THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN versus NATH MAL AND MITHA MAL
Supreme Court of India | Decided 12 March 1954 | [1954] 1 S.C.R. 982 | 1954 INSC 22
Key facts
- Decided
- 12 March 1954
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN*, BIJAN KUMAR MUKHERJEA, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, VIVIAN BOSE, GHULAM HASAN
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 136/1952
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1954] 1 S.C.R. 982
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 22
Text of the judgment
982
1954
Suleman Issa
v.
The Stak of
Bombay.
Ghulam Hasan J,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954}
inappropriate in a case where the accused is prosecuted
for an offence punishable with a maximum sentence of
3 months and a fine of Rs. 100. It was certainly
open to the court to order the property to be delivered
to the person claiming to be entitled to its possession.
Here the gold was found from the possession of the
appellant, and the court was not called upon to consider any rival claims about its possession. Admittedly
there was no evidence to prove that it was stolen, or
that it was fraudulently obtained
and all that was
found was that there was reason to believe that it was
stolen or fraudulently obtained and that the appellant
failed to account for its possession to the satisfaction
of the court. The High Court thought that the gold
was smuggled from Africa into India but assuming this
to be so its confiscation under section 517 upon the
existence of a mere belief required to sustain a conviction under section 61E was palpably harsh and
unreasonable.
We hold, therefore, that the order of
confiscation of gold cannot be supported.
We according! y set aside the order of confiscation
and direct that the gold seized from the appellant's
possession shall be restored to him.
Appeal allowed.
Agent for the respondent : R. H. Dhebar.
THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN
1954
v.
March 12
NATH MAL AND MITHA MAL.
J., MUKHERJEA, S. R. DAs,
VIVIAN BosE and GHuLAM HASAN JJ.]
lMam CHAND MAHAJAN. C.
Constitution of India, arts. 19(1)(1) and 31(2)-Raiasthan
Foodgrains Control Order, 1949, cl. 25-Whether ultra vires th<
Constitution.
Held, that the first portion of cl. 25 of the Rajasthan
Foodgrains Control Order, 1949, relating to the freezing of stocks
of foodgrains is not void under art. 19(l)(f) of the Constitution
because such freezing of stocks of foodgrains is reasonably related
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
983
to the object which the Act was intended to achieve, nan1ely _to
secure the equitable distribution and availability at fair prices and
to regulate transport, distribution, disposal and acquisition of an
.essential commodity such as foodgrains.
Held, that the last portion of cl. 25 to the effect that "such
stocks shall also be liable to be requisitioned or dispos~d of under
orders of the said authority at the rate fixed for purposes of
GoYernment procurement", is void both under art. 19(1)(f) and
art. 31(2) of the Constitution:-
(i) because the clause places an unreasonable restriction
upon the carrying on of trade or business and is thus an infringement of the respondents' right under art. 19(1)(f) of the Constitution ;
(ii) because the clause by vesting the power in the authority
to acquire the stocks at any price fails to fix the an1ount of co1npensation or specify the principles on which it is to be determined
and leaves it entirely to the discretion of the executive authority
to fix any compensation it likes and is thus hit by art. 31(2) of the
Constitution.
CIVIL APPELLATE TuRISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.
136 of 1952.
Appeal under articles 132 ( 1) and 133 (I) ( c) of the
Constitution of India from the Judgment and Order
dated the 19th October, 1951, of the High Court of
Judicature for Rajasthan at fodhpur in D. B. Miscellaneous Writ Petition No. 3/1951.
K. S. Haje/a, Advocate-General of Rajasthan, for the
appellant.
K. N. Aggart11al an<l P. C. Agarwal for the respondents.
M. C. Setalvad, Attornev-General for
India (Porus
A. Mehta, with him) for the intervener (the Union of
India).
1954. March 12.
delivered by
The Judgment of
the Court was
GHuLAM HASAN J.-The question involved in this
appeal relates to the constitutional validity of clause 25
of the Rajasthan Foodgrains Control Order, 1949,
hereinafter called the Control Order. and arises in the
following circumstances:The respondents, who are grain merchants at · Raniwara- in Jodhpur Division, Rajasthan State, hdd
1954
The State of
Rajasthan
v.
Nath Mal and
Mitha Mal.
984
1954
Th< Sta11 of
RajasthtJ.n
v.
Nath Mal and Muha Mal.
Ghulam Hasan J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
licences for dealing in foodgrains. They held considerable stocks of bajra in the ordinary course of business
but on October 7, 1950, their stocks were frozen by the
Deputy Commissioner, Civil Supplies, Jodhpur, through
the Sub-Divisional Officer. It is not disputed that the
market price then prevailing was about Rs. 18 per
maund. The State, however, requisitioned the stocks
at the rate of Rs. 9 per maund and sold them at
Rs. 13-5-4 per maund. The respondents claimed that
they had purchased the bajra at the prevailing market
rate of Rs. 17 to Rs. 18 per maund. They filed a petition on January 23, 1951, for the issue of a writ under
article 226 of the Constitution before the High Court
of Rajasthan, contending that clause 25 of the Control
Order was void under articles 14, 19(1) (g) and 31(2)
of
the Constitution. The High
Court held that
clause 25 was void inasmuch as it is a restriction upon
the fundamental right of the respondents to carry on
business under article 19 ( 1) (g) of the Constitution, that
the restriction is not reasonable and is not saved by
clause (6) of article 19. The High Court further held
that clause 25 was also hit by article 31 (2) as fair
compensation had not been fixed by the law for the
acquisition of the foodgrains. As the grains had
already been disposed of by the Government, the High
Court holding that Rs. 17 a maund was fair compensation directed .that the State of Rajasthan shall pay
compensation at that rate. The State has preferred
the present appeal on a certificate granted hy the High
Court.
The impugned clause 25 is as follows:"25.
Notwithstanding anything
contained
in
this Order, the Commissioner, the Director, the Deputy
Commissioner, the Nazim, the Assistant Commissioner,
the Suh-Divisional Officer, the Senior Officer of a jurisdictional Thikana, the enforcement officer or such
other officer as may be authorised by the Commissioner in this behalf, may freeze any stocks of foodgrai ns held by any person, whether in his own behalf
or not, and such person shall not dispose of any foodgrains out of the stock so freezed except with the
permission of the said authority. Such stocks shall
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
985
also be liable to be requisitioned or disposed of under
orders of the said authority at the rate fixed for purposes of Government procurement."
It is not disputed that bajra is an essential commodity within the meaning of the Essential Supplies
Act (No. XXIV of 1946). The question that arises
for consideration is how far and in what respects
clause 25 can be said to be void as violating Part III
of the Constitution. The clause authorises the Comm1ss10ner and yarious other authorities mentioned
therein and such other officers as may be authorised by
the Commissioner to freeze any stock of foodgrains
held by a person. It is true that the authority of the
Commissioner to delegate his powers to any other
officer at his discretion is expressed in somewhat wide
terms but we need not decide that that per se would
be sufficient to invalidate the clause. Admittedly that
power has not been exercised in the present case. Nor
do we think that the power to freeze the stocks of
foodgrains is arbitrary or based on no reasonable basis.
It is not disputed that the clause does not state in
express terms the circumstances in or the grounds on
which the stocks may be freezed but it should be read
along with section 3 of the Essential Supplies Act
which lays down the policy for controlling the production, supply and distribution of essential commodities.
Section 3 in so far as, it is material says:"The Central Government, so far as it appears to
it to he necessary or expedient for maintaining or
increasing supplies of any essential commodity, or for
securing their equitable distribution and availability
at fair prices, may by order provide for regulating or
prohibiting the production, supply and distribution
thereof. . , ............. "
Sub-section (2) lays down:"Without prejudice to the generality of the
powers conferred by sub-section ( l), an order made
thereunder may provide ......... .
(a) ............... .
(b) ............... .
(c) ............... .
1954
The State of
Rajt1sthan'
v.
}lath Mal and
Mitha Mal.
Ghufom Hasan J.
986
1954
-.-
The State of
· Rajasthan
v.
Nath~Afal ani
Mitha Afal. ~
Ghulam~Hasan ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19541
( d) for regulating by licences. permits or otherwise
the storage, transport, distribution, disposal, acqms1tion, use or consumption of any essential commocfoy;
( e) for prohibiting the withholding from sale of
any essential commodity ordinarily kept for sa 1e;
"
We are clear, therefore, that the freezing of stocks
of foodgrains is reasonably related to the object which
the Act was intended to achieve, namely, to secure rhe
equitable distribution
and availability at fair prices
and to regulate transport, ,:istribution, disposal and
acquisition of an essential commodity such as foodgraim. We do not agree wit]' the High Court 'hat
the fiN portion of clause 25 is void under article 19
(1) (g).
The last portion of clause 25 to the effect that
"such stocks shall also be liable to be requisitioned or
disposed of under orders of the said authority at tile
rate fixed for purposes . of Government procure1,..,ent'',
however stands on a different footing. The clause, es it
is worded, leaves it entirely to the Government ro
requisition the stocks at any rate fixed by it and to ,\i,.
pose of such stocks at any rate in its discretion· This
obviously vests an unrestrained authority to requtsttion the stocks of foodgrains at an arbitrary price. In
contrast with this provision we may refer to clau,es
23 and
24 of the Control
Order. They are as
follows:"2.). The Commissioner or the Director, and the
Deputy Commissioner or the Senior Officer of a jurisdictional Thikana with the approval of the Director,
may fix the ceiling prices at which foodgrains in any
area to which this-0rder applies shall be sold, and may
from time to time vary such prices."
"24. The Commissioner, the Director, the Deputy
Commissioner, the Nazim, the Assistant Commissioner,
the Sub-Divisional Officer, or the Senior Officer of the
jurisdictional Thikana as the case may be, may direct
any person or persons in possession, whether on his
own behalf or not of any foodgrains to sell such foodgrains or part thereof to any person or persons at any
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
987
specified place and at such price as may be fixed under
clause 23."
It appears from these clauses that while the authorities may fix the ceiling price at· which foodgrains
should be sold in the market by the dealers and may
direct any person in possession of foodgrains to sell
them to any other person at the price fixed under
clause 23, there is no such limitation upon the power
of the Government to acquire the stocks. In other
words, it will be open to the Government to requisition the stocks at a price lower than the ceiling price
thus causing loss to the persons whose stocks are freezed while at the same time the Government is free to
sell the same stocks at a higher price and make a profit.
It is obvious that the dealer whose stocks are thus
freezed will stand to lose considerably and will be
unable to carry on his trade or business at the prevailing market price. No dealer will be prepared to buy
foodgrains at the market price when he knows that he
is exposed to the risk of his stocks being freezed any
moment and the same being requisitioned at the procurement rate. The present is a typical case which
illustrates how the business of a grain dealer can be
paralvsed, for it is admitted that while the Government
procurement rate was Rs. 9 a maund, the market rate
was Rs. 17 or Rs. 18 per maund, with the result that
the stock holder suffered nearly
cent. per cent. loss,
while the Government made a profit of Rs. 4-5-4 per
maund on the stock requisitioned. We hold, therefore. that the last portion of clause 25 places an
unreasonable restriction upon the carrying on of trade
or business and is thus an infringement of the respondent's right under article 19(1) (g) of the Constitution
and is, therefore, to that extent void. The same
result follows if the impugned clause is examined in
the light of article 31 (2). The clause by vesting the
power in the authority to acquire the stocks at any
price fails to fix the amount of the compensation or
specify the principles on which the compensation is to
be
determined. The clause leaves it
entirely
to the discretion of the executive authority to
fix any compensation it likes. The High Court
1954
The State of
Rajastlum
v.
Nath Mal and
Mitha Mal.
Ghu!am Hasan).
988
1954
The State of
Rajasthan
v.
Nath Mal and
Mitha Mal.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
rightly
held
that the clause offended against
article 31(2).
For the foregoing reasons we hold that the last
portion of clause 25 is void and dismiss the appeal
with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Agent for the appellant and for the intervener:
R. H. D!tebar.
1954
SRIMA TI ORAMBA SUND ARI DASI
March 12.
ti.
SRI SRI ISWAR GOPAL JIEU.
[MuKHERJEA, VrvIAN BosE and
VENKATARAMA AYYAR JJ.)
Bengal Money-Lenders Act, 1940 (Bengal Act X of 1940), s. 36
-Scope of-Court whether competent to make an enquiry that
decree-holder on record is benamidar for another person.
Held, that in a proceeding under s. 36 of the Bengal
Money-Lenders Act, 1940, it is not competent to the court to go
behind the decree and embark on an enquiry as to whether the
decree-holders on record were in fact benamidars for another
person.
Scope oi s. 36 of the Act discussed.
Renual v. Manmatha (72 I.A. 156) and Bank of Commel'C6
Ltd. v. Amulya Krishna Basu Roy Chowdhury ( [ 1944 ]F.C.R. 126)
referred to.
C1v1L APPELLATE
JuR1smcTION : Civil Appeals
Nos. 130 and 131 of 1951.
Appeals from the Judgment and Decrees, dated the
12th August, 1948, of the High Court of Judicature at
Calcutta in Appeals from Original Decrees Nos. 214 of
1942 and 231 of 1943 arising from the Decrees, dated
the 16th June, 1942, of the Court of the Subordinate
Judge, Burdwan, in Money Suit No. 261 of 1932/
Miscellaneous Case No. 132 of 1941 and Money Suit
No. 262 of 1932/Miscellaneous Case No. 131 of 1941.
N. C. Chatterjee (A. K. Dutt and Sukumar Ghose,
with him) for the appellant.
Manmo!tan Mukherjee and P. K. Chatterjee for respondent No. I.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org