KUNJILAL AND ANOTHER versus THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 8 October 1954 | [1955] 1 S.C.R. 872 | 1954 INSC 86
Key facts
- Decided
- 8 October 1954
- Bench
- SUDHI RANJAN DAS*, GHULAM HASAN, NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 73/1953
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1955] 1 S.C.R. 872
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 86
Text of the judgment
872
1954
.Anderson Wright
Ltd.
••
Moran aii.d
Company.
Mukherjea ].
1954
October 8.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19551
to the arbitration agreement. If the Court 1s of opinion
that the respondent was in fact a party, the suit shall
be stayed and the appellant would be allowed to
proceed by way of arbitration in accordance with the
arbitration clause. If on the other hand the finding is
adverse to the appellant, the application will be
dismissed. The appellant will have its costs of this
appeal. Further costs between the parties will abide
the result.
Appeal allowed.
KUNJILAL AND ANOTHER
"·
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH.
[S. R. DAs, GHuLAM HASAN and BHAGWATI JJ.]
Criminal Procedure Code (Act V of 1898), s. 403 (!) and (2)Appellants convicted for offences under ss. 392 and 332 l.P.C. while
exporting conti·aband g(!ods-Previous acquittal
for
prosecution
under s. 7 of the Ersential Supplies (Temporary Powers) Act, 1946
-JlVhether a bar to the subsequent trial for offences under ss. 392
and 332 l.P.C.
The appellants were tried and convicted for offences
under
ss. 392 and 332 of the Indian Penal Code committed when they
were exporting certain essential supplies, the export of \vhich \Vas
prohibited and constituted an offence under s. 7 of the Essential
Supplies (Temporary Powers) Act, 1946. It was contended that
the appellants were already prosecuted for an offence under s. 7 of
the Essential Supplies (Ten1porary Powers) Act, 1946, and though
Additional
convicted by the Magistrate, v.·ere acquitted by the
Sessions Judge, S:igar, and on the basis of that judgment which
'vas not brought to the notice of the High Court the appellants
'vho had once been tried for the same offence and acquitted could
not be tried again under the provisions of s. 403( 1) of the Code of
Crin1inal Procedure for the same offence nor on the same facts for
any other offence for 'vhich a different charge fro1n the one made
against them might have been nlade under s. 236 of the Code of
Criininal Procedure or for \vhat they 1night ha,'c been convicted
under s. 237 of the Code of Crirninal Procedure.
Held, that neither s. 236 nor s. 237 'vas applicable and that
sub-section (2) of s. 403 of the C.Ode of Crin1inal Procedure \Vas a
complete answer to the contention because the appellants "''ere not
tried for the same offence as contcn1plated under s. 403( 1) but for a
distinct offence as conte1nplated by sub-section (2).
·•
-
•
•
_.._
:S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
CRIMINAL
APPELLATE
Appeal No. 73 of 1953.
..
j
>
•
JuRismcnoN :
873
Criminal
Appeal by Special Leave granted by the Supreme
Court by its Order dated the 30th January, 1953, from
the Judgment and Order dated the 12th November,
1952, of the High Court of Judicature at Nagpur in
Criminal Revision No. 399 of 1951 arising out of the
Judgment and Order dated the 26th March, 1951, of
:the Court of the Magistrate at Sagar in Criminal Case
No. 44 of 1950.
Y. Kumar for the appellant.
B. Sen and l. N. Shroff for the respondent.
1954. October 8. The Judgment of the Court was
·delivered by
GHULAM HASAN J.-This appeal under article 136 of
1:he Constitution is filed against an order of the High
Court of Judicature at Nagpur, passed in revision under
the following circumstances.
The two appellants, Kunjilal and Deopal, who are
father and son, the latter being aged 17, were prosecuted
under section 392 and section 332, Indian Penal Code,
in the Court of the Magistrate, Sagar. They were
sentenced under the
former to 1 year's rigorous
imprisonment and under the latter to a fine of Rs. 500
·each. Their convictions were upheld on appeal but
Kunjilal's sentence was reduced to six months R. I. and
Rs. 350 fine, while Deopal was bound over under
section 562 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the
sentence of imprisonment was set aside. His fine
was reduq:d under section 332, Indian Penal Code,· to
Rs. 250. They carried the matter further in revision
to the High Court but it was dismissed.
It appears that the export of certain essential supplies
such as rice and ghee was prohibited from Madhya
Pradesh to another State and anv person contravening
the prohibition was guilty of an offence under section 7
·of the Essential Supplies (Temporary Powers) Act,
1946.
Three bullock carts belonging to the appellants
and carrying bags of rice and tins of ghee were crossing
the river Dhasan on the Madhya Pradesh :111d Uttar
Prade~h border on 1st
March, 1949. Head Constable
Kury'ilal anti
Another
v.
TMSta.t< of
Madhya Pradesh.
874
1954
llunjilal and
Another
v.
Tht Stau of
·Madhya Pradesh.
Ghulam Hasan J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
f1955]
AbC:lul Samad on receiving information reached the
spot, seized the prohibited goods and brought the carts
back to Shahgarh in Madhya Pradesh. When they
reached the jungle near Shahgarh the two appellants
are alleged to have beaten the Head Constable and
taken away the property seized to the house of Paltu
Bania at Bo.grohi. They were according! y charged under
sections 332 and 392, Indian Penal Code, for voluntarily
causing hurt to a publi,c servant in the discharge of his
duty as such public servant and also for robbing him
of the goods seized by him. The appellants denied the
offence. They pleaded that the goods were not being
exported to Uttar Pradesh but to a place called
Baraitha and that they did not beat the Head Constable.
The Magistrate who tried the appellants found that
both the offences were proved against the appellants.
de accepted the prosecution evidence both on the
point of beating as well as on the point of exporting
the contraband goods. The medical evidence supported
the prosecution case. The appellants were accordingly
convicted and sentenced as stated above.
The learned Additim:al Sessions Judge, Sai;ar, while
agreeing with the findings of the Magistrate further
found that the story that the carts were being taken to
Baraitha which is in Mad:1ya Pradesh was false as the
route to Baraitha die! not pass through the Dhasan
river but lay in quite a different direction. He, how·ever, held that the carts were caught at the other bank
of the river Dhasan after they had crossed the Madhya
Pradesh border but the seizure was nevertheless legal.
This finding was sought to be made capital of in revision and it was contended that the seizure took place
beyond the border of the State of Madhya Pradesh and
was therefore illegal. Upon the question whether the
carts were within the limits of Madhya Pradesh State
when they were actually apprehended there was
evidence which was accepted that the carts were seized
when they were in the mid-stream and the cart-men
requested the Head Constable to let them take the
carts on the other side of the river so that they may
have their meals. This was allowed and after they had
finished their meals, the carts were brought back. Upon
..~
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
875
this evidence it was held that the carts were captured
before they had crossed the Uttar Pradesh border and
the seizure was in the circumstances legal and proper.
The convictions were maintained but the sentences
were reduced as already stated.
In a Special Leave to Appeal under article 136, it is
not open to the appellants to re-agitate questions of
fact and ask the Court to disturb the findings of fact
arrived at by the Courts below. Those findings must
therefore be accepted as binding. It was urged that
there was absence of mens rea which it is necessary to
establish under section 392. It is contended that the
appellants honestly believed that they were taking the
goods to a place within the State of Madhya Pradesh
when they were caught in the mid-stream. This
conclusion is, however, clearly negatived by the finding
that the route which the appellants had chosen was not
the route which led to Baraitha or any other place
within Madhya Pradesh State but actually led to
Uttar Pradesh.
It was also contended that the appellants were
already prosecuted for an offence under section 7 of
the Essential Supplies (Temporary Powers) Act, 1946,
for exporting the contraband goods and although they
were convicted by the Magistrate they were acquitted
on appeal by the Additional Sessions Judge, Sagar, on
October 31, 1952. It is argued upon the strength of
this judgment which was admittedly not brought to
the notice of the High Court that under section 403(1)
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the appellants
who had once been tried for the offence and acquitted
could not .be tried again for the same offence nor on
the same facts for any other offence for which a different
charge from the one made against them might have
been made under section 236 or for which they might
have been convicted under section 237. Neither section
236 which deals with a case where there is a doubt as
to which offence has been committed nor section 237
which entitles the Court to convict a person of an
offence which he is shown to have committed although
he was not charged with it, applies. Sub-section (2) of
section 403 in our opinion furnishes a complete answer
..
)
19-88
s. c. !ndia/59.
1954
Kunjilal anti
Another
v.
Tm Stat• of
Madhya Pradesh.
Ghulam Hasan J.
876
1954
Kun.jilal and
Another
v.
The State of
Madhya Pradesh.
Ghulam Hasan].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
to the contention raised on behalf of the appellants.
That sub-section reads :
"403 (2) .-A person acquitted or convicted of any
offence may be afterwards tried for any distinct offence
for which a separate charge might have been made
against him on the former trial under section 235, subsection (I)."
The appellants were not tried again for the same
offence as contemplated under section 403(1) but for a
distinct offence as contemplated by sub-section (2). It
is true that in order to sustain the charge under
sections 332 and 392, Indian Penal Code, the Court had
to consider whether the seizure was legal and was made
by a public servant in the discharge of his duty but
once that was found against the appellants the further
question to be determined was as to whether they
committed the offence of robbing the Head Constable of
the goods lawfully seized and whether they voluntarily
caused hurt to him while he was acting in the discharge
of his duties as a public servant. Upon both these
points the finding of the Courts below is concurrent.
We hold that there is no substance in this contention.
We accordingly dismiss the appeal.
Appeal dismissed.
1954
BACHA F. GUZDAR
October 28.
v.
COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX, BOMBAY.
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.J., S. R. D~s,
GHULAM HASAN, BHAGWATI and
VENKATARAMA AYYAR JJ.J
Indian Income-tax Act (XI of 1922), ss. 2(1), 4(3) (viii), 59 and
rule 24-Agricultural Income, Meaning of-Growing and manu·
facturing tea company's dividend, Nature of-Dividend how arises
·-Distinction bettveen shareholder and partner-Difference between
company and firm-Decided cases on English Tax Uw, Use of.
Agricultural income as defined ins. 2(1) of the Indian Incometax Act, 1922, signifies income proximately derived from direct
association with land by a ·person who actually tills the · land 01
-
-
...
•
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org