THE SALES TAX OFFICER, PILIBHIT versus MESSRS. BUDH PRAKASH JAI PRAKASH.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 3 May 1954 | [1955] 1 S.C.R. 243 | 1954 INSC 57
Key facts
- Decided
- 3 May 1954
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN*, BIJAN KUMAR MUKHERJEA, VIVIAN BOSE, NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI, T.L. VENKATARAMA AIYYAR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 23/1954
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1955] 1 S.C.R. 243
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 57
Text of the judgment
$.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
243
THE SALES TAX OFFIC_ER, PILIBHIT
r954
v.
May3:
MESSRS. BUDH PRAKASH JAI PRAKASH.
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.J., MuKHERJEA, VIVIAN
BosE, BHAGWATI and VENKATARAMA AYYAR, JJ]
>
'f
i.
J
\
.....;..
~:
Government of India Act, 1935, Schedule VII, List II, entry
No. 48-Sale of goods-Meaning of-U. P. Sales Tax Act (XV of
1948), s. 2(h )-Explanation III to s. 2(h) and s. 3B-Ultra vires
Provincial Legislature.
Held, that there is a well-defined and well-established distinction between a .sale and an agreement to sell.
The words "Taxes on the sale of goods" in entry No. 48, List
Ii, Schedule VII of the Government of India Act, 1935, confer
pbwer on the Provincial Legislature to impose a tax only when
there has been a completed sale and not when there is only an
agreement to sell.
Accordingly section 2(h) of the Uttar Pradesh Sales Tax Act,
XV of 1948, enlarging the definition of "sale" so as to include forward contracts must, to that extent, be declared ultra vires.
_ For the same reason Explanation III to section 2 ( h) which
provides that forward contracts "shall be deemed to have been
completed on the date originally agreed upon for delivery" and
section 3B of the Act must also be held to be ultra vires.
Colley v. Overseas Exporters ((1921] 3 K. B. 302 at 309, 310
referred to.
CrvrL APPELLATE JuRrsmcTION : Civil
Appeal
No. 23 of 1954.
Appeal under article 133(1) of the Constitution of
India from the Judgment and Decree dated the 28th
February, 1952, of the High Court of Judicature at
Allahabad in Writ Application No. 7297 of 1951.
C. P. Lal for the appellant.
N. C. Chatterjee (Radhey Lal Aggarwal., with him)
for the respondent.
1954. May 3. The Judgment of the Court was
<lelivered by
VENKATARAMA AYYAR J.-This is an appeal by the
Sales Tax Officer, Pilibhit, against the judgment of
the High Court of Allahabad granting firstly, a writ of
certiorari q,uashing certain assessment orders made
;igainst the respondent, and secondly, a writ of pro:hibition in respect of certain · other - proceedings for
244
1954
Tht Salu Ta."
Offictr, Pllibhit
v.
Missrs. Budh
Prakash
Jai Pralcruh.
Venlcatm-ama
Ayyar J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(19551
assessment of tax under the provisions of the Uttar
Pradesh Sales Tax Act (Act XV of 1948)~ The respondent is a firm doing business in forward contracts.
and was assessed in respect of such contracts to a tax
of Rs. 1,082-8-0 for the year 1948-49 by an order
dated 27th February, 1950, Exhibit A, and to a tax
of Rs. 7,369 for the year 1949-1950 by an order dated
23rd May, 1950, Exhibit B. For the period, 1st April.
1950, . to 31st January, 1951, the respondent paid a
sum of Rs. 845-4-0 as tax. Assessment proceedings
were also started by the appellant in respect of certain
forward contracts relating to gur and peas. The respondent challenged the legality of these proceedings
and of the assessment orders on the ground that the:
Act in so far as it imposed a tax on forward contracts
was ultra vires the powers of the Provincial Legislature •.
The learned Judges agreed with this contention, and
issued a writ of certiorari quashing the orders of assessment, Exhibits A and B, and a writ of prohibition in
respect of the proceedings for assessment of tax on·
forward contracts in gur and peas. The matter now
comes before us in appeal under a certificate of the
High Court under article 133(1) of the Constitution.
\.
7
Under the Government of India Act, 1935, the Provincial Legislature derived its power to impose a tax
on the sale of goods under entry 48 in List II of the
Seventh Schedule, and the Uttar Pradesh Sales Tax
Act, XV of 1948, was enacted in exercise of this power.
Section Z(h) of the Act defines "sale" as follows :
"Sale" means within its grammatical vanat1ons
and cognate expressions, any transfer of property in -~.
goods for cash or deferred payment or other valuable
consideration and includes forward contracts but does not
include a mortgage, hypothecation, charge or pledge."
It is the extended definition of sale as including
forward contracts in this section that is relied on as
conferring authority on the appellant to make the
orders in Exhibits A and B. The point for decision in
this appeal is whether the power to impose a tax on
the sale of goods under entry 48 includes a power ta ·
impose a tax on forward contracts.
A
S.C.ll.
f
)
-- '
SUPREME. COURT REPORTS
245
Under the statute law of India which is based on
English law on the subject, a sale of goods and an
agreement for the sale of goods are treated as two
distinct and separate matters. Section 4 of the Indian
Sale of Goods Act (Act III of 1930), runs as follows:
(1) "A contract of sale of goods IS a contract
whereby the seller transfers or agrees to transfer the
property in goods to the buyer for a price. There may be
a contract of sale between one part-owner and another.
(2) A contract of sale may be absolute or conditional.
(3) Where under a contract of sale the property
in the goods is transferred from the seller to the buyer,
the contract is called a sale, but where the transfer of
the property in the goods is to take place at a future
time or subject to some condition thereafter to be
fulfilled, the contract is called an agreement to sell.
( 4) An agreement to sell becomes a sale when the
time elapses or the conditions are fulfilled subject to
which the property in the goods IS to be transferred."
It will be noticed that though the section groups
both sales and agreements to sell under the single
generic name of "contracts of sale", following in this
respect the scheme of the English Sale of Goods Act,.
1893, it treats them as separate categories, the vital
point of distinction between them being that whereas
in a sale there is a transfer of property in the goods
from the seller to the buyer, there is none in an agreement to sell. When the contract is to sell future goods,
and under section 6(3) of the Sale of Goods Act even
if "the· seller purports to effect a present sale of future
goods, the contract operates as an agreement to sell
the goods'', there can be no transfer of title to the
goods until they actually come into existence ; and
even then, the conditions laid down in section 23 of
the Act should be satisfied before the property m the
goods can pass. That was also the law under the
repealed provisions in Chapter VII of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Section 77 of the Contract Act defined
"sale" as follows :
"Sale" is the exchange of property fot a price. It
involves the transfer of the ownership of the thing sold
from the seller to the buyer."
1 954
The Sales Tax:
Officer, Pilihhit
v.
Messrs. Bulik
Prakash
Jai Prakash.
r-~
Venkatarama
Ayyar J.
..'246
1954
_The~.Sale Tax
.Officer, Pilibhit
..v.
.Messrs. Budh
- Prakash
. :Jai Prakash.
.;vtnkatarama
Ayyar J.
SUPREME·COURT REPORTS
,[1955]
Section 79 enacted that,
"Where there is a contract for the sale of a thing
which has yet to be ascertained, made or finished, the
ownership of the thing is not transferred to the buyer,
until it is ascertained, made or finished."
The corresponding provisions of the English Act are
'sections 1, 16 and rule 5 of section 18. Section 1 is
·as follows :
(1) "A contract of sale of goods is a contract
'wherebv the seller transfers or agrees to transfer the
_property in goods to the buyer fqr a money consideration, called the price. There may be a contract of sale
.between one part-owner and another.
(2) A contract of sale may be absolute or condi.tional.
(3) Where under a contract of sale the property
·in the goods is transferred from the seller to the buyer
the contract is called a sale ; but where the transfer of
the property in the goods is to take place at a future
time or subject to some condition thereafter to be
.fulfilled the contract is called an agreement to sell.
(4) An agreement to sell becomes a sale when the
time elapses or the conditions are fulfilled subject to
which the property in the goods is to be transferred."
Section 16 enacts that,
"Where there is a contract for the sale of unascertained goods no property in the goods is transferred to the buyer unless and until the goods arc
ascertained.''
Section 18, rule 5, provides for the passing of property is future goods after they are ascertained.
The distinction between a sale and an agreement to
sell under section 1 of the English Act is thus stated
·by Benjamin on Sale, Eighth Edition, 1950 :
"In order to constitute a sale there must be( 1) An agreement to sell, by which alone the property does not pass ; and
(2) an actual sale, by which the property passes.
It will be observed that the definition of a contract
-of sale above cited includes a mere agreement to sell
'as well as an actual sale."
S.C.R.
.•.
-
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
247.
· · This distinction between· sales and agreements to sell
based upon the passing of the property in the goods is
of great importance in determining the rights of parties under a contract. The position is thus stated in
Halsbury's Laws of · England, Volume 29, page 15,
paragraph 13 :
"An agreement to sell, or, as it is often stated, an
executory contract of sale, is a contract pure and simple, whereas a sale, or, as it is called for distinction, an
executed .contract of sale, is a contract plus a conveyc
ance. Thus, by an agreement to sell a mere 7us in
personam is created, by a sale a jus in rem is transferred. Where goods have been sold, and the buyer
makes default in payment, the seller may sue for the
contract price, but where an agreement to buy is broken,
usually the seller's only remedy 1s an action for unliquidated damages. Similarly, if an agreement to sell
be broken by the seller, the buyer has only a personal
remedy against the seller. The goods are the property
of the seller and he can dispose of them. They may
be taken in execution for his debts, and if he becomes
bankrupt they pass to his trustee m bankruptcy.
But if there has been a sale, and the seller breaks his
engagement to deliver the goods, the buyer has not
only a personal remedy against the seller, but also the
usual proprietary remedies in respect of the goods themselves, such as the actions for conversion and detinue.
Again, if there be an agreement for sale and the goods
perish, the loss as a rule falls on the seller, while if
there has been a sale the loss as a rule falls upon the
buyer."
Thus, there having existed at the time of the enactment of the Government of India Act, 1935. a welldefined :ind well-established distinction . between a sale
and an agreement to sell it would be proper to inteipret the expression sale of goods" in entry 48 in the
sense in which it was used m legislation both m
England and India and to hold that it authorises
the imposition of a tax only when there is a complet~
sale involving transfer of ·title.
This conclusion is further strengthened, when regard
is had to the nature of the levy. Section 3 of the Act
1954
The Soles Tax
Officer, Pilibhit
v.
Messrs. Budh
Prakash-,
Jai Prakash;
Venkatarama
Ayyar J,
248
1954
TbeSa/es Tax
·Ojjicer, Ptlibhit
v.
Messrs. Budh
Prakash.
Jai Prakash.
.Venkatarama
Ayyar J . .
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1955]
provides for a tax being imposed at three pies in the
rupee on the turnover of the assessee, and "turnover"
is defined in section 2 ( i) as "the aggregate of the pre>ceeds of sale by a dealer'', and . that would consist· of
the price and any charges paid at the time of the delivery of the goods, as provided in Explanation I. The
substance of the matter is that the sales tax is a levy
on the price of the goods, and the reason of the thing
requires that such a levv should not be made, unless
the stage has been reached when the seller can recover
the pnce under the contract. It 1s well-settled that
an action for price 1s maintainable only when there is
a sale involving transfer of the property in the goods
to the purchaser. Where there is only an agreement
to sell, then the remedy of the seller 1s to sue for
damages for breach of contract and not for the price
of the goods. The law was thus stated m Colley v.
Overseas Exporte..s(') :
"In former days an action for the price of goods
would only lie upon one or other of two counts. First,
upon the indebitatus count for goods sold and delivered, which was pleaded as follows : 'Money payable by
the defendant to the plaintiff for goods sold and delivered by the plaintiff to the defendants': Bullen and
Leake, Precedents of Pleading, 3rd ed., p. 38. This
count would not lie before delivery: Boulter v. Arnott(').
The count was applicable when upon sale of goods
the property has passed and the goods had been delivered to the purchaser and the price was payable at
the time of the action brought. Secondly, upon the
indebitatus count for goods bargained and sold, which
.was pleaded as follows : 'Money payable by the defendcant to the plaintiff for goods bargained and sold by the
plaintiff to the defendant' : Bullen and Leake, p. 39.
This count was applicable where upon a sale of goods
the property had passed to the purchaser and the contract had been completed in all respects except delivery,
and . the delivery was not a part of the consideration
for the price or a condition precedent to ·its payment.
If the property had not passed the count would not
lie : Atkinson v. Be/1( 3 ). In my view the law as to the
(1) !1921] 3 K.B. 302 at 309, 310.
(2) 1833) I c,. & M. 333·
(3) (1828) 8 B. & C. 27).
•
:S;C.R.
•. '>-
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
249
1 954
circumstances under which an action will lie for the
price of goods has not been changed by the Sale of
TheSaks Tax
Officer, Pilibhit
Goods Act, 1893."
v.
That is also the law in this country under section 55
Messrs. Budh
Prakash
-of the Sale of Goods Act. The only . exception to this
Jai Prakash.
rule is when, under an agreement between the parties,
Venkatarama
the price is payable on a day certain irrespective of
AY.Jlar ].
delivery, and that is not material for the purpose of
the present discussion.
The position therefore is that a liability to be assessed to sales tax can arise only if there is a completed
sale under which price is paid or is payable and not
when there is only an agreement to sell, which can
only result in a claim for damages. It would be contrary to all principles to hold that damages for breach
of contract are liable to be assessed to sales tax on the
ground that they are in the same position as sale price.
The power conferred under entry 48 to impose a tax on
the sale of goods can therefore be exercised only when
there is a sale un<ler which there is a transfer of property in the goods, and not when there is a mere agreement to sell. The State Legislature cannot, by enlarging the definition of "sale" as including forward
contracts, arrogate to itself a power which is not conferred upon it by the Constitution Act, and the definition of "sale" in section 2(h) of Act XV of 1948 must,
to that extent, be declared ultra vires. For the same
reason, Explanation III to section 2(h) which provides
that forward contracts "shaH be deemed to have been
completed on the date originally agreed upon for
.delivery'', and section 3-B which enacts that,
"Notwithstanding anything contained in section
3, the turnover of any dealer in respect of transactions
of forward contracts, in waich goods are not actually
delivered, shall be taxed at a rate not exceeding rupees
two per unit as inay be prescribed." must also be
held to be ultra vires.
In the result, the decision of the High Court must be
affirmed and this appeal dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org