BIJAY COTTON MILLS LTD. versus THE STATE OF AJMER
Supreme Court of India | Decided 14 October 1954 | [1955] 1 S.C.R. 752 | 1954 INSC 92
Key facts
- Decided
- 14 October 1954
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN*, BIJAN KUMAR MUKHERJEA, VIVIAN BOSE, B. JAGANNADHADAS, T.L. VENKATARAMA AIYYAR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 188/1954
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1955] 1 S.C.R. 752
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 92
Text of the judgment
75:2
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
BIJAY COTTON MILLS LTD.
1954
v.
THE STATE OF AJMER.
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C. J., MuKHERJEA,
VIVIAN BosE, JAGANNADHADAS and
VENKATARAMA AYYAR JJ.)
Constitution of India, A1"ts. 19(1)(g), 19(6)-Minimum Wages
Act (XI of 1948) ss 3, 4 and 5-Appropriate Government-Fixing
minimum rate of wages-Whether
offends
fundamental rights
guaranteed under Art. 19(1)(g).
The provisions of ss. 3, 4 and 5 of the Minimum Wages Act
(XI of 1948) empower the appropriate Government to fix the
minimum rate of wages in an industrial dispute between the
employer and the employed and it is a criminal offence not to pay
the wages thus fixed under the Act.
~
Held, that the restrictions imposed upon the freedom of contract by the fixation of minimum rates of wages though they
interfere to some extent with the freedo1n of trade or business
guaranteed under Art. 19(1 )(g) of the Constitution are not unreasonable and being imposed in the interest of general public and with a
view to carry out one of the Directive Principles of State Policy
as embodied in Art. 43 of the
Constitution _are protected by the
terms of cl. ( 6) of Art. 19.
S. I. Est. etc. v.
The Stat< of
Madras, (1954) 1 M.L.J. 518
;----
referred to.
ORIGINAL JuRISDICTION : Petitions Nos. 188 and
189 of 1954.
Under article 32 of the Constitution of India for
the enforcement of Fundamental Rights.
H. M. Seervai, f. B. Dadachanji and Rajinder
Narain for petitioners.
C. K. Daphtary, Solicitor-General for India (M. M.
Kaul and P. G. Gokhale, with him) for respondent.
1954. October 14. The Judgment of the Court
was delivered by
MuKHERJEA J.-We now take up the two connected
petitions under article 32 of the Constitution. In one
.of these petitions, to wit Petition No. 188, Shri Bijay
Cotton Mills Ltd. (hereinafter called 'the
company'),
the appellant in Civil Appeal No. 139 of 1954, figures
as the petitioner, while the other petition, to wit,
•
S.C.R.
-
- ..
•
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
753
Petition No. 189, has been filed by a number of employees
working under it. To appreciate the contentions of
Mr. Seervai, who appears in support of both these
petitions, it will be necessary to narrate a few
antecedent facts :
It appears that sometime in 1950 there was an
industrial dispute between the company and its
labourers regarding enhancement of wages and the
dispute was referred by the Government of Ajmer to
an Industrial Tribunal, by a notification dated the 1st
December, 1950. The tribunal made its award on the
27th November, 1951, and held that "the present earning capacity of the mill precludes the award of higher
rates of wages and higher dearness allowance." The
employees took an appeal against this award to the
Appellate Tribunal. While this appeal was pending,
the Chief Cwnmissioner, Ajmer, took steps for the
fixation of minimum wages of labourers in the textile
industry within the State, under the provisions of the
Minimum Wages Act. A committee was formed, as
has already been stated, on the 17th of January, 1952,
which submitted its report on the 4th of October,
following and on the 7th of October, 1952, the notification was issued fixing the minimum rates of wages,
against which writ petitions were filed by several
textile companies including the petitioner company.
In the meantime however the appeal filed by the
labourers of the company proceeded, in the usual way,
before the Appellate Tribunal. The Appellate Tribunal
sent the case back to the Industrial Tribunal for
further investigation and the latter made its final
award on the 8th of September, 1953, by which it
rejected the basis upon which minimum wages of Rs. 56
were fixed by the Chief Commissioner and fixed the
minimum wages includes the dearness allowance at
Rs. 35 only. The company states in its petition that
the minimum wages fixed by the State Government of
Ajmer is altogether prohibitory and it is not at all
possible for the company to carry on its business on
payment of such wages. Accordingly the company
closed its mills on and from the 1st April, 1953. There
were about 1500 labourers working in the mills of the
company and since January, 1954, several hundreds of
1 954
Bijay C•tl1n
Mills lJd.
v.
The State ef
Ajmu.
MukherjeaJ.
754
1 954
Bijay Cotton
Mills Ud.
v.
The State of
~finer.
· Mukh~rjui J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
them, it is said, approached the managing authorities
and requested them to open the mills expressing their
willingness to work at Rs. 35 as wages as fixed by the
Industrial Tribunal. Though the majority of workers
were agreeable to work on the wages fixed qy the
Industrial Tribunal, the company is unable to open the
mills by reason of the fact that the Minimum Wages
Act makes it a criminal offence not to pay the wages
fixed under the Act. This being the position and as the
Minimum 'V' ages Act stands in the way of the company's carrying on its business, on terms agreed to
between itself and its workers, Petition No. 188 of 1954
has been filed by the company challenging the constitumaterial
provisions of the
tional validfry of the
Minimum Wages Act itself. The workmen who are
willing to work at less than the minimum wages fixed by
the State Government have filed the other petition
supporting all the allegations
of the company.
Mr. Seervai, who appears in support of both these
petitions, has invited us to hold that the material provisions of the Minimum Wages Act are illegal and ultra
vires by reason of their conflicting with the fundamental
rights of the employers and the employed guaranteed
under article 19(1) (g) of the Constitution and that they
are not protected by clause ( 6) of that article.
It is contended bv the learned counsel that the
Minimum Wages Act puts unreasonable restnct10ns
upon the rights of the employer in the sense that he is
prevented from carrying on trade or business unless he
is prepared to pay minimum wages. The rights of the
employees are also restricted, inasmuch as they are
disabled from working in any trade or industry on the
terms agreed to between them and their employers. It
is pointed out that the provisions relating to the
fixation of mmrmum wages are unreasonable and
arbitrary. The whole thing has been left to the
unfettered discretion of the "appropriate Government"
and even when a committee is appointed, the report
or advice of such committee is not binding on the
Government. The decision of the committee is final
and is not open to further review or challenge in any
Court of law. The learned counsel further says that the
restrictions put by the Act are altogether unreasonable
•
-
•
•
S.C.R.
-
r
c
-
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
755
and even oppressive with regard
to one class of
employers, who for purely economIC reasons are not
able to pay the minimum wages but who have no
intention to exploit labour at· all. In such cases the
provisions of the Act have no reasonable relation to
the object which it has in view. We will examine these
contentions in their proper order.
It can scarcely be disputed that securing of living
wages to labourers which msure not only bare physical
subsistence but also the maintenance of health and
decency, is conducive to the general interest of the
public. This is one of the Directive Principles of State
Policy embodied in article 43 of our Constitution. It
is well known that in 1928 there was a Minimum Wages
Fixing Machinery Convention held at Geneva and the
resolutions passed in that convention were embodied
The Minimum
in the International Labour Code.
Wages Act is said to have been passed with a view to
give effect to these resolutions, (vide S. I. Est., etc. v.
The State of Madras) ( 1 ). If the labourers are to be
secured in the enjoyment of minimum wages and they
;;re to be protected against exploitation by their
that restraints·
employers. it is absolutely necessary
should be imposed upon their freedom of contract and
such restrictions cannot in anv sense be said to be
unreasonable. On the other !~and, the employers cannot be heard to complain if they are compelled to pay
minimum wages to their labourers even though the
labourers. on account of their poverty and helplessness.
are willing to work on lesser wages.
·
We could not really appreciate the argument of
Mr. Seervai that the provisions of the Act are bound
to affect harshly and even oppressively a particular
class of employers who for purely economic reasons are
unable to pay the minimum wages fixed by the
authorities but have absolutely no dishonest intention
of exploiting their labourers. If it is in the interest of
the general public that the labourers should be secured
adequate living wages, the intentions of the employers
whether good or bad are really irrelevant. Individual
employers might find it difficult to carry on the business
on the basis of the minimum wages fixed under the
{') (1954) IM. L.J. 518, 521,
-
1954
Bijay Cotton
Mills Ltd.
v ••
The Stat; qf
Ajmer.
Mukherjea J.
756
•9~±
Bijay Cotton
Mills Lid.
...
The Sta" of
Aj,.,,,,.
MUfWrj,d J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19551
Act but this must be due entirely to the economic
conditions of these particular employers. That cannot
be a reason for the striking down the law itself as
unreasonable.
A, regards the procedure for the fixing of minimum
wages, the "appropriate Government" has undoubtedly
been given very large powers. But it has to take into
consideration, before fixing wages, the advice of the
committee if one is appointed, or the representations
on his proposals made by persons who are likely to be
affected thereby. Consultation with advisory bodies
has been made obligatory on all occasions of revision
of minimum wages, and section 8 of the Act provides
for the appointment of a Central Advisory Board for
the purpose of advising the Central as well as the State
Government both in the matter of fixing and revision
of minimum wages. Such Central Advisory body is to
act also as a co-ordinating agent for co-ordinating the
work of the different advisorv bodies. In the. committees or the advisory bodies ·the employers and the
employees have an equal number of representatives
and there are certain independent members besides
them who are expected to take a fair and impartial
view of the matter. These provisions, in our opinion,
constitute an adequate safeguard against any hasty or
capricious decision by the "appropriate Government."
In suitable cases the "appropriate Government" has
also been given the power of granting exemptions from
the operation of the provisions of this Act. There is
no provision undoubtedly for a further review of the
decision of the "appropriate Government", but we do
not think that by itself would make the provisions of
the Act unreasonable. In our opinion, the restrictions,
though they interfere to some extent with the freedom
of trade or business guaranteed under article 19(1) (g)
of the Constitution, are reasonable and being imposed
in the interest of the general public are protected by
the terms of clause ( 6) of article 19. The result is that
the petitions are dismissed. We make no order as
to costs.
Petitions dismissed.
-
•
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org