goverllment ! extensiTe powers to· control production,- supply. distribution of and trade and commerce-· in 0ssentia1
commodities and this power was delegated by the Central Govern'.
ment to the Provincial Government by notification dated 21st
October, 1946, under s. 4 of the 1946 Ordinance. ·The subsequent
amendments made by two Notifications dated 5th March, 1947,
and dated 15th November, 1947, withdrew the power so delegated
only with respect to "edible oils and oil seeds and pulses other than
gram" and such withdrawal was only with regard to production,
snpply, and distribution ol those commodities but was not with
regard to trade and commerce therein; (ii) that the Order of 1951
having been declared ultra "ires, the Order of 1945 which was
continued bys. 5 of the Ordinance of 1946 and then by s.·17 of
the Act of 1946 was still in force.
Held, (repelling the contentions) (i) that as the Order of i945
ceased to have effect with regard to the price, production; distribu·
tion and movements of those commodities, that Order could not
in any way continue to regulate or control trade or commerce in
those -commodities and the two Notifications of 1947 quite
effectively superseded the Order of 1945 so far as it purported to
regulate or control the price, production, distribution and move·
ment of or_ trade and commerce in edible oils and oil seeds and
pnlses other than gram;
'
·
. (ii) tha-t'the Order of .1951 was not declared ultra vires and
invalid in its entirety by the judgment of the Supreme Court dated
15th May, 1952. The Order was declared invalid in so far as it
purported to restrict the dealings in edible oils and oil seeds and
pulses other than gram. · The rest of the Order of 1951 and in
particular s. 9 thereof by which the Order of 1945 had been withdrawn, remained unaffected by the judgment of the Supreme Court,
...
I
I
'
·I
I
840
1 954
T /,, Chamber of
Commerce, Hapur,
and tliree Othtrs
v.
The State of
Uttar Pratksh
o.ndtwo Ot!urs.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
Strong disapproval was expressed by the Supreme Court of
the \Vholly unwarranted attitude adopted by the officers of the
Pradesh in circumventing the decision of the
State of Uttar
Supreme Court on a flimsy pretext.
The contentions advanced on behalf of the State Government
should have been advanced before the Supre1ne Court ~n the previous occasion \vhen it delivered its judgment dated 15th May,.
1952, or the 1natter should have been brought before the Supreme
Court by \vay of review if any review \.Vas competent.
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION : Petition No. 309 of 1953.
U oder article 32 of the Constitution of India for the
enforcement of Fundamental Rights.
K. C. fain and B. P. Maheshwari for the
petitioners.
K. B. Ast!tana and C. P. Lal for the respondents.
1954. October 18. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
DAs J.-This is a petition made under article 32 of
the Constitution by the Chamber of Commerce, Hapur
and three individual jJersons praying for a writ in the
nature of mandamus directing the State of Uttar
Pradesh and two of its officers in the Food Department
to abstain from enforcing the Uttar Pradesh Food
Grains (Futures and Options Prohibition) Order, 1945,
or any orders or directions contained in the letters'
issued by the respondents copies whereof are annexed
to the petition and marked B and D. The facts and
circumstances leading up to this application may be
shortly stated at the outset.
The Chamber of Commerce, Hapur, is a companyincorporated under the Indian Companies Act with it»
registered office at Hapur. There are about 20()
members of this Chamber of Commerce including
petitioners Nos. 2 to 4. Petitioner No. 3 is also its
President ancl Petitioner No. 2 is also a member of its.
Executive Committee. The members of the Chambercarry on business in foodgrains including pulses both
on ready and forward basis. The Chamber acts as a
clearing agent for a commission and guarantees the
performance of forward contracts by its members upon
payment of margin money according to the rules.
•
S.C.R.
...
.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
841
On or about the 1st September, 1945, the U. P.
Government, in exercise of pow,ers conferred on it by
rule 81 (2) of the Defence of India Rules, issued
Notification No. 8071/c.s. promulgating the United
Provinces Food Grains (Futures and Options Prohibition) Order, 1945, (hereinafter called "the 1945 Order").
Section 2(a) of that Order defined "foodgrains" as
meaning any of the foodgrains mentioned in the
schedule thereto. Arhar, peas, urd and moong were
mentioned as items 6. 7, 8 and 9 of that schedule.
Section 3 provided as follows :"3. No person shall-( a) enter into any futures in foodgrains or pay or
receive or agree to pay or receive any margin relating
to any such futures ;
(b) enter into any options in food grains."
The Defence of India Rules expired on the 30th
September, 1946, and consequently all orders made
thereunder were also due to expire on the same date.
On the 1st October, 1946, however, there came into
force the
Essential Supplies (Temporary Powers)
Ordinance, 1946 (hereinafter referred to as "the 1946
Ordinance") promulgated by the Governor-General and
published in the Gazette of India on the 25th September,
1946. Section 3 of that Ordinance conferred on the
Central
Government
extensive powers to control
production, supply, distribution of and trade and commerce in, essential commodities as defined in section
2(a) thereof. Section 4 authorised the Central Government to direct by notified order that the power to make
orders under section 3 should, in relation to such
matters and subject to such conditions as might be
specified in the direction, be excercisable also by such
officer subordinate to it or by such Provincial Government or such officer thereof as might be specified m
the direction. Section 5 of that Ordinance ran as
follows:"5. Continuance 111 force of existing orders.Until other provisions are made under this Ordinance,
any order, whether notified or not, made by whatever
authority under rule 80-B, or sub-rule (2) or sub-rule
(3) of rule 81 of the Defence of India Rules, in respect
1954
The Chamber of
Commerce, HaJluT.
and three Others
v.
Tht Stat6of
Uttar Pradeslt
and two Otlin-s.
Das]~
842
1954
The Chomb" of
Gmmerce, HaJmr.
and thrte Others
v.
The State of
Uttar Pradesh
.and two Otkrs.
Das].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
11955]
of any matter specified in section 3, which was in force
immediately
before the
commencement of this
Ordinance shall, notwithstanding the expiration of the
said rules, continue in force so far as consistent with
this Ordinance and be deemed to be an order made
under section 3 ; and all appointments made, licenses
or permits granted and directions issued under any such
order and in force immediately before such commencement shall likewise continue in force and be deemed
to be made, granted or issued in pursuance of this
Ordinance."
The 1945 Order, therefore, continued in force untn
other provisions were made under the 1946 Ordinance.
In exercise of powers conferred on it by section 4
of the 1946 Ordinance the Government of India, on the
21st October, 1946, made the notified order No.
PY603(2)-I directing that the powers conferred on it
by section 3(1) of that Ordinance should, in relation
to foodstuffs, be exercisable also by any Provincial
Government, subject
to certain conditions therein
set out.
In November, 1946, was passed the Essential Supplies (Temporary Powers) Act, 1946 (hereinafter called
"the Act"). Section 3 of the Act reproduced section 3
of the 1946 Ordinance with certain modifications not
material for our present purpose. Section 4 of the Act
corresponds to section 4 of the 1946 Ordinance. The
relevant portions of section 17 of the Act provide as
follows:"17. Repeal and savings.-(1) The Essential Supplies (Temporary Powers) Ordinance, 1946 (XVIII of
1946), is herehy repealed.
(2) Any order made or deemed to be made under
the said Ordinance and in force immediately before the
commencement of this Act shall continue in force and
be deemed to be an order made under this Act ; and all
appointments made, licences or permits granted and
directions issued under any such order and in force
immediately before such commencement shall likewise
continue in force and be deemed to be made, granted
or is~ued in pursuance of this Act.
•.
\(
.
•
S.C.R.
(3)
(4)
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
843
1954
,,
In exercise of powers conferred on it by section 4 of
th<". Act the Central Government, by Notification
No. C. G. 603(2)-III(1), dated the 5th March, 1947,
amended the abovementioned notified order No. PY
603(2)-I, dated the 21st October, 1946, by inserting
after the word "foodstuff" the words "including cocoanut oil but excluding other edible oils and oilseeds."
The net result of this notification was that "edible oils
and oilseeds" were excluded from the scope or operation of the delegated power. In other words, the power
delegated to the Provincial Government was withdrawn
in respect of "edible oils and oilseeds" so that the
Provincial Government could not thenceforth make
any order controlling the production, supply and
distribution of or trade and commerce in "edible oils
and oilseeds". On the same day another Notification,
being Notification No. C. G. 603(2)-III(2), was issued
by the Central Government in exercise of powers
conferred on it under section 3 of the Act directing that
no order made or deemed to be made by a Provincial
Government under the Act should have effect from that
date so as to prohibit or restrict the movement of
edible oilseeds or oils other than cocoanut oil from any
place in a Province to any other place within or outside
the Province, or so as to regulate or control the price,
production or distribution thereof in any way. Tl!erefore, the 1945 Order ceased to have effect so as to prohibit or res_trict the movement of edible oilseeds or
oils other than cocoanut oil or so to regulate or
control the price, production or distribution thereof in
any way.
On the 15th November, 1947, two Notifications were
Government. By Notification
issued by the Central
No. PY. 603(2)-VI(1) made under section 4 of the Act
the Central Government made a further amendment in
Notification No. PY. 603(2)-I dated the 21st October,
1946, by inserting after the word "oil-seeds" the words
"and pulses other than gram". The effect of this
amendment was that "pulses other than gram" were
Tiu Clwnber)j
C11mmtrce, Hll/IUf.
amJ thrtt Otfiers
v.
Tiu State of
Uttar Pralksh
and two Otlurs
Das].
844
195~
L
The Chamber of ,:.;
<Ammuct, Hapur.
•nd three 0 lhtrs
v.
Tilt State of
Uttar Pradesh
·and two Others.
Das].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
also excluded from the
operation of the power
delegated to the Provincial Governments. In other
words, the power delegated to the Provincial Governments was withdrawn in respect also of "pulses other
than gram", so that the Provincial Governments could
not thenceforth make any order controlling the production, supply and distribution of
or trade or
commerce in edible oils and oilseeds and pulses other
than gram. Simultaneously by Notification No. PY. 603'
(2)-VI(Z) made on the 15th November, 1947, under
section 3 of the Act the Central Government directed
that no order made or deemed to be made under the
Act by a Provincial Government should have effect
from that date so as to prohibit or restrict the movement of pulses other than gram from any place in a
Province to any other place within or outside the
Province or so as to regulate or control the price, production or distribution thereof in any way. As a result
<Jf this Notification the 1945 Order also ceased to
have effect so as to prohibit or restrict the movement
<Jf pulses other than gram or so as to regulate or control the price, production or distribution thereof in
any way.
Then came the Uttar Pradesh Foodgrains (Futures
and Options Prohibition) Order, 1951. It was promulgated by the State of Uttar Pradesh on the 20th
September, 1951. By section 2(a) this Order defined
'"foodgrains" as meaning any of the foodgrains specified
in the schedule thereto. Arhar, peas, urd and moong
were items Nos. 6, 7, 8 and 9 of that schedule. Section
3 of the Order ran as follows :"No person shall- .
(a) enter into any "futures in foodgrains" or pay
or receive any margin relating to any such futures ;
(b) enter into any options in foodgrains."
Section 8 made a contravention of any provision of
the Order or any order issued thereunder punishable
under sections 7 and 7-A of the Act of 1946. By section 9 of this Order the 1945 Order was withdrawn.
As the Uttar Pradesh Foodgrains (Futures and
Options Prohibition) Order, 1951 directly made it illegal
and a punishable offence for any person to enter into
.
'\
S.C.R.
j
'J
~.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
845
any futures in, amongst others, arhar, peas, urd and
moong or to pay or receive or to agree to pay or receive
any margin relating to any such futures. 10 members of
the Chamber of Commerce, Hapur, including the
present petitioners Nos. 2 to 4, on the 29th October,
1951, made an application to this Court under article
32 of the Constitution for enforcement of their fundamental right under article 19(1) (g) to carry on their
business and prayed for the issue of a mandamus
restraining the State of Uttar Pradesh from enforcing
the Uttar Pradesh Foodgrains (Futures and Options
Prohibition) Order, 1951, in so far as it related to pulses
other than gram and from exercising any power thereunder and for a declaration that section 2(a) read
with items 6, 7, 8 and 9 of the schedule thereto was
illegal and ultra vires the powers of the State Government. That application succeeded and the offending
Notification to the extent it dealt with arhar, peas, urd
and moong was declared invalid and the State of Uttar
Pradesh was directed to abstain from giving effect to
it. As will appear from the judgment pronounced by
this Court on the 15th May, 1952, on that application,
it was not seriously disputed that the effect of the
amendments referred to above was that the power to
control and regulate trade originally delegated to the
Provincial Government by Notification No. PY. 603(1)-I,
dated the 21st October, 1946, was modified so as to
exclude from the scope of such delegation "pulses
other than gram".
On the 10th June, 1953, a letter (Ex. B to the petition) was addressed by the Deputy Commissioner, Food,
Uttar Pradesh, to all Regional Food Controllers and
Deputy Regional Food Controllers and all District
Magistrates in Uttar Pradesh instructing them to regard
all futures in foodgrains mentioned in the schedule to
the 1945 Order including pulses other than gram as
punishable. The reasoning advanced was that the
Uttar Pradesh Foodgrains (Futures and Options Prohibition) Order, 1951, having been declared ultra vires
by the judgment pronounced by this Court on the 15th
May, 1952, that Order became unenforceable and
1954
T ht Chamber of
Comwrce, Hapur,
and three Othtrs
v.
Till :state of
Uttar Pradesh
and two Others.
Das].
846
1954
Th< Chambe> of
CM1UT10ce, Hapur,
and three Others
v.
TM State of
Uttar Pradesh
and two OtMrs.
Das].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1955)
consequently the 1945 Order continued in force. A
copy of this letter was forwarded, amongst others, to the
Chamber of Commerce, Hapur, for information and
guidance. By its letter dated the 25th June, 1953, the
Chamber pointed out that the earlier Order of 1945 had
been withdrawn by section 9 of the Order of 1951 and
as the last mentioned section had not been declared
ultra vircs by the Supreme Court the 1945 Order ~ould
not be regarded as continuing in force. On the 17th
September, 1953, the Regional Food Controller of
Uttar Pradesh wrote a letter (Ex. D to the petition)
to the President, Chamber of Commerce, Hapur, asking the latter to immediately stop all future transactions pertaining to the foodgrains mentioned in the
schedule to the 1945 Order in which delivery was contemplated within the State of Uttar Pradesh and
threatening action to be taken against the Chamber.
This threat of action necessitated the present petition
for the reliefs mentioned above.
Learned advocate appearing for the State seeks to
justify the attitude of the State on two grounds. It is
urged that section 3 of the 1946 Act which reproduced
with certain modifications
section 3 of the 1946
Ordinance, conferred on the Central Government
extensive powers to control production, supply, distribution of and trade and commerce in essential commodities. This power was delegated by the Central
Government to the Provincial Governments by Notification No. PY. 603(2)-I issued on the 21st October,
1946, under section 4 of the 1946 Ordinance. The
subsequent amendments made by Notification No. C. G.
603(2)-III(D dated the 5tl1 March, 1947, and Notification No. PY. 603(2)-VI(l) dated the 15th November,
1947, withdrew the power so delegated only with respect
to "edible oils and oilseeds and pulses other than gram"
and such withdrawal was only with regard to the
production, supply and distribution of those commodities but not with regard to trade and commerce therein.
The second ground advanced is that the Order of 1951
having been declared ultra vires the Order of 1945,
which was continued first by section 5 of the 1946
Ordinance and then by_ section 17 of the Act, remained
'r
I
•
S.C.R.
j
•
~·
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
847
1954
in full force. In our judgment there 1s no substance
The Chamb•r of
in either of the two arguments.
H apur
As we have already pointed out, two Notifications Commtrct?,
and thw Others
were published on the 5th March, 1947, and two Notifi\'.
The State of
cations were issued on the 15th November, 1947. By
Uttar Pradesh
Notification No. C. G. 603(2)-III(1) dated the 5th
and two Others.
March, 1947, and Notification No. PY. 603 (2)-VI
Das].
(1), dated the 15th November, 1947, the earlier Notification No. 603(2)-1, dated the 21st October, 1946, was
amended by inserting therein the words "edible oils
and oilseeds" and "pulses other than gram" and
thereby excluding those commodities from the scope of
the delegation. As a result of these amendments the
Provincial Governments could not, from and after the
respective dates of those amending Notifications, make
any order controlling production, supply, distribution
of or trade and commerce in those commodities. These
Notifications did not puport to affect Notifications that
had been previously made. But simultaneously with
these amending Notifications two more Notifications
were issued, namely, Notification No. C.G. 603(2)-III(2),
dated tl1e 5th March, 1947, and Notification No. PY.
603(2)-VI(2), dated the 15ili November, 1947. By these
Notifications the Central Government directed iliat no
order made or deemed to be made under the Act by a
Provincial Government should have effect so as to prohibit or restrict the movement of edible oils and oilseeds
and pulses other than gram or to regulate or control the
price, production or distribution of those commodities
m any way. As a result of ilie joint operation of these
Notifications the 1945 Order ceased to have effect so as
to prohibit or restrict the movement of edible oils and
oilseeds and pulses other than gram or to regulate or
control the price, production or distribution of those
commodities. As that Order of 1945 ceased to have
effect with regard to the price, production, distribution
and movement of iliose commodities, it is not easy to
comprehend how that Order could continue to regulate
or control trade or commerce in those commodities•
Trade or commerce in any commodity cannot be controlled unless ilie pnce, production, distribution and
movement of that commodity can also be controlled.
16-88 S. C. India/59.
J
848
1954
The Chamber of
Commerce, Hapur,
and three Others
v.
The Stale nf
Uttat Pradtsh
.and two Others.
D., ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
It follows, therefore, contrary to the contentions of the
State, that these two Notifications of 1947 quite
effectively superseded the 1945 Order so far as it
purported to regulate or control the price, production, distribution and movement of or trade and commerce in edible oils and oilseeds and pulses other than
gram.
The second branch of the argument is equally fa llacious. It is wholly incorrect to say that the judgment
pronounced by this Court on the 15th May, 1952,
declared the Uttar Pradesh Foodgrains (Futures and
Options Prohibition) Order, 1951, ultra vires and invalid
in its entirety. That judgment only declared it invalid
to the extent of the restrictions complained of by the
then petitioners, namely, in so far as it purported to
restrict dealings in edible oils and oilseeds and pulses
other than gram. The rest of that Order of 1951 and
in particular section 9 by which the 1945 Order had
been withdrawn remained unaffected by that judgment
of this Court. It is quite difficult to appreciate how,
in the circumstances, the Order of 1945 can be regarded
as having been rev.ived by the judgment in respect of
edible oils and oilseeds and pulses other than gram in
spite of the express withdrawal of that Order by section
9 of the Order of 1951 which otherwise remains
operative.
In our judgment there is no substance whatever
in either of the two branches of argument advanced
before us and this application must succeed. Accordingly we grant prayers (a), (b), (c) and (d) of the
petition.
Before concluding we desire to express our strong
disapproval of the
wholly
unwarranted
attitude
adopted by the officers of the State of Uttar Pradesh.
Assuming there was any substance in their contentions,
the same should have been advanced before this Court
on the previous occasion, for the contentions, if wellfounded, would have been a complete answer to that
application. If the contentions were subsequently ·
discovered, then the same should have been brought
before the Court by way of review, if any review lay.
•
. "·
S.C.R.
,
--
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
849
Instead of adopting that straightforward course the
officers of the State have sought to circumvent the
decision of this Court on a flimsy pretext and covertly
to challenge its correctness on an obviously untenable
plea which has not even the merit of a seeming
plausibility. This
conduct verges dangerously on a
contempt of this Court. We desire to make it quite
clear that we view with great disfavour such unworthy
attempt to get round the decision of this Court.
THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX,
MADRAS
v.
MYSORE CHROMITE LIMITED.
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.J., s. R. DAS,
GHl)LAM HASAN, BHAGWATI
and VENKATARAMA AYYAR JJ.)
Indian Income-tax Act, 1922 (Act XI of 1922), s. 4-Profits
derived by the assessee-Whether arose or were 1·eceived in British
India in the present case.
-
The assessee con;ipaqy with its registered office in Mysore
State and its management vested in Oakley Bowden Co. Ltd.,
Madras, sold Chrome ore to buyers mostly outside India who were
in America and Europe. The sales to the purchasers in Europe
were put through in London by Bowden Oakley and Co. Ltd.,
London, the agent of the assessee company in Europe, the said
'-.. agent signing the contracts for sale in London. The sales to pur<. chasers in America were effected through W. R. Grace & Co., New
York, who bought for undisclosed principals, the contracts for sale
to American purchasers being signed by W. R. Grace & Co., Ltd.,
New York, in America and by Oakley Bowden & Co. Ltd. (Madras),
in Madras. Under both forms of contracts with European purchasers and American purchasers the price was f.O.B. Madras.
• Provision was made for weighment, sampling and assay of goods at
destination. The course of dealing between the assessee company
and the purchasers was as follows :-
>
Before the goods were actually shipped, the buyers used to
open a confirmed irrevocable Bankers' credit with some first class
Bank in London. Being informed of the opening of such credit the
1 954
The Chamber of
Commerce, Ha/UT,
and three Others.
v.
The State of
Uttar Pradesh
and two Others.
1954
November r.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org