HEM RAJ versus THE STATE OF AJMER
Supreme Court of India | Decided 17 March 1954 | [1954] 1 S.C.R. 1133 | 1954 INSC 30
Key facts
- Decided
- 17 March 1954
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN*, VIVIAN BOSE, GHULAM HASAN
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 58/1953
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1954] 1 S.C.R. 1133
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 30
Text of the judgment
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1133
and a District Judge could only mean a Judge of the
High Court for
Rajasthan established under the
Rajasthan High Court Ordinance 1949 and a District
Judge of or in Rajasthan within the meaning of
section 5(ix) of Ordinance No. IV of 1950. Accordingly
we hold that the appointment of Shri Sukhdeo Narain
was perfectly valid.
1954
Tiu Stat• qf
Raja.sthan
v.
TM Mewar T ,,,_
Iii< Mthq J,td.,
, ·Bhilwara
and Ot/urs.
Ghulam Ha.son ]. '
We accordingly set aside the order of the High
Court but without costs, as the respondent is not
represented.
Agent for the appellant : R. H. Dhebar.
HEM RAJ
1954
().
THE STATE OF AJMER
(And Connected Appeal)
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C.
J., VIVIAN BosE
and GHULAM HASAN JJ.]
Constitution of India, art. 136(1)-Principles gorcrning the
exercise of powers by the Supreme Court under art. 136(1)-Confessions-Whether can be corroborated by evidence already in possession
of police.
Unless it is shown that execeptional and special circumstan~
ces exist that substantial and grave injustice has been done and
the case in question presents features _of sufficient gravity to war~
rant a review of the decision appealed against, the Supreme Court
does not exercise its overriding powers under art. 136 ( 1) of the
Constitution and the circumstance that the
appeal
has been
admitted by special leave does not entitle the appellant to open
out the whole case and contest all the findings of fact and raise
every point which could be raised in the High Court. Even at the
final hearing only those points can be urged which are fit to be
urged at the preliminary stage when the leave to appeal is asked
for.
·The contention that confession cannot be corroborated by the
use of materials already in the possession of the police is devoid
of force. A confession made and recorded even during a trial can
be corroborated by the evidence already recorded. It may .be made
and recorded in the court of committing magistrate and materia,ls
already in the possession of the police may be used for purpose ef
corroboration.
Marth 17.
1134
1954
Hem Ra].
v.
Till Sta" qf
- A.jmer
Mahajan C. ] 1
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
Queen v. Thompson ([189}] 2 Q.B. 12) and Mata
Emperor (A.I.R. 1931 Oudh 166) referred to.
CRIMINAL
APPELLATE
JURISDICTION :
[1954]
Din v. The
Criminal
Appeals Nos. 58 and 87 of 1953.
Appeal by Special Leave granted by the Supreme
Court on the 30th June, 1953, from the Judgment and
Order dated the 25th April, 1953, of the Court of the
Judicial Commissioner at Ajmer in Criminal Appeal
No. 13 of 1953 and Criminal Reference No. 19 of 1953
arising out of the Judgment and Order dated the 18th
March, 1953, of the Court of the Sessions Judge at
Ajmer in Sessions Trial No. 1 of 1953.
Appeal by Special Leave granted by the Suprem~
Court on the 27th October, 1953, from the Judgment
and Order dated the 25th April, 1953, of the Court of
the judicial Commissioner at Ajmer in Criminal Appeals
Nos. 14 and 15 of 1953 and Criminal Reference No. 15
of 1953 arising out of the Judgment and Order dated
the 18th March, 1953, of the Court of the Sessions Judge
at Ajmer in Sessions Trial No. 1 of 1953.
Bakhshi Tek Chand (Bhagwan Singh and Rajinder
Narain, with him) for appellant in Criminal Appeal
No. 58 of 1953.
B. D. Sharma for respondent in· Criminal Appeal
No. 58 and appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 87 of
1953.
K. N. Agarwala for .respondent in Criminal Appeal
No. 87 of 1953.
1954. March 17. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
MAHAJAN C. J.-Criminal Appeals Nos. 58 and
87 of 1953 relate to the same occurrence, and
arise out of a common judgment delivered by the
Judicial Commissioner of Ajmer. Both of them are
before us by special leave granted by this court on
· different occasions.
Unless it is shown that exceptional and special
circumstances exist that substantial and grave injustice
has been done and the case in question presents
features of sufficient gravity to warrant a review of
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1135
the decision appealed against, this court does not
.exercise its overriding powers under article 136(1)
of the Constitution and the circumstance that because
the appeal has been admitted by special leave does not
entitle the appellant to open out the whole case and
contest all the findings of fact and raise every point
which could be raised in the High Court. Even at the
final hearing only those points can be urged which
are fit to be urged at the preliminary stage when the
leave to appeal is asked for. The question for consideration is whether this test is satisfied in either of
these two appeals. After hearing the learned counsel
in both the appeals we are satisfied that none of them
raise any questions which fall within the rule enunciated above.
On the 16th of July, 1952, Mangilal deceased, partner
of firm Rambhajan Mangilal 0£ Bijainagar, received by
express delivery post a letter Exhibit P-5 in a closed
.cover Exhibit P-6. This letter was actually delivered
to Mangilal's son Laduram who, on reading it, found
that it purported to have been sent by "Bhayankar
Daku Dal" demanding payment of Rs. 5,000 at 6-30
p.m. on the 17th of July at the crossing near the 27th
milestone on the Ajmer-Bijainagar road and saying
that "if you cheat or do 420 or in case you inform the
police, no other punishment except that of death . will
be meted out to you and you will be shot dead and
made to lie on the ground." Laduram took the
miginal letter with the envelope to his uncle Ramjas
at Ajmer and both of them saw the Superintendent of
Police :and gave him the letter and the envelope and
asked for immediate protection and investigation. The
Superintendent of Police, however, took no action in
this behal£. Mangilal failed to comply with the demand
to pay. On the 17th of July about 9-30 p.m. when he
was sitting at his shop and his munim Gajanand was
writing the accounts, two persons came from the neighbouring street. One of them was dressed in a khaki
suit and the other in a blue suit. The man in blue
<lemanded from Mangilal a reply to the letter, while
the man in khaki entered the shop and removed Mangilal' s gun which was hanging in a canvas case from :I
1954
fle~Raj
v.
The Stajl of
Ajmer
Mahajo;C.].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1954
H1111 Raj
v.
711' /;tale of
4jmn
Mahajan C. ].
[1954]
peg on the wall of the shop. On Mangilal's replying
that his son Laduram had taken the letter to Ajmer,
the person dressed in blue fired from a Mauser pistol
and shot Mangilal dead. The two assailants then ran
away. On the way they threw the Mauser pistol and
khaki clothes in the street at a short distance from
the shop. Mangilal died shortly afterwards. The first
information report was lodged by Nand Lal (P. W. 1)
immediately after the occurrence at 9-45 p.m. In thi&
report Nand Lal described the occurrence in the following terms:
"From the lane two men, one of whom was wearing khaki clothes having a hat on the head and the
other wearing blue clothes with a blue cap on the head
came near Mangilalji and stood there. The man with
khaki clothes said something to Mangilal and the man
with blue clothes went straight inside the shop and
picked up Man gila\' s gun from behind the door shutter
and brought it out and stood near the khaki clad man,.
and at that time shot Mangilal with a pistol he had."
The prosecution challaned four persons, viz., Hem
Raj, appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 58 of 1953,
Hukum Singh, respondent in Criminal Appeal No. 87
of 1953, Milap Singh and Abdul Hakim. It was alleged that all the four of them had acted in conspiracy
and realised money from rich persons through threatening letters and in pursuance of the conspiracy Exhibit
P-5 was sent. Hem Raj and Hukum Singh were arrested on the evening of the 26th July at Bijainagar and
were sent to jail on the 28th of July, 1952. On the
30th of July, 1952, Hem Raj made a confession in iail
before a Magistrate. On the 5th of September, 1952,.
at the first hearing of the case before the committing
Magistrate, the confession was retracted by means of
an application made through counsel and a number of
grounds were given why the confession was inadmissible and not of any value. All the accused persons
denied the charge. Milap Singh and Abdul Hakim
were acquitted by the learned Sessions Judge who however convicted Hem Raj and Hukum Singh of the
different offences with which they had been eharged.
He'in Raj and Hukum Singh appealed to the Judicial
...'
~.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1137
Commissioner at Aimer. Hukum Singh's ·appeal was
al!owed but that of Hem Raj was dismissed. As stated
already, Hem Raj's appeal before us is by special leave
and the State has also
appealed against the
acquittal of Hukum Singh and that also by special
leave.
Dr. Tek Chand for Hem Raj raised three points
before us : ( 1) That the confession was inadmissible
in evidence, the prosecution having failed to establish
affirmatively that it was free and voluntary and that
it was not preceded by any inducement to the prisoner
to make a statement held out by a person in authority.
It was said that as no direct or circumstantial evidence
of any kind was available, the police was straining
every nerve to get any one of the four persons arrested
confess, so that he may be given pardon and made an
approver. The police was particularly keen to make
somebody an approver because of their own negligent
conduct in not giving protection to the deceased when
Laduram, his son, had approached the Superintendent
of Police with the threatening letter received by him
and that the police also had not been able to discover
how the pistol had been stolen from its owner. It was
contended that Hem Raj was actually arrested on the
25th July and illegally kept in custody, that even
after remand by the Magistrate he was not immediately sent to jail but was taken to the house of the
Superintendent of Police and kept there for more than
four hours, that all these circumstances raised a strong
suspicion against the voluntary character of the confession and showed that the police was making efforts
bv threats and inducements to extort a confession from
him. It was further suggested that while Hem Raj
was in jail the Superintendent of Police paid him a
visit. There is no relevant evidence to establish
this fact.
(2) That the Magistrate who recorded the confession
did not disclose his identity that he was a Magistrate
to Hem Raj and that instead of recording the confession in his court room he recorded it in jail without
any sufficient grounds for doing so and this circumstance also vitiated the confessions.
1954
Hem Raj
N.
T1" Stat1 of
Ajm,r
MahajanC.j.
1138
1954
Hem Raj
v.
The State of
Amer
Mahajan C. J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
119541
(3) That there was no independent corroboration of
any of the material facts contained in the confession
and that whatever material has been considered as
corroboration by the courts below was already in the
possession of the police before the confession was
recorded and therefore the confession was merely a
recital of facts already in possession of the police and
was modelled on it and that the police discovered
nothing in pursuance of the confession and their
knowledge about the material facts of the case was not
enriched in any manner by the confession and therefore there was no evidence whatsoever in the case
on which the conviction of the appellant could stanc.
The learned Judicial Commissioner as well as the
learned Sessions Judge considered all these contentions
and negatived them and there were valid reasons for
doing so. On the question whether the confession was
voluntary, there are concurrent findings of the courts
below and there are no grounds for going behind these
findings. On the question whether material particulars
of the confession have been corroborated, there are
again concurrent findings. All the arguments addressed to us relate to the re-appreciation of evidence which
had been believed by the courts below and do not
warrant interference by us in the decisions of the
courts below. We have, however, also examined these
arguments independently and we have no hesitation in
endorsing the views of the courts below.
As regards the voluntary nature of the confession,
the significant fact is that the confession was made on
the 30th of July, that is, two days after Hem Raj
had been lodged in jail, and was not in police custody
or amenable to police influence. He had more than
36 hours to make up his mind whether to make a confession or not. He is not a rustic but runs a cycle shop
in Bijainagar. It is noteworthy that Hukum Singh
was similarly situated and about whom an application
had been made that he was willing to confess. When
the Magistrate approached him he said that he would
only make a statement after consulting his lawyer
and declined to make any
statement.
Further
from the 30th of July till the 5th of September no
,.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1139
steps were taken by Hem Raj to resile from his confession. There was ample time at his disposal to make
an application to the Magistrate or to the District
Magistrate that the confession had been extorted from
him by threats and inducement. On the 5th of September when an application was made by his counsel
retracting the confession it was more in the nature of
an argument than in the nature of a detailed statement of the facts and circumstances in which the confession had been made. When examined under section
342, Criminal Procedure Code, he said that he made the
confession under threats held out by the Superintendent of Police and Sri Ram Chandra, Sub-Inspector.
He further said that the Superintendent of Police told_
him "that if I made a confession of my guilt, I would
be made an approver ; the Superintendent of Police
said that he was a Vaishya and as I too was a Vaishya
he would help me. I told the Superintendent of Police
that I would do as he asked me to do. About 10-30
a.m. on the 30th of July Sub-Inspector Ram Chanclra came to jail and compelled me to make a confession." The last portion was clearly a lie as there is
no evidence whatsoever that Ram Chandra visited him
at the time the Magistrate recorded his confession.
The Magistrate who recorded the confession has
been examined, and he states that he told the prisoner
that he was a Magistrate and that he complied with all
the requirements of law in recording the confession.
The memorandum made by him shows that the following questions were put to Hem Raj: "Do you wish
to make a confession ?", to which Hem Raj replied
"Yes". "Are you making it of your own free will
and without the compulsion of anybody?"; the answer
was "Yes". The third question was "You are not
bound to make a confession. Do you understand this ?"
The answer was "Yes". The fourth question was :
"If you make a confession it may be used in evidence
against you. Do you realize this ?" The answer was
"Yes". The last question was "Shall I record your
confession?" The answer was "Yes". It was after
these queries that a confession covering about 21 pages
and full of detail~ which are precise and cannot be
1954
Hem Raj
v.
The Stalt of
Ajmt"r
¥ ahajan C. j.
1140
1954
HtmRaj
v.
·rht Slat• of
Ajmet
.Mohajan C.J,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[.1954]:
described as vague was recorded. The police could
not even dream of these details or make an effort to
tutor such a detailed confession to the prisoner and it
is absolutely unthinkable that such a tutored confession could be narrated by Hem Raj to the Magistrate
after 36 hours of any possible attempt made to tutor
him. As a matter of fact, some of the facts contained
in the confession and indicated later were not even
known to the police then. The confession contained
the usual endorsement that the confession was voluntary and all the necessary matters had been explained
to the prisoner before he made the confession. It is
significant that the confession was not retracted till
Hem Raj took legal advice arid even then it was not
stated who supplied all the details contained in the
confession to Hem Raj. The allegations made by the
prisoner have been denied by the police officers examined and we are not inclined to accept those allegations as true. The circumstances relied
upon by
Dr. Tek Chand regarding the conduct of the police
before Hem Raj was lodged in jail do not, in our
opinion, affect the voluntary character of the confession.
The contention that the Magistrate did not tell the
prisoner that he was a Magistrate is also belied by the
Magistrate's evidence. No doubt the confession was
recorded in jail th9ugh ordinarily it should have been
recorded in the court house, but that irregularity
seems to have been made because nobody seems to
have realized that that was the appropriate place to
record it but this circumstance does not affect in this
case the voluntary character of the confession. Dr. Tek
Chand drew our attention to a quotation from Taylor's
Evidence, 11th Edn., page 588, para. 872, and to the
decision in Queen v. Thompson('), in which it had been
emphasized that in order that evidence of a confession
by a prisoner may be admissible, it must be affirmatively proved that such confession was free and voluntary and that it was not preceded by any inducement
to the prisoner to make a statement held out by a
person in authority, or that it was not made until after
such inducement had ·clearly been removed.
The
(1) [1893] 2 Q. B. 12.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1141
principle laid down in that case is well settled,
but we do not think that Dr. Tek Chand· is right
in contending that that principle has not beeQ
borne in mind by the courts below. The mere bald
assertion by the prisoner that he was threatened,
tutored or that inducement was offered to him,
There
cannot be accepted as true without more.
is no material whatsover to hold that the prisoner
was threatened or beaten. As a fact it has been found
by the cours below that that assertion was untrue.
The story of tutoring, on the face of it, is incredible.
It was not possible for the police or anyone to teach
the prisoner all that is contained in the confession. As
regards inducement, again, there is no material whatsoever and the circumstances relied upon are not such
which raise a suspicion that the confession was extorted
by inducement.
Even if some suspicion of this
character could be raised in this case, it has to be held
that the confession was made after the inducement had
dearly been removed.
As regards the question whether the confession
made by Hem Raj has been corroborated in material
particulars, we are satisfied that there 1s sufficient
evidence on the record to justify the Judicial Comm1ss10ner's conclusion. P. W. 34, Gajanand, an eyewitness of the occurrence, deposed that the man in
blue had the pistol and fired the fatal shot. This is in
line with what had been stated by Nand Lal in the
First Information Report though later on he made a
different statement. The courts below accepted the
evidence of Gajanand in preference to the statement of
Nand. Lal. That being so, Gajanand's evidence fully
corroborates the confession of Hem Raj that it was he
who fired the fatal shot and that he was dressed m
blue uniform.
On the 18th of July, 1952, certain articles were
recovered from Hem Raj's hc;mse-a hat, a mask, a
bush shirt and a pistol. These recoveries are good
independent evidence in corroboration of the confession. On the 0)th July, 1952, certain other items
were admittedly recovered from Hem Raj's house and
these also corroborate the confession. Hem Raj also
1954
H'1n Raj
v.
The Stdtt of
4ftmr
Mahajan C.J,
1142
1954
Hem Raj
v.
The Stat1 of
Ajmer
Mah•j•n C. ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
delivered to the . police a black pair of socks, a slate
coloured muffler, a blue pair of shorts and a torch.
These deliveries further support the confession. Then
certain recoveries were made, as stated in the confession, from the roof of Bansilal' s shop on 27th of
July, 1952. These were a revolver and a number of
cartridges. Lastly there is the recovery of the gun
case :ind the gun. The learned Judicial Commissioner,
in these circumstances, was justified in holding that
the confession had been corroborated in respect of
clothes worn by the assailant, and in respect of the
arms and ammunition and that it was also corroborated
by the removal of the latch from the shop of Hukum
Singh.
Dr. Tek Chand contended that the recovery of
clothes and delivery of arms and ammunition by Hem
Raj to the police had been made before the 30th of
July, when the confession was made, and that facts
within the knowledge of the police before the confession was made, could not be used as evidence corroborating the confession. For this proposition he placed
reliance on a decision of the Oudh Chief Court in Mata
Din v. The Emperor('), wherein it was observed that a
true confession made by a person who takes part in a
murder invariably adds something to the knowledge
already possessed by the investigating officer and that
is the greatest test of its truth.
In our opinion, the contention raised by the learned
counsel is not well founded. In the first instance, it is
not correct to say that all the facts mentioned in the
confession were known to the police at the time when
the confession was made. The police did not know
anything about the existence of 30 bore cartridges.
They did not know as to who had written the letter
Exhibit P-5 and did not know who had gone to Beawar
to post it. The police also did not know that death
had been caused by a shot from a Mauser pistol
Exhibit P-19. Be that as it may, we see no validity in
the contention that a confession can only be corroborated by evidence discovered by the police after a
material that is
confession has been made and any
(1) A.I.R. 1931 Oudh 166.
S.C.R.
'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1143
already in their possession, cannot be put in evidence
in support of it. The decision in Mata Din's case( )
does not support the view contended for. Th<c~
decision merely concerns itself with the value of a
confession and does not relate to the nature and
character of evidence that can be led to corroborate it.
It does not lay down the proposition that a confession
cannot be corroborated by use of materials already in
possession qf the police. A confession can be made
even during a trial and the evidence already recorded
may well be used to corroborate it. It may be made
in the court of the committing Magistrate and materials already in possession of the police may well be
used for purposes of corroboration. The contention
therefore that evidence in possession of the police
before the confession was made cannot be used to
corroborate the confession, must be repelled.
The result is that the evidence in conjunction with
the confession satisfactorily
estabilshes the charge
under section 302/34, Indian Penal Code, against Hem
Raj and also satisfactorily proves the offence under
section 386, Indian Penal Code. Dr. Tek Chand very
strong! y criticized the conclusion reached by the
Judicial Commissioner that the letter Exhibit P-5 was
posted by Hem Raj. He contended that from the
mere circumstance that Hern Raj was in Beawar on the
date the ktter was posted it could not be inferred that
it was posted by him. We think that the criticism is
not valid and the inference drawn in the circumstances
of this case by the courts below could not be said to be
unreasonable.
As regards the State's appeal against Hukum Singh,
clearly the confession of Hem Raj cannot be used as
substantive evidence against him. The learned public
prosecutor contended that Hukum Singh was the
writer of the letter Exhibit P-5 and the evidence
furnished by the key Exhibit P-12 found in his trouser
pocket, coupled with the breaking of the door latch,
and the circumstance that he was seen together with
Hem Raj, was sufficient material for his conviction.
We are unable to agree. We are of the opinion that
the learned Judicial Commissioner was perfectly right
(1) A.LR. 1931 Oudh 166.
B-98 S.C. India/59
195f
Hem Raj
v.
The State of
Ajmer.
Mahajan C. J.
1144
1954
Hem Raj
v.
The State of
Ajmer.
Mahajan C. J.
[1954]
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
in holding that this evidence by itself was insufficient
to uphold his conviction and that Hukum Singh was
entitled to the benefit of the doubt in respect of both
the charges found against him. There is hardly any
material on the record to justify our interference
with an order of acquittal in an appeal by special
leave. In the result both these appeals fail and are
dismissed.
Appeals dismissed.
1954
M. S. SHERIFF
March 18.
f/.
THE STATE OF MADRAS AND OTHERS.
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C. J., MuKHERJEA,
S. R. DAs, VIVIAN BosE and GHuLAM HASAN JJ.]
CTiminal Procedure Code (Act V of 1898), s. 476B-Whether
appeal competent to the Suprenie Court from aT?_ order of Division
Bench of High Court directing the filing of a complaint for
perjury.
Held that an appe~l is competent to the Supreme Court under
s. 476B of the Code of Criminal Procedure from an order of
a Division Bench of a High Court directing the filing of a complaint for perjury.
Also held. that the simultaneous prosecution of civil and
criminal proceedings regarding the same matter is likely to
embarrass the accused and so ord£narily, and in the absence of
special circumstances, the criminal proceedings should be given
precedence and the civil proceedings should be stayed pending
the termination of the criminal.
CRIMINAL
of 1951.
APPELLATE
JURISDICTION : Case
No. 281
Appeal under article 132 of the Constitution of
India from the Judgment and Order dated the 1st
August, 1951, of the High Court of Judicature at
Madras in Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions Nos. 1261
and 1263 of 1951.
K. Rajah Iyer (R. Ganapathy Iyer and M. S. K.
Aiyangar, with him) for the appellant/petitioners.
•
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org