THE VICE-CHANCELLOR, UTKAL UNIVERSITY AND OTHERS versus S. K. GHOSH AND OTHERS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 15 January 1954 | [1954] 1 S.C.R. 883 | 1954 INSC 3
Key facts
- Decided
- 15 January 1954
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN*, BIJAN KUMAR MUKHERJEA, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, VIVIAN BOSE, GHULAM HASAN
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7/1952
- Citation
- [1954] 1 S.C.R. 883
- Neutral citation
- 1954 INSC 3
Text of the judgment
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
883
conducted themselves not in accordap.ce with law or if
they have acted in excess of their jurisdiction. The
same is the answer to the petitioner's next contention
that the sale could not be confirmed by the Minister
and that under the rules it was only the Chief Comm1ss10ner who was authorised to confirm it. The
point of discrimination was not seriously argued
before us.
!954
Coovetjee
B. Bharucha
v.
The Excise Commissioner and the
Chief Commis~
sioner, Ajmer
and Others.
Mahajan C . .].
For the reasons given above we see no validity in
this application and we accordingly dismiss it with
costs.
Petition dismissed.
Agent for the peut10ner: S. D. Sekhri.
Agent for the respondent: G. H. Rajadhyaksha.
THE VICE-CHANCELLOR, UTKAL
UNIVERSITY AND OTHERS
fl.
S. K. GHOSH AND OTHERS.
[MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN. C.J., MuKHERJEA,
S. R. DAs, VrVIAN BosE and GHULAM HASAN JJ.]
Constitution of India, art. 226-Mandamus petition-High
Court-Whether can constitute itself as court of appeal-Resolu~
ti<>ns passed by University Syndicate-Validity of-Notice of
meeting issued to all-T¥ant of due notice waived-Substantial
compliance with spirit of law.
In the present case there were two meetings of the University
Proper notices of both
Syndicate, consisting of twelve members.
meetings were issued to all the members but one member did not
attend one meeting and another n1e111ber did not attend the other
·meeting. 1'he defect \Vas that the subject matter of the present
·case was not included in the agenda of either meeting but one of
the items in the agenda of both the notices was "other matters_,
if any." The subject matter consisted of leakage of examination
papers and the cancellation of results. ~fhose present passed the
resolution on both occasions unanimously. The High Court held
that want of notice in the two cases invalidated the resolutions
1951
Jariuary 15.
884
1954
The Vice Chan-
cellor, Utkal
University
and Others.
v.
S. K. G'wsh
and Ot'LtTs.
Bose].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954)
and issued a 1nandan1us directing the syndicate to take steps for
the publication of the results :
Held, that \vant of due notice can be \vaived in given circum~
stances. In the present case the two absentees did in fact attend
one or other of the meetings and expressed their views, not individually but as members of a meeting which was considering the
n1atter and there was unanimity on both occasions. The substance
is more important than the form and if there is substantial compliance \Vith the spirit and substance of the law, an unessential
defect in form shpuld not be allowed to defeat what is otherwise
a proper and valid resolution. As in the present case, there was
actual appearance without objection at meetings properly convened
and there was complete unanimity on bOth occasions the
two
resolutions were not invalid because whatever may
be thought
about each taken separately, the defects, if any, are cured when
two are read together and regarded as a whole.
Held further, that in a 1nandamus petition the High Court
cannot constitute itself into a court of appeal from the authority
against which appeal is sought. It is not the function of courts
of law to substitute their wisdom and discretion for that of the
persons to \Vhose judgment the matter in question is entrusted by
the law.
1'he present was not the sort of case in which a mandamus
ought to issue.
Radha Kishan faikishan v. Municipal Committee, Khandwa
(61 I.A. 125) and Young v. Ladies Imperial Club (89 L.J.K.B. 563)
referred to.
Civil
Appeal
CIVIL
APPELLATE
JURISDICTION :
No. 7 of 1952.
Appeal by special leave from the Judgment and
Order, dated 9th and 17th August, 1951, of the High
Court of Judicature at Orissa in Miscellaneous Judicial
Case No. 80 of 1951, and Order dated the 20th August,,
1951, in Supreme Court Appeal No. 15 of 1951, on the.
file of the said High Court.
Dr. Bakshi Tek Chand (G. C. Mathur and H. Mohapatra, with him) for the appellants.
N. C. Chatterjee ( V. S. Sawhney and R. Patnaik,
with him) for respondents Nos. 1-8, 10-16, 18-23
and 25-34.
1954. January 15. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
BosE J.-This appeal arises out of a petition made
by certain students of the Utkal University of Orissa
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
885
to the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack seeking a
mandamus under article 226 of the Constitution
against the Vice-Chancellor of the University and
certain other persons connected with it.
195-f
Thi Vi..-Chan-.
"/lo<, Utl:al
U•iveisity.
and Ol.-i.lfs.
v:J
In view of an undertaking given before us on behalf of
the University, the questions at issue lose most of their
practical importance and only two questions of principle remain. Because of this we do not intend to
examine the matters which arise at any length.
The facts are as follows. The first M.B.B.S. Examination of the University included Anatomy as one
of its subjects. This examination was divided
into
three parts. The theoretical portion, which was
written, was fixed for the 9th and 10th of April, 1951.
The practical was fixed for the 19th and the viva t•oce
for the 20th.
At 7 o'clock on the morning of the 9th, before the
examination began, a member of the Senate was to!<!
that there had been a leakage of the questions and
he was given a paper which was entitled "hints". He
at once contacted three other members of the Scm,te
and handed over copies of these "hints" to them. The
three members were Mr. Justice Jagannadhaclas,
Mr. Pradhan, the Director of Public Instruction in
Orissa, and Mr. Lingaraj Misra, the Minister tor
Education. The Vice-Chancellor was not inform,·cl •t
the time and no further action was taken. The
e:famination proceeded as scheduled on the chtes
fixed.
The Vice-Chancellor was informed on the 19th. He
at once asked Lt. Col. Papatla, the Principal of the
Medical College, to look into the matter. This was
done and Lt. Col. Papatla submitted a report on the
20th. He compared the
"hints" with the question
paper and considered that the similarity between
them justified the conclusion that there had been a
leakage.
It so happened that an ordinary meeting of the
University Syndicate had been called for the 21st to
S. 1'. Ulw&h
and mhm. ·
Bose J ..
886
t934
T1" I' ;,.:er.a.-
cell", Ul/;Jll
U•ioMsily
and OI ns.
••
S. I:. G "''h
ani '!)tlttrs.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
consider certain other matters. This question was
not on the agenda but the last item was, "other
matters, if any."
The Vice-Chancellor presided aml he told the members present what had happen.ed. He had already
prepared a note about this on the 21st before the
meeting began.
After setting out the facts the note
concluded"! request the syndicate to discuss the matter as it
is an important and urgent one before taking up the
publication of the M.B.B.S. results which are also
ready, though the subject is not in the agenda."
The report of the Board of Examiners setting out
the results of the examination was received on the
morning of the 21st some time before the meeting. It
showed that thirty seven students had appeared for
the examination in question. Of these, twenty seven
passed and ten failed in the written examination and
the same ten, plus one other (making eleven), failed in
the practical and viva voce tests. In the result, eleven of
the thirty seven failed and twenty six pasml. The petition for mandamus was made by the twenty six who had
passed and eight who failed: thirty four in all.
The syndicate heard Lt. Col. Papatla at length and
also examined three other persons, namely,
Mr.
Bhairab Chandra Mahanty, who first gave the information, Dr. R. K. Mahanty, the internal examiner foi
the M.B.B.S. and Dr. S. M. Banerjee, President of
the Board of Examiners. (Two members of the
syndicate were experts in Anatomy, namely Lt. Col.
Papatla and Dr. S. N. Acharya, the Civil Surgeon).
After carefully considering the question for some six
hours. the members present passed the following
resolution :
"That after enquiry, the syndicate is satisfied that
there has been leakage of questions in Anatomy and
that the result in Anatomy examination be cancelled
and that another ex"mination in the subject be held
commencing from the 7th May, 1951."
:S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
887
The svndicate consists of twelve members. Of
these, all but one Mr. Pradhan, the Director of Public
Instruction, were present at the meeting. Those
present passed the resolution unanimously. It is
admitted that Mr. Pradhan was not told that this ~as
one of the matters which would be considered at the
meeting. This is one of the grounds on which the
validity of this resolution is attacked.
The successful candidates entered a protest against
the resolution and asked the syndicate to reconsider
its decision. This was on the 26th. The Vice-Chancellor had
already called another meeting of the
syndicate for
the 28th to consider other matters.
·Once again, this was not placed on the agenda but the
Vice-Chancellor brought it
up suo moto as before.
Again, eleven of the twelve were present but this time
the absentee was Dr. M. Mansinha who had approved
·of the previous resolution. The former absentee, Mr.
Pradhan, was present at this meeting. For a second
time the decision was unanimous and all eleven refus. ed to review the former resolution. It is admitted
that Dr. Mansinha who was not there did not know
that this, question would be consid.:red again.
The learned High Court Judges held that the want
·of notice in the two cases invalidated the resolutions.
·They examined the facts for themselves and. concluded
that even if the evidence is sufficient to indicate a
possibility of some leakage, there was "no justifica'tion for the syndicate to pass such a drastic resolution
in the absence of proof of the quantum and the
amplitude of leakage." They held that the syndicate
had acted unreasonably and without due case. They
therefore issued a mandamus directing the syndicate
to take steps for the publication of the results.
The Vice-Chancellor and the others appeal.
The right of the syndicate to control the examinations, to scrutinise the results, to invalidate an examination for p:-oper reasons and to order a re-examinaction, when necessary, was not disputed. In view of the
mndertaking given the only points argued were the
•
1954
Tlit Vfre·C~ari ..
ctllor, Utkal
University
and Others.
v.
S. K. C.'1osh
aiid Others..
·nose],
888
1954
·r;ie Vice-Chancellor, Utkal
University
and Others.
v·
S. K. Ghosh
and Ol/1ers.
Bose].
two which
University.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
the
High Court decided against
11954}
the
Several English authorities were cited about the
effect of an omission to give notice to even one
member of a body entitled to receive it, in particular
a decisiqn of the Privy Council in Radha Krishan
Jaikishan v. Municipal Committee, KhandflJa(' ). We do·
not think it nece:>sary to examine the general principle
at any length because, in our opinion, this case is.
governed by its own facts. It may well be that when
there is a statutory requirement about notice the
provisions of the statute cannot be evaded or ignored_
It may also be, though we do not stop to enquire
whether it is that when the constitution of a nonstatutory body requires notice to be given, then als0<
there cannot be any relaxation of the rule.
The reason for the stricter rule laid down in the·
cases cited before us is that though an incorporated
body like an University is a legal entity it has neither
a living mind nor voice. It can only express its will in·
a formal way by a formal resolution and so can onlyact in its corporate capacity by resolutions properly
considered, carried and duly recorded in the manner
laid down by its constitution. If its rules require such
resolutions to be moved and passed in a meeting called
for the purpose, then every member of the body
entitled to take part in the meeting must be given.
notice so that he can attend and express his views.
Individual assents given separately cannot be regarded
as equivalent to the assent of a meeting because the
incorporated body is different from the persons of
which it is composed. Hence, an omission to give
proper notice even to a single member in these circumstances would invalidate the meeting and that in turn
would invalidate resolutions which purport to have
been passed at it. But this is only when such inflexible·
rigidity is imposed by the incorporating constitution.
The position is different when, either by custom or by
the nature of the body or by its constitution and rules"
greater latitude and flexibility are permissible. Each:
(1) 61 I.A. 125.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
889
case must be governed by its own facts and no universal rule can be laid down; also it may well be that in
the same body certain things, such as routine matters,
can be disposed of more easily and with less formality
than others. It all depends on the nature of the body
and its rules.
In the present case, there were not one but two
meetmgs. Proper notices of both meetings were issued
to all the members including the two absentees. The
only defect is that the matter we are concerned with
was not included in the agenda of either meeting. We
need not decide here whether this must always be
done-there are English cases which indicate that that
is not always necessary, see for example T lie King v.
Pulsford( '),La Compagnie De Mayville v. Whitley(')
and Parker and Cooper Ltd· v. Reading(•); also, in the
present case one of the items in the agenda of both
notices was "other matters, if any." But it is not
necessary to go into that because in this case these
members did in fact attend one or other of the
meetings and expressed their views, not individually,
but as members of a meeting which was considering
the matter; and there was unanimity on both occasions.
Even on the stricter view taken in the cases
relied on by counsel it is pointed out that want of due
notice can be waived in given circumstances. Thus, if
a person who was not noticed appears at the meeting
and waives the irregularity, the defect is cured; so also
when a person is too far away to be reached in time to
enable him to communicate with the Committee before
the meeting: the sending of a notice is then excused.
See Radlza Kislzan Jaikislzan v. Municipal Committee,
Klzandwa(') and Young v. Ladies Imperial Club, Lim.(•).
The substance is more important than the form and if
there is substantial compliance with the spirit and
substance of the law, we are not prepared to let an unessential defect in form defeat what is otherwise a
proper and valid resolution. We, however, confine our
(1) rn8 E.R. !073-
(2) [1896] I Ch. 788.
(3) [1926) I Ch. 975·
(4) 61 I.A. 125.
(5) 89 L.J.K.B. 563.
•
1954
The Vit.e-Chan··
tellor, Utl.al
Un.iVlr.sity
and Others.
v.
S. K. Ghosh:
and Others .
. Bo.seJ.
890
1954
·The Vire-Chancellor, Utkal
Univer!ily
and Others.
v.
S. K. Ghosh
and Others.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
remarks to the facts of this case where there was
actual appearance without objection at meetings pmperly convened and where there was complete unanimity on both occasions. Whether it would be proper
to reach the same conclusion when there is a dissentient voice we are not prepared to say. In our opinion,
the High Court was wrong in holding that the two
resolutions were invalid. Whatever may be thought
about each taken separately, the defects, if any, are,
in our judgment, cured when the two are read together
and regarded as a whole.
We also think the High Court was wrong on the
second point. The learned fudges rightly hold that in
a mandamus petition the High Court cannot constitute
itself into a court of appeal from the authority against
which the appeal is sought, but having said that they
went on to do just what they said they could not. The
learned udges appeared to consider that it is not
enough to have facts established from which a leakage
can legitimately be inferred by reasonable minds but
that there must in addition be proof of its quantum
and amplitude though they do not indicate what the
yard-stick of measurement should be. That is a proposition to which we are not able to assent.
r
We are not prepared to perpetrate the error into
which the learned High Court Judges permitted themselves to be led and examine the facts for ourselves as
a court of appeal but in view of the strictures the
High Court has made on the Vice-Chancellor and the
syndicate we are compelled to observe that we do not
feel they are justified. The question was one of urgency
and the Vice-Chancellor and the members of the
syndicate were well within their rights in exercising
their discretion in the way they did. It may be that
the matter could have been handled in some other
way, as, for example, in the manner the learned
udges indicate, but it is not the function of courts of
law to substitute their wisdom and discretion for that
of the persons to whose judgment the matter in
question is entrusted by the Law. The University
authorities acted honestly as reasonable and responsible
r
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
891
1954
men confronted with an urgent
situation are
entitled to act. They had experts of their own on their
T h1 Jiice-C'Aan.
ce!lnr, l!tkal
body. They examined others "\Vho in their opinion
University
might throw light on the incident. They themselves
and Ot,.ers.
v.
compared tl:ie two papers and, after a deliberation of
S.K. Gho;h
some six hours, arrived at an unanimous decision and
and Otrters,
then they reviewed the matter afresh at a second
Bose].
meeting with the assistance of one of their number
who was not present on the first occasion. It is
inaccurate to describe that as haste and unjust to
characterise their action as unreasonable and lacbng
due care. This is decidedly not the sort of case in
which a mandamus ought to issue. We accordingly set
aside the order of the High Court.
We now come to the undertaking given on behalf of
the Vice-Chancellor. As we have observed, the syndicate reached the conclusion that there had been a
leakage and so cancelled the examinations and ordered fresh ones. Had the High Court not stepped in,
those examinations would have be_en held nearly two
and a half years ago and it is possible that all the
students who were successful then would have passed
again, or at any rate many of them would. But because
of the High Court's order the examinations could not
be held and the University was virtually directed to
regard the examinations already held and the results
already declared as good. The result has been that the
students who passed have been studying and sitting
for examinations in the higher classes for some two
and a half years. If the status quo which would result
from our setting aside of the High Court's order were
to be resumed it would mean that those students
would be put back to where they were two and a half
years ago and would be compelled to do the courses
which they have already covered all over again. In
order to avoid such injustice we were told at the outset by counsel on behalf of the Vice-Chancellor that
the University did not want to penalise them and so
gave us the following undertaking drafted by the·
appellants' counsel :
"The students who are declared to have passed'
the first M. B. B. S. Examination of the Utkal University-
892
1954
·rht Vict-Chanrellor, Utkal
Clniversity
and Others.
v.
S. K. Ghosh
and Others.
Bose].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
held in April, 1951, shall be deemed to have duly
passed that examination and shall not be required to
appear again in Anatomy."
The appeal is allowed. The High Court's order is set
aside and the petition for mandamus filed before it is
dismissed, but without costs. There will be no order
about costs in this "court either.
Appeal allowed.
Agent for the appellants: Raiinder Narain.
Agent for the respondents Nos. 1-8, 10-16, 18-23
and 25-34: S. P. Varma.
JAGANNATH
1954
_7anuary 20.
v.
JASWANT SINGH AND OTHERS.
[MEHR
CHAND
MAHAJAN. C.J.,
MUKHERJEA,
S. R. DAs, VIVIAN BosE and GHULAM HASAN. JJ.j
Representation of the People Act (XL/II of 1951), s. 82Election petition-Non-compliance with the provisions of s. 82Proper party omitted frorn the list of respondents-Defect u1hcther
fatal.
Held, (i) that non-con1pliance with the provisions of s. 82
of the Representation of the People Ac_t, 1951 (XLIII of 1951),
and the omission of a proper party from the list of respondents is
not fatal and the tribunal is entitled to deal \Vith
the tnatter in
accordance with the rules of the Code of Civil Procedure which
have been ma<le expressly applicable;
.
(ii) that it is one of the rules of construction that a provision similar to the one in s. 82 is not mandatory unless noncompliance \Vith it is made penal.
Order XXXIV, r. l, of the Code of Civil Procedure, referred
to.
General principles
tions discussed.
governing the
decision of election peti-
C1v1L APPELLATE JuRISDICTJON : Civil Appeal No.
100 of 1953.
Appeal by special leave from the Judgment and
Order, dated the 27th November, 1952, of the High
Court of Judicature, Punjab, Circuit Bench at Delhi
in Civil Writ No. 65-D of 1952 arising out of the
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org