RAO SHIV BAHADUR SINGH AND ANOTHER versus THE STATE OF VINDHYA PRADESH
Supreme Court of India | Decided 5 March 1954 | [1954] 1 S.C.R. 1098 | 1954 INSC 16
Key facts
- Decided
- 5 March 1954
- Bench
- NATWARLAL HARILAL BHAGWATI*, B. JAGANNADHADAS, T.L. VENKATARAMA AIYYAR
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 7/1951
- Citation
- [1954] 1 S.C.R. 1098
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 16
Text of the judgment
1098
1954
March5.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
RAO SHIV BAHADUR SINGH AND ANOTHER
v.
THE STATE OF VINDHYA PRADESH.
[BHAGWATI, JAGANNADHADAS
AYYAR
and VENKATARAMA
JJ.]
Code of Criminal Proced11re (Act V of 1898), s. 164-Magistrate
not recording statement of accused as required by the section-Whether competent to give oral evidence of such statement--Disapproval
of the action of Police in entrapping the accused and providing the
bribe-giver the instruments of offence.
After the investigation into an offence has been started on the
registration of the First
Information Report by the Police, no
statement n1ade ~y the accused to the Magistrate can be proved unless
the statement has been recorded in accordance with the provisions
of s. 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and therefore, it
the non-confessional state1nent has not been recorded by the.
Magistrate in the manner indicated in s. 164,
the Magistrate would not be competent to give oral evidence of such statement having been made by the accused.
Nazir Ahmad v. King Emperor (A.LR. 1936 P. C. 253), Legal
Remembrancer v. Lalit Mohan Singh Roy (I.L.R. 49 Cal. 167),
Abdul Rahim and Others v. Emperor (26 Cr. L. J. 1279) and Karu
Mansukh Gond v. Emperor (A.LR. 1937 Nag. 254) referred to.
The conduct of the Police and the Additional District Magistrate in actively instigating the accused to commit the
offence
of which he was charged by furnishing him with the necessary
materials (without which he could not have committed the offence),
for the purpose of trapping him, was strongly disapproved.
It is the duty of the police to prevent the crimes being
committed. It is no part of their duty to provide the instruments
of the offence.
The observations of Mr. Justice P. B. Mukherji in the case
of M. C. Mitra v. The State (A.LR. 1951 Cal. 524 at p. 528) condemning the practice of sending Magistrates as witnesses of Police
trap endorsed because such practice makes a Magistrate a party
or a limb of the Police during police investigation and undermines
seriously the independence of the Magistrates and perverts their
judicial outlook.
CRIMINAL
APPELLATE
Appeal No. 7 of 1951.
JURISDICTION :
Criminal
Appeal under article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution
of India from the Judgment and Order dated the 10th
March, 1951, of the Judicial Commissioner, Vmdhya
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1099
Pradesh, Rewa in Criminal Appeal No. 81 of 1950
arising out of the Judgment and Order dated the 26th
July, 1950, of the Court of the Special Judge, Rewa, in
Criminal Case No. 1 of 1949.
Jai Gopal Sethi (K. B. Asthana, with him) for
appellant No. 1.
S. C. Isaacs (Murtza Faz! Ali, with him) for
appellant No. 2.
Porus A. Mehta for the respondent.
1954. March 5. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
BHAGWATI J.-The appellant No. I was the Minister
of Industries and the appellant No. 2 was the Secretary to the Government of the Commerce and Industries Department of the State of Vindhya Pradesh.
The appellant No. 1 was charged with having committed offences under sections 120-B, 161, 465 and 466
of the Indian Penal Code and the appellant No. 2
under sections 120-B and 161 of the Indian Penal Code
as adopted by the Vindhya Pradesh Ordinance No. 48
of 1949. They were tried in the Court of the Special
Judge at Rewa under the Vindhya Pradesh Criminal
Law Amendment (Special Courts) Ordinance No. LVI
of 1949 and the Special Judge acquitted both of them.
The State of Vindhya Pradesh took an appeal to the
Court of the
Judicial Commissioner, Rewa.
The
Judicial Commissioner reversed the order of acquittal
passed by the Special Judge and convicted both the
appellants of the several offences with which they
were charged. The Judicial Commissioner awarded to
the appellant No. 1 a sentence of 3 years rigorous
imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 2,000 in default rigorous imprisonment of 9 months under section 120-B
of the Indian Penal Code and a sentence of three
years' rigorous imprisonment under section 161 of the
Indian Penal Code, both the sentences to run concurrently. He imposed no sentence upon the appellant
No. 1 under sections 465 and 466 of · the Indian Penal
Code. He awarded to the appellant No. 2 a sentence
of rigorous imprisonment for one year and a fine of
Rs. 1,000 and in default ngorous imprisonment for
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Another
v.
The Slate of
Vindhya Pradesh.
Bhagwati].
llOO
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadut
Singh af'ld
Anothlr
Vo
The State of
Vindhya Pradesh.
Bhagwati],
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954}
nine months under section 120-B of the Indian Penal
Code. He did not award any separate sentence to
appellant No. 2 under section 161 of the Indian Penal
Code. On an application made to the Judicial Commissioner, Rew a, for leave to appeal to the Supreme
Court the Judicial Commissioner granted the appellants leave to appeal under article 134( l) ( c) of the
Constitution in regard to the four points of law raised
in the case before him.
The constitutional points involved in the appeal
came up for hearing before the Constitution Bench of
this court and were dealt with by the Judgment of
this court delivered on the 22nd May, 1953. The Constitution Bench held that the appeal to the Judicial
Commissioner from the acquittal by the Special Judge
was competent and that there was no infringement of
the fundamental rights of the appellants under articles
14 and 20 of the Constitution (Vide [1953] S.C.R. ll88).
The appeal was accordingly directed to be posted for
consideration whether it was to be heard on the merits.
An application was thereafter made by the appellants
to this court for leave to urge additional grounds and
this court on the 20th October, 1953, made an order
that the appeal should be heard on merits. The appeal
has accordingly come up for hearing and final disposal
before us.
The case for the prosecution was as follows. By an
agreement executed on the 1st August, 1936, between
the Panna Durbar of the one part and the Panna
Diamond Mining Syndicate represented by Sir Chinubhai Madholal and Hiralal Motilal Shah of the other
part, the Panna Durbar granted to the syndicate a
lease to carry on dian10nd mining operations for a
period of 15 years. The period of the lease was to
expire on the 30th October, 1951, but there was an
option reserved to the lessee to have a renewal of the
lease for a further period of 15 years from the date
of such expiration. There were disputes between the
syndicate on the one hand and the Panna Durbar on
the other and by his order dated the 31st October,
1946, the Political Minister of Panna stopped the
mining operations of the syndicate. The State of
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1101
Panna became integrated in the Unit of Vindhya
Pradesh in July, 1948, and the administration of
Panna came under the control and superintendence of
the Government of Vindhya Pradesh with its seat at
Rewa under His Highness the Maharaja of Rewa as
Rajpramukh and the appellant No. 1 became the
Minister in charge of the Industries Department in the
Cabinet which was formed by the Rajpramukh. The
appellant No. 2 held the post of Secretary, Commerce
and Industries Department, and was working under the
appellant No. I. On the 1st September, 1948, the
syndicate appointed one Pannalal as Field Manager to
get the said order of the Panna Durbar stopping the
working of the mines rescinded. Pannalal made
several applications for procuring the cancellation of
the said order and on the 13th January, 1949, and the
26th January, 1949, Pannalal made two applications
and handed them over personally to the appellant
No. 1 requesting for the resumption of the mining
operations and was asked to come in February for the
purpose. The appellant No. 1 consulted the legal
advisers of the
State and a questio11naire
was framed
which was to be addressed to the syndicate for its
answers. When Pannalal went to Rewa the questionnaire was handed over to him on the 9th February,
1949, for being sent to Sir Chinubhai. Sir Chinubhai
sent the replies to the said questionnare along with a
covering letter dated the 18th February, 1949, wherein he expressed a desire to meet the appellant No. I
for personal discussion in regard to the settlement of
the matter of the resumption of the mining operations
etc. In reply to the telegrams sent by Sir Chinubhai
on the 19th February, 1949, the Personal Assistant to
appellant No. 1 intimated to Sir Chinubhai that he
could go to Rewa and see the appellant No. 1 on the 7th
March, 1949. As Sir Chinubhai was ill he deputed hls
Personal Assistant, Nagindas Mehta to go to Rewa
and see the appellant No. 1 on his behalf. Nagindas
arrived at Rewa on the evening of the 6th March.
1949. The appellant No. 1 had gone out of Rewa and
Nagindas had to wait. He saw the appellant No. I
on the morning of the 8th March, 1949, but was asked
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Another
v.
The Stale qf
Vindhya Prad11Jh.
Bhagwati].
1102
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Anothtr
v.
The State of
f indhya Pradesh.
BhagwatiJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19541
to see the appellant No. 2. The appellant No. 2 saw
Nagindas at the Guest House ~here he had put up ~nd
informed Nagindas that a third party was offenng
Rs. 50,000 for the
mmmg
rights.
Nagindas
told the appellant No. 2 that the syndicate was
a limited concern and could not afford to pav
so much money
but
if
the
amount
was
reduced they would make an effort to pay the sum.
The appellant No. 2 then told Nagindas that he would
talk over the matter with the appellant No. 1 and let
him know. The same day in the afternoon the appellant No. 2 saw Nagindas at the Guest House and informed him that as the syndicate was working for the
last so many years the appellant No. 1 was prepared
to reduce the amount to about Rs. 25,000. Nagindas
told the appellant No. 2 that he would talk over the
matter with Sir Chinubhai in Bombay and would let
him know about it. Nagindas then left for Bombav
but he reached Bombay on the 29th March, 1949.
having been detained on the way for some other business of his. He saw Sir Chinubhai in Bombay and
reported to him what had happened at Rewa and gave
him to understand that resumption orders would not
be passed unless a bribe of Rs. 25,000 was paid. Sir
Chinubhai did not approve of the idea of giving a bribe
and suggested that Nagindas should lay a trap for
catching the appellant No. 1. Nagindas sent a telegram
on the 29th March, 1949, agreeing to go to Rewa in
the week thereafter for completion. On receipt of that
telegram the appellant No. 2 in the absence of appellant No. 1 who was on tour sent a telegram on the 1st
April, 1949, to Sir Chinubhai pressing him to come the
same week as his presence was essential to complete
the matter which had been already delayed. On the
4th April, 1949, Pannalal was informed by the appellant No. 2 that the appellant · No. 1 was leaving for
Delhi that day and that he should go to Bombay and
send Sir Chinubhai to Delhi to meet the appellant
No. 1 in the Constitution House where he would be
staying. He also gave a letter to Pannalal to the same
effect. Appellant No. 1 left for Delhi on the 4th April,
1949, with the files of the Panna Diamond Mining
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1103
Syndicate and reached Delhi on the 5th April, 1949. On
the 6th April, 1949, the appellant No. 1 sent a telegram
through his Personal Assistant Mukherji to Sir Chinubhai at Bombay asking him to meet the appellant No. 1
-0n the 7th, 8th or 9th April, 1949, at 31 Constitution
House for final talks regarding the Panna Diamond
Mining Syndicate. On receipt of the said telegram Sir
Chinubhai sent a telegram in reply stating that his
Personal Assistant, Nagindas and Pannalal were reaching Delhi on the 9th April, 1949. Nagindas reached
Delhi on the 8th April, 1949, and put up at the Maidens
Hotel and Pannalal reached Delhi on the 10th April,
1949, and put up at the Regal Hotel. On the 9th April,
1949, Nagindas informed the appellant No. 1 on the
telephone about his arrival at Delhi and an appointment was fixed for 10-30 a.m. on the 10th April, 1949.
Nagindas contacted Shri Bambawala, the InspectorGeneral of Police of the Special Police Establishment
-0n the morning of the 10th April, 1949, before coming
to meet the appellant No. 1 and told him how the
appellant No. 1 was coercing him to pay a bribe. Shri
Bambawala referred Nagindas to Pandit Dhanraj,
Superintendent, Special Police Establishment, and
Nagindas told him the whole story of his harassment
by the appellant No. 1 and it was then decided to lay
a trap for appellant No. 1. Nagindas informed Pandit
Dhanraj that he would meet the appellant No. 1 at
about 11 a.m. and then report their talk to him in the
afternoon. Nagindas then saw the appellant No. 1
at the Constitution House at the appointed time and
at this meeting the appellant No. 1 demanded from
Nagindas a sum of Rs. 25,000 as a bribe for allowing the
resumption of the mining operations and made it quite
dear that he would not accept anything less than
Rs. 25,000. As Nagindas had not received the moneys
from Bombay, the following day, i.e., the 11th April,
1949, at 3 p.m. was fixed for the next meeting. Nagin,das thereafter informed Pandit Dhanraj as to what had
taken place at the aforesaid meeting between him and
the appellant No. 1. Nagindas went to the Constitution House and saw the appellant No. 1 at about
3 p.m. on the 11th April, 1949. Pannalal was already
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadu1
Singh and
Anotf.er
V•
The State ef
V indhya Pradesh.
BhagwatiJ.
1104
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh anrl
Another
v.
T lu State oj'
Vindhya Pradesh.
BhagwatiJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954J
there. Nagindas and the appellant No. 1 went into
the bedroom where Nagindas requested the appellant
No. I to extend the period of the lease for 10 years so
that the syndicate might be compensated for the loss
sustained by the stoppage of the mining operations ..
The appellant No. I thereupon asked Nagindas to submit a written application in Hindi and as Nagindas
did not know it he called Pannalal into the bedroom
and asked him to write out an application to that effect.
The appellant No. I after making sure from Pannalal
that Pannalal was present at R_ewa on the 1st April,
1949, asked Pannalal to put the date on the said application as the 1st April, 1949. The appellant No. I
made an endorsement at the foot of the said application and dated it as of the 1st April, 1949. It waSc
arranged that Nagindas should see the appellant No. I
at 9 p.m. that day, that Nagindas should pav
Rs. 25,000 to the appellant No. I at that time and the
appellant No. 1 would deliver the resumption order
to Nagindas on payment of the said sum of Rs. 25,000.
Nagindas then left the Constitution House and reported to Pandit Dhanraj what had transpired between
him and appellant No. I. He further told Pandit
Dhanraj that he had not received any moneys upto
that time. Pannalal was asked to proceed to the
Constitution House in advance and inform the appellant No. 1 that Nagindas would be coming along at
9 p.m. that night. Nagindas and Pandit Dhanraj then
proceeded to the house of Shri Shanti Lal Ahuja,
Additional District Magistrate. Pandit Dhanraj made
arrangements for a raiding party. Nagindas's statement was recorded on oath and a search of his person
was made and he was then given three bundles containing 250 Government currency notes of Rs. 100 and a
memorandum of the same was also prepared. After
these formalities were gone through Pandit Dhanraj,
Nagindas and the Additional District Magistrate along
with the police party left for the Constitution House.
It was arranged that Pannalal should be sent out by
Nagindas after the completion of the transaction, on
some pretext or other to the taxi waiting outside and
that this would serve as a signal for the raiding party
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1105
which would rush into the room No. 31 Constitution
House which was occupied by the appellant No. 1.
Nagindas then went inside the suit of rooms occupied
by the appellant No. 1 and the appellant No. 1
took him to his bedroom and closed the door which
connected the bedroom with the sitting room where
Pannalal was already waiting. After this the appellant No. 1 handed over the resumption order to
Nagindas and on reading the same Nagindas found
that the extension given was only for 4 years and he
asked the appellant No. 1 why this was so when the
appellant No. 1 had promised before to give an extension for 10 years.
On this the appellant No. 1 told
Nagindas that he should put up another application
after a few months and then the appellant No. 1 would
extend the period. Appellant No. 1 then signed the
resumption order and put down the date thereunder
as the 2nd April, 1949. As .soon as the signed order
was handed over to him Nagindas handed over to
the appellant No. 1 the Government currency notes of
the value of Rs. 25,000 which had been given to him
District Magistrate.
previously by the Additional
Nagindas then asked for an extra copy of the said
order and the same was accordingly given to him after
being dated and initialled by the appellant No. 1. The
appellant No. 1 took the Government currency notes
and put them in the upper drawer of the dressing
table in the bedroom. After the transaction was thus
completed Nagindas shouted to Pannalal to go to the
taxi and bring his cigarette case. Pannalal went out
to the taxi and on receipt of this signal the Additional District Magistrate and Pandit Dhanraj rushed
into the sitting room along with the other members of
the raiding party. The appellant No. 1 met the raiding party at the communicating door between the two
rooms. After the Additional District Magistrate and
Pandit Dhanraj had disclosed their identity appellant
No. 1 was asked by Pandit Dhanraj whether he had
received any money as a bribe to which the appellant No. 1 rep,lie<l in the negative. Pandit Dhanrai
then told appellant No. 1 that he should produce the
money which he had received, otherwise he would be
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Anothtr
v.
The State of
Vindhya Pradesh~
BhagwatiJ..
1106
1954
.R.ao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Another
v ..
The S1ate af
V indhya Pradesh.
BhagwatiJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
forced to search the room. On this appellant No. 1
went to the said dressing table, opened the top drawer
and brought out the three bundles of Government
currency notes given to him by Nagindas and handed
them over to Pandit Dhanraj. On inquiry by the
Additional District Magistrate as to how he had come
into possession of the said notes, the appellant No. 1
stated that he had brought Rs. 40,000 from his home
out of which Rs. 15,000 had been spent by him in the
purchase of a motor car and the remaining sum was
with him which was required by him to purchase some
ornaments in connection with the marriage of his
daughter. In the meanwhile two respectable witnesses,
Shri Gadkari, who was a member of the Central Electricity Authority, Ministry of Works, Mines and Power,
Government of India, and Shri Perulakar, who was
the Minister for Agriculture and Labour, Madhya
Bharat, were brought to the bedroom of the appellant
No. 1 by the police. The appellant No. 1 repeated the
said statement and gave the same explanation before
these two witnesses which he had given and made
before the Additional District Magistrate and Pandit
Dhanraj a little while before. Nagindas was then
searched in the presence of these two witnesses and
the two copies of the order which had been given to
him by appellant No. 1 were recovered from his person.
Two other copies of the said order and the application
and the file of the Panna Diamond Mining Syndicate
were recovered from the search of the upper drawer
of the dressing table in the bedroom of appellant No. 1.
Appellant No. 1 also produced a receipt in support of
his story of the purchase of the car. The relevant
memos of the search were prepared and also a list of
the numbers of the Government currency notes of
Rs. 25,000 which had been produced by the appellant
No. 1. This list was compared and checked by the said
witnesses Gadkari and Perulakar with the numbers of
notes and also with those appearing in the list which
was in the possession of the Additional District Magistrate and which was shown to the said witnesses. They
found that the numbers in the said two lists tallied in all
respects. After the completion of the list the Additional
S.C.R.
1107
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
District Magistrate
confronted
appellant
No. 1
with the documents which were produced before him
by Naginuas antl also the list of notes and asked
appellant No. 1 if he had any explanation to offer.
The appellant No. 1 was confused and could give no
explanation. On further enquiry whether the appellant No. 1 had any other money with him, he opened
an iron confiuential box a key of which was in his
possession and brought out a sum of Rs. 132 which
was not taken charge of as the same had no concern
with the case. Thereafter appellant No. 1 was put under
arrest and was subsequently released on bail.
*
*
*
*
After these documents were forged the next important event was the passing of the sum of Rs. 25,000 as
and by way of bribe or illegal gratification by Nagindas
to the appellant No. 1. Here also it would have been
difficult for the prosecution to establish the guilt of the
appellant No. 1 if the matter had rested merely on
the evidence of Naginuas or that of the police witnesses supported as they were by Shanti Lal Ahuja, the
Additional District Magistrate. Nagindas's evidence
suffering from the infirmity pointed out before could
not be enough to carry conviction with the court. He
was out to trap the appellant No. 1 and had been
clever enough also to have inveigled the police authorities to procure the wherewithal of the bribe for him.
It is patent that but for the procurement of these
Rs. 25,000 by the police authorities and their banding
over the sum to Nagindas, Nagindas would not have had
the requisite amount with him and the offence under
section 161 would never have been committ<;d. The
police authorities also exhibited an excessive zeal in
the matter of bringing the appellant No. 1 to book
and their enthusiasm in the matter of trapping the
appellant No. 1 was on a par with that of Nagindas
and both the parties were thus equally to blame in the
matter of entrapping the appellant No. 1. The evidence of these witnesses therefore was not such as to
inspire confidence in the mind of the court. Shanti
Lal Ahuja, the Additional District Magistrate, also
lent himself to the police authorities and became
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Another
v.
The State of
Vindh)'a Pradesh~
Bhagwati].
1108
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Another
v.
The State of
Vindhya Pradesh.
Bhagwati].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
almost a limb of the police. His position as the Additional District Magistrate was submerged and he reduced himself to the position of an ordinary witness taking part in the affair as a member of the raiding party
and his evidence could be no better or no worse than
that of the police witnesses themselves. If therefore
the matter had rested merely upon their evidence it
would have been difficult to carry the guilt home to
the appellant No. 1. The evidence as to the recovery
of this sum of Rs. 25,000 from the top drawer of the
dressing table in the bedroom of the appellant No. 1
and also in regard to the handing over of that sum by
the appellant No. 1 to Shanti Lal Ahuja, the Additional District Magistrate, was equally tainted and if
that evidence stood by itself no court would have been
safe in acting upon the same. The statement which
was made by the appellant No. 1 to Shanti Lal Ahuja,
the Additional District Magistrate, was inadmissible in
evidence. Section 162 of the Criminal Procedure Code
rendered the statement made by the appellant No. 1
to the police officers inadmissible. The investigation into
the offence had already started immediately on the
First Information Report being registered by the police
authorities and Pandit Dhanraj himself admitted in his
evidence that the investigation into the offence had
thus started before the raid actually took place. The
statement made by the appellant No. 1 to Shanti Lal
Ahuja, the Additional District Magistrate was therefore
made after the investigation had started and during the
investigation of the offence and was therefore hit by
section 164 of the Criminal Procedure Code. It was
urged on behalf of the respondent that this statement
was not a confessional statement
and was therefore
not hit by section 164 and Shanti Lal Ahuja, the Additional District Magistrate, could therefore depose to
such statement even though the same was not recorded as required by the provisions of section 164 of the
Criminal Procedure Code. There is authority however
for the propos1t10n that once the investigation had
started any non-confessional statement made by the
accused also required to be recorded in the manner
indicated in that section and if no such record had
.
S.C.R.
}\
•>
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1109
been made by the Magistrate, the Magistrate would
not be competent to give oral evidence of such statement having been made by the accused. (See A.LR.
1936 Privy Council 253 and Indian Law Reports 49
Calcutta 167 followed in 26 Criminal Law Journal 1279
and A.LR. 1937 Nagpur 254). The statement made
by the appellant No. 1 therefore to Shanti Lal Ahuja,
the Additional District Magistrate, not having been
recorded by him in accordance with the provisions of
section 164 was inadmissible in evidence and could
not be proved orally by him. If therefore the statement was thus eliminated from evidence nothing
remained so far as the witnesses Nagindas and Pannalal on the one hand and the police witnesses as well
a.s Shanti Lal Ahuja, the Additional District Magistrate, on the other hand were concerned which could
bring the guilt home to the appellant No. 1.
Reliance was therefore placed by the . prosecution
on the evidence of Gadkari and Perulakar. They
occupied responsible positions in life and were absolutely independent witnesses. Two criticisms were levelled against their evidence by the Special Judge. The one
criticism was that contrary to the evidence of Pandit
Dhanraj they asserted that their statements were not
recorded on the night of the 11th April, 1949. Pandit
Dhanraj had re.corded their statements after they had
left the bedroom of the appellant No. 1 at the
Constitution House relying upon his memory of the
events that had happened that night. These statements
however were not read over to them and therefore could
not have the value which otherwise they would have had.
The other criticism was that they had appended their
signatures to the Panchanama of the numbers of the
currency notes recovered at that time which Panchnama
contained the statement that on being asked the appellant No. 1 had produced the bundles of currency notes
from the top drawer of the dressing table. This statement was not factually correct as both these witnesses
were brought into the bedroom of the appellant No. 1
after the recovery of the Government currency notes
by the police from the appellant No. 1. It was certainly indiscreet on their part not to have scrutinised
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Another
v.
T1" Stateof
Vindhya Pradesh.
Bhagwati].
1110
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Another
v.
The State of
Vindhya Pradesh.
BhagwatiJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
the contents of the Panchnama before they appended
their signatures thereto. That is however a far cry
from coming to the conclusion that they acted m a
highly irresponsible manner and their testimony was
unreliable. The circumstances under which the numbers of the currency notes were recorded m the
Panchnama, the statement made by the appellant
No. 1 to them and the confusion into which the app<"llant No. 1 fell when he was questioned by the police
authorities on the tallying of the numbers contained
in the memo prepared when the raid was organised
with the numbers of the currency notes actually found
in the bedroom of the appellant No. 1 were events
which would indelibly print themselves in the memory
of these witnesses and even though they were examined in the Court of the Special Judge about 10 months
after the occurrence, these events and particularly the
fact that the appellant No. 1 claimed these moneys
which were thus recovered as his own would certainly
not be in any manner whatever forgotten by them.
The only suggestion which was made against the credibility of these witnesses on this point was th::it they
must not have exactly remembered what transpired on
that night in the bedroom of the appellant No. 1 and
that they might have committed an honest mistake
when narrating the events that had happened on that
night. An honest lapse of memory would no doubt
be a possibility but having regard to the circumstances
of the case we are of the opinion that the events that
happened that night in the bedroom of the appellant
No. 1 and which were deposed to by these witnesses
were not such as to be easily forgotten by them and
when these witnesses deposed to the fact that the
appellant No. 1 claimed this sum of Rs. 25,000 as his
own and was utterly confused when explanation was
sought from him by the police authorities in regard to
the tallying of the numbers of these Government
currency notes, it is not easy to surmise that they
were suffering from any lapse of memory.
The evidence of these witnesses in regard to the
statement made by the appellant No. 1 before them
was also attacked on the ground that Shanti Lal
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1111
Ahuja, the Additional District Magistrate's asking the
appellant No. 1 to repeat the statement which he had
earlier made before him to these witnesses was a mere
camouflage. Shanti Lal Ahuja, the Additional District
Magistrate, knew very well that the statement made
by the appellant No. 1 to him was not recorded under
the provisions of section 164 of the Criminal Procedure
Code and was therefore inadmissible in evidence and
he therefore resorted to these tactics of having the
appellant No. 1 repeat the very same statement to
these witnesses so as to avoid the bar of section 164.
Reliance was placed in this behalf on A.LR. 1940
Lahore 129 (Full Bench) where it was held that if on
the facts of any case it was found that a statement
made to a third person was in reality intended to be
made t-0 the police and was represented as having
been made to a third person merely as a colourablc
pretence in order to avoid the provisions of section 162
the court would hold it excluded by the section. The
san1e ratio it was submitted applied to the statements
made to these two witnesses because they were a colourable pretence to avoid the provisions of section 164 of
the Criminal Procedure Code which had certainly not
been complied with by Shanti Lal Ahuja, the Additional District Magistrate. It has however to be observed that every statement made to a person assisting
the police during an investigation cannot be treated
as a statement made to the police or to the Magistrate
and as such excluded by section 162 or section 164 of
the Criminal Procedure Code. The question is one of
fact and has got to be determined having regard to
the circumstances of each case. On a scrutiny of the
evidence of these two witnesses and the circumstances.
under which the statements came to be made by the
appellant No. 1 to them we are of the opinion that tht
appellant No. 1 was asked by Shanti Lal Ahuja, the
Additional, District Magistrate, to make the statements
to these two witnesses not with a view to avoid the bar
of section 164 of the Criminal Procedure Code or by
way of colourable pretence but by way of greater caution particularly having regard to the fact that the
appellant No. 1 occupied the position of a Minister of
6-98 S.C. India/59
1954
Rao Shiv Bahatl"'
Singh and
Another
v.
The Stak of
VindfiJa Praduh.
Bhapati]•
1112
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Another
v.
TM State of
Vindhya Prarksh.
BhagwatiJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19541
Industries in the State of Vindhya Pradesh. The
statements made by the appellant No. 1 to these
witnesses therefore did not suffer from this disability
and were admissible in evidence.
The evidence of these witnesses being thus worthy
of credit and the statements made by the appellarit No.
1 to them being admissible in evidence there is no doubt
that the appellant No. 1 claimed these moneys, viz:,
Rs. 25,000, which were recovered from the top drawer
of the dressing table in the bedroom of the appellant
No. 1 as his own being the balance of Rs. 40,000 which
he had brought from his home when he came to Delhi.
If this was so the very fact that the numbers of these
Government currency notes of the value of Rs. 25,000
tallied with the numbers of the notes which had been
handed over to Nagindas earlier when the raid was
organised and which numbers were also specified in the
memo prepared at that time was enough to establish
the falsity of the allegation made by the appellant
No. 1 that he had brought these moneys from his
home. These moneys .were proved to have been provided by the police authorities and given to Nagindas
when the raid was organised and were the instruments
of the offence of the taking of the bribe or illegal gratification by the appellant No. 1. If the numbers of
these notes tallied with the numbers of the notes
which were thus handed over by the police authorities
to Nagindas they could not have belonged to the · appellant No. 1 and were certainly brought there by
Nagindas and handed over by him to the appellant
No. l as alleged by the prosecution. A suggestion
was made that there was opportunity for Nagindas to
plant these moneys into the top drawer of the dres~ing
table when the back of the appellant No.. 1 was turned
upon him. Even assuming that there· was that possibility it is sufficiently negatived by the fact that "".hei;i
these moneys were recovered from the top drawer
either at the instance of Nagindas as alleged by the
appellant No. 1 or at the . instance of the appellant
No. 1 as alleged by the prosecution the appellant No.
1 did. not .express any surprise at these moneys being
thus found there. If the version of the appellant No. 1
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1113
was correct he had only brought about Rs. 25,000
from his house. Rs. 15,000 has been already spent by
him in the purchase of the car. About Rs. 10,000
were spent by him in the purchase of the ornaments
and only a sum of Rs. 100 odd was the balance left
with him. According to that version there was _not
the slightest possibility of the sum of Rs. 25,000 being
found in the top drawer of the dressing table. flar
from expressing a surprise in this manner the appellant
No. 1 claimed these moneys as his own. The appellant No. 1 could not have by any mischance failed to
appreciate that these Government currency notes
which were thus recovered from the top drawer of the
dressing table exceeded by far the amount which according to him he had left with him by way of balance
and the most natural reaction to the recovery of this
large sum of
money
would
have been that
he would have certainly denied that these moneys
were llis and he would have been
surprised
at finding that such a large sum of money was thus
found there. No such reaction was registered on his
face. On the contrary if the evidence of the two
witnesses Gadkari and Perulakar is to be believed and
we see no reason why it should not be believed, the
appellant No. 1 claimed this sum of Rs. 25,000 as his
own being the balance out of the money which he had
brought from his home when he came to Delhi. This
is sufficient to establish that these moneys which earlier had been handed over by the police authorities to
Nagindas found their way into the top drawer of the
dressing table in the bedroom of the appellant No. 1
and were the primary evidence of the offence under
section 161 having been committed by the appellant
No. 1. The further circumstance that on the numbers of these notes being tallied and his explanation
in that behalf l?eing asked for by the police authorities
the appellant No. 1 was confused and could furnish no
explanation in regard thereto also supports this conclusion and there is no doubt left in our minds that the
appellant No. 1 was guilty of the offence under section
161 of the Indian Penal Code with which he was
charged.
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Another
v.
The State of
Vindll) a Pradesh.
1
BhagwatiJ.
1114
1954
Rao Shiv Baharlur
Singh and
Another
v.
The State of
VindJrya Pradesh.
BhagwatiJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
We cannot however leave this case without expressing our strong disapproval of the part which the police
authorities and Shanti Lal Ahuja, the Additional District Magistrate, took in this affair. As already observed this offence would never have been committed by
the appellant No. 1 but for the fact that the police
authorities provided Nagindas with the wherewithal
of the commission of the offence. Sir Chinubhai as it
appears from the evidence was not in a pos1t1on to
provide Nagindas with this sum of Rs. 25,000 or any
large sum and in fact in spite of the telephone calls
made by Nagindas upon him had not provided any
amount beyond Rs. 3,000 which was meant for the
other expenses of Nagindas, to him. Nagindas was
provide
this
therefore
not 111 a position to
sum of
Rs. 25,000 for payment of the bribe
or the illegal gratification to the appellant No. I.
But for the adventitious aid which he got from
the police authorities the matter would not have
progressed any further, and Nagindas would have
left Delhi empty handed. The police
authorities
however once they got scent of the intention of
Nagindas thought that it was too good an opportunity
to miss for entrapping the appellant No. 1 who occupied the position of the Minister of Industries in the
State of Vindhya Pradesh. They therefore provided
the sum of Rs. 25,000 on their own and handed it
over to Nagindas. The police authorities in this step
which they took showed greater enthusiasm than
Nagindas himself in the matter of trapping the
appellant No. 1. It may be that the detection of
corruption may sometimes call for the laying of traps,
but there is no justification for the police authorities
to bring about the taking of a bribe by supplying the
bribe money to the giver where he has neither got it
nor has the capacity to find it for himself. It is the
duty of the police authorities to prevent crimes being
committed. It is no part of their business to provide
the instruments of the offence. We cannot too
strongly disapprove of the step which the police
authorities took in this case in the matter of providing
the sum of Rs. 25,000 to Nagindas who but for the
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1115
police authorities thus coming to his aid ~ould nc;ver
have been able to bring the whole affair to its culromation.
Not only did the police authorities thus become
active parties in the matter of trapping the appellant
No. 1 they also provided a handy and an ostensibly
independent witness in the person of Shanti Lal Ahuja,
the Additional District Magistrate. Even though he
was a member of the judiciary he lent his services to
the police authorities and became a limb of the police
as it were. The part which Shanti Lal Ahuja, the
Additional District Magistrate, took in this affair cannot be too strongly condemned. We can only repeat
in this connection the observations of the Privy
Council in A.LR. 1936 Privy Council 253 at page 258
in regard to the Magistrates placing themselves in
positions where they would have to step into the
witness box and depose as ordinary citizens :"In their Lordships' view it would be particularly
unfortunate if Magistrates were asked at all generally
to act rather as police officers under section 162 of
the Code; and to be at the same time freed, notwithstanding their position as Magistrates, from any
obligation to make records under section 164. In the
result they would indeed be relegated to the position
of ordinary citizens as witnesses and then would be
required to depose to matters transacted by them in
their official capacity unregulated by any statutory
rules of procedure or conduct whatever .......... "
The position was laid down with greater emphasis
by Mr. Justice P. B. Mukharji in A.LR. 1951 Calcutta
524 at page 528 where the learned Judge observed :"Before I conclude I wish to express this court's
great disapprobation of the practice that seems to have
become very frequent of sending Magistrates as
witnesses of police traps. The Magistrate is made
to go under disguise to witness the trap laid by the
police. In this case it was Presidency Magistrate and
in other cases which have come to our notice there
have been other
Magistrates who became such
witnesses. To make the Magistrate a party or a limb
of the police during the police investigation seriously
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadur
Singh and
Anoth11
v.
The State of
Vindh;'a PradtJli.
BhagwatiJ.
1116
1954
Rao Shiv Bahad111
Singh atcd
Anotl1er
v.
Tht Stat1 of
Vindhya Pradesh.
Bhagwati].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
undermines the independence of the Magistrates and
perverts their judicial outlook. The Magistrates are
the normal custodians of the general administration
of criminal justice and it is they who normally decide
and pass judgments on the acts and conduct of the
police. It is not enough to say, therefore, that the
Magistrate acting as a witness in a particular case
does not himself try that case. This practice is all
the more indefensible here specially when there is no
separation of the executive from the judiciary. The
basic merit of the administration of criminal justice
in the State lies in the fact that the person arrested
by th~ police is entitled to come before an independent
and impartial Magistrate who is expected to deal with
the case without the Magistrate himself being in any
way a partisan or a witness to police activities. There
is another danger and that is the Magistrates are put
in the unenviable and embarrassing position of having
to give evidence as a witness and then being disbelieved. That is not the way to secure respect for
the Magistracy charged with tl1e administration of
justice. In my judgment this is a practice which
is unfair to the accused and unfair to the Magistrates.
It is also unfair to the police.
Because
charged with the high responsibility and duty of
performing a great and essential public service of
this State the police cannot afford to run the risk
of opprobrium, even if unfounded, that they have
enlisted the Magistrate in their cause. That risk is
too great and involves forfeiting public respect and
confidence ............ "
We perfectly endorse the above observations made
by Mr. Justice P. B. Mukharji and hope and trust
that Magistrates will not be employed by the police
authorities in the manner it was done by the Special
Police Establishment in this case before us. The
independence of the judiciary is a priceless treasure
to be cherished and safeguarded at all costs against
predatory activities of this character and it is of the
essence that public confidence in the independence of
the judiciary should not be undermined by any such
tactics adopted by the
executive authorities. We
S.C.R.
•
1117
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
have therefore eliminated from our consideration the ·
whole of the evidence given by Shanti Lal Ahuja, the
Additional District Magistrate, and come to our conclusion in regard to the gilt of the appellant No. 1
relying solely on the testimony of the two independ- .
ent witnesses Gadkari and Perulakar.
1954
Rao Shiv Bahadt11
Si'flgh and
Another
v.
The Stale of
Vindhya Pradesh.
Bhagwati].
The result therefore is that the appeal of the
appellant No. 1 will be dismissed except with regard
to his conviction and sentence under section 120-B
of the Indian Penal Code and the convictions and sentences passed upon him by the Judicial Commissioner
under section 465 and section 466 as also section
161 of the Indian Penal Code will be confirmed. The
appeal of the appellant No. 2 will be allowed and
he be acquitted Md discharged of the offences with
which he was charged and immediately set at liberty.
The bail bond of the
appellant No. 2 will be
cancelled.
V. M. SYED MOHAMMAD AND COMPANY
1954
v.
March111 ..
THE STATE OF ANDHRA.
(With Connected Appeal)
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN C. J., MuKHERJEA,
S. R. DAS, V1v1AN BosE and
GHULAM HASAN JJ.J
Constitution
of
India, art.
14-Government
of India
Act,
1935, "'"Y 48 in List I/ of the Seventh Schedule-Madras .General
Sales Tax Act (IX of 1939)-Whether ultra vires the Constitution
or Government of India Act, 1935-Rule 16(5) framed under the
Act-Whether ultra vires s. 5 (vi) of the Act.
Held, that the Madras General Sales Tax Act (IX of 1939) is
not ultra vires the
Government of India Act, 1935 as
in List II of the Seventh Schedule to the
entry
48
Government of India
Act, 1935 was wide enough to cover a law imposing
purchaser of goods as well as on the seller.
a tax on the
Held, also that inasmuch as there was nothing to suggest
that the purchasers of other commodities were similarly situated
as the purchasers of hides and skins in the present case, the Act
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org